TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.002 --> 00:00:28.606
I can maximize the results of the mechanical contact parts of my manual therapy by finding a discipline that I like, practicing that discipline so I can get really good at the manual contact part and maximize the kind of tissue response level that I get to my manual therapy.
00:00:31.585 --> 00:00:34.749
Are systems in manual therapy still helpful or valuable?
00:00:34.768 --> 00:00:39.232
Well, today we spoke to Mark Bishop, who's an associate professor at the University of Florida.
00:00:39.552 --> 00:00:44.476
He also has 30 years experience and loves researching the efficacy of manual therapy.
00:00:44.857 --> 00:00:52.043
We covered things like a force spread when you're using manual therapy, that you can get the same outcomes being specific and non-specific.
00:00:52.404 --> 00:01:10.921
And then we dug deeper into systems of assessment and systems of manual therapy and how sometimes systems can give you confidence and confidence can help patient therapists alliance and exactly what do we do with that information, particularly for young health professionals with this black or white narrative of manual therapy and non-manual therapy.
00:01:11.263 --> 00:01:12.944
This is a really interesting episode.
00:01:13.004 --> 00:01:13.644
Please enjoy it.
00:01:13.665 --> 00:01:16.087
My name is Michael Risk and this is Physio Explained.
00:01:21.713 --> 00:01:22.355
Welcome, Mark.
00:01:22.394 --> 00:01:23.296
Thank you for joining us.
00:01:23.936 --> 00:01:24.397
You're welcome.
00:01:24.436 --> 00:01:25.138
Good to be here.
00:01:25.602 --> 00:01:28.246
We're going to cover a fair few things manual therapy.
00:01:28.266 --> 00:01:33.275
You've done a wonderful masterclass for us, so we'll go a little bit deeper on that topic today with you.
00:01:33.296 --> 00:01:36.361
I thought we would start with some of the mechanisms.
00:01:36.382 --> 00:01:41.450
We were just chatting off air whether you would bother to know the mechanisms and what that does for you.
00:01:41.492 --> 00:01:47.042
What's your current understanding of the mechanisms of manual therapy and how it might all work?
00:01:47.841 --> 00:01:48.242
Right.
00:01:48.302 --> 00:01:53.209
So the mechanisms fall into a variety of different categories.
00:01:53.329 --> 00:02:08.050
I'm actually going to start out by saying, I think it's important that I understand those mechanisms because if I understand what those mechanisms are, then I have this opportunity to maximize the outcome related to each part, each type of mechanism.
00:02:08.091 --> 00:02:44.568
And that in the whole, that will has the prospect of increasing the outcomes that you and i when we're working together as patient and provider can get so first of all there's a lot of mechanical results from manual therapy i think defined for most people by the contact forces and movement of body parts And so I can maximize the results of the mechanical contact parts of my manual therapy by finding a
Load full transcript
discipline that I like, practicing that discipline.
00:02:45.650 --> 00:02:54.645
So I can get really good at the manual contact part and maximize the kind of tissue response level that I get to my manual therapy.
00:02:55.361 --> 00:03:03.318
And then other parts of the mechanism include this therapeutic condition or milieu around the interaction.
00:03:03.437 --> 00:03:14.980
And that's my expectations as a provider, your expectations as someone seeking care, the environment, the words that we're using, all those type of things that are happening.
00:03:15.741 --> 00:03:31.390
And if I know that that is possible, a mechanism that helps explain some of my results and I know how to maximise that therapeutic sort of interaction, then that has the opportunity to make my outcomes better because I'm maximising that part.
00:03:31.411 --> 00:03:37.759
So I've maximised the tissue response, maximised this therapeutic milieu around the place.
00:03:38.520 --> 00:03:52.519
And then there's also some, say, peripheral neurophysiological things and central neurophysiological separate from the expectation part where we're looking at autonomic nervous system responses and some of those types of things.
00:03:53.320 --> 00:03:57.411
And so if I look at each of those bits and I can say, this is how I get better at this.
00:03:57.531 --> 00:03:58.834
This is how I get better at this.
00:03:58.873 --> 00:04:00.478
This is how I get better at that.
00:04:00.834 --> 00:04:05.260
But I think that some of us intuitively do that automatically.
00:04:05.320 --> 00:04:19.622
But for those not as smart, maybe like myself, and I need to deliberately look at each bit and maximise each bit, then I can kind of get those same sort of response to manual therapy that someone who is intuitively doing all this at once is getting.
00:04:21.125 --> 00:04:21.305
Yeah.
00:04:21.745 --> 00:04:25.031
I like that you visualise it and break it up into those three areas.
00:04:25.071 --> 00:04:34.161
If we started with the mechanical as one of those areas specifically, What's your current understanding of the mechanical impacts when we do manual therapy?
00:04:34.802 --> 00:04:36.925
I'm just average physio.
00:04:37.245 --> 00:04:40.569
I don't read a lot of research, but I see what's happening on socials.
00:04:40.689 --> 00:04:45.596
My feeling is there's a sense of we can't be that specific anymore.
00:04:45.836 --> 00:04:53.267
Where does that sit with you and what are the specific impacts on that mechanical framework that you were speaking to?
00:04:53.307 --> 00:04:55.069
Absolutely.
00:04:55.089 --> 00:05:06.701
I think it's really well established that When I'm doing a manual therapy technique, whether it's a joint bias, muscle soft tissue bias, neurovascular bundles, that I directly affect that tissue.
00:05:07.382 --> 00:05:16.500
There's some really good evidence that we get movement, we get tissue deformation, changes in circulation, elongation of neurovascular bundles.
00:05:16.579 --> 00:05:21.408
So we've gotten really good at determining what the mechanical effect is.
00:05:22.593 --> 00:05:29.028
For some of the techniques, the actual localization does not seem to be that accurate.
00:05:29.470 --> 00:05:33.658
For example, with one of my preferred techniques is spinal manipulation.
00:05:33.699 --> 00:05:47.862
And if I'm doing a thrust technique, Walter Herzog is a chiropractic researcher who's done some really good stuff looking at when I apply a forceful technique, where does that force get translated?
00:05:47.961 --> 00:05:51.726
And it's usually over a 40 square centimeter area.
00:05:51.987 --> 00:05:57.875
And quite often, if there is a cavitation, it's not where I was aiming to get the cavitation, it's happening away.
00:05:57.935 --> 00:06:02.983
So not always, but just showing that the forces are distributed broadly.
00:06:03.062 --> 00:06:19.052
And we've seen similar sort of things for spinal mobilization that, you know, you're affecting multiple segments and While we can try very hard to be specific, we're probably not being as specific as once I thought I was being, for example.
00:06:20.014 --> 00:06:28.971
And it kind of turns out that in some studies that they've done, specificity isn't key to getting results.
00:06:29.091 --> 00:07:06.343
There's some really interesting work that if I let a computer pick the level that I'm going to treat, i get better at least the same or if not better results than when i pick the level that i want to treat based on my exam yeah you know part of that the debate that say joel bylosky the name some people might know and a couple of others here in the states that we have pretty regularly is who is the complex biomechanical exam for is it for me the provider or is it for you the patient because there's therapeutic value in a thorough exam.
00:07:07.264 --> 00:07:16.439
And there's also value to me just because that's how I've worked out how to do my interventions as I kind of need this sequence of exam stuff.
00:07:16.598 --> 00:07:28.358
But to get hung up on very specifically whether I'm on this part or this part may not be as important as the whole process, if that makes sense.
00:07:28.899 --> 00:07:29.158
Yeah.
00:07:29.259 --> 00:07:29.500
Yeah.
00:07:29.560 --> 00:07:40.999
So there are Definite changes at a tissue level when we apply manual therapy, and I'm assuming they're short-term, the short-term changes that happen with that.
00:07:42.100 --> 00:07:42.160
Yes.
00:07:42.180 --> 00:07:51.810
And then there's the specificity may be not as important on an impact level, but I was going to link that to it may be important to the patient.
00:07:52.069 --> 00:07:56.033
Like when a patient says, oh, that's the spot, you know, you're on the spot.
00:07:56.113 --> 00:08:06.437
So, yeah, a human could do it or a machine could do it, But what does that do to the patient when they think that we're, you know, on that tight spot or on their painful spot?
00:08:06.538 --> 00:08:09.560
Is there any thought or consideration to that or does that not matter either?
00:08:09.581 --> 00:08:15.348
No, I think you're right on to something there, at least in my opinion.
00:08:15.408 --> 00:08:25.180
The importance of that part, I think, is perhaps of bigger impact than the localisation of my treatment decision.
00:08:26.062 --> 00:08:26.141
Okay.
00:08:26.305 --> 00:08:42.298
So if I do an exam and then can tell you, okay, based on my exam, this is what I think, and it aligns very closely with either what you think, or I can explain it so that you believe that we're onto the same message.
00:08:42.317 --> 00:08:43.340
That's one part.
00:08:44.577 --> 00:08:51.866
The other thing is that the more I practice, the more that I work in my preferred philosophy, I'm Maitland trained.
00:08:51.988 --> 00:08:53.990
And so that is my preference.
00:08:54.049 --> 00:08:55.471
And that is what I do.
00:08:55.631 --> 00:08:57.134
And I've done that for 30 years.
00:08:57.173 --> 00:08:58.897
I feel very confident in that.
00:08:59.697 --> 00:09:14.724
And one of the things that has been noted is I then present that efficacy, my strong belief in that system and my ability to use that system is that you The patient in front of me perceives that.
00:09:14.764 --> 00:09:34.503
And when they're working out whether they're going to trust me, things that the qualitative research suggests patients value very highly in the therapeutic alliance is that they trust my expertise and that they infer my expertise in part through my confidence and my handling.
00:09:35.585 --> 00:09:38.707
And so I had to do all that practice, if this makes sense.
00:09:38.888 --> 00:09:40.249
I had to do all that practice.
00:09:41.250 --> 00:09:48.380
to be able to do a confident exam that gives the patient confidence that I know what I'm doing.
00:09:49.802 --> 00:09:51.306
So it kind of fits all together.
00:09:51.326 --> 00:09:52.967
I can't skip a step.
00:09:53.089 --> 00:09:54.951
I can't not train.
00:09:55.072 --> 00:10:03.404
I can't not practice because it's one thing for me to say, go out there, be confident, tell people they will be better.
00:10:03.524 --> 00:10:09.234
No, I still need to have good handling to transfer through to the patient's belief.
00:10:09.857 --> 00:10:31.666
You're exploring an area that I'm really curious about, and sometimes it's hard to articulate, but what we're seeing with some of the later research that specificity isn't important, what I see on ground in Australia is that therapists are, younger therapists are starting to say the specificity is not important.
00:10:32.326 --> 00:10:36.152
We're not making permanent changes when we do soft tissue work.
00:10:36.972 --> 00:10:42.294
So, Therefore, it's a big therefore and a big jump to, well, that's not that important.
00:10:42.475 --> 00:10:44.096
Manual therapy is not that important.
00:10:44.437 --> 00:10:47.039
I'm not going to put as much time or effort
into it.
00:10:47.360 --> 00:10:48.020
That's one side.
00:10:48.642 --> 00:10:58.272
And I think the other side you're exploring is if we have a structured system, a structured education, or at least a structured narrative in our head, we can stick to some structure.
00:10:58.312 --> 00:11:00.234
In that structure comes confidence.
00:11:00.274 --> 00:11:03.518
And in that confidence comes the rest of the therapeutic alliance, right?
00:11:04.001 --> 00:11:05.384
How do we bridge that gap?
00:11:05.683 --> 00:11:07.907
How have you seen that if you've been Maitland trained?
00:11:08.287 --> 00:11:13.673
And I'm sure some of those narratives have changed for you, but that doesn't mean you've thrown out your whole training.
00:11:13.714 --> 00:11:15.515
How do you explore that clinically?
00:11:16.496 --> 00:11:21.043
This is an excellent deviation to this conversation.
00:11:21.082 --> 00:11:21.884
That's fascinating.
00:11:21.923 --> 00:11:25.648
So this is an absolute parallel and a bunch of different things.
00:11:25.748 --> 00:11:35.203
I think if I remember around the turn of the century, you will remember John Childs and those guys developed a prediction rule saying, okay, You just need to do this.
00:11:35.303 --> 00:11:38.389
If they're stiff, low fear, within 14 days, go for it.
00:11:38.448 --> 00:11:39.250
Don't do anything else.
00:11:40.631 --> 00:12:00.183
And while there was some efficacy to that, it's a 50% improvement and those type of things, I think people interpreted it very directly that I don't have to learn anything else except I'll learn how to do a PA glide, take an FABQ and ask you if you're in pain, I'm done.
00:12:01.538 --> 00:12:09.288
The thing that they may not have taken into account is John Childs and Tim and those guys, they're fellows of the American Academy over here.
00:12:09.328 --> 00:12:12.714
They were good at what they did and they had practiced a lot.
00:12:12.813 --> 00:12:23.068
And part of what was not examined in those earlier studies is patient expectation, provider expectation, therapeutic, you know, a lot of that stuff.
00:12:23.990 --> 00:13:16.850
And so what we do know from other countries care in general is anytime you have a philosophy that you follow i like to point about structured thought that the more you do something and the more structured your thought becomes the better organized you become the better your outcomes are across a couple of different disciplines independent of what the intervention is it's because i'm my reasoning clinical reasoning gets better i'm collecting information more systematically there's a host of these other things that improve our relationship which improves part of the outcomes it improves my interactions and handling that that uh improves our outcomes so when this comes up and people say well do i even need to study this why would i study that and say well find something you'd like i happen to like Manual therapy.
00:13:17.371 --> 00:13:18.352
It's my go-to.
00:13:18.373 --> 00:13:20.394
I like the diagnostic process with it.
00:13:20.475 --> 00:13:21.196
I like the treatment.
00:13:21.375 --> 00:13:22.538
And that is my preference.
00:13:23.298 --> 00:13:29.184
If you want to become the best person at whatever philosophy it is, go and do that.
00:13:29.505 --> 00:13:30.807
Go and study that.
00:13:31.226 --> 00:13:32.269
Get really good at it.
00:13:32.389 --> 00:13:37.394
Get your handling, your interactions good, is my take on this.
00:13:37.894 --> 00:13:49.591
So debating between whether, oh, I'm mechanical this or I'm a whatever over here, post isometric movement person or a muscle energy person or whatever.
00:13:50.352 --> 00:13:57.284
I mean, I think as long as you have something that you're doing systematically, that you consistently get good results.
00:13:58.447 --> 00:13:59.528
Yeah, that's a nice thought.
00:13:59.669 --> 00:14:02.815
I'm starting to think about the other areas.
00:14:02.914 --> 00:14:12.825
So let's say that you've come through that training, you're quite structured, you're quite confident, but now you want to exploit, if that's the right word, the other areas that you were speaking of.
00:14:12.865 --> 00:14:18.533
So the therapeutic alliance, maybe some of the psychosocial things that happen in a consult.
00:14:19.474 --> 00:14:21.115
What are you doing in those areas?
00:14:21.196 --> 00:14:26.102
Is that an area that you've kind of trained just as hard at, like your manual therapy?
00:14:27.345 --> 00:14:27.644
Yes.
00:14:27.845 --> 00:14:37.089
I think the process needs to be deliberate and intentional and that some of us intuitively understand collecting some of this information and paying attention to it.
00:14:37.149 --> 00:14:51.784
But if I'm not thinking about it as part of my usual process, the very first thing is to say, Joel Bialewski again coined the term, he's probably not the first, but first one I know about the intervention buffet.
00:14:51.825 --> 00:15:09.028
So, you know, one of the things is when people with your condition, in my experience, respond well to this, or people with your condition, This clinical practice guideline says these are the best interventions, but there's no single best one of those interventions.
00:15:09.249 --> 00:15:11.292
So we need to do one of these things.
00:15:11.732 --> 00:15:13.836
We need to do a manual therapy.
00:15:14.436 --> 00:15:17.059
Here's what I like doing, one of these three.
00:15:17.159 --> 00:15:23.708
Is there anything there that you have a preference for or what has worked for you in the past or something like that?
00:15:24.750 --> 00:15:27.033
Okay, the other thing we have to do is exercise.
00:15:27.072 --> 00:15:32.408
I don't care what exercise you do, Michael, It's going to have to be some exercise.
00:15:32.467 --> 00:15:36.371
So you want to ride the bike, you want to walk in the pool, you want to walk on the treadmill.
00:15:36.812 --> 00:15:52.928
And so kind of giving people who
want, and by the way, not everybody wants to make decisions, but for those people who do have expectations, you can actually engage them a little bit more, that you can use their expectation of benefit.
00:15:53.129 --> 00:15:55.672
So, you know, I'm expecting this to help.
00:15:55.892 --> 00:15:56.091
Right.
00:15:56.212 --> 00:15:56.432
Great.
00:15:56.533 --> 00:15:57.094
That's good.
00:15:57.453 --> 00:15:57.533
Yeah.
00:15:57.634 --> 00:15:58.335
I'm good at that.
00:15:58.394 --> 00:16:02.902
I'm really good at cervical mobilization and manipulation.
00:16:02.942 --> 00:16:03.623
So let's do that.
00:16:04.264 --> 00:16:08.110
Or the alternative, of course, is they say, oh, no, that really didn't work for me.
00:16:09.071 --> 00:16:12.395
So, all right, well, here's some other things that we do well here.
00:16:12.456 --> 00:16:13.216
Which would you like?
00:16:13.937 --> 00:16:20.808
And that way I can really engage that expectation piece rather than just telling you, I'm going to do this and be done.
00:16:20.828 --> 00:16:20.849
I
00:16:21.529 --> 00:16:21.931
like that.
00:16:21.990 --> 00:16:26.880
My bias is to sit sit in the middle of all of that spectrum.
00:16:26.961 --> 00:16:35.994
And I do believe you can apply manual therapy and apply modern evidence-based practices and be aligned with collaboration and patient expectation.
00:16:36.053 --> 00:16:37.054
I think we can do that.
00:16:37.115 --> 00:16:39.457
I think that's our jam as clinicians.
00:16:40.178 --> 00:16:47.528
I still do think it's a confusing time for younger therapists, and it still feels like a little bit of camp creation, whether you're on one side or the other.
00:16:47.568 --> 00:17:00.956
If we were just to wrap this up, would you have a couple of tips for those younger therapists that are a little confused whether they're hands on, hands off, or that manual therapy is not doing what we thought, so I'm just going to scrap it all together.
00:17:00.976 --> 00:17:03.360
What would be two or three bits of parting advice?
00:17:04.522 --> 00:17:11.776
We have the unique opportunity to lay hands on people in a very intimate way.
00:17:11.796 --> 00:17:17.661
And I don't mean intimate relationship way, between you and your partner.
00:17:17.721 --> 00:17:24.211
I mean, intimate in the fact that very few other health professions get to touch as much as we do.
00:17:24.352 --> 00:17:31.044
And there is a lot of power in touch from this therapeutic sort of part of things.
00:17:32.705 --> 00:17:38.455
And that is a little bit separate from the actual mechanical force changing things, but it's still part.
00:17:38.536 --> 00:17:46.327
And so Just for me, I find it a very powerful part of our practice to be able to interact with people that way.
00:17:46.347 --> 00:18:00.128
And I'd encourage younger therapists who haven't tried or have deliberately avoided to see maybe if you like it as a provider, you will find patients who like it as patients.
00:18:00.269 --> 00:18:02.090
And it's a very powerful way to interact.
00:18:03.905 --> 00:18:04.647
Thank you, Mark.
00:18:05.088 --> 00:18:09.219
And if you want to go a little bit deeper, Mark has done a masterclass on this.
00:18:09.278 --> 00:18:11.023
We're going to put it in the show notes.
00:18:11.064 --> 00:18:15.555
You can have a free trial of that and go a little bit deeper into this topic with Mark.
00:18:15.895 --> 00:18:19.044
Thank you again for your time today and sharing all these pearls with us.
00:18:19.565 --> 00:18:20.125
You're welcome.
00:18:20.227 --> 00:18:21.630
Good to be here.