TRANSCRIPT 🔗
The transcript was generated automatically without human intervention.
Kevin Rothrock: [00:00:00] In mid August, the wall street journal published, what seemed like quite the scoop Putin rejected role for us forces near Afghanistan at summit with Biden, the newspaper reported after Afghanistan withdrawal us military hopes to position forces temporarily near Afghanistan, but Putin told Biden that Moscow objects, American journalists were rediscovering the war in Afghanistan as it was ending.
And it was good timing for the wall street journal except the Russian newspaper. Reported the same story a whole month earlier with the additional detail that Moscow had offered Washington use of Russian bases in central. Today, you'll hear from the author of that story. Yulaina Chenin com.[00:01:00]
Hello there. Welcome back to the Russia guy. I'm your host, Kevin Rothrock. And this is a podcast where I talk Russian news, politics and culture, and I interview various journalists, academics and activists. Doing interesting things in the field as always check your podcast, audio player for chapter headers.
That allow you to skip the specific segments in the conversation ahead, and you can check buzzsprout.com for an automatically generated transcript of everything that's said on today's show. As I mentioned at the top of the episode, my guest is Elina. A special correspondent at the newspaper [00:02:00] commerce, where she focuses on issues of cyber security non-proliferation and arms control, heavy stuff.
Now, I already knew all that when I asked you lean in for an interview. But when I did a little research to make sure that I was getting her, her title, correct. And all that, all the headline information, I learned that she holds a PhD in history from Moscow state university. Now, long time listeners of this podcast will know.
That I've personally bailed on two doctorates, one in political science and one in history. The first one was in history. So naturally my first question to Lena was how she went from getting a PhD in history to being one of Russia's former. International affairs reporters.[00:03:00]
Elena Chernenko: I got the gradually, um, for many years working, uh, for example, at the Russian edition of the Newsweek magazine, I was writing mostly about, um, social problems and, uh, society. So I would be writing about, uh, things like, um, unions of Housewives or for example, legalization of prostitution in European countries.
And whether this is applicable to. Um, and all kinds of the things, uh,
Kevin Rothrock: was it, was it
applicable?
Elena Chernenko: No, no threat, but it was fun. I mean, that was one of the, of the most interesting trips that I took as a report to me and a photographer. We went to Germany and actually visited to legalize prostitution house.
Which was quite a unique experience. And when we meet with this photographer and he is a good friend of mine way every time we remember that story, [00:04:00] because it was just such a, such a different trip from everything that, that both of us are doing right now, him working from, for Bloomberg, uh, shooting, all kinds of, uh, industrial pictures.
Most of the time of me working. Uh, at commerce out writing about foreign policy. So, um, there was quite a different time back then, but the end was gradually that I came to these topics that I'm writing about for maybe 10 years
Kevin Rothrock: mostly. So what was like the F what was your, how did you first arrive at this?
Like, what was your first step into the kind of reporting that you're doing now? This is like big international level staff. Do you remember like the, one of the first stories you
Elena Chernenko: did? It was two things, um, on cyber, it was. Uh, Vicky leaks and then this anonymous movement that was, um, this, uh, um, Heckers movement that were fighting for the rights of, uh, colleagues, uh, I guess a very intrigued and, um, maybe, uh, had [00:05:00] to romantic views about what can be achieved with search means.
I became very interested in cybersecurity, um, and the costs that Vicki leaks was fighting for. And I thought of us, I personally had a very big interest in that, um, And I started to researching about cyber security and the bridge leave writing about it. And when it came to, uh, uh, arms control and non-proliferation one of the, I would say the main event that led me to that topic, um, was a seminar which was organized by the peer center, um, in Vienna, or they had a meeting, um, I've, uh, Russian and American, uh, experts in this issues, uh, and not only experts, but also, uh, the, the current, uh, official.
Uh, and there I've heard many things that I haven't heard before. I kind of just stepped in from the outside in this, into this fascinating topic. And I just really felt was every piece of my body. This is it. This is something where I see the news. [00:06:00] I, even if it's at night and I will wake up and get up and get myself to write a story because it's, it's so fascinating that that's.
That's much more interesting than unions, a palace wipes. I see.
Kevin Rothrock: Have, have the issues that you see. So when you started, you said it was about 10 years ago when you came to these kind of, you know, big international issues. Would you say that in the last decade. It's that that has changed a lot specifically as it affects, you know, Russian foreign policy and Russia's place in those, in those international stories.
Have you seen a lot of changes over the last 10 years?
Elena Chernenko: I would say that in the beginning, like 2000 11, 12, 13, uh, it was more about cooperation. So we would be writing about all these projects that, um, Russia would be having, uh, was its international partners, um, in, including in the. Uh, and the, the ideas that they had for the future for example, was NATO.
There was all kinds of projects, um, on [00:07:00] Afghanistan security on, uh, uh, chromatin projects on the fight of terrorism. For example, uh, there
Load full transcript
was a fascinating project which is called spandex, where they, uh, together was NATO. Russia developed a tool to search, uh, We'll then close spaces for bombs. For example, it was tested for the first time.
I think in, in the, uh, in the subway in Paris, where they could look up to four 40 meters, if there's any, uh, devices, um, in this area and all kinds of these things, uh, after 2014, it was more about preparation. And then it started becoming more about confrontation.
Kevin Rothrock: So with the Crimea and Ukraine business. So that, that certainly affects the, the direction of stories and like overall tone.
I like, like, like you said, has that changed the working environment as well? Because I know that, you know, working so closely with the foreign affairs minister. And reporting on their actions. [00:08:00] Have you found that that changes like just the daily kind of the tone of your daily work or is, has it, has that kind of remained stable and you're talking, when you talk about the shift, you're talking more about kind of at the international level, or have you felt that like on a personal level,
Elena Chernenko: I felt that right away because before 2014, um, I would be traveling within the pool of the Russia for ministry of foreign affairs.
Quite often also to Western countries. Um, it would be at least one trip every week or every two weeks. Um, and many of those were to Vista the countries and then all of a sudden, yeah, actually
Kevin Rothrock: I remember, I think it was like, it was like six months ago or maybe even a year ago I wrote you and I was, I was trying to get you on the podcast.
And I was saying like, do you think you'll have time? And you're like, well, tomorrow I'm going to be in Tunisia and Thursday, I'm going to be in Cairo. And it was just like, you were ping pong and all over the world. And I thought, oh my gosh, I'm never going to get this woman on the show. She's constantly in movement.
But I guess [00:09:00] COVID helped out in that regard. Although are you moving again more than it's getting
Elena Chernenko: more now? Um, but not as much as before COVID, it's not even comparable, but when you look into do geography before 2014 and, uh, after that it's different. I mean, it's kind of getting back a bit into that more balanced, uh, Um, outreach, I would say for example, because of the foreign minister just went to several European countries, but for like two years, there was almost none of that.
And of course we felt that right away. Um, and yes, the topics that you've read about the, they would be so much different than it's nothing about cooperation, uh, anymore. It's more about confrontation, mutual suspicions, all kinds of sanctions, uh, limitations. Uh, yeah. It's, uh, The whole picture of what we write about today in foreign policies, of course, very much different.[00:10:00]
Kevin Rothrock: How would you characterize the Russian foreign? Security policy process. Like, would you say that from what you've witnessed, covering it now for decade closely, is it a fairly well institutionalized process, you know, with like clear procedures, uh, that, that all the different, you know, actors and players are following, or would you say it's like more ad hoc and more dependent and kind of constantly shifting based on, you know, like the, the issues and, um, the various personalities.
Was it, so, I mean, is it more about like individual personalities or. Are there formal procedures that kind of keep it going, going steady.
Elena Chernenko: I think it's both of them. Um, sometimes you see, um, you see a trend to see a strategy. You see a real thinking for four years ahead. Sometimes you see Moscow reacting to events [00:11:00] from outside.
Uh, and it's a balance of both, but of course, um, um, I'm writing mostly about the ministry of foreign affairs and. The minister, a surrogate labra, if you clearly states every time that, uh, his ministry is, has a coordinating role that it's playing, but it's the president who decides, um, and really it's, uh, Vladimir Putin who decides on the most important things that Russia does in foreign policy.
Um, the MFA, uh, might have more influence on like secondary. But on the, the PRI uh, on the priorities, of course, the feminine is the one that decides and the, then the diplomas are the one that are implementing it. So I would say it's a balance of, uh, institutionalized processes, but also of decision-making that is centered around one person.
Kevin Rothrock: Do you get the sense that, that, that Vladimir Putin is more interested in foreign policy than he is with domestic policy? I don't know if you're familiar with Tatiana has done that [00:12:00] via, but she's like regularly argued this point. That Putin only reluctantly does the domestic policy stuff, even though that's kind of where his constituents would like him to focus that he's more interest.
Sort of cementing his legacy in global history. And I would imagine that that would make work for the MFA more difficult, because he's kind of more interested in what they're doing, as opposed to say somebody dealing with housing or something that they're they're, you know, the criminal, it might be more, their attitude might be more like, just get it, get it done.
I don't want to know how just make it happen. Whereas. With the, with foreign affairs, I would imagine that Putin would be more involved in and, uh, the oversight would be greater. Did you have any sense of that's the case?
Elena Chernenko: I love reading to Tiana, Stan Avaya, and I admire, um, uh, her analysis. But when it comes to Putin, I'm always very, very careful about saying anything out or trying even to analyze anything that he might do has done his thought or might be thinking, because I have the feeling that [00:13:00] there's only one person in the world that knows what Putin thinks or wants and that's him personally.
Um, so I would not be judging if he likes, if he's more interested in foreign
policy or in that, in minor issues within the country, that domestic foreign and domestic. I it's so difficult to, to try to understand and kind of unlock our hack him, um, that I'm not even trying to do this. Like Kremlinology, it's septic that I don't
Kevin Rothrock: touch.
Gotcha. Okay.
Elena Chernenko: Um, and I guess that you know him as well. I mean, he is bragging about Putin personally for. Well, since Putin has been in power for the first date. And I think that out of all of the report does Andre might be the only person. That I would say has a feeling fair. What actually might apply to me putting the thinking or maybe doing the next, [00:14:00] uh, but even I think for , there's always room for surprises from the Kremlin.
Uh, we will see what will be happening. For example, in 2024, Andrei is quite sure that, uh, Vladimir Putin will Wolf stepped down and he has said it and written it on Facebook. And. Um, a few times, so I'm very, very interested to see if he's right. And this appears gut feeling is the right or
Kevin Rothrock: not Kolesnik of secret.
Is, is it, is it access or is it just that he has a intuition about Putin that most others do not
Elena Chernenko: access at the same time he is making an effort of, um, not getting too close. Um, he has described it quite well. I think one of the interviews that he gave, uh, Uh, he says he'd used it all, like the theatrical show on the stage and he's on the front row.
So he has a good seat, but he's not a stage. He watches his from in front of the auditorium. Uh, but I think he, his [00:15:00] secret, one of the main secret is that he just has this unique writing style. I am not sure when, uh, when it gets translated into English, whether it's still has this charm. And, um, I remember some of the phrases from his articles from years.
Um, sometimes they are painfully long, um, and that hurts. Um, but most of the times I really love reading him. Gotcha.
Kevin Rothrock: I recently spoke to, for this, for this podcast, I recently interviewed and tun butter Bosch, and about schools of thought within Russian foreign policy. And he, he, um, he shared an argument with me.
I think it appeared someone else made this argument recently, but he was arguing that, that, um, That even though everyone in Russia's kind of foreign policy school speaks like a realist. There are scholars and analysts who have other perspectives, whether it's, you know, liberal internationalism or whatever, but they're all kind of forced by essentially political rhetoric of the day to talk like realists.
Do you think. That that [00:16:00] that is true. Do you think that, I mean, do you think that, I guess it's a two-part question one, do you think realism this notion that, you know, really only raw power matters, is that the singular driving logic of Russian foreign policy, or is it actually more complicated than that?
And if it is more complicated, do you see serious ideological divisions among the Russian foreign policy elite? Or is there a consensus?
Elena Chernenko: It seemed that it really became the leading school of thought and driver and Russian foreign policy. It wasn't like that, I think in the beginning of the two thousands.
Um, but then it changed over time. And today, clearly realism is, um, the ex ex uh, the, the way that you would describe, uh, and, um, explain the Russian foreign policy, the main driver. So it out it, I don't think that, that the Moscow came to this conclusion by itself. Uh, it seems that the really in the beginning of the two thousands, there was much more of [00:17:00] a maybe not ramen TISM maybe not naiveness, but, um, some other drivers as well, but then it changed over time.
And today is I think that that's the, that's really the main to the school. Even if you read, for example, I isn't interested into English, but I waiting for it very much to be translated into English there. The fascinating new book that came out by the head of the Moscow Carnegie centered me through training just a few months ago on Russia's foreign policy.
And it's very much about realism. For me, he kind of explained the thing that I was thinking and feeling, but, uh, it's always wonderful if a great analyst puts it, uh, into, into phrases and the words and you say, ah, exactly, that's it. So I would try re recommended.
Kevin Rothrock: So you read Stanley via read trenin and they're both at, at, they both write for Carnegie or there are other experts in sources besides your own reporting, obviously that, that you recommend to people, whether in English or Russian fed.
Elena Chernenko: [00:18:00] I read everything that he writes and he's actually also about realism mostly, but he has also this wonderful kind of cynical view, um, on things that was a kind of a black humor sometimes. Uh, I appreciate that. Yeah, there's other experts on it on specific areas, for example, um, on all things, Russia, Asia, it's Alexander, we've also framed with the Carnegie center, but then of course I very much value the work that, um, the Russian experts, uh, do on things that I mostly write about on arms control.
Non-proliferation there is under
Um, and other and other people that really, I follow everything that they write in the comment about. And I really value very much that there's Twitter, which allows, um, experts that are on different issues from all over the world to be communicating real-time and
Kevin Rothrock: these things in terms of your job, it, it puts you in close contact with state officials in Russia.
And, you know, I assume in other countries as well, [00:19:00] So ear, especially, you know, involved with, with the, the Russian foreign affairs ministry. And I'm wondering, has your job changed very much as the Russian state's relationship with journalists has become kind of more tense over this year, over the course of this year.
But I mean, in, in recent years, I suppose, you know, even like, you know, recently there's been a lot of attention on the
foreign ministry himself. And his, his personal life even. And I wonder, does that affect your work? Does that make it difficult to talk to these officials or is it, is it, it doesn't, it hasn't really affected anything.
Elena Chernenko: The situation right now that, that, uh, many colleagues of mine are facing, uh, in Russia, working for different outlets, um, is difficult. Definitely. And it's getting more different. Um, this campaign, I was branding people forward agents. I think it's, it's stupid. I really, um, don't understand. I mean, I, I know the [00:20:00] logic of the Russian authorities to say that it's a, it's mirroring the thing said the U S and other countries too, but I think it's, it's quite, uh, illogical to take bad practices from other countries and try to implement it in, uh, in your own countries, explaining that the, we are doing this.
And, uh, several off colleagues that I have been working with us. Other outlets, for example, at the Russian Newsweek are now branded for an agents. And I know them personally, and I know how, how much they care for Russia, how much they want our country to be. Benefiting and flourishing and just becoming better.
And if they're criticizing events in, in, uh, in Russia, they're doing this because they really loved this country. They are living here that their kids are living here and they want to stay here. Just want to live here to become a better, that's why out of they have sometimes very critical, uh, when it comes to my work for some reason, uh, it feels sometimes that we're working at [00:21:00] still kind of an Oasis.
It's hard to explain. I mean, it's really hard to explain. For example, when people ask me that don't know how the ministry of foreign affairs works with journalists or how Maria is a higher at the spokesperson works with journalists. But, um, I can really say that, that it still works. I can do, um, the job that I have been doing.
Yeah, you see them having difficulties talking about this, but it goes, it's a very hard to explain, but no, I don't have the, luckily I don't have difficulties. I'm writing about the things that I am writing about, uh, security issues to, uh, Russia's foreign policy getting sometimes, uh, trying to get scoops and all of these issues.
It has become different, but it's not, it's not more difficult at the moment. Um, that doesn't mean that it apply for all of. Uh, one of my colleagues has been jailed, [00:22:00] um, more than a year ago. Yvonne says that he's being accused of treason. And I know that that, uh, my colleagues that are writing about, um, domestic, um, issues, um, especially about the political life in Russia, they're facing, uh, difficulties, uh, of all kinds.
But, um, I mean, even though it's getting really. More difficult to do the job, uh, as good as you want it to do. I think we still have an important mission trying to actually give a quality product to our readers. Um, just as any, as many years ago, just as today, giving all kinds of views on one issue, might they be conflicting if there's two sides or three sides?
Uh, Quoting any experts at is criticizing Russia or the Russian government just as we did before that. So, yeah, I would say that we're [00:23:00] lucky
Kevin Rothrock: in terms of the future for Russian journalism and journalists, do you think. I mean, things seem to be still getting a bit worse and, you know, presumably they have a ways to go before anything gets better. Do you have any like, not necessarily recommendations or advice for Russian journalists, but one trend I'm seeing is that by being pushed kind of to the periphery or by being made to feel persecuted a lot, a lot of journalists, it seems will turn their sort of sites on the state officials themselves.
And so that's one reason why I think, you know, we're seeing investigative reports about. Senior federal ministers and their love life's in their, you know, their property holdings. And so on. Maybe we wouldn't have seen that before. It seems like, you know, [00:24:00] that there's a sense that like, okay, the gloves are off now.
We're an open warfare. Do you think that's going to make things worse or do you think that the sort of the dis the, the, the change will not come from how journalists behave it'll come from state policy? Or like, how do you see the situation resolving or changing somehow?
Elena Chernenko: He probably had felt from my previous answer.
That is really difficult to me, to, to, uh, for me to talk about this issues. Not because I can't, but because they, they exactly, they touched me so deeply. And I'm thinking about all kinds of aspects of these processes, uh, all the time, uh, and more and more in the last time. Um, so I haven't dictated my personal position, um, on all of these events and.
All that I, that I feel that we can do in this situation. Uh, I can't speak like for other people, uh, very much. I, we, we tried to discuss it with [00:25:00] colleagues at commerce ended our foreign policy, um, department. There's eight of us. And, um, How do we work with all of those? I mean, the world is going crazy.
Definitely. And foreign policy is just absolutely crazy every day. You, you, you watch and see things that would have not been imaginable, I guess before maybe every generation of journalists is saying that, but it feels very, very bad right now. Like you wake up and you think nothing will surprise me anymore, but it does everything.
So what's your mission. How do you, how do you go through this? I mean, how do you still, uh, remain kind of sober and with a cool head and actually do your work and, and, uh, believe me, I feel every second week, or maybe even more often that I be, I should be going to some newspaper and write about gardening or something.
What flowers said that that should be much more reassuring. Relax. But, um, we feel that our mission is to really try to do [00:26:00] the same quality and objective journalism as before under all circumstances. And
they're all limitations with everything coming in at us. Try to do our job as good as we can, as long as it's possible.
And it's possible. I, for example, take from you, right? A very, very difficult issue at the moment where, uh, We're even in the words that you use, um, your position will be articulated in my, or the other way. I'm not talking about, um, my personal opinion on this, because it doesn't matter here. It's only the way that like, uh, commerce and, uh, right about these event.
So, um, I really appreciated our paper to try to be as balanced as possible, even with the most delicate. Uh, using the wording that would reflect on all the different opinions on this. It's difficult for me [00:27:00] to explain this in English, because I can only say that the Russian, the words that, that would matter here, like very, very pro-government, um, outlets, uh, or governmental at the state media would, um, much more often used the word , which could be a vital re reunification.
Showing that this process of 2014 was historically absolutely justified and the way that it should have been, right. Um, then, uh, government critical papers or Western papers, they would use the word annexation showing you that it's an illegal process, added some kind of crime that Russia committed. And we were trying to, uh, to do as balanced as it can mostly using the.
so Crimea joining, um, Russia, the going into Russia [00:28:00] uh, which shows what happened in reality, right? Because Crimea is a part of Fresha now, but not giving it any emotional judgment. Um, non no ideological. And that shows F like was all there's so many days dedicate issues where you really have to choose very carefully.
You're awarding that. Yeah. That hasn't been there before, but it's doesn't mean that it's not possible to make quality journalism it's still possible. And if, as many people that are doing this remain in the profession, don't go and write about gardening or, or immigrate or open bars. I think that we can make
Kevin Rothrock: it.
So you're talking about experiencing burnout essentially for, you know, for different reasons. You're, you're, you've stuck with this job now for 20 years, you've been doing the international stuff for half of that. How do you avoid burnout? You know, you, you don't write about gardening. Do you, do you do gardening?
Do you like, how do you, how do you keep your head to keep [00:29:00] yourself sane just for day to day? What do you, what do you do in your spare time to stay. No, I
Elena Chernenko: have a few flowers at home, but I think their survival for trawlers. Like, I don't think that nobody cares as little for them as I do. I I'm really surprised that that there's still grieve stuff in my apartment.
Um, I'm happy to have, uh, has been the, doesn't do journalism and doesn't do foreign policy. So we talk about normal things at home. Uh, I am not watching. Uh, almost at all. Um, I'm in, I'm watching cooking shows in German because I liked them so much. Uh, but that's all because when I see, um, any kind of TV shows that do, um, was foreign deal, was foreign policy, uh, be it on Russian TV or on a Western TV, let's say like CNN or Fox news or so I'm, I'm, I'm starting to talk to the TV.
I'm getting really [00:30:00] nervous. Uh, and my husband, does he shuts it off because he says no. Um, um, you're getting nervous, you're getting all upset about things. Um, so I'm trying to do, um, things that don't have anything to do with foreign policy. I have a few friends that are, uh, both in the profession, like both of them and journalists, and I don't know how they do it at home and how you just get back home and it's altogether.
It's all. Again, sounds like a nightmare. I don't know. I think, I think. Just today. I, again, was writing to one of my friends said, um, I think I'm in the wrong profession. What am I doing here? Um, I should be doing something totally different. And then I'm thinking like I haven't almost ever done anything different.
And again, as I said in the beginning, these topics that I've read about, I care about them so much. Even if I was doing anything else, they would be still, um, waking me up at night and keeping me thinking about them in one kilter, right. About them and [00:31:00] talking to people about them, asking for them opinions.
Um, and when my oldest son who is five, he asked me what I'm doing as a profession. I said, I'm asking questions. That's the best thing that I can do is ask questions. I don't always get the answers, but. Get the answers all the time, right. To the questions that we ask. So you can only do as best as you can.
And, um, if there is a moment when you think you're not good enough in this, um, anymore, oh, you don't get at all, any answers to your questions and it may be time to lead, but I'm lucky that it's not the time red now.
Kevin Rothrock: That's my interview with a special correspondent at the newspaper kommersant though her reporting is in Russian. Please check the description of this podcast for a hyperlink to her Twitter profile, where she does [00:32:00] often write in English. Thanks for listening to this show, everybody an extra. Thanks to those of you who are contributing to the podcast at patrion.com/kevin, Rob.
Monthly and annual contributions are very welcome and they're very possible. You can go to the website and do either of those things. They helped me pay for the audio software subscriptions that make this show possible and sounding good. Everything's a subscription these days. You can't just buy something and get it forever.
You got. Paying for it. Anyway, thank you again. And until next time .