TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:05
Speaker 1: From The Australian, here's what's on the front. I'm Claire Harvey. It's Friday, November 20, 2026. Australia will be the world's largest coal exporter by 2030, thanks to booming steel production in India and a huge surge in demand for coking and thermal coal. How does that fit in with the government's climate goals? Good question, and you can read all about it A young man sacrificed to Australian cricket's dishonesty and ruthlessness. That's the claim of Cameron Bancroft, the batsman caught cheating with sandpaper back in 2018. in a 4,000-word essay that brings Captain Pat Cummins and Cricket Australia's brass right into the frame. There's a hero in this story, but it's not Usman Khawaja or David Warner. And now there are fresh doubts about their claims too. Our columnist Andrew Webster's here in just a moment. Webby, can Pat Cummins keep his job and is that even in question at the moment?
00:01:17
Speaker 2: I think it's definitely in question, Claire. That's the matter for Cricket Australia. Todd Greenberg, David Boone, the interim chairman of Cricket Australia and what they do now after the fairly sensational, one word, but it was an evisceration of the credibility of the Australian bowlers and Australian cricket from Cameron Bancroft in his 4,000-word statement. statement, really. That's what it was. But yeah, it's an extraordinary 24 hours in the history of Australian cricket.
00:01:46
Speaker 3: Bancroft said, I have never been completely honest about what happened.
00:01:50
Speaker 2: It was the whole team.
00:01:52
Speaker 1: I withheld important details, he wrote. I did this to protect Cricket Australia's investigation and not implicate others around me. It's a moving account by Cameron Bancroft. And towards the end of it, he reflects on the fact that he just has not been able to make it back to the test team that he loved so much that in his telling, he sacrificed everything for including his honour. Would this problem have gone away if they had just reintegrated Cameron Bancroft into the team?
00:02:21
Speaker 2: Possibly. You know, he did play two tests in 2019, but as he claims in his piece that he basically became a pariah of Australian cricket and even more so when he told the Guardian in 2021 a line two words as he explains about it's self-explanatory whether the bowlers knew what he was doing or not but for mine what's happened with Cameron Bancroft is one of the subplots to this scandal like what he has explained in that piece is very very damaging to the reputation of Pat Cummins and those bowlers like Let's just be really clear about what he has said. And it conflicts a little bit with Uzman Khawaja's book as well. But this wasn't just scuffing up the ball with some sandpaper and giving the sandpaper to the 12th man. He was doing it, as he says, every single over of that last session of day two of the second test in Port Elizabeth. in South Africa in 2018, and this is the thing that's never really lined up
Load full transcript
for me and a hell of a lot of people who understand cricket, is why would he be doing that without consulting the people who benefit the most from it? And he goes into great detail in this account about how he talked to all the bowlers and Tim Payne, the wicketkeeper at the time, about the work that he was doing to the point where they said stop doing it, it's going to be obvious. And then it continued on in Cape Town until cameras picked him up doing it.
00:03:45
Speaker 4: I guess once I was sighted on the screens and having done that, I painted quite a lot. That obviously resulted in me shoving it down my trousers.
00:03:58
Speaker 5: So this is the umpires.
00:04:01
Speaker 2: Having a chat to Cameron Bancroft.
00:04:04
Speaker 5: I think they're asking him about what he had in his pockets.
00:04:09
Speaker 2: So this isn't just using it at the start of sessions. This is taking it on the field and doing it over and over and over.
00:04:15
Speaker 5: Just put that around the big screen in the crowd.
00:04:21
Speaker 3: It's damning in my mind.
00:04:24
Speaker 2: And the real hero out of the whole thing is Kate Hutchinson.
00:04:28
Speaker 1: Kate Hutchinson was a media manager working with Cricket Australia when the Sandpapagate scandal erupted. According to Bancroft, she's the only person who objected to the use of sandpaper to rough up the ball.
00:04:40
Speaker 2: She, to me, is the real hero, not the self-appointed hero of this scandal. It's Kate Hutchison because she's the only one in that setup that said this is wrong and we shouldn't be doing it.
00:04:51
Speaker 1: Yeah, it's quite remarkable. He describes two instances where she articulated very clearly her view, first when she said it was a bad idea in the first place and the second when he asked her what would happen if he got caught and she said it's not good. The other person, though, who he describes as not wanting to have anything to do with it was Steve Smith. Is that new?
00:05:08
Speaker 2: No, Steve Smith has said this came out at the time that he said, I don't want anything to do with it. But he was the captain of the team. He's the dominant, or should be the dominant force in that dressing room. Not the coach, not the bowlers, not Dave Warner, but Steve Smith. He's the captain of that side. Australian cricket has prided itself on its captaincy, particularly at test level, and they set the tone of the team. Now, I know that there was Pressure from CA about we don't pay you to play, we pay you to win. But at the end of the day, it's Steve Smith's team, just as the current Australian team is Pat Cummins' team. That's the issue for Pat Cummins. Pat Cummins was in his 13th test. He was in his early 20s. But he wasn't in his early 20s and only played a handful of tests when he did his media masterclasses. We all patted him on the back for just a week ago.
00:05:58
Speaker 3: When he says we all knew, if by that he means it, we knew sandpaper was going out in the field, he's 100% wrong. He says that I and others were architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper. That's complete and utter nonsense.
00:06:14
Speaker 2: That's a fairly damning assessment of Pat Cummins. If it's proven that he and the rest of Australian cricket have thrown Cameron Bancroft under the bus. Now, this is what I've argued in my analysis piece online on the Australian website. is this whole ridiculously lame idea of an independent forum now has to become an independent inquiry, an independent investigation. None of this, you know, let's sit around and hold each other's hands and sing Kumbaya. We need to get to the bottom of actually what happened and get to the bottom of it once and for all. And that's only going to happen until that independent inquiry occurs.
00:06:53
Speaker 1: Unless someone comes up with a text message or a written diary note where Pat Cummins had a conversation about knowing that Sandpaper was on the field, though, Pat Cummins is not going to be found to have lied at that press conference, is he?
00:07:07
Speaker 2: Well, that's the thing. Is there a smoking gun? Is it something in a WhatsApp group? Is there a text message? I reject the notion from Todd Greenberg at Cricket Australia, well, it's just going to... We might have an investigation because it will... degenerating to a he said, she said. Well, that's what you have an investigation for. That's what you have an independent investigation for. Imagine if the court system worked like that. Oh, well, we can't charge anyone because it'll be one story against another.
00:07:31
Speaker 1: He said it wants to be a safe space where everybody can tell their truth.
00:07:34
Speaker 2: Their truth. I don't know. You're a journo like I am. I always thought it was the truth, not someone's truth.
00:07:40
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:07:41
Speaker 2: I've all been listening to Oprah's soul sessions too much.
00:07:45
Speaker 1: Well, a lot of them are lawyers, though. There are plenty of lawyers at high levels of this game who know perfectly well the difference between my truth and the truth. And there is a way to get to, you know, a version of the objective truth, and that's to bring in a retired judge to hold some sort of, you know, hearing about it. For Cricket Australia, though, if you look at it sort of tactically from their point of view... Losing a captain potentially or, you know, having to engage in some sort of massive shake-up and reckoning is going to be bad for the sport and the game at this point, isn't it?
00:08:13
Speaker 2: Well, it will, but it needs to happen. Otherwise, this is just going to keep going and going until Dave Warner brings out his book, until Cameron Bancroft does his book, until Steve Smith does his book, until, you know, the only one we haven't heard from, Steve Smith was supposed to talk about it this week, but he still hasn't. As I understand it, and as a lot of people in Australian cricket will tell you, Steve Smith is so destroyed by this
episode in his career, like he just doesn't want to talk about it. It affected him deeply.
00:08:43
Speaker 5: I'm not proud of what's happened. You know, it's not within the spirit of the game. My integrity, the team's integrity, the leadership group's integrity has come into question, and rightfully so.
00:08:59
Speaker 2: That doesn't sort of absolve him of any blame, though, because as I said, he was the captain, but I've been jokingly saying to colleagues, the only one we haven't heard from is the sandpaper. Because I understand it's been doing it pretty rough.
00:09:12
Speaker 1: Oh, my God.
00:09:14
Speaker 2: The dad jokes. Sorry for trying to bring some humour to this never-ending story, this zombie of a story.
00:09:24
Speaker 1: Usman Khawaja in his book very vividly describes a moment where he sort of, you know, as the conscience of the team says, come on, guys, let's take collective responsibility. He said on the ABC 730 that that was effectively, he didn't use this word, this is my word, that was a tactical decision. I didn't think they would punish all of us. You say you wanted the whole team to take collective responsibility.
00:09:46
Speaker 2: Would a ban for the whole team have been the appropriate thing to happen at that time? I don't believe the whole team would have got a ban if we went in together. I don't think we would have. That's why I wanted collective.
00:09:57
Speaker 5: I think it would have been shared.
00:09:58
Speaker 4: It's very hard.
00:10:00
Speaker 2: To ban the whole team.
00:10:03
Speaker 1: That is missing from Cameron Bancroft's account.
00:10:06
Speaker 2: Glaring, glaring.
00:10:08
Speaker 1: Pat Cummins doesn't recall it.
00:10:09
Speaker 3: I don't remember any conversation around collective responsibility. I don't remember any team meeting where he stood up and said, that's why I own this as a team.
00:10:19
Speaker 1: What do we make of that now?
00:10:21
Speaker 2: With all due respect to Usman, I've heard it from numerous sources in Australian cricket that that's never, ever come up. It's in none of the transcripts of investigations from the time. It might have happened whether it's gone to the whole team or not, but I thought it was glaringly obvious in Bancroft's 4,000-word statement that there was no reference to that whatsoever. And he talks about coming forward after what Cummins had to say at his presser last Friday.
00:10:48
Speaker 1: Osman Khawaja says that he has, I guess, bad feelings because he feels that he was the victim of racism throughout his time in Australian cricket, and particularly when the prospect of serving as captain came up. Cameron Bancroft is obviously aggrieved because he feels he never made it back into the top tier. David Warner shouldn't be aggrieved, though. I mean, yes, he served a punishment, but he came back as the hero of Australian cricket and got the loving send-off that he deserved for his excellence as a player. He's got no axe to grind necessarily, does
he? Why would Warner not tell the truth?
00:11:22
Speaker 2: Well, he was fingered as the absolute architect of this idea. This is the thing that I found interesting out of what Cameron Bancroft had to say was I've read that chapter in Usman Khawaja's book four times now. I'm not going to read it again just to get it clear exactly what Uzi is saying. But he basically paints his childhood mate, Dave Warner, as a big player in the whole thing. Cameron Bancroft makes it very clear that the idea of using sandpaper on the ball was made by David Warner. And that's the bloke who took the sandpaper out onto the field. But I think Dave Warner accepts that. What he can't accept is that he was solely responsible for for the man that sort of came up with the idea of manipulating the ball. And if it was discussed on the field by the bowlers, as Bancroft claims, then surely there needs to be some culpability shared from the rest of the team, including the bowlers who benefited the most. So I can understand he has an axe to grind. I don't think, you know, in any way at all it absolves David Warner of what's happened. But, you know, this reckoning's been coming for a while for Australian cricket. I was watching the one-day international broadcast between Australia and England during Australia's run chase when the story dropped and I was reading it and then Adam Gilchrist was referring to it in commentary and you could hear the energy, let's say the energy in Dave Warner's voice.
00:12:42
Speaker 5: Oh, yeah.
00:12:43
Speaker 2: You know, more of the truth's coming out. It's been said for the last sort of week or so, if Bancroft has something to say, that's going to change this story and it has.
00:12:53
Speaker 1: Finally, Webby, Bancroft describes this sort of almost like giddy elation that this was working so well, that the ball was swinging so well, that everybody knew it was happening. And as you say, that the whole team was talking about it. However, he also talks about a deep consciousness of guilt. Warner came up with the idea but couldn't do it himself because he was under too much heat from the cameras and that Bancroft knew it was absolutely wrong at the time. If all that is true, why did Australian cricket, which is supposedly all about honour and decency and values, become a bunch of cheaters?
00:13:28
Speaker 2: It's the line that you have to tiptoe, particularly the Australian test team, between arrogance and swag and having the confidence, the supreme confidence, to be the best team in the world, which they are now at the moment, allegedly. sorry, I think they lost their number one ranking after the loss to South Africa last month. But, you know, that's the line that you've got to walk. A lot of Australian teams have walked that fine line over the years. Steve Waugh was the king of mental disintegration. That was his famous line. But, you know, I think the main thing that comes out of it, Todd Greenberg acknowledged this in his press conference yesterday, was that what happened in 2018 was the culture around that team to win at all costs. that was basically pushed after they lost that test to South Africa in Hobart in 16. It's fed from there and this is the price that's being paid. You know, I know they're all adults. As much as I found Cameron Bancroft's piece absorbing, it did have a bit of bleeding heart about it. It's like he was 25. I know you're a run cricketer, but you knew it was cheating and you could have stood up and said no. Ousmane Khawaja was sitting next to Cameron Bancroft in the dressing room in Cape Town. He could have said, don't do it. You know, it's all well and good to say after the fact this wasn't right. Well, it wasn't right at the time and you should have said. And it should have been left up to the meeting manager to say it. But again, this culture had been fed from the top of Cricket Australia and now it's up to the top of Cricket Australia to put a button in it and end it once and for all.
00:14:58
Speaker 1: Andrew Webster is a columnist with The Australian. This story just keeps breaking. You can follow all the twists and turns live at theaustralian.com.au.