TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
Catherine Roebuck: Is he really feeling awful right now?
Jackie Aston: He doesn't look like it to me. How about to you?
Catherine Roebuck: I'm not seeing it. it's not coming through. It it I'm seeing him produce what's expected of him in this moment. And we know he's a good masker. We know he's good at putting forward one picture while something else is going on for him. So I'm not convinced about what he's putting forward.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, he doesn't have much expression while his wife is furious and saying what she felt like and how it broke her. He just you know, yeah. You know, he's just sort of like there and acknowledging it. So he looks calm, he could look like he's listening, but it doesn't match what's going on in the session, how he's behaving, if he were really to be caring.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, he's also focusing on this question of is he evil or a sociopath and he's not showing that he's thinking very much about her experience. Like they were just talking about what was going on for her, and he hasn't actually said anything about that. Hi, welcome to Differentiated Love and Sex. Today Jackie and I are going to comment on this clip from couples therapy that features Chris and Sienna.
Jackie Aston: Okay, great, we'll get started. Okay, it was interesting to me. So that Chris, you know, he's describing his marriage story, and he said, you know, then we got married and I had a baby, and I'm this father, and then the rest is history. And then his wife jumps in and says, Except, like he's already kind of presenting it like it's a lovely story.
Catherine Roebuck: There was a moment that stood out to me where she said that's when when I went back to work. I guess that's when the cheating started. And he said something like, Well, sort of
Jackie Aston: Yes, You could see that he was sort of not being up front.
Catherine Roebuck: Right, and so I'm wondering, like there's a couple things here pointing to he's not that open, he's not that upfront, like you're saying, and I'm wondering, is it all on the table at this point or not? Like how how honest is he? I don't know yet.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, I think even how he says, you know, there was this betrayal in the relationship? It's very disconnected. It's sort of like it's this thing that happened versus him owning anything. It's disconnected from him. So the wife is sitting there. taking it in and it's like who who's responsible here? I mean, we know that couples are both responsible for the dynamics that they co create, but it seemed that he wanted to keep that away from him.
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I'm finding them a little difficult to track so far where I'm not sure what they're here for, like what is the issue, because there's actually not very much charge around this topic of infidelity so far.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. I think I see from Sienna that she feels she looks a little bit sad about the idea that her husband wasn't happy when she thought he was happy. Maybe we should watch more so we can track more. This Again, it's interesting how Chris presents what happened because he says at first it was started out with the Like he paid for the cuddling.
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. Yeah,
Jackie Aston: he was so f he first presents it as the cuddling service and then it moved into the physical when I'm thinking it's already it's already physical, in fact. Cuddling is a way of physically connecting with another person, but it it does seem to minimize what was going on initially. by not putting out the full idea, the the full picture of actually he was already engaging in physical touch and connection with another person.
Catherine Roebuck: Right. And there's again like the distancing showing up and how he talks about it that he says it got physical and with two different professional cuddlers. So why is he doing the professional cuddling? Why is he keeping it from his wife? it's not likely that two people who offer this as a professional service cross a boundary without him having a role in that.
Jackie Aston: Yes, that makes sense.
Catherine Roebuck: Like if they're offering a platonic cuddling service, they're offering a service that is boundaried. and how does it go from that to a full-fledged sexual affair, it sounds like, of some type?
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm.
Catherine Roebuck: And and why is he I mean, so I'm just interested in his role in this. does he really enjoy kind of like tempting people past the boundary or what's going on here and the the cuddling aspect itself, when it was just platonic cuddling, it's it's not coming through that his wife knew about that. And I'm wondering why not. And also why is he turning outside of the marriage for cuddling when he's got a wife who's describing herself as like extra attentive, really trying to pay attention to him and be supportive, you know. Why is it happening this way?
Jackie Aston: Mm. Yeah, I'm thinking that he's describing something that got out of control as if he had no decision making and as part of this something that got out of control that was not in his hands. it happened to him. He's a victim to the circumstance. When what you're describing, if it's a paid service, it's gonna be boundaried. He'd probably have to be clear about if he wanted to progress in the physical touch that he'd have to communicate that, that it wouldn't just be this is just all emotional, you know, in this moment.
Catherine Roebuck: Right. And it happens once and he goes back and does this again with another provider. And so it's really looking to me like he's a person who enjoys pushing boundaries. And that getting across the boundary appealed to him more than the connection with that specific first person. It's it's that's my hypothesis right now from what I'm seeing is that he he really likes that moment of kind of tempting someone past a limit they had set.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. I'm thinking about the wife, how she seems very proud of herself for the way she showed up. And she's
Load full transcript
talking about things that she's doing to give her husband time. And that all sounds good. I am wondering what's her motive behind what she's doing? Is it more about her looking like a good wife? Is it more that she's managing her husband's anxiety? And so let me give him this time. And I would just want to know how much is she really taking on. but she doesn't talk about it being like a feeling good about their relationship. She talks about feeling good about how she's showing up. So I don't know what she is observing in her relationship, but she is focused on how she is involved in it.
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. And the position she's in that she feels good about is a very supportive position. so it may be that that's important to her. What do you think? Is he really feeling awful right now?
Jackie Aston: He doesn't look like it to me. How about to you?
Catherine Roebuck: I'm not seeing it. it's not coming through. It it I'm seeing him produce what's expected of him in this moment. And we know he's a good masker. We know he's good at putting forward one picture while something else is going on for him. So I'm not convinced about what he's putting forward.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, he doesn't have much expression while his wife is furious and saying what she felt like and how it broke her. He just you know, yeah. You know, he's just sort of like there and acknowledging it. So he looks calm, he could look like he's listening, but it doesn't match what's going on in the session, how he's behaving, if he were really to be caring.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, he's also focusing on this question of is he evil or a sociopath and he's not showing that he's thinking very much about her experience. Like they were just talking about what was going on for her, and he hasn't actually said anything about that.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, that was really interesting to me too. I tracked that. That now he's li you know, it's kinda easier to say, like, am I just this bad guy?
Catherine Roebuck: Mm.
Jackie Aston: And then one, someone could swoop in and say, Well, you're not all bad or you know, you're not bad and start to take care of him. Or it just removes the focus from what his wife experienced and how he impacted her, which is what
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Aston: needs to be talked about. He's very clever at moving that conversation away from that and onto him.
Catherine Roebuck: Right, and so now the topic is kind of like bringing him down off of this extreme negative view of himself. And instead of looking at what's his real impact on his partner. A lot of people run into this move with a a parent where if you try to talk to your parent about something, they'll say, like, I guess I just was just a terrible mother then. and it's a way of getting out of talking about what you were actually bringing up. Where then you're like, yeah, you you end up in this position of like reassuring or something.
Jackie Aston: Yes. mom, you're not you weren't a bad mom and I understand.
Catherine Roebuck: Right, right, right. And so yeah, I'm I'm suspicious of the moves he's making here and I'm still not seeing in him any actual concern about his partner.
Jackie Aston: Yes. I'm curious what doctor Orna's gonna do. what a quick change in mood for the wife.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, and like a little bit disturbing.
Jackie Aston: Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: so watching her so Dr. Orna's talking to her about being really dissociated and actually she sounds incredibly dissociated with her responses there. Like she's not tracking anything in that moment. It's just like, well what do you mean? How do we do that? Like it it's it's kind of troubling because of how how much it lacks any substance or presence contact with reality.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, I was wondering if she's reacting to what her husband was saying in the session, where he's now pulled the conversation onto him, and if something's happening in her mind where that's really difficult to process that. And so that is sort of creating this disconnect in her. because he's he's doing something in the session and that she's probably picking up on that to some degree. But she's laughing and sort of clapping when Doctor Orna then says how she could maybe move forward.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, I I do agree with the view that they're both disconnected. they they lack contact. And they do it really different ways. And so we're seeing how she does it is she goes into this like very childlike, very soft, floaty kind of place where she just doesn't know what's going on. And I do think it's likely that that's a reaction to what just happened was upsetting.
Jackie Aston: You buy that?
Catherine Roebuck: No, I don't. this whole thing about they had to be attracted to him, they were on the young side. She's forty two, I assume he's also similar age. He's choosing women who are close to half his age, maybe even younger than that in some cases. It's not an accident. Like there is there is something going on here that from the outset has this intentionality that is sexual.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. Yeah, and he again is trying to paint a picture. He's just looking for connections, someone I think he's honest about he wants someone to like him. So he's validation seeking. But it's not out of like him wanting a friendship. It's it's more about him wanting, I think, to feel desirable and attractive. And I think it is good that his wife is. pushing back against the picture he's putting out there because she's saying, No, no, no, these are women that are attractive. it looks like it's sexual to me, she's from what she's describing, and she's not going with his picture.
Catherine Roebuck: I think there's a dominance aspect. I think he doesn't only want to feel validated and desired. I think he wants to feel in control. I think that's one reason he's choosing young people. It's easier to manipulate somebody who's 20 than someone who's 40, typically. but also his wife said, like she saw the pictures
of all the girls that he did this with. How many are there? You know, how, how How many times did he do this without
Jackie Aston: And and
Catherine Roebuck: getting clear or honest about what he was up to? but even the fact I mean, she knows that they all are big breasted. Okay, so that's not like headshots. Like I there's
Jackie Aston: Yeah, okay.
Catherine Roebuck: it also makes me question, like, where is he finding all of these women? Are they all through the same kind of agency? Is this really a cuddling thing, or is that some kind of cover?
Jackie Aston: Yes. Yeah, it it's it's seeming like a cover to me. and when she's saying how it brings up her own insecurities, he's saying yes, like yes, he knows. so he can acknowledge it a little bit, but he's not moving in on that. He's not curious about that. He's sort of, yep, like he recognizes it.
Catherine Roebuck: He's really good at tracking people and you can see that from his ability to lie and hide things. And you can also see that from his ability to map these young women, figure out what would make them feel attracted to him or drawn to him and present that.
Jackie Aston: I think what I'm reacting to is how disconnected he is from his wife in the session. And I don't know that she's connected either. I think she is tracking him, but it just seems like in the session you can see the issues between them and the way that they are together. And that would be clear that that would be going on outside the session to me as well.
Catherine Roebuck: So I think when you say he's disconnected from her, that you're saying he's not being caring toward her, he's not invested in her in a good way?
Jackie Aston: Yes, because I know what you're saying, probably saying is
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm.
Jackie Aston: he's quite good at figuring out how to get around his wife and he can track her and he's aware of her. So yes, thanks for distinguishing that because I think he can
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah.
Jackie Aston: track her well.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, I think there is a connection and I don't know what he's up to in these sessions, but so far I'm not seeing him be here to try to really get help. and so I guess we can't rule that out yet, but so far I think he's he's making a lot of moves and he's not being very collaborative with anybody. And that might be the point. Like the impact he's having on his wife in real time in the session is a type of connection.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm, if he was wanting to be warm to her and empathetic, he would do more than just sort of saying, like, Yep, you know, I'm
Catherine Roebuck: Yes.
Jackie Aston: here. He would be saying, I'm sorry I really hurt you, or I could imagine that it would be easy for you to compare yourself to these women, or this really isn't about you and your appearance, or this really isn't about how much I care about you, or something like that, but he's not making a warm, empathetic connection with her.
Catherine Roebuck: Right, okay, so all the warmth that we've seen so far has gone from her to him. And when he was describing the connection he was getting with these women that he was cheating with, he was saying he would map them out and figure out how to make them attracted to him, how to make them want him. I think he's doing the same thing to his wife and I think it's working. And so part of getting her to want him is to keep up this picture that he you know, he's he's kind of this traumatized person that needs lots of love and warmth and he's just confused and traumatized and i if she's just super warm and and supportive and understanding toward him. then they can have this relationship. So she's doing all of this work to try to reach him and empathize with him and be loving toward him. She's doing the wanting here.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. And I'm assuming that's a familiar role for her, where she is the person who's nurtures others. She in the last episode was excited about the fact that she let her husband have some time away and was supportive of him. So it's she's sort of in a role like that is probably familiar to her. And so she's taking that on in her her romantic relationship with her partner.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, and you can tell she really cares about understanding him and supporting him and the people who do care a lot in that way. can end up really drawn in with someone who is deceptive because it gives you this constant puzzle to be trying to understand. And so if your brain is really oriented toward trying to understand somebody, being with someone that is always messing with reality, hiding and misrepresenting things, it'll really hook you in.
Jackie Aston: Yes, that's such a great point. I love that you said that. Yeah, it's it's its own distraction for her. She's she's not
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. So Like I think he's mapped this is this is a really good way to get her even more invested in him is to present like, you know, I want this relationship so much that I would go on this show and work with this renowned Dr. Orna with you and, you know, put all of my vulnerable trauma on display. but I think it's all a move. I don't think he's serious about getting better. I think he just knows that all of that is the right play for the woman.
Jackie Aston: We can see the wife's collusion and you can see the wife's emotional issues showing up, the way she orients to her husband. So the fact that she is so focused on like him and taking care of him and not that he's not empathetic and warm to her or invested in her. She's she's not dealing with that.
Catherine Roebuck: Mm-hmm. Yeah, she mentioned that during the the period where he was doing this, where he was having having these affairs, that she was extra attentive to him. And I wonder if she can put together what was driving that. You know, I my guess is that she could tell something was up with him. But the way she handles it is to offer him like extra understanding and support instead of being like, What is going on?
You're you're not being open about something. Like I can tell you're hiding something. And so I think she yeah, I think she has a liability in this direction that makes it easy for people to deceive her.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, they talked about the dead shark face. This is from the last episode. And I'm wondering if that's a trigger for her to do even more of this like caretaking and attentiveness. Like, let me figure this out. Let me make him feel better instead of being direct about what is up here? What is going on with you? do you see how you're showing up in the relationship and how this is impacting me? I want to work with on this with you.
Catherine Roebuck: I'm seeing a lot of implanting pictures happening still.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm.
Catherine Roebuck: And it's adding to my view that he really likes to cross boundaries because they both agree that she is basically boundaryless, that anything that he asked for he could have. So that's gonna include cuddling, that's gonna include sex. And and so and even if she if he were to even tell her that he wanted to do this platonic cuddling, that she would probably say, No problem. And so he finds a way to cross a boundary. It's completely unnecessary for him to do this. Like he has multiple paths to get cuddling and sex, and even to get cuddling with other women, apparently, without having to cross a boundary, but that's still what he insists on doing.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I was thinking about it. If he knows he can get his wife to do whatever he wants, if that actually isn't satisfying to him. You know, if it's sort of like she's gonna do it anyway, it feels more exciting and fun for him to have the chase. It's more about like there's more of a it's more validating. Can I get someone who really may not say yes? be interested in me. Although it's a paid service, so there's like a little there, you know, there can't be real desire usually because it's sort of an exchange of you pay me, I do this for you. So the person paying isn't really desired either, but it could feel more like that. But I think her actually not having any boundaries is probably disappointing in some ways for his partner because he doesn't have to really do anything. And he on one hand could like that, but on another hand feel like, well, that's not that e exciting. I need to find someone who's gonna give me a bigger dopamine hit by validating me and wanting me when they shouldn't, or being open to me when they may not be, and I have to figure that out. Who can I get interested in me?
Catherine Roebuck: And I can understand on one hand, enjoying the chase and plenty of people do. And and there's ways to play with that in a marriage. There's no reason you can't. And having a partner who's really open to doing different things, like if you said like, hey, I really want to play with this idea that I'm chasing you and it's kinda I have to work pretty hard to get you, fine. They could do that. I think he's doing something darker
that's about dominating someone and getting past a a boundary that's actually an important boundary. because if these really are professional cuddlers, if if that's really what they're trying to offer is platonic cuddling, and he gets two of them to cross into a sexual encounter, he's pushed them past boundaries that are tied to their livelihood, right? That's that's a problem. it's also probably there's probably some legal problems with what they do there. I don't know whether there's money exchanged at that point or not. But he's doing the same thing with his wife, where like he's getting past a a boundary that really matters to her when there's all kinds of other ways he can play with if he wants to just play with the energy of doing something forbidden, doing something that takes a lot of work. There's a lot of consensual ways you can do that within a marriage and he has no interest in any of them.
Jackie Aston: Yes. Well, it's interesting. It sounds like you think that he did hire cuddlers that are just about cuddling.
Catherine Roebuck: I don't know. I I that seems to be how Dr. Orna is interpreting it and we just don't have enough information. I know that professional colours exist.
Jackie Aston: Yeah. Yes.
Catherine Roebuck: I don't have a lot of information beyond that about i is this a common front for basically a a sexual service. I don't know.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, I mean that's what I would want to understand more about because that would be a different picture. So if he's saying they're cuddlers and now I'm gonna push them past that, that's different than well they start out cuddling, but they're open to adding on additional services. So then it's not really a boundary thing. It's just sort of like he wants to move it to the next level and he can if he wants to. But I think
Catherine Roebuck: One one thing that pushes it more on the side of platonic cuddling to me is that it sounds like he did the platonic cuddling with way more than two. From how his wife talks about it, as like I've seen pictures of all the girls that he's done this with. That's more than two. I don't know what number she's talking about, but and so if it's true, and we can't really trust that he's coming forward with the whole truth. But if it's true that it becomes sexual with two, and then it doesn't become sexual with another five or something, that that looks to me more like he's getting people to cross a boundary than all the women involved really were offering sexual services.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, I'm thinking if these are all young, attractive women that they might be offering more than just cuddling services too. So we just don't we don't have the answer, but I see what you're saying where it could fit. I th
Catherine Roebuck: Well, that's also where I'd expect if it really is that this is a front and they're offering sexual services, I'd expect that to come at a a premium financially. So I'd expect them to be talking about this in terms of he paid for sex versus he had an affair, you know? And so there's there's a different way it's being framed that leans it away from the idea that he was paying for the sexual experiences.
Jackie Aston: versus just paying for the cuddling services. Yeah, and they don't talk about like how did he pay for it and how did did the wife notice any of the bills? Talk about noticing the text messages and she then she doesn't trust him, so she starts going into his phone. So again, that's another issue. She's in a relationship here, she's not trusting him, and she has to go out and search his phone. Because she does 'cause she doesn't think that he's gonna disclose to her what's really going on.
Catherine Roebuck: Right. Right. And in that kind of situation, like you're not really solving the problem by digging into your partner's phone because the problem is that you have a partner that's hiding things from you, right? And so going full detective mode rarely solves the core.
Jackie Aston: Yes, and then it can be it's understandable why someone would want to to do that, but then it can also be a breach of trust on the other side, you know, going through someone's personal things is also not trustworthy. So but you can understand why they would do it and they suspect something and they're right about it.
Catherine Roebuck: when he's listening to her then he'll he'll kinda nod along and say yeah and he's done this the whole time N nothing she says has any real impact on him. Like he's not that interested. He's not very attentive or connected. He's just sort of like, Yeah, I'll say whatever while you talk. Like it doesn't she's wasting her time and her effort trying to talk to him.
Jackie Aston: I think she's asking a good question. Why didn't I leave?
Catherine Roebuck: It's a really good question to take seriously that there's there's something going on on her side that keeps him feeling very attractive to her when he's not treating her well here. Like there's not that much here that makes him look as appealing as how she relates to him.
Jackie Aston: Mm-hmm. She also is feeling resentful for feeling like she has to make herself smaller. But I'm also curious about why she's willing to make herself smaller in her relationship. Like this is all at her own expense. So she's gonna manage the beast and make herself small.
Catherine Roebuck: Right, and and the resentment, like ultimately there are two people in this marriage that have been okay with her shrinking. And what she can do something about is her side of that where she could take that on and no longer be okay with shrinking to you know, keep the peace or keep him from exploding in some way. And that may mean that the marriage stops being viable. But if she's mad about the shrinking, there is something she can do about it, even if he won't do anything.
Jackie Aston: Seems that she's accepting the very limited attention that he's giving her in the session. So he's looking at her. So that might seem like I'm hearing you.
He's nodding along, I'm hearing you. But that's that's a very low bar.
Catherine Roebuck: Right. Yeah, and she doesn't seem to have a problem with how he's showing up. She's not objecting or commenting on it. And so this is probably what it's like between them. you can tell she's putting a lot of thought into the things she says, and then he's putting no thought into his responses to her. It's typically just yeah. There's no substance to it.
Jackie Aston: And I I think about couples that I work with where one is nodding along with the other and it doesn't have to be about the infidelity and and owning that, although I he's not really owning it. But I think she's sort of accepting like as if he's agreeing and he sees what she's saying, and she's really missing that she's having no impact on him and that he's just sort of Moving things along.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, if I were working with them, I would be prompting him to say more about what you agree with than that. You
Jackie Aston: Yes, yes, that's a great question.
Catherine Roebuck: know, get him to come out front a little bit. There's also a way that he he pretends that he's a really open person, but it's more true that he's willing to put forward pictures. And so he will put information on the table, but you can't count on it being accurate or complete or the most important thing to address.
Jackie Aston: Yeah, I would imagine his response to you, Catherine, if you were to ask that, would be to say, Yeah, I don't know why I'm not such a nice person. And then he'd make it about him, because that's what he's been doing in the session. And again, he can steer it away. You know, we can work with that. We do that, because clients don't always accept that. But you know, that's what the wife is struggling to do is push against that when he moves away and moves the conversation in a different direction, she goes along with it. So therapist we wouldn't be doing that.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah, there's a moment in I think it was when she was doing consultation that Dr. Orna made a comment about it's not that likely that he doesn't know anything about why he does these things. I would love to see her move in on that a little bit more. like show him that that's how she sees it. As like it's not that likely that you don't know anything about what was going on here for you. And really expect him to produce some type of answer to why he was doing this when he had all of these other options. because he's gonna know something about it. And he's revealed like little pieces about he does like the validation or the pursuit from the other person. But I think there's so much more he knows that he's not putting forward. And this is another thing that a deceptive person can do is they can pretend that they're open at the same time that everything that they reveal is concealing something else.
Jackie Aston: And then they make the other person work to figure it out. his wife is willing to do that work.
Catherine Roebuck: Yeah. Yeah, and so on on her side, I'd be working with her on why she's willing to do it this way and can she experiment on not working so hard, not being willing to?