TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
WEBVTT
cue-1
00:00:25.540 --> 00:00:29.800
I'm Justin. I'm an academic librarian, and
my pronouns are he and they.
cue-2
00:00:29.800 --> 00:00:33.900
I'm Sadie. I work IT at a public library,
and my pronouns are they/them.
cue-3
00:00:33.900 --> 00:00:38.320
Uh, I'm Jay. I'm a cataloging librarian,
and my pronouns are he/him.
cue-4
00:00:38.320 --> 00:00:41.120
And we have a guest. Would you like to
introduce yourself?
cue-5
00:00:41.120 --> 00:00:45.720
Hi. Yeah. I'm Britt Paris. I'm an
associate professor in the Department of
cue-6
00:00:45.720 --> 00:00:49.130
Library and Information Science at Rutgers
University,
cue-7
00:00:49.760 --> 00:00:51.030
and my pronouns are she/her.
cue-8
00:00:51.660 --> 00:00:54.600
-[cheering]
-Ooh, hilarious.
cue-9
00:00:55.420 --> 00:00:57.660
-[laughs]
-People are tickled by that. I'm never
cue-10
00:00:57.660 --> 00:01:01.160
gonna get rid of it. Jay, Jay always gives
me shit for having my, my soundboard, but
cue-11
00:01:01.160 --> 00:01:02.860
-people do like the-
-The applause is nice
cue-12
00:01:02.860 --> 00:01:04.560
- ... cheers. Okay.
-I like the applause one.
cue-13
00:01:04.560 --> 00:01:08.320
Yeah, but then he gets mad if I just,
like, have to play something like-
cue-14
00:01:08.320 --> 00:01:11.380
And then here's a damn ass fucking gay
damn ass rock.
cue-15
00:01:11.380 --> 00:01:12.300
-[laughs]
-Happy Pride.
cue-16
00:01:13.200 --> 00:01:16.240
-[laughs] Hi, gay.
-[laughs] I forgot to put the hi gay drop.
cue-17
00:01:16.240 --> 00:01:18.500
-We should do that.
-[laughs]
cue-18
00:01:18.500 --> 00:01:20.580
-Oh, well.
-That's needed.
cue-19
00:01:20.580 --> 00:01:22.340
-[laughs]
-We've got, we've got plenty more Pride to
cue-20
00:01:22.340 --> 00:01:25.980
go before... I don't know. What, what
month is next? Lust? I forget.
cue-21
00:01:25.980 --> 00:01:27.140
-Wrath.
-Wrath.
cue-22
00:01:27.140 --> 00:01:31.860
And that's less fun. All right. Well,
Britt, thanks for coming on. I know I
cue-23
00:01:31.860 --> 00:01:37.160
heard you on 404 Media and was like, "This
book sounds amazing because..." Hell
cue-24
00:01:37.160 --> 00:01:37.320
yeah.
cue-25
00:01:38.080 --> 00:01:38.600
-[laughs]
-[laughs]
cue-26
00:01:38.600 --> 00:01:39.580
Booker dog.
cue-27
00:01:40.420 --> 00:01:42.800
Thank- thanks for, thanks for jumping in
there, Britt. Um-
cue-28
00:01:42.800 --> 00:01:45.440
-[laughs]
-[laughs] Who was that? Sadie, was that
cue-29
00:01:45.440 --> 00:01:48.100
-your dog? [laughs]
-[laughs]
cue-30
00:01:48.100 --> 00:01:54.140
I, I heard you talking about co-ops, and
my grandfather worked for the REA for his
cue-31
00:01:54.140 --> 00:01:58.280
entire adult life and made a, a pretty
good living out of it. And so
cue-32
00:01:59.220 --> 00:02:03.720
I really wanted to hear more about, like,
the way you thought about internet
cue-33
00:02:03.720 --> 00:02:06.300
infrastructure, and particularly co-ops.
But
cue-34
00:02:07.020 --> 00:02:13.520
for people who aren't aware, the, the book
Load full transcript
is Radical Infrastructure. Hang on, let
cue-35
00:02:13.520 --> 00:02:17.740
me pull the full title. Radical
Infrastructure: Imagining the Internet
cue-36
00:02:17.740 --> 00:02:22.780
From the Ground Up. Uh, it's available
open access, so you can check it out, and
cue-37
00:02:22.840 --> 00:02:29.300
encourage your library to buy a print copy
'cause print's great. Um, but the thing
cue-38
00:02:29.300 --> 00:02:34.240
that I guess to get us started to talk
about infrastructure is what is
cue-39
00:02:34.240 --> 00:02:38.720
infrastructure? 'Cause you do use a very
specific definition in the book. And why
cue-40
00:02:38.720 --> 00:02:43.000
-should librarians care about it?
-Yeah. I mean, inc- infrastructure can mean
cue-41
00:02:43.000 --> 00:02:49.380
a lot of things, and increasingly people
use it to talk about anything, right?
cue-42
00:02:50.220 --> 00:02:57.100
But I draw from the science and technology
studies definition, which
cue-43
00:02:57.100 --> 00:03:02.240
is, you know, it sort of has a very
specific sociotechnical meaning, and it's
cue-44
00:03:02.240 --> 00:03:09.180
really focused on how people engage in
social practices with material stuff
cue-45
00:03:09.180 --> 00:03:15.800
that enable resources to be shared within
systems or within sort of networked,
cue-46
00:03:15.800 --> 00:03:17.480
you know, assemblages.
cue-47
00:03:18.120 --> 00:03:18.500
So
cue-48
00:03:19.180 --> 00:03:23.820
in the book, I talk about internet
infrastructure, but it's really about how
cue-49
00:03:23.820 --> 00:03:29.700
technology intersects with all types of
infrastructural concerns and how these
cue-50
00:03:29.700 --> 00:03:34.960
infrastructural concerns are really deeply
intertwined with some of the most, you
cue-51
00:03:34.960 --> 00:03:39.540
know, serious and pressing crises of our
time. And it also talks about how these
cue-52
00:03:39.540 --> 00:03:43.940
infrastructural concerns, as they engage
with technology, are not inevitable,
cue-53
00:03:43.940 --> 00:03:47.940
they're not neutral, but rather they're
material. There's stuff in the world. They
cue-54
00:03:47.940 --> 00:03:54.720
necessarily entail material things in the
world. They run on fuel. They're made of
cue-55
00:03:54.720 --> 00:03:59.020
minerals. They're made up of people's
labor, people's social practices with
cue-56
00:03:59.020 --> 00:04:04.620
these material, you know, arrangements.
And so I argue that they can be sites of
cue-57
00:04:04.620 --> 00:04:08.980
struggle. Because they are material and
because people are engaging with them,
cue-58
00:04:08.980 --> 00:04:12.440
they can be, they can be engaged
politically, and they are. And that's what
cue-59
00:04:12.440 --> 00:04:13.960
I hope to, you know,
cue-60
00:04:14.580 --> 00:04:18.820
surface in this book is some examples of
where people are engaging some of these
cue-61
00:04:18.820 --> 00:04:20.340
infrastructural concerns
cue-62
00:04:21.060 --> 00:04:24.680
-materially and politically.
-Right. And you talk
about... I, and you
cue-63
00:04:24.680 --> 00:04:31.260
work in an iSchool, so is something that
you talk to library science students
cue-64
00:04:31.260 --> 00:04:35.580
about, infrastructure? Like, what's the
context of in your teaching?
cue-65
00:04:35.580 --> 00:04:38.920
Yeah. Yeah. That was the second part of
your question that I didn't answer just
cue-66
00:04:38.920 --> 00:04:39.920
-now.
-Oh, it's totally fine.
cue-67
00:04:39.920 --> 00:04:42.080
-[laughs]
-I should, I should only ask one part... I
cue-68
00:04:42.080 --> 00:04:43.780
shouldn't ask two-part questions. Bad
interviewer.
cue-69
00:04:43.780 --> 00:04:48.980
Well, it's, it's good. I should be able to
hold more than one question in my head.
cue-70
00:04:48.980 --> 00:04:50.039
-Um-
-You can
cue-71
00:04:50.039 --> 00:04:51.480
-... hopefully.
-[laughs]
cue-72
00:04:51.480 --> 00:04:54.690
I should be able to. Am I able to? I don't
know. But,
cue-73
00:04:55.440 --> 00:04:57.880
so I try to
cue-74
00:04:58.540 --> 00:05:02.700
teach all of my master's students or
engage with, engage them with this concept
cue-75
00:05:02.700 --> 00:05:07.980
of infrastructure because it allows us a
lot of different entry points to
cue-76
00:05:07.980 --> 00:05:11.940
understand a lot of these, like, very
seemingly complicated, like,
cue-77
00:05:11.940 --> 00:05:18.640
sociotechnical processes and artifacts
and, you know, practices as they engage
cue-78
00:05:18.640 --> 00:05:22.300
with political life or as they sort of
intervene and intertwine with political
cue-79
00:05:22.300 --> 00:05:22.880
life. So
cue-80
00:05:23.860 --> 00:05:27.640
this is something that I have a lot of
librarians that I teach. I have a lot of
cue-81
00:05:27.640 --> 00:05:31.280
archivists, museum studies people, and IT
professionals
cue-82
00:05:31.940 --> 00:05:38.160
who really appreciate understanding things
infrastructurally. I mean, you know, in a
cue-83
00:05:38.160 --> 00:05:41.440
lot of ways you can think about it, you
know, that are sort of similar. Like, you
cue-84
00:05:41.440 --> 00:05:46.340
can think about it as, like, sort of a, an
information ecology or sort of an ecology
cue-85
00:05:46.340 --> 00:05:51.480
of, you know, how people interact with
these, you know, knowledge practices and,
cue-86
00:05:51.480 --> 00:05:55.580
you know, knowledge production n-
materials, et cetera. Or you can think
cue-87
00:05:55.580 --> 00:06:00.360
about it in terms of, like, you know, a
complex sort of systems theory
cue-88
00:06:01.108 --> 00:06:04.848
You know, you can sort of think about it
in that way. But I find grounding it
cue-89
00:06:04.848 --> 00:06:08.748
within these concepts of infrastructure
can be really helpful to students, not
cue-90
00:06:08.748 --> 00:06:13.308
only to, you know, it grounds them in
their own material practice at work, and a
cue-91
00:06:13.308 --> 00:06:17.048
lot of my students are, you know,
master's students who are working and have
cue-92
00:06:17.048 --> 00:06:20.788
a lot of examples of stuff that is
happening at work, and they're like, "What
cue-93
00:06:20.788 --> 00:06:27.667
the heck is this?" Like, it seems weird.
I don't necessarily have the tools that I
cue-94
00:06:27.668 --> 00:06:32.068
need to push back in the way that I feel
like is right, but I'm interested in
cue-95
00:06:32.068 --> 00:06:36.848
learning how. So you know, talking about
things in terms of infrastructure,
cue-96
00:06:36.848 --> 00:06:40.868
students have found that really helpful.
And you know, I think it makes a lot of
cue-97
00:06:40.868 --> 00:06:45.368
sense to me, and this is the way that I
sort of think about infrastructure as it
cue-98
00:06:45.368 --> 00:06:49.908
relates to information professionals
maybe, is that, you know, librarians in
cue-99
00:06:49.908 --> 00:06:56.708
particular I think should care because at
once they are workers who are engaging
cue-100
00:06:56.708 --> 00:07:02.968
with these technologies, they are policy
enactors, they are technicians, they're
cue-101
00:07:02.968 --> 00:07:09.128
partners with patrons that enable the
massive sharing of resources in some sort
cue-102
00:07:09.128 --> 00:07:13.848
of networked system, whether that's, you
know, a network of libraries or within,
cue-103
00:07:13.848 --> 00:07:19.587
you know, a consortium of, of academic
libraries or something like that. So I
cue-104
00:07:19.588 --> 00:07:25.468
think, you know, librarians in particular
not only enable these infrastructures of
cue-105
00:07:25.468 --> 00:07:31.578
knowledge distribution and production, but
also they engage deeply in
cue-106
00:07:31.578 --> 00:07:36.488
infrastructures of care and thinking
about, you know, how to do all of this
cue-107
00:07:36.488 --> 00:07:40.808
stuff and all this knowledge distribution
and production and, you know,
cue-108
00:07:40.808 --> 00:07:47.648
classification, whatever, in ways that,
you know, honors the experiences and
cue-109
00:07:47.648 --> 00:07:51.428
desires of people that they're engaging
with or who will engage with these
cue-110
00:07:51.428 --> 00:07:54.968
-materials.
-Yeah. There's definitely that, that higher
cue-111
00:07:54.968 --> 00:08:00.728
layer of it where you're talking about,
like, the cultural practices. I think
cue-112
00:08:00.728 --> 00:08:06.028
there's also the, the fact that so much
probably in people's practice, in
cue-113
00:08:06.028 --> 00:08:09.987
particularly in your students' practice,
is they're going to go into a library
cue-114
00:08:09.988 --> 00:08:13.788
ecosystem that's almost... That's entirely
dominated by cloud computing.
cue-115
00:08:13.788 --> 00:08:16.748
-Mm-hmm.
-And are going to have to deal with, like,
cue-116
00:08:16.748 --> 00:08:23.388
material realities of the cost of
processing data or, you know, if AI has
cue-117
00:08:23.388 --> 00:08:27.028
been shoehorned into half of the products
that we buy from our vendors, and the
cue-118
00:08:27.028 --> 00:08:31.288
costs of that are being passed on to
libraries.
And like I, you know, I, I
cue-119
00:08:31.288 --> 00:08:35.388
fight with Alma every single day, like Ex
Libris Alma, which is entirely cloud-based
cue-120
00:08:35.388 --> 00:08:39.788
and was, like, kind of its argument. And
I just have to sit there and go, like, is
cue-121
00:08:39.788 --> 00:08:43.388
the data, like, trying to get over here
from Israel? Like, why is it going so
cue-122
00:08:43.388 --> 00:08:47.548
slow? Why is it taking forever for this
thing to load? And, and because it's all
cue-123
00:08:47.548 --> 00:08:50.708
cloud computing, it's running all these
different processes, and it takes, like,
cue-124
00:08:50.708 --> 00:08:55.268
you know, 20 years for anything to, to run
on it because it's such a complex piece
cue-125
00:08:55.268 --> 00:08:56.468
-of software.
-Yeah.
cue-126
00:08:56.468 --> 00:09:02.427
I mean, I, I think vendors kind of rely on
the fact, and, and admin as well, that,
cue-127
00:09:02.428 --> 00:09:07.528
like, librarians don't know IT and tech
things. We don't understand
cue-128
00:09:07.528 --> 00:09:11.548
infrastructure, and therefore we have to
use their products, right? Or, like, we're
cue-129
00:09:11.548 --> 00:09:15.948
not taught these things, so how can...
We're too stupid to know, to understand,
cue-130
00:09:15.948 --> 00:09:20.828
and so we have to buy Ex Libris to have
this one-stop shop for, for everything and
cue-131
00:09:20.828 --> 00:09:22.688
not understand how everything's
cue-132
00:09:23.428 --> 00:09:27.028
connected. I used to, like, tell faculty
this when I was, like, teaching them about
cue-133
00:09:27.028 --> 00:09:30.748
how to actually talk to their students
about AI. It's like they make it sound
cue-134
00:09:30.748 --> 00:09:34.028
more complicated than it is so that you
think it's too difficult for you to
cue-135
00:09:34.028 --> 00:09:36.868
understand, and so therefore you have to
trust them.
cue-136
00:09:36.868 --> 00:09:40.248
You have to trust them, and how could you
possibly argue for pushing back on
cue-137
00:09:40.248 --> 00:09:43.008
-anything, right? Because you don't know-
-You're just a stupid little librarian.
cue-138
00:09:43.008 --> 00:09:43.648
-Right. Yeah.
-Yeah.
cue-139
00:09:43.648 --> 00:09:49.348
It's sort of like epistemic cudgel of,
like, necessary technical knowledge to,
cue-140
00:09:49.348 --> 00:09:53.748
you know, know how a technology is or
isn't helping you is such-
cue-141
00:09:53.748 --> 00:09:55.668
-Yeah
-... I'm so sick of it.
cue-142
00:09:55.668 --> 00:09:55.908
Yeah.
cue-143
00:09:56.508 --> 00:10:01.168
So what I really like about the book is
that you're coming at it directly from a
cue-144
00:10:01.168 --> 00:10:05.728
historical materialist perspective, and
I'm trained as a historian, so that's
cue-145
00:10:05.728 --> 00:10:09.828
something I, you know, had to deal with a
lot in graduate school, which is do a lot
cue-146
00:10:09.828 --> 00:10:15.328
of historiography and who's dominated, you
know, the way we talk about history more
cue-147
00:10:15.328 --> 00:10:20.328
than Marx, right? So when you were... When
you started, like, approaching this topic
cue-148
00:10:20.328 --> 00:10:22.557
of internet infrastructure, how,
cue-149
00:10:23.288 --> 00:10:27.688
how did the book come about? 'Cause I can
see how it got longer from the original
cue-150
00:10:27.688 --> 00:10:32.228
article. But, like, what was the original
process of, like, going from the idea to
cue-151
00:10:32.228 --> 00:10:35.507
I've got to write a whole book about this,
and I've got to explicitly make it
cue-152
00:10:35.508 --> 00:10:38.828
historical materialist in, in the way I'm
gonna talk about it, and you really dive
cue-153
00:10:38.828 --> 00:10:42.548
-into it.
-Yeah. So I will say this. I had... I've
cue-154
00:10:42.548 --> 00:10:46.548
been... Come to find out, I've been
working on this who- book my whole life,
cue-155
00:10:46.548 --> 00:10:49.158
so that helps, I think, a little bit.
[laughs]
cue-156
00:10:49.158 --> 00:10:53.068
-Yeah.
-But the paper, the Numidian Society paper,
cue-157
00:10:53.068 --> 00:10:59.988
came about after I had already submitted
my book proposal for this. But rather, you
cue-158
00:10:59.988 --> 00:11:04.768
know, it was sort of a way to, to press
it, you know, presage the book and, you
cue-159
00:11:04.768 --> 00:11:09.508
know, sort of plant my flag in the ground.
I don't like... I should not use that
cue-160
00:11:09.508 --> 00:11:14.688
terminology. But you know, like, to sort
of stake the claim as this topic as my own
cue-161
00:11:14.688 --> 00:11:16.788
or whatever. But so,
cue-162
00:11:17.388 --> 00:11:22.548
you know, I've been in- involved with
cooperative infrastructure my whole life.
cue-163
00:11:22.548 --> 00:11:26.888
I grew up in a super rural area. All we,
all of our utilities were all
cue-164
00:11:26.888 --> 00:11:31.388
cooperatives. I went to telephone
cooperative meetings with my grandma when
cue-165
00:11:31.388 --> 00:11:36.738
I was little. It's where I think I got my
penchant for sitting in long, boring
cue-166
00:11:36.738 --> 00:11:41.208
meetings where people mostly argue about
what their values are, right? That comes
cue-167
00:11:41.208 --> 00:11:46.008
in pretty handy in, like, socialist and,
you know, labor organizing and all the
cue-168
00:11:46.008 --> 00:11:52.528
things I'm involved with. But in the early
2000s then, this local telephone
cue-169
00:11:52.528 --> 00:11:56.588
cooperative turned into a co-
telecommunications cooperative, and one of
cue-170
00:11:56.588 --> 00:12:02.108
the first projects that they engaged in
was making this thing called the ITV
cue-171
00:12:02.108 --> 00:12:08.184
Classroom for all of us far-flung rural
kids to get college credit- By
cue-172
00:12:08.184 --> 00:12:13.594
connecting all of these far-frung-flung
rural schools into a classroom where there
cue-173
00:12:13.594 --> 00:12:20.244
was a TV, a teacher from, you know,
anywhere from like 10 to 100 miles away
cue-174
00:12:20.244 --> 00:12:24.864
would teach us and get like... We could
get college credit for extremely low
cue-175
00:12:24.864 --> 00:12:28.924
prices or for free. And that was something
that, you know, happened in one of those
cue-176
00:12:28.924 --> 00:12:33.643
long, boring meetings. That's what they
decided to do. I got 25 hour- 25 credit
cue-177
00:12:33.644 --> 00:12:39.384
hours out of the way for, not for free,
but for very low cost because that's how
cue-178
00:12:39.384 --> 00:12:43.983
they offered it. So that happened, and
then, you know, I sort of tr-
cue-179
00:12:44.624 --> 00:12:49.364
my trajectory through grad school, I was
very interested in infrastructure and
cue-180
00:12:49.364 --> 00:12:55.524
internet protocols and how the internet
came to be and that whole history, as well
cue-181
00:12:55.524 --> 00:13:01.484
as, you know, how various technological
infrastructure is intertwined and baked
cue-182
00:13:01.484 --> 00:13:07.844
into processes of global imperialism and
manifest destiny, some of which makes it
cue-183
00:13:07.844 --> 00:13:14.804
into the book. But in 2020, I was thinking
back to this ITV classroom that I had
cue-184
00:13:14.804 --> 00:13:19.014
in high school because I was teaching
students over Zoom for the first time and
cue-185
00:13:19.014 --> 00:13:24.184
had no experience teaching anybody over
Zoom. So I was thinking of how this, you
cue-186
00:13:24.184 --> 00:13:28.484
know, wonderful professor or wonderful
teacher, Mrs. Branstetter, used to teach
cue-187
00:13:28.484 --> 00:13:32.884
us college trigonometry, and I was sort of
trying to channel her as I was, like,
cue-188
00:13:32.884 --> 00:13:37.664
teaching my students over Zoom in 2020 and
thinking about how the cooperative, you
cue-189
00:13:37.664 --> 00:13:42.444
know, built that up for us and also
thinking about, you know, how I felt for
cue-190
00:13:42.444 --> 00:13:46.444
my own students, my colleagues, and, you
know, everybody across the world as the
cue-191
00:13:46.444 --> 00:13:51.624
world, you know, moved online in the
pandemic. You know, surveillance,
cue-192
00:13:51.624 --> 00:13:57.604
co-optation, commodification just became,
you know, heavily entrenched at that time,
cue-193
00:13:57.604 --> 00:14:03.204
and vendors started charging an arm and a
leg for all of these products that they
cue-194
00:14:03.204 --> 00:14:08.364
had, you know, offered for low cost or
even for free before. And so, you know,
cue-195
00:14:08.364 --> 00:14:12.804
this was all happening as well as I was
Zooming in a 400-square-foot apartment in
cue-196
00:14:12.804 --> 00:14:13.834
New York City [chuckles]
cue-197
00:14:14.684 --> 00:14:19.964
and paying out the nose for bad internet,
and meanwhile, my dad in rural Missouri
cue-198
00:14:19.964 --> 00:14:23.644
pays very little money for the fastest
internet I've ever seen in my life, and
cue-199
00:14:23.644 --> 00:14:28.444
I've lived in, you know, big cities on the
East Coast and West Coast. So it
was
cue-200
00:14:28.444 --> 00:14:34.844
really in 2020 that I got this idea for
this book, but it took a while to actually
cue-201
00:14:34.844 --> 00:14:37.284
mobilize and get everything into order
and,
cue-202
00:14:37.904 --> 00:14:42.064
you know, have this book come out. But,
but yeah, that's, that's sort of where it
cue-203
00:14:42.064 --> 00:14:46.683
came from. A lot of people ask me, you
know, "Oh, how did you select these
cue-204
00:14:46.684 --> 00:14:51.584
sites?" Or like, I was like, "Just by
being interested in this topic for 25
cue-205
00:14:51.584 --> 00:14:54.584
-years." I don't know. [chuckles]
-Yeah, you mentioned a lot of really
cue-206
00:14:54.584 --> 00:14:58.183
interesting things that didn't make it
into the book in, in, in either like the
cue-207
00:14:58.184 --> 00:15:02.704
forward or the introduction, and each one
of them could easily be expand- Like, just
cue-208
00:15:02.704 --> 00:15:07.824
the list of things you put could easily
be like the, the main chapters of another
cue-209
00:15:07.824 --> 00:15:11.224
-book.
-Yeah, I think so. And also, like, each of
cue-210
00:15:11.224 --> 00:15:14.404
the chapters in this book, like the
empirical chapters when I'm sort of
cue-211
00:15:14.404 --> 00:15:18.604
stepping through all of these histories
and these intertwined infrastructural
cue-212
00:15:18.604 --> 00:15:24.604
concerns with the cases, each of those
chapters could also be a book. There's a
cue-213
00:15:24.604 --> 00:15:26.804
lot that I left out of those that,
cue-214
00:15:27.564 --> 00:15:31.364
you know, maybe someday I'll, I'll pick
back up on, especially as, you know, time
cue-215
00:15:31.364 --> 00:15:36.884
moves forward and we can get a little bit
more of a historical sense as to what this
cue-216
00:15:36.884 --> 00:15:41.284
current moment and the, you know,
immediately preceding moment, how that's
cue-217
00:15:41.284 --> 00:15:46.274
-going to shape the future, or if it will.
-Yeah, I was reading... Obviously, we're
cue-218
00:15:46.274 --> 00:15:52.844
recording right before the big SpaceX IPO
that's, you know, hoping to funnel huge
cue-219
00:15:52.844 --> 00:15:58.524
amounts of money out of index funds and,
and things into this huge speculative
cue-220
00:15:58.524 --> 00:16:03.144
Muskism thing. Um, like what is M- Like
someone was writing today on like Blaming
cue-221
00:16:03.144 --> 00:16:07.004
Hydra, which was like, "What actually is
this Muskism thing? Is it something that
cue-222
00:16:07.004 --> 00:16:12.084
would even survive him? Is it even
comparable to Fordism or any... Or is it
cue-223
00:16:12.084 --> 00:16:17.744
much more like just the, the, the
buffoonery has like increased with the
cue-224
00:16:17.744 --> 00:16:23.843
material wealth?" It's like you really
have to just kinda sit on tenterhooks and
cue-225
00:16:23.843 --> 00:16:28.584
just go, "What's gonna happen?" Like,
what's... Is it going to be spectacular,
cue-226
00:16:28.584 --> 00:16:34.004
or is it going to
be just really slow
decline? Like, what on Earth? Like, it's
cue-227
00:16:34.004 --> 00:16:37.244
really hard to imagine what the next
year's gonna be like.
cue-228
00:16:37.244 --> 00:16:43.344
Yeah. Yeah. And Ben Tarnoff and Quinn, now
I'm alwa- I'm always saying his last name
cue-229
00:16:43.344 --> 00:16:47.764
wrong, Slo- Slovidien? I don't know if
I'm saying it right. They have that book
cue-230
00:16:47.764 --> 00:16:49.104
-on Muskism.
-I-
cue-231
00:16:49.104 --> 00:16:53.964
It's really good. But yeah, I mean, I
don't know. In this book, I argue, and
cue-232
00:16:53.964 --> 00:17:00.964
this is not a new argument or a unique
argument, but you know, we really see, you
cue-233
00:17:00.964 --> 00:17:06.094
know, Musk is Trump, you know, all of
these sort of imaginaries that are named
cue-234
00:17:06.094 --> 00:17:12.344
after guys, number one, about like how
our, you know, technological and, you
cue-235
00:17:12.344 --> 00:17:16.284
know, political world should and can
proceed.
cue-236
00:17:16.994 --> 00:17:21.384
It's a lot like the end of the robber
baron era where, you know, you had these
cue-237
00:17:21.384 --> 00:17:26.864
buffoons and these fools doing similar
types of things, and they all, you know,
cue-238
00:17:26.864 --> 00:17:31.744
ended up going bust, but some of that
material, some of the material guts were
cue-239
00:17:31.744 --> 00:17:35.564
still there and, you know, people did
stuff with them afterwards. That being
cue-240
00:17:35.564 --> 00:17:40.064
said, you know, all of these people wanna,
you know, engage in manifest destiny to
cue-241
00:17:40.064 --> 00:17:45.044
the stars, or they want to build bunkers
in the Honduras or Hawaii
cue-242
00:17:45.824 --> 00:17:50.864
while they scam us all out of our last
dollar by offering products that are, you
cue-243
00:17:50.864 --> 00:17:56.064
know, really just vaporware. And so yeah,
you wonder what it's gonna look like in a
cue-244
00:17:56.064 --> 00:17:59.144
year or so. You wonder what it's gonna
look, look like in five years.
cue-245
00:17:59.804 --> 00:18:04.544
It's hard to say. You know, you can use
history to sort of project into the
cue-246
00:18:04.544 --> 00:18:08.004
future, but it's always a little different
than you might imagine.
cue-247
00:18:08.004 --> 00:18:12.524
Honestly, it's one of the episodes I'm
working on right now is just going through
cue-248
00:18:12.524 --> 00:18:18.316
the Carnegie libraries and that whole
Robert Baron era like What was his
cue-249
00:18:18.316 --> 00:18:24.436
philanthropy about? What was the idea of
s- like welding himself
cue-250
00:18:24.436 --> 00:18:29.956
to the public in a way of saying like,
"I'll give you this grant, but you have to
cue-251
00:18:29.956 --> 00:18:33.576
then take on the maintenance. You have to
then take on the hiring,"
cue-252
00:18:34.396 --> 00:18:39.156
creating these like very specific roles,
the way he talks about wealth and like
cue-253
00:18:39.156 --> 00:18:41.236
his, his extreme anti-unionism.
cue-254
00:18:42.036 --> 00:18:47.306
And so I really want to actually talk a-
yeah, I love th- talking about something
cue-255
00:18:47.306 --> 00:18:50.276
that libraries are like, "Isn't this
great? You know, we got a Carnegie
cue-256
00:18:50.276 --> 00:18:54.376
Library." And I love just going, "Eh, he
sucks." It's, it's that post about, um-
cue-257
00:18:54.376 --> 00:18:59.316
-Get the Money Library Project.
-Yeah. That too. I mean, honestly, I mean,
cue-258
00:18:59.316 --> 00:19:05.026
who... Also, so many things like the Gates
Foundation was up to until they decided,
cue-259
00:19:05.026 --> 00:19:08.296
"Actually, we're not... We don't give away
money anymore. We're just gonna hoard it
cue-260
00:19:08.296 --> 00:19:10.266
in a big pile and sit on it," which is,
cue-261
00:19:11.156 --> 00:19:14.956
again, that, that sort of bunker-ism
approach to the economy. But yeah.
cue-262
00:19:15.716 --> 00:19:19.456
Anyway, I'm getting off topic. If I don't,
this is what the notes are for. Um,
cue-263
00:19:20.176 --> 00:19:20.416
so
cue-264
00:19:21.076 --> 00:19:26.906
you talk about the stack, and I think you
rightly say that a lot of the times when
cue-265
00:19:26.906 --> 00:19:30.956
we talk about the stack, we're talking
kind of about the application layer, the
cue-266
00:19:30.956 --> 00:19:36.436
higher layer of I- uh, probably like ISP
and higher. Like, everyone considers the
cue-267
00:19:36.436 --> 00:19:41.756
ISP as kind of the base even though
everyone understands there's cables and
cue-268
00:19:41.756 --> 00:19:45.296
there's electricity and there's data
centers, but everyone kind of thinks like,
cue-269
00:19:45.296 --> 00:19:47.336
"Oh, the ISP, that's the internet."
cue-270
00:19:48.196 --> 00:19:53.436
So if you were to try and like paint a, a
mental picture of like what is the
cue-271
00:19:53.436 --> 00:19:59.036
internet from like this actual structural
cha- like approach, which... where would
cue-272
00:19:59.036 --> 00:20:02.036
you start talking about it, building a
mental picture?
cue-273
00:20:02.036 --> 00:20:06.836
Well, I always start... I mean, the title,
subtitle is Imagining the Internet From
cue-274
00:20:06.896 --> 00:20:08.736
-the Ground Up. So-
-Mm-hmm
cue-275
00:20:08.736 --> 00:20:13.616
... you know, and I think different times
in this book, I talk about digging into
cue-276
00:20:13.616 --> 00:20:19.956
the ground to figure out, you know, what
these buried bones of the internet look
cue-277
00:20:19.956 --> 00:20:24.776
like, what they are, where they come from,
you know, how they shape and constrain
cue-278
00:20:24.776 --> 00:20:25.575
what is possible.
cue-279
00:20:26.196 --> 00:20:30.236
So, you know, that's, that's the data link
layer. That's the fiber stuff that's
cue-280
00:20:30.236 --> 00:20:35.175
buried deep underground or, you know,
sometimes existing cables, you'll see it
cue-281
00:20:35.176 --> 00:20:40.136
hanging up, you know, on, on telephone
poles. But so that's
where I look at it,
cue-282
00:20:40.136 --> 00:20:46.136
and that's sort of the point of departure
for this book. I start out with, you know,
cue-283
00:20:46.136 --> 00:20:50.856
after the sort of internet history and
how it came to be chapter, I talk about
cue-284
00:20:50.856 --> 00:20:55.836
like, okay, so then the internet is
constructed historically, but also like
cue-285
00:20:55.836 --> 00:21:01.036
here is the material, like how the
material has come to be, you know, buried
cue-286
00:21:01.036 --> 00:21:05.436
into the ground and all of the
difficulties that exist around... Even
cue-287
00:21:05.436 --> 00:21:10.176
that, right? The, you know, the sort of
taken for granted material practice of
cue-288
00:21:10.176 --> 00:21:15.536
like burying fiber, where the fiber comes
from, how it's made, how it gets there,
cue-289
00:21:15.536 --> 00:21:20.256
you know, how they make a decision on
where it's going to be laid. All of these
cue-290
00:21:20.256 --> 00:21:23.696
have a lot to do with what is possible
with the internet. So that's where, that's
cue-291
00:21:23.696 --> 00:21:28.856
where I start, and that's where I like to
start with this book. But I also wanna
cue-292
00:21:28.856 --> 00:21:34.776
highlight that, you know, so I give this,
you know, sort of hourglass shape of, you
cue-293
00:21:34.776 --> 00:21:39.736
know, the, the International Standards
Organization protocol logical stack for
cue-294
00:21:39.736 --> 00:21:44.256
the internet. So the data link layer is at
the bottom. The narrow, they call it the
cue-295
00:21:44.256 --> 00:21:50.276
narrow waist of the hourglass figure is
where the ISPs, you know, route and
cue-296
00:21:50.276 --> 00:21:56.056
transmit data through the internet up to,
you know, users at the application layer.
cue-297
00:21:56.056 --> 00:22:00.336
So, you know, you can think of it as like
a bow tie on its, on its side or as an
cue-298
00:22:00.336 --> 00:22:05.985
hourglass. But I wanna highlight also
that, you know, I use this protocol
cue-299
00:22:05.985 --> 00:22:12.366
logical stack, the ISO stack, to talk
about, you know, the various concerns that
cue-300
00:22:12.366 --> 00:22:17.396
exist and the different infrastructural
layers in the chapter. But really the book
cue-301
00:22:17.396 --> 00:22:23.256
highlights that the people and the
organizations involved in these chapters
cue-302
00:22:23.256 --> 00:22:28.576
have concerns that sort of flow up and
down this protocol logical stack. And the
cue-303
00:22:28.576 --> 00:22:35.316
layers aren't necessarily distinct in
social practice or political practice or
cue-304
00:22:35.316 --> 00:22:39.276
even technical practice, but rather
there's sort of a coordinated whole that
cue-305
00:22:39.276 --> 00:22:46.236
have to exist and function for the
internet to, you know, be a, be anything
cue-306
00:22:46.236 --> 00:22:49.916
at all. [chuckles] When people have to
grapple with all of these sort of
cue-307
00:22:49.916 --> 00:22:53.416
infrastructural layers in some more than
in part.
cue-308
00:22:53.416 --> 00:22:57.436
I opened up the notes and saw that diagram
and was like, "Oh, we're getting into the
cue-309
00:22:57.436 --> 00:23:03.016
OS, uh, the OSI model today. That's
interesting." I mean, a lot of it is...
cue-310
00:23:03.016 --> 00:23:08.476
That reflects my, like, experience in
working in IT, having come... in libraries
cue-311
00:23:08.476 --> 00:23:13.536
and having come from a customer service
background is, yeah, a lot of people don't
cue-312
00:23:13.536 --> 00:23:17.116
think about the fact that the internet is
buried cables. I think I actually told
cue-313
00:23:17.116 --> 00:23:20.956
somebody, and this was the first time they
had actually heard it, was the cloud is
cue-314
00:23:20.956 --> 00:23:24.116
just somebody else's computer. They were
like, "Oh, I've never actually really
cue-315
00:23:24.116 --> 00:23:28.976
thought about that." I was like, "It's,
it's very true." And it's really
cue-316
00:23:28.976 --> 00:23:33.676
interesting sometimes the way that local
politics will sort of
cue-317
00:23:34.416 --> 00:23:38.876
guide some of these things, which I think
a lot of people don't think about, the
cue-318
00:23:38.876 --> 00:23:43.916
politicalness of where you can bury a
cable or what building and what permits
cue-319
00:23:43.916 --> 00:23:48.626
you need to feed that cable into like a
building. So having been through a couple
cue-320
00:23:48.626 --> 00:23:54.056
of different library systems and had seen
that infrastructure work of just how to
cue-321
00:23:54.056 --> 00:23:58.406
get the base fibers, the cables actually
into a building is,
cue-322
00:23:59.156 --> 00:24:04.876
is really buried in a lot of local, like
hyper-local politics and also just like
cue-323
00:24:04.876 --> 00:24:08.576
sort of going out from there. Before I
worked at my current library, I worked at
cue-324
00:24:08.576 --> 00:24:15.576
a very rural library system in a pretty
physically remote location. And for a very
cue-325
00:24:15.576 --> 00:24:20.612
long time, it... the only cable that was
out there, it was a T1 line So the whole
cue-326
00:24:20.612 --> 00:24:26.572
geographical area was choked by this one
T1 line, and a lot of the problems we ran
cue-327
00:24:26.572 --> 00:24:30.672
into were like, nobody wants to come out
here and, and bother running a cable
cue-328
00:24:30.672 --> 00:24:35.052
because it's just too far away. It's just
there's too many physical obsta- like
cue-329
00:24:35.052 --> 00:24:40.912
geographical obstacles in the way to get
fiber out here. So no matter what we could
cue-330
00:24:40.912 --> 00:24:46.392
do as a library, it was never going to
chip away at this infrastructure that
cue-331
00:24:46.392 --> 00:24:51.411
needed to be built to even reach us. So...
And I mean, that sounds like a lot with
cue-332
00:24:51.411 --> 00:24:55.992
your experience with the whole ITV thing
in rural, was it Minnesota?
cue-333
00:24:55.992 -->
00:24:57.972
-Missouri, yeah.
-Missouri, yeah.
cue-334
00:24:58.832 --> 00:25:04.162
Yeah, and I mean, so for them, people
don't wanna build out because everything's
cue-335
00:25:04.162 --> 00:25:08.632
so far-flung that it costs, you know, so
much money for this material to begin
cue-336
00:25:08.632 --> 00:25:12.812
with, and the fact that you're only gonna
reach like, you know, at a high school,
cue-337
00:25:12.812 --> 00:25:16.072
like, so in that example, like at our high
school, like 400 students,
cue-338
00:25:16.672 --> 00:25:21.012
and it would take, you know, a massive
amount of money and resources to build,
cue-339
00:25:21.012 --> 00:25:24.812
most people would say, you know, "No,
we're not gonna do that." But, you know,
cue-340
00:25:24.812 --> 00:25:30.992
the, the local sort of community-based
governance systems made that a priority.
cue-341
00:25:30.992 --> 00:25:35.852
You know, people were happy to, to, to
mobilize whatever profits were made to
cue-342
00:25:35.852 --> 00:25:40.992
that end. But yeah, I mean, provision of
the internet is a problem in rural areas
cue-343
00:25:40.992 --> 00:25:46.012
as well as urban areas, and that's what
this book really tries to highlight is
cue-344
00:25:46.012 --> 00:25:51.411
that, you know, we often think of
cooperatives or, you know, the lack of
cue-345
00:25:51.412 --> 00:25:56.332
access is primarily a rural phenomenon,
but it's also, you know, heavily an, you
cue-346
00:25:56.332 --> 00:26:01.092
know, an urban phenomenon as well, and
that it exists for people in cities
cue-347
00:26:01.092 --> 00:26:05.631
similarly, right? I was going somewhere
with that, but I've forgotten. [laughs] I
cue-348
00:26:05.632 --> 00:26:09.382
think I was trying to answer your
question, but I forgot. I lost, I lost a
cue-349
00:26:09.382 --> 00:26:10.712
hold of it. Sorry.
cue-350
00:26:11.412 --> 00:26:14.072
-That's okay.
-I mean, I love the stories of the people
cue-351
00:26:14.072 --> 00:26:19.242
building mesh networks in New York City,
and I think you also... I didn't get to
cue-352
00:26:19.242 --> 00:26:22.432
this chapter, but it was, uh, were they
doing something similar in Philly?
cue-353
00:26:22.432 --> 00:26:28.062
Yeah, yeah. In Philly, you know, similarly
to New York City, they have built mesh,
cue-354
00:26:28.062 --> 00:26:32.432
-mesh networks for underserved areas.
-I love the photos of people just having
cue-355
00:26:32.432 --> 00:26:37.592
like, like mesh array rigs, like next to
their like clo- clotheslines outside in
cue-356
00:26:37.592 --> 00:26:38.902
New York City. I think that's just really
cool.
cue-357
00:26:39.632 --> 00:26:42.641
I, I'm kind of like excited to be living
in Boston now 'cause I was like, the first
cue-358
00:26:42.641 --> 00:26:45.812
thing I started looking up is like, is
anyone doing weird mesh stuff in Boston?
cue-359
00:26:45.812 --> 00:26:46.792
-Like-
-There used to be anarchist groups that
cue-360
00:26:46.792 --> 00:26:51.412
would do it, just sort of like, not quite
like dual organization, but setting up
cue-361
00:26:51.412 --> 00:26:57.392
like parallel structures to both learn how
to do it, but then to also maybe replace
cue-362
00:26:57.392 --> 00:27:01.632
existing, uh, structures, et cetera. Yeah,
I think there used to be like an
cue-363
00:27:01.632 --> 00:27:05.072
anarchist mesh network in the city. I used
to see that like at the anarchist book
cue-364
00:27:05.072 --> 00:27:05.852
-fair.
-See-
cue-365
00:27:05.852 --> 00:27:10.492
Yeah, I love that. It's very cool. One
thing you mentioned, I'm, I'm gonna get
cue-366
00:27:10.492 --> 00:27:16.732
more into like what you talk about for
like human-focused things, but it was, it
cue-367
00:27:16.732 --> 00:27:20.452
was interesting to me when you were
talking about how a lot of the models for
cue-368
00:27:20.452 --> 00:27:26.752
like packet exchange come from the postal
system and the train networks, and both of
cue-369
00:27:26.752 --> 00:27:33.452
them have like this very distinct element
in the internal imperialism of the
cue-370
00:27:33.452 --> 00:27:39.272
US, like the conquering of the West,
right? The, the, the campaign to actually
cue-371
00:27:39.272 --> 00:27:45.012
politically subjugate the West. And so
it's, it's interesting to me that like
cue-372
00:27:45.012 --> 00:27:48.352
every time... Because like markets are
created by governments, right? There is
cue-373
00:27:48.352 --> 00:27:51.712
really no market without a government,
right? A government needs to create a
cue-374
00:27:51.712 --> 00:27:57.222
market because it needs fundamentally to
con- like feed its army mostly.
cue-375
00:27:57.222 --> 00:27:59.752
-Right, exactly.
-It needs to exchange. It, it needs
cue-376
00:27:59.752 --> 00:28:03.292
exchange in order to do that, and that's
why you create markets 'cause you need to
cue-377
00:28:03.292 --> 00:28:07.092
have exchangeable goods, right? So the,
the main thing is like in imperialism, you
cue-378
00:28:07.092 --> 00:28:11.472
kind of see these, these hinterlands
being created and then these like, "Oh,
cue-379
00:28:11.472 --> 00:28:17.432
we're going to be, you know, yeoman
farmers on empty land," right? "Go to
cue-380
00:28:17.432 --> 00:28:21.532
Mars. There's no one there. It'll be
great." Even though immediately Musk in
cue-381
00:28:21.532 --> 00:28:24.472
like 2016 was still like saying, "Yeah,
we're gonna have to send prisoners 'cause
cue-382
00:28:24.472 --> 00:28:28.172
no one's wanna go, gonna wanna go die on
Mars 'cause it would suck." It's like you
cue-383
00:28:28.172 --> 00:28:32.512
remember there were empty islands in the
Americas. You know what we did? We brought
cue-384
00:28:32.512 --> 00:28:35.231
people to work them. I don't know if you
heard about this thing called the
cue-385
00:28:35.231 --> 00:28:37.812
transatlantic slave trade. Anyway, I had
someone at a DSA
cue-386
00:28:38.551 --> 00:28:43.112
ar- uh, meeting argue with me saying that
Mars was literally terra nullius. I'm
cue-387
00:28:43.112 --> 00:28:45.252
-like, "God, you're so fucking stupid."
-[laughs]
cue-388
00:28:45.252 --> 00:28:48.832
This guy was a political science professor
if that tells you anything about him.
cue-389
00:28:49.712 --> 00:28:50.912
[laughs] And so...
cue-390
00:28:51.852 --> 00:28:57.392
But could you talk a little bit about like
the, the way that... I know as I'm asking
cue-391
00:28:57.392 --> 00:29:02.812
you to just explain the book, but the,
the particular way and when you talk about
cue-392
00:29:02.812 --> 00:29:06.552
like the imperialism of the hinterlands
that the rail network created, for
cue-393
00:29:06.552 --> 00:29:09.612
example, and the hinterlands that the
internet creates now. If you could just
cue-394
00:29:09.612 --> 00:29:12.752
like bring... Like explain that to me
'cause that's something I was trying to
cue-395
00:29:12.752 --> 00:29:16.752
-get my head around.
-I'm drawing a lot from Rosa Luxemburg for
cue-396
00:29:16.752 --> 00:29:22.311
this. There's also a great emergent
scholar, Charlie Mueller, who writes some
cue-397
00:29:22.312 --> 00:29:22.952
about this.
cue-398
00:29:23.692 --> 00:29:30.472
But the idea is that the railroads brought
products and commodities west.
cue-399
00:29:30.472 --> 00:29:37.152
They brought in new, you know, outsides
for the capitalist core, sort of
cue-400
00:29:37.152 --> 00:29:42.172
enrolled them into the capitalist core and
made them markets, made them buy things,
cue-401
00:29:42.172 --> 00:29:47.092
made them buy things that, you know, the
boosters promised would be in Kansas, but
cue-402
00:29:47.092 --> 00:29:50.232
when they got there, there was no wood, so
they would have to ship in all of the
cue-403
00:29:50.232 --> 00:29:55.072
wood that they would use to build their
houses from the shipping yards in Chicago,
cue-404
00:29:55.072 --> 00:30:00.272
which made Chicago rise as a huge, you
know, sort of railroad terminal or
cue-405
00:30:00.272 --> 00:30:06.832
terminus and then terminal, you know, in
the late 1800s that really helped enroll
cue-406
00:30:06.832 --> 00:30:13.772
this sort of hinterlands that had been
made by policies of manifest destiny and
cue-407
00:30:13.772 --> 00:30:19.252
enrolled it into this, you know,
imperialist industrial, the imperialist
cue-408
00:30:19.252 --> 00:30:24.232
core of the industrial property state. And
so we see that today
cue-409
00:30:25.568 --> 00:30:31.488
Where the internet fiber is laid follows
along these, you know, materially lays
cue-410
00:30:31.488 --> 00:30:32.947
along these old
cue-411
00:30:33.548 --> 00:30:39.668
rail lines as telegraph poles eventually
were built along rail lines to help
cue-412
00:30:39.668 --> 00:30:44.188
coordinate things, help things move
efficiently, quickly, on time, help people
cue-413
00:30:44.188 --> 00:30:48.788
communicate with one another. And then
where some of these telegraph lines were
cue-414
00:30:48.788 --> 00:30:53.128
laid is where a lot of the internet cable
was laid,
especially, you know, with
cue-415
00:30:53.128 --> 00:30:58.438
transatlantic cable, like where they sort
of dump into the water. And so, so there's
cue-416
00:30:58.438 --> 00:31:04.308
that. So, you know, I argue that these
old systems of... And then also the postal
cue-417
00:31:04.308 --> 00:31:09.268
office, like you can't-- it doesn't get
much more manifest destiny than the
cue-418
00:31:09.268 --> 00:31:14.268
construction and, you know, maneuvering
and functioning of the postal office, not
cue-419
00:31:14.268 --> 00:31:19.488
only to, you know, provide communication
back to the capitalist core of an
cue-420
00:31:19.488 --> 00:31:24.908
industrial property state, but also to
facilitate then the shipping of, of market
cue-421
00:31:24.908 --> 00:31:29.507
goods to these hinterlands and back, you
know, back to the core of the industrial
cue-422
00:31:29.508 --> 00:31:35.268
property state. So both of these older
interventions, the railroads, telegraphs,
cue-423
00:31:35.268 --> 00:31:39.528
and I guess also, you know, the postal
system, are the material and conceptual
cue-424
00:31:39.528 --> 00:31:44.968
bases for the internet that expands across
the world with sort of a similar type of,
cue-425
00:31:44.968 --> 00:31:49.708
you know, imperialist drive, though with
the development and construction of the
cue-426
00:31:49.708 --> 00:31:56.708
internet, they're no longer looking to
focus on a single territorial
cue-427
00:31:56.708 --> 00:32:01.908
expansion of industrial property state,
but rather to consolidate power for the
cue-428
00:32:01.908 --> 00:32:06.748
imperialist drives of, of the West, and
particularly of the United States, and
cue-429
00:32:06.748 --> 00:32:10.628
particularly with the internet to, you
know, make the United States,
cue-430
00:32:10.628 --> 00:32:16.788
quote-unquote, "safe" or protect military
advantages in the face of communism and
cue-431
00:32:16.788 --> 00:32:19.888
-the Cold War.
-Right, like the internet, I feel like
cue-432
00:32:19.888 --> 00:32:22.748
sometimes I've seen things where there's
almost this like starry-eyed thing about
cue-433
00:32:22.748 --> 00:32:27.148
the internet and us communicating and all
that, but like it starts out as a military
cue-434
00:32:27.148 --> 00:32:33.027
te-technology, so it's got this like
inherent sort of like imperialist project
cue-435
00:32:33.027 --> 00:32:37.168
like built into it. You can't separate the
internet from the context it was like
cue-436
00:32:37.168 --> 00:32:40.668
-created for.
-Yeah. Yeah. A lot of people like to talk
cue-437
00:32:40.668 --> 00:32:43.668
about like, "Oh, the internet in the '90s,
like can we get back to that? It was
cue-438
00:32:43.668 --> 00:32:48.708
really nice, like before, you know, when
it was just chat, you know, message boards
cue-439
00:32:48.708 --> 00:32:52.108
and stuff like that." And I'm like,
"Well, yeah, I mean, I guess that was
cue-440
00:32:52.108 --> 00:32:52.687
before
cue-441
00:32:53.368 --> 00:32:57.888
maybe the Telecommunications Act of 1996
that really deregulated it all and
cue-442
00:32:57.888 --> 00:33:03.668
allowed, you know, then massive
profit-seeking entities to come in." But
cue-443
00:33:03.668 --> 00:33:07.748
yeah, that's always something that I have
to remind people of, that the internet is
cue-444
00:33:07.748 --> 00:33:12.528
primarily a military and market-driven
system.
cue-445
00:33:12.528 --> 00:33:16.848
But the, the thing that I find interesting
about this book too is you really
cue-446
00:33:16.848 --> 00:33:21.028
emphasize from the beginning that there
are futures available for us, and that
cue-447
00:33:21.028 --> 00:33:26.028
there's sort of this dialectical approach
of every time that you are seeing this
cue-448
00:33:26.028 --> 00:33:32.347
capitalist system trying to expand into
new places, you're also seeing the
cue-449
00:33:32.348 --> 00:33:38.888
interaction with the actual drives of the
people there to be independent and to make
cue-450
00:33:38.888 --> 00:33:42.388
communities and to... I'm also reading
Blood in the Machine at the same time, and
cue-451
00:33:42.388 --> 00:33:46.148
I swear to God on the walk home, he was
talking about the Internet Deregulation
cue-452
00:33:46.148 --> 00:33:49.088
Act for some reason in the middle of that
book, even though most of it takes place
cue-453
00:33:49.088 --> 00:33:53.828
in 1810. I don't know, I don't remember
why. I think I'm losing my mind. I've been
cue-454
00:33:53.828 --> 00:33:56.888
staring at words on screen all day for
weeks.
cue-455
00:33:57.528 --> 00:34:02.228
But anyway, when, when you talk to people
about like the, the opportunities that the
cue-456
00:34:02.228 --> 00:34:06.368
internet made, like, you know, it is a
startup program, but like what were some
cue-457
00:34:06.368 --> 00:34:07.968
of the things that
cue-458
00:34:08.568 --> 00:34:13.648
you would highlight to someone about the
internet creating opportunity for people
cue-459
00:34:13.648 --> 00:34:19.668
to organize in, in a new way and in a way
where they actually control the means of
cue-460
00:34:19.668 --> 00:34:24.468
-the internet, right?
-Yeah. And I think, you know, a lot of
cue-461
00:34:24.468 --> 00:34:31.328
these examples that I provide here, you
know, either cooperatives or, you know,
cue-462
00:34:31.328 --> 00:34:37.808
municipal internet, things like that, like
these drives have existed that predate,
cue-463
00:34:37.808 --> 00:34:41.227
you know, the, the advent of the internet.
And so,
cue-464
00:34:41.828 --> 00:34:48.228
you know, it allows for, you know, people
to engage with resources in different ways
cue-465
00:34:48.228 --> 00:34:52.768
and, you know, that's for, for better or
for worse, you know, in different cases.
cue-466
00:34:52.768 --> 00:34:59.148
It's, it's both. But yeah, I don't know.
And then so there's that, but then there's
cue-467
00:34:59.148 --> 00:35:03.308
also like a way to think about, you know,
some of these
cue-468
00:35:03.988 --> 00:35:09.948
longstanding sort of political
relationships and material relationships
cue-469
00:35:09.948 --> 00:35:16.648
to the idea of community, to the idea of
infrastructure or, you know,
cue-470
00:35:16.648 --> 00:35:22.968
relating to our environment or the
material world that I think keep, keep
cue-471
00:35:22.968 --> 00:35:26.608
bubbling up and keep coming to the fore,
and I think, you know, provide these
cue-472
00:35:26.608 --> 00:35:31.408
really nice ways to think about how the
world might be otherwise, how this, you
cue-473
00:35:31.408 --> 00:35:37.028
know, very deeply dystopian
socio-technical and political world might
cue-474
00:35:37.028 --> 00:35:41.908
be otherwise. I admit that a lot of the
examples that I offer in this book are at
cue-475
00:35:41.908 --> 00:35:48.248
best sort of socialist examples that
negotiate with, you know, sort of larger
cue-476
00:35:48.248 --> 00:35:52.428
capitalist structures, but nonetheless,
they offer us a glimmer of hope for how
cue-477
00:35:52.428 --> 00:35:58.388
things might be otherwise, how we might
take control over technology
cue-478
00:35:58.388 --> 00:36:05.068
production and deployment in ways that
would allow, you know, this technology to
cue-479
00:36:05.068 --> 00:36:10.848
be used in service of the people and not
just in service of the industrial property
cue-480
00:36:10.848 --> 00:36:17.188
state, military, and large corporations.
So, so that's sort of what I hope that I
cue-481
00:36:17.188 --> 00:36:21.448
offer in this book is like not only
examples, but also sort of
cue-482
00:36:22.068 --> 00:36:27.668
talking through about how these examples
came to be and how they imagine themselves
cue-483
00:36:27.668 --> 00:36:32.428
into the future, even though for the most
part, they are beset on all sides by sort
cue-484
00:36:32.428 --> 00:36:36.316
of capitalist encroachment. But they're
still fighting, and they've been around
cue-485
00:36:36.316 --> 00:36:40.676
and they've been doing this, you know, and
in one of the cases for over 100 years
cue-486
00:36:40.676 --> 00:36:44.396
and they're still fighting and they're
still finding ways to, you know, weasel
cue-487
00:36:44.396 --> 00:36:48.616
out of rent payments and things like that.
So, so there's hope there.
cue-488
00:36:48.616 --> 00:36:53.516
Yeah, I, I remember learning about, I
don't know, maybe five, five or more years
cue-489
00:36:53.516 --> 00:36:58.596
ago about the, the amount of states and
municipalities, or I think it was states
cue-490
00:36:58.596 --> 00:37:03.296
that had laws basically granting
monopolies to telecom companies. So if a,
cue-491
00:37:03.356 --> 00:37:08.976
if a city wants to have a municipally run
internet service and dig the cables and
cue-492
00:37:08.976 --> 00:37:13.616
run the cables themselves, they legally
can't do it because like this area has
cue-493
00:37:13.616 --> 00:37:19.296
been effectively legally signed over to
Comcast or, or to Spectrum and you just
cue-494
00:37:19.296 --> 00:37:25.536
can't, like legally can't do jack about
it, which is like, which was kind of...
cue-495
00:37:25.536 --> 00:37:28.996
I'm surprised it surprised me, but it
really did. Like it really did like shock
cue-496
00:37:28.996 --> 00:37:33.556
me that like there was something so
brazenly monopolistic and in just like
cue-497
00:37:33.556 --> 00:37:38.436
straightforward letter of the law
monopolies to, to give... You know,
cue-498
00:37:38.436 --> 00:37:42.616
everyone fucking hates Spectrum. No one,
no one wants to deal with it. So I'm
cue-499
00:37:42.616 --> 00:37:46.626
really glad that there are still people
building like buyers co-ops, but
cue-500
00:37:47.476 --> 00:37:52.536
I, I did appreciate how you, you put
forward Rosa Luxemburg's critique of
cue-501
00:37:52.536 --> 00:37:59.096
co-ops as a model of like change. Like
how, how do buyers co-ops turn into a
cue-502
00:37:59.096 --> 00:38:03.936
democratic controlled means of production
because like yeah, it's, it's you are
cue-503
00:38:03.936 --> 00:38:08.706
interacting ultimately with this same
system. But something I talk about with my
cue-504
00:38:08.706 --> 00:38:12.416
friends quite often is look, I would like
this transition to go as peacefully as
cue-505
00:38:12.416 --> 00:38:12.956
possible
cue-506
00:38:13.756 --> 00:38:17.456
into the future that we obviously have to
build. But like I don't have to be an
cue-507
00:38:17.456 --> 00:38:22.036
accelerationist. History's doing that for
me, right? Like I, I, I want things to go
cue-508
00:38:22.036 --> 00:38:24.356
easily. But I... Did you--
cue-509
00:38:25.056 --> 00:38:28.576
When you were, when you're imagining the
future, is that... What, what part of it,
cue-510
00:38:28.576 --> 00:38:32.736
I suppose, do you find the most
challenging? Is it that critique of we're
cue-511
00:38:32.736 --> 00:38:37.816
interacting ultimately with a capitalist
system and so is there a fatalism there or
cue-512
00:38:37.816 --> 00:38:43.816
do you find that there's other ways to
find hope for building the future we wanna
cue-513
00:38:43.816 --> 00:38:47.856
live in? 'Cause I, I think there are, but
I'm interested in what you have come out
cue-514
00:38:47.856 --> 00:38:49.346
-with.
-Yeah. And here's what
cue-515
00:38:50.016 --> 00:38:55.256
I talk about in some of the later chapters
in the book is that a lot of the time,
cue-516
00:38:55.256 --> 00:39:01.376
you know, especially projects that are
focused on tech justice as a concept that
cue-517
00:39:01.376 --> 00:39:05.896
goes hand in hand with environmental
justice, racial justice, economic justice,
cue-518
00:39:05.896 --> 00:39:10.116
you know, a lot of the time what they
find with, you know, this positive
cue-519
00:39:10.116 --> 00:39:14.636
visioning for the future that people
articulate is that they don't really need
cue-520
00:39:14.636 --> 00:39:19.736
technology for very much. If what they
would like is, you know, stronger
cue-521
00:39:19.736
--> 00:39:24.976
communities, better schools, better
libraries, better funded libraries, you
cue-522
00:39:24.976 --> 00:39:30.416
know, public spaces, parks, clean air to
breathe, clean water to drink, right? All
cue-523
00:39:30.416 --> 00:39:35.696
of which, you know, sound like, you know,
obvious. These are obvious things that we
cue-524
00:39:35.696 --> 00:39:41.316
all want. But you know, I've really found
in this book, in writing this book that,
cue-525
00:39:41.316 --> 00:39:48.066
you know, we need to sort of really deeply
interrogate and think through and
cue-526
00:39:48.066 --> 00:39:53.926
perhaps think through some modes of, of
stepping back from this idea that
cue-527
00:39:53.926 --> 00:39:59.696
technology is necessarily an inherent good
or that scale is necessary-- like scale
cue-528
00:39:59.696 --> 00:40:05.456
with technology is necessarily something
that is desirable. And you know, I think
cue-529
00:40:05.456 --> 00:40:09.876
this notion of focusing on, you know,
whenever anybody thinks about internet
cue-530
00:40:09.876 --> 00:40:13.476
infrastructure, they're thinking about,
you know, this concept of access and
cue-531
00:40:13.476 --> 00:40:17.196
connectivity and more is better, right?
But really what I've found in a lot of
cue-532
00:40:17.196 --> 00:40:21.896
these cases is that people don't really
feel like more is better. And so that
cue-533
00:40:21.896 --> 00:40:27.876
gives me a lot of hope because we can
allow this stuff to break and we can, you
cue-534
00:40:27.876 --> 00:40:32.976
know, build something out of the ashes
that feels better. You know, it seems
cue-535
00:40:32.976 --> 00:40:36.706
scary to people, you know, when I talk
about this in academic departments they're
cue-536
00:40:36.706 --> 00:40:39.996
like, "But what, what are you, what are
you saying? Like you wanna go back to the
cue-537
00:40:39.996 --> 00:40:43.795
past?" And I'm like, "No, it's not the
past. It'll have to be the future and
cue-538
00:40:43.796 --> 00:40:47.816
it'll be informed by the past. We don't
have to make the same mistakes as the
cue-539
00:40:47.816 --> 00:40:51.735
past." You know, I think technology
refusal, speaking of blood in the machine,
cue-540
00:40:51.735 --> 00:40:58.336
technology refusal or you know, even
resistance is something that is incredibly
cue-541
00:40:58.336 --> 00:41:02.796
progressive and hopeful and if we weren't
focusing so much on technology, we could
cue-542
00:41:02.796 --> 00:41:08.276
focus more on, you know, our relationships
with one another in physical space or
cue-543
00:41:08.276 --> 00:41:15.056
with any number of things, right? And so,
so that's one thing that I, that I really
cue-544
00:41:15.056 --> 00:41:20.716
I guess find helpful or, or hopeful in the
work that I've done here and I hope it
cue-545
00:41:20.716 --> 00:41:24.976
comes through in the book is that
sometimes what we need are necessarily
cue-546
00:41:24.976 --> 00:41:28.756
smaller scales of technology and we may
not even need things that are
cue-547
00:41:28.756 --> 00:41:33.126
technological. You know, we... Thriving
can look a lot of different ways. It
cue-548
00:41:33.126 --> 00:41:38.096
-doesn't mean an iPhone in every pocket.
-Yeah, I think a, a lot about the Luddites
cue-549
00:41:38.096 --> 00:41:42.256
in particular, 'cause I'm reading a book
about them, and how they have to go
cue-550
00:41:42.256 --> 00:41:46.676
through this grueling work for, you know,
a decade of their lives in order to
cue-551
00:41:46.676 --> 00:41:50.456
physically be able to do the, the kind of
trade that they're going into, right? They
cue-552
00:41:50.456 --> 00:41:54.536
get these-- they get particular calluses,
they grow particular muscles, like their
cue-553
00:41:54.536 --> 00:42:00.136
body becomes conditioned to the work. And
obviously the automated looms would make
cue-554
00:42:00.136 --> 00:42:05.116
their lives easier, but something a friend
of mine has said recently is like people
cue-555
00:42:05.116 --> 00:42:10.636
need to work. They need something that
they do and have pride in and gets them
cue-556
00:42:10.636 --> 00:42:13.646
-doing a thing and have purpose. And I've-
-Yeah
cue-557
00:42:13.646 --> 00:42:15.506
-... I'm always, yeah.
-Yeah.
cue-558
00:42:15.506 --> 00:42:18.156
Yeah, I'm always resistant to that 'cause
I've got like a lot of, you know, I grew
cue-559
00:42:18.156 --> 00:42:21.816
up very Protestant and, and conservative
so it's like, you know, I, I have a lot of
cue-560
00:42:21.816 --> 00:42:27.156
undoing that in my head that's very
unhelpful, right? So I always am the first
cue-561
00:42:27.156 --> 00:42:33.166
person to be anti-work and, and anti-work
ethic. But it's true 'cause I think like
cue-562
00:42:33.166 --> 00:42:37.376
especially reading about what people were
saying about the Luddites at the time
cue-563
00:42:37.376 --> 00:42:40.836
which is like they should be happy that
these things aren't going to Are gonna
cue-564
00:42:40.836 --> 00:42:43.756
make their lives easier, and they can
focus on the craft. They can focus on the
cue-565
00:42:43.756 --> 00:42:47.015
high-level stuff, the same thing we're
hearing about AI now, right? It's the
cue-566
00:42:47.016 --> 00:42:50.996
whole point of the book. But it's, you
know, it's very clear, like, they were
cue-567
00:42:50.996 --> 00:42:56.515
never going to own these machines, and
even if they did, the entire economy of
cue-568
00:42:56.516 --> 00:43:00.375
making a machine that makes something
faster is so that you make it cheaper. So
cue-569
00:43:00.376 --> 00:43:04.976
they were always going to be impoverished.
It would just be some of them would've
cue-570
00:43:04.976 --> 00:43:09.376
gotten rich, and the rest of them wouldn't
have. The same sort of immiseration still
cue-571
00:43:09.376 --> 00:43:13.996
would've happened because the entire
economy of scale was dependent on it. And
cue-572
00:43:13.996 --> 00:43:14.796
as, as
cue-573
00:43:15.456 --> 00:43:18.896
another guest we had on recently, Hagen
Blix, uh, said something that's really
cue-574
00:43:18.896 --> 00:43:21.856
stuck out to me. There's no one capitalist
you can say, "I think this is a bad
cue-575
00:43:21.856 --> 00:43:24.886
idea." They can't stop the train either,
right?
cue-576
00:43:25.556 --> 00:43:28.676
You know, any one of them can say, "I give
up. I'm not doing this anymore." And
cue-577
00:43:28.676 --> 00:43:32.706
there were people who had their looms
smashed or whatever and, and gave up. It's
cue-578
00:43:32.706 --> 00:43:39.216
a runaway train, but I am sort of hopeful
of the fact that neoliberalism emerged
cue-579
00:43:39.216 --> 00:43:43.616
from the fact that capitalists were
absolutely scared shitless by the New Deal
cue-580
00:43:43.616 --> 00:43:48.016
and the fear that the state was too...
How did they say it? The state was too
cue-581
00:43:48.016 --> 00:43:51.636
powerful, but the, the state was too
unreliable, right? There were too many
cue-582
00:43:51.636 --> 00:43:56.096
things that were direct interventions on
the market. So yeah, I think, you know,
cue-583
00:43:56.096 --> 00:44:01.696
these kind of co-ops do genuinely do the
things that people want to do in their
cue-584
00:44:01.696 --> 00:44:08.016
societies, which is have control over your
life and, and not have everything metered
cue-585
00:44:08.016 --> 00:44:12.046
out. I wrote a, I wrote a chapter about
cloud computing years ago for an emerging
cue-586
00:44:12.046 --> 00:44:16.356
technologies book for librarians, and the
whole thing I was talking about is your
cue-587
00:44:16.356 --> 00:44:20.296
computer is turning into a terminal. Like,
you're not... You don't own the computer
cue-588
00:44:20.296 --> 00:44:25.226
anymore. And then having Sam Altman say,
like, "We want intelligence as a utility."
cue-589
00:44:25.226 --> 00:44:25.876
Yeah.
cue-590
00:44:25.876 --> 00:44:29.496
Right? We don't want you to think. We want
to, we want to think for you and sell you
cue-591
00:44:29.496 --> 00:44:32.336
the thing. And so it is much more of, you
know,
cue-592
00:44:32.936 --> 00:44:37.216
should kids have to write pencil and
paper? Like, yeah, it's nice to use a
cue-593
00:44:37.216 --> 00:44:41.776
computer, but maybe that is the callus on
your hand that you have to get to have
cue-594
00:44:41.776 --> 00:44:45.356
meaning in life. Like, the, the
technological thing doesn't, isn't
cue-595
00:44:45.356 --> 00:44:47.535
-important.
-Yeah. Yeah.
cue-596
00:44:47.536 --> 00:44:52.216
I'm talking too much. But another thing
in, in, that I found interesting is you
cue-597
00:44:52.216 --> 00:44:57.135
mentioned society's control, uh, Deleuze.
And if we do imagine a future of the
cue-598
00:44:57.136 --> 00:45:01.256
internet, is there any kind of
counter-tendency you see to that, that
cue-599
00:45:01.256 --> 00:45:07.716
centralization and that control, that sort
of cybernetic i- impulse to, like, you
cue-600
00:45:07.716 --> 00:45:11.616
know, centralize
production and centralize
information and do, you know, kind of
cue-601
00:45:11.616 --> 00:45:17.436
-like a Soviet thing?
-Yeah. I mean, you know, I feel like I see
cue-602
00:45:17.436 --> 00:45:18.586
a lot of, like,
cue-603
00:45:19.696 --> 00:45:23.605
whether or not it happens in, you know,
actual technical practice, but like,
cue-604
00:45:25.036 --> 00:45:29.036
is a question. But, you know, some of
these groups that I talked with and some
cue-605
00:45:29.036 --> 00:45:32.676
of which I d- you know, didn't even make
it in the book, you know, they're focused
cue-606
00:45:32.676 --> 00:45:34.016
on, you know,
cue-607
00:45:34.676 --> 00:45:35.456
I guess
cue-608
00:45:36.156 --> 00:45:40.756
not necessarily, like, separating off,
but, like, you know, not participating
cue-609
00:45:40.756 --> 00:45:45.476
and, like, focusing much more, like I g-
like I was saying, like, on cooperativity
cue-610
00:45:45.476 --> 00:45:49.816
within small groups rather than
connectivity with the rest, you know, the
cue-611
00:45:49.816 --> 00:45:55.716
rest of the, you know, interconnected
fiber system that, you know,
cue-612
00:45:56.516 --> 00:46:01.496
is laid out across the world. You know,
and they're v- very much less interested
cue-613
00:46:01.496 --> 00:46:07.816
in seeing the world as a data stream to be
managed and commodified, but rather, you
cue-614
00:46:07.816 --> 00:46:12.396
know, thinking about, you know, maybe in
sort of an anarchist way, like, okay, if
cue-615
00:46:12.396 --> 00:46:14.536
we don't have any money to, to,
cue-616
00:46:15.156 --> 00:46:20.016
to do this, you know, technical project
and we, you know, don't have the means
cue-617
00:46:20.016 --> 00:46:24.976
and, you know, technical means in other
ways, like, how might we live and engage
cue-618
00:46:24.976 --> 00:46:25.556
in, you know,
cue-619
00:46:26.356 --> 00:46:30.736
with technology in ways that, that feel
good and that are helpful and meaningful?
cue-620
00:46:30.736 --> 00:46:36.026
So, like, I think, you know, thinking
about low resource settings, like c-
cue-621
00:46:36.026 --> 00:46:40.896
cooperatives or sort of, you know,
alternate modes of engaging with one
cue-622
00:46:40.896 --> 00:46:43.796
another and, and providing infrastructural
cue-623
00:46:44.516 --> 00:46:49.596
interventions is a, a nice way to look at
things. And so I draw from a number of
cue-624
00:46:49.596 --> 00:46:54.956
fiction examples in the book as well as,
you know, some, some real life grounded
cue-625
00:46:54.956 --> 00:47:00.196
experiences to talk about, you know,
there, there are many different futures
cue-626
00:47:00.196 --> 00:47:05.916
that might progress. The one that is the
most likely to happen if we do nothing
cue-627
00:47:05.916 --> 00:47:10.596
will break the internet just as surely as,
you know, intentionally breaking it and
cue-628
00:47:10.596 --> 00:47:14.016
sort of going off into, you know, sort of,
if we wanna think about it, like, smaller
cue-629
00:47:14.016 --> 00:47:16.236
technical communes or something like
that.
cue-630
00:47:16.956 --> 00:47:22.556
So, you know, the future is for us to
build and for us to, to take, right?
cue-631
00:47:22.556 --> 00:47:26.796
Because immiseration awaits all of us if
we do nothing.
cue-632
00:47:26.796 --> 00:47:27.266
I know,
cue-633
00:47:28.056 --> 00:47:28.776
uh, Rojava,
cue-634
00:47:29.456 --> 00:47:32.916
they're one of, like, the backbone of how
they're structuring their society is,
cue-635
00:47:32.916 --> 00:47:37.096
like, through these, like, cooperatives,
right? Like, as this sort of, like, I
cue-636
00:47:37.096 --> 00:47:41.836
think it's communalism, like the Murray
Bookchin kind of idea where it's, like,
cue-637
00:47:41.836 --> 00:47:46.935
anarchist adjacent, but with this sort of,
like, also communist adjacent sort of,
cue-638
00:47:46.936 --> 00:47:51.776
like, structuring of how, like, if we have
to have a society that has logistics and
cue-639
00:47:51.776 --> 00:47:56.276
has functions and isn't just, like, little
affinity groups, what does that look
cue-640
00:47:56.276 --> 00:48:02.336
like, but in a way that isn't controlled
by a state and, but is, you know, still
cue-641
00:48:02.336 --> 00:48:06.196
functional? And, you know, obviously
there's a lot of military stuff happening
cue-642
00:48:06.196 --> 00:48:10.576
there, but, like, it's been, like, more
successful over, you know, the period of
cue-643
00:48:10.576 --> 00:48:14.936
time it ex- it's existed than, like, I
don't know, maybe people expected. So,
cue-644
00:48:14.936 --> 00:48:19.116
'cause I know there's some both, like,
anarchist com- anarcho-communist and,
cue-645
00:48:19.116 --> 00:48:24.816
like, just communist communist criticisms
of, like, the cooperative model, but I
cue-646
00:48:24.816 --> 00:48:28.336
think in their context, like, Rojava's
been doing pretty well with it.
cue-647
00:48:28.336 --> 00:48:32.136
Yeah. Yeah, and this isn't to say, like,
the cooperative model is the best model.
cue-648
00:48:32.136 --> 00:48:33.616
-It's just the one, the-
-Yeah
cue-649
00:48:33.616 --> 00:48:34.245
-... the most-
-Yeah
cue-650
00:48:34.245 --> 00:48:36.916
-... easily available model that we have.
-Mm-hmm.
cue-651
00:48:36.916 --> 00:48:38.896
I mean, certainly there are, you know,
many-
cue-652
00:48:38.896 --> 00:48:41.176
-Yeah
-... qualms that people have with
cue-653
00:48:41.176 --> 00:48:46.644
cooperatives I think it comes down to,
again, yeah, like resource- like managing
cue-654
00:48:46.644 --> 00:48:52.604
the resources necessary to operate any
sort of, you know,
cue-655
00:48:52.604 --> 00:48:58.924
technical infrastructural intervention
gets you into a place very quickly of,
cue-656
00:48:58.924 --> 00:49:05.034
like, needing a lot of resources to make
something scale up. And so there are
cue-657
00:49:05.034 --> 00:49:09.564
examples of, you know, how this works.
There are tons of examples of, you know,
cue-658
00:49:09.564 -->
00:49:15.904
the, the Russian example or Cybersoon,
Cyber Signe that, you know, still sort
cue-659
00:49:15.904 --> 00:49:22.044
of focused on centralization and control
and a sort of like technocratic
cue-660
00:49:22.044 --> 00:49:26.744
rationality that sort of runs from a, from
a communist or like, you know, negotiated
cue-661
00:49:26.744 --> 00:49:31.344
communist perspective. And so a lot of
the, a lot of the examples that I find in
cue-662
00:49:31.344 --> 00:49:35.924
the book of like stuff that's, that goes
well, they're not real examples. Like,
cue-663
00:49:35.924 --> 00:49:39.404
they... We only... We have to look at
fiction, and we have to imagine it because
cue-664
00:49:39.404 --> 00:49:41.904
they don't exist, right? But just because
they don't-
cue-665
00:49:41.904 --> 00:49:42.844
-Mm-hmm
-... exist doesn't mean they're not
cue-666
00:49:42.844 --> 00:49:44.724
-possible.
-Exactly.
cue-667
00:49:44.724 --> 00:49:50.264
And that's what I like up to a lot about
the book is the, the insistence straight
cue-668
00:49:50.264 --> 00:49:55.584
from the beginning of imagining the
alternatives. And, you know, you lay out
cue-669
00:49:55.584 --> 00:50:00.964
like two bad possibilities of futures, but
also two good ones, uh, or two
cue-670
00:50:00.964 --> 00:50:04.944
possibilities of futures. And something I
did a long time, for a long time on this
cue-671
00:50:04.944 --> 00:50:08.884
show was say like, "What do you want,"
whatever problem we're talking about in
cue-672
00:50:08.884 --> 00:50:14.684
that episode. "In your ideal world, how
would this wor- work, or would it exist?"
cue-673
00:50:14.684 --> 00:50:15.334
Or, you know,
cue-674
00:50:15.984 --> 00:50:19.643
because I feel like there's so many people
I know who are really hard workers and,
cue-675
00:50:19.644 --> 00:50:24.274
like, really great organizers who can't
answer that question, who they go, "I just
cue-676
00:50:24.274 --> 00:50:29.234
love the work. I just love working." And
I go b- like, "Don't you imagine some- do
cue-677
00:50:29.234 --> 00:50:34.734
you daydream?" And I always find it really
strange when someone says, like, "I don't
cue-678
00:50:34.734 --> 00:50:38.764
think about it. I just think about the
work now that needs doing," which again,
cue-679
00:50:38.764 --> 00:50:42.904
my, my rebellion against the Protestantism
inside me wells up and I say, "No, you
cue-680
00:50:42.904 --> 00:50:46.464
need to, you need to, you need to do
better for yourself. You need to [laughs]
cue-681
00:50:46.464 --> 00:50:49.144
you need to, you need to take a day off
and go do something else."
cue-682
00:50:49.144 --> 00:50:51.684
-[laughs]
-But yeah, I really appreciate that, and
cue-683
00:50:51.684 --> 00:50:57.284
I've, I've been trying to convince people
to actually think about what you want in
cue-684
00:50:57.284 --> 00:51:00.244
-the world.
-Utopianism doesn't have to be naive.
cue-685
00:51:00.244 --> 00:51:01.964
-[laughs]
-Yep.
cue-686
00:51:01.964 --> 00:51:06.024
Are there any other questions before we
wrap up, Jay or Sadie?
cue-687
00:51:06.024 --> 00:51:10.384
Uh, are the sharks comrades that are
eating the internet notion? I think they
cue-688
00:51:10.384 --> 00:51:12.004
-are, but-
-I think they are, yeah.
cue-689
00:51:12.004 --> 00:51:12.564
-Yeah.
-Yeah.
cue-690
00:51:12.564 --> 00:51:16.344
[laughs] I'm always talking about our
shark comrades that are eating the
cue-691
00:51:16.344 --> 00:51:20.763
internet, the, the, the re- reoccurring
character on this podcast. [laughs]
cue-692
00:51:20.764 --> 00:51:25.784
Yeah, and here's the thing. I think I said
it before. The internet is already always
cue-693
00:51:25.784 --> 00:51:27.764
-breaking. It takes-
-Yes
cue-694
00:51:27.764 --> 00:51:34.284
... amounts of resources and capacity to
continue to rebuild it, you know, whether
cue-695
00:51:34.284 --> 00:51:39.104
it's because the sharks are eating it or
because the cables that run through the
cue-696
00:51:39.104 --> 00:51:41.344
-Strait of Hormuz are being bombed.
-Yeah.
cue-697
00:51:41.344 --> 00:51:46.284
Like, it is always, it is always
contested. You know, the internet is dying
cue-698
00:51:46.284 --> 00:51:52.384
because of AI. It's killing web pages.
Like, what does that mean, right? And so
cue-699
00:51:52.384 --> 00:51:56.704
even in that, like, I see a lot of hope.
It allow... When things break, there's a
cue-700
00:51:56.704 --> 00:52:01.584
possibility for, for us to build it
otherwise, right? So that's-
cue-701
00:52:01.584 --> 00:52:03.364
-Mm-hmm
-... that's how I see it.
cue-702
00:52:03.364 --> 00:52:05.644
What's that Gramsci quote, "Now is the
time of monsters"-
cue-703
00:52:05.644 --> 00:52:07.484
-Yeah
-... or whatever. Yeah.
cue-704
00:52:07.484 --> 00:52:13.284
Yeah, it's... I think a lot of leftists
and socialists and have, have read too
cue-705
00:52:13.284 --> 00:52:17.864
many books like, like The Jakarta Method
or Disaster Capitalism and don't realize
cue-706
00:52:17.864 --> 00:52:19.604
that that process can work in reverse
cue-707
00:52:20.524 --> 00:52:23.624
of, you know, if you wait for the
opportune moment to build something
cue-708
00:52:23.624 --> 00:52:28.064
better, that's also a possibility. It's
just, you know, those possibilities have
cue-709
00:52:28.064 --> 00:52:35.013
been missed, or those disasters were
intentionally engaged by the,
cue-710
00:52:35.013 --> 00:52:39.864
the capitalist class in order to
capitalize on those things like, you know,
cue-711
00:52:39.864 --> 00:52:44.824
breaking public schools so that you can
then come in with the privatized solution.
cue-712
00:52:44.824 --> 00:52:48.474
Which by the way, I find it so crazy that
we don't know who owns the cables.
cue-713
00:52:48.474 --> 00:52:50.184
-Yeah.
-Like, the sharks are just biting
cue-714
00:52:50.184 --> 00:52:55.184
anonymously owned cables. So, like, I
didn't realize, like, it's actually hard
cue-715
00:52:55.184 --> 00:52:58.884
to find out who owns the
cables. [laughs]
Like,
cue-716
00:52:59.504 --> 00:53:02.224
-I just feel like there should have been-
-The sharks own them. [laughs] Seize the
cue-717
00:53:02.224 --> 00:53:02.664
means.
cue-718
00:53:04.744 --> 00:53:07.574
-That'd be a sick shirt.
-Seize the means is just a shirt.
cue-719
00:53:07.574 --> 00:53:08.644
-Seizure of the shark eating the cable.
-Yeah.
cue-720
00:53:09.304 --> 00:53:09.484
Yeah.
cue-721
00:53:10.183 --> 00:53:12.504
-[laughs]
-Sadie, did you have any questions?
cue-722
00:53:13.924 --> 00:53:16.134
-N- no, but it has, it- it's given me-
-Yeah
cue-723
00:53:16.134 --> 00:53:17.364
-... a lot to think about
-... as the person who knows the most about
cue-724
00:53:17.364 --> 00:53:19.404
-this than any of us.
-Yeah.
cue-725
00:53:19.404 --> 00:53:21.644
-[laughs]
-Well, the internet is breaking all of the
cue-726
00:53:21.644 --> 00:53:27.344
time, and therefore we can build something
out of it. Out of those broken spots is,
cue-727
00:53:27.344 --> 00:53:34.064
I think, a very good way to look at it
because it is breaking all of the time and
cue-728
00:53:34.064 --> 00:53:39.824
relies on so many different singular
people maintaining very singular things.
cue-729
00:53:39.824 --> 00:53:43.404
And I don't know, here in the, here in the
Pacific Northwest, we have a lot of nurse
cue-730
00:53:43.404 --> 00:53:48.324
trees where the big old, old growth tree
falls down, and then, you know, you walk
cue-731
00:53:48.324 --> 00:53:52.204
through the forest, and you see like six
other tiny trees sticking straight up out
cue-732
00:53:52.204 --> 00:53:56.844
of it, growing out of the, like, half
decomposed log of the old, old growth
cue-733
00:53:56.844 --> 00:54:00.304
tree. And the internet is a lot like that
to me in that-
cue-734
00:54:00.364 --> 00:54:03.384
-Yeah
-... it is constantly growing out of this
cue-735
00:54:03.384 --> 00:54:10.274
constantly decomposing ground, and we can,
we can bonsai those trees how we want
cue-736
00:54:10.274 --> 00:54:12.584
-if we think about it right.
-Yeah.
cue-737
00:54:12.584 --> 00:54:15.904
-That's fucking beautiful, Sadie. [laughs]
-It's nice.
cue-738
00:54:15.904 --> 00:54:19.854
-That's inspired. That poetry.
-Yeah. [laughs]
cue-739
00:54:19.854 --> 00:54:21.494
-Um, Britt, thanks so much for coming on-
-Thank you
cue-740
00:54:21.494 --> 00:54:25.524
... and talking with us and, and indulging
with our, our dumb jokes about sharks.
cue-741
00:54:25.524 --> 00:54:28.844
-[laughs]
-[laughs] Is there anything you want people
cue-742
00:54:28.844 --> 00:54:32.804
to know or check out or places you want
them to follow you, or do you want people
cue-743
00:54:32.804 --> 00:54:33.464
to leave you alone?
cue-744
00:54:34.124 --> 00:54:37.874
-Oh, yeah. That's a good question. Um-
-[laughs]
cue-745
00:54:37.874 --> 00:54:43.764
-[laughs]
-So part of my job is working with our
cue-746
00:54:43.764 --> 00:54:50.004
national higher education union to push
back on the top-down deployment
of AI
cue-747
00:54:50.004 --> 00:54:51.304
across higher education.
cue-748
00:54:51.956 --> 00:54:52.896
And so
cue-749
00:54:53.516 --> 00:54:57.496
stay tuned for that with the American
Association of University Professors.
cue-750
00:54:57.496 --> 00:55:03.135
We're always doing tons of stuff, and you
know what? Like, you know, you work in
cue-751
00:55:03.136 --> 00:55:09.856
libraries, are academic librarians. You're
very, I think, very attuned to this, is
cue-752
00:55:09.856 --> 00:55:16.136
that, you know, higher education in a lot
of the institutions that we have come to,
cue-753
00:55:16.136 --> 00:55:20.756
you know, sort of understand or feel to
be, you know, a necessary component of
cue-754
00:55:20.756 --> 00:55:25.436
society, we're in a fight for our lives,
and we don't want it to go back to how it
cue-755
00:55:25.436 --> 00:55:31.776
was in the 1990s or the 1950s. We want to
build a higher education for all that
cue-756
00:55:31.776 --> 00:55:38.636
works, you know, for everybody and that
doesn't imagine, you know, a future of
cue-757
00:55:38.636 --> 00:55:43.516
capitalist immiseration as, you know, the
only given that we can plan on. So
cue-758
00:55:44.496 --> 00:55:50.576
yeah, that's ... Follow the AAUP, become a
member, fight, because I think if we're
cue-759
00:55:50.576 --> 00:55:54.776
not fighting for it, higher education's
gonna look a lot different and a lot worse
cue-760
00:55:54.776 --> 00:55:57.256
in the next five years. So join the
fight.
cue-761
00:55:57.876 --> 00:56:01.816
You're a faculty librarian and you're not
unionized but are eligible to be, you
cue-762
00:56:01.816 --> 00:56:05.356
might ... And your faculty at your
university are AAUP, you might be able to
cue-763
00:56:05.356 --> 00:56:06.486
-join their union.
-That's right.
cue-764
00:56:06.486 --> 00:56:09.336
See if you can become part of their
bargaining unit. I used to be an AAUP
cue-765
00:56:09.336 --> 00:56:10.736
-member.
-Sick.
cue-766
00:56:10.736 --> 00:56:14.236
It's fun. More librarians need to be in
AAUP. [laughs]
cue-767
00:56:14.236 --> 00:56:20.276
Yeah. My, my best pals and closest
comrades are, are librarians-
cue-768
00:56:20.276 --> 00:56:21.875
-Hell yeah
-... in the union.
cue-769
00:56:21.876 --> 00:56:27.116
Yeah. I, I started talking to some local
anarchists about possibly getting a, a
cue-770
00:56:27.116 --> 00:56:27.936
newspaper going,
cue-771
00:56:28.596 --> 00:56:31.626
and they were like, "Why are there so many
librarians showing up to anarchist
cue-772
00:56:31.626 --> 00:56:32.476
things?" [laughs] Like,
cue-773
00:56:33.276 --> 00:56:35.216
I don't know, we just like hanging out.
[laughs]
cue-774
00:56:35.216 --> 00:56:38.596
Self-selecting, like, I think we're
trajectory, right?
cue-775
00:56:39.296 --> 00:56:41.396
-Yeah.
-Yeah. [laughs] Anarchists are the one who
cue-776
00:56:41.396 --> 00:56:41.996
have book fairs.
cue-777
00:56:42.636 --> 00:56:47.046
[laughs] Yeah, exactly. And then
librarians just grow on them like fungus.
cue-778
00:56:47.046 --> 00:56:47.216
-[laughs]
-Yes.
cue-779
00:56:48.416 --> 00:56:54.096
Like moss. Before we wrap, I wanted to
plug the Queer Liberation Library is
cue-780
00:56:54.096 --> 00:56:56.706
currently doing their annual Pride
fundraiser.
cue-781
00:56:57.616 --> 00:57:01.256
If you're not familiar with Queer
Liberation Library, they are overdrive
cue-782
00:57:01.256 --> 00:57:05.886
library that provides queer literature and
fiction and all sorts of things
cue-783
00:57:06.536 --> 00:57:10.115
no matter where you live in the United
States. We've had them on the podcast
cue-784
00:57:10.116 --> 00:57:15.616
before. They are a fantastic group of
volunteers who are doing their best to
cue-785
00:57:15.616 --> 00:57:19.376
make the world what they want it to look
like going forward in the future.
cue-786
00:57:20.336 --> 00:57:25.856
I have started a t- fundraising team
which, for Library Punk, if you are part
cue-787
00:57:25.856 --> 00:57:30.656
of the Discord, there is a link in there.
If you have it in you to donate, that is a
cue-788
00:57:30.656 --> 00:57:34.936
fantastic cause to do so. And if we hit
the markers to
cue-789
00:57:35.716 --> 00:57:41.126
get to decide what book they add, I will
be taking, we'll be taking suggestions and
cue-790
00:57:41.126 --> 00:57:44.876
running polls so we can figure out what
book to add to their collection if we hit
cue-791
00:57:44.876 --> 00:57:50.166
fundraising goals. So join the Discord,
look for it there, and I will be promo-ing
cue-792
00:57:50.166 --> 00:57:54.736
it again there so, uh, sometime soon. So
Queer Liberation Library, friend of the
cue-793
00:57:54.736 --> 00:57:58.036
-pod.
-Hell yeah. Yeah. Very excited. All right.
cue-794
00:57:58.036 --> 00:58:00.736
Well, thanks, Britt, so much for making
the time to come on. I really do
cue-795
00:58:00.736 --> 00:58:02.376
-appreciate it.
-Thanks for having me.
cue-796
00:58:02.376 --> 00:58:03.156
-Yes.
-It was fun.
cue-797
00:58:03.156 --> 00:58:04.696
Great. Good night.