TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
00:00:14
Speaker 1: You're listening to Part-Time Genius, a production of Kaleidoscope and iHeartRadio. Guess what, Mary? What's that, Mango? Did you know there's a river in Canada that is actually a person?
00:00:31
Speaker 2: OK, at first that sounded like a setup for something like you're going to say there's a river in Canada you want to sell me.
00:00:37
Speaker 1: No. And in fact, there's no way I could sell you this river because in 2021, it was granted personhood status, which means, among other things, that the river can take legal action against anyone who violates its rights.
00:00:51
Speaker 3: How does a river get to court?
00:00:53
Speaker 2: I know that sounds like another bad joke set up, but I'm genuinely curious here.
00:00:58
Speaker 1: By crossing the road, I think is the answer. Well, the river itself is staying put. It is called the Magpie River, and it runs through northeastern Quebec from the border near Labrador to the Gulf of St. Lawrence. So any legal action taken on its behalf would have to be carried out by humans who could, you know, put on pants and show up at a courthouse. The magpie's unique status was granted by the regional county government and the Council of the Innu, the Indigenous Canadians who've lived in eastern Canada since long before Europeans arrived. And the resolutions they've adopted gave the river nine distinct rights, including the right to preserve its biodiversity, the right to flow, and yes, the right to protect itself from harm by taking legal action. If it comes to that, municipal authorities and the Innu Council can appoint guardians to represent the river in order to, quote, ensure the protection of its fundamental rights.
00:01:51
Speaker 3: And are there any immediate threats to the magpie?
00:01:55
Speaker 1: Not yet, but Quebec is one of the largest hydroelectric power producers in the world. Hydro-Quebec, which is a provincial public utility, already has a generating station on the magpie, which has a lot of hydro potential because it's fast-moving and deep. So the Innu are worried about the threat of dams along the magpie. Hydroelectric dams elsewhere in Canada have done irreparable damage to Indigenous communities. They've flooded out settlements and cut off access to traditional fishing and hunting lands, even burial grounds. So, of course, people are worried. Of course.
00:02:26
Speaker 2: So the idea was to get ahead of any potential problems by giving the river the power to fight back.
00:02:32
Speaker 1: Exactly. And though it sounds strange... There is precedent for this. Today on the show, we're going to explain the concept of environmental personhood, the idea that places can have legal rights the same way that people do. We'll talk about where it began, where it's being tested, and where it might be going, including to space. So let's dive in.
00:02:52
Speaker 3: Let's dive in.
00:03:13
Speaker 1: Hey there, podcast listeners. Welcome to Part-Time Genius. I'm Mungish Hatikler, a.k.a. Mango. Will Pearson is busy consulting attorneys to find out if his candy cabinet can earn legal personhood, and if so, what kinds of actions it might take against him. So today I am joined by producer Mary, and over there in the booth holding a framed photo of a distinguished gentleman in a jacket and tie, it is our pal and producer Dylan Fagan. I don't often say this, but Dylan's kind of stumped me. I have no idea who that guy is.
00:03:42
Speaker 2: Oh, well, it's a good thing I'm here because I know exactly who it is. That's legendary Canadian broadcast journalist Rex Loring.
00:03:51
Speaker 1: Oh, so it's just a reference to that Canadian river I was telling you about in the opening?
00:03:55
Speaker 2: No, that's more like a fun coincidence. Come on, Dylan's more clever than that. Let's give him some credit. No, in the early 1960s, Rex Loring hosted a CBC kids program called People and Places, which is what we're talking about today. people and places and places that are also people.
00:04:12
Speaker 1: Did you get access to that program in Maine? No, I didn't.
00:04:15
Speaker 3: I found it on the internet.
00:04:18
Speaker 1: Of course, I should have known, which is excellent work, both from Dylan and you, Mary. But be honest, before we started working on this episode, had you heard of environmental personhood?
00:04:28
Speaker 2: I had, but I knew very little about it. Like for some reason, I thought it was an idea that had just come up within the past decade or so.
00:04:35
Speaker 3: And it turns out that's not the case.
00:04:38
Speaker 2: But before we go any further, I think we need to talk about what makes a person a person.
00:04:42
Speaker 1: I mean, I feel like I'm a person, or at least I think I am. So I have no real idea of how to answer that.
00:04:53
Speaker 2: I know, because it sounds crazy. Obviously, people are people. But there's also this thing called legal personhood. And that's when something that's not a human is treated like a person for legal purposes. So, for example, a business entity like a corporation... That can be a legal person.
00:05:10
Speaker 1: I mean, I'm from Delaware and the corporations have increased our population significantly, but it also reminds me of like Citizens United, right? That decision that said corporations are people, too.
00:05:21
Speaker 3: Yeah, exactly.
00:05:22
Speaker 2: And actually, the concept of corporate personhood has been around for a very long time. It was used in early Rome and ancient India. But most people in the U.S. do know it in the context of that 2010 case where the Supreme Court decided that corporate spending was To influence elections is free speech protected by the First Amendment. It was and still is a very controversial decision. And I am in no way defending Citizens United. But corporate personhood isn't always used for nefarious purposes. For one thing, it means you can sue a corporation as an entity if it harms you instead of having to
Load full transcript
go out and bring individual lawsuits against all of its executives.
00:06:00
Speaker 1: Which makes sense. But how did we get from corporate personhood to environmental personhood?
00:06:06
Speaker 2: So environmental personhood was first proposed in 1972 by Christopher Stone, a law professor at the University of Southern California. In a paper titled Should Trees Have Standing Toward Legal Rights for Natural Objects, he pointed out that if corporations get to enjoy legal personhood, nature should too. And shortly after Stone's paper was published, the U.S. Supreme Court issued a ruling in Sierra Club v.
00:06:32
Speaker 1: Morton.
00:06:33
Speaker 2: This was a case involving the Sequoia National Forest in California, specifically a valley called Mineral King. The Walt Disney Company wanted to build a ski resort there and the Sierra Club sued to block the project. But after years of legal wrangling, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the Sierra Club didn't have standing to bring a lawsuit because they couldn't prove that they would be directly affected by this resort. And so the Sierra Club appealed to the Supreme Court, which took up the case. But once again, they lost. However, one justice, William O. Douglas, wrote a dissent that echoed Christopher Stone's concept of environmental personhood. He basically said, hey, this whole question of who has standing to bring lawsuits about environmental issues is would be a lot easier if we made it possible for the threatened environments to bring their own lawsuits. He even suggested that if that were possible, the case could have been renamed Mineral King versus Morton.
00:07:28
Speaker 1: That's really fascinating and I guess pretty progressive for 1972. But you said the Sierra Club lost, right? So did Disney end up building that ski resort?
00:07:38
Speaker 2: No, actually, they backed down because, you know, the publicity around this generated so much opposition. So in the end, the Sierra Club did get its wish. And Justice Douglas' dissent remains a touchstone for supporters of environmental personhood. It just took a few decades for the idea to find its way back to the spotlight. Which brings us to the first time environmental personhood became law. And I think you looked into that, right? So I'm curious what you found.
00:08:02
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's right. So this past September marked the 20th anniversary of the first time a community passed a rights of nature law. And it happened in Tamakwa Borough, which is this tiny town of about 7,000 people in Schuylkill County in eastern Pennsylvania. This used to be coal mining country. And when the mines closed, they left behind these giant pits that began to be used as industrial waste dumps. And, you know, some residents supported the dumping because it raised revenue for the town. But by the early 2000s, a lot of people were worried about the health impacts of all that toxic sludge in the area. Now, a nurse named Kathy Miarelli started hearing about local cancer clusters, so she decided to do something. She ran for borough council, and from there, she got involved in conversations about new sludge dumping proposals. At one meeting, she met representatives from an organization called the Community Environmental Legal Defense Fund, and they teamed up and worked with other grassroots groups. And in the end, they drafted Ordinance 612, which was adopted by the Borough Council in 2006. And besides outlawing corporate sludge dumping, Ordinance 612 states that borrowed residents and ecosystems shall be considered persons for purposes of the enforcement of their civil rights.
00:09:15
Speaker 3: And a few decades later, is that law still standing?
00:09:18
Speaker 1: It is, but it doesn't seem to have been applied in concrete ways, nor has it been really tested in court. So we don't know how well it would hold up against a challenge. It's just kind of there. And of course, sludge is still a problem across Schuylkill County. Just yesterday, there was a local news report about residents in a town called Tremont where the stench had gotten so bad that they couldn't walk outside or open their windows, which is just so awful. They say a nearby sludge processing facility straight up ignores environmental regulations and operates in a way that violates its permits, which to me raises a couple of questions, right? First, that's always the thing with hyperlocal policy changes. They can make this positive impact, but it's very limited in scope. And second, if you're dealing with corporate polluters who don't want to follow the rules in the first place, You kind of have to wonder if a township ordinance is really enough to stop them.
00:10:08
Speaker 3: Yeah, those are all very good questions.
00:10:10
Speaker 2: And we'll talk much more about some of those issues later in the episode. But for now, I want to tell you about another place that wrote environmental personhood into law, but in a much more dramatic way. I'm talking about the first country in the world to enshrine the rights of nature in its constitution.
00:10:27
Speaker 1: So I'm guessing it is not the United States.
00:10:30
Speaker 2: Yeah, no, surprisingly, surprisingly, we have not done that yet. It's Ecuador, which, of course, has some of the most extraordinary biodiversity on Earth. It includes everything from the Andes Mountains to Amazon rainforests to the Galapagos Islands. And despite its tiny area, it's actually smaller than the state of Nevada. It's home to 6% of all the plant and animal species in the world.
00:10:53
Speaker 1: What?
00:10:53
Speaker 3: That's incredible.
00:10:55
Speaker 2: I know.
00:10:55
Speaker 3: Field trip to Ecuador. Let's do it.
00:10:58
Speaker 2: But so in 2007, Ecuador's newly elected president, Rafael Correa, called for a referendum on updating the country's constitution. The referendum passed, a new constitution got drawn up, and the following year it was adopted. And for the first time
ever, a nation's constitution included a chapter called The Rights of Nature. And it begins by saying, Now, I'm going to ask a dumb question because I feel.
00:11:20
Speaker 1: Like Pachamama is one of those things I hear with like granola and carob and like other sort of natural food store words. What is Pachamama?
00:11:45
Speaker 2: Well, what you're referring to is white people doing marketing.
00:11:49
Speaker 1: Right, right.
00:11:51
Speaker 2: But in reality, it's the native goddess of life and nature, Mother Earth, basically. And this new rights of nature chapter in Ecuador's constitution really reflects an indigenous worldview. It grants Pachamama the right to exist, the right to regenerate, the right to be restored. And it says that everyone has a right to benefit from the environment and that anyone can call on the government to enforce the.
00:12:12
Speaker 3: Rights of nature.
00:12:14
Speaker 1: I feel like Justice Douglas would be so proud. But I'm curious, like, has this actually held up in court? Well, again, mixed results. In practice, it has been difficult to implement these rights. And it turned out that President Correa didn't limit mining as much as Indigenous leaders had hoped when he took office. In fact, In the past two decades, there have been several major protests against expanded mining operations, including a massive copper mine in the heart of the Amazon. But in 2021, Ecuador's highest court ruled that a proposal to mine copper and gold in a protected cloud forest violated the rights of nature and therefore was unconstitutional. The verdict even imposed a ban on any future mining in the area. And supporters hailed this as an example of environmental personhood going from this abstract legal concept to a real world impact, right? At the same time, they pointed out that mining activity in nearby areas still threatened this forest and its wildlife. As one conservationist told the BBC, quote, the game isn't over yet. The forces of the extractive industry are still actively working against us. So it sounds like a few steps forward, a few steps back. Well, we have to take a quick break, but when we come back, we'll tell you about some more places that have been granted personhood, including some gorgeous corners of New Zealand and the most important river in India.
00:13:33
Speaker 3: Stay tuned.
00:13:34
Speaker 1: Music Welcome back to Part-Time Genius, where we're talking about environmental personhood. And I want to give a special shout out to any places listening right now. Places you can call our hotline. You can send us emails. We love your reviews. Rivers, mountains, valleys. We are glad you're here. Yeah, sure.
00:14:05
Speaker 2: I mean, you know, if rivers can bring lawsuits, I guess they can listen to podcasts too, right?
00:14:09
Speaker 3: Why not?
00:14:10
Speaker 1: And review them. And review them. Yes.
00:14:13
Speaker 2: Well, so earlier I was talking about some of the challenges happening in Ecuador and And I guess the lesson here is that just because someone or something has rights defined by law doesn't mean they actually get to exercise those rights, right? I mean, it seems so obvious now that I say it, rights get trampled all the time.
00:14:30
Speaker 1: Yeah, of course. And that's one of the big criticisms of environmental personhood as a mechanism for conservation. If enforcement isn't also written into the law, the whole thing can be meaningless. And from a practical standpoint, there could be lots of different entities involved with any given natural resource, like municipal or federal government agencies, community groups, businesses, local landowners, you know, more of that type of thing. And coordinating all of those competing interests is a challenge no matter what. Now, one place where we really see the limitation of environmental personhood is the Ganges River or the Ganga, as it's known in Hindi, right? And it's hard to adequately convey how important this river is to Indians. It's obviously at the heart of Indian identity and culture. It's been that way for thousands of years. But just for some quick statistics, It's over 1,500 miles long. It originates in the Himalayas and drains into this vast delta that makes up most of Bangladesh. There are ongoing disputes between India and Bangladesh about water rights and management of the river. But one thing is clear, and that's that millions of people in both countries rely on the Ganges for food, water, and their livelihoods. It's also an important part of Hindu faith practices like ritual bathing and cremations, which is why its pollution is such a massive problem. You might have heard that the Ganges is one of the most polluted rivers in the world, which is true. But just to give you a sense of how bad it is, earlier this year, a study found 20 times the legal limit of bacteria in the river.
00:15:58
Speaker 3: Oh, my God. Well, so what's causing all of this pollution?
00:16:01
Speaker 1: There's no single cause, which is part of what makes the cleanup so difficult. It's this mix of industrial and chemical dumping, agricultural runoff, plastic crash, human waste and sewage. I mean, there are a lot of things contributing to this. Now, over the years, there have been efforts to improve things, but progress has been limited. So in 2014, a man named Mohammed Saleem brought a public interest case against the government of Uttarakhand, this state in northern India. He was concerned about ongoing development and construction along the Ganges and accused the government of not protecting the river. Now, the case wound its way all the way up to the High Court of Uttarakhand, which in late 2016 said that, yes, the government needed to crack down on illegal construction and follow the law. But it actually went further than that. The High Court wrote that the Ganges and its tributary, the Yamuna River, were losing their very existence and therefore extraordinary measures must be taken.
Specifically, the court decreed that the Ganges and the Yamuna would henceforth be declared legal persons, with all of the rights that conveyed. It also appointed officials from the Uttarakhand government to serve as the river's guardians, with the obligation to represent them in legal matters and protect their health and well-being.
00:17:13
Speaker 3: So that sounds like a pretty groundbreaking decision.
00:17:16
Speaker 1: It was, but the river's legal personhood only lasted a few months. The state of Uttarakhand appealed, and the decision was promptly overturned by India's Supreme Court.
00:17:26
Speaker 2: Wait, so even though the river is so important and everyone knows pollution is such a big problem?
00:17:31
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, the Supreme Court didn't dispute any of that. It's not like they were saying, actually, we think the Ganges should stay dirty. The problem, they said, was that applying this doctrine of legal personhood to rivers felt impractical. It just left too many open questions, like if the river floods and destroys property or kills people, is the river actually open to compensation claims? And if so, who pays them? I mean, the Supreme Court also pointed out that the Ganges flows through several states, so it's not just Uttarakhand. So it wasn't fair for the state's court to make such a momentous decision on its own.
00:18:02
Speaker 2: OK, that does make sense. But what about public opinion? What did locals think about this?
00:18:06
Speaker 1: You know, obviously, there's a wide range of reactions. But even some folks who believe that extraordinary measures were necessary to protect the Ganga, they agreed that the legal personhood decision just didn't cut it. Among other things, appointing government representatives as the river's legal guardians didn't make a ton of sense either. When you remember that this is the same government that had failed to clean it up in the first place. And, you know, just logistically, no one knew how making the river a person would actually speed up the process of reducing pollution, especially from those large scale corporate polluters.
00:18:36
Speaker 3: Yeah, sure.
00:18:37
Speaker 2: Well, so, OK, but since the Ganges is also central to life in Bangladesh, how has this played out there?
00:18:43
Speaker 1: Turns out in 2019, Bangladesh became the first country in the world to give all its rivers legal personhood, which is incredible. And there are actually over 900 rivers there. This is a ruling by the Bangladeshi Supreme Court. And in addition to granting personhood, it made pollution illegal and required clearance from the country's National River Conservation Commission before any new development could begin. But there was an appeal. And although the appeals court upheld the concept of personhood for the rivers, it It weakened many of the mandates attached to the decision. So we're kind of back to the same problem, right? This lack of real oversight and enforcement.
00:19:18
Speaker 2: Yeah, that does seem to be the common thread. But it is interesting that these efforts do at least acknowledge a view of the environment as having meaning beyond extraction or use. You know, I think about that phrase, natural resources, right? It overlooks the idea that a place can have inherent cultural or spiritual meaning, especially for Indigenous communities. And one country that's taken some noteworthy steps toward recognizing Indigenous perspectives on the environment is New Zealand. And in a couple of high-profile cases, that has led to granting places legal personhood.
00:19:40
Speaker 1: Thank you.
00:20:01
Speaker 2: It's got a massive rainforest, lots of lakes and rivers, rugged hills and valleys dotted with Maori settlements. The area was designated as a national park in the 1950s, but in 2014, the park was disestablished through a new law that recognized the rainforest as a legal entity unto itself. It also named the local Maori tribe the Tuwe as its legal guardians, responsible for protecting the land, managing visitors, like me someday, and monitoring plant and animal life. And to do this, they rely on an ancient practice known as kaitiaki tanga, which is not a word that has a precise equivalent in English. I have seen it translated as guardianship, but it's deeper than that. It's rooted in the Maori belief that people and nature are inextricably connected, that we're all part of the natural world and responsible for protecting its health.
00:20:52
Speaker 1: That is really beautiful. And I You know, it's funny, at the end of the series, I feel like you, Gabe, Will, and I have to go through all our scripts and figure out all the bucket list places we have to visit because I feel like there's so many places. I mean, I was laughing as you said that because like every time we do one of these shows, I feel like there's a place or something I feel like I need to investigate more than we've done on the show. And it's pretty incredible. But, you know, your comments kind of make me realize that legal personhood, as it's defined in a court, just can't capture like all the nuances of the indigenous view of the environment.
00:21:23
Speaker 3: No, no, that's absolutely right.
00:21:25
Speaker 2: And I had a similar thought when I was reading about another high-profile decision in New Zealand, and this was just a few years after Te Uruwera. The government settled over a century of land claims with the Maori and designated the Whanganui River as a legal person. This was a very long time coming. Since the 1870s, the Maori had been petitioning the New Zealand Parliament to compensate them for damage to caused by boat traffic and mining operations along the river. So in addition to granting personhood, the final agreement recognized the river as the life force of Maori ancestors and ensured that it would be represented equally by local tribes and the government. And you know, even if it is imperfect, I do think there's something
powerful in this, as there was in Ecuador. This idea of articulating Indigenous values in the laws of the land. And in the case of the Wanganui, many saw it as some small compensation for the very real damage that had been done to Indigenous values over the years.
00:22:20
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, I feel like even if you have to pull it back some, protecting these lands is really special. Anyway, we have to take one last break. But when we come back, can environmental personhood extend to space? Plus, we'll talk with author Lisa Siraganian-Gilbert. who wrote a very smart book about personhood that extends beyond people. So of course we had to ask her to play a silly game with us. Stay tuned. Welcome back to Part-Time Genius, where we're talking about environmental personhood. And one thing has become ridiculously clear to us. Although it can have so much symbolic value, environmental personhood's ability to actually stop damage to the environment can vary.
00:23:11
Speaker 3: That's right. And that brings us to Lisa Saraganian. She teaches comparative.
00:23:15
Speaker 2: Thought and literature at Johns Hopkins, and she's the author of a book that came out earlier this year called It is called The Problem of Personhood, Giving Rights to Trees, Corporations, and Robots. And as you might tell from the title of her book, Lisa is critical of environmental personhood as a conservation strategy.
00:23:32
Speaker 4: It feels like an exciting solution, but it is one that has so many dangerous consequences that I think we have to be quite wary of it.
00:23:44
Speaker 1: I mean, dangerous is a strong word. How can granting a river personhood be dangerous unless you fall in during some kind of ceremony on a bridge?
00:23:50
Speaker 2: Well, yes, that could happen. And look, climate change and pollution are really urgent issues. And Lisa told me that getting legal personhood for the environment isn't easy. And given the amount of effort it takes to wrangle legal cases or lobby for legislation, the payoff just isn't worth it.
00:24:07
Speaker 5: Not only do I think it's a distraction from the work, but I think it could be a kind of dissipating of the necessary political energy to actually get that work done. If you're really putting all your energy into trying to pass personhood and, you know, amendments into the Constitution, as, for example, they did in Ecuador, then you put your energy there, you put money and resources there, and instead afterwards you realize, well, actually, look what has happened. Nothing has changed in terms of the devastation of the environment in Ecuador. So, I mean, I think the distraction has real consequences that can be really damaging.
00:24:46
Speaker 2: In other words, yes, we need to take action to protect the environment and Indigenous cultures, but maybe there are better ways to do that.
00:24:54
Speaker 5: Personhood is a concept. We're trying to make it do so much work it is not fit for. Obviously, it's incredibly important for things like human rights, but When we try to shoehorn in all these other kinds of worries and concerns and true problems and try to get personhood to fix it, it creates more problems.
00:25:17
Speaker 1: Got it. So instead of fighting to get personhood for a river, we could fight for the enforcement of existing water pollution laws because those were actually designed specifically to protect rivers.
00:25:27
Speaker 3: Exactly.
00:25:27
Speaker 2: And the other thing is environmental personhood evolved from the concept of corporate personhood. Remember at the beginning of the episode, I mentioned that 1972 paper by Christopher Stone? His whole thesis was that if personhood can be expanded to include corporations, it should expand further to include nature. Lisa kind of flips that around. She wants us to ask, should we expand personhood anywhere beyond actual people?
00:25:51
Speaker 3: And it's a great question.
00:25:53
Speaker 2: You know, I don't know about you, but I don't love the idea of treating robots or artificial intelligence products like people because they're not people.
00:26:00
Speaker 1: Yeah, I mean, I guess if you start expanding personhood, you can find yourself on this slippery slope pretty fast. That's right.
00:26:06
Speaker 3: And if the slippery slope leads down to a river, you know, think about it.
00:26:09
Speaker 1: You're going in.
00:26:11
Speaker 2: Anyway, the point is, if we care about the environment, perhaps what we should be doing is trying to limit personhood, not expand it.
00:26:19
Speaker 5: I think a really key point, and this is happening in a lot of different places, is to try and overturn this encroaching power of corporate personhood. And it's increase of civil rights. I think there's been a lot of work that has shown that the more corporations have these kinds of powers, the more that they are doing damage to the environment and to other places.
00:26:42
Speaker 1: That makes a lot of sense. Reign in the corporations, doing the polluting, and save the human rights for humans. I've got to say, there's just something delightful about the idea of recognizing forests and rivers as living beings with unique rights, though. Like, to me, that just feels kind of joyous. Oh, I agree.
00:26:57
Speaker 2: And Lisa sees that, too. She actually told me this great story about how Dr. Seuss's book, The Lorax, got tied up in our understanding of environmental personhood. Because it actually came out right around the same time Christopher Stone wrote his landmark paper. You know how it has that line, I speak for the trees, for the trees.
00:27:15
Speaker 3: Have no tongues?
00:27:16
Speaker 1: Yeah, completely. Yeah.
00:27:18
Speaker 2: Apparently some people kind of conflated Stone's paper and the Lorax, which is really funny, but also inspiring, as long as we remember that fiction isn't real life.
00:27:28
Speaker 3: I don't want.
00:27:29
Speaker 5: To deflate that excitement, but I also want to just
make sure we recognize the work it's doing. It's a fantasy. And fantasies can be really productive, right? They give us a kind of imagination of what the world could be. But then you need to say, all right, so what happens when we actually manifest this, when we make this real in the world? What is it actually going to look like? So I would say we have to be careful not to be tempted by the fantasy of the Lorax.
00:28:04
Speaker 2: Anyway, since I was talking to such a highly regarded author and academic about all these weighty matters, I figured we should also take some time to play a silly game.
00:28:14
Speaker 1: Oh, Mary, you know I love this.
00:28:16
Speaker 3: Okay, so it's a game I.
00:28:17
Speaker 2: Invented, and it's called Person Place or Place Place. Want to find out how Lisa did?
00:28:23
Speaker 1: Of course I do.
00:28:25
Speaker 2: I'm going to tell you the names of seven places in the United States. You are going to tell me if that place was named for another place or for a human person, okay? And we're going to start off in my home state of Maine with the city of Calais. Named for a person or named for a place?
00:28:45
Speaker 5: How is Cal spelled?
00:28:46
Speaker 3: C-A-L-A-I-S.
00:28:50
Speaker 5: Oh, I think place. That feels like French, Calais.
00:28:53
Speaker 3: Correct. We just say it wrong or they say it wrong. Who's to say? Very good. All right. So number two is Petersburg, Virginia.
00:29:01
Speaker 5: That feels complicated. It could be St. Petersburg for Russia or it could be, which was also for Peter.
00:29:07
Speaker 1: The Great, right?
00:29:08
Speaker 5: So I don't know how far back you go.
00:29:10
Speaker 3: It's only one degree. I should have clarified that. It's only one degree of naming.
00:29:14
Speaker 2: So it's either named for a place or it's named for a person directly.
00:29:19
Speaker 5: I guess I would say place would be my guess.
00:29:22
Speaker 3: I'm so sorry.
00:29:23
Speaker 2: One of the co-founders of Petersburg, Virginia was Peter Jones. And so they decided to name it Petersburg.
00:29:29
Speaker 5: Would not have guessed that.
00:29:30
Speaker 3: Number three is Bruno, Nebraska. B-R-U-N-O? B-R-U-N-O. I guess.
00:29:40
Speaker 5: I would say person, but I feel like this might be place. But we'll say person.
00:29:44
Speaker 3: Okay.
00:29:44
Speaker 2: It is a place. It is named for Brno in the Czech Republic. A lot of the original settlers were from Moravia. Of course, the city over there is spelled B-R-N-O, which for Americans is difficult. So it got turned into B-R-U-N-O in Nebraska.
00:30:00
Speaker 3: You're doing great.
00:30:01
Speaker 5: Don't worry.
00:30:01
Speaker 2: No, I'm not.
00:30:02
Speaker 3: Yes, you are. Number four is Paris, New York.
00:30:06
Speaker 5: This one feels like place, but I feel these are going to be tricky.
00:30:11
Speaker 1: All right.
00:30:11
Speaker 3: I'll say person. You're correct.
00:30:13
Speaker 2: It was named for a local merchant named
Isaac Paris. I love that it was just a local merchant. It wasn't even someone who founded the town, I don't think. It was just a guy that everyone liked, and his name was Isaac Paris. Number five is Austin, Minnesota.
00:30:26
Speaker 1: Person.
00:30:27
Speaker 5: Person.
00:30:28
Speaker 3: That's correct.
00:30:29
Speaker 2: An early settler named Austin Nichols. And I find that fascinating, kind of like with Petersburg. They used his first name. You know, they didn't use his last name.
00:30:38
Speaker 3: Austin Nichols.
00:30:39
Speaker 1: All right.
00:30:40
Speaker 3: Number six. This is our second to last question. Holland, Massachusetts.
00:30:46
Speaker 5: Place.
00:30:47
Speaker 2: That's a person. It was named for Henry Fox, the first Baron Holland. He was the leader of the British House of Commons in the 1750s. He was best known for corruption and using his political influence to enrich himself.
00:31:01
Speaker 3: And he is memorialized. Good job, Holland, Massachusetts.
00:31:05
Speaker 1: All right.
00:31:05
Speaker 3: And our final one. This one is tricky. Jetto, Pennsylvania. I'll spell it for you. It's J-E-D-D-O, Pennsylvania. Place or person?
00:31:16
Speaker 1: Wow.
00:31:17
Speaker 5: I have no idea what that name could be. Jethro?
00:31:21
Speaker 3: I don't know.
00:31:23
Speaker 1: Jeddo.
00:31:23
Speaker 3: J-E-D-D-O. Yeah, but what it could be.
00:31:27
Speaker 5: I guess I will say place.
00:31:29
Speaker 3: You are correct.
00:31:31
Speaker 2: In fact, Jeddo, Pennsylvania, a tiny borough in the northeastern coal country of Pennsylvania, is named for the city of Tokyo, which was previously Edo, which got anglicized to Jeddo. I went way down a rabbit hole on this little borough. And Apparently, the coal company that founded it used to have business dealings in Japan thanks to our trade treaties in the 1860s and 70s.
00:31:56
Speaker 1: Who knew?
00:31:57
Speaker 5: That's wild.
00:31:59
Speaker 2: Congratulations. You win the part-time genius quiz. I'll get your mailing address and we will send you a prize.
00:32:05
Speaker 3: Thank you. This is so fun.
00:32:09
Speaker 1: That was surprisingly tricky. I know.
00:32:12
Speaker 3: Lisa did great.
00:32:14
Speaker 1: She really did. Well, before we go, I think we should take a minute to talk about where environmental personhood might be headed, which is to space. Now, in 2021, an organization called the Australian Earth Laws Alliance published a document called the Declaration of Rights of the Moon. This affirmed the moon's right to exist unharmed by humans and states that no individual entity or nation can can assert ownership of it. Which, you know, might sound a bit out there, but it's actually an echo of established international law. During the Cold War, the UN drafted something called the Outer Space Treaty, or OST, which says that the moon cannot be claimed by any nation because it belongs to all mankind. Over 100 countries, including the US, signed on this treaty,
which is particularly interesting in this moment as there's a race to put a space station on the moon. But This declaration actually took it a step further by defining the moon as a sovereign entity in its own right.
00:33:12
Speaker 3: So lunar personhood, basically.
00:33:14
Speaker 1: Yeah. But this declaration is just that. It's a declaration written by a small Australian nonprofit and published on their website. It hasn't been ratified by the international community. It doesn't carry any legal weight, but it does remind us that current space law hasn't kept up with what's actually happening in space. The OST says countries can't own the moon, but its language is unclear about ownership of resources extracted from the moon. Because back then, lunar mining wasn't a thing. And these days, we know the moon has helium, rare earth elements, other valuable resources, and many countries are developing the technology to harvest them. In 2020, President Trump signed an executive order stating that the U.S. doesn't view space as the global commons and that Americans have the right to help themselves to extraterrestrial resources. And when you think about the push to colonize Mars, that's just a whole nother can of worms.
00:34:10
Speaker 3: A can of worms in space. Yeah.
00:34:14
Speaker 2: No, you know, I got to say, I started this episode thinking that environmental personhood was pretty straightforward, right? Like that it's this elegant idea answer to some of our most challenging problems. But the more I've learned, the more complicated that answer seems and the problems feel even more urgent.
00:34:31
Speaker 1: I'm totally with you. And of course that happens, right? Like you start looking for answers and then you find even more questions. Like the questions from the Indian government are true. Like who's responsible when the river floods? And in this case, I think we have a lot to gain just from having the conversation because even if environmental personhood isn't a magic bullet, It can show us new ways to look at the world and hopefully inspires us to do what we can to protect the places that we love. Anyway, that is.
00:34:59
Speaker 3: All for today.
00:35:00
Speaker 1: If you'd like to leave a message to help say goodbye to Part-Time Genius, I know we're so sorry to be saying goodbye, give us a call at 302-405-5925 or email us at highgeniuses at gmail.com. We've got six more episodes in the can waiting for you to listen to. And trust me, they are all great. So I really hope you'll join us. Thank you so much to Lisa Serenganian. We'll put a link to her book in the show notes, so please be sure to check that out. And we will be back next week with another new episode. But in the meantime, from Will, Dylan, Gabe, Mary, and myself, thank you so much for listening. Part-Time Genius is a production of Kaleidoscope and iHeartRadio. It is hosted by my good pal, Will Pearson, who I've known for almost three decades now. That is insane to me. I'm the other co-host, Mange Shatikular, a.k.a. Mango. Our producer is Mary Phillips Sandy. She's actually a super producer. I'm going to fix that in post. Our writer is Gabe Lussier, who I've also known for like a decade at this point, maybe more. Dylan Fagan is in the booth. He is always dressed up, always cheering us on, and always ready to hit record and then mix the show after. He does a great job. I also want to shout out the executive producers from iHeart, my good pals Katrina Norvell and Allie Perry. We have social media support from Calypso Rawless. If you like our videos, that is all Calypso's handiwork. For more podcasts from Kaleidoscope and iHeart Radio, visit the iHeart Radio app, Apple Podcasts, or tune in wherever you listen to your favorite shows. That's it from us here at Part-Time Genius. Thank you so much for listening.