TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.160 --> 00:00:03.439
Hi, Peter here for a quick cold open.
00:00:03.680 --> 00:00:13.039
In this episode, I'm going to be talking about the recent investigative report by CNN into the traffic and activity on a website called motherless.com.
00:00:13.199 --> 00:00:24.079
While the episode's focus is not sexual assault itself, there still will be frank conversation about it and about the harm done by men who prey on others for their own gratification.
00:00:24.239 --> 00:00:28.960
If that's not something you're looking to hear about on a podcast, I totally understand.
00:00:29.120 --> 00:00:35.600
I've got other episodes besides this one that you can check out, or you can just skip it or come back to it when you feel ready.
00:00:35.759 --> 00:00:50.719
If you or someone you know and love are the victims of domestic or sexual violence in the United States, you can call the National Domestic Violence Hotline at 1-800-799-7233.
00:00:51.119 --> 00:00:54.960
Or you can chat online at thehotline.org.
00:00:55.119 --> 00:00:57.439
All calls are free and confidential.
00:00:57.679 --> 00:01:03.679
You matter, and you don't have to endure abuse, coercion, or manipulation to deserve love.
00:01:03.920 --> 00:01:06.799
There are people who care about you and support you.
00:01:07.120 --> 00:01:08.239
There is hope.
00:01:09.040 --> 00:01:10.480
Okay, thank you for listening.
00:01:10.719 --> 00:01:12.319
Let's move on to the episode.
00:01:17.519 --> 00:01:35.120
In March of 2026, a CNN as equals investigative report detailed the online activities of individuals posting to the website for pornographic videos, motherless.com, a quote, morals-free file host where anything legal is hosted forever.
00:01:35.359 --> 00:01:53.280
The report suggested that, no, much of its content did not seem to be legal at first blush, especially a popular category of videos known as sleep videos, in which users film themselves or others committing sexual violence upon and raping their unconscious partners.
00:01:53.760 --> 00:01:55.840
Here is how the report describes it.
00:01:59.599 --> 00:02:06.719
In these videos, men film themselves lifting the closed eyelids of women to show they are sleeping or sedated.
00:02:07.200 --> 00:02:12.000
With some eye check videos surpassing 50,000 views.
00:02:12.639 --> 00:02:25.199
Inside the motherless sleep community, first reported on by German investigative journalists Isabel Beer and Isabel Stroh, members trade advice on how to drug their partners.
00:02:27.039 --> 00:02:37.599
The report goes on to describe how the reporters maintained contact with individuals who were and are members of group chats and message boards devoted to these predations.
00:02:38.000 --> 00:02:46.960
They learned that men trade secrets, talk about what kinds of drugs to use to incapacitate their partners, the right doses, the best circumstances to try it.
00:02:47.840 --> 00:03:06.319
One of the hardest things for people who have no experience with this kind of thing, either as a perpetrator or a victim, is to understand how it is that someone could ever get in the headspace where they would find these actions not only permissible, but the kind of thing that you would collaborate in community to try and optimize.
00:03:06.639 --> 00:03:18.479
I play video games, so I'm no stranger to reading message boards and even commenting from time to time about the best ways to equip your party to take on an optional super boss in Final Fantasy V.
00:03:18.879 --> 00:03:37.680
But I would say that the amount of time I've spent on this particular endeavor pales in comparison to the amount of time and effort these men have put into literally committing crimes against people they claim to love, not to mention the risks they take exposing themselves to others on the internet and potentially to their victims.
00:03:38.080 --> 00:03:46.479
At some point, a guy doing this has to just turn off something in their brain or their conscience that says, hey, this isn't a good idea.
00:03:46.639 --> 00:03:48.000
This is wrong.
00:03:50.319 --> 00:03:52.639
How does a person get to this point?
00:03:52.879 --> 00:03:55.759
And is there anything society can do to fix it?
00:03:56.000 --> 00:04:01.520
Or is someone who commits an act of this heinous just morally bankrupt forever?
00:04:02.879 --> 00:04:04.240
Hi, I'm Peter.
00:04:04.400 --> 00:04:22.399
I'm a professor of ethics and your host for this episode of Things You Can Do, an ethics podcast of approximate regularity, where I take your ethics questions and transmography them into meaningful answers so that you can know some things you can do.
00:05:03.600 --> 00:05:09.120
And before we were married, I would often refer to her in my YouTube videos as girlfriend of the show Meg.
00:05:09.279 --> 00:05:11.920
Similar to how I would refer to a friend of the show.
00:05:12.079 --> 00:05:16.319
But when we got married, wife of the show Meg just sounded weird.
00:05:16.480 --> 00:05:19.839
And also it lent itself to too many bull rat type moments.
00:05:20.720 --> 00:05:25.439
So Meg and I decided that we would give her a promotion and start referring to her as producer of the show.
00:05:25.680 --> 00:05:28.480
So today's question comes from producer of the show, Meg.
00:05:28.639 --> 00:05:37.759
She asks, Do you think it's possible to rehabilitate someone who has the urge to knowingly commit sexual assault and film it and share it?
00:05:38.000 --> 00:05:45.040
Does someone with the intent to do this thing to another person have the self-awareness to prevent themselves from causing harm?
00:05:45.279 --> 00:05:53.360
And who should be centered in the conversation about the systemic problem of men committing sexual violence against women?
00:05:57.759 --> 00:06:00.800
This is a big, heavy question.
00:06:01.040 --> 00:06:04.000
And I want to start by putting some borders around it.
00:06:04.240 --> 00:06:15.120
There's all kinds of questions that we
Load full transcript
could get into, but some of them would require us to move this question from a matter of ethics into one that feels more detached.
00:06:15.600 --> 00:06:22.399
For example, sometimes talking about consent requires talking about it in terms that feel very abstract.
00:06:22.639 --> 00:06:34.160
The danger of this is that it can lead us to forget that we talk about consent because it matters to human actions, and those actions have effects on real people, people who we love and care about.
00:06:34.399 --> 00:06:38.800
In rabbinic Judaism, there's an idea called fencing the Torah.
00:06:38.959 --> 00:06:41.680
So we can take a very quick moment of Hebrew.
00:06:46.959 --> 00:06:56.480
Fencing the Torah comes from the phrase Asus Siagla Torah, a phrase found in the first chapter of an important text in Judaism called Pirke Avot.
00:06:56.720 --> 00:07:08.079
The name of this text literally means something like chapters of the forefathers, but perhaps a translation more faithful to the idea of the phrase would be something like the Book of Foundational Principles.
00:07:08.240 --> 00:07:16.720
And in the very first bit, we read that a foundational principle of rabbinic Judaism is this idea of putting a fence around the Torah.
00:07:16.879 --> 00:07:29.279
What this means is that rabbis and teachers will recommend certain actions that aren't necessarily commands, but that are prudent precautions to take against accidentally transgressing the commands of Hashem.
00:07:29.600 --> 00:07:31.040
According to Rabbi David E.
00:07:31.199 --> 00:07:46.240
Ostridge of the Congregation Barit Shalom, just as a fence around a yard or house protects it, many of the rabbinic innovations were designed to protect the commandments in the Torah.
00:07:46.480 --> 00:08:01.040
These developments were not seen as additions or subtractions, prohibited by the Torah in Deuteronomy 4.2 and 13.1, but rather as aids in maintaining the integrity of the mitzvot.
00:08:01.600 --> 00:08:05.600
I like to think of it with an image from my childhood.
00:08:05.839 --> 00:08:14.000
Many long driveways were lined with oak trees, and often the oak trees had tiny picket fences around them.
00:08:14.160 --> 00:08:19.920
A careless driver would break the fence, and not the oak tree.
00:08:20.480 --> 00:08:33.440
The goal here is, as Rabbi Ostrich says, if you mess something up, you end up breaking the fence, something that can be fixed, and not killing the tree, which is a lot more precious and harder to replace.
00:08:33.600 --> 00:08:43.519
So I don't want to get caught up in any discussion that might descend into a casual casuistry when it comes to talking about sexual and intimate partner violence.
00:08:43.759 --> 00:08:57.440
It could be easy to talk too casually or flippantly about the harm caused by this form of violence, even when you're trying to be careful, even when you're trying to explore the idea with the express purpose of making the world better.
00:08:57.759 --> 00:09:10.320
Casuistry is a method of taking particular cases or events and applying broader concepts and ideas to them, often concepts that are based in paradigmatic or precedential cases themselves.
00:09:10.559 --> 00:09:19.279
So in United States jurisprudence, when we talk about the right to an attorney, we often talk about the 1963 Supreme Court case Gideon v.
00:09:19.360 --> 00:09:27.919
Wainwright, in which the Supreme Court unanimously decided that states must provide legal counsel to defendants that couldn't afford it.
00:09:28.080 --> 00:09:34.639
That concept, you have a right to an attorney, is then applied to other cases with different specifics.
00:09:34.799 --> 00:09:39.360
It's sort of like a theorem in geometry or a save point in a video game.
00:09:39.519 --> 00:09:48.159
You don't have to redo anything before that point, but instead you can point to this established principle in building a case based on it.
00:09:49.519 --> 00:09:58.399
But when we talk about casuistry, we often mean something like that person used a clever and disingenuous argument to deflect criticism or judgment.
00:09:58.559 --> 00:10:10.320
It takes advantage of the idea that to make a claim that all X is wrong, all one would have to do to cast doubt on that or disprove it, would be to find one single case in which it wasn't wrong.
00:10:10.480 --> 00:10:21.360
So for example, if someone were to say, all relationships between people who are more than 20 years apart in age are bad, to disprove that, someone could just say, well, look at this one case.
00:10:21.519 --> 00:10:24.720
They seem quite happy and healthy, so it seems that you're wrong.
00:10:24.879 --> 00:10:38.799
What the first person was probably saying was something like: in general, people 20 years apart in age might not have a lot in common, and there's the potential for unhealthy relationship dynamics that might not exist in relationships where the ages are closer.
00:10:38.960 --> 00:10:52.960
But the casuistry here is in making that all age gap relationships are bad claim seem weaker by pointing to an exception and then quietly reinforcing the opposite claim, age gap relationships are fine.
00:10:53.279 --> 00:11:00.159
Now, don't think that that represents my ethical breakdown of the case for or against age gap relationships.
00:11:00.399 --> 00:11:06.559
I'm just using it as a useful example that people likely have strong yet divided opinions on.
00:11:06.799 --> 00:11:16.159
So obviously, case law, precedent, and exceptions in law and morality are usually a lot more complicated than all X is Y.
00:11:16.480 --> 00:11:25.120
And there's a lot of value in digging down deep into the details of these kinds of things and finding all the nooks and crannies of meanings and definitions.
00:11:25.279 --> 00:11:32.080
But I don't care to do that when it comes to something as serious and as morally unambiguous as sexual assault.
00:11:32.320 --> 00:11:41.440
So to bring this back around to
fencing in, I won't be entertaining any ideas that the kind of behavior described and depicted on these websites is acceptable.
00:11:41.600 --> 00:11:49.519
Yes, I think there are exceptions or situations where an actual consent could underlie the appearance of a lack of consent.
00:11:49.759 --> 00:11:56.159
But I'm not interested in those cases right now because they are statistically and logically the tiniest minority of those cases.
00:11:56.399 --> 00:12:02.159
Filming the sexual assault of your partner and sharing it online for the pleasure of others is wrong and evil.
00:12:02.399 --> 00:12:03.279
Full stop.
00:12:10.799 --> 00:12:23.440
Now that we've established that, we can also establish that the question here isn't really about sexual assault, it's about the people who do it and the people who have these impulses, intentions, or fantasies.
00:12:23.679 --> 00:12:32.559
Sometimes it can seem like even though a topic is ethical, remember, ethical just means choicey, it can be weird to think of it as philosophical.
00:12:32.799 --> 00:12:41.919
I've spent a lot of energy in this podcast on trying to explain what I think makes something ethical, but not really on what makes something philosophical.
00:12:42.159 --> 00:12:53.759
So first, I'm going to explain what I think makes something philosophical by way of talking about why thinking about character formation and virtue is a philosophical thing.
00:12:54.000 --> 00:13:09.200
Then, I want to use that conversation to carry us into a discussion of what it is that makes someone might want to do something like commit sexual crimes or victimize others in a way that's coercive or manipulative or violent.
00:13:09.360 --> 00:13:17.200
Why does it seem like there's this weird social exception to treating others poorly when it comes to sexual or romantic relationships?
00:13:17.440 --> 00:13:27.440
What is it about the idea of masculinity or sexuality or relationships that makes otherwise reasonable people think that it's okay to treat someone like an object?
00:13:27.679 --> 00:13:33.200
I'll be drawing on the work of Bell Hooks and our old friend Immanuel Kant to try to find some answers here.
00:13:33.440 --> 00:13:41.919
Finally, I want to conclude with a little bit about how it is that people who are conditioned to think that sexual violence isn't that big a deal.
00:13:42.159 --> 00:13:50.399
Well, how do we make them into people who understand that the way they've been conditioned to think and have given their assent to thinking is wrong?
00:13:50.559 --> 00:13:56.399
What does it take to change a way of thinking when that way of thinking is socially pervasive?
00:13:56.559 --> 00:14:11.519
We'll see what Plato has to say about teaching virtue at the level of society in his great work, The Republic, and how Foucault's idea of discipline and practices can help us take practical embodied steps toward this virtue.
00:14:16.159 --> 00:14:22.000
Here's a moment of Greek that I can't believe we haven't had yet.
00:14:22.159 --> 00:14:32.960
Philosophy is our English word for the Greek word philosophia, a combination of the Greek word philain, to love, and Sophia, wisdom.
00:14:33.200 --> 00:14:39.519
If you know that Philadelphia is the city of brotherly love, you've heard this phil root before.
00:14:39.679 --> 00:14:49.600
We also might have heard of a bibliophile, a lover of books, or even a philanderer, a man who has many irresponsible romantic dalliances.
00:14:49.840 --> 00:14:53.519
So the idea of loving is built right into philosophy.
00:14:53.759 --> 00:15:01.600
Loving wisdom is an action, and philosophy is never just a thing, but always kind of an action, a mode of activity.
00:15:01.840 --> 00:15:13.919
While there are many different definitions of what that activity is and means, there are probably three primary ideas that have affected my personal view of what it means to do philosophy.
00:15:14.159 --> 00:15:26.879
First, in their short 1992 book, What is Philosophy, Gilles Deleuze and Felix Gottari say that, quote, philosophy is the art of forming, inventing, and fabricating concepts, close quote.
00:15:27.039 --> 00:15:33.919
They tease out this idea of the lover of wisdom, saying that the philosopher is the concept's friend.
00:15:34.159 --> 00:15:38.080
What does that mean, to be the friend or lover of a concept?
00:15:38.320 --> 00:15:42.240
Well, first I think we need to know what a concept is, right?
00:15:42.399 --> 00:15:45.600
So here's my moment des Deutsch.
00:15:49.039 --> 00:15:56.000
The word concept in English comes from the Latin concipere, literally to take something in.
00:15:56.159 --> 00:16:03.039
But I think the best word picture is brought to us by the Germans, those masters of the philosophical vocabulary.
00:16:03.360 --> 00:16:05.919
Concept in German is begriff.
00:16:06.320 --> 00:16:11.200
It comes from the verb greifen, which means to grab or grasp.
00:16:11.360 --> 00:16:16.080
The prefix b, be is sort of like ed in English.
00:16:16.320 --> 00:16:18.320
It signifies a past participle.
00:16:18.480 --> 00:16:27.360
So a begriff is the thing which has been grasped, i.e., metaphorically, my mind grasps the idea of a thing.
00:16:27.519 --> 00:16:34.639
I'm able, to use an idiom of English, to wrap my mind around the idea of a thing by grasping it.
00:16:37.360 --> 00:16:46.879
For Delaws and Gottari, then, if doing philosophy means forming and fabricating concepts, I think that says a lot about what philosophy can do.
00:16:47.200 --> 00:16:55.600
We need to find out ways to understand the world, and sometimes the language and ideas that were given by the world just don't quite fit.
00:16:55.840 --> 00:17:02.559
Instead, we work with ideas, uh, twisting them, bending them, making new connections, making them work in different ways.
00:17:02.799 --> 00:17:09.599
Think about how new technologies sometimes use the words and ideas of older technologies to describe them.
00:17:09.839 -->
00:17:12.880
When we turn on a computer, we call it booting up.
00:17:13.039 --> 00:17:17.440
This is a reference to an older phrase, to pull up by the bootstraps.
00:17:17.599 --> 00:17:19.119
We still have this phrase in English.
00:17:19.279 --> 00:17:33.680
It generally means to rely on oneself to do a difficult task, but bootstrapping became a term for getting a computer system to run a program by having a smaller program whose job it was to run programs.
00:17:34.160 --> 00:17:41.039
We call this a boot drive, and a computer has what we call a BIOS, basic input-output system.
00:17:41.279 --> 00:17:45.759
One of its primary jobs is to tell the operating system to start up.
00:17:46.000 --> 00:17:49.759
So we use this old language that is largely obsolete.
00:17:49.920 --> 00:18:00.799
Most folks don't use bootstraps to pull their shoes on anymore unless they wear a specific kind of boot, but we use it in a creative way to describe a newly developed process.
00:18:01.839 --> 00:18:04.240
There are so many examples of this.
00:18:04.400 --> 00:18:11.119
The save icon on our computers still looks like a floppy diskette, even though we don't really use those anymore.
00:18:11.440 --> 00:18:18.079
You drive a car instead of operate it, because driving was what you did with the car's predecessor, a team of horses.
00:18:18.240 --> 00:18:24.559
When you call someone, you get them on the line, because phones used to literally operate using lines of cables.
00:18:24.720 --> 00:18:34.640
The person in charge of steering the airplane is a pilot because, well, a plane is like a skyboat, and the person in charge of steering the water boat is a pilot.
00:18:37.599 --> 00:18:49.920
In order for these ideas to work for us, that is, for them to make these phenomena intelligible and functional for our everyday lives, they had to be malleable enough to be adapted into new situations.
00:18:50.160 --> 00:18:58.720
So when the first computer programmers were building operating systems, they were doing something philosophical when they tried to describe that activity with old language.
00:18:58.960 --> 00:19:10.079
I especially love this definition because I describe critical thinking, a phrase often associated with philosophy, as the act of being really good at relating concepts to particulars.
00:19:10.319 --> 00:19:16.400
And that's why thinking critically about ideas and problems requires being a friend to concepts.
00:19:16.559 --> 00:19:25.119
You've got to get them to also be friends with these things that happen out there in the world so that the concept can be used to understand that particular.
00:19:25.279 --> 00:19:31.039
I have a future episode where I talk more about this, and we're a bit in the weed, so I don't want to belabor the point.
00:19:31.119 --> 00:19:41.039
But suffice to say that part of understanding what it means to do philosophy has a lot to do with how we apply our ideas to the things that happen in the world.
00:19:41.519 --> 00:19:47.119
Another way of thinking about philosophy comes from early 20th century German philosopher Edmund Husserl.
00:19:47.200 --> 00:19:57.279
Husserl was an important figure in what is called phenomenology, which is a branch of philosophy that deals with what it means to have an experience of consciousness.
00:19:57.519 --> 00:20:04.640
We understand that things happen out there in the world, and that we also have thoughts that happen in here or in our minds.
00:20:04.799 --> 00:20:25.440
Matthias and I discussed how this is part of the mind-body problem in our Gollum episode, and part of what phenomenology seeks to do is tease out the boundaries of what kinds of things happen on the side of our minds, or the subject, hence subjective, and how those experiences reflect what we think happens out there in the world.
00:20:25.680 --> 00:20:30.960
A way of thinking that is quite crucial to Husserl's later thought is what he calls the epoch.
00:20:31.359 --> 00:20:40.640
This is a Greek word literally meaning cessation, but it has the connotation somewhat of discontinuing a participation in or consent to something.
00:20:40.880 --> 00:20:46.880
An easier way to remember this is to call it bracketing or sometimes a phenomenological reduction.
00:20:47.119 --> 00:20:52.400
What Husserl means is that sometimes we think about things in a way that takes those things for granted.
00:20:52.559 --> 00:20:55.119
I get in the car and I turn the key, the car starts.
00:20:55.279 --> 00:20:58.000
I put the laundry in the dryer and it comes out hot and dry.
00:20:58.160 --> 00:21:00.880
I give my dog some food and she snarfs it down.
00:21:01.039 --> 00:21:03.680
But other times we think about them in a different way.
00:21:03.920 --> 00:21:08.000
Sometimes this is because they don't do what we expect them to do.
00:21:08.240 --> 00:21:14.400
The car doesn't start, the laundry doesn't get dry, my dog spits out the food and leaves it in a wet blob on the floor.
00:21:14.559 --> 00:21:22.880
So in order to think about that problem, we bracket the sort of everydayness of the idea, and we start to think about it as itself.
00:21:23.119 --> 00:21:28.559
Now, the mere act of problem solving a difficulty isn't necessarily bracketing like this.
00:21:28.720 --> 00:21:33.440
After all, solving the everyday roadblocks we bump into is kind of a part of everydayness.
00:21:33.599 --> 00:21:36.240
But taking that moment to go, hey, you know what?
00:21:36.319 --> 00:21:39.759
This is a thing, this is an experience in itself.
00:21:39.920 --> 00:21:48.960
This is its own little self-contained something that has a whole history behind the way I understand it, the way I talk about it, the way I imagine it.
00:21:49.119 --> 00:21:57.519
That way of thinking, what Husserl elsewhere calls the critical attitude, is what it's like to do philosophy as an activity.
00:22:03.759 --> 00:22:09.680
As an introduction to my third idea, I want to take a moment to talk about this
phrase, the critical attitude.
00:22:09.920 --> 00:22:13.279
I've said this before, but this point bears repeating quite often.
00:22:13.519 --> 00:22:18.240
Critical thinking, or a critical attitude, doesn't mean criticism.
00:22:18.400 --> 00:22:23.440
That is, to tell someone that what they're doing is wrong or to be rude and negative about something.
00:22:23.759 --> 00:22:31.759
Critique, as a word and idea, goes all the way back to the Greek word krinain, which means to make a judgment or a decision about something.
00:22:32.000 --> 00:22:40.240
When we do critical thinking, we are thinking in a way that allows us to make a decision about the usefulness of an idea.
00:22:40.640 --> 00:22:50.319
For example, I have a friend who used to work for the News Literacy Project, an initiative that seeks to help students be thoughtful about the information they see in news and social media.
00:22:50.559 --> 00:23:06.880
To think critically about a particular news story or an anecdote of dubious veracity on social media, a student will have to make a judgment about this information using various concepts like: are multiple news outlets reporting on this story?
00:23:07.200 --> 00:23:10.799
Is there empirically verifiable information backing up this claim?
00:23:11.039 --> 00:23:14.960
Is there a bias that isn't being acknowledged or an agenda being pursued?
00:23:15.119 --> 00:23:19.519
Is this story attempting to come to conclusions that the evidence doesn't support?
00:23:19.759 --> 00:23:27.920
This is what we mean when we talk about being critical, using all of the available information to come to the best conclusion.
00:23:28.400 --> 00:23:37.279
In order for us to think about whether something works as an idea, we have to be able to think about if it were different than the way that it is right now.
00:23:37.599 --> 00:23:44.400
That seems a little counterintuitive, but if we interrogate this a bit, I think we can see the way this works.
00:23:44.640 --> 00:23:48.319
In order to even ask the question, is this the right conclusion?
00:23:48.559 --> 00:23:58.400
We have to have an idea, even the faintest, vaguest wisp of a notion that what there is right now could maybe be different than that.
00:23:58.640 --> 00:23:59.279
Think about it.
00:23:59.440 --> 00:24:03.279
What is the most taken-for-granted, unchangeable thing in your life?
00:24:03.519 --> 00:24:09.200
Maybe it's breathing oxygen or using your eyes to see things or gravity holding you down on the ground.
00:24:09.440 --> 00:24:14.799
You almost never think about that being different because, well, those things hardly ever change.
00:24:15.039 --> 00:24:24.160
And trying to imagine breathing ammonia or sensing light through your fingertips or floating in zero G is almost too difficult to describe.
00:24:27.759 --> 00:24:34.960
This is why I think the idea of the otherwise is really important in describing what it means to do philosophy.
00:24:35.119 --> 00:24:42.960
If nothing needed to change, or everything already worked in a way that didn't cause any problems, we wouldn't need to think very hard about those things, right?
00:24:43.200 --> 00:24:46.559
Gravity isn't a problem until you have to push a heavy rock up a hill.
00:24:46.799 --> 00:24:50.000
Ah man, I wish this rock wasn't so heavy and stuck to the ground.
00:24:50.160 --> 00:24:53.920
What if it had magical wings from the gods that could make it levitate?
00:24:54.160 --> 00:24:57.200
What if it were taken away on a huge gust of wind like a feather?
00:24:57.359 --> 00:25:01.359
What if it could float in the air like an apple in a barrel of water?
00:25:01.599 --> 00:25:07.599
This what if, this otherwise, is part of the activity of philosophy.
00:25:07.920 --> 00:25:10.640
Todd May, in his excellent book about G.
00:25:10.880 --> 00:25:17.759
Deleuze, says this about Deleuze and Gatari's definition of philosophy that we talked about before.
00:25:29.200 --> 00:25:38.880
It is a way of articulating the hidden virtual reality out of which the actually experienced reality emerges.
00:25:39.200 --> 00:25:49.920
In Deleuze's hands, philosophy does not seek to offer a coherent framework from within which we can see ourselves and our world whole.
00:25:50.160 --> 00:25:52.960
It does not put everything in its place.
00:25:53.440 --> 00:25:57.599
It does not tell us who we are or what we ought to do.
00:25:57.759 --> 00:26:01.759
Philosophy does not settle things, it disturbs them.
00:26:01.920 --> 00:26:15.839
Philosophy disturbs by moving beneath the stable world of identities to a world of difference that at once produces those identities and shows them to be little more than the froth of what there is.
00:26:16.000 --> 00:26:19.119
And it does this by creating concepts.
00:26:19.359 --> 00:26:31.759
Concepts reach beneath the identities our world presents to us in order to touch upon the world of difference that both constitutes and disrupts those identities.
00:26:35.599 --> 00:26:45.200
What Mei means here is that philosophy is the act of making concepts that can describe what it would be like if reality wasn't actually like that?
00:26:45.359 --> 00:26:47.839
What if it wasn't like that but something else?
00:26:48.000 --> 00:26:52.079
Well, to describe something else, I probably need a new concept.
00:26:52.240 --> 00:26:56.799
One that will describe a possible situation that doesn't actually exist right now.
00:26:57.039 --> 00:27:00.960
What would it be like for a computer to tell itself to do computering?
00:27:01.119 --> 00:27:05.279
Well, let me think, we could have it pull itself up by its own bootstraps.
00:27:05.440 --> 00:27:07.279
We could make it boot up.
00:27:07.680 --> 00:27:16.160
This is why I present Angela Davis's definition of philosophy as a third and maybe most practically crucial offering for us to consider.
00:27:18.559 --> 00:27:33.039
My idea of philosophy is that if it is not relevant to human problems, and if it does not tell us how we
can go about eradicating some of the misery in this world, then it is not worth the name of philosophy.
00:27:33.200 --> 00:27:41.599
I think Socrates made a profound statement when he asserted that the reason for being a philosopher is to teach us proper living.
00:27:41.839 --> 00:27:54.240
In this day and age, proper living means liberation from the urgent problems of poverty, economic necessity, indoctrination, and mental oppression.
00:27:58.319 --> 00:28:05.519
When we think about how reality could be different than what it is, sometimes we're doing it because it's fun, it's creative, it's enjoyable.
00:28:05.680 --> 00:28:11.920
But often we're doing it because we find reality unfair, intolerable, unworkable, unjust.
00:28:12.160 --> 00:28:30.240
And I believe that to think philosophically, to do philosophy as an activity, is to think about how what there is now could be otherwise in a way that makes the world a better place to live, that solves human problems, that creates more and better situations for human flourishing.
00:28:30.400 --> 00:28:40.400
Because if we're going to heed Socrates' admonishment that we care for the self, that we cultivate the goodness of people, we have to think about how things could be different.
00:28:41.039 --> 00:28:48.559
We'll talk about how we can apply these ways of doing philosophy to the problem of sexual and gender violence after a quick trip to the agora.
00:29:27.200 --> 00:29:33.279
Do you ever have a thought you maybe shouldn't say out loud and then immediately find yourself talking about it for an hour?
00:29:33.440 --> 00:29:36.880
We're Katie and Katie, and that's exactly how we operate.
00:29:37.039 --> 00:29:47.359
On I Suspect, a podcast for the curious and the chatty, we bring that dynamic to weekly conversations on topics ranging from the serious to the very unserious.
00:29:47.599 --> 00:29:52.960
We're two friends navigating life a decade apart with chemistry that would impress your high school science teacher.
00:29:53.279 --> 00:29:56.799
But for everything we agree on, there's just as much that we don't.
00:29:57.039 --> 00:30:02.799
We are not afraid to disagree and challenge one another's perspective, and you might find yourself picking sides.
00:30:02.960 --> 00:30:08.240
But one thing is true: we always leave the conversation with a fresh perspective and more to think about.
00:30:08.400 --> 00:30:09.599
And we hope you do too.
00:30:09.759 --> 00:30:13.119
Join us on Mondays for new episodes of I Suspect.
00:30:13.359 --> 00:30:16.079
Listen on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.
00:30:25.279 --> 00:30:31.200
Or maybe you've read the books, but it's been a while and you've got some questions about the deeper lore of Middle-earth.
00:30:31.440 --> 00:30:34.319
Questions like, where do orcs come from?
00:30:34.480 --> 00:30:37.119
Why do dwarves and elves hate each other?
00:30:37.359 --> 00:30:39.839
And just who the heck is Tom Bombadil?
00:30:40.319 --> 00:30:42.240
Well, if so, I'm here to help.
00:30:42.480 --> 00:30:54.240
Hi, I'm Matthias Austin, and each week on the Lord of the Rings AMA podcast, I answer listener questions about Lord of the Rings, the Hobbit, and the Greater Legendarium of J.R.R.
00:30:54.400 --> 00:31:01.839
Tolkien, giving as in-depth an answer as I can, while trying to stick to a manageable 30-minute episode.
00:31:02.000 --> 00:31:06.559
If you've got questions about hobbits, elves, dwarves, or wizards, I've got answers.
00:31:06.720 --> 00:31:09.279
Check out the Lord of the Rings AMA podcast.
00:31:09.440 --> 00:31:12.240
Available wherever you get your podcasts.
00:31:14.000 --> 00:31:26.319
There's a buzzword that's been going around for the last 10 years or so that attempts to describe the behaviors and attitudes of men who take advantage of their maleness to gratify themselves at the expense of others.
00:31:26.640 --> 00:31:28.160
Toxic masculinity.
00:31:28.400 --> 00:31:30.000
Well, I suppose that's two words.
00:31:30.079 --> 00:31:31.599
So, buzz phrase?
00:31:31.759 --> 00:31:32.480
Is that a thing?
00:31:32.799 --> 00:31:33.839
You know what I mean though.
00:31:34.000 --> 00:31:42.079
It's one of those sayings that starts out maybe as helpful, and then it gets sort of twisted and used up until it can kind of mean anything anyone wants it to mean.
00:31:42.240 --> 00:31:55.039
I don't know when I started using this phrase, and I wasn't really sure about its origins, even though I know that the ideas I associate with it have a firmly established history in the last hundred years of sociology, philosophy, and psychology.
00:31:55.279 --> 00:32:05.119
It turns out that the term toxic masculinity likely didn't begin as a term in feminist conversations, but was actually an idea meant to be a response to feminism.
00:32:05.279 --> 00:32:09.680
Let's talk about it in a new little segment I'm calling Minute History.
00:32:10.960 --> 00:32:18.319
One man's quest to tell the story of a thing in 60 seconds or less.
00:32:18.640 --> 00:32:27.039
Sometimes I have a habit of really belaboring a point to extinction, or doing such a deep dive into an idea that I risk losing the plot.
00:32:27.200 --> 00:32:32.640
That's why I'm challenging myself to explain this little nugget in just one minute.
00:32:32.880 --> 00:32:33.920
So here goes.
00:32:34.240 --> 00:32:43.839
Toxic masculinity was a phrase used in the mythopoetic men's movement as a response to what these men saw as unintended consequences of second-wave feminism.
00:32:44.000 --> 00:32:51.279
Men were being challenged to change their toxic behaviors without a proper understanding of what their non-toxic behaviors should be.
00:32:51.519 --> 00:32:56.480
Enlisting the ideas of psychologist Carl Jung, poet Robert Bly, and analyst Robert A.
00:32:56.640 --> 00:33:00.960
Johnson, they create practices that helped them recover a deep masculinity.
00:33:01.200 --> 00:33:12.559
These practices, such as reconnection with father figures and spaces
for all-male collaboration rather than competition, aided men in grappling with the effects of a world that was changing the meaning of what being a man meant.
00:33:12.799 --> 00:33:24.319
Robert Bly, in his 1990 bestseller Iron John, a book about men, says, quote, The grief in men has been increasing steadily since the start of the Industrial Revolution, and the grief has reached a depth now that cannot be ignored.
00:33:24.480 --> 00:33:35.200
This grief is due in part to a difficulty in understanding the changing form of masculinity and how previous ways of understanding how to become a man have become hurtful, damaging, or toxic.
00:33:35.599 --> 00:33:37.680
Alright, that was Minute History.
00:33:37.839 --> 00:33:38.799
Let me know what you think.
00:33:38.960 --> 00:33:40.319
Did I explain it well enough?
00:33:40.480 --> 00:33:42.160
Did I leave too many questions unanswered?
00:33:42.319 --> 00:33:46.079
Is there a single noun in that paragraph that I didn't read a Wikipedia article for?
00:33:46.240 --> 00:33:50.960
Sound off in the comments or open the nearest window and shout your answer into the void.
00:33:53.200 --> 00:34:00.799
Using the term toxic masculinity in as good faith and constructive a way as possible probably looks something like this.
00:34:01.119 --> 00:34:07.519
Children learn what it means to be a man by watching the behaviors and attitudes of the adults in their lives.
00:34:07.599 --> 00:34:12.159
And sometimes those behaviors and attitudes cause them or others harm.
00:34:12.400 --> 00:34:17.199
Harm for which those adults don't really seem to need or want to apologize for.
00:34:17.440 --> 00:34:23.039
Often these behaviors are excused as boys just being boys, or this is just how guys are.
00:34:23.199 --> 00:34:28.480
Many times they're explained as usual or necessary components of what it means to love.
00:34:28.719 --> 00:34:30.559
Why does that boy keep picking on me?
00:34:30.719 --> 00:34:33.599
Well, because he likes you and he just doesn't know how to show it.
00:34:33.760 --> 00:34:38.320
Why does dad come home and sit on the couch and watch TV instead of helping with chores or playing outside?
00:34:38.559 --> 00:34:43.360
Well, honey, he's worked all day to provide for this family, and he's tired, so we should just leave him alone.
00:34:43.519 --> 00:34:50.880
I want to be really clear that I don't think toxic masculinity should be a way to browbeat men or make them feel guilty about being men.
00:34:51.119 --> 00:34:54.800
It's not a stick for hitting, it's a tool for demonstrating.
00:34:55.039 --> 00:35:01.280
Think about what we mean when we say that something, or more often some amount of something, is toxic.
00:35:01.599 --> 00:35:12.960
Certraline, the generic name for what many people know as Zoloft, is a drug that helps people overcome the symptoms of clinical depression by keeping their chemical serotonin in their system longer.
00:35:13.199 --> 00:35:18.719
It's known as a select serotonin reuptake inhibitor, or SSRI.
00:35:18.960 --> 00:35:29.920
When it's used under the direction of a physician, it's incredibly effective, and it's earned its reputation as being one of the most successful pharmaceutical developments of the 20th and 21st centuries.
00:35:31.280 --> 00:35:41.840
But like many substances, sertraline can be toxic if you take too much, or if you start on too high a dose, or if it interacts with your body in an unhelpful or unexpected way.
00:35:42.239 --> 00:35:45.599
On its own, it doesn't make sense to say that sertiline is toxic.
00:35:45.840 --> 00:35:54.800
It becomes toxic when it is in the wrong kinds of circumstances, when it's employed incorrectly or recklessly, when it isn't right for the person trying to use it.
00:35:54.960 --> 00:35:57.599
Here's another mini moment of reading.
00:35:58.079 --> 00:36:04.159
The Greek word pharmacon is where we get the modern English word pharmacy, a place to get our medicine.
00:36:04.400 --> 00:36:10.079
But just like the word drug, pharmacon meant both medicine and poison.
00:36:10.320 --> 00:36:14.960
Hey, this thing can help you get better, and also it can kill you graveyard dead.
00:36:15.280 --> 00:36:23.920
Even as far back as ancient Greek times, doctors understood that the same thing that can make you better can, under the wrong circumstances, be terrible for you.
00:36:24.559 --> 00:36:28.800
So I think it's prudent to take this approach to thinking about masculinity.
00:36:28.960 --> 00:36:33.519
Now, I'm taking for granted that masculinity is not an inherently bad thing.
00:36:33.760 --> 00:36:36.079
Which, to be fair, some people don't do this.
00:36:36.320 --> 00:36:45.199
There are folks who have reasonable arguments to say, well, these forms of gender presentation are oppressive and just sort of permanently messed up, and we need something different.
00:36:45.440 --> 00:36:46.960
I think that's a thing you can think.
00:36:47.039 --> 00:36:48.639
But it's not my personal position.
00:36:49.119 --> 00:36:58.400
Instead, I think that because what it means to be a man looks different in lots of different contexts, what it means to be masculine can also look different.
00:36:58.559 --> 00:37:02.079
But that there are ways to do it that, for lack of a better word, work well.
00:37:02.559 --> 00:37:07.920
But it seems pretty clear that there are habits associated with masculinity that do not work well.
00:37:08.239 --> 00:37:15.840
When a little boy gets hurt and starts to cry, maybe someone says to him, Oh, don't be such a baby, or big boys don't cry, or man up.
00:37:16.079 --> 00:37:18.320
The explicit message here is don't cry.
00:37:18.559 --> 00:37:25.119
The implicit message is if you cry about this pain, you aren't being a man in the right way.
00:37:25.280 --> 00:37:28.400
You're jeopardizing your chance to become a real man.
00:37:28.559 --> 00:37:33.360
So don't feel that feeling and ball it up and put it away, because real men don't show
that.
00:37:33.840 --> 00:37:44.559
It's 2026, and I think we've seen enough examples of good, strong, manly men showing their emotions to feel comfortable saying that the men don't cry trope is just wrong and silly.
00:37:44.719 --> 00:37:49.360
But there are lots of men who grew up with these ideas implicit in the media we consumed.
00:37:49.519 --> 00:37:55.039
The adults we watched make decisions, the way that our actions were praised, ignored, or punished.
00:37:55.360 --> 00:38:03.679
Cast your mind back to our episode about teeth, and you'll remember that we don't learn things deep inside us simply by someone saying to us over and over, You must learn this.
00:38:03.920 --> 00:38:17.039
We get it from our environment, from interacting with countless little moments of affirmation and denial that build up over the course of many years, an idea that can't simply be worn down by telling ourselves the opposite.
00:38:17.519 --> 00:38:24.079
Let's bring this back specifically to the issue of men who abuse their partners, or take advantage of them, or sexually assault them.
00:38:25.039 --> 00:38:29.280
At some point in their lives, these men, I think, learned one or both of two things.
00:38:29.920 --> 00:38:33.679
I deserve to be in control, or I am an exception.
00:38:34.000 --> 00:38:35.199
Let me explain what I mean.
00:38:38.320 --> 00:38:47.599
One thing that the CNN report makes clear about the men that were observed participating in these online communities that celebrate rape and abuse, is that they enjoy it.
00:38:47.679 --> 00:38:49.199
They're titillated by it.
00:38:49.280 --> 00:38:56.159
They're excited and gratified by sharing it with others, in one-upping each other, in helping each other achieve the same results.
00:38:56.400 --> 00:39:02.960
The conversations revolve around encouraging each other to more effectively subjugate their partners against their will.
00:39:03.199 --> 00:39:18.960
What should horrify us is that many of these men, probably most of them, believe in some way that they love their partners, are good family people, or at the very least, are doing the kinds of things in their everyday life that entitles them to do these things privately, or at least in secret.
00:39:19.199 --> 00:39:23.039
I think this speaks to a sense that they are an exception to some rule.
00:39:23.280 --> 00:39:32.639
Hey, don't treat your partner badly, but also, every once in a while you can do things that you probably wouldn't tell your friends about, because you work really hard and deserve to have some fun every now and then, right?
00:39:32.960 --> 00:39:38.719
Yes, this is horrendous, and I want to be clear that I'm not using this line of reasoning to justify their conduct.
00:39:38.960 --> 00:39:45.199
To borrow a phrase from one of my favorite officiating analysts, here I'm trying to explain, not excuse.
00:39:45.679 --> 00:39:52.960
But what do we think of this idea, I am an exception, or there's a rule, but sometimes I get to
break it if I did the right things to earn it.
00:39:53.119 --> 00:39:56.400
That seems to be the attitude that these men have, right?
00:39:56.719 --> 00:40:03.119
Let's take a look at this idea of making an exception of oneself in a slightly less high-stakes example.
00:40:03.920 --> 00:40:12.960
In 1799, Kant published an article in Berlinische Blotter called On a Supposed Right to Lie Because of Philanthropic Concerns.
00:40:13.280 --> 00:40:14.480
Kant took exception.
00:40:15.119 --> 00:40:15.519
I get it.
00:40:15.760 --> 00:40:18.239
It's just a little philosophy button there for you.
00:40:18.559 --> 00:40:27.840
Kant took exception to another thinker, Benjamin Constant, who said that sometimes it's okay to lie if there are major overriding philosophical concerns.
00:40:29.039 --> 00:40:40.000
The moral principle stating that it is a duty to tell the truth would make any society impossible if that principle were taken singly and unconditionally.
00:40:40.239 --> 00:40:48.719
We have proof of this and the very direct consequences which a German philosopher, he's talking about Kant here, has drawn from this principle.
00:40:48.960 --> 00:41:00.559
This philosopher goes so far as to assert that it would be a cramp to tell a lie to a murderer who asks whether our friend who is being pursued by the murderer had taken refuge in our house.
00:41:00.719 --> 00:41:02.320
It is a duty to tell the truth.
00:41:02.400 --> 00:41:06.639
But the concept of duty is inseparable from the concept of right.
00:41:07.039 --> 00:41:12.960
To tell the truth is a duty, but it is a duty only with regard to one who has a right to the truth.
00:41:13.119 --> 00:41:16.400
But no one has a right to a truth that harms others.
00:41:16.719 --> 00:41:20.320
What Constant is saying here is pretty common sense, right?
00:41:20.480 --> 00:41:23.360
Hey, don't tell an axe murderer where his next victim is hiding.
00:41:23.519 --> 00:41:28.639
If the Nazis come to your door looking for Jews in your basement, you have no obligation to tell them the truth.
00:41:28.960 --> 00:41:32.880
So it seems weird that Kant wants to die on this hill, right?
00:41:33.280 --> 00:41:35.599
But remember what we've said about Kant in the past.
00:41:35.920 --> 00:41:38.159
Kant wants to make ethics a science.
00:41:38.639 --> 00:41:50.320
So he wants to find a way to make sure that we can get the morally upright response to a difficult situation, not just in the moment, in a specific context, but all the time and for all time.
00:41:50.719 --> 00:41:56.559
So Kant's response here is something like, hey, we don't tell the truth because it usually turns out well.
00:41:56.960 --> 00:42:01.840
We tell the truth because it is the foundational principle that all duties are based in.
00:42:02.079 --> 00:42:03.840
Kant says in response to Constant.
00:42:12.000 --> 00:42:20.239
And the laws of such duties would be rendered uncertain and useless if even the slightest exception to them were admitted.
00:42:20.719 --> 00:42:25.760
So we don't need to agree with Kant about whether there are exceptions to the rule, don't lie.
00:42:26.159 --> 00:42:35.519
To understand what he's saying about exceptions here, and what he says about them in other places, especially in his more fleshed-out ethical works like The Critique of Practical Reason.
00:42:35.760 --> 00:42:49.840
Practical reason is Kant's way of saying ethics, because it's the use of our rational faculties not for pure things, that is, things that are not about experience, but for practical things, that is, stuff that does have to do with experience.
00:42:50.159 --> 00:43:02.239
Kant repeatedly doubles down on the idea that when someone does something against the moral law, what they're tacitly saying to themselves is, this is probably a good rule, but I am an exception in this circumstance.
00:43:02.480 --> 00:43:09.199
I think what we can take from this is that we should be really careful about doing things as an exception.
00:43:09.360 --> 00:43:14.400
I mean, things that are exceptions are, by definition, rarer than the things that usually happen.
00:43:14.559 --> 00:43:32.320
And if you can find a whole internet forum of guys helping each other literally commit crimes of sexual violence against other people, and if that internet forum is on a website that brags that it's the place for all this clandestine activity, well, I don't think you can really admit you're doing something that's merely a matter of course, right?
00:43:32.559 --> 00:43:41.920
What these men are doing when they commit these acts of violence in secret is asserting that they believe that they are the exception, but that they really want that exception to be the rule.
00:43:42.000 --> 00:43:46.559
And they do it in the open if there weren't so many darned consequences to it.
00:43:46.800 --> 00:43:53.519
Constantly asserting yourself as the exception betrays that you think the exception should be a rule.
00:43:53.679 --> 00:43:58.480
And I think this is what Kant is afraid of in allowing exceptions to moral rules.
00:44:00.480 --> 00:44:04.559
I also said that these men are expressing that they think they should be in control.
00:44:04.800 --> 00:44:11.039
I think that's pretty clear from the fact that they aren't obtaining proper consent from their partners and are bragging about it.
00:44:11.199 --> 00:44:19.440
But also from the fact that they're using substances to literally drug their partners, substances that damage or remove the agency of their victims.
00:44:19.679 --> 00:44:24.079
You don't take away someone else's agency when you think that they would do what you want in the first place.
00:44:24.320 --> 00:44:31.360
These men want and feel entitled to their partners' bodies in ways that they most likely feel like their partner would not consent to.
00:44:31.519 --> 00:44:39.039
But since they're the exception and they deserve to be in control, well, they just need a little help from a date rape drug to make sure that they get what they deserve, right?
00:44:39.679 --> 00:44:58.880
I don't think this point needs belaboring, but I do want to draw a principle out here that reflects some of the work of feminist scholar Belle Hooks, and that I think is important for us all to learn as we navigate all kinds of relationships: romantic, platonic, relationships between parents and children, between friends, between mentors and learners.
00:44:59.119 --> 00:45:06.000
Any relationship that is founded and guided by a sense of love and care, Hooks says, must be based in justice.
00:45:06.159 --> 00:45:09.679
And there can be no justice where there is abuse.
00:45:24.400 --> 00:45:33.599
But in fact, so many of us have been wounded in some way in our childhoods that we really need to cling to the idea that if someone hurts you, they can also be loving you.
00:45:33.840 --> 00:45:37.440
And I tried to make a big distinction in that book between care and love.
00:45:37.599 --> 00:45:42.000
That like saying that my parents cared for me deeply, and care is important.
00:45:42.239 --> 00:45:47.119
A lot of children don't receive any care, but it's it's only one ingredient of love.
00:45:48.159 --> 00:45:55.920
Hooks here is talking about the relationship between parents and children, but she is clear that this also is the case in relationships between equals.
00:45:56.079 --> 00:46:02.880
In her book All About Love, she recollects how once at a gathering, the subject of corporal punishment for children was raised.
00:46:03.039 --> 00:46:12.559
One woman said, She doesn't hit her kids, but when they do something she doesn't want, she clamps her fingers down onto their arm until they stop doing whatever it was they weren't supposed to be doing.
00:46:12.800 --> 00:46:22.960
Imagine, Hooks asks us, if a man said that he didn't hit his wife, but he did clamp his fingernails down onto the skin of her arm until she did what he wanted.
00:46:23.199 --> 00:46:25.920
We would be justifiably outraged at that.
00:46:26.079 --> 00:46:32.400
Hooks' point is that coercion and abuse are the same between parents and children and between intimate partners.
00:46:32.639 --> 00:46:35.039
They are a sign of an absence of justice.
00:46:35.119 --> 00:46:37.920
And where there is no justice, there can be no love.
00:46:38.159 --> 00:46:46.480
If men claim that they love their partners, but they coerce, abuse, or secretly violate their bodies and agency, there is no love there.
00:46:47.760 --> 00:46:57.440
The last part of producer of the show Meg's question was about who we should center when we're having conversations about how to fix the problem of men who prey on women.
00:46:57.679 --> 00:47:06.159
Briefly, what we mean when we say centering someone in a conversation is all about whose interests become the primary focus of our words and actions.
00:47:06.400 --> 00:47:22.079
For example, if a tree in my yard gets struck by lightning and falls on my neighbor's house, making it
impossible to live in, I would seem pretty callous or at least out of touch if I presented that as a story of how I can never seem to have nice landscaping and how it always gets ruined by the weather.
00:47:22.320 --> 00:47:30.639
Sure, my interests were affected because maybe I love that tree and maybe it'll cost a lot of money to get it cleaned up and all the branches and debris out of my yard.
00:47:30.719 --> 00:47:32.960
But like someone's house got wrecked.
00:47:33.119 --> 00:47:37.760
And we reasonably tend to think that that interest in general carries more weight.
00:47:37.920 --> 00:47:39.199
Trees are nice to have.
00:47:39.360 --> 00:47:41.679
A safe place to live is a necessity.
00:47:41.920 --> 00:47:48.480
So in this conversation about violence against women, we do have to think about whose interests weigh more heavily here.
00:47:48.639 --> 00:48:05.920
In the 2015 case against Brock Turner, a man convicted of felony sexual assault, the judge in that case considered Turner's lack of criminal record and apparent remorse as sufficient reason for deviating from minimum sentencing guidelines and only giving him a six-month prison sentence, of which he served half.
00:48:06.079 --> 00:48:16.960
I'm not going to debate the merits of that choice from a jurisprudential perspective here, but I do think that giving Turner a sort of benefit of the doubt on whether or not he would offend again feels really off.
00:48:17.280 --> 00:48:26.960
It feels like we didn't take the right lesson away from this situation, which was a man took sexual advantage of a woman who was incapacitated and incapable of consenting.
00:48:27.119 --> 00:48:36.559
Instead, it seems we reinforced a lesson like, sexual assault is a peccadillo, and we don't want to upturn anyone's life too badly if we catch them doing it.
00:48:39.119 --> 00:48:44.239
Despite this, I think that the conversation about sexual violence cannot just be about victims.
00:48:44.400 --> 00:48:45.920
I think this for two reasons.
00:48:46.159 --> 00:48:55.119
One, to do this, I think, makes victim into a really flat category and makes it harder for us to remember that all kinds of folks are victims of sexual violence.
00:48:55.360 --> 00:49:00.239
Men, women, children, non-binary and trans folks, black and white, gay and straight.
00:49:00.480 --> 00:49:10.480
Failing to understand the dynamic between abuser and victim creates a conversation where we are always on the defensive, always trying to fix things after the fact.
00:49:10.639 --> 00:49:13.199
This kind of violence is preventable.
00:49:13.360 --> 00:49:20.559
And if we only focus on victimhood, I think we tacitly accept that, well, it's gonna happen, so we can only react to it.
00:49:21.039 --> 00:49:23.679
So my second reason is related to this first.
00:49:23.920 --> 00:49:36.000
If sexual violence is preventable, one of the ways that we can prevent it is by focusing on the perpetrators or potential perpetrators, and by focusing on the situations, behaviors, and knowledges of those people.
00:49:36.159 --> 00:49:41.360
We can think about how to create situations where it would be harder for sexual violence to occur.
00:49:41.519 --> 00:49:45.760
I remember having a conversation with the dean of students at my university, Dr.
00:49:45.840 --> 00:49:46.800
Jesse Brown.
00:49:46.960 --> 00:49:52.960
I genuinely don't remember what we were talking about, but I remember him using this word picture that was so vivid to me.
00:49:53.119 --> 00:50:03.519
He said something like, if someone is throwing babies into a river, yes, we need to rescue those babies, but we also need to go upstream and figure out who the heck is throwing babies into the river.
00:50:03.760 --> 00:50:13.039
I think about that word picture all the time when I try to imagine how to solve problems of any kind, not just big life-threatening issues like the river baby bandit.
00:50:13.280 --> 00:50:16.239
What are the effects that need to be mitigated in the short term?
00:50:16.320 --> 00:50:20.880
And what are the underlying causes that need to be addressed to prevent long-term effects?
00:50:21.119 --> 00:50:28.800
And so I want to wrap up here by invoking an ancient philosopher and a contemporary philosopher, who both seem to be on the same page about this.
00:50:32.320 --> 00:50:39.440
In The Republic, Plato talks about the way to ensure that there is what he calls a calypolis, or a good city.
00:50:39.599 --> 00:50:48.239
He thinks that in order to have a just society, its citizens have to conduct themselves a certain way, and the government of that city has to function a certain way.
00:50:48.719 --> 00:50:57.280
Using Socrates as his mouthpiece, as he does in many of his dialogues, Plato begins with questions like, is a righteous life better than an unrighteous one?
00:50:57.519 --> 00:50:59.679
And what's the use in being good?
00:50:59.840 --> 00:51:10.400
It's Socrates' and Plato's contention that it is better for a soul and a city to be good than to merely be lucky, advantageous, or dominant.
00:51:10.880 --> 00:51:23.920
This honestly sounds like an analogous situation to one we see in modern Western culture, where the question about various forms of masculinity could be posed something like: Is it better to be a man who feels powerful or a man who is good?
00:51:24.159 --> 00:51:27.840
We should be careful not to use Plato's Republic as a perfect roadmap.
00:51:28.159 --> 00:51:37.679
For instance, he would ban certain forms of art and advocated state-mandated open marriages, policies that would not be popular today.
00:51:37.920 --> 00:51:45.760
But one thing I think we should be thoughtful about is what he says about education and the kinds of stories and examples we use to teach people.
00:51:47.760 --> 00:51:58.239
Because I think we'll say that what poets and prose writers tell us about the most important matters concerning human beings is bad.
00:51:58.639 --> 00:52:13.920
They say that many
unjust people are happy, and many just ones wretched, that injustice is profitable if it escapes detection, and that justice is another's good but one's own loss.
00:52:14.320 --> 00:52:25.119
I think we'll prohibit these stories and order the poets to compose the opposite kind of poetry and tell the opposite kind of tales.
00:52:25.360 --> 00:52:26.880
Don't you think so?
00:52:27.760 --> 00:52:34.320
So, to be clear, I think Socrates and Plato here are advocating for a certain kind of censorship in education.
00:52:34.480 --> 00:52:39.280
And I don't think we can take his advice one-to-one and just apply it to our world.
00:52:39.360 --> 00:52:50.159
But it should make us think about the kinds of stories and images we use to teach things, especially to teach the kind of socialization it takes to grow up in the world as a male.
00:52:50.400 --> 00:52:53.760
What images are we using to describe what male looks like?
00:52:54.000 --> 00:52:59.039
What stories communicate most effectively what manly is and means?
00:52:59.199 --> 00:53:09.360
What are young men and women absorbing, consciously and unconsciously, that tell them this is how to be a man, or this is the conduct to expect and accept from a man?
00:53:09.599 --> 00:53:21.039
I have this weird habit of getting kind of emotional when I watch a show or movie where two men have a meaningful, vulnerable, emotional interaction without relying on tropes or humor to carry them through.
00:53:21.199 --> 00:53:28.719
What I mean is, oftentimes the most visible examples of men sharing vulnerability come in the context of punchlines or bits.
00:53:28.880 --> 00:53:34.719
But sometimes they're just two men talking and sharing and showing that they can trust each other.
00:53:34.880 --> 00:53:37.599
This can just feel really special and comforting to me.
00:53:37.840 --> 00:53:44.719
For example, I've been watching Downton Abbey for the first time with producer of the show Meg, and I really like the head of the family, Lord Grantham.
00:53:44.880 --> 00:53:50.159
There's a scene where he gets upset with one of his servants for resigning his position on short notice.
00:53:50.320 --> 00:53:53.280
As the viewer, we have the information to know that the servant, Mr.
00:53:53.360 --> 00:53:59.440
Bates, is doing so in order to protect Lord Grantham and the family, but his lordship doesn't know this.
00:53:59.599 --> 00:54:04.559
Later, when the two men come back together, Lord Grantham apologizes and he bears his heart to him.
00:54:04.719 --> 00:54:07.360
He says, Come back, help me, I was wrong.
00:54:07.519 --> 00:54:09.039
I want your friendship and support.
00:54:10.960 --> 00:54:11.599
What's the news?
00:54:14.320 --> 00:54:18.159
But now the thought of Matthew gone and the future once again destroyed.
00:54:18.320 --> 00:54:20.239
More than all that, I loved him like a son.
00:54:20.960 --> 00:54:23.920
No, I love him present, Mr.
00:54:24.159 --> 00:54:24.480
McCann.
00:54:24.800 --> 00:54:27.840
Will you come back with me and help me through the fade of shadow?
00:54:28.400 --> 00:54:30.880
I expected my if you want me to.
00:54:31.039 --> 00:54:34.239
I misjudged you, Pate, and I abused you when we parted.
00:54:34.320 --> 00:54:35.280
I'm sorry.
00:54:35.599 --> 00:54:45.199
I want to use this to take us to the second piece of what I want to say about what we do about men who behave badly, especially ones who commit violence against others.
00:54:45.360 --> 00:54:51.760
As nice as this would be, we don't live in a world where just knowing something makes us good at doing it.
00:54:51.920 --> 00:55:01.519
There are plenty of men who acknowledge, and maybe even want to imitate, an image of what a safe, good, masculine man looks like, but they keep doing it wrong.
00:55:01.679 --> 00:55:11.280
But becoming a certain kind of person requires us to engage in practices that build us up over time into that new person.
00:55:14.800 --> 00:55:33.280
In Michel Foucault's 1982 lectures at the Collage de France, later published as Hermeneutics of the Subject, he talks about how the Delphic maxim in ancient philosophy, it's the exhortation to know thyself, this is always paired with a second command, take care of thyself.
00:55:33.519 --> 00:55:38.719
Now, here, care means more like health care or caretaking than take care.
00:55:38.960 --> 00:55:51.599
That is, the care here is a sort of self-cultivation, a set of practices that build up the self into what we wanted to be, in the same way that we have healthcare practices that build us up into a healthy body.
00:55:51.840 --> 00:55:53.280
How do we do this?
00:55:53.519 --> 00:55:59.199
We have what he calls practices or techniques that are aimed toward that goal.
00:55:59.440 --> 00:56:01.840
We engage in learning that takes us closer.
00:56:02.000 --> 00:56:06.079
We obtain mentorship and guidance from those who are farther ahead on the path than we are.
00:56:06.239 --> 00:56:09.599
We're aware of and track our temperaments and attitudes.
00:56:09.760 --> 00:56:13.280
These are the techniques we use to obtain our goal.
00:56:13.440 --> 00:56:19.360
And if we want to be the kind of person who is a safe man, for example, there are things we can do.
00:56:19.599 --> 00:56:22.000
We can make into practices and habits.
00:56:22.239 --> 00:56:25.039
These things will get us closer to that goal.
00:56:25.280 --> 00:56:38.079
I like this interaction between Grantham and Bates because it shows a good example of modes of practice that can get you closer to being a masculine man that is also safe, emotionally vulnerable, and just.
00:56:38.559 --> 00:56:44.239
Even just those phrases, I was wrong, I apologize, I need help.
00:56:44.480 --> 00:56:49.679
Those are phrases that the mere utterance of can be really difficult for many people.
00:56:49.920 --> 00:56:55.199
Practicing saying them in the right context with the right attitude, it takes work.
00:56:55.440 --> 00:57:10.480
You won't get it right the first time, but it can help to see it modeled for you, so that when you aren't sure if you can get it right, you can rely a little bit on that social script you've seen to help you act in a way that will turn you into the person you're becoming.
00:57:14.400 --> 00:57:21.920
This is a very small piece of what it means to understand and address male violence against others, especially against women.
00:57:22.159 --> 00:57:29.039
I have only scratched the surface with these ideas, but my hope is that when we approach this issue, we see reason for hope.
00:57:29.199 --> 00:57:38.159
The history of gender relations in Western civilization is suboptimal, but it is better than it was, and it can keep getting better.
00:57:38.320 --> 00:57:48.559
Especially if there are more and more folks every day who tell themselves that they will put effort into changing themselves, or put effort into not accepting bad behavior from the men in their lives.
00:57:48.800 --> 00:57:54.320
The hardest part might be that it can never happen in one big, epiphanous moment of clarity.
00:57:54.559 --> 00:57:56.480
That just isn't how people are made.
00:57:56.719 --> 00:58:03.280
It takes a long time to become a person, and you have to navigate the person that you already are while you're on the way there.
00:58:03.599 --> 00:58:06.320
But I want us maybe to consider the words of C.S.
00:58:06.480 --> 00:58:07.199
Lewis.
00:58:08.000 --> 00:58:12.400
It may be harder for an egg to turn into a bird.
00:58:12.559 --> 00:58:18.000
It would be a jolly sight harder for it to learn to fly while remaining an egg.
00:58:18.159 --> 00:58:25.280
For we are like eggs at present, and you cannot go on indefinitely being just an ordinary decent egg.
00:58:25.519 --> 00:58:28.400
We must be hatched or go bad.
00:58:29.360 --> 00:58:36.000
I think a lot of people, but especially men, fear changing themselves because they don't know if it's gonna be worth it.
00:58:36.159 --> 00:58:45.599
They don't know if it's gonna be worth becoming someone better, especially if it means they won't get the kinds of social privileges or advantages that they know they get now.
00:58:45.760 --> 00:58:55.280
I also think a lot of men fear changing because they feel like they already can't measure up, so why would you put even more pressure on yourself to change and probably fail at that too?
00:58:55.519 --> 00:58:57.679
But honestly, I kind of see it this way.
00:58:57.920 --> 00:59:10.159
It's more likely that you'll be forgiven for messing up at trying to be a better version of yourself than it is that you'll be forgiven for being found out to be no better than the men we find overtly monstrous.
00:59:13.199 --> 00:59:22.000
For those of us men who are embarrassed and outraged by the behavior of those who would use their masculinity as a weapon, we must either be hatched or go bad.
00:59:22.239 --> 00:59:33.920
Developing habits that support our knowledge and goals about what it means to be the best versions of ourselves is the slow and steady work of picking away the shell of our former selves little bits at a time.
00:59:34.079 --> 00:59:38.639
But it will be worth it to one day spread our wings and become someone better.
00:59:39.599 --> 00:59:40.880
Thanks for listening.
00:59:41.119 --> 00:59:45.519
See you next time when we'll talk about some more things you can do.
00:59:58.320 --> 01:00:01.599
For references and citations, you can see the show notes.
01:00:01.920 --> 01:00:04.800
The Things You Can Do intro theme is written by Brantgum.
01:00:05.039 --> 01:00:08.880
The outro theme, and Around the Sun Again We Go, was written by me.
01:00:09.519 --> 01:00:28.400
Other music includes Right of Spring by Igor Stravinsky, performed by Philharmonia Orchestra, conducted by Igor Markovich, Sight of Summer 89 by Colors of Illusion, and Cascade and True Bayou Detective by Patrick Harding.
01:00:28.800 --> 01:00:33.199
The minute history theme was Titans by Dreamcave.
01:00:33.920 --> 01:00:38.880
Thanks to Nikki Adkinson for her voice talents on this episode as Angela Davis.
01:00:40.480 --> 01:00:51.119
If you've got a smooth groove you'd love to have featured on the podcast, or you're interested in being a reader for a future episode, email me at thingsyoucando pod at gmail.com.