TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:04.408 --> 00:08.651
[UNKNOWN]: Hello everyone, you're listening to the Katie Helper Show and I'm your host, Katie Helper.
00:09.111 --> 00:13.974
[UNKNOWN]: If you like the show, please leave us a five-star review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
00:14.395 --> 00:19.138
[UNKNOWN]: And as always, we remind you that this show could not happen without the support of our listeners.
00:19.598 --> 00:27.604
[UNKNOWN]: To support the show, visit patreon.com slash the Katie Helper Show, where for just $1 a month, you can make this show happen.
00:28.284 --> 00:37.571
[UNKNOWN]: And for $5 a month, you get great bonus content, including extended interviews, bonus episodes, sneak peeks at my upcoming documentary feature film and more.
00:41.097 --> 00:46.679
[UNKNOWN]: Hello everybody and welcome to a Friday daytime stream of the Katie helpers show we are thrilled to be here with you.
00:46.699 --> 00:47.800
[UNKNOWN]: We have a great lineup.
00:48.180 --> 00:49.901
[UNKNOWN]: I'm already getting emotional as you can see.
00:50.341 --> 00:51.981
[UNKNOWN]: We have three different segments.
00:52.102 --> 00:55.043
[UNKNOWN]: We are going to be speaking to in reverse order Jake.
01:10.789 --> 01:22.253
[UNKNOWN]: Before that, though, we're going to be speaking to a special guest, Ron Placone, who is an anti-fascist comedian, and he's going to be talking to us about anti-fascist comedy and being anti-fascist and Italian.
01:22.833 --> 01:34.376
[UNKNOWN]: So, before we start though, we remind people as always to please like this stream, give it a thumbs up, also please subscribe, so you don't miss any streams, because we do stream every Tuesday and Friday more or less,
01:37.497 --> 01:41.901
[UNKNOWN]: This week, all the six were having Rokana on Brad, I forgot to tell you about that.
01:42.001 --> 01:42.561
[UNKNOWN]: But we got it.
01:42.621 --> 01:44.783
[UNKNOWN]: We got to accommodate the congressman.
01:45.043 --> 01:46.064
[UNKNOWN]: He is a busy schedule.
01:46.504 --> 01:49.207
[UNKNOWN]: He was supposed to join us last week and he couldn't because of travel.
01:49.627 --> 01:51.168
[UNKNOWN]: Sometimes things change because of vote.
01:51.208 --> 01:54.891
[UNKNOWN]: So we will be streaming the six, which is this Wednesday, right?
01:54.931 --> 01:55.532
[UNKNOWN]: Am I right?
01:57.205 --> 01:57.886
[UNKNOWN]: Oh, sorry.
01:57.966 --> 01:58.246
[UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:58.646 --> 02:00.227
[UNKNOWN]: We are streaming on Thursday this week.
02:00.948 --> 02:01.428
[UNKNOWN]: Good to know.
02:01.508 --> 02:02.088
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you, Brad.
02:02.629 --> 02:02.949
[UNKNOWN]: All right.
02:03.069 --> 02:03.730
[UNKNOWN]: So Thursday.
02:03.770 --> 02:04.110
[UNKNOWN]: Thursday.
02:04.130 --> 02:04.550
[UNKNOWN]: Thursday.
02:04.630 --> 02:04.970
[UNKNOWN]: Thursday.
02:05.050 --> 02:07.372
[UNKNOWN]: August 6 is our next Katie help or show.
02:07.812 --> 02:10.114
[UNKNOWN]: We made you on before, but we may not.
02:10.654 --> 02:11.275
[UNKNOWN]:
Load full transcript
We'll let you know.
02:11.295 --> 02:13.676
[UNKNOWN]: But either way, we're definitely streaming on Thursday.
02:13.816 --> 02:14.397
[UNKNOWN]: August 6.
02:14.437 --> 02:15.778
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you everyone for contributing.
02:15.798 --> 02:18.580
[UNKNOWN]: I was just making sure that you are on your toes and prepared.
02:19.658 --> 02:22.519
[UNKNOWN]: Please do become Patreon supporters or YouTube supporters.
02:23.019 --> 02:25.880
[UNKNOWN]: So you can do that by going to Patreon.com slash the Katie Helper Show.
02:25.900 --> 02:28.361
[UNKNOWN]: Again, that's Patreon.com slash the Katie Helper Show.
02:28.381 --> 02:32.322
[UNKNOWN]: That's a great way to support the show, but also get bonus content.
02:32.362 --> 02:41.125
[UNKNOWN]: You can also join our YouTube membership program, and that is just by doing subscribe, and then join right Brad, that's the process to become a YouTube member.
02:41.585 --> 02:46.767
[UNKNOWN]: If you are agnostic, I mean, if you're someone who likes being on YouTube and that's your thing, then of course, we embrace it.
02:47.087 --> 02:49.369
[UNKNOWN]: and welcome and are grateful for the YouTube membership.
02:49.649 --> 02:52.150
[UNKNOWN]: If you could go either way, don't listen YouTube.
02:52.390 --> 02:56.653
[UNKNOWN]: If you can go either way, please do a Patreon because you keep more of it, financially.
02:57.193 --> 03:00.015
[UNKNOWN]: But we love YouTube and everything it represents and everything it does.
03:00.035 --> 03:04.798
[UNKNOWN]: Okay, without further ado, I'm going to be bringing on to the show.
03:05.218 --> 03:08.220
[UNKNOWN]: I've had him on, but it's been a while, so I'm really excited to have him back on.
03:08.580 --> 03:12.723
[UNKNOWN]: Ron Placone, who is a great comedian and he's bringing his own show,
03:15.424 --> 03:18.565
[UNKNOWN]: anti-fascist post tonight to the fringe festival.
03:18.585 --> 03:19.666
[UNKNOWN]: So welcome back run.
03:20.226 --> 03:21.727
[UNKNOWN]: Anti-pasta fascist night.
03:21.747 --> 03:22.607
[UNKNOWN]: That's a different show.
03:22.667 --> 03:27.269
[UNKNOWN]: I think someone's doing that down the street, but I'm anti-fascist post tonight.
03:27.329 --> 03:28.309
[UNKNOWN]: Good to see you, Katie.
03:28.349 --> 03:29.350
[UNKNOWN]: It's been way too long.
03:29.770 --> 03:30.330
[UNKNOWN]: You too.
03:30.770 --> 03:31.070
[UNKNOWN]: I know.
03:31.110 --> 03:34.011
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that would be a terrible show to walk into.
03:34.072 --> 03:34.852
[UNKNOWN]: Right, expecting.
03:35.112 --> 03:36.152
[UNKNOWN]: But that can be your next thing.
03:36.172 --> 03:38.433
[UNKNOWN]: You can do like a send up, you know,
03:40.445 --> 03:40.886
[UNKNOWN]: There.
03:41.086 --> 03:41.787
[UNKNOWN]: Yes.
03:41.807 --> 03:43.368
[UNKNOWN]: That'll be gluten free fascists.
03:43.409 --> 03:47.073
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that'll be 2027's run going to get it right now.
03:47.313 --> 03:47.754
[UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
03:47.774 --> 03:47.934
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
03:48.474 --> 03:57.205
[UNKNOWN]: So tell us about this anti fascist post tonight, which is a actually is a phenomenon, but it's also the name of your one person show, but tell us the idea and history behind it.
03:58.093 --> 04:10.003
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, so anti-fascist pasta nights are a thing and they're mostly an Italy, but they're also all around the world and it all started when Mussolini, when Mussolini was taken out of power.
04:10.063 --> 04:12.025
[UNKNOWN]: First of all, Mussolini was anti-pasta.
04:12.085 --> 04:14.127
[UNKNOWN]: He wanted people to not eat pasta.
04:14.187 --> 04:15.688
[UNKNOWN]: He said, oh, pasta makes you weak.
04:15.728 --> 04:26.237
[UNKNOWN]: We need to eat meat and stuff like that and then he took away coffee as well and he did a lot of stuff in between there, but then the Italian people decided they're going to kill them.
04:26.537 --> 04:29.398
[UNKNOWN]: But food wise, pasta and coffee were the big things.
04:29.458 --> 04:38.741
[UNKNOWN]: He decided I'm going to take away one of one of the favorite foods of a group of people that I'm going to take away their ability to be caffeinated and he thought it was going to work out for him.
04:38.961 --> 04:39.421
[UNKNOWN]: It did not.
04:40.362 --> 04:42.522
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that I mean forget the fascism part.
04:42.542 --> 04:43.883
[UNKNOWN]: This is actually more disturbing.
04:44.203 --> 04:44.823
[UNKNOWN]: This idea.
04:44.863 --> 04:47.184
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, right.
04:47.884 --> 04:54.487
[UNKNOWN]: So when he was removed from power, there was a group of partisans who started serving free pasta in the streets.
04:54.827 --> 04:55.827
[UNKNOWN]: That's so cool.
04:55.887 --> 05:01.889
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and so it became a tradition anti-fascist post tonight, all throughout Italy.
05:02.750 --> 05:06.631
[UNKNOWN]: And it recently kind of spread around the world.
05:06.751 --> 05:10.653
[UNKNOWN]: And this year, there were ones in other parts of Europe.
05:10.693 --> 05:13.474
[UNKNOWN]: And then there were some here in North America.
05:13.514 --> 05:19.737
[UNKNOWN]: The main time to celebrate it is July 25th, which was last week.
05:20.257 --> 05:22.478
[UNKNOWN]: We did an actual happy belated.
05:22.798 --> 05:23.378
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, all right.
05:23.738 --> 05:40.286
[UNKNOWN]: We did an actual anti-fascist post tonight in Los Angeles and in the San Pedro neighborhood where I live and we had a bunch of comics there Jake Flores was there grandma was there Dren and Davis, Dana Shock we had a really fun lineup and we had music and we all sang Bella Chow at the end.
05:40.306 --> 05:41.367
[UNKNOWN]: Oh, it's great.
05:41.627 --> 06:01.207
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it was really cool and yeah, and there was there was it was a really cool vibe and there were ones and I think New York had one Philly had one boss and had one I think Providence Rhode Island had one so so it's kind of it's a cultural thing and and I was entertaining the idea of calling the show that
because I talk about it in the show and
06:04.030 --> 06:13.658
[UNKNOWN]: And then I also talk about being Italian American and some of the misconceptions around being Italian American because it's, I'm sure you, I mean, especially being in New York.
06:13.758 --> 06:22.765
[UNKNOWN]: It's, it's like, it's commonly associated with this right wing reactionary politics like rock, Columbus Day, Chris Christie, Rudy Giuliani, rock, rock.
06:23.586 --> 06:25.247
[UNKNOWN]: And that certainly exists.
06:25.387 --> 06:26.148
[UNKNOWN]: I'm not going to pretend
06:28.810 --> 06:31.532
[UNKNOWN]: this big reaction against all that.
06:31.592 --> 06:37.596
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, I mean, there has been a ton of anarchist thought linked to Italian Americans over the years.
06:37.676 --> 06:46.822
[UNKNOWN]: A lot of union efforts, Italian immigrants were a really, really big part of that and a lot of it started up and Vermont with like the stone workers and stuff like that.
06:47.317 --> 06:50.859
[UNKNOWN]: Wow, I didn't even know there's a big presence in Vermont of Italians.
06:50.919 --> 06:55.421
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, they did, I think it was limestone or some kind of stone.
06:55.441 --> 06:56.301
[UNKNOWN]: I want to say it was limestone.
06:56.341 --> 07:00.743
[UNKNOWN]: And a lot of them were working in that industry when they came to the States.
07:00.823 --> 07:02.624
[UNKNOWN]: And they had unions over there.
07:02.664 --> 07:04.365
[UNKNOWN]: So they kind of brought it to the States.
07:04.825 --> 07:09.207
[UNKNOWN]: So there's a huge kind of leftist history of bits of Italian Americans.
07:09.247 --> 07:13.990
[UNKNOWN]: There has been anti-Columbus-state protests led by Italian Americans since the 30s.
07:15.070 --> 07:18.312
[UNKNOWN]: So there's always been no idea that was that the one back that far.
07:18.353 --> 07:21.695
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that's like very ahead of its, you know, time.
07:22.215 --> 07:25.338
[UNKNOWN]: Right, because this was this was pre people's history, right?
07:25.438 --> 07:33.364
[UNKNOWN]: And but but so that's always existed and people try to pretend like like this this group is some monolith.
07:34.124 --> 07:40.594
[UNKNOWN]: And for the first time in my lifetime, at least that I'm aware of, there's organizations pushing back against this.
07:40.634 --> 07:48.887
[UNKNOWN]: There's a group called piachi, there's a historian named Steven truly, there's a group called pushing back against the fascism, not against the anti fascist.
07:49.327 --> 07:50.629
[UNKNOWN]: pushing back against the fascism.
07:50.649 --> 07:52.430
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, pushing back against the fascism.
07:52.450 --> 08:02.720
[UNKNOWN]: And also just pushing back against this idea that Italian Americans are some monolith politically and just kind of saying, hey, you know, a lot of us don't share this part.
08:02.780 --> 08:07.905
[UNKNOWN]: We celebrate the food and the culture and all that, but we don't celebrate this other stuff.
08:07.945 --> 08:09.187
[UNKNOWN]: And we do feel differently.
08:09.447 --> 08:12.170
[UNKNOWN]: And for some reason, we're written out of the conversation all the time.
08:13.691 --> 08:22.022
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, it's kind of reminds me of anti, there's the anti-fascist Italian American like community and there's the anti Zionist Jewish American community, right?
08:22.082 --> 08:28.631
[UNKNOWN]: And obviously, you don't have like an Italian apac, but I would say that, you know, Jews have been able to somewhat.
08:30.053 --> 08:39.957
[UNKNOWN]: You know, create a real challenge to these the perception of a Zionist monolith, I mean, something we obviously still struggle with and more Jews need to be on design, etc.
08:40.817 --> 08:49.321
[UNKNOWN]: And you guys don't have the same thing like there's not like an active like genocide going on that claims to be in your name right, but I do think that there's a similar thing with.
08:50.701 --> 08:56.767
[UNKNOWN]: kind of like reclaiming your identity or not even reclaiming it because it's it's been there, as you point it out.
08:56.807 --> 09:02.352
[UNKNOWN]: Like people know about, you know, the Italian communist about Gromchie, but less so about the Italian Americans.
09:03.233 --> 09:08.658
[UNKNOWN]: And so I think that's great to do and do deal with a lot of people thinking you're Irish because of your hair color.
09:09.696 --> 09:11.557
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, totally, absolutely.
09:11.817 --> 09:16.079
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, say Patty, say I've always popular in a bar and I'm actually not Irish at all.
09:16.259 --> 09:26.743
[UNKNOWN]: My wife is, but when we went to what we were in Dublin and stuff like that, we went to all the immigration centers and she put it in her last name and a ton of stuff came up, you know?
09:26.943 --> 09:30.205
[UNKNOWN]: Like a like of heritage and possible relatives and stuff.
09:30.525 --> 09:33.546
[UNKNOWN]: I put in Placone just for fun and they were like, dude, go to Italy.
09:33.566 --> 09:34.266
[UNKNOWN]: What are you doing here?
09:34.666 --> 09:35.747
[UNKNOWN]: You're not gonna find anything here.
09:36.592 --> 09:36.772
[UNKNOWN]: Right.
09:36.792 --> 09:37.032
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
09:37.552 --> 09:39.974
[UNKNOWN]: What is the significance of the July 25th, you said?
09:40.814 --> 09:41.454
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
09:41.474 --> 09:44.355
[UNKNOWN]: So that's when they celebrate Mussolini falling.
09:44.716 --> 09:46.997
[UNKNOWN]: And so that's, so that just happens to be the date.
09:47.117 --> 09:52.819
[UNKNOWN]: But part of the reason I settled on the name anti-fascist Boston, I was one because I just got a kick out of it.
09:52.839 --> 09:53.920
[UNKNOWN]: I just thought it was a fun name.
09:54.040 --> 09:55.901
[UNKNOWN]: I do talk about it in the show.
09:56.521 --> 10:02.964
[UNKNOWN]: And then I kind of likened the Italian American part into it too, because I was seeing all these groups in New York,
10:03.584 --> 10:09.409
[UNKNOWN]: kind of reclaiming this thing, or
you know, amplifying it, because like you said, it's already been there.
10:09.890 --> 10:11.211
[UNKNOWN]: And that was really inspiring.
10:11.251 --> 10:19.018
[UNKNOWN]: The Italians for Zoron account, which is now Italian anti-fascists, like that's how they rebranded themselves, post the campaign.
10:19.799 --> 10:31.762
[UNKNOWN]: Um, they were doing a lot of amazing things, you know, there was that kind of standoff, uh, I think around Columbus Day, we're like the, the Macaroni, uh, and which is what we call them.
10:31.802 --> 10:32.983
[UNKNOWN]: That's what we call them now.
10:33.083 --> 10:41.705
[UNKNOWN]: And shout out to George, this, this, Stefano, who coined that, but, um, but yeah, like the Macaroni sect was there and the anti-fascist set was there and they were clashes.
10:41.725 --> 10:46.747
[UNKNOWN]: It was literally like that episode of sopranos in real life, uh, anyone remembers that episode.
10:48.327 --> 10:59.404
[UNKNOWN]: But yeah, so seeing them do that and I think it was actually Matt Lek who I talked to this I talked about this to we talked about how just
10:59.965 --> 11:01.025
[UNKNOWN]: the majority report?
11:01.405 --> 11:08.867
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, like right now reclaiming radical history is so important to figure out a way forward.
11:08.907 --> 11:19.570
[UNKNOWN]: Like it's time, it's time that people know that the people in North Dakota love their public bank because they know what a public bank can do and they probably wouldn't have that public bank if it wasn't for the anarchist farmers.
11:20.190 --> 11:22.693
[UNKNOWN]: it's time for people to know these things.
11:22.833 --> 11:26.557
[UNKNOWN]: And to know that we didn't get the new deal, because FDR was a nice guy.
11:26.577 --> 11:39.449
[UNKNOWN]: We got the new deal because anarchists and socialists and communists and labor leaders and just regular working people were pretty much in unison saying you got to give a little here because we're fed up and we're not going to take it any.
11:40.035 --> 11:53.761
[UNKNOWN]: right we need to reclaim that so so you know I'm trying to do my part of that I'm an Italian American so I want to I want to amplify all this stuff and that's a part of the show too and a lot of it's about just what's happening in the United States right now.
11:55.142 --> 12:01.765
[UNKNOWN]: And where is your family from and when did they come over and and do you come from a political family or did you kind of find your own politics?
12:02.861 --> 12:20.575
[UNKNOWN]: Well, as far as the micro level, a little bit of both my, so first of all, my family is mostly from Avellino, which, you know, the you mentioned off Mike, the ginger parents might link to southern Italy, but or northern Italy, but actually my relative sir or southern Italy and most Italian Americans are because that's where people are poor.
12:21.776 --> 12:29.242
[UNKNOWN]: So so most most Italian Americans have descended to the south, but but my family is.
12:30.487 --> 12:31.768
[UNKNOWN]: reasonably progressive.
12:31.809 --> 12:34.151
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, my my parents are retired now.
12:34.171 --> 12:35.232
[UNKNOWN]: My dad was an academic.
12:35.252 --> 12:38.756
[UNKNOWN]: My mom worked in admin in in academia as well.
12:38.836 --> 12:40.818
[UNKNOWN]: So fairly academic minded family.
12:41.358 --> 12:44.622
[UNKNOWN]: And they are yeah, they're fairly progressive.
12:44.662 --> 12:50.227
[UNKNOWN]: We we we butt heads a little bit on some things, but for the most part, and in these days, every now and again, they'll say,
12:51.088 --> 13:03.894
[UNKNOWN]: something that surprises me in a good way, you know, like they were saying something about, in fact, something about Gaza recently, because I am not Jewish myself, but I do have Jewish members of my family.
13:04.414 --> 13:05.615
[UNKNOWN]: And so, you know, like that.
13:05.635 --> 13:07.796
[UNKNOWN]: Patabakos, we call them people, if they're half.
13:08.336 --> 13:35.436
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, yeah, so yeah, so my niece and nephews are my special little pizza bagels, but yeah, so so that's that is, you know, something that does come up and, you know, recently my parents, you know, not not that I expected them to be, you know, totally the other way or anything like that, but but I was worried there might be a little bit of a Bill Mar influence in their in their thoughts, but there wasn't and I was I was very happy about that.
13:36.885 --> 13:44.851
[UNKNOWN]: By the way, less people think you're exaggerating here is an actual New York Times article showing the Mussolini war on pasta.
13:44.891 --> 13:50.336
[UNKNOWN]: This is from August 8, 1926, spaghetti finds a foe in Mussolini.
13:50.796 --> 13:55.400
[UNKNOWN]: Italy is dictator threatens to substitute potatoes for the national dish.
13:56.280 --> 13:58.061
[UNKNOWN]: which is a terrible idea.
13:58.981 --> 14:10.546
[UNKNOWN]: The climax of fascism has been reached nothing since the black church where first dawn can compare in its way with the importance of premier Mussolini's announcement that Spaghetti must go.
14:10.566 --> 14:17.049
[UNKNOWN]: It's placed to be taken by potatoes to help conserve wheat Italy faces a Spaghettiless future.
14:17.069 --> 14:21.031
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, so that's that is fascinating and was clearly a terrible
14:24.252 --> 14:26.354
[UNKNOWN]: You brought up the Italians for Zaron.
14:26.554 --> 14:28.176
[UNKNOWN]: Let's take a look at this video that you did.
14:28.196 --> 14:30.118
[UNKNOWN]: You do a racist.
14:30.518 --> 14:32.140
[UNKNOWN]: He wiped little Italy off the map.
14:32.540 --> 14:33.301
[UNKNOWN]: No, he didn't.
14:33.661 --> 14:35.223
[UNKNOWN]: First of all, it wasn't even his map.
14:35.243 --> 14:37.144
[UNKNOWN]: That map was made when Eric Adams was an office.
14:37.445 --> 14:41.408
[UNKNOWN]: Second of all, it was meant to focus on more active immigrant communities, not just symbolic ones.
14:41.449 --> 14:43.571
[UNKNOWN]: So yes,
Little Italy wasn't on that map.
14:43.631 --> 14:45.452
[UNKNOWN]: Neither was Little Germany or Little Syria.
14:45.733 --> 14:48.415
[UNKNOWN]: And finally, he's putting it back on the map anyway.
14:48.495 --> 14:48.836
[UNKNOWN]: So...
14:49.784 --> 14:50.885
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, we won.
14:51.345 --> 14:52.565
[UNKNOWN]: We've been sharing that video.
14:52.866 --> 14:57.768
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I couldn't help but notice the video you guys shared, excluded the part where he mentioned it wasn't even his map.
14:58.048 --> 15:02.190
[UNKNOWN]: It's almost like you're just really angry that a social Democrat is mayor of New York.
15:02.270 --> 15:03.231
[UNKNOWN]: He's a communist.
15:03.691 --> 15:07.653
[UNKNOWN]: Edrick Walmo's a Democrat and he's plenty social, especially with the ladies.
15:08.713 --> 15:11.174
[UNKNOWN]: Oh boy, I'll try to explain that one later.
15:11.474 --> 15:14.516
[UNKNOWN]: There's a photo of Mondani flipping off a Columbus statue.
15:14.676 --> 15:15.436
[UNKNOWN]: That's violent.
15:15.777 --> 15:18.598
[UNKNOWN]: Yes, I only hope someday the statue recovers.
15:19.414 --> 15:20.118
[UNKNOWN]: It's not funny.
15:20.560 --> 15:21.486
[UNKNOWN]: Thomas is our guide.
15:21.606 --> 15:22.511
[UNKNOWN]: He represents us.
15:23.317 --> 15:24.437
[UNKNOWN]: No, he doesn't.
15:24.758 --> 15:31.800
[UNKNOWN]: He was a horrible human by every measurable metric, and there have been anti-column-based actions led by Italian Americans since the 1930s.
15:31.900 --> 15:36.481
[UNKNOWN]: You know, you always love to cry discrimination in exclusion.
15:36.721 --> 15:43.503
[UNKNOWN]: Meanwhile, for years, you have tried to pretend that every single Italian American who doesn't share your worldview doesn't even exist.
15:43.723 --> 15:44.883
[UNKNOWN]: You want to talk about inclusion?
15:45.104 --> 15:46.224
[UNKNOWN]: How about starting there?
15:46.424 --> 15:47.344
[UNKNOWN]: How about this October?
15:47.364 --> 15:48.285
[UNKNOWN]: We actually have a real
15:50.503 --> 15:50.743
[UNKNOWN]: What?
15:50.863 --> 15:51.523
[UNKNOWN]: What?
15:51.543 --> 15:52.364
[UNKNOWN]: I can't hear you.
15:52.384 --> 15:52.964
[UNKNOWN]: You break it up.
15:53.084 --> 15:53.824
[UNKNOWN]: I'm sorry.
15:53.844 --> 15:54.665
[UNKNOWN]: I can't hear you.
15:54.685 --> 15:55.625
[UNKNOWN]: I'm going to have to call you back.
15:57.706 --> 15:58.526
[UNKNOWN]: That was Magaroni.
15:59.126 --> 16:00.106
[UNKNOWN]: That was Magaroni.
16:00.467 --> 16:01.227
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
16:02.167 --> 16:08.149
[UNKNOWN]: And so everyone, you know, macaroni, the dish, the Italian food, and then Magaroni putting going in the maga.
16:08.189 --> 16:09.850
[UNKNOWN]: And there yeah, that's that's very clever.
16:09.870 --> 16:10.070
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
16:10.829 --> 16:15.093
[UNKNOWN]: It's nice to have that available and that's traveled worldwide.
16:15.153 --> 16:25.642
[UNKNOWN]: Again, shout out the New York base journalist, George the Stefano coined that and he's been he's been carrying the torch for a very, very long time of Italian Americans aren't a monolith.
16:25.842 --> 16:30.726
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, he coined that and it got everywhere like people literally use it now to it's just awesome.
16:31.867 --> 16:37.992
[UNKNOWN]: And it's it's actually scary because Georgia Maloney, the prime minister of Italy, has some fascist tendencies
16:39.054 --> 16:39.795
[UNKNOWN]: She's a fascist.
16:39.875 --> 16:44.381
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, yes, she's not quite as extreme as what we got going on here.
16:44.421 --> 16:46.084
[UNKNOWN]: I would say, but yeah, she's a fascist.
16:46.724 --> 16:52.572
[UNKNOWN]: Italy is really interesting right now as far as what's going on, because yeah, they have George and Maloney.
16:53.173 --> 16:55.737
[UNKNOWN]: They have also been so outspoken.
16:56.077 --> 17:05.720
[UNKNOWN]: for Palestine, and they have had general strike after general strike after general strike, and the dockers have refused to load the weapons heading to Israel.
17:05.740 --> 17:07.260
[UNKNOWN]: And they've been doing that for years.
17:07.321 --> 17:08.701
[UNKNOWN]: This is not the first time.
17:09.081 --> 17:15.283
[UNKNOWN]: You know, that's why, I mean, the anti-fascist in that video had on the Lavorno T-shirt, that is on purpose.
17:15.323 --> 17:24.806
[UNKNOWN]: I also have a cat named Lavorno, and it's not just Lavorno, by the way, it's, you know, the ports in general have been doing it too, so I don't want to, I don't want to make it out like it's just one port because it isn't
17:25.272 --> 17:29.056
[UNKNOWN]: Don't be poor, don't be poor, don't be in this.
17:29.336 --> 17:31.958
[UNKNOWN]: So yeah, I mean, it's really interesting.
17:32.078 --> 17:44.129
[UNKNOWN]: And the most popular, the most popular figure culturally and Italy right now, arguably at least, is Zero Kokare, who's in onapologetic anti-fascist cartoonists.
17:44.150 --> 17:49.534
[UNKNOWN]: I don't know if you've ever watched any of his series on Netflix, but I mean, that second season in particular,
17:50.215 --> 17:52.318
[UNKNOWN]: never would have gotten made in the United States.
17:52.338 --> 17:56.864
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, it's literally about fighting Nazis as Antifa in Italy.
17:56.944 --> 17:58.807
[UNKNOWN]: Like, that's what the series is about.
17:59.447 --> 18:06.156
[UNKNOWN]: And it's, uh, I was, I was surprised it was even available in the US, but, you know, probably because it's a different country.
18:06.176 --> 18:07.038
[UNKNOWN]: They were like, yeah, whatever.
18:07.518 --> 18:17.247
[UNKNOWN]: But yeah, I mean, he's in unapologetic, you know, anti-fascist comic book artist, you know, has a bunch of like lefty punk bands in a show and stuff like that.
18:17.847 --> 18:20.209
[UNKNOWN]: And he's huge over there right now.
18:20.509 --> 18:24.112
[UNKNOWN]: And there's been, you know, again, protests after protests for Palestine.
18:24.593 --> 18:27.756
[UNKNOWN]: So it's really interesting what's going
on.
18:27.856 --> 18:30.658
[UNKNOWN]: And just in other parts of the world too, I mean, on June 13.
18:31.819 --> 18:39.924
[UNKNOWN]: You know, the fascists were marching throughout the UK and throughout other parts of Europe, and they got, they got driven away in every single situation.
18:40.985 --> 18:41.205
[UNKNOWN]: Wow.
18:41.625 --> 18:47.709
[UNKNOWN]: And by the way, when did you start looking into the kind of radical Italian American history that exists?
18:48.589 --> 18:54.433
[UNKNOWN]: Both the history and it's present day existence, what made you look into that and what were your sources.
18:55.418 --> 19:02.441
[UNKNOWN]: Well, a lot of it was, well, some of it was just stuff that I kind of just knew about and kind of wondered why doesn't anyone talk about this side of it.
19:02.481 --> 19:15.367
[UNKNOWN]: Why is it all so one side it, but, but I just sort of was like, well, I guess that's just the way it is, but then it was the Italians for Zoran account and there's the other organization Piace learning about the existence of those things.
19:16.127 --> 19:29.655
[UNKNOWN]: and seeing what they were doing, and I'm like, well, if other people are really spreading this message, I should do my part, especially since I want to talk about it in my show, but in particular, in October.
19:31.452 --> 19:36.213
[UNKNOWN]: The Italians for Zoron account, because October is when there is, quote, unquote, Columbus Day.
19:37.954 --> 19:52.277
[UNKNOWN]: The Italians for Zoron account every day in October posted a piece of leftist oriented Italian American history every single day, and it was something totally different each day, and it was awesome.
19:52.397 --> 19:57.278
[UNKNOWN]: And shout out to Stephen Shirley, he's a historian in Italian American historian who curated
20:01.739 --> 20:22.052
[UNKNOWN]: And a lot of it was stuff I didn't know about, I mean, even though I know the basic propaganda around Columbus Day and how it kind of came to be, there were even layers to that thing that I was unaware of that I learned about for the first time and there's even a connection to Mussolini because some of those statues were from him because they wanted.
20:22.752 --> 20:37.197
[UNKNOWN]: they wanted Italian Americans to kind of feel this sort of connection to Italy still, but they wanted to paint this idea of what's like, well, you're not these, you're not these wafes, you're not totally white, but you're also not these others either.
20:37.237 --> 20:47.760
[UNKNOWN]: You're this, you're this in between thing and Columbus's your guy and it was, you know, it was baked into, you know, racism and xenophobia and, and
20:47.980 --> 21:08.409
[UNKNOWN]: Zidi baked into the Zidi baked into the Zidi big time and it's a people body because I mean it's it's hard to resist a good bowl of baked Zidi, but but yeah, so so that was a big thing and and around that same time I was thinking about my next friend show in the process of naming it so so yeah, that all kind of found its way in and it took shape like just beginning noodle it took shape
21:08.773 --> 21:09.655
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, exactly.
21:09.835 --> 21:11.297
[UNKNOWN]: Like a monoclox congealing.
21:11.898 --> 21:13.682
[UNKNOWN]: Where can people watch the show?
21:13.762 --> 21:14.683
[UNKNOWN]: People who are at fringe.
21:14.944 --> 21:17.087
[UNKNOWN]: And if not, where can they find out more about your work?
21:17.127 --> 21:18.530
[UNKNOWN]: If they can't get to the fringe festival.
21:19.283 --> 21:21.645
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, so I'm going to be at the French festival.
21:21.785 --> 21:25.368
[UNKNOWN]: I actually my run starts on August 6, which is a Thursday.
21:25.829 --> 21:26.670
[UNKNOWN]: It's a Thursday.
21:26.690 --> 21:30.533
[UNKNOWN]: So yeah, I go August 6 to 30 at the Westport Oracle.
21:30.633 --> 21:31.854
[UNKNOWN]: I'm part of the free fringe.
21:31.894 --> 21:32.755
[UNKNOWN]: So you don't need to take it.
21:32.815 --> 21:34.176
[UNKNOWN]: Just show up.
21:34.236 --> 21:36.518
[UNKNOWN]: So anyone who's going to be at the fringe comes say hello.
21:36.558 --> 21:38.820
[UNKNOWN]: My show is at 345 each day.
21:38.840 --> 21:41.362
[UNKNOWN]: And yeah, I'm really excited about it.
21:41.382 --> 21:44.265
[UNKNOWN]: It's the most excited I've ever been about to stand up hour.
21:44.445 --> 21:45.446
[UNKNOWN]: It's been the preview.
21:46.787 --> 21:47.627
[UNKNOWN]: the New York Preview.
21:47.667 --> 21:53.310
[UNKNOWN]: We actually sold out, which I was really thrilled about and we want to social justice award do.
21:54.290 --> 21:56.631
[UNKNOWN]: So I'm really looking forward to the official premiere.
21:57.551 --> 22:02.493
[UNKNOWN]: For those who will not be in Edinburgh at the French Festival, please do follow me online.
22:02.513 --> 22:04.234
[UNKNOWN]: I'm romplicone on all the socials.
22:04.254 --> 22:06.215
[UNKNOWN]: You can see my movie left at wall now.
22:06.595 --> 22:10.156
[UNKNOWN]: It's even available on YouTube free with ads and it's also free on 2B.
22:10.177 --> 22:11.537
[UNKNOWN]: So I recommend watching it for free.
22:11.577 --> 22:13.538
[UNKNOWN]: Why not get a free movie left at wall?
22:13.938 --> 22:15.038
[UNKNOWN]: Is the name of that movie?
22:16.459 --> 22:34.991
[UNKNOWN]: Just left that wall just the three words left at wall and it's uh, yeah, you can you can watch it right after this stream is over right after the episodes over you can pop over somewhere else and watch the movie you can just type it in and it'll come up on YouTube and then also I will humbly mentioned one thing real quick.
22:44.217 --> 22:45.017
[UNKNOWN]: very soon.
22:45.457 --> 22:47.618
[UNKNOWN]: Right now, we're still at the beginning stages.
22:47.658 --> 22:49.138
[UNKNOWN]: We're still at the soft launch phase.
22:49.538 --> 22:57.080
[UNKNOWN]: So we've been streaming on Wednesdays and you can catch that if you follow my sub stack, I'm just romplicone on sub stack and he is no one picked in
on sub stack.
22:57.100 --> 22:58.740
[UNKNOWN]: So we're in the soft launch phase now.
22:59.181 --> 23:05.602
[UNKNOWN]: So you can catch it now on Wednesdays, but we're going to be launching with projects centered here very shortly once everything gets settled.
23:06.102 --> 23:06.642
[UNKNOWN]: Oh great.
23:07.082 --> 23:07.923
[UNKNOWN]: And he's like a big
23:09.575 --> 23:15.477
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, he's an academic and you know, I have a past life as a as a pseudo academic I got out after master.
23:15.557 --> 23:19.538
[UNKNOWN]: So yeah, we started collaborating some and then this this idea kind of took off.
23:19.658 --> 23:23.779
[UNKNOWN]: So what was your what was your master's in communication.
23:24.799 --> 23:29.601
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, I was I was going to maybe go on for my PhD, but I don't know.
23:29.621 --> 23:33.262
[UNKNOWN]: I decided to give the comedy thing a chance and a lot of it didn't work out.
23:33.382 --> 23:33.622
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
23:34.472 --> 23:38.615
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, you probably make more money as a comedian than you would have at the beach day.
23:38.635 --> 23:40.556
[UNKNOWN]: So you probably made the safer decision.
23:41.037 --> 23:41.417
[UNKNOWN]: I did.
23:41.437 --> 23:45.480
[UNKNOWN]: I made the, especially since the academy's over now, which is also talked about in the show.
23:46.300 --> 23:46.561
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
23:46.801 --> 23:47.201
[UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
23:47.221 --> 23:47.381
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
23:47.781 --> 23:49.623
[UNKNOWN]: Well, Ron, thank you so much for coming on.
23:49.663 --> 23:51.164
[UNKNOWN]: We will link to your show.
23:51.204 --> 23:54.786
[UNKNOWN]: So people know where it is, but it sounds like you don't need to get tickets.
23:54.806 --> 23:55.587
[UNKNOWN]: So just walk over.
23:55.607 --> 24:02.872
[UNKNOWN]: If you're an Edinburgh and come back on and yeah, let's talk to you after you launch your next show that you just mentioned.
24:03.387 --> 24:04.928
[UNKNOWN]: Thanks a lot, Katie, so good to see you again.
24:05.268 --> 24:06.689
[UNKNOWN]: You too, have a great day.
24:07.129 --> 24:07.289
[UNKNOWN]: Bye.
24:08.370 --> 24:09.451
[UNKNOWN]: All right, that was great.
24:09.571 --> 24:15.074
[UNKNOWN]: That was the best anti-fascist comedy Italian American interview we've done in a long time.
24:15.754 --> 24:17.575
[UNKNOWN]: I saw a video of the show and it's great.
24:17.736 --> 24:18.916
[UNKNOWN]: So people should definitely see it.
24:19.337 --> 24:22.578
[UNKNOWN]: Also, Ron writes a cat, what do you call this?
24:22.659 --> 24:23.599
[UNKNOWN]: Like a cartoon.
24:24.239 --> 24:25.480
[UNKNOWN]: I'm so dumb about this stuff.
24:25.720 --> 24:27.001
[UNKNOWN]: I think it's called the cartoon, right?
24:27.421 --> 24:28.482
[UNKNOWN]: Ron is a call the cartoon?
24:28.742 --> 24:30.043
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, okay, it is a cartoon.
24:30.183 --> 24:31.284
[UNKNOWN]: About his cat Lucy.
24:32.060 --> 24:33.641
[UNKNOWN]: We are going to keep the show going.
24:33.701 --> 25:00.677
[UNKNOWN]: Now, please do if you haven't already, do like the stream that is a free way for you to support the show, make sure that more people come to it, tweet it out, Facebook it out, Instagram it out, tick, talk it out, because we want to make sure that people come and see the great guests that we have on give it thumbs up, join the Patreon, patreon.com, touch the Katie, help for show you get exclusive content, like the entire interview that we did with John Mirchheimer and Janice Verofakis, which people are loving and more exclusive content down the pipe.
25:01.357 --> 25:10.240
[UNKNOWN]: We are honored to bring back onto the show to fan faves, show faves, Ron Yucalic of Breakthrough News and Medea Benjamin of Code Pink.
25:10.320 --> 25:11.540
[UNKNOWN]: Welcome back, ladies.
25:12.080 --> 25:12.940
[UNKNOWN]: Hello.
25:13.321 --> 25:14.501
[UNKNOWN]: Hi, hello, Ron.
25:14.621 --> 25:15.541
[UNKNOWN]: Hello, Medea.
25:15.621 --> 25:16.421
[UNKNOWN]: Hello, Katie.
25:16.482 --> 25:18.622
[UNKNOWN]: What, wow, what a fabulous group of women.
25:18.962 --> 25:19.923
[UNKNOWN]: Yes, I know.
25:19.963 --> 25:21.963
[UNKNOWN]: We, we were on a panel together once, right?
25:22.003 --> 25:23.984
[UNKNOWN]: We're, we're, we're going on a panel about Hillary.
25:24.384 --> 25:26.464
[UNKNOWN]: Feel like that, that sounds correct.
25:26.825 --> 25:27.825
[UNKNOWN]: Age is a go.
25:28.405 --> 25:31.367
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, like in New York, I say, nice reunion.
25:31.407 --> 25:33.969
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, this is one of the iterations of that show.
25:33.989 --> 25:36.671
[UNKNOWN]: I've been wanting to launch, which is the lefty version of the view.
25:36.832 --> 25:40.534
[UNKNOWN]: So we can consider this an audition for that.
25:40.615 --> 25:52.103
[UNKNOWN]: But you know, we we just did and Ron, you're joining us from Bay Root and Medea, you're joining us from DC, the code pink house, as you can tell from the pink behind that you sex orange behind me.
25:52.684 --> 25:54.345
[UNKNOWN]: Oh, but there's pink to pink accent.
25:57.560 --> 26:00.964
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, is it the orange or is this code of code orange in between?
26:03.186 --> 26:04.848
[UNKNOWN]: Things are more urgent so it makes sense.
26:05.189 --> 26:18.904
[UNKNOWN]: So we just had this segment on fascism and anti-fascism and speaking of anti-fascism and fascism both of the organizations that you are part of have made the state department's new Cuba report.
26:19.544 --> 26:24.186
[UNKNOWN]: Well, actually break to news did not make the report, but code ping did I'm so sorry.
26:24.286 --> 26:25.847
[UNKNOWN]: I don't mean to give you guys a complex.
26:25.907 --> 26:27.888
[UNKNOWN]: I thought you were you had made it also.
26:28.088 --> 26:29.349
[UNKNOWN]: Okay, so actually this is a good.
26:29.409 --> 26:30.830
[UNKNOWN]: So this is an important clarification.
26:31.190 --> 26:34.952
[UNKNOWN]: Okay, so code ping made it into the report.
26:35.412 -->
26:42.215
[UNKNOWN]: Now I know that you read the entire report, Medea, can you tell us about the report and then Ron and you can tell us about what happened to you.
26:42.535 --> 26:47.358
[UNKNOWN]: I guess you guys were just subpoenaed along with the people's forum and try content and the research institute.
26:47.718 --> 26:53.424
[UNKNOWN]: I want to bring that up because I don't want to make you feel like a loser just because you didn't make their report.
26:53.525 --> 26:54.546
[UNKNOWN]: So thank you.
26:54.646 --> 26:55.186
[UNKNOWN]: Much appreciated.
26:55.226 --> 26:56.087
[UNKNOWN]: Much appreciated.
26:56.428 --> 26:56.708
[UNKNOWN]: Yes.
26:57.529 --> 27:02.615
[UNKNOWN]: So tell us, Medea, about the report you're in and then we'll talk about the attacks on you guys, Ronja.
27:03.860 --> 27:07.264
[UNKNOWN]: So this is the State Department report that came out.
27:07.484 --> 27:20.918
[UNKNOWN]: It's a 99 page screen about what this fantastical Cuban being the vector, the center.
27:21.619 --> 27:37.939
[UNKNOWN]: of a global revolution that includes on the international side, Russia and China and Iran, but really focuses on Cuba's infiltration into the U.S. going back many decades.
27:38.700 --> 27:45.385
[UNKNOWN]: spanning the, a lot of it is around civil rights uprisings in the US.
27:46.866 --> 27:58.895
[UNKNOWN]: Stokely Carmichael, Asadashakur, Angela Davis, on and on about connections that actually existed during the 60s, the 70s.
27:58.915 --> 27:59.535
[UNKNOWN]: But then jumping.
28:02.457 --> 28:26.991
[UNKNOWN]: to say that today there is this conspiracy that Cuba's finger prints or footprints are in all of these movements in the U.S., whether it is student uprising on campuses, anti-Is, Black Lives Matter, you name it Cuba is involved and has infiltrated these movements,
28:29.412 --> 28:41.600
[UNKNOWN]: And I want to read you what this is part of, in case people don't understand, a hemispheric marks his revolution that are wants to erase the United States from the Earth.
28:42.841 --> 28:44.762
[UNKNOWN]: Wow, what year would we even go?
28:45.498 --> 28:52.368
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, right, the singular goal of the Cuban Revolution has been conquering the United States.
28:53.750 --> 29:00.179
[UNKNOWN]: And then it's not just that it's a revolution against Western civilization itself.
29:01.169 --> 29:13.296
[UNKNOWN]: So it is a quite a crazy report, but what is so important about it is that one, it comes from the state department.
29:13.356 --> 29:19.760
[UNKNOWN]: So it is official, no matter if it was AI that wrote it, which is what some people are saying.
29:20.800 --> 29:24.022
[UNKNOWN]: But it is also put in this context.
29:24.122 --> 29:26.944
[UNKNOWN]: And I know Ron, you talk about this context.
29:27.704 --> 29:43.917
[UNKNOWN]: of the national security memorandum that was put out last year that talks about how the US is now going to get the go ahead to investigate and prosecute.
29:44.557 --> 30:08.614
[UNKNOWN]: the far left, and then more recently, this meeting that came together that the State Department hosted of over 60 representatives from over 60 countries to come together to talk about how on the global level, we are going to fight this far left extremists, including domestic terrorists and all of these countries.
30:09.434 --> 30:17.377
[UNKNOWN]: And then on top of that is the investigation that's being done of CodePink about the cubitrips.
30:17.558 --> 30:25.001
[UNKNOWN]: So all of that I think you have to put in context and of course then Ryan, you can talk about the context for the subpoena that they have received.
30:26.181 --> 30:26.481
[UNKNOWN]: Right.
30:26.601 --> 30:26.821
[UNKNOWN]: Yes.
30:27.022 --> 30:32.964
[UNKNOWN]: And I was on that trip to Cuba and I have to so far I have not received anything in the mail, but we'll see.
30:33.744 --> 30:34.605
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, knock on wood.
30:34.645 --> 30:34.785
[UNKNOWN]: Yep.
30:35.855 --> 31:00.006
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, as as marker review and Steven Miller target, uh, people who are just, we're just trying to deliver humanitarian aid to the Cuban people who marker review and Steven Miller starving, uh, there was another angle of this attack on breakthrough news and that is that we received a pee as a peanut from the houseways and means committee and congress demanding our internal communications.
31:00.826 --> 31:03.470
[UNKNOWN]: Which is first amendment protected materials.
31:03.890 --> 31:13.842
[UNKNOWN]: Now this comes of course on the heels of what Media was talking about the anti communism summit that took place a couple of weeks ago that was held by Marco Rubio and Steven Miller.
31:14.805 --> 31:22.771
[UNKNOWN]: where they basically tried to insinuate that ideas on the left are the equivalent of violence and terrorism.
31:23.352 --> 31:37.382
[UNKNOWN]: They talked about something that they're calling far-left extremism, far-left terrorism, far-left radicalism, without ever defining what any of that means, which is very dangerous, right, because they're literally trying to say,
31:38.863 --> 31:48.255
[UNKNOWN]: are just like we are where against murdering people in Cuba with an oil blockade where against dropping bombs on babies in Iran and on Gaza, right?
31:48.716 --> 31:51.680
[UNKNOWN]: That somehow is the equivalent of violence is what they're saying.
31:52.060 --> 31:53.803
[UNKNOWN]: So that's how it happened a couple weeks ago.
31:54.103 --> 31:57.227
[UNKNOWN]: But being anti-violence is violent for them.
31:57.327 --> 32:06.252
[UNKNOWN]: Basically, basically, basically, so that's something happened a couple of weeks ago, and they promised that there were more terrorist designations to come.
32:06.672 --> 32:19.880
[UNKNOWN]: You heard Steven Miller reference that NSPM7 on national security directive that is targeting the domestic left in the U.S. as being a part of that program.
32:20.520 --> 32:28.036
[UNKNOWN]: And then a few days later, you had a state
department publishing this insane Cuba report that Media just talked about, which basically listed, you know,
32:29.235 --> 32:42.625
[UNKNOWN]: People from all of these different organizations and individuals themselves, including elected officials, sitting mayors, like LA Mayor Karen Bass was on that list, by the way, and I'll get to why that matters.
32:42.926 --> 32:51.372
[UNKNOWN]: But also, co-pink the DSA, the people's for the National Lawyers Guild, as all being agents of Cuba.
32:51.873 --> 32:54.094
[UNKNOWN]: And, you know, by, I guess,
32:54.995 --> 32:59.999
[UNKNOWN]: You know, 10, gently, also agents of any other American adversary that listen that report.
33:00.059 --> 33:04.282
[UNKNOWN]: They said, Ron, Russia, China, Hasbala, Hamas.
33:04.902 --> 33:06.343
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, you guys are prolific.
33:06.704 --> 33:09.085
[UNKNOWN]: It was just completely completely absurd.
33:09.105 --> 33:17.692
[UNKNOWN]: Like this we're supposed to believe this tiny island of Cuba that the U.S. is literally strangling to death, were 1800 babies have died in excess because of that strangling.
33:18.332 --> 33:23.122
[UNKNOWN]: is also puppeteering what they call the destruction of American civilization.
33:23.162 --> 33:25.105
[UNKNOWN]: They literally say keep us trying to conquer America.
33:25.145 --> 33:26.067
[UNKNOWN]: It's so absurd.
33:26.758 --> 33:27.598
[UNKNOWN]: project head.
33:27.978 --> 33:28.178
[UNKNOWN]: Right.
33:28.298 --> 33:40.061
[UNKNOWN]: Also included as individuals in the report are people who attended the wedding of my co-director, Jodi Evans, and it was because they attended the wedding that they were listed.
33:40.121 --> 33:42.462
[UNKNOWN]: So that was Ben Cohen of Ben and Jerry's.
33:42.582 --> 33:44.842
[UNKNOWN]: It was Amy Goodman of Democracy Now.
33:45.382 --> 33:48.743
[UNKNOWN]: It was V and Slurs attending weddings.
33:49.223 --> 33:52.164
[UNKNOWN]: Now is now the equivalent of working as an age of Cuba.
33:57.565 --> 33:59.046
[UNKNOWN]: Well, too close, too close.
33:59.586 --> 34:03.287
[UNKNOWN]: Come, the guilt bias association is completely absurd.
34:04.447 --> 34:07.968
[UNKNOWN]: It's just, it's all, it wouldn't be so laughable if it wasn't so dangerous.
34:08.368 --> 34:16.131
[UNKNOWN]: So I just want to say I'm putting like what happened to Breakthrough News in the context of all of this escalation against the US left.
34:16.571 --> 34:19.712
[UNKNOWN]: And then so we received a few days after that keeper report.
34:20.392 --> 34:25.414
[UNKNOWN]: We've received a subpoena from the Houseways and Means Committee, like I said, demanding our internal communications.
34:25.855 --> 34:36.840
[UNKNOWN]: Now, this is a part of a concerted effort by Republicans and Congress who've been harassing us for years, they keep pushing this false claim that, you know, our journalism is a full part of a foreign plot.
34:37.620 --> 34:52.528
[UNKNOWN]: And that's come from other members of Congress, but the
ways in means committee specifically started sending us letters back in February of this year and in those letters, they kept referencing our coverage specifically of Israel's genocide in Gaza.
34:53.368 --> 34:59.553
[UNKNOWN]: and of our coverage of the opposition across the U.S. to the ice killings and kidnappings around the world.
35:00.174 --> 35:04.678
[UNKNOWN]: So literally just going after our viewpoints, upset about our reporting.
35:05.438 --> 35:15.687
[UNKNOWN]: And they sent several letters and I just want to say also, by the way, you guys, these letters, we almost every time learned about them first from Fox News, of course.
35:16.940 --> 35:18.121
[UNKNOWN]: which is really interesting.
35:19.121 --> 35:24.304
[UNKNOWN]: In fact, the first letter we received from them back in February, we didn't even get the letter ourselves.
35:24.324 --> 35:26.545
[UNKNOWN]: It didn't even come to us or to our lawyers.
35:27.046 --> 35:29.347
[UNKNOWN]: We learned about it because it was published at Fox News.
35:29.967 --> 35:36.931
[UNKNOWN]: So there's definitely some sort of collaboration going on between Fox News and these members of Congress to try to drum up
35:37.451 --> 35:43.975
[UNKNOWN]: hostile media coverage of us and other left progressive organizations.
35:44.235 --> 36:00.866
[UNKNOWN]: And they've done that with, I think they've done it as well with code pink in the case of, you know, media, you receive supposedly according to Fox news, a subpoena from the DOJ over your over your humanitarian aid trip to Cuba, but you actually never got a subpoena so sometimes they're just making things up.
36:01.751 --> 36:17.091
[UNKNOWN]: No, but you know, um, yes, we heard about it from Fox News as well and only found it because it was in Jody Evans spam box, but, um, but it was just yeah, but it wasn't as a peanut was a list of questions from what I understand.
36:17.451 --> 36:40.612
[UNKNOWN]: It's not a subpoena, but I've got and Jodi reminded me that we actually did get a subpoena last year from one of the committees, the natural resources, and it was about us talking about clean energy and things about, you know, the problem of big oil and that these were supposedly China talking points.
36:41.332 --> 36:47.355
[UNKNOWN]: And so that means, you know, that's about our relationship to China, talking points and clean energy.
36:47.475 --> 36:50.016
[UNKNOWN]: I, you know, I forgot about that whole thing.
36:50.056 --> 36:59.320
[UNKNOWN]: The other thing is like yesterday, I was in the Senate and Senator Josh Hawley, he, I was asking him about, you know, how are you going to vote on the Iran War Powers?
36:59.360 --> 37:02.061
[UNKNOWN]: And he says, oh, I'm so glad you're being investigated.
37:02.121 --> 37:03.561
[UNKNOWN]: Now you're being investigated.
37:05.342 --> 37:06.142
[UNKNOWN]: I said, for what?
37:06.542 --> 37:08.383
[UNKNOWN]: And you said, you're China connections.
37:09.083 --> 37:17.385
[UNKNOWN]: And you know, they've been saying that over and over again, and maybe they aren't investigating us, but the truth is that there's nothing there.
37:17.465 --> 37:18.586
[UNKNOWN]: There's no there there.
37:19.126 --> 37:27.088
[UNKNOWN]: So every time we're told that we're being investigated, they don't follow up because there's nothing to follow up.
37:27.148 --> 37:33.410
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, we have a donor who is an American who lives in China and that's connection.
37:34.520 --> 37:35.901
[UNKNOWN]: Wow, inexcusable.
37:36.502 --> 37:47.170
[UNKNOWN]: So this is part really what's going on here is you have right wingers and Congress that are completely abusing congressional investigative authority to target and view points they disagree with.
37:47.230 --> 37:48.091
[UNKNOWN]: That's what's happening here.
37:48.451 --> 37:55.057
[UNKNOWN]: And it's interesting you mentioned energy media because there was waves of this under Trump where they were targeting the environmental justice movement.
37:56.798 --> 38:08.424
[UNKNOWN]: It was basically driven by Trump's allies in Congress, but the ways in means committee, which is currently targeting breakthrough news, if this were like their entire reason for existing is to review tax policy, right?
38:08.844 --> 38:11.086
[UNKNOWN]: So they say, oh, we're just reviewing non-profits.
38:11.406 --> 38:19.730
[UNKNOWN]: Well, if this was really about reviewing non-profits, there's massive non-profits across the US that they could be looking into in terms of tax policy.
38:20.230 --> 38:23.332
[UNKNOWN]: Breakthrough News has a microscopic budget.
38:23.652 --> 38:29.938
[UNKNOWN]: compared to other media outlets in the country, and it's specifically compared to non-profits across the country.
38:30.379 --> 38:39.507
[UNKNOWN]: So they've said in previous letters that they're going after us because they don't like our viewpoint, say, we're too soft on adversaries like China and Russia as well.
38:40.008 --> 38:41.869
[UNKNOWN]: So like this is about viewpoint.
38:41.889 --> 38:43.311
[UNKNOWN]: This is about the first amendment.
38:43.811 --> 38:45.213
[UNKNOWN]: It's not about attack status.
38:45.253 --> 38:47.235
[UNKNOWN]: I think it's really important to understand that.
38:47.895 --> 39:04.831
[UNKNOWN]: Um, and in the case of breakthrough news, I mean, they're also going after other other smaller non-profit, other small nonprofits, but in the case of breakthrough news, they're targeting an independent media outlet, and I just want to point out, we are expressing the majority sentiment of the people in the US, which I think is interesting here, because
39:05.752 --> 39:18.255
[UNKNOWN]: You know, when you talk about the kinds of stuff that they're upset that we're reporting on, if we're talking about the genocide in Gaza and the movement to stop it or ice terror across the U.S., majority sentiment is on our side here.
39:18.723 --> 39:18.883
[UNKNOWN]: Right.
39:18.903 --> 39:19.804
[UNKNOWN]: It's not French.
39:20.024 --> 39:20.524
[UNKNOWN]: Well, exactly.
39:20.544 --> 39:25.966
[UNKNOWN]: Well, there's a one to our fringe, like you don't try to criminalize descent when you're winning the argument.
39:25.986 --> 39:27.707
[UNKNOWN]: You do it when you're losing the argument.
39:28.067 --> 39:30.449
[UNKNOWN]: And we know that the Trump administration is deeply unpopular.
39:30.849 --> 39:37.232
[UNKNOWN]: They have midterms coming up meanwhile you look across the country at these, you know, primary races that are taking place in progressives.
39:37.872 --> 39:56.528
[UNKNOWN]: And socialist candidates are winning these primaries, which is why they had a whole section on DSA and that Cuba report, they're very upset about DSA doing well in elections, because people, again, the majority of the countries against it as that in Gaza people want free healthcare and they want to stop funding wars Trump is currently.
39:57.288 --> 40:02.713
[UNKNOWN]: You know, overseeing the most unpopular war, I think in American history, the Iran War.
40:02.974 --> 40:09.620
[UNKNOWN]: So like the foreign plots here is all they really have left because they can't win their arguments on the merits of their arguments.
40:10.020 --> 40:13.764
[UNKNOWN]: So they're just accusing all of us of being some part of a foreign operation.
40:14.044 --> 40:15.446
[UNKNOWN]: There's no proof of this.
40:15.766 --> 40:19.329
[UNKNOWN]: They just like when Dia said, you just keep saying it over and over and over again.
40:19.369 --> 40:21.611
[UNKNOWN]: I just want to mention a few numbers here, because
40:22.638 --> 40:24.840
[UNKNOWN]: they they can't arrest their way out of this.
40:25.601 --> 40:34.288
[UNKNOWN]: Um, they really can't they can't I don't think they can criminalize their way out of this net favor ability towards Israel has dropped 67 points in eight years.
40:34.888 --> 40:39.472
[UNKNOWN]: It was from plus 51 during Trump's first term to now minus 16.
40:39.772 --> 40:45.997
[UNKNOWN]: That's roughly 90 million Americans who've literally changed their minds in just the last few years.
40:46.338 --> 40:51.242
[UNKNOWN]: You know how 55% of Americans who want to reduce or completely end military aid,
40:51.582 --> 40:52.022
[UNKNOWN]: to Israel.
40:52.322 --> 40:54.563
[UNKNOWN]: So this is not some fringe opinion.
40:54.583 --> 40:56.064
[UNKNOWN]: This is the majority of the country.
40:56.504 --> 41:10.350
[UNKNOWN]: And another thing that they kept saying in these letters against breakthrough news, prior letters, is they kept accusing us of using anti-American rhetoric, which is also something that Steven Miller says NSPM7 is going after anti-American rhetoric, whatever that means.
41:10.851 --> 41:17.254
[UNKNOWN]: And it really is just like summoning the ghost of the House of American Activities Committee, which the Cuba report that
41:21.216 --> 41:24.361
[UNKNOWN]: which is just utterly shocking because, you know, I went to school in the US.
41:24.381 --> 41:25.402
[UNKNOWN]: I think you guys did too.
41:25.743 --> 41:27.966
[UNKNOWN]: And we were taught that McCarthyism was a bad thing.
41:28.407 --> 41:32.172
[UNKNOWN]: But this administration is saying it's a good thing and it wants to openly resurrect it.
41:32.593 --> 41:35.116
[UNKNOWN]: But one thing that I keep saying that I think is really important.
41:35.657 --> 41:47.567
[UNKNOWN]: Is that under during McCarthyism and that entire era, you know, there was all these congressional committees doing what a lot of the committees today are trying to do, but they were able to get the public on board.
41:47.727 --> 41:52.551
[UNKNOWN]: And that is why it works so well, but I just referenced some opinions just on Israel.
41:52.571 --> 42:00.197
[UNKNOWN]: I didn't even go to the opinions that are also on our side when it comes to so many other issues that I don't think they'll be able to get the public on board with this one.
42:01.257 --> 42:13.645
[UNKNOWN]: And you know, they have a limited window to still do it in because midterms are coming up, you know, Trump don't think he's going to be able to be president forever, but never say never, but all of that's to say they are losing and this is what losers do.
42:13.985 --> 42:15.466
[UNKNOWN]: That doesn't mean it's not dangerous.
42:15.506 --> 42:16.506
[UNKNOWN]: We shouldn't wrap it up.
42:16.526 --> 42:17.447
[UNKNOWN]: We shouldn't dismiss it.
42:17.807 --> 42:20.168
[UNKNOWN]: because we all have to stand together against this.
42:20.428 --> 42:25.689
[UNKNOWN]: We have to like show solidarity with any organization that is being targeted is in the crosshairs right now.
42:26.049 --> 42:29.230
[UNKNOWN]: And you know, I'll tell you what you can do to help break through new specifically here.
42:29.591 --> 42:32.051
[UNKNOWN]: But this is part of a broader attack on the left.
42:32.371 --> 42:34.232
[UNKNOWN]: We mentioned that summit, the Cuba report.
42:34.652 --> 42:47.820
[UNKNOWN]: Well, forget also you had the prairie land case not too long ago, or you had ice anti ice protestors and Texas, who were sentenced to between 30 to 100 years in prison for protesting ice and ice detention center.
42:47.840 --> 42:49.921
[UNKNOWN]: You, you know, I.
42:50.481 --> 42:51.522
[UNKNOWN]: We can go on and on.
42:51.542 --> 42:52.262
[UNKNOWN]: They're looking also.
42:52.282 --> 42:59.006
[UNKNOWN]: They're looking to shape an entire campaign that goes after people who fund movements and who fund organizations that organize and educate.
42:59.386 --> 43:02.348
[UNKNOWN]: That's happening in conjunction with in addition to this as well.
43:02.628 --> 43:03.728
[UNKNOWN]: So they're going after funders.
43:03.748 --> 43:04.849
[UNKNOWN]: They're going after organizers.
43:04.869 --> 43:05.789
[UNKNOWN]: They're going after journalists.
43:06.170 --> 43:10.012
[UNKNOWN]: They are trying to go after the organized progressive movement.
43:10.692 --> 43:16.774
[UNKNOWN]: in America to try to shut it
down because they can't defeat it in a legal way.
43:17.215 --> 43:24.958
[UNKNOWN]: So all of that's to say like we all need to keep our eyes on this because they're literally trying to take the war on terror playbook and use it domestically.
43:25.458 --> 43:36.122
[UNKNOWN]: And if people are outraged about them coming after a media outlet like breakthrough news, which they should be, even if you hate breakthrough news, even if you don't like ideas, you have to recognize that this isn't a tack on freedom
43:39.347 --> 43:55.948
[UNKNOWN]: In that, you know, on that note, I encourage people to go to breakthroughnews.org slash donate and please if you can donate to our legal defense fund, you can also just go to breakthroughnews in the pop up window and there's a pop up window that will come up to tell you, you could do one of two things you can go sign our petition.
43:56.368 --> 44:03.369
[UNKNOWN]: to tell the House Ways and Means Committee to stop their which hunt into breakthrough news, and you can donate there as well.
44:03.429 --> 44:08.931
[UNKNOWN]: But I highly encourage people to please help us do that because it starts with breakthrough news.
44:09.291 --> 44:20.053
[UNKNOWN]: But if they succeed, which I don't think they will, but let's say they do, they will continue to go after the entire left and progressive media ecosystem to shut down.
44:21.657 --> 44:35.805
[UNKNOWN]: Well, it's interesting around you because and great analysis as always, but they don't want you guys to exist because you are kind of like a counterweight if you think about it how they use Fox news as they're like press arm right that's how they like announced their decisions.
44:36.225 --> 44:44.329
[UNKNOWN]: It's like Fox news is literally they're they're PR firm so they don't want anything that challenges that they don't want any media that challenges those narratives.
44:44.610 --> 44:44.890
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
44:45.510 --> 44:56.373
[UNKNOWN]: And in terms of, you know, what the activism that you engage in, Medea, let's take a look at why I mean, we, I think Ron is made a very clear why they're so threatened by breakthrough news.
44:56.833 --> 45:04.135
[UNKNOWN]: In case people want examples of the dangerous stuff that you guys do, and I'm being sarcastic because it's not dangerous, but it is dangerous for the powers that be.
45:04.175 --> 45:10.276
[UNKNOWN]: But let's watch a video, a recent video of you Medea, and fellow activists confronting US ambassador to the UN,
45:14.177 --> 45:15.859
[UNKNOWN]: about the blockade of Cuba.
45:17.240 --> 45:22.005
[UNKNOWN]: Please respond to those questions about the blockade on Cuba.
45:22.025 --> 45:25.248
[UNKNOWN]: You lied here and you were saying there's no blockade.
45:25.328 --> 45:27.911
[UNKNOWN]: Mr. President, there's a lot of talk today of an embargo.
45:28.912 --> 45:29.673
[UNKNOWN]: Indeed, there is one.
45:29.713 --> 45:30.894
[UNKNOWN]: It's staring us all in the face.
45:31.535 --> 45:33.516
[UNKNOWN]: It's the embargo that Cuban regime
45:34.370 --> 45:49.232
[UNKNOWN]: mercilessly and poses on its own people decade after decade after decade there is a blockade the president says there is a blockade it is an evil evil evil evil policy that is hurting 11 million Cuban people there
45:49.272 --> 45:54.478
[UNKNOWN]: There is not a drop of oil that the U.S. has allowed in since the end of March.
45:54.798 --> 45:59.563
[UNKNOWN]: That is an evil demonic, set tonic, unconscionable policy.
45:59.724 --> 46:04.229
[UNKNOWN]: The Cuban people are starving and you are doing that.
46:05.150 --> 46:07.332
[UNKNOWN]: You are responsible for their death.
46:07.692 --> 46:09.314
[UNKNOWN]: Bear blood is on your hands.
46:10.035 --> 46:12.217
[UNKNOWN]: The problem is that you don't listen.
46:12.557 --> 46:15.019
[UNKNOWN]: You have just one track.
46:15.119 --> 46:16.279
[UNKNOWN]: The problem is psychotic.
46:16.299 --> 46:16.660
[UNKNOWN]: You know what?
46:16.920 --> 46:17.520
[UNKNOWN]: It's fun.
46:17.700 --> 46:19.021
[UNKNOWN]: And you never go to Cuba.
46:19.141 --> 46:20.623
[UNKNOWN]: I've got people who don't know.
46:20.683 --> 46:21.263
[UNKNOWN]: Of course.
46:21.363 --> 46:23.084
[UNKNOWN]: And what has for those letters?
46:23.304 --> 46:24.225
[UNKNOWN]: Who has for them?
46:24.445 --> 46:28.208
[UNKNOWN]: It's Maria Alvira Salazar from Florida Congresswoman.
46:28.708 --> 46:33.370
[UNKNOWN]: Tell them, they said, they won't be a drunk and wail going in, and it doesn't be.
46:33.410 --> 46:34.311
[UNKNOWN]: Why is it what about?
46:34.371 --> 46:37.652
[UNKNOWN]: I think that you mean, well, but you have been fooled.
46:37.772 --> 46:39.893
[UNKNOWN]: No, but I'm trying to go away.
46:39.913 --> 46:42.635
[UNKNOWN]: You know, I talk to people on the street who hate the government.
46:42.935 --> 46:44.736
[UNKNOWN]: I talk to people on the street who like the government.
46:45.196 --> 46:45.736
[UNKNOWN]: None of them.
46:45.756 --> 46:46.857
[UNKNOWN]: Why do I have the government?
46:46.897 --> 46:47.617
[UNKNOWN]: I have the government.
46:47.697 --> 46:48.498
[UNKNOWN]: I have the government.
46:48.738 --> 46:49.578
[UNKNOWN]: But you know, democracy.
46:49.658 --> 46:50.138
[UNKNOWN]: I need democracy.
46:50.238 --> 46:51.839
[UNKNOWN]: I need democracy.
46:51.919 --> 46:52.820
[UNKNOWN]: I need democracy.
46:52.880 --> 46:56.281
[UNKNOWN]: And you don't die that children die in the incubators while this happens.
46:56.701 --> 46:57.782
[UNKNOWN]: You know, you have freedom.
46:57.982 --> 46:59.305
[UNKNOWN]: Are you going to use that?
46:59.425 --> 47:00.387
[UNKNOWN]: I'm going to have to run!
47:00.467 --> 47:01.869
[UNKNOWN]: Go back to your fancy!
47:01.889 --> 47:03.151
[UNKNOWN]: I'm going to be okay!
47:06.276 --> 47:12.219
[UNKNOWN]: Wow, you know what's fascinating is that she was born in the United States and she has an accent.
47:12.259 --> 47:14.741
[UNKNOWN]: I'm not saying this is this is not like an anti
immigrant thing.
47:14.781 --> 47:30.470
[UNKNOWN]: I'm not mocking her, but it's fascinating because it just speaks to like the strength of the Cuban American like community where you literally grow up in Miami and you're so surrounded by people from Cuba, yet you don't go to Cuba that she actually has an accent.
47:36.292 --> 47:45.796
[UNKNOWN]: You know, it took me a while to realize that she has never been to Cuba, right, the same with Marco Rubio to think he has never been to Cuba.
47:46.236 --> 47:52.718
[UNKNOWN]: And I'm learning it about all of these southern Florida right wing Cuban Americans.
47:53.158 --> 47:56.720
[UNKNOWN]: They haven't been to Cuba and they don't have any family left in Cuba.
47:56.840 --> 48:02.742
[UNKNOWN]: And that's why they can have this cruel policy because they have no feedback from people in Cuba.
48:05.303 --> 48:25.754
[UNKNOWN]: It really is a, and then, you know, in that clip you have after that, I was yelling at her, you know, cool when OS Miami, cool when OS Miami, Cuba is not Miami, and it's so cruel to think that you can pretend that you care about the Cuban people and you're doing all of this because you care so much about them.
48:26.054 --> 48:33.498
[UNKNOWN]: And the other thing, you know, Marco Rubio says is for for this administration democracy is capitalism.
48:34.018 --> 48:37.779
[UNKNOWN]: So if you open up the economy, you privatize everything.
48:37.859 --> 48:40.140
[UNKNOWN]: That is freedom, that is democracy.
48:40.580 --> 48:58.567
[UNKNOWN]: Well, the Cuban government, because it's really against the wall right now, it has opened up and announced all of these new openings for selling off private and state enterprises to private companies, to have all kinds of ways that foreigners can invest.
48:59.087 --> 49:04.755
[UNKNOWN]: In Cuba and yet the sanctions are preventing that from happening.
49:04.875 --> 49:12.767
[UNKNOWN]: So even if Cuba does what the US wants them to do in terms of the economy and openings, it doesn't work.
49:12.867 --> 49:14.950
[UNKNOWN]: And of course, what they really want is to
49:15.390 --> 49:16.631
[UNKNOWN]: get rid of the government.
49:16.731 --> 49:20.154
[UNKNOWN]: They understand it's Cuba, no as men as well.
49:20.174 --> 49:22.716
[UNKNOWN]: I tell them, Poco, you know, it's not men as well, either.
49:23.337 --> 49:24.497
[UNKNOWN]: And so they're stuck.
49:24.558 --> 49:27.960
[UNKNOWN]: And so what the policy is, just keep starving them.
49:28.481 --> 49:40.911
[UNKNOWN]: A policy that was announced in 1960 with a memorandum from a state department, official saying, we have to make the miserable, we have to starve them.
49:41.511 --> 49:42.972
[UNKNOWN]: Because Castro is too popular.
49:44.145 --> 49:53.007
[UNKNOWN]: That's what they said, like they're not there's too much support for for Castro and Cuba that the only way we can like destabilize them is by making them suffer.
49:53.327 --> 50:09.650
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, exactly the Mallory
Memo and by the way, a little side, I see a lot of comments saying that's not a Cuban accent you're I don't know what it's her accent again, it's not I guess it's a Miami accent people are saying, but the point is it's it's it's shaped by by people who are from Cuba and ironically, though,
50:10.270 --> 50:17.532
[UNKNOWN]: like their parents generation or grandparents generation, but these people ironically, even though they have an accent, they have not been to Cuba.
50:18.012 --> 50:21.653
[UNKNOWN]: But yeah, I mean, I think it's such an important point that she's like, I need democracy.
50:21.673 --> 50:26.654
[UNKNOWN]: Like, no offense lady, if you believe in democracy, then listen to the people of Cuba, right?
50:27.094 --> 50:34.296
[UNKNOWN]: If you're all about democracy, you're basically like calling, like you want to be the dictator of Cuba and decide that you want the political system you want.
50:34.316 --> 50:36.416
[UNKNOWN]: And in the meantime, you're fine with people suffering.
50:36.436 --> 50:39.837
[UNKNOWN]: And as you point to that, Medea, and I can attest to this too, having been to Cuba.
50:40.537 --> 50:44.904
[UNKNOWN]: No matter what people's views of the government there are, nobody wants to be deprived of oil.
50:45.004 --> 50:45.705
[UNKNOWN]: Who does that help?
50:52.972 --> 51:04.579
[UNKNOWN]: Well, that's right, and you know, another thing we didn't talk about that Cuba report is how it says that the Cuba has its hands in every country in Latin America trying to manipulate.
51:04.959 --> 51:16.826
[UNKNOWN]: And you know, it's so ironic coming at a time when the U.S. has openly revived the Monroe doctrine or the Don Road doctrine is now running the Venezuelan government is using.
51:19.047 --> 51:47.775
[UNKNOWN]: U.S. pressure both the carrot and the stick to influence elections all over Latin America and to say that, you know, it's Cuba, this little island that has lost at least 10% of its population in the last few years is influencing the entire continent is so crazy when it's the U.S. that has been doing this on steroids in the last since this last Trump administration with Mark or Ruby on power.
51:48.922 --> 52:12.719
[UNKNOWN]: I wanted to ask both of you about the bipartisan nature of this kind of new McCarthyism because obviously this crackdown is being led by the Republicans under Trump, you know, it's always a it's a fine line it's like we want to be clear right about this, this is a departure and aberration to some extent, but it also is a continuation of something that happened before, which is the repression and suppression that happens of the of the left.
52:13.199 --> 52:16.640
[UNKNOWN]: under Democrats as well, but it is, it is a rationing up.
52:16.700 --> 52:18.381
[UNKNOWN]: I think we can be honest about that, right?
52:18.401 --> 52:24.323
[UNKNOWN]: Like, we can be critical Democrats in their complicity while acknowledging that this is a qualitative and quantitative difference.
52:24.743 --> 52:27.764
[UNKNOWN]: But it's important and you tweeted about this, Ron, yet.
52:27.784 --> 52:39.648
[UNKNOWN]: So during an interview with Semaphore this week, Democratic Congresswoman from Michigan, Hillary Schulton had some interesting things to say about Senate candidate, Abdul al-Sayed.
52:42.029 --> 52:51.535
[UNKNOWN]: In interview with Semaphore Repillary Schulton, Democratic Michigan was asked whether she plans to support a dual sciat if he wins the Michigan Democratic Seminit primary her response.
52:51.615 --> 52:57.378
[UNKNOWN]: I will not stand beside someone who is allowed distinctly anti-American sentiment to end your public dialogue.
52:58.059 --> 53:08.145
[UNKNOWN]: Okay, and Ron, you respond to this in a tweet where you said, here's the Democrat sounding like Steven Miller accusing a dual sciat of being in accomplice to anti-American sentiment.
53:08.665 --> 53:16.800
[UNKNOWN]: So what do you think this is the result of his this because he's brown is it's because he calls a genocide a genocide is it both what what is this happened what's happening here.
53:18.100 --> 53:23.904
[UNKNOWN]: So I'm going to address that, but I just really quickly wanted to say this one thing about the Cuba report before I do address that.
53:24.165 --> 53:29.368
[UNKNOWN]: I hope you don't mind, because I just just to go back to it, that no, Ronnie, I'm in a silence you.
53:29.428 --> 53:31.810
[UNKNOWN]: If you, I'm going to subpoena you if you'd say that.
53:32.030 --> 53:32.851
[UNKNOWN]: Oh, I don't feel it.
53:33.091 --> 53:42.178
[UNKNOWN]: Just to tell you guys, maybe think of the key that you're having about the US and Cuba of like interfering in everything and the US is actually interfering in everything, which is absolutely true.
53:42.638 --> 53:44.740
[UNKNOWN]: But the report goes after Cuba.
53:44.840 --> 53:46.061
[UNKNOWN]: It says Fidel Castro.
53:47.762 --> 53:52.347
[UNKNOWN]: began plotting armed assault against neighboring governments after the Revolution.
53:52.367 --> 54:00.056
[UNKNOWN]: That's what it says launching expeditions against Haiti, the Dominican Republic, Nicaragua, and Panama, and just that year of 1959 alone.
54:02.236 --> 54:23.153
[UNKNOWN]: Um, the Guardian actually wrote a piece pointing out to that statement that was in the QA report that what it feels to mention is that Haiti was then run by Francois Puppa Dr. Valier, who killed an estimated 60,000 of his own people that a minute kid republic was run by Rafael Trujillo, who launched the partially massacre killing between 20,000 to 35 Haitians.
54:23.634 --> 54:28.498
[UNKNOWN]: And Nicaragua by the Somos of Family, who are accredited with the murder of up to 50,000 Nicaraguan's.
54:28.878 --> 54:43.088
[UNKNOWN]: So I just wanted to point out that the report is whining that a bunch of U.S. backed mass murderers across Latin America are what Cuba allied with popular sentiment in those countries against in the year 1959.
54:44.821 -->
54:52.646
[UNKNOWN]: Um, because they're really trying to, this, this, this, this, this government that we talked with the Don road doctrine, they're trying to take us back to that time before the Cuban revolution.
54:53.127 --> 54:58.390
[UNKNOWN]: When every single country was under the thumb of American empire, it was just like a colony of America.
54:58.771 --> 55:04.435
[UNKNOWN]: And in some cases, they've sort of succeeded a little bit, uh, and in this kind of far right tide across Latin America.
55:05.355 --> 55:09.096
[UNKNOWN]: But anyways, to your question about, oh sorry, do you want to ask me to do that?
55:09.236 --> 55:26.443
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I think we should add that both Mark or Rubio and even Chad Cruz who said that their families fled the the the the impressive regimes and came out turns out that they fled the about Tester regime that's exactly revolution over through.
55:26.543 --> 55:26.763
[UNKNOWN]: So,
55:27.783 --> 55:29.784
[UNKNOWN]: Kind of like thugs and liars.
55:30.084 --> 55:35.066
[UNKNOWN]: I know unless they were able to engage in time travel, they were lying and left the forecast was rise.
55:35.086 --> 55:37.426
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, thugs and liars these people.
55:38.247 --> 55:43.088
[UNKNOWN]: But you know, but to what you were saying about that woman who commented on Abdul, I'll say it.
55:43.148 --> 55:46.890
[UNKNOWN]: I think it speaks to a broader issue in the Democratic party that isn't at all surprising.
55:47.410 --> 55:55.833
[UNKNOWN]: And that is that, you know, they like to call Trump a fascist and I absolutely agree there are fascists in Trump's administration who really scare me and just scare all of us.
55:57.282 --> 56:09.191
[UNKNOWN]: But instead of being the opposition party against the fascists, the Democrats have been quite silent in the face of this unprecedented at least my lifetime assault on the progressive left across America.
56:09.211 --> 56:12.253
[UNKNOWN]: I didn't see anybody say a word.
56:12.313 --> 56:18.738
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, against the Cuba report, Ilhan Omar, and I think 10 other progressive Democrats released a statement, and that's nice.
56:19.198 --> 56:21.200
[UNKNOWN]: That's 10 Democrats among hundreds.
56:21.820 --> 56:31.784
[UNKNOWN]: in Congress who said nothing, who said nothing and I suspect the reason for that is because it's kind of like the enemy of my enemy.
56:31.924 --> 56:39.588
[UNKNOWN]: They hate the DSA, they hate the they hate their base, the Democratic leadership hates their base because their base is progressive.
56:40.208 --> 56:41.188
[UNKNOWN]: And so they would
56:45.310 --> 56:52.794
[UNKNOWN]: just like completely bulldoze, the left of the Democratic Party, so that they don't have to deal with these DSA primaries.
56:53.275 --> 56:54.335
[UNKNOWN]: I think that's what it's about.
56:54.695 --> 57:02.960
[UNKNOWN]: And that speaks to what that pretty white blonde lady said about the dark, the dark barbarian, Abzulal said.
57:02.980 --> 57:06.842
[UNKNOWN]: That's what it sounded like when she was saying, Abzulal said is so well-spoken.
57:07.383 --> 57:08.603
[UNKNOWN]: And what's anti-American?
57:08.664 --> 57:10.705
[UNKNOWN]: What anti-American sentiment is he put in?
57:11.405 --> 57:19.973
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, it's because, I mean, she is, unless she thinks that opposing a genocide as anti-American or that supporting healthcare for all is anti-American, maybe she believes that.
57:20.693 --> 57:22.335
[UNKNOWN]: But what I see there is race-bating.
57:22.655 --> 57:24.317
[UNKNOWN]: That's pure race-bating to me.
57:25.077 --> 57:26.238
[UNKNOWN]: Pretty explicitly so.
57:26.659 --> 57:27.540
[UNKNOWN]: And that's tolerated.
57:27.560 --> 57:35.306
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, you also saw, I think it was last week, there was like that that woman who was a surrogate for Haley Stevens.
57:36.147 --> 57:44.351
[UNKNOWN]: making a comment about being uncomfortable with the fact that Abdullah Sayid has Arabic music or something or the speaking Arabic.
57:44.671 --> 57:47.552
[UNKNOWN]: I actually, I didn't know that by the way, I didn't know he was playing Arabic music.
57:47.572 --> 57:48.232
[UNKNOWN]: I've never seen that.
57:48.613 --> 57:50.473
[UNKNOWN]: There's nothing wrong with that, by the way.
57:51.334 --> 57:54.315
[UNKNOWN]: There's also nothing wrong with speaking Arabic to Arabic speakers.
57:54.735 --> 58:03.299
[UNKNOWN]: But the fact that that sort of bigoted rhetoric is tolerated in the most well-funded wing of the Democratic Party is very upsetting,
58:05.840 --> 58:18.788
[UNKNOWN]: At the end of the day, they will align with Republicans or basically stand by silently and watch rather than stand up against fascists if it means staying in power themselves.
58:19.963 --> 58:22.664
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that's true, and it's scary.
58:22.864 --> 58:29.907
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, yeah, and it's, it's sorry, Ron, about these people talk about a bullseye being a threat to the Democrats and eating Republicans.
58:29.967 --> 58:36.870
[UNKNOWN]: Lady, this woman is not even vowing, like, is vowing, won't even say that she'll help him defeat the Republican.
58:37.270 --> 58:43.032
[UNKNOWN]: And then you have a former Biden aide saying that he like won't vote for him if he, if he wins.
58:43.092 --> 58:45.995
[UNKNOWN]: because they would rather the Republican win than him.
58:46.236 --> 58:47.537
[UNKNOWN]: Like, and that's the problem.
58:47.557 --> 58:50.701
[UNKNOWN]: And this is the Democratic Party is not a Democratic Party.
58:51.261 --> 58:52.242
[UNKNOWN]: Small D Democrat.
58:52.683 --> 58:58.089
[UNKNOWN]: It is a corporation that is beholden to its donors at the end of the day.
58:58.389 --> 59:01.673
[UNKNOWN]: And these are like the soul as ghouls, who will,
59:02.494 --> 59:24.411
[UNKNOWN]: Like speak the language of what anybody who gives the money tells them to speak whether it's a pack, whether it's the pharmaceutical industry, whether it's the weapons industry, that
is what they are beholden to and so, you know, they're making tons of money doing that and people who are trying to come into this party to reform it, which I don't think that's possible, but by all means go ahead and try.
59:25.471 --> 59:30.996
[UNKNOWN]: But the people who are coming into this party trying to reform it or trying to actually reflect the sentiment of the base of this party.
59:31.736 --> 59:34.898
[UNKNOWN]: uh, they are a major threat to that donor base.
59:35.378 --> 59:40.101
[UNKNOWN]: And so this is like totally predictable and actually quite logical behavior.
59:40.121 --> 59:40.881
[UNKNOWN]: Right.
59:41.262 --> 59:41.522
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
59:41.822 --> 59:52.208
[UNKNOWN]: For the last section of this interview, I would love to ask you, Ron, yeah, since you are based in Baywood, I want to ask you about stuff that's happening in the region that you're in.
59:52.768 --> 59:56.410
[UNKNOWN]: So obviously the war between the US and Iran has been escalating
59:59.652 --> 01:00:07.897
[UNKNOWN]: And last week, President Trump met with the President of Lebanon, Joseph Owne, let's take a listen to some comments he made during this press conference.
01:00:09.438 --> 01:00:17.463
[UNKNOWN]: The only was told from the bottom, if they're in a process of doing that, they're in the process of re-deploying to other sections.
01:00:18.191 --> 01:00:20.153
[UNKNOWN]: And again, they get along very well.
01:00:20.173 --> 01:00:21.134
[UNKNOWN]: That was a great agreement.
01:00:21.174 --> 01:00:22.356
[UNKNOWN]: They're signed with Lebanon.
01:00:22.876 --> 01:00:23.817
[UNKNOWN]: And they're re-deployed.
01:00:23.917 --> 01:00:24.898
[UNKNOWN]: Is this an argument?
01:00:24.958 --> 01:00:26.060
[UNKNOWN]: So that is him.
01:00:26.220 --> 01:00:30.144
[UNKNOWN]: He's saying that Israel is in the process of withdrawing from Lebanon.
01:00:30.224 --> 01:00:33.067
[UNKNOWN]: And he's saying they're in the process of re-deploying.
01:00:33.488 --> 01:00:35.069
[UNKNOWN]: So what is your reaction to that, Ron?
01:00:35.089 --> 01:00:35.330
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:00:35.870 --> 01:00:37.231
[UNKNOWN]: They don't use the word withdrawal.
01:00:37.271 --> 01:00:40.474
[UNKNOWN]: They use the word redeploy in place of withdrawal.
01:00:40.554 --> 01:00:41.835
[UNKNOWN]: It's a very confusing term.
01:00:41.915 --> 01:00:43.056
[UNKNOWN]: I don't understand why.
01:00:43.116 --> 01:00:47.720
[UNKNOWN]: Maybe it's because like that gives in the option to actually redeploy.
01:00:48.661 --> 01:00:49.641
[UNKNOWN]: That's not accurate.
01:00:49.681 --> 01:00:51.043
[UNKNOWN]: The Israelis have not withdrawn.
01:00:51.423 --> 01:00:54.165
[UNKNOWN]: There was like one village where they kind of withdrew.
01:00:54.185 --> 01:00:57.668
[UNKNOWN]: And then there was a village they withdrew from that they were never in in the first place.
01:00:57.688 --> 01:00:58.869
[UNKNOWN]: So it was all just like a fee.
01:00:58.949 --> 01:00:59.570
[UNKNOWN]: It was theater.
01:01:00.290 --> 01:01:05.495
[UNKNOWN]: uh, the Israelis are still occupying Southern Lebanon, the framework agreement that was signed was basically written by the Israelis.
01:01:06.155 --> 01:01:26.552
[UNKNOWN]: Uh, and it is, it was signed solely to try to undermine Iran's placement of Lebanon in the first clause of the memorandum and understanding that is now collapse between the Americans in Iranians, which stated that there must be a ceasefire in Lebanon and that that Lebanon's territorial integrity must be protected meaning that Israel must be
01:01:27.433 --> 01:01:47.748
[UNKNOWN]: So that is why Marco Rubio actually oversaw that framework agreement between the Israelis, Americans and the Lebanese that essentially cemented Israel's occupation of Southern Lebanon, and conditioned Israel's withdrawal or redeployment as they call it on his Bala first being disarmed.
01:01:48.929 --> 01:01:51.091
[UNKNOWN]: And has put in place
01:01:52.812 --> 01:02:04.818
[UNKNOWN]: this growing idea that the U.S. will be training special units in the Lebanese army to first disarm his balla before Israel withdraws, which was essentially me in civil war in Lebanon.
01:02:04.838 --> 01:02:07.240
[UNKNOWN]: So they're trying to ferment us of a war in Lebanon.
01:02:07.600 --> 01:02:10.562
[UNKNOWN]: There's no timeline for Israel's withdrawal.
01:02:10.642 --> 01:02:20.187
[UNKNOWN]: Israel's withdrawal is totally up to the Israelis when they decide they feel that Lebanon has done a decent job disarming his balla.
01:02:21.027 --> 01:02:26.089
[UNKNOWN]: based solely on their own conditions and American-led performance reviews.
01:02:26.929 --> 01:02:34.931
[UNKNOWN]: So yeah, this is the cementing of an occupation of the south and this really is still blowing up villages, making sure that people have nothing to return to.
01:02:35.191 --> 01:02:37.672
[UNKNOWN]: They're setting up checkpoints like they have in the West Bank.
01:02:38.746 --> 01:02:42.290
[UNKNOWN]: Um, and every single day there's these fire violations.
01:02:43.031 --> 01:02:46.215
[UNKNOWN]: Uh, and now the ammo you between the Iranians and Americans has collapsed.
01:02:46.235 --> 01:02:49.419
[UNKNOWN]: So like that's not really acting to do much at the moment.
01:02:49.519 --> 01:02:54.405
[UNKNOWN]: So Lebanon doesn't really have a say in what happens in Lebanon.
01:02:54.625 --> 01:02:58.770
[UNKNOWN]: Everything is sort of up to how this war between the Iranians and Americans turns out.
01:02:58.890 --> 01:03:03.594
[UNKNOWN]: And once there is a broader settlement, the Iranians will likely make demands about Lebanon.
01:03:04.055 --> 01:03:06.637
[UNKNOWN]: And that will be why the Israelis will withdraw if they do.
01:03:06.677 --> 01:03:11.481
[UNKNOWN]: It will be because they were forced to buy the Americans because the Iranians insisted on it.
01:03:11.861 --> 01:03:13.042
[UNKNOWN]: So that's where we're at right now.
01:03:13.323 --> 01:03:15.765
[UNKNOWN]: Let's
hope a civil war doesn't happen before that.
01:03:16.791 --> 01:03:17.492
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:03:17.532 --> 01:03:18.753
[UNKNOWN]: And what is the sentiment?
01:03:18.793 --> 01:03:29.665
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, I know that it's not a monolith, but what are people saying and feeling and thinking to the extent that you are witnessing this about what is happening right now, like what what do the people lemon on think are there.
01:03:30.105 --> 01:03:37.593
[UNKNOWN]: I know that there are some people who support his ball of some people don't is there is there you increasing opposition to Israel just because of literally what it's doing.
01:03:38.554 --> 01:03:43.138
[UNKNOWN]: A majority of the country is opposed to Israel, and sees them as a big threat to the country.
01:03:43.719 --> 01:03:44.540
[UNKNOWN]: Poles have shown that.
01:03:44.980 --> 01:03:47.362
[UNKNOWN]: A majority of the country is opposed to normalization with Israel.
01:03:47.402 --> 01:03:48.643
[UNKNOWN]: It doesn't mean they're opposed to peace.
01:03:49.084 --> 01:03:51.326
[UNKNOWN]: They want peace, and it's about how you get there.
01:03:52.287 --> 01:03:57.832
[UNKNOWN]: Whether people in the country support his bullet disarming or not, kind of depends geographically on where they're located,
01:03:59.213 --> 01:04:05.015
[UNKNOWN]: If you're not from the South, it's very easy to see it as just a South Lebanon problem, and not your problem.
01:04:05.335 --> 01:04:10.456
[UNKNOWN]: And then there's an entire media apparatus in Lebanon that's funded by right wing oligarchs.
01:04:10.476 --> 01:04:25.841
[UNKNOWN]: There's a guy, including a guy called Anton Saino, who is a Lebanese banker who helped collapse the economy, still people's money, and is now in a relationship with Morgan or Tegas, Trump's envoy to the Middle East, who I don't know if you saw got a lot of backlash for basically
01:04:26.281 --> 01:04:33.268
[UNKNOWN]: sitting at the same table as Benjamin Netanyahu a few days ago at Lindsey Graham's memorial service in Washington at a dinner.
01:04:34.409 --> 01:04:45.419
[UNKNOWN]: He funds a lot of media in the country and this kind of media promotes the idea that everything's as well as full and that the only way out of this is to normalize and Israel is not actually the enemy Iran is so really matters.
01:04:46.540 --> 01:04:53.322
[UNKNOWN]: who you're talking to, where they're located in the country, what their family's political affiliation is, that sort of thing.
01:04:53.602 --> 01:05:12.567
[UNKNOWN]: But some of the things that are dominated across the country is opposition to Israel, recognizing Israel's a threat to the entire country, and not wanting to normalize with it because it's coming into genocide and Gaza, and it's destroying South Lebanon, and if people in the South, more than anybody else are opposed to disarming his Ebola, because that's the only protection they have.
01:05:13.187 --> 01:05:14.287
[UNKNOWN]: The state doesn't protect them.
01:05:14.307 --> 01:05:15.167
[UNKNOWN]: The army doesn't protect them.
01:05:15.187 --> 01:05:27.410
[UNKNOWN]: The army of Lebanon is funded in armed by the Americans with like hand me down night vision goggles and broken guns because the Americans would never give weapons to the Lebanese army that would threaten Israel's military edge.
01:05:27.970 --> 01:05:29.570
[UNKNOWN]: That could actually be used to fight the Israelis.
01:05:29.610 --> 01:05:37.952
[UNKNOWN]: In fact, the Lebanese army Israel's killed like dozens of soldiers during this year and the Lebanese army is not allowed to fire back in Israel.
01:05:39.118 --> 01:05:42.942
[UNKNOWN]: So I guess I was wondering, like I understand what you were just talking about with the polls.
01:05:42.982 --> 01:05:52.232
[UNKNOWN]: I'm just wondering, has this changed, like, are there any people who were Israel supporters and has Bala opponents who because of Israel's actions are changing their minds?
01:05:53.363 --> 01:05:59.188
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, I had to, I'd have to pull the country, I feel like I can't get back to us on that after you pull the country.
01:05:59.228 --> 01:06:00.570
[UNKNOWN]: I'll go ask people and I'll get back to you.
01:06:00.590 --> 01:06:13.822
[UNKNOWN]: What I can say is that Israel invades Lebanon as they did this time around, people's opinions change because disliking his bullet domestically is not the same as opposing Lebanon's right to resist.
01:06:13.902 --> 01:06:17.285
[UNKNOWN]: Israel and recognizing that the army doesn't do it, so somebody has to.
01:06:17.933 --> 01:06:22.137
[UNKNOWN]: Right, right, probably helps build like build popularity for his Bala.
01:06:22.698 --> 01:06:30.545
[UNKNOWN]: And I'm not saying that like the way here, like Democrats being like, and that's why this is so evil because it's doing that, you know, that's not my point, but it is ironic.
01:06:31.766 --> 01:06:34.008
[UNKNOWN]: Ronia and Media, thank you so much for joining.
01:06:34.128 --> 01:06:35.790
[UNKNOWN]: As always, love hearing from you guys.
01:06:35.810 --> 01:06:36.851
[UNKNOWN]: You do the amazing work.
01:06:37.231 --> 01:06:38.392
[UNKNOWN]: Any final words for my interview?
01:06:39.615 --> 01:06:43.098
[UNKNOWN]: Well, I'll put in a plug for a cookpink to go to the website.
01:06:43.178 --> 01:06:54.830
[UNKNOWN]: We have a petition there, a letter going to Marco Rubio to say, dump this report, Cuba report in the trash, but also dump in the trash, the US blockade on Cuba.
01:06:55.470 --> 01:07:00.916
[UNKNOWN]: We have peace camps that people are organizing this summer coming together to talk about strategies for
01:07:01.676 --> 01:07:03.537
[UNKNOWN]: building up a real piece movement.
01:07:04.297 --> 01:07:07.298
[UNKNOWN]: And we have two things we want people to focus on as well.
01:07:07.438 --> 01:07:20.023
[UNKNOWN]: One is that section in the national, the budget for the Pentagon that would merge the U.S. and Israeli militaries together, it's
in the Senate called.
01:07:20.443 --> 01:07:42.600
[UNKNOWN]: Section 1217 and we want people to call your senators and say get that out of there and then finally to say we can't allow this Pentagon budget to just keep ballooning like it is of Trump once 1.5 trillion dollars and we have to be opposing that so those are some of the things and we hope people will go to code ping to work with us.
01:07:42.740 --> 01:07:43.060
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you
01:07:44.023 --> 01:07:44.263
[UNKNOWN]: Great.
01:07:44.303 --> 01:07:44.903
[UNKNOWN]: Thanks so much.
01:07:45.503 --> 01:07:50.605
[UNKNOWN]: I just want to say thank you to both of you for all of the amazing work you do and all of the solidarity.
01:07:51.405 --> 01:07:58.208
[UNKNOWN]: I think the most important thing to be doing is to make sure we aren't isolated when we're under attack like this as individuals and organizations.
01:07:58.268 --> 01:08:04.630
[UNKNOWN]: So it's so important that we get to you know have coverage from UK and that code pink is continuing to do the work it's doing.
01:08:04.670 --> 01:08:08.491
[UNKNOWN]: So I would just encourage everyone who's watching to go to all the things that Medija just mentioned.
01:08:09.131 --> 01:08:14.736
[UNKNOWN]: And to also go to BrictonNews.org and sign the petition that we have, donate if you can.
01:08:15.076 --> 01:08:26.345
[UNKNOWN]: So we can fight back against these attacks and just, you know, make sure you don't let these fascists make you so fearful you get silent because that's exactly what they want.
01:08:26.685 --> 01:08:32.290
[UNKNOWN]: So again, we got to stick together, not be isolated so that we can be strong when we push back.
01:08:33.277 --> 01:08:36.380
[UNKNOWN]: Well, amen, secular amen to that, agnostic amen to that.
01:08:36.440 --> 01:08:36.640
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:08:37.301 --> 01:08:37.881
[UNKNOWN]: All right.
01:08:38.622 --> 01:08:39.783
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you, Katie.
01:08:39.943 --> 01:08:40.464
[UNKNOWN]: Bye.
01:08:40.524 --> 01:08:41.665
[UNKNOWN]: Have a great day, lady.
01:08:42.707 --> 01:08:52.514
[UNKNOWN]: All right, now we are going to bring on Jake wrong, but because I didn't get to play it and I want I don't want to deprive it anyone and we were referring to the kind of the bipartisan nature of McCarthyism.
01:08:52.974 --> 01:08:53.675
[UNKNOWN]: Let's take a look.
01:08:53.695 --> 01:09:12.328
[UNKNOWN]: Let's take a stroll down memory lane and take a look at a video of Nancy Pelosi being asked by Dan and bash on CNN and January 2024 about anti genocide activists asking for a ceasefire and right after that, we will speak to attorney Jake from the in Rajab foundation.
01:09:14.203 --> 01:09:14.983
[UNKNOWN]: all the time.
01:09:15.364 --> 01:09:22.206
[UNKNOWN]: So I have a feeling for what feelings they have, but we have to think about what we're doing.
01:09:22.566 --> 01:09:26.528
[UNKNOWN]: And what we have to do is try to stop the suffering and gossip.
01:09:26.808 --> 01:09:29.049
[UNKNOWN]: This is women and children.
01:09:29.109 --> 01:09:30.889
[UNKNOWN]: People don't have a place to go.
01:09:31.209 --> 01:09:32.550
[UNKNOWN]: So let's address that.
01:09:33.150 --> 01:09:37.552
[UNKNOWN]: But for them to call for a ceasefire is Mr. Putin's message.
01:09:38.453 --> 01:09:40.814
[UNKNOWN]: Mr. Putin's message, make no mistake.
01:09:40.854 --> 01:09:44.236
[UNKNOWN]: This is directly connected to what he would like to see.
01:09:44.937 --> 01:09:46.378
[UNKNOWN]: Same thing with Ukraine.
01:09:46.838 --> 01:09:48.619
[UNKNOWN]: It's about Putin's message.
01:09:49.119 --> 01:09:54.402
[UNKNOWN]: I think some of these protesters are spontaneous and organic and sincere.
01:09:54.942 --> 01:09:57.624
[UNKNOWN]: Some I think are connected to Russia.
01:09:57.724 --> 01:10:02.507
[UNKNOWN]: And I say that having looked at this for a long time now.
01:10:02.527 --> 01:10:04.668
[UNKNOWN]: You think somebody's protests are Russian plants?
01:10:06.275 --> 01:10:13.301
[UNKNOWN]: I think some financing should be investigated and I want to ask the FBI to investigate that.
01:10:14.281 --> 01:10:16.123
[UNKNOWN]: Sorry, I was off screen crying.
01:10:16.163 --> 01:10:17.924
[UNKNOWN]: I was so moved by Nancy's word.
01:10:18.962 --> 01:10:21.664
[UNKNOWN]: So let's see another great, oops, another great Friday show.
01:10:21.684 --> 01:10:23.005
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you so much Brian for that.
01:10:23.205 --> 01:10:24.126
[UNKNOWN]: Keep up the great work.
01:10:24.186 --> 01:10:24.566
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
01:10:24.606 --> 01:10:24.966
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
01:10:25.046 --> 01:10:25.907
[UNKNOWN]: I'm Shanti for that.
01:10:26.087 --> 01:10:28.029
[UNKNOWN]: So two great, super chats.
01:10:28.109 --> 01:10:29.830
[UNKNOWN]: Now we are going to keep the show going.
01:10:29.890 --> 01:10:32.672
[UNKNOWN]: If you haven't already, like this stream, like this show, please do.
01:10:32.712 --> 01:10:34.473
[UNKNOWN]: If you haven't already subscribed, please do.
01:10:34.994 --> 01:10:41.999
[UNKNOWN]: Also, I'll be taking part in a special stream on Sunday for Abdul al-Sahed, 630 to 8.
01:10:42.079 --> 01:10:43.560
[UNKNOWN]: We'll post details later on that.
01:10:43.960 --> 01:10:47.762
[UNKNOWN]: But we will be, I think, co streaming part of that, let you know detail.
01:10:47.802 --> 01:10:48.602
[UNKNOWN]: So, okay.
01:10:48.802 --> 01:10:50.983
[UNKNOWN]: So, let us bring on Jake.
01:10:51.183 --> 01:11:03.929
[UNKNOWN]: Ram, he is an attorney with the Hidden Roger App Foundation, which actually does what so many people should be doing, so many institutions should be doing, but do not do, which is, hold his rarely war criminals accountable.
01:11:03.949 --> 01:11:05.189
[UNKNOWN]: So, welcome to the show, Jake.
01:11:05.609 --> 01:11:05.950
[UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:11:06.110 --> 01:11:06.570
[UNKNOWN]: Thanks, Robin.
01:11:07.391 --> 01:11:08.712
[UNKNOWN]: Hi, thank you for joining.
01:11:08.732 --> 01:11:09.373
[UNKNOWN]: Of
course.
01:11:09.893 --> 01:11:11.735
[UNKNOWN]: And thank you for all the work that you do.
01:11:12.055 --> 01:11:18.661
[UNKNOWN]: I wanted to start off by just asking you about what the Hin Rajap Foundation is and how you chose to name it.
01:11:18.821 --> 01:11:19.862
[UNKNOWN]: Hin Rajap Foundation.
01:11:21.003 --> 01:11:30.070
[UNKNOWN]: Yes, so the Hin Rajap Foundation is where a group of activists and lawyers started in very early 2024.
01:11:30.110 --> 01:11:32.472
[UNKNOWN]: So like a few a few months into the present genocide.
01:11:36.820 --> 01:11:40.343
[UNKNOWN]: You know, long short of this, we try to put Israeli soldiers in jail around the world.
01:11:40.463 --> 01:11:45.027
[UNKNOWN]: Try to have them arrested for their crimes, their work crimes, their crimes against humanity, and the crime of genocide.
01:11:45.588 --> 01:11:53.875
[UNKNOWN]: The way we do that is we compile dossiers of evidence on individual soldiers, were able to, I don't like, track where they were in Gaza,
01:11:55.247 --> 01:12:00.411
[UNKNOWN]: And you know, find out what crimes they committed, try to, you know, sometimes it's, you have the individual soldier.
01:12:00.572 --> 01:12:02.293
[UNKNOWN]: And we know they committed crimes.
01:12:02.313 --> 01:12:03.014
[UNKNOWN]: We've been tracking them.
01:12:03.114 --> 01:12:04.515
[UNKNOWN]: Sometimes we start from the crime.
01:12:04.535 --> 01:12:06.456
[UNKNOWN]: And we try to figure out what unit was in the area.
01:12:06.476 --> 01:12:08.538
[UNKNOWN]: And then from there, figure out what soldiers were around.
01:12:09.259 --> 01:12:11.641
[UNKNOWN]: But basically, compile these dosis of evidence.
01:12:11.801 --> 01:12:12.461
[UNKNOWN]: And then we,
01:12:14.083 --> 01:12:22.372
[UNKNOWN]: Once we have enough to proceed with the case, once we think enough to make a prosecution feasible, we will present it to prosecutors around the world and the relevant jurisdiction.
01:12:22.592 --> 01:12:25.615
[UNKNOWN]: Now this is either against what we call traveling soldiers.
01:12:25.755 --> 01:12:30.921
[UNKNOWN]: So this is soldiers who are on vacation after their tour of duty in Gaza.
01:12:32.082 --> 01:12:35.403
[UNKNOWN]: Let's say they go to Brazil, we are able to figure out that they're there.
01:12:35.743 --> 01:12:54.009
[UNKNOWN]: We have a file prepared, we submitted to the Brazilian prosecutor, under the principle of universal jurisdiction, which is to say that there are certain crimes that are so heinous that every country in the world has not only the moral obligation, but also the legal obligation and the legal duty and the legal ability to prosecute them, because the idea is that
01:12:54.689 --> 01:12:58.351
[UNKNOWN]: you know, these crimes are so awful that humanity as a whole is injured.
01:12:58.491 --> 01:13:02.252
[UNKNOWN]: And that's really paradigmatically at war crimes crime genocide, crimes against humanity.
01:13:03.353 --> 01:13:06.014
[UNKNOWN]: The only thing we do is we, we file against dual nationals, right?
01:13:06.794 --> 01:13:12.877
[UNKNOWN]: As, as maybe you might be aware, there are many tens of thousands of dual nationals serving in the Israeli army.
01:13:12.897 --> 01:13:14.238
[UNKNOWN]: I think there's something like
01:13:15.536 --> 01:13:17.559
[UNKNOWN]: almost 20,000 from the United States alone.
01:13:18.120 --> 01:13:19.622
[UNKNOWN]: These are people who go over.
01:13:19.702 --> 01:13:28.674
[UNKNOWN]: They either don't hold his family citizenship or they do, but they go over from their home country to go commit genocide in Palestine.
01:13:28.834 --> 01:13:29.555
[UNKNOWN]: And so these people,
01:13:31.095 --> 01:13:31.155
[UNKNOWN]: Dr.
01:13:31.175 --> 01:13:39.437
[UNKNOWN]: I really think is like the core of our work, though maybe not what people know us for, because we're able to move much more slowly and deliberately on these.
01:13:39.457 --> 01:13:47.899
[UNKNOWN]: You know, with universal jurisdiction, jurisdiction expires once the person leaves that whatever country they're in, right?
01:13:47.999 --> 01:13:51.880
[UNKNOWN]: The jurisdiction has tied to their physical presence with dual nationalism never expired.
01:13:51.920 --> 01:13:52.581
[UNKNOWN]: It's always there.
01:13:52.621 --> 01:13:57.062
[UNKNOWN]: So we can really take our time with these things and try to make sure that political conditions
01:13:58.750 --> 01:14:13.396
[UNKNOWN]: So you're saying, if it is really soldier is in Brazil, once it is really soldier or leaves Brazil, Brazil doesn't have jurisdiction, but if they're dual nationals, then there's no temporal limitations.
01:14:14.416 --> 01:14:16.297
[UNKNOWN]: Exactly, yeah, there's no temporal limitations.
01:14:16.417 --> 01:14:21.999
[UNKNOWN]: I should say that Brazil, like, if they launch an investigation while they have jurisdiction, will then they continue, right?
01:14:22.599 --> 01:14:24.420
[UNKNOWN]: It's just they have to act while the person is there.
01:14:25.145 --> 01:14:29.107
[UNKNOWN]: Sorry, dual national means you don't have to be citizen of two countries.
01:14:29.147 --> 01:14:32.149
[UNKNOWN]: So I thought that's what being a dual national means.
01:14:32.189 --> 01:14:33.070
[UNKNOWN]: So what does it mean?
01:14:34.030 --> 01:14:36.952
[UNKNOWN]: No, we say dual national is, but it does mean that citizen of two countries.
01:14:36.992 --> 01:14:43.896
[UNKNOWN]: But what I mean when I say, like, sometimes a person is not yet a citizen of Israel when they go there to- Right.
01:14:43.936 --> 01:14:45.757
[UNKNOWN]: So they have citizenship other than Israeli.
01:14:45.797 --> 01:14:48.199
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it's correct, yeah.
01:14:48.819 --> 01:14:50.640
[UNKNOWN]: And then with respect to the name,
01:14:52.260 --> 01:14:57.948
[UNKNOWN]: You know, I'm sure, you know, listeners know the story of Indraajra, but a brief recap for those who might not.
01:14:58.630 --> 01:15:01.354
[UNKNOWN]: Indraajra was a little girl in in Gaza
who.
01:15:03.364 --> 01:15:04.584
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, that's her.
01:15:05.445 --> 01:15:19.189
[UNKNOWN]: And in 2024, she was, I think 2024 or December 2023 was fleeing Northern Gaza itself with her family, with her cousin Leon and I think cousin's parents.
01:15:19.209 --> 01:15:24.971
[UNKNOWN]: And as they were fleeing, their car came under fire from an Israeli tank and just Israeli armored unit.
01:15:25.271 --> 01:15:25.411
[UNKNOWN]: And
01:15:27.870 --> 01:15:42.522
[UNKNOWN]: We have the, the reason she became so famous is because we have audit recording of the phone call that her cut sheet, her cousin made to the Palestinian red crescent begging for help, right, you know, the adults in the car had been killed by the Israeli fire.
01:15:49.843 --> 01:16:04.033
[UNKNOWN]: And it's kind of just like begging the passing red crescent to come, you can like hear her screaming and the eventually the passing red crescent to come and to medical workers were also murdered that day by by these real soldiers and
01:16:05.470 --> 01:16:10.214
[UNKNOWN]: They claimed initially that they weren't in the area, so then still came that and you see it online.
01:16:10.494 --> 01:16:14.957
[UNKNOWN]: A lot of husbandry people say, and actually Hamas did this, which is just, you know, the pastures.
01:16:15.518 --> 01:16:19.781
[UNKNOWN]: Eventually they opened the site became accessible after like two weeks.
01:16:20.381 --> 01:16:24.064
[UNKNOWN]: And they found the car and it was riddled with over 350 bullets.
01:16:24.244 --> 01:16:27.347
[UNKNOWN]: They were able to find like the charred out remains of the ambulance because it was struck.
01:16:28.127 --> 01:16:31.870
[UNKNOWN]: I've tank fire, if I remember correctly, and the bodies of the two workers.
01:16:32.177 --> 01:16:36.661
[UNKNOWN]: So they targeted the ambulance precisely because it was on its way to save people.
01:16:37.462 --> 01:16:43.727
[UNKNOWN]: Yes, and that's just a part of the broader campaign of the murder of medical workers in Gaza.
01:16:44.668 --> 01:16:54.617
[UNKNOWN]: And you know, we named, I didn't have a wrong name, the organization I joined after it was already up and running, but the organization was named after him because, you know, it is really,
01:16:56.030 --> 01:17:04.493
[UNKNOWN]: one of the more heart-wrenching and just like egregious stories that is emerged from the genocide, but it's also a typical one, right?
01:17:04.513 --> 01:17:13.055
[UNKNOWN]: It isn't really indicative of what these railways are doing every day, which is murdering people and gossip, killing children, killing aid workers.
01:17:13.075 --> 01:17:19.857
[UNKNOWN]: It's just indicative of just what this campaign is, which is the wholesale extermination of life in Gaza, is what they are trying to do.
01:17:20.618 --> 01:17:24.063
[UNKNOWN]: And it just happens to be that this one, we have the audio of.
01:17:24.384 --> 01:17:26.006
[UNKNOWN]: And it, like, so haunting.
01:17:26.547 --> 01:17:26.988
[UNKNOWN]: Exactly.
01:17:27.108 --> 01:17:27.288
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:17:27.328 --> 01:17:28.810
[UNKNOWN]: This movie can be played in this place.
01:17:29.572 --> 01:17:32.276
[UNKNOWN]: Again, this is, this is a commonplace occurrence.
01:17:32.883 --> 01:17:44.387
[UNKNOWN]: And it's also, I mean, it's really heartbreaking because you hear the, like, at the, I mean, you hear him Rajab's voice, and she sounds like a little girl, but she is a little girl, and she's asking for help.
01:17:44.868 --> 01:17:55.932
[UNKNOWN]: And then you hear the voices of the Red Press and volunteers, workers, and they have such like, you can see how, I mean, it's like, obviously heartbreaking for them, but they are being so, I don't know how to explain it.
01:17:55.952 --> 01:17:59.013
[UNKNOWN]: Like, they're trying so hard to give her, like, five,
01:17:59.413 --> 01:18:25.810
[UNKNOWN]: Hope kind of and and and it's her yeah, yeah, yeah, and like pray with her Yeah, and it's just heartbreaking because they wanted to I mean that and they was delayed because they knew that it was risky like they were trying to get permission So I mean, it's just must be it's again It's like also like all the trauma and secondary trauma like the trauma faced by the people trying to save people who are themselves Also targeted as you pointed out medical workers just like journalists and
01:18:26.270 --> 01:18:36.655
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, anything, if you, if you dare to try the save lives, or you dare to try to record the killing, you know, especially at risk.
01:18:37.716 --> 01:18:37.916
[UNKNOWN]: Yes.
01:18:38.136 --> 01:18:39.597
[UNKNOWN]: And it's absolutely disgusting.
01:18:40.317 --> 01:18:42.639
[UNKNOWN]: So what kind of successes have you had so far?
01:18:42.659 --> 01:18:45.160
[UNKNOWN]: Have you had any yet, or are you still in the process?
01:18:46.440 --> 01:18:48.882
[UNKNOWN]: We're still in the, I mean, we have, but.
01:18:50.277 --> 01:18:51.539
[UNKNOWN]: So, we've had successes.
01:18:52.139 --> 01:18:55.302
[UNKNOWN]: None of them knows really soldiers have been put in prison yet.
01:18:55.382 --> 01:19:06.974
[UNKNOWN]: You know, we're operating from a position of the world has abandoned the Palestinian people and if not outright back to their extermination, right?
01:19:07.474 --> 01:19:09.456
[UNKNOWN]: And so it's really an uphill battle of trying to
01:19:11.038 --> 01:19:15.181
[UNKNOWN]: You know, make states follow their legal obligations.
01:19:15.221 --> 01:19:23.047
[UNKNOWN]: And I really need to stress that this isn't just that, you know, states have like statutes in their criminal code that criminalize these things and give them jurisdiction.
01:19:23.567 --> 01:19:27.470
[UNKNOWN]: It's also that they have the international legal obligation to prosecute people, right?
01:19:27.570 --> 01:19:28.991
[UNKNOWN]: Under the Geneva Convention, Article 46,
01:19:30.352 --> 01:19:41.123
[UNKNOWN]: It imposes an affirmative duty on states to
seek out people who are alleged to have committed great grave breaches of the convention and investigate them and bring them to trial without regard to national.
01:19:41.143 --> 01:19:46.988
[UNKNOWN]: So that means, basically, you have a duty to exercise universal jurisdiction over war crimes.
01:19:47.649 --> 01:19:47.989
[UNKNOWN]: And so,
01:19:48.957 --> 01:19:53.619
[UNKNOWN]: You know, and there are similar provisions in the genocide convention and the convention against torture, right?
01:19:53.739 --> 01:19:56.000
[UNKNOWN]: Like these states all have the ability.
01:19:56.440 --> 01:19:57.681
[UNKNOWN]: No, I mean, a lot of them are just incorporated.
01:19:57.701 --> 01:20:02.703
[UNKNOWN]: The room statute, the U.S. hasn't incorporated the room statute, but we have our own war crime statute and genocide statute.
01:20:03.403 --> 01:20:04.384
[UNKNOWN]: And they have the obligation.
01:20:04.684 --> 01:20:08.606
[UNKNOWN]: And so they are failing their legal obligations under treaties that they have sought.
01:20:09.306 --> 01:20:12.227
[UNKNOWN]: There's another legal obligation, which is stems from a 2007 ICJ case.
01:20:14.218 --> 01:20:29.250
[UNKNOWN]: where once the risk of genocide, not even just like a genocide, well, it's the risk of genocide becomes apparent, it becomes known or you ought to know it, states have an obligation to do everything within their power to bring it to an end, right?
01:20:29.270 --> 01:20:32.632
[UNKNOWN]: And that's a universal, every state has an obligation to do this, under the genocide convention.
01:20:33.453 --> 01:20:39.858
[UNKNOWN]: And, you know, it's no excuse, the court says, that one individual action won't actually bring it to an end
01:20:44.681 --> 01:20:46.223
[UNKNOWN]: they could affect the outcome and save lives.
01:20:47.044 --> 01:20:53.331
[UNKNOWN]: And measures that are within their power are things like cutting off diplomatic ties, cutting off economic ties, sanctions, right?
01:20:54.873 --> 01:20:57.476
[UNKNOWN]: But one that's really manifestly within their power.
01:20:57.576 --> 01:20:58.918
[UNKNOWN]: And it's frankly quite easy to do.
01:20:58.978 --> 01:21:04.004
[UNKNOWN]: It's discrete demand is if a war criminal comes to your state, investigate them and prosecute them.
01:21:05.347 --> 01:21:05.727
[UNKNOWN]: That's easy.
01:21:06.368 --> 01:21:08.609
[UNKNOWN]: So you already have the obligation stemming from other things.
01:21:08.649 --> 01:21:12.712
[UNKNOWN]: But now because there's a genocide going on, you have an extra obligation on top of that.
01:21:13.493 --> 01:21:16.775
[UNKNOWN]: And so they said, we're facing a very hostile terrain.
01:21:16.835 --> 01:21:18.857
[UNKNOWN]: But that's not to say we haven't had some successes, right?
01:21:18.897 --> 01:21:26.803
[UNKNOWN]: So we've had investigations launched in Peru and Brazil and they're ongoing, a couple other jurisdictions.
01:21:27.463 --> 01:21:30.485
[UNKNOWN]: We had Israeli soldiers arrested
at a music festival in Belgium.
01:21:30.706 --> 01:21:33.388
[UNKNOWN]: Last year, they were ultimately
01:21:34.932 --> 01:21:39.816
[UNKNOWN]: You know, they interrogated and ultimately released and they referred the case to the ICC, which is not what they should do.
01:21:39.856 --> 01:21:41.958
[UNKNOWN]: They should prosecute under their own domestic courts.
01:21:41.978 --> 01:21:43.399
[UNKNOWN]: We can get into a while later.
01:21:43.479 --> 01:21:57.750
[UNKNOWN]: But we had that, and just recently, just in the past few days, and Israeli soldier, who's committed war crimes in Gaza, was on his way to the Netherlands to judge some kind of collegiate debate competition.
01:21:58.551 --> 01:22:03.295
[UNKNOWN]: And as a result of our filing, the competition was canceled because they're like, you are not going to go through it this.
01:22:03.735 --> 01:22:09.320
[UNKNOWN]: So, you know, none of these are what the law demands because the law demands that these people get prosecuted and punished, right?
01:22:09.940 --> 01:22:18.207
[UNKNOWN]: But we are trying to chip away at this wall of impunity that has existed for Israel since 1948, right?
01:22:18.587 --> 01:22:27.414
[UNKNOWN]: They have never been held accountable for the crimes they've committed against thousand and people and they have been committing crimes against the Palestinian people since the colonization of Palestine began, right?
01:22:27.434 --> 01:22:27.915
[UNKNOWN]: Even prior to 48,
01:22:32.414 --> 01:22:36.396
[UNKNOWN]: And this wall of impunity is so ingrained, especially in the Western world.
01:22:37.156 --> 01:22:40.557
[UNKNOWN]: But I also don't want to let the global South up the hook because it's ingrained there as well.
01:22:41.958 --> 01:22:48.580
[UNKNOWN]: But it's so ingrained and it's such, um, it's it's starting from such a profound disadvantage.
01:22:48.760 --> 01:22:58.464
[UNKNOWN]: And yet, it's an iterative process by which I mean, the more we just do these filings, the more we do the better the outcome start becoming.
01:22:59.024 --> 01:23:00.965
[UNKNOWN]: And part of that is a result of
01:23:01.921 --> 01:23:05.486
[UNKNOWN]: These statutes are kind of dormant in so many states.
01:23:05.526 --> 01:23:08.490
[UNKNOWN]: They don't really prosecute workers or use universal jurisdiction very often.
01:23:08.590 --> 01:23:17.343
[UNKNOWN]: Although the Europeans did it quite robustly against ISIS and also crimes by a committed by people in the Assad government.
01:23:19.378 --> 01:23:20.579
[UNKNOWN]: So they know what they have, right?
01:23:20.699 --> 01:23:21.660
[UNKNOWN]: But a lot of governments don't.
01:23:22.260 --> 01:23:27.905
[UNKNOWN]: And so part of it is like getting these illegal tools back in the view of prosecutors.
01:23:28.766 --> 01:23:33.509
[UNKNOWN]: Part of it is letting people in these countries know that this is a discrete demand that they can make of their government.
01:23:33.750 --> 01:23:36.932
[UNKNOWN]: You know, a lot of people that I speak through don't know that this is a tool that's available.
01:23:37.553 --> 01:23:41.376
[UNKNOWN]: And through the findings that people become aware of that and do start to exert political pressure.
01:23:41.856 --> 01:23:45.539
[UNKNOWN]: And you know, something we always say is that, you know, the law is very clear.
01:23:46.099 --> 01:23:47.320
[UNKNOWN]: It could not be clear, frankly.
01:23:48.301 --> 01:23:49.682
[UNKNOWN]: But the only thing missing is political will.
01:23:49.982 --> 01:23:59.868
[UNKNOWN]: And that does come from like grassroots movements and people on the ground in these countries, trying to pressure their governments to do something, do anything to stem the tide of the genocide.
01:24:00.629 --> 01:24:11.516
[UNKNOWN]: And as more filings come out, not only did they become aware of it, but also it puts very helpful, I think, a faces to these crimes.
01:24:15.739 --> 01:24:21.823
[UNKNOWN]: And a lot of the demands that are placed on governments, which are good ones, that are correct ones to make, are structural and hatred, right?
01:24:22.323 --> 01:24:29.488
[UNKNOWN]: It's disentangle your economies, divest disentangle your military production and arms sales, right?
01:24:30.049 --> 01:24:34.152
[UNKNOWN]: And these things are important, and they must be done, and they are legally required.
01:24:35.172 --> 01:24:40.536
[UNKNOWN]: But they, I think, for reasons that should be obvious, are like somewhat difficult for people to
01:24:42.137 --> 01:24:49.522
[UNKNOWN]: cognize or people to get emotionally invested in, whereas the language of criminality is quite clear.
01:24:49.542 --> 01:24:54.005
[UNKNOWN]: And like this is a guy, this is his crime, go get him, everyone understands that.
01:24:54.566 --> 01:25:04.393
[UNKNOWN]: And I don't mean to we don't mean to like individualize the genocide because exactly our proposition is this is why we go after rank and file soldiers is that this is not a few bad apples.
01:25:04.493 --> 01:25:07.154
[UNKNOWN]: This is not a product of just the higher ups, right?
01:25:07.655 --> 01:25:10.217
[UNKNOWN]: Because even though Netanyahu and Galant and
01:25:11.407 --> 01:25:16.304
[UNKNOWN]: Generals may have authored the policies, those policies are carried out by soldiers on the ground.
01:25:16.922 --> 01:25:21.445
[UNKNOWN]: Those are the people who are on the ground committing the crimes that have been authorized by their higher else.
01:25:21.965 --> 01:25:25.287
[UNKNOWN]: And so it's not that like, oh, this guy's a bad apple, that guy's a bad apple.
01:25:25.627 --> 01:25:33.172
[UNKNOWN]: It's really that the entire military, really the entire military apparatus is involved in a campaign of criminality.
01:25:33.292 --> 01:25:40.076
[UNKNOWN]: There is no way for them to execute this campaign legally within the bounds of the law because the aim is genocide, right?
01:25:41.277 --> 01:25:41.617
[UNKNOWN]: And so,
01:25:42.257 -->
01:25:43.839
[UNKNOWN]: Like a pointless fashion, right?
01:25:43.940 --> 01:25:49.767
[UNKNOWN]: I think a composite picture of the overwhelming and total criminality emerges through these individual fights.
01:25:51.168 --> 01:26:14.084
[UNKNOWN]: It is interesting because I think people who think like you and me, obviously, we, you know, think like structurally like you were saying and we often see like the lower it's like lower hanging I don't want to say that because that's makes it dismissive, but we often see like for Abbu Gray, for instance, like the people punished for Abbu Gray were very like low down on the chain, right, but it does seem also like you want to kind of create like denormalize.
01:26:15.674 --> 01:26:19.897
[UNKNOWN]: this criminality, like stigmat appropriately stigmatize it, right?
01:26:20.097 --> 01:26:33.928
[UNKNOWN]: And create a sense of, like, chip away at the sense of impunity, but it also seems like a workaround given the kind of sadly, the, I don't know, the neutered nature of international humanitarian law.
01:26:35.129 --> 01:26:39.793
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, 100% and, you know, part of that is just the way it's set up, right?
01:26:39.813 --> 01:26:43.957
[UNKNOWN]: Like the ICC is designed to go after, like, quote, those most
01:26:45.032 --> 01:27:01.794
[UNKNOWN]: Right, because of the past few issues and because of the mandate that does mean going after people like and then young right and there's obviously more that they should be going after but they're also like severely limited by like they've severely limited resources and they're constantly under attack by the United States and so.
01:27:02.813 --> 01:27:11.095
[UNKNOWN]: There's a sense in which like international justice is equipped to handle the higher-ups, but it is really not equipped to handle individual soldiers.
01:27:11.556 --> 01:27:22.619
[UNKNOWN]: You know, the only thing that really would be is if a special tribunal was set up, something like the international criminal tribunal for the former live Yugoslavia, or the one I set up for Rwanda, and that these are set up for specific
01:27:23.566 --> 01:27:24.347
[UNKNOWN]: They're not general course.
01:27:24.367 --> 01:27:26.528
[UNKNOWN]: They're for specific scenarios, right?
01:27:26.628 --> 01:27:31.012
[UNKNOWN]: And so they have a wider mandate and they can generally take in more more perpetrators.
01:27:31.452 --> 01:27:33.714
[UNKNOWN]: But key thing is they're set up by the security council.
01:27:34.635 --> 01:27:37.477
[UNKNOWN]: And we know who's on the security council.
01:27:37.537 --> 01:27:39.078
[UNKNOWN]: So this is not going to happen.
01:27:39.619 --> 01:27:41.981
[UNKNOWN]: And so it really falls to domestic courts.
01:27:42.481 --> 01:27:45.884
[UNKNOWN]: And I think that I think it should fall to domestic courts anyway, right?
01:27:46.044 --> 01:27:49.366
[UNKNOWN]: And for a few reasons, one is that that is how international law gets
01:27:50.267 --> 01:27:53.389
[UNKNOWN]: It's up to countries who enforce international law.
01:27:53.429 --> 01:27:55.330
[UNKNOWN]: And we see this with the ICC arrest warrant, right?
01:27:55.710 --> 01:27:56.771
[UNKNOWN]: And arrest warrant has been issued.
01:27:56.911 --> 01:27:57.892
[UNKNOWN]: The ICC has no army.
01:27:57.912 --> 01:27:58.572
[UNKNOWN]: It has no police.
01:27:59.052 --> 01:28:05.356
[UNKNOWN]: And so it's up to individual countries to affect those arrest warrant and arrest them, and y'all, which not they are abrogating their duties to do.
01:28:05.416 --> 01:28:10.419
[UNKNOWN]: Every time he flies over a country to get to the United States, those countries are in violation of the robes' action.
01:28:12.875 --> 01:28:19.789
[UNKNOWN]: So there's that that it's up to individual countries to to affect your international law and give it teeth, but also
01:28:21.133 --> 01:28:25.456
[UNKNOWN]: We don't want these countries to be able to say, well, he belongs in the hate.
01:28:25.516 --> 01:28:27.257
[UNKNOWN]: It's true, big people belong in the hate.
01:28:27.937 --> 01:28:28.938
[UNKNOWN]: They belong in your course, too.
01:28:29.198 --> 01:28:42.107
[UNKNOWN]: And this is a way of kind of creating a global effort, a truly global effort, and a global consensus that these work criminals, basically everyone who's in the ITF, they're not welcome.
01:28:42.747 --> 01:28:46.089
[UNKNOWN]: And this is a way of making them feel not welcome, and making the world much smaller for them.
01:28:46.569 --> 01:28:47.970
[UNKNOWN]: The world needs to become small for them.
01:28:50.552 --> 01:28:54.114
[UNKNOWN]: following through on their very basic legal obligations to press.
01:28:55.055 --> 01:29:01.680
[UNKNOWN]: And is the hope that they will also be like scared and encourage more defection or more, does that play any part in it?
01:29:01.720 --> 01:29:04.722
[UNKNOWN]: That it'll cause like a, I don't know, some kind of mutiny.
01:29:05.522 --> 01:29:10.826
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, I don't know about a mutiny because the, the vast majority was really society is, um,
01:29:11.252 --> 01:29:15.996
[UNKNOWN]: Like in favor of the genocide and actually it has been over time radicalizing and moving further to the right.
01:29:16.736 --> 01:29:20.619
[UNKNOWN]: Like, which is now a trend in much of the world, but it wasn't always.
01:29:22.078 --> 01:29:31.202
[UNKNOWN]: So, no, not really, but it is like part of why they feel they can commit these crimes is because they can commit these crimes.
01:29:31.502 --> 01:29:36.484
[UNKNOWN]: They've gotten away with the many of these crimes for so long, and they have no fear of consequence.
01:29:36.544 --> 01:29:42.587
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, and this is very obvious to us because so much of the evidence that we gather comes from their own published videos.
01:29:43.207 --> 01:29:47.389
[UNKNOWN]: People on social media, publishing their own crimes, because they aren't even thinking
01:29:50.330 --> 01:29:54.974
[UNKNOWN]: you
have ministers and soldiers, kind of just being like, you know, f*** the hate, like, come and get me.
01:29:55.194 --> 01:29:59.238
[UNKNOWN]: Well, there's this real culture of infunity that has been fostered by the world.
01:29:59.298 --> 01:30:01.140
[UNKNOWN]: That's refusal to prosecute them.
01:30:01.740 --> 01:30:03.202
[UNKNOWN]: And so we do want them to be afraid.
01:30:03.242 --> 01:30:08.987
[UNKNOWN]: We want them to feel that consequences are coming and will this curve they were heavier?
01:30:09.427 --> 01:30:09.748
[UNKNOWN]: Maybe.
01:30:10.288 --> 01:30:13.191
[UNKNOWN]: But it will, I think,
01:30:15.171 --> 01:30:21.272
[UNKNOWN]: kind of force some contradictions to the four in the world system and in international law.
01:30:21.853 --> 01:30:29.094
[UNKNOWN]: It's self that can help bring about a time when countries feel more comfortable sanctioning them.
01:30:29.154 --> 01:30:36.396
[UNKNOWN]: It's, you kind of make the road by walking and once that wall of impunity falls, it's the floodgates are open, right?
01:30:37.076 --> 01:30:42.077
[UNKNOWN]: I really think that once the first soldier, the first official is prosecuted and put in prison,
01:30:45.546 --> 01:30:50.409
[UNKNOWN]: And it's not, right, and I don't want to suggest that, like, the law is the tool that's going to liberate Palestine.
01:30:50.669 --> 01:30:51.009
[UNKNOWN]: It's not.
01:30:51.650 --> 01:30:53.331
[UNKNOWN]: It is one of the tools in the toolbox.
01:30:53.671 --> 01:30:56.853
[UNKNOWN]: And we are using that tool, but it's not the endo and B.O.
01:30:56.873 --> 01:30:58.634
[UNKNOWN]: There's all this other work that needs to happen.
01:30:59.134 --> 01:31:00.335
[UNKNOWN]: But this is the one we know how to do.
01:31:00.395 --> 01:31:01.195
[UNKNOWN]: It's the one we're good at.
01:31:01.295 --> 01:31:04.297
[UNKNOWN]: And so we are playing our part, but it's, I think, a very important.
01:31:05.141 --> 01:31:10.144
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, and just to clarify, I didn't mean what this encouraged me to need because it would cause like a moral transformation.
01:31:10.184 --> 01:31:16.348
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, literally out of self-interest, people will be like, I don't want to not be able to travel and go to like Thailand and Latin America.
01:31:16.369 --> 01:31:17.829
[UNKNOWN]: And what, you know, they always do this, right?
01:31:18.370 --> 01:31:23.593
[UNKNOWN]: Although I guess those trips are like between, is it between before the Army or after the Army that they go on these days?
01:31:23.613 --> 01:31:24.494
[UNKNOWN]: Excuse me, that's what we Army.
01:31:24.634 --> 01:31:26.295
[UNKNOWN]: So it's actually like the crimes, right?
01:31:27.196 --> 01:31:32.739
[UNKNOWN]: But it is, I mean, there's actually a very interesting case recently in Australia, where these
01:31:34.209 --> 01:31:45.355
[UNKNOWN]: Israeli teenagers basically were granted refugee status because we're granted asylum because they said, we don't, we have like made an oath not to serve in the IDF.
01:31:45.615 --> 01:31:51.198
[UNKNOWN]: And if we are compelled to go back to Israel, we will be forced to commit four crimes.
01:31:51.898 --> 01:31:55.340
[UNKNOWN]: And we will be, I would rather be imprisoned or we will be forced to commit four crimes.
01:31:55.500 --> 01:31:59.262
[UNKNOWN]: And the Australian government was like, yeah, yeah, you're no arguing with that.
01:31:59.282 --> 01:32:00.063
[UNKNOWN]: So you get asylum.
01:32:00.832 --> 01:32:03.375
[UNKNOWN]: And they're not like great on this issue, the Australian government.
01:32:03.715 --> 01:32:05.176
[UNKNOWN]: No, we'll put it down on that generally.
01:32:06.498 --> 01:32:07.659
[UNKNOWN]: But it's just indisputable, right?
01:32:07.859 --> 01:32:10.061
[UNKNOWN]: And that's also a part of what the work does is,
01:32:12.307 --> 01:32:22.572
[UNKNOWN]: Like building consensus that these people that there are work on is being committed, even if they're not actually putting them in prison like they're obligated to do, it has other downstream effects like this and it's great.
01:32:22.612 --> 01:32:31.016
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, it's a, it's a handful of people who are refusing to serve in the idea, but the handful that do has been growing and that's a good thing.
01:32:31.337 --> 01:32:31.917
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, it's not.
01:32:33.471 --> 01:32:34.392
[UNKNOWN]: It's really a small.
01:32:34.452 --> 01:32:39.756
[UNKNOWN]: I really don't want to discount the kind of genocidal further that is overtaken is really society in total.
01:32:39.796 --> 01:32:48.704
[UNKNOWN]: But like there are people there who are refusing to serve and it's encouraging that they are couching it in these terms that we will be forced to commit warrants.
01:32:49.004 --> 01:32:51.106
[UNKNOWN]: That's that's an important thing for them to be saying.
01:32:52.432 --> 01:33:03.419
[UNKNOWN]: Talk to us about how this relates to, you know, Zoran obviously said he would arrest Nanyahu, then he, he was very, you know, straightforward about the limitations of that, right?
01:33:03.439 --> 01:33:08.923
[UNKNOWN]: So he, he basically said his administration looked into it and they were, they would not be able to.
01:33:09.283 --> 01:33:37.377
[UNKNOWN]: But then you have people like, you know, John Fetterman making it seem like he was obviously like not able to like it was as if it was this like black and white thing that Zorn was being ridiculous or a lying or there's no actual, I mean, obviously like Fetterman says ridiculous things and and the only time we ever seemed like put on the suit is one of the boss net now who comes to town, but talk about those limitations, I think these limitations kind of speak to why you're approaching in Rajab is is so needed.
01:33:38.498 --> 01:33:41.299
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I mean, Zaron can't hear us, no, no, he's right about that, right?
01:33:41.479 --> 01:33:43.160
[UNKNOWN]: And he just sees what's never able to.
01:33:43.680 --> 01:33:46.701
[UNKNOWN]: I appreciate that he explored all his legal options, right?
01:33:46.721 --> 01:33:50.222
[UNKNOWN]: It's not, no, very few legal issues are cut and dry, right?
01:33:50.522 --> 01:33:51.102
[UNKNOWN]: That's what I'm saying.
01:33:51.142 --> 01:33:55.364
[UNKNOWN]: It's not like I'm not saying that O Zaron couldn't and federal meant wrong, but the way he presented it.
01:33:55.464 --> 01:33:58.445
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, obviously, the guy that I've been asked on this, yeah.
01:33:59.385 --> 01:34:03.667
[UNKNOWN]: Federman is a moron and a racist and a genocidal Nazi.
01:34:03.687 --> 01:34:05.368
[UNKNOWN]: So like mean just kind of is not him, right?
01:34:05.388 --> 01:34:10.110
[UNKNOWN]: But like, but yeah, Zoran can not rest in Yahoo, it was always kind of clear that he wouldn't be able to.
01:34:10.370 --> 01:34:14.531
[UNKNOWN]: But it's it's important to explore and say that you are interested in doing it.
01:34:14.571 --> 01:34:27.797
[UNKNOWN]: And so I really appreciate that that he did and that opens up at the surface of space and he is calling, you know, he's he's probably the first major politician in the United States, as far as I can remember to call for the United States federal government to rest in the United States.
01:34:27.937 --> 01:34:28.858
[UNKNOWN]: and they do that that way.
01:34:29.038 --> 01:34:29.678
[UNKNOWN]: They can do that.
01:34:30.258 --> 01:34:32.299
[UNKNOWN]: Even though they're not a party of their own statue, it doesn't matter.
01:34:32.319 --> 01:34:37.722
[UNKNOWN]: You can arrest him under domestic laws, you can arrest him and just send him to the hate.
01:34:37.762 --> 01:34:40.284
[UNKNOWN]: You don't need to be a party to effectuate the warrants.
01:34:40.824 --> 01:34:45.947
[UNKNOWN]: So no, I mean, there are limitations and they really stem not from like no one can arrest that young
01:34:48.448 --> 01:34:49.709
[UNKNOWN]: He can't do it.
01:34:50.009 --> 01:34:52.650
[UNKNOWN]: And he can't do it because US isn't a party of their own statutes.
01:34:52.670 --> 01:35:00.513
[UNKNOWN]: So it's not like the warrants have any actual legal effect here the way they do in countries that are a party of their own statutes.
01:35:00.994 --> 01:35:04.635
[UNKNOWN]: It's also that Netanyahu has committed crimes under U.S. law, right?
01:35:04.815 --> 01:35:06.056
[UNKNOWN]: Under the U.S. War crimes Act.
01:35:06.977 --> 01:35:10.623
[UNKNOWN]: and the genocide statute, but those crimes are federal crimes.
01:35:11.384 --> 01:35:19.337
[UNKNOWN]: And as the Mary, he's like not empowered to necessarily effectuate arrest people for all federal crimes, I feel like some specific grants or some like.
01:35:20.162 --> 01:35:30.906
[UNKNOWN]: It technical stuff, but right like the United States government could turn around tomorrow and say we are arresting them Yahoo for crimes under US law, right?
01:35:32.087 --> 01:35:37.208
[UNKNOWN]: They won't do that, obviously, because they're not only just like
complicit in the genocide, but go perpetrating it.
01:35:38.589 --> 01:35:39.049
[UNKNOWN]: But they could.
01:35:39.149 --> 01:35:41.370
[UNKNOWN]: And there's issues of immunity, right?
01:35:41.450 --> 01:35:43.191
[UNKNOWN]: But head of state immunity is not absolute.
01:35:43.731 --> 01:35:45.892
[UNKNOWN]: And the US practice on head of state immunity is basically
01:35:47.082 --> 01:35:49.784
[UNKNOWN]: you either get it or you don't, depending on whether we like you, right?
01:35:50.864 --> 01:36:00.971
[UNKNOWN]: And most countries now have a consensus that head of state of immunity goes away with respect to international crimes, like genocide and war crimes.
01:36:01.031 --> 01:36:03.173
[UNKNOWN]: So the US could just brush that aside.
01:36:03.753 --> 01:36:10.477
[UNKNOWN]: There is a kind of like temporary immunity that he enjoys because of the,
01:36:12.320 --> 01:36:24.852
[UNKNOWN]: The treaty on the privileges and immunities of the United Nations, which is that if you are coming to New York to go to the United Nations, you cannot be arrested for the like the duration of that visit as long as you are like in the like official.
01:36:25.887 --> 01:36:26.467
[UNKNOWN]: This, right?
01:36:26.487 --> 01:36:31.691
[UNKNOWN]: So then Yahoo goes to the UN, but then goes off mission to go do something else, that's not the UN.
01:36:31.711 --> 01:36:32.671
[UNKNOWN]: He could be arrested, right?
01:36:33.111 --> 01:36:35.493
[UNKNOWN]: But, well, no, I feel like this is a good treaty.
01:36:35.593 --> 01:36:37.854
[UNKNOWN]: It's important to have that treaty, right?
01:36:38.475 --> 01:36:40.136
[UNKNOWN]: And the US kind of violates it anyway.
01:36:40.256 --> 01:36:43.218
[UNKNOWN]: But it's important to have that treaty, but it's also,
01:36:44.163 --> 01:36:49.748
[UNKNOWN]: You know, that's just a very specific way, you get a immunity for that very time-bound period.
01:36:50.128 --> 01:36:56.974
[UNKNOWN]: But it's also, I think, the important distress that, like, this is why it's all, it's important to suspend Israel from the United Nations, right?
01:36:57.034 --> 01:37:00.417
[UNKNOWN]: This is, it's something that Malaysia has brought up, it's something it's been talked about before.
01:37:00.877 --> 01:37:03.199
[UNKNOWN]: And there hasn't been any movement on it, which I think is quite cowardly.
01:37:03.540 --> 01:37:09.225
[UNKNOWN]: And there should be movement on it that you, you, you, in general, assembly has the capacity to do this, and they did it to South Africa.
01:37:10.337 --> 01:37:19.566
[UNKNOWN]: Um, and they should do it to Israel, and if they were to do it to Israel, then there could be no official UN delegations from Israel, and they would never enjoy that kind of immunity.
01:37:19.907 --> 01:37:23.790
[UNKNOWN]: And of course, this wouldn't make the US arrest them, but it is like,
01:37:24.666 --> 01:37:31.974
[UNKNOWN]: There is, these people are a joint immunity from genocide charges because of their official human status in this one specific way.
01:37:32.735 --> 01:37:35.358
[UNKNOWN]: And it would really send a signal that like, they are a periostate.
01:37:35.478 --> 01:37:38.361
[UNKNOWN]: Like, these are exactly the things that you're not supposed to do.
01:37:38.902 --> 01:37:41.985
[UNKNOWN]: There's this principle in your national awkward, use Cogans norms, right?
01:37:42.566 --> 01:37:43.707
[UNKNOWN]: And these are the norms that are
01:37:44.528 --> 01:37:46.850
[UNKNOWN]: Like, basically, it means like the most important ones.
01:37:47.010 --> 01:37:48.872
[UNKNOWN]: These are things that are non-derogable.
01:37:48.972 --> 01:37:51.795
[UNKNOWN]: So you can't like a torture as long, genocide is another, right?
01:37:52.335 --> 01:37:58.321
[UNKNOWN]: You cannot have in your legal code any exception to the prohibition on torture, which is real doubts, by the way.
01:38:00.958 --> 01:38:21.028
[UNKNOWN]: And so like these like Israel's routinely violated the most important norms in their national law is also routinely violating the sovereignty of every country around it by invading their committing to like on top of everything else the crime of aggression right and that is how rogue states act and it is exactly the mandate of the United Nations.
01:38:21.808 --> 01:38:34.280
[UNKNOWN]: to prevent that from happening, and when it does happen to do anything it possibly can to maintain international peace and security, and the greatest threat to international peace and security of science in the United States is Israel at this moment.
01:38:34.360 --> 01:38:38.124
[UNKNOWN]: And whether there's any separation, it's also still a matter of debate.
01:38:39.425 --> 01:38:42.268
[UNKNOWN]: And can you explain what the Rome statute is for people who don't know?
01:38:43.314 --> 01:38:49.939
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, so the Rome statute is the statute that creates the international criminal court and lays out the crimes and the procedures, right?
01:38:49.959 --> 01:38:51.901
[UNKNOWN]: So it's a treaty, right?
01:38:51.941 --> 01:38:57.185
[UNKNOWN]: If you a seed to the Rome statute, then you are a member of the international criminal court.
01:38:57.986 --> 01:39:01.148
[UNKNOWN]: And that is one of the ways court can get jurisdiction.
01:39:01.168 --> 01:39:04.091
[UNKNOWN]: I want to be clear because it's something that Israelis and the Americans say a lot.
01:39:04.691 --> 01:39:06.493
[UNKNOWN]: That's not the only way to court can get jurisdiction.
01:39:06.753 --> 01:39:08.054
[UNKNOWN]: Israel is in the Americans always say,
01:39:10.463 --> 01:39:17.065
[UNKNOWN]: Well, no, because the court can also get jurisdiction if over any crime that is committed on a state territory.
01:39:17.465 --> 01:39:20.786
[UNKNOWN]: Palestine is, I mean, a state party territory.
01:39:21.126 --> 01:39:22.027
[UNKNOWN]: Palestine is a state party.
01:39:22.367 --> 01:39:30.449
[UNKNOWN]: So whoever commits a crime on Palestinian territory, that the Rums
that you'd have, I mean, the international criminal court has jurisdiction, right?
01:39:32.030 --> 01:39:32.750
[UNKNOWN]: And this is the same thing.
01:39:32.770 --> 01:39:35.031
[UNKNOWN]: This is how they have jurisdiction over Russia, right?
01:39:35.451 --> 01:39:37.391
[UNKNOWN]: Russia is not a state party, Ukraine is.
01:39:39.198 --> 01:39:40.699
[UNKNOWN]: There, there you go.
01:39:41.159 --> 01:39:42.820
[UNKNOWN]: So yeah, but that is what the room's that you.
01:39:42.840 --> 01:39:43.840
[UNKNOWN]: All right.
01:39:43.920 --> 01:39:44.260
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you.
01:39:44.601 --> 01:39:47.402
[UNKNOWN]: Now, I want to actually show Brad at put this on the screen.
01:39:47.422 --> 01:39:50.543
[UNKNOWN]: We have state parties to room statute and all and their statuses.
01:39:50.583 --> 01:39:51.444
[UNKNOWN]: So let's take a look at this.
01:39:52.319 --> 01:39:55.142
[UNKNOWN]: Okay, say parts that were statute of the international criminal court.
01:39:55.662 --> 01:39:56.563
[UNKNOWN]: So what do we have.
01:39:56.583 --> 01:40:06.653
[UNKNOWN]: We have state party signatory that's not ratified state party that subsequently withdrew its membership signatory that subsequently withdrew its signature non state party non signatory.
01:40:07.333 --> 01:40:15.181
[UNKNOWN]: So what what stands out here in terms of I mean, I'm basically you see the what do you ask was a signature that subsequently withdrew its signature.
01:40:16.535 --> 01:40:22.197
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, so the Rome statue, when it first, I think it was Clinton signed the Rome statue.
01:40:22.217 --> 01:40:26.198
[UNKNOWN]: But they never ratified it, which means that they were never actually a member.
01:40:26.958 --> 01:40:34.780
[UNKNOWN]: And so it was like kind of like keeping it on the table, even signing it and encourage some kind of legal obligations to it, you can't undermine the object in purpose of the treaty.
01:40:36.221 --> 01:40:37.601
[UNKNOWN]: But the US was never actually a party.
01:40:38.021 --> 01:40:43.163
[UNKNOWN]: And indeed under Bush, that's when I think they would do the signature, they also passed the,
01:40:44.690 --> 01:40:49.751
[UNKNOWN]: It's cool that I forget the actual name of it, something like protecting US Service Members Act, but it's the Hague Invasion Act or something.
01:40:49.771 --> 01:41:03.315
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, an Hague Invasion Act, which is that if any US Service member or ally, I think gets brought before the International Criminal Court, they're authorized to use force against the Netherlands to stop a trial, right?
01:41:03.355 --> 01:41:11.378
[UNKNOWN]: And this was, of course, passed in the context of the US's so-called global war on terror, which was a globe spanning campaign of criminality.
01:41:11.518 --> 01:41:12.358
[UNKNOWN]: That's all, you know,
01:41:13.161 --> 01:41:26.185
[UNKNOWN]: the US torture program, a number of other war crimes, and so it makes sense that the US would be afraid of ICC jurisdiction, and the US should be about for the ICC for the crimes that's committing in the Caribbean, right?
01:41:26.705 --> 01:41:27.426
[UNKNOWN]: Right, my God.
01:41:27.446 --> 01:41:28.386
[UNKNOWN]: It's committing in the institution.
01:41:28.906 --> 01:41:32.487
[UNKNOWN]: The crimes that's committing in Palestine, all manner of things, right?
01:41:32.587 --> 01:41:34.908
[UNKNOWN]: So it makes sense that these cases would be afraid of it.
01:41:35.844 --> 01:41:48.747
[UNKNOWN]: And take certain reject, I just wanted to ask you and to show everyone, I pulled up the state department is launching their campaign to dismantle international criminal courts threat to American sovereignty.
01:41:48.787 --> 01:41:58.170
[UNKNOWN]: And just as you laid out there, it really does seem to stem from the main issue they have is that America can be subject to the international
01:41:58.610 --> 01:42:05.413
[UNKNOWN]: court and internet and US politicians and whatnot and that's what seems to be the real sticking point there.
01:42:05.913 --> 01:42:09.555
[UNKNOWN]: I would actually dispute that because I don't think that's the real sticking point.
01:42:09.575 --> 01:42:15.357
[UNKNOWN]: The real sticking point is that they are defending it because the US is not currently under investigation.
01:42:15.377 --> 01:42:20.039
[UNKNOWN]: There was one for crimes committed in Afghanistan, but it's dormant now in kind of gone away.
01:42:20.519 --> 01:42:22.800
[UNKNOWN]: But Israel has obviously there's more words out for Netanyahu's arrest.
01:42:25.081 --> 01:42:29.552
[UNKNOWN]: This is not the United States being afraid that they are going to come before the dock at any time.
01:42:29.713 --> 01:42:32.560
[UNKNOWN]: It's really like this is about defense of the authority.
01:42:33.503 --> 01:42:38.065
[UNKNOWN]: Well, do you think that, and I totally agree with what you said now that you've corrected me and thank you for that.
01:42:38.225 --> 01:42:38.986
[UNKNOWN]: I would agree.
01:42:39.306 --> 01:42:48.990
[UNKNOWN]: But would you say that when sort of W Bush pulled out in the early 2000s, do you think at that point it was out of concern that there could be a kind of 100%
01:43:00.916 --> 01:43:01.576
[UNKNOWN]: spanning the globe.
01:43:01.616 --> 01:43:10.700
[UNKNOWN]: I'm the U.S. Head Blacksites a number of other countries, and we're concerned about being brought before the dot for torture and the other war crimes they were committing.
01:43:10.720 --> 01:43:19.703
[UNKNOWN]: And to bolster what you just said about the current scenario, this is from the times of Israel, from two or three days ago.
01:43:20.273 --> 01:43:24.414
[UNKNOWN]: Chad announces intent to withdraw from ICC drawing praise from the US.
01:43:24.974 --> 01:43:38.776
[UNKNOWN]: Again, please correct me, but it seems like now part of this push from the state department to dismantle the ICC is to pressure other states to withdraw from the ICC and that's starting to happen.
01:43:39.256
--> 01:43:44.497
[UNKNOWN]: This was saying there are some is the fourth African country, Chad.
01:43:48.878 --> 01:43:52.479
[UNKNOWN]: And I should say that like, yeah, the U.S. is doing this to protect Israel.
01:43:52.519 --> 01:43:53.700
[UNKNOWN]: That's how much she's very clear.
01:43:53.720 --> 01:43:59.922
[UNKNOWN]: But there is a broader campaign to basically dismantle the international legal order as we have known it since 1945.
01:44:02.923 --> 01:44:10.086
[UNKNOWN]: Like the United States right now, and this is why I think that it can be properly called fascist, right?
01:44:11.386 --> 01:44:12.807
[UNKNOWN]: It's trying to remake the world
01:44:14.684 --> 01:44:20.229
[UNKNOWN]: in a, like, kind of 19th century might make right, like, rule of conquest, rule of power.
01:44:21.911 --> 01:44:34.503
[UNKNOWN]: And, you know, the international legal order, obviously not perfect, obviously, has resulted in, or enabled, you know, mass death around the world, since it was inaugurated, I mean, 1945, end of World War II.
01:44:34.903 --> 01:44:39.007
[UNKNOWN]: United Nations, genocide, and convention comes in 1949, and even convention's 49.
01:44:39.967 --> 01:44:49.856
[UNKNOWN]: And then Vietnam, Korea, all of these horrible wars and campaigns of mass murder by the West, since then, right?
01:44:50.336 --> 01:44:55.741
[UNKNOWN]: So I'm not saying that the order was perfect, but I am saying what's coming next is worse, right?
01:44:55.861 --> 01:44:58.504
[UNKNOWN]: What the United States is trying to usher in, I think looks like,
01:44:59.818 --> 01:45:00.859
[UNKNOWN]: is real around the world.
01:45:01.359 --> 01:45:12.167
[UNKNOWN]: It looks like states committing mass murder with complete impunity and without even the discursive tools to speak the same language of the law.
01:45:12.267 --> 01:45:15.730
[UNKNOWN]: I mean, that is what international law largely is.
01:45:15.770 --> 01:45:18.272
[UNKNOWN]: It's a discourse that creates norms, that creates global norms.
01:45:18.332 --> 01:45:21.114
[UNKNOWN]: They're not always followed, and there's no central force of mechanism.
01:45:21.835 --> 01:45:25.197
[UNKNOWN]: But these norms like have gained power, they do gain power over times.
01:45:29.049 --> 01:45:35.967
[UNKNOWN]: are really trying to just completely dismantle them, so that it is whoever has the most bombs, gets to do whatever they want.
01:45:37.611 --> 01:46:05.533
[UNKNOWN]: Jake, you mentioned or we mentioned John Fetterman and have no one really takes him seriously, obviously, but, you know, the whole issue of genocide, you still people claiming, oh, this is not a genocide and and not just saying it's not genocide, I mean, this is ridiculous argument that it's anti cement or blood liable to call the genocide, which is, I mean, these people obviously have no concern with anyone ever taking that term seriously again, because how can anyone take that seriously, like even if you disagree on whether it's genocide.
01:46:06.013 --> 01:46:08.714
[UNKNOWN]: that does not make people who call it that anti-Semitic.
01:46:08.774 --> 01:46:13.895
[UNKNOWN]: But do you do have people who are lawyers who hide behind language of expertise?
01:46:14.335 --> 01:46:16.595
[UNKNOWN]: And I want to show one of these arguments.
01:46:16.656 --> 01:46:19.736
[UNKNOWN]: And this was in response to a tweet from Medi Hassan.
01:46:20.476 --> 01:46:26.998
[UNKNOWN]: OK, so Medi had tweeted out, the term genocide for Gaza is not actually highly contested, except by pro-Israel partisans.
01:46:27.478 --> 01:46:36.124
[UNKNOWN]: is the near consensus view of genocide's college human rights groups, including Israeli human rights groups, like Betselam, and UN investigators, reporters, and commissions.
01:46:36.645 --> 01:46:43.230
[UNKNOWN]: Okay, and now here, let's take a look at the response to this, and this comes from some named Elliott Malen, who is himself a lawyer.
01:46:43.910 --> 01:46:44.210
[UNKNOWN]: Okay.
01:46:44.571 --> 01:46:46.572
[UNKNOWN]: This, of course, isn't true for many his son.
01:46:46.652 --> 01:46:54.158
[UNKNOWN]: If you're to actually read these reports and understand what the law says about genocide, you'd understand that each of them failed to apply the jurisprudence.
01:46:54.719 --> 01:47:00.203
[UNKNOWN]: And this these reports said that the jurisprudence of the ICJ would likely preclude a finding of genocide and Gaza.
01:47:00.583 --> 01:47:07.809
[UNKNOWN]: But Selam's report states expressly that they use a quote broader analytical framework and quote, the UNCOI fails to apply
01:47:10.491 --> 01:47:13.453
[UNKNOWN]: not testing other possible explanations to the conduct of Hamas.
01:47:13.813 --> 01:47:21.278
[UNKNOWN]: Not a single one has tested the sub-stantiality requirement to determine that in-part, quote-unquote, in-part destruction, was the intended outcome.
01:47:21.778 --> 01:47:23.760
[UNKNOWN]: These reports and accusations are shams.
01:47:24.080 --> 01:47:27.202
[UNKNOWN]: They're lying to you about what genocide is and what tapping in Gaza.
01:47:27.602 --> 01:47:31.145
[UNKNOWN]: What this is is circular logic, and it's ultimately illogical.
01:47:31.486 --> 01:47:44.677
[UNKNOWN]: But most damning of all for Medi Hassan is the fact that the now-fire prosecutor of the ICC implied to him that the evidence doesn't support a church for genocide, especially after its request for a warrant for the lower threshold crime against humanity of extermination was already rejected.
01:47:45.078 --> 01:47:52.785
[UNKNOWN]: In a few years time, there will be decision at the ICCJ, and the only way to find that Israel committed genocide will be for the ICCJ to change what genocide is.
01:47:53.125 --> 01:47:53.846
[UNKNOWN]: and how it works.
01:47:53.906 --> 01:47:59.834
[UNKNOWN]: If they stick to the intent of the drafters and even Raphael Lempkin, it will not find that Israel has committed genocide.
01:48:00.255 --> 01:48:01.777
[UNKNOWN]: So, a lot to respond to there.
01:48:01.797 --> 01:48:05.522
[UNKNOWN]: No, I know that arguments, you know, like, this is a thin year all the time.
01:48:05.823 --> 01:48:07.525
[UNKNOWN]: Um, and you're like,
01:48:08.734 --> 01:48:12.536
[UNKNOWN]: This guy is either like a literate or a liar and with like, how's Barat people?
01:48:12.596 --> 01:48:14.016
[UNKNOWN]: It's sometimes it's both, right?
01:48:15.537 --> 01:48:20.700
[UNKNOWN]: But what he's referring to, you see this a lot with how's Barat lawyers.
01:48:21.240 --> 01:48:30.484
[UNKNOWN]: They like to bring up this thing that comes from, the ICJK's about the genocide in Boston, against the Bosnia's, right?
01:48:31.304 --> 01:48:34.166
[UNKNOWN]: And there's this thing they say that like,
01:48:35.113 --> 01:48:37.214
[UNKNOWN]: It must be the only reasonable inference.
01:48:37.234 --> 01:48:39.915
[UNKNOWN]: You can get from the utility of the circumstances.
01:48:40.195 --> 01:48:46.158
[UNKNOWN]: Because often with the genocide, there's not like a written down master plan, but we are going to make genocide.
01:48:46.198 --> 01:48:47.679
[UNKNOWN]: So you have to gather the evidence.
01:48:48.711 --> 01:48:53.613
[UNKNOWN]: circumstantially from what people are saying, what people are doing, and it must be the only reasonable inference.
01:48:54.093 --> 01:49:01.677
[UNKNOWN]: Now, that is what the what it says, but the only reasonable inference, just means that it refers to like that there is genocide on 10.
01:49:02.097 --> 01:49:05.738
[UNKNOWN]: It doesn't mean the exclusive reasonable inference, right?
01:49:06.299 --> 01:49:09.860
[UNKNOWN]: And so their argument is that, well, if these rallies are doing all
01:49:12.343 --> 01:49:19.250
[UNKNOWN]: You know, against Palestinians and Gaza, maybe their intent is just military nature and they're trying to kill Hamas and everything is collateral or whatever, right?
01:49:19.751 --> 01:49:20.452
[UNKNOWN]: Well, that doesn't matter.
01:49:20.532 --> 01:49:31.243
[UNKNOWN]: They can also have the intent to complete a military objective alongside genocide on 10 and if they couldn't have that, then basically no genocide has ever been committed, right?
01:49:31.744 --> 01:49:32.004
[UNKNOWN]: And like,
01:49:32.465 --> 01:49:34.927
[UNKNOWN]: This is, it's so like, obviously, spacious.
01:49:35.188 --> 01:49:44.356
[UNKNOWN]: If you just go to like the test of Article I of the first article of the genocide convention, they'll just read it, I haven't pulled up.
01:49:44.436 --> 01:49:51.203
[UNKNOWN]: The contracting parties confirm that genocide, whether committed in time of fees or in time of war is a crime under international law, which they undertake to prevent and to punish.
01:49:51.871 --> 01:49:55.293
[UNKNOWN]: So that text is like, yeah, genocide can be committed in time of work.
01:49:55.794 --> 01:50:06.921
[UNKNOWN]: If the exclusive intent, the exclusive inference must be that you have genocide on 10, then
you can't commit it really in time of work because you always have also military objectives.
01:50:06.941 --> 01:50:08.522
[UNKNOWN]: Like I think of the Armenian genocide, right?
01:50:08.983 --> 01:50:15.567
[UNKNOWN]: The Turks who couch this, a saying, or the Ottoman's, they couch this is saying, the Armenians represented the military threat.
01:50:15.587 --> 01:50:19.310
[UNKNOWN]: They were a fifth column being used by Russia against the empire, against the war effort.
01:50:19.911 --> 01:50:24.297
[UNKNOWN]: Well, they'd still commit a genocide, even if they also had military objectives for killing our minions.
01:50:25.419 --> 01:50:30.025
[UNKNOWN]: Similarly, these rallies do have a military objective.
01:50:30.226 --> 01:50:33.050
[UNKNOWN]: They also have a genocide objective, and they co-exist quite neatly.
01:50:33.613 --> 01:50:35.834
[UNKNOWN]: And so one time, it's real practice is co-existence.
01:50:36.194 --> 01:50:38.295
[UNKNOWN]: Right, exactly.
01:50:38.656 --> 01:50:39.696
[UNKNOWN]: So it's just like obviously wrong.
01:50:39.776 --> 01:50:46.460
[UNKNOWN]: And it's also like not in our articulation of, it's really also not, and he like misclothes the MSD report.
01:50:47.000 --> 01:50:51.282
[UNKNOWN]: The MSD report is like, they're not saying the ICJ would need to change their jurisprudence.
01:50:51.302 --> 01:50:52.703
[UNKNOWN]: They're doing what any good lawyer would do.
01:50:53.283 --> 01:50:56.766
[UNKNOWN]: and raising one of the objections that they're anticipating and putting it down.
01:50:57.046 --> 01:51:03.951
[UNKNOWN]: And so what we're seeing is there's a really restrictive reading you could do of that line in the ICJ case and they know these railways are going to do it.
01:51:04.311 --> 01:51:06.933
[UNKNOWN]: So they raise it to say, there's this restrictive reading.
01:51:07.094 --> 01:51:07.834
[UNKNOWN]: Here's why it's wrong.
01:51:08.755 --> 01:51:09.756
[UNKNOWN]: So like that's what they're doing.
01:51:09.776 --> 01:51:12.017
[UNKNOWN]: And also like, states agree that as well.
01:51:12.458 --> 01:51:15.780
[UNKNOWN]: Like, you know, there's this good article I'd recommend everyone read.
01:51:23.366 --> 01:51:38.550
[UNKNOWN]: what the ICJ meant by that statement and also referring to how a number of state parties the genocide convention agree with the very obvious plain reading of it that like this has to be the only reasonable inference you can make but not the exclusive inference, right?
01:51:38.950 --> 01:51:47.992
[UNKNOWN]: Which is to say you need to look at the totality of the evidence and say the only reasonable thing I conclude is that they are trying to commit genocide and they can be trying to do that alongside any
01:51:52.053 --> 01:51:58.616
[UNKNOWN]: Set talks about how you can have multiple layers of intent and multiple motives for doing some personal motives, financial motives.
01:52:00.117 --> 01:52:16.184
[UNKNOWN]: You know, let's think of a case that I like to talk
about because it's an important case for corporate complicity, is this case, I guess Bruno Tesh, and it happened in the, the post-World War II tribunal, so it wasn't, it wasn't Nuremberg, if I remember correctly, but it was an American British tribunal.
01:52:16.765 --> 01:52:17.285
[UNKNOWN]: And Bruno Tesh
01:52:22.238 --> 01:52:24.539
[UNKNOWN]: He was a test, he was a test bro, sorry.
01:52:24.779 --> 01:52:25.039
[UNKNOWN]: I can't.
01:52:25.059 --> 01:52:27.499
[UNKNOWN]: I can't, I can't, I can't, I can't.
01:52:27.920 --> 01:52:34.041
[UNKNOWN]: So he produced Zeikon B, which people don't know was the pesticide that they use in the gas chambers.
01:52:34.061 --> 01:52:37.982
[UNKNOWN]: And his argument before the court was, I didn't have any intent to get him hurt.
01:52:38.462 --> 01:52:39.763
[UNKNOWN]: I just wanted to make a buck.
01:52:39.843 --> 01:52:40.623
[UNKNOWN]: I just wanted to make money.
01:52:40.843 --> 01:52:44.004
[UNKNOWN]: And so the SS did with the Zeikon B is none of my business.
01:52:44.620 --> 01:52:50.304
[UNKNOWN]: And the court returned the verdict, saying, had they not been using this to commit mass murder?
01:52:50.724 --> 01:52:51.845
[UNKNOWN]: You would not have made a profit.
01:52:51.965 --> 01:52:55.107
[UNKNOWN]: And so uni, well, that may have been your primary intent was to make money.
01:52:55.507 --> 01:52:59.790
[UNKNOWN]: You also had the secondary intent to commit mass murder, because that is how you made your money.
01:53:00.210 --> 01:53:01.291
[UNKNOWN]: And so be home, right?
01:53:01.811 --> 01:53:02.192
[UNKNOWN]: And like,
01:53:02.972 --> 01:53:14.282
[UNKNOWN]: Under the Israeli interpretation of international law, Bruno Tech walks away, Scott Freypan, the man who made the pesticide for the mass murder in the Holocaust, right?
01:53:14.302 --> 01:53:15.704
[UNKNOWN]: Like he goes away, he's fought.
01:53:15.724 --> 01:53:15.904
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:53:16.244 --> 01:53:18.546
[UNKNOWN]: And so it's just like obviously nonsense.
01:53:18.826 --> 01:53:21.209
[UNKNOWN]: That's get to the other points that he raises.
01:53:21.889 --> 01:53:27.935
[UNKNOWN]: He talks about the substantiality requirement, and what that means is that, so the genocide statute talks about the
01:53:29.232 --> 01:53:38.840
[UNKNOWN]: You know, it's a number of acts committed of the intent to destroy a whole or in part, a group, like I think group really just group, whatever.
01:53:40.081 --> 01:53:42.784
[UNKNOWN]: And so the in part needs to be substantial, right?
01:53:42.804 --> 01:53:46.267
[UNKNOWN]: It's not just like, oh, I killed one guy for a discriminatory word, if that doesn't rise to it.
01:53:47.068 --> 01:53:49.490
[UNKNOWN]: And what they're saying is that,
01:53:51.370 --> 01:53:57.054
[UNKNOWN]: They're taking the number of known deaths just 70,000 right now.
01:53:57.714 --> 01:53:59.535
[UNKNOWN]: Of course, it's obviously much higher than that.
01:53:59.635 --> 01:54:02.297
[UNKNOWN]: We know
that it's obviously much higher than that.
01:54:02.597 --> 01:54:07.260
[UNKNOWN]: But they're taking that and saying that's actually not really a substantial portion of the Palestinian population of Gaza.
01:54:07.625 --> 01:54:14.229
[UNKNOWN]: Now, of course, I think all of us would disagree with that just on its face already, but let's take it out of its word and say that's actually not substantial.
01:54:14.790 --> 01:54:15.490
[UNKNOWN]: Again, of course it is.
01:54:16.391 --> 01:54:28.939
[UNKNOWN]: What they're ignoring is the actual text of the genocide statute, which is to say killing people is how we like understand colloquial genocide is, but there's five enumerated acts that constitute the crime genocide.
01:54:29.199 --> 01:54:32.021
[UNKNOWN]: The first one is killing, none of the other ones are killing.
01:54:32.901 --> 01:54:43.749
[UNKNOWN]: And so, when you're targeting a substantial portion of the group, it's not just how many people have died, it's also how many people have else read them off, have you caused serious bodily or mentally harm to, right?
01:54:43.969 --> 01:54:49.713
[UNKNOWN]: How many people have you deliberately inflicted conditions of life calculated to bring about their physical destruction and whole-arm part?
01:54:49.993 --> 01:54:50.974
[UNKNOWN]: Nine people are subject to that.
01:54:51.434 --> 01:54:55.177
[UNKNOWN]: How many people have been subject to, like the imposition of measures intended to prevent births?
01:54:55.657 --> 01:54:57.618
[UNKNOWN]: So, I mean, let's just take C, right?
01:54:58.099 --> 01:55:00.260
[UNKNOWN]: Deliberally inflicting on-group conditions of life,
01:55:03.755 --> 01:55:12.003
[UNKNOWN]: almost every single dwelling in Gaza has been destroyed, almost every single hospital in Gaza was destroyed.
01:55:12.143 --> 01:55:13.804
[UNKNOWN]: People were subject to startation.
01:55:14.385 --> 01:55:16.967
[UNKNOWN]: People were forced to drink dirty water.
01:55:17.027 --> 01:55:22.593
[UNKNOWN]: People are living in tents in these, like, absolute, like, objects, conditions of deprivation.
01:55:23.193 --> 01:55:35.404
[UNKNOWN]: all of these people, which is to say basically all 2.2 million residents of Gaza who were there prior to war, the number obviously now is much lower because of the murders, have been subjected to those conditions.
01:55:35.504 --> 01:55:38.707
[UNKNOWN]: And so when you talk about substantiality and like in part, well,
01:55:39.588 --> 01:55:46.451
[UNKNOWN]: every single person in Gaza has been so objective to this, every single person in Gaza has been subjected to serious bodily or mental harm, right?
01:55:46.471 --> 01:55:55.174
[UNKNOWN]: And this is not even including the genocide that is ongoing, I would say, in the West Bank as well, I'm just obviously across all about you by Palestine, against all Palestinians.
01:55:55.194 --> 01:56:01.256
[UNKNOWN]: So this is also just like, again, like either a case of deliberate line or a case of just like straight up a literacy.
01:56:02.337 --> 01:56:03.197
[UNKNOWN]: To the point where like,
01:56:05.228 --> 01:56:13.341
[UNKNOWN]: It's really like it's really so cynical and they really depends on hiding behind this, you know, this label of like, I'm a lawyer.
01:56:13.361 --> 01:56:17.627
[UNKNOWN]: I know what I'm talking about and you need to do needs and thinking of people aren't going to look into it.
01:56:18.288 --> 01:56:19.170
[UNKNOWN]: And it also I think.
01:56:20.789 --> 01:56:35.075
[UNKNOWN]: And it's my, the ironic coming from someone who works at legal organization as a lawyer, but like, this is kind of a problem with like the language of the law in general, is that, once you start talking about, well, this is illegal, that strike was illegal, that one's illegal.
01:56:43.958 --> 01:56:55.408
[UNKNOWN]: You go to this rabbit hole of legality, where you're now instead of talking about what's happening to the Palestinian people, you are talking about discreet instances and debating the finer points in the details.
01:56:55.448 --> 01:56:56.969
[UNKNOWN]: And like for lawyers, I mean we have to do that.
01:56:56.989 --> 01:56:57.750
[UNKNOWN]: That's important, right?
01:56:58.290 --> 01:57:07.058
[UNKNOWN]: But it's easy, these house bra guys like Elie and Mal and they want you to go down that path because then you're kind of like playing a logic game.
01:57:07.798 --> 01:57:15.360
[UNKNOWN]: and you're not thinking of like, you know, hey, these are a colonized people who are being exterminated by their colonizer and they want you to lose sight of that.
01:57:15.660 --> 01:57:34.265
[UNKNOWN]: They really want you to lose sight of the total situation in Palestine, which even before October 7th, right, was a murderous one, but like even even if Israel wasn't routinely committing mass murder against the Palestinians, was it routinely bombing Gaza and starving them, right?
01:57:35.105 --> 01:57:38.147
[UNKNOWN]: This situation would still be unjust because colonialism is unjust.
01:57:38.407 --> 01:57:42.510
[UNKNOWN]: It needs to be done away with entirely regardless of these crimes.
01:57:42.530 --> 01:57:47.954
[UNKNOWN]: So they want you to focus on the finer points of legality so that you miss the forest for the trees.
01:57:49.410 --> 01:57:54.952
[UNKNOWN]: And they also pretend to be objective and they pretend to be based in the law and listen to me, I'm an expert.
01:57:55.052 --> 01:58:02.396
[UNKNOWN]: And I mean, the other thing is that like the same people who say it's not a genocide, it would be one thing if they were like, there are war crimes, but there's no genocide.
01:58:02.416 --> 01:58:04.496
[UNKNOWN]: These people never bring up the war crimes, right?
01:58:04.757 --> 01:58:06.257
[UNKNOWN]: They always misrepresent law.
01:58:06.277 --> 01:58:09.138
[UNKNOWN]: They're like, oh, well, there was a Hamas person in this hospital.
01:58:09.279 --> 01:58:10.959
[UNKNOWN]: So obviously, it's okay to
strike.
01:58:10.979 --> 01:58:15.221
[UNKNOWN]: It's like, no, that's actually just a blatant violation of international humanitarian law.
01:58:17.362 --> 01:58:18.422
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, you're not allowed to do that.
01:58:18.462 --> 01:58:40.432
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, they're like, so these people, I hate, I really hate the like I've said this on a recent episode, but I hate the combination of condescension and either stupidity or dishonesty like what you said a literacy or disingenuous and the other thing is Brad, can you show can you throw that definition back up on the screen, please, you know, with the five parts, the five elements of it because or I mean, I can just say it, but
01:58:40.832 --> 01:59:02.440
[UNKNOWN]: You know, something that's significant is that it doesn't require it says in the present convention genocide means any of the following acts committed right so it's not like you have to prove A through E for it to be genocide and you know it just so annoying and frustrating because obviously this is supposed to be actionable right that was the it's like the convention to prevent genocide right it's not just.
01:59:08.542 --> 01:59:14.166
[UNKNOWN]: The other thing that people like to say as an excuse is like, oh, no, the ICJ found that genocide was plausible.
01:59:14.206 --> 01:59:25.894
[UNKNOWN]: They didn't find genocide, but isn't that because it takes, it's so much, it would take so much longer to determine that genocide is there than genocide is possible at the only possible way to reacting in a timely manner.
01:59:26.434 --> 01:59:51.880
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, what they said was like they said it like this roundabout way that like the Palestinians have like their claim that they're they're right to not be subjected to the genocide as a possible one so the case can proceed and they would only say that because the possible genocide is being committed and these really is like to twist it around right but like but yeah and like it is it is the convention on the prevention and punishment of the crime of genocide and so the argument that well you need to wait until it's complete
01:59:56.741 --> 01:59:57.942
[UNKNOWN]: Like utterly preposterous.
01:59:58.062 --> 02:00:04.186
[UNKNOWN]: It goes it's not what the convention is for and going back to ICJ Okay, so I was I also had to do it.
02:00:04.246 --> 02:00:05.407
[UNKNOWN]: It was this reverend needs a case.
02:00:06.208 --> 02:00:17.335
[UNKNOWN]: They were talking about what they said was once Once genocide becomes like a remote possibility once the possibility of genocide is known or ought to be known
02:00:17.980 --> 02:00:19.561
[UNKNOWN]: That's when all of the obligations kick in.
02:00:19.821 --> 02:00:21.242
[UNKNOWN]: Because the whole point is to prevent it from happening.
02:00:21.262 --> 02:00:23.463
[UNKNOWN]: The whole point is that we don't want this crime to be committed.
02:00:23.943 --> 02:00:28.186
[UNKNOWN]: And the Israeli argument of like, well, we don't know
if it's been committed yet, because we haven't finished doing it.
02:00:28.926 --> 02:00:31.388
[UNKNOWN]: It's just like, it's like obviously preposterous.
02:00:31.928 --> 02:00:32.088
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:00:32.308 --> 02:00:32.809
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
02:00:32.969 --> 02:00:34.490
[UNKNOWN]: It's like with the Salam Witch trials, right?
02:00:34.510 --> 02:00:36.130
[UNKNOWN]: Where they would like drown a woman.
02:00:36.231 --> 02:00:37.651
[UNKNOWN]: They throw a woman into the water.
02:00:37.731 --> 02:00:39.532
[UNKNOWN]: And if she drown, she was not a witch.
02:00:40.053 --> 02:00:40.273
[UNKNOWN]: Right.
02:00:40.353 --> 02:00:41.674
[UNKNOWN]: And if she didn't drown, she was a witch.
02:00:41.714 --> 02:00:43.855
[UNKNOWN]: So it's just basically how can we kill this woman?
02:00:47.917 --> 02:00:58.044
[UNKNOWN]: So what can you just mention, this is kind of nerdy, but can you, you mentioned earlier that there's a point that Amnesty brought up that Israel would raise and then they raised it and then they debunked it.
02:00:58.064 --> 02:01:00.025
[UNKNOWN]: What, do you know what that is on hand?
02:01:01.166 --> 02:01:10.332
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, it's basically they were saying that like, so that only reasonable inference test that comes from the, the Bosnia decision of the ICJ.
02:01:10.392 --> 02:01:12.754
[UNKNOWN]: Like, it's on page, I was just looking at that.
02:01:12.774 --> 02:01:14.615
[UNKNOWN]: I think it's like on page like, well, I want to say like one 11.
02:01:15.193 --> 02:01:17.234
[UNKNOWN]: No, 112, just kind of, I have no idea.
02:01:17.775 --> 02:01:21.377
[UNKNOWN]: No, it's an event, it's, whatever.
02:01:21.417 --> 02:01:24.019
[UNKNOWN]: It's sort of the end of the MSU report, not going to get the exact exact page.
02:01:24.359 --> 02:01:33.045
[UNKNOWN]: So the end of the MSU report, and they're saying that like, OK, like, this, the only reasonable inference test, they bring it up to be like, there is a reading of that line.
02:01:33.972 --> 02:01:40.316
[UNKNOWN]: that the Israelis are advancing, that is extremely restrictive and would basically preclude a finding of genocide ever.
02:01:40.656 --> 02:01:42.817
[UNKNOWN]: So they're like, that is one possible reading.
02:01:43.357 --> 02:01:46.159
[UNKNOWN]: We are raising that so that we can say, that is not the correct reading.
02:01:47.119 --> 02:01:53.363
[UNKNOWN]: And these laws will take in that quote to say, oh, they're saying that's the reason, or the reasoning we have to like, yeah.
02:01:53.383 --> 02:01:55.724
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah, I've got it, so again, totally dishonest.
02:01:56.945 --> 02:02:00.447
[UNKNOWN]: I just had a quick question, Jake, if you could,
02:02:01.084 --> 02:02:06.266
[UNKNOWN]: clarified this or let me know if I'm understanding this correctly because you're helping me better understand.
02:02:06.627 --> 02:02:23.154
[UNKNOWN]: I knew that the US had withdrawn from the ICC and removed its, you know, acknowledgement or of the Rome statute, but then you mentioned that we have our own genocide laws and look into that.
02:02:23.754 --> 02:02:27.416
[UNKNOWN]: The information that I could find is saying that essentially,
02:02:28.116 --> 02:02:44.063
[UNKNOWN]: What it then requires for the US like if if we wanted to arrest Netanyahu when he comes to the US or something like that it's all at the end of the day the prevention part of this it says that the US holds the legal and diplomatic obligation to help prevent punish acts of genocide globally.
02:02:44.773 --> 02:02:53.559
[UNKNOWN]: The formal political determinations on one atrocities legally constitute genocide remains subject to executive and congressional form policy evaluation.
02:02:53.620 --> 02:03:01.445
[UNKNOWN]: So basically it would require Congress or the president to formally acknowledge that genocide is happening.
02:03:01.746 --> 02:03:02.386
[UNKNOWN]: Is that correct?
02:03:02.826 --> 02:03:03.907
[UNKNOWN]: No, it wouldn't.
02:03:04.187 --> 02:03:04.387
[UNKNOWN]: So.
02:03:06.737 --> 02:03:08.458
[UNKNOWN]: If you watch this live, you're in luck.
02:03:08.478 --> 02:03:09.659
[UNKNOWN]: You got to see that whole thing.
02:03:09.759 --> 02:03:16.882
[UNKNOWN]: And if you're watching this later, and you want to see the full thing, you can find it at Patreon.com slash the Katie Helpershow that's Patreon.com slash the Katie Helpershow.
02:03:16.902 --> 02:03:20.084
[UNKNOWN]: But again, we are providing you with so much free content.
02:03:20.124 --> 02:03:22.345
[UNKNOWN]: We never would deprive you of hours.
02:03:22.765 --> 02:03:25.227
[UNKNOWN]: So we're giving you hours of free content as always.
02:03:25.287 --> 02:03:27.248
[UNKNOWN]: But we do ask you to become patrons of borders.
02:03:27.828 --> 02:03:36.072
[UNKNOWN]: either at the $1 month level, which is literally $12 a year, which I think most people hopefully can afford, or a lot of people can afford.
02:03:36.612 --> 02:03:50.058
[UNKNOWN]: And if you can do it at the $5 month level, that's especially appreciated, and that is less than 25 cents a day Monday through Friday, and that gets you access to all sorts of exclusive content, early release, bonus content extended interviews.
02:03:50.579 --> 02:03:52.960
[UNKNOWN]: Oh yes, we will be interviewing Rokan in this Thursday.
02:03:53.540 --> 02:03:54.541
[UNKNOWN]: I believe it's 630.
02:03:54.601 --> 02:03:56.023
[UNKNOWN]: We'll put it post about that.
02:03:56.383 --> 02:04:01.829
[UNKNOWN]: Also, I'll be posting information about this thing that we're doing on Sunday for Abdul al-Sayad.
02:04:02.650 --> 02:04:03.511
[UNKNOWN]: We will see you.
02:04:03.631 --> 02:04:05.853
[UNKNOWN]: I guess Sunday and then next week.
02:04:05.993 --> 02:04:06.754
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you, Brad.
02:04:06.834 --> 02:04:07.675
[UNKNOWN]: Thank you, Nate.
02:04:07.955 --> 02:04:10.658
[UNKNOWN]: And thank you all for tuning in.
02:04:11.879 --> 02:04:12.400
[UNKNOWN]: Bye, Ron.
02:04:16.708 --> 02:04:19.471
[UNKNOWN]: Thanks again so much for listening to the Katie Helper Show.
02:04:19.611 --> 02:04:24.797
[UNKNOWN]: To hear the rest of that discussion, please join the Patreon at patreon.com slash the Katie Helper Show.
02:04:25.197 --> 02:04:27.700
[UNKNOWN]: Again, that's patreon.com slash the Katie Helper Show.
02:04:28.421 --> 02:04:36.370
[UNKNOWN]: Please leave us a five-star review on Apple podcasts or Spotify, and as always, we remind you that this show could not happen without the support of our listeners.
02:04:36.830 --> 02:04:44.338
[UNKNOWN]: To support the show, visit patreon.com slash the Katie Helpershow, where for just $1 a month, you help make this show happen.
02:04:44.739 --> 02:04:54.550
[UNKNOWN]: And for $5 a month, you get great bonus content, including extended interviews, bonus episodes, sneak peeks, and my upcoming documentary and early access interviews.
02:04:55.150 --> 02:04:57.973
[UNKNOWN]: Our show is produced by me, Katie Helpers and Brad Bloom.
02:04:58.534 --> 02:05:03.080
[UNKNOWN]: Brad Bloom and Andrew Callaway are the audio engineers, and our researcher is Nate Newborn.
02:05:03.621 --> 02:05:05.943
[UNKNOWN]: Our theme song is by the Band for Dova.
02:05:06.204 --> 02:05:06.905
[UNKNOWN]: See you next time!