TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:16.597 --> 00:00:23.017
This is fictional problems a podcast where we discuss all things writing in
00:00:23.017 --> 00:00:28.797
association with speculative fiction ireland on today's episode we're going
00:00:28.797 --> 00:00:32.197
to be continuing a discussion in relation to identity fiction,
00:00:32.437 --> 00:00:38.177
with a particular focus on Star Trek. Join us.
00:00:41.857 --> 00:00:46.297
And welcome back to Fictional Problems, the podcast where we discuss all things
00:00:46.297 --> 00:00:51.337
writing in association with speculative fiction ardent, with myself, Gary J. Martin.
00:00:51.657 --> 00:01:01.037
And myself, A.R. McDevon. So, today we are going to do a little bit of a closer
00:01:01.037 --> 00:01:05.157
inspection of recent science fiction property.
00:01:05.497 --> 00:01:11.457
Yes, well, so, yes, I get to launch a rant again as Gary fixes the clock.
00:01:12.897 --> 00:01:18.117
So, I saw this video recently, and it was a short video.
00:01:18.925 --> 00:01:22.005
Featuring a writer from TNG, from the next generation.
00:01:22.185 --> 00:01:28.385
That is my preferred generation of Star Trek. I watched TOS. I thought it was grand.
00:01:28.605 --> 00:01:32.645
I probably couldn't tell you the names of the episodes, but I can tell you the
00:01:32.645 --> 00:01:35.145
stories that were covered, how seminal it was.
00:01:35.365 --> 00:01:37.645
There was some bad and some good.
00:01:38.825 --> 00:01:43.385
It was a unique vision, certainly, at the time. Absolutely. And that's something
00:01:43.385 --> 00:01:45.065
I want to get back to as well.
00:01:46.305 --> 00:01:49.285
So TNG was my Star Trek. yeah same here
00:01:49.285 --> 00:01:53.145
and it's similar age we are yes
00:01:53.145 --> 00:01:55.985
but for me it
00:01:55.985 --> 00:01:59.005
also was i had a physics a science slash
00:01:59.005 --> 00:02:03.165
physics teacher who only in fifth year did i discover that she watched this
00:02:03.165 --> 00:02:07.285
and it became part of our conversations there was an episode where wharf went
00:02:07.285 --> 00:02:12.685
through parallel dimensions or parallel and she she chatted to us myself and
00:02:12.685 --> 00:02:16.285
and a classmate about how that was actually That's just quantum physics.
00:02:16.585 --> 00:02:22.085
And this was a 16, 17-year-old going, this is real?
00:02:22.945 --> 00:02:26.785
You know, what? And it was a... Did you not see the sliding doors on the shop
00:02:26.785 --> 00:02:28.825
front as well from Star Trek?
00:02:29.345 --> 00:02:32.965
You know, the infrared doors. No, no, no, not that sort of way.
00:02:33.045 --> 00:02:34.925
I mean, the science was real.
00:02:36.485 --> 00:02:40.125
I'm just being facetious, sorry. Yes, you are. Don't get me started on the crap
00:02:40.125 --> 00:02:44.385
of the futuristic crap of futurism, all that is. But I digress.
00:02:45.385 --> 00:02:49.445
So the writer was talking about how he pitched an idea, this was before Gene
Load full transcript
00:02:49.445 --> 00:02:52.545
Rodney passed, he pitched an idea to Gene Rodney about Q,
00:02:53.045 --> 00:03:01.605
that Q faked losing his powers, and then led the Enterprise on an adventure
00:03:01.605 --> 00:03:03.865
all the way around the galaxy. There were Klingons involved,
00:03:04.045 --> 00:03:04.885
there were all this other stuff.
00:03:05.485 --> 00:03:08.605
And Gene Rodney said, okay, but what's it about?
00:03:09.405 --> 00:03:12.725
Right. And the writer went, it's it, it's it, it's it.
00:03:13.465 --> 00:03:18.545
Q is in it. It's a chase movie. King Ant. It's going all the way around the galaxy.
00:03:19.820 --> 00:03:26.620
What's it about yeah and the writer went away and came back with the Q episode
00:03:26.620 --> 00:03:30.480
where he actually loses his powers yeah and he has to find his humanity where
00:03:30.480 --> 00:03:33.740
God has to find his humanity that is what it was about,
00:03:34.580 --> 00:03:38.220
and the writer said and I it may have been Brendan Braga I can't remember the
00:03:38.220 --> 00:03:42.140
name of the writer he said that every time he talks to a new writer these days,
00:03:42.720 --> 00:03:46.940
that every time someone brings a story to him he's like no no no what's it about yeah,
00:03:47.600 --> 00:03:54.340
and And in this particular short video, it then showed shots of Alex Kurtzman
00:03:54.340 --> 00:03:58.580
being asked, the writer of all the news track.
00:03:58.980 --> 00:04:03.320
Okay. Oh, yes. Referred to his Kurtzman track. Yes. Yeah.
00:04:03.780 --> 00:04:09.380
And he was asked, I think he wrote Discovery, he writes Strange New Worlds, he writes Academy.
00:04:09.740 --> 00:04:12.920
Okay. And he was asked, what's about?
00:04:13.200 --> 00:04:19.220
Just happens to be that question was happening in an interview. Okay. And he babbled.
00:04:19.600 --> 00:04:22.620
Do you think the question was asked by a Gene Roddenberry fan?
00:04:23.240 --> 00:04:31.080
No, I think it was just a just a shill journalist or a shill YouTuber asking
00:04:31.080 --> 00:04:32.920
a very simple question. Yeah.
00:04:34.080 --> 00:04:39.000
And he not being able to answer it without relying on identity.
00:04:39.160 --> 00:04:43.320
The answer he gave was, ultimately after babbling was, this is about a female
00:04:43.320 --> 00:04:45.860
Klingon taking control of the empire.
00:04:45.940 --> 00:04:50.620
This was in the first season of Star Trek Discovery okay yeah.
00:04:52.639 --> 00:04:55.619
And that's it. Yeah, that's not what it's about. That's what happens.
00:04:55.859 --> 00:05:01.919
Yes, that's the function of it. That's the action of it. They are things that
00:05:01.919 --> 00:05:02.919
happen, not what it's about.
00:05:04.099 --> 00:05:09.559
And you could have went deeper. This is about a person struggling in an environment
00:05:09.559 --> 00:05:15.939
that even their gender is not allowed to be in in the past, that they are looking
00:05:15.939 --> 00:05:18.799
at how that they can affect social change.
00:05:19.179 --> 00:05:21.819
These are very progressive things you can say. But he didn't know.
00:05:21.819 --> 00:05:25.899
He couldn't say them because it isn't about that.
00:05:26.059 --> 00:05:30.159
It's about a showing of a thing. It's like, look how great we are.
00:05:30.419 --> 00:05:34.739
No, you're not. You're like, it appears superficial. Exactly. It's on the surface.
00:05:35.259 --> 00:05:39.899
Like Measure of a Man, the data episode. Yeah.
00:05:40.559 --> 00:05:44.799
It's a courtroom episode. It is. There is six speakers, I think,
00:05:44.819 --> 00:05:47.339
in the entire thing. One of the greatest episodes. Yes.
00:05:48.439 --> 00:05:52.739
Melissa Snodgrass a one time collaborator with George R.
00:05:52.839 --> 00:05:56.419
Martin fantastic writer she just delivered
00:05:56.419 --> 00:06:03.019
a fantastic fantastic piece like even the things that like say like there's
00:06:03.019 --> 00:06:07.119
only six there's six speakers in that because there's the five people directly
00:06:07.119 --> 00:06:12.679
involved in the thing and then there's Guinan she has scenes and Guinan is there
00:06:12.679 --> 00:06:15.519
as a African American woman she,
00:06:16.359 --> 00:06:21.759
does this wonderful piece of basically allowing she almost drags Picard to the
00:06:21.759 --> 00:06:27.559
conclusion that she has such a blank face expression because she says.
00:06:28.999 --> 00:06:32.199
Even every line in that,
00:06:32.879 --> 00:06:39.019
You could pick a part. We talked about dialogue. Just, she is just so po-faced,
00:06:39.179 --> 00:06:42.639
she's just straight-faced going, well, I think you're exaggerating about that. And he's not.
00:06:42.859 --> 00:06:50.299
He's talking about a slave race. And it is, she doesn't need to go to express.
00:06:51.819 --> 00:06:57.519
To, in a better word, express her blackness or express her culture.
00:06:58.119 --> 00:07:05.239
We all can see it. Yes. We all can see it quite clearly plain as the nose on her face.
00:07:05.399 --> 00:07:10.499
We can absolutely see who she is, why she's saying these things and even though
00:07:10.499 --> 00:07:17.819
it's hundreds of years after present day, it is a person, an actress,
00:07:18.079 --> 00:07:20.519
a character delivering these lines.
00:07:20.839 --> 00:07:25.279
You look at even... To an audience in the 90s. Absolutely.
00:07:25.519 --> 00:07:30.139
You look at... We could spend the next half an hour just taking that episode apart.
00:07:30.439 --> 00:07:37.679
And like, when Riker gets chosen to be the prosecutor and he gets threatened
00:07:37.679 --> 00:07:44.139
either it's a summary execution essentially of a friend of his or he has to fight against him.
00:07:44.719 --> 00:07:49.439
And he's then given access to Data's spec and he goes, okay,
00:07:49.439 --> 00:07:54.059
and he's drinking a cup of coffee or a cup of tea and he sees a spec in front
00:07:54.059 --> 00:07:55.939
of him
and for a moment he smiles.
00:07:56.639 --> 00:07:59.899
Because him, as a character, I want to win.
00:08:00.099 --> 00:08:04.379
Yeah. and he realises he can fucking win and then he realises that his face
00:08:04.379 --> 00:08:07.539
falls oh no I can win I can actually win it is so,
00:08:08.099 --> 00:08:14.359
wonderful this is a master class yeah in having in writing yeah because he's
00:08:14.359 --> 00:08:17.919
true to his character in that moment and then and he's also true to his friend
00:08:17.919 --> 00:08:22.279
yes in the moment after yeah and indeed even if you wind back to the start where.
00:08:23.619 --> 00:08:29.799
Picard tries to talk Data into going and Data goes oh it's because I'm not biological yeah,
00:08:30.278 --> 00:08:33.798
Or we should replace all our eyes with Geordi's eyes because they're better.
00:08:34.338 --> 00:08:41.678
Oh, and he shames his boss. And he forces Picard. It's such a wonderful...
00:08:42.398 --> 00:08:46.638
It's 45 minutes of television and it's absolutely fantastic.
00:08:47.578 --> 00:08:52.378
It's a deep investigation into humanity. And the conclusion is, we don't know.
00:08:53.618 --> 00:08:59.898
When Picard goes, this organization is built on finding new life.
00:09:00.558 --> 00:09:01.858
It's there it sits.
00:09:02.858 --> 00:09:06.418
And it is just, I can feel this chill in the back of my spine as this,
00:09:06.878 --> 00:09:09.498
you know, because everyone does a fantastic job in it.
00:09:09.678 --> 00:09:13.898
Even the villain Maddox, all the actors are at top of their game.
00:09:14.098 --> 00:09:19.058
So when I say that this Shakespearean actor, it's not to diminish the other
00:09:19.058 --> 00:09:25.158
actors because he does this wonderful...
00:09:25.158 --> 00:09:29.218
It's the pathos and it's the gravity that he has around him.
00:09:29.218 --> 00:09:33.878
It's absolutely fantastic Patrick Stewart exactly there is he is in that moment
00:09:33.878 --> 00:09:37.258
any because this is first season any moment that,
00:09:37.978 --> 00:09:43.418
they're like where's Picard where's Kirk where's Scotty where's Spock by that
00:09:43.418 --> 00:09:48.178
stage it's only I think like nine to nine I think of that season it's very early
00:09:48.178 --> 00:09:53.578
in it just does such a fantastic job of just delivering,
00:09:54.698 --> 00:10:01.518
everyone's like who's that Kirk guy this is my boy now exactly it was such a
00:10:01.518 --> 00:10:07.798
wonderful moment they tried they essentially tried to replicate it in Strange
00:10:07.798 --> 00:10:11.598
New Worlds they tried to replicate it in Star Trek Discovery.
00:10:12.818 --> 00:10:17.998
But they simply fell to it being not being able to deliver,
00:10:19.043 --> 00:10:24.243
What is such a wonderfully, fundamentally good thing?
00:10:24.343 --> 00:10:30.783
Now, the thing is, once that's happened, it's very, very hard to do it again. Yeah.
00:10:32.203 --> 00:10:37.183
With as much authenticity. Yes,
or even at all.
00:10:37.683 --> 00:10:42.763
If we wanted to write, in our respective worlds, if we wanted to write something
00:10:42.763 --> 00:10:45.203
like that, we'd be cribbing off that episode.
00:10:45.203 --> 00:10:50.823
It would be we'd be desperately trying to shave off the file off the serial
00:10:50.823 --> 00:10:57.043
numbers to hide the fact that because it's like I remember take the grip exactly
00:10:57.043 --> 00:10:59.883
I would I was asked would you ever write,
00:11:00.483 --> 00:11:04.523
a medical a medical drama and this was during the height of the house and I'm
00:11:04.523 --> 00:11:06.723
like no house exists I don't need to do it,
00:11:07.383 --> 00:11:10.063
there's certain things that you simply go no,
00:11:10.743 --> 00:11:15.103
the pinnacle already exists I'm not touching it so the fact that these writers
00:11:15.103 --> 00:11:18.363
these shows feel that they can,
00:11:18.972 --> 00:11:26.612
speaks to an arrogance and a lack of respect of what has gone before inside their own franchise.
00:11:28.452 --> 00:11:38.372
In Strange New Worlds, the number one is revealed to be a refugee.
00:11:40.792 --> 00:11:47.672
And this is a big political court case. So it kind of has analogies to a measure of man.
00:11:48.972 --> 00:11:55.992
And it is ultimately determined that she, it was out of fear that she joined Starfleet.
00:11:56.272 --> 00:12:01.712
And it was out of fear that she, so she was operating because she was...
00:12:01.712 --> 00:12:03.432
I'll hide inside the police station.
00:12:03.992 --> 00:12:10.272
In part, yes. That it was that she broke the rules because she was, so she was afraid.
00:12:10.552 --> 00:12:15.792
And this is supposed to be a immigration allegory.
00:12:15.792 --> 00:12:21.892
Okay unfortunately all the stuff that happened to her was 18 years prior,
00:12:22.572 --> 00:12:27.032
prior to prior to the captain finding out right and it was this was part of
00:12:27.032 --> 00:12:32.872
the captain the captain should have well exposed her essentially so is she still
00:12:32.872 --> 00:12:36.152
afraid 18 years later that she's going to be because when she's she's light
00:12:36.152 --> 00:12:40.292
years away from from the problem no it's not quite the same yes.
00:12:41.092 --> 00:12:45.932
Immediacy it is I think you could still make that analogy you could still make
00:12:45.932 --> 00:12:52.932
that story work but the writers simply wanted the moment they didn't well I
00:12:52.932 --> 00:12:55.832
mean now I get just devil's advocate you don't know from,
00:12:56.628 --> 00:12:59.968
If you're saying it's an immigrant allegory. Yeah.
00:13:00.328 --> 00:13:06.288
So I'm sure there are immigrants to different countries that maybe have that
00:13:06.288 --> 00:13:11.368
looking over their shoulder for 18 years, never knowing if someone's going to come for them.
00:13:11.468 --> 00:13:14.008
So there could be that fear still. Oh, sure. But they are not,
00:13:14.108 --> 00:13:20.368
in this regard, they are not literally millions of miles away from the problem. Sure.
00:13:20.808 --> 00:13:24.908
So if you're still in the problem, absolutely, 100%. If you're just over that border,
00:13:25.088 --> 00:13:28.128
if you're in El Paso rather than in Medina then
00:13:28.128 --> 00:13:33.368
sure then if you're it's a borderline it's still within even you know not even
00:13:33.368 --> 00:13:37.948
in view but if it's in if you're still being threatened by ice 100% there is
00:13:37.948 --> 00:13:43.648
there is plenty of stories even like in Picard season Picard season 1 or season
00:13:43.648 --> 00:13:47.508
2 where they go back in time yeah fucking terrible season.
00:13:48.308 --> 00:13:53.348
There is I don't remember them going back in time they did they spent the entire
00:13:53.348 --> 00:13:58.808
season back in time there is often a thing a truism that is said that if a TV
00:13:58.808 --> 00:14:02.668
show is starting to deal with time travel then it's lost its ideas,
00:14:03.248 --> 00:14:08.188
it is a yes just as I'm about to release a book with time travel in it well
00:14:08.188 --> 00:14:13.308
done right no no no that's no but I agree that one thing that's a book about
00:14:13.308 --> 00:14:16.548
time travel it has a time travel plot so.
00:14:17.649 --> 00:14:20.809
I agree that there's certain elements that are jumping the shark,
00:14:20.889 --> 00:14:25.209
but it's when you are moving away from your core storytelling principle.
00:14:25.349 --> 00:14:31.509
It's like when DS9 got The Defiant, they suddenly had all these stories they could have on ships.
00:14:31.809 --> 00:14:35.709
Yeah. It's like, what the hell with DS9? Exactly. We're out of here, losers.
00:14:35.989 --> 00:14:43.809
So all the stories that had left over from previous shows, that,
00:14:44.169 --> 00:14:46.889
okay, we can retrofit them for now for DS9. You've got a ship.
00:14:47.009 --> 00:14:51.349
We have a ship. we can feck off somewhere else yeah so when you think about
00:14:51.349 --> 00:14:56.029
it DS9 is like okay after a while it's like it's only stuff that happens in
00:14:56.029 --> 00:15:00.469
the station yes but Babylon 5 did that too and Babylon 5 did it fucking better,
00:15:01.349 --> 00:15:04.669
so and indeed there's only what one,
00:15:05.529 --> 00:15:11.549
there's only one episode I can think of that happens that actually happens off station okay,
00:15:12.349 --> 00:15:16.989
other than the final war that takes them all the way back to Earth but there's
00:15:16.989 --> 00:15:21.349
there's one episode where they are off planet they're on the drowsy homeworld,
00:15:22.132 --> 00:15:24.292
But the vast majority all happens on the station.
00:15:26.872 --> 00:15:31.112
So these shows, I wonder what these shows are for.
00:15:31.932 --> 00:15:38.012
We can't find ratings. We can't, so they're being given seasons and indeed they
00:15:38.012 --> 00:15:41.452
claim, oh look, we did five seasons
and TNG did seven.
00:15:41.952 --> 00:15:45.992
TNG did seven seasons of 22 episodes apiece.
00:15:46.232 --> 00:15:50.712
Yeah, slightly different content volume. Yeah, you're doing five seasons of eight episodes apiece.
00:15:50.772 --> 00:15:57.412
Yeah, not the same. Which, in all of itself, is a terrible situation for the TV world to be in.
00:15:58.372 --> 00:16:02.272
That an entire season is essentially a miniseries now. Yeah.
00:16:03.212 --> 00:16:07.772
And I think if you look at... Used to be like Shogun or Roots back in the 80s.
00:16:07.872 --> 00:16:13.892
When it was these four or five episodes or six episodes. And they served as those stories.
00:16:14.972 --> 00:16:19.312
But we never looked for Roots season two. We never looked for Shogun season
00:16:19.312 --> 00:16:22.232
two. There used to be the event. Exactly.
00:16:22.512 --> 00:16:27.052
The TV event of the year. And indeed, if you look at, say, BBC,
00:16:27.492 --> 00:16:29.292
which always did six-episode runs...
00:16:30.450 --> 00:16:34.630
If you look at, say, and Channel 4 did six, eight, and 12 episode runs,
00:16:35.210 --> 00:16:39.330
if you, they don't get locked into a year.
00:16:39.510 --> 00:16:44.850
It was like, say, Taskmaster is on its 20th season. No way.
00:16:45.210 --> 00:16:48.870
And I thought it started about 10 years ago because they can do basically two
00:16:48.870 --> 00:16:53.590
seasons, two seasons a year, then they do the Christmas special and they do another two seasons.
00:16:53.810 --> 00:16:59.210
So they essentially are doing what, they're doing 24 episodes essentially in a year.
00:16:59.390 --> 00:17:02.490
Okay. which is great yeah and they have two different sets of cast and they
00:17:02.490 --> 00:17:06.630
do all that so you know Taskmaster's fantastic Jason Mark Dukas fucking best
00:17:06.630 --> 00:17:11.670
episode best member of that I feared that he would be terrible he is by far
00:17:11.670 --> 00:17:15.650
the best the best cousin they've ever had there's a super cut of all this stuff
00:17:15.650 --> 00:17:17.870
I highly recommend it but I digress,
00:17:18.650 --> 00:17:25.210
the all this all these stories that are being put out now I'm not certain what
00:17:25.210 --> 00:17:30.130
the purpose is because it's not to entertain what is it about yeah what are
00:17:30.130 --> 00:17:31.230
they about these stories,
00:17:31.773 --> 00:17:34.953
What's the question? Exactly. What are each of them about?
00:17:35.253 --> 00:17:41.793
And when you have about 100 million, they're about 40 minutes long.
00:17:43.933 --> 00:17:47.233
It's like, let's have a Klingon who doesn't want to be a Klingon.
00:17:47.613 --> 00:17:51.773
Great. Okay. We can actually do that. In fact, we've done it before.
00:17:53.013 --> 00:17:56.333
Like they say, Worf's son, Alexander, didn't want to be his Klingon.
00:17:56.873 --> 00:18:01.153
Despite the fact that he was mostly a Klingon, he was more human than Klingon,
00:18:01.153 --> 00:18:02.633
having been raised by human beings.
00:18:02.673 --> 00:18:06.533
What was the scene in Voyager, Balana Torres, when the Klingon arrives and he's
00:18:06.533 --> 00:18:08.353
like, where are the images of Kalis?
00:18:08.493 --> 00:18:11.813
And she's like, oh, they didn't match with the carpet. Yeah.
00:18:13.253 --> 00:18:19.273
And because she has a problem with her Klingon anger ruining relationships for her.
00:18:19.373 --> 00:18:22.153
So they've already dealt with that.
00:18:22.373 --> 00:18:26.433
Can you deal with it again? Yes. But you have to bring something new to the occasion.
00:18:27.113 --> 00:18:34.493
Could you have a high school Star Trek show yes they've done it it's what first,
00:18:35.393 --> 00:18:38.573
principle or first first responsibility I can remember the Wesley
00:18:38.573 --> 00:18:41.893
Kusher episode where they do the star maneuver in Starfleet Academy
00:18:41.893 --> 00:18:47.113
yeah and they kill a guy a guy dies first duty and there's a training accident
00:18:47.113 --> 00:18:52.913
or it's a display accident and Tom Locano is the leader he gets kicked out but
00:18:52.913 --> 00:18:58.753
then he comes back as Tom Paris was it something Locano but yeah and
00:18:59.133 --> 00:19:03.673
Seto Jackson then who then comes back later on in Lower Decks,
00:19:03.773 --> 00:19:09.853
the episode which again, fucking fantastic and that was a season 7 episode, which was lovely,
00:19:10.933 --> 00:19:12.373
about peer pressure.
00:19:13.953 --> 00:19:17.753
It has all these different elements to it could you do a full season on it?
00:19:18.013 --> 00:19:23.533
Absolutely, could you show the difference between the utopian lifestyle that
00:19:23.533 --> 00:19:27.353
everyone thinks about, or even rather than going,
00:19:27.921 --> 00:19:32.221
juxtapose it rather than deconstruct it actually spend some time and going actually
00:19:32.221 --> 00:19:35.801
yeah this is the utopia because this is what we want to have and then they can
00:19:35.801 --> 00:19:39.601
see the bad side well rather than us being have utopia,
00:19:40.141 --> 00:19:46.221
there's so much fertile ground there to dive into any kind of you know coming
00:19:46.221 --> 00:19:50.521
of age story 100% you know like I was saying peer pressure stories.
00:19:51.581 --> 00:19:59.261
Exam pressures yes you know how young people deal with social problems,
00:19:59.641 --> 00:20:02.321
all that kind of stuff could be in there. Oh, absolutely.
00:20:02.501 --> 00:20:08.261
And you can, you imagine the, what effect technology has on kids today.
00:20:08.641 --> 00:20:11.981
What does replicators have on kids today?
00:20:12.101 --> 00:20:15.821
If you have someone who has an eating disorder and they can get cake.
00:20:16.741 --> 00:20:22.881
I'm being facetious here, but you consider, you know, you can binge eat in front of a replicator.
00:20:23.381 --> 00:20:26.921
There's no loss. And it is the best stuff you've ever tasted.
00:20:27.141 --> 00:20:31.981
Like, how will that deal, how will someone who is trying to come to their own
00:20:31.981 --> 00:20:36.741
body image deal with having that sort of thing and ready supply?
00:20:37.061 --> 00:20:39.901
Sounds like they should do a show about Starfleet Academy.
00:20:40.704 --> 00:20:44.304
It'd be fantastic. That's a pity they didn't. They didn't.
00:20:44.784 --> 00:20:50.624
As you mentioned, the idea of exams, everything we've seen about Starflake Academy
00:20:50.624 --> 00:20:54.764
from the other shows, particularly from Wesley Crusher's point of view,
00:20:54.904 --> 00:20:57.524
is they have to be top of the class.
00:20:57.644 --> 00:20:59.884
They have to be a student to get in.
00:21:00.044 --> 00:21:02.724
They have to be fecking great. Not former criminals.
00:21:02.984 --> 00:21:06.784
Not people who are picked up off the street. They have to be the very best at
00:21:06.784 --> 00:21:09.944
what they do to get that far. They are the cream of the crop.
00:21:10.704 --> 00:21:15.984
And then you can have a situation where the person rises up who is,
00:21:16.144 --> 00:21:21.904
like, a perfect example of a, someone who is beyond their scope, the Dunkin' Egg story.
00:21:22.424 --> 00:21:25.624
The Night of the Seven Kingdoms. Yeah. He is, have you seen it?
00:21:25.764 --> 00:21:28.904
Yeah. It's fucking fantastic. It is amazing, yeah. It is fantastic.
00:21:29.124 --> 00:21:31.944
It's one of the best things I've seen on TV in a long time. In a long time.
00:21:32.084 --> 00:21:34.784
The only problem I have with it, each episode is half an hour long.
00:21:34.984 --> 00:21:38.544
Yes. And it's only eight episodes. So again, why can't we have more?
00:21:39.544 --> 00:21:43.144
Both Dunkin' Egg are people who are not who they want to be.
00:21:43.424 --> 00:21:45.704
They are trying, as in the prince, who's not trying to be the prince,
00:21:45.884 --> 00:21:50.704
and there is the little peasants. Square, who's trying to be a knight.
00:21:51.764 --> 00:21:54.964
It is so wonderful that he couldn't knight someone in the story,
00:21:55.204 --> 00:21:56.524
because only a knight could knight a knight. Yeah.
00:21:57.104 --> 00:22:00.164
And only a knight could knight a knight, yeah. So he had to say,
00:22:00.384 --> 00:22:02.724
yeah, he had two knights. Only a knight could knight a knight tonight.
00:22:05.084 --> 00:22:11.604
That's funny. Absolutely. So, but you can see this question in him and that
00:22:11.604 --> 00:22:15.224
he is now, effectively, and now he can't go back.
00:22:15.784 --> 00:22:20.464
So he is now permanently an imposter. It is wonderful.
00:22:20.824 --> 00:22:29.644
It is, and there's no, it's expressly said in the last episode where he asks,
00:22:29.964 --> 00:22:33.584
essentially, the other night, why he never dies from him just before he dies.
00:22:33.584 --> 00:22:37.364
And you can imagine that that question has been laying on his mind for,
00:22:38.526 --> 00:22:41.666
and he only got the courage to ask just in those last few moments,
00:22:41.826 --> 00:22:43.206
and he never got his answer.
00:22:44.246 --> 00:22:47.086
So now... It's wonderfully done, yeah, brilliant. It's fantastic.
00:22:48.126 --> 00:22:52.846
Can you do that in a Star Trek situation where you have someone who is rising up, who's an imposter?
00:22:53.646 --> 00:22:57.646
Absolutely. You could have someone who is not the right person,
00:22:58.166 --> 00:23:00.286
but ultimately the best person to be there.
00:23:00.346 --> 00:23:04.466
You know, and that can be done from an identity point of view.
00:23:04.626 --> 00:23:08.906
You could have someone going, well we don't allow X in or we don't allow this
00:23:08.906 --> 00:23:15.026
is the first Y in and you can even push them they would think well they expect
00:23:15.026 --> 00:23:19.066
me to do 10 times the amount for half the benefit it's like yeah,
00:23:19.726 --> 00:23:25.226
even Zootopia did that when they let a bunny cop join exactly I mean Jesus Christ,
00:23:25.806 --> 00:23:30.746
if you can how well done was that you can get an animation to do better this is where.
00:23:32.710 --> 00:23:38.110
This is, it's, I can't, it's the tip of my brain, but there are these wonderful
00:23:38.110 --> 00:23:40.710
examples of, it's like when,
00:23:41.330 --> 00:23:45.190
it's almost like there's this big, I was about to say big woke eye,
00:23:45.610 --> 00:23:49.230
but big eye, and it tends to be left wing, because left wing tends to be the
00:23:49.230 --> 00:23:50.130
ones that do the cancel culture.
00:23:50.950 --> 00:23:54.410
It's like a scanning, a big eye, scanning.
00:23:54.570 --> 00:23:59.190
Eye of Sauron. Yeah, a big eye of Sauron, scanning every product that comes
00:23:59.190 --> 00:24:05.070
out, every story that comes out, and you have to sneak through and then you get your zootopias.
00:24:05.210 --> 00:24:10.450
You get a person who goes through a struggle, goes through a story,
00:24:10.750 --> 00:24:14.870
goes through a narrative to get to the end and it is wonderful because it doesn't
00:24:14.870 --> 00:24:15.830
fucking matter it's a bunny.
00:24:16.050 --> 00:24:18.530
It matters that that bunny is us.
00:24:19.570 --> 00:24:23.810
Everyone can see that bunny. Everyone's a bunny. Everyone's a fucking bunny.
00:24:24.250 --> 00:24:27.930
Or a fox. Or occasionally some. Many are foxes.
00:24:30.330 --> 00:24:35.310
It is so when you have this wonderful I think it's that's one thing like I started
00:24:35.310 --> 00:24:40.410
off life I started off my writing focus writing screen plays as mentioned before
00:24:40.410 --> 00:24:45.590
for a brief time I had a literary agent in the states and that was my dream
00:24:45.590 --> 00:24:50.230
that I wanted to basically write TV shows,
00:24:50.810 --> 00:24:55.430
and in another life in another path won't go into this you're a Hollywood baby
00:24:55.430 --> 00:24:57.190
I could be a Hollywood baby
yeah,
00:24:58.630 --> 00:25:01.730
And these days I look at it and go, I'm glad I didn't go there because,
00:25:02.070 --> 00:25:05.950
or didn't get, didn't have a certain degree of success because then I'd be stuck
00:25:05.950 --> 00:25:08.290
going, I do not want to write this sort of shit.
00:25:08.610 --> 00:25:12.310
And maybe you have decent writers who are stuck going, I want a career.
00:25:12.650 --> 00:25:15.130
And fuck, I'll pump out what was asked of me.
00:25:15.690 --> 00:25:21.570
Needs to get paid. yeah they need to pay their mortgage but then you look particularly look at,
00:25:22.610 --> 00:25:29.770
Alex Kurtzman as he is responsible for this utter shite death of Star Trek and
00:25:29.770 --> 00:25:33.050
yes he has killed the franchise there is.
00:25:34.719 --> 00:25:38.479
He was, sorry, it came to my mind.
00:25:38.619 --> 00:25:45.699
He was discussing the backlash that the Starfleet Academy was getting.
00:25:45.919 --> 00:25:50.599
And he was essentially saying, don't give out about it or Star Trek's going to go away.
00:25:51.139 --> 00:25:54.139
Exactly what I was just going to say. Oh, right? Yeah, 100%. Good!
00:25:54.979 --> 00:26:00.439
Let it go away for a while. But even unpack that statement. Yeah. Does he know it's shit?
00:26:01.059 --> 00:26:03.759
He must. But does he know it's shit?
00:26:03.759 --> 00:26:10.159
Or if it goes away then yeah it goes away for a while I don't get paid if Star
00:26:10.159 --> 00:26:14.859
Trek goes away you already got you're apparently 160 million dollars for two
00:26:14.859 --> 00:26:18.859
years of work in trashing a franchise that I like.
00:26:20.099 --> 00:26:21.459
These stories are,
00:26:22.061 --> 00:26:26.461
I used to talk to my physics teacher about it. I talked to history teachers
00:26:26.461 --> 00:26:28.001
about it. This was when I was a kid.
00:26:28.361 --> 00:26:32.901
I used to talk to English teachers about it. I have found, and it's almost,
00:26:33.381 --> 00:26:36.781
I remember being slightly shamed by this in the past.
00:26:37.101 --> 00:26:40.381
I found a love of Shakespeare through Star Trek.
00:26:41.321 --> 00:26:44.641
I didn't, I thought, you know, old English was, ah, this is terrible.
00:26:44.801 --> 00:26:50.441
I was wrong at the end. And when I saw Shakespeare through Star Trek,
00:26:50.441 --> 00:26:55.881
means, when I saw them using the, when they talked about, like Data and Picard
00:26:55.881 --> 00:26:57.061
talking about different things,
00:26:57.721 --> 00:27:03.441
like seeing Christmas Day speech or Macbeth or things, it was only when I was,
00:27:04.081 --> 00:27:07.581
like, when I had almost, I'd left proper school.
00:27:08.241 --> 00:27:11.001
Secondary. Well, I'd left secondary. I'd repeated my leaving.
00:27:11.161 --> 00:27:16.961
And in that year, I remember there was this, I could feel the metamorphosis happen.
00:27:17.141 --> 00:27:22.241
You had a come to Shakespeare moment. I had, yes, but it was through the vector
00:27:22.241 --> 00:27:24.361
of Star Trek that I found that look.
00:27:24.661 --> 00:27:28.781
I always try to, when I'm having conversations with people, to say,
00:27:28.921 --> 00:27:32.701
I don't like science fiction, or I don't like fantasy, I don't like science fiction.
00:27:33.921 --> 00:27:40.341
That's, Star Trek is where I go to, to say, it's not about blinking lights and lasers. Yes.
00:27:40.681 --> 00:27:45.561
It's not about warp cores and aliens.
00:27:45.901 --> 00:27:51.981
Yes. it's about the stories that are told in these series and like as we were
00:27:51.981 --> 00:27:55.461
talking about the dressing the scene setting is.
00:27:56.721 --> 00:28:04.361
Science fiction but at the core of it is deeply human stories that speak to
00:28:04.361 --> 00:28:08.121
so many people on so many levels and that's,
00:28:08.601 --> 00:28:13.581
that was the brilliance of Star Trek not all science fiction obviously but when
00:28:13.581 --> 00:28:18.081
I talked to someone like someone that says, I don't like science fiction and I was like,
00:28:18.658 --> 00:28:24.038
You know, I, not that I get offended that someone doesn't like something that
00:28:24.038 --> 00:28:28.858
I love, but I am like, well, what is it you don't like?
00:28:29.198 --> 00:28:35.538
You know, because if you pay attention to what's going on in a particular Star
00:28:35.538 --> 00:28:38.458
Trek episode, it could be about drug addiction or it could be about,
00:28:38.458 --> 00:28:40.178
it could be about anything. Yeah.
00:28:40.831 --> 00:28:47.371
And then, like I said, just the furniture is blinky lights. Exactly, yes.
00:28:48.811 --> 00:28:57.511
It's like, if you list off the 10 greatest episodes, or if you go through the
00:28:57.511 --> 00:28:59.931
episodes and go, okay, which are the ones that really stand out to me?
00:29:00.231 --> 00:29:07.951
The only one that stands out to me that has special effects to it is yesterday's Enterprise,
00:29:08.991 --> 00:29:15.131
where the Enterprise C comes through a temporal rift and there's a fight between
00:29:15.131 --> 00:29:18.391
the Enterprise D and a few Klingon ships.
00:29:19.491 --> 00:29:22.591
That's not great special effects, but of the time, it was fantastic.
00:29:22.831 --> 00:29:26.691
But there's a line in it where Picard goes, well, we could outrun them,
00:29:26.751 --> 00:29:27.931
but we have to protect the Enterprise C.
00:29:28.331 --> 00:29:30.851
Let's ensure that the history never forgets the name Enterprise.
00:29:31.311 --> 00:29:36.391
And that makes me cry like a fucking girl every fucking time I hear it.
00:29:36.511 --> 00:29:42.931
It is just, I will weep like, tears will well up in my eyes whenever I hear it.
00:29:42.951 --> 00:29:46.631
When he delivers that, when the history never, let the history never forget the name.
00:29:46.991 --> 00:29:50.551
Enterprise. Enterprise. And there's just this pause, and he hits the note.
00:29:50.771 --> 00:29:52.911
Again, great acting, but also great writing.
00:29:53.211 --> 00:29:59.671
And it's just, all the other episodes are inner life, which is about someone living a life.
00:30:00.051 --> 00:30:02.931
One coming to terms with living a life, of coming out of, say,
00:30:03.691 --> 00:30:10.091
there's an old, I think it's Confucius, There's an old Chinese poem,
00:30:10.311 --> 00:30:14.471
I think, about, and Bob, our listener, will probably know it already,
00:30:14.951 --> 00:30:22.891
where am I a person dreaming about being a butterfly or a butterfly dreaming about being a person?
00:30:23.551 --> 00:30:27.931
And in that episode, Picard first has to realize that it has to come to terms
00:30:27.931 --> 00:30:32.951
with the fact that, hang on, have I actually spent what I feel to be my life
00:30:32.951 --> 00:30:34.971
dreaming about being Picard?
00:30:35.631 --> 00:30:37.891
And actually being Gaiden I think his name was yeah.
00:30:39.184 --> 00:30:43.524
And it is, that is trauma. That is dealing with trauma.
00:30:43.744 --> 00:30:46.344
And it is, we were very worried about you and you're coming out of it.
00:30:46.444 --> 00:30:52.004
And then dealing with a narrative about coming to terms with a relationship
00:30:52.004 --> 00:30:57.684
that was on the rocks that we had to rebuild. I think it's rebuilding a relationship.
00:30:58.404 --> 00:31:01.164
It's so much harder than actually going, actually breaking up.
00:31:01.584 --> 00:31:05.204
Like that's the path that story takes.
00:31:05.324 --> 00:31:08.464
It is opposite so many other paths.
00:31:08.464 --> 00:31:13.884
It's about rather than him going off you go no no hang on I am Picard I'm going
00:31:13.884 --> 00:31:17.764
to figure it out yeah every other almost every other show I could think of would do that,
00:31:18.284 --> 00:31:24.644
but no it stuck inside this what he probably existed until the end of his days,
00:31:25.244 --> 00:31:30.164
until not Bray Tack what is his name appears at the end as the younger version
00:31:30.164 --> 00:31:34.224
basically said and says you know thank you old friend and he's going I was real
00:31:34.224 --> 00:31:38.804
I was right it was the old man he lived a full life a full family,
00:31:39.424 --> 00:31:43.824
and he only at the end goes oh and it's what 40 minutes of his life and he remembers
00:31:43.824 --> 00:31:47.244
it I guess the flute as of importance and all that jazz.
00:31:48.726 --> 00:31:52.466
Then you have Picard season one where he's like, no, no, he never had a family. He did. In our life.
00:31:53.026 --> 00:31:56.906
No one else knew he had a family. But he did. Yeah. So he didn't have to have
00:31:56.906 --> 00:31:57.886
that. He didn't have that trauma.
00:31:58.706 --> 00:32:02.166
Or like, the other one that jumped out was Chain of Command.
00:32:02.646 --> 00:32:07.366
Where, again, not very special effects, heavy episode where you both had Jericho
00:32:07.366 --> 00:32:10.086
on the Enterprise running
around and changing everything.
00:32:10.506 --> 00:32:14.086
Yeah. In any other situation, Jericho will be a hero. But because he's messing
00:32:14.086 --> 00:32:16.086
with our friends. Yeah. Our kid friends.
00:32:16.526 --> 00:32:20.466
Wonderful. And then it's the, like, why are you upsetting the whole thing there
00:32:20.466 --> 00:32:25.226
what are you doing and the two him and Reich are really putting heads and indeed
00:32:25.226 --> 00:32:30.726
the line about Troy wearing a uniform was because Marina Sirtis didn't want to wear,
00:32:31.786 --> 00:32:35.886
wanted to be didn't want to stand out anymore she wanted to wear the uniform
00:32:35.886 --> 00:32:40.306
as everyone else she was a lieutenant commander so I find we'll use this as
00:32:40.306 --> 00:32:43.646
a vector for her to be in her uniform in a uniform from then on which was great,
00:32:44.506 --> 00:32:47.226
but it's the four lights thing the torture of Picard,
00:32:48.306 --> 00:32:53.086
that is psychological and physical torture and it is both horrible and again
00:32:53.086 --> 00:32:56.766
we're talking about we're talking from a story point of view from a story point
00:32:56.766 --> 00:32:59.166
of view it's wonderful storytelling,
00:33:00.106 --> 00:33:03.466
the conversation that he has and I can't remember the name of the actor I think
00:33:03.466 --> 00:33:06.246
he's passed already he's had a few Star Trek roles.
00:33:08.806 --> 00:33:13.186
Two Shakespearean actors having this conversation it is,
00:33:15.255 --> 00:33:19.255
wonderful. And even as a, I don't know, 15 year old listening to that for the
00:33:19.255 --> 00:33:22.015
first time, I was meeting a friend of mine thereafter.
00:33:23.375 --> 00:33:27.895
And he was walking from his house and I was walking from my house and I could
00:33:27.895 --> 00:33:31.095
see him at the end of a road and we walked to the center road.
00:33:31.295 --> 00:33:34.135
It was about seven o'clock, eight o'clock on a Saturday, Sunday,
00:33:34.415 --> 00:33:37.015
Saturday evening in the middle of summer.
00:33:37.555 --> 00:33:41.155
We walked down the middle of the road towards each other, stopped about 30 feet
00:33:41.155 --> 00:33:45.135
from one other. and at the same time at the very same moment shouted at one
00:33:45.135 --> 00:33:46.755
another there are four lights.
00:33:48.035 --> 00:33:50.715
And we walked towards it and that was pretty good wasn't it?
00:33:51.335 --> 00:33:55.855
And then we did the usual kind of banter. Yeah. Oh that was great that was great.
00:33:56.255 --> 00:34:01.935
There are four lights. There are four lights. And the fact that Picard confessed
00:34:01.935 --> 00:34:06.975
to Diana afterwards that he that he genuinely saw three. Yeah.
00:34:07.455 --> 00:34:11.635
And it was just yeah and that's this mental fortitude right there.
00:34:11.815 --> 00:34:13.615
No, but it's, no, it's, he failed.
00:34:13.895 --> 00:34:15.815
He said, he admits failing.
00:34:16.335 -->
00:34:19.455
And that is wonderful because he's.
00:34:20.136 --> 00:34:23.016
He was about to fail when he was rescued, essentially.
00:34:23.536 --> 00:34:27.676
But it is your hero showing frailty.
00:34:27.916 --> 00:34:31.636
And that's something these characters in these new shows can't do.
00:34:31.816 --> 00:34:36.596
They cannot show because by hooking themselves into identity politics,
00:34:36.696 --> 00:34:39.516
it means that, as they're saying, we are of this type. Yeah.
00:34:39.816 --> 00:34:42.936
They're latching on to a wider idea.
00:34:43.196 --> 00:34:47.456
Yeah. So they're no longer just themselves. They're some kind of cyborg.
00:34:47.696 --> 00:34:50.456
They are They're representing everybody.
00:34:50.776 --> 00:34:53.616
They're representing this type of person.
00:34:54.076 --> 00:34:56.756
So they cannot have any failing. Yeah.
00:34:57.236 --> 00:35:00.716
Because they are attaching every failing. You're no longer a lieutenant commander
00:35:00.716 --> 00:35:04.236
who happens to be trans. You are a trans lieutenant commander.
00:35:04.536 --> 00:35:08.956
Exactly. You're no longer a gay lieutenant or a gay captain. Yeah.
00:35:09.236 --> 00:35:12.196
Or, yeah, you're a captain that happens to be gay.
00:35:12.416 --> 00:35:16.056
You are a gay captain. Yeah, it doesn't. And that's the top billing.
00:35:16.336 --> 00:35:18.156
Your identity gets the top billing. Yeah.
00:35:18.936 --> 00:35:26.016
Then the story gets second. Yeah, so then the story becomes limited.
00:35:26.276 --> 00:35:28.696
The story says you can't have that fairly.
00:35:29.776 --> 00:35:35.516
If you put a, so one, you'd never put a person of identity.
00:35:35.936 --> 00:35:40.876
And by saying that, anyone, Bob will almost... I'm a person of identity.
00:35:40.876 --> 00:35:44.476
But the thing is, yes, we are, but in the current zeitgeist,
00:35:44.636 --> 00:35:48.916
there is a certain caliber or type who are of an identity.
00:35:49.876 --> 00:35:52.816
They will never be put through a torture scene.
00:35:53.436 --> 00:35:58.996
And the thing is, we're talking about fiction again. We're talking about it being a story to be told.
00:36:00.196 --> 00:36:03.316
And the mayor is responsible, well, why should we put it through?
00:36:04.116 --> 00:36:07.296
But we're not putting the identity through it.
00:36:07.376 --> 00:36:14.756
We're putting a character through it as a- the character in the story from the
00:36:14.756 --> 00:36:16.856
identity of the character in the story.
00:36:19.064 --> 00:36:22.824
It is because in these type of stories, the story doesn't matter.
00:36:23.184 --> 00:36:27.804
It is, as we're talking about in our woke episode, it's a PSA.
00:36:28.464 --> 00:36:37.664
If you look at even, if you listen to the dialogue, that as much as they try and deliver things,
00:36:38.158 --> 00:36:43.498
There's no, there's no, we could talk, we basically spend our time on this podcast
00:36:43.498 --> 00:36:47.478
talking
about breaking down different types of stories, whether it be talking
00:36:47.478 --> 00:36:50.118
about time travel, talking about dialogue, we talk about all these different
00:36:50.118 --> 00:36:52.758
things about how to tell a good story.
00:36:53.898 --> 00:36:57.498
I don't think these people are trying to tell good stories. I think they're
00:36:57.498 --> 00:36:59.798
trying to just pay their mortgages.
00:36:59.998 --> 00:37:04.918
And I think that they have got to the point of going, we can't put out a good
00:37:04.918 --> 00:37:09.878
story or we'll get fired. Yeah, it's shackled, isn't it? Yes.
00:37:10.298 --> 00:37:16.498
They're hobbled by their own fear of losing their job because of some public
00:37:16.498 --> 00:37:20.958
outcry that they made, you know, fill in the blank. Yeah.
00:37:21.578 --> 00:37:26.858
Individual, a villain, or they tortured this type of person. Exactly, exactly.
00:37:27.218 --> 00:37:31.578
And it is. Yeah. It is. Whereas the story may have called for it to make it a, like.
00:37:31.618 --> 00:37:35.538
Yeah, you can't do the, and the thing is, you can't do the work.
00:37:35.538 --> 00:37:38.458
Because if you we can talk about
00:37:38.458 --> 00:37:41.738
in our chain of command we can talk about it in we can
00:37:41.738 --> 00:37:44.498
talk the torturer in a positive light I can talk
00:37:44.498 --> 00:37:47.518
about the episodes of Babylon 5 where
00:37:47.518 --> 00:37:50.778
Sheridan was tortured I can talk about how the torturer was
00:37:50.778 --> 00:37:56.218
an incredibly well written well acted character he's a fucking evil cunt yeah
00:37:56.218 --> 00:38:00.958
but that's how he makes you feel as an audience you want that reaction but it
00:38:00.958 --> 00:38:06.758
doesn't he's a he's a true believer it doesn't it doesn't matter the identity
00:38:06.758 --> 00:38:09.218
of that person, it matters about the character of that person.
00:38:09.598 --> 00:38:15.038
It doesn't matter that it's a Kardashian who is in Tenet Command who is the
00:38:15.038 --> 00:38:17.798
one who is suffering his own trauma.
00:38:18.138 --> 00:38:24.038
That character was in Academy or in the new track of crap.
00:38:24.738 --> 00:38:29.138
Because he has suffered trauma, he would be seen in a positive light.
00:38:29.798 --> 00:38:33.158
Had to be seen in a positive light because he has suffered. Because it is so
00:38:33.158 --> 00:38:40.538
much about therapy speak they have to so that either you are white and evil,
00:38:41.219 --> 00:38:44.919
Or if you're suffering trauma, then the trauma... Trauma is like a desperate
00:38:44.919 --> 00:38:47.019
need for everyone to be okay.
00:38:47.659 --> 00:38:53.159
Sure. And okay is about as good as the thing gets, ever.
00:38:55.179 --> 00:38:59.399
That's absolutely one way of looking at it. Yeah. That chain of command would
00:38:59.399 --> 00:39:02.099
have ended with the two of them holding hands or hugging or going,
00:39:02.219 --> 00:39:05.279
you're okay, you'll be okay, I'll be okay, you'll be okay. Okay, bro. Yeah.
00:39:05.699 --> 00:39:08.519
And so they... And Card would not have...
00:39:08.519 --> 00:39:13.779
Like the torture would have broke. the torture never broke in that he was absolutely
00:39:13.779 --> 00:39:19.599
100% the same person he was maybe he was a little bit changed by like he failed
00:39:19.599 --> 00:39:25.879
because Picard never admitted to failure in his face so he never realised that he succeeded but.
00:39:26.859 --> 00:39:31.439
He might have known though well no but that's I think it's the key thing that
00:39:31.439 --> 00:39:37.979
we could talk about again about identity and about these sort of shows a lot but it's about the,
00:39:38.759 --> 00:39:44.199
ambiguity or about the clear focus about the story at the end.
00:39:44.699 --> 00:39:49.739
At the end of Chain of Command, you have, if you just look at that twofer between
00:39:49.739 --> 00:39:56.919
the torture and Picard, Picard essentially failed. He's broken.
00:39:57.539 --> 00:40:02.199
The torture never realized this. In one of these new shows, it would be absolutely
00:40:02.199 --> 00:40:05.179
spelled out that both people are fully aware of that situation.
00:40:05.739 --> 00:40:11.859
The fact that you have a lack of information on one side and a secret on the
00:40:11.859 --> 00:40:15.559
other is almost unheard of today.
00:40:15.959 --> 00:40:22.979
Well, it's what we were talking about in a previous episode in relation to subtext.
00:40:23.199 --> 00:40:26.339
Yes. It's like everything hits you over the head these days.
00:40:26.439 --> 00:40:32.359
Yes. Because they don't trust the people watching them to figure it out. Yes.
00:40:33.359 --> 00:40:38.179
It's like the writers feel like, Oh, this audience is dumb.
00:40:39.050 --> 00:40:43.450
So we're going to explain everything. We're going to spell it out like they're a five-year-old. Yes.
00:40:43.990 --> 00:40:46.850
And we can't have ambiguity. Yes.
00:40:47.010 --> 00:40:52.030
We can't have anyone being unsure about what I actually said about that person.
00:40:52.230 --> 00:40:54.330
Yes. Or what they actually think.
00:40:54.570 --> 00:40:57.710
Yes. Everything has to be all out in the open, all cards on the table.
00:40:57.950 --> 00:41:03.490
There can't be any room for ambiguity, mystery, subtext.
00:41:03.630 --> 00:41:06.270
And subtext is key to making a good story.
00:41:06.490 --> 00:41:09.330
Yeah, absolutely. because you're dealing with flawed people.
00:41:09.750 --> 00:41:12.690
And that's where I think the difference is that none of these new characters
00:41:12.690 --> 00:41:17.050
are in any way flawed. They are pinnacles. Yeah.
00:41:17.370 --> 00:41:21.710
And in an opposite way of what we talked about before as in to get in the academy
00:41:21.710 --> 00:41:23.230
before it had to be the best of the best.
00:41:23.410 --> 00:41:26.530
Yeah. But the best of the best still carry with them trauma.
00:41:26.710 --> 00:41:31.310
They still carry with them issues that they need to... And everything they've done to become that.
00:41:31.810 --> 00:41:36.710
Exactly. For example. Like you ask anyone, anyone at all who is a straight-A
00:41:36.710 --> 00:41:41.990
student and you're going to find just a litany of problems backing that up.
00:41:42.070 --> 00:41:45.670
Now, they got there, they succeeded, anyone at the top of their game is going
00:41:45.670 --> 00:41:51.230
to have a litany of, not all would have, I'm going to list off a bunch of things,
00:41:51.350 --> 00:41:53.510
they won't have all of them, but you'll definitely go, oh yeah.
00:41:54.530 --> 00:41:58.470
They'll have regrets, they'll have suffered traumas, they'll have lost friends,
00:41:58.610 --> 00:41:59.530
they'll have lost family members.
00:41:59.970 --> 00:42:03.710
If they ever had friends in the first place because their parents never let
00:42:03.710 --> 00:42:05.750
them go out and had to have them back doing homework.
00:42:06.010 --> 00:42:09.090
Yes. or they had to be on the track every night
00:42:09.090 --> 00:42:12.170
and they had to do no television so they
00:42:12.170 --> 00:42:15.050
didn't have anything to relate to the other kids about exactly they
00:42:15.050 --> 00:42:17.910
never watched Star Trek because their parents wouldn't let them because
00:42:17.910 --> 00:42:21.050
they didn't believe Star Trek was something worthwhile oh yeah
00:42:21.050 --> 00:42:29.330
or that there was they had to be they had to be on the track or in the gym or
00:42:29.330 --> 00:42:34.090
at the they had to do the thing that they had to do and then had to get home
00:42:34.090 --> 00:42:35.290
do their homework then they had
00:42:35.290 --> 00:42:41.030
to do their thing So what these shows are failing to do in reality is...
00:42:41.814 --> 00:42:45.214
Representation 100 well i
00:42:45.214 --> 00:42:48.354
think also i mean i would
00:42:48.354 --> 00:42:51.334
say my knee-jerk reaction was yes 100 i would
00:42:51.334 --> 00:42:54.234
say that they're failing to do they they
00:42:54.234 --> 00:42:57.534
want to do representation in a certain way and they're abjectly
00:42:57.534 --> 00:43:00.794
failing at that representation representation of human
00:43:00.794 --> 00:43:03.814
beings well no because they want to represent the identities
00:43:03.814 --> 00:43:06.854
yeah and and no one
00:43:06.854 --> 00:43:09.974
is just one thing 100% now this is this actually i did
00:43:09.974 --> 00:43:13.034
a a we should finish
00:43:13.034 --> 00:43:18.994
up soon so i did a i think i mentioned before i did a one of my degrees is in
00:43:18.994 --> 00:43:23.054
game design and we didn't do a final thesis but we did do various projects along
00:43:23.054 --> 00:43:31.854
the way yeah and one of them was essentially i did a discursive piece about Divergent,
00:43:32.074 --> 00:43:40.774
and how in that you are said to be one of the things, you're either erudite or dauntless,
00:43:41.054 --> 00:43:43.094
or you're one of five different things.
00:43:43.174 --> 00:43:45.394
Yeah. And to be Divergent. If you choose.
00:43:46.194 --> 00:43:49.614
And you can choose to be another one. Yes. Yeah, absolutely. So what's the point?
00:43:49.834 --> 00:43:53.354
Yeah. So either you can use the sorting hat to go to a specific location.
00:43:53.434 --> 00:43:55.874
Or tell the sorting hat to fuck off. And you can choose yourself.
00:43:56.074 --> 00:43:57.794
Yeah. So that's already broken.
00:43:58.720 --> 00:44:02.220
Where's the janitor class? Oh, no, the janitor class was there. Was there? Yeah.
00:44:02.560 --> 00:44:05.360
There were, I think it was Erudite. No, no, Erudite was intelligent ones.
00:44:05.480 --> 00:44:07.400
There was, there was, there was the compassionate ones.
00:44:07.640 --> 00:44:11.920
The, the, the best you do, who did, um, Yeah. Charity work. I just remember, I mean, anyway, sorry.
00:44:12.320 --> 00:44:17.740
But I basically, so I essentially, in that, to be divergent would be two things.
00:44:17.980 --> 00:44:19.240
So you can be brave and intelligent.
00:44:19.880 --> 00:44:22.940
That's most fucking people. Um, so it was, it was really fucking bad.
00:44:23.160 --> 00:44:28.320
I used that, and I compared it to the classes in, or the clans in Vampire and Masquerade. Yeah.
00:44:29.000 --> 00:44:38.760
Where you can have, say, the Ventrue are the nobles and the Bruja are the rebels.
00:44:38.980 --> 00:44:42.760
You can have a rebellious Ventrue and you can have a noble Bruja.
00:44:42.980 --> 00:44:48.720
And by just swapping those two words, you have two different character types.
00:44:48.980 --> 00:44:52.800
It's fantastic because you just go, okay, yes, he is coming from a noble background,
00:44:52.980 --> 00:44:54.000
but he's a fucking killer.
00:44:54.360 --> 00:44:56.680
This guy is coming from- Like Robin Hood was a noble.
00:44:57.120 --> 00:45:01.280
100%. Robin Hood could be an adventurer who's a rebel. 100%.
00:45:01.280 --> 00:45:04.680
So you can, so we're not one thing.
00:45:04.940 --> 00:45:11.520
And by labeling these characters of one type, that you're not,
00:45:11.620 --> 00:45:15.300
and I think that's why the shows are failing. Yeah.
00:45:15.680 --> 00:45:19.020
That they decided that the audience was a certain type.
00:45:19.900 --> 00:45:25.680
And didn't have, and lacked a certain maturity or I don't know what it is.
00:45:26.320 --> 00:45:31.840
Like a certain perception that they have to be smacked around with it a little bit.
00:45:32.524 --> 00:45:41.044
Well, actually, I would say that the audience that they thought was there is also kind of foolish,
00:45:41.364 --> 00:45:47.304
because they wanted an audience that would like this sort of stuff,
00:45:47.384 --> 00:45:52.784
and an audience that would essentially have that dictated back to them,
00:45:53.164 --> 00:45:55.804
have an echo chamber, have a bubble.
00:45:55.804 --> 00:45:59.264
And while there is that idea
00:45:59.264 --> 00:46:03.344
about modern audience a modern audience is again it's like the term woke you
00:46:03.344 --> 00:46:07.424
can apply the term in so many different ways that yes there's a modern audience
00:46:07.424 --> 00:46:11.904
that exists but not how you're defining not how Kurtzman is defining it because
00:46:11.904 --> 00:46:16.584
Kurtzman has just found out that yeah he's made his bones he killed a franchise,
00:46:17.284 --> 00:46:24.224
dead yeah just fucking flat dead and I for actors and actresses who some of
00:46:24.224 --> 00:46:29.804
which I respect doesn't like Paul Giamatti sure he happily worked he took his money and walked,
00:46:30.364 --> 00:46:34.044
it's a it's a horror show to be,
00:46:34.724 --> 00:46:39.124
this bad like I remember in school we can do better people we can do better
00:46:39.124 --> 00:46:40.384
I remember in school that the,
00:46:41.144 --> 00:46:44.284
normal people would be talking about Star Trek Red Dwarf.
00:46:45.244 --> 00:46:50.104
Shows that are now so fucking niche that they wouldn't be talked about anymore.
00:46:51.528 --> 00:46:59.568
So yeah so that was that okay wow that's another one yeah it's just these shows these shows will,
00:47:00.748 --> 00:47:08.288
they'll die off and I can only hope that someone will realize why like a like
00:47:08.288 --> 00:47:15.388
a tree branch that the roots just don't go to anymore yeah like after season
00:47:15.388 --> 00:47:20.288
3 of Picard which was fun season 3 was by Terry Metallus came along and did a fantastic job yeah,
00:47:20.928 --> 00:47:26.828
it's a really fucking good job and I really respect the what's come before and build on it.
00:47:27.468 --> 00:47:33.848
When they had the Enterprise G at the end with 709 as the captain and all the
00:47:33.848 --> 00:47:37.728
crew around her I was like yeah I'm fully on board for a TV show.
00:47:38.208 --> 00:47:41.268
Star Trek Legacy give me Star Trek Legacy I will watch the shit out of this show.
00:47:42.528 --> 00:47:46.128
Kurtzman decided no we're going to Academy instead.
00:47:46.628 --> 00:47:53.708
So he intensely so he saw this He saw someone else coming in and doing a much fucking better job.
00:47:54.608 --> 00:48:00.288
There's a difference between being a head writer and a head of a head of a studio, head of a franchise.
00:48:00.688 --> 00:48:04.968
You have to allow for someone who's better than you to come in.
00:48:06.468 --> 00:48:10.248
Not in Hollywood. That's your job, Ghan. Yeah. Good luck and thanks for playing.
00:48:10.528 --> 00:48:14.408
Do not collect 200 euros. Do not pass. Don't really fucking collect 160 million.
00:48:15.148 --> 00:48:18.968
All right. Well, we'll wrap it up there for today.
00:48:19.568 --> 00:48:24.828
Rant. over rant the first over rant the second about.