TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:20.199 --> 00:00:23.120
Greetings friends, and welcome to the podcast of Jewish Ideas
2
00:00:23.160 --> 00:00:26.199
a Torah in motion production i'm jj Kimrie. Over the
3
00:00:26.280 --> 00:00:29.600
last thousand years or so, much of the intellectual creativity
4
00:00:29.640 --> 00:00:32.479
of Jewish scholars has been spent writing on matters of
5
00:00:32.520 --> 00:00:36.320
Halachah or Jewish law. Oceans of ink have been spilled
6
00:00:36.359 --> 00:00:39.320
on the endeavors of explaining and expanding Jewish law, which
7
00:00:39.359 --> 00:00:43.799
continue unabated to this day. Halaric writing comes in various forms,
8
00:00:43.799 --> 00:00:46.840
and in the past centuries has been rather dominated in
9
00:00:46.880 --> 00:00:51.280
certain respects by two specific forms. One is halaric codes,
10
00:00:51.320 --> 00:00:53.880
in which the author lists the bottom line of the
11
00:00:53.960 --> 00:00:56.479
law as he sees it, whereas the other is halarchic
12
00:00:56.520 --> 00:00:59.280
responsor a lot truvat, in which the scholar seeks to
13
00:00:59.320 --> 00:01:03.280
apply the law to specific cases. These two genres represent
14
00:01:03.399 --> 00:01:06.719
two entirely different ways of analyzing, applying, and conceiving of
15
00:01:06.760 --> 00:01:10.159
Jewish law. And there's these fruitful differences between these genres
16
00:01:10.239 --> 00:01:12.840
that shall be capturing our attention today. With us to
17
00:01:12.920 --> 00:01:16.480
talk about these genres of halahi writing is him Seman,
18
00:01:16.719 --> 00:01:19.120
a professor of law and chair in Jewish Law at
19
00:01:19.200 --> 00:01:22.120
Villanova University as well as a dian on the bed
20
00:01:22.120 --> 00:01:24.879
Din of America. He has published widely on topics in
21
00:01:24.920 --> 00:01:28.959
both American and Jewish law, including his acclaimed work Halacha,
22
00:01:29.319 --> 00:01:32.159
the Rabbinic Idea of Law, published by Princeton University Press
23
00:01:32.159 --> 00:01:34.959
in twenty eighteen. It is a pleasure to welcome Professor
24
00:01:34.959 --> 00:01:36.959
Simon to the Podcast of Jewish Ideas today.
25
00:01:37.040 --> 00:01:40.959
Welcome sir, Thank you, thank you, jayj. It's great being
26
00:01:41.000 --> 00:01:43.879
with you. Although usually we have some scotch and charllt
27
00:01:44.319 --> 00:01:47.640
when we meet after Kiddish, during Kiddish after sure, but
28
00:01:47.959 --> 00:01:50.079
we'll make do today with the virtual interface.
29
00:01:50.599 --> 00:01:53.680
I agree. It's usually usually conversations are greatly improved by
30
00:01:53.680 --> 00:01:56.120
scotch and challenge, So today we'll have to have to
31
00:01:56.120 --> 00:01:58.799
see what we could do without it. So I'm interested
32
00:01:58.840 --> 00:02:02.519
in discussing these these two types of halakk writing. And
33
00:02:02.599 --> 00:02:04.719
so let's start a little bit with with halaki responsor,
34
00:02:04.760 --> 00:02:07.680
because I think they are slightly older, and just ask.
35
00:02:07.760 --> 00:02:12.159
I mean, firstly, how would one define halaki responsor slats
36
00:02:12.159 --> 00:02:15.400
of true VOTs? What exactly are they? When did they emerge?
37
00:02:15.400 --> 00:02:17.199
What are their principal characteristics? Give us a little of
38
00:02:17.240 --> 00:02:18.840
an overview of that.
39
00:02:19.560 --> 00:02:22.360
Sure, So as the as the name that we use
40
00:02:22.439 --> 00:02:26.919
shlotin shoe vote indicates they kind of can include anything
41
00:02:27.120 --> 00:02:30.840
in which somebody asks a rabbi a question and the
42
00:02:30.919 --> 00:02:35.400
rabbi provides an answer in truth. Already in the Gamarah
43
00:02:35.680 --> 00:02:42.879
there are examples shall right so so so in some
44
00:02:43.000 --> 00:02:47.919
sense the genre of shlotin shoe vote is already found
45
00:02:47.919 --> 00:02:51.919
in the Gamara, where questions are asked either and shallhoo
46
00:02:51.919 --> 00:02:54.800
sounds like they're sending some sort of writing, perhaps an
47
00:02:54.879 --> 00:02:59.479
oral message, hard to know, and they're getting a response back.
48
00:03:00.960 --> 00:03:03.520
But usually we don't think of something in the Gamara
49
00:03:03.599 --> 00:03:06.639
as prior to part of shaylatan chewe vote. So therefore
50
00:03:06.719 --> 00:03:09.879
the next phase or the gonme have have their own
51
00:03:09.960 --> 00:03:13.360
shayload to chew vote. Some of them are incredibly short.
52
00:03:13.800 --> 00:03:16.759
What does this word mean? Is one of my favorites
53
00:03:17.199 --> 00:03:19.919
right this. They're living in a world before Rashi, certainly
54
00:03:19.960 --> 00:03:23.000
before arts girl, so people would ask what does this
55
00:03:23.039 --> 00:03:25.759
word mean? Or what is this idea? And sometimes they
56
00:03:25.800 --> 00:03:31.520
are they are more complex. Over time, Shane Loan Tchubote
57
00:03:31.520 --> 00:03:36.439
has come to be identified more with sort of questions
58
00:03:36.439 --> 00:03:41.879
on concrete particular cases that have come up. Those could
59
00:03:41.879 --> 00:03:44.280
be cases that come up in real life those can
60
00:03:44.360 --> 00:03:48.599
be kind of hypotheticals that are thought about, but something
61
00:03:48.639 --> 00:03:52.599
with a specific set of parameters. There are shaylotan Chu
62
00:03:52.639 --> 00:03:55.280
votes from the ear of the reshow name and there
63
00:03:55.280 --> 00:03:57.319
she looked to vote from the era of the early
64
00:03:57.400 --> 00:04:02.319
afroyme and as you said, up to including to this day.
65
00:04:02.759 --> 00:04:05.159
So it's a very you know, it's it's a very
66
00:04:05.240 --> 00:04:07.599
it's a little bit of a catch off phrase because
67
00:04:07.759 --> 00:04:10.000
it could be, as I said, as it's come to
68
00:04:10.039 --> 00:04:13.120
mean a kind of specific and relatively kind
Load full transcript
of crete
69
00:04:13.159 --> 00:04:16.959
ALACKI question. But some of the older ones certainly aren't
70
00:04:17.000 --> 00:04:19.199
like that at all. They're literally things that people ask
71
00:04:19.319 --> 00:04:20.680
rabbis whatever they.
72
00:04:20.519 --> 00:04:23.279
Are, right, Okay, good, So now we've gone over that.
73
00:04:23.279 --> 00:04:25.279
And the truth is, as you mentioned before, it's it's
74
00:04:26.120 --> 00:04:27.639
one of the oldest poems I like writing we have,
75
00:04:27.680 --> 00:04:30.399
but of course continues very much to this day. It
76
00:04:30.519 --> 00:04:34.959
is arguably probably the most enduring vehicle of halak writing.
77
00:04:35.279 --> 00:04:38.959
Every year another volume, many more volumes are produced in
78
00:04:39.000 --> 00:04:39.800
this in this genre.
79
00:04:40.079 --> 00:04:42.480
Sure, and and this point of volumes I think I
80
00:04:42.519 --> 00:04:45.000
think is important. In other words, and maybe we could
81
00:04:45.839 --> 00:04:49.079
is that it's I think today when someone says I'm
82
00:04:49.079 --> 00:04:51.800
going to write Shaylo two. They know that they're going
83
00:04:51.879 --> 00:04:54.639
to publish them, and they're going to be in the collections.
84
00:04:55.079 --> 00:04:57.600
But certainly as we go back, it's not clear. And
85
00:04:57.639 --> 00:05:00.720
this is one of the big differences between the the genres.
86
00:05:00.759 --> 00:05:04.480
When someone writes alach code or alak commentary, right, they
87
00:05:04.519 --> 00:05:08.959
sort of know what they're doing, right, and you know,
88
00:05:09.040 --> 00:05:11.000
certainly at some point they understood that this would be
89
00:05:11.040 --> 00:05:15.439
disseminated and later published in print. Right. If you think
90
00:05:15.480 --> 00:05:20.560
of your own correspondence, right, you correspond by orally by text,
91
00:05:21.000 --> 00:05:25.399
by email, sometimes by email where you attach a PDF, right.
92
00:05:25.439 --> 00:05:28.600
And these are various layers of formality which are sort
93
00:05:28.600 --> 00:05:31.160
of like your assumptions about how much is this like
94
00:05:31.439 --> 00:05:34.120
an answer of the moment, like your wife says, hey,
95
00:05:34.120 --> 00:05:35.680
when are you coming home? And you say, you know,
96
00:05:35.680 --> 00:05:38.399
six point thirty, and then you know even if you
97
00:05:38.439 --> 00:05:40.160
may email it, but the fact that you may put
98
00:05:40.199 --> 00:05:42.759
it into a document in a PDF, like you're signaling
99
00:05:42.800 --> 00:05:45.879
that this is something kind of more permanent, more important.
100
00:05:46.120 --> 00:05:47.959
And those are a range of things, and I think
101
00:05:48.360 --> 00:05:51.879
Shout and Chubaut sort of work the same way, at
102
00:05:51.959 --> 00:05:54.560
least when they're produced. Right. Some of them are very
103
00:05:54.639 --> 00:05:56.800
quick and dirty things. Of that moment, and some it's
104
00:05:56.879 --> 00:05:59.800
very clear that the author understands that he is writing
105
00:05:59.839 --> 00:06:03.480
some thing for the ages. Sometimes whether it's for the
106
00:06:03.519 --> 00:06:06.680
ages or not is not understood until some ages have
107
00:06:06.959 --> 00:06:10.519
happened in past. I think as we move in time,
108
00:06:10.600 --> 00:06:13.279
people have a better sense of what they're going to
109
00:06:13.319 --> 00:06:16.279
do with them, at least the ones that are published.
110
00:06:16.319 --> 00:06:19.279
But any important Rabbi is going to have lots and
111
00:06:19.319 --> 00:06:23.040
lots of communications with you know, we'll call them his audience,
112
00:06:23.480 --> 00:06:26.120
right to varying degrees of formality. And therefore what shows
113
00:06:26.199 --> 00:06:28.360
up in a in a volume of de Vote and
114
00:06:28.360 --> 00:06:30.959
how it's published sort of you know, is a little
115
00:06:30.959 --> 00:06:35.040
bit sporadic, but changes our assumptions about what it is. Something
116
00:06:35.199 --> 00:06:37.959
clearented in a volume called Child to Vote we read
117
00:06:38.040 --> 00:06:39.839
as sort of being written for the ages, so it
118
00:06:39.879 --> 00:06:42.000
may not have been intended that way.
119
00:06:42.639 --> 00:06:45.279
Right, Okay, thank you for that that brief overview, and
120
00:06:45.279 --> 00:06:47.040
I'm going to ask you to do the same for
121
00:06:47.120 --> 00:06:51.680
al codes. Explain what you mean by that again, what
122
00:06:51.839 --> 00:06:54.879
is the scope? What do they intend to do? And
123
00:06:55.079 --> 00:06:57.519
I suppose again that's sort of a brief history of
124
00:06:57.560 --> 00:06:59.879
when they arise and whether they're still being written.
125
00:07:00.120 --> 00:07:02.720
Sure, So let's start with the word codes. And as
126
00:07:02.759 --> 00:07:05.279
you mentioned, I'm a law professor and the law professor
127
00:07:05.279 --> 00:07:08.360
and me uses the term but doesn't love the term
128
00:07:08.680 --> 00:07:11.680
because to the modern ear, a code is something produced
129
00:07:12.040 --> 00:07:15.839
by some governing institution. Right, so we think of the
130
00:07:15.959 --> 00:07:17.959
you know, we're sitting here in the state of Pennsylvania
131
00:07:18.199 --> 00:07:20.279
or the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. It has a code. The
132
00:07:20.360 --> 00:07:24.920
United States has codes, et cetera. And what makes those
133
00:07:24.959 --> 00:07:29.439
authoritative is that the governing body is thought to be
134
00:07:29.560 --> 00:07:32.199
the sovereign in one sense or another that can produce those.
135
00:07:32.759 --> 00:07:35.160
In Halaha, it doesn't work that way. I don't know
136
00:07:35.160 --> 00:07:37.079
if the soun hedron ever published a code, but we
137
00:07:37.120 --> 00:07:41.079
don't have it. So the codes that we have, and
138
00:07:41.120 -->
00:07:43.160
I think maybe a better way to think about them
139
00:07:43.199 --> 00:07:46.120
as a word that lawyers use and non lawyers don't.
140
00:07:46.160 --> 00:07:49.959
It's called a restatement. We'll use codes. But what a
141
00:07:50.000 --> 00:07:53.000
restatement means is that somebody trying to restate what the
142
00:07:53.079 --> 00:07:57.160
law is, and therefore it's authority comes from people accepting it,
143
00:07:57.399 --> 00:08:00.000
as in the case of you vote. So they're not
144
00:08:00.319 --> 00:08:03.600
codes in that sense of the modern usage. In as
145
00:08:03.600 --> 00:08:06.120
long as the listeners understand that I'm happy to use
146
00:08:06.160 --> 00:08:10.639
the word so codes start with. I would say a
147
00:08:10.639 --> 00:08:14.279
certain type of problem is anyone who's learned Gamara knows
148
00:08:14.319 --> 00:08:18.160
that if you now want to make this massive work
149
00:08:18.519 --> 00:08:22.120
the basis of practice, gosh, that's very hard because there's
150
00:08:22.160 --> 00:08:25.360
so much going on in there, some of it relevant,
151
00:08:25.439 --> 00:08:27.439
some of it not relevant, some of it relevant to
152
00:08:27.560 --> 00:08:31.240
other parts that it needs to be pared down. And
153
00:08:31.279 --> 00:08:34.960
the earliest thing that's in the kind of code tradition
154
00:08:35.919 --> 00:08:38.480
this is called the most famous one of those is
155
00:08:38.480 --> 00:08:42.000
al Hote Alfassi, also known as the Riff Riff standing
156
00:08:42.039 --> 00:08:45.639
for Rebusk that Alfasi e fez right in North Africa,
157
00:08:46.080 --> 00:08:49.960
who basically what he does largely is he he has
158
00:08:50.000 --> 00:08:52.240
all imagine, he has all the talmlet on a computer
159
00:08:52.360 --> 00:08:56.080
and he largely uses his cut function. So he takes
160
00:08:56.200 --> 00:08:59.639
out all the kind of back and forth all of
161
00:08:59.679 --> 00:09:02.759
the ad a looted to the dress shownk and focuses
162
00:09:02.919 --> 00:09:07.480
more or less on the bottom line, occasionally adding in
163
00:09:07.559 --> 00:09:10.720
his own voice. Although the vast bulk of the text
164
00:09:11.080 --> 00:09:14.320
is simply the Gamar's text, it preserved as to what
165
00:09:14.360 --> 00:09:19.159
he understood was like normative binding Hallja Bismann Haase and
166
00:09:19.240 --> 00:09:21.679
this era in other words, in the post temple, post
167
00:09:21.679 --> 00:09:25.879
monarchy era of what we probably call goblut. In fact,
168
00:09:26.039 --> 00:09:30.240
if one takes the new editions, you know, printed in
169
00:09:30.240 --> 00:09:33.559
the last ten to fifteen years, they very usefully will
170
00:09:33.679 --> 00:09:36.000
highlight in when one looks in the riff the parts
171
00:09:36.039 --> 00:09:39.399
that are in his voice, which is a super useful feature.
172
00:09:39.399 --> 00:09:42.120
And you see it's not the majority of it at all,
173
00:09:42.559 --> 00:09:45.440
so that it's not the first. There were precursors to that,
174
00:09:45.519 --> 00:09:49.000
but that's sort of the first thing in that tradition. However,
175
00:09:49.519 --> 00:09:54.240
it is in the Gamar's language and in the Gamar's order,
176
00:09:55.360 --> 00:09:58.360
and therefore lack of order. The first thing we might
177
00:09:58.399 --> 00:10:02.600
call a code is of course the rambam, which is
178
00:10:02.720 --> 00:10:06.000
to some degree in some sense has not been surpassed.
179
00:10:06.000 --> 00:10:08.639
In some sense it has right. What the Rambam does,
180
00:10:08.679 --> 00:10:11.399
he does a couple of very important things. First of all,
181
00:10:11.399 --> 00:10:15.799
he creates his own structure in Taxonomy fourteen books, right,
182
00:10:15.960 --> 00:10:19.039
something that maybe you could say there's some reference to
183
00:10:19.120 --> 00:10:21.240
in the mission, but largely a thing of his own creation,
184
00:10:21.919 --> 00:10:25.679
and takes every alatan the talmud. And here he is
185
00:10:25.720 --> 00:10:29.159
following the riff, usually in the sense of which bits
186
00:10:29.159 --> 00:10:33.639
in the Talmud he thinks are normative and which opinions are.
187
00:10:33.679 --> 00:10:37.039
Except it's broader than the Riff because he covers everything
188
00:10:37.080 --> 00:10:39.759
the Gamar talks about the riffs if it's not applicable,
189
00:10:40.000 --> 00:10:43.279
Bisman hasaid, the Riff generally doesn't have it. The Rambam
190
00:10:43.399 --> 00:10:47.399
has everything. He also changes the language. It's not in
191
00:10:47.480 --> 00:10:50.519
the Talmudic language, but it's in something that's pretty close
192
00:10:50.519 --> 00:10:54.080
to modern Hebrew or close ish based on the shne Hebrew,
193
00:10:54.120 --> 00:10:56.360
and therefore it's an easy read to the modern reader.
194
00:10:56.759 --> 00:11:00.519
And he creates a conceptual structure for it to some
195
00:11:00.600 --> 00:11:02.360
degree to how he views a laha and to what
196
00:11:02.440 --> 00:11:07.240
he views as the mitzvote rita in each topic. So
197
00:11:07.360 --> 00:11:10.480
that's the Rombum. There's more to say. What he doesn't
198
00:11:10.519 --> 00:11:13.799
do is he doesn't retain any of them a cloak it,
199
00:11:14.600 --> 00:11:17.440
any of the various opinions that are found in the Gamara,
200
00:11:17.559 --> 00:11:22.879
and he largely does not pay attention to post Talmudic developments.
201
00:11:22.879 --> 00:11:25.200
I don't want to say never, but that's certainly not
202
00:11:25.279 --> 00:11:27.240
a feature of the Rombum. So you could think of
203
00:11:27.240 --> 00:11:30.399
it as what he says, he's trying to summarize the
204
00:11:30.480 --> 00:11:34.720
rules in the Tumul now it is ingenious. And you know,
205
00:11:34.759 --> 00:11:37.200
even today, if we have all the databases and all
206
00:11:37.200 --> 00:11:40.000
the ais and all the
computers, it's it's it's mind
207
00:11:40.039 --> 00:11:43.200
boggling how we did this even with our technology, how
208
00:11:43.279 --> 00:11:49.039
Vahlmer with basically very very primitive technology. So it's it's
209
00:11:49.039 --> 00:11:53.759
truly a master work. And in some sense, nothing like
210
00:11:53.799 --> 00:11:57.000
this has really been attempted to that scale since obviously
211
00:11:57.000 --> 00:12:01.879
there's some asterisks to that point. That's Rombumb the next
212
00:12:01.919 --> 00:12:05.639
probably most famous code. There are others, but the one
213
00:12:05.639 --> 00:12:09.039
that really kind of takes up central space is known
214
00:12:09.039 --> 00:12:13.679
as the Arbaturim, written by yakovman Usher or the son
215
00:12:13.799 --> 00:12:17.559
of the Rush, and it is known today commonly as
216
00:12:17.600 --> 00:12:20.440
the Tour. The Tour is different from the Rhmbam in
217
00:12:20.440 --> 00:12:23.200
a few different ways. First of all, it doesn't have
218
00:12:23.279 --> 00:12:28.039
fourteen books, but four. And importantly, it only deals in
219
00:12:28.080 --> 00:12:30.519
this sense. It follows the Riff more closely in only
220
00:12:30.600 --> 00:12:33.480
dealing with those laws that are applicable in what we
221
00:12:33.519 --> 00:12:36.679
call bisman Haze right in this era or in the
222
00:12:36.720 --> 00:12:39.840
era that they lived in. So it does not have
223
00:12:40.120 --> 00:12:42.559
laws of the temple and laws of the sacrifices and
224
00:12:42.879 --> 00:12:46.159
laws of purity largely and even only a little bit
225
00:12:46.200 --> 00:12:48.519
of laws that applied to the land of Israel, because
226
00:12:48.519 --> 00:12:52.080
they're asserving they're living without it. Drop in there, but
227
00:12:52.120 --> 00:12:56.039
basically not. The Tour is also different in that he
228
00:12:56.159 --> 00:13:01.679
is he retains some debates, and he is much more
229
00:13:01.720 --> 00:13:06.759
interested in post Talmudic applications, so he will cite frequently
230
00:13:06.799 --> 00:13:09.159
from the toast Slot and the other reshow Neme that
231
00:13:09.240 --> 00:13:11.320
are talking not just what the law of the Talmud is,
232
00:13:11.360 --> 00:13:16.480
but how it became instantiated in practice in the various
233
00:13:17.000 --> 00:13:20.879
communities in which people lived. So the Rambomb is much
234
00:13:20.879 --> 00:13:23.159
more classical in the sense is much more driven by
235
00:13:23.159 --> 00:13:26.879
the Talmud, whereas the Tour begins to fill that gap,
236
00:13:27.159 --> 00:13:29.200
and he's writing at the end of the period of
237
00:13:29.200 --> 00:13:32.279
the reshiow Nme and largely collects not everything, but a
238
00:13:32.320 --> 00:13:36.279
lot of that material in there. The four sections I
239
00:13:36.399 --> 00:13:40.759
assume are fairly well known are highm right, which actually
240
00:13:40.759 --> 00:13:44.320
is an ingenious arrangements. It's three cycles. It's the cycle
241
00:13:44.360 --> 00:13:46.879
of the day starting with waking up, It's on the
242
00:13:46.919 --> 00:13:49.399
cycle of the week i e. Shabas and Aravin, and
243
00:13:49.440 --> 00:13:52.519
on the cycle of the year yaridaea, which is a
244
00:13:52.519 --> 00:13:55.039
little bit more of a grab bag is largely kosher,
245
00:13:55.960 --> 00:14:01.360
and then other ritual laws evan As is about marriage,
246
00:14:01.360 --> 00:14:04.080
family and divorce law and closi mishbud is, you know,
247
00:14:04.320 --> 00:14:07.480
procedure and substance of the civil law, and the sort
248
00:14:07.480 --> 00:14:12.519
of halachic court system. That is the tour. That and
249
00:14:12.559 --> 00:14:17.279
then after that comes the Shokanauch, which has an interesting
250
00:14:17.279 --> 00:14:22.159
sort of story because the Lano basically adopts the tour's structure.
251
00:14:22.799 --> 00:14:26.240
So his four main books and the chapter divisions in
252
00:14:26.320 --> 00:14:30.240
between them are taken from from the tour. Now the
253
00:14:30.879 --> 00:14:34.399
is written BYO raviosv. Cairo, who really begins by writing
254
00:14:34.440 --> 00:14:39.559
a Betjo Seth right, his sort of encyclopedic compendium slash
255
00:14:39.559 --> 00:14:43.360
commentary written as a commentary on the tour. And if
256
00:14:43.559 --> 00:14:45.799
we had the bay, if we had Joseph Cairo here
257
00:14:45.840 --> 00:14:48.200
on the podcast, he would say, that is my work.
258
00:14:48.399 --> 00:14:50.639
That is how be remembered, That is my by it right,
259
00:14:50.679 --> 00:14:53.600
that is my estate. I think people trys to his house,
260
00:14:53.639 --> 00:14:54.799
but if you look at how he writes it, I
261
00:14:54.840 --> 00:14:56.679
think like, sort of the estate of your states is
262
00:14:56.679 --> 00:14:59.879
probably the way I would say it. Then later on
263
00:15:00.039 --> 00:15:01.679
he said, you know what, that's a very long and
264
00:15:01.840 --> 00:15:04.840
complicated work let me try to summarize the main points
265
00:15:04.879 --> 00:15:07.080
from it. And he did that, and he called the
266
00:15:07.080 --> 00:15:09.639
shikhanaruch like I'm sending the table for you. This is
267
00:15:09.720 --> 00:15:11.960
the kind of head notes of it. And that's the
268
00:15:11.960 --> 00:15:15.840
way it reads. But you know, whatever revosif Cairo intended
269
00:15:16.159 --> 00:15:19.559
history had it, or Hashkeetha had it, maybe those are
270
00:15:19.559 --> 00:15:23.080
the same thing that that became the work that we
271
00:15:23.120 --> 00:15:27.840
call colloquially the code of Jewish law. And therefore that
272
00:15:27.879 --> 00:15:32.200
then becomes, since that's published with the commentary of the Rama,
273
00:15:32.240 --> 00:15:34.360
which we'll come back to in a second, that becomes
274
00:15:34.639 --> 00:15:39.240
the main sort of framework of apply Jewish law
really
275
00:15:39.279 --> 00:15:42.759
to this day. We might talk about more contemporary innovations
276
00:15:42.799 --> 00:15:45.039
in a second. Just a word on the Rama. So
277
00:15:45.159 --> 00:15:48.639
Ravos if Cairo is from the Spardik tradition and was
278
00:15:48.720 --> 00:15:53.399
largely very influenced by the Rambam and is somewhat less
279
00:15:53.399 --> 00:15:58.480
influenced by the ballets vote and the Ashkenazic tradition. The
280
00:15:58.559 --> 00:16:00.759
Rama who's re of motion is who lives in the
281
00:16:00.799 --> 00:16:04.559
crackout at roughly the same time that Ragulosa Kiro was
282
00:16:04.559 --> 00:16:08.000
writing in Spot sees this work and then adds his
283
00:16:08.039 --> 00:16:11.960
own glosses to it, reflecting more of the Ashagnasok school
284
00:16:11.960 --> 00:16:14.600
of thought, and many scholars say that the success of
285
00:16:14.639 --> 00:16:18.399
this work is precisely because it combines both of these,
286
00:16:18.399 --> 00:16:20.519
and basically since the very first printing of the bait
287
00:16:20.799 --> 00:16:23.440
of the Schoharu, which was just him, from the second
288
00:16:23.480 --> 00:16:27.039
printing on it has always been published with the Hagota rama,
289
00:16:27.799 --> 00:16:30.799
the commentary or the editions of the rama, and together
290
00:16:31.000 --> 00:16:33.399
those are sort of known as the shukan.
291
00:16:33.799 --> 00:16:37.960
Right, and so those are as you outlined it with
292
00:16:38.039 --> 00:16:42.879
admirable sucinctness. I think the three major ones have there
293
00:16:42.879 --> 00:16:45.919
been codes ever since because one could argue possibly, but
294
00:16:45.960 --> 00:16:49.559
since the shukar there is only commentary. Is that is
295
00:16:49.559 --> 00:16:50.200
that plausible?
296
00:16:50.840 --> 00:16:55.399
So I would say yes, and no, you know, there's
297
00:16:55.480 --> 00:16:58.600
one could say that. And really the tour they sort
298
00:16:58.600 --> 00:17:01.559
of have to be taken together because structure they basically
299
00:17:01.559 --> 00:17:05.960
displaced the Rambam. So, you know, I think as a
300
00:17:06.400 --> 00:17:11.160
artistic manner, the rambum is a superior work. It's conceptually organized,
301
00:17:11.400 --> 00:17:15.559
language is clear and beautiful, it's an ingenious structure. But
302
00:17:15.680 --> 00:17:19.839
basically the while the Rambam as his Halakic sock, becomes
303
00:17:19.839 --> 00:17:24.200
super important. His wave of organizing and conceptualizing Halaha. Doesn't
304
00:17:24.720 --> 00:17:27.720
that really belongs to to the tour? And then I
305
00:17:27.720 --> 00:17:29.079
would like to say the tour because I think he
306
00:17:29.079 --> 00:17:31.599
gets short terped He came up with the structure. Others
307
00:17:31.599 --> 00:17:34.160
built on it in part because the rama deals with
308
00:17:34.240 --> 00:17:39.759
everything and the tour really deals only
with practice Tamaha. Now,
309
00:17:39.920 --> 00:17:43.440
since then, as you said, there's there's then in the
310
00:17:43.519 --> 00:17:48.240
generations after, there's waves of commentaries on it, some written
311
00:17:48.440 --> 00:17:53.160
directly as commentaries in terms of new codifications. The one
312
00:17:53.200 --> 00:17:56.039
that I think everyone would point to Isan and one
313
00:17:56.039 --> 00:17:59.960
will notice the wordplay there, which doesn't cover every single thing,
314
00:18:00.160 --> 00:18:03.440
but most of it. And it's a sort of assimilative
315
00:18:04.160 --> 00:18:07.759
commentary code. In other words, it's written with the same
316
00:18:07.880 --> 00:18:12.000
chapter headings and as the Shokhan Ruch, and it tries
317
00:18:12.039 --> 00:18:15.119
to kind of retell the Sugia if it starts with
318
00:18:15.200 --> 00:18:17.400
Pukim from Sukim, if it starts from the Gamar from
319
00:18:17.400 --> 00:18:20.519
the Gamara, and kind of fold in all the various
320
00:18:20.680 --> 00:18:24.200
kind of commentaries that have come on along the way.
321
00:18:24.799 --> 00:18:27.559
It's very influential because it's very well written. The other
322
00:18:27.680 --> 00:18:31.079
famous one is only on Orsiam is the Mission of Brewer,
323
00:18:31.200 --> 00:18:34.440
which you know, takes a large space, particularly on issues
324
00:18:34.440 --> 00:18:36.839
that it relates to. But it, as you noted, is
325
00:18:36.880 --> 00:18:40.400
really written as a commentary on the Shokran Ruhe, although
326
00:18:41.279 --> 00:18:43.079
you know, it's a little bit of its own thing,
327
00:18:43.119 --> 00:18:45.359
but at least that's the way it's graphically written, and
328
00:18:45.400 --> 00:18:47.039
that's the way it's meant to be read. It is
329
00:18:47.119 --> 00:18:49.640
it is on the Chican roof. You know. In more
330
00:18:49.680 --> 00:18:55.039
recent times, certainly certain areas of Alaha, particularly areas that
331
00:18:55.240 --> 00:18:59.319
are not well covered in the Chokan, have seen various
332
00:18:59.440 --> 00:19:02.599
kind of codes and treatments to them, but none have
333
00:19:03.160 --> 00:19:07.359
reached the sort of level of the ubiquitous uh both
334
00:19:07.400 --> 00:19:11.599
popularity and authority as the as the But for example,
335
00:19:11.640 --> 00:19:15.960
I have on on matters of hoshin Mishbat, there's a
336
00:19:16.000 --> 00:19:19.920
ten volume treatise called Pitre Fochen or Peture Fosian, written
337
00:19:19.960 --> 00:19:22.559
by a rabbi who lived in New Shilaim in the
338
00:19:22.640 --> 00:19:24.880
latter half of the twentieth century, which for anyone involved
339
00:19:24.920 --> 00:19:28.920
in that world is very influential. One's doing Arevin or Micava,
340
00:19:29.319 --> 00:19:32.319
door Trumant de Mastro. You know, there's there's there's various
341
00:19:32.359 --> 00:19:35.839
sort of areas, specific things that have become very important.
342
00:19:36.240 --> 00:19:39.200
But in terms of this sort of monumental thing that
343
00:19:39.240 --> 00:19:42.920
everyone understands the code, I think it remains with the Chikan.
344
00:19:43.440 --> 00:19:47.000
I would say one fairly interesting and new development is
345
00:19:47.400 --> 00:19:50.839
Rabbail Lazar Malhammad in Israel has been writing a series
346
00:19:50.839 --> 00:19:54.119
of books called nine Hawaja, which is a kind of
347
00:19:54.240 --> 00:19:57.680
modern recasting and has become very very popular in sort
348
00:19:57.680 --> 00:20:00.680
of the datilu me community in in Israel, and of
349
00:20:00.680 --> 00:20:03.799
course hasn't replaces, but I think it might be replacing
350
00:20:03.839 --> 00:20:07.160
the mission of Brewer. It's more modern Hebrew, it's it
351
00:20:07.200 --> 00:20:11.119
has also theological framework to it, finishing work that's worth
352
00:20:11.119 --> 00:20:14.000
study itself. So that's sort of the way I see
353
00:20:14.039 --> 00:20:15.720
the lay of the land at the moment.
354
00:20:16.880 --> 00:20:19.400
Okay, fair enough, Now let's uh, I do to ask
355
00:20:19.400 --> 00:20:21.920
a little bit more about codes. But before I do,
356
00:20:22.039 --> 00:20:25.319
I mean the sort of I think crux the central
357
00:20:25.400 --> 00:20:27.920
question I really want to ask here is, you know,
358
00:20:28.000 --> 00:20:30.920
what are the advantages or disadvantags of writing in these
359
00:20:30.920 --> 00:20:33.039
two genres, because in some senses, of course, they are opposite.
360
00:20:33.759 --> 00:20:35.720
And I'll let you elaborate on that, but sort of
361
00:20:35.920 --> 00:20:38.480
what can one do in a code that one can't
362
00:20:38.480 --> 00:20:39.720
do in response and vice?
363
00:20:39.799 --> 00:20:39.960
Vice?
364
00:20:40.000 --> 00:20:43.400
And what would push one to write or read or
365
00:20:43.440 --> 00:20:47.039
adopt a code like a way of writing halaa? What
366
00:20:47.079 --> 00:20:50.319
would push one towards a responsor manner of writing and
367
00:20:50.359 --> 00:20:52.119
reading an application of halaca?
368
00:20:52.319 --> 00:20:55.079
Sure, so let me start not in the Halaki tradition,
369
00:20:55.200 --> 00:20:59.039
but in the Western tradition. So the common law, which
370
00:20:59.079 --> 00:21:01.519
is the system that is from England and this sort
371
00:21:01.519 --> 00:21:05.119
of the basis of American, Canadian, Australian and all the
372
00:21:05.160 --> 00:21:08.119
English speaking law, has a very different view on this
373
00:21:08.200 --> 00:21:11.519
from from the systems emerging in continental Europe, which typically
374
00:21:11.519 --> 00:21:15.920
called the Romanist systems. The common law believes that that
375
00:21:15.920 --> 00:21:19.480
that really it's the reality of a case with its
376
00:21:19.519 --> 00:21:24.400
specific facts and the pressures of coming to a determination
377
00:21:25.079 --> 00:21:28.039
that sort of produces the ideal law right, and it's
378
00:21:28.079 --> 00:21:30.839
only and that law must be forged within the context
379
00:21:31.000 --> 00:21:36.079
of a decision that will be actuated, that has that
380
00:21:36.240 --> 00:21:39.480
is sort of coming from a particular case. And sometimes
381
00:21:39.519 --> 00:21:42.160
it's called law in action, or at least it tells
382
00:21:42.160 --> 00:21:45.119
that way, and it is a little bit suspicious of
383
00:21:45.200 --> 00:21:48.440
more academic projects what it calls law in the books
384
00:21:48.720 --> 00:21:51.440
that are sort of dealing with sort of abstract principles
385
00:21:51.839 --> 00:21:56.200
but not forged within the sort of reality or the
386
00:21:56.279 --> 00:22:00.039
you know, the potentiality of being effectuated the Roman in
387
00:22:00.079 --> 00:22:03.480
this systems. Think the opposite is that the only way
388
00:22:03.480 --> 00:22:05.400
to do this right is to step back and have
389
00:22:05.440 --> 00:22:08.880
a plan and have your concepts, and have that kind
390
00:22:08.880 --> 00:22:12.319
of carry through each and every bit of the law
391
00:22:12.640 --> 00:22:16.319
creating or law writing enterprise, and that every specific case
392
00:22:16.440 --> 00:22:19.119
is too tied to the quirks of its facts or
393
00:22:19.160 --> 00:22:21.880
any kind of particular things that come up there, or
394
00:22:21.920 --> 00:22:26.160
any pressures of the moment or any exigencies to trust it.
395
00:22:26.200 --> 00:22:28.839
And also so that is again that we have not
396
00:22:28.880 --> 00:22:30.839
talked about Jewish law yet. But this is kind of
397
00:22:30.880 --> 00:22:33.559
like there are two broadly speaking, and I'm a little
398
00:22:33.599 --> 00:22:36.319
over dramatizing, but there are kind of two schools of
399
00:22:36.480 --> 00:22:39.680
thought about this, and I think you see these reflected
400
00:22:39.680 --> 00:22:42.119
in the Halachic literature as well. If we start with
401
00:22:42.160 --> 00:22:44.000
the round bomb, right, if you want to kind of
402
00:22:44.079 --> 00:22:47.640
give you a map of what is Halatha, the only
403
00:22:47.680 --> 00:22:50.240
way to do that is to write a book where
404
00:22:50.279 --> 00:22:52.440
you know what you're doing at the outset and you
405
00:22:52.519 --> 00:22:55.720
understand the plan, and the round bomb is the master planner. Right.
406
00:22:56.079 --> 00:22:59.480
You have your divisions, you have your conceptual categories, you
407
00:22:59.559 --> 00:23:02.079
start each book and then each chapter and then each
408
00:23:02.119 --> 00:23:04.640
halaca with an idea of where it's going and how
409
00:23:04.680 --> 00:23:08.920
it goes right, and that gives you that overview. In addition,
410
00:23:09.400 --> 00:23:12.400
as we said, when you're writing a book, you know
411
00:23:12.480 --> 00:23:14.519
you're going to publish it, you know what you're doing
412
00:23:14.599 --> 00:23:17.480
with it. Right by contrast, right, if we're going to
413
00:23:17.519 --> 00:23:21.160
take that perspective, as we all know, sometimes you know,
414
00:23:21.960 --> 00:23:24.559
rabbis have to answer questions really quickly. They kind of
415
00:23:24.599 --> 00:23:26.960
give an answer, am I saying that this is an
416
00:23:26.960 --> 00:23:30.279
answer that like for generations is quote the halacha or
417
00:23:30.279 --> 00:23:32.759
am I like just answering a question here and now
418
00:23:33.599 --> 00:23:35.599
if one reads the true of literature, you'll see last
419
00:23:35.640 --> 00:23:37.720
of ways, I'm in a hurry, I don't have time,
420
00:23:37.799 --> 00:23:39.400
I don't have access to all my books. You know,
421
00:23:39.440 --> 00:23:43.319
these sort of catchphrases repeat throughout, So that would be
422
00:23:43.400 --> 00:23:45.720
sort of you know, the sort of why the codes
423
00:23:45.759 --> 00:23:48.279
are the actual halaka and an idea of that like look,
424
00:23:49.599 --> 00:23:50.680
you know and I get it too. This in my
425
00:23:50.680 --> 00:23:53.119
book a little bit like the true halacha is these
426
00:23:53.200 --> 00:23:56.920
like more abstract principles and ideals that are stated generally.
427
00:23:57.480 --> 00:24:00.559
And we shouldn't confuse that with like specific applays that
428
00:24:00.599 --> 00:24:05.519
are always attentive to the moment. Revlustenstein has this effer
429
00:24:05.559 --> 00:24:09.000
sing what he calls stock and Sika. Right. So, SOACA
430
00:24:09.079 --> 00:24:12.240
is the sort of the enduring halak An efficiency is
431
00:24:12.279 --> 00:24:14.920
a localized application. And you could take the opposite view
432
00:24:15.480 --> 00:24:19.279
that no, exactly, it's that when all those pressures of
433
00:24:19.799 --> 00:24:22.680
both what the sources say, and there's a critique would
434
00:24:22.680 --> 00:24:26.279
be that it's too classical, it's too source driven, it's
435
00:24:26.319 --> 00:24:29.279
too driven by the kind of abstractions and not about
436
00:24:29.359 --> 00:24:32.359
real life. And that really when you want to see
437
00:24:32.400 --> 00:24:36.519
when all the pressures come together and precisely within those contingencies,
438
00:24:36.599 --> 00:24:39.960
within those places, because that's where life happens. That how
439
00:24:40.000 --> 00:24:43.240
that emerges from there is the sort of the more
440
00:24:43.559 --> 00:24:46.359
authentic products or the sort of better way to understand
441
00:24:46.480 --> 00:24:49.559
how the system works. Again, this debate exists outside of
442
00:24:49.599 --> 00:24:52.200
Alosa and exists within Alaha. Right.
443
00:24:52.480 --> 00:24:58.480
And and do you think that the mapping of this
444
00:24:58.599 --> 00:25:01.880
difference between common law or case law and let's say
445
00:25:02.160 --> 00:25:04.200
Roman or constitutional law havings that you want
to put it?
446
00:25:04.640 --> 00:25:07.720
Does this how accurately does this map on to the
447
00:25:07.759 --> 00:25:10.079
code's response issue within Jewish law?
448
00:25:11.079 --> 00:25:16.039
I think it maps on to some degree. The codes
449
00:25:16.200 --> 00:25:20.880
also tend to be what I would call they're quite
450
00:25:20.960 --> 00:25:24.359
classical in the sense of their their they're responding to
451
00:25:24.440 --> 00:25:28.160
the tamuk sugia and the way that that is organized. Right,
452
00:25:28.279 --> 00:25:30.960
this is certainly true of the rambamb. It's true in
453
00:25:31.000 --> 00:25:33.559
the tours, slightly less true, but they're too so in
454
00:25:33.640 --> 00:25:37.000
other words, what cases they're talking about, right, what are
455
00:25:37.079 --> 00:25:40.359
their examples, what are their paradigms? Are a function of
456
00:25:40.519 --> 00:25:42.519
the mission and the talmud to some degree, and then
457
00:25:42.640 --> 00:25:45.559
some of the commentary of the reshowing that becomes standard.
458
00:25:46.319 --> 00:25:48.359
You'll see in the tour, for instance, it's very clear
459
00:25:48.440 --> 00:25:51.000
he'll always start with like the mission and then the gamar,
460
00:25:51.079 --> 00:25:54.079
and then occasionally he'll say certain things came up in
461
00:25:54.079 --> 00:25:56.920
a certain to vote right. This is another point that
462
00:25:57.000 --> 00:26:00.319
they also intermix. So the rush, his father is one
463
00:26:00.319 --> 00:26:04.599
of the well known uh meshivin of his era and
464
00:26:04.720 --> 00:26:08.319
especially in holocient Mish. But he'll Evanezer, he'll bring a
465
00:26:08.359 --> 00:26:10.839
lot of stuff from the rush and the rush, but
466
00:26:10.960 --> 00:26:13.200
in various things, right, But those will be at the
467
00:26:13.440 --> 00:26:15.799
end and they'll be sort of like there, and then
468
00:26:15.880 --> 00:26:18.920
that'll kind of feed into itself, which will often kind
469
00:26:18.960 --> 00:26:23.759
of retain this structure. So therefore, you know, what they're
470
00:26:24.119 --> 00:26:27.680
less responsive to is like what's happening in the world. Okay,
471
00:26:27.720 --> 00:26:30.519
but you know, to take the example anyone who's studied
472
00:26:30.519 --> 00:26:33.079
babakama with a kid, but we don't have oxen, but
473
00:26:33.200 --> 00:26:35.559
all the examples there have oxen, right, and then like
474
00:26:35.640 --> 00:26:38.960
that's or boor or ash. In other words, the codes
475
00:26:39.160 --> 00:26:43.920
tend because they are they're assimilating talmudic information in the
476
00:26:44.000 --> 00:26:46.400
way they're mapping the sudiya based on how they see
477
00:26:46.400 --> 00:26:49.200
the tama. They tend to be very classical, where a
478
00:26:49.279 --> 00:26:52.200
chuva is going to start with the facts that happen
479
00:26:52.359 --> 00:26:54.480
in the world, in our world or the world of
480
00:26:54.599 --> 00:26:57.160
the writer, and then say, okay, now let me go
481
00:26:57.359 --> 00:27:00.720
and see which are the relevant sudio that to bring
482
00:27:00.799 --> 00:27:04.319
in here. So you have that process of translating both
483
00:27:04.359 --> 00:27:08.960
the language and the conceptual architecture of the classical sources
484
00:27:09.279 --> 00:27:12.640
into the real world in which the the may sheave
485
00:27:13.480 --> 00:27:14.480
is operating in.
486
00:27:16.559 --> 00:27:20.559
Right, And it seems, at least from an immediate look,
487
00:27:21.000 --> 00:27:24.359
that one can one can apply quite a bit more
488
00:27:24.799 --> 00:27:28.519
creativity or wiggle room within a response that than one
489
00:27:28.599 --> 00:27:32.519
can in a code. I mean, is that the case?
490
00:27:32.920 --> 00:27:35.920
And secondly, you know, is that simply a function of
491
00:27:36.720 --> 00:27:39.039
the way that genre is exists.
492
00:27:40.400 --> 00:27:42.119
Yeah, so let's let's let's talk about I think the
493
00:27:42.279 --> 00:27:46.039
I think the CEO in different ways. The one let's
494
00:27:46.119 --> 00:27:52.480
remember that what we call the essay, right, is not
495
00:27:52.960 --> 00:27:56.599
a known genre of as you said, I think you
496
00:27:56.640 --> 00:27:59.400
said this in the outside. There's basically three genres of
497
00:27:59.480 --> 00:28:05.839
classical There is commentary rashi post quote right, usually following
498
00:28:05.920 --> 00:28:09.759
the order of the Talmudic trac date. There are these codes,
499
00:28:09.960 --> 00:28:13.680
and then commentaries on the codes, and then there's a
500
00:28:13.799 --> 00:28:16.480
chew vote the response. The response is the most open
501
00:28:16.640 --> 00:28:18.400
ended of those. So, in other words, if one wants
502
00:28:18.440 --> 00:28:21.960
to publish a Halakic essay right, so today already you
503
00:28:21.960 --> 00:28:24.440
can write an article and publish it in a Halakic journal.
504
00:28:24.559 --> 00:28:28.200
But that's a fairly new sort of thing. It's really
505
00:28:28.279 --> 00:28:31.119
the chuva is the vehicle for that. So in that sense,
506
00:28:31.200 --> 00:28:35.640
it's the most flexible form. You don't have to pretend
507
00:28:35.839 --> 00:28:38.319
that it's a commentary on something. You could just say,
508
00:28:38.440 --> 00:28:41.000
here's what I want to say. Now, there's a history
509
00:28:41.039 --> 00:28:43.119
to this too. If you think of the names, and
510
00:28:43.519 --> 00:28:45.720
you know, if we think let's say that you vote
511
00:28:45.759 --> 00:28:49.759
of the rishi name, right, they're called the Chuvashirashba, the
512
00:28:49.839 --> 00:28:53.480
Chuvashi rush, et cetera. In other words, these people are
513
00:28:53.680 --> 00:28:58.519
known as typically tumudic commentators or codifiers or quasi codifiers.
514
00:28:58.839 --> 00:29:02.559
And then we also have their tew vote. They're on uh.
515
00:29:02.880 --> 00:29:06.400
I think a little bit later, the very famous ones,
516
00:29:07.759 --> 00:29:13.039
the Hahamsi, the no Huda, that's tm Sofer, the Massa
517
00:29:13.079 --> 00:29:15.720
bin Yemen. Those are the names of the Chubas farm,
518
00:29:15.799 --> 00:29:19.119
the Sagotari, right, and we know them by by dint
519
00:29:19.160 --> 00:29:21.799
of their Tubas farm. And then oh, they also wrote
520
00:29:21.839 --> 00:29:24.480
these these other things. And part of what's happening there,
521
00:29:24.480 --> 00:29:26.680
I think is that I think this has to probably
522
00:29:26.720 --> 00:29:28.799
do with printing and with other developments, is that the
523
00:29:28.880 --> 00:29:32.559
tuba can now become the primary vehicle through which a
524
00:29:33.279 --> 00:29:38.240
rabbinic author is no and they're right, they become to
525
00:29:38.359 --> 00:29:42.799
some degree essays on halahik topics, whether the questions were
526
00:29:42.880 --> 00:29:45.359
asked to them or whether they ask themselves the questions
527
00:29:45.400 --> 00:29:47.440
and things like that. So I do think that in
528
00:29:47.559 --> 00:29:51.240
that sense it's a more flexible form which allows for
529
00:29:51.359 --> 00:29:55.160
greater creativity, greater literary flair, right, there's often they start
530
00:29:55.240 --> 00:29:57.279
with kind of poems and things like that, things that
531
00:29:57.400 --> 00:30:01.039
in a code and in so much more mode of discourse.
532
00:30:01.039 --> 00:30:04.559
In other words, yes, there are shacks that run for
533
00:30:04.720 --> 00:30:07.480
three pages, but basically they're very tight and focused on
534
00:30:07.640 --> 00:30:09.960
what the specific thing. So think of this as as
535
00:30:10.039 --> 00:30:13.160
your way to do an essay. If you're a binic writer,
536
00:30:13.279 --> 00:30:15.440
you're going to use the tube of form. The other
537
00:30:15.559 --> 00:30:17.359
thing is, and this is you know, something that in
538
00:30:17.440 --> 00:30:20.680
legal philosophy we talk about about is that the very
539
00:30:20.880 --> 00:30:25.799
active ap application two concrete facts is what generates kind
540
00:30:25.839 --> 00:30:29.400
of creativity. Right, So I always say, if one looks
541
00:30:29.880 --> 00:30:33.960
at the laws of bore and ash hit and fire
542
00:30:34.079 --> 00:30:37.759
liability in the rob bumb and then a couple hundred
543
00:30:37.880 --> 00:30:40.759
years later in the Chanch, they're basically the same. And
544
00:30:40.839 --> 00:30:45.119
what that tells you is those were not applied, those
545
00:30:45.200 --> 00:30:48.319
are not applied them. Therefore they it's just basically copy paste.
546
00:30:48.359 --> 00:30:50.839
By contrast, if one looks at he'll hoach star rote
547
00:30:51.240 --> 00:30:55.680
or he'll hotel vote debts, negotiated instruments, of which in
548
00:30:55.759 --> 00:30:59.359
the ear of reshowing them,
there's tremendous creativity. The world
549
00:30:59.440 --> 00:31:03.920
of the tour look completely different than the realbum. So
550
00:31:04.079 --> 00:31:08.079
the act of applying law two concrete situations changes it
551
00:31:08.200 --> 00:31:10.599
and molds it and modifies it. And in that sense,
552
00:31:11.200 --> 00:31:14.319
I think that is at least the first cut is
553
00:31:14.400 --> 00:31:18.240
done in chew vote. Later chew vote may become part
554
00:31:18.319 --> 00:31:21.160
of the kind of canonized law. Right. Like we said,
555
00:31:21.519 --> 00:31:23.759
the tour contains a number of chew vote of the rush,
556
00:31:24.559 --> 00:31:28.359
the shah schite site, chew vote, et cetera. And there's
557
00:31:28.400 --> 00:31:32.680
this interesting interplay of how these different genres commentary code
558
00:31:33.240 --> 00:31:37.920
and Cuba influence and impact each other. I see.
559
00:31:39.400 --> 00:31:41.640
I mean focusing back on the codes for a moment.
560
00:31:42.000 --> 00:31:43.960
You claim something quite interesting in your work, which is
561
00:31:44.039 --> 00:31:48.119
that that the code, the Halai code, at least can
562
00:31:48.279 --> 00:31:51.759
never fully achieve its purpose. And that struck me as
563
00:31:51.759 --> 00:31:55.799
a very interesting and thought provoking claim. Could you elaborate
564
00:31:56.000 --> 00:31:58.599
on that for us? What is it about the laha
565
00:31:58.720 --> 00:32:04.160
that frustra rates the composition or the ultimate aim of
566
00:32:04.200 --> 00:32:05.359
a composition of a low code?
567
00:32:06.000 --> 00:32:09.519
Sure, so let's start with that. Lasting if you think,
568
00:32:09.640 --> 00:32:11.440
and there's an if here, that the point here is
569
00:32:11.480 --> 00:32:16.759
to tell you clear and unequivocal rules, right, So, I
570
00:32:16.839 --> 00:32:19.799
think there's a few things going on, some relevant to
571
00:32:19.880 --> 00:32:24.079
Halaha specifically, and some possibly found in various forms in
572
00:32:24.119 --> 00:32:26.440
all legal systems. So one of the themes of my
573
00:32:26.599 --> 00:32:31.319
book is the idea of Tamutah right, that the study
574
00:32:31.400 --> 00:32:35.720
of Torah is its own goal, right, it's its own
575
00:32:36.000 --> 00:32:41.319
self standing, self justifying practice, and that anyone who is
576
00:32:41.920 --> 00:32:46.519
sort of known as a alahk authority sort of subscribes
577
00:32:46.599 --> 00:32:50.839
to some version of this idea. Okay, there were different
578
00:32:50.920 --> 00:32:54.160
in different times, in different eras Ashkin aspired, etc. But
579
00:32:54.440 --> 00:32:57.839
something like that, and therefore very different than any other
580
00:32:57.960 --> 00:33:03.039
legal system in which the production of law its goal
581
00:33:03.279 --> 00:33:08.680
is ultimately to regulate the social and political sphere. In Halaha,
582
00:33:09.839 --> 00:33:12.519
because of this idea of tomatoa that is so central
583
00:33:12.599 --> 00:33:15.839
to the rabbis of the Tumutin exerts a tremendous influence
584
00:33:15.880 --> 00:33:18.640
on everyone after. Is that no, there are what we'll
585
00:33:18.680 --> 00:33:22.160
call spiritual purposes in the study of law. Now again,
586
00:33:22.440 --> 00:33:25.319
these change over time and in different places, they're not consistent,
587
00:33:25.400 --> 00:33:29.440
but that idea is there, and therefore I think that
588
00:33:30.039 --> 00:33:32.319
you even I would say not it's not that these
589
00:33:32.359 --> 00:33:34.359
what the codes are, but they even in the codes
590
00:33:34.400 --> 00:33:37.000
which in sum sets are trying to just get to
591
00:33:37.079 --> 00:33:41.319
the bottom line. But the authors also have another investment,
592
00:33:41.359 --> 00:33:45.559
the investment in Thura study in explicating the Tamudik studia.
593
00:33:45.880 --> 00:33:49.599
In other words, that instinct of Tubdi commentary is there too.
594
00:33:50.279 --> 00:33:53.359
And therefore I think one of the reasons that it fails,
595
00:33:53.680 --> 00:33:57.079
so to speak, is because there are While there are
596
00:33:57.119 --> 00:33:59.680
some works that really do try to just tell you
597
00:33:59.759 --> 00:34:02.720
the rules, inevitably the commentaries are going to say, oh,
598
00:34:02.799 --> 00:34:05.640
but what about this talmudic ciay, what about this tostboon,
599
00:34:05.720 --> 00:34:07.839
and what about this other thing? And they'll they'll they'll
600
00:34:08.000 --> 00:34:11.239
just kind of re enter it into that toal munic dialogue.
601
00:34:11.679 --> 00:34:14.039
Perhaps the most dramatic example of this is not in
602
00:34:14.079 --> 00:34:17.280
the In the Rambam, the ram Bumb says that he's
603
00:34:17.360 --> 00:34:20.880
trying to end the kind of need to consult the talmad,
604
00:34:20.960 --> 00:34:25.480
and therefore presents its very clean. It's long, but it's
605
00:34:25.519 --> 00:34:27.880
sort of given where it's coming from, it's ultimately short
606
00:34:28.000 --> 00:34:31.559
compared to the tamud tight text. The he says, now
607
00:34:31.599 --> 00:34:33.880
you could just look at this and know the rules,
608
00:34:33.920 --> 00:34:36.480
and you don't need to do that. You don't need
609
00:34:36.559 --> 00:34:38.360
to work your way through the tamad. And as you know,
610
00:34:39.079 --> 00:34:42.440
almost immediately when that starts happening. People then write commentaries
611
00:34:42.480 --> 00:34:48.039
and they basically start reintegrating the rambamb into the Tummunk discussion,
612
00:34:48.079 --> 00:34:50.079
so much so that in the nineteenth century and the
613
00:34:50.519 --> 00:34:54.880
Brisker school, the ram bumb was, you know, the kind
614
00:34:54.920 --> 00:34:57.679
of source material from which they did the exact opposite
615
00:34:57.719 --> 00:35:01.119
of what he intended. They they made
it the basis
616
00:35:01.199 --> 00:35:04.639
of their very analytical and very creative but very not
617
00:35:04.800 --> 00:35:07.960
bottom line discussions, right, And I think like the fact
618
00:35:08.000 --> 00:35:10.159
that they're at checking the ram bomb are there are
619
00:35:10.199 --> 00:35:13.000
reasons for that, but it's one cannot but laugh that
620
00:35:13.159 --> 00:35:15.599
it basically turned what the rama was trying to do
621
00:35:15.719 --> 00:35:18.719
inside out. I think with it's less dramatic. But if
622
00:35:18.719 --> 00:35:21.199
we think it's some of the main commentaries again learned
623
00:35:21.199 --> 00:35:24.000
in Yeshivai, So so it's a hot the the Cebos,
624
00:35:25.000 --> 00:35:27.920
to some degree, the Shah, they are all involved in
625
00:35:28.000 --> 00:35:32.440
this process of sort of expanding the Talmudic dialogue outwards.
626
00:35:32.480 --> 00:35:34.800
Now there's also commentaries that go the other way, but
627
00:35:35.320 --> 00:35:38.599
but there's that push and pull between those and therefore
628
00:35:38.880 --> 00:35:43.000
to some degree, the codes themselves. And if you look
629
00:35:43.039 --> 00:35:46.360
at just the page of the standard Skan's it's it's
630
00:35:46.519 --> 00:35:49.280
literally dizzy. So's so that you know, about twenty years ago,
631
00:35:49.480 --> 00:35:51.320
thirty years ago they started reprinting it to make it
632
00:35:51.400 --> 00:35:54.800
a little more and it just became another focus of
633
00:35:55.039 --> 00:35:59.000
tourist study with a slightly different entry point at the
634
00:35:59.119 --> 00:36:02.360
same time having this other goal of the bottom line rules. Now,
635
00:36:02.400 --> 00:36:04.400
I think that that's true of the Mishtah, that's true
636
00:36:04.400 --> 00:36:06.159
of the tumud that started through all the way down
637
00:36:06.159 --> 00:36:08.280
this right right book. That's one of the central tensions
638
00:36:08.559 --> 00:36:11.079
within the Holarism as a whole is that we use
639
00:36:11.119 --> 00:36:14.000
the same body of materials to do different things with it.
640
00:36:14.119 --> 00:36:16.800
And I think the literature reflects that that is something
641
00:36:16.880 --> 00:36:20.119
you don't really have in other systems. Now, I think
642
00:36:20.159 --> 00:36:21.960
in other since you do have this that you know,
643
00:36:22.039 --> 00:36:26.599
as soon as something becomes codified, there's always wrinkles to it,
644
00:36:26.639 --> 00:36:29.599
there's always new developments that that sort of complicated and
645
00:36:29.719 --> 00:36:34.920
that you have everywhere. The Marshall in the sixteenth century
646
00:36:35.559 --> 00:36:38.800
gave a kabbalistic sort of reason for this is drawing
647
00:36:38.840 --> 00:36:42.159
on earlier sources, but he's criticizing the then Code of
648
00:36:42.280 --> 00:36:45.480
Fying movement, and he says he says it's sort of
649
00:36:45.559 --> 00:36:48.000
about the nature of ala has the encounter between the
650
00:36:48.119 --> 00:36:51.280
infinite God and the finite man, and it is not
651
00:36:51.480 --> 00:36:55.480
something reducible to a finite code, is one of his claims, right,
652
00:36:55.599 --> 00:36:57.800
So he says, it cuts to the very nature of
653
00:36:58.239 --> 00:37:01.840
what Halifa is as a meeting between an infinite mind
654
00:37:01.920 --> 00:37:04.239
and a finite mind, and the finite mind is going
655
00:37:04.320 --> 00:37:06.280
to try to kind of limit it to some code,
656
00:37:06.320 --> 00:37:09.960
and it's never going to work because there's always more there.
657
00:37:10.320 --> 00:37:12.760
And the little bit ask a slight procketive question about that,
658
00:37:12.760 --> 00:37:16.360
which is that is that necessarily the case? In other words,
659
00:37:16.480 --> 00:37:21.199
could you imagine, even in theory, the construction of such
660
00:37:21.679 --> 00:37:24.920
a detailed or such a such a flawless code that
661
00:37:25.199 --> 00:37:29.639
no further commentary would be possible or necessary or meaning.
662
00:37:29.840 --> 00:37:32.719
And thords the enormous amount of commentary that has been
663
00:37:33.159 --> 00:37:37.079
precipitated by the rama by others, one could say that's
664
00:37:37.079 --> 00:37:41.119
because either there were you know, in some area's lack
665
00:37:41.159 --> 00:37:45.760
of clarity, or questions that arose, perhaps internal inconsistencies, or
666
00:37:45.840 --> 00:37:47.440
you know, any of the things that would spur on
667
00:37:47.519 --> 00:37:53.119
commentary if somehow a supercomputer were to create a perfect code.
668
00:37:53.159 --> 00:37:56.920
I mean, it's such a thing possible at all? Or
669
00:37:56.960 --> 00:37:59.400
are you saying no. The very nature of the system
670
00:38:00.440 --> 00:38:03.639
demands extra writing for me. I know this is a
671
00:38:03.719 --> 00:38:06.239
rather upset question, but one that's fun to think about it.
672
00:38:06.320 --> 00:38:08.480
Well, it's not so so I think there's a few
673
00:38:08.519 --> 00:38:10.400
things going on here. So first of all, I think
674
00:38:10.719 --> 00:38:13.599
I think the Marshall in his way is asking your
675
00:38:13.679 --> 00:38:16.960
question saying no, it's about the essence amount. I do
676
00:38:17.159 --> 00:38:21.360
think another point has to do with finality, in other words,
677
00:38:24.039 --> 00:38:26.400
and how you view sort of what is the ultimate
678
00:38:26.519 --> 00:38:31.039
Alachic authority, because we tend to say that the Talmud
679
00:38:31.519 --> 00:38:35.679
retains precedence even after the rambamb and even after the
680
00:38:36.480 --> 00:38:39.119
and even after the mission of Burua, right, ultimately, if
681
00:38:39.159 --> 00:38:43.199
you can resort back to the talmudik sugia right, which
682
00:38:43.639 --> 00:38:46.360
is written in anything but a linear, clear sense. So
683
00:38:46.440 --> 00:38:50.519
therefore that's always out there. And while it's true that
684
00:38:50.639 --> 00:38:53.559
we say we possibly like X, but why but not why?
685
00:38:53.920 --> 00:38:55.880
But then a new case comes up and they say, yes,
686
00:38:55.960 --> 00:38:58.800
we possibly like X, but limited to cases one, two
687
00:38:58.840 --> 00:39:01.039
and three, not the four or five and six we do.
688
00:39:01.800 --> 00:39:03.519
Now we've got to go back to the TOMUDXU. Yeah,
689
00:39:03.840 --> 00:39:08.119
I just describe basically howevery you know, this isn't super common. Right,
690
00:39:08.639 --> 00:39:12.719
so that even when we accept the authority of the shukanaru,
691
00:39:13.599 --> 00:39:16.400
much of the interpretive process saying I, yes, but that
692
00:39:16.800 --> 00:39:20.360
was here, not here, and my proof is this, Tommy Dixu. Yeah,
693
00:39:20.360 --> 00:39:23.039
and then we're back off to the races. So I
694
00:39:23.280 --> 00:39:26.599
think it would be more possible in let's say, a
695
00:39:26.679 --> 00:39:30.320
modern system which once the court, the High court says
696
00:39:30.440 --> 00:39:32.280
this is what it is. I don't want to say
697
00:39:32.320 --> 00:39:35.039
that solves all questions, but that then cuts off at
698
00:39:35.119 --> 00:39:38.320
least certain avenues. One of the things that is typical
699
00:39:38.400 --> 00:39:43.559
of halakha is that we never, at least in certain traditions, right,
700
00:39:43.760 --> 00:39:46.519
certainly in the sort of traditions that comes from the
701
00:39:46.719 --> 00:39:49.639
you know, Lithuanian yeshibas, we never cut ourselves off from
702
00:39:49.639 --> 00:39:53.039
the tamudxu. Yeah. This goes back to discussions and astized
703
00:39:53.039 --> 00:39:56.079
and because that's always available, and because the tumatif any
704
00:39:56.199 --> 00:39:59.880
is anything but univocal, I think you cannot escape it.
705
00:40:00.320 --> 00:40:02.400
And again I said before also, I think that people
706
00:40:02.559 --> 00:40:06.039
who write these things are living in a world where
707
00:40:06.119 --> 00:40:09.760
Taurus study has this sort of mayan haabet or the
708
00:40:09.840 --> 00:40:13.400
overflowing stream nature to it, and to under we are
709
00:40:13.440 --> 00:40:16.880
attracted to that now, I think there are schools of thoughts,
710
00:40:17.199 --> 00:40:19.440
typically to be more spartic, that tend to be more
711
00:40:19.480 --> 00:40:21.880
bottom line rules. Here's what they are. We can reduce
712
00:40:21.960 --> 00:40:24.920
them to this. But then stuff comes up, and then
713
00:40:25.039 --> 00:40:27.840
but that's not exactly consistent here, it's not consistent here.
714
00:40:28.159 --> 00:40:30.599
Wait a minute, there's this new idea or that maybe
715
00:40:30.679 --> 00:40:33.159
only covers this case, and then we're back to this
716
00:40:33.840 --> 00:40:38.440
sort of diological Talmudic process
with maybe our starting point
717
00:40:38.559 --> 00:40:42.239
not the Talmud but different code provisions or different sections
718
00:40:42.280 --> 00:40:46.480
in the commentaries. But analytically it's that process. So I
719
00:40:46.679 --> 00:40:50.519
think the answer is no. One can give a metaphysical account.
720
00:40:50.599 --> 00:40:54.119
One could say it's no for all legal systems, but
721
00:40:54.199 --> 00:40:59.880
it's certainly in Alaha because of the lack of definitive finale.
722
00:41:00.360 --> 00:41:03.440
There's no governing body. It's just a kind of consensus
723
00:41:03.480 --> 00:41:05.880
that emerges over time, so there's always going to be
724
00:41:06.000 --> 00:41:08.360
gaps and being able to resort backward, and then you're
725
00:41:08.440 --> 00:41:13.639
back into the the analytic discussions, right. I see.
726
00:41:14.119 --> 00:41:16.480
And I want to drill a little bit on one
727
00:41:16.559 --> 00:41:18.360
element that we've been touching on, which is the role
728
00:41:18.480 --> 00:41:21.840
of the commentaries on the codes, because this is interesting
729
00:41:21.840 --> 00:41:24.320
because of course these individuals are not themselves involved in
730
00:41:24.360 --> 00:41:29.360
writing codes, but they are, and but they do have
731
00:41:29.400 --> 00:41:31.920
to certainly play a role in the development and dissemination
732
00:41:32.119 --> 00:41:35.760
of the code itself. So you know, certainly one possible
733
00:41:35.800 --> 00:41:38.480
functions you mentioned the kind of brisk approach approach to
734
00:41:38.559 --> 00:41:42.000
reading the Ramba on others, is to almost reverse engineer
735
00:41:42.960 --> 00:41:45.159
the thinking process that goes into the writing the code,
736
00:41:45.159 --> 00:41:47.280
because of course the code almost by definition is quite sparse,
737
00:41:47.559 --> 00:41:50.280
you know, sparing in its in as these and elaborasm
738
00:41:50.360 --> 00:41:52.599
show it's working as it were, and therefore it's an
739
00:41:52.639 --> 00:41:54.840
exercise for the code to kind of crack that open.
740
00:41:55.599 --> 00:41:59.719
What else are the nose aklim the great commentaries on
741
00:41:59.800 --> 00:42:04.039
the major codes, What else are they doing and in
742
00:42:04.159 --> 00:42:06.360
what in what way do they I don't know, do
743
00:42:06.440 --> 00:42:10.039
they bring the code closer to other genres such as
744
00:42:10.079 --> 00:42:13.239
responso or commentary or other other forms for lack of writing.
745
00:42:13.519 --> 00:42:17.280
Yeah, absolutely so. So first let's just start with this word.
746
00:42:17.440 --> 00:42:19.400
So this is really and I recently had to write
747
00:42:19.440 --> 00:42:23.239
something in English and you realize that there's no equivalent
748
00:42:23.400 --> 00:42:26.679
in in the in the Anglo American system to this
749
00:42:26.880 --> 00:42:30.360
idea of no say kleen right, So literally, they if
750
00:42:30.400 --> 00:42:33.840
we translate the word they are arms bearers right now.
751
00:42:33.960 --> 00:42:37.280
It's interesting to think about this phrase because I think
752
00:42:37.280 --> 00:42:40.320
it even changes over time. What is an arms bearer?
753
00:42:40.920 --> 00:42:43.440
Well, I mean the biblical sense, it's quite literal. It
754
00:42:43.559 --> 00:42:46.159
is someone who you know, goes into battle with someone
755
00:42:46.400 --> 00:42:50.920
as their second or as the person who holds their
756
00:42:51.079 --> 00:42:54.559
their weaponry. And probably you know. I imagine the closest
757
00:42:55.440 --> 00:42:57.440
modern analogy I can think of as a golf caddy,
758
00:42:57.639 --> 00:42:58.079
And that's.
759
00:42:58.039 --> 00:43:02.719
Exactly what I say, I caddy, right, the caddy. Now,
760
00:43:02.920 --> 00:43:05.639
so that way, the caddy is like on your team,
761
00:43:05.800 --> 00:43:09.760
he's helping you, right, But over time that turns to
762
00:43:09.840 --> 00:43:12.639
be no say kalim. They're doing battle with you, right.
763
00:43:12.800 --> 00:43:15.480
In other words, And I think that this idea of
764
00:43:15.519 --> 00:43:19.719
the no say kilem starts as they're going to help
765
00:43:19.840 --> 00:43:24.280
you make your arguments, right, but immediately then they also
766
00:43:24.400 --> 00:43:27.639
are battling you. So it's interesting that there's no such
767
00:43:27.840 --> 00:43:29.880
when when I have to describe this to people don't
768
00:43:29.880 --> 00:43:33.800
know Jewish law, I cannot rest on anything that is known,
769
00:43:33.880 --> 00:43:37.400
even to a lawyer, because such a literature doesn't really exist.
770
00:43:37.559 --> 00:43:39.719
You can write your own book, you can attack that, right,
771
00:43:39.760 --> 00:43:42.239
but you but this idea that you're you're both a
772
00:43:42.360 --> 00:43:47.360
commentary that's supportive but also undermining the sort of finality
773
00:43:47.440 --> 00:43:50.360
of the text of the code is sort of unique,
774
00:43:51.000 --> 00:43:53.960
at least within the legal world I'm aware of. So
775
00:43:54.079 --> 00:43:57.199
this no say kilem, and it's most dramatic on the
776
00:43:57.199 --> 00:44:00.320
Shukan uh because it's printed they have you in the
777
00:44:00.400 --> 00:44:02.320
in the in the nineteenth century when they were the
778
00:44:02.440 --> 00:44:05.199
various publishing houses sort of each try to outdo each
779
00:44:05.199 --> 00:44:08.519
other by how many commentaries they have, which which makes
780
00:44:08.559 --> 00:44:11.559
the page very very difficult to the uninitiated to summat
781
00:44:11.599 --> 00:44:15.679
for voting. But we can sort of categorize them into
782
00:44:15.760 --> 00:44:19.280
different functions. So some we can maybe start at the extreme.
783
00:44:19.400 --> 00:44:22.159
Some really bring it back to the Talmudic dialogue and
784
00:44:22.239 --> 00:44:24.960
are not super interested in what the bottom line rule is,
785
00:44:25.199 --> 00:44:27.800
but are using the shukanas. Okay, he said, this is
786
00:44:27.880 --> 00:44:30.599
a principle. Let's test it here. Let's see right, So
787
00:44:30.679 --> 00:44:33.599
that would be the soat this under the shah uh,
788
00:44:33.960 --> 00:44:36.599
are are are on that extreme. At the other extreme,
789
00:44:37.559 --> 00:44:41.880
you have people who will then bring the Chuva literature
790
00:44:42.760 --> 00:44:44.840
and maybe we should talk about organ maybe we'll make
791
00:44:44.880 --> 00:44:48.719
sure we talk about organization, uh. And they say okay.
792
00:44:49.039 --> 00:44:52.000
These are the cheu vote that speak on the topic
793
00:44:52.599 --> 00:44:55.000
that is the subject matter of the code. Section of
794
00:44:55.079 --> 00:44:59.519
the Piskechuva and the dark Chuva are famous for this,
795
00:45:00.239 --> 00:45:02.599
and in other words, that is how you'll connect the
796
00:45:04.079 --> 00:45:07.079
Charlotte tan Chubat literature to what's going on in the
797
00:45:07.119 --> 00:45:09.599
Shahan roof. And then you could think of most other
798
00:45:09.679 --> 00:45:14.960
ones being somewhere in between of explicating qualifying, right, the
799
00:45:15.079 --> 00:45:18.679
sma the shot. They're constantly qualifying the hukan roos, oh,
800
00:45:18.800 --> 00:45:22.440
yes he said this, but here, and typically point to
801
00:45:22.480 --> 00:45:25.159
another place where, well, you see, there's some tension between them.
802
00:45:25.599 --> 00:45:28.079
So there's a lot of lawmaking that goes on in
803
00:45:28.159 --> 00:45:31.800
these codes as they refine and define what's going on,
804
00:45:32.000 --> 00:45:35.440
whether it's between the ramada chi or contradictions or just
805
00:45:35.559 --> 00:45:39.280
new stuff that comes up. So it's interesting because in
806
00:45:39.360 --> 00:45:42.519
some ways they would never say. Very the early early
807
00:45:43.280 --> 00:45:47.559
layer is willing to outright disagree with the shoch ama.
808
00:45:48.000 --> 00:45:50.760
Later on they become much less so, but they disagree
809
00:45:50.800 --> 00:45:53.920
by qualifying and saying oh only here, but not here,
810
00:45:54.079 --> 00:45:56.880
or introducing a new series of distinctions, very much the
811
00:45:56.960 --> 00:45:58.800
way that the talma does to the mischilon or you
812
00:45:58.800 --> 00:46:00.719
showed them due to the talma, and that's why I
813
00:46:00.800 --> 00:46:04.400
see this as very much a part of the same process.
814
00:46:04.679 --> 00:46:07.880
So right, when we refer today, when someone says chokin,
815
00:46:08.599 --> 00:46:13.320
they typically don't mean the language of Joseph Caro. They
816
00:46:13.400 --> 00:46:16.400
mean yang the jose kiro plus rama plus at least
817
00:46:16.480 --> 00:46:19.480
some of the canonical commentaries, and you can argue which
818
00:46:19.559 --> 00:46:22.840
ones are. So we really say, you'll see sometimes abbreviated
819
00:46:23.800 --> 00:46:27.159
venose kalem shan meaning the whole kind of web of
820
00:46:27.360 --> 00:46:29.679
literature which you know to a story, and is somewhat
821
00:46:29.719 --> 00:46:32.480
maddening because we're referred to this book, but we really
822
00:46:32.559 --> 00:46:35.440
mean the book is printed and received, not the words
823
00:46:35.800 --> 00:46:39.280
of any any specific person. I do want to say
824
00:46:39.679 --> 00:46:42.079
a word about organization, because I think this matters a lot.
825
00:46:43.360 --> 00:46:46.199
Perhaps the greatest success of the shokranuch is that it
826
00:46:46.320 --> 00:46:51.880
became the way we conceptualize alaka certainly practice alaka. And
827
00:46:51.920 --> 00:46:55.320
this way, though the Rambam system is more can comprehensive
828
00:46:55.360 --> 00:46:58.519
and more elegant. I think that the chikan wins the day.
829
00:46:59.119 --> 00:47:01.440
And then what starts having is that you will see
830
00:47:02.000 --> 00:47:07.199
works of cheu vote are organized according to the section
831
00:47:07.480 --> 00:47:09.480
of shokhan. Right because One of the main problems with
832
00:47:09.559 --> 00:47:12.880
you vote is they have no natural order, right. I
833
00:47:12.960 --> 00:47:14.559
mean you could have like the order that they were
834
00:47:14.599 --> 00:47:17.719
written in, but that's not super helpful, right, So part
835
00:47:17.960 --> 00:47:20.400
the big the big downside of chew vote. We talked
836
00:47:20.440 --> 00:47:23.000
before about their analytic character, but just as practice, how
837
00:47:23.039 --> 00:47:24.920
do you find them? How do you know if something
838
00:47:25.000 --> 00:47:26.800
is relevant to what you're working on? So every once
839
00:47:26.800 --> 00:47:28.920
in a while you'll have a gono vilna or vaduo
840
00:47:29.000 --> 00:47:32.320
sense it just like knows everything, okay, But if you're
841
00:47:32.360 --> 00:47:34.440
not that, how do you find them? So today we
842
00:47:34.519 --> 00:47:36.920
have computers and things like that, but in the inter
843
00:47:37.159 --> 00:47:41.119
interstitial period, what we see is that the code chapters
844
00:47:41.480 --> 00:47:44.840
then become like the sort of headings of halaka, so
845
00:47:44.960 --> 00:47:49.000
we know, oh, this is Simon Sanivov okay, and therefore
846
00:47:49.280 --> 00:47:52.760
the true vote will be written or published I should
847
00:47:52.760 --> 00:47:56.360
say not written published in in a way of like
848
00:47:56.519 --> 00:48:00.159
the rough order of the Shokanara. Now, of course, chew
849
00:48:00.199 --> 00:48:02.480
bote can draw from many different places, so sometimes they
850
00:48:02.519 --> 00:48:05.480
have to be split in parsed, and therefore indexes in
851
00:48:05.559 --> 00:48:08.000
the back of chew vote, and sometimes even the way
852
00:48:08.000 --> 00:48:12.480
they're organized are in accordance with the orders. So if
853
00:48:12.480 --> 00:48:16.079
you to me, one of the most enduring influences of
854
00:48:16.159 --> 00:48:19.280
this is beyond what the Schardrok paskins, is that it's
855
00:48:19.320 --> 00:48:22.519
the way we now frame and think of Halakha. So
856
00:48:22.800 --> 00:48:25.960
and therefore you see this as I said both earlier,
857
00:48:26.239 --> 00:48:29.000
people like the Shakh will already start quoting chew Vote,
858
00:48:29.000 --> 00:48:30.840
but then like the dark tube of the Pistley Cuba
859
00:48:31.199 --> 00:48:35.159
on the page citing chew Vote, and then Chewbote themselves
860
00:48:35.280 --> 00:48:37.199
become published. I think the most interesting example is the
861
00:48:37.320 --> 00:48:39.920
bach who's one of the commentaries on the tour. The
862
00:48:40.000 --> 00:48:43.360
first edition is published in a fairly random way, and
863
00:48:43.440 --> 00:48:46.000
then they republish it scramble the order, so now it
864
00:48:46.119 --> 00:48:49.719
matches the order of Schuchhan. What's super interesting is that
865
00:48:49.840 --> 00:48:53.920
in modern times rofessal Weis's Chubas have this, but he's
866
00:48:53.960 --> 00:48:56.159
not the only one. They will publish them in the
867
00:48:56.320 --> 00:48:58.599
order of the four volumes of Chukhrana Ruche and then
868
00:48:58.639 --> 00:49:03.400
a fifth one Lakah who are medicine. So they're saying that,
869
00:49:03.880 --> 00:49:05.280
I say, like, what you see is like this like
870
00:49:05.360 --> 00:49:08.360
fifth value should earth sort of happening before our eyes
871
00:49:08.639 --> 00:49:11.159
because people realize there's no great place to put this
872
00:49:13.039 --> 00:49:15.719
kind of its own thing and not really reflected. So
873
00:49:15.760 --> 00:49:18.119
I think it's very interesting. It'd be a great practice.
874
00:49:18.239 --> 00:49:20.599
Who's the first to publish it this way? But so
875
00:49:20.840 --> 00:49:23.519
to me, it's interesting even when you're deviating Falk, you're
876
00:49:23.519 --> 00:49:25.920
still using that as as the structure.
877
00:49:26.480 --> 00:49:30.239
Okay, there's much to say that I want to drive
878
00:49:30.360 --> 00:49:33.039
us a little bit in love direction because time is
879
00:49:33.079 --> 00:49:36.679
running a little bit short, which is similar to what
880
00:49:36.760 --> 00:49:39.679
you're seeing before. There is of course yet another genre
881
00:49:40.199 --> 00:49:42.519
of I like writing, which we haven't really mentioned thus
882
00:49:42.559 --> 00:49:47.199
far so much, which is we continued attempt at talbuted commentary,
883
00:49:47.519 --> 00:49:49.440
and in fact, even some of the great writers of
884
00:49:49.599 --> 00:49:52.199
codes or of response and many of them are also
885
00:49:52.199 --> 00:49:55.800
at the same time providing commentaries on the talmud itself,
886
00:49:55.800 --> 00:50:01.559
which seeks to explain, perhaps apply, perhap perhaps you know,
887
00:50:02.000 --> 00:50:05.679
make update or make relevant, sudden secure certain discussions of
888
00:50:05.719 --> 00:50:09.039
the talbut and that exists side by side with these
889
00:50:09.039 --> 00:50:11.280
other genres like writing, And I guess my question is,
890
00:50:11.480 --> 00:50:15.159
you know, to what extent do they interrelate? And are
891
00:50:15.199 --> 00:50:19.519
these talmulive commentaries, so to speak, better friends of the
892
00:50:19.599 --> 00:50:23.679
writing of responsor or better friends of writing of codes?
893
00:50:24.199 --> 00:50:28.000
And how does it fit into this, this rather this
894
00:50:28.159 --> 00:50:31.519
constructed kind of opposition between the response and the code.
895
00:50:32.679 --> 00:50:36.000
Yeah, so I would say, I'm not sure everyone would
896
00:50:36.000 --> 00:50:38.159
agree with this, but you know a lot of people.
897
00:50:38.679 --> 00:50:40.199
Why else would we have you on? Please, If you're
898
00:50:40.199 --> 00:50:43.199
going to say something I would agree on, then I would.
899
00:50:43.000 --> 00:50:48.960
Say that that kind of page by page chamudic commentary
900
00:50:49.159 --> 00:50:52.159
is something very very dominant in the Reshow name and
901
00:50:52.239 --> 00:50:55.320
maybe the earlier name, and has largely leveled off. In
902
00:50:55.400 --> 00:50:58.719
other words, it's hard to think they exist, but it's
903
00:50:58.760 --> 00:51:03.639
hard to think of an influentyal page by page commentary
904
00:51:03.800 --> 00:51:06.320
on the Talmud of the last one hundred or two
905
00:51:06.400 --> 00:51:08.800
hundred years. Now someone's going to say, what about this,
906
00:51:08.920 --> 00:51:10.519
And I'm sure there's one there, right, But like if
907
00:51:10.559 --> 00:51:14.960
we think of them, obviously Rashi Tosos, you know, the Rashon,
908
00:51:15.119 --> 00:51:20.760
sard rambamb Rashba Ron, etc. Son others, they exist and
909
00:51:20.800 --> 00:51:22.639
they're still I'm sure you could go to a sparm
910
00:51:22.679 --> 00:51:26.440
shop and find a fairly new thing on Bubba atsierb
911
00:51:26.480 --> 00:51:29.679
of a Comma or something like that. But largely the
912
00:51:30.320 --> 00:51:32.800
in the modern era, I think it's been codes and
913
00:51:32.880 --> 00:51:36.239
response that have been and then like sort of various
914
00:51:36.320 --> 00:51:42.039
rabbinic essays that have been more more influential than kind
915
00:51:42.079 --> 00:51:45.559
of daff bay daf commentary. Now, what has happened is,
916
00:51:45.599 --> 00:51:47.039
as they said, I mentioned this word a few times.
917
00:51:47.280 --> 00:51:49.480
I think what has emerged, let's say, is the idea
918
00:51:49.519 --> 00:51:53.599
of the essay or article on a topic, right, something
919
00:51:53.639 --> 00:51:56.199
that you don't really have in the earlier writings. In
920
00:51:56.280 --> 00:51:59.920
other words, the ram Band's Cuntristadina de Garmi is exceptional
921
00:52:00.360 --> 00:52:02.239
because it's one of the only examples of in the
922
00:52:02.320 --> 00:52:04.920
year of the reshown in of someone saying I'm going
923
00:52:05.000 --> 00:52:06.960
to write on this topic and try to cover it
924
00:52:07.159 --> 00:52:11.320
in some sort of introduction, thesis, conclusion. Right. In general,
925
00:52:11.440 --> 00:52:15.840
I would say rabbinic writing doesn't have that structure. It's
926
00:52:15.880 --> 00:52:18.039
really hard to think. And I'll say something that is
927
00:52:18.039 --> 00:52:21.920
a little provocative. What is the that there's not many
928
00:52:22.000 --> 00:52:24.840
Hoboutic books and you're gonna say, what are you talking
929
00:52:24.880 --> 00:52:27.199
about it? Walking Indy based mentors. There's a gagillion of them,
930
00:52:27.280 --> 00:52:30.440
And by book I mean a thing on a single
931
00:52:30.559 --> 00:52:34.119
topic that has a thesis that is pursued from beginning
932
00:52:34.280 --> 00:52:39.719
to end. This is a monograph exactly. There aren't many
933
00:52:40.760 --> 00:52:43.119
more recently sure in the last to say, hundred years,
934
00:52:43.159 --> 00:52:45.559
you see more of these, but but there really aren't many.
935
00:52:46.280 --> 00:52:48.719
So the monograph we've been talking about genres and also
936
00:52:48.760 --> 00:52:52.440
worth thinking what genres don't exist, And I think therefore
937
00:52:53.480 --> 00:52:55.800
the word commentary does a lot more work there in
938
00:52:55.800 --> 00:52:58.079
the same way the gomar is quote commentary on the MISSIONA.
939
00:52:58.360 --> 00:53:01.000
I mean yes and no right, and the same is
940
00:53:01.079 --> 00:53:04.000
true right, so and therefore the and we're talking and
941
00:53:04.079 --> 00:53:05.639
the chew vote wind up doing this. But I saying
942
00:53:05.880 --> 00:53:08.920
more recent thing is the sort of article and or
943
00:53:09.039 --> 00:53:11.800
the book where you can take a topic and kind
944
00:53:11.840 --> 00:53:14.119
of pursue it consistently. I think one of the first
945
00:53:14.800 --> 00:53:16.559
maybe the on m you could count them, but I
946
00:53:16.639 --> 00:53:20.360
think the shim and schup Shario share. There's some predecessors
947
00:53:20.400 --> 00:53:22.960
to ship Schmid, but in others it's pretty thin in
948
00:53:23.280 --> 00:53:26.559
that sense. So I think today the type of person
949
00:53:26.599 --> 00:53:28.679
who would have written a page by page to munic
950
00:53:28.719 --> 00:53:32.039
commentary is more likely to write sort of essays or
951
00:53:32.039 --> 00:53:34.679
maybe a book on a given topic. It's more fitting
952
00:53:34.760 --> 00:53:37.320
with the way that we write today and that we
953
00:53:37.400 --> 00:53:40.800
think today. And therefore I think that that genre is
954
00:53:41.519 -->
00:53:44.239
while I agree it's been continuing, but it's not. It's
955
00:53:44.239 --> 00:53:47.599
hard to think of very influential page by page commentaries
956
00:53:48.280 --> 00:53:52.800
since the kind of midachronin. Maybe the ark Lanaire is.
957
00:53:53.000 --> 00:53:55.880
But again you can't compare that to the earlier ones.
958
00:53:55.920 --> 00:53:59.159
For example, him his chewbot Binanci and is the alcavette
959
00:53:59.199 --> 00:54:02.800
linger I think are more influential than his tem me
960
00:54:02.920 --> 00:54:07.480
to commentary routhlynaire now where if it's in certainly of
961
00:54:07.599 --> 00:54:10.239
the reshown him, it's just considered primary loss. So in
962
00:54:10.280 --> 00:54:12.599
other words, that fits you know, what the past leots say,
963
00:54:12.760 --> 00:54:15.440
fits into codes all over the place, and fits into
964
00:54:15.480 --> 00:54:18.960
response all over the place as we move on somewhat less.
965
00:54:19.360 --> 00:54:23.480
Right, Okay, fair enough? It is interesting to note the
966
00:54:24.199 --> 00:54:28.000
influx of of the the optic, let's say, of the
967
00:54:28.039 --> 00:54:30.920
phenomen of the Halak monograph and Hala essay and really
968
00:54:30.960 --> 00:54:34.000
honestly the Hallakic footnotes. There's also something that did not
969
00:54:34.559 --> 00:54:37.199
exist much in previous centuries. But I suppose you know,
970
00:54:37.400 --> 00:54:39.679
has you know, writing has taken on the track.
971
00:54:39.880 --> 00:54:42.039
I think I think the missioner Brewer, I don't want
972
00:54:42.039 --> 00:54:45.079
to say the first, but the mission brewer writes footnotes
973
00:54:45.119 --> 00:54:47.280
on the missioner burah right. In other words, he might
974
00:54:47.400 --> 00:54:50.360
be his missioner. Burgh is itself some sort of footnote
975
00:54:50.360 --> 00:54:52.559
slash commentary, right, But then the shared Sea, and he
976
00:54:52.599 --> 00:54:55.599
has like footnotes on his text. But yes, this idea,
977
00:54:56.039 --> 00:54:58.679
this modern way of writing of text and footnotes and things,
978
00:54:58.719 --> 00:55:00.800
which is now you know, you could find certainly in
979
00:55:00.840 --> 00:55:02.480
the Monera sex world. I think when we were in
980
00:55:02.519 --> 00:55:06.599
the Hibi world. This is a fairly new phenomenon. But
981
00:55:06.760 --> 00:55:08.719
by the way I think this is I wrote in
982
00:55:08.800 --> 00:55:10.559
my book, I think this goes all the way back.
983
00:55:10.639 --> 00:55:14.000
In other words, if we go to before the world
984
00:55:14.079 --> 00:55:16.960
of Hazal, it take us to the first century. So
985
00:55:17.079 --> 00:55:19.679
we know of Joe Ciphis, and we know of Filo,
986
00:55:20.119 --> 00:55:23.039
who write what we would call monographs. Right they write
987
00:55:23.280 --> 00:55:27.440
one person writing in their own voice about a topic
988
00:55:27.559 --> 00:55:31.039
that is definable. And then once you get to Razal,
989
00:55:31.519 --> 00:55:33.400
they don't do that. First of all, they don't write,
990
00:55:34.159 --> 00:55:37.000
by which I mean like a written product. It's all tbalpe.
991
00:55:37.320 --> 00:55:41.159
We should remember that though we engage to pe as books,
992
00:55:41.320 --> 00:55:43.360
that's not the way haza did. It's all about Peh
993
00:55:44.320 --> 00:55:50.960
and all the collections. Mishna Medrisha, Medrisha, Gada Damarabavla Murisli
994
00:55:51.039 --> 00:55:56.800
are collections of inter multi generational works that don't have
995
00:55:57.000 --> 00:56:00.719
a very clear structure and conceptual structure. And that goes
996
00:56:00.800 --> 00:56:03.400
all the way from the earliest hazal until you get
997
00:56:03.440 --> 00:56:05.920
to the own meme that begin to kind of write
998
00:56:05.920 --> 00:56:08.320
a single people in their own voice. You know, there
999
00:56:08.320 --> 00:56:11.480
writes some essays pias is mecha memcar and commercial ar
1000
00:56:11.679 --> 00:56:13.679
shar go, and you know, then you begin to have it.
1001
00:56:13.760 --> 00:56:15.559
But I think it's I think part of what's driving
1002
00:56:15.599 --> 00:56:18.039
this is, you know, not only Talmud Tara in the
1003
00:56:18.320 --> 00:56:21.239
idea that to study, but also the form that tore
1004
00:56:21.320 --> 00:56:24.320
study has taken for Hazau, I think bears a huge
1005
00:56:24.400 --> 00:56:26.239
influence on everything after.
1006
00:56:26.880 --> 00:56:30.280
Right, okay, and and let me let me move a
1007
00:56:30.320 --> 00:56:34.000
little bit into sort of an analysis of these of
1008
00:56:34.079 --> 00:56:38.599
these different codes, sorry, the genres, codes and response as
1009
00:56:38.679 --> 00:56:41.920
it pertains to the education of rabbis or you know,
1010
00:56:42.039 --> 00:56:45.679
the syllabi in Yeshivat and other and lot of those places.
1011
00:56:45.920 --> 00:56:47.840
And you know, it is very interesting to think about that.
1012
00:56:48.079 --> 00:56:50.679
You know, there is quite a clear prioritization where you
1013
00:56:50.840 --> 00:56:53.920
have the talm wood and its commentaries as the major aspect,
1014
00:56:53.960 --> 00:56:56.400
and then a kind of distant second is the learning
1015
00:56:56.440 --> 00:56:59.000
of the codes and their commentaries and then are really
1016
00:56:59.119 --> 00:57:03.199
really distant. Third is the study of responsor, which comes
1017
00:57:03.320 --> 00:57:06.920
which is very infrequent, let's say, in your average tumbletic
1018
00:57:06.960 --> 00:57:09.760
training and general training, which most rabbi still to this
1019
00:57:09.880 --> 00:57:13.039
day undergo. And the question that becomes, firstly, why is
1020
00:57:13.119 --> 00:57:16.280
this the case? And secondly, I mean is this wise?
1021
00:57:16.360 --> 00:57:21.639
I mean do we ought there be a reconsideration, recalibration
1022
00:57:22.239 --> 00:57:24.440
of the educational focus of some of these places.
1023
00:57:24.920 --> 00:57:29.840
Sure, so what you're saying is certainly true of the
1024
00:57:30.119 --> 00:57:33.440
tradition that emerges from Valajen, which has a huge influence
1025
00:57:33.519 --> 00:57:37.440
on yeshivas of all stripes today, and that, like you said,
1026
00:57:38.239 --> 00:57:41.800
the subject matter is still a famitic masecta and it's
1027
00:57:41.920 --> 00:57:45.199
main reshowname and you might look at the schuch to
1028
00:57:45.239 --> 00:57:48.079
see what he does with it, or particularly if there's
1029
00:57:48.119 --> 00:57:50.559
a well known shock or exos and you kind of
1030
00:57:50.599 --> 00:57:52.800
gotta find your way in there. But that's not what
1031
00:57:52.880 --> 00:57:55.360
you're focused on. And that is certainly true for the
1032
00:57:55.440 --> 00:57:58.079
way we you know, when you're young, we learn the
1033
00:57:58.119 --> 00:58:01.280
gamura itself. As you go on, you learned the gamara
1034
00:58:01.480 --> 00:58:03.400
shown him, and that's what it means to understand the
1035
00:58:03.519 --> 00:58:05.880
sud yeah, so I think that's very much driven by
1036
00:58:05.920 --> 00:58:08.360
how the talmat itself works and by this idea that
1037
00:58:08.559 --> 00:58:11.000
talmut toa again to me this kind of say, because
1038
00:58:11.000 --> 00:58:14.480
that is sort of its ideal form. Now. Of course,
1039
00:58:14.599 --> 00:58:18.000
when you go to study Smicha, which is typically after
1040
00:58:18.119 --> 00:58:21.360
several years of this, you will change your focus to
1041
00:58:21.519 --> 00:58:25.079
the shukan uh and the things around it. And depending
1042
00:58:25.159 --> 00:58:27.360
on where and how you studied it, how much are
1043
00:58:27.400 --> 00:58:29.719
you really going back to the talmud and working down
1044
00:58:29.840 --> 00:58:31.679
or how much are you starting from these kind of
1045
00:58:31.719 --> 00:58:35.000
codes and working forward. But you're certainly right that in
1046
00:58:35.079 --> 00:58:39.360
the classical is Shiva chuvote are almost non existent. I
1047
00:58:39.559 --> 00:58:42.480
can speculate that this is part of the ideology that,
1048
00:58:42.480 --> 00:58:44.199
in other words, that very much comes from a legions.
1049
00:58:44.239 --> 00:58:46.719
There's the pure Tora and the pure Toa is in
1050
00:58:46.840 --> 00:58:49.159
the Gemara and the chu vote are kind of already
1051
00:58:49.280 --> 00:58:53.480
sullied by the complexities of human interaction in the world,
1052
00:58:53.559 --> 00:58:56.840
and I think the g Sevagic says things in this direction.
1053
00:58:56.920 --> 00:58:58.400
I'm not sure you would say it quite in the
1054
00:58:58.440 --> 00:59:00.159
way I'm saying now, but I think he's reflecting this
1055
00:59:00.280 --> 00:59:04.519
sort of idea as one moves to Smicha in more
1056
00:59:04.559 --> 00:59:08.039
practical
things. There is definitely more emphasis on these later
1057
00:59:08.119 --> 00:59:10.440
works on more modern questions, and of course don't come
1058
00:59:10.480 --> 00:59:13.199
up in the kamara. You know, certainly, if you're studying castus,
1059
00:59:13.239 --> 00:59:15.000
you got to know how factories work and all these
1060
00:59:15.039 --> 00:59:17.880
sorts of things. And you know that stuff is obviously
1061
00:59:18.199 --> 00:59:22.320
in the in the much more contemporary literature. And you know,
1062
00:59:22.440 --> 00:59:24.760
in my in my job or part of my job
1063
00:59:24.840 --> 00:59:29.639
of interviewing various day anin you know, rabbinical court judges,
1064
00:59:30.159 --> 00:59:31.840
and they will all say that at some point they
1065
00:59:31.880 --> 00:59:34.119
had to start learning again. In other words, they learned
1066
00:59:34.119 --> 00:59:36.519
in yeshiva in this classic way, and then when they
1067
00:59:36.639 --> 00:59:39.039
decided to try to, you know, go to the day
1068
00:59:39.159 --> 00:59:42.920
a new track to be a sort of practicing a
1069
00:59:43.039 --> 00:59:46.159
diane they basically sort of they'll have this story where
1070
00:59:46.159 --> 00:59:48.239
they like start over and now I got to learn
1071
00:59:48.320 --> 00:59:51.119
to learn again and learn differently, which is always interesting.
1072
00:59:51.920 --> 00:59:55.559
But of course you don't get selected into a dianute
1073
00:59:55.639 --> 00:59:57.639
program unless you're really good at doing the other thing.
1074
00:59:58.320 --> 01:00:00.320
And I would say, sitting on these cases in my
1075
01:00:00.400 --> 01:00:02.480
other job, you can see the influence of this that
1076
01:00:02.639 --> 01:00:05.400
some of them are very classical and and you know,
1077
01:00:06.039 --> 01:00:08.679
are very wedded to how this is kind of constructed
1078
01:00:08.719 --> 01:00:10.599
in Yeshiva and less so into sort of okay, what
1079
01:00:10.679 --> 01:00:13.639
are we actually going to do here? And now? So
1080
01:00:13.760 --> 01:00:15.719
I think that that is going And now I think
1081
01:00:15.760 --> 01:00:18.239
there are changes too. You know, there's what you described
1082
01:00:18.360 --> 01:00:21.079
is certainly true of the Balasian tradition. But you know,
1083
01:00:21.199 --> 01:00:25.400
even in my lifetime, you see a change towards different
1084
01:00:25.440 --> 01:00:28.679
ways of studying. Certainly once you enter kind of mifha
1085
01:00:28.800 --> 01:00:31.960
tracts where there's going to be more emphasis on you vote,
1086
01:00:32.000 --> 01:00:35.239
and certainly you know the true boative emotion find seeing
1087
01:00:35.280 --> 01:00:38.599
that everyone quote has to know right and things like that.
1088
01:00:38.719 --> 01:00:40.840
So I do think there is a change. But I
1089
01:00:41.440 --> 01:00:45.119
also think that the centrality of the gamara to the
1090
01:00:45.280 --> 01:00:48.599
process of talmatara and therefore everything that flows from it,
1091
01:00:48.719 --> 01:00:51.079
even if you're trying to do something quote practical, still
1092
01:00:51.159 --> 01:00:53.519
exerts a tremendous influence and under That's one of things
1093
01:00:53.519 --> 01:00:55.320
I tried to talk about my book, that this goes
1094
01:00:55.360 --> 01:00:57.239
back to well, what are we doing here? Is this
1095
01:00:57.400 --> 01:01:01.400
a legal system? Yeah, it's that this has this other dimension,
1096
01:01:01.480 --> 01:01:04.159
and it's understood that that is captured kind of most
1097
01:01:04.280 --> 01:01:07.800
essentially in the Gamura and the commentary around it, and
1098
01:01:08.000 --> 01:01:10.519
less so in its practical orientation. Now, I will say,
1099
01:01:10.679 --> 01:01:13.239
sitting here in a law school, some aspects of this
1100
01:01:13.519 --> 01:01:16.440
exist in the American legal academy, and I suspect in
1101
01:01:16.599 --> 01:01:21.320
graduate education throughout. We don't teach in law school much
1102
01:01:21.360 --> 01:01:26.679
about which forms to file in the trial court in Pennsylvania, right.
1103
01:01:26.719 --> 01:01:29.519
We tend to think about more theoretical discussions. There are
1104
01:01:29.559 --> 01:01:33.880
far more classes on constitutional law and constitutional theory than
1105
01:01:33.920 --> 01:01:38.239
there are on Pennsylvania civil practice, even though in reality
1106
01:01:38.400 --> 01:01:40.280
most of the lawyers are not going to be arguing
1107
01:01:40.760 --> 01:01:44.159
questions of first impression of constitutional interpretation. They're going to
1108
01:01:44.159 --> 01:01:46.960
be doing the daily work of lawyers. My wife went
1109
01:01:46.960 --> 01:01:50.800
to architecture school, and similarly, the sort of model project
1110
01:01:51.000 --> 01:01:54.159
was you know the museum commission, which is some sort
1111
01:01:54.159 --> 01:01:57.840
of conceptual statement made through a building, rather than you know,
1112
01:01:57.960 --> 01:02:00.880
how to do you know a supermarket in the strip mall.
1113
01:02:01.239 --> 01:02:05.320
So I do think that there's something about educational systems generally,
1114
01:02:06.239 --> 01:02:10.079
or power professional education systems generally, where the kind of
1115
01:02:10.519 --> 01:02:12.800
there's a sort of ideal type of study that is
1116
01:02:12.960 --> 01:02:17.039
prized by the kind of educational establishment, which is that
1117
01:02:17.400 --> 01:02:20.960
some gap between what the graduates actually do in practice
1118
01:02:21.000 --> 01:02:24.119
is certainly true inneshiva, certainly true in law school, you know,
1119
01:02:24.199 --> 01:02:29.480
and I know by analogy in architecture school. Although in
1120
01:02:29.599 --> 01:02:31.400
law school I know that there's a yin and yang,
1121
01:02:31.440 --> 01:02:33.639
and these things change do We're now in a more
1122
01:02:33.719 --> 01:02:36.199
clinical route, and so these things go back and forth,
1123
01:02:36.760 --> 01:02:38.559
you know, the fads kind of go back and forth.
1124
01:02:38.599 --> 01:02:42.119
And I suspect the same is true in rabbinic education
1125
01:02:42.280 --> 01:02:45.079
and also as instead we've been talking a lot about
1126
01:02:45.079 --> 01:02:47.320
the volution tradition. If one comes from a kind of
1127
01:02:47.320 --> 01:02:51.039
Spardic tradition, I think the world does look somewhat different, right.
1128
01:02:51.199 --> 01:02:55.159
And the final point that I wanted to raise is
1129
01:02:56.440 --> 01:02:59.239
sort of the threads of thought that is woven throughout
1130
01:02:59.280 --> 01:03:01.840
your work on which this question of these two different
1131
01:03:01.880 --> 01:03:05.840
genres of Halaic writing bear, which I think is is interesting,
1132
01:03:06.239 --> 01:03:09.760
which is on what is halaha? Which seems to be
1133
01:03:09.840 --> 01:03:14.440
a strikingly a question that is deceptively or appears simple,
1134
01:03:15.000 --> 01:03:17.880
but is deceptive in that particular appearance, and in fact,
1135
01:03:18.079 --> 01:03:21.079
as you have articulated over now, regain is actually a mutal,
1136
01:03:21.119 --> 01:03:25.599
complex question. And of course you have these opposing or
1137
01:03:25.920 --> 01:03:29.719
I'm not sure opposing these strikingly different ways of writing
1138
01:03:29.760 --> 01:03:32.760
halaa and trying to develop it and expand it, and
1139
01:03:32.840 --> 01:03:35.440
and and further it, advance it. And the question becomes,
1140
01:03:35.519 --> 01:03:39.000
how does a consideration of these different forms of Alaric
1141
01:03:39.039 --> 01:03:42.760
writing bear on the major question, which is how does
1142
01:03:42.840 --> 01:03:45.280
one define alaa? The term?
1143
01:03:45.480 --> 01:03:47.719
Okay, so we were ending with the with the question
1144
01:03:47.800 --> 01:03:50.000
maybe with correct but.
1145
01:03:50.519 --> 01:03:52.880
I think now that we have a better appreciation of
1146
01:03:53.039 --> 01:03:55.760
what what is involved in this question, now we can
1147
01:03:55.840 --> 01:03:57.880
sort of set the table if yeah.
1148
01:03:57.840 --> 01:04:01.119
So so as your as youre as you say. So.
1149
01:04:01.480 --> 01:04:03.840
That is something I've been thinking a lot about over
1150
01:04:03.920 --> 01:04:07.880
the years, and my book, which is called the Rabbinica,
1151
01:04:07.920 --> 01:04:10.480
the Rabbinic Idea Law, is trying to kind of articulate.
1152
01:04:10.679 --> 01:04:13.559
So let me just kind of pose where we went into.
1153
01:04:13.639 --> 01:04:18.519
I would say, both codes and response that would broadly
1154
01:04:18.679 --> 01:04:23.559
be considered under the rubric of halahalam se right applied halakha,
1155
01:04:24.159 --> 01:04:27.719
and therefore, you know, kind of not not already a subset.
1156
01:04:27.840 --> 01:04:30.960
Now I tend to say that there are actually three terms.
1157
01:04:31.039 --> 01:04:36.239
There's halakah, there's hala halamas, and there's halaka lamas lemis
1158
01:04:37.320 --> 01:04:40.679
meaning there is halaha in the sense of this kind
1159
01:04:40.719 --> 01:04:44.639
of broad system of ideas, we could say, largely captured
1160
01:04:44.679 --> 01:04:49.800
in the talmudiness related literature in which minority opinions. You know,
1161
01:04:49.880 --> 01:04:52.280
be Shami is part of alaha, even though we know
1162
01:04:52.360 --> 01:04:55.400
we don't poscu in that. Robbie Mayer is halaja, even
1163
01:04:55.440 --> 01:04:58.239
though we of course don't post in that, and halaha
1164
01:04:58.360 --> 01:05:01.280
about all sorts of things that no bearing you know,
1165
01:05:02.079 --> 01:05:04.400
the various discussions in the talma that sort of end
1166
01:05:04.519 --> 01:05:07.719
inconclusively or end or are all picking up on ashita
1167
01:05:07.800 --> 01:05:10.159
that the tama knows from the beginning it's not going
1168
01:05:10.239 --> 01:05:12.079
to right, So that's haw aha sort of in its
1169
01:05:12.239 --> 01:05:16.719
broadest sense. Right, then we have what we would call halakalama,
1170
01:05:17.679 --> 01:05:19.840
which I say is the stuff that if we go
1171
01:05:20.000 --> 01:05:22.039
back to our discussion of the riff, the sort of
1172
01:05:22.079 --> 01:05:24.679
stuff that is within the riffs bar another legal term
1173
01:05:25.079 --> 01:05:27.639
rule of recognition, in other words, within his rule of
1174
01:05:27.719 --> 01:05:31.199
what we kind of is the applied normative alaka. But
1175
01:05:31.400 --> 01:05:35.079
even there, if one studies shikhana uf, there's vast tracts
1176
01:05:35.119 --> 01:05:38.000
of it that is not what we actually do in
1177
01:05:38.199 --> 01:05:41.960
observant communities today. So for example, we mentioned this already
1178
01:05:42.519 --> 01:05:46.039
tambdic torte law right, so bor and ash and sure
1179
01:05:46.840 --> 01:05:50.320
and regel. All these things are in shohan uch and
1180
01:05:50.880 --> 01:05:53.800
are not at all reflective in the practice of observant
1181
01:05:53.880 --> 01:05:57.599
communities today. By contrast, something like the laws of Krishma
1182
01:05:58.440 --> 01:06:01.320
do so I would say, we typically say ala Kalama,
1183
01:06:01.480 --> 01:06:03.719
say is that which is kind of codified by the
1184
01:06:03.840 --> 01:06:08.840
riff you know, rush tour Chilgrenarre. But even there I
1185
01:06:08.880 --> 01:06:12.679
think there's a further distinction between what our actual practices
1186
01:06:12.800 --> 01:06:15.079
are and what's stated in these books. So therefore I
1187
01:06:15.199 --> 01:06:16.840
tend to think of it that it's probably best to
1188
01:06:16.880 --> 01:06:18.920
think of it in three ways. The sort of rawest
1189
01:06:19.039 --> 01:06:22.679
is roughly that which is
in the tale. Then we
1190
01:06:22.760 --> 01:06:25.559
could say that which is understood to be normative in
1191
01:06:25.719 --> 01:06:28.360
some sense in some place. By the way, there's another category.
1192
01:06:28.480 --> 01:06:31.000
Or what do we do with the Rombam's codifications of
1193
01:06:31.119 --> 01:06:34.199
the of the laws of the Beta mkdash right, which
1194
01:06:34.199 --> 01:06:36.480
are like they are halaja in the sense of these
1195
01:06:36.480 --> 01:06:39.320
are the correct rules occurring around them, but they're in
1196
01:06:39.400 --> 01:06:42.679
no way sort of part of our functional lives, and
1197
01:06:42.840 --> 01:06:44.639
sort of a layer below that is the sort of
1198
01:06:44.760 --> 01:06:48.039
everything is chicano, which includes things that are extremely relevant
1199
01:06:48.360 --> 01:06:50.519
and things that are not and things that we do
1200
01:06:50.639 --> 01:06:53.039
somewhat differently, et cetera. And then there's like the actual
1201
01:06:53.119 --> 01:06:55.960
practices of Jewish communities which are found in she voked,
1202
01:06:56.000 --> 01:06:58.159
which are found today, and like you know, the letters
1203
01:06:58.280 --> 01:07:01.639
rabbis send their congregants before pass you know, this year
1204
01:07:01.800 --> 01:07:05.519
was so that which the rabbi wrote to the shows,
1205
01:07:05.599 --> 01:07:09.000
and sometimes that's the actual thing that we do. Here's
1206
01:07:09.039 --> 01:07:10.639
how we're selling the comments. Here is how we're doing this.
1207
01:07:11.079 --> 01:07:12.679
So I think that we have to think of it
1208
01:07:12.960 --> 01:07:15.360
as in a variety of levels. I would say my
1209
01:07:15.519 --> 01:07:18.599
own finish, if you will, or my own point of
1210
01:07:18.679 --> 01:07:22.599
emphasis into the discussions. Actually not at the bottom end,
1211
01:07:22.679 --> 01:07:25.599
but at the top is the range of things that
1212
01:07:25.760 --> 01:07:28.239
halaja can cover. And this is a lot of what
1213
01:07:28.320 --> 01:07:30.960
I talk about my book is that what what rabbinic
1214
01:07:31.039 --> 01:07:34.480
discourse does is it uses legal language to talk about
1215
01:07:34.599 --> 01:07:38.199
all sorts of questions and issues that may not be
1216
01:07:38.639 --> 01:07:42.119
thought of as legal in other contexts. So I always say,
1217
01:07:42.599 --> 01:07:46.280
you know, in our culture, we have poetry, we have film,
1218
01:07:46.599 --> 01:07:49.760
we have literature, we have art. We have high brow
1219
01:07:49.920 --> 01:07:51.920
versions of the things, we have low brow versions of
1220
01:07:51.960 --> 01:07:54.880
these things. We have Facebook, we have podcasts, right, and
1221
01:07:55.079 --> 01:07:57.639
lots of lots of ways to communicate and lots of
1222
01:07:57.679 --> 01:08:00.320
lots of ways to frame ideas, and we tend to
1223
01:08:00.400 --> 01:08:05.719
think about law as fairly narrow, bound to the
state
1224
01:08:06.719 --> 01:08:10.719
right and bound to prescriptive behaviors. So halaka has that.
1225
01:08:11.239 --> 01:08:14.000
But what Rabinic literature doesn't have is all these other
1226
01:08:14.119 --> 01:08:17.159
modes of discourse, or if it hasn't, they're all smushed together.
1227
01:08:18.279 --> 01:08:20.680
You know, it has agada, it has drush out, but
1228
01:08:20.880 --> 01:08:23.720
they all kind of tend to sort of revolve often
1229
01:08:23.800 --> 01:08:26.760
around legal concepts. And therefore the idea is that the
1230
01:08:27.000 --> 01:08:30.680
legal takes up so much space and therefore does a
1231
01:08:30.720 --> 01:08:34.439
lot of work. And the challenge is, you know, now,
1232
01:08:34.520 --> 01:08:36.479
maybe going back to the bottom line, is that we
1233
01:08:36.680 --> 01:08:39.319
use the same body of texts in the same sort
1234
01:08:39.319 --> 01:08:41.399
of set of concepts both to do our kind of
1235
01:08:41.479 --> 01:08:44.560
big thinking about the world and to do our regulating
1236
01:08:44.800 --> 01:08:47.680
and that could be hard because those are designed different things.
1237
01:08:47.720 --> 01:08:51.079
I think the process of creating halahala myset from Hallaha
1238
01:08:51.359 --> 01:08:55.640
is complicated precisely because it has to traverse this distance
1239
01:08:56.000 --> 01:08:58.640
and the lines are not always clear and open for debate.
1240
01:08:59.079 --> 01:09:01.640
Fair Enough, that was the kind of answer that has
1241
01:09:01.840 --> 01:09:06.640
was both detailed and complex enough but also irreducible enough.
1242
01:09:06.960 --> 01:09:10.479
I think we have to expect that you cannot reduced
1243
01:09:10.640 --> 01:09:13.119
to a thing or another thing. It is somewhat like
1244
01:09:14.239 --> 01:09:17.560
like law, and somewhat not, and inclusive of some aspects
1245
01:09:17.600 --> 01:09:20.640
of it, but also ranges vastly beyond it. And I'm
1246
01:09:20.680 --> 01:09:24.159
afraid that time has forced us to draw this conversation
1247
01:09:24.199 --> 01:09:26.960
to a close. And I thank you very much for
1248
01:09:27.000 --> 01:09:28.880
as a high samon, for joining us today on the
1249
01:09:28.920 --> 01:09:31.279
Podcast of Jewish Ideas. This has been a lot of
1250
01:09:31.319 --> 01:09:34.760
fun and we look forward to your future publications, whatever
1251
01:09:34.960 --> 01:09:37.119
and whenever they may they may be.
1252
01:09:37.560 --> 01:09:37.840
Thank you.
1253
01:09:39.920 --> 01:09:42.359
This has been the Podcast of Jewish Ideas by Tora
1254
01:09:42.439 --> 01:09:46.640
in Motion, produced by Alisha Kellman and myself Jjkimbri, edited
1255
01:09:46.720 --> 01:09:49.159
and mixed by Alisha Kelman. You can stay up to
1256
01:09:49.239 --> 01:09:52.000
date by subscribing in your favorite podcast app. To support
1257
01:09:52.119 --> 01:09:54.720
more thoughtful Jewish content like this, please visit Toro in
1258
01:09:54.760 --> 01:10:01.319
motion dot org slash donated then then thet them me