TRANSCRIÇÃO 🔗
MIchael Bograd: everybody. Welcome back to another episode of As Planned. I'm Stelic Vice President Mike Bograd. With me, as always, is the man behind the scenes, Pedro the producer. And today we have a very special guest. I'd like to also welcome Stelic Vice President Brooke Bolger. Excuse me, Brooke Bolger. Thanks for joining us. How are you doing today?
Brook Bolger: I'm doing great. How about yourself, Mike?
MIchael Bograd: Doing really well. So what I really like about these podcasts and and doing these episodes, now up to episode six, is these are unprompted, right? We don't know the script before these. Do even know what we're talking about today, Brooke?
Brook Bolger: no.
MIchael Bograd: Okay, so Pedro does a great job of doing research and seeing what's what topics are on LinkedIn and out in the field and being discussed. And I've actually seen this one a lot, right? And I'm sure you've seen a couple of these LinkedIn posts as well. And the topic revolves around float. Who owns the float on a project? So, you know, if you don't mind, why don't you give everyone a little bit of background about, you know, what do you think? How do you interpret that when you hear someone say, hey, who owns the float?
Brook Bolger: When somebody says who owns the float, I look around the room and I say, I I'm about to hear a lot of guesses or a lot of experience from past projects, right? but at the end of the day, I just tell everybody, Full stop, hit the brakes, look at your contract, right?
MIchael Bograd: Completely
Brook Bolger: And that
MIchael Bograd: agree. and in candidly, you know, we've both been doing this for what, close to twenty years now. I can't think of an instance where the float where the contract has never said that float is a sh not a shared commodity, correct?
Brook Bolger: actually it is
MIchael Bograd: Okay.
Brook Bolger: completely dictated by the contract. So there's a few things to look at with float. so if you're working with Caltrans, for instance, whoever generates that float gets the float, right? So if I how they maintain competitive roadway bids is if one contractor can do it in two years and another one can do it in three because roadways are phased. They get to keep that savings on their general conditions, and the owner can't just blow out their schedule because the original contract duration was three years. now Caltrans gets that savings because they get the advantage of a lower bid. Usually that's how you competitively bid a a Caltrans contract without without compressing your margins. so
MIchael Bograd: Does that come with risk?
Brook Bolger: it well the float is yours to consume, but if you consume it, you don't get an increase in overhead costs or general conditions. if the now if you know if the owner pushes you late, you do get increased general conditions cost. Right? now granted if the owner generates float by approving a critical submittal, let's say in two days instead of like the twenty days, which is usually contractually contractually dictated, then they get those eighteen days of float. So it's really in in Cal in the Caltrans world, whoever generates the float keeps the float.
MIchael Bograd: there sounds like there's two paths because this is actually, you know, full transparency. This is new to me. You know, I'm I have the Army Corps of Engineers spec pulled up, the UFGS spec, that I was gonna run through and it basically says float is a shared commodity. So this is a great com this is a learning experience for me. So there is a
Brook Bolger: Yeah, you'll see that on most you'll see that on most contracts actually. from general contractors to owners, you will see that that shared float, that sh float is shared. Absolutely.
MIchael Bograd: Yeah. So so on these Caltrans projects, let's stick with them. You bid you bid the job, it turned you, you know, hey, we can do this a year earlier. The substantial completion date in P6 says, you know, January of 2027. The schedule actually says January of 2026. You've created that year buffer. And then the You're just not collecting general conditions for that gap if it slips one way or the other. And then let me ask you this follow up.
Brook Bolger: Well exactly.
MIchael Bograd: On an individual task basis, are you also Catherine Flo? Okay.
Brook Bolger: No. So the the it's it's really only critical path float. So it's the
MIchael Bograd: Okay.
Brook Bolger: end of the milestone. And so the the advantage is that the general contractor prices two years of overhead. Maybe they add a little bit for their risk, but but that's what goes in the price, right? And the the state of California, the the public of California gets the benefit of that lower overhead cost because at the end of the day you're still putting the same amount of sticks and bricks and dirt into the ground. you're just paying paying less money. there's a a few other things. well, float, if you're a subcontractor, you would they'll have a clause in your schedule that says you must keep pace with our schedule quite often, right? They don't want a subcontractor consuming all their float. Our general contractor doesn't. So you should almost look at the schedule that you're given as a list of dates you need to hit. There might be float on float on those activities. They may they may you know have an activity that gives float. they may give you a primavera XCR native file or a PDF with float on it. But if that clause in your contract says you must keep pace with the schedule, that doesn't prevent you from being in default. You have to hit those dates. there's a a list of dates in there that you have to hit. Really, the only float there just means that they can't pass along their liquidated damages to you should they incur them if you consume that float. But it doesn't mean you're not in default of your contract terms. So again, go to the contract.
MIchael Bograd: Do you like this setup? I mean you do Caltrans. Do you like having this float as a
Load full transcript
not a shared commodity, as a buffer? Almost I wouldn't even call it a buffer. It's almost a cost.
Brook Bolger: i it depends. So on like on a hospital or something, it's so i the shared float is is very useful, right? It allows some things to slip, some things not to slip. It allows for project flexibility. However, I quite like it because in the bid process it allows us to do some really good engineering. If we could, you know, if we're doing a highway, and typically they save time by turning by getting creative with with traffic plans and turning a three-phase project into a two-phase project, right? and that's just a lot of time and energy spent by a lot of smart engineers and and smart project managers that are that are compressing this project. And and really what it does is it allows for these companies to be profitable without just racing to the bottom because there are contractors out there that just slim their margins down or maybe cut a corner or two to win projects or they buy projects, but with this model the public saves, the public gets a low bid, and the contractor gets their, you know, their planned margin.
MIchael Bograd: Does this have does this change your approach to risk analyses, time impact analyses? How did how are those different then?
Brook Bolger: Yeah, absolutely. the Caltrans example.
MIchael Bograd: Mm-hmm.
Brook Bolger: you absolutely need to maintain a schedule update month over month. And if the end date moves, you need to understand whether or not you know, if if the end date slips, you need to understand causation almost immediately, right? because you know, if there's float on the back another project is whose float are you consuming? Are you if if it was an owner caused delay, are you submitting a TIA for a couple extra days? Because it's, you it's often thousands or tens of thousands of dollars a day in overhead cost. but if the schedule gains time as well, you need to make a determination is do you mark that float as contractor float or is that owner float?
MIchael Bograd: Hmm.
Brook Bolger: Yeah.
MIchael Bograd: Who keeps who's whose responsibility again? This is you have you seem like, you know, this seems like very specific Caltrams. I was actually just reviewing the UFGS spec, where it says, you know, the owner, like let's say you do accelerate the schedule, right? On a typical, I I don't want to say typical, but on a Army Corps of Engineer, NAFAC project, you accelerate and it literally says in that spec, hey, the owner is not required to keep pace with you. Literally says
Brook Bolger: Mm-hmm.
MIchael Bograd: the opposite of what you just described. So I guess whose responsibility is it to track this float? I mean, is this project controls? Is this the general contractor?
Brook Bolger: It's project controls. you know, so the scheduling is super important. and you know, when you get into these self into work that's self perform like like roadway construction is quite often, or if you're working for sub
trades,
MIchael Bograd: Mm-hmm.
Brook Bolger: labor risk is is is where you gain and you know, where you make or break your your bank. so efficiency is big. but you know, it's in collaboration with the owner's representative. They have to agree on any float on on who generated or who consumed the float. Now, granted, if if this contractor says I consume some of my float, that's not necessarily a an argument usually. but if the contractor's saying, Hey owner, you've delayed us, that's, you know, usually a a bit of a negotiation. or, if you know who generated float is sometimes and how much is is sometimes up in the air as well.
MIchael Bograd: you know, it's maybe off on a little bit of a tangent or deep into the weeds. What about like force majeure, weather? How does that get handled?
Brook Bolger: So w weather days, I mean it again depends on the contract. In
MIchael Bograd: Exactly.
Brook Bolger: for Caltrans specifically, you actually get a a time extension of one day for inclement weather on the critical affecting critical path activities, but you generally don't get increased in in general conditions. You just it's a shared risk. however, some some projects have a weather bank built in. Some projects the contract tells you to anticipate weather. And unless you've gone over the the I guess usually it's an NOAA ten year average for the area, you don't get a time extension there. so it read your contract. Like it is e everybody needs to know your contract.
MIchael Bograd: final thoughts on this, you know, with total float is you know, float isn't yours versus the float being a shared commodity. you know, curveball for me, you know, I always enjoy good lessons learned. So thank you for that insight on you know the Caltrans experience. You think is this pretty common in you know, is Caltrans typically do public private partnerships?
Brook Bolger: well so Caltrans, it's they're usually doing CMGC or bid build, but in in on projects where there's very dynamic constructibility constructibility methods, things where you can come in and really get creative. this is pretty common. but like you know, on like a hospital or a vertical building, it's not too common. You're gonna start at the bottom, you're gonna work your way up. there's not too many ways to accelerate these things other than throwing money at it or, you know, getting creative in other ways. So, yeah, th it's it's it's common in in civil construction.
MIchael Bograd: And it sounds like your final takeaway for everyone is read your contract, understand your contract, know what's in there.
Brook Bolger: Yes. Yeah, exactly.
MIchael Bograd: there. So one of the nice things that Pedro does is he provides us with a list of prompts. and maybe you'll have to translate this for us, broke. what it says float isn't free. Can you explain what that means?
Brook Bolger: Yeah, so total float it isn't free. So when you're talking about the contractual relationship between an owner and general contractor, is the project gonna be late or not? right that deals with liquidated damages, generally on the gener j general contractor side, contractual obligations on the general contractor side. but quite often the owner has like a revenue stream or a a I assume they need the building for some reason that they're the asset that they're building for some reason. So from a project delivery standpoint, float's very important. But from a trade standpoint, if you're doing any self-perform work or your trade partner, somebody that's carrying a lot of labor risk, float isn't free. if you if you take up total float of one of your subcontractors and all of a sudden they have a crane sitting around longer than they thought they would, their their contract price increases, their overhead prices increase. if you stack trades. For instance, you have somebody building five retaining walls and instead of doing one after the other, if they have to now do two retaining walls at a time, their their rental cost for forms goes up or you know they have to purchase more forms or more material that they can't cycle. perhaps you build in a more efficient manner instead of moving dirt from one area to another, you have to stockpile dirt. So consuming float excuse me, consuming float doesn't, you know, usually it it means that you're not going to incur liquidated damages or charge liquidated damages, but it doesn't mean that you shouldn't expect a change order from anybody that has labor risk associated with shifting your plan.
MIchael Bograd: Sounds even yeah, I that that's very insightful. take it even a step further. The the amount of planning and coordination has to be even more represented on these jobs. You know, if you if do the GC decides to shift one contractor or or subcontractor to a six-day calendar or a second shift, it almost feels like everyone has to be lockstep with that because you have to keep with that same pace again if if you're you are working towards the same goal.
Brook Bolger: Yeah, absolutely. So I mean, let's just use a specific example. let's just say you have a large campus that has an enormous building and it's a three year schedule and there's a guardhouse that's associated with this, and the guard house only has a six month build time. If you issue your schedule a bid that you're gonna build that guard house in months one to six of this thirty six month schedule, you're gonna get a certain amount of pricing. But if you delay that two and a half years to let's say months months thirty to thirty six, you can expect change orders, material escalation, union labor agreements escalation. So again, the the float just means you're finishing on time, but you know, you you you can expect change orders from any s any any subcontractors that that you have engaged on that project.
MIchael Bograd: Example. Appreciate that.