TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.400 --> 00:00:03.200
Has de facto MMT been implemented?
00:00:03.359 --> 00:00:08.160
And if so, what are the consequences and the implications of it doing so?
00:00:08.320 --> 00:00:12.000
This is what John and I are going to talk about this week on Transatlantic Takeaway.
00:00:12.160 --> 00:00:13.279
Hey John, how are you?
00:00:13.919 --> 00:00:14.720
Doing well, Brent.
00:00:14.800 --> 00:00:15.519
How about you?
00:00:15.839 --> 00:00:16.399
I'm good.
00:00:16.480 --> 00:00:16.879
I'm good.
00:00:17.039 --> 00:00:24.480
You know, I saw this Twitter post last week or earlier this week, and I thought to myself, this isn't quite right.
00:00:24.559 --> 00:00:32.159
And basically what it had said was MMT policies had been implemented all over the world, and now we are suffering the consequences.
00:00:32.320 --> 00:00:36.560
And my argument was that it's not totally wrong, but it's also not totally right.
00:00:36.880 --> 00:00:38.799
That's not exactly what MMT says.
00:00:38.880 --> 00:00:48.320
But I immediately thought of you and I was like, this is a perfect thing for you and I to talk about because I'm not an MMT proponent and I'm not really an Austrian schools proponent.
00:00:48.560 --> 00:00:51.039
I think you've done a lot of studying of both of them.
00:00:51.200 --> 00:00:58.159
But anyway, it would be a good topic for us to kind of banter back and forth and figure out has MMT been implemented?
00:00:58.320 --> 00:00:59.600
If so, what are the implications?
00:00:59.679 --> 00:01:01.359
Or has it not been implemented?
00:01:01.520 --> 00:01:04.239
And do the proponents think we need to go even further?
00:01:04.400 --> 00:01:06.719
So that's where we're going to go with it this week.
00:01:06.799 --> 00:01:11.040
And if uh if if if if you're open to it, I think it'll be a fun discussion.
00:01:11.439 --> 00:01:12.959
Oh, I'm open to it all right.
00:01:13.040 --> 00:01:18.079
I I've written about this quite a bit in recent years as MMT has grown in popularity.
00:01:18.319 --> 00:01:21.120
And and uh, it's it's a it's a good topic.
00:01:21.200 --> 00:01:36.480
It's it's quite theoretical, but it is one that ultimately can lead to some significant financial market and investment implications, depending on whether indeed MMT is being implemented or becomes implemented in future.
00:01:47.599 --> 00:01:50.480
It misrepresents what MMT actually says.
00:01:50.640 --> 00:01:59.680
And and basically what it said was MMT has been implemented because governments think that they can do whatever they want and deficit spend without any implications.
00:01:59.840 --> 00:02:02.159
And in my mind, that's not what MMT says.
00:02:02.640 --> 00:02:06.560
And I think that kind of misrepresents what MMT says.
00:02:06.799 --> 00:02:13.439
MMT does not claim that there is no consequences, and it doesn't claim that they can just print money and do whatever they want.
00:02:13.680 --> 00:02:22.719
And I think, in my in my understanding,
Load full transcript
that MMT is in many ways a description of how the mechanics of the system work.
00:02:22.879 --> 00:02:28.319
But then many of the people who are proponents of MMT say we should do this.
00:02:28.879 --> 00:02:34.159
I don't think that the proponents of MMT would say what we're doing now is exactly what they would do.
00:02:34.319 --> 00:02:36.479
I think they would take it even further.
00:02:36.719 --> 00:02:50.319
Um, but first question to you is do you agree that the MMT is a descriptive uh explanation of the mechanics, and then the proponents put their prescriptions on top of it?
00:02:50.479 --> 00:02:53.680
Or do you think it is prescriptive by nature?
00:02:54.479 --> 00:02:59.919
Well, I think it lends itself to being prescriptive, but it doesn't necessarily need to be.
00:03:00.319 --> 00:03:06.479
There can be a strict descriptive um MMT, modern monetary theory.
00:03:07.120 --> 00:03:31.520
And and and I think that that's part of the muddle because describing how things currently work, describing how they could alternatively work, and then having a view as to what the relative advantages or disadvantages of those views are, you know, those are those are all different things, and and they can all be discussed uh uh differently, separately.
00:03:31.680 --> 00:03:33.520
Um, but they tend to get muddled, right?
00:03:33.599 --> 00:03:42.319
They tend to get muddled, and so the MMT debate uh tends to blur quite easily between the lines of descriptive and prescriptive.
00:03:43.280 --> 00:04:06.639
Yeah, so I I think what really makes this interesting to me is I think if we had, you know, a Warren Mosler or a Stephanie Kelton or another MMT proponent on here, I think that they would say MMT describes how the system works, and then they would have their prescriptions of what we should be doing in in excess of what we are already doing.
00:04:06.800 --> 00:04:15.840
So in other words, I don't think they would favor the current monetary policy either, even though in some ways there are MMT aspects of it.
00:04:16.000 --> 00:04:25.680
Um and so I don't think I don't think the may maybe the neo-Kynesians are happy with the system, but I don't think the MMT proponents are happy with the system.
00:04:25.759 --> 00:04:29.839
I I'm I know the Austrian school is not happy with the current system.
00:04:31.680 --> 00:04:32.800
Where do you fall on that?
00:04:32.959 --> 00:04:38.079
Do you think I think if Stephanie Kelton was here with us, do you think she would say she's happy with the system?
00:04:38.560 --> 00:04:39.279
No, no.
00:04:39.439 --> 00:05:02.079
Uh I I I think she believes that the system is stuck in this no man's land currently between between the these legacy assumptions that she would associate with a gold standard type system and a future in which we have truly, fully decoupled from any of those legacy uh constraints.
00:05:02.319 --> 00:05:10.399
So she thinks we're stuck in in uh purgatory, you might say, monetary policy purgatory, is I think where she would come down on that.
00:05:10.560 --> 00:05:13.040
And she would say, so look, let's continue to evolve.
00:05:13.120 --> 00:05:15.759
You know, let we've been stuck in purgatory long enough.
00:05:15.839 --> 00:05:17.519
Uh let's just keep let's just move on.
00:05:17.680 --> 00:05:37.040
Let's move on, let's rid ourselves of those legacy issues, and let's free up the system to do what it's able to do without any um specific uh physical constraint on the money supply, on the supply of government debt, on government spending, so on and so forth.
00:05:38.160 --> 00:05:48.959
And so what is your main disagreement, if that's the right way to say it, with Warren Mosler or Stephanie Kelton or another MMT proponent?
00:05:49.199 --> 00:05:58.720
Where do you think I mean I know there's going to be many answers here, but what do you think is the fundamental misunderstanding that they have versus what you think would be the better way to do it?
00:05:59.120 --> 00:06:07.120
Well, that jumps way ahead from the pure mechanics of uh uh that the MMT would like us to migrate the monetary system to.
00:06:07.279 --> 00:06:11.120
I mean, they they simply simply want things to be made explicit.
00:06:11.279 --> 00:06:18.079
They simply want the that they simply want to do their version of what what people uh in the mainstream call physical dominance.
00:06:18.399 --> 00:06:29.519
They want to go the whole hog and and and basically get rid of this illusion that somehow an independent central bank is is necessary to running to running the economy.
00:06:30.399 --> 00:06:38.800
And and I mean uh again, in in a certain sense, that they really do have a point, and I have a lot of sympathy with that.
00:06:39.040 --> 00:06:50.560
Um but they they w my concern is that that you you end up throwing out the baby with the bathwater to some extent if you start marching down that road.
00:06:50.879 --> 00:07:14.000
And the history demonstrates pretty clearly that as a general rule, if you remove constraints on government power, however weak, however obscure, however unclear those constraints are, however arbitrary they are, any incremental removal of a constraint tends to result in a net growth of government versus the private sector.
00:07:14.319 --> 00:07:24.079
Uh as we know, government spending is far less productive in an economic sense than what the private sector does, because the private sector's access to capital is naturally restrained.
00:07:24.160 --> 00:07:31.199
They naturally have to pay for it, they have to make proper trade-offs, cost-benefit analyses, and allocate that capital efficiently.
00:07:31.279 --> 00:07:32.879
And if they don't, they go bankrupt.
00:07:33.040 --> 00:07:38.639
Whatever resources they acquired up to that point circulate to another business that's being run more sensibly.
00:07:38.959 --> 00:07:45.439
You go through creative destruction, call it whatever you want, and you come out the other side
with a more productive, stronger, healthier economy.
00:07:45.519 --> 00:07:50.319
I mean, this is the this is this is the lesson of the last couple centuries of economic development.
00:07:50.879 --> 00:08:13.680
And so I worry that if you let MMTers get their way, that we we basically remove the magic from what was a far more dynamic, uh efficient uh economic system with proper price signals, including interest rates, including currency values, that that more efficiently allocate resources.
00:08:13.759 --> 00:08:21.199
That that's a very Austrian take, as it were, on why I think MMT could lead in a very, very bad uh direction.
00:08:21.759 --> 00:08:23.120
Well, so let me ask you this.
00:08:23.279 --> 00:08:33.360
So I'm pretty sure that if if if you if you could advocate for a system, you would make it more of a hard money system or a you know a market-based system, right?
00:08:33.679 --> 00:08:46.240
Okay, so look if if we were to take that option off the table for now, okay, and we and and we go to what the system we currently have, which is kind of, as you've said, this purgatory, which I would agree is kind of in this purgatory.
00:08:46.559 --> 00:08:56.399
Or if we went full MMT and the MMTers had their way and they fully implemented their policies, which do you think would be worse out of those two?
00:08:56.799 --> 00:08:58.399
The current system or the full MMT?
00:08:58.879 --> 00:08:59.440
Okay, okay.
00:08:59.600 --> 00:09:02.480
There's two ways to there's two ways for me to answer that that I can think of.
00:09:02.639 --> 00:09:05.759
The first is a very simple way, the other one is slightly more complex.
00:09:05.919 --> 00:09:07.200
Let's do the simple way.
00:09:08.159 --> 00:09:30.480
Um in a way, if you were simply to say, look, um why if a central bank is always and everywhere willing to fund deficits at whatever interest rate somehow allows nominal GDP growth to reach whatever target you happen to have.
00:09:30.720 --> 00:09:36.159
Um we and we don't really care about the growth-inflation mix because that's what nominal GDP is.
00:09:36.240 --> 00:09:37.679
It's it's a mix of the two.
00:09:38.720 --> 00:10:03.919
You know, if if you if you simply go ahead and do that and and and make it explicit, well then in a way, right, you can get rid of a substantial portion of the existing financial system because the government effectively creates money itself rather than relying on a central bank and a commercial bank system to do so by lending money into existence, not only lending it to the public sector, but to the private sector.
00:10:04.080 --> 00:10:05.840
In MMT, it's very different.
00:10:06.080 --> 00:10:09.039
Um the public sector has senior age, effectively.
00:10:09.440 --> 00:10:20.399
They're the ones that spend the money into existence, and then that money will, through the commercial banking system, move horizontally throughout the private sector.
00:10:20.639 --> 00:10:31.919
And so you could argue that that
you know you're disintermediating what is in that context an unnecessary layer of monetary bureaucracy.
00:10:32.080 --> 00:10:40.559
You know, all these people that work at the Fed can go find other jobs, and you know, they're they're bright people, so you know they'll they'll go become, you know, who knows, accountants, lawyers, you know, whatever.
00:10:40.799 --> 00:10:44.720
And and and so you get you and you get rid of this opacity as well.
00:10:44.879 --> 00:10:52.080
That is, you bring you bring the creation of money and the further creation of credit into the private sector.
00:10:52.240 --> 00:10:55.840
You you remove this public-private opacity.
00:10:57.519 --> 00:11:02.240
People can't even give a clear answer, it seems, whether the Fed is public or private.
00:11:02.720 --> 00:11:03.120
Right?
00:11:03.360 --> 00:11:04.480
Yeah, I think.
00:11:04.799 --> 00:11:05.039
Yeah.
00:11:05.120 --> 00:11:05.679
No, it isn't.
00:11:05.919 --> 00:11:07.039
And so they have a point.
00:11:07.440 --> 00:11:08.399
They have a point.
00:11:08.639 --> 00:11:19.759
If the central bank is just there to fund deficits at below market rates of interest if necessary, to reach whatever nominal GDP target you happen to have, well then get rid of the charade.
00:11:19.919 --> 00:11:22.000
I I I I do I have some sympathy with that.
00:11:22.159 --> 00:11:23.039
I really do.
00:11:23.440 --> 00:11:41.600
But as I said earlier, that puts you on a very slippery slope towards something which is a form of central planning that goes above and beyond what we've been experiencing even since 2008, when clearly, you know, central planning took over for a while.
00:11:41.840 --> 00:11:49.440
Yeah, you know, I'm gonna put something, I'm gonna put a slide up here that I think will help the audience kind of understand what we're talking about a little bit.
00:11:49.600 --> 00:11:55.039
Um, I don't know if we will agree 100% that this, but I'm gonna use this for for display purposes.
00:11:55.200 --> 00:12:01.759
Um, what we have here is if you borrow money and then spend it, or if you spend it into existence.
00:12:02.000 --> 00:12:06.080
And basically, it's basically you borrow first or do you spend first?
00:12:06.559 --> 00:12:13.600
And I think the MMT proponents would say a government doesn't need to borrow, they can just spend the money into existence, right?
00:12:13.840 --> 00:12:23.279
Whereas um someone who believes that money is an emergent phenomenon out of a free market, the government has to borrow that and then spend it.
00:12:23.519 --> 00:12:29.120
And so what I just showed here, again, people can just kind of either download this or take a screenshot.
00:12:29.279 --> 00:12:36.879
Uh I think this does a good job of explaining kind of the free market versus the the the MMT prescription.
00:12:37.120 --> 00:12:40.960
And what I think is really interesting is I think either one of these works.
00:12:41.200 --> 00:12:43.519
Now, one might work better than the other.
00:12:43.679 --> 00:12:53.519
You could even say a feudal system works, it doesn't work very well, and it certainly doesn't work well for for the for the uh you know for the the serfs, but it does work.
00:12:53.600 --> 00:12:57.279
And so the point I think is always important to understand is how does it work?
00:12:57.440 --> 00:13:00.320
If we're in this system, how does it work?
00:13:00.879 --> 00:13:08.080
And I think if if if we were if we went back to the very beginning and we said the government borrowed the money initially.
00:13:08.320 --> 00:13:10.159
Now, whether they did or not, that's a whole other zone.
00:13:10.320 --> 00:13:16.720
But let's just say that they initially borrowed the money and then they spent it, and then they borrowed it, and they spent it and borrowed it and they spent it.
00:13:16.799 --> 00:13:21.679
You get down the road far enough, and it doesn't really matter whether the chicken or the egg came first.
00:13:21.840 --> 00:13:25.600
One comes and then the next comes, and then one comes and then the next comes.
00:13:25.759 --> 00:13:27.919
And so my question to you, John, is on this one.
00:13:28.000 --> 00:13:34.960
Let's go with the system, just focus on the MMT argument for now, where they spend it into existence.
00:13:35.039 --> 00:13:43.519
So the government spends the money into the public economy, the government then borrows some of it back in the they, you know, that they they issue bonds.
00:13:44.080 --> 00:13:45.519
Well, they they might they might not.
00:13:45.600 --> 00:13:47.759
I mean, that that depends, right?
00:13:48.240 --> 00:13:49.840
But but but but they could, right?
00:13:49.919 --> 00:13:52.240
They one of the way to suck up the liquidity.
00:13:52.799 --> 00:13:59.360
But the the key the key thing is that they spend it into existence, by spending it, it ends up in the private sector.
00:13:59.519 --> 00:14:17.360
The private sector then deposits it in the banking system, and the banks then decide what to do with those deposits, who to lend it to, uh, and who to basically the narrow money that the government spends into existence, the monetary base, cash and circulation, and so on.
00:14:17.600 --> 00:14:20.960
Um, that a portion of that ends up in the banking system.
00:14:21.039 --> 00:14:23.919
In fact, most of it ends up in the banking system uh at some point.
00:14:24.159 --> 00:14:32.559
And then the banks decide whether they're going to offer longer-term credit, shorter-term credit, uh, you know, mortgages, uh, who knows what it is.
00:14:32.879 --> 00:14:37.600
And and and so, and so that that's the way I it it works.
00:14:37.759 --> 00:14:45.519
Now, the government has the option of issuing bonds, but it but it's not strictly necessary to that system.
00:14:46.080 --> 00:14:58.720
So I th I so I think correct me if I'm wrong, but I think what you're saying is if they did not borrow and if they kept taxes low and they just kept spending money into existence,
you're gonna have rampant inflation.
00:14:59.120 --> 00:15:02.080
Oh, yeah, I and I think most MMTers would agree with that.
00:15:02.240 --> 00:15:22.879
That's why they say it's very important that the fiscal authority is prepared to adjust taxes in regularly uh in response to indications, whether you're approaching full employment indications, whether you're reaching other resource constraints.
00:15:23.120 --> 00:15:50.320
And as long as you have your eye on the ball and you and you s and you manage to stay one step ahead of of the um of full employment and the resource constraints by raising taxes if necessary to slow the economy, or cutting taxes if necessary to free up resources again to the private sector, as long as you're on the ball 24-7, um then then you know you then you can run the economy smoothly to everyone's benefit.
00:15:51.200 --> 00:15:53.759
Okay, so this is good.
00:15:54.559 --> 00:16:08.480
I think I think we're getting close to a point to where it helps explain why my argument is that while I would not necessarily prescribe this myself, it's important to understand how it works.
00:16:08.559 --> 00:16:12.000
And this is, I think, I'm curious what you think.
00:16:12.320 --> 00:16:17.200
Why I think this can potentially last longer than many people thought it would.
00:16:17.519 --> 00:16:20.480
In other words, they've spent the money into it.
00:16:20.559 --> 00:16:23.519
Let's just go with the idea that they've spent the money into existence.
00:16:23.679 --> 00:16:28.720
They tax some of it back, and they issue debt, which mops up some of it.
00:16:28.799 --> 00:16:34.879
But when they mop up some of that liquidity via debt, the public now has an asset.
00:16:34.960 --> 00:16:38.159
And that is their that you could argue that's public savings.
00:16:38.399 --> 00:16:52.159
And as a result of that happening, while this will eventually, because the government will get out of control, they will spend more than they should, they will not be on the ball as you suggest, and we will eventually have an inflationary nightmare.
00:16:52.320 --> 00:16:56.399
I think it does explain why this can take longer than many people expect.
00:16:56.799 --> 00:16:58.399
Do you agree with that or no?
00:17:00.879 --> 00:17:19.519
Look, um, it it really depends on to what extent uh the the government is responsible in principle and whether they are effective uh at um what is effectively a f uh a very a very comprehensive form of economic central planning.
00:17:19.759 --> 00:17:24.480
Um and and I have huge question marks about both of those, uh to be honest.
00:17:24.960 --> 00:17:30.240
I mean, so it it probably ultimately comes down to flawed individuals trying to manage this.
00:17:30.880 --> 00:17:32.480
Would you agree with that?
00:17:34.319 --> 00:17:34.799
Sorry.
00:17:36.799 --> 00:17:49.599
So I think we've said the system could work like this, and perhaps it even does work like this, but when the individuals who are trying to,
I don't know, stay on the ball, trying to manage the tax rate or the bargain.
00:17:49.920 --> 00:17:50.640
Bureaucracy, right?
00:17:50.880 --> 00:17:56.160
The bureaucracy, while they are trying to manage all this, I think we would both argue.
00:17:56.640 --> 00:17:58.240
Or that this is what they claim to be, yeah.
00:17:58.559 --> 00:18:08.160
They claim to be that this is a much bigger problem, or this is a much bigger issue, and that uh you know 12 guys in DC cannot adequately do this.
00:18:08.240 --> 00:18:08.960
And that's why a free.
00:18:10.319 --> 00:18:10.720
Wait, wait, wait.
00:18:12.319 --> 00:18:16.160
No, I I mean the Politburo, how many members did the Soviet Politburo have?
00:18:16.319 --> 00:18:17.119
Was it 12?
00:18:17.359 --> 00:18:18.559
I'm just making up a number.
00:18:18.640 --> 00:18:20.880
I'm just saying like a handful of watching.
00:18:21.359 --> 00:18:22.240
I'm just making a joke.
00:18:22.319 --> 00:18:22.480
Sorry.
00:18:22.720 --> 00:18:23.359
Yeah, yeah, no.
00:18:23.680 --> 00:18:39.680
No, but that's that's that's essentially what we're saying is it could work like this, but the problem is that it's ultimately up to individuals to try to manage this appropriately, even if the mechanics of it would work, it's still dependent upon individuals.
00:18:40.720 --> 00:18:43.599
On paper, socialism works extremely well.
00:18:43.920 --> 00:18:45.599
I mean, seriously, fair enough.
00:18:45.680 --> 00:18:47.039
What why else would it be so popular?
00:18:47.200 --> 00:18:48.799
I mean, you know, yeah.
00:18:49.119 --> 00:18:55.119
Okay, and so tell me in your words, why this is doomed to fail.
00:18:55.359 --> 00:18:58.319
And it's we we said we're in purgatory now, right?
00:18:58.480 --> 00:19:10.079
And let's so so so maybe in your words, say tell us why purgatory is doomed to fail, and if they if the memtiers got their full wishes, why it would fail, in your opinion.
00:19:10.799 --> 00:19:16.799
Well, I mean, it it it's it's purgatory in one sense, it's a bit of a charade uh in the other.
00:19:17.200 --> 00:19:46.160
So so for the basic beginning in the 20th century and and especially following the the the Second World War, we ended up in a policy regime where there was this uh this sort of policy regime settlement that uh the government would be in charge of fiscal policy and the central bank would set interest rates as necessary to try and maintain some degree of price stability.
00:19:46.319 --> 00:19:47.279
Now, I know that the U.S.
00:19:47.359 --> 00:19:58.000
Fed mandate is dual, but the the post-war settlement was much more, had much more to do about price stability as the Fed's role than full employment.
00:19:58.079 --> 00:20:09.279
That was sort of slotted in uh later on for political reasons, although you could argue it put uh that policy regime on a slippery slope towards the purgatory we've ended up in.
00:20:10.000 --> 00:20:13.279
So there was this idea that you should have independent central banks.
00:20:13.440 --> 00:20:18.160
Of course, Milton Friedman and the Chicago School were the great champions of this idea.
00:20:18.720 --> 00:20:22.400
And on paper, uh it's not an unreasonable idea.
00:20:22.480 --> 00:20:27.039
I mean, you know, Milton Friedman gets the Nobel Prize in Economics for you know for good reason.
00:20:27.200 --> 00:20:28.240
He made a point.
00:20:28.720 --> 00:20:40.240
And and uh and and anyway, but the thing, but even Milton Friedman, even Milton Friedman, when pressed, especially later in life when he didn't really have any social ladder to climb anymore.
00:20:40.319 --> 00:20:43.519
He'd kind of achieved everything he could ever have hoped to achieve.
00:20:44.000 --> 00:20:48.720
When pressed, you know, what happens if the government and the central bank really have it out with one another?
00:20:48.960 --> 00:20:59.039
And the government wants to run deficits, and the central bank doesn't want to finance them at uh low enough interest rates to achieve whatever employment target the government happens to have.
00:20:59.279 --> 00:21:02.400
Um Milton Friedman said that the central bank would always lose.
00:21:02.799 --> 00:21:04.480
He was clear on that when you pressed him.
00:21:04.640 --> 00:21:07.039
The central bank will always give in.
00:21:07.200 --> 00:21:08.000
So do you agree?
00:21:08.240 --> 00:21:10.240
This idea that central bank is independent.
00:21:10.799 --> 00:21:11.920
Do you agree with him, by the way?
00:21:12.079 --> 00:21:15.279
Do you agree with Milton Friedman that the central bank would always lose?
00:21:15.599 --> 00:21:16.400
Yes, I do.
00:21:16.640 --> 00:21:16.960
I agree.
00:21:17.039 --> 00:21:17.759
Okay, I do too.
00:21:17.920 --> 00:21:18.400
Okay, go ahead.
00:21:18.480 --> 00:21:18.720
Sorry.
00:21:18.880 --> 00:21:32.720
Yeah, yeah, I I I I mean the central bank can try to bring the government down, but if the government is properly politically astute and connected and truly in control of the elite of the country, they they will win that one.
00:21:32.799 --> 00:21:36.240
And you'll end up with fiscal dominance and or MMT.
00:21:36.319 --> 00:21:40.480
You know, outright, outright MMT when the government simply takes over.
00:21:40.720 --> 00:21:45.119
So so I I I think Friedman saw that later, especially again, especially later in life.
00:21:45.279 --> 00:21:50.880
He might have seen it when he was younger, but was unwilling to talk to say that because it would damage his reputation.
00:21:50.960 --> 00:21:54.960
Uh but but when you know, once he once he was in his 80s, he didn't care anymore, right?
00:21:55.279 --> 00:21:56.880
Uh same with Greenspan.
00:21:57.039 --> 00:21:59.759
You know, Greenspan uh said some very forthright things.
00:22:00.319 --> 00:22:06.480
Uh not immediately after his retirement, but a couple decades after his retirement, he started to speak his mind.
00:22:07.519 --> 00:22:08.640
So that's not so uncommon.
00:22:08.799 -->
00:22:12.079
Anyway, so so sorry, I I've gone off on a tangent now.
00:22:12.240 --> 00:22:12.720
No, that's right.
00:22:12.960 --> 00:22:20.799
Um but but uh sorry, what what what re- restate precisely what it is you want me to to opine on here.
00:22:21.119 --> 00:22:31.839
Well, no, I was just just curious what if if if what you thought the you know why why why this is ultimately going to fail.
00:22:32.000 --> 00:22:34.880
In other words, we we we talked about we're in purgatory.
00:22:35.440 --> 00:22:40.160
We talked about how if the if the MMAT proponents had their way, it would go even further.
00:22:40.400 --> 00:22:40.960
Right.
00:22:41.359 --> 00:22:46.480
And my question, I guess, is to you is what's I mean, I know you could expand on this for an hour.
00:22:46.720 --> 00:22:48.559
Okay, so there's a couple minutes.
00:22:48.720 --> 00:22:50.079
Why will this lead to failure?
00:22:50.319 --> 00:22:50.559
Right.
00:22:50.720 --> 00:22:53.599
So one step further on from where I just was.
00:22:54.079 --> 00:23:02.400
The fact is, is that so the central bank loses, you get fiscal dominance, you move on to full MMT where the government is spending money into existence.
00:23:02.640 --> 00:23:17.119
The central bank is just there as a liquidity manager, basically, to allow that liquidity um to uh to be provided to the to the commercial banking system and to support economic activity, commercial activity generally.
00:23:17.599 --> 00:23:26.160
But the government's in charge and the government is is spending money into existence, they may or may not issue debt depending on policy preferences, political, whatever it is.
00:23:26.240 --> 00:23:29.839
Um they may have to raise taxes from time to time because of resource constraints.
00:23:29.920 --> 00:23:44.079
But every time, every time there is a dispute about, gee, maybe we're running things a little hot, you're gonna have these political battles fought regarding can we get away with a little more largesse?
00:23:45.680 --> 00:23:50.799
Can we keep the economy going through the next election cycle, maybe?
00:23:51.039 --> 00:23:55.839
Um, can we redefine inflation and tell the public that it's not actually a problem when it is?
00:23:56.079 --> 00:23:59.839
You're gonna get into all of these political shenanigans.
00:24:00.000 --> 00:24:02.880
These people are going to become increasingly unaccountable.
00:24:03.039 --> 00:24:05.279
They're gonna try to get away with murder.
00:24:05.359 --> 00:24:13.839
Um, and sadly, if there's not a constraint, uh a true constraint on their power, they will get away with murder.
00:24:14.000 --> 00:24:16.640
And it will be an economic disaster, in my opinion.
00:24:16.799 --> 00:24:18.960
So the problem is an incentive problem.
00:24:19.279 --> 00:24:22.799
It is a um, what do you call it, control fraud.
00:24:22.960 --> 00:24:34.559
You end up with a severe control fraud where you give people practically unlimited fiscal and monetary power, and there's no effective check on that power.
00:24:34.799 --> 00:24:44.799
There's not even really transparency because they can just redefine the economic aggregates however they like, make it up as they go, uh, and and there's nothing anyone can do about it.
00:24:45.920 --> 00:24:46.880
That's where we end up.
00:24:47.119 --> 00:24:49.440
Not a good place to okay.
00:24:49.759 --> 00:24:51.440
So agreed.
00:24:51.680 --> 00:24:55.119
Um let's let's dial it back just for a second.
00:24:55.200 --> 00:25:01.200
And let's talk about the purgatory that we're in right now, or if we went further into MMT.
00:25:02.400 --> 00:25:15.599
Um it's my opinion, based on my understanding of MMT, is that you can't have a public savings or private savings.
00:25:15.759 --> 00:25:26.640
The private market can't have savings if the public is not running a deficit or if the government is not running a deficit, which kind of leads to the national debt.
00:25:26.799 --> 00:25:32.480
Um, and so this is kind of a two-part question, but let's let's and maybe I'll bring this graphic back up here to talk about this.
00:25:32.559 --> 00:25:42.240
But in the system we have now, because we do agree that we're in this like purgatory system that leans MMT adjacent, perhaps is the right way to say it.
00:25:42.559 --> 00:25:56.559
In that system, if we were to pay off the national debt, which we know we can't, but if we were to attempt to pay off the national debt, and if we were to get reasonably close, that would be sucking the savings out of the private market.
00:25:58.079 --> 00:26:06.960
And it would actually decrease the amount of collateral in the world, and it would create a depression unless we changed the monetary system.
00:26:08.000 --> 00:26:10.559
Do you agree with me on that or do you disagree with me on that?
00:26:10.880 --> 00:26:20.240
Well, see, this is where this is one of the fundamental fallacies of MMT, but then you could argue it's a fundamental fallacy of neo-Keynesian economic thinking, too.
00:26:21.119 --> 00:26:38.960
Um, in the same way Keynes argued that if you get into a downturn, the government needs to become the borrower and spender of last resort to prevent complete, complete breakdown, widespread bankruptcies, Great Depression type stuff, and whatnot.
00:26:39.119 --> 00:26:43.200
So he so that so the government was sort of the borrower and lender of last resort.
00:26:43.359 --> 00:26:52.319
That said, Keynes uh also had a responsible side where he said, oh, by the way, once you come out of the slump, you need to run surpluses and pay down the debt.
00:26:52.640 --> 00:26:54.079
He was very clear on that.
00:26:54.400 --> 00:26:57.920
So Keynes is not quite the villain that some people make him out to be.
00:26:58.000 --> 00:27:02.880
Uh well, it depends on what aspect of his personality and lifestyle we're talking about, but let's not go there.
00:27:03.119 --> 00:27:08.559
Um anyway, so but but that that to me is a fundamental economic
fallacy.
00:27:08.880 --> 00:27:14.720
The fact is, within the private sector itself, let's assume the government is so small it's irrelevant.
00:27:15.359 --> 00:27:20.160
Let's assume this is like pre-Civil War, you know, federal government size, when the U.S.
00:27:20.240 --> 00:27:27.279
was industrializing rapidly, the the uh economic growth was was super high compared to where it is today.
00:27:27.440 --> 00:27:37.119
Um I mean it was just explosive economically, and yet the federal government was maybe 2%, if that, 3% of economic activity.
00:27:39.519 --> 00:27:48.000
How did all those businesses that were growing rapidly pre-Civil War how how how did they finance their expansion?
00:27:49.039 --> 00:27:50.960
How how did where did they get the money?
00:27:51.839 --> 00:27:55.359
The private sector got the money from itself.
00:27:55.839 --> 00:28:05.839
There were people in the private sector who wanted to say, there were people in the private sector who wanted to borrow, and they found ways to meet within the financial system of the day.
00:28:06.000 --> 00:28:10.960
The government played literally zero role in most of that.
00:28:11.200 --> 00:28:12.480
Around the margins, yes.
00:28:12.559 --> 00:28:12.720
Right?
00:28:12.880 --> 00:28:19.759
You have the canal projects, you had some railroad financing, that will eventually blow up because the government subsidizes it too much.
00:28:20.079 --> 00:28:26.480
But anyway, there's no reason why the private sector cannot save with itself, borrow and save with itself.
00:28:26.640 --> 00:28:29.200
It doesn't need the government to intermediate credit.
00:28:29.359 --> 00:28:33.920
Marx thought it did, and that's why he threw that into the Communist Manifesto, plank number five.
00:28:34.160 --> 00:28:41.759
Very important to Marx that the government takes the power to borrow and save away from the private sector and does it itself instead.
00:28:41.920 --> 00:28:44.480
Um, but it doesn't need to be done that way.
00:28:45.200 --> 00:28:49.440
So I agree if we were starting anew, it doesn't need to be done that way.
00:28:49.599 --> 00:28:57.359
But if we start for if you and I get assigned to Washington by threat of a gun to our head and we have to solve this, right?
00:28:58.079 --> 00:29:06.400
How do we, if we were to pay off the national debt in the system we currently have, that would make money disappear.
00:29:06.640 --> 00:29:09.279
And that would, by definition, be deflationary.
00:29:09.920 --> 00:29:10.319
Wait, wait, wait.
00:29:10.400 --> 00:29:11.599
I'm not sure I agree with that.
00:29:11.759 --> 00:29:12.720
I'm not sure I agree.
00:29:12.880 --> 00:29:16.400
Um this is where I was trying to get to.
00:29:16.720 --> 00:29:17.039
Okay.
00:29:17.440 --> 00:29:17.839
Good.
00:29:18.000 --> 00:29:19.680
All right, look, we can have it out now.
00:29:19.839 --> 00:29:20.079
Yeah.
00:29:20.240 --> 00:29:23.920
Um we can go on as we're going.
00:29:24.240 --> 00:29:35.200
Um, we
can continue to run deficits, we can continue to finance those deficits at below natural market rates of interest, uh, which of course is long-term inflationary.
00:29:35.759 --> 00:29:47.519
We can continue to suck resources out of the private sector into the public sector, uh, therefore, from relatively more productive uses to relatively less productive uses, um, economic potential growth will continue to decline.
00:29:47.680 --> 00:30:00.480
Eventually it will approach zero, and uh we'll end up, you know, kind of like Japan, but worse because we'll have uh a far higher crime rate uh and uh less cultural homogeneity and whatnot and so on.
00:30:00.720 --> 00:30:02.640
Okay, that's option, that's one option.
00:30:02.880 --> 00:30:08.559
The other option is we say, you know what, we really, really shouldn't continue down that road much longer.
00:30:08.799 --> 00:30:17.759
It will end in disaster, and therefore, we need to figure out how to how to do something about this chronic deficit and debt problem that we have.
00:30:18.000 --> 00:30:30.960
So, okay, let's revalue gold to$50,000 and therefore devalue the dollar accordingly.
00:30:31.839 --> 00:30:35.359
Uh at that gold price, the debt becomes serviceable.
00:30:35.519 --> 00:30:40.480
Now, sadly, a huge wave of inflation is going to roll through the economy as other prices adjust.
00:30:40.720 --> 00:31:01.759
But the good news is if you if you revalue gold and then repay to gold, following that massive one-off wave of inflation, interest rates will decline to very low levels because you'll have the confidence in the gold backing being credible and the debt being paid down in a sustainable, credible way.
00:31:02.240 --> 00:31:09.039
And therefore you'll have an economic boom, the uh the likes of which we probably haven't seen since the end of the Second World War.
00:31:09.599 --> 00:31:26.480
That to me is difficult, politically extremely difficult to deliver, but that is a credible, sustainable way out of this based on economic history, um, and simply based on running the numbers as the as they currently are.
00:31:26.640 --> 00:31:28.640
Uh so that is an option.
00:31:28.799 --> 00:31:31.839
I I don't see the political will to do that.
00:31:32.079 --> 00:31:38.160
Uh the political will currently is just to keep kicking the can, but um, that doesn't lead to a very good place.
00:31:38.960 --> 00:31:41.119
So if we so again, I agree.
00:31:41.279 --> 00:31:50.720
And I think I believe that that's one of the reasons that governments around the world hold gold because they know if they ever got forced to do that, they could do that.
00:31:50.880 --> 00:31:52.000
I don't think they want to do it.
00:31:52.079 --> 00:31:57.119
I don't think they're planning to do it, but I think they know if they had to do it, they could do that.
00:31:57.359 --> 00:32:00.799
But coming back to let's take a step back.
00:32:00.960 --> 00:32:05.920
Let's pretend that we didn't have any gold and we didn't have that option.
00:32:06.720 --> 00:32:13.359
Would you agree that paying down the national debt or even paying it off would be deflationary?
00:32:13.839 --> 00:32:15.440
Well, the thing is that the U.S.
00:32:15.519 --> 00:32:18.079
runs a chronic current account deficit, right?
00:32:18.240 --> 00:32:22.640
Uh, which is the legacy of, of course, running a chronic trade deficit.
00:32:23.440 --> 00:32:25.920
And so we're a huge debtor to the rest of the world.
00:32:26.079 --> 00:32:40.720
If you don't have any gold, if you don't have any reserves, then the only realistic way to pay off your debt is to devalue versus the rest of the world and export your way out of it to get to get your economy back in balance.
00:32:40.880 --> 00:32:43.200
You need competitive labor globally.
00:32:43.599 --> 00:32:50.960
Um that way you could service the debt without resort to a deflationary collapse.
00:32:51.200 --> 00:32:57.359
You would you you would do it through inflation uh and export-led uh growth instead.
00:32:57.599 --> 00:32:59.039
So that that could be done.
00:33:00.720 --> 00:33:06.000
But it would do you agree it would be deflationary in the short term, or you don't think it would be deflationary to pay off the debt?
00:33:06.319 --> 00:33:09.680
Only only if it's done in a mismanaged, disruptive way.
00:33:09.839 --> 00:33:46.640
I I I think if the if if the if the US uh simply um you know was was willing to was willing to do that, if if the US was simply willing to accept that, to accept a weaker dollar, uh, and to uh you know force labor costs to come down uh vis-a-vis the rest of the world, and other countries would resist that, of course, uh and and so and and and and so everybody would devalue versus everybody, and of course that would be generally inflationary, and that would make everyone's debts more serviceable uh to the point where they could be paid down without resort to deflation.
00:33:46.799 --> 00:33:50.000
Um this is the part where I lose you.
00:33:50.160 --> 00:33:53.839
If money is disappearing, how is it inflationary?
00:33:54.160 --> 00:33:55.200
It's not disappearing.
00:33:55.279 --> 00:33:56.480
You're you're everyone's creating more.
00:33:57.920 --> 00:33:59.359
How is it not disappearing?
00:33:59.599 --> 00:34:03.839
If you're paying off, if everyone's creating everyone's creating more money relatively.
00:34:04.240 --> 00:34:05.200
How are they creating more money?
00:34:05.279 --> 00:34:06.720
How are they creating more money?
00:34:06.960 --> 00:34:10.400
Well, they lend it into existence, they spend it into existence.
00:34:11.039 --> 00:34:12.400
No, but okay, but okay.
00:34:12.559 --> 00:34:15.760
Maybe you're missing my my supposition.
00:34:16.000 --> 00:34:27.920
My supposition is that we start paying off the net with whatever budget surplus we have, instead of a deficit, we retire debt.
00:34:28.159 --> 00:34:32.239
And when we retire debt, oh you don't need to retire debt.
00:34:32.400 -->
00:34:36.320
You you just you just you you you you you just fulfill your obligations, right?
00:34:36.400 --> 00:34:37.599
You don't just retire it.
00:34:37.760 --> 00:34:41.679
You you you you you you can pay it down gradually over time.
00:34:42.000 --> 00:34:42.159
Right?
00:34:42.800 --> 00:34:43.119
Okay.
00:34:43.360 --> 00:35:01.119
We could but if we chose to pay my point is is if we were to pay down, aggressively pay down the debt, not just let it mature, not just spend a little less, if we were to aggressively go from 40 trillion in debt to 19 trillion in debt.
00:35:01.599 --> 00:35:03.440
That would be deflationary.
00:35:03.679 --> 00:35:04.000
Okay, okay.
00:35:04.159 --> 00:35:04.880
That would be deflationary.
00:35:05.119 --> 00:35:05.360
So I'm not sure.
00:35:05.519 --> 00:35:06.559
Okay, so we agree on the mechanic.
00:35:06.719 --> 00:35:10.239
I just want to make sure we're I don't I wanted to make sure we agreed on the I'm thinking more debt.
00:35:10.320 --> 00:35:14.079
I'm thinking more I'm thinking more about debt in real terms versus national income.
00:35:14.239 --> 00:35:24.639
So the thing is is that in in the nominal amounts of debt might never decline, but if you devalue enough, it goes from being 120% of GDP to 1.2% of GDP.
00:35:24.800 --> 00:35:28.239
And then it's a non-issue that nobody cares about anymore, right?
00:35:28.639 --> 00:35:30.480
Uh that would not be deflationary.
00:35:30.639 --> 00:35:31.840
That would be inflationary.
00:35:32.079 --> 00:35:32.239
Right.
00:35:32.400 --> 00:35:35.519
But if okay, I I'm we agree on the mechanics at least.
00:35:35.679 --> 00:35:38.320
Uh okay, so now here's a question for you.
00:35:38.639 --> 00:35:40.320
I'm sure you've thought of this.
00:35:40.480 --> 00:35:48.480
Now let's go back to the the case that you you you you supposed a few minutes ago where we used our the gold reserves.
00:35:48.559 --> 00:35:51.599
We revalued gold to, I don't know, 25,000, 50,000.
00:35:51.760 --> 00:36:00.320
You pick your number, that money gets deposited into they they they repegged the gold, that money gets deposited into the treasury's general account.
00:36:00.480 --> 00:36:05.840
There's a wave of inflation because you know all the prices adjust, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, right?
00:36:05.920 --> 00:36:08.880
The dollar is devalued dramatically.
00:36:09.519 --> 00:36:16.559
Okay, so in that scenario, the people who held real assets and gold do phenomenally well.
00:36:17.679 --> 00:36:19.360
Before taxes, yes.
00:36:20.239 --> 00:36:24.960
Which there would probably be some kind of a windfall tax attached to that, but let's say there wasn't.
00:36:25.119 --> 00:36:37.760
Now, the people who didn't hold real assets or hard assets or gold or whatever, their dollars are devalued, their retirement savings are devalued, they do phenomenally badly in this scenario, right?
00:36:38.400 --> 00:36:38.719
Okay.
00:36:39.280 --> 00:36:49.599
So here's my why is it preferable
to do predominantly badly for the majority of the population all at once rather than a little bit at a time over 30 years?
00:36:50.079 --> 00:36:56.719
Well, I think policymakers always prefer to um not have the frog jump out of the slowly boiling pot.
00:36:56.960 --> 00:37:00.559
Uh but the problem is it's that that's a difficult game to play.
00:37:00.800 --> 00:37:12.880
And if you if you overdo it and you spend too much, if politics allows that spending to run too unconstrained for too long, you know, the frog, the frog jumps out and you and and and you lose control.
00:37:13.519 --> 00:37:23.920
So they they nobody wants to just you know initiate and oversee a reset unless they truly fundamentally believe they have the political capital to do so.
00:37:24.079 --> 00:37:39.599
You know, there's a reason why Argentina had to go through what it went through for so long for people to finally decide that yes, this guy waving a chainsaw around is the solution to to what's to this can kicking.
00:37:39.840 --> 00:37:51.360
And and so he get and so Malay gets elected, and he remains extremely popular, notwithstanding having cut the government budget by something like I forget what it is now, it's like 60 or 80 percent.
00:37:51.440 --> 00:37:52.800
It's unbelievable.
00:37:53.039 --> 00:37:55.599
Um so it can be done.
00:37:55.920 --> 00:37:57.599
It can be done.
00:37:57.920 --> 00:38:01.199
But Argentina is the exception that proves the rule.
00:38:01.360 --> 00:38:15.519
Very, very few countries uh ever come round to that sort of realization without having gone through severe prolonged inflation, uh, you know, bureaucratic mismanagement and hardship prior.
00:38:16.800 --> 00:38:25.840
Okay, so so in our scenario where we revalue gold higher, we go back to a gold standard, we peg the dollar to whatever the dollar value is.
00:38:26.239 --> 00:38:31.199
In that scenario, we do have mass hardship, right?
00:38:31.360 --> 00:38:36.480
Because people's savings are wiped out or they're entitled, all that stuff, right?
00:38:36.639 --> 00:38:47.280
Is it your belief that the boom would come after that would more than off or would at least partially, if not more than offset that one-time immense hardship?
00:38:47.440 --> 00:38:50.719
And that would be preferable to slow hardship?
00:38:51.039 --> 00:38:54.719
It would take it would take a few it would take a few years for the economy to adjust.
00:38:54.880 --> 00:39:15.280
So basically, um obviously to do the reset properly, not just to repeg the gold and allow interest rates to get down to a low level uh to allow people to rebuild, because that again, they would naturally be at a very low level if we if we repegged to gold, you know, probably on the order of, I don't know, two, maybe three percent, something like that.
00:39:15.679 --> 00:39:23.440
Um But of course, the government would therefore no longer be able to finance deficits because of the gold constraint.
00:39:23.519 --> 00:39:26.880
They wouldn't be able to spend more money into existence, a la MMT.
00:39:27.360 --> 00:39:45.840
And so the government would no longer be able to do things like, you know, pay people not to work, uh pay green or other unprofitable, inefficient industries to somehow exist because it's politically, you know, uh popular, um, the defense budget would have to come way down, the U.S.
00:39:45.920 --> 00:39:50.079
would no longer be able to fund prolonged, expensive wars all over the world.
00:39:50.239 --> 00:39:55.119
Um, those would be tough decisions to make, and yet that they would have to be made, and I think they would be made.
00:39:55.280 --> 00:40:15.199
And if you free up all the resources from defense, if you free up all the resources from paying people not to work, if you free up all the resources subsidizing inefficient, chronically unprofitable industries, you know, wait maybe two or three years, and the boom will be, you know, as big as anything that we've experienced in the post-war era.
00:40:15.519 --> 00:40:28.079
Um, all these new technologies that we think are so wonderful would actually be put to efficient uses uh as opposed to just allowing you know people to entertain themselves on social media all day long while they're paid not to work.
00:40:28.320 --> 00:40:30.079
So um it could be done.
00:40:30.320 --> 00:40:32.800
It would be tough, but we would get through the other side.
00:40:33.039 --> 00:40:34.800
We got through the Great Depression.
00:40:34.960 --> 00:40:38.719
Uh in fact, the Great Depression wasn't the first Great Depression, by the way, right?
00:40:38.800 --> 00:40:45.199
That was the one after the Civil War when the greenbacks were being retired and paid down, and that was very deflationary.
00:40:45.360 --> 00:40:47.519
Um it anyway, it could be done.
00:40:47.760 --> 00:40:48.800
You know, there's another one.
00:40:48.880 --> 00:40:55.679
I I you probably know this, but if you don't, if if you don't, I'm gonna tell you, and if you already do, then we'll let the audience uh learn about this.
00:40:55.840 --> 00:41:13.280
But there was another almost Great Depression in 1920, where the market had a huge downturn, and Warren Harding, rather than bail everybody out, slashed slashed the government budget, let deflation run rampant.
00:41:13.519 --> 00:41:19.679
He's the most hated president in history because he didn't bail everybody out and he made everybody take the tough medicine.
00:41:19.840 --> 00:41:21.280
And guess what came next?
00:41:21.519 --> 00:41:22.960
The Roaring Twenties.
00:41:23.199 --> 00:41:24.559
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:41:24.719 --> 00:41:33.280
And the the first part of the Roaring Twenties was a genuine, healthy, economic boom, fueled in part by new technologies.
00:41:33.440 --> 00:41:40.159
That is, uh, by the time you get to the 1920s, right, there there's oil and distillage are flowing everywhere, right?
00:41:40.320 --> 00:41:42.079
There are railroads everywhere.
00:41:42.239 -->
00:41:48.719
You've got energy, you've got transport, you have all this new infrastructure to support industries of all kinds.
00:41:49.280 --> 00:41:57.199
And and and and so uh, but sadly, you know, it it gets it it gets carried away in the late 20s because as it always does, right?
00:41:57.440 --> 00:41:58.320
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:41:58.480 --> 00:42:00.639
But the first part of it was actually very healthy.
00:42:00.960 --> 00:42:07.360
1927 is the year that it goes from being healthy to being unhealthy, in my opinion, but economic historians you know debate that.
00:42:07.519 --> 00:42:09.840
Uh, but yeah, so it it it could be done.
00:42:10.239 --> 00:42:11.199
It could be done.
00:42:11.519 --> 00:42:12.320
It could be done.
00:42:12.480 --> 00:42:14.079
Well, I think we're gonna wrap it up.
00:42:14.159 --> 00:42:23.360
Um, John, you and I could talk another two or three hours about this, and I'm sure I'm probably I'm sure this topic will uh come up again in some form or another as we go forward with this series.
00:42:23.519 --> 00:42:26.239
But uh I always enjoy talking to you about this stuff.
00:42:26.320 --> 00:42:31.440
Uh I always learn stuff from when I talk to you, and you know, thanks again for agreeing to do this.
00:42:31.920 --> 00:42:34.000
Oh, my my my pleasure is good fun.
00:42:38.639 --> 00:42:41.280
Well, that was fun and engaging.
00:42:42.079 --> 00:42:54.400
We had a good back and forth, Brent and I agreeing to some extent, disagreeing to some extent, agreeing on generalities, I would say, for the most part, disagreeing on certain specifics.
00:42:55.599 --> 00:43:45.679
But one thing that I think came out of this is that whether you agree or not with the tenets of modern monetary theory, wrestling with it and considering it and using it as a framework for trying to understand how the workings of the current system we have works in all is actually quite helpful because we're simply not told or taught that the money we use is some combination of being loaned into existence, usually by a central bank and commercial banks, or uh spent into existence by governments.
00:43:46.639 --> 00:43:57.039
In a way, it's a combination of the two, and in a way it almost doesn't really matter, which is sort of the MMT crowd's point.
00:43:58.079 --> 00:45:56.320
If governments can simply spend money into existence you you don't need uh this elaborate central banking apparatus you don't need this uh large uh interest burden uh to carry uh as a government if you believe that uh it's not inflationary and so if it's not inflationary to spend money into existence uh then then why burden yourself with debt payments why why burden yourself with anything if there are spare resources to be used up use them but again this is where my concerns grow this idea that deficits don't matter that spend that public sector spending doesn't matter the fact is resources are not only constrained to the extent that those constrained resources are monopolized or acquired by the public sector they will not be available to the private sector and that's my biggest criticism of MMT it's not this idea that of course if you wanted to you could spend money into existence governments have the power to do that circumvent the central bank but that that is damaging to an economy to divert resources from the private sector that faces competition that must satisfy its customers to make a profit and survive vis-a-vis the public sector that doesn't face competition and doesn't need to satisfy anyone except at the ballot box and who the hell knows what might happen at the ballot box depending on what shenanigans are being played out uh in Washington or if we're talking about other countries such as here in the UK uh Westminster so that's my concern now Brent points out quite rightly that you can boil the frog in the pot for a long time.
00:45:56.559 --> 00:46:13.840
As Adam Smith said there is a lot of ruin in a nation there are a lot of things that the government can do that are not helpful, not salutary, do not further the national interest but they do them and they do them over sustained periods of time.
00:46:14.079 --> 00:46:21.119
And as investors we have to find a way to nevertheless deal with that environment in a practical way.
00:46:21.519 --> 00:46:23.840
And so what's the practical takeaway here?
00:46:24.000 --> 00:46:45.440
In my opinion we need to accept that we are already living in a structurally inflationary world and we need to structure our portfolios accordingly not just because the price level is going to be rising but because that rising price level will also be associated with the misallocation of resources around the margin.
00:46:45.679 --> 00:46:59.039
And so we need to invest accordingly to invest in industries that have pricing power and that will have a profit stream that keeps up with or exceeds inflation over time.
00:46:59.199 --> 00:47:21.679
Those tend to be basic industries and those the ones that I've been and will continue to recommend I avoid the intangible bubble industries because those are the ones that simply benefit from the occasional hype and the occasional mania but don't structurally address the problem of living in this structurally inflationary world.
00:47:21.920 --> 00:47:25.760
So I enjoyed my chat with Brent and I hope it was helpful and enjoyable for you.
00:47:26.000 --> 00:47:26.880
Thank you.
00:47:29.440 --> 00:47:49.360
Yesterday's discussion with John was really fun and that is exactly the reason I kind of wanted to do this whole series to begin with because these topics are important to under really more than anything to gain an understanding of how things currently are, how they could be and what the implications of staying the same or moving to something different are.
00:47:49.599 --> 00:48:05.679
And I think my biggest takeaway from yesterday's episode was you know one that you know I think we probably all know but we probably need to be reminded of time and time and time again is that all of these things work great in an ivory tower.
00:48:05.840 --> 00:48:18.559
They all pencil out great on a spreadsheet the problem comes when we have individuals who must implement them and then oversee them and be responsible for them.
00:48:18.800 --> 00:48:55.679
And regardless of which system we have at the end of the day they are run by individuals and individuals have flaws individuals can lose focus individuals can be misaligned or misdirected and they can be selfish and they can eat they can also make mistakes they can have the greatest intentions in the world but still make mistakes and I think that is what's to be remembered um at the end of the day these systems are overseen and implemented by people and people have flaws and despite the greatest of intentions things can go wrong.
00:48:55.840 --> 00:49:12.320
And in my mind this is why I'm a free market guy I think that it's better to let the wisdom of the crowd or let the wisdom of the market figure this out rather than having a group of people do it on their own thinking that they know better than the will of the market.
00:49:12.480 --> 00:49:28.880
So that's my biggest takeaway it's a good reminder and I think John did a good job of explaining while even though you know the MMT method may look good on paper why it often ends up leads to to bad outcomes if fully implemented.
00:49:28.960 --> 00:49:34.719
So anyway that's my takeaway hope you guys enjoyed this episode and we'll be back next week