TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:07.479 --> 00:08.960
[SPEAKER_03]: Hello, and welcome to USVILITY.
00:09.080 --> 00:09.881
[SPEAKER_03]: I'm Katie Helper.
00:10.281 --> 00:10.881
[SPEAKER_10]: I'm Erin Mattay.
00:10.901 --> 00:12.002
[SPEAKER_10]: Thank you so much for being here.
00:12.102 --> 00:14.403
[SPEAKER_10]: Our website is USVILITYIt'sPodcast.com.
00:14.804 --> 00:17.365
[SPEAKER_10]: Go there to support the show and get bonus content.
00:18.146 --> 00:24.410
[SPEAKER_10]: This week, we take a look at the midterms where Democrats are looking pretty good.
00:25.230 --> 00:33.254
[SPEAKER_10]: especially because Trump has betrayed one of his key promises which was to have no new wars and to address the cost of living.
00:33.394 --> 00:34.814
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, Trump did the exact opposite.
00:34.854 --> 00:39.236
[SPEAKER_10]: He started a war which is driven out the cost of living, especially energy prices.
00:39.597 --> 00:43.578
[SPEAKER_10]: And so our Democrats seizing the range, are they seizing the anti-war mantle?
00:44.119 --> 00:52.702
[SPEAKER_10]: No, because Trump, to get out of this predicament of spiking energy prices because of his warning Ron, he's recently made a gas deal with
00:54.043 --> 01:02.631
[SPEAKER_10]: to claim he's bringing prices down and rather than just point out that Trump is only doing this to say face and this is because he's lost the anti-war lane.
01:03.612 --> 01:09.697
[SPEAKER_10]: Democrats are instead of accusing him once again to being a traitor to Russia and war monitoring with Russia again.
01:09.757 --> 01:12.419
[SPEAKER_10]: So we'll discuss that and hold up more with James Cardan.
01:13.060 --> 01:16.403
[SPEAKER_10]: Author of the new book, The Great Betrayal, how the Democrats became the party.
01:17.184 --> 01:17.864
[SPEAKER_10]: of war.
01:18.385 --> 01:21.468
[SPEAKER_10]: And then we'll speak to journalist and author, Kylie Chung.
01:22.049 --> 01:31.979
[SPEAKER_10]: She is author of the brand new book called Plane the Victim, how the powerful denying attacks her bivours of violence from domestic abuse to genocide.
01:32.439 --> 01:33.841
[SPEAKER_10]: Making the connection between
01:35.042 --> 01:39.405
[SPEAKER_10]: the tactics of domestic abusers and imperialism and Zionism.
01:39.445 --> 01:42.848
[SPEAKER_10]: It's really fascinating book and we get into that topic with her.
01:43.288 --> 01:48.232
[SPEAKER_10]: Before then, we do a weekly segment, recapping news of the week.
01:48.252 --> 01:49.353
[SPEAKER_10]: It's called the Friday Free Frol.
01:49.853 --> 01:51.495
[SPEAKER_10]: It is for our paid subscribers.
01:51.575 --> 01:53.736
[SPEAKER_10]: If you're a free subscriber, here's a preview.
01:56.358 --> 02:01.663
[SPEAKER_10]: The Trump administration says, don't worry, we're not going to bomb Iran before the midterms.
02:02.525 --> 02:04.407
[SPEAKER_10]: after the midterms is a different story.
02:04.467 --> 02:12.114
[SPEAKER_10]: But before the day when Republicans want your vote, we're not going to bomb because the bombing is so unpopular.
02:12.195 --> 02:13.616
[SPEAKER_10]: Afterwards, different story.
02:14.176 --> 02:22.765
[SPEAKER_10]: And someone, though, who can't contain his glee for resuming the bombing, and it's pretty much guaranteeing that it will resume is four to Senator Rexcott.
02:23.163 --> 02:26.708
[SPEAKER_12]: Iran is clearly their economy is decimated, but these people are crazy.
02:27.449 --> 02:32.617
[SPEAKER_12]: They wanted to destroy us, they wanted to destroy Jews, I mean they wanted to destroy Israel.
02:33.298 --> 02:36.783
[SPEAKER_12]: So unfortunately we're going to have to continue to fight until they don't have power.
02:37.925 --> 02:38.525
[SPEAKER_12]: It's frustrating.
02:39.115 --> 02:41.977
[SPEAKER_03]: Did he say they won destroyed us and Jews?
02:42.137 --> 02:44.058
[SPEAKER_03]: Is he now like an honorary Jew?
02:44.638 --> 02:52.403
[SPEAKER_10]: I guess so, and I guess the Jews of Iran who Israel bombed, when Israel literally bombed a synagogue inside Tehran, I guess they don't count.
02:52.964 --> 02:55.165
[SPEAKER_10]: I guess their last Jewish then Rick Scott thinks he is.
02:55.525 --> 02:59.508
[SPEAKER_03]: Exactly, right, yeah, tough love, tough love for the Jews and Iran.
02:59.992 --> 03:03.033
[SPEAKER_12]: We like war, but this prison is to the right thing to save America lives.
03:03.353 --> 03:08.555
[SPEAKER_12]: I'm very appreciative of what the Israeli defense force is done because it's going to save America lives.
03:09.375 --> 03:11.336
[SPEAKER_12]: So I got a lot of briefings while I was over there.
03:11.836 --> 03:15.197
[SPEAKER_12]: And while Iran's economy is decimated, it's going to take a while.
03:15.297 --> 03:18.579
[SPEAKER_12]: I mean, it's going to, you know, we're going to have to keep working at this to make sure.
03:18.739 --> 03:26.521
[SPEAKER_03]: Again, remember, they have nothing to say for America's pain, the pain of Americans, but don't worry, you're supposed to feel better because Iran is suffering.
03:26.741 --> 03:28.102
[SPEAKER_03]: And that's going to pay the bills somehow.
03:28.693 --> 03:32.616
[SPEAKER_12]: you know we're gonna have to keep working at this to make sure there's a regime change eventually.
03:33.357 --> 03:47.129
[SPEAKER_10]: Well there we have it uh sorry everyone the fights can have to go on because regime change hasn't been achieved and the irony there if I'm saying that you know this was done to protect American lives when on top of all the lives in Iran that will continue to be threatened by this war.
03:47.489 --> 03:50.212
[SPEAKER_10]: This will also threaten American lives because the people who have to
03:50.912 --> 04:15.831
[SPEAKER_10]: launch the regime change war, care at the regime change war, that Rick Scott advocates our American soldiers, working class American soldiers, who have already died, at least 17 of them, and Rick Scott is fading more to possible death and certainly to
Load full transcript
prolong suffering because it's working class people who bear the brunt of these wars, whether they're American soldiers or Ronnie and civilians.
04:16.467 --> 04:21.992
[SPEAKER_03]: But again, don't worry, guys, feel better because the death and destruction of Iran, it's so transparent.
04:22.533 --> 04:40.230
[SPEAKER_10]: All right, so along with admitting to and ongoing regime change work, and it's to Iran, another Republican talking point these days is to fear monger in an Islamic public way about Abdul Asayid, the Democratic Senate candidate in the Michigan, here's Ted Cruz.
04:40.867 --> 04:46.210
[SPEAKER_14]: I believe this man is Muslim Brotherhood, and I'll tell you, Sean, one of the most frightening things.
04:47.310 --> 04:51.432
[SPEAKER_14]: If he were to win, Senators don't undergo a security clearance.
04:51.532 --> 04:57.035
[SPEAKER_14]: By virtue of being elected to a constitutional office, you are deemed to have a security clearance.
04:57.755 --> 05:02.978
[SPEAKER_14]: Chuck Schumer could place Abdul al-Assayed on the Senate Intelligence Committee.
05:03.018 --> 05:08.020
[SPEAKER_14]: He would have access to the very highest level of classified materials, and I believed
05:09.881 --> 05:27.307
[SPEAKER_14]: there would be an unacceptably high risk that American service men and women, their lives would be endangered and that our covert intelligence assets, their lives would be endangered because there's every reason to believe Abdultsa Al-Sayed would share that classified information with Muslim brotherhood terrorists.
05:28.107 --> 05:53.997
[SPEAKER_10]: I mean, he's saying that I'm going to decide if he gets elected Senate is going to basically be a traitor and is going to knowingly help a U.S. enemy hurt U.S. service members and the irony of this on top of this being ludicrous because again we've gone to this like I'm going to decide has no ties to muscle brotherhood apparently his mother when she was in her 20s like as a student activist was like someone involved in a
05:54.657 --> 05:56.199
[SPEAKER_10]: most of my brotherhood organization.
05:56.359 --> 06:01.945
[SPEAKER_10]: It's a big organization inside Egypt where his family is from, but there's nothing to do with him.
06:02.405 --> 06:14.318
[SPEAKER_10]: On top of that, Ted Cruz, the guy who said that like, my job in Congress is to serve Israel, but basically, so if anyone has, you know, questionable and dangerous foreign ties, it's him.
06:14.811 --> 06:18.414
[SPEAKER_03]: Yeah, he even had a fight about that with Chuck or Carl Stranger member.
06:18.434 --> 06:26.742
[SPEAKER_03]: He tried to cite like religion and the Bible to justify basically ethnic cleansing in Palestine.
06:27.003 --> 06:28.224
[SPEAKER_03]: And he didn't even know how to cite it.
06:28.264 --> 06:29.185
[SPEAKER_03]: That was the other funny thing.
06:29.225 --> 06:33.449
[SPEAKER_03]: Like he didn't even know the real lines that he was claiming to be oriented by.
06:34.021 --> 06:36.583
[SPEAKER_14]: Growing up in Sunday's school, I was talking from the Bible.
06:36.743 --> 06:41.007
[SPEAKER_14]: Those who bless Israel will be blessed, and those who curse Israel will be cursed.
06:41.327 --> 06:44.130
[SPEAKER_14]: And from my perspective, I wanna be on the blessing side of thing.
06:44.750 --> 06:48.073
[SPEAKER_14]: Those who bless the government of Israel, those who bless Israel is what it says.
06:48.093 --> 06:50.035
[SPEAKER_14]: Don't say the government of it says the nation of Israel.
06:50.175 --> 06:53.237
[SPEAKER_14]: So that's in the Bible as a Christian, I believe that.
06:53.277 --> 06:53.778
[SPEAKER_14]: Where is that?
06:54.218 --> 06:54.999
[SPEAKER_14]: I can find it to you.
06:55.019 --> 06:57.321
[SPEAKER_14]: I don't have the the the scripture off the tip of mine.
06:57.922 --> 06:59.604
[SPEAKER_13]: You pull out the phone and use this in jail.
06:59.624 --> 07:00.285
[SPEAKER_13]: It's in Genesis.
07:00.445 --> 07:03.007
[SPEAKER_13]: So you're quoting a Bible phrase.
07:03.027 --> 07:03.808
[SPEAKER_13]: You don't have context for it.
07:03.828 --> 07:06.071
[SPEAKER_13]: You don't know where the Bible it is, but that's like ideology.
07:06.091 --> 07:06.731
[SPEAKER_13]: I'm confused.
07:06.991 --> 07:08.093
[SPEAKER_13]: What does that even mean?
07:08.593 --> 07:08.913
[SPEAKER_13]: Tucker.
07:09.114 --> 07:09.634
[SPEAKER_13]: I'm a Christian.
07:09.654 --> 07:10.795
[SPEAKER_13]: I want to know what you're talking about.
07:11.723 --> 07:14.345
[SPEAKER_14]: Where does my support for Israel come from, number one?
07:14.625 --> 07:17.047
[SPEAKER_14]: Because, biblically, we are commanded to support Israel.
07:17.067 --> 07:29.397
[SPEAKER_13]: But, number two, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no
07:31.295 --> 07:42.733
[SPEAKER_03]: And to access the rest of that Friday free for all where we get to see all the creative ways that Republicans, smear, I'm dual-alsaiad, and the liberal media says nothing about it, or kind of jumps on the bandwagon.
07:43.094 --> 07:45.578
[SPEAKER_03]: You can do that at usefuladidspodcast.com.
07:45.983 --> 07:47.684
[SPEAKER_10]: For this week's interview, we hear from two guests.
07:47.824 --> 07:49.325
[SPEAKER_10]: Up first is James Cardan.
07:49.766 --> 07:58.331
[SPEAKER_10]: He served as an advisor to the US Russia bilateral presidential commission and to the special representative for Intergovernmental Affairs at the State Department.
07:58.792 --> 08:03.435
[SPEAKER_10]: His latest book is The Great Betrayal, how the Democrats became the party of war.
08:08.838 --> 08:09.939
[SPEAKER_10]: James Cardan, thanks
for being here.
08:10.379 --> 08:11.000
[SPEAKER_10]: Sure, thanks.
08:11.913 --> 08:16.697
[SPEAKER_10]: The book is called The Great Betrayal, how the Democrats became the party of war.
08:17.298 --> 08:32.151
[SPEAKER_10]: Just come out, and it's great timing because right now at a time where Trump because of his failed regime change war on Iran, he's trying to kind of reclaim the anti-war mantle by talking about making peace with Russia.
08:32.611 --> 08:33.152
[SPEAKER_10]: And you're great.
08:33.833 --> 08:35.894
[SPEAKER_10]: And Democrats, rather than, you know,
08:37.255 --> 08:46.877
[SPEAKER_10]: uh, welcoming and end to a horrible conflict that's caused so much death and suffering, they're saying hold my beer and they're not pushing back on Trump for daring to talk to Russia.
08:46.917 --> 08:50.538
[SPEAKER_10]: Here, for example, is Senator Chris Murphy.
08:50.558 --> 08:58.840
[SPEAKER_09]: This is a pattern of behavior over the course of about a week that looks to be a strategy, a strategy to put Russia in the
08:59.861 --> 09:07.747
[SPEAKER_09]: most powerful position possible in order to gain a settlements a ceasefire that is on Russia's terms.
09:07.847 --> 09:09.368
[SPEAKER_09]: It's just absolutely devastating.
09:09.388 --> 09:10.349
[SPEAKER_09]: There's no reason for it.
09:10.669 --> 09:18.975
[SPEAKER_09]: Frankly, Ukraine was making really important gains on the battlefield over the course of the last year, not with standing Trump's refusal to help.
09:19.156 --> 09:27.062
[SPEAKER_09]: And I guess Putin is called in a favor using whatever leverage he has over the president and you're seeing the results of that in this series of decisions.
09:27.522 --> 09:29.565
[SPEAKER_10]: Okay, there's so many great things in that clip.
09:30.066 --> 09:32.369
[SPEAKER_10]: There's a callback to Putin having leverage over Trump.
09:32.729 --> 09:35.293
[SPEAKER_10]: He claims that Ukraine was winning on the battlefield.
09:35.393 --> 09:36.554
[SPEAKER_10]: I don't know where he got that from.
09:36.695 --> 09:39.719
[SPEAKER_10]: But overall, what do you make of what Trump is now doing?
09:39.839 --> 09:42.583
[SPEAKER_10]: Trying to make a deal with Russia easing some sanctions.
09:43.724 --> 09:44.746
[SPEAKER_10]: And the Democrats response.
09:45.745 --> 10:05.530
[SPEAKER_08]: The clip from Murphy sort of highlights or illustrates the depth of his non-understanding about what's going on on the ground between Russia and Ukraine, but it also demonstrates his great non-understanding about Trump's motives.
10:06.030 --> 10:12.932
[SPEAKER_08]: So he said something along the lines that Trump's strategy is to put Russia in the most powerful position possible.
10:13.512 --> 10:18.055
[SPEAKER_08]: has nothing to do with Russia, has nothing to do with Ukraine, it has everything to do with the midterm elections.
10:18.836 --> 10:30.604
[SPEAKER_08]: This diesel deal that they're all up in arms about is a transparent foil on the part of Trump to pretend that he cares about the people who vote in them into office.
10:31.344 --> 10:42.392
[SPEAKER_08]: So again, this is nothing to do with Zelensky, is nothing to do with his Trump's proclivities towards oligarchs and the authoritarian's
10:43.773 --> 10:57.506
[SPEAKER_08]: And the like, it has everything to do with Trump trying to make a last minute appeal to the working class voters in this country who he abandoned over the last two years.
10:57.846 --> 11:00.129
[SPEAKER_08]: So Murphy is usual has it dead wrong.
11:00.882 --> 11:08.988
[SPEAKER_10]: And what's amazing is rather than just make that point like and focus on the fact that Trump has put himself in a perilous position by launching a regime change war on Iran.
11:09.368 --> 11:15.232
[SPEAKER_10]: And by betraying his promise to his own voters when Trump said no new wars and the Democrats are the party war.
11:15.513 --> 11:22.778
[SPEAKER_10]: And rather than really focusing on that, it's like Democrats can't accept the victory there and they're trying to reclaim the pro-war mantle.
11:23.338 --> 11:33.523
[SPEAKER_10]: by again encouraging a Bellicose policy when it comes to the Ukraine proxy where he's talking about Ukraine was winning on the battlefield and our Trump is undermining them.
11:33.563 --> 11:35.324
[SPEAKER_10]: I mean, what do you make of that?
11:35.344 --> 11:38.105
[SPEAKER_10]: This claim that Ukraine was winning on the battlefield until Trump came along?
11:38.726 --> 11:40.687
[SPEAKER_08]: Well, it's under nonsense.
11:40.727 --> 11:40.967
[SPEAKER_08]: Again,
11:42.091 --> 12:01.915
[SPEAKER_08]: The usual measurement that people like Murphy and people in the mainstream media and Solence Gaze enables even among so-called progressive foreign policy thinkers is that Russia is losing because they haven't made territorial gains, right?
12:01.935 --> 12:03.936
[SPEAKER_08]: And that is true, they haven't.
12:04.596 --> 12:05.856
[SPEAKER_08]: However, that's not their strategy.
12:06.596 --> 12:09.157
[SPEAKER_08]: The strategy is to fight a war of attrition.
12:10.037 --> 12:21.481
[SPEAKER_08]: The strategy is to kill as many Ukrainian soldiers as possible, and then once they achieve that goal, the territorial gains will come.
12:21.801 --> 12:35.466
[SPEAKER_08]: But if you look at the war and you say, well, they've only captured 100 square miles over the past, whatever amount of months or years, therefore they're not making any progress.
12:36.046 --> 12:36.967
[SPEAKER_08]: That's the wrong metric.
12:37.691 --> 12:43.372
[SPEAKER_08]: The metric is the ratio of Ukrainian dead to Russian dead.
12:44.152 --> 13:00.355
[SPEAKER_08]: And I have a very good source who had lived in Ukraine, who understands what's happening there, who says that during the exchange of bodies, which happens every now and again, the ratio is something among the lines of 36 to one.
13:01.415 --> 13:04.236
[SPEAKER_08]: In other words, for every one Russian
dead,
13:08.648 --> 13:10.749
[SPEAKER_08]: So that's the wrong metric.
13:10.849 --> 13:12.050
[SPEAKER_08]: Territory is the wrong metric.
13:12.930 --> 13:15.152
[SPEAKER_08]: And they don't understand that where they don't want to understand it.
13:15.932 --> 13:20.615
[SPEAKER_10]: Let's turn to another prominent Democrat, one very influential on this whole war.
13:20.635 --> 13:21.435
[SPEAKER_10]: That's Jake Sullivan.
13:22.116 --> 13:23.977
[SPEAKER_10]: He was Biden's national security advisor.
13:24.597 --> 13:25.418
[SPEAKER_10]: He was basically,
13:26.705 --> 13:33.807
[SPEAKER_10]: at the helm of the Biden administration strategy, which entailed refusing to reach a deal with Russia that could have avoided the war.
13:34.387 --> 13:45.910
[SPEAKER_10]: And then after the war began, when Ukrainian and Russian officials sat down and negotiated their own deal, the Biden administration came along and told Zelensky, we're not going to back you up if you reached this deal.
13:46.150 --> 13:51.311
[SPEAKER_10]: The message was delivered infamously by British Prime Minister Boris Johnson, and now here we are.
13:51.571 --> 13:51.651
[SPEAKER_10]: And
13:55.592 --> 14:05.981
[SPEAKER_10]: the Biden administration support for the genocide in Gaza, and he still cultivated the self-image as his foreign policy genius when two of the world's worst crises in recent memory happened under his watch.
14:06.021 --> 14:13.108
[SPEAKER_10]: But anyway, here he is, recently speaking about what he sees as the viability of a peace deal with Putin.
14:13.860 --> 14:14.941
[SPEAKER_11]: alone for Putin.
14:15.482 --> 14:16.783
[SPEAKER_11]: We'd be in a different situation.
14:16.883 --> 14:21.867
[SPEAKER_11]: I think he doesn't just want the four O blasts, and I think he doesn't just want a neutral Ukraine.
14:22.127 --> 14:27.872
[SPEAKER_11]: He wants a neutered Ukraine, and he wants it neutered so that at some point he can come back in and take all of it.
14:28.333 --> 14:37.721
[SPEAKER_11]: So he wants a peace outcome, peace in quotes that will allow him ultimately to render Ukraine essentially a non viable entity.
14:37.761 --> 14:38.582
[SPEAKER_11]: I think that's his goal.
14:38.682 --> 14:38.962
[SPEAKER_02]: Okay.
14:39.042 --> 14:52.689
[SPEAKER_11]: And I think he needs to be denied that goal because I do think it is in the American National interest, not just to provide the support we're providing to Ukraine, but also to ensure that this kind of aggression cannot ultimately succeed.
14:52.990 --> 14:57.812
[SPEAKER_10]: Okay, so James, you're thought on his argument there about what he sees as Putin's goal.
14:57.852 --> 15:06.477
[SPEAKER_10]: And overall, I mean, how his worldview, as expressed in that clip, fits into evolution of democratic foreign policy thinking that you document in your book, The Great Petrape.
15:07.190 --> 15:13.972
[SPEAKER_08]: It's hard to know where to begin with such a fast-style analysis of Russian intentions.
15:15.332 --> 15:26.075
[SPEAKER_08]: I will say that Sullivan is not among their best thinkers, despite his very impressive pedigree.
15:26.875 --> 15:35.217
[SPEAKER_08]: In the book, I cite an interview that he did with the New Yorker's Susan Glasser while he was National Security Advisor.
15:36.037 --> 15:43.862
[SPEAKER_08]: And these are his words, and this is how he described his view of what is at stake in Ukraine.
15:44.242 --> 15:54.488
[SPEAKER_08]: He says, as a child of the 80s and rocky and red dawn, I believe in freedom fighters, and I believe in righteous causes, and I believe the Ukrainians have one.
15:55.658 --> 16:06.471
[SPEAKER_08]: Now, you know, if you were a high school history teacher, you would have flunked your student for writing or such a thing in a paper.
16:06.511 --> 16:14.540
[SPEAKER_08]: So that is about the level of solivins understanding of the crisis there.
16:15.021 --> 16:15.141
[SPEAKER_08]: And,
16:16.168 --> 16:23.833
[SPEAKER_08]: You know, Biden surrounded himself with people like Sullivan, like Blankin, who basically know nothing.
16:24.453 --> 16:25.073
[SPEAKER_08]: And it showed.
16:25.093 --> 16:29.956
[SPEAKER_10]: I might have been sure if he knows it, but you're about Rocky because Rocky is about a boxer.
16:30.376 --> 16:31.697
[SPEAKER_10]: I'm sorry about Freedom Fighter.
16:32.177 --> 16:35.459
[SPEAKER_10]: I mean, he's an underdog, so he's right, just cause it.
16:35.479 --> 16:44.144
[SPEAKER_10]: But he's not exactly like, you know, I think he's mixing up, mixing up his semester Sloan 80s movies, but and Red Dawn certainly is a movie about Freedom Fighters.
16:45.105 --> 17:00.799
[SPEAKER_10]: But that's, you know, fighting against, that's an insurgency against an occupier, and of course, jakes all of the solidarity for insurgency against occupiers didn't translate to Palestine, where he supports the occupier unconditionally and even supported given the weapons.
17:01.219 --> 17:01.419
[SPEAKER_10]: Sure.
17:01.439 --> 17:03.962
[SPEAKER_08]: Oh, nor did it, I mean,
17:05.065 --> 17:16.120
[SPEAKER_08]: Well, it's also the Rocky thing is so crazy because he clearly never saw the end of Rocky Four, where Rocky mixes speak speech, which is basically a plea for understanding.
17:17.242 --> 17:20.786
[SPEAKER_08]: between the two countries, if I can change, you can change, oh, that's right.
17:20.966 --> 17:30.156
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, hold on, like back up, because I for people who are familiar, Rocky and Rocky four, it's a big deal because he goes to fight, you know, the most intimidating fighter in the world who's from the Soviet Union.
17:30.576 --> 17:32.298
[SPEAKER_08]: Thought of Fwongerin's character, right?
17:32.398 --> 17:34.320
[SPEAKER_08]: And but in the end, they kiss and make up.
17:34.700 --> 17:38.545
[SPEAKER_08]: And that was, and that movie was issued at, you know, released at the height.
17:39.805 --> 17:50.649
[SPEAKER_08]: of the Cold War, and so Sullivan's
misunderstanding extends even to popular culture, but I guess these are the products that Harvard and Yale turn out.
17:51.249 --> 18:02.173
[SPEAKER_10]: Yeah, I don't know, yeah, and of course, you know, like missing from his description of Putin's goals were Putin only wants a neutered Ukraine, not a neutral one.
18:03.108 --> 18:07.211
[SPEAKER_10]: There was a deal on the table early on in the war that Ukraine negotiated itself.
18:08.132 --> 18:11.815
[SPEAKER_10]: And it wouldn't have left Ukraine neutered.
18:11.835 --> 18:17.379
[SPEAKER_10]: It would have just left Jake Sullivan and his friends about the ability to use Ukraine as a NATO bull work on Russia's borders.
18:17.399 --> 18:22.763
[SPEAKER_10]: That's what they mean by neutered, like not containing, I don't know, Tomahawk missiles to threaten Russia with.
18:23.164 --> 18:24.385
[SPEAKER_10]: I guess that's their definition of neutered.
18:24.405 --> 18:28.048
[SPEAKER_10]: But in terms of having their territory intact, with the exception of Crimea,
18:28.888 --> 18:41.334
[SPEAKER_10]: uh, having their people still alive, they would have had all that, but, but because it would have left Jake Sullivan and, and by partisan neocons without the ability to threaten Russia, that in their worldview means a Ukraine neutered.
18:41.918 --> 18:59.392
[SPEAKER_08]: Well, I also love, you know, you hear this from people like Sullivan, who are like corporate, you know, Democrats, but also you hear this from people like AOC and even the Senatorial candidate for Michigan, I'll say it is that if we end the war we're doing Russia a favor.
19:00.493 --> 19:05.337
[SPEAKER_08]: As if ending the war is going to somehow be a disservice.
19:06.305 --> 19:29.489
[SPEAKER_08]: to the Ukrainians who have possibly lost an entire generation of young men, and their cities are destroyed, their economies destroyed, and there's no happy future there, and the Europeans and us lie to their faces all the time by telling them that we're going to welcome you with open arms into the EU.
19:30.599 --> 19:32.160
[SPEAKER_08]: There's no future in which that happens.
19:32.921 --> 19:36.723
[SPEAKER_08]: So again, ending the war is a favor to Russia.
19:36.924 --> 19:38.064
[SPEAKER_08]: That's the talking point.
19:38.685 --> 19:48.132
[SPEAKER_08]: I think ending the war is a favor to the Ukrainians, especially to all those people who are now being dragged off the streets, put into buses and sent off to the front lines to die.
19:48.812 --> 19:54.076
[SPEAKER_08]: I mean, everyone should be working to solve this thing and end it and nobody is.
19:55.479 --> 20:04.103
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, and what's amazing is that even that thought that they just expressed is not allowed even in the progressive wing of the Democratic Party.
20:04.303 --> 20:05.243
[SPEAKER_10]: Correct.
20:05.603 --> 20:19.289
[SPEAKER_10]: So your book, and talking about the evolution of Democrats into being more hawks, sadly it's now no longer just a story about like liberals, you know, like people in the mold of Jake Sullivan and Hillary Clinton in that camp, but it's also Bernie Sanders
20:25.211 --> 20:37.977
[SPEAKER_10]: Progressive Democrats from the House for a brief moment four years ago in the fall 2022 around this time actually when they called for diplomacy with Russia Correct and Bernie Sanders said he opposed that and they were intimidated.
20:38.397 --> 20:42.179
[SPEAKER_10]: They were bullied into retracting their their call for diplomacy after 24 hours
20:43.215 --> 20:48.778
[SPEAKER_08]: They hung a very, very smart and good and decent staff for out to dry on that.
20:48.898 --> 20:50.679
[SPEAKER_08]: I remember that incident very well.
20:50.700 --> 20:53.121
[SPEAKER_08]: I won't say his name because I don't want to embarrass him.
20:54.001 --> 20:56.803
[SPEAKER_08]: But that was a disgraceful moment.
20:56.823 --> 21:05.488
[SPEAKER_08]: But one of many progressive foreign policy today, you can describe it this way.
21:06.449 --> 21:10.872
[SPEAKER_08]: They're all pretty good on the Israel, Gaza, Palestine
21:13.143 --> 21:18.686
[SPEAKER_08]: somewhat better on the forever wars and then really bad on everything else.
21:19.327 --> 21:28.292
[SPEAKER_08]: And the most pressing issue that we face, I think, as a country going forward, is whether or not we can develop
21:29.378 --> 21:36.679
[SPEAKER_08]: It kind of maturity to understand that the world has changed and that we aren't the global hedge demand.
21:37.019 --> 21:38.320
[SPEAKER_08]: We aren't and we shouldn't be.
21:38.780 --> 21:43.300
[SPEAKER_08]: And we need to be able to find our place within the multi-polar system.
21:44.141 --> 21:58.323
[SPEAKER_08]: But as long as we're saddled with elites, like Jake Sullivan or Bernie or the people who the geniuses who advise Bernie and AOC,
21:59.645 --> 22:12.508
[SPEAKER_08]: we're never going to get anywhere, and they fully embraced this new cold war division between the so-called democracies and the so-called acts of authoritarianist.
22:12.888 --> 22:14.388
[SPEAKER_08]: It's the new called war playbook.
22:15.288 --> 22:22.210
[SPEAKER_08]: And it's the playbook has been totally, it's gone totally unchanged since the days of Harry S. Truman.
22:22.430 --> 22:23.710
[SPEAKER_08]: And that's what I tried to demonstrate.
22:24.593 --> 22:25.053
[SPEAKER_08]: in the book.
22:25.513 --> 22:33.656
[SPEAKER_08]: And then during the Cold War, at least you had a debate, a real debate within the Democratic Party over American foreign policy.
22:34.357 --> 22:42.400
[SPEAKER_08]: You had people who lined up behind the Rooseveltian vision, and people who lined up behind what I call the Achesonian vision.
22:43.080 --> 22:48.682
[SPEAKER_08]: The Achesonians or Hawks, they embraced and built up the National Security State.
22:50.118 --> 22:58.241
[SPEAKER_08]: and the people who embraced the vision of Franklin Roosevelt, the post-war vision of Franklin Roosevelt,
and the Bellon on Roosevelt, and of JFK, I have RFK.
23:00.322 --> 23:07.285
[SPEAKER_08]: And at Martin Luther King, Jr., and Jesse Jackson later in the 80s, those voices have been all that science.
23:08.345 --> 23:12.167
[SPEAKER_08]: And so once we entered the post-Cold War era,
23:13.757 --> 23:18.119
[SPEAKER_08]: that was it, the hawks, the achesonians, the Jake Sullivan's a Hillary Clinton's.
23:18.579 --> 23:25.342
[SPEAKER_08]: One out, you can't really point to a prominent Rooseveltian within the Democratic Party.
23:26.242 --> 23:27.203
[SPEAKER_08]: That's active today.
23:27.263 --> 23:37.827
[SPEAKER_08]: Now, you could say that Jerry Brown and some respects, you know, would represent that way of thinking, you could say that Ambassador Chass Freeman does or Ambassador Matt Lock.
23:38.348 --> 23:38.488
[SPEAKER_08]: But,
23:39.369 --> 23:40.031
[SPEAKER_08]: outside of that.
23:40.572 --> 23:41.615
[SPEAKER_08]: There are precious few.
23:42.657 --> 23:48.652
[SPEAKER_08]: And I think that that lack of debate is a problem and that's why that that's why I wrote wrote the book.
23:49.468 --> 23:53.811
[SPEAKER_10]: And you're all talking about people who are now over the age of 80 years old, in the case of facts.
23:54.011 --> 24:09.203
[SPEAKER_10]: And Jack Matlock served a Republican president, the first George Bush, as his ambassador to the Soviet Union, Chass Friedman, and Chass Friedman's interesting, so for those who don't know of Chass Friedman's story, he was a storied U.S. diplomat, he was Nixon's interpreter.
24:10.023 --> 24:30.088
[SPEAKER_10]: when he went to China, and when Obama was elected, he appointed Chess Freeman to be the chair of the National Intelligence Council, and what happened was there was a freak out from the Israel lobby, because Chess Freeman advocated for the rights of Palestinians and the rights of self-determination, and for, and Obama pulled the plug on him.
24:30.773 --> 24:54.305
[SPEAKER_10]: And that was, I think, a really overlooked episode in the history for like the soul, the Democratic Party, when it comes to foreign policy, the fact that Obama cave to APEC so easily and shutting a very credentialed veteran U.S. diplomat, you know, he also served as as under secretary for defense under George Bush, so he had bipartisan credentials and Obama backed out under APEC pressure.
24:54.892 --> 24:55.573
[SPEAKER_08]: He certainly did.
24:56.453 --> 25:03.979
[SPEAKER_08]: There's a couple, and I recount that episode in the book, there's a similar episode that happened under President Carter.
25:05.200 --> 25:15.329
[SPEAKER_08]: President Carter, during his transition period, was considering under Secretary of State George Ball to become Secretary of State.
25:15.369 --> 25:22.315
[SPEAKER_08]: George Ball was served under the Kennedy and Johnson administrations, and he became known as the Devil's Advocate.
25:23.043 --> 25:36.085
[SPEAKER_08]: He was the guy within the highest councils of government who warned both Kennedy and Johnson against escalation in Vietnam, Carter to his everlasting discredit.
25:37.893 --> 25:50.458
[SPEAKER_08]: refused to put ball up for Secretary of State because he was afraid of the Israel lobby, because ball had written critically of US Israeli relations and a very famous article on Foreign Affairs.
25:51.239 --> 26:00.242
[SPEAKER_08]: And Carter knew that he was going to get a headache from people like Henry Scook Jackson and the rest of the Neocons, and he didn't put him up.
26:01.363 --> 26:03.143
[SPEAKER_08]: If you look at the Obama administration,
26:07.205 --> 26:14.468
[SPEAKER_08]: was who the Obama people actually embraced and did bring in to the highest councils of government.
26:15.068 --> 26:18.170
[SPEAKER_08]: And here I have in mind a gentleman by the name of John Brennan.
26:19.130 --> 26:28.074
[SPEAKER_08]: And John Brennan rose up through the ranks of the CIA because he attached himself to the co-tails of George Tenon.
26:29.774 --> 26:33.376
[SPEAKER_08]: And if you speak to people like John Kiryaku, who was a colleague,
26:34.295 --> 26:45.513
[SPEAKER_08]: of Brennan's in those early years and is no Brennan for something like 40 years, you will learn that Brennan did not command a lot of respect among his colleagues in the IC.
26:46.194 --> 26:46.595
[SPEAKER_08]: However,
26:48.056 --> 26:52.719
[SPEAKER_08]: He early on joined the Obama administration as a foreign policy advisor.
26:53.499 --> 26:57.441
[SPEAKER_08]: And once he was in, he was in, and they promoted him rapidly.
26:58.122 --> 27:06.546
[SPEAKER_08]: And so, you know, you have people like Freeman who were kept out and people like Brennan who were put in.
27:06.986 --> 27:14.871
[SPEAKER_08]: And that really tells the story or at least part of the story or an important part of the story of the Obama administration's foreign policy.
27:17.945 --> 27:26.008
[SPEAKER_10]: Injection weight loss drugs like GLP ones have become a growing craze, promoted by influencers, celebrities, and pharmaceutical companies.
27:26.328 --> 27:32.450
[SPEAKER_10]: But no one seems to really know the extent of the potentially harmful short and long-term side effects they may bring to the body.
27:32.770 --> 27:38.531
[SPEAKER_10]: So what if you're looking to lose weight, but not interested in those intense side effects or the painful weekly injections?
27:38.932 --> 27:43.053
[SPEAKER_10]: That's why doctors created a weight loss supplement that isn't a prescription GLP one.
27:43.613 --> 27:48.576
[SPEAKER_10]: It's our sponsor, Lean, and the results show it can positively affect your weight loss journey.
27:48.876 --> 27:57.121
[SPEAKER_10]: The studied ingredients in Lean have been shown to lower your blood sugar, burned fat by converting it into energy, and curb your appetite and cravings, so you're not as hungry.
27:57.821 --> 28:01.844
[SPEAKER_10]: But listen, Lean is not for the casual dieter with only a few pounds to lose.
28:02.424 --> 28:07.568
[SPEAKER_10]: The doctors of breakout nutrition created lean for frustrated dieters with 10 pounds or more to lose.
28:07.968 --> 28:13.332
[SPEAKER_10]: If you're frustrated with your weight loss journey, but not looking to inject potentially, sketchy substances into your body.
28:13.872 --> 28:15.233
[SPEAKER_10]: Lean could be a great choice for you.
28:15.554 --> 28:18.175
[SPEAKER_10]: Let's get you started with 20% off and free rush shipping.
28:18.636 --> 28:21.298
[SPEAKER_10]: So you can add lean to your healthy diet and exercise plan.
28:21.858 --> 28:25.941
[SPEAKER_10]: Visit TakeLine.com and enter a useful for your discount.
28:26.361 --> 28:29.744
[SPEAKER_10]: That's promo code useful at TakeLine.com.
28:32.405 --> 28:33.266
[SPEAKER_10]: Let's go to more clips.
28:33.666 --> 28:50.165
[SPEAKER_10]: Someone very influential in Democratic Foreign Policy, and that is Hillary Clinton with her thoughts on Trump now, easing some sanctions on Russia, making a diesel gas deal with Russia and overall slowing down some U.S. support for Ukraine.
28:52.132 --> 28:53.112
[SPEAKER_06]: So he's stick with puppet.
28:53.832 --> 28:55.653
[SPEAKER_06]: Anything like puppet and he is a puppet.
28:55.833 --> 28:58.433
[SPEAKER_06]: He's a willing Putin puppet to help Putin.
28:58.953 --> 29:01.454
[SPEAKER_06]: You know, Putin's not gonna stop with Ukraine.
29:01.734 --> 29:02.374
[SPEAKER_06]: Yeah.
29:02.694 --> 29:07.795
[SPEAKER_06]: And you know, I guess Trump has this idea that he wants to divide the world.
29:08.536 --> 29:10.176
[SPEAKER_06]: He gets the Western Hemisphere.
29:10.636 --> 29:15.037
[SPEAKER_06]: Putin gets Russian Europe and Xi Jinping gets the rest of the world.
29:16.017 --> 29:18.399
[SPEAKER_10]: So listen, she's been calling up a Putin puppet forever.
29:18.439 --> 29:26.945
[SPEAKER_10]: We all know where that went, that went into Reshigate, you know, you and I were in a small minority to call that out from the start, and I think we're proved pretty red on that one.
29:27.005 --> 29:39.395
[SPEAKER_10]: But on this talking point that she has now where Trump is okay with dividing up the world into spheres of influence, you know, like dividing up the world with Putin and Xi Jinping, that's actually a very common talking point now.
29:40.735 --> 29:49.681
[SPEAKER_10]: even on the progressive left where people think that like Trump is fine to see part of the world to other strong men, autocrat to he admirers.
29:49.701 --> 29:50.401
[SPEAKER_10]: We make a that one.
29:51.242 --> 30:04.950
[SPEAKER_08]: They might want to consult the maps of the joint commands across the American military, joint commands across the map of the world, because
30:06.458 --> 30:11.381
[SPEAKER_08]: There is one country that has divided up the world into different spheres.
30:12.142 --> 30:12.742
[SPEAKER_08]: It is ours.
30:13.623 --> 30:18.646
[SPEAKER_08]: And so we have a central command to look over the Middle East.
30:18.747 --> 30:20.328
[SPEAKER_08]: And we have an Indo-Pacific command.
30:21.128 --> 30:25.411
[SPEAKER_08]: And we have a Western hemispheric command.
30:26.452 --> 30:27.553
[SPEAKER_08]: And so we've done that.
30:29.164 --> 30:31.845
[SPEAKER_08]: And where are the only ones that are allowed to do that?
30:32.706 --> 30:39.431
[SPEAKER_08]: And no other great power is allowed to have a sphere of influence in their backyard except for us, of course.
30:40.712 --> 30:41.913
[SPEAKER_08]: And Hillary Clinton,
30:43.455 --> 31:01.142
[SPEAKER_08]: is actually, actually, she came out and said it that she was basically supportive of the Don Rowe doctrine, which is just an updated gloss on the Monroe doctrine, which is a classic statement of sphere of influence geopolitics.
31:04.530 --> 31:05.411
[SPEAKER_08]: we're allowed to do it.
31:05.672 --> 31:06.954
[SPEAKER_08]: No one else is allowed to do it.
31:07.855 --> 31:17.332
[SPEAKER_08]: And if someone else tries to do it, we're going to embark on a proxy war or a covert war or an all-out war.
31:17.826 --> 31:18.767
[SPEAKER_08]: in order to prevent that.
31:19.828 --> 31:22.370
[SPEAKER_08]: So the hypocrisy is astounding.
31:22.770 --> 31:33.320
[SPEAKER_08]: And the fact that she hasn't updated her talking points since the 2016 campaign points to a certain laziness, too.
31:33.420 --> 31:40.886
[SPEAKER_08]: It's not like Trump hasn't provided people a lot of other material and a lot of other avenues with which to criticize him, right?
31:41.547 --> 31:42.628
[SPEAKER_08]: So yeah.
31:42.908 --> 31:49.681
[SPEAKER_08]: And then you have someone like Cara Swisher who just nods and goes along with it because she doesn't know anything either.
31:50.883 --> 31:54.249
[SPEAKER_08]: But that's the state of the mainstream, you know, media in this country.
31:55.015 --> 32:08.402
[SPEAKER_10]: Yeah, well, that exactly, I think it's important to not just falter Hillary Clinton here, because she's been given still cart blanche to continue this whole Trump as Putin puppet line, because everybody bought into Russia get initially, so nobody wants to admit defeat.
32:09.182 --> 32:17.307
[SPEAKER_10]: So even though she foisted upon liberals, the dumbest conspiracy theory of all time, that was so disastrous and so self-defeating,
32:17.847 --> 32:30.356
[SPEAKER_10]: for so many reasons, channeling Trump positions into a like a dumb conspiracy theory that served Hillary's narrative that it was Russia's fault, not hers that she lost because everybody into that nobody wants to still tell the emperor that they have no close.
32:30.616 --> 32:36.840
[SPEAKER_10]: And so this, this like Trump is putting puppet thing still persists and no, there's no accountability for it whatsoever.
32:37.421 --> 32:45.546
[SPEAKER_10]: Certainly, no return publishers by the near times and watching and post who gave themselves the Pulitzer for being stenographers for the Hillary
32:46.895 --> 32:47.155
[SPEAKER_08]: Right.
32:47.816 --> 32:51.658
[SPEAKER_08]: And why aren't they going down more fruitful avenues?
32:51.998 --> 33:02.564
[SPEAKER_08]: I mean, you know, he's clearly in the second term made himself the most corrupt president that we've ever had and may ever have.
33:04.285 --> 33:10.409
[SPEAKER_08]: Why isn't he being criticized for his field T to a foreign nation?
33:15.202 --> 33:15.442
[SPEAKER_08]: Right?
33:16.442 --> 33:26.925
[SPEAKER_08]: Why aren't people up in arms about him appointing an Asian of Israeli influence his son-in-law as his chief envoy?
33:27.926 --> 33:28.246
[SPEAKER_08]: Why?
33:28.606 --> 33:37.268
[SPEAKER_08]: I mean, there are so many where were these people when he was overthrowing quite illegally the government of Venezuela?
33:38.669 --> 33:39.529
[SPEAKER_08]: Where are they going to
33:44.798 --> 33:51.767
[SPEAKER_08]: You know, it's absurd, but they are stuck.
33:53.028 --> 33:57.814
[SPEAKER_08]: They are stuck reading from this cold war playbook.
33:58.631 --> 34:26.151
[SPEAKER_08]: and it dovetails nicely with this new obsession among the Democratic Farm Policy Elite over this so-called axis of authoritarianism that we as the great democracies and the great light of the world have to fight a global cold world over to what end and it's really depressing that outside of voices like yours and a couple of other people we know no one speaks up about it on the left
34:30.012 --> 34:44.381
[SPEAKER_08]: I don't know why, but even among you, no, there's a whole complex, I know you know this, in Washington, that you could put under the moniker of realism and restraint incorporated.
34:44.801 --> 34:50.625
[SPEAKER_08]: And it's a constellation of think tanks, they try to be transpartisan by partisan, whatever,
34:59.416 --> 35:15.041
[SPEAKER_08]: But once you get beyond the Israel Gaza Middle East issue, almost every single one of them, with the exception of maybe a three or four guys over at Quincy, they are all on board with this new Cold War program.
35:17.622 --> 35:18.762
[SPEAKER_08]: That isn't restraint.
35:19.382 --> 35:21.183
[SPEAKER_08]: That isn't anti-anterventionism.
35:21.723 --> 35:26.905
[SPEAKER_08]: If you think that we have to somehow serve as the exemplar,
35:29.139 --> 35:32.241
[SPEAKER_08]: to these great nations, these great civilizations.
35:33.241 --> 35:33.681
[SPEAKER_08]: I don't get it.
35:34.702 --> 35:49.570
[SPEAKER_08]: I could be missing something, but I just don't understand how that falls under the umbrella of anti-anterventionism when you insist that the Russians, the Chinese, the Iranians, have to emulate us.
35:49.850 --> 35:52.852
[SPEAKER_08]: Like emulation has become kind of the core demand.
35:53.929 --> 36:04.418
[SPEAKER_08]: of the progressive foreign policy elite that's in my view but you're more in touch I think with that that side anyway but it might missing something here.
36:04.931 --> 36:10.714
[SPEAKER_10]: No, no, I mean, and that's when you start getting into
these convoluted arguments where you'll hear it off in the line.
36:10.734 --> 36:12.915
[SPEAKER_10]: Like, we can hold two truths at the same time.
36:12.975 --> 36:15.936
[SPEAKER_10]: We can both oppose the military industrial complex.
36:15.956 --> 36:25.861
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, also enriching it when we have to to fight authoritarians and aggressors like Putin, that's basically like the Bernie Sanders camp line that like, yeah.
36:26.261 --> 36:31.424
[SPEAKER_10]: We asked for a favor of a piece of diplomacy, and we, we don't support the military or so complex.
36:31.464 --> 36:36.307
[SPEAKER_10]: But let's go ahead and give the military to the complex $100 billion, and ignore, and this is the key part.
36:36.667 --> 36:39.769
[SPEAKER_10]: They always ignore all the diplomatic opportunities that are available.
36:39.809 --> 36:45.832
[SPEAKER_10]: So for example, who, and the progressive foreign policy circuit, the more established one?
36:46.673 --> 36:49.154
[SPEAKER_10]: Who in the Democratic Party has ever talked about what happened in Istanbul?
36:49.394 --> 36:50.315
[SPEAKER_10]: Where there was a piece deal.
36:51.703 --> 36:53.044
[SPEAKER_10]: Almost almost a girl.
36:53.124 --> 37:05.941
[SPEAKER_10]: No one talks about it because that undermines the whole narrative required to paint as Hillary Clinton did Vladimir Putin as this irredeemable dictator that you can't just Negotiate with because he's always gonna want to go and invade more countries
37:06.545 --> 37:14.252
[SPEAKER_08]: And by the way, I hear that argument fairly often, as well, that you can walk and chew gum at the same time.
37:14.552 --> 37:17.755
[SPEAKER_08]: Well, maybe on an individual basis, that's true.
37:18.115 --> 37:21.939
[SPEAKER_08]: I've seen very, very little evidence at the United States government has that ability.
37:22.679 --> 37:32.928
[SPEAKER_08]: And all you have to do is consider the presidency of say, Lyndon Bange Johnson, to see that that's not the case.
37:34.132 --> 37:37.617
[SPEAKER_08]: that you can't have guns and butter at the same time.
37:39.199 --> 37:48.271
[SPEAKER_08]: And all you have to really, if you look at Johnson, what happened to the great society and the, that all got the rail because of you, not a president,
37:49.340 --> 37:54.725
[SPEAKER_08]: can't even weather a personal scandal and still keep things really running on track.
37:55.205 --> 38:09.617
[SPEAKER_08]: Look at the Clinton foreign policy, as he was dealing with Lewinsky and impeachment, and how that affected his presidency and the foreign policy of that administration.
38:09.977 --> 38:16.443
[SPEAKER_08]: So you hear that a lot about having the ability to walk at you come at the same time.
38:18.296 --> 38:24.297
[SPEAKER_08]: Show me a case where that's actually been true and really they can't.
38:25.138 --> 38:26.818
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, since you mentioned Bill Clinton, let's go to him.
38:27.198 --> 38:32.059
[SPEAKER_10]: He recently commented on
Trump making nice in his view with Putin.
38:33.019 --> 38:37.980
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm tired of the way we treat our allies like dirt.
38:38.080 --> 38:40.861
[SPEAKER_00]: And now just this last week.
38:42.237 --> 38:52.222
[SPEAKER_00]: President Trump has finally done what he's threatened to do when he ran the first time, which is to abandon Ukraine and replace what I'm recruiting all over again.
38:52.802 --> 38:58.145
[SPEAKER_10]: James, you heard there, Bill Clinton complain about Trump treating our allies like dirt.
38:59.066 --> 39:03.468
[SPEAKER_10]: And in light of what you know of Bill Clinton's own presidency, what do you make of that critique?
39:04.348 --> 39:06.990
[SPEAKER_08]: Well, I thought the clip was going to end after he said I'm tired.
39:10.295 --> 39:10.855
[SPEAKER_08]: He went on.
39:11.616 --> 39:24.188
[SPEAKER_08]: Bill Clinton's administration is responsible for much of the turmoil that we are dealing with today in Russia and Ukraine.
39:24.308 --> 39:32.436
[SPEAKER_08]: For no strategic or moral reason, he decided within 24 months of the fall of the Soviet Union to expand NATO.
39:33.857 --> 39:44.728
[SPEAKER_08]: That set off a chain of events that led us directly to the Civil War and Ukraine that began in 2014 and then the Russian invasion in 2022.
39:45.809 --> 39:54.398
[SPEAKER_08]: Clinton's foreign policy record, where three guard to the former Soviet space, is utterly disastrous.
39:56.537 --> 40:13.336
[SPEAKER_08]: You know, the goal for him to even speak out on Russia policy is quite a stand and given given given the horrible record that his administration had in the region.
40:14.245 --> 40:18.709
[SPEAKER_10]: And for me, like, the goal also to complain about badly treating an ally.
40:18.749 --> 40:20.410
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, how did he treat Boris Yeltsin?
40:20.871 --> 40:24.273
[SPEAKER_10]: They made fun of Boris Yeltsin behind his back because Yeltsin was a drunkard.
40:25.054 --> 40:28.897
[SPEAKER_10]: And Clinton bullied him when Yeltsin complained about NATO expansion.
40:29.898 --> 40:31.179
[SPEAKER_10]: He was mocked.
40:31.620 --> 40:38.346
[SPEAKER_10]: There's even an anecdote that Stroke Talbot to Relay Stroke Talbot was Clinton's deputy secretary of state.
40:38.947 --> 40:53.741
[SPEAKER_10]: And you know, I learned this from our mutual friend, the late Stephen F. Cohen, you know, the great Russia scholar, where Cohen would write about what Talbot said about him and Clinton's discussions about how they would joke about, they would shove excrement.
40:54.563 --> 41:02.269
[SPEAKER_10]: Metaphorically, figuratively, and Yeltson's face, and they joked about this because they kept basically ignoring him whenever he would complain.
41:02.329 --> 41:07.153
[SPEAKER_10]: So it's very rich to me that Bill Clinton would complain about treating an ally badly.
41:07.193 --> 41:12.517
[SPEAKER_10]: While, of course, they also pushed shock therapy that helped really decimate Russia's economy.
41:12.537 --> 41:13.578
[SPEAKER_10]: It's post-Soviet economy.
41:13.598 --> 41:15.059
[SPEAKER_10]: A lot of people fell in the deprivation.
41:16.000 --> 41:20.564
[SPEAKER_10]: That was how Clinton treated his supposed ally, his new ally in Moscow.
41:21.365 --> 41:37.399
[SPEAKER_08]: Well, yeah, and there's an interest, there's, I go a little bit in my book into a kind of under-appreciated or unknown episode during the Clinton administration.
41:37.439 --> 41:48.689
[SPEAKER_08]: And that is that Clinton, instead of listening to people like Steve Cohen and Bill Bradley and others, he ignored their advice.
41:50.447 --> 41:57.491
[SPEAKER_08]: and became very close and very influenced by a certain elder statesman at the time.
41:57.771 --> 42:11.719
[SPEAKER_08]: So close, in fact, that this elder statesman would stay over at the White House and Clinton and this person would stay up until the small hours of the morning discussing the post-Soviet space and Russia policy.
42:12.900 --> 42:14.361
[SPEAKER_08]: And that person is Richard Nixon.
42:15.549 --> 42:24.398
[SPEAKER_08]: And Clinton, a Talbot himself, says that Clinton and developed a strange affinity for Nixon.
42:24.959 --> 42:29.804
[SPEAKER_08]: And they took Nixon's very misguided advice, very seriously.
42:30.885 --> 42:36.892
[SPEAKER_08]: And so Clinton, the other thing that people forget about, Clinton,
42:37.956 --> 42:43.722
[SPEAKER_08]: is that he unabashedly ran to the right of George H.W.
42:43.782 --> 42:47.105
[SPEAKER_08]: Bush on foreign policy during the 1992 election.
42:48.106 --> 42:56.415
[SPEAKER_08]: Unabashedly, all that talk about global dictators and all that stuff really took flight.
42:58.025 --> 43:20.004
[SPEAKER_08]: during the Clinton administration, and in point of fact, in the early years of the Clinton administration, his national security advisor, a gentleman by the name of Anthony Lake, gave a famous speech in Washington where he laid out this vision of the democracies versus the dictators.
43:20.124 --> 43:22.907
[SPEAKER_08]: They were calling them the dictators, not the authoritarianists that came later.
43:24.670 --> 43:28.133
[SPEAKER_08]: The interesting thing about the speech isn't so much the content.
43:29.575 --> 43:30.556
[SPEAKER_08]: It is the speech writer.
43:31.737 --> 43:36.221
[SPEAKER_08]: The speech writer was a young staffer by the name of Anthony Blinken.
43:36.402 --> 43:43.589
[SPEAKER_08]: So these people and these ideas have been around for 30, 40 years with the same results.
43:44.750 --> 43:54.341
[SPEAKER_08]: And it's very depressing to me that you now here, leading progressive foreign policy thinkers, embrace these very same discredited ideas.
43:55.062 --> 43:57.164
[SPEAKER_10]: James, we're gonna wrap heading into the midterms.
43:58.005 --> 44:01.589
[SPEAKER_10]: Democrats stand to gain electorally from Trump.
44:02.719 --> 44:04.141
[SPEAKER_10]: abandoning the anti-war mantle.
44:04.501 --> 44:09.787
[SPEAKER_10]: Again, promising no new wars, but then launching this disastrous regime change war against Iran.
44:09.807 --> 44:17.595
[SPEAKER_10]: And being openly contemptuous of the cost to his own population, I never mind the cost to the people of Iran.
44:17.815 --> 44:19.998
[SPEAKER_10]: And keep promising that prices are going to come down.
44:20.038 --> 44:21.519
[SPEAKER_10]: But doing nothing,
44:22.280 --> 44:27.482
[SPEAKER_10]: to achieve that goal, except this deal with Russia that's probably not going to make a very big difference.
44:27.983 --> 44:46.111
[SPEAKER_10]: So, as Democrats stand, at least in this cycle, to gain from Trump being pro-war, what do you want people to take away from your book, which documents a long shift over time of Democrats embracing war, and therefore, seeding the anti-war lane to people like Trump?
44:49.068 --> 44:50.929
[SPEAKER_08]: You won't be surprised by my answer, right?
44:50.969 --> 44:52.930
[SPEAKER_08]: Because we know each other a little bit.
44:53.091 --> 44:54.431
[SPEAKER_08]: And I tend towards pessimism.
44:55.492 --> 45:02.717
[SPEAKER_08]: I think the message of the book is not to get too excited when the Democrats sweep the house in the Senate.
45:03.457 --> 45:08.020
[SPEAKER_08]: People sometimes build up great expectations that change is going to come.
45:08.901 --> 45:09.981
[SPEAKER_08]: We made that mistake in 2008.
45:11.946 --> 45:24.534
[SPEAKER_08]: I've certainly voted for Obama first twice, and there was this expectation that the Bush chaining era of neo-conservative foreign policy was over, and it wasn't.
45:25.634 --> 45:32.718
[SPEAKER_08]: So I would just say to people, given the long history of democratic foreign policy, democratic caucusiness,
45:35.050 --> 45:36.551
[SPEAKER_08]: Don't get your hopes up, things are not.
45:37.432 --> 45:47.021
[SPEAKER_08]: And let me underline, not going to change very much in terms of foreign policy, should the Democrats sweep in a week or so?
45:47.662 --> 45:54.188
[SPEAKER_10]: The book is called The Great Betrayal, how the Democrats became the party of war will link to it in the show notes for this episode.
45:54.568 --> 45:55.529
[SPEAKER_10]: James Carter, thanks a lot.
45:56.370 --> 45:57.091
[SPEAKER_10]: Thanks, Aaron Goodsien.
46:03.092 --> 46:04.893
[SPEAKER_10]: At thank you again to James Cardan.
46:05.433 --> 46:06.574
[SPEAKER_10]: Up next is Kylie Chung.
46:06.674 --> 46:10.776
[SPEAKER_10]: She's a journalist and author whose book's focus on the relationship between gender and power.
46:11.136 --> 46:18.361
[SPEAKER_10]: Her latest is playing the victim, how the powerful denying attacks survivors and violence from domestic abuse to genocide.
46:21.042 --> 46:22.323
[SPEAKER_10]: Kylie Chung, thank you for joining me.
46:23.056 --> 46:24.357
[SPEAKER_04]: Thanks so much for having me.
46:24.837 --> 46:32.860
[SPEAKER_10]: The book is called Playing the Victim, how the powerful deny and attacks survivors of violence from domestic abuse to genocide.
46:33.500 --> 46:41.604
[SPEAKER_10]: And a major part of your book is focused on the genocide in Gaza and the language used to perpetuate it.
46:41.684 --> 46:49.707
[SPEAKER_10]: So talk to us about the link between what Israel has done the people of Gaza and how that mirrors the tactics of domestic abusers.
46:50.332 --> 47:08.368
[SPEAKER_04]: You know, I think a really central tactic that the book really impacts is Darvo, which stands for deny attack, reverse victim and defender, and it's about weaponizing this often completely delusional and false claim of victimhood to justify all kinds of horrific violence.
47:08.748 --> 47:16.070
[SPEAKER_04]: And we typically think of Darva as like, you know, a matter of interpersonal domestic abuse between partners.
47:16.130 --> 47:34.615
[SPEAKER_04]: But I, in my book, I really want to argue that we see this tactic as really or this tactic is very central to justifying state violence as well, to how state oppressors justify a wide range of horrific violence and specific to Israel and Palestine.
47:35.535 --> 48:00.331
[SPEAKER_04]: to genocide and, you know, I think that was really important to me in having Israel's decades long genocide against Palestinian's be such a focal point of this book was, you know, I've felt often a deep frustration with, I think, this kind of vacuum of Western liberal or Western feminist condemnation of Israel and, you know, they're genocide of the genocide
48:03.593 --> 48:25.419
[SPEAKER_04]: extensively, horrifically documented mass and systematic sexual violence that Israel has perpetrated against Palestinians, including horrific reproductive violence as well, and so it was really important to me to really have this be at in a lot of ways the center of my book, and specifically,
48:27.080 --> 48:42.701
[SPEAKER_04]: unpack this concept or this strategy of Darbo, which we see very much even in just like the language of quote and quote Israel has a right to defend itself and how, you know, that I think really speaks to this tactic of framing a genocide as a self defense.
48:43.338 --> 48:58.897
[SPEAKER_10]: I want to read a few quotes from your book, you write anyone truly concerned with advocating for sexual violence victims would direct their attention to Israel, whose very existence as a colonial oppressor is an act of gender-based violence under colonization and occupation.
48:59.658 --> 49:01.859
[SPEAKER_10]: sexual violence is inescapable.
49:02.459 --> 49:12.002
[SPEAKER_10]: And you also write, Zionists aggressively wield sexual atrocity propaganda to obscure how Israel itself is a perpetrator of mass sexual violence.
49:12.503 --> 49:18.445
[SPEAKER_10]: Just as all colonizing forces have been throughout history, because sexual violence is a tool of colonization.
49:19.105 --> 49:23.426
[SPEAKER_10]: All this directly mirrors the gas flooding, manipulation, exploitation of power dynamics,
49:28.268 --> 49:31.732
[SPEAKER_10]: This has always been true of imperialist aggression.
49:33.713 --> 49:42.077
[SPEAKER_10]: You know, when I read that, I think that I think this is such a brave statement to make, even though it's true and I'm thinking, well, why is it brave to speak the truth?
49:42.097 --> 49:52.202
[SPEAKER_10]: And that's because the culture we're in is so skewed towards Palestinians that, you know, as you document, it's Israelis who manage to portray themselves as the victims.
49:52.802 --> 49:53.963
[SPEAKER_10]: How would they be able to do that?
49:54.043 --> 49:59.306
[SPEAKER_10]: Like, how is it even a situation where, you know, pointing out that the colonization is a form of
50:00.086 --> 50:05.268
[SPEAKER_10]: of oppression and it breeds sexual violence that that's now considered a sort of a a radical point of view.
50:06.069 --> 50:19.154
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, no, I'm really glad you asked that because there's, you know, I've had a lot of thoughts on this very specific strategy that we've seen from Zionists around, you know, rape related atrocity propaganda and October 7th.
50:19.494 --> 50:20.594
[SPEAKER_04]: So I'm glad you asked glad.
50:22.195 --> 50:39.373
[SPEAKER_04]: you know, I think that what it has been very strategic from, you know, the Zionist propaganda machine is it's, it's, it's, it's collusion and how deeply embedded it is in a lot of liberal, like neoliberal Western feminist, like feminism.
50:41.175 --> 50:52.020
[SPEAKER_04]: where, you know, I think that, you know, just the narrative of, oh, there was this systematic coordinated mass rate campaign on October 7th, that mine.
50:52.380 --> 50:58.023
[SPEAKER_04]: You know, for one thing, there is just objectively, there is no evidence of any kind of coordinated
50:58.463 --> 51:15.274
[SPEAKER_04]: planned mass rape campaign, the only reason that anyone believes that is, just because, you know, it's about, it's just deeply embedded in racism and colonial tropes of whatever one's personal feelings are what not about the events of October 7.
51:15.634 --> 51:26.161
[SPEAKER_04]: You know, it had very specific political objectives and the only reason that people are so willing to believe that it was just this nihilistic barbaric rampage of sexual violence
51:27.442 --> 51:33.587
[SPEAKER_04]: they just believe these deeply racist colonial tropes about Arab men, where they would just believe that that would happen.
51:33.988 --> 51:45.917
[SPEAKER_04]: Even when it defies all logic about the specifics of the fact that there were political objectives that day and it's about obscuring the fact that anything that happened or not to over a seventh was a response to
51:46.858 --> 51:48.079
[SPEAKER_04]: was a response to anything.
51:48.120 --> 52:01.914
[SPEAKER_04]: It's about divorcing it from any political context or political reality and just framing it as this senseless rampage of, you know, within the colonial imagination these sub-human Arab men.
52:02.395 --> 52:08.021
[SPEAKER_04]: And, you know, what I think is also very strategic about that is, you know, strategic from like, um,
52:08.982 --> 52:23.198
[SPEAKER_04]: the Zionist propaganda machine is that it's about then framing anyone who questions the logic of, you know, there's no evidence of a quote unquote coordinated mass rate campaign, no human rights, like Israel itself.
52:25.088 --> 52:40.972
[SPEAKER_04]: up intervened and stopped the UN's like investigation of sexual violence within this quote unquote conflict with Palestine because they knew that they themselves or Israel itself would be like blacklisted on the UN sexual violence list and this has been reported by Israeli media.
52:41.652 --> 52:44.653
[SPEAKER_04]: But all to say, I think that was very strategic from
52:45.273 --> 52:58.348
[SPEAKER_04]: The standpoint of like the Zionist propaganda machine is that, you know, if you then question this narrative about a quote unquote mastery campaign, then they will just smear you as a misogynist or frame.
53:00.750 --> 53:24.869
[SPEAKER_04]: any amount of support for Palestine or any amount of casting doubt about rape atrocity propaganda as being a misogynist or I think we very much seen that in the response to the Twitch streamer, Hassan Piker, where even just any amount of expressing support for Palestine or questioning these very baseless narratives that emerge from October 7 is then just
53:25.329 --> 53:48.890
[SPEAKER_04]: equated with misogyny because that in so many ways shapes forms like as this genocide become like becomes you know clear and clear about the day even though it's been clear for a very long time all that they can really do is you know essentially set up this sort of trap to a keep like to accuse you of being a misogynist if you yeah if you question any of these
53:51.478 --> 53:54.680
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, let's go and look, James, that I think illustrates so much of re-talking about.
53:54.700 --> 54:02.246
[SPEAKER_10]: And this is with Congress member, Primalajaya Paul, and CNN anchor, Danabash, back in December 2023.
54:02.266 --> 54:06.309
[SPEAKER_05]: I want to ask you about sexual violence.
54:07.090 --> 54:15.516
[SPEAKER_05]: And it's kind of remarkable that this issue hasn't gotten enough attention globally.
54:19.232 --> 54:22.835
[SPEAKER_05]: brutal rape sexual violence against is really women by Hamas.
54:24.117 --> 54:33.966
[SPEAKER_05]: I've seen a lot of progressive women generally speaking, they're quick to defend women's rights, and speak out against using rape as a weapon of war.
54:34.666 --> 54:43.354
[SPEAKER_05]: But downright silent on what we saw on October 7th and what I'd be happening inside Gaza right now to these hostages.
54:43.634 --> 54:44.155
[SPEAKER_05]: Why is that?
54:45.297 --> 54:47.299
[SPEAKER_07]: I mean, I don't know that that's true.
54:47.339 --> 54:51.483
[SPEAKER_07]: I think we always talk about the impact of war on women in particular.
54:51.503 --> 54:54.947
[SPEAKER_07]: In fact, I remember 20 years ago I did a petition around the war in Iraq.
54:54.967 --> 54:57.649
[SPEAKER_07]: And you said, saying that talked about it so absolutely.
54:57.689 --> 54:59.751
[SPEAKER_07]: And I've condemned what Hamas has done.
54:59.791 --> 55:01.873
[SPEAKER_07]: I've condemned all of the actions.
55:02.074 --> 55:02.714
[SPEAKER_07]: Absolutely.
55:03.014 --> 55:05.096
[SPEAKER_07]: The rape, the, of course.
55:05.317 --> 55:08.239
[SPEAKER_07]: But I think we have to remember that
55:08.920 --> 55:10.761
[SPEAKER_07]: Israel is a democracy.
55:10.801 --> 55:12.882
[SPEAKER_07]: That is why they are strong ally of ours.
55:13.303 --> 55:26.170
[SPEAKER_07]: And if they do not comply with international humanitarian law, they are bringing themselves to a place that makes it much more difficult strategically for them to be able to build the kinds of allies, to keep public opinion with them.
55:26.471 --> 55:31.554
[SPEAKER_07]: And frankly, morally, I think we cannot say that one war crime deserves another.
55:31.674 --> 55:34.655
[SPEAKER_05]: That is not what international humanitarian law says.
55:34.815 --> 55:36.556
[SPEAKER_05]: Okay, with respect, I was just asking
55:37.637 --> 55:40.680
[SPEAKER_05]: the women and you turned it back to Israel.
55:41.120 --> 55:42.662
[SPEAKER_05]: I'm asking you about Hamas in fact.
55:42.862 --> 55:44.784
[SPEAKER_05]: I already answered your question, Dana.
55:44.864 --> 55:49.408
[SPEAKER_07]: I said it's horrific and I think that rape is horrific, sexual assault is horrific.
55:49.708 --> 55:57.475
[SPEAKER_07]: I think that it happens in war situations, terrorist organizations like Hamas, obviously, are using these as tools.
55:57.936 --> 55:59.738
[SPEAKER_07]: However, I think we have to be
56:00.358 --> 56:05.784
[SPEAKER_07]: balanced about bringing in the outrages against Palestinians.
56:05.984 --> 56:12.812
[SPEAKER_07]: 15,000 Palestinians have been killed in Israeli air strikes, three quarters of whom.
56:12.872 --> 56:17.697
[SPEAKER_05]: And it's our women and children horrible, but you don't see Israeli soldiers raping.
56:18.578 --> 56:20.200
[SPEAKER_07]: Well, Dana, I think we're not.
56:20.500 --> 56:22.480
[SPEAKER_10]: So, you know, I've so many problems with this clip.
56:22.560 --> 56:27.641
[SPEAKER_10]: Obviously, Dana Bash has come in there where she says, yeah, sure, okay, fine.
56:27.921 --> 56:30.462
[SPEAKER_10]: It's always a killed 15,000 housing civilians.
56:31.002 --> 56:31.642
[SPEAKER_10]: Yeah, that's bad.
56:31.722 --> 56:36.803
[SPEAKER_10]: But you don't see Israelis raping Palestinian women, which, of course, is not even true.
56:37.463 --> 56:41.624
[SPEAKER_10]: Then, of course, even if it were true, how could it possibly justify killing always Palestinians.
56:41.944 --> 56:48.365
[SPEAKER_10]: But then, Premier LeJapal, too, I have some problems with what she is saying, but I'd like to hear your thoughts on it.
56:48.885 -->
56:58.004
[SPEAKER_04]: You know, it's just I'm very familiar with her or Danabash's comments about you don't see this front you don't see this from Israeli soldiers or whatnot and it's just
56:59.697 --> 57:06.319
[SPEAKER_04]: It's honestly incredible to me in some ways this alternate reality that she seems to be referencing.
57:06.419 --> 57:26.805
[SPEAKER_04]: I mean, you know, just speaking for myself and, you know, my background and my reporting work is largely focused on gender-based violence and in a lot of ways or that is how I first kind of came into this issue of, you know, Israel's decades-long or generations long, genocide against Palestinians.
57:26.825 --> 57:27.065
[SPEAKER_04]: It was
57:27.495 --> 57:43.648
[SPEAKER_04]: you know, speaking with different activists and legal advocates who can just say like just plant-blank like this Israel's occupation of a Palestine, it just creates these inescapable conditions for sexual violence, which has been true since long, long, long before October 2023.
57:43.748 --> 57:46.871
[SPEAKER_04]: We're just to move from one place to another.
57:47.877 --> 58:06.857
[SPEAKER_04]: through checkpoints has required these highly invasive strips searches that just amount to a state like to sexual assault, just to move from one place to another against women, against children, against men, against anyone, because at the core of all sexual violence, it really just is about
58:08.518 --> 58:25.148
[SPEAKER_04]: it just is about humiliation and it is about like expressing this level of like power and dominance and that's why you know sexual violence has always been this this tool of colonial oppressors and you know I think that another thing it's not even even just beyond
58:26.529 --> 58:32.671
[SPEAKER_04]: you know, just the casual systematic sexual violence of just moving from one place to another under occupation.
58:33.091 --> 58:39.994
[SPEAKER_04]: There's also the fact that, and this was an issue that I had with, you know, from a lot of jieples comments about Israel being a debunker scene.
58:40.014 --> 58:49.997
[SPEAKER_04]: What not is that, you know, for people living under occupation, you can just be arrested, detained, and held in Israeli prisons for no reason, not even be given
58:50.417 --> 58:51.758
[SPEAKER_04]: a reason indefinitely.
58:51.778 --> 59:10.931
[SPEAKER_04]: It's also the only quote unquote country in the world that allows, you know, or children to be tried in military courts, where children are then detained and imprisoned in these horrific, like these beyond horrific Israeli prisons, where all number of forms of human rights violations and abuses are happening.
59:11.211 --> 59:32.549
[SPEAKER_04]: but especially certainly sexual abuses against, again, women, children, men, the elderly, and, you know, it is so well documented that, you know, I think even, I believe it was last year, we have seen of Israeli's riot over prison guards right to commit sexual violence.
59:32.870 --> 59:34.951
[SPEAKER_04]: They are very, very open about about,
59:35.812 --> 59:36.332
[SPEAKER_04]: about this.
59:36.452 --> 59:57.478
[SPEAKER_04]: And like if you speak about it from the point of being critical of Israel and critical of these conditions, you will be called anti-Semitic or you will be called like you will be asked about, oh, what about the quote unquote, like mass rate campaign by homosexual, what not when, you know, the reality is that when we actually see Israeli soldiers or representatives of
59:57.898 --> 01:00:17.305
[SPEAKER_04]: The state of Israel like they will be very open about, you know, about supporting sexual violence or you even see like the pictures that the photos that soldiers will post themselves like having raided like women's homes and whatnot and it's all about like this horrific sexual degradation that they are very open about and lethal about.
01:00:17.865 --> 01:00:36.320
[SPEAKER_04]: And there was this level of like extreme like sadism that is really rooted in, you know, all of what we've seen from colonial oppressors for a very long time of just like sexual violence as this normalized tool and so, you know, it's just it's hard not to be like flabbergasted when you hear things like
01:00:36.620 --> 01:00:52.427
[SPEAKER_04]: Danibash has comments, but there is so, so, so much document, like, I, there doesn't even need, there, it doesn't, there doesn't even have to be this much documentation of how much sexual violence there is because, you know, just from the standpoint of the power dynamics that exist of
01:00:52.887 --> 01:00:57.829
[SPEAKER_04]: you know, a state like that are inherent to illegal occupation and what not.
01:00:58.109 --> 01:01:04.071
[SPEAKER_04]: You know, I absolutely believe that that creates the conditions for sexual and violence without or with impunity.
01:01:04.431 --> 01:01:07.493
[SPEAKER_04]: But the fact that there is so much horrific documentation.
01:01:07.513 --> 01:01:16.656
[SPEAKER_04]: I mean, it's stuff that like it's difficult for me to even verbalize and talk about where there has been a case of a doctor who was in in his really prison and was raped to death.
01:01:16.836 --> 01:01:21.058
[SPEAKER_04]: And that is well documented and horrific, but I'll stop myself there.
01:01:21.358 --> 01:01:28.917
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, and not only are those individual cases ignored, despite the documentation, but what you also discussed, the power dynamic is totally
01:01:30.049 --> 01:01:30.450
[SPEAKER_10]: erase.
01:01:30.730 --> 01:01:37.137
[SPEAKER_10]: So there's no acknowledgment that this is an occupation and everything is framed as the aggressor as the victim.
01:01:37.517 --> 01:01:45.166
[SPEAKER_10]: And that clip, it to me, it illustrates how far to the right things are that even like, first of all, the dissenting voice is a lawn maker.
01:01:45.466 --> 01:01:51.312
[SPEAKER_10]: Like the journalist who's supposedly neutral is totally just like
repeating the most cynical is really talking points.
01:01:51.953 --> 01:02:04.639
[SPEAKER_10]: that are not only wrong, the idea of like Palestinians raping Israelis when in reality to Israelis who as you've been discussing rape Palestinians and homosexual bonds as Palestinians.
01:02:06.080 --> 01:02:09.581
[SPEAKER_10]: But so it's not just the journalist, but then also a criminal jaypalt hurt.
01:02:09.941 --> 01:02:13.223
[SPEAKER_10]: She hasn't challenged the claim that there is mass rape by Hamas.
01:02:13.243 --> 01:02:14.284
[SPEAKER_10]: She says, I condemned it.
01:02:14.304 --> 01:02:15.684
[SPEAKER_10]: Well, condemn what?
01:02:15.704 --> 01:02:16.765
[SPEAKER_10]: There's no evidence for it.
01:02:17.505 --> 01:02:18.426
[SPEAKER_10]: which she doesn't challenge.
01:02:18.786 --> 01:02:39.078
[SPEAKER_10]: And then our argument for like why Israel shouldn't commit mass murder is that, well, Israel's a democracy and it's harder to support the democracy if it's, if it's committing war crimes, which again, it's, it's so fluck as a, as you point out, it's not a democracy and, and be like, the reason to oppose war crimes is not because it makes it harder to like support an ally, it's because there are war crimes.
01:02:39.638 --> 01:02:41.040
[SPEAKER_10]: and you like the right to go kill people.
01:02:41.080 --> 01:02:53.196
[SPEAKER_10]: So it just amazing, even the dissenting voice here, is still accepting so much propaganda, and so much, and the legitimacy of occupation at face value.
01:02:53.769 --> 01:03:07.676
[SPEAKER_04]: absolutely, you know, there's so much about that conversation that's incredibly frustrating and interesting because it was very early, it was like at the onset of, you know, this iteration of Israel's genocide and because I think it was October 2023, isn't it?
01:03:08.036 --> 01:03:18.001
[SPEAKER_10]: The clip is from early December to 2023, so now at that point we're like, you know, more than a month into a mass murder campaign
01:03:23.035 --> 01:03:31.905
[SPEAKER_04]: You know, it is this point of frustration and it has been throughout, you know, in my, my day today, I do a lot of reporting on reproductive rights and all of that.
01:03:31.945 --> 01:03:39.714
[SPEAKER_04]: And so, you know, I've also done a lot of reported work on the impacts of Israel's genocide on.
01:03:40.054 --> 01:03:59.059
[SPEAKER_04]: pregnant people and cause and just the reality that this genocide has made it so it is just impossible to carry a pregnancy safely which is obviously an extension of the genocide which is to make it difficult if not impossible for a population to reproduce and continue.
01:03:59.539 --> 01:04:20.231
[SPEAKER_04]: continuing that way and you know I think that just what has been very first frustrating is you'll see many you know American or Western politicians who will be vocally pro-choice or will locally support reproductive rights in the United States but often just have this level of like cognitive dissonance about the horrific reproductive violence that
01:04:20.651 --> 01:04:28.777
[SPEAKER_04]: you know, our tax dollars are perpetrating and Gaza where we saw, you know, miscarriages, skyrocket, we saw sea sections without anesthetic.
01:04:29.278 --> 01:04:31.239
[SPEAKER_04]: We see children starving to death.
01:04:31.339 --> 01:04:39.125
[SPEAKER_04]: We see these horrific maternal mortality rates, or just Israeli soldiers quite literally sniping at and shooting pregnant women.
01:04:39.165 --> 01:04:42.407
[SPEAKER_04]: And this has been the case where for so long, we're even,
01:04:46.272 --> 01:04:51.778
[SPEAKER_04]: Israeli soldiers distribute these t-shirts that showed, you know, a pregnant woman as a target.
01:04:52.458 --> 01:05:02.148
[SPEAKER_04]: And, you know, this just, you know, this genocide and like its implications in terms of gender-based violence, it has been so, so obvious.
01:05:02.828 --> 01:05:16.618
[SPEAKER_04]: and if you're reading and horrific for so long and it's just, I think, disappointing to see that, you know, there really is just this vacuum, I think of western feminist opposition to any of this.
01:05:17.343 --> 01:05:22.685
[SPEAKER_10]: Let's turn to some domestic issues in the Ohio governor's race.
01:05:23.305 --> 01:05:45.853
[SPEAKER_10]: There's a really ugly episode that's unfolding where the Republican candidate, Vivek Romaswani, he spent millions of dollars on an ad campaign that features the estranged mother of his Democratic opponent, Amy Acton, and the estranged mother who Amy Acton hasn't spoken to in decades, denies that Amy Acton was sexually abused
01:05:46.873 --> 01:05:52.176
[SPEAKER_10]: as a child, and Vivek is promoting this in an ad campaign.
01:05:52.596 --> 01:05:57.339
[SPEAKER_10]: And this is led to some controversy, even some Republicans have been critical of this.
01:05:57.419 --> 01:05:58.259
[SPEAKER_10]: And so here's J.D.
01:05:58.379 --> 01:06:03.002
[SPEAKER_10]: Vance defending Vivek Ramoswami.
01:06:03.662 --> 01:06:06.124
[SPEAKER_02]: You mentioned that for this, you're going to a campaign event.
01:06:06.704 --> 01:06:14.228
[SPEAKER_02]: The big Ramoswami's campaign brought out a controversial ad featuring his opponent's mother Republicans, some are backing away from that.
01:06:14.308 --> 01:06:16.049
[SPEAKER_02]: Do you think that that ad was appropriate?
01:06:16.800 --> 01:06:21.463
[SPEAKER_15]: Well, I'll be honest with you, whether the ad was appropriate or not is not really my concern.
01:06:22.283 --> 01:06:28.167
[SPEAKER_15]: What is my concern is who's going to govern the next generation of American government?
01:06:28.587 --> 01:06:31.168
[SPEAKER_15]: Who is going to win the Senate race in the state of Ohio?
01:06:31.228 --> 01:06:33.550
[SPEAKER_15]: Who's going to win the governor's race in the state of Ohio?
01:06:33.990 --> 01:06:36.712
[SPEAKER_15]: And I got to be honest, that when I see Republicans,
01:06:37.350 -->
01:06:43.734
[SPEAKER_15]: people in my party, reacting so strongly, especially elected officials, look, have the opinion you want to have on that ad.
01:06:43.754 --> 01:06:47.556
[SPEAKER_15]: If you think it was too tough, say it was too tough, if you think it wasn't tough enough, say that.
01:06:47.957 --> 01:06:50.538
[SPEAKER_15]: But I have to admit that I'm a little bit disgusted.
01:06:50.999 --> 01:07:01.285
[SPEAKER_15]: When I see Republicans across the country who are whining more about that advertisement, then they are about what the congressional Democrats and other Democrats want to do to the United States of America.
01:07:01.585 --> 01:07:14.874
[SPEAKER_10]: So he's more disgusted with people criticizing the ad than the ad, exploiting a strange mother to deny that her daughter, the effects of opponent, was sexually abused as a child.
01:07:15.375 --> 01:07:25.682
[SPEAKER_04]: I know, yeah, it's, this and talk like all of it is just, you know, I sometimes really like all also been like the rest of my life, like looking for the words for how disgusting it is.
01:07:30.766 --> 01:07:46.043
[SPEAKER_04]: You know, it's this smear campaign against a child rape survivor and, you know, it's like they want to make it seem like it's just about this one woman, but no, it really is this discussing smear campaign against all child rape victims, all child rape survivors.
01:07:46.543 --> 01:08:01.861
[SPEAKER_04]: And you know, no less from like this political party that stands with their their president being like, you know, best friends with Jeffrey Epstein and they don't even really clearly don't even really try to like distance themselves from that that narrative.
01:08:02.722 --> 01:08:12.950
[SPEAKER_04]: I do think something that's interesting because one of my first thoughts, you know, as Vivek has started running this just group tests, like snare campaign and like ad campaign.
01:08:13.410 --> 01:08:17.534
[SPEAKER_04]: It is something that reminded me I was back in like 2022.
01:08:17.594 --> 01:08:21.076
[SPEAKER_04]: This was within a few weeks of the Supreme Court overturning Rovy Wade.
01:08:21.497 --> 01:08:26.401
[SPEAKER_04]: There was this horrible devastating story of a 10-year-old rape victim in Ohio,
01:08:29.703 --> 01:08:33.206
[SPEAKER_04]: who had to travel to Indiana to receive abortion care.
01:08:33.606 --> 01:08:45.495
[SPEAKER_04]: And in this case, as more and more news associated with that case started coming out, you know, we found that the child's rapist was convicted, which, you know, rarely happens, but did in this case.
01:08:45.595 --> 01:08:49.878
[SPEAKER_04]: And yet, you know, for several weeks, we saw Ohio Republicans in Indiana,
01:08:50.018 --> 01:09:11.916
[SPEAKER_04]: Republicans both, you know, cast a lot of doubt on the credibility of, you know, they wanted to make it seem like they were doubting this story, but, you know, what the material impact of that is is that they were questioning the credibility of a 10-year-old rape victim because they just did not want to confront how violence and cruel their laws are.
01:09:12.416 --> 01:09:13.517
[SPEAKER_04]: And, you know, I mean,
01:09:14.458 --> 01:09:23.823
[SPEAKER_04]: I think it just speaks to this moral rod that is so much deeper than this one, you know, incredibly disgusting, disgusting case.
01:09:24.603 --> 01:09:25.084
[SPEAKER_10]: Another J.D.
01:09:25.164 --> 01:09:29.606
[SPEAKER_10]: Vance clip, he was recently asked to define socialism.
01:09:30.126 --> 01:09:31.807
[SPEAKER_10]: And this was his answer.
01:09:32.407 --> 01:09:34.729
[SPEAKER_01]: How do you define socialism personally?
01:09:34.789 --> 01:09:38.310
[SPEAKER_01]: And why do you think socialism candidates are popping up everywhere across your country?
01:09:38.511 --> 01:09:40.732
[SPEAKER_15]: No, man, you know, I guess
01:09:42.543 --> 01:09:54.589
[SPEAKER_15]: It's honestly, it's a hard term to define these days, because very often socialism, you know, classically, you would think socialism is about prioritizing workers.
01:09:55.170 --> 01:10:06.216
[SPEAKER_15]: And yet, in reality, I guarantee that most of the self-described socialist running across the United States of America are going to have about this announcement today, which is prioritizing American workers over foreign workers.
01:10:06.576 --> 01:10:06.736
[SPEAKER_15]: So
01:10:07.296 --> 01:10:08.917
[SPEAKER_15]: I don't know what the term means anymore.
01:10:09.037 --> 01:10:17.383
[SPEAKER_15]: I think in reality what it actually means in the American context is that you want to replace American workers with foreign workers and you want boys to play in girl sports.
01:10:17.423 --> 01:10:24.247
[SPEAKER_15]: That's what unites the socialist and I see running across the United States of America today, you know, it's- So you write a lot about this in your book.
01:10:24.988 --> 01:10:35.295
[SPEAKER_10]: The centering, especially by Republicans, of the trans issue and trying to basically turn trans people into the cause of all problems and to the point where JD bands,
01:10:36.015 --> 01:10:45.040
[SPEAKER_10]: exploit to really, relatively minor issue of, you know, in terms of like who, but, you know, plays and sports into defining socialism.
01:10:46.021 --> 01:10:50.483
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah, it's just so, like, you know, at its courts, it's incredibly desperate.
01:10:50.543 --> 01:10:52.785
[SPEAKER_04]: I don't know any other words to describe it.
01:10:52.825 --> 01:11:04.531
[SPEAKER_04]: It's so interesting, but, you know, I think the, the central argument that I tried to make in my book is that, you know, whether it's, in terms of, like, domestic abusers or whether it's the government, like state institutions,
01:11:06.092 --> 01:11:30.386
[SPEAKER_04]: This key strategy of justifying and building upon oppressive systems is by framing the very people that they're oppressing and marginalizing as this towering monstrous
oppressor, whether that's immigrants, whether that's trans people, whether that's, you know, as I've reported on the anti-apportion movement, the way that they justify like fire-bombing abortion clinics or enacting all kinds of horrific
01:11:31.126 --> 01:11:36.611
[SPEAKER_04]: and brutal laws and restrictions is by portraying doctors and patients as murderers.
01:11:36.651 --> 01:11:44.899
[SPEAKER_04]: It's about this classic revert like this reversal of victim and defender to justify extreme oppression.
01:11:45.079 --> 01:11:47.081
[SPEAKER_04]: And yeah, I mean, J.D.
01:11:47.121 --> 01:11:49.604
[SPEAKER_04]: Vance is just so smart me in discussing it.
01:11:49.684 --> 01:11:55.769
[SPEAKER_04]: Also, I mean, I'm so curious, like, he and not that this is the issue with him at all, but
01:11:56.590 --> 01:11:59.255
[SPEAKER_04]: I don't know, is he like on like, it was epic or something.
01:11:59.295 --> 01:12:01.580
[SPEAKER_04]: He looks kind of like, he looks kind of different.
01:12:01.740 --> 01:12:04.966
[SPEAKER_04]: I feel for now, he he's looked before.
01:12:04.986 --> 01:12:07.331
[SPEAKER_04]: I don't know, just as I was watching those clips.
01:12:07.965 --> 01:12:12.567
[SPEAKER_10]: There's been a lot of speculation about what he's done to his eyes, you know, with his character.
01:12:12.747 --> 01:12:19.189
[SPEAKER_10]: Like mascara, but you know, that's not my lane, but listen, you have another lane in terms of writing.
01:12:19.209 --> 01:12:25.911
[SPEAKER_10]: You're not just a nonfiction writer, but you have a book coming out soon called another book on top of your current book playing a victim.
01:12:26.011 --> 01:12:30.793
[SPEAKER_10]: Another book called My Boyfriend the Superhero talked to us about this project.
01:12:31.248 --> 01:12:44.179
[SPEAKER_04]: Sure, obviously it's quite quite different from playing the victim and from a lot of my other day today work and yet it does draw a lot on like my reporting on like state violence and gender based violence.
01:12:44.219 --> 01:12:48.043
[SPEAKER_04]: And so I think I just kind of want or the yeah, I it.
01:12:48.488 --> 01:12:56.011
[SPEAKER_04]: It kind of takes a more allegorical approach than just like, stating point-playing, like, this is happening, and this is wrong, or whatnot.
01:12:56.091 --> 01:13:12.657
[SPEAKER_04]: But basically, it's an erotic, political thriller, and it kind of draw or it's sets in this time where superheroes exist, but they create a lot more problems and violence than
01:13:14.378 --> 01:13:16.761
[SPEAKER_04]: you know, despite like the name or the label.
01:13:17.623 --> 01:13:30.961
[SPEAKER_04]: And eventually there is this or it centers from the perspective of this woman who like leads a protest movement against them, but then like finds herself in this psychosexual relationship with one of them, but then every time she tries to leave
01:13:31.602 --> 01:13:36.085
[SPEAKER_04]: the relationship, she's then another near-death
experience that he has, the saver from.
01:13:36.505 --> 01:13:58.900
[SPEAKER_04]: And so I kind of was trying to comment with this book on, you know, the police state and the ways that, you know, the way that policing is often justified to us is, you know, with, you know, this narrative that police are saving us, but it's often from the very problems that they create by existing or by siphoning off so much funding.
01:13:59.310 --> 01:14:08.297
[SPEAKER_04]: And so I kind of wanted to interrogate that a bit obviously in a very, not necessarily a very traditional way, but I had a lot of fun with it.
01:14:08.497 --> 01:14:08.778
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.
01:14:09.138 --> 01:14:10.039
[SPEAKER_10]: And this is your first novel?
01:14:10.379 --> 01:14:11.220
[SPEAKER_04]: Yes, yeah.
01:14:11.620 --> 01:14:12.120
[SPEAKER_10]: Congratulations.
01:14:12.140 --> 01:14:12.741
[SPEAKER_10]: I mean, look up.
01:14:12.761 --> 01:14:13.141
[SPEAKER_04]: Thank you.
01:14:13.461 --> 01:14:15.883
[SPEAKER_10]: I just finished writing my first book, which is non-functioning.
01:14:16.024 --> 01:14:16.504
[SPEAKER_10]: Amazing.
01:14:16.584 --> 01:14:20.047
[SPEAKER_10]: And I just can't fathom doing a novel.
01:14:20.187 --> 01:14:25.051
[SPEAKER_10]: And especially with the things that you explore, it sounds really interesting.
01:14:25.071 --> 01:14:26.252
[SPEAKER_10]: And it's got some great blurbs on it.
01:14:26.796 --> 01:14:27.016
[SPEAKER_04]: Oh, thanks.
01:14:27.036 --> 01:14:27.176
[SPEAKER_04]: Yeah.
01:14:27.196 --> 01:14:27.677
[SPEAKER_04]: Well, thank you.
01:14:27.697 --> 01:14:28.658
[SPEAKER_04]: I'm really excited to read your book.
01:14:28.678 --> 01:14:28.998
[SPEAKER_04]: What's it about?
01:14:29.018 --> 01:14:29.499
[SPEAKER_04]: I'll talk about my book.
01:14:29.519 --> 01:14:50.080
[SPEAKER_10]: Yeah, I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my book and I'll talk about my
01:14:50.289 --> 01:15:13.275
[SPEAKER_04]: You know, I think that a key, something that oppressive systems really subsist on is kind of this public illiteracy about how power and power dynamics work, where, you know, people might see like a violent protest and response to police murdering someone and see that as like the only violence that's happening or the only issue at hand or they might see like.
01:15:13.775 --> 01:15:28.406
[SPEAKER_04]: Luigi Mangion and like the murder or like the assassination of the United Healthcare CEO and see that as like the only violence that's happening rather than the privatized health insurance murdering so many people or they might see something like
01:15:29.647 --> 01:15:35.110
[SPEAKER_04]: you know October 7th and divorce it from any political context of this decade's long genocide.
01:15:35.530 --> 01:15:55.098
[SPEAKER_04]: And so I think that what I really hope people take away from this book would be would be just kind of this ability to critique and analyze power and and you know be understand the ways that resistance to violence and oppression is so demonized because it goes against this norm
01:15:58.860 --> 01:16:11.464
[SPEAKER_04]: people gain more clarity about that, you know, we'll be able to, I mean, my hope certainly is that there will be able to fight back against that in a more coherent and united way.
01:16:12.044 --> 01:16:19.667
[SPEAKER_10]: The book is called playing the victim how the powerful deny and attacks her bivours of violence from domestic abuse genocide, there it is.
01:16:20.207 --> 01:16:21.547
[SPEAKER_10]: Kylie Chang, thanks so much for joining us.
01:16:22.108 --> 01:16:23.328
[SPEAKER_04]: Thank you so much for having me.
01:16:29.092 --> 01:16:37.499
[SPEAKER_10]: Thanks again to Kylie Chung for joining us, again, the book is called Plain the Victim and the Powerful Denying Attack Survivors of Violence from Domestic Abuse to Genocide.
01:16:38.340 --> 01:16:38.900
[SPEAKER_10]: That's our show.
01:16:39.120 --> 01:16:40.261
[SPEAKER_10]: Thanks for watching Usalidians.
01:16:40.461 --> 01:16:41.002
[SPEAKER_10]: We'll see you next time.
01:16:41.302 --> 01:16:41.782
[SPEAKER_03]: Bye, Ron.
01:16:45.546 --> 01:16:47.247
[SPEAKER_03]: Thanks for tuning into Usalidians.
01:16:47.487 --> 01:16:54.333
[SPEAKER_03]: For extended episodes, bonus content and our weekly Friday free for all episode, please subscribe at Usalidianspodcast.com.
01:16:54.745 --> 01:16:59.491
[SPEAKER_10]: Support the show for free by subscribing on YouTube, Rumble, and wherever you get your podcast.
01:16:59.571 --> 01:17:02.915
[SPEAKER_10]: And if you like the podcast, don't forget to rate and review.
01:17:03.236 --> 01:17:06.440
[SPEAKER_10]: You can also follow us on Twitter, X at useful idiot pod.
01:17:06.960 --> 01:17:09.563
[SPEAKER_10]: Thanks so much for supporting independent media, we'll see you next time.