TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:25.359 --> 00:00:28.800
Welcome to another episode of the Restless Theologian Podcast.
00:00:28.800 --> 00:00:32.640
Today we're going to be talking about the doctrine of original sin.
00:00:32.640 --> 00:00:42.320
We're going to be taking a look at a little bit of the perspective of the Orthodox Church, the Roman Catholic Church, and the Reformed Church.
00:00:42.320 --> 00:00:49.200
So we're probably going to primarily focus on the Reformed understanding of it, but we're going to kind of compare and contrast some of the other views.
00:00:49.200 --> 00:00:56.479
And so we're going to be diving deep into the will and a little bit of the understanding of that and the fall of man.
00:00:56.479 --> 00:01:00.240
And today I have back on with me my guest, Corey Rechner.
00:01:00.240 --> 00:01:01.200
How are you doing, Corey?
00:01:01.200 --> 00:01:02.159
Pretty good.
00:01:02.159 --> 00:01:03.119
How are you, Zach?
00:01:03.119 --> 00:01:04.000
Good, good.
00:01:04.000 --> 00:01:05.200
I appreciate you coming back on.
00:01:05.519 --> 00:01:05.840
Yep.
00:01:05.840 --> 00:01:07.439
Anytime, man, I love doing this.
00:01:07.439 --> 00:01:17.120
It's a pretty popular topic that I don't ever really remember talking to anybody about it, even though that's the case, you know.
00:01:17.359 --> 00:01:17.680
Yeah.
00:01:17.680 --> 00:01:27.680
Coming from a Calvinist perspective, I you know, I talk about total depravity, but understanding it in relation to what original sin is, it's, you know, obviously it's a little bit more complex.
00:01:27.680 --> 00:01:33.680
But so I want to start off with um just kind of giving a definition of original sin.
00:01:33.680 --> 00:01:41.599
And obviously these can be very complex depending on what you read, and also dependent on what tradition you're coming from.
00:01:41.599 --> 00:01:51.120
But just for our purposes, the doctrine of original sin is basically the state and guilt into which all human beings are born because of Adam's first sin.
00:01:51.120 --> 00:01:56.239
It includes both corruption of nature and liability to judgment.
00:01:56.239 --> 00:02:03.680
In Reformed theology, this is expressed through the imputation of Adam's guilt and the total depravity of man.
00:02:03.680 --> 00:02:21.280
I did find it very fascinating to uh compare and contrast just the traditions because, and I thought it was worth including the Eastern Church on this just because I think it sheds light into the issue.
00:02:21.280 --> 00:02:29.199
Sometimes looking at a comparative or like a comparing an alternate view kind of makes you think about questions within your own view.
00:02:29.199 --> 00:02:34.879
And um, I also think too, orthodoxy definitely seems to be the big thing right now.
00:02:34.879 --> 00:02:43.439
Like I definitely feel like there's a lot more in the West, because obviously it's predominantly more common in you know the East.
00:02:43.439 --> 00:02:49.039
But I feel like it's been um kind of gaining
Load full transcript
quite a bit of ground in the West as well.
00:02:49.039 --> 00:03:05.439
So I figured I figured I, you know, I don't know if you I don't know how you feel about this, but I feel like Protestants, I mean, and Catholics, they've been so busy arguing with each other, and then you know, they here you have the Orthodox coming out of left field and then kind of injected into the conversation as well.
00:03:05.439 --> 00:03:22.000
Not that they shouldn't be, I'm just saying that, you know, we don't really when you watch debates online, it's usually gonna be between either people of different Protestant traditions or Roman Catholic versus Protestant, stuff like that, but the East doesn't get engaged with as much as well.
00:03:22.000 --> 00:03:29.680
So I feel like as being in the West, I feel like a lot of Western Christians can be maybe put at a disadvantage because they don't know a lot about it.
00:03:29.680 --> 00:03:36.000
And so I'm trying to learn more about it and try to figure out um their understanding of the will and everything.
00:03:36.080 --> 00:04:07.919
So yeah, it seems like a healthy inclusion to have people of other sides of the world, especially to bring what they believe into the conversation so that we can all kind of, like you said, kind of re-examine what it is that we truly believe, go over it again, maybe reevaluate some of the things that somebody else does, and you know, kind of come back and just I don't want to say make more conclusions or better conclusions or different conclusions, but just kind of like you said, just reevaluate the whole at large.
00:04:08.319 --> 00:04:08.639
Yeah.
00:04:08.639 --> 00:04:09.759
Yeah, for sure.
00:04:09.759 --> 00:04:21.439
So one of the interesting things that I've come to kind of learn is um trying to differentiate between like the will that we have and um concupiscence.
00:04:21.439 --> 00:04:25.120
Concupiscence isn't a word that we use very often in today's society.
00:04:25.120 --> 00:04:30.959
Concupiscence, from what I understand, it's basically disordered desire or evil desire.
00:04:30.959 --> 00:04:35.120
Um, this was definitely something that Augustine talked about.
00:04:35.120 --> 00:04:38.000
You know, one of my previous guests, he he D.P.
00:04:38.000 --> 00:04:41.759
Curtin actually brought this up when we were talking about Eastern Orthodoxy.
00:04:41.759 --> 00:04:53.839
He had mentioned that Augustine for them is almost the true source of all heterodoxy, meaning that like a lot of Western air really stems from him.
00:04:53.839 --> 00:05:00.959
And I thought that that was really fascinating to think about because if you look at the Reformed's position, and if B.
00:05:00.959 --> 00:05:01.199
V.
00:05:01.199 --> 00:05:17.519
Warfield is correct, and I think he is, that the Reformation is nothing other than Augustinianism, it makes sense why the Reformed in particular are gonna have a lot of disagreements with the East, probably even more so than Roman Catholicism.
00:05:17.519 --> 00:05:31.759
So in thinking about this too, with the understanding of the will, from what I gather is that here you have with Roman Catholicism expressed in the Council of Trent that man is spiritually weakened.
00:05:31.759 --> 00:05:35.680
And um the Orthodox also hold that view.
00:05:35.680 --> 00:05:40.879
Um, the Reformed view would be that man is dead, spiritually dead.
00:05:40.879 --> 00:05:44.480
So they're kind of an outlier out of those three groups.
00:05:44.480 --> 00:06:00.000
Um and then, but I would say where the Rome and the East definitely differ is they believe they don't really use the term original sin very much because it's almost an Augustinian invention to them, but they use ancestral sin.
00:06:00.000 --> 00:06:03.360
Have you looked into that at all, or what's your understanding of it?
00:06:03.839 --> 00:06:07.279
You're saying from the Eastern Orthodox.
00:06:07.600 --> 00:06:10.079
Yeah, about ancestral sin and what that means.
00:06:11.360 --> 00:06:13.199
So yes.
00:06:13.199 --> 00:06:20.079
And it's funny because sometimes I get all of these views kind of mixed together.
00:06:20.079 --> 00:06:20.560
Yeah.
00:06:20.560 --> 00:06:23.759
Um you know, the Eastern Orthodox view.
00:06:23.759 --> 00:06:30.079
I feel like in my own experience, I feel like I might have heard a little bit more of that than the other two views.
00:06:30.079 --> 00:06:52.000
So and I'm not Eastern Orthodox, but I feel like just generally speaking, if you were to talk to, you know, most people out there, just in general, maybe bring up some type of ancestral quality or trait or something, you know, the idea of like a sinful tie to all of that would be probably pretty normal for most people, meaning like that's how they would view it.
00:06:52.000 --> 00:07:03.920
So they would say, oh, he's like this because his dad was like this, or you know, um, he's a a thief or a swindler because his father was like that, or his mother was like that, right?
00:07:03.920 --> 00:07:07.360
So it's tied very much into like a biological view of it.
00:07:07.839 --> 00:07:10.319
Well, either biological or maybe imitation.
00:07:10.319 --> 00:07:26.000
Um because that sure that I think was really what Augustine was arguing against with the Pelagians, is that when man fell, other men that are born, like they don't inherit Adam's sin or guilt.
00:07:26.000 --> 00:07:31.439
Like none of that is in none of that is transferred to them in any way or imputed to them in any way.
00:07:31.439 --> 00:07:35.360
And basically, they learn through bad imitation.
00:07:35.360 --> 00:07:36.639
You know what I mean?
00:07:36.639 --> 00:07:39.759
So they sin because they see Adam's example of sinning.
00:07:39.759 --> 00:07:50.639
People learn through imitation and that like but the issue is is like through Adam's disobedience, even though he was disobedient, like he may not have committed murder or adultery.
00:07:50.639 --> 00:07:56.959
So it's like, how do
you explain those particular sins being learned through if it's really truly learned through imitation?
00:07:57.199 --> 00:07:58.959
Right, because they're not imitating him doing it.
00:07:59.199 --> 00:08:00.879
No, yeah, yep.
00:08:00.879 --> 00:08:03.759
I thought that that was kind of interesting to think about.
00:08:03.759 --> 00:08:08.879
But the reforms view, there was something that got brought up.
00:08:08.879 --> 00:08:24.160
So I watched a couple videos from um, well, more than a couple, but um, from the Eastern Orthodox, and I was wanting to hear what they had to say about not only original sin, but um their reasoning for baptizing babies, right?
00:08:24.160 --> 00:08:33.519
Because in like the Roman system, they believe in baptismal regeneration, and they also believe that baptism itself removes original sin.
00:08:33.519 --> 00:08:48.080
So since they don't have a concept of original sin like the like the West does, you know, they hold to more of it like as being an entry into the church, um, giving of the Holy Spirit, you know, also for sanctification.
00:08:48.080 --> 00:09:00.720
So they kind of go that that route rather than it removing original sin, which was one of the reasons that Augustine argues against the pol against the Pelagians.
00:09:00.720 --> 00:09:10.399
He's saying the reason we baptize babies is to remove original sin, and that babies that are unbaptized who die, basically they they go to hell.
00:09:10.399 --> 00:09:18.080
And obviously, Rome's stance on that now is a little bit different because obviously they don't know they don't side with Augustine on that.
00:09:18.080 --> 00:09:22.480
They believe it's a little bit more of like maybe limbo is probably what they would believe.
00:09:22.480 --> 00:09:24.559
Um, because it sounds harsh, right?
00:09:24.559 --> 00:09:29.360
Like thinking of babies that haven't committed any actual sin going to hell.
00:09:29.679 --> 00:09:30.720
Because of original sin.
00:09:30.720 --> 00:09:32.240
Because of original sin.
00:09:33.120 --> 00:09:44.559
But then again, it's like if so, how is so from the videos it sounds like the East accuses Augustine and the West in general of is Traducianism.
00:09:44.559 --> 00:09:49.919
Traducianism teaches that both the soul and body are derived from the parents.
00:09:49.919 --> 00:09:53.840
This view is found in Tertullian and later in Augustine.
00:09:53.840 --> 00:10:01.759
It suggests that the human soul, like the body, is propagated naturally, and thus sin is transmitted along with human nature.
00:10:01.759 --> 00:10:07.519
Augustine leaned towards this explanation because it appeared to support the doctrine of original sin.
00:10:07.519 --> 00:10:13.200
If all humans were an Adam, then the corruption of his nature was shared by all.
00:10:13.200 --> 00:10:22.720
Obviously, the Eastern Church rejects Traducianism, and the more I researched it, it doesn't sound like that he followed Traducianism closely.
00:10:22.720 --> 00:10:27.759
He cautiously used some of the reasoning and ideology of it.
00:10:27.759 --> 00:10:31.600
So have you heard about Traducianism before?
00:10:32.000 --> 00:10:43.600
It's funny because I do remember having a few conversations many years ago with a couple of friends about the concept of Traducianism, but I never knew that there was a title for it, right?
00:10:44.000 --> 00:10:47.919
Okay, so it's like you were discussing the idea of it without even knowing what it's formally called.
00:10:47.919 --> 00:10:48.720
Exactly.
00:10:48.879 --> 00:10:51.279
Like when is the soul made?
00:10:51.279 --> 00:10:53.600
Like when's the soul created, you know?
00:10:53.600 --> 00:11:09.759
And yeah, it it's something, you know, in preparing for this with you, I came across that term, and I'm like, it's so funny because sometimes you don't even realize that there are labels already given to some of these concepts until you go looking for that means.
00:11:09.919 --> 00:11:11.519
Yeah, you're like the heresy I'm thinking about.
00:11:11.519 --> 00:11:13.759
There's already there's gotta be a name for it.
00:11:14.000 --> 00:11:14.879
Oh, there we go.
00:11:14.879 --> 00:11:16.480
Yeah, that's what it's called.
00:11:16.480 --> 00:11:17.279
Okay, yeah.
00:11:17.279 --> 00:11:21.679
No, but I knew my error wasn't just theoretical, it's actually been practicalized before.
00:11:21.679 --> 00:11:22.799
Yeah, yeah.
00:11:24.000 --> 00:11:25.759
No, I I get I get what you're saying, though.
00:11:25.759 --> 00:11:44.080
It's like I I've had that experience before where it's just kind of like you stumble across, you're like, I know there's gotta be someone's got had a have thought through this before and come up to a similar, like not that you were supporting the idea, but just questioning how the soul is made and when it's made.
00:11:44.080 --> 00:11:56.240
Um and then I mean you have some people actually, I think there was one early church father who believed in it, might it might have been Origin or Tertullian, I think it might have been origin that believed in like the preexistence of souls, yeah.
00:11:56.240 --> 00:12:00.559
Um, which is really weird because I think that that might be something more of a Mormon.
00:12:00.559 --> 00:12:09.360
Uh I think Mormons actually kind of believed that, but it from what I can tell, it looks like Tertullian and Ambrosiaster were the ones that leaned towards Trinusianism.
00:12:09.360 --> 00:12:24.240
And Augustine took some of Ambrosiaster's um writings, and that's where they think that he got that kind of idea in his head about um because it's like how how literal do you want to take it, right?
00:12:24.240 --> 00:12:43.519
Because you know, I think I came across something in the book where they were talking about some people that maybe held to, since Adam is the father of all, um biologically, so since we were in his loins, that like that we participated in the act of disobedience along with him.
00:12:43.519
--> 00:13:00.799
And obviously that's an extreme view, but I mean, as far as I can tell, I don't think that um formally, I I mean, I don't think any Roman Catholics, uh, Protestants or Orthodox believe that now, but I know that that was like a discussion that was kind of on the table.
00:13:00.799 --> 00:13:12.879
Um, so yeah, it it contrasting the East, though, it's like they believe in that physical death came to man and that like we inherit corruption.
00:13:12.879 --> 00:13:17.120
And obviously we're but we're only guilty, I think, of actual sin.
00:13:17.120 --> 00:13:19.600
We're not guilty of Adam's sin.
00:13:19.600 --> 00:13:27.919
And I thought that that was it's kind of crazy to think about because when you're in the West, you don't really I mean that's not something that we really ponder on, right?
00:13:27.919 --> 00:13:30.960
Like it's just automatically a given that original sin.
00:13:30.960 --> 00:13:38.639
It you see how it affects both Protestantism and Roman Catholicism, which which are both Western uh churches, you know.
00:13:38.879 --> 00:13:40.000
Yeah, yeah, for sure.
00:13:40.000 --> 00:13:59.360
Yeah, I feel like uh even just in our day-to-day, um, you know, if we think about why we do some of the things we do, we usually just relate it directly to our parents rather than necessarily like, oh, theologically speaking, it's because of our inherited sin, you know?
00:13:59.600 --> 00:14:00.080
Yeah.
00:14:00.320 --> 00:14:02.000
So yeah, that makes more sense.
00:14:02.399 --> 00:14:28.480
Yeah, and one of the arguments that the East I I noticed was kind of a repeated pattern when I'd watched the videos, is that it sounds like they follow a little bit more after John Chrysostome, who thought it was a ridiculous notion that God would punish someone for the sins of another, or that it's unjust to make the son pay for the sins of the father.
00:14:28.480 --> 00:14:34.559
And literally they they just thought it was absurd and that God is unjust.
00:14:34.559 --> 00:14:41.919
And I I actually have a lot to say about that just because I it didn't sit well with me.
00:14:41.919 --> 00:14:47.360
And the reason is is because corporate guilt is a real thing in scripture.
00:14:47.360 --> 00:14:51.600
And so this is Exodus 20, verse 5.
00:14:51.600 --> 00:15:04.000
So it says, You shall not bow down to them or serve them, for I the Lord your your God am a jealous God, visiting the iniquity of the fathers on the children to the third and fourth generation of those who hate me.
00:15:04.000 --> 00:15:13.120
And then and to really highlight this, and just to show you it's not clearly just an old testament thing that was a fluke.
00:15:13.120 --> 00:15:17.440
So this is in Matthew 23, when Jesus is given the seven woes.
00:15:17.440 --> 00:15:32.480
So verse 29 it says, Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites, for you build the tombs of the prophets and decorate the monuments of the righteous, saying, If we lived in the days of our
fathers, we would not have taken part with them in shedding the blood of the prophets.
00:15:32.480 --> 00:15:37.039
Thus you witness against yourselves that you are the sons of those who murdered the prophets.
00:15:37.039 --> 00:15:44.480
Fill up then the measure of your fathers, you serpents, you brood of vipers, how are you to escape being sentenced to hell?
00:15:44.480 --> 00:15:55.600
Therefore I send you prophets and wise men and scribes, some of you whom you will kill and crucify, and some of them you will flog in your synagogues, and persecute from town to town.
00:15:55.600 --> 00:15:56.639
Why?
00:15:56.639 --> 00:16:07.759
He says, So that on you may come all the righteous blood shed on the earth, from the blood of righteous Abel to the blood of Zachariah, son of Barekiah, whom you murdered between the sanctuary and the altar.
00:16:07.759 --> 00:16:12.159
Truly I say to you, all of these things will come upon this generation.
00:16:12.159 --> 00:16:24.080
I I mean, when I read through that and read it again, it's mind-blowing to me because here it almost seems that Christ is saying the culmination of all of God's wrath.
00:16:24.080 --> 00:16:34.480
And he goes, You know, you guys admit that you were the sons of those who murdered the prophets, and he said you testify against yourselves that you were the sons of who did that.
00:16:34.480 --> 00:16:43.440
And he says, you know, it's like because of this, all the righteous blood, you know, even before they were born, is going to be counted against them.
00:16:43.440 --> 00:17:00.240
And I'm like, where is the Eastern defense on the idea that God is unjust to declare any sort of punishment on the sons like ancestrally?
00:17:00.240 --> 00:17:06.559
Like I to me, it's like it's such a biblical idea that there is such a thing as corporate guilt.
00:17:06.559 --> 00:17:19.359
And um, even recently I was thinking about um this is completely a side note, but I thought it was kind of relevant to bring up just because I was kind of reading more about the Salem Witch trials and everything.
00:17:19.359 --> 00:17:19.680
Uh-huh.
00:17:19.680 --> 00:17:26.880
And it's kind of like it's just a crazy um incident that happened, and you're just kind of like, well, why did this happen?
00:17:26.880 --> 00:17:28.799
Why did this mass hysteria happen?
00:17:28.799 --> 00:17:32.000
And um, you know, obviously it was a terrible thing that happened.
00:17:32.000 --> 00:17:43.680
And um, well, one of the reasons was was because now obviously Hollywood and other books overdraumatize everything, and and you know, no one was burned at the stake.
00:17:43.680 --> 00:17:45.359
Obviously, that's a misconception.
00:17:45.359 --> 00:17:46.559
People were hung.
00:17:46.559 --> 00:17:51.599
From what I can tell, it sounds like 20 people were total in total were executed.
00:17:51.599 --> 00:17:55.119
So, which is far different from Europe.
00:17:55.119 --> 00:18:03.200
It sounds like I think between 40 and 60,000
people were actually um killed during like the hysteria over you know, witches.
00:18:03.200 --> 00:18:16.720
Um, so it's like if you look in comparison between America and Europe, obviously it's far more minimized, or not minimized, but far to far lesser degree, I guess.
00:18:16.720 --> 00:18:23.920
Um, not to downplay the sadness or terribleness that happened, but basically the point I'm getting at is why did they do that?
00:18:23.920 --> 00:18:26.319
Well, it's because they believed in corporate guilt.
00:18:26.319 --> 00:18:33.200
They believed that if there was witches among them, that God wouldn't just punish those witches, he would punish them all.
00:18:33.200 --> 00:18:43.920
And that led them to do what they you know what I mean, to panic and um unjustly uh execute people.
00:18:44.319 --> 00:18:51.359
Yeah, it it makes me also think of the um Exodus story uh with the firstborn right in Egypt.
00:18:51.359 --> 00:18:51.920
Yeah.
00:18:52.079 --> 00:18:54.559
Where I didn't even think of that, but that's a great, great point.
00:18:54.799 --> 00:19:05.599
Yeah, where God, you know, pretty much sends death upon all the firstborn in Egypt just because Pharaoh wouldn't submit to what God wanted.
00:19:05.920 --> 00:19:18.880
And not only that, but Pharaoh uh uh it would have been his father, did the same thing when Moses was born because remember he had the firstborn males killed because of the prophecy.
00:19:18.880 --> 00:19:19.440
Right, right.
00:19:19.440 --> 00:19:22.079
And then so it's like talk about an eye for an eye situation.
00:19:22.400 --> 00:19:22.880
Yeah, yeah.
00:19:22.880 --> 00:19:24.240
It's like revenge, you know?
00:19:24.240 --> 00:19:25.759
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:19:26.319 --> 00:19:26.640
Yeah.
00:19:26.640 --> 00:19:33.440
Well, I mean, scripture does say vengeance is mine, and that's clearly expressed in that story.
00:19:33.440 --> 00:19:46.960
And and I also too wanted to you have to be careful to sit there and say, Oh, God would be an unjust judge if he did this, and then it's like, but what if he did do this, and then now you're subjecting God to your judgment?
00:19:46.960 --> 00:19:50.000
And I don't think that that's really a situation you want to be in.
00:19:50.079 --> 00:19:51.119
But yeah.
00:19:51.119 --> 00:19:54.880
Yeah, you deny what God is actually capable of.
00:19:55.359 --> 00:20:05.200
Yeah, so if Traducianism doesn't like since things don't really work that way, obviously, as in the reformed world, we don't believe in Traducianism.
00:20:05.200 --> 00:20:14.319
So, how is Adam's sin uh like how are we guilty or how do we bear the guilt of Adam's sin?
00:20:14.319 --> 00:20:22.000
So it's like not only do we lose original righteousness, original justice, um, loss of the spirit, physical death comes.
00:20:22.000 --> 00:20:30.480
And obviously in the Reformed view, we also believe that spiritual death comes because it says, you know, you were dead in your trespasses and sins.
00:20:30.480 -->
00:20:36.000
When we think about this, like how does Adam's sin actually like how do we bear the guilt of that?
00:20:36.000 --> 00:20:39.759
How are we in any way guilty or bear the guilt?
00:20:39.759 --> 00:20:42.160
I guess it's through imputation.
00:20:42.160 --> 00:20:54.400
Imputation is since Adam's the federal head, the representative head of humanity, then it would make sense that his sin is is uh imputed to us.
00:20:54.400 --> 00:21:00.079
Like we don't we don't it doesn't um transmit genetically by DNA.
00:21:00.079 --> 00:21:07.279
Obviously Rome believes in imputation, you know, they believe that we uh Adam's sin is imputed to us.
00:21:07.279 --> 00:21:09.279
I mean the concept of original sin.
00:21:09.279 --> 00:21:21.759
And the thing is, is um but they uh also don't believe in imputed righteousness, they believe in infused righteousness, you know, infused into the soul during baptism.
00:21:21.759 --> 00:21:26.960
Where in the Reformed view, uh Christ's righteousness is imputed to us.
00:21:26.960 --> 00:21:36.720
And I think it just kind of makes sense because if he's our federal head, and then so so it's like uh with Adam it's disobedience and imputed original sin.
00:21:36.720 --> 00:21:40.880
With Christ, it's his obedience and his imputed righteousness.
00:21:40.880 --> 00:21:49.839
Do you think that that's a fair I know it's kind of a little bit more of a high level kind of generalization, but what do you what are your thoughts on it?
00:21:50.240 --> 00:21:56.319
You mean what do I think about just imputation compared to like an infusion? That view?
00:21:56.519 --> 00:22:04.000
Or just what do you think about um imputation of Adam's original sin versus imputation of Christ's righteousness.
00:22:04.000 --> 00:22:06.960
Like, do you think that that is the biblical view and your perspective?
00:22:07.839 --> 00:22:09.119
So, all right.
00:22:09.119 --> 00:22:14.319
Let me try to sum up what I'm thinking because that is a really good question.
00:22:14.319 --> 00:22:26.240
Um overall, and I don't want to like jump ahead here because I'm not sure if you'd like to discuss some of these points in any more detail before or you know You're totally fine.
00:22:26.240 --> 00:22:28.640
So okay, so I'll just riff here a little bit.
00:22:28.640 --> 00:22:47.680
So um I do think there is teaching in scripture where we get you know just the general picture that Adam is like the representative of humanity, right?
00:22:47.680 --> 00:22:48.400
Right.
00:22:48.400 --> 00:23:07.680
And then we have Christ, who because of everything he's done, and how he even said he came to seek and save that which was lost, and you know, we have the crucifixion, we have the resurrection, and then we have the gift of the Holy Spirit given to all of us.
00:23:07.680 --> 00:23:14.799
I do believe that Christ brought about a different, like you said, headship, right?
00:23:14.799 --> 00:23:20.160
Yeah, a different leadership, a different uh covenant, so to speak.
00:23:20.160 --> 00:23:26.480
And because of that, there is a new representation that's available now, right, to people.
00:23:26.480 --> 00:23:27.119
Yeah.
00:23:27.119 --> 00:23:43.759
But what I think the Bible definitely teaches is that there are still people who are in the bracket or the category or the headship of Adam still, but then there are also people who are now under the leadership of Christ, right?
00:23:43.759 --> 00:23:45.759
He's the f like you said, the federal head, right?
00:23:45.759 --> 00:23:46.319
Right.
00:23:46.319 --> 00:23:50.559
So I do think that that is very well taught in the Bible.
00:23:50.559 --> 00:23:56.079
Paul talks about that in multiple occasions um in Romans, right?
00:23:56.079 --> 00:23:57.039
Yeah.
00:23:57.039 --> 00:24:19.839
And like you'd mentioned, the pat uh the passage in Matthew, where Jesus was confronting religious leaders and Pharisees, saying, Because of these previous generations, you could pretty much be, you know, bracketed with this old group, which is in the bracket of Adam, where you'd consider that group to be the sinful group, right?
00:24:19.839 --> 00:24:21.920
The group that's stuck in sin, you know.
00:24:21.920 --> 00:24:22.480
Yeah.
00:24:22.480 --> 00:24:36.319
So I do think, yes, I think that scripture definitely teaches there are two different options here for people to be in, and you're either going to be in the the under the headship of Adam or the headship of Christ.
00:24:36.319 --> 00:24:40.079
I think that that is like the big takeaway from those teachings.
00:24:40.079 --> 00:24:42.319
Um and there's no other alternatives.
00:24:42.319 --> 00:24:43.359
Pretty much, right?
00:24:43.359 --> 00:24:50.079
Like it's he's not like saying, like, oh no, but there's a third category, which is kind of like you said earlier, like in limbo or something, right?
00:24:50.079 --> 00:24:55.839
I don't think we're really given that option at all based off of what scripture teaches.
00:24:55.839 --> 00:25:00.400
Now getting more detailed about that is where it gets tricky, in my opinion.
00:25:00.400 --> 00:25:09.119
Um, because you'd mentioned the Augustinian or perhaps the cow the Catholic view, the Eastern Orthodox view, and then what was the other one?
00:25:09.119 --> 00:25:10.720
Oh, the Reformed view, right?
00:25:10.720 --> 00:25:11.519
Yeah.
00:25:11.519 --> 00:25:19.119
So I don't know if you wanted to go into any more detail about any one of those first, or what what you'd like to do.
00:25:19.119 --> 00:25:20.559
Like, should we just keep going?
00:25:21.039 --> 00:25:30.799
Well, I guess I can kind of give like a brief summary of like because the understanding of the will and then concupiscence is another aspect.
00:25:30.799 --> 00:25:38.240
Um so the Council of Trent declared that basically Adam's sin is transmitted to all by propagation, not imitation.
00:25:38.240 --> 00:25:45.200
So as Protestants, we we'd agree with that, that it's not imitation like the
Plagians you know declared.
00:25:45.599 --> 00:25:47.119
So and let's pause there for one second.
00:25:47.119 --> 00:25:49.839
So you're saying and and what group is that?
00:25:49.839 --> 00:25:51.119
The Roman Roman Catholics.
00:25:51.359 --> 00:26:04.720
So the Roman Catholic view in the Council of Trent, at least this part portion of it, they rejected the idea that sin is transmit, not transmitted, but um they rejected the idea that sin is learned through imitation and it's not transmitted.
00:26:05.039 --> 00:26:19.680
So it's kind of like they're not um let's put it a little bit more um, you know, kind of proverbially, where they're denying the fact that you can just watch somebody sin and therefore that's what causes you to sin.
00:26:19.680 --> 00:26:21.920
They're saying it it runs deeper than that.
00:26:21.920 --> 00:26:24.799
It's actually through like like bloodline, right?
00:26:25.279 --> 00:26:29.119
Well, not through bloodline, but through That's more of the Eastern Orthodox view.
00:26:29.119 --> 00:26:30.720
Well the bloodline?
00:26:30.720 --> 00:26:37.680
No, it's actually see, they don't believe um, they call it ancestral sin, but we do not inherit ancestral sin.
00:26:37.680 --> 00:26:45.839
So it's like if you kind of use the term ancestral sin in lieu of original sin, because it's basically their version of it.
00:26:45.839 --> 00:26:53.599
From what I gather is that so original sin is not um transmitted, it's not imputed.
00:26:53.599 --> 00:26:57.680
We do not bear any guilt for anything that Adam did.
00:26:57.680 --> 00:27:02.160
The only thing that we inherit is the state of corruption and death.
00:27:02.160 --> 00:27:05.759
Okay, and um sin reigns because death reigns.
00:27:05.759 --> 00:27:13.200
So it you know, I found it repeatedly that the idea that they think that we sin because death exists.
00:27:13.200 --> 00:27:28.640
Where it's like almost like in I could be misunderstanding it, but one of the things I'm not sure what nuance they're they're using or how how they're nuancing that, but basically, obviously death exists because of sin, not the other way around.
00:27:28.640 --> 00:27:29.680
You know what I mean?
00:27:29.680 --> 00:27:35.680
Like we don't sin because death reigns, we are sinners, therefore death reigns.
00:27:35.680 --> 00:27:36.319
You know what I mean?
00:27:36.319 --> 00:27:38.559
Like death is a consequence of sin.
00:27:38.559 --> 00:27:56.480
So much so that I think that that is why, in my opinion, that you would have to have someone like um like like Mary in the the Roman Catholic perspective, um, you can't say that she died of natural old age.
00:27:56.480 --> 00:28:01.599
The reason why you can't say that is because, well, she had no sin.
00:28:01.599 --> 00:28:17.680
If she is sinless, therefore, I mean, other other than like maybe I I mean, I don't know how far deep down this rabbit hole, you know, we can go, but basically, you know, you would be immortal because death is a consequence of sin.
00:28:17.680 --> 00:28:18.079
Right.
00:28:18.079 --> 00:28:25.119
So I think that that is why they have to have a category of, oh, well, she was um assumed into heaven.
00:28:25.119 --> 00:28:28.079
So that's why the assumption became a thing.
00:28:28.079 --> 00:28:33.839
Now, like the assumption to Mary, like I don't think there's any biblical evidence for it.
00:28:33.839 --> 00:28:38.079
Like, I mean, we can I mean, I know Mary's a separate side issue.
00:28:38.079 --> 00:28:44.000
I'm just making the point that like the idea of sin obviously brings about death.
00:28:44.000 --> 00:28:56.559
Now, what I did find really interesting is that, um, and I have known this, was with the Council of Trent, it it does seem to reject a lot of Augustinian views.
00:28:56.559 --> 00:29:00.319
And the Council of Trent believes that man is spiritually wounded.
00:29:00.559 --> 00:29:00.880
Okay.
00:29:01.200 --> 00:29:02.720
And the East agrees with that.
00:29:02.720 --> 00:29:04.480
Man is spiritually wounded from the fall.
00:29:04.480 --> 00:29:07.519
Like they both are in agreement, and at least on that point.
00:29:07.519 --> 00:29:16.640
But the difference is is with while Rome believes that we inherit corruption, loss of original justice, righteousness, all of that.
00:29:16.640 --> 00:29:24.880
Um, but you know, obviously the original sin is transferred to his offspring.
00:29:24.880 --> 00:29:32.640
But with obviously the East, think of it like, yeah, that there's the loss of all that stuff, but Adam's sin isn't.
00:29:32.640 --> 00:29:33.839
We're not guilty of that.
00:29:33.839 --> 00:29:37.680
We don't bear any that that that can't be on us.
00:29:38.000 --> 00:29:42.160
It's kind of like you you are responsible for you and you alone.
00:29:42.160 --> 00:29:42.640
Right.
00:29:42.640 --> 00:29:43.279
Yeah, yeah.
00:29:43.519 --> 00:29:53.440
Yeah, because they they follow after Chrysostome, like I said, who thought it would be ridiculous for one person to be responsible or guilty of someone else's sin.
00:29:53.440 --> 00:29:55.599
So that would make that would make sense.
00:29:55.599 --> 00:30:02.799
But I I believe that Augustine's view, in my opinion, is the far more biblical view, biblical understanding.
00:30:02.799 --> 00:30:03.440
Okay.
00:30:03.440 --> 00:30:04.079
Yeah.
00:30:04.400 --> 00:30:05.119
Gotcha.
00:30:05.440 --> 00:30:07.440
Because it's all about how do we explain this?
00:30:07.440 --> 00:30:12.559
How is how is sin transmitted or imputed or in the West?
00:30:12.559 --> 00:30:13.920
We have to explain that.
00:30:13.920 --> 00:30:14.319
Yeah.
00:30:18.240 --> 00:30:18.559
Yeah.
00:30:18.559 --> 00:30:21.920
So this is such a challenging subject.
00:30:21.920 --> 00:30:23.759
I um You want to leave.
00:30:23.759 --> 00:30:24.720
I'll see you later.
00:30:24.720 --> 00:30:25.680
I'm gonna get out of here.
00:30:25.680 --> 00:30:25.920
Yeah.
00:30:25.920 --> 00:30:28.720
Thanks for bringing this up,
but I'm gonna go not sleep tonight.
00:30:28.720 --> 00:30:38.480
Um no, so I've heard a really interesting, almost kind of a like a proposition relating to this subject too.
00:30:38.480 --> 00:30:45.839
And that is okay, let's say original sin is imputed to us, right?
00:30:45.839 --> 00:30:52.720
It's not just uh each person's responsible only for their own sin, they're also responsible just for sin in general, right?
00:30:52.720 --> 00:30:59.440
So, um, and it almost ties back into the idea that you mentioned earlier about like traducianism, right?
00:30:59.440 --> 00:31:01.680
Like when is the soul created, right?
00:31:01.680 --> 00:31:02.079
Yeah.
00:31:02.079 --> 00:31:21.519
And I don't want to like go off the tracks here with where we're heading in the conversation, but to me it seems kind of relevant because it is still tied to this idea of you know what you're born into and what you're you know inheriting as you're born, and whether or not with your soul, that is a part of that as well, right?
00:31:21.519 --> 00:31:27.279
Meaning like whenever your soul is made, right?
00:31:27.279 --> 00:31:27.839
Yeah.
00:31:27.839 --> 00:31:38.160
Whenever that is, um are you born with that original sin almost like imprinted into your soul, you know?
00:31:39.200 --> 00:31:41.519
Yeah, I would I would say I would say yes.
00:31:41.519 --> 00:32:30.799
Um because so like as far as I know, that I'm the East, Rome, and the Reformed, they would all agree that um you know, because that none of them are Traducian, so they don't believe that the soul like pre-existed or that or that the soul in some way was um handed down from Adam, like actual literal souls, like as in D DNA, like his not only his biological DNA, but his actual think of a DNA storehouse for souls, just amassed in him, like he he holds all of that bank of souls within him, and then it you know, down the line of propagation, you know, those souls are delved out in whatever mysterious way you you think of.
00:32:30.799 --> 00:32:39.680
But so they all agree that you know basically I think it's at conception that God is the one who like creates the soul.
00:32:39.680 --> 00:32:41.279
You know what I mean?
00:32:41.279 --> 00:32:45.359
Like he creates the soul then and like a creationist act, yeah.
00:32:45.359 --> 00:32:52.079
Um, so it's not like a soul is passed down or like as if it's some sort of seed that can be passed down.
00:32:52.400 --> 00:32:53.920
Yeah, so and that's good.
00:32:53.920 --> 00:33:00.160
So I've heard there there are like three descriptions I've heard of that soul creation.
00:33:00.160 --> 00:33:05.359
The first one is the pre-existent soul created, right?
00:33:05.359 --> 00:33:10.720
Like you said, like maybe in the case of this, you know, being tied to Adam, like you said, our souls were created when Adam was created.
00:33:10.720 --> 00:33:11.119
Yeah.
00:33:11.119 --> 00:33:13.200
Or before that, even, you know.
00:33:13.200 --> 00:33:25.839
Uh the next one
is what is, I guess, titled um creationism, and it's not like the creationism from like the book of Genesis, right, where God created everything.
00:33:25.839 --> 00:33:30.640
It's more just like He creates your soul at the time of birth.
00:33:30.640 --> 00:33:38.240
And then there's that third one, and that's that traducianism, where your parents are the ones that pretty much give you the soul.
00:33:38.240 --> 00:33:38.640
Yeah.
00:33:38.640 --> 00:33:42.319
Like you're born from your parents, so they not only the father in particular, yeah.
00:33:42.319 --> 00:33:48.960
Yeah, and and so like you're the parents are passing down everything to the the next person, you know.
00:33:48.960 --> 00:34:06.880
Um and so I think that's all pretty much tied to this subject, too, because I think that like you'd mentioned, is it directly connected to sin and death uh even before we're born?
00:34:06.880 --> 00:34:18.400
Is it directly connected to sin and death, you know, perhaps when we're born on the spot, or is it, you know, directly connected to sin and death just, you know, I guess in general, right?
00:34:18.400 --> 00:34:28.880
And I think that that is really important because it kind of explains a little bit more, you know, with the answer we come up with.
00:34:28.880 --> 00:34:34.400
I think it explains a little bit more with why things are the way they are, if that makes sense.
00:34:34.400 --> 00:34:34.800
Yeah.
00:34:34.800 --> 00:34:35.679
Does that make sense?
00:34:35.679 --> 00:34:36.400
Kind of.
00:34:36.400 --> 00:34:43.679
I'm kind of like trying to sum it all up, but like still, you know, talk about those three main points with the creation of the soul, you know?
00:34:43.679 --> 00:34:44.000
Yeah.
00:34:44.000 --> 00:34:50.480
But like the imputed guilt from Adam, right?
00:34:50.480 --> 00:34:59.199
Like, is it actually imputed if you have a soul that's already created, you know?
00:34:59.199 --> 00:35:05.119
So and I and I'm asking that because um what's up?
00:35:05.119 --> 00:35:05.760
No, go ahead.
00:35:05.760 --> 00:35:17.519
No, I was just thinking, so I'm asking that because the proposition that's what I was talking about earlier that I've heard is that let's say God creates the soul, it's not tradition, but it's more of the creation creationism one, right?
00:35:17.519 --> 00:35:18.000
Yeah.
00:35:18.000 --> 00:35:22.400
That would mean that God creates like a dirty soul, right?
00:35:22.400 --> 00:35:25.599
Like he creates like a sinful soul from the beginning, you know?
00:35:25.920 --> 00:35:26.960
Oh, I see what you're saying.
00:35:26.960 --> 00:35:27.199
Yeah.
00:35:27.199 --> 00:35:27.840
Yeah.
00:35:27.840 --> 00:35:29.519
So that that would that would be a problem.
00:35:29.519 --> 00:35:43.280
Because I think you can say that he creates the soul, but it it is not when the soul is created or created by him, it is not him that creates the original sin.
00:35:43.280 --> 00:35:43.840
Okay.
00:35:43.840 --> 00:35:56.639
So the original sin, obviously, that's that's passed down, and it's passed down based upon, and I think that this is why it makes more sense that traducianism in reform theology is unnecessary.
00:35:56.639 --> 00:36:08.159
It's unnecessary because Adam's sin is imputed to us based upon a covenant, the covenant of works, which you know, Adam was under, you you do this and you live, right?
00:36:08.159 --> 00:36:21.920
Because I mean, we can say, I mean, even though there might not be like clear like statements saying, Oh, this is the covenant I make with Adam, but it is kind of clearly expressed that you do this and live.
00:36:21.920 --> 00:36:27.599
You know, you can eat of every tree in the garden, except the tree of the knowledge of good and evil.
00:36:27.599 --> 00:36:29.920
Because when you do eat of it, you will surely die.
00:36:29.920 --> 00:36:31.119
You will surely die.
00:36:31.119 --> 00:36:31.599
Yeah.
00:36:31.599 --> 00:36:34.000
So and then death and sin spread.
00:36:34.000 --> 00:36:38.639
So obviously, we in the Reformed can't believe in spiritual death.
00:36:38.639 --> 00:36:48.559
Um, I don't want to go too far off the topic that you brought up, but but there's um I want to go back to what I mentioned before about concupiscence.
00:36:48.559 --> 00:36:48.960
Yeah.
00:36:48.960 --> 00:36:59.760
So disordered desire, for example, that in and of itself, I think, um, so the Roman Catholic Church doesn't believe that concupiscence is sin.
00:36:59.760 --> 00:37:01.840
John Calvin believed it was sin.
00:37:02.159 --> 00:37:12.639
And and remind me, maybe just so we get a good definition, concupiscence is like you said, it's a disordered or like a fractured desire coming from you.
00:37:13.039 --> 00:37:17.199
Yeah, it's a disordered or depraved or sinful, I think, desire, from what I can tell.
00:37:17.440 --> 00:37:17.679
Okay.
00:37:17.920 --> 00:37:21.840
So basically, it it isn't the will, but it stems from the will.
00:37:21.840 --> 00:37:30.800
So if you have a corrupted will, by necessary consequence, you're gonna have um a disordered desires.
00:37:30.800 --> 00:37:35.039
Because your will kind of is what drives everything else, right?
00:37:35.039 --> 00:37:39.519
It is, it it drives your not only your desires, but your actions.
00:37:39.519 --> 00:37:52.480
And so while the Council of Trent said, I mean, at least from what I could tell, the Council of Trent, I think, was basically making the statement, or at least the Roman Catholic view in general, I guess doesn't hold to that concupiscence is a sin.
00:37:52.480 --> 00:38:09.679
The Reformed view basically says it is, because I mean, you look at what Christ says, you know, you look at a woman with lust, you've committed adultery in your heart, you um, you know, you're angry with your brother, you know, you're guilty of, you know, it's basically kind of like you're a murderer.
00:38:09.679 --> 00:38:16.719
Not literally, but like he's making the statement that like obviously it's these these evil desires stem from somewhere.
00:38:16.719 --> 00:38:18.400
It's like the root of it.
00:38:18.400 --> 00:38:20.480
That's the root of the that's where it's coming from.
00:38:20.559 --> 00:38:21.840
It's the root inside of you.
00:38:21.840 --> 00:38:22.079
Yeah.
00:38:22.320 --> 00:38:27.039
Yeah, because when we I think I mean, because we sin in thought and deed and action.
00:38:27.039 --> 00:38:35.280
And I would say that like if our thoughts are twisted, he just because we don't act on them doesn't make them any less sin.
00:38:35.280 --> 00:38:35.679
Right.
00:38:35.679 --> 00:38:36.559
If that makes sense.
00:38:36.880 --> 00:38:38.719
Yeah, it's already quote unquote dirty.
00:38:38.719 --> 00:38:39.119
Yeah.
00:38:39.119 --> 00:38:43.119
So it's starting off dirty, so it just makes sense if it overflows dirty.
00:38:43.440 --> 00:38:43.679
Yeah.
00:38:43.679 --> 00:38:55.360
I know to some people like the reform view sounds a lot darker just because it's like, well, it's a it's probably the lowest view of man when it comes to.
00:38:55.360 --> 00:39:04.480
I mean, obviously, we believe that man is made in the image of God, but like in the reform camp, you believe in total depravity.
00:39:04.480 --> 00:39:07.119
And um, I know a lot of people, other people have said this.
00:39:07.119 --> 00:39:14.960
It's not that each person is is as evil as they can be, but that it's infected the entirety or the whole of the person.
00:39:14.960 --> 00:39:21.199
And one of the theologians that I was reading, I thought he made a a good analogy.
00:39:21.199 --> 00:39:33.119
So if you take a glass of water, good in and of itself, and then you put a little drop of poison in it, it taints the entire thing, the whole, so it's all encompassing.
00:39:33.119 --> 00:39:42.880
So whether you drink from the top or you drink the last little bit, it's still poison because it's corrupted the entirety of that nature of the water.
00:39:42.880 --> 00:39:45.519
Yeah, so it's compromised.
00:39:45.519 --> 00:40:05.360
So I thought that that was a really good way of looking at it to kind of express what total depravity is because Calvin's argument too is that um, okay, so he's basically he seemed like he was more accusing those at Trent of not holding a strong enough view against sin.
00:40:05.360 --> 00:40:09.360
So he cites basically Genesis 6.5.
00:40:09.360 --> 00:40:11.199
This is in section seven.
00:40:11.199 --> 00:40:26.480
His antidote to the Council of Trent, Calvin attacked Rome's softened view of sin, citing Genesis 6.5, and says, and he says, Scripture testifies that all the imaginations of the heart of man are only evil continually.
00:40:26.480 --> 00:40:33.920
Calvin argued that Trent's anthropology denies the extent of human depravity and turns grace into a cooperative system.
00:40:33.920 --> 00:40:38.559
So he emphasized that, you know, concupiscence is not a neutral thing.
00:40:38.559 --> 00:40:41.119
Um, it's also
condemned by Paul.
00:40:41.119 --> 00:40:46.320
It's it's affected every faculty of man, you know, heart, mind, soul, the will.
00:40:46.320 --> 00:40:50.239
No spot is left untainted.
00:40:50.800 --> 00:40:54.239
And that's what we would refer to as like our sinful nature.
00:40:54.239 --> 00:40:55.360
Yeah.
00:40:55.360 --> 00:40:58.159
It's just it's just a part of who we are.
00:40:58.559 --> 00:41:11.119
Well, in the spiritual deadness, obviously, with both the East and Um Rome uh, you know, both holding that man is spiritually weakened from the fall and not spiritually dead.
00:41:11.119 --> 00:41:17.679
Um, but I mean I think that there's passages that see that to me appear to obviously support that man is spiritually dead.
00:41:17.679 --> 00:41:24.079
You know, he's you're dead in your trespasses and sins, uh, no one can please God, no one seeks after God.
00:41:24.079 --> 00:41:38.400
Um, it seems like Paul in particular like riddles the New Testament with those type of statements about the total inability and total corruption of man apart from God's grace.
00:41:38.400 --> 00:41:45.360
So, and it does make sense that I don't I don't know if you know this, but like the East they don't believe in predestination.
00:41:45.360 --> 00:41:53.840
Their view of predestination is Arminian because they hold that God only chooses people based upon foreseen faith.
00:41:53.840 --> 00:42:19.519
If you think about it, they they hold the East holds that um God wants to save everybody, He does basically equal amount of effort to try to save everybody, which is a difficult position to be put in because it's like if salvation comes through Christ and then not every tribe out there in the world hears about Christ and they die in their sins, how do you explain that that universal offer was equally offered to all?
00:42:19.519 --> 00:42:19.920
Right.
00:42:19.920 --> 00:42:22.639
You can't, I mean, it seems impossible to hold that view.
00:42:22.800 --> 00:42:23.199
Yeah.
00:42:23.199 --> 00:42:27.840
Um not everybody has the same opportunities to hear the same stuff all the time either.
00:42:27.840 --> 00:42:28.159
Yeah.
00:42:28.320 --> 00:42:28.480
Yeah.
00:42:28.480 --> 00:42:28.960
Yeah.
00:42:28.960 --> 00:42:30.079
Yeah.
00:42:30.079 --> 00:42:32.559
I I was really fascinated to kind of learn.
00:42:32.559 --> 00:42:48.320
I mean, obviously, they the Arminians did hold to original sin, but they obviously believed in like provenient grace and that each person was able to and had the ability or the the the capacity in their will to reject or accept Christ.
00:42:48.320 --> 00:43:03.199
And the same holds true in the East, but like with the East, it's um they think it would be an evil God or an unjust God to try to compel or force people against their will to basically come to him.
00:43:03.199 --> 00:43:10.800
It's a different thing to force someone against their will, it's a whole nother thing as Calvin observes to put a new will in somebody and make them willing.
00:43:11.119 --> 00:43:11.519
Yeah.
00:43:11.519 --> 00:43:25.440
Yeah, especially if you have the power of the Holy Spirit who works with your will, you know, and um like counsels the will.
00:43:25.440 --> 00:43:30.559
You know, that's a little different than just like forcing you to do something, you know?
00:43:30.880 --> 00:43:33.920
Yeah, or just you know, giving you a new will entirely.
00:43:34.320 --> 00:43:34.800
Absolutely.
00:43:34.800 --> 00:43:38.400
Well, and I think that that's what maybe that could even mean, too, right?
00:43:38.400 --> 00:43:49.679
It's like we know God gives rebirth and God is spirit, and God gives spiritual rebirth.
00:43:50.159 --> 00:43:51.199
Well, that's a good point.
00:43:51.199 --> 00:43:54.639
What do you yeah, what do you think that their view of rebirth is?
00:43:54.639 --> 00:43:57.840
Who which which person or which uh classes view?
00:43:57.840 --> 00:44:04.719
I mean, I guess Rome and um I kind of want to say Constantinople just to keep it.
00:44:04.719 --> 00:44:08.639
I mean that's because obviously I know the East it's complex.
00:44:08.639 --> 00:44:19.679
I can't just sit there and say one city, but obviously isn't the Patriarch of Constantinople like kind of the you know kind of almost like a Pope-like figure, but he's not like the Pope.
00:44:19.679 --> 00:44:31.519
You know, I I'm just kind of trying to make an apples to apples comparison here and it's probably not fair because they have patriarchs but they don't have one, you know, one that rules over all the others.
00:44:31.519 --> 00:44:32.320
Right.
00:44:32.320 --> 00:44:43.599
Um I I guess I'm confused as to their understanding of like what is the meaning behind being born again if you're not spiritually dead.
00:44:43.599 --> 00:44:44.880
Right, right.
00:44:44.880 --> 00:44:47.039
Like what what would the purpose be?
00:44:47.039 --> 00:44:49.920
Why do you need to be born again if you're not spiritually dead?
00:44:49.920 --> 00:44:56.000
Like if your will is perfectly capable of just choosing Christ and what's the what's the point?
00:44:56.400 --> 00:44:57.199
I I agree.
00:44:57.199 --> 00:45:25.199
And I think the only because I don't know I don't know what their answer would be overall but I would say I would love to have a conversation with some it would be interesting to hear that because I think and I'm just speculating but I would assume that perhaps it's almost kind of like a continual rebirth you know which you know has some grounds in scripture right there are there are things that are related to like a continual rebirth renewal.
00:45:25.199 --> 00:46:00.239
Yeah like it's like a renewal right like you're you're like almost like Paul says in Romans, you know, don't be conformed to the world and the patterns of the world but be renewed by you know with your mind right so it's kind of like there is like this effort that would have to be put into like a continual spiritual renewal like on your part
you know yeah um but because it seems like it would be like okay I think it's fair to say that the continual renewal of your mind and then continual repentance obviously are an important part of the Christian life.
00:46:00.239 --> 00:46:10.639
Like one actual rebirth itself.
00:46:10.639 --> 00:46:20.320
Not necessarily not like a renewal or a continual renewal but just that it's like actu actually having a baby you know like in real life in the physical world.
00:46:20.320 --> 00:46:31.519
Yeah you know you have a baby you don't keep having a baby over and over and over again that one baby right it's like it's just that's that's the moment right that's where you have the child and I agree with you.
00:46:31.519 --> 00:46:41.679
I think that like what Jesus taught to Nicodemus especially he's like you have to be reborn right if you want to see the kingdom of God.
00:46:41.679 --> 00:47:00.400
And I like I said I'm speculating but from what I can understand from what scripture does teach I think that Jesus is actually saying there is an actual full moment rebirth that happens with the person and that's how they truly get saved and that's where the Holy Spirit starts to indwell the person actually and manifests.
00:47:00.400 --> 00:47:20.400
So yeah I think tied to the idea of like a continual rebirth or or how that group might view it, I would only assume that and I I could be wrong about what they think so I'm not trying to put words in their mouth but I would assume that the thought is that like let's say you reach a a testing moment where you can choose to sin or not sin, right?
00:47:20.400 --> 00:47:24.559
And you don't sin, well that means you're kind of like reborn in that moment, right?
00:47:24.559 --> 00:47:29.840
And it's like almost like a constructive thing like it keeps going until you reach heaven, right?
00:47:29.840 --> 00:47:50.559
And I could see why somebody might justify that because they could see passages like where Paul's like I've fought the good fight of faith and you know I've made it this far and I'm still faithful so I'm good you know but it does almost kind of sound like that could be more of a works based salvation idea right rather than grace based.
00:47:50.960 --> 00:48:07.760
Which Paul continually preaches constantly says grace constantly grace, grace, grace, says you know it's not of works lest anyone should boast I'll see if you have anything else to say on that and then I was going to jump to some of the um some of the reformed confessions and catechisms and what they say.
00:48:07.760 --> 00:48:08.559
You want to do that?
00:48:08.559 --> 00:48:08.960
Okay.
00:48:08.960 --> 00:48:37.199
So the Westminster Confession of faith chapter six says they being the root of all mankind the guilt of this sin was imputed in the same death in sin and corrupted nature conveyed to all their posterity descending from them by ordinary generation the Heidelberg Catechism question and answer seven to eight okay question seven
When then comes this depraved nature of man?
00:48:37.199 --> 00:48:42.960
Answer from the fall and disobedience of our first parents, Adam and Eve, in paradise.
00:48:42.960 --> 00:48:48.400
Hence our nature is become so corrupt that we are all conceived and born in sin.
00:48:48.400 --> 00:49:38.480
Question eight is are we then so corrupt that we are wholly incapable of doing any good and inclined to all wickedness answer indeed we are, except we are regenerated by the Spirit of God The canons of Dor, this is the third and fourth heads of doctrine Articles two and three man after the fall begat children in his own likeness, a corrupt stock produced a corrupt offspring therefore therefore all men are conceived in sin and are and are by nature children of wrath, incapable of any saving good so here you see across countries you know the canons of Dort were in the Netherlands um Heidelberg Catechism I want to say obviously Germany and then the Westminster Confession of faith in England.
00:49:38.480 --> 00:49:44.320
It's like here you have different reformed groups all saying kind of the same thing about the fall of man.
00:49:44.320 --> 00:49:53.440
Man's um you know corruption Adamson imputed and our inability to please God and choose God.
00:49:53.440 --> 00:50:09.599
So you know what I mean like I feel like that's kind of a good way to sum it up that they all kind of had the same it's nice to see that kind of cohesiveness among uh the reformed camp in different important historical documents whether it's catechisms or confessions.
00:50:09.599 --> 00:50:44.320
I will say like when you're kind of looking at like the reformed view or in Romanism like usually you have like a catechism to refer to with the East it's it's not so much it's it's a little bit more of like usually if you ask chat GPT or Google something it's going to pull up an early church father or like a either an early church father or like a middle aged or you know the uh middle aged father in Archie that actually I was trying to avoid saying that but I was already down that path so I had to say the the middle aged fathers.
00:50:44.320 --> 00:50:50.400
I think maybe that's what we should call it fathers or fathers of the faith from the Middle Ages.
00:50:50.559 --> 00:51:19.440
Yeah that's probably a more proper way of saying it yeah well do you mind reading for me um that passage Psalm 515 Psalm 515 Behold I was brought forth in iniquity and in sin did my mother conceive me yeah that's the that's the question right like how do we explain that like how was he conceived in sin?
00:51:20.079 --> 00:51:37.599
So like there's been some debate as to what like David means obviously is you know from an Augustinian viewpoint we believe that what he's saying is even from the time of conception he was sinful um based upon Adam's transgression.
00:51:37.599 --> 00:52:06.719
Um now I mean we could also look at it the simple or we could also look at it at an another angle being like well since disorder desire is always involved in basically all of our actions um like that would be um the act of procreation uh would also be you know not not unstained from disorder desire.
00:52:06.719 --> 00:52:17.920
So therefore like I think it would make sense to me why like since Jesus himself, you know obviously born of a woman I guess you can say I mean he was human, right?
00:52:17.920 --> 00:52:19.760
So he had a human nature.
00:52:19.760 --> 00:52:40.960
But since um concupiscence wasn't involved in the procreative act and since obviously God crew you know created him in Mary's womb directly so that would maybe be one reason why you know he wouldn't have had original sin, why he would be sinless and not have the stain of Adam.
00:52:40.960 --> 00:52:43.360
Do you still have Romans five up?
00:52:43.360 --> 00:52:50.880
Uh yeah let's start with verses sixteen and if you want to just read it to the end of the chapter or sixteen to nineteen basically.
00:52:51.440 --> 00:53:05.360
And the free gift is not like the result of that one man's sin, for the judgment following one trespass brought condemnation, but the free gift following many trespasses brought justification.
00:53:05.360 --> 00:53:23.119
For if because of one man's trespass death reigned through that one man, much more will those who receive the abundance of grace and the free gift of righteousness reign in life through the one man Jesus Christ.
00:53:23.119 --> 00:53:33.519
Therefore as one trespass led to condemnation for all men, so one act of righteousness leads to justification and life for all men.
00:53:33.519 --> 00:53:41.840
For as by the one man's disobedience the many were made sinners, so by the one man's obedience the many will be made righteous.
00:53:42.400 --> 00:54:03.920
Yeah I think that that was that's a very enlightening passage just about the parallels between Adam and Christ and you know Adam's disobedience Christ's obedience to the law and obviously through Adam's disobedience many were made sinners so by one man's disobedience or one man's obedience the many will be made righteous.
00:54:03.920 --> 00:54:26.559
So going further up though in um earlier on I think it's in maybe verses 16 you notice how it says for the judgment following one trespass brought condemnation so if it brings condemnation to all men it's like well we bear the punishment of an act that we didn't commit.
00:54:26.719 --> 00:54:26.960
Right?
00:54:27.440 --> 00:55:19.440
Like we're all condemned yeah I mean we're all condemned for I mean we would be condemned on original sin alone not just our actual sins This topic is so encompassing and affects so many different doctrines and it you can see how it affects different belief systems because it's like uh James Montgomery Boyce for example he says when people have trouble with the doctrine of election and many do the real problem is not with the doctrine of election although they think it is but with a doctrine of depravity that makes
election necessary it makes sense that people who criticize or have trouble accepting the idea of predestination that God elected certain individuals because they don't like to think that they don't have the ability to come to Christ on their own.
00:55:19.440 --> 00:55:26.480
But it's like scripture does say you know Christ does say no man can come to me unless the Father who sent me draws him.
00:55:26.880 --> 00:55:27.440
Yeah.
00:55:27.440 --> 00:55:28.639
Yeah that's good.
00:55:28.639 --> 00:55:47.440
It's um and from that quote it sounds like what he was kind of getting at was it's not as much about and repeat the very last part you said he said people don't have a problem with what they have a problem with the depravity part.
00:55:47.440 --> 00:55:48.079
What was the first part?
00:55:48.480 --> 00:55:56.480
Yeah when people when people have trouble with election and many do you know yeah the real problem is not with election but with the doctrine of depravity.
00:55:56.719 --> 00:56:06.000
Yeah and I think that that is kind of tied to the idea of people aren't as upset about the idea of some people being chosen to be saved.
00:56:06.000 --> 00:56:24.639
It's more just relating to how depraved we truly are right and how you know we do have this nature that is utterly you know incapable of being saved alone right we need the Lord to do that.
00:56:24.639 --> 00:56:36.079
So it does sound like that's that is quite a point of contention for a lot of people and and it's not as much about oh I'm upset that God would actually choose some people over the others.
00:56:36.079 --> 00:56:42.320
It's more like I just am dismissing the fact that we're all just utterly devoid of God in general.
00:56:42.800 --> 00:57:06.639
Yeah yeah it's no I agree it's it's almost like um well because once you have the idea that man is maybe spiritually wounded or that man is hasn't been affected at all like the um Pelagians where it's just kind of like well man sins through imitation each man that is born is born in the same state that Adam was with the ability to choose good or evil.
00:57:06.639 --> 00:57:23.920
And but it like I said it all kind of stems from the will if you have a a will that's in bondage or enslaved to sin then it's like well naturally your your desires are going to be disordered and as a result actions stem from your desires.
00:57:24.639 --> 00:57:59.440
So it's you see how it's affected both will desire and action outcome you know I think that people I'm sorry I don't want to no you're totally fine taking even more time here but um I feel like people that couldn't even imagine that that could be a possibility that we are born just with this sinful nature and that we have a lot of capability to just find God on our own to me it just sounds like these are people that haven't really experienced God enough, you know it's kind of like the idea of when Isaiah saw God, right?
00:57:59.440 --> 00:58:07.920
He falls down his knees and he's like I am just a dirt bag, you know I do not belong even right in front of you right now.
00:58:07.920 --> 00:58:20.000
To me it just kind of sounds like we're like denying something like we're not really getting the full scope of what scripture teaches and what God has taught, you know, according to the Bible.
00:58:20.000 --> 00:58:26.639
So I'm not gonna say that you know people I I think people are very optimistic a lot of times.
00:58:27.039 --> 00:58:40.239
Well they would like to like to believe that man is either um inherently good or maybe not or or maybe a more moderate view that he's not as bad as they as they would like to think.
00:58:40.239 --> 00:58:40.719
Yeah.
00:58:40.719 --> 00:59:23.440
That he at least has some good in him but obviously even in the Roman system like the the ability to do good the ability to choose God obviously they they believe is of grace but the question is is is this grace given equally to everybody and is everyone equally have the ability to um to choose of their own quote unquote free will and because I mean from the Orthodox view it's absurd to them and uh I mean pretty much what they said was in one of the videos I watched it's basically an absurdity that like God would command something that is not within our power to do.
00:59:23.440 --> 00:59:30.400
But it's like well that is exactly what he's commanding because and it's to show our utter helplessness.
00:59:30.400 --> 00:59:30.800
Yeah.
00:59:30.800 --> 00:59:31.199
Right.
00:59:31.199 --> 00:59:35.280
And I think that that's why the law came it's it does show our utter dependency.
00:59:35.280 --> 00:59:38.000
And inability to do it.
00:59:38.079 --> 00:59:38.400
Yeah.
00:59:38.639 --> 00:59:49.039
Yeah because I as far as I know apart from Christ I don't think that there's anyone else that's walked the earth that can say that they've kept God's law perfectly.
00:59:49.599 --> 00:59:50.800
Or who is even trying.
00:59:50.800 --> 00:59:51.039
Yeah.
00:59:51.280 --> 01:00:13.199
Yeah because if it's if it's possible if if if if if in their view that God is God wouldn't command something that we couldn't meet then it's like well the commandments themselves but it's like I think Christ basically shatters that opinion because he basically says you know even our desires and our thoughts are evil.
01:00:13.519 --> 01:00:17.360
Yeah that's awesome man what a subject we just discussed.
01:00:17.599 --> 01:00:22.239
Yeah hopefully I let you chime in enough I know I can ramble I'm a rambler.
01:00:22.559 --> 01:00:47.760
No I like how um you're bringing a lot of history to light with theological beliefs and cultural beliefs with this stuff because I think uh shout out to the Restless Theologian podcast but I think that this podcast is good uh where you're able to kind of you know just bring up these kind of historical examples of maybe where these beliefs kind of came from yeah and where people are at today because of those beliefs.
01:00:47.760 --> 01:00:48.159
Yep.
01:00:48.159 --> 01:00:49.920
So I think you do a really good job of that.
01:00:49.920 --> 01:00:53.760
So I appreciate when you when you I you I don't think it's rambling at all.
01:00:53.760 --> 01:00:56.559
I think you're kind of just summing things up very well.
01:00:56.559 --> 01:01:06.480
Um and I appreciate just being able to be on here with you and getting to kind of share my brain a little bit because I think my brain kind of goes all over the place too.
01:01:06.480 --> 01:01:09.039
So I think this kind of helps me organize my thoughts a little better too.
01:01:09.360 --> 01:01:10.800
Yeah I think that that's you're welcome.
01:01:10.800 --> 01:01:24.159
Yeah thank thank you for being on I um I I love this topic just because I think it reveals so much and uh it you know you could spend a lot of time on it but uh thanks again for coming on and um you know we'll see you next time.
01:01:24.320 --> 01:01:26.400
All right sir thank you appreciate it