TRANSCRIPT 🔗
David Vernon: welcome back to What's the Theory Sara and I thought it'd be really interesting to talk about what's the theory behind working from home. we've done a couple of posts on LinkedIn recently that have got quite explosive responses but also some understandable ones. So we thought why not make a podcast out of it and actually discuss it. Sara and I have have been in previous roles in different agencies and in-house brands over the years. Now we run an our own agency, so we know what it's like to be owners and be in that position. So I think we've got quite a diverse perspective on like the working from home. I think in particular because
Sara Kavanagh: Mm.
David Vernon: when you're an employee, you know, e everyone stands together, don't they? And they're like, Right, we should have this, we should have these benefits, we should be able to do this. And and I feel like as we've gone into ownership, we've kept those principles. We've not gone like really
Sara Kavanagh: in.
David Vernon: strict that some owners do and go, no, now it's my business and I care about it more. I'm gonna
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: make everyone sit in a hot sweaty office all day and like make sure down to the T they do it every hour possible
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: and I felt like we've kept our values quite consistent throughout. so we've got a couple of opinions on working from home ourselves. But where do you want to get started, Sara?
Sara Kavanagh: Well, I guess since we're in the middle of a heatwave, might as well start with that one. I think that was kind of the crux and the thing that sets it all off is that we've seen quite a lot of different approaches when it comes to how businesses are approaching the heatwave. you know, you've seen articles from the BBC, what's appropriate to wear during a heatwave when you're in a professional setting, like all of this stuff. And in the last two heatwaves, I did some surveys on LinkedIn to see. well, what do business owners think about this and what do actually the employees think about this? It's very interesting to see that a lot of business owners said basically they're saying you don't have to travel to office, but you have to work as normal. There were some that were saying super flexi hours, which is something that we did. So if it's too hot during the day, just do some work early in the morning and then the rest of it in the evening when it cools down, whatever's easiest for you. And then there was three people that just said no change, everything's as normal. And I was kind of like, okay, fair enough. And then from the employee side, a lot of them were saying that their employees essentially haven't made any changes and they were really struggling. So it's really interesting to see that I had employers that were like, yeah, we're doing all these super flexy or you don't have to come to the office apart from the three that were like, no changes. But then there were a few employees that were saying, you know, when it came to their survey, a lot of them were kind of like, I still have to do things as normal. No one's even questioned it or thought about it. So it's interesting to see that. know David, you've got a few stories of people who have had horror stories of this. But I think that was the thing that for me was like, if you can't even look at things in a heat wave, because I know there are laws around if it's too cold in the office, can only, you have to like go home. There's a certain temperature or something like that. But there isn't anything about max office space, I think, if it's like.
David Vernon: Mm.
Sara Kavanagh: you just, know, same with schools, you just kind of have to deal with it. But I think there comes a point where it's a bit irresponsible to just assume everyone has to pretend things are as normal. So I'm curious to hear your thoughts and stories on this topic.
David Vernon: Yeah. Well, the I I think the heat waves exposed like a a quite a large problem in the UK, especially with rising temperatures every
Sara Kavanagh: Mm.
David Vernon: single year. It feels like every single year now, in a lot of cases, it's getting warmer and warmer. And the UK famously doesn't have air conditioning anywhere. And that that also
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: includes the commute, right? So not
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: everyone, believe it or not, has aircon in their car. not everyone not every place has aircon in shops or buses or trains. Obviously if you ride a bike it's even worse because you're exercising so you're exert like exhausting yourself. and
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: I think what I've seen throughout this year's heat wave is is is a bit of an outcry for a lot of change in UK and business owners' perception on like what is an acceptable level of temperature to be working in. And I understand
Sara Kavanagh: Mmm.
David Vernon: that you know, we we've got an economy that we need to keep going. We've got a obviously, you know, it it's already hard. We need people to be working, but at the same time, we all need to live and operate in safe temperatures. I think the the worst case scenario, and I think most people in the UK to be fair, work in offices, in an office environment where there is no air conditioning. And I got a text from an ex colleague of mine. I won't name him but He sent me pictures of him literally drenched in sweat and this was at like what lunchtime I think it was. So he sent me those these WhatsApp
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yeah, it was something like that.
David Vernon: images and I asked him, I was like, as if you're being asked to go into work today. Like, have you raised with your employer that like you're you're too hot, you're sweating, you're overheating, you can't work comfortably? And he was like, Yeah, he'd my boss just told me to take a shower 'cause he had a shower facility at the office So he'd
Sara Kavanagh: God.
David Vernon: so what he's been doing is every
Load full transcript
hour jumping in the shower, putting it on cold, and then coming out and rinse and repeating that process. And that's that's what he was sending me images of and being like, This is ridiculous. And that went on
Sara Kavanagh: Mmm.
David Vernon: for such a long time. and and I think the grey area is that I think in the UK there's not really like any specific employment laws per se around the safe working conditions. So theoretically speaking, even if it was fifty five degrees Celsius, which would be ridiculous, inside of an office space, there's no employment law preventing the employee from, you know, working from home. So I think that needs to change in regards to the heat wave. But I think businesses who have adapted to a flexible working policy going back on the working from home debate, have
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: have absolutely won this year because people have been able
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: to be comfortable in their own homes. You know, you can literally s sit in your underwear if you want to, you know, in work
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: or like, you know, you've got a paddling pool outside and you've got a fan on you and you don't feel embarrassed because you're sweating loads and I think those with great flexibility policies have got the best out of their employees. So I think from a performance and happiness
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: perspective it it works wonders there. I just don't understand how businesses haven't adapted post COVID anyway.
Sara Kavanagh: Well, that's an interesting point to raise because I think to us, because we allow super flexible, we are pretty much fully remote, except if you do want to go to the office, which people have the option of doing. I think a lot of businesses have adapted and they do have flexible working,
David Vernon: Hm.
Sara Kavanagh: but it's like, is it flexible working? Because it's still enforced, say, three days in the office. So you still have to come in on specific days. It's more hybrid working in that sense. And it isn't like still flexible working. So as an example, you still have a lot of, yes, you can work from home two days a week, but I expect you three days in the office and you actually have to be in during these specific hours. So you have like set hours. You can't even just come in when you want to. It's still set hours. And I found that with a lot of those businesses, there's a lot of that mentality of, we've got a really cool office. It's got air conditioning. you should come to the office more often. But reality is we basically forked out a ton of cash and we want to get a return on investment is what it really is. But does working in an office actually increase productivity? And I think that's the theory that we're trying to kind of unpack today. has, you you and I, we've worked in full-time in office, you we're pre-COVID people, we have had done full office. We have done COVID where it's fully remote. We have done hybrid working.
We've done the two days in office or two days at home, sorry, three days in office. We've done basically all the different combinations. And now that we're also managing all these different combinations and have managed in previous roles, we've had different, you know, employees with different kinds of ways of working. What can we actually really say about productivity? Because I would argue that our stance on it versus other potentially employers might be different and to kind of set the scene, my previous role. And that wasn't the only role we've had. I've had a few roles where essentially the stance was that Teams calls, Google calls, online talking to each other, ruins communication, ruins productivity, and ultimately client work suffers. And there was a big push for not allowing online calls, coming to the office as much as possible and If you left the office at the time that you were meant to leave, so say I came in at eight, if I left at four or four thirty, but I still had a lot of work to do, you would get told off because the thinking was, well, if you've got work to do, why are you leaving? You should be in the office finishing your work. So that was the sense of productivity. Now, I have a slightly different view on that, but I'd be keen to hear because obviously same as me, you've done all the different roles and managed different types of people. Do you think that productivity and communication suffers when people work from home?
David Vernon: When it comes to productivity and communication, no. I think it it's it's actually the opposite. I think productivity and commun well, productivity in particular increases I think quite substantially when there
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: is work in when people are working remote and that's for a number of reasons. You know, one you you wake up if you've got the right flexibility policy of course, you wake up with enough sleep so you don't have to rush out the door and get somewhere on time. And let's say I
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: dunno, you start work at ten AM versus the standard,
Sara Kavanagh: Mm-hmm.
David Vernon: you know, half eight, nine o'clock in the morning at an office which in reality you'd have to wake up at eight AM to then commute in. I think because of that reason people are more productive but also if there is that flexibility allowed, people work around their current lifestyle, which in turn makes them happier and more productive. I think where
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: there's a disadvantage to working from home and I think it is really the only disadvantage is probably like culture. And when I say culture I mean things like, you know, togetherness and feeling
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: connected and like a group and and and f and
Sara Kavanagh: Amen.
David Vernon: and feeling a a better sense of purpose. And I think those things
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: can also still exist in a a fully remote business, right? If you're doing
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: regular Teams calls and you're messaging each other, yes that can still exist. But I do think
Sara Kavanagh: Thank you.
David Vernon: the culture is more powerful in the office. Is it a reason to
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: make people and force people to go into the office? Absolutely not. Culture is absolutely vital to any business
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: and I think giving people the freedoms of choice is the right
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: approach because People will come into the office if that facility is available, those who want to, right? And those
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah,
David Vernon: who can't or aren't going at the minute will either just not go because they need they they want to maintain that working from home, that's their lifestyle. Or they'll get a fear
Sara Kavanagh: Mm-hmm.
David Vernon: of missing out and just just go anyway and and join those
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: little moments in the office. But I've found that when I am working in the office There are too many distractions and same same could be said with home, but I have my own like private office at at at home. I think a lot of people do nowadays.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, they do, yeah.
David Vernon: but in the office there's, you know, the gossip and you know, what did you do
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: last night? And the conversations that are a bit like
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yeah.
David Vernon: you're not bothered about having, which I guess is where the culture part comes in. But I always find
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: I get distracted and I don't end up doing anywhere near as enough work as I I usually do
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah,
David Vernon: at home.
Sara Kavanagh: yeah, definitely. And that's something that I'm really bad for, because when I'm in office, I just end up talking to someone. I don't get
David Vernon: Yeah.
Sara Kavanagh: anything done. I just chat to everybody or I book all my meetings on the day I'm in the office so that if I've got, one to ones or anything like that, we can do it in person, which is, I guess, what I would use my office day for. But I think what's been interesting, and again, I did a survey on this. We did a survey internally with our team, but also a few LinkedIn ones. And it was just more to ask, you know, if you had a choice, what would you prefer? And it was very interesting to see millennials, pretty much every single millennial said they like flexibility. So they would like to still work in office, but choose their days. So essentially, if I feel like coming in, I will come in. If I don't show up for three weeks, also nobody will care. Gens,
David Vernon: Yeah, hybrid. Yeah.
Sara Kavanagh: yeah, basically, but super flexi-hybrid, not like... set roles hybrid.
David Vernon: Yeah.
Sara Kavanagh: Jen's head, interestingly enough, Jen said a lot of them, and we saw this, we've got one Jen said, I'm gonna call out Henry here, sorry, anonymous
survey, but we know who you are. Henry, and then to be fair, a lot of people on LinkedIn of that younger generation were pretty vocal that they actually would like to go to office full time because they're missing that culture, it's harder for them to connect online. which I suppose I get, but I think because I'm pre-COVID, I've worked in an office full time and I have experience going in every single day and having those really rigid rules of you have to be there every day. And I don't look back on it fondly if I'm being completely honest. have a lot of, you know, there are a lot of times where I went in, but I know if I could have stayed home that day, one, I would have probably gotten a lot more done. This was always the worst around deadlines. Because the minute I went into the office, if you put your headphones on because you wanted to focus, you were seen as rude because people would
David Vernon: Mm.
Sara Kavanagh: want to talk to you and chat to you, but you were like, don't talk to me. I've got a deadline. And you were just seen as rude because you weren't, you know, conversing with everybody. But then equally, I couldn't ask to stay home and do my work because I had a deadline and I wanted to focus. So it was just like a really, really hard toss up. Whereas now we have the ability. to be able to choose that. And I think that's what's so difficult that I think Genza didn't get to experience almost and see, at least in like an office environment, because you do have jobs where you are at work every day, warehouses and shops, whatever it might be. But that's been something that's been interesting to see is their perception of what working in an office is. And
David Vernon: Mm.
Sara Kavanagh: I do agree. I think that element of togetherness and the gossip and all of that stuff. It's really kind of like, it's easier to do in person. But equally, when we did our survey, a lot of the team were saying that actually they find that they can just as easily message each other. know, I mean, we even have that, we'll have like a chat for literally just random crap where people will put in the dumbest questions you can think of and just start the most random conversations. I think a lot of people that are maybe younger aren't as comfortable doing that. I don't know. I don't know. What do you think is the reason for that?
David Vernon: Yeah, I it is a strange one because I would have expected like Gen Z to be
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: like, yeah, fully remote. I want to be home and like watch memes on my Instagram. but it is the complete
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: opposite which which surprises me. And I I think it probably comes down to the fact that they've never like experienced the working environment much. Or, you know, those
Sara Kavanagh: Mmm... yeah.
David Vernon: who are just coming into work, that was their expectation from like a young age that they'd be going into an office with a shirt and a tie and all
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: of these things. And and perhaps once they experience that properly they will then turn
Sara Kavanagh: Mm-hmm.
David Vernon: into, yeah, I'm paying an extra three hundred pounds a month just to commute in and,
Sara Kavanagh: Mm-hmm.
David Vernon: you know, the office sucks. You know, because not everyone has a great office. Like some companies have
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, no, that's true.
David Vernon: amazing offices. I think I think agencies in particular will have like really flashy offices and perks. But I've worked
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: at some places where you have to show up with a shirt and tie and all the girls have to wear tights and skirts and and and you've got these fluorescent lights above your head with a slight
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: buzz to them and then you've got some guy called Gary who's been there for fifty fucking years who's pouring himself the worst cup of coffee you've ever tasted in your life
Sara Kavanagh: Mmm.
David Vernon: and you just think this can't be my life and I th I think it's just a lack of experience in in
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: those areas. but, you know, when I put I put a post out on LinkedIn and I I titled it, you know, Let me finally put the working fr from home debate to bed. And I
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yeah.
David Vernon: just basically put my opinion on working from home, which is, you know, just give people the option to either come into the office or not and what whatever happens, happens. one
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: of the one of the comments 'cause a lot of a lot of it was in support, but one of the comments was, Well, so do you still pay for an office? business rates and all the overheads that go with it, even if the office is entirely empty? Or do you opt to just not have an office at all and keep
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: the profits and give the team a raise?
Sara Kavanagh: interesting question. I mean, it's a it's a valid question. But like I said at the start, a lot of businesses ask you to come to the office because they pay a lot for fancy office. So they want to get their money's worth out of you as mean as that sounds. That is the truth. So I do I do understand the question. It's a valid question. What do you think?
David Vernon: I I think, you know, yes, that's that there's a cost to an office. You know, you've got business rates, you've got the rent, you've got the service charges, the insurances and things like that. But I think
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: giving people the best of both worlds is always the way to go and that's just that's a business cost to me. And I think there are many ways
Sara Kavanagh: I'm ready.
David Vernon: now that you can actually optimize that so you don't actually have in you know have a giant bill for an office that's barely used.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah,
David Vernon: And that's called
Sara Kavanagh: yeah.
David Vernon: shared spaces. something we've done from
the get go at Search Theory
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: is that we got shared offices. So one is on Deansgate, very prestigious place. We've took clients there, we've booked out meeting rooms. They they a lot of them think we pay an absolute fortune for it. The reality is it's like three, four hundred pounds a month. it's the
Sara Kavanagh: Mm-hmm.
David Vernon: same with the office down in Cheltenham. Did I say that right? I didn't Okay, okay, I'm really
Sara Kavanagh: You did, you did.
David Vernon: I butcher it so much. But it's the same with that. Like we pay when we use it and we can have the
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: space when we use it. And I think there are alternative ways to look at it. Like I understand if you have, you know, a five year lease that's seven several thousand pounds a month, it's gonna be tough. But
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: I still do believe that if you got to the point where you've already got that office, you've probably got a big enough team that half at least half of the people will still come in because they want to and that
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: will be better than half of the team being upset because they're forced to work from home and half of the team being upset because you know they don't get to work from home because you f you you're
Sara Kavanagh: Hmm.
David Vernon: punishing them because you pay so much for rates. So I think my opinion on that is you've got to understand what the market wants and I think at the minute the market wants hybrid by and large. And so I think
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: given both options and given freedoms is where you'll get the best talent and there are many ways to optimise the cost for it if you're not already tied down to a lease. And even if you are, I still think your office g is gonna get used. I very much highly doubt it's gonna be empty.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, and to be fair, I've worked for a place like that and it was empty. Half of it was empty, but think half of it was the owner just wanting everybody in on the time
David Vernon: Mm.
Sara Kavanagh: and he got the biggest office space possible in the building. And it was just a bit silly because he got the space and I would get angry that people wanted to work from home sometimes and didn't want to be there every single day because he came in all the time and it was like, great, but you love it and you live around the corner. But some of us travel over an hour to get in. Some of us have children. We need to have flexible work. It just wasn't what he thought it was. So I think one of the things that I found interesting, and I see this a lot on LinkedIn as well as you do, is that there is a mix of those old... I don't want to sound sexist and ageist here, but it is older men who just expect everybody to be in the office all the time, or
David Vernon: Literally.
Sara Kavanagh: women who just... They don't have anything else to do, so they just want their team there all the time. But a lot of us do have families, we do have other things to do. And the reality is no employee is going to be as passionate about your business as the business owner is. No one's going to love search theory more than me and you ever will. Because
David Vernon: Hm.
Sara Kavanagh: it's our business, we built it, we're responsible for it, we have to sit and deal with taxes for it, that's our thing. I would never expect an employee to want to come in all the time because they love search theory so much. I would actually think it's a bit, like I would question are they okay if they felt that way? It's not normal. You cannot be that passionate. So I think, I don't know. I just think there's an expectation of this like cause an online world is ruining the work. isn't, I really don't think it is. I think people work in different ways and expecting your product, your services. to get better just because you have everybody in the office five days a week or three days a week. I just think that's a bit of a, there's a deeper issue that you need to look under it and it isn't people working from home.
David Vernon: Yeah, I I completely agree because, you know, we've we've experienced that firsthand. We've had periods of time where I think me and you in the same business where we were renovating an office and everyone had to go remote for the for two, three months. and then when they were back in the office for three days a week, I wouldn't say there was any significant statistical performance issues, spikes or downfalls from either of the
Sara Kavanagh: No. No. No.
David Vernon: two. Like peop at the end of the day, people just got their work done to a high standard on time.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: And we never had an issue with delivery when working remote or working in the office. And I think s
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: in a lot of the cases it was that some people fell behind because they were in the office so much and they were chatting away. And so they would have to delay that
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: work or go home and do it later that night. I've done that many times before where I'm like, God,
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, same.
David Vernon: it's five PM and I I haven't done what I'm supposed to do, so I'm gonna have to go home and do work.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: in addition to that, I think, you know a lot of business owners who have been in business for a very long time, you can understand that, you know, yes, they're in the business and they pay probably pay themselves a way above average wage. And understanding that is key because
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: my cost to go into the office full time and park in Manchester City Centre, if I was going five days a week right now, would be four hundred and fifty pounds a month in parking fees. And then I would probably be tempted to buy lunch at expensive places in the
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: city because
why not? I'm just there. I'm I you know, I can't be bothered to make it at home because I'm having to get up so early. And so the additional cost and strain that it puts on employees, I feel like founders and and business owners need to recognise more because at the moment people are struggling to find an extra one hundred pounds a month in the pay
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: slip, let alone three, four, five hundred. so
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yeah.
David Vernon: I feel like you need to be in touch with where people's finances are as well as where their heads are at. Because for for some
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: it's just not possible. And I've
Sara Kavanagh: None.
David Vernon: I've had in previous businesses that I've been at, I've had employees resent the business and res absolutely resent their job because they have to go in every day. And I've seen, you know, they've pulled up the phone and said, This is my monthly cost for the train, for my lunch. foot and and this is just because you want me in the office when I can work from home. I've had people confront me with that before where it's not my decision to let them work fully remote and and
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yes, I'm, yeah.
David Vernon: it's staggering and you go, Okay, well your costs are two hundred a month and then the the counter argument is, well everyone else is paying for it and stuff and then they're like, Well yeah,
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: I get paid two thousand pounds a month and after all my bills I'm left with two hundred quid So where do you expect
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: me to find the extra money to go on holiday and actually book a holiday or you know, buy
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: food or account for inflation and you know, hearing those stories and being in touch with your employees is so important and so many people aren't.
Sara Kavanagh: they're not. And I think that kind of, I think what I really struggled and this was something that you and I talked about as well as it wasn't until I actually worked at, well, to be fair, I think it was our last job where we met and then one years and years and years ago where I had flexible working as in whenever I came in, as long as I did the seven, seven and a half hours, depending on how you run your business. then I could go home. But I have had a job where it was literally you had set hours so could, they gave you a sense of illusion that you get to pick because it was like you can come in at 8 30 or 9 which which window do you want to choose? It was literally like that I kid you not you had to choose a window.
David Vernon: My God.
Sara Kavanagh: And it was like you had to come in, come in during your window right and if you didn't come in during your window you would get a text message like are you late today? Are you coming in today? They had to come in during your window and then if you finished during your window but you still had work to do, it was massively frowned upon because it was like, what do mean you're going home to finish your work? And it's like, I want to go home and eat my frickin' dinner and then I can finish the work, that's fine, but can I just go home, see my family, eat a dinner and just maybe it'll be easier for me to finish my work in the evening when I've had time to like unwind. And I think one thing I find interesting about how we're doing things here is that I don't really care how the, like, I don't care when you do your work. As long as you're contactable during work hours and you show up to meetings and calls, if you're doing your work at 10 PM, that is none of my business unless you literally are that stacked, in which case it is my business. But if it, if it is just a case of during the day, I couldn't focus, I don't do great during the daytime, but in the evening, because I'm a night owl. I'll get everything done 10 times faster. Then who am I to question that? As long as it's there for the deadline, I don't think it really matters that much. And I think the argument I always had whenever I raised this and I would say to my boss and say, look, does it matter when they do their work as long as it's done on time? His answer was always, well, are they actually doing the work? Are they actually doing the work? And it was like, genuinely, it was like, are they actually doing the work? I think they're just abusing the the fact that they can work from home and abusing that they can leave on time, literally abusing that you can leave on time because you you're allowed to leave on time. And my answer to that is yes, people will abuse it but I think it's pretty easy to spot it because the work isn't turned in on time then I know you're not working in which case you are abusing the policy so you will not be working here for much longer. But what does it matter what time people do the work? I just don't think I ever understood that.
David Vernon: No, I d I don't either as well because, you know, at the end of the day people have if you're a good manager, people will have like KPIs and they will know
Sara Kavanagh: Mm. Yeah.
David Vernon: where they're heading and what they need to do to achieve their goals. And they'll have the daily, monthly, weekly work schedule, which will be usually in a system. So, you know, the simple answer is is that if someone is abusing that system, it will show up in that KPI. If they're abusing it
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, definitely.
David Vernon: and they're meeting all their KPIs, who gives a fuck? No one gives a fuck.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: Like Like I I mean I I did a search on Reddit like for the worst habits that people have when working from home. And I think the sooner
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: you get over these as like a owner, manager, whatever, the better. And and and we all
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: do this. Everyone's guilty of this. Scrolling on their phone, you know, doom scrolling
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: on
Instagram, sending reels, you know, people not changing out of their sleep clothes. I think th the funniest one I've got here is I wake up at 8 59 and start at 9. Like y you know, ever or or just
Sara Kavanagh: nice impressive
David Vernon: working from your sofa or working from your bed or or doing your washing like at 2 PM. You
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: know, everyone does those things and that's that's the beauty of it. Like you are genuinely most employees are gonna save two hours in their work in their work day by not commuting, and so they're gonna fill that stuff with other bits in between. But at the end of the day.
Sara Kavanagh: Mm.
David Vernon: The work gets done, who gives a shit what they do outside of that? We don't own people. They're not slaves. Like I don't understand that either.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. No, I mean, it's to be honest, the argument I've heard, you know, I've had that conversation before. The argument literally was, well, I paid them for seven hours a day. So I expect them at their desk for seven hours a day. And it's just like, OK, but you know, like it got to a point where I was like, do we need to log time for going to the toilet? Is that what you'd like to see that we look?
David Vernon: Yeah, it's
Sara Kavanagh: It's just not normal. And I think I understand the whole we pay for X amount of time. Yes, they are being paid for X amount of time. But realistically, again, you're actually paying them to do a job. So if they've done the job and they've done the work, does it matter if they spent six and a half hours doing it instead of seven and that they did all of it at different times? Like, does it actually matter? I think. You know, there are things where we have to remain professional, like, let's be real, don't show up in your pajamas to a client call, that's just obnoxious. You know, be responsive. I think we as an agency, we have KPIs and SLIs where we say to everybody that during work hours, if we know that you've clocked in or you're online, you are expected to respond within 10 to 15 minutes unless you're on a call, in which case respond after your call. So we do have those expectations. But we always make that very clear and say, like, you get to have really flexible working, but here are also our rules around it. So you will respond, you will, you know, you are going to go on calls, you are going to do emails. Like if I see that you haven't responded to something for a very long time, I am going to assume that you're just pissing about, which isn't okay if you do have stuff to do. But also I'm not going to be mad if someone's filling their dishwasher. between writing freaking landing pages. Like if that's what helps you focus, who am I to judge? I
David Vernon: For sure.
Sara Kavanagh: send you memes in the middle of the day sometimes. So happens.
David Vernon: Yeah, we're all guilty of it.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, it happens. Like it does genuinely happen. And I think there is that kind
of weird stance of just, you know, we have to do this or we have to do that. And I think it's interesting how people perceive it that, I don't know. I have to be at my desk doing this and that. And it's really, like you said, it's so easy to spot if someone isn't doing work. Like it's so easy to spot. Like if the stands are crap, if the work isn't good, and that's what managers are for, to spot those things. And I think maybe that's where business owners don't trust their managers and they
David Vernon: Mm.
Sara Kavanagh: don't trust their leadership team. And they have problems with maybe micromanaging. I think a lot of business owners are really bad for micromanaging and sticking their beak into everything. And I think there comes a point as an owner where you need to step back, you need to trust your team.
David Vernon: Yeah, and also like, you know, when you know, we we work on computers all day. I think it's very clear that, you know, if you are using a computer, I think the I I don't know what body it is, but the government recommends that every hour you have a five to ten micro break. You know, five to ten
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yeah.
David Vernon: minute micro break. And so, you know, people will take advantage of that. But th you know, when you're in your when you're in the office, no one's doing that. You know, no one's gonna do
Sara Kavanagh: No.
David Vernon: it because they feel guilty or they feel like they're being watched like,
Sara Kavanagh: Mmm.
David Vernon: you know, or you've you've gone outside for a walk for 10 minutes. Where were you? What were
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: you doing? And that's that's the kind of attitude that is in a lot of business at the moment. And so people
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: feel guilty. I I mean especially me like when w you know several years ago when I when I moved to Manchester and I I started working for an agency because I tried out a a couple before I landed at a long term longer term business but we had clocking cards So every time we
Sara Kavanagh: no.
David Vernon: every time we went into the office we'd have to swipe. Every time we exited we would have to swipe.
Sara Kavanagh: No.
David Vernon: And so I went on my lunch break once and, you know, swiped out. We've got thirty minutes and I and I I walked to it's near the social chain offices of Portland Road, I think it was, and and got a meal
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
David Vernon: deal. And then I I sat outside 'cause it was a sunny day and I ate my lunch. And I come back and I clocked back in. Not thinking about it, I was as quick as I could be. And the operations manager came up to me and was like, You took thirty one minutes instead of th instead of thirty. Like you've got to make sure you Yeah, and you've gotta make sure that you've gotta be here at least like one to two minutes early so you don't go over the clock. She said, Because if I keep doing it, they'll start docking my wages for for micr like the minutes that I were late. And they did that for like start
Sara Kavanagh: God.
David Vernon: times and finish times as well. But they weren't they the
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, I've heard that.
David Vernon: They didn't pull you up when you would do three hours overtime. They wouldn't turn round and go, well done, good job. And and and that yeah. You know, I
Sara Kavanagh: No, no, Here's extra money for your overtime.
David Vernon: and I would always say, Well, I've done like fifteen hours overtime this month and you're kicking my ass over one minute. And I think that kind of behaviour in work when forcing people to be in the office and be on time and be so stringent will create resentment that will have the opposite effect of what you're trying to do. So if you're trying to get
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: people to be more productive by getting them to come on the dot on time and absolutely be
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: in the office five days a week, you will find yourself in the opposite camp of employers aren't productive, they hate your guts, and they're looking for a new job as soon as possible.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: And you're gonna have to pay more for recruiters, you're gonna have to pay
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: more to train someone up, and you're just gonna have a bunch of unhappy people who think you're an absolute cunt. So I I
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, and who could blame them, but like genuinely. You know what, you've said it, and actually I do remember I was managing a team of 12 and they had their windows and I once got told by my boss that I need to speak to my team that when their start window, it 9 o'clock for example, that means they've already made their coffee. They've already sorted themselves out and are actually sitting out there just working at nine, which means they need to get to the office 15 minutes earlier to start their day so that they're working at nine o'clock. And I was just, I remember just sitting there like, that is, that is insane. Like it's very fascist. Why are we being so fascist about a 15 minute window of when you've made your coffee? Like, does it matter? Does it really genuinely like, what is that 15 minutes going to save you? Nothing.
David Vernon: Yeah, my my first boomer boss has said said said that to me. If you're not fifteen minutes early, fifteen minutes I've heard that everyone's heard that at one point. It's so ridiculous.
Sara Kavanagh: I like I grew up with a dad who whose logic was if you're on time, you're late. So I've always been early to everything because it was just ingrained
David Vernon: Yeah.
Sara Kavanagh: in me from when I was little that if you're on time, you're late. So that's like, it's just like a different thing. But I feel like at work, we're policing people that much, it's just a bit crazy. And like you said, we don't track the overtime. So all the time where people actually put in more. hours. And one thing I find interesting, and I guess
this is my last point on all of this, in our kind of like survey, when we asked people that work from home, do you actually do more work or less work? Every single one of them said that I actually end up doing more work and going over my hours because I don't notice the time going by and maybe there needs to be better boundaries. think people do need to be better at switching off because it's hard to switch off at home, I think. but they do more work, they do go over time. So they kind of feel like if I'm given the flexibility and the trust and respect, then I actually end up doing more for the company without complaining about it if they just leave me alone and let me be. And I think that was really interesting. And to be fair, I do that as well. Like because I work from home, I'll end up doing more because I just don't notice the time or... I'll in the evening think of something that I actually let me just quickly do this while I'm thinking of it. And it does creep up on you, which I think is a whole host of other problems where people do need to put boundaries sometimes in place. But it
David Vernon: For sure.
Sara Kavanagh: is interesting, isn't it? Actually being at home, you will end up doing more for the company because you're not just bothered with clock watching.
David Vernon: Yeah, and and you can you have the freedom of choice to like, you know, live where you like, you know, so that means cheaper
Sara Kavanagh: mm-hmm yeah
David Vernon: areas. I got out of the city five years ago, pretty much this month. So I used to pay one thousand five hundred and fifty pound a month for a a two bed apartment, which was still small. And
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: the council tax on that would be, you know, it was the higher band. So I'd I that would be like two hundred and something pounds a month. And I just remember
Sara Kavanagh: Mmm.
David Vernon: looking at my My and I was literally like five minute walk away from the office. So that was the benefit, right? It was like, I can get to the
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah. Yeah.
David Vernon: office easy. And this was back when five days a week was like there was no working from home, pretty much. It was very
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah, yeah, Yeah.
David Vernon: rare. And and that for me was just soul destroying seeing that money just go away. So when I got
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: out of the city and and bought my own home, which I'm thinking I'm a 35-minute drive away from Manchester right now, it was such a relief being able to work remotely. Because my living cost went down by like four or five times and my happiness
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: went up massively because I didn't have to
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: sit, you know, like dr worry about commuting in and I could work from home even though I was a
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: little bit further away. So I think it does open up opportunities for employees and I think
Sara Kavanagh: us.
David Vernon: in this market, ha especially with how competitive it is, I think we can attract the best talent in the world by having the best flexibility pol policy. Because no one's getting good talent on five days a week, trust me. No one.
Sara Kavanagh: No, no, it's not the time and it's like you said, it opens up the opportunity. Like I live in the middle of nowhere and I can, you know, I can live in the middle of nowhere. And if I were to need a job, I could get a job anywhere as long as they offer about working. And there's so many great people who would be excellent employees, but because they're stuck in say, you know, they might live in a little tiny town and their only opportunities are around them or they have to travel two hours. And it's, exhausting so then you're not getting the most out of them but actually giving them flexibility. They might only come to your office once or twice a month but you're getting a fantastic professional so why shouldn't we be open to that you know and just let people work from home and at least get great talent that we would have otherwise missed and I think that's a really really great point that a lot of companies are missing out on.
David Vernon: Absolutely. So I think we agree that Working from home is a must if you're able and it's
Sara Kavanagh: Mm.
David Vernon: a must if that employee isn't able to their employees. And you know the benefits of that is that you do get increased productivity by working from home. The slight negative is is the culture side, which can be fixed with a hybrid approach by giving people the option.
Sara Kavanagh: Yeah.
David Vernon: I think forcing them is not the way to go, giving the option is is is definitely the way.
Sara Kavanagh: No. Yeah.
David Vernon: so yeah, d does do any of the listeners agree with our opinion, let us know in the comments. also do do like and rate the podcast if you enjoy it. But that's mine and Sarah's views and breakdown on working from home and that's comes from decades of experience. You know, we're not newbies to this. So
Sara Kavanagh: No, no, from all sorts. We have done five days a week. We know what we're talking about.
David Vernon: Yeah. So yeah, thank thanks for watching and listening everyone and stay tuned for the next episode.