TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:03.390 --> 00:00:16.010
You're listening to Why We Do What We Do. Welcome
2
00:00:16.070 --> 00:00:19.030
to Why We Do What We Do. I am your
3
00:00:19.149 --> 00:00:21.570
budding behaviorist host, Abraham.
4
00:00:22.160 --> 00:00:24.399
And I am your key pecking host, Shane.
5
00:00:24.420 --> 00:00:29.269
That was a good one. We are a psychology podcast.
6
00:00:29.289 --> 00:00:33.030
We talk about the things that humans and non-human animals do.
7
00:00:33.750 --> 00:00:38.350
And in our twilight time together as a show, we're
8
00:00:38.409 --> 00:00:42.590
going to talk about one of the people who made
9
00:00:42.609 --> 00:00:46.420
a show like this possible in a way. We're going
10
00:00:46.479 --> 00:00:49.119
to be talking about BF Skinner. And this is actually
11
00:00:49.140 --> 00:00:51.880
going to be a little suite of episodes that we're
12
00:00:51.920 --> 00:00:54.600
going to do. And that'll actually be, this is kind
13
00:00:54.619 --> 00:00:56.619
of our swan song, if you will. This is how
14
00:00:56.649 --> 00:00:59.750
we're going to close things out for the next few episodes.
15
00:00:59.829 --> 00:01:02.329
So excited to have everyone here.
16
00:01:02.810 --> 00:01:05.030
Yeah, I'm really excited to get into this because this
17
00:01:05.090 --> 00:01:07.290
is this feels like a full circle moment, right? Like
18
00:01:07.590 --> 00:01:11.140
the show started because we're behaviorists. It ends with arguably
19
00:01:11.189 --> 00:01:14.280
one of the most, if not the most influential behaviorist
20
00:01:14.739 --> 00:01:16.599
of our field. And I think it's kind of nice
21
00:01:16.620 --> 00:01:18.040
to kind of like bring it all back to like
22
00:01:18.060 --> 00:01:18.840
where it started, you know?
23
00:01:19.299 --> 00:01:20.079
Yeah, absolutely.
24
00:01:20.200 --> 00:01:20.579
Started-ish.
25
00:01:20.719 --> 00:01:25.219
Started-ish, exactly. So if you're joining us for the first time,
26
00:01:25.260 --> 00:01:27.870
then welcome. We hope that you enjoy in this discussion.
27
00:01:27.890 --> 00:01:30.390
If you're a returning person, then welcome back. Thank you
28
00:01:30.409 --> 00:01:32.870
for continuing to seek us out. And either way, if
29
00:01:33.629 --> 00:01:35.189
you'd like to support us, you can leave us a
30
00:01:35.209 --> 00:01:38.000
rating and a review, like, subscribe, tell a friend, join
31
00:01:38.019 --> 00:01:40.959
us on Patreon for the next few episodes, or... And
32
00:01:41.040 --> 00:01:42.799
other things. I'll talk more about that at the end
33
00:01:42.980 --> 00:01:46.609
of this discussion. This episode comes out on November 4th.
34
00:01:46.750 --> 00:01:50.569
So happy International Stress Awareness Day. Yes.
35
00:01:51.129 --> 00:01:53.849
Also, happy King Tut Day. I think of that SNL
36
00:01:53.870 --> 00:01:58.000
skit where Steve Martin sang King Tut and he like
37
00:01:58.019 --> 00:01:59.840
danced the song. It was great.
38
00:02:00.439 --> 00:02:02.670
Nice. Is King Tut the one who was just a
39
00:02:02.709 --> 00:02:03.489
kid when he died?
40
00:02:03.510 --> 00:02:07.280
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And he was a child of incest
41
00:02:07.340 --> 00:02:09.900
as well, which is pretty, I guess, common for royalty.
42
00:02:09.960 --> 00:02:13.219
But I believe they think he had a club foot,
43
00:02:13.699 --> 00:02:15.560
like one of those types of situations. He had a
44
00:02:15.659 --> 00:02:16.580
limb difference. Oedipus.
45
00:02:16.840 --> 00:02:20.759
Yeah. Sorry, enough for that, for this holiday. National Block
46
00:02:20.819 --> 00:02:23.330
It Out Day is also the day that it is.
47
00:02:23.849 --> 00:02:26.110
Yes, it is. It's also National Candy Day.
48
00:02:26.780 --> 00:02:28.400
I guess that makes sense. I mean, we're just past
49
00:02:28.419 --> 00:02:31.189
Halloween at this point, so maybe people are just still
50
00:02:31.210 --> 00:02:34.490
living on that as their main source of caloric intake. Yeah.
51
00:02:34.669 --> 00:02:34.949
Who knows?
52
00:02:35.629 --> 00:02:39.550
It's National Easy-Bake Oven Day. Oh, what an interesting idea
53
00:02:39.610 --> 00:02:41.990
that was. I feel like maybe that even deserves a mini.
54
00:02:42.849 --> 00:02:48.520
Yeah. Also, how dangerous. It is National Eating Healthy Day,
55
00:02:48.560 --> 00:02:49.639
speaking of easy-bake ovens.
56
00:02:51.280 --> 00:02:53.699
Very good. Well, I'm not sure I believe in all
57
00:02:53.719 --> 00:02:57.599
that because it is National Skeptics Day. So that's like
58
00:02:57.740 --> 00:02:58.479
our day, baby.
59
00:02:58.919 --> 00:03:01.219
That's our day. That's the whole premise of the show.
60
00:03:01.819 --> 00:03:02.099
Yeah.
61
00:03:02.250 --> 00:03:05.050
It is also National Waiting for the Barbarians Day.
62
00:03:05.069 --> 00:03:07.879
Oh, waiting is over. They've been here the last couple
63
00:03:07.900 --> 00:03:08.240
of years.
64
00:03:08.340 --> 00:03:09.120
They got voted in.
65
00:03:09.719 --> 00:03:13.370
Yeah, they voted in. It is Use Your Common Sense Day.
66
00:03:13.530 --> 00:03:16.629
And given that Election Day, I think, was yesterday, I
67
00:03:16.650 --> 00:03:18.449
feel like that maybe should have been Use Your Common
68
00:03:18.490 --> 00:03:21.939
Sense Day, but Common Sense Day hangover.
69
00:03:21.960 --> 00:03:26.439
Yes, yes, yes, yes. It is Drowsy Driving Prevention Week.
70
00:03:26.659 --> 00:03:27.240
I love that.
71
00:03:27.599 --> 00:03:33.870
Definitely seems important. Give wildlife a break, B-R-A-K-E. Week means
72
00:03:33.879 --> 00:03:36.669
stop and don't hit them with your car or other vehicle.
73
00:03:36.689 --> 00:03:40.129
Yeah, save the turtles. It is National Allied Health Week.
74
00:03:41.050 --> 00:03:43.289
Save the turtles is so applicable to like one tiny,
75
00:03:43.370 --> 00:03:44.430
tiny part of this country.
76
00:03:45.069 --> 00:03:45.870
Yes, that's true.
77
00:03:46.610 --> 00:03:47.669
Road safety
Load full transcript
goes.
78
00:03:47.710 --> 00:03:50.069
There are so many turtles on our roads here. It's crazy.
79
00:03:50.129 --> 00:03:54.569
So save the deer. Yes. It's most of them.
80
00:03:55.090 --> 00:04:00.199
Yeah, that's true. Sorry. Did you do the next one? Okay. Well,
81
00:04:00.740 --> 00:04:04.259
it is national animal shelter and rescue appreciation week. So
82
00:04:04.500 --> 00:04:05.919
that's awesome. And very good.
83
00:04:06.400 --> 00:04:08.500
It is very good. It's also a national cat week.
84
00:04:09.250 --> 00:04:10.789
I love all the animal stuff going on right now.
85
00:04:10.990 --> 00:04:11.349
Very good.
86
00:04:11.650 --> 00:04:11.990
Yeah.
87
00:04:13.050 --> 00:04:16.490
Awesome. And as we mentioned, yesterday was election day. Hopefully
88
00:04:16.529 --> 00:04:19.480
that went well. Uh, you were recording this in the past.
89
00:04:19.569 --> 00:04:23.560
So you people of the future know I tentatively optimistic
90
00:04:23.600 --> 00:04:27.480
having seen where polls were going recently. So maybe I'm
91
00:04:27.500 --> 00:04:30.240
sad right now. Maybe, maybe I'm happy. Maybe you are too.
92
00:04:30.339 --> 00:04:33.160
Who knows? But, uh, I'm hoping that it went well.
93
00:04:33.600 --> 00:04:36.180
I'm tentatively optimistic that it did. But we're not here
94
00:04:36.199 --> 00:04:38.560
to talk about a recap of the election, partially because
95
00:04:38.610 --> 00:04:41.110
we don't know what happens during that election, but also
96
00:04:41.129 --> 00:04:44.089
because we're here to talk about something else because we're
97
00:04:44.110 --> 00:04:46.949
a psychology podcast. I think we're ready to get into it.
98
00:04:47.009 --> 00:04:48.910
Anything that a mystery you'd like to add before we start?
99
00:04:49.470 --> 00:04:50.790
No, I think we're ready to go.
100
00:04:51.290 --> 00:04:54.269
All right. So we received our graduate training and our
101
00:04:54.310 --> 00:04:57.769
professional training in the science that largely developed out of
102
00:04:57.810 --> 00:05:02.560
the pioneering work done by B.F. Skinner. Never in the
103
00:05:02.639 --> 00:05:04.819
time that we have been doing this show have we
104
00:05:04.980 --> 00:05:08.629
actually spent a lot of time actually talking about Skinner.
105
00:05:08.670 --> 00:05:11.870
He's come up periodically, right? But we've never done like
106
00:05:11.910 --> 00:05:15.740
a very deep dive into anything Skinner related. And so
107
00:05:15.759 --> 00:05:18.379
kind of seemed like it was about time.
108
00:05:19.139 --> 00:05:21.540
Yeah, so if you're not into behavior analysis, you're not
109
00:05:21.600 --> 00:05:24.050
working in that field, you might remember the name Skinner
110
00:05:24.060 --> 00:05:29.149
in association with pigeons, piloting missiles, operant quote-unquote reward-based learning
111
00:05:29.170 --> 00:05:32.050
and psychology, his work with lab rats, and specifically the
112
00:05:32.129 --> 00:05:34.689
Skinner box, you might have heard that term, the incorrect
113
00:05:34.769 --> 00:05:36.970
rumor that he raised his child in a Skinner box,
114
00:05:37.470 --> 00:05:41.610
or a misassociation with the Little Albert Experiment or Pavlov's dogs.
115
00:05:42.370 --> 00:05:44.589
Yes, or maybe you never heard of Skinner at all,
116
00:05:44.810 --> 00:05:49.060
or maybe you are very much in the know Whatever.
117
00:05:49.199 --> 00:05:52.170
Glad you're here. Hopefully you'll be able to learn something
118
00:05:52.199 --> 00:05:54.129
in this. I actually learned quite a few things that
119
00:05:54.170 --> 00:05:57.649
I didn't know about Skinner going into putting these notes together.
120
00:05:58.129 --> 00:06:01.529
But as we're sort of entering this suite of episodes
121
00:06:01.569 --> 00:06:04.629
and you're maybe wondering, why are you spending so much
122
00:06:04.670 --> 00:06:07.089
time talking about Skinner? As I said, for one thing,
123
00:06:07.589 --> 00:06:10.509
the science and philosophy that he developed laid the groundwork
124
00:06:10.589 --> 00:06:13.660
for the careers that we now have. Yeah. And so
125
00:06:13.720 --> 00:06:16.839
there's something to be said about that contribution. Definitely. But
126
00:06:16.860 --> 00:06:18.959
I also do want to point out that we are
127
00:06:19.060 --> 00:06:21.000
not worshipful of Skinner.
128
00:06:21.199 --> 00:06:21.430
Right.
129
00:06:21.470 --> 00:06:24.870
Skinner is not a god. He is not infallible. He
130
00:06:24.949 --> 00:06:27.759
is not our leader or our saint. We don't worship anyone.
131
00:06:28.769 --> 00:06:31.829
But he was a very important figure in the development
132
00:06:31.910 --> 00:06:33.629
of the philosophy of the science in which we earned
133
00:06:33.680 --> 00:06:36.540
our degrees and in which we make our living and
134
00:06:36.579 --> 00:06:39.420
has informed sort of a lot of the ideas and
135
00:06:39.500 --> 00:06:42.560
beliefs that we have. It is shaped like that philosophy
136
00:06:42.660 --> 00:06:44.959
has shaped our approach to the topics that we bring
137
00:06:45.060 --> 00:06:47.220
up and discuss in this podcast.
138
00:06:47.860 --> 00:06:48.019
So.
139
00:06:49.160 --> 00:06:51.220
It felt like it was worth spending a little time
140
00:06:51.240 --> 00:06:55.709
to pay homage to where we came from and sort
141
00:06:55.750 --> 00:06:57.930
of how we got here, if you will, or why
142
00:06:57.990 --> 00:06:58.769
we do what we do.
143
00:06:59.410 --> 00:07:02.350
Yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly. So the next few episodes in
144
00:07:02.389 --> 00:07:05.680
our final series of episodes... We were to discuss various
145
00:07:05.759 --> 00:07:08.439
aspects of BF Skinner, his life, his work, his philosophy,
146
00:07:08.459 --> 00:07:10.720
his inventions, his books. I mean, we were to talk
147
00:07:10.740 --> 00:07:13.759
about so much about him in, like you mentioned, in
148
00:07:13.779 --> 00:07:15.600
the hopes of like, there's probably
going to be stuff
149
00:07:15.620 --> 00:07:17.720
in here that, you know, if you're in behavior analysis,
150
00:07:17.980 --> 00:07:19.730
there may be some stuff that you learn because we're
151
00:07:19.759 --> 00:07:21.910
learning stuff as we go through this too. And I
152
00:07:21.930 --> 00:07:23.589
think it's kind of fun to deep dive on somebody
153
00:07:23.629 --> 00:07:26.110
who is as influential as he is. So I think
154
00:07:26.129 --> 00:07:27.310
we're going to have a good time with this one.
155
00:07:27.750 --> 00:07:28.819
Yeah. I'm looking forward to it.
156
00:07:29.129 --> 00:07:30.310
Can't wait to talk about corn pudding.
157
00:07:30.329 --> 00:07:33.870
Yeah. So this first discussion is largely going to be
158
00:07:33.889 --> 00:07:36.560
just about his life. We're going to just walk through
159
00:07:36.680 --> 00:07:40.079
Skinner's whole sort of timeline. It's going to be obviously
160
00:07:40.259 --> 00:07:43.800
truncated from the perspective of detailing minute by minute everything
161
00:07:43.839 --> 00:07:45.819
that happened to him. Also, I don't know what happened
162
00:07:45.839 --> 00:07:47.699
to him minute by minute. And I don't think it
163
00:07:47.740 --> 00:07:50.319
would make for a great podcast episode, but we're going
164
00:07:50.339 --> 00:07:53.800
to hit like sort of the major highlights, the important moments,
165
00:07:53.860 --> 00:07:56.279
the things that sort of shaped him into the person
166
00:07:56.319 --> 00:07:59.810
he became and whatnot. So this first discussion, we're just
167
00:07:59.829 --> 00:08:02.209
going to talk about the life of the man. And
168
00:08:02.649 --> 00:08:06.750
then later we'll be taking on more specific topics related
169
00:08:06.810 --> 00:08:09.529
to him, things that he wrote and invented, as you
170
00:08:09.569 --> 00:08:11.990
already said, all that. So yeah, let's go ahead and
171
00:08:12.009 --> 00:08:15.379
dive into this then. Yes. The fun fact of the episode,
172
00:08:15.439 --> 00:08:20.040
revealing right at the top of this discussion, starts with, well,
173
00:08:20.160 --> 00:08:23.939
it's BF Skinner, but what does the BF stand for?
174
00:08:24.639 --> 00:08:27.449
And why did he go by initials instead of his
175
00:08:27.509 --> 00:08:30.670
first name? Again, many of you who are trained in
176
00:08:30.709 --> 00:08:34.009
the field know this already, but his full name was Burrus,
177
00:08:34.629 --> 00:08:41.820
spelled B-U-R-R-H-U-S, Burhus or Burrus, Frederick Skinner. So that's the BF,
178
00:08:41.960 --> 00:08:46.690
Burris Frederick BF Skinner. His friends called him Fred, but yeah,
179
00:08:46.750 --> 00:08:50.590
his first name was Burris. So he writes that Burris
180
00:08:50.610 --> 00:08:55.009
was his mother's maiden name and was, quote, always troublesome
181
00:08:55.210 --> 00:08:59.950
and must be spelled out and explained, end quote. Which
182
00:09:00.009 --> 00:09:03.970
I think is a very humble way of saying that
183
00:09:04.090 --> 00:09:07.590
he hated it and just didn't want to use it anymore.
184
00:09:07.659 --> 00:09:11.990
So mostly went by Fred, otherwise went by BF. Yeah. Yeah.
185
00:09:12.330 --> 00:09:15.129
So he was born on March 20th, 1904, the first
186
00:09:15.149 --> 00:09:19.129
of two boys in Susquehanna, which by the way, if
187
00:09:19.169 --> 00:09:21.360
you ever spend any time in New England, there are
188
00:09:21.379 --> 00:09:24.340
a lot of words that do not sound the way
189
00:09:24.379 --> 00:09:27.259
they are spelled for lots of reasons. Worcester is one
190
00:09:27.299 --> 00:09:28.600
example in Massachusetts.
191
00:09:28.620 --> 00:09:29.679
Oh, that's very true.
192
00:09:29.740 --> 00:09:31.840
I think there's something really interesting about this because there
193
00:09:31.940 --> 00:09:34.179
is so much, like, indigenous language inside of some of
194
00:09:34.200 --> 00:09:37.080
the cities and places there, too. So, like, and enunciation
195
00:09:37.100 --> 00:09:40.299
and all that's different. Now, this is in Pennsylvania, and
196
00:09:40.330 --> 00:09:43.509
he was born to William Arthur Skinner, a lawyer and
197
00:09:43.549 --> 00:09:48.509
a first-generation American on his father's side, and Grace Madge Skinner, nay, Burris.
198
00:09:49.019 --> 00:09:52.860
making Skinner a second-generation American on his father's side. Susquehanna
199
00:09:53.000 --> 00:09:55.789
is a small railroad town, which as of 2020 had
200
00:09:55.809 --> 00:09:57.370
a population of 1,365 people. So you can imagine how
201
00:10:00.340 --> 00:10:03.860
large it might've been in 1904. And that is not very.
202
00:10:04.220 --> 00:10:06.720
Yeah. Small little town. And he grew up there, but
203
00:10:06.799 --> 00:10:10.440
aside from losing his younger brother at the age of 16,
204
00:10:10.440 --> 00:10:14.669
his brother was 16 who passed away from a cerebral hemorrhage.
205
00:10:15.169 --> 00:10:17.929
Skinner actually mostly described his early life growing up in
206
00:10:17.950 --> 00:10:20.950
Susquehanna as warm and stable. Yeah.
207
00:10:21.029 --> 00:10:23.149
From an early age, Burris, I don't know. Should we
208
00:10:23.190 --> 00:10:25.340
call him Skinner? I don't know. Can we decide on
209
00:10:25.649 --> 00:10:27.200
maybe a format for that? Do we want to go
210
00:10:27.220 --> 00:10:28.620
with Skinner or do we want to go with Burris
211
00:10:28.659 --> 00:10:30.379
or Fred? I mean, we're not friends with him, so
212
00:10:30.419 --> 00:10:32.159
we couldn't call him Fred.
213
00:10:33.240 --> 00:10:36.120
Mostly throughout this, I think I refer to him as Skinner.
214
00:10:36.360 --> 00:10:38.159
I don't know. I think if we go back and forth,
215
00:10:38.230 --> 00:10:41.389
it's okay. We're obviously only talking about primarily one person here.
216
00:10:41.769 --> 00:10:42.429
He's a focal point.
217
00:10:43.120 --> 00:10:46.480
Yeah, either Burris or Skinner, or if we're
feeling nasty, Fred.
218
00:10:46.659 --> 00:10:49.600
We're feeling nasty. Yeah, we're going to be, yeah. No,
219
00:10:49.820 --> 00:10:52.139
I feel like Skinner makes sense. So Skinner was, from
220
00:10:52.159 --> 00:10:54.120
an early age, he was inventing and building things. So
221
00:10:54.539 --> 00:10:57.129
a cart that accidentally had a steering wheel that worked backwards.
222
00:10:57.509 --> 00:11:00.730
He built a perpetual motion machine, which didn't work because
223
00:11:00.750 --> 00:11:03.490
they break the laws of physics and are impossible. He
224
00:11:03.509 --> 00:11:05.710
and his friends built a cabin in the woods. They
225
00:11:05.750 --> 00:11:09.429
picked elderberries and built a flotation system to separate ripe
226
00:11:09.450 --> 00:11:12.840
berries from green berries. They went around selling elderberries door
227
00:11:12.860 --> 00:11:16.360
to door. And while working at a shoe store while
228
00:11:16.399 --> 00:11:19.240
in high school, he built a contraption, which I think
229
00:11:19.279 --> 00:11:22.279
that contraption feels like a very perfect word for Skinner.
230
00:11:22.700 --> 00:11:25.250
He built a lot of contraptions, but built a contraption
231
00:11:25.259 --> 00:11:28.289
to distribute green dust, quote unquote green dust, that helped
232
00:11:28.409 --> 00:11:30.669
a broom pick up dirt while sweeping.
233
00:11:31.009 --> 00:11:41.600
They're still doing ads for that today. All right, we're back.
234
00:11:41.860 --> 00:11:46.009
We've been describing a lot of Skinner's early life and
235
00:11:46.070 --> 00:11:49.490
that he was quite the inventor as he was growing up.
236
00:11:50.269 --> 00:11:53.149
Parents seemed pretty supportive of this, that they were happy
237
00:11:53.169 --> 00:11:55.470
to let him sort of do his thing and make
238
00:11:55.529 --> 00:11:59.350
mistakes and learn from those mistakes. I got that it
239
00:11:59.409 --> 00:12:02.629
was not a super religious household that he grew up in.
240
00:12:02.909 --> 00:12:05.940
And he noted that he didn't know that his parents,
241
00:12:06.100 --> 00:12:09.179
his grandparents at least were religious, except for one time
242
00:12:09.200 --> 00:12:12.980
hearing them exclaim something about someone not believing in Jesus
243
00:12:13.000 --> 00:12:14.460
Christ or something of that nature.
244
00:12:14.950 --> 00:12:15.190
Sure.
245
00:12:15.389 --> 00:12:17.350
But anyway, so it seemed like he kind of grew
246
00:12:17.409 --> 00:12:21.789
up in a, it wasn't like anti-religious, but maybe more
247
00:12:22.009 --> 00:12:24.429
on the secular end type of households.
248
00:12:24.789 --> 00:12:25.049
Sure.
249
00:12:25.169 --> 00:12:27.139
Maybe it was those things where they like say, I
250
00:12:27.179 --> 00:12:30.200
pray for you and God bless you and that sort
251
00:12:30.220 --> 00:12:33.600
of thing. But that was not a particularly significant part
252
00:12:33.620 --> 00:12:34.500
of their time growing up.
253
00:12:34.779 --> 00:12:34.960
Yeah.
254
00:12:35.240 --> 00:12:37.039
And it would kind of make sense to me that
255
00:12:37.059 --> 00:12:40.059
that was the case because he was very much a
256
00:12:40.179 --> 00:12:43.519
lover of literature. He loved to read. He read a lot.
257
00:12:43.580 --> 00:12:47.309
He quoted books a lot. When he was told that
258
00:12:47.330 --> 00:12:50.490
he was wrong about something, he went and researched that thing. Specifically,
259
00:12:50.529 --> 00:12:56.269
at one point, someone misquoted, I think it was Shakespeare,
260
00:12:56.389 --> 00:12:59.539
and they quoted Francis Bacon. And then Skinner was like,
261
00:12:59.580 --> 00:13:00.799
that's not right. And they're like, you don't know what
262
00:13:00.820 --> 00:13:03.299
you're talking about. So he's like, went and read everything
263
00:13:03.360 --> 00:13:06.000
by that person, by Francis Bacon. So he kind of
264
00:13:06.019 --> 00:13:09.259
became his own little mini scholar of Francis Bacon. Yeah.
265
00:13:09.399 --> 00:13:12.330
So while he was attending Hamilton College in New York...
266
00:13:12.509 --> 00:13:15.210
he decided he wanted to be a writer because he
267
00:13:15.610 --> 00:13:18.750
loved literature, he wanted to write. However, upon embarking on
268
00:13:18.789 --> 00:13:21.570
his writing career, he wrote very little, just a handful
269
00:13:21.590 --> 00:13:24.529
of things here and there, some articles, et cetera, like
270
00:13:24.590 --> 00:13:28.440
newspaper articles, yeah. But he did stumble upon books by
271
00:13:28.519 --> 00:13:32.840
John Watson and Ivan Pavlov while working in a bookstore
272
00:13:33.299 --> 00:13:36.519
and was intrigued by their writing and very eager to
273
00:13:36.559 --> 00:13:39.059
learn more about what they were doing. And so that
274
00:13:39.120 --> 00:13:40.940
sort of set him on a new path when he
275
00:13:40.980 --> 00:13:41.620
discovered those.
276
00:13:42.299 --> 00:13:45.490
Yeah. So at the age of 24, Skinner enrolled in
277
00:13:45.549 --> 00:13:49.570
psychology at Harvard University and found a like-minded mentor in
278
00:13:49.710 --> 00:13:53.370
William Kosher, who was the chair of the new physiology department.
279
00:13:53.809 --> 00:13:58.330
Kosher was considered a bit rebellious, which I think a
280
00:13:58.370 --> 00:14:00.830
lot of psychologists at the time, the really fun ones,
281
00:14:00.850 --> 00:14:02.350
were a little bit rebellious. You know what I'm saying?
282
00:14:02.870 --> 00:14:06.009
And believed in studying the, quote, whole organism, believed in
283
00:14:06.029 --> 00:14:08.309
studying the whole organism instead of focusing on and placing
284
00:14:08.350 --> 00:14:11.350
exclusive importance on individual components. He was happy to let
285
00:14:11.370 --> 00:14:13.429
students experiment and follow their hunches.
286
00:14:14.120 --> 00:14:16.039
So he granted his students a lot of freedom and
287
00:14:16.080 -->
00:14:19.500
he really encouraged them to pursue their curiosities and to
288
00:14:19.539 --> 00:14:22.159
just kind of like experiment with stuff and see what happened.
289
00:14:22.720 --> 00:14:27.799
And with this freedom, Skinner started building contraptions, apparati, if
290
00:14:27.850 --> 00:14:31.289
you will, to experiment with rats. He built some mazes.
291
00:14:31.350 --> 00:14:35.129
He also apparently constructed several things to use for his
292
00:14:35.210 --> 00:14:38.759
various experiments and And through what he later described as
293
00:14:38.840 --> 00:14:44.190
happy accidents, he developed a device to specifically record and
294
00:14:44.250 --> 00:14:47.370
measure whenever a rat pressed a lever. And he wanted
295
00:14:47.389 --> 00:14:52.250
to have an ongoing record, if you will, of every
296
00:14:52.309 --> 00:14:55.100
lever press so that he could look at patterns in
297
00:14:55.120 --> 00:14:55.480
the data.
298
00:14:55.909 --> 00:14:59.740
Yeah, the device continually fed paper through like kind of
299
00:14:59.759 --> 00:15:02.820
like this, this whole contraption at a constant rate. And
300
00:15:02.879 --> 00:15:05.179
every time the animal pressed the trigger or lever or
301
00:15:05.240 --> 00:15:07.639
button or whatever it was, a little needle with ink
302
00:15:07.879 --> 00:15:11.029
that rested against the moving paper would tick upward and
303
00:15:11.049 --> 00:15:14.649
the apparatus gradually moved across the paper, specifically the paper feed.
304
00:15:14.990 --> 00:15:18.730
with every response from the animal recording their total responses.
305
00:15:19.009 --> 00:15:22.570
And Skinner called this the cumulative recorder. And we'll talk
306
00:15:22.610 --> 00:15:24.490
more about this in a different episode. I have seen
307
00:15:24.610 --> 00:15:28.129
one of the original cumulative recorders, and it's really cool
308
00:15:28.169 --> 00:15:30.240
to see. It's really like, you're just kind of like,
309
00:15:30.639 --> 00:15:33.220
this is just an interesting device that exists in the world.
310
00:15:33.580 --> 00:15:34.500
And super impactful.
311
00:15:35.100 --> 00:15:37.980
If you were to imagine sort of the old timey
312
00:15:38.080 --> 00:15:40.879
look of a polygraph machine with those needles that like
313
00:15:40.919 --> 00:15:43.259
go back and forth, it kind of looks like that,
314
00:15:43.299 --> 00:15:45.500
except for instead of the needles going back and forth,
315
00:15:45.519 --> 00:15:47.759
they only move one way across the page until they
316
00:15:47.820 --> 00:15:49.659
reach the far end. Then they go all the way
317
00:15:49.700 --> 00:15:52.539
back really quickly and start over. But it's same basic
318
00:15:52.580 --> 00:15:54.679
setup of like a sort of feeding paper through at
319
00:15:54.720 --> 00:15:56.899
this constant rate and then would move every time there's
320
00:15:56.919 --> 00:15:59.549
a response. And that allowed to see sort of changes
321
00:15:59.610 --> 00:16:01.809
in the rate of the response because the paper moved
322
00:16:01.830 --> 00:16:03.889
at a constant rate, the needle ticked at the constant rate.
323
00:16:04.389 --> 00:16:06.549
with respect to presses at least, it moved a consistent amount.
324
00:16:06.970 --> 00:16:10.840
So with every press, you would get essentially a pattern
325
00:16:11.000 --> 00:16:13.220
in the data that would show these really clear curves
326
00:16:13.240 --> 00:16:17.090
that either sloped or slanted in particular directions, and then
327
00:16:17.129 --> 00:16:20.159
that would That would depict something really interesting about the
328
00:16:20.200 --> 00:16:23.889
pattern of their behavior. Right. And through these experiments, he
329
00:16:23.929 --> 00:16:27.250
discovered that the behavior as animals shifted and responded to
330
00:16:27.269 --> 00:16:31.809
not just in relation to the preceding stimulus. Because this
331
00:16:31.850 --> 00:16:35.889
was the idea essentially hypothesized and described by Pavlov and
332
00:16:35.929 --> 00:16:38.590
Watson was this idea of reflexes. where you had, there
333
00:16:38.610 --> 00:16:42.240
was an onset of some kind of triggering event. And
334
00:16:42.250 --> 00:16:45.080
then following that event, you would have the organism's behavior
335
00:16:45.500 --> 00:16:49.940
that followed. And that was called SR psychology for stimulus response,
336
00:16:50.399 --> 00:16:54.220
because that was this new way of thinking about behavior
337
00:16:54.320 --> 00:16:57.320
was this like, well, you have, rather than it being,
338
00:16:57.340 --> 00:17:00.100
there's all these internal states and these internal things are
339
00:17:00.120 --> 00:17:03.480
what caused behavior to happen. you have an external stimulus
340
00:17:03.720 --> 00:17:07.220
and a behavior that follows. And that does a really
341
00:17:07.259 --> 00:17:10.000
good job describing a lot of how and why behavior happens.
342
00:17:10.299 --> 00:17:13.160
But Skinner then saw something else that was that as
343
00:17:13.200 --> 00:17:16.460
they received food pellets following their lever pressing, their rates
344
00:17:16.500 --> 00:17:21.309
of behavior changed according to very reliable patterns, where the
345
00:17:21.509 --> 00:17:24.890
thing that preceded the lever press was not as predictive
346
00:17:24.970 --> 00:17:28.309
of what their behavior would be, But the consequence that
347
00:17:28.549 --> 00:17:31.490
followed the lever press, them receiving these food pellets, all
348
00:17:31.509 --> 00:17:33.950
of a sudden became very predictive of, and you would
349
00:17:33.970 --> 00:17:38.730
be able to see these very clear, reliably reproducible patterns
350
00:17:38.839 --> 00:17:44.480
in the data that adhered to these schedules of reinforcement,
351
00:17:44.559 --> 00:17:47.480
which were how often and under what conditions those food
352
00:17:47.559 --> 00:17:51.140
pellets were delivered. So, If
they were, for example, delivered
353
00:17:51.180 --> 00:17:53.619
every single response, you'd see a very reliable pattern happen.
354
00:17:54.240 --> 00:17:57.140
If they only happened after so many responses, but on
355
00:17:57.180 --> 00:18:00.240
a fixed rate, then you would see very specific behavior
356
00:18:00.279 --> 00:18:03.849
happen where you'd essentially have a constant sort of low
357
00:18:04.390 --> 00:18:08.490
lever pressing. Yeah. If they happened at intervals, you would
358
00:18:08.529 --> 00:18:11.329
see a very reliable pattern happening where they wouldn't respond.
359
00:18:11.369 --> 00:18:12.839
And as it got closer to the end of the interval,
360
00:18:12.859 --> 00:18:17.930
they'd start responding a ton. If it happened... completely unpredictably,
361
00:18:18.190 --> 00:18:21.380
then you'd see these super high rates of continuous responding.
362
00:18:21.700 --> 00:18:24.559
So anyway, the point being that he could produce these
363
00:18:24.640 --> 00:18:29.200
patterns based on the consequence that followed the behavior and
364
00:18:29.240 --> 00:18:32.380
do so very reliably. And that was a big discovery.
365
00:18:32.890 --> 00:18:36.509
Huge, huge. So through his observations, he started synthesizing a
366
00:18:36.549 --> 00:18:38.910
theory to describe the massive amounts of data that he
367
00:18:38.950 --> 00:18:42.990
was collecting. Thus was born the theory of reinforcement. And
368
00:18:43.230 --> 00:18:46.819
essentially that what happens immediately after behavior could increase or
369
00:18:46.900 --> 00:18:51.160
decrease the likelihood that behavior would occur again. So this
370
00:18:51.240 --> 00:18:54.569
is not something that is new in terms of human
371
00:18:54.670 --> 00:18:59.789
history in that clearly reinforcement has happened since organisms have existed, right? Like,
372
00:19:00.269 --> 00:19:02.960
That is essentially, by its very nature, the reason why
373
00:19:03.000 --> 00:19:07.349
we still exist. But he finally discovered these patterns in
374
00:19:07.380 --> 00:19:09.609
a way, or could at least describe these patterns in
375
00:19:09.650 --> 00:19:12.309
a way that were more systematic and give it more
376
00:19:12.369 --> 00:19:13.390
language than we had before.
377
00:19:14.900 --> 00:19:18.390
Yeah, he was able to synthesize these observations into a
378
00:19:18.450 --> 00:19:24.390
description that really facilitated research to move forward in a
379
00:19:24.549 --> 00:19:28.069
much faster and productive way. Because you're absolutely right. Yeah,
380
00:19:28.109 --> 00:19:31.619
like without reinforcement, like we would have never evolved to
381
00:19:31.660 --> 00:19:35.390
this point. No organism would have. And so it's not
382
00:19:35.450 --> 00:19:41.240
like he didn't invent reinforcement. He uncovered this process as
383
00:19:41.420 --> 00:19:45.480
part of how behavior at all is shaped and develops. Right.
384
00:19:45.539 --> 00:19:48.329
But that was, again, a big discovery because although people
385
00:19:48.390 --> 00:19:51.160
had had like a vague understanding. about this in the past,
386
00:19:51.579 --> 00:19:55.109
no one had ever cobbled together something so comprehensive and cohesive.
387
00:19:55.509 --> 00:19:58.130
in a description as what he had done. Right. And
388
00:19:58.190 --> 00:20:00.670
there were many people who didn't even necessarily believe that
389
00:20:00.690 --> 00:20:03.190
this was, it played that important of a role or
390
00:20:03.230 --> 00:20:04.930
believed it didn't play a role at all. Like there
391
00:20:04.970 --> 00:20:06.369
was definitely people who thought that too.
392
00:20:06.650 --> 00:20:06.829
Right.
393
00:20:06.869 --> 00:20:11.880
So this helped cement that. In fact, it did. He
394
00:20:11.920 --> 00:20:14.640
was correct. Yep. And I mean, he was standing on
395
00:20:14.660 --> 00:20:16.660
the shoulders of people who came before him. So like
396
00:20:16.680 --> 00:20:19.220
some of the experiments that like Thorndike had done with
397
00:20:19.259 --> 00:20:20.900
Cats in the Box, I think we talked about Thorndike
398
00:20:20.960 --> 00:20:23.319
actually in Learning Curves at a very, very early episode.
399
00:20:23.869 --> 00:20:28.250
in this podcast, because again, this was all sort of
400
00:20:28.630 --> 00:20:31.190
in the zeitgeist, things that it was like sort of
401
00:20:31.269 --> 00:20:36.069
moving in that way that people understood this. Actually, J.R. Cantor,
402
00:20:36.109 --> 00:20:38.960
who we talked about a bit, he had more or
403
00:20:39.019 --> 00:20:41.140
less talked about this as well as part of his
404
00:20:41.160 --> 00:20:43.960
sort of philosophy. He just hadn't necessarily been doing the
405
00:20:44.019 --> 00:20:46.400
similar types of experiments or describing them in the same way,
406
00:20:46.880 --> 00:20:50.529
but definitely understood that the outcomes of behavior warfare were
407
00:20:50.670 --> 00:20:54.329
important and understanding how then behavior shapes and emerges too.
408
00:20:54.509 --> 00:20:54.690
Right.
409
00:20:54.869 --> 00:20:57.829
And he wrote about that even before many of Skinner's
410
00:20:57.869 --> 00:21:03.180
publications came to, came to light. So, Anyway, he eventually
411
00:21:03.240 --> 00:21:07.519
graduated from Harvard with his PhD in 1931, but he
412
00:21:07.579 --> 00:21:09.960
continued to work at the university and further develop and
413
00:21:09.980 --> 00:21:13.789
explore his research on operant conditioning, is what he called it,
414
00:21:14.329 --> 00:21:16.250
for the next several years. Yeah.
415
00:21:16.710 --> 00:21:19.170
So in 1936, this was a big year for Skinner.
416
00:21:19.190 --> 00:21:20.910
This was the year that he took on a teaching
417
00:21:20.950 --> 00:21:24.910
position after he left the advertising industry. Here's one of
418
00:21:24.930 --> 00:21:35.180
the ads as an example. I'm just kidding. Skinner
didn't
419
00:21:35.200 --> 00:21:37.640
do that. That was Watson. We know Watson was working
420
00:21:37.660 --> 00:21:40.630
in marketing. Skinner wasn't doing that. That's right. So in 1936,
421
00:21:40.609 --> 00:21:42.650
he took a teaching position at the University of Minnesota,
422
00:21:42.950 --> 00:21:46.440
and he married Yvonne Blue in 1936. And the couple
423
00:21:46.480 --> 00:21:49.910
eventually had two daughters in Minneapolis, Minnesota. And that would
424
00:21:49.930 --> 00:21:54.470
be Julie in 1938 and Deborah in 1944. So in 1938.
425
00:21:54.470 --> 00:21:58.970
So this is when Julie was born, he also published
426
00:21:59.049 --> 00:22:01.730
a summary of all of the research and the synthesis
427
00:22:02.029 --> 00:22:06.339
of data he'd been collecting over 10 years across his
428
00:22:06.380 --> 00:22:09.019
experiences at Harvard, as well as some in the University
429
00:22:09.039 --> 00:22:12.980
of Minnesota. And this culminated in his first book ever,
430
00:22:13.059 --> 00:22:16.559
The Behavior of Organisms. And this is considered the founding
431
00:22:16.619 --> 00:22:20.660
text for the experimental analysis of behavior, the field that
432
00:22:20.880 --> 00:22:24.289
would essentially arise out of this. If you read through it,
433
00:22:24.309 --> 00:22:27.569
it does kind of almost sound like a collection of
434
00:22:28.410 --> 00:22:32.569
his observations and like a sort of summary of thoughts
435
00:22:32.650 --> 00:22:34.430
about many of the experiments that he did. It is
436
00:22:34.490 --> 00:22:39.099
a very dense book about a lot of research.
437
00:22:39.519 --> 00:22:39.799
Yes.
438
00:22:40.000 --> 00:22:43.579
Almost like if you compiled just like 200 articles together
439
00:22:43.819 --> 00:22:46.960
and like, or maybe a hundred articles together in one place,
440
00:22:47.200 --> 00:22:50.480
that's sort of how it reads. So it's, it's very scholarly,
441
00:22:50.559 --> 00:22:53.119
if you will, that he published in 1938. And that
442
00:22:53.140 --> 00:22:56.529
essentially set the foundation for what would become the experimental
443
00:22:56.569 --> 00:22:58.220
analysis of behavior. Yeah.
444
00:22:58.660 --> 00:23:01.759
So, of course, if you're hearing these timeframes, these timelines,
445
00:23:01.779 --> 00:23:03.960
you're probably thinking, like, well, this seems like a pretty
446
00:23:04.009 --> 00:23:07.710
important year or decade for the United States, at least.
447
00:23:07.809 --> 00:23:11.410
What might have been happening around then? Well, World War
448
00:23:11.430 --> 00:23:14.539
II was ramping up, and as the United States officially
449
00:23:14.680 --> 00:23:17.640
entered the war, Skinner became interested in helping the war effort.
450
00:23:18.000 --> 00:23:20.400
And I think that, you know, there's important cultural factors
451
00:23:20.420 --> 00:23:24.789
here too. Like there was so much propaganda and stuff
452
00:23:24.829 --> 00:23:27.190
going
on about like supporting the war effort. And it
453
00:23:27.210 --> 00:23:29.420
was like, even you can help your troops. Like it
454
00:23:29.450 --> 00:23:31.319
was like, there was a lot of that going on.
455
00:23:31.380 --> 00:23:33.019
Like that was such a big part of the culture.
456
00:23:33.440 --> 00:23:36.400
So it stands to reason that like, And people are
457
00:23:36.420 --> 00:23:38.059
going to want to do a lot of stuff. And
458
00:23:38.079 --> 00:23:40.369
Skinner was actually pretty interested in this. So at the time,
459
00:23:40.700 --> 00:23:44.730
the missile guidance systems were basically non-existent. They did not
460
00:23:44.829 --> 00:23:47.390
have missile guidance systems at the time. And a lot
461
00:23:47.430 --> 00:23:49.250
of times the bombs that were dropped or the missiles
462
00:23:49.269 --> 00:23:52.269
that were fired were not as accurate, especially as they
463
00:23:52.309 --> 00:23:54.910
are today. And even then, they're still not perfect and
464
00:23:55.089 --> 00:23:58.890
still a problem. But Skinner proposed to teach pigeons to
465
00:23:58.970 --> 00:24:03.250
guide missiles and actually received funding to do this very thing.
466
00:24:03.920 --> 00:24:08.369
So in this very creatively named Project Pigeon, Skinner created
467
00:24:08.430 --> 00:24:13.230
an apparatus inside the nose cone of missiles and trained
468
00:24:13.309 --> 00:24:17.190
pigeons to peck buttons inside this apparatus to then direct
469
00:24:17.250 --> 00:24:22.140
the missile towards specific targets. And he succeeded with aplomb.
470
00:24:22.660 --> 00:24:26.410
He was able to demonstrate that pigeons could reliably and
471
00:24:26.630 --> 00:24:31.049
accurately peck the correct buttons even while falling continuously and
472
00:24:31.089 --> 00:24:36.019
being constantly bombarded and exposed to the sounds of explosions
473
00:24:36.119 --> 00:24:38.819
and war and gunfire and stuff like that. He trained
474
00:24:38.880 --> 00:24:44.940
them to maintain their performance even when faced with those situations.
475
00:24:45.539 --> 00:24:48.859
Yeah. He had received a grant for this. I believe
476
00:24:48.900 --> 00:24:52.920
it was something close to $ 35, 000 as a grant for this.
477
00:24:53.490 --> 00:24:55.670
And it is the equivalent of like almost a million
478
00:24:55.710 --> 00:24:58.569
dollar grant that he received for this in today's money.
479
00:24:58.630 --> 00:25:03.130
So like it's about $ 850, 000 in today's money. So he
480
00:25:03.190 --> 00:25:05.970
received money to do this. It's pretty interesting to think
481
00:25:06.009 --> 00:25:09.539
about that. But At the time, though, because, you know,
482
00:25:09.599 --> 00:25:13.680
sometimes what happens is different researchers or different organizations start
483
00:25:13.700 --> 00:25:17.839
to engage in duplicative tasks. Radar technology was secretly being
484
00:25:17.880 --> 00:25:20.480
developed at the same time, and eventually the
pigeon technology
485
00:25:20.829 --> 00:25:25.569
became obsolete for the war effort, so it wasn't necessary. However, Skinner, opportunistically,
486
00:25:25.890 --> 00:25:28.490
was able to observe that pigeons can peck much faster
487
00:25:28.509 --> 00:25:31.349
than rats can press levers... And this meant that he
488
00:25:31.390 --> 00:25:34.029
could make discoveries much faster using pigeons as subjects instead
489
00:25:34.049 --> 00:25:36.750
of rats. And he reportedly never worked with rats again
490
00:25:37.170 --> 00:25:39.849
because pigeons were a better subject, according to him.
491
00:25:40.450 --> 00:25:42.359
So yeah, as you said, for those of you worried
492
00:25:42.390 --> 00:25:44.559
about the poor pigeons and the nose cones of missiles,
493
00:25:44.680 --> 00:25:46.839
and I would have been too, it seems that none
494
00:25:46.880 --> 00:25:49.460
of them ever actually ended up going into a bomb
495
00:25:49.500 --> 00:25:50.839
and directing that bomb at a target.
496
00:25:51.180 --> 00:25:51.420
Yes.
497
00:25:51.519 --> 00:25:54.420
But out of this, we got a bunch of new
498
00:25:54.480 --> 00:25:57.059
research because Skinner was like, wow, these were This was
499
00:25:57.079 --> 00:25:58.779
much faster to train them than it would have been
500
00:25:58.799 --> 00:26:00.960
to train a rat to press a lever. So let's
501
00:26:01.000 --> 00:26:07.309
keep using them. Sidestepping that part of the experimentation he
502
00:26:07.329 --> 00:26:10.049
was doing at the time, he's still a person who
503
00:26:10.069 --> 00:26:13.309
has a family and he's being a good dad and
504
00:26:13.329 --> 00:26:15.190
a good husband to his family. He also learned, as
505
00:26:15.210 --> 00:26:17.240
far as I know, he also learned a lot about
506
00:26:17.259 --> 00:26:20.480
the practical issues in parenting from raising a daughter with
507
00:26:20.519 --> 00:26:22.829
his wife. So when she was pregnant again in 1943-
508
00:26:25.299 --> 00:26:27.500
And the pigeons in the missile were a twinkle.
509
00:26:27.240 --> 00:26:28.980
In his eye.
510
00:26:29.009 --> 00:26:32.130
She asked him if he could design a better, safer
511
00:26:32.190 --> 00:26:34.630
crib for the new child that was coming. She cited
512
00:26:34.670 --> 00:26:37.730
the fact that cribs have bars that kids' arms and
513
00:26:37.750 --> 00:26:40.710
legs can get caught in the bars. They can hurt themselves.
514
00:26:40.730 --> 00:26:42.970
They're very low to the ground, which requires a lot
515
00:26:43.009 --> 00:26:45.950
of bending over. The blankets in a crib can suffocate children,
516
00:26:46.029 --> 00:26:47.589
but you also don't want them to get too cold.
517
00:26:48.269 --> 00:26:51.690
So taking these into consideration, he did exactly as he
518
00:26:51.730 --> 00:26:54.900
was asked and built a brand new type of crib
519
00:26:54.980 --> 00:26:58.700
to address these safety and practical concerns. Yes.
520
00:26:58.960 --> 00:27:02.839
And so his quote unquote baby tender, as he called it,
521
00:27:03.190 --> 00:27:06.910
was extremely successful. for his family. However, it did not
522
00:27:06.950 --> 00:27:09.529
catch on and in fact became confused with experimental chambers
523
00:27:09.569 --> 00:27:13.930
he designed for pigeons and therefore even called a Skinner box,
524
00:27:14.170 --> 00:27:17.190
the name for his operant experimental boxes. Although to be fair,
525
00:27:17.630 --> 00:27:19.430
to be clear, I should say, that's not at all
526
00:27:19.450 --> 00:27:21.390
what it was. And this could have been cool and
527
00:27:21.430 --> 00:27:23.930
probably allowed for some cool developmental studies, but that's not
528
00:27:23.990 --> 00:27:26.089
what it was for. And we'll talk more about that
529
00:27:26.130 --> 00:27:28.150
in a later episode. But the thing that we're talking
530
00:27:28.170 --> 00:27:30.130
about here, this quote unquote baby Skinner box or the
531
00:27:30.150 --> 00:27:32.609
baby tender was not at all. It was very confused.
532
00:27:32.650 --> 00:27:34.930
People were very confused by it. Yeah.
533
00:27:35.230 --> 00:27:36.880
And it literally was just a crib. It was just
534
00:27:36.930 --> 00:27:39.160
like a new take on a crib. He was very
535
00:27:39.220 --> 00:27:41.700
proud of it. He tried to market it. He had
536
00:27:41.740 --> 00:27:44.799
some interest, but it really never caught on. But he
537
00:27:44.819 --> 00:27:46.380
was like, I mean, this solves a lot of problems
538
00:27:46.400 --> 00:27:48.779
people are having. So it seems like a good idea.
539
00:27:48.819 --> 00:27:51.900
And everyone's like, yeah, but you're Skinner and you experiment
540
00:27:51.920 --> 00:27:52.640
with pigeons in a box.
541
00:27:52.660 --> 00:27:54.759
You experiment on babies. And that was not at all
542
00:27:54.779 --> 00:27:56.069
what he was doing. Right.
543
00:27:57.569 --> 00:28:00.069
And that would come back over and over again. Anyway,
544
00:28:00.630 --> 00:28:03.710
on that point, he was harangued by rumors and misconceptions
545
00:28:03.769 --> 00:28:05.779
that his daughter spent all of her time in the
546
00:28:05.819 --> 00:28:07.720
crib and that he experimented on her and that she
547
00:28:07.759 --> 00:28:11.279
eventually died by suicide, with the implication being that her
548
00:28:11.359 --> 00:28:13.980
suicide was due to her time in the experimental chambers.
549
00:28:15.230 --> 00:28:18.430
Every single part of this is completely false. Yeah. She
550
00:28:18.470 --> 00:28:21.170
spent no more time in her crib than any other
551
00:28:21.210 --> 00:28:23.609
baby would have spent in there in this. Cause it's,
552
00:28:23.710 --> 00:28:25.170
I mean, it was a crib. It was, it was
553
00:28:25.299 --> 00:28:27.200
used as a crib and nothing more. Like you put
554
00:28:27.220 --> 00:28:28.079
the kid in the crib, right?
555
00:28:28.140 --> 00:28:29.599
It was a safety device. Yeah.
556
00:28:29.640 --> 00:28:31.680
You just, you keep them in there for their sleeping.
557
00:28:31.779 --> 00:28:34.519
And like, if they're going down for a nap or like,
558
00:28:34.559 --> 00:28:36.240
if you just need them to have a place to
559
00:28:36.279 --> 00:28:37.839
keep them for a minute while you're doing other things,
560
00:28:37.900 --> 00:28:40.039
it was just a crib. Like, So she didn't spend
561
00:28:40.099 --> 00:28:41.700
any more time in there than any kid would have
562
00:28:41.720 --> 00:28:43.859
spent in any other crib. It's just a crib. Right.
563
00:28:44.240 --> 00:28:48.569
He also never performed any experiments on either of his children. Also,
564
00:28:48.930 --> 00:28:51.670
Debra's still alive. Like this whole idea about her time.
565
00:28:51.750 --> 00:28:54.690
She's still currently alive. She's a successful artist and lives
566
00:28:54.710 --> 00:28:57.430
with her husband in London. Some of her art is
567
00:28:57.490 --> 00:29:00.700
around and available to see. So like, yeah, the whole
568
00:29:00.759 --> 00:29:03.859
thing was just utter nonsense came out of nowhere by
569
00:29:03.920 --> 00:29:07.619
stupid people. And yeah, Continued, perpetuated in certain circles, but
570
00:29:07.859 --> 00:29:09.849
all of that was wrong. Yeah. As far as we
571
00:29:09.869 --> 00:29:11.950
can tell, he was a good dad and the crib
572
00:29:11.990 --> 00:29:14.849
was just a practical thing to help make it a
573
00:29:14.950 --> 00:29:17.609
little easier. Like we'll talk more about it, but like
574
00:29:17.650 --> 00:29:18.869
it was raised up a little bit so you didn't
575
00:29:18.890 --> 00:29:22.009
have to bend over as much. It had plexiglass so
576
00:29:22.029 --> 00:29:23.930
that you could see them, but that they couldn't fall through. Well,
577
00:29:24.430 --> 00:29:26.910
we'll describe it more in a separate discussion, but it
578
00:29:26.950 --> 00:29:28.950
was really just a practical crib and that's all that
579
00:29:28.970 --> 00:29:29.190
it was.
580
00:29:29.529 --> 00:29:31.819
Yeah. And also, too, if you've never had a chance,
581
00:29:32.119 --> 00:29:34.740
I've gotten to see some of Deborah Skinner's paintings, and
582
00:29:34.759 --> 00:29:37.710
they're beautiful. I mean, she is truly a talented artist.
583
00:29:38.130 --> 00:29:40.279
I got to do some subject matter expert work. work
584
00:29:40.400 --> 00:29:43.940
at the BACB, and they had a series of her paintings,
585
00:29:44.460 --> 00:29:47.269
her watercolors hung up in the hallways right around the
586
00:29:47.289 --> 00:29:49.930
corner from Jerry Shook's personal library. So like some really
587
00:29:50.009 --> 00:29:52.910
cool things like artifacts exist there. And so I got
588
00:29:52.950 --> 00:29:54.430
to see some of her works, and they were just
589
00:29:54.589 --> 00:29:56.779
absolutely beautiful. Yeah. So, like, I would hang them up
590
00:29:56.819 --> 00:29:58.019
at my house because I was like, this
was just,
591
00:29:58.039 --> 00:30:01.660
they were just gorgeous. Like, just aesthetically, very aesthetically pleasing.
592
00:30:01.680 --> 00:30:03.200
That's awesome.
593
00:30:03.220 --> 00:30:06.740
Now, in 1945, Skinner's family moved to Bloomington, Indiana, where
594
00:30:06.960 --> 00:30:10.940
he became the chair of the psychology department at the
595
00:30:11.079 --> 00:30:13.259
local university. And it was here that he began building
596
00:30:13.279 --> 00:30:16.039
the foundations of the field that would eventually become behavior
597
00:30:16.099 --> 00:30:17.019
analysis today.
598
00:30:17.500 --> 00:30:19.839
So that was 1945. I believe that was the year
599
00:30:19.859 --> 00:30:22.829
that he published Walden 2. And we'll talk more about
600
00:30:22.849 --> 00:30:26.109
that in a separate discussion. Best-selling book of his, though.
601
00:30:26.369 --> 00:30:26.849
Yeah.
602
00:30:27.089 --> 00:30:30.069
In 1946, they held the first ever meeting for the
603
00:30:30.130 --> 00:30:34.789
Society of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, which eventually led
604
00:30:34.829 --> 00:30:37.309
to the development of a journal to publish the research
605
00:30:37.349 --> 00:30:40.740
being shared and pioneered by the people attending to and
606
00:30:40.799 --> 00:30:43.920
participating in the Society and And that journal was its
607
00:30:43.940 --> 00:30:46.430
debut issue published in 1958. So we're almost at 70
608
00:30:46.430 --> 00:30:47.970
years of that being a journal.
609
00:30:50.710 --> 00:30:53.670
Yeah, absolutely. Which is really, really cool. Now, Skinner was
610
00:30:53.690 --> 00:30:57.569
invited to join the psychology department at Harvard in 1948.
611
00:30:57.549 --> 00:31:01.529
Did you try and say Harvard? Harvard. Yeah, I couldn't
612
00:31:01.549 --> 00:31:04.609
help it. When I see Harvard, I can't help but
613
00:31:04.650 --> 00:31:08.309
think of Ben Affleck. So Harvard, pack the cap. So
614
00:31:08.349 --> 00:31:10.210
he was asked to join the psychology department at Harvard
615
00:31:10.490 --> 00:31:12.390
in 1948, where he had a whopping 400 students enroll
616
00:31:12.789 --> 00:31:19.799
in his course. He reportedly struggled to keep up with
617
00:31:19.839 --> 00:31:22.299
producing the materials needed to teach the course, but again,
618
00:31:22.319 --> 00:31:25.789
this proved a fruitful circumstance, and he assembled the materials
619
00:31:25.829 --> 00:31:28.809
he produced into what would become his book, Science and
620
00:31:28.849 --> 00:31:29.519
Human Behavior.
621
00:31:30.299 --> 00:31:33.160
Yes. And I believe that his first time at Harvard
622
00:31:33.420 --> 00:31:37.029
for teaching was like an invited presentation and then essentially
623
00:31:37.069 --> 00:31:40.349
was invited to just be on faculty at Harvard. Yeah.
624
00:31:40.589 --> 00:31:42.329
And then he was going to spend some time there.
625
00:31:42.349 --> 00:31:47.029
So that was 1948. In 1953,
he attended Deborah's fourth
626
00:31:47.069 --> 00:31:51.000
grade math class for Father's Day. And while he was
627
00:31:51.160 --> 00:31:53.920
in this class, he observed teaching that he described as
628
00:31:53.980 --> 00:31:57.200
violating everything he had learned about shaping and how learning happens. Yeah.
629
00:31:58.759 --> 00:31:59.599
Which is pretty good.
630
00:31:59.640 --> 00:32:01.859
He was very kind and very soft in the way
631
00:32:01.880 --> 00:32:03.839
he described things, I think. Yes.
632
00:32:04.799 --> 00:32:07.440
He observed and noted that some students would fly through
633
00:32:07.480 --> 00:32:10.019
exercises they already knew how to do and were essentially
634
00:32:10.039 --> 00:32:13.140
learning nothing. Other students who didn't know the work weren't
635
00:32:13.259 --> 00:32:16.380
actually given adequate instruction that would help them and then
636
00:32:16.440 --> 00:32:20.349
blamed for their failures. And that, like, it was just like,
637
00:32:20.369 --> 00:32:22.329
this just, none of this makes sense. Like, you aren't
638
00:32:22.410 --> 00:32:27.960
shaping behavior correctly. by allowing it to contact successful approximations
639
00:32:28.019 --> 00:32:32.079
toward what it needs to become. Some students have work
640
00:32:32.099 --> 00:32:34.119
that's too easy, some that's too hard, and then you
641
00:32:34.140 --> 00:32:35.960
blame the students when you don't actually teach them what
642
00:32:35.980 --> 00:32:41.440
to do. All of this sort of had him motivated
643
00:32:41.480 --> 00:32:44.549
to want to do something about the situation. Yeah.
644
00:32:44.609 --> 00:32:47.170
And so this inspired him to build his first teaching machine,
645
00:32:47.470 --> 00:32:50.170
which was a device designed to deliver instruction and feedback
646
00:32:50.190 --> 00:32:53.420
to support learning through practice. And again, we'll talk more
647
00:32:53.440 --> 00:32:55.220
about this in a different episode. But for now, here's
648
00:32:55.240 --> 00:32:57.039
an ad for the teaching machine that was really cool.
649
00:33:04.829 --> 00:33:07.109
We're back. There are no ads for The Teaching Machine
650
00:33:07.309 --> 00:33:11.609
because although The Teaching Machine had some interest from manufacturers
651
00:33:11.650 --> 00:33:15.710
and publishers and academic publishing groups and whatnot, and it
652
00:33:15.750 --> 00:33:18.690
had promise, most investors saw it as too risky of
653
00:33:18.730 --> 00:33:21.859
an investment, thought it was too complex, that it wouldn't
654
00:33:21.940 --> 00:33:24.160
be able to be really rolled out and utilized in
655
00:33:24.200 --> 00:33:26.920
a wide-scale way, that it wouldn't necessarily have support from
656
00:33:26.960 --> 00:33:30.019
other educators. And to be fair, like, it really wasn't
657
00:33:30.059 --> 00:33:31.720
doing a lot in the way of instructing. It was
658
00:33:31.799 --> 00:33:35.420
mostly just presenting opportunities to practice on a randomized order
659
00:33:35.960 --> 00:33:39.519
so that they could get lots of opportunities to practice
660
00:33:39.559 --> 00:33:43.789
the thing. Nevertheless, there was not enough appetite among sort
661
00:33:43.849 --> 00:33:47.710
of publishing company investors to build a lot of these.
662
00:33:48.410 --> 00:33:51.509
And the idea behind teaching machines was instead sort of
663
00:33:51.549 --> 00:33:56.890
converted into books in a line called programmed instruction. Similar idea,
664
00:33:57.009 --> 00:34:00.150
like it was sort of follow the same logic. But
665
00:34:00.329 --> 00:34:02.849
even then, they essentially decided to stop publishing these books
666
00:34:03.049 --> 00:34:06.710
in 1968. And that year, Skinner published a book about
667
00:34:06.799 --> 00:34:10.809
education topics called The Technology of Teaching as sort of a...
668
00:34:13.000 --> 00:34:16.400
what would you call this? It was like an obituary,
669
00:34:16.440 --> 00:34:19.269
if you will, to his teaching machines, but also like a,
670
00:34:19.400 --> 00:34:23.139
here's what I've learned and things that you could and
671
00:34:23.179 --> 00:34:26.380
should know that might help with education in the future.
672
00:34:26.699 --> 00:34:28.500
Yeah. I mean, I think that there's something really valuable
673
00:34:28.539 --> 00:34:30.909
inside of this, right? Like, so in a lot of situations,
674
00:34:30.929 --> 00:34:36.110
like his inventions or his discoveries didn't persist in in
675
00:34:36.289 --> 00:34:39.090
the form that we knew them as. So it didn't
676
00:34:39.150 --> 00:34:42.530
persist as a teaching machine itself, but he did learn
677
00:34:42.889 --> 00:34:45.130
more about the principles of learning inside of that. And
678
00:34:45.170 --> 00:34:47.230
this is where you get so much of his works.
679
00:34:47.269 --> 00:34:50.989
He goes, yeah, sure. The teaching machine is maybe, when
680
00:34:51.010 --> 00:34:53.599
we think about it today, is maybe cumbersome and a
681
00:34:53.619 --> 00:34:55.679
little bit, I mean, a little bit outdated, very outdated
682
00:34:55.699 --> 00:34:57.679
when we have computers and stuff like that. But the
683
00:34:57.780 --> 00:35:01.920
idea of the way that the instructional design part of
684
00:35:01.960 --> 00:35:04.179
it worked and the principles of learning inside of that
685
00:35:04.719 --> 00:35:08.300
those persist. And that's essentially what he has done, has
686
00:35:08.340 --> 00:35:11.389
gone like, yeah, this worked in this context this way,
687
00:35:11.829 --> 00:35:15.489
but the ideas and the principles and the science persist
688
00:35:15.510 --> 00:35:18.369
beyond that. And that was his strength. I think that's, like,
689
00:35:18.389 --> 00:35:20.489
when we really talk about it, that's the strength that
690
00:35:20.530 --> 00:35:24.010
Skinner brought to the table was going, yeah, we did this,
691
00:35:24.050 --> 00:35:25.780
and
here's what we learned. And he did a really
692
00:35:25.820 --> 00:35:27.699
great job of describing what he learned as a result
693
00:35:27.739 --> 00:35:30.340
of those things. And those things that he learned haven't
694
00:35:30.360 --> 00:35:31.260
changed very much since then.
695
00:35:31.760 --> 00:35:33.760
Yeah. A lot of the similar ideas that came out
696
00:35:33.800 --> 00:35:37.900
of this were used in bi-precision teaching and bi-precision teachers.
697
00:35:38.460 --> 00:35:43.610
They were used in the personalized system of instruction or PSI,
698
00:35:43.639 --> 00:35:47.869
which is still being implemented today in some places. So
699
00:35:48.409 --> 00:35:51.829
the ideas never went away and actually did sort of
700
00:35:52.230 --> 00:35:55.429
grow and evolve on their own sort of separate trajectories
701
00:35:55.449 --> 00:36:00.489
and So, like, the invention itself didn't necessarily find a
702
00:36:00.510 --> 00:36:05.840
lot of commercial success, but the ideas have led to
703
00:36:05.880 --> 00:36:07.860
a lot of other things down the road.
704
00:36:08.400 --> 00:36:11.920
Right, right. Now, starting in 1937, Skinner had started working
705
00:36:11.980 --> 00:36:14.119
on a book in an attempt to explain language and
706
00:36:14.159 --> 00:36:16.800
cognition using everything he had learned from the experimental analysis
707
00:36:16.820 --> 00:36:19.949
of behavior. He worked on it on and off for
708
00:36:19.949 --> 00:36:27.929
20 years, finally publishing his magnum opus treatise. Treatise? Treatise. Treatise. Yeah. Treatise. Treatise. Treatise.
709
00:36:28.369 --> 00:36:31.269
Language is so funny. Treatise. And this book was Verbal
710
00:36:31.289 --> 00:36:35.010
Behavior in 1957. And this drew a lot of criticism
711
00:36:35.050 --> 00:36:38.440
from Noam Chomsky. And also, just, we'll talk about this more, but,
712
00:36:38.579 --> 00:36:39.860
I mean, at the end of the day, like, this
713
00:36:39.920 --> 00:36:41.920
was an incomplete work of sorts.
714
00:36:42.360 --> 00:36:42.539
Yeah.
715
00:36:42.639 --> 00:36:45.280
For lots of reasons, but that's because science is often
716
00:36:45.320 --> 00:36:46.619
incomplete when it's discovered, so.
717
00:36:46.920 --> 00:36:47.119
Yeah. Yeah.
718
00:36:47.260 --> 00:36:49.219
But this drew a lot of criticism from Noam Chomsky,
719
00:36:49.500 --> 00:36:53.949
who had invented his own asinine, non-evidence-based, and ultimately debunked
720
00:36:54.090 --> 00:36:56.869
theory of language and cognition. We'll talk more about that later.
721
00:36:57.110 --> 00:37:00.050
But it's so funny because Noam Chomsky is also still
722
00:37:00.110 --> 00:37:02.929
touted as this brilliant man. And not to say that
723
00:37:02.969 --> 00:37:06.429
he wasn't brilliant, but his ideas around language were very,
724
00:37:06.489 --> 00:37:06.969
very wrong.
725
00:37:07.510 --> 00:37:10.530
Yeah. I mean, he definitely became more well-regarded in sort
726
00:37:10.570 --> 00:37:13.989
of the social justice and political space and a lot
727
00:37:14.010 --> 00:37:16.920
of his teachings and writings there. Yeah. And I can
728
00:37:16.960 --> 00:37:20.019
appreciate some of that. But my first exposure to Chomsky
729
00:37:20.039 --> 00:37:23.099
was in his combative relationship with Skinner. And yeah, he
730
00:37:23.239 --> 00:37:27.110
just made up this idea about language that was just
731
00:37:27.889 --> 00:37:31.929
bonkers and Yeah. Totally backwards. And ultimately, like, again, we
732
00:37:31.949 --> 00:37:34.210
showed that pretty much everything he thought was wrong. Yeah.
733
00:37:34.269 --> 00:37:37.050
But he did also like this really not what most
734
00:37:37.070 --> 00:37:39.730
people know Chomsky for is because afterward he sort of
735
00:37:39.769 --> 00:37:41.789
more gotten to the political arena of things.
736
00:37:42.269 --> 00:37:44.210
That's how I met him. Like when I when I
737
00:37:44.409 --> 00:37:46.510
I knew about Noam Chomsky coming into behavior analysis and
738
00:37:46.530 --> 00:37:48.869
when I read about his arguments about verbal behavior, I
739
00:37:48.909 --> 00:37:49.889
went the anarchy guy.
740
00:37:50.389 --> 00:37:50.590
Yeah.
741
00:37:50.829 --> 00:37:53.159
Like, I remember being like, I was like, that guy,
742
00:37:53.199 --> 00:37:55.619
the guy that published all these, like, really cool political
743
00:37:55.639 --> 00:37:57.539
books and pamphlets, like, that's the guy that was mad
744
00:37:57.579 --> 00:37:59.280
at Skinner? Like, it was so, it was such a
745
00:37:59.340 --> 00:38:01.949
weird thing, because I had already had, like, a relationship,
746
00:38:02.030 --> 00:38:04.849
like a, or like an influence by Chomsky coming into this.
747
00:38:05.300 --> 00:38:08.800
Yeah, yeah. I was in the opposite direction. Started with
748
00:38:08.840 --> 00:38:11.050
a bitter taste and then had to find things to
749
00:38:11.110 --> 00:38:14.849
appreciate about it. But yeah, I think after his attempts
750
00:38:15.010 --> 00:38:20.090
at foray into hypothetical imaginations about language, that's not really
751
00:38:20.130 --> 00:38:22.769
what he was known for anymore. Yeah, yeah. Which, for
752
00:38:22.809 --> 00:38:23.170
the better.
753
00:38:23.190 --> 00:38:23.730
Right.
754
00:38:24.070 --> 00:38:26.960
Anyway, over the next couple of decades, Skinner, working in
755
00:38:27.019 --> 00:38:30.480
these teaching capacity, ended up with some brilliant and innovative
756
00:38:30.519 --> 00:38:34.750
students who would greatly propel the field forward and I mean, honestly,
757
00:38:34.789 --> 00:38:36.849
I think some of the reason that what was so
758
00:38:36.889 --> 00:38:39.309
successful about all the things he developed was the fact
759
00:38:39.329 --> 00:38:41.360
that he had a new generation of people to take
760
00:38:41.380 --> 00:38:44.539
these ideas and really allow them to grow and expand
761
00:38:44.579 -->
00:38:48.179
and become something just much bigger than I think was
762
00:38:48.739 --> 00:38:52.889
even maybe envisioned at the outset for the experimental analysis
763
00:38:52.929 --> 00:38:56.150
of behavior, what would essentially become behavior analysis. And of course,
764
00:38:56.170 --> 00:38:57.789
there are a couple of duds who would try and
765
00:38:57.829 --> 00:39:01.920
drag the field backwards, Richard Herrnstein. But he did have
766
00:39:01.940 --> 00:39:05.519
some really great and important students while he was teaching
767
00:39:05.539 --> 00:39:10.079
that definitely were instrumental in continuing to propel behavior analysis
768
00:39:10.119 --> 00:39:10.960
forward and upward.
769
00:39:11.579 --> 00:39:15.239
Yeah, yeah. Now, Skinner became increasingly concerned with societal issues
770
00:39:15.280 --> 00:39:17.829
and believed that the experimental analysis of behavior offered potential
771
00:39:17.849 --> 00:39:20.949
solutions to help address the many issues facing society at large.
772
00:39:21.429 --> 00:39:23.269
He published some of these ideas in the book Beyond
773
00:39:23.309 --> 00:39:26.889
Freedom and Dignity, which resulted in some relatively high-profile TV
774
00:39:26.929 --> 00:39:29.710
interviews and high publicity, not all of it good at
775
00:39:30.039 --> 00:39:32.679
he implied humans did not have free will. As a
776
00:39:32.699 --> 00:39:34.960
quick side note, we have done an episode on this,
777
00:39:35.300 --> 00:39:37.199
but the short version is, it depends on how you
778
00:39:37.219 --> 00:39:39.730
define free will. Either we don't have it, or it's
779
00:39:39.750 --> 00:39:42.550
a useless concept that means nothing. But I think people
780
00:39:42.610 --> 00:39:46.170
took that as people don't have choice or whatever it
781
00:39:46.190 --> 00:39:49.469
might be. And people really struggle with this idea of
782
00:39:49.719 --> 00:39:52.440
being governed by things in our environment. And I think
783
00:39:52.480 --> 00:39:55.289
that people had a hard time wrapping their heads around it.
784
00:39:55.880 --> 00:40:01.960
It is also free will is essential. To believe that
785
00:40:02.000 --> 00:40:07.170
there is any justification for divine retribution for your actions. Right.
786
00:40:07.210 --> 00:40:13.650
So you can't have a reasonable commandment from some kind
787
00:40:13.710 --> 00:40:17.610
of deific or deity figure that says that if you
788
00:40:17.679 --> 00:40:21.679
do these things wrong, then I will punish you. If
789
00:40:21.880 --> 00:40:25.099
the things that you do wrong are things that were,
790
00:40:25.840 --> 00:40:30.019
let's say... not in your control if you're compelled to
791
00:40:30.059 --> 00:40:34.119
do them. And so the crux of the argument here,
792
00:40:34.599 --> 00:40:39.789
where some people sort of saw the writing on the wall,
793
00:40:39.809 --> 00:40:42.619
if you will, I was not saying this correctly, people
794
00:40:42.639 -->
00:40:45.619
could derive the implication of this that essentially was very
795
00:40:45.760 --> 00:40:48.219
similar to the experience Darwin went through when he was
796
00:40:48.260 --> 00:40:52.190
writing about evolution. And Darwin was observing the natural world
797
00:40:52.210 --> 00:40:56.190
around him going, uh, I think life may have evolved
798
00:40:56.409 --> 00:40:59.610
and not just spontaneously popped into existence in the way.
799
00:41:00.230 --> 00:41:02.769
Cause like all of my observations tell me that like
800
00:41:02.809 --> 00:41:06.880
the best explanation, the most parsimonious explanation is that these
801
00:41:07.090 --> 00:41:11.360
are biological traits that are shaped over time. Right. And, Actually,
802
00:41:11.460 --> 00:41:15.159
I would also say I think the entire philosophy of
803
00:41:15.280 --> 00:41:18.639
behaviorism only makes sense in the context of evolution as well.
804
00:41:19.059 --> 00:41:19.280
Right.
805
00:41:19.519 --> 00:41:22.989
And I think it is a complement to and extension
806
00:41:23.289 --> 00:41:27.250
of Darwin's ideas that we even get the experimental analysis
807
00:41:27.289 --> 00:41:27.829
of behavior.
808
00:41:28.110 --> 00:41:28.289
Right.
809
00:41:28.329 --> 00:41:30.670
And it is a perfect companion to it. It makes
810
00:41:30.909 --> 00:41:32.610
all of the sense in the world to think about
811
00:41:32.710 --> 00:41:36.530
how evolution or the development of behavior was part of
812
00:41:36.570 --> 00:41:40.860
the development of evolution and how species evolve. Right. Anyway,
813
00:41:41.820 --> 00:41:44.510
in that similar vein where we both had that species
814
00:41:44.650 --> 00:41:47.710
are not created and also it doesn't make sense to
815
00:41:47.789 --> 00:41:51.710
believe that their behavior is something they should suffer for
816
00:41:51.730 --> 00:41:54.469
a million years of punishment or an infinite amount of
817
00:41:54.489 --> 00:41:57.480
time in punishment because that behavior was shaped by their environments.
818
00:41:57.820 --> 00:42:00.059
Like of the three legs you had to stand on,
819
00:42:00.119 --> 00:42:03.940
two of them are now gone. And so– The implications there,
820
00:42:03.960 --> 00:42:05.639
I think, were clear for an audience who is not
821
00:42:05.679 --> 00:42:08.960
prepared to accept that kind of narrative and still aren't.
822
00:42:09.099 --> 00:42:11.860
I think most people still really, really struggle with the
823
00:42:11.969 --> 00:42:15.610
idea that we don't have free will. Yeah. At this point,
824
00:42:15.670 --> 00:42:18.550
it feels like an argument almost not worth having, but
825
00:42:18.690 --> 00:42:20.530
I am still happy to have it if someone wants to.
826
00:42:20.550 --> 00:42:21.489
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
827
00:42:21.650 --> 00:42:25.550
But I think that's part of where he drew ire
828
00:42:25.670 --> 00:42:26.449
from an audience.
829
00:42:27.159 --> 00:42:28.960
Sure. I think that's completely fair.
830
00:42:29.320 --> 00:42:31.610
I think he would have drawn more ire if he'd
831
00:42:31.679 --> 00:42:34.050
also just placed a bunch of ads in it. Ew.
832
00:42:34.409 --> 00:42:36.110
God, ads in his books? Gross.
833
00:42:36.130 --> 00:42:45.840
All right, we're back. We've been sort of describing why...
834
00:42:49.000 --> 00:42:51.440
Skinner drew some criticism for some of his work, particularly
835
00:42:51.460 --> 00:42:54.239
when we got to Beyond Freedom and Dignity, a title
836
00:42:54.280 --> 00:42:55.750
that itself is fairly provocative.
837
00:42:56.110 --> 00:42:59.090
Right. And, you know, he continued to draw criticism. Just
838
00:42:59.250 --> 00:43:01.289
this was a constant thing. I mean, to me, it
839
00:43:01.889 --> 00:43:06.989
sounds like so much of the concern around Skinner's views
840
00:43:07.429 --> 00:43:11.550
were that people felt that they were overly simplistic. They
841
00:43:11.570 --> 00:43:14.329
felt like, we can't just be reduced to behavior. We're
842
00:43:14.389 --> 00:43:17.010
complex creatures. I mean, he was separating out mind from
843
00:43:17.050 --> 00:43:20.139
body and all those things. He's saying, no, they're not different.
844
00:43:20.159 --> 00:43:22.980
They're the same thing. They're part of the entire constellation
845
00:43:23.000 --> 00:43:25.239
of variables that are you know, the organism. So like,
846
00:43:25.599 --> 00:43:28.340
I could see people being upset from that perspective, especially
847
00:43:28.409 --> 00:43:32.389
given that like psychology started with being more than behavior, right?
848
00:43:32.469 --> 00:43:34.730
Like that's kind of really where people were really looking
849
00:43:34.769 --> 00:43:37.170
at that. So, you know, he continued to face criticism
850
00:43:37.250 --> 00:43:39.889
from people who didn't understand or who were confronted by
851
00:43:39.929 --> 00:43:41.960
misrepresentations of his work. So that was the other side.
852
00:43:41.969 --> 00:43:45.039
It's like people just didn't, they misrepresented his work, the
853
00:43:45.119 --> 00:43:47.760
air crib being one of those examples. So in part
854
00:43:47.840 --> 00:43:51.239
to address some misunderstandings, he wrote a book, another book
855
00:43:51.460 --> 00:43:55.010
about behaviorism, which he published in 1974. So he went, oh,
856
00:43:55.070 --> 00:43:57.090
you don't understand my work. Here's another work for you
857
00:43:57.110 --> 00:43:57.869
to understand my work.
858
00:43:58.869 --> 00:44:02.050
Yes. Yeah. And although the book was about behaviorism, the
859
00:44:02.110 --> 00:44:06.280
actual title was about behaviorism. Yeah.
860
00:44:06.420 --> 00:44:06.980
Yeah.
861
00:44:07.820 --> 00:44:08.960
You might, you might hear us say he wrote a
862
00:44:08.980 --> 00:44:10.760
book about behaviorism. Like, well, of course he did. All
863
00:44:10.780 --> 00:44:12.900
of his books are about behaviorism. I'm like, but the
864
00:44:12.940
--> 00:44:14.800
title of this one is about behaviorism.
865
00:44:15.510 --> 00:44:16.949
One thing I want to point out, too, that we
866
00:44:17.050 --> 00:44:18.469
talked about at the top of the episode is that
867
00:44:18.489 --> 00:44:21.190
we don't worship people in our field. He makes an
868
00:44:21.230 --> 00:44:24.610
explicit point in the first chapter of that book to say, hey,
869
00:44:24.840 --> 00:44:26.639
I am just somebody who likes to study this stuff.
870
00:44:27.079 --> 00:44:29.119
You don't need to take my word for it. Go
871
00:44:29.139 --> 00:44:32.079
study this stuff. He makes it explicitly clear that he
872
00:44:32.219 --> 00:44:34.440
also does not want to be worshipped as somebody. So
873
00:44:34.460 --> 00:44:36.440
if you're a behavior analyst and you're like, oh, Skinner
874
00:44:36.519 --> 00:44:39.820
is just da-da-da-da-da, it's important to know that he didn't
875
00:44:39.860 --> 00:44:40.440
even want that.
876
00:44:41.030 --> 00:44:43.949
Yeah. He stated very clearly, he thought that he was
877
00:44:43.989 --> 00:44:48.349
not special, that everything that he contributed was happy circumstances,
878
00:44:48.389 --> 00:44:49.679
that he happened to be in the right place at
879
00:44:49.699 --> 00:44:51.579
the right time. He happened to have the right environment
880
00:44:51.900 --> 00:44:55.940
to facilitate him exploring his curiosities. And that he was
881
00:44:55.980 --> 00:44:58.039
quite clear, I think, on this point that he did
882
00:44:58.079 --> 00:45:03.219
not see himself as being like some great, magnificent person
883
00:45:03.239 --> 00:45:05.780
and that he just got lucky. And I think that
884
00:45:06.750 --> 00:45:10.510
most real behavior analysts would understand and feel the same
885
00:45:10.550 --> 00:45:13.329
way about both him and themselves, and to whatever extent
886
00:45:13.369 --> 00:45:16.369
they may have made also valuable contributions, is that they
887
00:45:16.409 --> 00:45:20.260
also got lucky. Anyway, that is, I think, an important feature, yeah,
888
00:45:20.280 --> 00:45:23.579
because as you said, we don't worship any of this. Like,
889
00:45:23.599 --> 00:45:27.559
he went on to publish some memoirs, some other sort
890
00:45:27.599 --> 00:45:30.820
of more personal books, one called Enjoy Old Age as
891
00:45:30.860 --> 00:45:33.420
he was getting up there, one called The Particulars of
892
00:45:33.460 --> 00:45:36.300
My Life, And so there was a lot that he
893
00:45:36.320 --> 00:45:39.210
was sort of doing in his final years. But in 1989,
894
00:45:39.210 --> 00:45:42.269
he was diagnosed with leukemia, but he did remain as
895
00:45:42.409 --> 00:45:45.389
active as he could, even given his diagnosis. Obviously, he
896
00:45:45.429 --> 00:45:48.820
was in a somewhat limited capacity to do much. Our
897
00:45:49.199 --> 00:45:51.599
treatments for cancer were not as good in 1989 as
898
00:45:51.639 --> 00:45:54.119
they are now, although I Very likely he would have
899
00:45:54.159 --> 00:45:57.800
followed a similar path anyway, given that we've only gone
900
00:45:57.840 --> 00:46:00.800
so far with treatments of these things. Anyway, he continued
901
00:46:00.840 --> 00:46:03.780
to write and give talks, even giving a presentation at
902
00:46:03.820 --> 00:46:07.659
the American Psychological Association only 10 days before he died.
903
00:46:08.230 --> 00:46:09.510
although I'm sure he didn't know at the time that
904
00:46:09.530 --> 00:46:10.690
it was 10 days before he died.
905
00:46:10.750 --> 00:46:11.309
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
906
00:46:11.389 --> 00:46:15.289
He received during this a Lifetime Achievement Award from the APA,
907
00:46:15.809 --> 00:46:18.320
and then he converted the talk that he gave there
908
00:46:18.480 --> 00:46:21.420
into an article which he finished writing the day that
909
00:46:21.480 --> 00:46:25.300
he died, which was August 18th, 1990.
910
00:46:25.559 --> 00:46:29.079
Wow. I mean, that's incredible. I mean, his legacy of
911
00:46:29.099 --> 00:46:31.159
the theory of reinforcement and the use of scientific method
912
00:46:31.179 --> 00:46:35.070
to objectively study behavior has expanded to a field consisting
913
00:46:35.110 --> 00:46:37.989
of tens of thousands of professionals and a wide variety
914
00:46:38.010 --> 00:46:42.849
of applications, including sports, pharmaceuticals, animal care at zoos, organizational structure, education,
915
00:46:42.909 --> 00:46:47.550
workplace safety, and now to cognitive psychotherapy and many others
916
00:46:47.590 --> 00:46:49.590
as well, and continues to advance. Wow.
917
00:46:50.150 --> 00:46:52.190
Yeah. I mean, there's so many. There's so many ways
918
00:46:52.250 --> 00:46:55.389
that this has been applied and adopted and integrated into
919
00:46:55.449 --> 00:46:59.719
other things. And like functional psychotherapy has sort of a
920
00:46:59.760 --> 00:47:04.079
leg here, dialectical behavioral therapy, acceptance and commitment therapy. There's
921
00:47:04.119 --> 00:47:06.460
a lot of these that all sort of developed from
922
00:47:06.519 --> 00:47:09.179
this and just so many other things that feel like
923
00:47:09.219 --> 00:47:11.179
they're maybe even outside of the scope of what you
924
00:47:11.219 --> 00:47:14.519
might've expected something like behavior analysis to be. But it
925
00:47:14.599 --> 00:47:17.420
actually has expanded quite broadly and quite successfully in many
926
00:47:17.440 --> 00:47:21.190
of these places. Skinner received many awards and accolades throughout
927
00:47:21.230 --> 00:47:24.519
his life. Some hailed him as a hero. Others reviled
928
00:47:24.559 --> 00:47:26.739
him as a villain. But I think as far as
929
00:47:26.780 --> 00:47:30.179
we can tell, Skinner was a very well-intentioned man doing
930
00:47:30.219 --> 00:47:33.480
his best to use science to help people. He wasn't perfect.
931
00:47:33.619 --> 00:47:36.630
He wasn't infallible. He
wasn't even completely right about everything.
932
00:47:37.250 --> 00:47:40.010
And he started something that has been used by people
933
00:47:40.329 --> 00:47:43.710
in some horrible ways. Like very terrible things have been
934
00:47:43.750 --> 00:47:46.510
done with the tool of behavior analysis that was given
935
00:47:46.530 --> 00:47:49.699
to them. But I think it's been used by many, many,
936
00:47:49.900 --> 00:47:54.739
many more people In compassionate, productive, and helpful ways. Like
937
00:47:54.880 --> 00:47:57.340
I would say that this has helped a lot more
938
00:47:57.400 --> 00:47:59.730
than it has hurt. And it's not to say that
939
00:48:00.010 --> 00:48:02.909
the cost of people suffering that did happen at the
940
00:48:02.949 --> 00:48:05.789
hands of people who are trying to implement the ideas
941
00:48:05.829 --> 00:48:08.579
that came from behavior analysis was worth it. Because I
942
00:48:08.639 --> 00:48:10.659
think human suffering was never worth it.
943
00:48:11.000 --> 00:48:11.320
Agreed.
944
00:48:11.400 --> 00:48:14.920
But at least we have a lot more good to
945
00:48:14.980 --> 00:48:17.619
say about what has happened from this than there is bad.
946
00:48:18.260 --> 00:48:20.730
And I think that that has definitely helped it continue
947
00:48:20.750 --> 00:48:22.989
to thrive and be a successful field because so much
948
00:48:23.070 --> 00:48:24.909
good has come out of it. And I think the
949
00:48:25.349 --> 00:48:27.190
amount of good that has come out of it has dwarfed,
950
00:48:27.710 --> 00:48:29.949
utterly dwarfed, the bad that has come out of it.
951
00:48:29.949 --> 00:48:31.940
And I wish that the bad never had happened, but...
952
00:48:32.659 --> 00:48:34.579
Maybe we can see that as opportunities to learn and
953
00:48:34.619 --> 00:48:34.980
do better.
954
00:48:35.199 --> 00:48:35.380
Right.
955
00:48:35.539 --> 00:48:37.880
And I think that has continued to more or less
956
00:48:37.900 --> 00:48:38.440
be the case.
957
00:48:38.960 --> 00:48:41.860
Absolutely. Now, Skinner's science and philosophy did not capture the
958
00:48:41.920 --> 00:48:45.139
entirety of human experience either, though he did write about
959
00:48:45.179 --> 00:48:47.110
just about everything that we could think of off the
960
00:48:47.119 --> 00:48:49.690
top of your head. He's got some comment about religion
961
00:48:49.809 --> 00:48:52.010
and politics and all the things that come along, right?
962
00:48:52.829 --> 00:48:54.789
It did not solve the problems he thought it would solve.
963
00:48:55.309 --> 00:48:58.809
But many, since his time, have continued to elaborate on,
964
00:48:59.110 --> 00:49:02.239
iterate on, and expand upon his work well beyond what
965
00:49:02.260 --> 00:49:04.639
he had done. And they've gotten closer to his vision
966
00:49:04.679 --> 00:49:06.800
of what was possible with behavior analysis. I mean, the
967
00:49:06.860 --> 00:49:08.860
amount of things that we have been
able to do
968
00:49:09.400 --> 00:49:14.349
since his work first came out is pretty astounding. And truly,
969
00:49:14.389 --> 00:49:17.449
the applications of our work are pretty incredible when you
970
00:49:17.469 --> 00:49:19.469
really think about the power of what we can do.
971
00:49:20.079 --> 00:49:22.659
I think that he would be both pleased and very
972
00:49:22.719 --> 00:49:27.340
humbled by how much it has developed since his passing.
973
00:49:27.840 --> 00:49:30.829
How much it has grown and evolved and become what
974
00:49:30.869 --> 00:49:33.530
it has become. I think that he would see this
975
00:49:33.590 --> 00:49:37.170
both as And sort of like, wow, I was like
976
00:49:37.210 --> 00:49:40.769
a small piece of this important piece. But like relative
977
00:49:40.809 --> 00:49:42.739
to what we have done with it, it's kind of
978
00:49:42.760 --> 00:49:45.079
a small piece. And in a good way, I think
979
00:49:45.119 --> 00:49:47.260
that's that would be like I would be very proud
980
00:49:47.280 --> 00:49:48.969
to have a legacy where I'm like, wow, I feel
981
00:49:49.010 --> 00:49:51.210
like this. I was such a small piece of something
982
00:49:51.250 --> 00:49:53.610
that became so much bigger, but I'm so happy I
983
00:49:53.630 --> 00:49:55.429
could have been part of it at all. Yeah. Even
984
00:49:55.469 --> 00:49:57.170
if I was sort of the founding part of it,
985
00:49:57.210 --> 00:50:00.309
just like this thing has outgrown me considerably, I would
986
00:50:00.349 --> 00:50:03.139
be very proud of that personally. So I feel like,
987
00:50:03.400 --> 00:50:05.699
and given how we've seen him sort of write and talk,
988
00:50:05.739 --> 00:50:08.079
like that seems very in line with how I sort
989
00:50:08.099 --> 00:50:11.000
of understood him. Yeah. And I'll share that on a
990
00:50:11.019 --> 00:50:15.659
personal note, the foundational concepts in this field have entirely
991
00:50:15.739 --> 00:50:19.090
shaped like my worldview, right? In a way, it feels
992
00:50:19.170 --> 00:50:22.789
cohesive and comprehensive to me. It is more satisfying in
993
00:50:22.829 --> 00:50:25.320
the way that it addresses topics than anything else I
994
00:50:25.360 --> 00:50:31.400
have ever encountered. Everything makes sense through this lens in
995
00:50:31.440 --> 00:50:33.769
a way that it didn't in any other lens that
996
00:50:33.829 --> 00:50:36.500
I have encountered. And it has helped me see humans
997
00:50:36.960 --> 00:50:40.000
more compassionately, to allow me to be more patient, to
998
00:50:40.019 --> 00:50:42.650
be kinder. And it's helped me connect with many people
999
00:50:42.690 --> 00:50:45.750
and families I otherwise would not have. This is a
1000
00:50:45.909 --> 00:50:48.929
science and philosophy and his work and specifically that was
1001
00:50:48.989 --> 00:50:53.090
not complete, but science never is. Right. It is, however,
1002
00:50:53.170 --> 00:50:56.969
the best thing we've got for trying to be humans
1003
00:50:57.030 --> 00:50:59.809
together on this planet. That is the best thing we've
1004
00:50:59.849 --> 00:51:01.710
come up with so far. And yeah, sure, a lot
1005
00:51:01.750 --> 00:51:03.070
of problems have come out of it, but I think
1006
00:51:03.090 --> 00:51:06.159
there is also a lot more potential for solutions to
1007
00:51:06.199 --> 00:51:08.480
come out of it than any of the other systems
1008
00:51:08.500 --> 00:51:10.760
we've had that mostly have just created problems.
1009
00:51:11.199 --> 00:51:12.039
Yeah, agreed.
1010
00:51:12.159 --> 00:51:14.280
So anyway, I, that's sort of where I want to
1011
00:51:14.320 --> 00:51:17.400
land on this because, you know, I think everything I
1012
00:51:17.579 --> 00:51:22.059
think and do is now has the foundational concepts that
1013
00:51:22.099 --> 00:51:26.139
are part of the philosophy of behavior analysis. And again,
1014
00:51:26.320 --> 00:51:28.260
that's how the world makes sense to me. And it just,
1015
00:51:28.340 --> 00:51:31.960
it doesn't not work. And to be fair, like my
1016
00:51:32.000 --> 00:51:34.699
worldview is not just based on Skinner's work. Like it
1017
00:51:34.739 --> 00:51:36.920
is also based on Cantor's work. Like a lot of
1018
00:51:36.960 --> 00:51:40.199
that has shaped it as well. And Linda Hayes, who
1019
00:51:40.239 --> 00:51:42.949
has built on Cantor's work that has shaped a lot
1020
00:51:42.969 --> 00:51:45.809
of those similar thoughts. And there's so many people that
1021
00:51:46.190 --> 00:51:49.570
have happened before and since that have contributed to that.
1022
00:51:49.650 --> 00:51:54.110
But the way that I describe it is behavior analysis
1023
00:51:54.159 --> 00:51:57.579
or behavior analytic. And that foundation was more or less
1024
00:51:57.639 --> 00:51:58.579
established by Skinner.
1025
00:51:59.340 --> 00:52:02.519
Absolutely. I mean, I agree, too. I think that once
1026
00:52:02.539 --> 00:52:05.610
I discovered behaviorism, I went, oh, this makes sense. It
1027
00:52:05.670 --> 00:52:08.309
makes sense not because it just feels good. It's because
1028
00:52:08.349 --> 00:52:11.389
there's evidence that also supports it feeling good. Like, that's
1029
00:52:11.429 --> 00:52:12.929
the way that I feel about it, right? Like, as
1030
00:52:12.969 --> 00:52:16.619
I go, like, yeah, this makes sense to me. And also, look, there's, like,
1031
00:52:17.260 --> 00:52:19.739
a huge body of literature to back this up and
1032
00:52:19.840 --> 00:52:23.900
verify that this feels like I'm seeing it. So there's
1033
00:52:23.940 --> 00:52:25.000
something really special about that.
1034
00:52:25.980 --> 00:52:27.940
Yeah, for me, it really sealed the deal when I
1035
00:52:27.980 --> 00:52:29.579
got to see it in action. I was like, oh,
1036
00:52:29.659 --> 00:52:31.449
my God, like you took something I would have thought
1037
00:52:31.469 --> 00:52:33.610
was impossible and you made it quite possible.
1038
00:52:33.909 --> 00:52:34.110
Yeah.
1039
00:52:34.190 --> 00:52:37.909
And behavior like seeing someone go go from something that
1040
00:52:37.949 --> 00:52:40.780
was a skill so far outside of their repertoire that
1041
00:52:40.800 --> 00:52:42.320
you would have thought that they would never be able
1042
00:52:42.360 --> 00:52:44.809
to get there. And then they got there with some
1043
00:52:44.849 --> 00:52:46.789
basic shaping. And like, sure, it took a while, but
1044
00:52:46.829 --> 00:52:49.369
like they eventually got there to the point where I'm like, okay,
1045
00:52:49.409 --> 00:52:52.019
so pretty much anything is possible inside of human behavior.
1046
00:52:52.059 --> 00:52:54.639
Like if you have the time, resources, and effort to
1047
00:52:54.679 --> 00:52:57.420
shape a behavior, like whether it's yours or someone else's,
1048
00:52:57.480 --> 00:52:58.960
like it will eventually get there.
1049
00:52:59.239 --> 00:52:59.440
Right.
1050
00:52:59.599 --> 00:53:01.940
If you know what you're doing. That blew my mind.
1051
00:53:02.119 --> 00:53:05.889
You know, just the practical application of it really working
1052
00:53:05.929 --> 00:53:09.269
in real time, that blew my mind. Yeah. If you
1053
00:53:09.329 --> 00:53:11.409
had thoughts that this is just how people are born,
1054
00:53:11.429 --> 00:53:13.349
I'm like, I have seen things that have convinced me
1055
00:53:13.389 --> 00:53:16.829
that is just never the case. Everybody has a certain
1056
00:53:16.849 --> 00:53:20.489
capacity in sort of what their parameters and limitations of
1057
00:53:20.530 --> 00:53:22.070
what they might be able to achieve are. I know
1058
00:53:22.329 --> 00:53:24.719
I use this example a lot, but I cannot fly
1059
00:53:25.280 --> 00:53:28.139
using just my wings because I don't have wings. Right.
1060
00:53:28.820 --> 00:53:30.940
So like that is a capacity that is set by
1061
00:53:31.019 --> 00:53:34.260
my biology. But there are a lot of things inside
1062
00:53:34.559 --> 00:53:37.559
of human capabilities that I definitely can do if my
1063
00:53:37.599 --> 00:53:39.230
behavior is shaped to the point where I could get
1064
00:53:39.269 --> 00:53:41.949
there because I've seen it happen and the data are there.
1065
00:53:41.969 --> 00:53:43.250
And like that was the other thing, too, is like
1066
00:53:43.289 --> 00:53:46.530
this is such a data driven field. It's like we
1067
00:53:46.550 --> 00:53:49.800
don't have to impose our feelings or hopes or ambitions
1068
00:53:49.880 --> 00:53:51.840
upon this. We can just see what's working, what isn't.
1069
00:53:52.300 --> 00:53:53.760
And if it's not working, then you change it. And
1070
00:53:53.800 --> 00:53:55.119
if it is, then keep doing what you're doing.
1071
00:53:55.320 --> 00:53:55.519
Right.
1072
00:53:55.619 --> 00:53:57.840
You'll only know that because you have data to tell
1073
00:53:57.880 --> 00:54:01.840
you that it's doing that thing. So that was extremely
1074
00:54:01.880 --> 00:54:04.059
appealing to me is that like, let's just get rid
1075
00:54:04.099 --> 00:54:06.159
of the like, oh, I think this is getting better
1076
00:54:06.539 --> 00:54:09.039
part and be like, no, here's actual data.
1077
00:54:09.360 --> 00:54:09.579
Right.
1078
00:54:09.719 --> 00:54:11.960
That suggests one thing or another. Right.
1079
00:54:12.199 --> 00:54:13.199
Nailed it. Absolutely.
1080
00:54:13.219 --> 00:54:16.320
Okay, great. Well, closing thoughts that you might have since
1081
00:54:16.340 --> 00:54:18.010
we're talking about the guy.
1082
00:54:18.570 --> 00:54:22.130
You hit it on the head. I think that for me, behaviorism...
1083
00:54:22.230 --> 00:54:24.610
you know, for all the flack that it gets because
1084
00:54:24.730 --> 00:54:29.219
people will misconceive it as reductionist, I think that it
1085
00:54:29.320 --> 00:54:32.179
is arguably the most compassionate, or to me, feels like
1086
00:54:32.219 --> 00:54:35.119
the most compassionate way to go about practice if it's
1087
00:54:35.139 --> 00:54:37.820
done well and done with care, right? I think that,
1088
00:54:38.280 --> 00:54:40.090
you know, yes, there are horrible things that have been
1089
00:54:40.110 --> 00:54:42.190
done in the name of behaviorism, and that's unfortunate because
1090
00:54:42.210 --> 00:54:44.090
I don't think that that's the spirit of the field.
1091
00:54:44.630 --> 00:54:46.550
I think that ultimately the spirit of the field is
1092
00:54:46.570 --> 00:54:50.989
that And the spirit of the philosophy is to reduce
1093
00:54:51.070 --> 00:54:56.079
suffering by making teaching and practice more efficient so that
1094
00:54:56.099 --> 00:54:58.989
people can contact more of their reinforcers and they have
1095
00:54:59.030 --> 00:55:01.510
more degrees of freedom as a result of that. I
1096
00:55:01.570 --> 00:55:04.570
think that this has also opened up the doors for
1097
00:55:04.590 --> 00:55:06.880
me to be more inquisitive. I think that I can
1098
00:55:06.909 --> 00:55:09.840
go back and when somebody does something, I can go
1099
00:55:09.880 --> 00:55:11.760
back and go like, well, what led them to that?
1100
00:55:12.159 --> 00:55:15.460
Like what circumstances brought them here? Because, you know, I
1101
00:55:16.239 --> 00:55:18.599
think of like that phrase, like, you know, everybody's doing
1102
00:55:18.619 --> 00:55:20.920
the best they can in their circumstances. And I think
1103
00:55:20.960 --> 00:55:25.500
that that is true. And I think people have problematic
1104
00:55:25.539 --> 00:55:27.510
behaviors for sure. But I think at the end of
1105
00:55:27.530 --> 00:55:30.460
the day, Like everybody's doing the best they can. And
1106
00:55:30.500 --> 00:55:33.820
it has made me at least pause more to take
1107
00:55:33.860 --> 00:55:36.090
a step back and go, what led them here? How
1108
00:55:36.110 --> 00:55:38.769
did they get here? Why are they doing this? and
1109
00:55:38.949 --> 00:55:40.690
allows me to approach it a little bit differently. That
1110
00:55:40.710 --> 00:55:42.710
doesn't mean I don't get frustrated about stuff, but it
1111
00:55:42.769 --> 00:55:45.349
has allowed me to kind of at least pause more
1112
00:55:45.449 --> 00:55:48.190
than when I was younger and think more deeply about
1113
00:55:48.210 --> 00:55:50.989
the circumstances under which somebody has engaged. And so, I
1114
00:55:51.030 --> 00:55:53.269
think that that has made me a better human as
1115
00:55:53.289 --> 00:55:56.869
a result of understanding the sequence of events that lead
1116
00:55:56.909 --> 00:55:59.889
somebody to a particular decision or a particular action or
1117
00:55:59.949 --> 00:56:02.489
anything like that. Like, it has made me just, I
1118
00:56:02.510 --> 00:56:05.320
think a better human. And that's not just Skinner, right?
1119
00:56:05.360 --> 00:56:07.699
Like I think that we were talking about this before,
1120
00:56:07.840 --> 00:56:11.000
like getting into it, like behaviorism is not solely Skinner, right?
1121
00:56:11.039 --> 00:56:13.519
Like it's, you brought up Pavlov, you brought up Watson,
1122
00:56:13.559 --> 00:56:16.219
we brought up Thorndyke, all these people, these contributors. And
1123
00:56:16.260 --> 00:56:18.139
there are lots of other contributors too. Like, you know,
1124
00:56:18.230 --> 00:56:20.269
like you brought up Linda Hayes, you brought up, like,
1125
00:56:20.309 --> 00:56:23.110
there's so many people that are in this space that
1126
00:56:23.130 --> 00:56:26.829
are doing this work in different ways and making an impact.
1127
00:56:26.949 --> 00:56:29.659
And I think that you know, Skinner himself stood on
1128
00:56:29.679 --> 00:56:32.579
the shoulders of giants. Like you don't have behaviorism if
1129
00:56:32.619 --> 00:56:36.969
you don't have initial writings of philosophy from like Aristotle
1130
00:56:37.070 --> 00:56:40.170
and Socrates and all those folks too. So yeah, I
1131
00:56:40.190 --> 00:56:42.489
think that it's really important as we go through this, too,
1132
00:56:42.510 --> 00:56:46.300
to remember that everything is an iterative process. It's building
1133
00:56:46.380 --> 00:56:48.980
upon and building upon and building upon. And Skinner was
1134
00:56:49.019 --> 00:56:51.780
doing just that. He just happened to write about it
1135
00:56:52.280 --> 00:56:55.739
a lot. And he happened to just, like, I don't
1136
00:56:55.760 --> 00:56:59.269
want to say discover, but give us language to describe
1137
00:56:59.309 --> 00:57:01.650
the things that were already happening, right? And do it
1138
00:57:01.670 --> 00:57:04.210
in a way that was systematic and discover ways to
1139
00:57:04.469 --> 00:57:07.210
explore those and I think that we're a little bit different.
1140
00:57:07.250 --> 00:57:10.420
So I'm very grateful. I'm very grateful for the science
1141
00:57:10.460 --> 00:57:12.619
of behavior and the work that he did, because I
1142
00:57:12.639 --> 00:57:14.199
think that, again, you and I, you brought it up
1143
00:57:14.219 --> 00:57:16.380
at the beginning of this episode that like, if it
1144
00:57:16.440 --> 00:57:19.690
wasn't for the groundbreaking work that he was doing and
1145
00:57:19.730 --> 00:57:22.349
the way that he talked about this stuff, we wouldn't
1146
00:57:22.389 --> 00:57:23.730
be here as a podcast.
1147
00:57:24.010 --> 00:57:24.170
Yeah.
1148
00:57:24.309 --> 00:57:26.010
You know, we'd be talking about something very different if
1149
00:57:26.030 --> 00:57:28.429
we were on a podcast, like who we, who you
1150
00:57:28.469 --> 00:57:29.679
and I wouldn't have connected.
1151
00:57:29.699 --> 00:57:29.780
Yeah.
1152
00:57:30.400 --> 00:57:32.940
Very likely if it wasn't for this, you know, and
1153
00:57:32.980 --> 00:57:35.280
there's lots of friendships and relationships that I have with
1154
00:57:35.340 --> 00:57:38.159
people like, like people that I've grown to care about
1155
00:57:38.260 --> 00:57:41.639
and love deeply that are a result of this field.
1156
00:57:42.110 --> 00:57:44.969
And I am so grateful for it. Yeah.
1157
00:57:45.130 --> 00:57:48.250
Yeah, absolutely. Very well said. You know, and I do
1158
00:57:48.269 --> 00:57:50.150
appreciate the point that you said that like, it's everyone's
1159
00:57:50.170 --> 00:57:53.449
doing the best with what they've got, um, except advertisers.
1160
00:57:53.469 --> 00:57:53.610
Yeah.
1161
00:58:01.260 --> 00:58:03.719
All right. We're back. We're wrapping this up. Advertisers do
1162
00:58:03.739 --> 00:58:04.659
the worst with what they've got.
1163
00:58:04.679 --> 00:58:06.780
Yeah. Yeah. That's a choice.
1164
00:58:07.300 --> 00:58:10.469
Maybe also Stephen Miller doing the worst with what he's got. Yeah.
1165
00:58:10.800 --> 00:58:15.139
And he doesn't have much, but he's really stretching it.
1166
00:58:15.369 --> 00:58:18.429
Yeah. Really leaning into the hardcore evil as much as
1167
00:58:18.449 --> 00:58:19.409
he possibly can. Yeah.
1168
00:58:19.630 --> 00:58:20.329
Yeah.
1169
00:58:20.349 --> 00:58:22.269
Let's do evil for the sake of evil. And then
1170
00:58:22.429 --> 00:58:26.190
that's tattooed on the inside of his eyelids. Yep. Yep.
1171
00:58:26.690 --> 00:58:29.150
Lest he forget someday that that was his mantra.
1172
00:58:29.170 --> 00:58:30.269
Yeah, exactly.
1173
00:58:31.469 --> 00:58:34.949
Anyway, we like to recommend some things that are usually
1174
00:58:35.010 --> 00:58:37.369
unrelated to our topic at hand, which will be the
1175
00:58:37.409 --> 00:58:40.030
theme today. But after we get through some credits, we're
1176
00:58:40.050 --> 00:58:41.940
going to get the recommendations. And it's very fun. I've
1177
00:58:41.980 --> 00:58:43.860
even thought that maybe we do a whole episode where
1178
00:58:43.880 --> 00:58:46.980
we just do recommendations because it's that much fun. You're
1179
00:58:47.000 --> 00:58:49.820
here for this, so let's do some
recommendations for today.
1180
00:58:49.900 --> 00:58:52.119
But first, I would like to tell you, if you'd
1181
00:58:52.139 --> 00:58:54.440
like to support us, we have a few more episodes
1182
00:58:54.480 --> 00:58:56.360
coming out, so we definitely could use your support if
1183
00:58:56.389 --> 00:58:58.349
you'd like to. You can leave us a rating and
1184
00:58:58.369 --> 00:59:00.869
a review, like, subscribe, or tell a friend. All of
1185
00:59:00.889 --> 00:59:04.190
that helps the algorithm reach more people. And while we're
1186
00:59:04.210 --> 00:59:06.230
trying to reach more people, that's a great thing for us.
1187
00:59:06.329 --> 00:59:08.969
So we appreciate your willingness to go out and do
1188
00:59:09.030 --> 00:59:12.590
that thing. We are almost at 500 episodes. That doesn't
1189
00:59:12.610 --> 00:59:14.849
even include the minis that we've been releasing. So if
1190
00:59:14.889 --> 00:59:16.449
you would like to go back and check out some
1191
00:59:16.489 --> 00:59:18.349
of our past work, there's lots of stuff out there
1192
00:59:18.369 --> 00:59:20.070
that we are quite proud of that we have made.
1193
00:59:20.670 --> 00:59:22.360
And that will be up at least for a while.
1194
00:59:22.389 --> 00:59:24.420
I don't know when these things go away, but our
1195
00:59:24.460 --> 00:59:26.739
distribution service that we are maintaining is going to be
1196
00:59:26.760 --> 00:59:29.000
paid for a while. So it'll stick around at least
1197
00:59:29.019 --> 00:59:31.329
for a bit. Yeah. Otherwise, you can support us again
1198
00:59:31.789 --> 00:59:33.409
for a little time that we've got going on. You
1199
00:59:33.429 --> 00:59:35.110
can join us on Patreon. If you do that, you
1200
00:59:35.130 --> 00:59:37.880
get early episodes, ad free episodes, and I will read
1201
00:59:37.909 --> 00:59:39.960
your name in the list of our supporters. at the
1202
00:59:40.019 --> 00:59:42.010
end of each of our discussions. So I'd like to
1203
00:59:42.050 --> 00:59:45.489
do a giant shout out and thank you to Mike M, Megan,
1204
00:59:45.570 --> 00:59:49.969
Mike T, Justin, Kim, Brad, Stephanie, Brian, Kiara, and Charlie.
1205
00:59:50.050 --> 00:59:53.010
Thank you all so much for having been with us
1206
00:59:53.030 --> 00:59:55.590
this whole time, helping us be a podcast, doing your thing.
1207
00:59:55.650 --> 00:59:56.829
You are the best.
1208
00:59:57.170 --> 00:59:57.969
We love you so much.
1209
00:59:58.489 --> 01:00:00.480
Also, I need a team of people to help me
1210
01:00:00.519 --> 01:00:03.199
make this podcast, writing and fact-checking from Shane and myself.
1211
01:00:03.219 --> 01:00:04.800
Thank you for recording with me today, Shane.
1212
01:00:05.139 --> 01:00:06.360
Yeah, of course. Thank you for having me.
1213
01:00:06.619 --> 01:00:11.219
Our social media coordinator is Emma Wilson and our producer, engineer,
1214
01:00:11.440 --> 01:00:15.849
recording technician, almighty God Emperor Penguin is Justin, who is
1215
01:00:15.889 --> 01:00:16.389
the best.
1216
01:00:17.030 --> 01:00:18.150
Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful.
1217
01:00:18.590 --> 01:00:21.650
And of course, thank you all for listening because we
1218
01:00:21.869 --> 01:00:24.269
need an audience to be a podcast. But I think
1219
01:00:24.289 --> 01:00:25.750
that is what we have to say for credits before
1220
01:00:25.789 --> 01:00:27.530
we get to recommendations. Am I missing anything?
1221
01:00:27.550 --> 01:00:29.079
I don't think so. I think you covered it.
1222
01:00:29.530 --> 01:00:42.449
Let's recommend some stuff. recommendations. All right. I'm recommending this
1223
01:00:42.510 --> 01:00:45.340
is a soft recommend, which means like I recommend it
1224
01:00:45.949 --> 01:00:49.219
more or less, but with some caveats. So this is
1225
01:00:49.900 --> 01:00:54.219
a TV show on HGTV called the scariest house in America.
1226
01:00:54.239 --> 01:00:57.260
It's hosted by Retta. Essentially what they do is they
1227
01:00:57.500 --> 01:01:00.380
pick a few regions around the country and they drive around.
1228
01:01:00.440 --> 01:01:03.159
People submit to have their houses feature. They sort through
1229
01:01:03.179 --> 01:01:05.300
all their applications and they go and they pick out
1230
01:01:05.860 --> 01:01:10.239
five houses per region. And then they explore those houses,
1231
01:01:10.380 --> 01:01:13.340
and then eventually they decide on one house per region
1232
01:01:13.500 --> 01:01:15.949
for each of the five regions. And then they select
1233
01:01:16.070 --> 01:01:19.050
one of those houses of the five finalists to receive
1234
01:01:19.090 --> 01:01:21.309
a $ 150, 000 renovation.
1235
01:01:21.730 --> 01:01:22.010
Okay.
1236
01:01:22.289 --> 01:01:24.409
This was, as far as I can tell, sort of
1237
01:01:24.449 --> 01:01:27.050
a spinoff show off of one called Ugliest House in America.
1238
01:01:27.820 --> 01:01:30.280
And the scariest house is a lot more themed around
1239
01:01:30.300 --> 01:01:34.099
houses that are very old, usually have a history with
1240
01:01:34.139 --> 01:01:37.289
like people who have died there. And then reportedly by
1241
01:01:37.329 --> 01:01:40.409
the occupants, the house is haunted. And man, do they
1242
01:01:40.469 --> 01:01:44.380
lean into that in a very unnecessary way. So I
1243
01:01:44.679 --> 01:01:48.360
am really not a fan of people taking ghosts very seriously.
1244
01:01:48.639 --> 01:01:48.889
Sure.
1245
01:01:48.929 --> 01:01:51.929
Doing it for fun and like being silly, perfectly good
1246
01:01:51.949 --> 01:01:54.090
with that. But these are like, they seem to be
1247
01:01:54.230 --> 01:01:58.489
leaning into this for the hamminess of it all. And it's,
1248
01:01:58.989 --> 01:02:03.050
I just find it a little disingenuine, I guess is
1249
01:02:03.070 --> 01:02:04.179
maybe the word I'd use for it.
1250
01:02:04.320 --> 01:02:04.579
Yeah.
1251
01:02:04.780 --> 01:02:07.119
But the show itself
is still really fun. Like essentially
1252
01:02:07.179 --> 01:02:11.119
like they explore all these wonky, crazy houses and then they,
1253
01:02:11.969 --> 01:02:13.619
go in and they do this renovation where they make
1254
01:02:13.659 --> 01:02:15.219
it look all nice and they fix a bunch of
1255
01:02:15.239 --> 01:02:17.239
stuff that's broken and they help a family out. And
1256
01:02:17.300 --> 01:02:22.000
because it's like, it's basically like $ 150, 000 prize, like some
1257
01:02:22.039 --> 01:02:24.750
families really get a boost that they could use, which
1258
01:02:24.789 --> 01:02:26.829
I appreciate. So, and it's, you know, one of those
1259
01:02:26.929 --> 01:02:30.210
HGTV shows. So it's, it's always well done in that way. Yeah.
1260
01:02:30.230 --> 01:02:32.190
So anyway, it's, it's a fun show. Like I said,
1261
01:02:32.230 --> 01:02:33.590
I don't love that they lean so hard on the
1262
01:02:33.630 --> 01:02:36.380
ghosts thing, but the scariest house in America is a
1263
01:02:36.409 --> 01:02:40.150
really fun renovation show anyway. So I recommend checking that out.
1264
01:02:40.190 --> 01:02:42.659
I know a lot of it's streaming on HBO at
1265
01:02:42.699 --> 01:02:43.699
the time of our recording this.
1266
01:02:44.159 --> 01:02:44.340
Yeah.
1267
01:02:44.579 --> 01:02:44.800
Nice.
1268
01:02:44.940 --> 01:02:46.519
I like it. I like it. I mean, I do
1269
01:02:46.559 --> 01:02:49.619
like some spooky things, so that's fun. Sure. Yeah. All right.
1270
01:02:49.639 --> 01:02:51.739
I'm going to recommend a book. Speaking of like behavior
1271
01:02:51.760 --> 01:02:54.019
analysis and kind of like the advancement of stuff, this
1272
01:02:54.079 --> 01:02:56.989
book is called Carry Your Heart, Indigenous Helping Wisdom and
1273
01:02:57.010 --> 01:03:01.789
the Science of Psychological Flexibility written by Dr. Louis Bush. Wow.
1274
01:03:01.829 --> 01:03:07.269
He is a Canadian behavior analyst and psychologist, psychotherapist. This
1275
01:03:07.309 --> 01:03:10.940
is his bio. Oh, Louis Bush is a bear clan
1276
01:03:10.980 --> 01:03:14.099
member of the Cree nation. It's the, um, this is
1277
01:03:14.139 --> 01:03:17.280
why is seek. I believe is how it's pronounced. Cree nation,
1278
01:03:17.400 --> 01:03:20.789
a registered psychotherapist and behavioral scientist. He actually studied and
1279
01:03:20.809 --> 01:03:24.469
did a residency at Harvard, uh, Where Skinner was working
1280
01:03:24.710 --> 01:03:27.489
and as part of like a behavior analysis program. So
1281
01:03:27.550 --> 01:03:31.639
the book is this really cool melding of indigenous knowledge
1282
01:03:31.780 --> 01:03:35.300
and experience and psychological flexibility and act and what that
1283
01:03:35.320 --> 01:03:38.059
all looks like together. And this is one of the
1284
01:03:38.099 --> 01:03:39.340
most impactful books I've ever read.
1285
01:03:39.699 --> 01:03:39.900
Wow.
1286
01:03:40.099 --> 01:03:42.480
And I'm not saying that because I know Louie personally.
1287
01:03:43.000 --> 01:03:45.480
It's one of those, I read it, I finished it yesterday.
1288
01:03:45.500 --> 01:03:48.849
He had me crying on the plane because so much
1289
01:03:48.889 --> 01:03:50.909
of it has to do with just connecting with who
1290
01:03:50.949 --> 01:03:54.070
you are and identity and culture and what that means
1291
01:03:54.329 --> 01:03:57.670
and indigenous knowledge systems and all this stuff. And so
1292
01:03:57.690 --> 01:04:00.179
I just strong recommend, if you are somebody who is
1293
01:04:00.199 --> 01:04:03.900
interested in ACT in particular, this is a great read
1294
01:04:04.320 --> 01:04:07.940
in that space. It's called Carry Your Heart, Indigenous Helping
1295
01:04:08.000 --> 01:04:10.659
Wisdom and the Science of Psychological Flexibility by Louis Bush.
1296
01:04:10.840 --> 01:04:14.570
And it's his debut book and it is unbelievable. So
1297
01:04:15.309 --> 01:04:16.550
I recommend everybody check it out.
1298
01:04:17.000 --> 01:04:18.940
I'm very glad you went last because I would not
1299
01:04:18.980 --> 01:04:20.590
want to follow that recommendation.
1300
01:04:20.840 --> 01:04:21.590
It's hard, right?
1301
01:04:22.170 --> 01:04:24.869
All right. So, Scariest House in America TV show. You
1302
01:04:24.889 --> 01:04:28.750
can disregard that. Carry Your Heart by Lewis Bush is
1303
01:04:28.809 --> 01:04:31.190
the book that you're recommending. Anyway, if you'd like to
1304
01:04:31.210 --> 01:04:33.090
tell us your thoughts on what we've said about Skinner
1305
01:04:33.110 --> 01:04:36.030
so far, you can email us directly at info at WWD,
1306
01:04:36.280 --> 01:04:40.000
WWD podcast.com, or reach us on the social media platforms.
1307
01:04:40.079 --> 01:04:41.980
And we do look forward to hearing from you. I've
1308
01:04:42.000 --> 01:04:44.679
been a little bit more attentive to blue sky lately.
1309
01:04:44.780 --> 01:04:46.980
So if you're on there, it's possible you will stumble
1310
01:04:47.039 --> 01:04:49.409
upon me while I'm also on there. Anyway, I think
1311
01:04:49.429 --> 01:04:50.869
that's what we have to say about our topic for now.
1312
01:04:50.909 --> 01:04:52.449
Is there anything that you'd like to add or that
1313
01:04:52.469 --> 01:04:53.690
I missed before we say our goodbyes?
1314
01:04:54.050 --> 01:04:55.369
No, I think that covers it. All right.
1315
01:04:55.389 --> 01:04:57.239
Thank you all so much for listening. This is Abraham.
1316
01:04:57.510 --> 01:04:58.019
And this is Shane.
1317
01:04:58.440 --> 01:04:58.719
We're out.
1318
01:04:59.019 --> 01:04:59.230
See ya.
1319
01:05:00.219 --> 01:05:02.400
You've been listening to Why We Do What We Do.
1320
01:05:02.920 --> 01:05:05.570
You can learn more about this and other episodes by
1321
01:05:05.610 --> 01:05:11.389
going to www.wwdpodcast.com. Thanks for listening, and we hope you
1322
01:05:11.409 --> 01:05:11.969
have an awesome day.