TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
[01:00:00:00 - 01:01:06:20]
(Music) We did some work with a group called Worthy Strategy Group. They have asked everyday Americans across different political backgrounds to bring in a photo, an image of how they feel about their financial life. Unconnected, these are people who don't know each other, bring in images of a person with a boot on their neck. So that's the condition that people are feeling. When you suck out all of the wealth and give to the few, you're left with a society of everyday people who feel like there's a boot on their throat. It's absolutely another gill of age and in fact, unprecedentedly so. Billionaires today have around $20 trillion and there's 3,400 billionaires. So not a lot of people. These companies and Facebook in particular just doesn't check. They don't look to see if they're putting kids in harm's way or adults in harm's way. These kinds of influences in the newsfeed became extremely concerning to me. And a lack of willingness from Mark himself to actually research it and understand and address it. Did you ever reach out to him directly? Either by email or- Yeah. Yeah, you reached out and what did he say to you?
[01:01:11:10 - 01:01:11:10]
(Music)
[01:01:12:22 - 01:01:24:03]
From World Within Studios and PRX, you're listening to the How to Change the World podcast. I'm your host, Roastam Zafag. (Music)
[01:01:25:19 - 01:02:37:23]
Income inequality in America has reached unprecedented levels. Levels not seen since the Gilded Age and by some measures well beyond it. The top 1% of Americans now hold more wealth than the entire 90% combined. My guest today has had a front row seat watching this unfold, both as an early employee of a tech oligopoly and later as the whistleblower testifying before Congress against the very same organization he once believed in. Brian Bolin was a vice president at Facebook. And what he witnessed there convinced him that these companies aren't exceptions to how our economy works. They're its clearest expression. Since then, Brian has conducted extensive research into just how much strain our financial system and its emphasis on shareholder primacy is placing on everyday Americans. Stagnant wages, vanishing safety nets, the growing gap between what people produce and what they're able to keep. Through unlock ownership, he's now building and making the case for what he calls an ownership economy, a practical blueprint for an economic future that has room for us all. Brian Bolin, let's dive in.
[01:02:39:23 - 01:04:30:21]
Brian, thank you so much for being on today's episode of How to Change the World. Hey man, it's always great to have a conversation with you and excited to be here. So we're actually doing a series where we're talking a lot about community ownership, but we're looking at it from a few different perspectives. Your perspective to me is really interesting, which is someone who was an early employee at Facebook. You were in the tech world. You drank the Kool-Aid, much like I did. And now you are a leading investor practitioner in this community ownership space. That's almost as like the antithesis to the tech world. Before we get into your personal journey and how that's all kind of unraveled, I want you to set the table for me to like, what is the stakes right now? Like, why should people even care about the concentration of wealth and power, about what's happening in tech? I mean, we're living in almost like a second gilded age where the levels of inequality are on par with what we saw in the late 1870s to early 1900s, in some ways exceeding it. But why does it matter and what's at stake for everyday people and society? It's not almost like another gilded age. It's absolutely another gilded age. And in fact, unprecedentedly so. We're surpassing the gilded age. It looks like billionaires today have around $20 trillion in total assets. Like all the billionaires we can buy now, it's $20 trillion that sit with all the billionaires. And there's 3,400 billionaires. So not a lot of people. But let's like take that, let's throw like average minimum wage working Americans and say, okay, you 3,400 people, you just got to work until you reach that $20 trillion in work hours. And it turns out it takes 386,000 years for that group of 3,400 people to make that $20 trillion.
[01:04:32:00 - 01:05:07:01]
That means that it's 77 times recorded human history for that group of people to make as much money as this group of 3,400 people have. Not only that, if you look at just political statistics, a billionaire's 4,000 times more likely to be a holder of political office. And we know that when we look at the top hundred billionaires in the United States, they contributed 16% of all political giving in the last cycle. And so this massive imbalance of wealth and power has created a society that just people believe is rigged.
[01:05:08:02 - 01:05:43:14]
And you look at a lot of the turmoil that we have, you look at the discontent we have societally, people feel like the systems have failed them. When you look at any sort of polling or data around how people experience things, it's worse. And progressively getting worse is America's GDP does better and better. And so we have this system that is working great for these 3,400 billionaires and the millionaires and centimillionaires below them, where you look at the last trillions and trillions of dollars that were created, two thirds of the wealth created in the last five years went to that top 0.001%.
[01:05:44:18 - 01:06:11:05]
You have a very inequitable system delivering for very few and people feel it in their everyday lives. There's this incredible chart that shows this productivity in the United States and how productivity in the U.S. has steadily ticked up and the gains of productivity have grown. And at some point wages just flatten and wages have not kept up with the growth of productivity. And that space in between that triangle has gone somewhere and it's gone to the
Load full transcript
wealthiest of the wealthy.
[01:06:12:06 - 01:07:35:01]
And so you've had everyday working class people who have had wages suppressed for over 50 years, which means that their savings, their purchasing power, their everyday lives have gotten harder and harder and harder. 40% of Americans' households struggle financially and half of American households can't come up with $1,000 in an emergency. So if something goes wrong, if the car breaks, you have an unexpected medical expense, it's not inconvenient, it's catastrophic. You are out of luck. You don't fix your car. You don't know how to pay the medical bill that you have to pay. And so suddenly you're in debt and struggling under that burden as well. We did some work with a group called Worthy Strategy Group, where they went out over years and they have asked everyday Americans across every state in the United States, across different political backgrounds, across different economic backgrounds, to go out before they get interviewed and bring in a photo. And that photo they need to bring in is an image of how they feel about their financial life. And five years ago, people were bringing in images of people drowning. And in the last couple years, it shifted towards people being in cages and feeling trapped in a cage. And most recently, people who are unconnected, these are people who don't know each other, bring in images of a person with a boot on their neck.
[01:07:37:04 - 01:08:07:00]
And so that's the condition that people are feeling. And that's when you suck out all of the wealth, when you have this wealth pump that pulls from everybody and gives to the few, you're left with a society of everyday people who feel like there's a boot on their throat. And so we have something where the happiness index for the United States has fallen significantly for the first time since it's been measured and is trending negatively. Everyday people know that the system is working and it's not working for them.
[01:08:08:06 - 01:09:07:17]
Why does that matter? Well, historically, when you have these levels of wealth inequality, you can look at great data from historians like Peter Turchin or a new book, Goliath's Curse by Luke Kemp. They don't really take an opinion. They just go through history. And they show you sequentially over time that when you have these extreme levels of wealth inequality, when you have a public that feels like the systems are failing them, that system collapses. And so that's where we are today. We're on the verge of this systemic change where this model, this system we've chosen to fund and work our economy. People know it's not working. It's starting to collapse and something new has to come along. And so that's what's at stake at this moment of time and why we're at this crazy edge. And what do you think the actual tipping point is? Because I constantly wonder how is that this system is so unfair and that it's allowed to go on for so long in this way. And you see this in not just
in the business world where a lot of the biggest corporations
[01:09:09:07 - 01:09:25:13]
privatize all the benefit and externalize all the negative onto society. I mean, you take Bank of America, for example, which I think was studied where their bank tellers, roughly a third of them are on public assistance. So the US taxpayers paying them subsidizing that business to the tune of roughly $900 million a year.
[01:09:26:14 - 01:11:24:17]
And so you see the example after example where it's like, take all the good, give the society all the bad. A lot of people feel like you've said, but there's also a lot of people who are still on the base of the economic pyramid that seem to somehow see themselves at the top one day or see some of these villains as heroes. Yeah. You know, I mean, you know the power of storytelling and narrative. We've built this system from the 70s onward that just capitalized on American exceptionalism and turned it into this like markets will sort things out and all the winners will win. Winners winning will be the best outcome for society because markets will price magically external bad things happening into the markets. And we have 50 years of data that shows that doesn't happen. And yet the narrative persists because it's been a very strong narrative for years and years that the wealthiest of our society are the best. They're like the most incredible examples of American exceptionalism. And you have our first trillionaire who is on track to be responsible for the greatest loss of human lives in the 21st century with the cuts that he made through Doge. And so you've got this really strange economy where people aren't looking at somebody who's probably going to be responsible for a couple million people dying. And they instead say, what a great visionary leader. He put rockets in the space and he led this car company. But I think the tipping point starts to happen now where people see those examples and they kind of are starting to know that despite their narrative saying you too can one day be a billionaire, even though there's 3400 of them and your chances of that are probably fraction as likely of you becoming an NFL player, which is insanely unlikely to happen in the first place. People still hold onto those narratives, but they're starting to feel the cracks and they're starting to feel the system really not working for them or anyone they know. Nobody knows a billionaire.
[01:11:26:07 - 01:14:39:18]
And so when you start to see that happen, when you have 40% of people who are unable to handle a thousand dollar emergency in the United States, that means you have a system that's in distress. When you look at Washington state, we have 8 million Washingtonians, 900,000 of them are on SNAP food benefits. And so we start to feel the cracks and the breakage and your point earlier is that people feel like it's not one party or the other that has failed them. It is the system, the government, the parties both have failed them, which is why you're seeing this rise in populism and this rise in people looking for something different. Give me something to change things dramatically. If that's burned down the system, fine. Why would I fight hard to support a system that has been screwing me over for decades? So that's where people's energy is coming from is this system's failing them. Why would you go vote? Why? Why would I vote? Not helping me. So it's that kind of dynamic that people are feeling today. It's this rise in energy and anger and populism. And I think the interesting period of time that we're in is that when you look historically, if society started to fail and inequality grew to the extremes, what happened is the masses would just move. They would literally pick up from their city and they would just migrate somewhere else. You see these massive migrations out of areas. That's harder to do in this kind of global inequality economy. Harder to do in something as big as the United States where you can't really just leave easily somewhere else if you don't have the means to do so. So the tensions are different and the outcomes are different. I think that rise of populism, I think giving people a different path and a different future to fight for and create is kind of what we need to see happen. And get some of the folks who are in these elite positions to say, "You know what? Like we did around the New Deal. We need to change the system. Then we need to deal with wealth inequality, which we dealt with around the New Deal era. And we need to fundamentally restructure our society so it doesn't collapse." You want to point out that the whatever 3,000 odd billionaires, not only is it like the chance of being one of them, it's not even worth being. I think that's the bigger point I think is, because like when you meet people of extreme wealth, there's nothing to be proud of in saying, "I've extracted X amount from the rest of the world." It's just not something worth being. The way that you interact, the way the breakdown of real connection, of real community, and the sense of superiority that comes with it. So it's like, it's less for me that's just a mathematics of, "Oh, it's not achievable." It's that there are more worthy things, many of them, in life worth striving for, community, connection, purpose, impact. I think that's the billionaires are just the 3,000, but then all the way down to the person who, the lowest paid advisor, everyone almost feels like, "Okay, well, at least I'm on Noah's Ark. I'm on the safety ship." No one's asking, "The flood hasn't quite reached me yet. And so I'm okay with this." Versus saying, "Hey, unless we change course, we're all going to drown eventually. And does it really matter if mine is 10 years after you?" No, that's totally true. Look, you have 56,000 people that make up 0.001%. And that 56,000 people holds as many assets as 2.8 billion human beings.
[01:14:42:05 - 01:17:22:16]
That's crazy. And we look at a lot of
these numbers and we kind of look at them and they don't compute because they are so astronomically different that it's very hard to make them make mathematical sense and logical sense. And a lot of that 56,000 people are looking at symptoms and not they're like, "Oh, no, democracy's failing. Why is it failing? Let's get people like civically taught how they should go out and vote better. Let's educate people because maybe they don't understand their vote matters." That's not the issue. It's the underlying roots of the system that are causing these symptoms to show up. And so instead of treating these symptoms, like let's get to the roots, that's failing because people vote and they have the system fail, though. That's logical. Wouldn't it be wonderful if the most convenient option was the best option? But hardly ever is, and especially with something as entrenched as what we see now, which is how can we ever have a democracy without economic democracy? How can we ever have a fair future without a fair economy? And until we do the hard rewiring of that foundation, the rest is just putting lipstick on a pig. Your quote goes all the way back to the founding of America, where there was a firm belief that you can't have political democracy without economic democracy. And the principles of found this nation were that we didn't want kings. And that was because the aggregation of wealth and power was symbolized by kings, fascinated by a conversation if you could resurrect some of the founders of the United States and say like, "Hey, let's talk about Elon." Their heads would explode over the amount of wealth and power and influence that we have given an individual who is a living king in so many ways. I think we've come a long way from the ideals of what America was founded on. I think that's happened by choice. But let's be clear, that creates an opportunity to reset the system here, but it also creates a global opportunity because we know that the US has been a financial colonizer for the last 50, 100 years and imposed our will on the world. And that is collapsing and breaking every single hour of every single day right now. And so now there's a pathway for the world to reset how all of this stuff works together, reset the role of nations and how they can build different systems. And so that's an unprecedented opportunity. And I want to talk about, go back to your Facebook days, because just the way Elon amasses all that power economically, politically. Zuckerberg has too. You were one of the early employees of Facebook. You were a VP there. Walk me through that period. At the height of its cultural power you were there, what did you believe
[01:17:24:03 - 01:20:36:06]
they were? What was the promise that you bought into? Yeah, you know, at the outset, the companies had two missions. When I joined, the first mission was to make the world more open and connected. The idea there was that if we can start to get people to connect with each other and share
ideas and share a relationship, wouldn't that make the world better? Wouldn't we be better off because we would understand each other, we would have less division, and you would start to build a global society. So that was a compelling vision. And there were so many things you could use to confirm that and overemphasize your own role. And when the Arab Spring happened, Facebook and social media was largely credited with being a huge tool in helping the Arab Spring happen. Probably got way too much credit than what was happening because the credit was given by the media and social media companies themselves. We started to see these changes happen and how people were using these tools. And it felt like you were a part of a system that was helping democracies grow, that you were helping freedom advance. It really felt that way on the inside. And these products were growing. At the first big Facebook office that we had, we had conference rooms that the conferences were named for countries that were smaller than Facebook's user base. And so you'd continue to add a country as we got bigger than that country's population. And so you were hoping for India one day and hoping for China one day and it's now past those. And so every conference room was this scale sign. And there was a belief that this was actually getting better at that time and that it was good for the world to be doing these things. The tragedy that you see over time is that those promises, whether Mark Zuckerberg ever believed them or not, we can debate. But then the forces of power and the forces of success and the forces of being one of the wealthiest, most powerful people on the planet with a platform that's one of the most influential that has existed in history, sent it down a path of just greater dominance and power aggregation. And I think at some point, the allure of massive power, the ring, having that ring became the driving force, whether that was always there and hidden or whether that was shaped by these forces, I don't know. But there's interesting research now along having, you know how we have a poverty line that we understand where there's a limit to poverty where it's so unhealthy you can't survive. There's actually research going on around a wealth line of when do you have too much wealth that it's psychologically unhealthy for you to have more wealth than that. And so there's this interesting notion that this like aggregation of wealth and power, that it doesn't have negative impacts on you when a lot of research is showing that it's really bad for you. And it turns out bad for society and everybody else. I mean, that to me is not surprising at all, right? There's always like a right amount of things, right? Whether it's oxygen or our blood, whether it's water, it's everything. I mean, that's true for everything, and I think being powerless is extremely unhealthy when you feel that you have no agency in your life. And I think the opposite is true too, where you have so
much power that you can just
[01:20:37:07 - 01:23:06:07]
haphazardly, as you mentioned with USAID, destroy millions of people's lives. That is more power than any one person should ever have. You talked about the promise that you were sold, again, irregardless of whether or not the leadership actually believed it. When did your belief start to crack? Yeah, it was a steady accumulation of evidence. So, you know, when you work around people who you think are very intelligent, who treat you really nicely, they care for their family, they care for each other. But then you start to see evidence around decisions that you're making that impact the faceless people around the world, right? So, you know each other internally, but you don't know the billions of people who use the product. And so they become a number. And the goals become something to chase and metrics to pursue. And you see changes where you decide to make more of the service encrypted. And your argument is, hey, if we encrypt things, the bad guys can't read people's messages. So in these authoritarian regimes, people can safely revolt against the government. And then you say, well, hey, what about all the child sex exploitation material that we're struggling to combat on the platform? And they're like, oh, well, you know, we have ways of, you know, sort of kind of not really fixing that when it's encrypted. And so you start to see a mismatch between decisions being made and people being put at risk. And then as it got closer to, you know, teams that looked at what happened in the algorithms and the systems, I became really concerned that this system that people were using so many hours a day that we knew was influential. I mean, I helped build an advertising system that you might this morning like just love Crest toothpaste. And then over advertising, you might feel like, oh, maybe Colgate's better because I've been kind of seeing all this stuff that says it's better. And I might switch to Colgate. I can change how you think about toothpaste. Doesn't it seem logical that I could change how you think about other people that you might find immigrants suddenly distasteful because you're getting a bunch of messages talking about how bad they are for you and how bad they are for America. I might have you hate religious people because I'm bringing up all this content in your feed. That's, that's about religious groups being toxic for your, your own class. These kinds of influences in the newsfeed became extremely concerning to me. And so I started to see all these pieces come together and a lack of willingness in from Mark himself to actually research and understand and address it. Did you ever reach out to him directly either by email or yeah, you reached out and what did he say to you?
[01:23:07:13 - 01:27:52:03]
He said, I hope there's still things you're proud of. Like he just wasn't like, not interested. Other executives I took it to were like, I don't think this is a problem. I was like,
yeah, but the evidence, like the evidence, there's a lot of smoke and we don't know. And so there's, there's a desire for more confirmation bias of like, you don't have to look. So why look? No one's forcing you to look. There's no accountability in that system. If I had a house and I had kids who played in their basement, we had a basement playroom. And if, and if I was in an area that was like, hey, look, there are radon readings, which is a chemical that's very bad for your health. And there are a lot of basements with radon, like in Connecticut, I would check and see if there was radon in my basement. These companies and Facebook in particular just doesn't check. They don't look to see if they're putting kids in harm's way or adults in harm's way. They just say, go play in the basement. Good luck. And what, I mean, what would be the reason for not, I mean, that seems like such a crazy thing for them not to do. What is the corporate mumbo jumbo logic behind not making sure it's a safe place for people? Well, they're not responsible for it. Legally, they are not responsible for ensuring that it's a safe place. When we created our laws around tech and the internet in particular, we created something called Section 230. It was part of legislation that said that if people post on your services, the very beginning of the internet, when the idea of user generated content was like, oh my gosh, what are the revolutionary new thing? We all think it's just like normal now. Back in the day, it was like, this is new. We should make sure people aren't, like, that companies that host this content aren't liable for anything that's put on their systems. They created this Section 230. And it's given blanket liability for massive harms that we've seen on Snapchat with people connecting with kids to sell them drugs, from Facebook with the trials that are talking about youth, mental health, and youth harms that are happening from what's shown on these platforms. And there's no legal structure for accountability until these very recent court cases. And it's a new theory of law that's being tried in these cases. It's more of a product liability law that gets around Section 230. But the platforms are still arguing Section 230 because they want to fight that fight. It's a beautiful for them set of immunity. When you kind of look at accountability, right? You'd be like, oh, you know, here's what's going to happen. The markets will hold them accountable. We're told forever that the stock market will hold you accountable for externalities and that the markets will protect society. That's like Milton Friedman's 101 doctrine. When Frances Hagen came out, she was the Facebook whistleblower. She had like 10,000 documents that categorized a whole bunch of concerning harms around Facebook. Everything from teen mental health to human trafficking in the Middle East to cartel recruitment in Mexico. Awful, awful, awful stuff. She comes out. She testifies it for Congress. Big story. Wall Street Journal is running an article a day for a week. Bang, bang, bang. Stock drops 4.9, 5%. And so you're like, oh, okay, like the market's holding them accountable. Well, it recovered a week later. And so that like, it was literally a dip. It was like, oh, like people are being harmed. Boop, drops. Also, not to mention that like sex trafficking of kids and cartel recruitment, a 5% drop of a stock is a bullshit, right? Like, hey, look, I agree with you there. And that makes it even more the point that it doesn't matter. So drops 5% recovers a week later. That was in October, 2021. In February of 2022, so November, December, January, February. So like three months later, Meta has their earnings report. And it turns out they've spent way too much money in the Metaverse. And Wall Street doesn't like the earnings number. So the stock dropped 26% in a single day. There was 230 billion in market cap wiped out over the finances, not over the human trafficking or the teen mental health or the cartel recruitment. And so then later 2022, Meta laid off a bunch of people and the market said, yay, we're so happy. And the stock goes right back up. So this notion that externalities will get priced in is time and time again shown to be untrue. Market forces do not hold companies accountable for any of their bad harms and bad actions, only for financial actions. Hey, everyone, Rustam here. Sorry to interrupt whatever brilliant point I was about to make. I have a simple request. Like subscribe, leave a comment. And most importantly, share this conversation with a friend and makes a huge difference to us and helps us grow the channel. If you want to learn more broadly, check us out online at world within.org. Now back to the show.
[01:27:54:05 - 01:29:04:13]
Can you tell me a little about how you left Facebook? Like when was that and what your relationship has been? I know you've testified to Congress at least once. You've been on a lot of media channels. Like what does it look like since leaving? It was the summer of 2020. I was looking at teams that were part of my group that were helping algorithms, a public company called CrowdTangle. And their data was really concerning in the kinds of content that was the most popular in the platform. And so that was the next in a series of issues that made me quite concerned about the influence we were having. And so I raised that with Mark Zuckerberg in leadership and tried to get that to change and said I was going to quit because I thought we're on the wrong side of history. But I would stay if I could build out those systems that enabled us to investigate what was happening in the platform and build greater transparency for academic researchers and for journalists and other activist partners. I was told no. And so I decided to quit the company and didn't expect or plan on becoming a public voice against the company until actually after January 6th happened. So when that whole
[01:29:05:20 - 01:32:27:10]
storming of the Capitol happened and stop the steel had grown, the company came out publicly. Two weeks later said, "Well, none of this happened on our platform. This happened on Parler and all places," which I knew they were lying because I knew that they wouldn't have been able to do those investigations to know what had or hadn't happened on the platform. And so that shifted my perspective to say I can't just be a quiet person who departed the company, but I need to be vocal about it. And then ended up speaking with the New York Times for an article and then became a source in the Facebook papers, helping them understand the documents that came out around corroborate a lot of what I knew there to be true. And then subsequently have testified before the U.S. Senate and now recently in some of these trials that have gone on in LA and Santa Fe, New Mexico, around the team mental health and these algorithms in the platform. So not an easy journey, but one that feels important. When you know that we each need to step up in our own ways and take the opportunities that we have to fix things for people, it's pretty straightforward to say that we should do that despite the discomfort, despite it not being the way that I want to spend all my time. It's an important thing to do. I wanted to take a step back and ask about Facebook in its place in this broader financial system, right? Was Facebook, did it get to where it is now? And I'm actually curious now that you've had some distance from it, what you think its actual impact on society has been and take that impact. And if you were to walk backward, is this a very unique company that made a very unique set of choices along the way to get here? Or is this the natural course for any powerful platform that has this little regulation and oversight? I think it's a lot of aspects of the product of the system than people making unaccountable, harmful decisions because of the system not holding them accountable. So if you look at, if there's like CEO school, which there kind of is, there's like all these CEOs have their networks of mentors and it's like this super like tight group of people who run all the things. And they're told in CEO school that your number one job is to maximize shareholder value instead of stakeholder value. And shareholders are just literally the people who own your company, own your stock. And then the stakeholders are the consumers and customers who use your products. It's your supply chain, it could be your workers, like all these people are stakeholders in your business. And we've told since the 1970s that the religious doctrine of corporations in the global economy is shareholder value. And that means that the only thing you have to do and the only thing you're responsible for is growing. And that leaves everybody behind. And in some ways, to your point, it's easier because one of the things that happened when we created shareholder primacy was that everything became a financial metric. And the only thing that mattered were metrics and growing that one financial metric. Companies love to say, our greatest asset is our employees. In your filing to the SEC, where do employees show up? They're on the cost side. They're not an asset, they're the cost side. So employees are a cost to be managed. Your supply chain, a cost to be managed. Anything that you invest in that would build safer plants is a cost to be managed. Everything
[01:32:28:16 - 01:32:50:17]
on the positive stakeholder contribution side is a cost. Everything on the just the revenue side is the thing we celebrate. And so we've structurally set it up to incentivize these CEOs, most of which, when you look outside of Zuckerberg, most of which aren't in tenure at their firm for very long. It's only a few years they're there. So it's like, get in, quick cycle, make my bank, get out.
[01:32:51:18 - 01:33:36:10]
And so that structure takes bad behavior and makes it even worse. So if you have somebody like Mark Zuckerberg, who's probably become extremely power hungry, that system enables him to aggregate more and more power without ever, ever having to worry about the externalities. Kill a few teens? I don't know, engagement's up. Cause the revolution in a country? Engagement's up. Metrics look great. Unfortunately, we did a genocide in Myanmar. And so it's like those things become non-essential parts of the accountability in the company. And so that system perpetuates that behavior that you see across all sorts of companies and businesses. Look at what's happening every time a company announces massive layoffs. Stock goes up a bunch
[01:33:37:14 - 01:33:48:13]
because they're cutting costs. And so that is a externality onto society of these people were important nine months ago. Are you just really bad at your job and you hired 30,000 people too many?
[01:33:49:14 - 01:37:15:07]
Is that what you're saying? Like, so maybe you shouldn't be CEO because you hired too many people, right? But instead it's this like cost cutting thing that gets celebrated for the short term and we move on. So when you look back then at the promise you were made, you know, you were told young Brian Boland and the outcome you have now witnessed, what do you think is the true legacy of Facebook? Are we more connected world? Are we more open? Are we more divided? Are we more closed off? Yeah. The second mission of the company was to give people the power to build community and bring the world closer together. And the interesting thing is that I saw Mark and the other leaders only focus on the first half of give people power to build communities. And they've built some communities on that system. There's some like rampant anti-health communities that they've helped to build, some rampant anti-democratic communities they've helped to build, stop the steal was uniquely grown and powerful on the platform. So yeah, they're doing great at building communities. I think the net that we're seeing when
I first joined the company, we didn't want to share usage numbers publicly because of the time when I joined, people were using Facebook 30 minutes a day. And you never have products that people use every day for the same amount of time. It goes down. You like start to play a game, you play it a lot, a lot, a lot, then the next day less and it goes down. Well, now you're at like six hours a day that people are spending on Facebook and social media. So the opposite's happened. People are spending more time there. And I think, you know, Mark Zuckerberg and other leaders talked about there being a ledger of good and bad, that there was no product that existed that didn't do some harm in the world. But the good news was that when we look at the Facebook ledger, we're on the side of human progress and there's more good happening than bad in our platform. The problem is that that ledger doesn't actually exist. They're not actually like trying to measure it and look for it. It's this kind of faith argument that you just need to believe, just believe that we're doing more good in the world and then everything will be fine. When I think we're starting to see that there are juries of peers in the United States who are finding that the company is harming teens. Not to mention, I think there's this other element of it. Going back to something you said about how a lot of the people you worked with were really kind, caring people. Like on a personal level, I know in my own life, friends, mentors who are exceptional in a specific skill at marketing, at financials, but they seem to be in that very position and I've asked them, "Well, you're helping make X amount of things in the world that are not good. Oh, but I'm doing this amount in my own small circle, my own life, my own community." And I've pointed out, well, the amount of negative that you're kind of amplifying or helping happen is much greater. And they say, "Oh, we don't do that math. We don't do that calculus." It goes back to the ledger. Then we all have a ledger and we're all afraid to look at it. I used to think, because I love stories my whole life, I love especially the epics, right? Like the Lord of the Rings. In Lord of the Rings, you don't have like a single orc who has any sort of self-reflection or any doubt. I expect that's how evil is propped up. It's undeniable. It's visceral. If you're around it, you feel awful. You feel the effects of the ring. That's not what happens. When you're around it, you get handed a glass of champagne. You get invited to a really cool sporting event. The people are super nice. They can be thoughtful. They give you a gift, but it's like,
[01:37:16:08 - 01:41:42:12]
that is the facade. And even really good people who you mentioned, the CEOs who get brought into these companies. I have friends who are in that position and amazing parents, amazing friends. And it's almost like, hey, as long as we get ours, then we can exit that like, hey, we don't really care if the structure is deeply, deeply elitist and unfair. As long as we can be among the elite for a period of time and live the life we want to live, then we just kind of look the other way. And it's easy to do that because as you said earlier, all those are the people are faceless, but my family is real and I'm real. It's the human element of everything. And it's the fact that we have enabled a lot of systems of dehumanization. When you have people who know each other and they're remembering birthdays, they're taking care of their kids, they're doing things that seem to be like carrying good person. And yet they can go into an office and they look at a bunch of spreadsheets and metrics where everything has been reduced and dehumanized away from the messy parts of humanity. Like, oh man, if I was in that position and I would stand up on a heartbeat, there's no way that that would go on under my watch, right? People love to say like, I'd be the moral warrior and champion. And you start to see that when people are in these systems, there's a whole bunch of forces that are working against them to convince them otherwise, to celebrate them, to celebrate them for being a part of the country club that they're now able to, because they have this great paying job to celebrate the fact their kids are going to the best private schools and that's really great. And what a great parent you are and look at all these great things you're doing. And oh, your philanthropy, we came to your gala, it was so wonderful and we gave a little bit of money and you gave a lot of money. You bought that auction item for so much money, you're so good. And so those reinforcements skew people from reconnecting the humanity behind all of these business decisions. A lot of the reason that we care about the community ownership work and the community governance work is that it specifically rehumanizes the entire process. Because you're connecting with human beings, you're connecting with communities, you're not turning those people and those groups into a metric, into a number, into something to be optimized. And that's a fundamentally different relationship with how capital can and should work that we've lost in our market-centric world. And I think that's the power of example, right? When someone sees the work you're doing and Katie is doing, it's like, oh wait, there is another way. As you said, I'm certainly not out here pointing fingers in the sense of I have invested like that before myself. And a lot of this has been a journey for my own sense of what really is impact, what is purpose, what is a meaningful life. As you said, it's hard to believe like, wait, there's no way that all of these smart people who are many of them very decent, how could we, could everyone be getting it wrong? And the answer is yes, right? And I think it took me a long time to realize the answer could be yes. Yeah. Yeah, and the answer could be yes. And the answer could be the fact that we teach everybody
in high school economics for the AP Econ exam that these economic laws that we live by are science laws like gravity and not just happen to be things that we have chosen. And then we go and reinforce that when people go into their college Econ courses and get their MBA from the University of Chicago, which is, you know, probably the economics department that is responsible for the greatest amount of human suffering in the history of economics departments and their drive for shareholder privacy. And so it's a made up fairy tale land. Now that we've exposed the fairy tale to 50 years of real world, it doesn't work. And so it's time to say a fairy tale was actually terrible. It was actually a nightmare story. Let's figure out what comes next. We've been talking a lot about Facebook and then jumping into like the greater economic structure. How did a critique of Facebook end up becoming a critique of a whole economic system? When I left Facebook, I was interested in kind of what projects I wanted to work on next. I had a little bit of time that I could do that in. And it was kind of coming in a period of time where there was so much anger and, you know, upheaval over the election cycles in the United States. It was like, you know, people seem really angry. Like why? What's going on? Why people are angry? Started to do that homework and research of just what's going on with everyday people. And it
[01:41:43:13 - 01:44:49:06]
really came down to a lack of opportunity, a lack of financial stability. And so that led to a first project around the minimum wage and the fight for 15. And so I worked with the fight for 15 folks, did some protesting in San Francisco and a whole bunch of other efforts to spend time with the offices of different Senate leaders to get the $15 minimum wage passed in the Senate that had already passed in the House. And that process of talking with those kind of offices for the centers was really discouraging. And it showed me that the system was not playing for something that was 70% popular when you poll it. They had all these excuses that they would make that you could kind of tell came from the restaurant lobby or a different lobbying group that was not excited about a $15 minimum wage. And so couldn't get enough people in the Senate to support a minimum wage. So I said, "Okay, well, that seems to be a broken door. What other avenues are there that we can accomplish the same thing of better wages, better benefits, better voice and control for workers, for everyday people?" And really started down the path of employee ownership. And so that became the question of, "Okay, well, it looks like when people own their own companies, when all the employees on the company, and when they have voice, they can actually govern what happens at the company, hey, they actually make better wages. They make better benefits because they're deciding, as a company, what everyone gets out of the company. And so you have a much more equitable and fair marketplace." And so as we started to work towards that work, the question was like, "Why isn't this happening more normally? This is just really great for communities, really great for outcomes and people." And it kept pointing over and over again to the class of investors who only care about their investment pool growing. Despite the fact that a lot of these investors have way more than they'll ever be able to spend in their lifetime or their next kid's lifetime or their grandkids generations, there's still this drive to accumulate, accumulate, accumulate, and not a thought towards built. It feels like this economy that's coming out of this neoliberal Milton Friedman Chicago School of Economics economic model, it seems like there's a lot of data and evidence that this is not working. And it's true. If you look at the amount of research done, it's overwhelming that it doesn't work. And so then it came to the question of like, "Okay, cool. What do we replace it with?" And started to go on a journey with Kate Rayworth in Donor Economics and Thomas Piketty and his work and Gabriel Zuckman and Stiglitz and other people who have thought of models that are more equitable and models that we can shift to, we can create, we can do. And so it became really exciting to think, "Oh, we're not totally at a loss here. We just need to start to figure out how to build the movement and the momentum and the people and the groups to start to say, let's change this thing." We changed it before 50 years ago. We can absolutely choose something else and change it again. As David Graber says, "These systems are just our choice. They're not something that's inevitable." What is civil society's role in all of this? What is the role for philanthropy, for foundations? Where can they step up and where has it so far fallen short? You talked earlier about the corpus that sits in these foundations and the balance sheet. That is
[01:44:50:13 - 01:44:55:10]
probably the most underutilized resource. I think there's one and a half trillion dollars in assets
[01:44:56:12 - 01:45:42:19]
that are invested in the stock market or into the very private equity and hedge funds that are undermining their mission. You mentioned Ford earlier. They're one of the largest investors in the world of foundations in private equity and hedge funds. I would wager that if you looked at the history, I actually bet this, if somebody wanted to put money in, I would bet them, that if we actually did the math on their investments over the last 15 years and we looked at their mission, I would say that Ford has been more harmful to the world and their existence than a good force in the world. I think that their investments in private equity and hedge funds has probably created more anti-emission outcomes than any of their grants have done in total.
[01:45:43:19 - 01:47:33:17]
I'll take that bet. When you look at how you deploy that, you could take the 15, 16 billion that Ford Foundation has, I think
that's what they are today, 16 billion that they have, and you could 100% mission align and mission deploy that capital. If you think about the gap in employee ownership, we think there's probably 600 to $700 million that you could absorb inside of employee ownership funds that exist today. We're talking about foundations having 1.5 trillion. We need less than 1% of it to go towards the employee ownership gap. Scale that up. Or if you made it 10 billion, 50, 100 billion of that 1.5 trillion towards ownership economy. Now deploy the same investments towards housing and home ownership. You could start to see how the assets that are sitting parked doing harm rather than actually creating towards their mission, if they invested them in patient capital, low rate ways, they protect their principle. Their principle would still come back, but they would enable businesses to have 2% loans to be able to become employee owned. They would enable homes and homeowners and apartment buildings to be built at incredibly favorable patient rates. That amount of capital would transform fundamentally the economics in our society and the economics for the working class who's drowning and struggling today. It's not hard. It just takes courage. And it takes way more courage than some CEO saying, "Oh, you know what? We're going to move from 5% to 6% this year because we care so much." Don't give me that. That's baloney. Allocate your portfolio towards your mission if you actually care about achieving the mission. To me, there's two things that are remarkable. One is the amount
[01:47:34:19 - 01:48:10:03]
of effort and things we have to do to actually make an equitable world. And two, how little sacrifice and courage it actually takes from those with the most power and wealth to make it happen. The difference of making a low double digit return to making a single digit return, but being able to fund municipal bonds and community funds. It is such a... And for people who will never be affected by that difference, by and large. That's what's mind boggling to me. You're still growing, but at a slightly lower rate. That delta and a lot of that
[01:48:11:16 - 01:52:12:12]
traditional growth isn't even real growth. A lot of those fail. You look at the number of underperformed SMP over 30 years. It's insane. And so it's just the thought of more money. What if you flip the paradigm? What if you said, "Hey, instead of your carve out being your mission aligned carve out, your carve out was your big bets carve out." So you had like 90% of your portfolio aligned towards your mission and then you let somebody go chase the crazy multiple returns on big crazy bets and new innovations and things that have outsized returns. Flip that. Right now, the folks who steward these funds, they get wind and dined. They're taken out to fancy nice dinners. They're offered seats on boards to hobnob with other super influential, powerful, wealthy people. I mean, how many of these boards of the top foundations have board members that are actually from the communities that they help? Or have a 30% of their board from the communities they actually help? Or gasp. A majority of board members from the communities are actually trying to help. Imagine that. Or a single member from the communities they're trying to help. Yeah, a single member. Yeah. Just the fact that foundations have a 5% payout requirement. I think, for example, Musk's has not made just that 5% number in the last three years and is facing some penalties for that. But that's a very small number, 5%. 95%, they are legally allowed and not even allowed. It is the standard to invest in things that are antithetical to their mission. And so when people say to me, "Well, do you really believe in community ownership? Do you really believe that impact investing can work or philanthropy in a smart way?" I'm like, "Of course it can." But if you add a diet that was 95% Twinkies and 5% broccoli, why the hell would you blame the broccoli? You would blame the Twinkies. And I think that's what we have. We have a Twinkie endowment model right now. And you could tell that I didn't study econ 101 very well because I have a very basic understanding of- You're the everyman economist. Exactly. So it's just like you have all this money that people have supposedly earmarked and taken a benefit by donating. But as you said, "side lines" is a good word. It's sitting on the sideline. It's so frustrating knowing that we have all the money that we need to solve these problems, not in some made up place, in philanthropic vehicles. There already is there. And I think one of the greatest conceptual fallacies I see in philanthropy is the idea that, "Well, if we just compound it in highly unethical ways, we'll have more to give later. But what happens is we have more to compound highly unethical ways. It gives us more to compound in highly unethical ways in the future, which just exacerbates things. I'm grateful that there's people like you who are so vocal that we do a new course." I think that's one thing that you've also pointed out to me in private conversations, that the powerful forces that are doing negative have done a really good job organizing and putting out a blueprint and being very clear on what their goals are. And that those who are looking for an alternative future that's not so run like a pyramid scheme, that we all need to do a better job in coalition, in relationship, putting out a blueprint. What do you think it would take for that to happen? And so I think showing people the things that they can do in their everyday lives that make all this happen and happen quickly and happen easily for them helps them be a part of the movement and know that the stories behind it, which is one of the things I love about what you do or within is telling the stories of these great organizations, of what community ownership at AFC Wimbledon looks like and feels like and why it's different and powerful and
inspiring and interesting. That stuff gets people to feel like and know that they're a part of building something bigger. So with unlock ownership, we have so many great stories that we're starting to put out and tell the stories of the organizations that we're just lucky enough to be able to provide funding for,
[01:52:13:12 - 01:58:57:01]
that are actually meaningfully changing communities outcomes and families outcomes. And interestingly, when people own and people govern, they actually feel civically engaged again. So back to that hand wavy democracy thing, the way that you save democracy is you save community ownership and community governance. Because once you do that, people get re-engaged again. It's almost too obvious that people believe in the things that they are a part of. A lot of people call us the ownership economy. What is an ownership economy and how is it fundamentally different from the one we have now? Important to kind of boil that down into just two simple ideas, kind of who owns and as a part of who owns who benefits from something and who governs, who gets to decide, make decisions around a thing. And historically, we've had a whole mix of, we love, love, love in America. Talk about the small business owner on Main Street who owns their little shoe shop and they decide all the things and it's their thing that they made and built. And that's a great romantic story. And that's a kernel of what we want to aspire towards, is how do we give people the ability to have that kind of control? And you can have ownership and you can have governance together. So you can think about a co-op being kind of the easiest form of ownership and governance, where all the employees who work at a food retailer, maybe a co-op food retailer, they all have an ownership stake in that. It's owned by the co-op. They participate in the income and the benefits from the co-op. And then when the co-op gets together, they're voting and deciding on the future and what happens with that retailer. That's like a very pure example. Sometimes you can just have ownership. And as long as there's a lot of ownership, you'd like there to be voice, but it can still be great for people. So you look at what organizations like APIS and Heritage are doing around ESOPs, making companies 100% employee owned. There may not be full voting rights and full governance across every single employee. They're represented by a trust for the ESOP. So there is governance and there's power in their voice, but they are gaining economic benefits. Then you think about governance. So you can have systems that are much more about stewardship and governance. Think about the power that unions used to have where they really were protecting people and workers and getting them better benefits and outcomes and wages. That's a huge part of the governance lens is having a strong voice. When you have a sale of a business, you have equitable share of the returns, not the investors making 16X and the
workers making 0.5X. You spread that equitably in the kind of outcomes that happen for a business or profits. The profits don't go first to the investors. They're shared more equitably. Think about where you live. We've had a huge explosion in the last 50 years of the value of homes in the United States. The two largest drivers of the racial wealth gap are wages and benefits and homeownership. And so we've seen that explosion and it probably won't continue to the level that it was. But how where you live can better serve you economically. How do we get more people to participate in either directly owning where they live or being a part of a co-op that owns where they live, then shares the profits from that rental property back to the people who live there, either by lowering their rents or giving them credits or other interesting structures that are coming up. So that lens of really rethinking about who owns and governs everything from our businesses to the apartment buildings where we live to the retail block downtown, the businesses who owns that, those buildings who owns those structures on that block, the more that those are owned and shared in prosperity across the community, the better outcomes you have for everyone in that community. And you have people really caring and engaging with each other in that community. So that really creates a different way where you're not saying like, "Hey, we're moving to communism," or like whatever the stupid rhetorical points that people throw at this stuff. And they're really, when people make those arguments, like, "Isn't this socialism? Isn't this communism?" Those are lazy, lazy arguments. They're just people throwing out rhetoric to try to undermine the ideas you're talking about here. And that you can have social benefits, you can have social safety nets, you can take care of each other and still have a system that deploys capital. So these are not antithetical to each other. Yeah, the implicit almost like, "Why do you hate billionaires?" And be like, that's not the point. That's not what we're saying. Why do you hate everyday people? You know, like, "Well, what's your..." At World Within, a lot of what you said is exactly, I mean, for us, the blueprint of how we actually get there is show what works, right? The power of stories, seeing is believing, showing that you can have a community owned bank, apartment, housing. And like that for me is success for us is that, how do we move community ownership from this weird niche thing to a way of seeing the world that actually touches everything? They're not like just kind of granola cutesy ideas that they actually work. I mean, you take Mondragon Corporation in the Basque region of Spain, right? That's, I believe, roughly over 100 federated cooperatives with over 70,000 workers. And the average GDP to capita in the Basque region is 22% higher than the EU average. So our blueprint is how do you show it working and working everywhere across every sector? So
it's integral part of the DNA of our economy. But that's just the way our lens is, right? So we fund it and we film it. I'm curious, what is your blueprint? How do you see us laddering up? How does unlock ownership? What is the philosophical current that guides that work? Good news is that these are not my ideas or Katie's ideas or, you know, our personal ideas. These are built off of really great thinkers and economists and people who study these problems all day every day. And they write books about them and they write white papers that nobody wants to read because they're incredibly dense and long when they write books that are even longer and even more dense. Examples of ownership are really positive. It's funny, the ERISA laws that made ESOPs and employee ownership possible happen in the 1970s, I think it was 1972, at the same time that Milton Friedman was popularizing his shareholder primacy. And so you actually have the same amount of time of evidence for both models. The employee ownership models win time and time and time again. Those companies outperform. The employees make money, they do better. It just works better and provably works better. Even when you look at models in the shareholder primacy system like Costco that has decided over the years to pay their employees really, really well. They've created a bunch of millionaire employees who worked there for a long time and their employee satisfaction is really high and their supply chains love them. And they have outperformed the S&P over the entirety of their life.
[01:58:58:16 - 02:02:33:13]
So we can build these systems that work in our society. We go all the way back. Let's go back to the new deal. When we did the new deal, it was like a new... Its position is like a new deal for the working class, but it really wasn't. It was like a new deal for white male working class. So it was great for the people who were predominantly voting and controlling society at the time. And it prevented a societal collapse. And so then you had an era where you had a much more equitable society coming out of the 1940s and 50s to the fact that I love when people are like, "Oh man, I got 39%, 40% tax rate. That's un-American. We would never in America have a 40% tax rate." Our top marginal tax rate at one point was 90%. Now, in the 70s when Friedman's Doctrine came out, the working class, middle class and upper middle class was super comfortable. Like things were working for white people. They didn't need a new economic paradigm. There wasn't energy that was like, "Hey, things aren't working." They had to introduce this shareholder primacy ideology and gradually get it to become a belief system for a lot of families that were fine. They didn't need change. And so somehow over 50 years, they were able to indoctrinate everybody into a different economic system that interestingly undermined the economic stability of the middle class and the upper middle class to the point where the lower upper class today feels in economic peril, whole other side story. So now what do we have? We have a lower middle class, middle class, upper middle class who is angry, who feels like they're struggling, can't get by. We have a lower upper class who feels like they are on the verge of insolvency. So now we have a system with a lot of energy and dissatisfaction into it. So what those guys had to do over 50 years to change an economy against people's best interests when they were feeling pretty comfortable, we now have the to take a moment in time where people feel uncomfortable, where they feel like the system is failing and broken. And now we can use this energy to more quickly show these examples in a different way and solve a problem that people are feeling as opposed to have to convince people over a course of time that they should do something differently. That's the opportunity of this moment. Instead of hating billionaires, we should look at billionaires and say, "Look, it's actually a symptom of a broken, of an economy that doesn't work for everybody that they exist." I don't have to hate them. I can just say their existence in and of itself is an indictment on the system that we've chosen. So let's just make no billionaires, not because they're bad people, because it's a bad outcome for all of us. And so that's the energy that we can start to propagate and build out in this system. Because all these uber billionaires, they were smart, they worked hard, but the amount of luck involved with every single one of these billionaires, particularly the ones that just got lucky because the right sperm and egg came together. We're now at the point where 60% of billionaires are either inheritors or from monopoly or crony capitalism. So it's an Oxfam number. So it's not like those people worked hard to get there. It was an insane amount of luck and opportunity for pretty much anybody in this wealthy side of things. And one of the reasons I feel very optimistic is because you only take an alternate route when the main route starts breaking down. The good seeds, the blueprints that we talked about, they already exist, but to support them so that they succeed, support them financially, support them with media and storytelling, with all the resources and networks we have,
[02:02:34:17 - 02:05:26:02]
I think that's really to me, as you said, the mission of this moment in time. A lot of what we talked about today was how endowments or foundations or how they can get involved in this. For someone listening to this conversation who wants to do something about it, who has capital deploy, or they're just trying to better understand what they can do, where would they start? Yeah, I mean, look, there's a million different ways. I'll move from some things that anyone can do, like Boston Impact Initiative. They're fantastic. Seed Commons, similarly. I think that's a great one for people to look at how they can participate with them. I think when you look at ways to deploy the rest of your capital, there's things like municipal bonds that Clarion Call Capital is doing. They're actually looking at the communities that actually need the capital and you need bonds to build things. You need bonds to build stuff. They're like one of the coolest, most boring in the universe things that you could buy that do really amazing work building communities and important communities across the United States. As we wrap up, because we're so much of what we talked about with stories and movies, is there a book, a movie, a quote, a line that has meant a lot to you that kind of gives you a little extra energy in doing the work that you do? I've talked about it a few times. This is from Breaking Bad, the TV show. There's this kind of scene where these two characters are talking about a very dramatic situation that they lay out and the key takeaway that the guy says to Walt is to have no half measures and really to not kind of go halfway on these things that are critical or important or you know have to happen in the world. I really thought about that a lot. How many of these things that we engage with that we do as half measures, we do a little bit of the way. For me, that driving force of go hard with all of these kinds of approaches, don't leave anything half done, don't leave a half measure out there, but bring the full measure to this work is the thing that has really stuck with me. I think my takeaway from this episode is figuring out whether it's in our own investments, whether it's in our economy, in our businesses. So thanks for spending the perfect amount of time with me today, Brian, and I look forward to doing again soon. The How to Change the World podcast is produced by World Within Studios with PRX. World Within is a nonprofit that invests in solutions and stories that help visionary ideas become real and inspire us all to act. Find out more about us at worldwithin.org. Our producer and composer is Alexander Miller. Our editing team is Eve Weston, Martin McGreevy, and Kenny McMillan. Special thanks to Gabe Sweeney for technical assistance. If you were moved by this conversation, please like, subscribe, leave us a review, and most importantly, share it with a friend. Your support means a lot and helps us keep this show on the road. Until next time.