TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:02
S1: The father is not the son. The father is perfect, the son is perfect, and the difference must be perfect. And therefore I must be able to be in communion. And it's really hard work with people who are different to me, and that is part of the richness of life. It expands me. It makes me a bigger person.
00:00:27
S2: Welcome to the habit podcast conversations with writers about writing. I'm Jonathan Rogers, your host. Marshmallow is an interesting man. He's an Englishman, but he grew up on Malta. He and his wife, Tula, lived for 17 years in Vienna when the Iron Curtain divided Europe. There they organized book translation and distribution while researching the beliefs, practices and problems of life under communism in the post-communist period, they lived in Slovakia for 16 years, establishing publishing houses in seven countries. They also ran a learning community and held seminars with student groups in Central Europe, Russia and Ukraine committed to awakening the imagination, encouraging critical thinking and fostering a deeper practical understanding of biblical ideas. Marsh is the author of rumors of a Better Country Searching for Trust and Community in a Time of Moral Outrage. In this episode, Marsh and I talk about utopianism, individualism, and the surprising truth that we can only be our true, distinct selves, what our selves are shaped by the people around us. Marsh, so happy to have you on The Habit podcast to talk about your book, rumors of a Better Country Searching for Trust and Community in a Time of Moral Outrage. Thanks for being here.
00:01:42
S1: Thank you for having me.
00:01:43
S2: Um, so tell me about where this this book came from. I mean, your your story is an interesting story. Um, you've been in, um, spent part of your life in Central Europe. I'd love to hear hear about some of that. And yeah.
00:01:59
S1: I heard. I lived for 34 years in Central Europe. Um, the first 15, 16 years were when Central Europe was largely under communism. The Iron Curtain was still in place, and we were living in Vienna, traveling backwards and forwards and meeting lots and lots of people. The second set of years was when it all crumbled. And and what emerged out of that when, uh, what we fondly then looked on as freedom, um, was, was, um, just emerging and, and things were quite wild and slowly began to, um, settle down. Yeah. Um, so, yeah, that's where the book came from. Was I was in I was traveling a lot to Ukraine, trying to help people understand concepts of trust and goodness. And one of the things that I started to realize is that when we talk about evil, it's very concrete. But when we talk about goodness, it tends to be extremely abstract and trying to communicate abstract concepts didn't land with anyone. And so we started a thing we called the cafe now and not yet, where we would lay out a room like a really lovely cafe, and we would give everyone one of the second half of the Ten Commandments and we would say, imagine
Load full transcript
what would happen economically, sociologically and psychologically in your community if everyone just said, we're going to try and obey this one commandment.
00:03:29
S2: Huh?
00:03:30
S1: And the the I've done that now hundreds of times this, this exhibition, this sort of exercise. And it was quite shocking that what people generated, whether they were Christian or not, Christian was the same thing. And it was, um, profound. And usually at the end of it, because we'd have group sharing after, after, after the, after they'd done the sort of 45 minutes of group work each group would share with all the other groups, and people would say things like, wouldn't we be able to trust one another? And trust in Central Europe is in short supply. I mean, it's becoming in short supply in England where I'm from. Yeah. Um, and, um, what we assumed in those days, um, in, in, in British life and I think in American life too, was that people tended to trust one another because they had this sub structure that we knew we knew there was a moral law, and we were going to be more or less committed to it. Yeah. But when we got to Eastern Europe, um, morality by defined by the communists is whatever, whatever furthers the, um, the revolution. So, so that wasn't really a very good foundation for trusting anyone.
00:04:55
S2: Mhm.
00:04:56
S1: And with the secret police and all the other things, you could imagine how trust became undermined. And I was walking down a street in Kharkiv many years ago, and I saw a man with a very large bunch of keys. I mean heavy, heavy bunch of keys. And then I, then I, I didn't think of it, put it out of my mind. But when my friend got to his house, he opened his briefcase and brought out a bunch of keys, which was just as big as the other guy. And it took him eight keys to get from the front door up to his apartment, because, um, because people really didn't trust each other and they had to protect themselves. And then I had a dream some some time later. I can't remember the timeline anymore, but where I was in London and people were bringing their keys. Do you know where Trafalgar Square is? The big.
00:05:49
S2: Yes.
00:05:50
S1: Nelson's column, right in the centre of London. Yeah. Um, people were bringing their keys and leaving them there because they didn't need them anymore. Huh? This was a mountain and mountain of keys. Tons of metal and locks and all the other stuff. And I began to think. How much energy did it take? A to drag all that metal up out of the earth and smelt it, and do all the technical stuff to get it to be a key? And how did, um, how how much mental energy did it take to design the whole system, the locks and everything? Yeah. What could have happened with all that energy and all that resources? Um, I mean, we got to the moon. I don't know if they got locks on the spaceship. We got to the moon in spite of, you know, where could we have gone if all of that energy had gone into more productive, fruitful things?
00:06:46
S2: Wow. I'd never thought about, uh, the possibility of maybe turning keys into plowshares.
00:06:51
S3: Yeah, well, that's that's what.
00:06:53
S1: So the book is really it goes through the commandments from about halfway in and and unpacks in a kind of a deeper way. A breakthrough came to me when I when I was thinking about the Old Testament. And what do you do with the law? And I recognized that that it it was a shadow because the New Testament tells us so and that then you know well what is a shadow. It's a two dimensional representation of a three dimensional reality. Mhm. The goal is to find the third dimension, which you find in the third, a little bit illuminated in the sermon on the Mount. So the attempt really then became to, to try to imagine in concrete terms the third dimension of, of um, of what the law was trying to tell us. What was the, the and it's very relevant to now that power is either raw power as we're experiencing in our times, or it's mediated by law, or it's mediated by love. And what is this loving thing that we as believers should actually participate in? And, um, so that's that's really what the book is about. Yeah. I describe the cafe in the first chapter in one of the first chapters, the early chapters. And, um, uh, it's a great thing to do. It's simple to do. And you can even download the, the instructions on my website.
00:08:29
S3: Oh, really?
00:08:29
S1: A better country? Um, because it's simply, it's just very simple to do.
00:08:36
S3: Yeah.
00:08:36
S1: And you can do it over a dinner table, or you can do it over a series of weeks, or you can. It's very flexible.
00:08:42
S3: Yeah.
00:08:43
S2: I love it. So. Okay. Uh, rumors of a Better Country is what you the title of this book. Um, How is the better country you're talking about? Distinct from a utopia?
00:08:59
S3: Um, I.
00:08:59
S1: Think we have to. I have a glass desk, and the reason I have a glass desk is I want to see my feet on the ground.
00:09:07
S3: Because I.
00:09:09
S1: Like to think about, you know, magnificent things, the glory of God, and so on. But I live in the middle of the tension between dignity and depravity.
00:09:19
S3: Yeah.
00:09:19
S1: And and I expect everything human beings do has both dignity and depravity. And the depravity is so much in your face in every newspaper, every news, uh, journal and all the things that we we all know. But dignity is rare to see.
00:09:39
S3: Yeah.
00:09:39
S1: It's there and you can find it. It's all around us, but we don't articulate it because we we expect it to be there. And so I think the, the utopian ideal is very dangerous. Um, I think Lenin was a utopian. Hitler was a utopian for his people.
00:09:58
S3: Mhm.
00:09:58
S1: If you weren't his people. Tough luck. You're in trouble.
00:10:00
S3: Yeah.
00:10:01
S1: Um, Lenin was, was was, um, a utopian and he wanted to to get everybody to, um, have more and better and but he didn't the process didn't matter. And he was in a hurry.
And building consensus was too, too, too arduous. And so anyone who gets in your way gets, gets put out of the way. Mhm. Um and that's a dangerous thing. So I'm, I'm, I'm not trying to build a utopia on earth now, but I do think that a clearer vision of the good, the good life can help a person and a group of people say this is what we want and we are going to move towards it as a community. Yeah. Um, and, um, so I'm, I'm not a romantic. In fact, I have a whole lecture called cynicism and romanticism as ways we avoid reality.
00:10:57
S3: Um, yeah.
00:10:59
S1: They're both dangerous.
00:11:01
S3: Um.
00:11:02
S1: And we should we should be integrating, um, ourselves. Not not sort of ourselves into into. Um. I find the challenge of of, um. Disagreement useful?
00:11:20
S3: Yeah.
00:11:20
S1: Is that in in a Russian friend of mine a couple of years ago said what? Why do you need Her Majesty's loyal opposition, which is the name of the other party, whichever party is out of. And I thought about it because in Russia, they don't have an opposition.
00:11:37
S3: Yeah.
00:11:37
S1: Dead people or people in prison and and, um, I said, you know, that's how that that dialogue is how the ideas emerge. And if you don't have a loyal opposition, who's saying, no, it's not right, you either drift to one side or you or you, um, just lose any, any stimulus to rethink your own ideas. And everything gets very staid and boring, quite honestly. And not to say dysfunctional.
00:12:06
S2: Yeah, yeah. And the, the, uh, democracy is arranged around the idea of a civil way of disagreeing with one another. Not not seeking uniformity.
00:12:20
S1: Yeah.
00:12:21
S2: Um, and, uh, the the totalizing effect of communism, fascism, all these things. It's it's this, this, uh, search for conformity is ends up being very bloody. Yeah.
00:12:36
S1: And I think the, the communalism of the East and the individualism of the West are problematic, deeply problematic. And that the answer that Christians bring to the table is trinitarianism. So I'm not the left. I'm not the right. I am Trinitarian, that means I believe in the the 3 in 1 God in whose image we are made. So I. I am in his image as one, but I'm also in his image as three. And so me and and other people in my community are representing the image of God. And if if I just fall off the horse on one side or the other, I, um, I head into problems. And at the moment we've got in the West a sort of hyper individualism, right. Where the only reference point you have to your identity is no longer geography or history, but it's just what you feel. It's a massive identity problems, anxiety problems and so on that come out of disregarding the other and only finding the locus of yourself in yourself. Well, I find the locus of myself in you because you're Stimulating me in ways that I would. I would if I was staring at my screen this afternoon, we wouldn't. I wouldn't be having these conversations with you.
00:13:57
S2: And that's what you
mean when you say that we are made in the image of God. Um, uh, as three is it is that our identity is not individual. It's not. It's not self-contained.
00:14:09
S1: Yes. Right.
00:14:10
S2: Is that a fair way to say it? Is that I think.
00:14:12
S1: So when I go to my local church and I'm part of the body, uh, the deeper my relationships with people. And that really depends on how deep the trust in the community is. The deeper my relationships, the more honest they are, the more fully I become myself because they draw out of me things I didn't know that were there. Yeah, I think it was, um, it was in one of the books about, um, uh, one of the inklings who died a brilliant writer. He's the.
00:14:48
S2: Williams. Charles. Williams.
00:14:49
S1: Charles Williams. Yeah, yeah. When he died, um, Lewis said, I won't I won't be able to see him joke with, um, with Tolkien. Yeah. And that's something completely outside of myself. And it's beautiful. Yeah. And so I see that all the time in our community. We have a lovely community here of people who who trust one another and are vulnerable with one another and who are helping one another. And, uh, it's, um, it's beautiful work to be in a Trinitarian community. And that's what we need to rediscover. And we've lost it in, in our because we are functional individualists, which, um, even though we're trying to be communal, uh, we're trying to be Trinitarian.
00:15:36
S2: Uh, what do you think about the, the the term like mindedness? Is that a term you use?
00:15:45
S1: Um, well, have this mind in you. That was in Christ Jesus. Yeah, but of course, he had these infinite imagination. And I think the I think of the Trinity as being the infinite intimate, the three that is one always. And so the depth of that intimacy, it's not it's not unity. Your uniformity, it's communion. It's not conformity, it's communion. But communion allows for difference. And in my imagination, I've got the artist and the accountant. Yeah, one is all in the box, the other is all outside the box. And yet a good Trinitarian community will be they will be together. They will appreciate one another. They will appreciate the difference as well as as the sameness.
00:16:34
S2: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Um, yeah. I asked about like, mindedness. Uh, again, I think that's a a I think that's a useful term, as long as we don't think it means conformity. All thinking the same thing. Yeah. Yeah. Um, and, you know, I'm sure it would be.
00:16:53
S1: Very boring if it was that. Yeah. I think of like minded, um. Ah, people who bring new thoughts to my mind.
00:17:03
S2: Mhm. That you like? Yeah. Well.
00:17:07
S1: They challenge me. I don't really care as long.
00:17:09
S2: Right, right.
00:17:10
S1: As long as we are, um, um, trusting one another. Right. And I trust their intention, even if it hurts. I'm all right with that. Um, I prefer it not to, but that's. Yeah. Right. Um. Yeah. It's a beautiful thing to say. Um, I, I am bigger because I've met you. I'm
richer because that's what blessing means. I'm larger because I've met you. Um, and that has to be good. But if we're all have the same cliches and the same language and the same way of doing things. It becomes boring. And I don't think God is boring, right? You know, just Genesis one is an explosion of from nothing to everything. And it's a glorious moment. And, uh, I love the C.S. Lewis thing that the creation is singing. Yeah.
00:18:09
S2: I was just. Yeah. When you said that. I was thinking about in The Magician's Nephew. Yes.
00:18:13
S1: Yeah.
00:18:13
S2: It's a lion singing the world into existence.
00:18:16
S1: It's a beautiful thing.
00:18:17
S2: Yes. Yeah. Now, I wanted to to really continue on the same idea. I wanted to to hear you talk a little bit more about a sentence that caught my attention from your book. You said modern communities tend to be silos of agreement around promoting and defending specific points of view.
00:18:36
S1: Mhm.
00:18:37
S2: And you know, one thing I thought about when I, when I read that is again to to return to the inklings, C.S. Lewis talked about the idea that, um, um, in his parish church, he was around people he didn't agree with, but that was his parish. And there he was. And and I don't know what your situation is, uh, in your, in your village in the UK, but I know here we drive, you know, I drive past, I don't know how many churches to get to church because I'm, you know, we, we manage to to be silos of like mindedness. Yeah. Um, I'm not stuck going to church with anybody. Um, and I think it's a, it's a sanctifying thing to be stuck in situations that I shouldn't say. I think it is a it's a sanctifying thing to be, uh, singing hymns next to somebody who you may not like, you may not agree with. But here we are.
00:19:36
S1: Yeah. I completely agree that it's it's hard work. It's hard work. I've just been in this United States, and I drove from Chattanooga down to Atlanta, through the back streets, because we didn't want to go on the freeway. Every village or town you came to, there would be four churches, kind of almost at the crossroads. Yeah. And they'd be First Baptist. Second Baptist first, whatever they are, you know, and, and and, um, um, if you don't like the person, you go and you make another one.
00:20:08
S2: Yeah.
00:20:08
S1: And that's so unfruitful because we grow through those conflicts. If we are Christian, we work towards resolution. Yeah. Because God the Father is not the son. The father is perfect. The son is perfect. And the difference must be perfect.
00:20:26
S2: Mhm.
00:20:27
S1: Yeah. And therefore I must be able to be in communion. And it's really hard work with people who are different to me. Yeah. And that is part of the richness of life. It expands me. It makes me a bigger person. Yeah. And, um, I, um, I, I've been through conflict. I've been through my, uh, and people who disagree and people who disagree across cultures and so on. And I'm richer for it.
00:20:58
S2: Yeah. Yeah. I mean, in the great divorce, hell is a place where if there's conflict, you just imagine yourself a new house. And so you have this. I don't know if that's centripetal. I don't know the difference between centripetal and centrifugal, but everything spreads out, so hell is huge. Yes. Because people aren't. There's no friction that keeps them. That makes it hard for them to to.
00:21:18
S1: It's it's huge and it's flat.
00:21:21
S2: Yeah yeah yeah. That's right.
00:21:23
S1: Who wants that? And, uh. And it's full of fear and it's full of a lack of or empty of trust. Yeah. And, um. And so when people who don't trust one another don't reveal themselves to each other, and that creates loneliness.
00:21:39
S2: Yeah. You know, the joke about the the, um, the Coast Guard or the Navy ship that found a man on a deserted island, lived there by himself, and he had built himself a hut and, uh, you know, uh, a little bowling alley and a little movie theater for himself out of coconuts or whatever, and and a church and then another church. And they said, what are you. Why, what's that church for? Oh, that's the church I used to go to.
00:22:09
S1: Yeah. That's right. And we and we hollow ourselves out in the process. Yeah. And it, it one of the, one of the commandments you shall not murder. I remember reading, um, I listed the commandments on the whiteboard in my study, and I was going through them at Easter just to reflect on my own state, and I, I came to you shall not murder. And I said, well, at least I haven't murdered anyone. Um, and immediately two people came into my mind who I was avoiding, and they were functionally dead to me.
00:22:42
S2: They were dead to you. Yeah.
00:22:43
S1: And I thought, wow, you know, that the communion of the Holy Spirit, the father and the son isn't dead to itself. It's alive. So if I am in the image of God, I have to be alive to other people. Wow. And that means forgiveness. It means honesty. It means humility. Um. And it's hard. And we. We are supposed to be light to the world in exactly that way. That our trust should be ten times more the trust of in the society we're in. Mhm. Um, and, and our relationship should be strong and rich and different because the, the infinite, uh, imagination of God, um, must have there must be I don't know how it works and I don't want to commit blasphemy, but it it's rich.
00:23:34
S2: Yeah. It's rich. Um. I, I don't want to devote all our time to this particular idea, but it's there's so much to talk about that. But you know, remember in in Chesterton I guess this is in Orthodoxy, he talks about the idea that the symbol for eastern religion is a circle, because ultimately all is one. And and if I so I, I love you because we're all one in effect, all love is self-love. And so in Christianity the symbol is not a circle but the cross. It's collision. Yeah. And and Christianity recognizes that, uh, because we're different. We have to love and we don't. I don't love people
because we're all the same. I wouldn't need to, because I'm really good at loving myself. I don't need any practice. Um, but, uh, because we are inevitably going to be in collision. We have to love one another.
00:24:29
S1: Yeah, that that's absolutely right in my understanding. I mean, the eastern idea of actually, uh, the Buddhist idea of of of difference. Being problematic means that love. Really? It isn't possible. Um, because love requires, um, the acceptance of difference. Yeah. Um, and I think it's a very profound, profound observation. We we have to deal with difference, and the differences can be quite extreme. And and we don't have to have complete agreement. Um, but we have to disagree graciously.
00:25:09
S2: Yeah. Uh, and it was in a River Runs Through It that Norman McLean talks about this father and son who could never understand one another. And and he says, you know, what he learned was that, um, you can love completely without understanding completely. And that's such a helpful way of framing, uh, the fact that I, I there are a lot of people I don't understand. I don't understand where they're coming from. Yeah. Um, and yet I'm not thereby excused from loving them.
00:25:40
S1: And it does seem to me that, um. Our definition, our intuitive definition of love, needs to be reworked. It's been so invaded by the romance of Hollywood that the thing that we think of first is, is a feeling of. And I test this with, with, with students. I ask them, what does love feel like? And usually what I get back is this sort of emotional, emotional sort of, um, and I do believe love is an emotion, um, or a series of emotions, but it's, um, a highly romanticized. And, and when you're loving your neighbor and it costs you a lot, you're not going to feel warm feelings. You're going to feel tired and afraid and all sorts of other things. But those other feelings of love in that moment, because you are moving towards the person, not away from them.
00:26:35
S2: Mhm.
00:26:35
S1: Yeah.
00:26:38
S2: Um, okay. Let's talk about the idea of, uh, you talk about individualism and more than that, hyper individualism. Um, what do you mean by hyper individualism? I think that'll get us into a discussion of the nature of reality, which is.
00:26:56
S4: Well, I.
00:26:57
S1: When when I, when I talk to students, I will often say, when you think of your identity, do you first think of I or do you think of we um, and in the Western world, 99% of people I've talked to and asked the question and it's thousands now they will say we they will say I.
00:27:20
S4: Yeah.
00:27:21
S1: But if I go say to South Africa and, um, I make the same question a lot of the automatically the black South Africans will say we and I've sat around tables with a mixture of groups when half say I and half say we and we. So what is that? What are you. Um, and and really, it's the communal identity of of the East and of of of farming communities. Often because you need one another. Um, um, village communities. Um, so Eastern Europe very much we centered but but since the transition to a more western economy, they've moved towards more individual, which is interesting to see the individual bank account, the individual vote, one person, we assume it's so deeply, but we so we can't imagine what it was like. Um, and I remember I remember a friend of mine who who was was Chinese from the Philippines, and he, I met him for the first time on the island of Malta, which is where I grew up. And we were young teenagers. So we were talking about dating rituals. And he said to me, how will you find a wife? And I bit early for me then, but I, I, I went through the process of dating and all that sort of stuff, and he said, how do you trust yourself with that decision? So I said to him, well, what do you what do you do? Well, I won't do anything. My parents will find me a wife. And then I went completely. I said, how do you trust your parents? And that that communal individual thing was right there. Yeah. And, um. Uh, he he ironically, he moved to California and married a woman he discovered. That was many years later. Um, I, I, um, I think that the the individual, if you if you thought of an individual 25 years ago and you said, who are you? They would have talked about, um, where they were from and their history. And their interests. If you talk to some of the modern young people who come to us today, they don't have a place to be from because they've moved around so much and they don't have, um, so they don't have a geography and they don't have much of a history because the divorce and the fragmentation and all the rest of it and living online.
00:29:53
S2: Um.
00:29:54
S1: And so, so they will, they will start to talk about how they feel about themselves.
00:30:00
S2: Mhm.
00:30:01
S1: And um. And that's and often there'll be a lot of loneliness involved in that. So I, that's what I call hyper individualism that, that loss of a sense of location and, and a history to be from. And so belonging becomes very important. Um, you often find it in military kids because they've moved around and around around. And I was I was there too. So I, I had I wrestled with this myself, uh, having a place to be rooted which, which is what I love about this place, because I've been here now for a long time, and I know people and I'm known by people. Whereas, um, the hyper individualist isn't really known by many people, and that knowledge is very often very superficial and it has to be made up. I mean, there's nothing so lonely as having to generate your own identity. Yeah. And and then, uh, wonder if that identity is stable because it isn't. Because you change and, and you're supposed to be changing, but you're supposed to be from somewhere and belong somewhere so that you can be corrected and you have some anchors which which stabilize you. Yeah. Those anchors are now gone for so many people. Yeah. And and that causes enormous internal conflict. Mhm.
00:31:23
S2: It's hard to give yourself a nickname isn't it.
00:31:26
S1: Yeah.
00:31:26
S2: You need other people to give you a nickname.
00:31:28
S1: That's absolutely right. That's a good idea. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:31:32
S2: I've uh, you know, I've wanted to be my nickname to be the Admiral or something like that, but I can't ever make it stick. Somebody else has to the governor. I could do the governor. That'd be fine. But, um. Yeah. You say for the hyper individualist or I guess you say maybe we're talking about just pure individualism. Um, you said their reference points come less from the shared reality of the external world and more from their internal experience.
00:31:57
S1: Yeah, yeah.
00:31:59
S2: Um, and you know, this this happens not just individual to individual, but sometimes in, you know, group to group, this shared the news becomes a, a choose your own adventure novel. Yeah. Yeah. Because I've got my ideas about how things how the world works and therefore, you know, two people looking the same news story and think it's a completely different story.
00:32:24
S1: That's and especially in this, in the last sort of five years, um, in the last three days, we we were all still sort of whiplashed from Greenland and, and uh, um, and the idea that history doesn't matter, precedent doesn't matter. If I want this, I can take it because I'm big enough is, um, exactly what's happening in in with Russia and Ukraine. Yeah. Russia wants it. They're going to take it, but they've discovered that they they aren't big enough. And, um, and they we do need one another. And there is strength in, in needing one another. Um, I don't find that to be a problem at all. Um, and the idea that I'm a self-made man to me is somewhat primitive. Um, um, and it. And very lonely. Yeah.
00:33:20
S2: Oh. I mean, I saw a guy who tried to make a toaster by himself. Like, he he somehow dug up the or learned how to smelt. It ended up, you know, took him years to make a a not very good toaster. But even when he I think he still plugged it in to a, to a electrical grid that he didn't make. Yeah. And there's just no way to there's no way to be an individual, actually.
00:33:48
S1: That's right. And and but to be a unique person means to be unique in a community of persons. And that is a very much richer concept. So I am unique. There will never be another one like me. Um, but, um, I'm also personal. That means I'm in communion with other persons. Um, and that's a, that's a beautiful that's a Trinitarian idea, which I find much richer because I'm also in communion at a certain level with the nature around me as well. Mhm. And, and that is much more, much richer thing than just a naturalistic frame which, which sees me as one among one, one amongst many of the atoms that are here. So. Yeah.
00:34:35
S2: Um, so could you sort of summarize what is the the foundation of a better community? I mean, I know when you say rumors of a better country, on the one hand, we're talking about the
kingdom of God, that that is not ours to create, and yet we do. I mean, you're connected with La Brea. Uh, well.
00:34:57
S1: We we participate in the creation. And that's a magnificent thing to me, that God, in the beginning names the reality. He creates a chaos and he brings order out of chaos, takes it to Sabbath. And then he says to Adam, now I want you to name some of the reality. So we participate in the creation through our language, through our naming things, through our describing things, through seeing what things get connected together. Um, and I think that's extraordinarily generous, God, to do that. an extraordinary, hospitable God to create the whole thing in the first place. And so I learn in Genesis one and two that God is both hospitable and generous. And that's what that's what we should be. But God trusts God. That is the essence. The father trusts the son with the going, and the son trusts the father with the resurrection. So trust is the center of the, uh, of good community. And everything I can do that builds up trust is for the good. And everything I do that destroys trust is is really a definition of what evil looks like. Um, because we are in the image of a communal deity, a god who is three and one, never less than, nevertheless than either and fully, um, fully one. So what I call it, as I said before, the infinite intimate, um, um, and and that's how what we should be aiming at in our marriages, in our families, in our churches. And if we did, we were to do that. Um, yeah, I think people would be hungry for it. They are hungry for it. Um, and, um, trust is absolutely at the center of it all. And and the commandments and the use of power is what destroys trust. And commandments are there as a as a backstop, if you like. But love is the ultimate stop to the thing that is supposed to hold it all together. Yeah. And I don't get that from inside myself. I get it from, from from being reconnected to the source of life and love, which is God. Um, our problem is we have this dark, nagging fear that God actually isn't loving and that he's a bit of a judge and a bully and a, um, but he's not. He says, name the animals, whatever you call it. That's what it will be.
00:37:24
S5: Yeah. Can you speak.
00:37:26
S2: To. So you've been, uh, connected with, um, LaBrie and, uh, and other, um, efforts at hospitality and generosity. Um, I'd love to hear you speak to, uh, I'm circling all the way back around to the idea of your dream of piling up the keys and your question of what could have been freed up, what could have happened if that energy of locking up, you know, locking against our trustlessness if that energy were released? What is what is your your experience in your own life of what is what has happened with that? The energy that's been freed up in you from being from having trust and not having to lock everything up?
00:38:15
S1: I think, I mean, I do live in a world where I have to lock my front door, which is painful. Yeah. And
I use that. When I locked the front door, I remember this is not how it should be. I grieve a little bit. The more you pursue these thoughts of goodness, the more you grieve that you don't get them. Which is perhaps the balance in the in the utopia thing. Um, but but, um, deep relationships, interesting people, richness. Um, and, um, I think, I think to, to live with, um. Communion means that when you fall down, there are people to pick you up and you fall down. In this world, we need one another. Um, and, um, if I look back over the 60 years I've been 70 years I've been alive, and 50 years I've been in ministry. Then I. I think of all the times someone's come alongside and picked me up and all the people I've helped go forward. Um, that's that's an enormous benefit. Enormous benefit.
00:39:26
S5: Yeah.
00:39:27
S1: I'm thinking of a situation, um, in Slovakia, we used to have a learning community, and we would have 20 people come and stay with us there for six weeks at a time. And the first thing we would do is give them all a key to get in and out. This is a practical necessity. And, um, at the end of several of the things we had in evaluation, people sat around and said, well, they what they thought of the six weeks. And many people said, on day one, you gave me a key, told me you trusted me. And, um, we we it was, for us, purely a practical necessity. We had no strategic learning moment in mind, and it was a strategic learning moment for them because they're not used to being trusted.
00:40:19
S2: Can you imagine how much energy you would have expended on taking care of people that you couldn't give a key to.
00:40:26
S5: That's right.
00:40:28
S1: Yeah. And, uh, it's a it's a tragedy that we don't can't trust each other more. Yeah. And so the vision of the good has to be concrete so we can implement it.
00:40:40
S5: Yeah. Yeah.
00:40:42
S2: All right. Marsh, I want to end with the question. I typically end with, um. And that is, who are the writers who make you want to write?
00:40:48
S5: Wow.
00:40:49
S1: Um, I just read Theo Golden.
00:40:53
S5: Oh. Did you. Isn't that lovely?
00:40:55
S1: Uh. It's lovely. It's. I wouldn't say it's a great book. It's a great story. And it's got wonderful moral, uh, uh, practical goodness all over it. And it's a rich, rich, rich thing. Um, and, um, I've been telling everybody I know about it, so. So, um, uh, Chaim Potok is a great writer. Um, his book The Gates of November, which is about Jews in Russia, is a really good retelling of the situation.
00:41:27
S2: I've never even heard of that book.
00:41:29
S1: No, many people have. And they're used to The chosen, the promise, and all the other ones. So. So that that's that's.
00:41:35
S2: Why I love the Asher Lev books.
00:41:36
S1: Oh, yeah, I, I use him for young Christians who are struggling to be artists. Mm. And he gives them a sense of this is the journey you're going to be on because.
00:41:47
S2: Yeah.
00:41:47
S1: Lots of evangelical Christians don't understand art and think it's wrong because they don't understand it, which is tragic.
00:41:54
S2: Yeah.
00:41:55
S1: Um. Uh, so so his his his books, um, are there are so many. Um, you had a leaf.
00:42:06
S2: Oh, yeah. Like finger.
00:42:07
S1: Finger. Um. I love his books.
00:42:09
S2: Yeah. They're great. Yeah.
00:42:11
S1: And, um. Oh. So. Yeah. So. So many.
00:42:15
S2: Yeah. Well, marshmallow, thanks so much. It's been so much fun. I've been looking forward to talking to you for a long time, and I'm glad it finally happened.
00:42:22
S1: Thank you very much I really appreciate it's stimulating and I enjoyed it.
00:42:27
S2: Yeah. The habit podcast is brought to you by the Rabbit Room, where art nourishes community and community nourishes art. You can support their work, including this podcast, by becoming a member. Visit Rabbit Comics. Special thanks as well to Taylor Leonard for letting us use her song diamonds as a theme music for The Habit podcast. You can learn more about Taylor and follow her work at Taylor. The Habit Membership is a library of resources for writers by me, Jonathan Rogers. More importantly, the habit is a hub of community where like minded writers gather to discuss their work and give each other a little more courage. Find out more at the habit.