TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:05
Speaker 1: Hi, and welcome back to the Carol Marcowitz Show on iHeartRadio.
00:00:09
Speaker 2: My guest today is Harry Siegel.
00:00:11
Speaker 1: Harry is, among other things, a lifelong Brooklyn night, a senior editor at the Newsroom the City, a moynihan public scholar at City College, the creator and a co host of the Pac NYC and litt NYC podcast, and a long time New York Daily News columnist.
00:00:28
Speaker 2: Hi, Harry, so nice to have you on.
00:00:31
Speaker 3: Hey, Carol. Always great to see you have.
00:00:34
Speaker 1: One of my favorite New York accents, like the one that I consider my part of Brooklyn New York accent, get out of you Yeah, oh yeah, yeah for sure, Like I think when I hear you, you've sound super familiar to me and like my childhood.
00:00:50
Speaker 3: It's funny because everything is always on these weird legs, right, Like you grow up and you see six year olds dressing the way they thought was real cool. We're nineteen, and how they talk, and then you talk that way and you don't realize it's all channeling this older stuff. Like when I grew up, there really was like a DS and dose Brooklyn for sure, much heavier accents. And I'm always trying on my podcast and whatnot to speak like an uninflected English like queen or something.
00:01:24
Speaker 2: I don't think you're succeeding good luck with that though.
00:01:27
Speaker 3: Apparently when I try, I sound much more inflected, so I've given up on that, right.
00:01:33
Speaker 1: I would say that I worked on decreasing my New York accent, not because I didn't like it or anything, but because nobody understood.
00:01:40
Speaker 2: Me in Scotland and in Georgia and places that I lived.
00:01:44
Speaker 1: And now I kind of regret it because my brother still sounds super Brooklyn and I don't do.
00:01:51
Speaker 3: You ever get identified by voice as a New Yorker? Now?
00:01:54
Speaker 2: Never?
00:01:55
Speaker 1: No. In fact, when we first moved to Florida, when we were kind of doing like our Florida Testra, and my daughter was like, why does everyone sound like they're from New York except us? So so tell me about how you got your start in this crazy thing of ours.
00:02:14
Speaker 3: You've seen Goonies, right, I love Goonies.
00:02:17
Speaker 2: My youngest son is super into it right now.
00:02:19
Speaker 3: Great movie. One of the joys of kids, of course, is getting to revisit all the stuff yeah when you were a kid again and see it with someone seeing with fresh eyes. But there's the great scene in Goonies where they got Chunk. Who's you know, the pudgy kid. Yeah, Chunk, And sure they're holding a blender behind it, but he thinks it's a chainsaw or something and they say, tell us everything you know, and they mean you know about the treasure and the highest of the things that are relevant to the movie. Chunk starts one time. Second great, I peed in my pants, so I'm not.
00:02:55
Speaker 2: The time you peed in your pants. And second RDE.
00:02:58
Speaker 3:
Load full transcript
That's a different, that's a show. My resolution for this year is to figure out elevator pitches. But in some ways I got into this thing of journalism and the news and all that just because of the house I grew up in. My dad, Fred Siegel, who's passed away now, was a professor and an academic and those things who got frustrated with some of the limits of the academy and feeling like the map wasn't matching the territory and all that. So I was still teaching. He was a professor of history at Cooper Union in Manhattan. He started getting very involved in the New York political scene, and then he was writing a column for the Daily News and he was editing this magazine City Journal, and was involved in that world. And so I sort of grew up steeped in a lot of this stuff without even quite knowing it or having any idea what I was doing in life necessarily. And then long story, very short, I graduated from college. I'm a sort of a total loss in life. Not entirely together.
00:04:07
Speaker 2: Cool among us, you know, I'm still.
00:04:10
Speaker 3: There at forty eight and twenty five years later. Break up with my girlfriend nine to eleven happens, and i'd been working my first job sort of around politics for this political consultant, you know, Hank Shinkaff for this candidates for controller at the time, Bill Thompson. But I was working in the municipal archives, which were a weird, cool place, doing research. And the primary was supposed to be.
00:04:34
Speaker 1: Nine to eleven, right, Oh, I remember very well looking for where to go vote in my new neighborhood.
00:04:40
Speaker 3: Yeah, And the morning of the primary, I was like giving money to people to pass out flyers. I'm not sure if that's legal, but the statute of.
00:04:48
Speaker 2: Limitations, nobody's going to come get you.
00:04:51
Speaker 3: And someone says there's a plane accident, I'm like, oh boy, I've been to rush into the city. So is the trans are gonna get all screwed up? Yeah, And now, making this a nine to eleven story, I'll skip ahead, and this happens. I was in the city and I ended up doing some stuff, just volunteering around Ground zero and all of that, and then left New York and went to visit a family member I'd never met before outside of Seattle. Was all messed up, and I'd done a handful of pieces, writing things here and there because I had some ideas and it had a sort of interesting and peripatetic five Burroughs life, and I had no idea what was doing. And it was this new paper, the New York Sun, starting and they were interested in talking to me, and I took a train back to New York for the interview and they stood me up and really they did, and seth and Ira indeed, oh wow. And then I had had a second interview and they were there, and I got this incredible job, like being on the editorial page, writing some of the editorials, like commissioning some and editing all of the op eds. It's like, so I can edit three thousand words a day, lay it out in quirk right, because we're before the whole internet thing. Here, write some editorials and do all this stuff, and you'll pay me thirty two thousand dollars a year. And I'm like, what a scam. And I can have all the books I want for free and all I have to do is plus yeah and review them. You know. I'm like, what an incredible job. And I get to call up powerful and interesting people and ask them questions and they have to answer yeah. And all I have to do in exchange for that is write it up in a really tight, exactly shaped box intelligently as if I had massive knowledge of all of the issues coming in with as much of that as possible. And I just loved it.
00:06:55
Speaker 1: It all sounds very good except for the thirty two thousand dollars apart.
00:06:58
Speaker 3: But yeah, they paid me thirty six thousand by accident, and then about three months in are like, well, we paid you too much by accident, so we're going to doc your checks. And I kept working there. I'd been prior to that. I started this magazine with my friend Tim Marshman, who at the time was a clerk at the Strand bookstore in Manhattan, and that was great because it meant I could get an employee discount on books the best, and I had all these sort of pals who worked there. I was any responsible young guy. So I did spend some time romancing all of the clerks at the Strand and getting my book discount. And he had an online magazine we'd started called New Partisan that was totally incoherence, just let's do good and interesting things. And we'd been running that for a bit and this came up at the Sun. I worked there, and they gave me a couple of like I did good. So there was all these interesting characters who were there, and people were sort of recognizable in journalism now. So I was editing erro Lewis and Smith was there, and it was a really good era.
00:08:00
Speaker 2: Yeah, it was.
00:08:00
Speaker 3: Wonderful, and I had no idea what I was doing and was just just sort of thrilled, like I can't believe I'm in this, this sort of fascinating world. And one thing went to another, but I never I never quite found my way out.
00:08:14
Speaker 1: And I guess my question to you for anybody who's listening. Harry mentioned his dad, Fred Siegel, who was just a legend in New York City in the political world. And in you know, the writing world, the journalist world. How did you not think you were going to end up there? You seem so surprised. I mean, just based on who your dad is. It seemed like that was a natural path.
00:08:39
Speaker 3: Fathers and sons, children and parents. It's complicated. Like my dad, like, who's a very tough and aggressive guy and with me my brothers in certain ways, and was also inordinately proud of everything we did. Yeah, to the point where it was a little insane. So he played college football. He was a very good basketball player little pool for a bit. It was like a really talented ass of that. Not to brag, but I'm not no, but my dad was like utterly convinced, like, oh, you know
from from the pickout games we played where I be the sixth best out of nine. They was like, you know, you probably could have gone pro. And took tremendous pride in my accomplishments and my brother Jake's, and we rewarded that pride by being aggressive, very clear, and everything he was wrong about in the world and arguing these things to death and without without full filters on this, you know, like inside voice arguments and so forth, for years and so the idea I was going to follow that part of his life didn't occur to me. The thing he wanted me to do, which he'd done, is he's like, you need to stay in school, get credentialed, and have that sort of stability in life, which twenty five years and to be a cranky journalist who always has at least two jobs so that nobody fully owns me and could tell me what to say or think, and not having that that sort of stability of I'm teaching. I've sort of gone through these hurdles and I have this protection. In hindsight, I have a lot of regrets about but at the time, every time he's like, you need to do this. You know this is with kids you can't help but say it, and kids like you don't know what you know?
00:10:21
Speaker 1: So what would have been the plan be if this hadn't worked out, what would you have done instead?
00:10:25
Speaker 3: I have literally no idea. You know, I was gonna I was going to be a novelist. I did a little, uh, you know, kid stuff, and it's some drug selling and some this and some that, and some restaurant work. And in hindsight, I really think maybe I should have been a postman and just have like a nice civil service thing, and you can have all your big thoughts and ideas and about the world and not have to cross that over with I need to have those ideas to eat and participate in those things. But I think that's that's that's a little bit sour grapes. One of the things I love about journalism is some of this normalizes and there's routines like with anything day to day, but there's always new questions and questions, new challenges and new puzzles you're figuring out. Like there's not some last level or plateau that you you must reach. You know, some people sort of choose to plateau and that that that can be fine. Like I want to put this much into my work life and be bounded and I finished my banker's hours or whatever, and here I am. But it's it's really a young person's game in a lot of ways. I'm realizing, Ye, I'm not so young. Yeah, but I just I wit. We don't know what else I would do or would want to do. I love teaching and I've done a little of that, but don't just want to teach. I think a lot of what I have to teach is it's not Actually, journalism isn't a field of study. And I tell everyone I teach journalism this, and you should probably just go and start writing and be a paper.
00:11:50
Speaker 2: Yeah, I say the same thing, and.
00:11:52
Speaker 3: Stop studying or study something else. But being in these mixes, you know a lot of the things you know when you're different person person. When I was twenty, I just had no idea about and being able to sort of explain how this actually works. Yeah, how the news is produced, what the compromises that go into that are, what the things you won't compromise are, and how that plays out in practice. I think a lot about generational transmission these days, not just because of my own kids, but because we're in such a strange period with technology and AI and economic disruption, and I see all the things that aren't really getting passed down or like the Kredi institutions very much, including colleges that are doing they're sort of holding on to what they have but doing less and less to actually pass on right knowledge.
00:12:40
Speaker 2: And some of the kids, you know, do you make tiktoks?
00:12:44
Speaker 3: No? And I don't think I'm on TikTok either, So I just see them as they show up in other feeds.
00:12:50
Speaker 1: Yeah, same, same, right two weeks later on Instagram. So you said you might have wanted to write a novel. Do you think that you might still do that.
00:13:01
Speaker 3: It's been the week I'm going to get it together for twenty five years now, and I've not got.
00:13:06
Speaker 2: This is a good week to get it together.
00:13:09
Speaker 3: It is, but I haven't given up either, and I love If I end up with the time and space to do that. My guess is I won't, or if I do, it'll be a different phase in life and sort of as a hobby thing again, not something I want to eat off of, right, right, or sort of stake myself to those ways. I feel like my kids are thirteen and eleven now, so I've got about ten years just thinking about stability, health, insurance, college.
00:13:38
Speaker 2: And then you could yolo, right, yeah?
00:13:41
Speaker 3: Or what's the other one? You either yolo or you faffo and you don't.
00:13:45
Speaker 2: Find out until after could be either one.
00:13:47
Speaker 1: But you know, the kids these days, they really are not out at like that age. It's still what I hear from parents older than us, because I also my oldest is fifteen, I have twelve and ten.
00:14:01
Speaker 2: They don't leave at eighteen and that's it. They stick around for a while.
00:14:05
Speaker 1: They stay on your phone, plane and your Netflix password and all of that for a while.
00:14:11
Speaker 3: I mean, I was on my parents' car insurance until definitely after having kids, maybe forty, and was otherwise like a very independent person. You have these little boons and take advantage, and you know, I think about that, and I had some The reason I got hired at the Sun initially was they were scouting around. My dad said you should talk to my son, and I've written some things, and I did this, and that was sort of the whole of the connection. And this wasn't a guaranteed job or thing or anything else, but like it cracked open a door and then I burst through that door. And I'd like to think, all these years later, I did all this.
00:14:48
Speaker 2: You did You
should absolutely feel that you did this.
00:14:51
Speaker 3: But I did all this. I should feel a lot of that. But I remember both as like a son and a paranow myself and all that that, Like that door was cracked and at that point, as I said, I had no idea what I was doing in life, and I would maybe not have even gone to that door otherwise, or it might have been just a little more closed and I would have walked on into some other door. And like, I'm very grateful to have had parents who were invested in me.
00:15:20
Speaker 2: Keep your insurance.
00:15:21
Speaker 3: Yeah, that thank you, mam.
00:15:26
Speaker 2: What are you most proud of in your life?
00:15:28
Speaker 3: Again, I'm working on my elevator pitches, but like I am inordinately proud of my my my children. I think they're just incredible Eric Adams wisdom, perfectly imperfect.
00:15:42
Speaker 1: That you're going to tell me you're proud of Eric Adams, which is going to be confusing.
00:15:46
Speaker 3: And brilliant and very much their own people who I have responsibility for and uh I love, but are going to go off and do their own things. And so far these very fraud ages and they all in different ways have like figured it out and risen every challenge. And just seeing them grow and sometimes with help from me, quite honestly, sometimes in spite of me, like just makes me feel full and like like like fruitful with the with the world. I love that, yeah, and with everything else. I just I you know, maybe this is why I keep doing the daily journalism thing. I'm just always turning over stones and what feels great in the morning by the afternoon, I'm shaky about or what's next or what's wrong with this one? And I like having gotten somewhere and having done some things in the in the world, but I don't really care with me that way, whereas with my kids, who by the way, could definitely go pro it just nothing. But just like swelling with Pratt love it.
00:16:49
Speaker 1: We're going to take a quick break and be right back on the Carol Marcowitch Show.
00:16:56
Speaker 2: Give us a five year out.
00:16:58
Speaker 1: Prediction can be about the kind of the world, music, art, anything.
00:17:02
Speaker 3: I think the bottom may be coming out all around and for all of us in a lot of different ways, and I'm concerned about that. The other way I think about it is sort of a flood, almost in biblical terms, that's going to wash away a lot of what's seemed permanent and health. And I do mean in the next five years thinking about this in terms of technology and then the effects that that I think is having on our politics and everything else. But just broadly speaking, I think a lot of the certainties we've had about our economic positions, our social positions in the world, how we treat other human beings. Big stuff is much more fraught than it's felt for me as somebody who grew up in sort of a golden age of America, a golden age for Jews in America, really good times. And my consolation in all that, and it's a big one, is I think, without some of the same immediate imperatives to provide for and understand ourselves in the world, like some beautiful new things may open up. It may just be other we destructive and all of the other problems and won't be around or want of time to think about it if that's the case. But I'm hopeful that we might have a period where suddenly people can can think and write very much on their own terms because there's no other reason to engage in those activities. People are going to have to be very focused on what's happening immediately around them in ways we've moved away from, and that some beautiful moments and opportunities might emerge from all that. So that's what I'm hoping, all.
00:18:35
Speaker 1: Right, that's a hopeful ending to that, because it started kind of iffy there.
00:18:40
Speaker 2: I wasn't sure things were going to end on a high note.
00:18:42
Speaker 3: I see mostly very dark clouds, but I am not dismissing silver linings, and you know, moments of big shift, lots of things get lost for better and for worse, and it feels very painful for the people who've been through that or connected to the old empires, if you will. Usually is something on the other end, and that something can be beautiful and good and healthier in certain ways. I love humanity, but I'm aware that we're like cricket timber, and the only thing worse than cricket timber, like the lunatics who would try to straighten it out entirely.
00:19:16
Speaker 1: Yes, Harry, I have loved this conversation. I've been a longtime fan of yours. I just think you're a fantastic writer and a fantastic human. Leave us here with your best tip for my listeners on how they can improve their lives.
00:19:31
Speaker 3: I am not the right person to ask, but since you did, Carol, and I think you're actually a pretty awesome and incredible person, journalist and person in the world as well. I think being focused and concerned with the things that are around you is almost the whole thing, and by around you, I mean within sight and within reach, and that if you think about the really big and global questions that way and things that don't end at the end of your siteline. You end up in like a healthier and more honest place that way, And I think it's also a lot of a lot easier than to talk to other people who have totally different giant world views and all that stuff. But being present where you are is like the thing I found that has rewarded me the most of life. And conversely, when I failed to do that, and I have like a galaxy brand sometimes about giant things and you.
00:20:26
Speaker 2: Get lost, you got to come back to basics.
00:20:29
Speaker 3: Yeah, yeah, come back to basics and be where you are.
00:20:33
Speaker 2: I love it. He is Harry Siegel.
00:20:35
Speaker 1: Check out his podcast fac NYC and lit NYC and beat him in the Daily News New York Daily News.
00:20:42
Speaker 3: Thank you, Harry, Thank you Carol for the record. I wanted it to be FAQ. I wanted it to be fac NSC, and then it was going to be okay, what the fact was going to be? That sounds right, yeah, And I love that and sometimes use that, but I've been forced by my partners on.
00:20:59
Speaker 2: The pod f a Q, thank you, n y C and is it l I T n y C.
00:21:05
Speaker 3: I've been going back and forth on that because I can't figure out what l I T would be as an acronym.
00:21:12
Speaker 1: All right, Check him out at f a Q n y C and lit NYC podcast.
00:21:17
Speaker 2: Thank you, Harry, Thanks so much.
00:21:19
Speaker 3: Yah,