TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.160 --> 00:00:03.600
So Florida just solved the problem of failing students.
00:00:03.600 --> 00:00:12.320
Here's how it works: you walk into a science exam, and the question is explain the evidence for evolution through natural selection.
00:00:12.320 --> 00:00:13.679
You don't know the answer.
00:00:13.679 --> 00:00:14.960
You didn't study.
00:00:14.960 --> 00:00:19.920
So instead, you write, God created all living things in six days.
00:00:19.920 --> 00:00:21.440
Genesis 1.1.
00:00:21.440 --> 00:00:25.920
Your teacher marks it wrong because it is wrong.
00:00:25.920 --> 00:00:28.160
It doesn't answer the question.
00:00:28.160 --> 00:00:35.520
But under a new Florida bill, that teacher just made a $25,000 mistake.
00:00:35.520 --> 00:00:40.960
Because you didn't just fail a test, you expressed a sincerely held belief.
00:00:40.960 --> 00:00:46.320
And in Florida, that might be worth more than actually learning the material.
00:00:46.320 --> 00:00:47.520
Thanks for tuning in.
00:00:47.520 --> 00:00:52.960
I'm Mike Smithgall, the unelected mayor of Atheistville, and this is today's Mic Drop.
00:00:52.960 --> 00:01:02.079
To understand what's happening in Florida right now, you have to go back to late 2025 and the University of Oklahoma.
00:01:02.079 --> 00:01:08.319
A junior named Samantha Fulnicky is taking a psychology course called Lifespan Development.
00:01:08.319 --> 00:01:10.319
The assignment is straightforward.
00:01:10.319 --> 00:01:17.760
Read a peer-reviewed article on gender norms and mental health, then write a response engaging with that research.
00:01:17.760 --> 00:01:19.120
She didn't do that.
00:01:19.120 --> 00:01:22.319
Instead, she wrote an essay citing the Bible.
00:01:22.319 --> 00:01:26.480
She argued that the concept of multiple genders was demonic.
00:01:26.480 --> 00:01:32.159
She didn't engage with the study, she didn't respond to the prompt, she preached.
00:01:32.159 --> 00:01:34.959
The teaching assistant gave her a zero.
00:01:34.959 --> 00:01:39.680
Not because she was Christian, but because she didn't answer the question.
00:01:39.680 --> 00:01:46.640
If you don't do the assignment, you fail the assignment.
00:01:46.640 --> 00:01:48.560
That's how school works.
00:01:48.560 --> 00:01:52.000
But Fulnicki cried religious discrimination.
00:01:52.000 --> 00:01:57.599
And did the administration stand up and fight the good fight and protect academic integrity?
00:01:57.599 --> 00:01:58.799
Um, no.
00:01:58.799 --> 00:02:03.760
They suspended the instructor and fell all over themselves apologizing.
00:02:03.760 --> 00:02:05.680
That was a signal flare.
00:02:05.680 --> 00:02:10.719
Conservative lawmakers across the country saw that and thought, whoa, whoa, whoa, wait.
00:02:10.719 --> 00:02:12.479
We can legislate this.
00:02:12.479 --> 00:02:15.599
And Florida said, hey, hold my beer.
00:02:15.599 --> 00:02:24.479
There is a bill sitting in the Florida legislature right now, SB 1006 in the Senate and
Load full transcript
HB 835 in the House.
00:02:24.479 --> 00:02:26.240
These bills haven't passed yet.
00:02:26.240 --> 00:02:27.599
They're still in committee.
00:02:27.599 --> 00:02:31.120
But the fact that they exist at all should tell you something.
00:02:31.120 --> 00:02:38.639
All right, the long title is the Florida Student and School Personnel First Amendment and Religious Liberties Act.
00:02:38.639 --> 00:02:39.919
It's a mouthful.
00:02:39.919 --> 00:02:46.800
But whenever you see a bill with the words Liberty and First Amendment in the title, you should probably check your wallet.
00:02:46.800 --> 00:02:49.759
And in this case, check your kid's report card.
00:02:49.759 --> 00:02:51.199
Here's the pitch.
00:02:51.199 --> 00:03:00.560
Schools can't apply any academic penalty to students for expressing their religious, political, or ideological beliefs in coursework.
00:03:00.560 --> 00:03:03.520
Now, on the surface, that sounds actually quite reasonable.
00:03:03.520 --> 00:03:11.039
If a kid writes an essay arguing for lower taxes, a teacher shouldn't fail them just for disagreeing politically.
00:03:11.039 --> 00:03:12.560
We all get that.
00:03:12.560 --> 00:03:14.960
That's already a standard.
00:03:14.960 --> 00:03:20.639
But the bill isn't protecting kids from bias, it's protecting wrong answers.
00:03:20.639 --> 00:03:22.800
So here's the key language.
00:03:22.800 --> 00:03:29.599
A student cannot be penalized if the assignment requires a student's viewpoint to be expressed.
00:03:29.599 --> 00:03:34.400
I'm going to read that one more time, just because I want you to hear it.
00:03:34.400 --> 00:03:42.639
A student cannot be penalized if the assignment requires a student's viewpoint to be expressed.
00:03:42.639 --> 00:03:44.719
Think about what that covers.
00:03:44.719 --> 00:03:47.120
History requires interpretation.
00:03:47.120 --> 00:03:49.199
Literature requires analysis.
00:03:49.199 --> 00:03:51.039
Civics requires perspective.
00:03:51.039 --> 00:03:55.439
Biology involves understanding evidence-based conclusions.
00:03:55.439 --> 00:04:11.360
So if a student writes that the Civil War isn't about slavery, or that evolution is a hoax, or that vaccines contain microchips, and the teacher marks that down for being factually incorrect, that teacher just opened the door to a lawsuit.
00:04:11.360 --> 00:04:16.000
And we're not talking about a slap on the wrist or a note that goes in their personnel file.
00:04:16.000 --> 00:04:20.160
We're talking about $25,000 payout.
00:04:20.160 --> 00:04:25.759
Now let me walk you through how this works because the financial incentive is the entire ball game here.
00:04:25.759 --> 00:04:29.519
The bill creates what's called a private cause of action.
00:04:29.519 --> 00:04:38.319
That's legal speak for students can sue the school district directly if they think their grade was lowered because of their beliefs.
00:04:38.319 --> 00:04:40.560
And the payout isn't symbolic.
00:04:40.560 --> 00:04:48.560
The
law mandates statutory punitive damages between $15,000 and $25,000 plus attorney fees.
00:04:48.560 --> 00:04:49.920
And this is important.
00:04:49.920 --> 00:04:58.399
The state explicitly waives sovereign immunity, which means school districts can't claim they're protected from these lawsuits.
00:04:58.399 --> 00:05:00.079
So let's play this out.
00:05:00.079 --> 00:05:02.399
You're a high school science teacher.
00:05:02.399 --> 00:05:05.279
You got 30 papers to grade on evolution.
00:05:05.279 --> 00:05:11.360
29 kids write about natural selection, and one kid writes about Adam and Eve.
00:05:11.360 --> 00:05:13.439
You know the answer is wrong.
00:05:13.439 --> 00:05:15.600
It didn't engage with the curriculum.
00:05:15.600 --> 00:05:19.360
It doesn't demonstrate understanding of the material.
00:05:19.360 --> 00:05:23.759
By any objective academic standard, it deserves to fail.
00:05:23.759 --> 00:05:25.519
But now you're doing the math.
00:05:25.519 --> 00:05:28.800
If you give that kid an F, they might sue.
00:05:28.800 --> 00:05:34.560
And even if the district fights it and wins, they've spent tens of thousands on legal fees.
00:05:34.560 --> 00:05:38.160
If they lose, it's $25,000 plus costs.
00:05:38.160 --> 00:05:39.839
So what are you gonna do?
00:05:39.839 --> 00:05:41.199
You're gonna pass them.
00:05:41.199 --> 00:05:48.480
Not because they earned it, not because they learned anything at all, but because failing them is the financial liability.
00:05:48.480 --> 00:05:50.319
That's not protecting free speech.
00:05:50.319 --> 00:05:53.920
That's creating a bounty system for bad answers.
00:05:53.920 --> 00:05:55.360
All right, quick pause.
00:05:55.360 --> 00:05:59.360
If you haven't subscribed yet, I would love to have you join the community here at Atheistville.
00:05:59.360 --> 00:06:11.600
I realize that some of you will fundamentally disagree with me, but my hope is that you value open discussion and you appreciate different perspectives presented without yelling and screaming and name-calling.
00:06:11.600 --> 00:06:13.439
And do me a favor, leave a comment.
00:06:13.439 --> 00:06:17.360
I read every one, even the ones that are intended to rile me up.
00:06:17.360 --> 00:06:22.000
But again, if you value respectful discussion, I am happy to engage with you.
00:06:22.000 --> 00:06:26.399
And if ultimately we walk away friends and agree to disagree, that's fantastic.
00:06:26.399 --> 00:06:27.920
Oh, and hey, one more thing.
00:06:27.920 --> 00:06:31.920
If you think someone else may have an opinion on this subject, share this with them.
00:06:31.920 --> 00:06:35.439
We need to have more calm discussions on important issues.
00:06:35.439 --> 00:06:37.040
All right, let's get back to it.
00:06:37.040 --> 00:06:38.959
Now, here's what kills me about this.
00:06:38.959 --> 00:06:45.920
The people pushing this bill, Senator Yarborough and Representative Barrero, they love to talk about merit.
00:06:45.920 --> 00:06:50.639
They hate participation trophies, they want accountability in schools.
00:06:50.639 --> 00:06:52.800
But look at what they're actually building.
00:06:52.800 --> 00:06:55.839
This is the ultimate participation trophy.
00:06:55.839 --> 00:07:04.160
It says you don't have to be right, you don't have to demonstrate knowledge, you don't even have to try, you just have to invoke belief.
00:07:04.160 --> 00:07:06.319
And it doesn't apply evenly.
00:07:06.319 --> 00:07:09.920
If a secular student writes a lazy essay, they fail.
00:07:09.920 --> 00:07:12.079
They've got no legal recourse.
00:07:12.079 --> 00:07:20.959
But if a religious student writes the same lazy essay and sprinkles in some Bible verses, suddenly they're a protected class with a legal shield.
00:07:20.959 --> 00:07:24.399
No reasonable person would see that as fairness.
00:07:24.399 --> 00:07:27.759
It's preferential treatment with a price tag attached.
00:07:27.759 --> 00:07:29.600
Now I want to be clear about something.
00:07:29.600 --> 00:07:33.519
Obviously, teachers shouldn't discriminate based on a viewpoint.
00:07:33.519 --> 00:07:42.959
If a student writes a well-argued conservative opinion in a history class and the teacher fails them just because they disagree politically, that's wrong.
00:07:42.959 --> 00:07:44.480
It's clearly wrong.
00:07:44.480 --> 00:07:47.920
I will absolutely support you if you say that's wrong.
00:07:47.920 --> 00:07:49.920
We all agree on that.
00:07:49.920 --> 00:07:51.759
But that's already the case.
00:07:51.759 --> 00:07:54.079
That's the way the rules already work.
00:07:54.079 --> 00:07:56.560
This bill isn't solving that problem.
00:07:56.560 --> 00:07:58.480
It's creating a new one.
00:07:58.480 --> 00:08:03.040
It's telling students that ideology can substitute for accuracy.
00:08:03.040 --> 00:08:08.959
And once you do that, education stops being about learning and starts being about litigation.
00:08:08.959 --> 00:08:11.600
Think about the long-term cost here.
00:08:11.600 --> 00:08:15.360
What's a Florida high school diploma gonna be worth in 10 years?
00:08:15.360 --> 00:08:28.480
If I'm a college admissions officer in another state and I see a transcript from a Florida public school, I have to wonder, did this kid actually earn that A in biology, or they just threatened to sue until the teacher gave up?
00:08:28.480 --> 00:08:30.639
We're not protecting students here.
00:08:30.639 --> 00:08:34.879
We're devaluing their education to score points and a culture war.
00:08:34.879 --> 00:08:38.320
And the people who get hurt the most are the kids themselves.
00:08:38.320 --> 00:08:49.679
We're teaching them that facts are negotiable, that evidence doesn't matter as much as confidence, that the legal system is a tool you use to bully your way past accountability.
00:08:49.679 --> 00:08:55.679
That might work in a Florida classroom in 2026, but it doesn't work where they go to college.
00:08:55.679 --> 00:09:03.919
It doesn't work in the job market, and it doesn't work in the real world where being wrong still has consequences.
00:09:03.919 --> 00:09:07.919
All right, that's my two cents, unblessed and unfiltered as always.
00:09:07.919 --> 00:09:10.480
Agree or disagree, but that's what I've got for you today.
00:09:10.480 --> 00:09:14.240
Look, at the end of the day, this comes down to one simple idea.
00:09:14.240 --> 00:09:17.279
Education only works when answers matter.
00:09:17.279 --> 00:09:23.919
Once belief overrides evaluation, the whole system just falls apart and we all lose.
00:09:23.919 --> 00:09:32.720
You can support free expression without sabotaging academic standards, and you can support religious liberty without turning a classroom into a courtroom.
00:09:32.720 --> 00:09:39.120
These bills haven't passed yet, they're still sitting in committee, but the fact that they even exist at all should worry you.
00:09:39.120 --> 00:09:44.320
Because once you put a dollar amount on being wrong, wrong becomes profitable.
00:09:44.320 --> 00:09:47.039
And that's not a system anyone should want.
00:09:47.039 --> 00:09:49.759
I'm Mike SmithGo, and I'll catch you on the next one.
00:09:49.759 --> 00:09:51.120
Hey, thanks for tuning in.
00:09:51.120 --> 00:09:52.799
I really hope you enjoyed that.
00:09:52.799 --> 00:09:54.480
Make sure you like and subscribe.
00:09:54.480 --> 00:09:58.799
That really does help us and it lets us bring you more conversations from beyond belief.
00:09:58.799 --> 00:10:01.200
And don't forget to go to atheistville.com.
00:10:01.200 --> 00:10:07.679
I almost always have an article that kind of fleshes out what we just talked about, and it also includes any of the links we may have mentioned.
00:10:07.679 --> 00:10:10.799
So make sure you go there and check that out as well.
00:10:10.799 --> 00:10:17.440
And in the meantime, take care and remember that reason and compassion go a very, very long way.