TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:02.799 --> 00:00:04.959
Welcome to Truth in Motion with Dr.
00:00:05.040 --> 00:00:09.679
Jocelyn, where insight, clarity, and wisdom help you thrive.
00:00:10.480 --> 00:00:13.759
I'm really glad you are here with me today.
00:00:14.240 --> 00:00:17.839
Yesterday we slowed down and stepped into wonder.
00:00:18.079 --> 00:00:25.039
We remembered that each of us began as one cell and that every one of our own cells came from it.
00:00:25.199 --> 00:00:36.479
We walked that one cell through our five questions, and we sorted what we observe from what we model, what we experience, and what we hold by faith.
00:00:36.880 --> 00:00:40.479
Today we pick up the question we touched on yesterday.
00:00:40.799 --> 00:00:42.719
Is reality real?
00:00:43.600 --> 00:00:49.039
On Monday, I said every question we ask stands on things we've already decided.
00:00:49.359 --> 00:00:54.560
The first two were what is real and how we know what we know.
00:00:54.799 --> 00:01:03.840
Today we look at both of those directly, because if reality isn't real, then everything we said about science this week falls apart.
00:01:04.000 --> 00:01:06.079
And it goes further than science.
00:01:06.319 --> 00:01:13.680
If nothing is really there, then there's only my truth and your truth, and no way to ask the simplest questions of all.
00:01:14.000 --> 00:01:15.040
Is it true?
00:01:15.280 --> 00:01:18.319
Why does this matter for our health?
00:01:18.879 --> 00:01:25.760
Because every time we're told what's real about our bodies, someone is asking a claim about reality.
00:01:26.159 --> 00:01:29.760
A scan can say one thing, our body says another.
00:01:30.000 --> 00:01:33.920
One person says it's all energy, another says it's all chemistry.
00:01:34.159 --> 00:01:38.079
If we don't know what we mean by real, we can't weigh any of it.
00:01:38.319 --> 00:01:44.159
We either believe whoever sounds most certain, or we stop believing anything at all.
00:01:44.640 --> 00:01:54.719
Knowing what's real and how we know it lets us sort what's measured from what's modeled, and what's experienced from what's assumed.
00:01:55.040 --> 00:01:57.439
And then we can choose where to stand.
00:01:58.079 --> 00:02:01.439
Let me start with a story about a stone.
00:02:03.040 --> 00:02:12.000
On August 6, 1763, two friends walked out of a church in Harwich, a port town on the east coast of England.
00:02:12.240 --> 00:02:18.000
One was Samuel Johnson, the man who wrote the first great dictionary of the English language.
00:02:18.319 --> 00:02:22.879
The other was his young friend and biographer, James Boswell.
00:02:23.199 --> 00:02:28.080
They were talking about an Irish bishop and philosopher named George Berkeley.
00:02:28.319 --> 00:02:29.840
We met him on Monday.
00:02:30.080 --> 00:02:38.960
Berkeley argued that matter doesn't exist on its own, that everything we call real is made of ideas and perceptions in our minds.
00:02:39.199 --> 00:02:45.360
Boswell said that even though they were sure Berkeley was wrong, it was impossible to refute him.
00:02:45.520 --> 00:02:50.240
And Boswell wrote, he would never forget how quickly Johnson answered.
00:02:50.479 --> 00:02:57.919
Johnson kicked a large stone so hard that his foot bounced back and said, I refute it thus.
00:02:58.479 --> 00:03:03.840
It's a great story, and people have been arguing about it for more than 250 years.
00:03:04.080 --> 00:03:07.840
Because Berkeley would have said, Of course the stone hurts.
00:03:08.080 --> 00:03:10.400
I never said you wouldn't experience it.
00:03:10.639 --> 00:03:13.680
I'm asking what the stone is.
00:03:14.159 --> 00:03:18.159
That's our question today, not whether we experience the world.
00:03:18.319 --> 00:03:19.199
We all do.
00:03:19.439 --> 00:03:25.039
The question is whether what we experience is really there and whether we can know it.
00:03:25.280 --> 00:03:27.280
Here's where we have to be honest.
00:03:27.520 --> 00:03:30.319
Our senses don't hand us the world directly.
00:03:30.479 --> 00:03:35.439
They take in signals and our brain builds what we experience.
00:03:36.159 --> 00:03:43.360
Light enters the eye, pressure waves enter the ear, molecules touch the nose and tongue.
00:03:43.599 --> 00:03:46.400
Every one of those becomes an electrical signal.
00:03:46.560 --> 00:03:52.080
And the brain turns those signals into color, sound, smell, and taste.
00:03:52.319 --> 00:03:54.560
You can test this yourself today.
00:03:54.800 --> 00:03:57.039
Each of our eyes has a blind spot.
00:03:57.199 --> 00:04:00.240
It's the place where the optic nerve leaves the eye.
00:04:00.479 --> 00:04:03.360
There are no light sensing cells there at all.
00:04:03.599 --> 00:04:06.000
And yet you don't see a hole in your vision.
00:04:06.240 --> 00:04:07.919
Your brain fills it in.
00:04:08.159 --> 00:04:16.879
Close one eye, hold up a small dot on a page, look a little to the side of it, and move the page slowly.
00:04:17.120 --> 00:04:20.079
At the right distance, the dot disappears.
00:04:20.319 --> 00:04:21.839
Anyone can repeat it.
00:04:22.079 --> 00:04:24.720
Or think of two lines of equal length.
00:04:25.040 --> 00:04:30.480
One with arrowheads pointing in, one with arrowheads pointing out.
00:04:30.639 --> 00:04:31.839
One looks longer.
00:04:32.079 --> 00:04:33.920
Measure them and they're the same.
00:04:34.160 --> 00:04:36.160
And here's the remarkable part.
00:04:36.480 --> 00:04:39.759
Even after you know, it still looks longer.
00:04:40.079 --> 00:04:43.120
That's called the Mueller Liar illusion.
00:04:43.360 --> 00:04:46.480
It's been repeated for more than a hundred years.
00:04:46.800 --> 00:04:51.519
And in 2015, a photo of a dress split the internet.
00:04:51.920 --> 00:04:54.720
Millions of people saw it as white and gold.
00:04:54.959 --> 00:04:57.519
Millions saw it as blue and black.
00:04:57.680 --> 00:05:01.519
Same photo, same screen, different brains.
00:05:02.079 --> 00:05:05.360
Our brains render our
Load full transcript
own bodies too.
00:05:05.600 --> 00:05:10.160
After an amputation, many people still feel the missing arm or leg.
00:05:10.399 --> 00:05:15.680
Some feel it cramped and painful, clenched in a fist they can't open.
00:05:15.920 --> 00:05:20.560
In the 1990s, a neuroscientist named V.S.
00:05:21.199 --> 00:05:27.680
Ramachandran at the University of California, San Diego tried something simple.
00:05:28.000 --> 00:05:30.399
He put a mirror in a box.
00:05:31.040 --> 00:05:36.000
So a person could see the reflection of the healthy hand where the missing hand should be.
00:05:36.240 --> 00:05:41.360
When the patient moved the healthy hand, the brain saw the missing hand move.
00:05:41.519 --> 00:05:44.000
And for some, the cramp let go.
00:05:44.480 --> 00:05:49.839
A mirror, a box, and the brain changed what the body felt.
00:05:51.279 --> 00:05:57.519
So yesterday's quote from Anise Nin holds up, we do not see things as they are.
00:05:57.759 --> 00:06:00.000
We see them as we are.
00:06:01.120 --> 00:06:03.839
Now, some thinkers take this much further.
00:06:04.079 --> 00:06:09.040
Donald Hoffman is a cognitive scientist at the University of California Irvine.
00:06:09.360 --> 00:06:13.680
In 2019, he published a book called The Case Against Reality.
00:06:13.920 --> 00:06:21.040
His argument goes like this: evolution shaped our senses to help us survive, not to show us the truth.
00:06:21.279 --> 00:06:25.680
He compares what we see to the icons on a computer desktop.
00:06:25.920 --> 00:06:28.160
A blue folder icon is useful.
00:06:28.319 --> 00:06:34.079
You can click it, move it, open it, but the file isn't blue, and it isn't a folder.
00:06:34.399 --> 00:06:39.920
The icon hides what's really going on, and that's exactly what makes it useful.
00:06:40.160 --> 00:06:46.720
Hoffman says space, time, objects, even our own bodies are like those icons.
00:06:47.120 --> 00:06:56.800
He and his colleagues built computer simulations and a mathematical theorem they call quote unquote fitness beats truth.
00:06:57.199 --> 00:07:04.240
In their models, creatures that see the truth lose out to creatures that see only what helps them survive.
00:07:04.480 --> 00:07:08.319
And yet Hoffman himself doesn't step in front of trains.
00:07:08.480 --> 00:07:13.600
He says we should take our perceptions seriously, just not literally.
00:07:13.839 --> 00:07:19.839
A train icon may not be what a train really is, but it still means get out of the way.
00:07:20.079 --> 00:07:22.639
He's not alone in asking these questions.
00:07:22.879 --> 00:07:33.279
More than 200 years ago, the German philosopher Immanuel Kant argued that we never know things as they are in themselves, only as they appear to us.
00:07:33.680 --> 00:07:41.519
In 2003, the Oxford philosopher Nick Bostrom asked whether we might be living in a computer simulation.
00:07:41.759 --> 00:07:56.800
And in 2022, the Nobel Prize in Physics went to three scientists whose experiments showed that tiny particles
called photons don't behave as if they carry fixed instructions ahead of time.
00:07:57.040 --> 00:08:02.399
Something about the smallest level of nature is stranger than common sense.
00:08:03.040 --> 00:08:11.040
So when someone says, quote unquote, science has shown that reality isn't real, it can sound like the final word.
00:08:11.519 --> 00:08:13.120
Let's look closer.
00:08:13.360 --> 00:08:15.360
Here's the twist I want us to see.
00:08:15.600 --> 00:08:23.360
Hoffman's case uses science to argue that our senses don't show us reality, but science is built on our senses.
00:08:23.600 --> 00:08:30.800
Every observation, every measurement, every reading on an instrument comes to us through our eyes, our hands, and our minds.
00:08:31.040 --> 00:08:43.120
So if our senses can't be trusted to show us what's real, then the observations that taught us about evolution can't be trusted either, and neither can the science used to tell us our senses can't be trusted.
00:08:43.360 --> 00:08:46.720
The argument saws off the branch it's sitting on.
00:08:47.120 --> 00:08:49.039
And notice something from Tuesday?
00:08:49.360 --> 00:08:54.159
Hoffman's key evidence is computer simulations and mathematical models.
00:08:54.320 --> 00:08:56.799
Those are models, not observations.
00:08:57.039 --> 00:09:03.440
They may be brilliant, but a model can't overturn the very observations it was built from.
00:09:03.679 --> 00:09:13.039
The philosopher Elvin Plantinga, who taught for decades at the University of Notre Dame, raised a related question back in 1993.
00:09:13.519 --> 00:09:19.440
If our minds were shaped only for survival, why should we trust them to find truth at all?
00:09:19.759 --> 00:09:26.799
This answer was that we can trust them because they were made for truth by a God who is truthful.
00:09:27.039 --> 00:09:30.159
And that brings us to what science has to assume.
00:09:30.639 --> 00:09:35.039
Every experiment we talked about this week rests on three things.
00:09:35.360 --> 00:09:37.600
First, something is really there.
00:09:37.919 --> 00:09:42.399
Something exists apart from us whether we're looking at it or not.
00:09:42.799 --> 00:09:45.840
Second, it behaves the same way each time.
00:09:46.080 --> 00:09:52.480
The same conditions give the same results, today, tomorrow, and in a lab across the world.
00:09:52.720 --> 00:09:58.639
Third, our senses and minds can know it, not perfectly, but truly.
00:09:59.279 --> 00:10:03.360
Take away any one of those and science has nothing to stand on.
00:10:03.600 --> 00:10:15.679
When Simon Stevin dropped two lead balls from the church tower in Delft, he trusted that the balls were real, that they would fall the same way again, and that his ears would tell one sound from two.
00:10:16.080 --> 00:10:17.120
One sound.
00:10:17.360 --> 00:10:20.000
And people have been repeating it ever since.
00:10:20.240 --> 00:10:22.480
Science doesn't prove these three things.
00:10:22.720 --> 00:10:23.360
It can't.
00:10:23.519 --> 00:10:26.720
It has to assume them before it can begin.
00:10:26.960 --> 00:10:30.159
And these assumptions aren't only for physicists.
00:10:30.320 --> 00:10:31.759
They're in every clinic.
00:10:32.000 --> 00:10:37.919
Every time a dose is prescribed, it assumes the body tomorrow will work the way it worked in the study.
00:10:38.159 --> 00:10:49.519
Every time we keep a log of our sleep or our pain, like the notebook from Tuesday's blog, we're trusting that what we write down is really happening and that a pattern will hold.
00:10:49.759 --> 00:10:55.600
Without a real and consistent world, there's no such thing as evidence-based anything.
00:10:55.919 --> 00:10:57.519
And here's what moves me.
00:10:57.840 --> 00:11:02.720
For many of the people who built early modern science, those assumptions came from faith.
00:11:02.879 --> 00:11:18.320
This season the Torah readings are in Bereshit, which is Genesis, and in Bereshit the world is made with order, light and darkness, night and day, each kind bringing forth after its kind, and God sees that it is good.
00:11:19.279 --> 00:11:30.799
Centuries later the prophet Jeremiah spoke of God's covenant with day and night, and the ordinances of heaven and earth, an ordered world, a world that can be known.
00:11:31.200 --> 00:11:33.039
So where does that leave us?
00:11:33.279 --> 00:11:39.600
I believe reality is real, and I believe our experience of it is a rendering shaped by who we are.
00:11:39.840 --> 00:11:42.320
Both can be true at the same time.
00:11:42.559 --> 00:11:50.720
In 1933, a Polish American scholar named Alfred Korbinski wrote a line that's become famous.
00:11:50.960 --> 00:12:00.480
Quote, a map is not the territory it represents, but if correct, it has a similar structure to the territory which accounts for its usefulness.
00:12:02.320 --> 00:12:04.399
Our perception is a map.
00:12:04.559 --> 00:12:09.840
It isn't the land, but a good map matches the land well enough to get us home.
00:12:10.080 --> 00:12:12.879
When we catch a ball, our eyes and hands agree.
00:12:13.039 --> 00:12:18.960
When a dozen people measure the same line, they get the same length, even while it still looks longer.
00:12:19.279 --> 00:12:22.080
This matters deeply for how we think about pain.
00:12:22.320 --> 00:12:25.519
Pain is real, and it's also rendered.
00:12:25.679 --> 00:12:32.320
The brain can turn it up or down, depending on fear, memory, attention, and what we expect.
00:12:32.559 --> 00:12:34.639
The mirror box showed us that.
00:12:34.879 --> 00:12:41.519
So when pain is shaped by the brain, that doesn't make it imaginary and it doesn't make it all in our heads.
00:12:41.759 --> 00:12:43.919
It means the whole person is involved.
00:12:44.080 --> 00:12:48.480
And that's good news because it means there's more than one door into healing.
00:12:48.720 --> 00:12:53.919
That's exactly why we test, why we repeat, why we compare notes with others.
00:12:54.159 --> 00:12:59.679
Not because reality isn't real, not because of each of us sees it through our own filter.
00:13:00.000 --> 00:13:04.799
Science, done honestly, is how we check our maps against the land.
00:13:05.279 --> 00:13:07.120
There are two kinds of doubt.
00:13:07.360 --> 00:13:10.639
One says, I might be wrong, so let me check.
00:13:10.879 --> 00:13:13.759
That kind of doubt is the engine of science.
00:13:13.919 --> 00:13:16.399
It's what sent Stevin up the tower.
00:13:16.639 --> 00:13:21.200
The other kind says, nothing can be known, so why check it at all?
00:13:23.279 --> 00:13:25.519
And humility is part of it.
00:13:25.840 --> 00:13:32.240
When we remember that we see things as we are, we hold our certainty a little more gently.
00:13:32.399 --> 00:13:36.000
We listen to the person who sees the dress in different colors.
00:13:36.320 --> 00:13:38.240
We stay curious.
00:13:39.039 --> 00:13:41.600
Our practice this week is to question.
00:13:41.840 --> 00:13:50.480
Today, when you notice a strong reaction to a person, a headline, a sensation in your body, pause and ask one question.
00:13:50.799 --> 00:13:54.879
Is this what's there or how I'm seeing it?
00:13:55.360 --> 00:13:57.679
You don't need to answer it right away.
00:13:57.919 --> 00:14:00.639
Just asking it opens a little space.
00:14:00.879 --> 00:14:04.480
And in that space, we can choose how to respond.
00:14:04.799 --> 00:14:07.600
Today we asked whether reality is real.
00:14:07.840 --> 00:14:10.879
We stood with Samuel Johnson as he kicked a stone.
00:14:11.039 --> 00:14:16.720
We saw that our senses render the world from the blind spot to the dress to the mirror box.
00:14:16.960 --> 00:14:27.120
We looked at Donald Hoffman's case against reality, and we saw that using science to argue reality isn't real undercuts the science itself.
00:14:27.440 --> 00:14:30.080
Science stands on three assumptions.
00:14:30.480 --> 00:14:35.120
Something is there, it behaves consistently, and we can know it.
00:14:35.360 --> 00:14:39.519
Faith gives us the reason to trust those three, and a good map.
00:14:39.759 --> 00:14:43.360
Though it isn't the land, it can still bring us home.
00:14:43.600 --> 00:14:47.360
Tomorrow we'll ask the question underneath all of this.
00:14:47.679 --> 00:14:49.519
What actually exists?
00:14:49.840 --> 00:14:53.279
Even the people who doubt reality agree on one thing.
00:14:53.600 --> 00:14:55.440
Experience is happening.
00:14:55.600 --> 00:15:01.120
We'll start there and ask what must be true for any of this to work.
00:15:01.360 --> 00:15:02.799
I'll see you there.
00:15:04.879 --> 00:15:06.639
Keep the conversation going.
00:15:06.799 --> 00:15:11.360
Find your next steps in notes from a fellow traveler, my blog.