TRANSCRIPT 🔗
The Hippocratic Society: Benitism, mortality, and meaning. She serves as the medical director of Pyramid Medicine ACI, helps for patients navigating serious illnesses. But beyond her clinical work, Dr. Furry has given us given medicine something increasingly rare language. Language to describe suffering, language to describe the limits of cure, and language to describe the moral work of being present when there is no monitor treatment to offer. Her memoir, That Good Night Life. Life and medicine at the 11th hour is both a personal and professional recognition with the culture of model medicine. I'm reading through this now, and it's excellent, and I highly recommend it for everyone in medicine, all the trainees and in SED practicing. and it looks at discomfort with death and its reflexive in insistence on fighting at all costs. Through deeply in the stories of patients and her own journey through training, she challenged us to reconsider what healing means. when cure is no longer possible. Her writing has appeared in outlets such as The New Yorker, The Atlantic, The New York Times, and the Los Angeles Times, and she has spoken nationally about suffering, dignity, and the moral responsibility of physicians to accompany patients and not just treat them. Tonight we have the privilege of learning with someone who has devoted a career to helping patients live fully, even as life draws to a close, and helping physicians rediscover the meaning of their work in the process. So please join me and welcome Dr. Summit. In the beginning. I just have to say that was like such an excellent summary. I would like to send that to my agent. I'll just use this for anything up in the thing. I actually have very limited writing capability, so I thought maybe it's so very happy to be here with all of you. And I think we had kind of talked about me opening by doing a leading. So because we're kind of talking about what it means to be a good doctor, right? I wanted to read from a piece I wrote to me worker about CPR, the fallacies around it, the social life it has and what it actually is. So Shortly after his 67th birthday, Ernesto Chavez retired from his job at a Los Angeles food warehouse. Sara, his boy, his wife of 45 years, told me that he meticulously took his medications for high blood pressure and cholesterol, hoping to enjoy his time with his grandchildren. But one morning in January 2021, Ernesto burned with fever. His chest heaving as though he were once again lifting heavy losses. At the hospital, he tested positive for COVID-19. His oxygen levels vomited, and he was properly into it. Ten days later, his lungs were failing, his face was bloated from layers of intrigues filling, and his hands and feet had begun to flee. As his chances of survival waned, I arranged to speak with his family about a subject inseparable from death itself, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, or CPR. For decades, physicians have debated whether CPR should be offered to people who suffer in the final blows of incurable illness, be with heart failure, advanced cancer, and dementia. Although CPR has become synonymous with medical heroism. Nearly 85% of those who receive it in a hospital died, their final moments left by pain and chaos. The pandemic only deepened the risks. Every chest compression spewed contagious particles into the air, and intubation, which often follows chest compressions, exposed doctors to virus named saliva. Hospitals in Michigan and Georgia reported that no COVID patient. Survive the procedure. An old question required an emergency. Why was CPR a default treatment mean for people as sick as it must be? As a palliative care physician, I helped people with serious, often terminal illness consider a path forward. During the pandemic, this involved weekly Zoom meetings with each family whose loved ones in the ICU. We discussed how the virus could damage the lungs irreversibly, how we gauged a patient's condition, and what we what we would do if, despite lean on life support, that patient died. On a gray afternoon, I longed on to Zoom to speak with Ernesto's family. I would be joined by Stella, Nancy, and Joe Nelson as a meeting of the city. We were meeting, I asked you all when we've been taught how to have these conversations. Nope, he said. I asked him what he might say to any of this woman. Quote, unfortunately, he still needs the belly for his lungs and he's not showing signs of improvement. We want you to know that he is very sick. He said, He's expecting some. Because he is so safe, his heart can stop. If that happened, would you want us to use CPR with your life? He used his hands to simulate chest compressions on the bed and body. In my own residency, I'd been taught to ask patients whether they wanted CPR and to build around a big decision. But an informed decision I wanted required me to do. One night I cared for Andrew, a man with imperial colon cancer. Who'd stop urinating and became disdianted, unable to handle copper surgery? He needed immediate dialysis, so I didn't attend to the ICE. When I discussed CPR with his wife, I didn't explain that Andrew's cancer had caused his heart and became used to fail, that he was dying, and that CPL wouldn't change that. I placed the entire volume of the decision on her shoulder. Reducing what should have been a conversation into a highly consequential customer question. If Andrew stops breathing, do you want to imagine? If his heart stops, do you want us to lose CPI? To Andrew's wife, no to most people, those questions being, do you want us to try and save them? I offered CPR as the regular choice between what you have. On the Zoom call, My spring slipped into three rectangles. Sarah and Nancy, her potato. Dark circles given Sara's eyes, and she believed that the Nestle in her mind. He said he wants everything done to save his life. She said, If he's going to die anyway, why not try with her lips? She disappeared, her left angle said any dark. Sorry, I just
Load full transcript
don't want to see. I don't want you to see me cry again. During residency, I would have assumed that if Ernesto wanted everything dying, he would want CPR. But this conversation was about Norman resuscitation. It was about death and how Ernesto would want to be careful as he approached it. Speaking with Sara, I tried to be frank about a procedure that symbolized both to doctors and to patients, something other than its reality. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you, Marina. Thank you. I have a lot of questions about your experience in what you describe as the Bordelance of life and death. Before we get into that, would you mind sharing with the audience a little bit about your journey to the medicine? Yeah, totally. So my mom's position, she's an anesthesiologist, and I kind of grew up wanting to be like her, but also I was really trying to be a So I feel very lucky that things have panned out as they have. But I really wanted to follow her example of service to others. I mean, she's an amazing anesthesiologist and I'm around with her in the Paccu when she wouldn't want me to be babysat. So my brother and I literally, we were five years old. This was not, I don't think HIPAA was a thing. But we would just go around with her to see patients. And I thought I I saw how they looked at her and I saw how she interacted with them. And I was like, this is amazing. I want to be like my mom. but then when I went to med school, to be honest, I was like, what am I doing? Like it just did not seem like what I had signed up for. And as I approached residency, I was getting very nervous about whether I had made choice. And it was at the very end of medical school that I happened by chance to do a palliative care elective with the man who became my mentor, BJ Miller, who's an amazing being and an amazing palliative care doctor. And I just watched him take a totally different approach with patients. We weren't there to just get in and out We were there to ask questions that I'd never heard asked very directly about dying and about suffering and what all of that meant to people and the difference between whether we should offer a therapy just because we could or because it was the right thing for the patient in front of us. And I had never seen, for example, an attending say to a patient that to do CPR on you would be unethical. And we're gonna keep you comfortable instead. I still remember that moment. I was like, you're allowed to say those things because you're kind of beating the the autonomous, that it's whatever the patient wants, and it's an advocation of our responsibility to be honest with people and to weigh the risks and the benefits of what we choose to offer. And so I also had a background in ethics, and so this kind of fit a lot of things together for me. And so that's how I decided to kind of pursue palliative care. I will say that in my residency, I tried very hard not to want to pursue palliative care because I was like, I love the ICU. I still love the ICU.
Like nothing makes me happier than like rounding the thing of the teams and having conversations and then in the unit. But the thing that I really enjoyed in the ICU was figuring out. Why am I doing this for this person? Am I just putting a line in them because that's what we do? Or where is this taking this person really? Am I extending life or am I extending depth? And I think that's the line. If you take anything from this talk tonight, I want you guys as mental students to think about that line, right? Technology is you're going to be taught exist to extend life. You're going to be taught that your responsibility is to extend life, not the cost of suffering. Right. And things can go very quickly from extending life to extended. And that to me, intellectually and personally, was really where I wanted to live in this. Thank you for sharing that thing. A lot of medical students I think are drawn to really fast-paced technical fields. How would you find weaning for yourself in the body? I think we are deeply technological, Wesapia. We're technological because we're using humans' oldest technology, which is that of words. Before everything we had, we've always had words in the oldest physician accounts of how they tended to suffering. So much of it was about being present with patients and choosing to witness even when you couldn't fix things. And so for me, the meaning is really about. Have I given someone the ability to articulate how they want to live their life till it is ending? Because to me, it's not about death as a menace or death as the end of everything. I think people as they approach it are really more interested in talking about how they want that time. So so much of what I do is really about helping people live well. Whether they've just gotten a cancer diagnosis and we're giving them beds to keep them feeling like they can walk around regarding or whatever they want to do that brings the meaning versus being at the bedside at the alarm when we're taking somebody out the elevator. I think there's meaning in all of that. There's meaning in the witnessing. There's the meaning of what words you deploy, how you use your silences, how you use your body language. Like your body is a tool as well, doctoring. And people pick up on that. That's actually the first thing they pick up on. So I think all of it is just for me, both as a writer and as a person, like you really get to see people grapple with things you might think are insurmountable, but people have always found their way through. And I think that witnessing that and learning from that is also really quite incredible. Hmm. Do you think that with all the technological advancements that we are as a society slowly losing our ability to communicate, to use words effectively? I totally think so. And I think there's a couple examples of that. See one is when I'm in family meetings and someone says, you know, my dad or mom. They're fighters. Yeah, or someone says, I want you to do everything for them. Or I'm a meeting a miracle. I actually give a talk called Fighter Miracle Everything. Because these tend to be the big words that come up in meetings and you don't know where to go from. Because, like I was reading, like if somebody said they're a fighter, I would just assume, okay, I guess I have to pull out all the stocks. But it's actually about saying, tell me what fighting means to you. When you tell me that you're a fighter, help me understand it. Right? When you say you want everything done, tell me that everything looks up to you. And then having the courage to say, what if I told you that we are doing everything and she's still done? And medicine will never land against nature. I think we've lost a sense of nature because the technology binds us. And there's a way to hold both. The sacredness of healing when cure is not possible, the sacredness of a body minding down, and all the ways we can try to forestall that. Both can coexist. And there have been times. Give you an example where something was like, you know, I do not want chemotherapy because my sister had it and it really. And I'll have to say, but tell me about what cancer. So it turns out that that cancer is very different from the life that she has. So by saying no to chemo, it's actually not informed. So I have actually had this, I have sent people to oncology to say, I just want you to hear them out because I want you to make the best choice for your whole life. But I think you're closing the door on something without understanding what it has looked like. So I think that's another interesting part of my job too, is I can actually help people think about what they're trying to suit their best interest, which people don't expect from value at all. But my role is to hear people out, make sure they understand what's going on, and then weigh it. So sometimes I have been the one to say, actually I think I think there's things to try before estimating him. Because you have to be the advocate in all directions. That's definitely challenging. your book reflects a lot about this tension of wanting to fight and prolong life and the impermanence of of death. And I'm at this intersection all the time. Yes. And especially with we're talking about the cardiovascular ICU, we've pushed the forme gun technology and life safety measures. How do you how has your work in palative care really reshaped your understanding of what it means to be a good physician in these circumstances? Yeah. So I think the term a good physician depends on context. So I think there's certain values that must inform being a good doctor, upholding ethics, listening to your patients, offering things that where benefit outweighs harm, right? And those principles hold across contexts. But I think sometimes being a good physician at that very sharp razor-thin line between life and death and the ICU. Sometimes meaning saying things like, We are not going to offer this, or this is no longer helping, and
we have reached the limits of our capabilities. And I say it differently than that, but I'm just speaking somewhat colloquially here. and I think that is a very hard thing to do. Some people might think a good physician will do whatever the patient says. And I don't know that I agree with that. I think again, in Even to talk about it in ethical terminology, true informed choice depends on us weighing risks and benefits and not offering people everything in a textbook, but offering people what fits that situation. And sometimes what fits that situation is the thing we have to set limits on. And that's very hard. And some people might say that's a bad thing. But I think we have to have moral courage in medicine. To say what's true, even when what's true might break someone's heart. And I'll often say that to people that I know that some of the things we're talking about will break your heart. But I'm gonna be here through this conversation, you know. So or sometimes I'll say, I would rather tell you the ugly truth than a pretty one. Because it's easy for us to say, okay, let's just do it this because we want it. But we know the consequences. So it's sometimes at those decisions. So I think the moral courage piece of it is a way to also combat idental distress. Because I know there's several times leading them, but like how many of us have been in situations where we're like, I should not have offered that? Or I offered it in good faith, but now I'm seeing the consequences. My worship would turn back to So, you know, we've all been there. And these are very thorny, extremely challenging situations. But I think what it means to be good ultimately means also doing guiding people. I think our role as a guide is extremely important. I mean something I think we've lost track of because we're so eager not to seem quote unquote paternalistic. And I'm not for paternalism, but I am for being sometimes a strong guy because we know this landscape, right? I sometimes will tell my trainees, like, you are like a sharp, and this is a very crazy mountain. And like, you know the gear that you're gonna need to scale it. They do not know that. This is their first trip up the mountain. We have been up this mountain. So it's our job to guide, because There's so much in that landscape that is uncertain and unpredictable. And the uncertainty that people have to live with when they're sick, that is one of the single hardest things for them to do. So being a guide is a firm hand, a firm but gentle hand through the forest. How do you balance, you know, it's very difficult to explain that to families and to patients. How do you balance that the gravity of those discussions while also not wanting them to lose hope? Yep. So I get this question a lot. And I think hope is more elastic than you think it is. So I think some people think that hope is only about getting better and making the hospital. But there's all sorts of shades of hope in dire surfaces, right? So sometimes The hope is not that we would get him falling, but that we can excavate him, we can have even your mates being able to say something to you. Right? Sometimes the hope is for him to no longer be in any pain. Sometimes the hope is to get him on hospice. And then we have to use the window of time that is available. And so sometimes that means going that day. And so part of my role is to ask people what they're looking for. And that is central to how we journey through these conversations. I will also say is sometimes I have to, I often have to roll up. They do not know who I am, they've never met me. And I have, this is what I tell my trainees you have about a minute to get people to trust me when high stake situations and wherever it is. And even if it's not the high octane time in the ICU, you still have about a minute in our shoes. Because we often show up as strangers because we're called way too late. And so I have about a minute to get people to trust me and to trust that I am trying to put their best interests at the heart of everything we do. And a lot of how I do that is started by telling what we know about what's going on Because people have four million people coming in and out of their rooms in the hospital. They're like, I don't know, the dialysis guy said this and someone else said this. Like, I don't really know what's going on. So even explaining to people in kitchen table language, not jargon, what is actually happening to them helps them to find hope. And that's the guiding light. But sometimes I do have to say, I am hoping for the mayor with you, but I also want us to have a plan B in case we don't get to the error. And so there's a way to fit both the hope and the realism. I'm also of the opinion that I can never take someone's home. I think that is kind of a superhuman thing to do. I think people always have the agency to find hope. And by being honest with them, that actually gives them a moment to refer anyway. If we're not honest with people, then they can't make decisions that we can't find hope in a bunch of different possible outcomes. So it's a hard balance sometimes. And I'm actually very transparent with my patients. So I'll be like, you know, I am not saying this to take your hope away. I'm saying this because I allow us to hold open reality again. And I'm very much for just being fair and honest with people, even about your own discomfort in the situation. I like that. I like that you, you know, sometimes families will tell us, you know, please don't tell my family member this or that. They're gonna lose hope and they're not gonna want to continue. But I like that idea that it's it's really not our response, not responsibility, but in within our power. necessarily do that for people. Yeah. Which is interesting. You mentioned trainees and you're in talking with them. And I want to read an excerpt from your from your book and I'll ask you a question a little bit after about education, medical education. but this is a part
where you you were describing a time during your fellowship training. so here's a quote. If one is in the business of treating illness, surely one must also have the skills to recognize and discuss stability, mortality, and suffering. What had happened to medicine, to medical practice that enabled us to become physicians without acquiring the skills I was now learning? We're so blinded by the shiny allure and promise of technology and scientific innovation that we'd convinced ourselves we could defy nature and overlook the common human experience of death and suffering? Were we so focused on learning facts and procedures that we'd forgotten to consider medicine's limits? Had the time pressure to see more and more patients convinced us that we couldn't take on the sorts of discussions we at some level knew were important? Had we built such a strong identity around always being able to offer something, anything, to patients, that we prescribe medications or perform procedures out of a sense of professional obligation? We were so paralyzed by the thought of the litigation of the treated patients with procedures they demanded, especially towards life's end, rather than considering the immense harm inherent in these offerings. Modern medicine often emphasizes cure over care. What virtues do you think are missing from our medical education, and how can we cultivate another methods in the future? So I think the biggest disservice we do is we not teach people how to talk to patients from the get-go. And you all do these awesome things with there's an actor and they're like, I have stuck pain, and they're gonna leave a bunch of stuff. I never found a whole lot of use in that. I don't know if there's any medical education people in charge here who are gonna hate me for saying that. I just don't think it's Useful. And if you are here, this is my opinion. But I think like the situations that most people are in terrible distress about when they rotate with me or when they're consulting me is they don't know how to handle or talk about these things. We're all distressed also if we're like, did I come up with the right differential? Did I miss something? Did I do that central line right? Should I have it gone for the subclavian instead? All of those things are really gonna be distressing. But everything I see from med student to attending level is did I do that conversation right? Like thinking about things when you go home, like I can't get, like a fellow recently told me that someone was getting intubated and she was doing the intubation and she could just see in the patient's eyes like cleaving it. Please don't do this to me. And the family was right there saying, do everything. And like she was, she was very upset. It was fine technically. Everything about the medical piece of it was fine. But she was like, I cannot get this woman's eyes on my mind. It was a code at night and a respiratory code. And she had it fully arrested, but. That fellow was there to intubate and move on with her light. Never saw this patient again. And like the feeling of I didn't know how to handle this family. And why did no one talk about this before she got to this point? Is very distressing. And I think there was a point in my residency where I was putting so many dialysis catheters in people who did not need them. But I was like, does anyone else want to do the quintin life? I'm fine not doing this. And of course, a lot of my co-residents jumped at the opportunity because we have to get signed off on a certain number of lines. But I think for me, this is the nexus of like practice and ethics. And we don't do enough with the ethics and locality of therapies of this. So you get all this technical information of education, you need that. You need to be very good at that. But you also need a parallel curriculum in how do we talk to people? How do we think about dying? What does dying look like from cancer? What does it look like from heart failure? You can learn about heart failure and learn about the end stages of heart failure at the same time. And that doesn't mean we're saying your role isn't to do everything you can, but it's what everything means is very context specific. And I think not giving you guys those intellectual frameworks early on and continuing to impress upon you how those apply, that is I see the consequences of that every day. And I wish I didn't have to see that. I also wish I didn't get called to clean up messes. But is that is my role. And I just wish the mess wasn't there. I wish people felt like they could have these conversations. And you need training for that. You need an investment in the importance of this skill. Because it is like a skill. It's like putting in 10 central lines. You have to practice. And in palliative care, conversations are not procedure. So just like a surgeon goes to the OR and they have a thing they do with different instruments that they pick up in different situations. That is exactly what we do. And I will be honest, there are some doctors who think we are a nonsense specialty because anyone can talk to someone. And I'm like, yeah, you come do my job for a day. Let's see how you're doing at the end of that day. But that's not a small point. It's the reason why a lot of us burn out. It's all the misconceptions. And if we had education through med school, I would like to think that they were not as many misconceptions. You you emphasize it in Pylet Carrie, you also just mentioned it that words are your tools and communication is your procedure. what are some practical ways for med students to start practicing using the language of compassion and and even precision in in the words that you use in talking about machine? So I think one of the first things is you want to ask people, tell me what you know about what's going on. Or tell me what the other doctors have said to you about your condition and your treatment. Because people do not know. Like you'd be surprised at how
many times people cannot tell you what's going on, or they're like, you tell me what's going on. No, no, you tell me what you know. And then I can fill in the blanks because there are so many people coming in and out of hospital rings from so many different teams. So starting even there, tell me how you're putting this together and being conversational and using kitchen table language. So we don't want to say things like your prognosis is poor, which I hear a of time. We know what that means, but they don't know what that means. Or you're in multi-system organ failure, or I need to intubate you to protect your air. Like, okay, like I don't know what that means. Sounds fancy, so it must be good for me. and people really do think the more you do for them, the better. And I always have to tell people, let me reframe that for you because the more life support you need, actually the less your body can do for itself. And that's another good thing. Improvement means you need less and less life support, less life support, body heal. More life support, body and triple. And it's like breaking down really simple things like that. Being a God. So you start just telling what you're what's going on. Be able to fill in the blanks. Again, simple length tray. You know, I know that you you know that you have that static column cancer and that it is incurable. The consequences we are seeing is that your body, which is susceptible to infection, is also unable to fight it off because the cancer is so Right, kitchen table basic language, like how you would probably talk before you came to med school and resocialized into this full level of set of languages, right? So and listening to the language people are using because they are telling you a story, and you need to understand that story in order to help. So you want to step into it, like like I said earlier, tell me what being a fighter means to. What sorts of things have you fought back against in other parts of your life? Right? How have you dealt with the uncertainty? Like I hear that this is really scary that we don't know the treatments are possible for your cancer. How have you coped with uncertainty before? You know, like getting to know them through questions that are directly relevant to the situation and not being afraid to ask for more. Like, I was in a situation. Last week where I asked a patient's son, tell me what everything looks like. And he was like, Well, it's everything. I was like, Well, that can mean a lot of things. So tell me what really the CR is. He's like, do it all, do CPR. And I was like, okay, so tell me again that you understand that pretty well. And sometimes it just means you have to push and push and push gently. To get to the core. And it also means understanding that sometimes you will not get there. Right? Just like sometimes the surgery will not fit somebody. Sometimes the chemo will not rescue. Sometimes every tip and trick and tool I have is not gonna reach the core. And that's
the other piece of medicine is accepting your limits, not just the limits of the body and the limits of technology that we all have. And there are some situations I cannot fix. And then I ascribe it in my own set of beliefs to mystery and to fate that I am not meant to walk any further than this point with this person. And where they will walk to next is about something much bigger than me. That kind of brings me to another example that you bring up in your book. You talk about a patient named Jack, who is essentially the young patient who's essentially a persistent vegetative state. And his parents are the decision makers, and they, you know, understandably always want everything done for him, even though he's getting more and more infections, readmitting pneumonia many times. And your team is consulted and seems to make finally a breakthrough. With the parents and saying that, you know, the next infection he gets, he's not, he probably don't have the tools to fight it because he's had so many bodies. And you make a breakthrough that they say, you know, you know, CPR will probably be more suffering for him than beneficial. And they sign a pulse and he leaves the leaves the hospital, but the next time he's readmitted, his mother tears up the pulse for him. And they seem to are on even unsuccessfully per over an hour. You reflect on that experience that as physicians we also need to learn more about surrendering access. Can you elaborate a little bit more on the idea of how as physicians we also need to realize that we are not capable? Yeah. So yeah, that was a very hard case for me. this young man had coded initially during a scope. He just Was getting an EGD and let out. Totally unexpected. And they did some KR in the GI suite, and he was unfortunately in a persistent vegetative state. And so he was coming in and out of the hospital looking lumnias, and he was just resistant to so many environments. So we have to talk about it. And there was a lot, like I can still see his parents' faces in my life. Like they were really struggling and suffering because how can you say, okay, I'll let my child to go? Because that's what it sounds like to people. When you say, this may not help, like this is the limit, it they'll they'll say it sometimes also it sounds like we just like whoever go. And that's definitely a lot. But it feels that way, especially with parents sometimes. And I just remember there was like an ethics meeting about this, and there was a lot, I think, from different teams, they are all very distressed about what to do with someone if he got sick or named another left, or if he couldn't because he's against will. And so When we finally got the parents to agree, it felt like, okay, right, because you can still bring him back if something is going on and we can try our best. But we want him to be prepared, but they may not be back somewhere. And then if he gets to his limits and his body is showing us his body and come, we don't need to do
procedure that will only extend his development. And so It felt like okay. I was at a point in my fellowship too where I was like running from my attendance that turned me out of all the language I thought we helped him. And then when he came back and floated in the ER, I just was so angry. I was so angry. I was like, why would they do that to me? You know, and this is again now with 12 years since fellowship reflecting back, a lot of it is that at the end of the day, we don't know. What decisions people are making. People often say things to me, those like, yeah, there's some set of things out there like, I had a year to live, I need to blow up. I mean, the whole point of mortality is we don't know what it's coming. Right? And when we ask questions like, if you have this, I think, we don't know if these people change their mind. Because when you're in the situation, you don't actually might be guessing or maybe we use the saying, no, that's not for me. So I think they panicked and they weren't ready. And I don't know they were ever ready. Right. I think that's kind of a fallacy just like accepting death is a fallacy. The residents would call me and say, I don't think they've accepted this. Tell me what it's it's means to be what does it look like to enact acceptance? And so, you know, that case was a really big moment for my mentor and the other ship was that you cannot control how people actually end up done. No control over that. So you need to run that unit. And it's just like going to the other one, you can't as a symbol control of everything that's been happening because you don't know ahead of time, everything that happens in the end. didn't know this would cause him to meet there's just a lot of stuff that happens you cannot be free. I do not think that his mom especially was like ready to say, okay. I think when the patient isn't the staff also, and so we bring that to these situations, we bring The hesitance of asking the 35 or do cancer what they want. Well we will ask for 75 to or maybe we won't. Maybe we won't see this match of culture actually, yeah. but that is I think one of the mysteries of turning a book is you don't actually know what's about. But you have to be there like what's Well, you I want to share another quote from your book that I really appreciate. You took care of unfortunate another young patient who's on a definite life development. And to relate your fellowship, but you describe your family meetings that you had. And I really like this this metaphor, this imagery that you use to illustrate the the path of of patient care. So here's a quote. During my first month of fellowship, I started to visualize the treatment of serious illnesses as a journey the medical duty took with patients, a hike taken together in a dense forest with only a sliver of moon visible overhead. The hike itself might be arduous and frightening, complete with trails that splintered into many paths, but both doctor and patient continued in search of their mutual destination. I thought of Gold's discussions as a necessary pause on the path. An invitation for both doctors and patients to take stock of the journey thus far to discuss how best to reach the destination. Where on the map did the patients think they were? Did the doctors agree? Was the destination still within reach, or had a boulder fallen on the known path to reach it? Was there a way around the boulder, or was it important to consider a different destination? Continuing on a tenuous journey, blind P was a recipe for failure, but a goal is to session. Discussion could be helpful only if the doctor could tell the patient clearly and compassionately if they were at a juncture where either of two trails would lead them to their destination, or whether they now found themselves unexpectedly at the edge of a cliff, their destination now out of reach. And if they needed to aim for a different destination, what sort of place would the patient want to see? What would they want along this new different path? Family meetings are a procedure, prominent palliative care physician named Susan Block had once said, and they require no less skill than performing an operation. Your writings often highlight difficult conversations with families. What practical advice would you give young trainees or young doctors for initiating those conversations? What kind of language to use, especially when families maybe are resistant or unprepared? So one thing I just wanted to acknowledge is this is heavy material. And I say this to my trainees too, that we all bring something to these sorts of conversations. So I just like I just wanted to acknowledge that because how many of you are first years? Second years, third years, fourth years? Okay, so we have a range in here, but a lot of you are first years. How many of you have had any sort of discussions about serious illness death or diet in your first year? Sounds like nothing. How many? How many? So this is that, I guess. And so it's not, this is not easy material. It's also not easy to rely around when you're starting that screen or you're at the very end and thought it back on how you were or were not prepared for this. but it is a part of the reality. Of life and of privacy medicine with this thing to come up. And before I answer your question, I also just wanted to say sometimes this has nothing to do with death or dying specifically, but it has everything to do with suffering. And have you guys ever had a lecture on suffering or engaged in any discussion of what that means? Who has? Okay. Yes. I think I don't know you, but I'm thinking you're an attending. I am great cause. two. I love the surgeons. I do. My mom's an anesthesiologist. So the surgeons babysat me disaster. All I did and their surgical elements like a soda fountain. And I wasn't tall enough to reach it. So there was always a surgeon who would get me some. And I think they have it wasn't plombite bars. It was like a crappy version
of those. Anyway, nice to meet you. so I think the question of suffering is one that we should be having with everyone, whether they are terminally ill or just gotten an incurable diagnosis or whatever. And I think one question as students, because you're there with more time. Then you can ask is tell me about your suffering. Tell me how you're suffering. I'm here to listen. Right? That I think is something every patient and family member deserves. I think the other thing you could do is use that language with the caregivers. Tell me what this has been like for you, taking care of your husband, because no one talks about the caregivers. And that is a huge oversight. And so a very simple question, very simple language is really around suffering. Tell me where the pain is. Tell me how it's affected your life. Tell me how I can be an advocate. They're sometimes going to think as men students that you are doctors. I think it's important to also clarify that you're not, because you're not, and they're going to probably expect expertise from you. You don't yet have. But you were a human being and you were immensely qualified to talk about how people suffer. And I highly encourage you to read about. Some of the great work on something. And has anyone read Viktor Frankel's Man Search for Learning? That's an outstanding account of what helps people going, how keep people going when the circumstances are truly horrific. So Viktor Frankel was an Austrian psychiatrist who ended up in a concentration camp. And a lot of what he writes about it is how people find a way to endure. And it's an excellent book. I highly love it with it. I think the writings of the Dalai Lama on what suffering is is really important. There's so many in different spiritual traditions. The Bhagavad Gita in Hinduism is our central text and talks a lot about what suffering is. And you don't have to be religious to read it. It's philosophy. And I think starting to wrap your mind around how people suffer, what illness takes from them. Even asking, what has this taken from you? Because illness is a series of losses. We think death is the big loss, but illness is a series of losses. Tell me what it's been like when you couldn't go back to your job that gave you purpose. What gives you purpose? Right? These are questions anyone can ask. You don't need to be in medical school to ask these questions. But this is the stuff that emanates from the existence. And like it or not, you are in the central muck and luck of human existence. Everyone is going to get sick. Everybody is going to die. Everybody is going to suffer. You will heal and cure some people, but you won't win them all, because we're not here to win them all. Medicine is a stall. It can buy time, but it cannot fix. Medicine can't cure mortality, nor should it try to be, because without mortality, what would we do? Why would I be pressured to finish my second book proposal if I knew I could live forever? Then I'd just be lazy and watch Industry, which is a great show. I recently got into it and I'm like, I can't stop. I can't look away. So that was kind of a meandering answer, but I think as students, think about the basic stuff, right? Tell me how you'd have someone said to me, if I was sick. Tell me about your suffering. my God, I would just fall apart by someone asking it in that way. It's very different than what's your pain today on this feeling that you said. Yeah. Which is a question I do not ask. And if you rotate with me, you'll see a different approach. But I would just start from a place of like also the people you've loved who have been sick, right? How many of us have had people involved with very serious illness from a or death? If you haven't, it's coming. And so thinking about if you had the experience, what did you wish someone had asked your love or the caregiver of your love? Because those are the questions to ask. You mentioned in the in new test, there's a book that you they use often, and I'm to write it down, but It's that the the souls volume like a cloth discards it at the time it died. Yes. I I really love that quote as well. And you you obviously talk about spirituality a lot in your writings, your parents' really strong faith, your own journey with your faith, spirituality of your patients, and how it informs their decisions and how they rely on it one way or the other. How do you see a physician's role in adding that dimension to the affair? Yeah. So I think in medicine, we hear the word God and we want to run. Right. There's like this tension of we are people of science. And so what do we do with faith? Right. I am of the belief that those two systems of belief can coexist, that it doesn't have to be a choice between one or the other. It doesn't mean you have to have a faith that you need to rely on, but your patients are gone. And I think approaching it from a place of curiosity, right? Do you have a faith practice? Do you follow a specific religion? Tell me about your relationship to God. Because again, you're just trying to learn what is that meaning and purpose. You do not have to have the same faith. You don't have to agree with their beliefs. But it is a huge part of how people cope, how families cope, what binds people together in community. And so I always, my big tip for you guys is approach things from a place of curiosity. If you are curious and open to their answers, people are going to feel it. Okay. And so being open to this dimension of life, I think is very important. In my own faith tradition, so I am Hindu and I also Practice Buddhism, they're very related, Buddhism and Rada Buddhism. So a lot of the shared beliefs around the impermanence of all things, right? Engaging with the fact that everything we live and everything we die. Like embracing that rather than running away from it is a big part of philosophy. And it doesn't mean that we're just talking about human death. It's like this tree that I love around the corner for
me. Like it's just a magnificent tree. And it's bare right now. But I know the leaves are gonna come and I know the leaves are gonna fall. And that in and of itself, like the way nature performs and punelins for us, it's teaching us. When we have a pet and that pet dies, it's showing us something, right? The world is turning and our patients' lives and our lives will turn. And I think finding a way to contend with that, whether that is through spiritual traditions or not, I think is very important because I'll tell you a story. I was on call for cardiology nights at San Francisco General Hospital, which was a nightmare. and I had two men come in in full rest. Both happened to be Vietnamese, both happened to have same similar like medical problems, both were the same age. We did the same things. I learned the code the same way. One died that night and the other walked out of the hospital. How do you explain that? I think that was God telling me you must learn to have the answer to how you reconcile this, because this will be your life and will be your career. I still remember, I mean, I get like tipful thinking about that night because I was like, was it me? Did I do something wrong? But ACLS is a protocol. You follow the protocol and your card, the Clides fellows showed up, like there was nothing we could have done differently. And I think contending with that, I mean, it's still like emotional for me. Because I had to be the one to go tell the family that she had died or he had died. I had to tell the other family, we'll go into the catholic, but he's coded three times. It was PEA arrest, which is a bit different than VTEC or V. So I say these things because these are the things that have really impacted me. And I've had to reflect on that. Because if things happen and we don't take a pause and ask ourselves, why did this shake blowing past opportunities for me and growth? So it's difficult to deal with. how have you dealt with so much suffering and pain and and I liberated no idea. Like I do not know. How do we not get desensitized? You don't seem desensitized. I don't know how that's possi. I mean, I'm desensitized to the nonsense of the hospital, but like Not I think yet to the kind of suffering I've seen. I honestly don't know. I I don't have a little answer to this. it is very hard. It is very hard to see very similar intense amounts of suffering, not just from the patients and families, but the teams that don't know what to do. The nurses who are distressed when there's a medical plan that they're like, where is this going? The social workers who are like, the home is a disaster and we cannot send in back there, but there's like nowhere else to send it. All of that stuff is hard to hold. I go to Orange Theory. I try to do a lot of yoga. I have a wonderful family and I have an amazing doll who's a very human presence for me. So I'm lucky to have that in my life. But I will tell you, earlier in my career, I thought my job is everything. Your
job is not everything. And so I would say about five years ago, I was like, screw this. Like I need some serious boundaries. I cannot be boundless. I cannot fix all this, right? That's kind of how I do it. I have wonderful, I just have some wonderful people in my life and thank God for them. Because otherwise I would just be watching Breaking Bad since I think it is the best written show on a television cover. Although the writer is also very good. I love drugs and it's it's very different than like my everyday life so maybe that's it but so is industry you never live in that old never it's about these like investment bankers in England and but then it's like become something very dark because the investment bank actually goes bellied up. But all these different traders, like each of their life trajectories is like split off in all these different directions. And now I'm on a season more. But I am now in seasonful. I really I'm like how many hours somebody can use. I have a couple more questions. your journey spans multiple worlds. Your physician, a writer, daughter of immigrants. I was reading there said any shaped your perspectives in this. I think that coming from a very spiritual home and coming from a home of immigrants really I think it just helped gives me a lot of perspective on our patient population and some of the things that people don't need to explain to me. There's like a shared, there's a sub so there's a text and there's a subtext in any conversation. The subtext is what you sense and validate without having to say it. And I think having lived in a lot of different worlds has helped me to find that with only a lot of the people I end up taking care of. I think as a writer, so the big thing doctoring and writing shares is we both rely on observation, whether it's at the human condition or whether it's walking into a room and being like, This guy's breathing in the 50s. What is going on here? You need to, where's the primary team? We need to intervene now. but I think it's the observation that I bring to it that might be slightly different than somebody who's not a writer might bring to it. Because I'm looking for a lot of things, like even the language, in the voice, character. What is the story these people are telling them something about the settings? What is the story the wife is telling herself about you need to be someone's advocate? What story is the primary timebrate? It's about we can fix everything. Like a lot of what I do in family meetings is reconciling different stories at a narrative level. So, like when I teach my writing students, this is the example I give that life's about negotiating different stories. Because it's about negotiating different perspectives. And the thing that defines character in just a literary way is perspective. And so that's happening at multiple levels in these conversations. And the medicine and the writing reinforce each other. I'm a better writer because I'm a doctor. I'm a better doctor
because I'm a writer. I like that law. I wish I was a better writer. We are we can all be writers. It can be done. But it is a I mean, I think some people think this is best in the glamorous world. It's not. Being a writer is being a recluse in a lot of ways. Like when I'm deep in peace, I like and tell my partner that everyone get me. Like I can't talk to you. Like it's it is a very, very tough practice if you want to be good at it. And You can be very good at it and still not make it. And so there's like a lot in that literary world that is very, very tough. And putting like throwing in the sentence and being like, is this communicating what I want to communicate? You can spend hours rearranging one paragraph to get it right. And that is a compulsion, not the source of some glamorous line. Just in case anyone was wondering. my final question for you is if you could offer one ethical lesson to all the manifest students in this room about suffering, mortality, what it means to be a true physician, a new doctor, and how that's defined. What would you just because you can does not mean you should. Just because you can do something for somebody does not mean that it makes sense in the context of their lives. A ventilator is a neutral technology. Right. If someone's in a car accident and we think their little bleed is going to go away, but they can't breathe. Okay, let's bridge you recovery. It's a very different technology. Someone is dying from metastatic cancer and grandmother about sepsis and the isolated machines. You can put them on a ventilator, but should you? Just because you can does not mean you should. And ask people about their self. Tell me about yourself. You'd be astounded at how that simple question changes your relationship with that. It makes it deeper and truer. Don't be afraid of the depth. The depth is where that's at. That's where life's at. Thank you so much. Appreciate you being here. You can have to see if anyone from the audience has questions. I have a question. Thank you. This has been so wonderful. you mentioned a couple of times developing moral courage for these difficult conversations. What was most impactful? Just a couple of things in your education and your left as an attendant to help raise the bar for that. I think serious model, right? When I was in doing my palliative care meditation, and it's really a tragedy that you Can graduate medical school without doing a palliative care rotation. Right? That is not acceptable. It's not acceptable to me that you can graduate medical school and never do a home hospice visit to see what happens when you discharge your patients. So I really think it was modeled for me at just the right time when I did my palliative rotation of fifth year, when I would consult palliative in my residency. Or like I had so many just General medicine attendings or ICU attendings that were very good at this. And I just I modeled off the ones that helped me. And I also pay attention to the people
who don't do it well, because they're teaching you something too. I think that was really the source. And then I think for me, just like going to my attendings and saying, I don't. Why are we gonna trade this guy? Like, I wouldn't say it like that, but I would just be like, I am concerned about what his life is gonna be like after we trick him. Like, should we be tricking him? And if the answer was the family wants it, I mean, as a resident, you're not really in a position of that. But where I could, I would try to push it and say, like. What would the worst that can happen be if we have a family meeting? To just be like, is this the path we need to go down before we do the trick? and then just seeing how people responded. And I think reflecting on the times where I could say people, I can do this, but I'm not gonna do this. Watching fellows who did it well, watching people who did it badly. I think that was huge for me. And then, and this is something I try to model in our service is saying, here's all the things we can do, but we will not do CPL, right? Like modeling that is very important. And I think it's not just in Pali Lakel that this is more. A lot of physicians can do this. You just want to be around the ones who do well. Like seek them out, right? Seek out the ones who speak well to patients and say, Can you, can I be your apprentice? Not in the Donald Trump, but in like a like I'm waiting for a student to come to me at UCI and be like, I would like to learn how to communicate with people. Teach me how to communicate with people. Nothing would make me happier, truly. We want to mentor people in this because we know the consequences of nothing like how to do this. Personal, emotional, and practice. So I think that's how everything's been done. Thank you. thank you for a very good talk. actually related to that last question, do you think as palliative care has the number of residencies, fellowships, programs itself to develop, which has been tremendous? Do you think that that's actually been a negative though in in terms of the rest of medical education, the rest of the groups? not learning it as much we rely on you guys i think a little too much and we were just talking about this when we we met for the first time in the parking lot and i was like i'm just this has been a shitty day because of the following and it is because sometimes i feel like people outsource communication to me and i'm like you have to trust i am not getting involved unless the foundary team is trust And by try, I don't mean asking, do you want CPO? I mean actually sitting down and having a conversation with them. And I do feel ethically confident that I'm like, am I enabling bad behavior? Like, what if we practice in a place where there's no palliative care team? Because there isn't a palliative care team everywhere. Sometimes it's just one nurse or social work. You don't always have palliative doctors around. And so it's a real tension in my own mind because I have noticed here I get consulted a lot as the first pass in communication. And it's very hard for me to get because my mission as an educators also give me the tools, but also part of your learning is going to be messing up. And if you mess up, call me. But you might be able to do it. You might not need me. But you have to try. And it's hard because it's a consult heavy hospital. And so there's just that culture of calling consults. And so it becomes hard if you're like, no, I'm not going to get involved. Because you might be the one consultant that's not going to unless the team trains. But it's still important to try. So it's kind of a, it's a very hard balance, even for pain management, right? Like people follow me someone's got cancer and pain. And I'm like, I'm going to learn how to help you, but I'm not seeing any pain mass or inside. I need you to try. Yeah, you talked about a whole kind of the longevity requires stopping on this. is that a luxury you feel like to go to that smear level where you have to make the boundaries of what you're like attending? Because how can we drop those boundaries? That is so I think it's different when you're in training. It is relevance in your training and it should be, right? This is what you're getting to do is something upset. So you need to learn hard as students and as residency, right? This is necessary. But I think the boundaries we can't come are about, for example, study run out of the pace by studying sort of purpose and I will make time for the other people and interests in that. Or am I just gonna make a voice about how am I, what is love? Let me just be honest with you that there's no real such thing as love in medicine, right? We're not well. Like that's why we're shooting. So that's why we do this job. but it is a very personal thing to be like, what if I need to not to flail? But to keep going finding meaning hopeless and spirit. So you're not going to be able to tell your attending, I'm sorry, this is my boundary. But it's the internal recognition of what can I do to make my life safer. So I don't have to feel like I'm completely comfortable with that. That's the power of stories. Because you're not always going to be able to say. No, right? If someone's like, you need to go see this patient and it is whatever, 8:30 p.m., you can't really tell your attendant, you know. But you can tell yourself, what am I gonna do so that I can come back towards that state? And that's a dialogue I encourage you guys to start having with each other and internally like in that, because sustainability is a long goal and it's something that is going to shift. Certainly understanding what works for you and what doesn't work for you, I think is really important. and I will tell you, medicine does not really know what boundaries are. So I might be 12 years into anything attending one, but I can't say, sorry, have a boundary. Like it's not possible sometimes. So I have to go back to okay, if I'm gonna be warped
into the ground for three weeks, what am I gonna do on my writing week? Am I even gonna write on my writing week? Or am I gonna give myself like permission to just recover that week? Right? It's a dialogue and conversation that is going to shift as your content shifts. and you can hold both in. The importance of working hard and also the importance of working hard at what's going to keep you well. And ask for help if things are getting better, right? You are not going through this alone. It's gonna feel like we're going through it alone when you are not well and you need help and support. Ask for it. Could I address that? by the end in the us we lose a doctor invited a student to self suicide that is not acceptable we cannot have that i mean that is just that's a reflection taking in so much to the point where a person Can't handle it and yet there are resources. So use those resources if you ever find yourself in a situation of hopelessness. PG 138. I can't I can't even count all the incredibly stressful situations counter and in moments of burnout, moments of hopelessness. There's always always a different answer, and there's always The colleague who is going to listen to you if you say this is serious. Yeah. So please reach out. Yeah. You're you're not getting someone. It's a team sport. A hundred percent. And chances are there's someone within walking distance of you in your class or homework that is feeling the same. So really, I mean Call me if you want. But seriously, I always tell my rotators, like if you are not well, or if you're well, then tell me about it. Like just find a mentor and invest in relationship of care and support. That's what got me through. I still talk to my mentors like every other week. I'm not making that up because they saw me through so much. So find a mentor, latch on to them. That's also part of your community. Go ahead. So if you were going to recommend, you know, obviously mortality being in the doctor is a very, very odd topic and know what piece of in all of that. If you were going to recommend one piece of literature to income medical students or people early in their career in order to start approaching that topic, what would that be and why? Am I allowed to say my book? It should have been assigned in my books for like the class grade, would they just buy a bunch of books for the incoming class? But actually, let's put that in parentheses. I would say being mortaled by Uncle Gwande, who is just a lovely human being. And I love that book. I think it's a really good introduction to some of these concepts. it grew out of a piece he wrote in the meeting of her called Letting Go. About you know, this is one of the chapters in the book about a young mother who delivers her vacuum or gets a diagnosis of metastatic and lung cancer while she's pregnant. And it's I I think his work is really admirable. and I do think that book is great. The other book I will say that I think is potentially just higher literary value
and more like. Gripping of the story is Knocking on Heaven's Door by Katie Butler. So she wrote about her father who had dementia and her mother, the mother was the caretaker. Very, very difficult. But he got a hernia and they were gonna operate on him. But he was a little bradycardic and so, but not symptomatic from it. But cardiology wouldn't clear him unless they put a pacemaker in. So even though there was no, I was like, why would they do that? But okay. because there's profit, right? There's profit in paced friends. I hate to say it, but it's part of the current medical landscape. And so he continued to live being paced as his quality of life just became worse and worse and worse, and no doctor would turn the paced off. So the book is about Katie and her mother's quest to get this turned off. And what happened. And she's a journalist and is just a gorgeous writer, really incredible. And she brings in a lot of the journalism. So it's a blended story. And I think it's just exquisite. I mean, really well done. So I think that's another book I would highly recommend. And then I think The Year of Magical Thinking by Julie Diddy, which is a fantastic book about grief. Do you guys know who Joan Didian is? Does anyone not know who Joan Diddy is? Okay, this is not okay. Perhaps a premier essayist of this and the last century. she's really incisive and precise in her writing and is a journalist, also wrote some movie scripts, but she wrote The Earl of Magical Thinking about the year. That she lived through after she lost her husband very suddenly of a massive at the dinner table. And it's a pretty incredible account of this idea. The magical thinking piece of it is like she talks about not wanting to get rid of his shoes because she's like, Well, what is he gonna wear when he comes there? And it's really, it's just very well done. So that's a map of grief. I think everybody should read. I bought copies of it for my fellows this year, so that's important. Those are my three books. You have time to read those books, or something. I can also agree. you talk about those game conversations that are personal and how to you can I don't think popularize position and the patient don't reach the same or don't reach the final destination, so to say the what don't reach the final destination that you want to reach or like share this formal. but you also talk about like how You gotta keep on pushing in the conversation, right? How do you know when you've hit the destination versus like how to stop knowing to stop reaching? Yeah. And also like maybe like if you're not even talking to the patient, to like don't have capacity, like how do we know when to push them from someone else's normal perspective? So it's a good question. And I think it's very context specific. So In some situations, and I'm trying to think, it's almost eight o'clock and my brain is winding down. Let me see if I can give you an example. So, you know, there was a situation recently where a man
had metastatic pancreatic cancer, and he was not going to survive the hospitals today. And his wife and his family, some of them understood it and some of them really didn't. And so in the conversation, I had to be very careful. Again, you walk into these situations. I don't know these people. Actually, none of us really know the people that we're taking care of. I was just telling each other an example of that too. But I have to assess, it's almost like when you eventually put a central line. You are pushing, but you have to be precise about whether you're pushing too hard. what their anatomy is like, what the turber of their skin is like. There's a lot of variables. And it's the same thing in a conversation where I have to sense the emotions in the room. I have to read the emotions in the room. And I have to kind of get a sense of what people are saying and how others are responding to figure out how far I can get in a discussion. So sometimes when there's civil war breaking out in the room, I have to say, you know, Here's what I've learned today. And like here's what I'm hearing you tell me about whatever someone's hoping for. But I think this might be a good place to speak. And I'd like to revisit this tomorrow because you have to know when to call it to. And that is also a skill that you're not going to get. If a family meeting is going on past an hour, something has gone up. There's that's not okay. It's like going to the OR. You don't want someone to be on the table for 5,000 hours. You know, get in and out. So it's the same sort of concept. And I think also asking, or also not having a predetermined idea necessarily of what a destination is going to be. Because sometimes you don't know, right? You might go into a conversation saying, here's where I'm hoping to get. But then something comes up in the conversation or someone says something and that's going to change everything. So just like our patients deal with uncertainty, we don't always know what we're walking into. When I prep my fellow for a family meeting, I'm like, outline your strategy, but I also say we don't actually know what we're walking into because we don't. So you have to be able to hold both when you get good at this. And coming in hoping to achieve certain things. I don't know what they're hoping to achieve. And if things go crazy and this is not the Jimmy Springer show, then find out and say, we will pick this up tomorrow. And you are not intent on playing a chair with your next husband. So I kind of wanted to understand this. This is kind of like a two-part question. And one is sort of like viewing these goals of care discussion from like the, you know, the third person perspective versus like the, you know, person like being the partner. And then the second is kind of like about like what death is. And we're gonna try to try to get a side train that will take a step at some point. Let's get on that track. so you know, like it, you know, I imagine like, well, I try not
to imagine, but yeah, we know the nine images. Suppose like I'm like married to my wife of 10 years and she ends up in some terrible accident. You know, the the medical details are not gonna be very important. But then, you know, I come in and then I go to my physician, and my physician is like, okay, you know, we've seen like a hundred thousand cases of this. and, you know, in one of those cases, for some reason I cannot explain, there was actually like a pretty good outcome. And what my physician is thinking is like 99,999 times I was breaking ribs, I was doing these terrible things, putting a lot of suffering onto this person. and that suffering you know is probably not worth inflicting on another person. Now, what I'm seeing is the as the husband and a relatively mason marriage, all right I don't know, like Mary. what I'm not hearing that, right? Like I'm hearing like Wow, like, you know, you've given me possibly like a lottery ticket there. And you know, you would be lying to me if you told me that all a hundred thousand of them had died, right? So you wouldn't tell me that. but I see like, like break the ribs, do the everything, right? Like if you told me it was one in a million, if you told me it was one in like 8.7 billion, like if you think about people that you dearly, dearly, dearly love, what denominator would you accept to say no? Right? And And it seems like what that's coming down to is like where the end point is. Like, you know, are we going to stop sort of these suffering inducing measures? like where are we going to do that? and and the point that I think a lot of I I imagine having in my mind in that situation is the point of death. You know, like one of one of the thoughts about death, which is controversial because everything's controversial, but like so some people say death is irreversible. and the the reason you know that you've reached the death point is because it can't be reversed, right? So if you tell me like, okay, your wife is dead, and I'm like, go like go in there, do the CPR, like I would feel a little ridiculous. And I think that's not quite right. But it seems like the the core of a lot of these discussions is like, where is the endpoint? Is the end point going to be when doing this invasive sort of procedure is going to certainly cause a lot of suffering for very, very, very unlikely benefit? Which seems reasonable from the physician's perspective. but from my perspective as the the future husband, I you know, I I see it as like it's not over until it's over. It's not over until this this death thing has actually happened. whereas if I, you know, if I excavate someone or I don't do CPR, depending on like what form of what account of death you're going with, they may not be dead yet. and it may even be that like You know, our patients are not really in the wrong for thinking this way because this person that you imagine you were going to spend the rest of your life with, like, maybe you have a special obligation to think in this irrational way, or maybe that magical thinking, that's just how we're wired to be. so if I had to kind of boil it down like the and and talk about station one and station two, station two is kind of like, you know, it I'm assuming that when most patients are saying like do everything, they mean do everything until the person is like dead. And actually, yeah, like and what's the what's the conception of death that is gonna work for us here? And then the second is, or I guess the first station then is is like this is a weird situation where we've ended up in now where like it's it's a lot of responsibility on the family member, the people that have like the greatest stake and possibly maybe seeing the situation the least clearly, whereas the physician is seeing the the ninety-nine thousand nine hundred and ninety-nine other times it's led to unnecessary. I'm sorry, yeah. The question is, what what conception of death do you think is going to work for for these conversations that you're having? And the first is, or maybe I should go in order. The first question is, what conception of death do you think makes the most sense to facilitate these conversations and goals of care discussion? And then the second question is, like, do you think there's something like structurally like Should like, okay. Again, I do not back determination, but like, don't it really be up to the person who is the least likely to see the situation clearly to make this decision that is likely to cause suffering to the person that live up? So I need to take that second question first. I think we need to be very careful as physicians when someone asks us, have you ever seen someone come out of this? Because what does coming out of it? Mean, right? And this happens a lot with oncology, where they will say, yeah, one time I had somebody on four pressors with acute AML, dialysis, the whole thing, and he walked out last year. And I always have to ask them, What were the circumstances then? And it's like, well, who's 22? Okay, this guy's like set too. So this is not the same circumstances. I think we have to be really careful when we say those things to people because you know that someone who is desperate to keep a level of life is going to deliver onto that. And so how this is like communication should never be off the cuff in high situation situations. But we say these off-the-cuff things that people will not forget. And then they'll come back to it and say, Well, you said you've seen this before, but in what context does that enemy? And does the person in front of you match that other situation? Because if they don't, then we should not be pulling that example. And I think redirecting people towards everything we do in medicine is ultimately about enabling a quality of life. So it doesn't matter if one out of a million. Got out of here. My question is, how did they get there? Who did they become? Right? Was their life worth living if they were
quadrically jet trached and pegged when they were following their thought about her? Like I think that's also we're getting at who is this person? Who is your wife? Tell me about your wife. Tell me about her day-to-day. Tell me about her. That's the guiding light. Because I think also in times of desperation, it is our job to draw the boundaries and to say, I say this to people quite a lot in tough family meetings where I will say, you know what, I'm not going to ask you to make the decision of CPR, because I need decision. Here are all the things we can do. But when her heart stops and she dies, I'm going to make it my ultimate goal, achievement myself. And sometimes people are like, well, isn't that our decision? I was like, honestly, it's the body's decision. It's really what we choose to do in response to when the body shows us that. And actually, just because I think you mentioned the absolute point of death. In the hospital, if you were full code and you died, we will do CPR because CPR begins at the end of death. And a line from my piece that I would like you guys to remember is. Reversing a death is not the same as restoring a life. And I am being self-reverential here because I wrote this piece because no one had taught me anything about how to talk about things. So I offer this to you because that's the spirit in which I wrote the piece. So you've got to know we only do CPR when someone's done. We're not there to extend the life. We're there to reverse a death. And we don't know who they're going to be after they come. Because CPR is not about restarting, it's about preserving blood flow to the birth. And the neurologic consequences of a code, as Cyrus will tell you, they run the gamut, but generally not. And once you tell people that, they're like, whoa, like, I don't want to be in a chibola, which is a term that's just so broad. I have to ask people what they mean by that too. But but yeah, I think it's like, A very big responsibility to also validate the husband at that point and say, I see how hard you're advocating for your life. And I know that's coming from a play. I see yourself too. But we don't want to put the two of you through any unnecessary stuff. Do we know exactly what's going to happen? No, we never know. Could she be the one that defies it all? Possibly. But we also have to give her body a chance to show us where it's going to shake out and give the tools that will help it and not hurt it. And I use this visual a lot, and it's this for benefit of her harm. This is the equation we deal with. And people need to know that we know more than that about what benefit is. We know more than that about what harm is, strictly from a medical perspective. They know more about what benefit and harm means for that person. So that's where the dialogue is. But setting limits is less so paternalistic. It's doing your job. But you have to be careful enough and confident enough to do it. Yeah. I know we're in. I hope we'd be this. I lost both of my parents over the last decade. My mom said, you know, if I'm ever in a situation where I can't get up the car and go to Target, I don't want to be brad. And she was being too. When she had a master stroke, she should have she had a massive stroke. I got there in time, they were able to communicate with her and hold her hand. she knew that I was there. my siblings got there and we gave guidance to the team that we're not gonna do anything heroic, we're not gonna interfere with the natural process of death. So the natural process of dying, something the physicians tell the folks have to see. My dad. survived the Great Depression. He was born in Oak Cabin on the Indian Reservation. He flew 10,000 hours of the Air Force, survived war. he said, I want to live as long as I possibly can. But in the end, he he died in hospice. It was hard for my stepmom to make that decision, but she had a very they had a very caring geriatrician who felt that decision. Never forget. that your duty is to the patient. It's not the family, quote unquote. And if you do have any legal duty to somebody other than the patient, it's because the patient can't make decisions. So not in a position to tell you how they feel. So you have to align someone else. And the way I approach that with those people is I ask them how did your block button express his or her desires? about a situation like this. And that sort of tends to relieve the burden that they feel like, you know, I'm signing the death warrant by saying no seed. Yeah. It's so important that we have these conversations with people while they are still able to tell us what they really want to. And it's really really asking and evacually would you want this? I think the whole lead to advanced that. Because we don't give people context, right? The context is the story, speaking as a writer and as a doctor. And if you don't put these decisions into some sort of context, then you're just saying, what would you want to yield to it? And that's not informed anything. But ask that people you love, like what would you want and also what would you not want? And some ways to get into that or to say, remember when grandma died and she was like on a ventilator forever? Like, what did you think about that? What's a good death? What's a bad death? Those are relative terms. I maintain that sometimes a good death happens in the ICU. And if home was a disaster and no one can actually meet your needs. So these are relative terms, but these are things to start exploring with yourself. And so thank you guys.