TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Connecting with Malia Blom of Grassroot Institute of Hawaii. And Malia, welcome and a very good morning.
00:00:09
Speaker 2: Good morning to you.
00:00:10
Speaker 1: How you been?
00:00:13
Speaker 2: Well, pretty well, thank you. You know, we've just got through the election, which I'm a lot better off than many of my contemporaries on the mainland. I'll put it that way.
00:00:23
Speaker 1: Oh, wow. How so?
00:00:24
Speaker 2: Oh, well, you know, there's, you know, a lot of different state think tanks, just like the Grouchy Institute of Hawaii. And many of them, you know, experienced fairly significant election shifts. And also that in the last meeting I had, they asked us, you know, so how do you do it? How do you work in a blue state? Like, we've got answers to all your questions.
00:00:55
Speaker 1: Understand. What's the vibe back in D.C. with the midterms now over?
00:01:01
Speaker 2: Well, you know, inevitably we're in a very, what does this mean, who's on top kind of place.
00:01:10
Speaker 1: Gotcha.
00:01:11
Speaker 2: A lot of, I'd like to say a lot of soul-searching, but I think we're still in finger-pointing. So a lot of finger-pointing still.
00:01:17
Speaker 1: Well, I mean, we just take a look at what's happening in the White House, all the speculation going from Hex Seth to Stephen Miller taking over. I understand Dana White was approached to be the new White House press secretary.
00:01:34
Speaker 2: I heard that, too. Is it okay for me to be a little sad that didn't happen?
00:01:41
Speaker 1: Oh, sure. Express the angst, Malia. Yeah.
00:01:47
Speaker 2: I mean, I think it would have... It would have made me much more likely to watch those press conferences. I'll put it that way.
00:01:52
Speaker 1: Oh, I would run them live 24-7. You want to talk about entertainment value. Goodness gracious. Oh, man. Any buzz on who it could possibly be, or we're just hanging on?
00:02:07
Speaker 2: Oh, yeah. I mean, the Dana White was the best rumor I'd seen, and so I haven't seen anything that's It even comes close to that in interest or, well, maybe legitimacy, but definitely in interest.
00:02:22
Speaker 1: Malia, remind our friends a little bit about yourself and what brings us together.
00:02:28
Speaker 2: Yes, of course. My name is Malia Hill. I am the policy director at the Grassroot Institute of Hawaii. Grassroot is a free market, nonpartisan think tank. And we look at Hawaii, mostly just how issues that affect you know, the economy and freedom in Hawaii and Hawaii's interests, you know, nationwide.
00:02:50
Speaker 1: You know, I was just commenting that it's 2001 when our brother Dick Rowland started Grassroot Institute of Hawaii, and here we are. It's been 25 years.
00:03:03
Speaker 2: I know. It's so strange when you look back because you see, you know, the different issues that, you know, the different landscapes, some things are very different. Some things are the same. I know that Dick was very interested in
Load full transcript
the problems of the rail. It's like I've been writing about the problems of the rail forever.
00:03:21
Speaker 1: Yes. Amen, sister. That is true. But once he was immersed in a topic or whatever, the thoroughness of analysis and opinion and so much more, It was such an invaluable source, and that's a common factor that exists today.
00:03:48
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think one of the things that I really appreciate, Dick, and I wish people really understood, was his incredible philosophical consistency and rigor. You know, we talked to him about issues, you know, this bill or this issue that's facing Hawaii. And for him, he was so great at getting to the fundamental philosophical question, you know, is this, you know, is this good for freedom or is it not? And he could boil these things down to that. And it sort of set the standard for the Gratiot Institute because, you know, you take a look at things and they might be, you know, these incredibly, you know, complicated, occasionally dull political things, you know, should this licensing thing law change, but you could boil it down, you know, like Dick always did, to, you know, what does this mean for freedom? And that kind of gives us guidance in how we approach these things.
00:04:42
Speaker 1: You know, through the many, many years, and I'm not trying to be Captain Obvious, but I may sound it, is that this is the first time in my history of paying attention that we're really on the brink of something so significant in the change to our country. And game on. I mean, it is underway to relatively, as Barack Obama said, fundamentally transform the United States. Transform America. I post kind of a hypothetical, but maybe you could help us out. I'm stating to my friends, we need to be aware. We need to be able to respond and reply. And if somebody approached you or you got in a conversation and this came up, Malia, and it came up, you know, capitalism is terrible. Capitalism is the worst thing for our society. You know, the reason why socialism and the acceptance is growing is because it's an antidote for all of the incredibly wealthy and the rich and the powerful and to return freedoms back to the people and dot, dot, dot. Because that's Those are conversations taking place around America. What would you counsel folks in regard to responding?
00:06:12
Speaker 2: Well, you know, my background is history. And I agree with you that you can sort of instinctively feel, you know, the ground shifting. And, you know, what does it mean? You know, it's always hard to know when you're in the middle of it. It's so much easier to be able to look back several hundred years and go, oh, well, that's what was happening. And it's a frustration for me with the background in history that we see these rise in socialism, but I understand it because it's just, you know, the ground is shifting. We can feel people just fundamentally unhappy with the way things are, and it goes beyond, you know, who the president is. It's about changes in our society and changes in technology and changes in the economy. And so they kind of go to this utopianism. of socialism, the kind of thing that works in heaven, but it's not on Earth.
00:07:02
Speaker 1: Right.
00:07:03
Speaker 2: Well put. And, you know, you can tell them, you know, point to an example where that's worked, and no one ever can. And then they try to tell you, you know, well, you know, we're going to be the ones. But the problem is that, like any utopian-based philosophy, it doesn't account for human nature. And that's why, you know, democracy... is not perfect. It's the least bad option relative to other things. Capitalism has a lot of problems, but they're usually when it's being thwarted for one interest or another. So the question is not, you know, let's throw away this thing that works better than all the other things, even when it's flawed, for something that is proven to definitely not work. Look at how you can improve where you are. That's why people.
00:07:57
Speaker 2: Have been susceptible to this socialist rhetoric. Because it is, you know, well, let's just, you know, make it better where we are. But it promises things it can't deliver. And it promises, and the only way to get them, as, you know, humans have found out so many times, is by, you know, through methods that everyone will hate, by very unfree, undemocratic methods. It's not achievable. And it never has been. Um... So let's look at what we can do. You know, what is the real problem? That's kind of what I like to ask, because these whole, like, capitalism, the problem. Well, what? What specifically? You know, because I know, you know, as you scroll on your iPhone, that you do not have a problem with capitalism, like, more generally. You have a specific problem. So let's talk about the specific problem, because probably what people are upset about is not capitalism. They're upset about you know, sort of the rapacious way that tech companies operate or the lack of, you know, guardrails on certain things or they're upset with crony capitalism or regulations that favor big, big companies over small companies. And that's not capitalism.
00:09:12
Speaker 1: Correct. Very well put. You know, when I urge, and you said it, name an example where it is flourishing and freedoms abound and security and all of this. And when people try to say it, I tell them, you're not talking about citizenship. You're talking about subjects. You're subjected to. You have no say, no influence. You are relegated. And there are some folks that, that's okay. I'll do anything you want me to do. What do I have to do? Just Sit here and you'll pay for my food and my shelter and you'll take care of my kids going to school. and you'll get me car insurance and get me a car. The differentiation between a helping hand and a living hand is very, very different. But there are those that would like to just be entitled to being taken care of. It's amazing.
00:10:22
Speaker 2: Yes, exactly.
And, you know, how that works, no one ever has an answer because they just kind of feel like they have a strange view of how money works and what rich really is. You know, it's the Batman analogy. You know, someone... I like Batman. Someone will always go, why doesn't Bruce Wayne, he's a billionaire, why doesn't Bruce Wayne just give everyone in Gotham money? And that'll solve the crime problem. But no, it wouldn't. Number one, you know, you could do the math of how many people there are and how much money Bruce Wayne has, and Bruce Wayne would be able to give everyone about ten bucks. Is that going to solve the problem? Is that going to solve the crime problem? But it also misunderstands crime. It misunderstands money. It misunderstands wealth. You know, one of my aggravations is that people think that, you know, when you say, we'll stick with Bruce Wayne so I don't alienate anyone. Bruce Wayne is worth a billion dollars. They assume he has a billion dollars in the bank, not, you know, property and stocks and such. It's not how money works. It's not how wealth works. It's not, you know, that's Everyone is better off with Wayne Industries paying out money in the way of salaries and improvements than it is with Bruce Wayne giving everyone in Gotham $ 10.
00:11:48
Speaker 1: So before we take a break and we're going to get into other topicalities, Act 11 is really top of mind and remains with Grassroot taking the lead in many ways, and there are other more specifics, but Just at what point, Malia, or has it been ingrained with us historically speaking? Animosity towards those who are quote-unquote successful and success being defined towards those who are quote-unquote successful and success being defined, I guess, by socioeconomic standards or even by governmental standards. proclamations that if you make this much, then you're rich, or whatever it is. The disdain and the anger and the real distaste for people that have succeeded. And I still try and grasp why. What are people's problems if other folks are doing better?
00:12:54
Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, we're basically talking about the politics of envy, and I mean... That's biblical, in a literal sense.
00:13:03
Speaker 1: Well put, yes, yes.
00:13:08
Speaker 2: So yeah, it's a problem that goes back as long as there's been human nature. And I have sympathy for it, especially in our modern age where you just seem so much closer to the mechanisms of envy. You know, I understand how you get yourself, how we get into this thinking where, you know... You just kind of want to bring everyone else down a peg.
00:13:30
Speaker 1: Yeah, I guess so.
00:13:31
Speaker 2: But it is functionally, I mean, hey, this person has stuff that I don't have, and that doesn't seem fair, and I'm going to vote to take it away from them. You know, dress it up however you want, but that's the politics of envy. Yeah.
00:13:47
Speaker 1: What do you think thematically was stated by the midterms with the Democrats and left superseding and republicans really in in all honesty uh took a.
00:14:02
Speaker 2: Beating yeah you know there's a there's a lot of people with a lot of takes on it at the moment ask me next year and my opinion might change but at the moment i think it's an expression of people's unhappiness i think you know listening to some of my uh peers in other states, they say, also, we could have had some better candidates on the Republican side, at least for the conservative side. But I think it's also, you know, in France, they burn things down and destroy property. We don't really do that. We express our disappointment at the ballot box, which is what you're supposed to do. That's what the system is supposed to do. I might not be thrilled about the results, but you can kind of be happy that there exists a mechanism to show, look, I don't like where things are. Given the choice of two, there's only two ways to go. And if you were going to express your dissatisfaction with the status quo, you're going to go left with your vote. Now, I wish I could individually talk to everyone and say, you know, here's why I think maybe that wasn't the best decision. But I understand, you know, what drove it. And I think that's probably most of it. I think in some places it's just very close. In some places, you know, they just had really bad candidates. So it's not across the board. But I think in general... It's just a reaction to, like you pointed out, it feels like we're living on the precipice of something, and I think this is one of those little indicators.
00:15:46
Speaker 1: You know, we're at 731 already in the morning. Love when Malia's on the program. How do we connect with you, and how do we connect with Grassroots Institute of Hawaii?
00:15:58
Speaker 2: Well, you can reach me through the Grassroot Institute email, info at grassrootinstitute.org. You can reach us online at grassrootinstitute.org. We're also on social media, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, all of those, so you can find us there. Reach out. We'd love to hear from you.
00:16:16
Speaker 1: We are going to continue with Malia Blumhill of Grassroot Institute of Hawaii. Love our time with Malia. Love our time with you. The Rick Hamada Program on News Radio 830 KHVH. Once again, it is Aloha Monday and it is the Rick Hamada Program on News Radio. 830 KHVH. Delighted that you are part of this radio program. More to come after the top of the hour news, but we're delighted that Malia Hill is with us, Grassroots Institute of Hawaii. She is based out of Washington, D.C. Just curious, how's the surf in D.C., Malia?
00:17:06
Speaker 2: Disappointing.
00:17:08
Speaker 1: Yes. Boy, that's an accurate statement. Toxic. Swampy. Oh, my goodness gracious. All right, what's the over-under here? on who leaves the administration first, either by the old accord or by the inevitable chainsaw of impeachment?
00:17:37
Speaker 2: Oh, that's a good question. I mean, you know, we're headed into gridlock, for sure. A lot of
infighting. You know, if you're really swarthy conservative i guess you could see it as a good thing because very little is going to get done we're going to be all taken up with this you know how to attack trump how to defend trump you know vetoing everything left and right proposing ever more absurd laws left and right uh i'm gonna go with well it's cheating to say that hegseth is the first one to uh to face the fire, but I'm going to say that anyway.
00:18:19
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:18:23
Speaker 2: But, you know, generally speaking, people tend to resign if it's looking bad, at least historically speaking, resignation before you actually get there. No bet on whether they, you know, pass articles of impeachment on Trump. I feel like that's just kind of a hobby now, you know, like crochet.
00:18:43
Speaker 1: Yeah. Well, I'm afraid, again, your accuracy. I mean, it's almost like it's a cottage industry that attorneys enrich themselves on both sides. They're the ones that really glean anything. Unreal.
00:19:01
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:19:01
Speaker 1: Unreal.
00:19:02
Speaker 2: When I was in law school in D.C., and this was a while ago, they told us that one of five people in D.C. was an attorney. Wow. That's a very depressing statistic.
00:19:15
Speaker 1: Wow. Goodness gracious. Well, I'll say this. This has all happened before, and there was so much caterwauling about the number of seats lost, and it was an absolute on Donald Trump and all of this, but I've been apprised that Bill Clinton in 94, he lost 54 seats in the midterms. Obama lost 63. 63 in 2010. And Donald Trump lost 41 seats in these latest midterms. But there's not a whole lot of caterwauling going on about the Dem numbers. But Donald Trump loses a fraction of the other boy's. Oh, my gosh, see, this is an indictment. This is an absolute fire.
00:20:16
Speaker 2: Yeah, you're totally right about that. And I was a little surprised because it's common knowledge. The two things that are common knowledge is that the governorship of Virginia always flips to the opposite of the president, opposite party of the president, which it did, and that the sitting president always loses power. seats in the midterms. And, you know, both of those things. And that's the thing that you'd think you'd see a little more of. And like you said, not actually as full of rejection as, you know, the very famous Newt Gingrich Clinton election back in the 90s. That was, you know, and that one was arguably transformative. But, I don't know if I should give this away, ultimately pretty good for Clinton. Yeah. because although it did end up, you know, kind of hurting him in the scandal, he got credit for a lot of the reforms that were passed by the Republican Congress, and it was generally kind of good.
00:21:16
Speaker 1: For his legacy. I bring up Dick Morris and triangulation as being a key for Clinton, but I think it was also the one thing that stood out, part of that was the welfare reforms. Which back in the day, everybody was just going cray-cray, able to strike that thing, and that propelled them to a second term. So you're right, well put. But the correlation between today's political, shall I say, process, kind of hate that word, but it's true. Politicking is so different today. I mean, I was just being apprised of a thing where a podcaster making jokes about Charlie Kirk's death, trying to give an apology. Nope, nope, sorry, you're done. Corporate companies pulling out the support and all this. I bring it up as it's just, there's just so many variables. It's not a traditional politicking like I'm aware of.
00:22:28
Speaker 2: Yeah, that part, you know, it feels, honestly, like we all went a little insane, and we're trying to climb back out of it, but things have changed so much. We're in this algorithm-led discourse where no one really knows how to do it. We swing wildly, you know, we cancel people, and then we, you know, sometimes an apology works, sometimes it doesn't, right? You know, we've become intolerant of any kind of speech that we don't like, and at the same time, you know, you still remember that we are a free speech society from time to time. It's a very, very strange place, and I miss the monoculture.
00:23:10
Speaker 1: Amen. Let's turn that clock back, shall we? I mean....
00:23:17
Speaker 2: I'm okay with that. I don't even mind waiting one week between TV episodes. I can live with that.
00:23:22
Speaker 1: Okay, hold on. Let's not push it. Let's not push it.
00:23:28
Speaker 2: Oh, no, you're not a TV binger, are you?
00:23:30
Speaker 1: Oh, I am a binge. Ted Lasso, my favorite television program, waited until all the episodes aired before going to the show and then just binged it in two days. this last season.
00:23:47
Speaker 2: Oh, no. I like the slow release. I like to watch and then think for a week. Granted, I do like it when they maybe give me one more. I wish Gilded Age had just started. They dropped one more right off the bat so I could kind of get the feel for it. But I can wait. I can wait a week. I can talk about it at the water cooler or wherever. Yeah.
00:24:08
Speaker 1: I think the differentiation is you would go to a buffet that have crab legs and go one time. I would go to the buffet for crab legs 147 times at once. So the differentiation makes itself known.
00:24:27
Speaker 2: That's true. I do only hit the crab legs the one time. But I will point out that in the old way, they would have had to make 22 episodes of Ted Lasso. So you might have been happier per season.
00:24:38
Speaker 1: There we go again. You are on it again. No doubt. We're at 745, but I really want to touch on passage of laws around the country that may be similar or even identical in some ways to Act 11. And I know we've had conversations about it in the past. Joe and I have as well. But bring us up to speed, Act 11, and what the impact could be to Grassroots Institute and other organizations.
00:25:10
Speaker 2: Yeah, you know, so we've talked
about Act 11 and how it's fundamentally about free speech, but I haven't talked about what was really going, much about what was really going on. So Act 11 passed in Hawaii earlier this year, a legislative session signed right away. And what it does is it prevents groups like the Grassroots Institute or any organization that is basically recognized by the state from speaking in an electoral context, you know, giving money to candidates or candidate committees or speaking out on ballot issues, which is what we do, or, you know, for a candidate or giving opinion about a candidate if you're like, you know, one of those C4s that says, you know, you need to know this about this candidate's stances. All that would be forbidden under Act 11. But this is really the brainchild of a progressive group from the mainland, and their big idea was... We can, you know, we can't prevent people from exercising their First Amendment rights. The Supreme Court is very clear about that. But what we'll do is it states that allow, that basically through their state law, give the mechanism to create corporations and partnerships and limited liability companies and associations and nonprofit organizations. You know, when you start a company or you start a nonprofit or whatever it is, you basically... you know, fill out a bunch of state paperwork to make it exist under state law. So their big idea was, we're going to change state law so that when you, those companies, these groups, these organizations and such, they just don't have the right to speak. We're just going to say that the state gives you the ability to exist, but we don't give you the ability to speak. And that model, you know, was introduced in multiple states. passed first in Hawaii by the Hawaii legislature, and then just this, just last week, two ballot initiatives, one in Montana, one in Michigan, that were extremely similar, same kind of groups behind it, same, you know, same idea, little bits and differences because, you know, states have different laws, but basically the same function, both got passed by ballot. And Both immediately, immediately suit upon. Because if you really drill down, what this is trying to say is that you have the ability, you have free speech. No one can take that away. But if you and three friends get together and, you know, create a group, you guys working together don't have free speech.
00:27:56
Speaker 1: That's amazing.
00:27:58
Speaker 2: Yes, and it's that simple. I feel bad because if you voted for this, they are selling it to you as some kind of campaign finance thing. It doesn't have anything to do with campaign finance. It just has to do with how you organize associations. It affects unions. It affects nonprofits. Obviously, it affects companies. But it's really just about this function of speaking together. you know, in a created organization. And the funny thing is, it's always sold as this whole, like, oh, we're going to hit the billionaires, when in fact, it doesn't affect billionaires at all. You know, it's not campaign finance, and it doesn't hurt billionaires. Because Elon Musk can spend whatever he wants, and he could blanket our airways, and no one would be able to stop him. That's exercising free speech. But none of us, you and I together, we can't counter-counter Elon Musk. We don't have that kind of money. So we would have to get together with a bunch of other people in order to put on one ad that counters Elon Musk. But this wouldn't let us do that.
00:29:15
Speaker 1: I know I'm running. I have a break coming up. I want to follow up on this just a little bit more. The implications are great. I hope our friends are grasping exactly what's taking place and spreading around the country. So we'll get this very short break in with Malia Hill of Grassroot Institute of Hawaii.
00:29:38
Speaker 2: The Rick Kamata Program, simulcast every morning on Alelo Channel 53 on Spectrum.
00:29:50
Speaker 1: Time is flying by with Malia Hill of Grassroot Institute of Hawaii, based out of Washington, D.C., Just a quick question on Act 11-ish and other areas in the nation. What is the legal reply? Is it constitutional-based? How do you challenge what's passed in various legislatures?
00:30:15
Speaker 2: Well, everyone now has sued in federal court, basically saying that it violates the First Amendment. We actually... In our complaint, we added some other things, issues about the vagueness of it, you know, how it's written. Because, for example, the Hawaii law exempts news organizations. But what does that mean? That also shows you how bad it is because news organizations don't need to be exempted. They have rights. free speech under the Constitution. The government doesn't have the ability to give it back to them. They always had it, which just kind of shows you what the problem with this was. But anyway, the Hawaii case is the furthest along because we were the first to file. We've already had a hearing on motions to a preliminary injunction and motion to dismiss, and we're just kind of waiting to see what will happen with the court on that. The Montana and Michigan, they filed last week pretty much as soon as the law passed. Those laws go into effect on January 1st, so there's going to be pressure on all these courts to come down with a decision pretty quickly, at least in terms of whether to issue an injunction to prevent the law from taking effect. So we are going to see Montana, Michigan, and Hawaii all issue opinions on the constitutionality of this Act 11-style law. Very likely, especially if there's any disagreement, that is going to keep going up. It may be that Act 11, it's possible that Act 11 will end up in front of the Supreme Court at some point, just because it's something that's happening around the country.
00:32:07
Speaker 1: In the process where we are now, where in the courts are we, And is it going to hit the Hawaii Supreme Court? And if and when it does, the current composition of that
court, what can you surmise of what the possible outcome would be?
00:32:27
Speaker 2: Well, we are in federal district court, not Hawaii state court, because it's a U.S. Constitution issue.
00:32:34
Speaker 1: Gotcha.
00:32:36
Speaker 2: So I... It's hard to say, even if it was able to, it won't go to the Hawaii Supreme Court, but even if it did, it's hard to say because courts are supposed to pay attention to precedent, and the legal precedent on this issue is very clear. It's so clear that the Hawaii Attorney General urged the legislature not to pass it because it was so obviously unconstitutional and the state was going to have to spend money defending a law that was ultimately unconstitutional. probably due to failure. And that's what they did. But we do that a lot. We often pass laws that we then have to spend taxpayer money to defend and then lose. If it gets appealed, it'll get appealed up to the circuit courts. In Hawaii, it'll go to the Ninth Circuit Court. And then... Hard to say, because these courts tend to be a little bit more liberal. But the... So jurisprudence on First Amendment is very, very clear, you know, which we should win all the way, which doesn't mean that we will, but we should.
00:33:46
Speaker 1: Right. No, I got it. Thank you for that indeed. And there's no real ETA of speaking of process as far as the resolution, when that could possibly be?
00:34:02
Speaker 2: There isn't because courts move at their speed no matter what we want, but we are hopeful that we will get a decision on the Hawaii case relatively soon because the hearing was last month. In the Montana and Michigan cases, they are probably sort of accelerated as well, even though they just filed, because that law takes effect on January 1st, and if there's going to be an injunction, you kind of expect that it would happen before then.
00:34:30
Speaker 1: We have only a couple of minutes remaining. Unfair question. But with occupational licensing restrictions, why are they imposed?
00:34:42
Speaker 2: Usually out of a combination of safetyism, you know, we can protect everyone from every possible problem. And protectionism, let's also protect the people who work here from people who would come from other places, you know. There are good sides to that. You do want a licensed contractor putting together electrical wild work, but do you really care if that contractor got his license in Hawaii or California? And that's one of the things that Hawaii should look at because Hawaii has such restrictive licensing that we are running out of people, not just doctors, which everyone knows about, but just across the board, things like elevator maintenance mechanics. and electricians and all those kinds of things, we could make it easier to get more just by being more accepting of licenses from other states. Do you really need your elevator mechanic to get your license in Hawaii? Can you accept an elevator mechanic from New York? And I think you can, especially if it means that your elevator actually works, especially after a natural disaster.
00:35:55
Speaker 1: It's the final commentary, just very quickly. It's just the desire, and I used the word subject previously under a socialist type of regime, is that we become subjects. The government knows every single thing for our lives, what we need, the quality that we require, the controls that have to be placed on us because we simply can't do it ourselves without And they need to preserve us in order to take everything from us, including freedoms. And it gets a little frustrating.
00:36:34
Speaker 2: It really does. I think people would be shocked if they knew how much the government reaches into just the tiny little pieces of your life and affects them that way.
00:36:44
Speaker 1: Malia, I love getting together. I really appreciate you taking the time.