TRANSCRIPT 🔗
PETER: if you think about managing talents and developing it, right, the way we used to do it anyway required a lot of predictability because we were gonna take you and put you on this path, where we were planning in ten years you would be doing this job, right? And that became untenable. For organisations because they couldn't predict their business needs 10 years out. The economy changed in fundamental ways, at least the US economy, more deregulation, more international competition, harder to know what you're gonna be doing 10 years out. But the other issue is it involved a lot of upfront costs, which companies just don't want to pay for anymore. So you've got to figure out what do we think you are good at. We have to figure out what do we think our needs might be. and we have to spend time and energy developing you, even if we do it cheaply, right? So the obvious cheapest way to do it is to give people stretch assignments, which basically mean, you know, just giving them work experiences that they could learn something from. And companies didn't want to do that. Some of it is line management. we've just pushed back on them and made them do so much more independent work. So not only are you supervising. more and more people. And you know, the latest trend in the US is to expand spans of control even further. In some cases, supervisor has twenty people to supervise. And you've got to be an individual contributor too. They just don't have any time to develop people, nor do they know how. So you know, employers don't want to front the money to do this. And the fact that it is more expensive later on is not something that they pay very much attention to.
David Clutterbuck: Peter, welcome to the podcast. most people know you from your your work at Wharton, but let's start with your backstory a little bit. How did you get to where you are as one of the the the key authorities in this whole area of of of talent development and and more?
PETER: well, y you know, the usual story if this was a job interview is to trace out this sensible, rational path. And you know, nobody's path is really quite like that. I mean, my my academic path, I went to graduate school at Oxford and studied income policies.
David Clutterbuck: All right.
PETER: And as soon as I finished, inflation was licked and income policies disappeared. So okay, what are you gonna do after that, right? So I had a postdoc back in the US at MIT. We were studying basically the it ended up being about the decline of unions. And that decline was I did that for about eight years or so and the decline was so successful there was nothing much else to say. So you see the problem here, whatever I touch dies in terms of phenomena. so at Wharton I had to teach, you know, things about management af after that, especially people weren't so interested in unions. but I was also kind of always interested in public policy stuff, mainly. And I got pulled into the Department of Labor when Ann McLaughlin was the Secretary of Labor. And the questions There were about the labor force as a whole and skill issues and skill requirements and things. And after that I ran a research center with a colleague here at Wharton for the US Department of Education on skill issues in the economy. And it occurred to us, I think early on, that what happens to the workforce in the US is almost entirely driven by what employers decide to do. You know, are they gonna train people? Who do they hire and why? Do they give them opportunities? You know, all that stuff. So I was interested in these management issues, but but from the policy perspective and recognizing that employer practices were the things that really mattered. and I think it took quite a while for people to catch on to the fact that these employer policies had changed in quite fundamental ways. So I wrote a book early on. called the New Deal at work, which was about the decline of lifetime employment, at a time when not everybody believed that it was actually happening. And of course it has, and we've moved towards much more open labor markets. And it's taken quite a while for the academic community anyway, to s figure out that these were now full of interesting questions, particularly the mobility across companies, you know, and
David Clutterbuck: Hmm.
PETER: issues of career advancement, which we still don't understand very well. So so that's how I got to this sort of peculiar place, I suppose. And it helps to get tenure in the US system because
David Clutterbuck: Yes.
PETER: then you you don't have to play to a particular audience. and when I was you know beginning at least part of this career, there was no audience in the academic world for this. In fact, people didn't want to talk about what was new in management at all. They were quite fixated on traditional questions and traditional practices.
David Clutterbuck: Yeah, thank you. I I I'm there's an analogy that comes to mind as you're talking, going back a hundred and fifty years to the labour markets when the farmer would come into the or the or the the the landowner would come into town and for the season would would would the the people you know the people would c go basically be marketed. and you'd go and choose the the strongest looking one or the you know or the better looking one or whatever.
Riddhika Khoosal: and you'd go and choose the the strongest looking one or the you know the better space cooking one or whatever,
PETER: Mm-hmm.
David Clutterbuck: But you would choose people on pretty arbitrary immediate site and and and f and and and and criteria. I'm not so sure that we've actually moved on a great deal from that.
Riddhika Khoosal: but you would choose you would on pretty arbitrary media site and criteria. I'm not so sure that it's actually moving on the break deal with actually
PETER: I think that I think you're you're right. I mean, at a practical level, of course, the US had this until the most recent Trump administration, with a lot of
Load full transcript
day laborers who used to congregate around the big Home Depot and Lowe's stores that basically were do-it-yourself things, and people would drive by and say, I need three people for a day, and they would pick up. the Trump administration and the ICE immigration. you know, exporting of of labor has kind of eliminated that. But I know you're thinking more broadly in regular jobs. Are we lousy at hiring and are we kind of doing it randomly? Yeah, we're way worse at it than we used to. And that in and of itself is an interesting question and a problem.
Riddhika Khoosal: Peter, in your work, you talk about how most organisations have defaulted to just in-time hiring. So looking externally for talent rather than developing it from within. And you note that it's not because it's necessarily the best strategy, but because it's the path of least resistance. So how did talent acquisition eclipse talent management and What do feel like we've lost along the way?
PETER: Yeah. Well, so just to back up on those phrases, right? So people used to think about personnel management and then they changed the name to to human resources to try to make it more appealing to business leaders, you know, that we should think about how are these people useful for us rather than how are we just trying to be nice to them. And then talent management became popular and I wrote a book with that title in nineteen ninety nine. And that was reflecting the fact that employers were fixated on this question of what do we need and how are we going to get it, which is sensible. But now that has given way to this issue of just talent acquisition. So, you know, what do we need? we're not trying to figure that out. And how could we develop talent? So you have build buy and borrow questions. No, we're just gonna hire, right? So I I I think you were asking me now I've forgotten the original question, but I think it was how do we get to this point? Was that the question? Or Yeah. Well
Riddhika Khoosal: Yeah. How did we or how did we get to the point where we are just looking externally to fill our talent needs rather than looking to develop the capability internally?
PETER: Right, right. Well, I think I a slightly elaborate answer, so forgive me for this, but I think if if you think about managing talents and developing it, right, the way we used to do it anyway required a lot of predictability because we were gonna take you and put you on this path, where we were planning in ten years you would be doing this job, right? And that became untenable. For organisations because they couldn't predict their business needs 10 years out. The economy changed in fundamental ways, at least the US economy, more deregulation, more international competition, harder to know what you're gonna be doing 10 years out. But the other issue is it involved a lot of upfront costs, which companies just don't want to pay for anymore. So you've got to figure out what do we think you are good at. We have to figure out what do we think our needs might be. and we have to spend time and energy developing you, even if we do it cheaply, right? So the obvious cheapest way to do it is to give people stretch assignments, which basically mean, you know, just giving them work experiences that they could learn something from. And companies didn't want to do that. Some of it is line management. we've just pushed back on them and made them do so much more independent work. So not only are you supervising. more and more people. And you know, the latest trend in the US is to expand spans of control even further. In some cases, supervisor has twenty people to supervise. And you've got to be an individual contributor too. They just don't have any time to develop people, nor do they know how. So you know, employers don't want to front the money to do this. And the fact that it is more expensive later on is not something that they pay very much attention to. They're so fixated, I think, on cutting costs, you know, getting rid of I mean the most egregious example of this is getting rid of recruiters. So if you think about what do recruiters do, they source good candidates and they at the very least make recommendations to hiring managers to say, you know, here are three that are all pretty good. You get to pick the last three. Well, they don't do that anymore. why? Because they were trying to cut headcount. But they pushed the problem onto the hiring managers themselves, who really don't know how to do any of this stuff. And as a result, it's the opposite of what you would think efficiency was, you know. So efficiency you would think would be to take the cheapest tasks away from expensive people and give them to cheaper people. So we've done the reverse. We've taken tasks that were done by cheaper people and we've given them to expensive people. who don't know how to do them and don't do it very well. But it does count headcount and for lots of quirky reasons, headcount is reduction is what the investor community wants to see, so that's what they get.
David Clutterbuck: I I I'm we've you keep it we we keep using this word talent, but does anybody actually know what it means?
Riddhika Khoosal: But does anybody actually tell good
PETER: Well, it's a really interesting c question, David, as you as you probably know, that there are parts of the world where if you say talent, they are thinking high potential people. And if you use that phrase, that's what it means. I I think in the US context, it simply meant the jobs that you were concerned enough about to take hiring seriously. It could be blue collar people, it could be people who are doing a particular task which is effectively kind of professional. So, you know, we just assume you can do it, right? If we hire a CPA. so I think, you know, do we know what potential is? I think they had some sense 30, 40 years ago, because they were trying to look and see. You know, what do we know about you today? And then we look twenty years
later and say, who blossomed? What predicts who's going to be good. But I think now do we know? No, no, probably not.
David Clutterbuck: We we we go back for thirty years and can't remember her second name, Rosemary something, did her study at Warwick looking at comparing the perceptions of who will make a good leader, who should should be you know should be on the promotion tree or should be seen as talent, and what actually and what actually happened. and the predictability
PETER: Yep. Hmm.
David Clutterbuck: of the boss was the lowest. So the b the bosses got it
PETER: really? To being a boss.
David Clutterbuck: that got it got it wrong more often than not than not.
PETER: they couldn't predict. Yeah. Well, and that's a interesting point too. It's about, you know, what we usually do is take the best individual contributor and make them the manager. And for some jobs we've we know quite well that that is about the worst thing you could do. So for sales
David Clutterbuck: Yeah.
PETER: positions, for example, we there's good research on this and what we find is that, you know, promoting good salespeople makes worse sales managers because the task is completely different, right? Trying to make other people successful is quite different from making yourself successful. And if you are oriented toward making yourself successful all the time, you're just not inclined to try to figure out how to help other people, right? So
David Clutterbuck: Yeah. Th there was a study I I came across some years ago. it was just a bench study, but it was rather fun. Somebody decided to look at what would happen if you promoted the best performer in each team to be the manager of that team, and and did it entirely across the organisation consistently. And they came to the conclusion that you get a you'd get a worse outcome than if you simply pr chose people at random.
Riddhika Khoosal: There was a study I came across a couple of years ago. it's a base study with file flexibility the most the best of all energy would be the manager of that team that did it entirely in the field condition basically. And they came to the conclusion that you get the you get a worse outcome than if you simply chose people brand on
PETER: At random, yeah. No, I think that's that's probably right. but you can see
Riddhika Khoosal: the room, different output you
PETER: why if if you didn't think about this carefully, you would say, you know, just get somebody who's really good, they'll be good at something else, right? This is in psychology the fundamental attribution error, right? And that is the assumption that if you are good it is at a particular task. It isn't a fit issue, it might not be an effort issue, it is a dispositional issue, it's just something about you, right? And a lot of leaders believe this. and maybe it's because they believe, I'm sure, that, you know, they're wonderful. And so and I probably could be good at anything, and they could be, maybe, because they work maybe incredibly hard and maybe they are better than than average. But you know, the evidence is that people's performance is not always better when they change jobs. Good performers in A are not necessarily good performers in B. And even in the same job, we did a study on this a few years ago. And the performance scores for individuals in the same job over about seven years or so did not predict particularly well what my performance would be next year. So we just asked the question if you knew your performance this year, how well would it predict performance next year? If it was perfect, it'd be a hundred percent. If it was completely random, it would be zero. And the answer was twenty-five percent. So it was way closer to zero than it was to the idea that good performers are always good and bad performers are always bad.
David Clutterbuck: That's scary, isn't it? So let's move on to talk about the the everybody's talking about the about technology and AI and so forth. So I was at a a workshop just a few weeks ago with a bunch of youngsters, eighteen to twenty two, organized by the the EY Foundation, looking at AI recruitment. And
Riddhika Khoosal: But the everybody talking about the technology and AI subject. So I we did a workshop just a few weeks ago with a bunch of youngsters, eighteen to twenty two, organized by the the E Line Foundation, looking at AI with
PETER: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
David Clutterbuck: and universally every single one of these young people felt demeaned
Riddhika Khoosal: every single one of these young people felt immediate.
David Clutterbuck: they felt it distanced them from from from from employers. they were absolutely vehemently negative about the whole thing.
Riddhika Khoosal: they felt distance from employees. They were absolutely vehemently negative about the whole thing.
PETER: Hmm. And this is about using AI to recruit. Is that the the task? Yeah. Yeah. Well, there's an interesting story. I mean, I think it's interesting anyway, about how all this happened. and it happened in the dot-com boom, which was an unusual period in the US because we had gone for so long with basically a buyer's labor market. So from about nineteen seventy-three to about two thousand seventeen. The unemployment rate in the US fell below four percent only once. And that was 1999 or so. So in 1999, employers were panicked at an unemployment rate which became pretty common from 2018 on. But it was hard to hire. And so they're thinking, okay, what do we do about this? And the conclusion was we've got to make it easier and easier for people to apply, right? Which I think is the wrong approach, right?
David Clutterbuck: Ha ha ha.
PETER: it's the wrong approach, but you hear this all the time. There's a funnel, you know, for recruiting, and we have to just toss more people into the funnel. The problem is the more people you toss into the funnel, the more you have to rely on your ability to sort them out further down. And if you're not good at that, tossing
more people into the top of the funnel just means you're going to make more and more mistakes. So how do we make it easier for people to apply? we just said, you know, you can do it online. First of all, that was kind of straightforward. You don't even have to send in your resume or you could send it in and we'll code it and you know, just click a button, boom, you can apply. So what happened is, you know, candidates apply to a few hundred jobs at once, and even boring, not particularly interesting jobs will get hundreds and hundreds of applicants. could the companies afford to hire people to screen those humans? They probably could, but they don't want to, right? So we ended up with a need to screen lots of candidates cheaply. And that's where we got applicant tracking software, which is basically the kind of word count thing, you know. And the reality is we don't really have AI in the sense of large language models screening applicants now. It's the same kind of technology that. we had before. And that is we're just doing looking at, you know, what a job might require, keywords. We're looking at keywords on your resume. They're just matching it, right? what is a little different is some of the interviews that are done. And by the way, foolishly I think employers have moved away from testing and relying so heavily on interviews. And that's maybe a lot because of the earlier point about line managers are having to do it. They know how to set up tests, right? So they're just doing interviews. And doing interviews with rem remotely, and then having software kind of screen it, but they're screening it on simple kinds of things, you know, basically looking for keywords and things that you have said before, right? ends up being quirky for people and and students don't like it, candidates don't like it. But the other thing that we're discovering is it's super easy to cheat,
David Clutterbuck: Mm.
PETER: right? and employers have discovered that the person they hired did not look at all really like the person they interviewed remotely, right? And particularly in the tech world, people were wearing hoodies and things where you couldn't quite see their face. And they're hiring people to do the interview for them, or right in front of them, they have a screen, which now you can get large language models to provide answers to the questions in real time they're asking you. So, you know, skills test things don't don't work very well. So it's not clear this is actually helping the employers at all. Now it could. So if we had really good AI tests for recruiting, they are better than what recruiters can do. But here's how have to do it: you have to build a machine learning model unique to your company. And you build it like this. Tell us, looking back, what we knew about all the candidates that we assessed. And now tell us. since then the ones we hired, who proved to be good and who proved to be lousy. And then the machine learning algorithm is going to build this algorithm for us that will tell us people with these attributes do better than people who don't. And that will probably be better than what we're doing now. In fact, I would wager almost anything it would be better, partly because we're lousy at what we do. The reason we don't do that, it's really expensive to build. So we could do that, and that would be better. But I think what it has done now is this just put more screens up in front of candidates and fewer people and they really don't like that. It's not better. It's probably just cheaper and it's clunkier.
David Clutterbuck: Yeah. One of the student one of young recent graduates at this workshop t told me that she f she decided she'd played with the system. So she put she she put in she put in some some applications just as she normally would. And then for the others she got the AI to write them an an AI to write them for her. And the ones she got responsive for were the ones with the with the AI had written it. Yes. So
PETER: good.
Riddhika Khoosal: So she she she put it she put in some some applications just she would already put the end of the others she got the AI to one and other an AI supply before her. And the button she got responsive was little buttons with the AI. So you know, this is
PETER: Hmm, mm-hmm. With the AI. wow. Well,
Riddhika Khoosal: a really troubling problem.
PETER: you know, this is a really troubling problem for higher education more generally, because AI writing is so good students don't write their papers anymore, you know. And also they don't read because AI provides the summaries to the articles. So they just got the summaries, they don't write and you know, what we're supposed to be doing is not entirely clear now. And we're the higher education is ducking it for the most part, you know.
Riddhika Khoosal: Hmm.
PETER: Just pretending it's not a real problem. So
Riddhika Khoosal: Peter, what are your thoughts on the criteria that we're still currently using when hiring people in the context of a world where there is so much rapid change and evolution? And, you know, it's very hard to now know what we need for the future. So past performance isn't necessarily a predictive for future performance, as we touched on. So what are your thoughts around how we need to evolve? maybe from a job description to looking at what kind of skills we need and how we even start to nurture and build a whole new ecosystem around skills.
PETER: Yeah, so I I think so I've s I've spent much of the last year, a couple of years, looking at what actually happens in organisations that introduce AI. So I'm not interested in the stories about we what we think AI can do, possibly, which is what we hear from the AI people. You know, there's a difference between what conceptually or theoretically a tool could do and what in practice it can actually do. And you know, the simplest issue, like machine learning, which could do all kinds of interesting things, is it's really expensive to do, so
doesn't get used very much, right? So I think the problem we've got now is that we are awash with hypotheses about what will change about work, particularly from AI. So far, they've been spectacularly wrong. and I would say, why are we listening? To them and they come mainly from people who are selling you the tools too, right? Which is also a little troubling. but I think I think so far, it has not changed work all that much. so it is I mean it has not eliminated low-skilled jobs, for example. and the the evidence on that is quite clear, right? and it may change how individuals do their own job, getting it built into the workflow of an organisation. is taking a lot of time. but you hear things like, well, what we need AI skills. The whole thing about learned language mod large language models, they're not hard to use, right? That's why they're so ubiquitous. It's like if you can use a search engine, you can use a large language model. The problem is the change in the organisations needed to pop one of those agents in, figuring out where to pop them in, figuring out how to get the employees to help you use them. Figuring out the workflow afterwards, all that stuff is is the hard part. So I I guess my sense is it's I I would not freak out and try to guess what the future will look like on these things. Our predictions have almost always been wrong. and the change is almost always slower than what we think. even though a technology is really cool, it takes a very long time for it to work its way into the system. Think about the internet, for example. which has taken, you know, twenty-five years now to become I mean it's super dominant, right, in terms of how we operate, but it took twenty-five years for that to happen. so I think I would, as an employer, I think you could spend some time trying to figure out, first of all, go back and hire a recruiter and bring them back in to do job analysis and look and say, what are we actually doing in these jobs right now? And then what do we need? from candidates, what will that look like, right? Because part of the problem is, you know, here's the worst hiring practice, at least in the US now. We want people who fit our culture. right. Okay. So, all right.
David Clutterbuck: Yes.
PETER: So, what is our culture? Well, we got this statement of what our culture is, which is largely aspirational, right? We want to be an organisation like this, but we're not, right? So we are and then that statement. You know, I mean then the next question is gonna be, what would someone look like who fits our culture? Well, we don't know, right? Really. We hadn't thought about that. So it ends up being an excuse just for people to hire candidates who look like themselves, right? Which is largely what's what's happening, right? So I don't think it's such a big problem. I guess I would say to organisations, just don't try, don't worry so much about trying to predict what your company will look like. in five years. You the typical
turnover in the US across companies is about 30% per year anyway. You know? So many people churn in and out. And especially if you're looking at new hires out of college, turnover rates are even higher. So, you know, you're not hiring somebody for 30 years. So, you know, your organisation in five years, I bet, won't look that different from what it looks like right now. It's still the case that the best predictor of future behavior Is what you're doing now and what the trends that you've seen now probably will just continue. So just do that. So it turns out, for example, the Bureau of Labor Statistics in the US, its prediction models on employment by occupation have turned out to be pretty accurate and far more accurate than the predictions we're hearing out of the AI world.
David Clutterbuck: Our our our hypothesis in all of the work that we're doing at the at the moment i i i is it and comes from the original study that I did fifteen years or more ago. Is
PETER: Mm-hmm.
David Clutterbuck: that but basically that a lot of what HR does is part of the problem, not part of the solution. Because
PETER: Hm.
David Clutterbuck: it's it it's it's linear th in its thinking, it's not systemic
PETER: Hm.
David Clutterbuck: in its thinking, it's trying to fix a particular problem without any idea of how that's gonna impact the rest of the system.
PETER: Yeah. Yeah.
David Clutterbuck: See would you g would you go along with that or or or ca or challenge that?
PETER: Well, I think you we could broaden that out. I mean I think employers have a and organisations a whole
Riddhika Khoosal: Yeah, it's good.
PETER: have a very hard time dealing with uncertainty. It's just not surprising, we all do. But they are trying they effectively try to assume it away. So if you think about workforce planning, for example, right?
David Clutterbuck: Yes.
PETER: So workforce planning means we're trying to figure out today what we will need, you know, a couple of years out. Well, that comes from the business plans, right? The business plans are really, really Inaccurate, right? They're almost never true. And if you doubt it, just go back and ask yourself how well did we predict the financial crisis? Or how about COVID? Or how about the Iranian current Iranian war in the US? Or whatever Donald Trump did yesterday? How well do we able to predict any of that stuff? Not at all, right? And so whatever business plan we thought we had just before then becomes obsolete. So we have to start thinking about. managing uncertainty rather than assuming it away. And what you hear with workforce planning, and David, I wonder whether you hear this the same thing we hear here, is give us your best guess. Well, well what if your best
David Clutterbuck: Yeah.
PETER: guess is really terrible and you know it's terrible, right? So our colleague here, Paul Schumacher, who you you may have known, created scenario planning for Royal Dutch. And that at least is a better start to say, okay, if you're gonna
have a a guess. This is my best guess, but what's my second best guess? And my third best guess. And sometimes the second and third best guess imply very similar things. and they're together maybe more likely than your best guess. And what you really ought to be thinking about is, you know, those overlaps, right? What sorts of things are probably going to be true even if our first, second, third guess is are not exactly right, right? So and then how can we be responsive? And some of this might be things like placing small bets. Don't get rid of all our recruiters just because the economy is turning down, we might lay people off, right? Because it's got to come back at some point. The forecast could be wrong, and then we're really stuck, right? Because, you know, it's kind of like this phenomenon about advice on if you're lost. So think we're assuming we're lost here. What's going to happen in the future, but you're lost in the wild, what should you do? And the answers usually do nothing, right? Because if you race off on a tangent, your best guess, and you're wrong, you've backing up is really expensive, right? You've burned a lot of calories, you've wasted a lot of time, and you've run out of water and stuff, and then you're lost someplace, it's probably even more lost than you were before, right? So maybe we ought to think about not racing off, but thinking about where to place some bets. and do some scenario planning and think about what what the array of options might be. This one's not completely likely, but if it happens it'll kill us, you know. and manage the uncertainty rather than assume it away, right? And so yes, you're right. HR is assuming it away, but they do that in part because that's what the business does. It assumes it away as well.
David Clutterbuck: Yeah. We've been looking at the we are looking at the employee journey from recruitment all the way through decruitment. And things like it's amazing how few organisations actually view previous employees as a resource.
PETER: Yeah, that's true. Yeah.
David Clutterbuck: And so if you were if you were to advise HR, just one basic thing they could do.
Riddhika Khoosal: If you will if you well to advise HL, just one basic thing they can do to give them a more systemic approach to all their
David Clutterbuck: To give them a more systemic approach to this whole area of talent management, what would it be?
PETER: Well, I guess is a a a short thing. I would go have lunch with my head of marketing. and one of the things, for example, on that particular question, I would say, what does it cost you if you have an irritated customer? And you'll discover it's not cheap, right? If you irritate somebody. So what does it cost you if we have an irritated employee who leaves us? Right? well, you could sort of figure that out and factor it into turnover costs, for example, right? And I think, you know, the the biggest problem I see in the US is what leaders just don't know about people in management. So for example, speaking to CFOs, they have no idea what turnover costs are, right? I mean they assume that there are costs if people quit, but they got no idea what the number is. And if you have no idea, you ignore it. So they effectively think it's zero. And then sometimes the only number they get is the administrative costs of bringing a new person in. Which are kind of trivial, right? So, you know, it changes the way they think. I mean, they think, for example, what is what does it cost if we leave a position vacant? They think, well, it saves us money because the payroll is not being paid. But it turns out work doesn't get done. And it ends up in terms of shareholder value really costing you there. So I would say the other thing I would do is go get some numbers on these things, because right now the people who are making the big decisions don't have any. any idea about these human resource questions like turnover, like keeping positions vacant, like how much more valuable is a good employee than an average employee. They don't have any idea on any of these things. So they're making decisions as if they don't matter because they think they don't, right?
David Clutterbuck: So Peter, you you talk about get some numbers. We've HR is flooded with what they call HR analytics, but I tend to refer to as banalytics because
Riddhika Khoosal: We can HR is collabul with what they call HR analytics, so I tend to refer to as bad analytics.
David Clutterbuck: it's totally meaningless.
PETER: Mm. Mm.
David Clutterbuck: what's the difference between the kind of data that HR is collecting and the kind of data they should be collecting?
Riddhika Khoosal: What's the difference between the kind of data that HR is collecting and the kind of data that he shouldn't
PETER: Well, I think if you have to persuade a a a senior leader why this number
Riddhika Khoosal: be collecting? Well I think if we have something
PETER: matters, you got the wrong number, right? So th they should they
David Clutterbuck: Mm, I love it. Yeah.
PETER: should know that this is translated into dollars and you might think that they shouldn't care about that, but that's the way they think, right? That is the way the game that they are playing is judged. It's based on dollars or pounds or whatever you you know. Whatever your currency is, that's where the way they think. So if you can't show why this matters to their concerns, you're not going to get anywhere, you know? And trying to tell them these are just nice things to do for employees. I mean, we wish they would respond to that, but that is a second order concern for them, right? They are trying to stay in business, the game they're playing is based on outcomes, money outcomes. So you should look for measures that you could translate into that. And the ones we're talking about. Are fundamental because those are the ones they're gonna use, right? Like, does it cost us if people quit? Yes. If we replace them with other people,
is that costless? They kind of think it is. It's not, right? if you lose a good person and you have to fill that vacancy with somebody else, those costs are not trivial. It'll take a while for the new person coming in to become useful. They may burn out quickly. And what does that cost us? You know, the people at the top have no idea. So that's why they're inclined to do this kind of layoff. we'll just lay people off because that looks good to the investor world. And then we'll just hire them when we need them and you know. it's nutty, right?
Riddhika Khoosal: So if organisations were to become really skilled at building the talent within, so really moving their core focus into building and developing their existing workforce, what would you have them start with and really focus on?
PETER: Yeah, well the first thing I would I would do is I would have to explain to them why this is not a stupid thing to do, because the leaders think it is now. And that is we invest in our people and they just leave, right? and they are so persuaded of that that that training just does not happen. I mean, there's very little training going on now in US companies, and developing talent, maybe even less. That is preparing you for particular bigger jobs really doesn't happen. So I think I would start by recognizing that the most important types of development are learning by doing, right? And
David Clutterbuck: Yeah.
PETER: stretch assignments. And these really can save your managers time and effort because stretch assignments should come from your own desk as a leader to say, okay, here are things that I have to do. My direct reports have never done these. They're not that hard to do. For me, but for them, really challenging. Let's try to get them to do those jobs, right? Or those tasks. and if I can get that done, it frees up time on my calendar. So I would try to persuade the management team, at first starting at the very top, why this is in their interest to do, and that it is not costly to the organisation. In fact, it really doesn't cost much of anything. I mean, right now what what I see is leaders and even you know, senior positions that aren't all that far up don't want to give their junior people time to do anything else because they feel so much pressure to get the work done. And it's so short term oriented, right? By doing this, we burn people out because we just keep them on the same task forever. They get bored doing that, they want to grow in development. They can't do it, so they end up leaving going someplace else, right? If we did it the right way, we would cut our turnover rates. But leaders have to know that that's gonna save us money, right? So it all comes down, I think, to educating people at the top about these issues.
David Clutterbuck: Wa one of the the issues that came out of the original study that that we did was the realisation that talent management is something typically done to people, not with people.
PETER: Mm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah.
And so the issue there, I think, in practice is US companies back in the days where we were still talking about academy companies. By the way, academy companies like GE in the glory days of the eighties and nineties were just doing the same thing all corporations did, you know, f forty years before, right after World War Two, all this stuff got started, much more sophisticated than what happens now. What they started to realize is that they couldn't just dictate these practices to individual employees. You couldn't say, you know, Rika, time for you to go to Hong Kong for a year on this rotational assignment, right? Because people would say, no, I'm not going. And they might say, Well, it's a career ending move if you don't, which is what they used to say. And you'd say, No, it's not, because I'm quitting and going to work for these guys over here, right? So I think th they started to realize the better ones that you couldn't do that and you had to involve people in their development experience. Here's a quick example that Microsoft was doing at least a little while ago. And they would tell their direct re direct reports, pick two different jobs that you'd like to do in three years. Your boss, I have to approve them. I have to check with people above and say these two make sense for you and where the needs are. Develop the basic competencies to do both and then the company gets to pick. in three years which one you go to based on where the demand is, right? So, you know, we can engage employees in some of these fundamental decisions and give them some choice because ultimately they've got the choice to walk or not, right? So it doesn't have to be completely top down.
David Clutterbuck: Thank you, Peter. So if we could pick one issue that HR and or talent should should focus on in talent management, above everything else, what would it be?
PETER: Well, I it sounds pretty persuasive like the one we're talking about should be a good one. And that is how do we develop people? because that reduces turnover, that makes people less bored, it makes them feel like they're going someplace. It helps the organisation, right? and it allows people to advance internally rather than have to continually look someplace else to jump, right? So that would be the biggest win for the organisation and the employees themselves. And I think we've walked so far back on that that we could move forward a lot and get a lot of quick wins and a lot of benefits just by just by stop backing up, you know. We we make some progress.
David Clutterbuck: Thank Thank you. Really good.
Riddhika Khoosal: guess my final question, if I had one, was what do you really feel like? We have a platform right now to be able to speak to a wide audience of HR professionals that are genuinely looking. For new ways to evolve and for us to be able to create a workplace that is in line with the way the world is evolving. So, with that context, I guess what would you want to say to organisations and HR professionals around what talent management could really look like if we were living in, I guess, the best case scenario?
PETER: Well, I think y you know, what I see underneath the hood is and this is not unique to HR managers, but you know, particularly in the US, there is this approach from the very top people to say, don't wait too long to fire people. Right. And I think when they say that, and you hear this anecdote a lot, you know, I've never felt I fired somebody too soon. I think the reality of that is They often don't try to fix problems. They just wait till they get so irritated that they fire somebody, right? but I think HR leaders are afraid. and they're afraid to make a lot of these arguments. They're afraid to confront the CEO or challenge a CFO in in particular, I would think, right? so I think that's the the biggest problem. They've been in hunker down mode since the nineteen eighties, really. and I think that's the problem. I mean, th we can't really get anywhere if y we just rely on waiting for the CEO to think about what she wants to do with HR and then we're going to execute it. It is important to have an agenda that you can go to, if not, you know, once you're in, before you go in, to say, look, here's what I think needs to be done, and here's why, and here's why it pays off for the organisation, right? You have to be able to make that case. Otherwise, nobody's gonna make it for you. Right. And I think that's the problem I see, which has not changed for a while, is is not that people couldn't think about what would make more sense. They're just afraid to raise their hand and say, you know, h here's what we should try to do and why.
David Clutterbuck: Hm. Fascinating. We did a a study a while ago, where we asked HR directors, what is it you know now that you wish you'd known before you took up the role?
PETER: Hmm.
David Clutterbuck: and hold on, but what you're what you described there is exactly one of the co one of the key themes that came out of it. Having
PETER: Hmm.
David Clutterbuck: the courage the to challenge and knowing that if you don't do it early on, you're not gonna be able to do it later. you've yeah.
PETER: Yeah. And you can do it with facts, right? It's not an ethical thing, you know, here's the evidence, right?
David Clutterbuck: Yeah.
Riddhika Khoosal: Peter, what I really love quite consistently in all of your responses is how you've always linked the core idea with the the the cost implication in the business. And if you can't translate how a shift or a change is going to impact the business financially, it's unlikely to get hurt. And I think you really draw that line very cleanly across the board, no matter what you're talking about in relation to HR. And I think, you know, that's a really valuable lesson I'm taking out of this conversation, which is Maybe that's something we need to do more of, which is to have more financial, more of a financial lens when it comes to HR, to be able to have a seat at the table, having the conversations that are genuinely going to have an audience listen, respond, and act.
PETER: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I just one final thought on that. And that is a a a topic that mentioning seat at the table, our colleague Dave Ulrich has obviously talked about that a lot. And the question that comes from that is often is HR a profession, right? And the problem with thinking about it as a profession, the professions are in business, are accounting and law, right? They have separate sets of standards that already have outside legitimacy. You get in trouble if you do things that the accountants say you shouldn't do. You get in trouble as a corporation if you do things that your lawyers say you shouldn't do. HR does not have that, right? so you're not going to get in trouble with any external organisation if you don't do things the way HR wants to do things, thinks you should do them. And so you know HR best practices are a nice idea, but we're not a profession. in that same way, right? And the problem is if we think we are and act like we are, like this is just the way you should do things because the CE the CEO's gonna just ignore you, right? Because you're not the general counsel and you're not the CFO talking to the Security Exchange Commission for us, right? So we have to get over that and say, you know, look, we've got we are executives on the executive team here and we gotta figure out how to make that group succeed. We want to try to do it in a way where we can represent employees and their interests. But the extent to which we think that's important, we've got to sell it to a group to whom that is not their primary agenda, right?
David Clutterbuck: Yeah. Thank you, Peter.
PETER: Thank you both.
Riddhika Khoosal: Thank you, Peter. It's been a really interesting conversation and yeah, very enjoyable. Thank you so much for bringing your insights to our audience.
PETER: Thank you.