TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Eric Hess: [00:00:00] On this week's episode of the Encrypted Economy, Dyann Heward Mills joins us. Dyann is a renowned privacy expert who was recently highlighted by Business Insider as being among the 28 most influential lobbyists advocates and lawmakers influencing Europe's emerging technologies and the issues arising from those technologies.
She has had an impressive career with roles at Linklaters, GE, Baker and McKenzie and others before founding her own data privacy firm. Recently tapped by the EU to advise legislatures on data, ethics and privacy by design, she is a passionate and knowledgeable advocate. We talked about GDPR, the Schrems decision and of course privacy by design. The time, seemed to fly by with her on the show and I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. As always, if you liked this episode, please subscribe, send the link to others, and let us know about it. Now, our episode with Dyann Heward Mills.
All right, this is the Encrypted Economy today. We're really excited to have Dyann Heward Mills , who owns Heward Mills in the UK. She has a intriguing background, a lot of experience in the data protection sphere. And she is basically a privacy expert and an advocate and has a fascinating career, and we're so excited to have her on the show today. So, welcome Dyann, thanks for joining us.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:01:51] Thank you very much for the invite. I'm excited to be here.
Eric Hess: [00:01:55] Great. So to start off as I alluded to you've got a very interesting background. Heward Mills provides data protection, offers support for multinational corporations doing GDPR, EU privacy regulation, cybersecurity, legal regulatory, so the whole gambit . Diane has 20 years of experience in data protection and cyber security, and the EU appointed her as an ethics expert and tasked her with advising legislators on privacy, by design. Anybody who knows me that anytime you get into something by design for software development I get really excited.
She works a lot with the C-suite level. As I said, global in scope . Building robust privacy and data protection programs works on governance, trust, transparencies. She's written a lot. She's spoken a lot. She was with Baker McKinsey, Linklaters, GE, the whole gambit. And she comes from a very intriguing storied background it's definitely not the crew of underachievers in your family. So Diane, what's it like growing up in the Heward Mills family? Tell us a little bit about yourself.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:02:56] Yeah my family is originally from Ghana, and we have a lot of lawyers in the family. I think, coming from a developing country and many will relate to this, if you have the benefit of education, you've got very limited choices in terms of what you do for a career. You could be a doctor or an accountant or a lawyer, I think essentially. But no, we do have a number of lawyers in the family. Including my mum actually. So she's, a qualified lawyer herself practicing in the UK and also in, in Ghana. And I guess, I grew up around the law and by osmosis, absorbed it and felt very natural operating in this sphere.
Eric Hess: [00:03:30] Great. And when you came to the UK and you were starting off your career, starting to get at bat with Linklaters you had three children and then you also surprisingly acquired guardianship of three more.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:03:42] So actually, at the time of acquiring guardianship, I actually had two children. So I went from two to five and then had my surprise. My daughter who I love dearly, I have to always say this, you were very much wanted and very much loved, but you were a surprise
Eric Hess: [00:03:58] It was just a lot
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:04:03] Yeah, at the time I was qualified as a barrister, so effectively you're self employed. And it's something I've been scratching my head over since. I've never had maternity leave because as a self-employed practitioner, you don't have mat leave. You don't have maternity leave. What I've managed to do is to strike a really good balance between sort of work and family life. I've always had to do that. Always working around the children but continuing in my career, which has also brought me a lot of satisfaction. So I, am a very strong advocate for supporting any family that wants to do the same. Mothers that want to work. And those that want to obviously be home and raise children, absolutely admirable too. But I think you should just, the important thing is having the choice and I feel very grateful that I've had that choice throughout my career.
Eric Hess: [00:04:46] You started off with Linklaters and you started off with binding corporate rules. That's what you were tasked with initially, in a law firm . Having worked at a law firm, you think like law firms are also compliant, but one thing I learned working in a law firm is if it's not billable, they really don't want to do it.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:05:02] Yeah. That is a challenge. And again, I was very fortunate that we were able to persuade the senior practitioners at Linklaters of the importance of getting data, and data management in particular. I had a very sort of visionary partner there, Christopher Milad, who also was my lecturer at university who saw the benefits of having a global program that had been sanctioned by the supervisory authorities. And that's what binding corporate rules allows for.
Interesting, still as relevant today as it was, 10 years or so ago when we were making that application. Effectively allows for an organization to transfer data freely within the group, the corporate group, but also you have to demonstrate before you get that accreditation by the supervisory authorities. As I say, that you have got a robust program in place, that you have the right policies and procedures in place that you've got the right... an audit framework in place that you are training your individuals within the organization. And that there's good accountability
Load full transcript
throughout the organization for data protection.
Having that vision 10 years ago was fantastic. And since then I've gone on to develop programs in-house and also advise on programs for other multinational organizations and small, medium sized businesses too.
Eric Hess: [00:06:18] So when you look back at Linklaters, what was the single thing that enabled you to push this through? If you look back at it, what was the biggest obstacle and what was the thing that enabled you to get past that obstacle?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:06:30] I think it's the same issues, really that many privacy practitioners, data protection officers, chief privacy officers face now is that it's a question of persuading. You have to persuade the decision makers because it is an investment of time, which is money in a law firm and in any other organization. And engaging valuable resources to this issue of building a privacy program. And so it's very much convincing organizations what's in it for them. And I guess a key point to get across is, what happens if we don't do this and what happens if we don't get this right?
And you don't really have to go far in the law firm to understand the importance of good information, governance and compliance because when things go wrong in terms of impact on brand it will and can be very devastating. And really, it was interesting in terms of just the focus that data protection and privacy compliance was getting. And it's only increased actually since then. It was a question of actually drawing attention to this issue and its importance and being persuasive and getting senior leaders within the organization to understand the importance and to buy into supporting investment in our data protection and privacy program.
Eric Hess: [00:08:00] I guess like any big organization, everybody says yeah sure, of course we'll do that. And then there's a question of now you have to implement and people actually have to do work and that's where the rubber hits the road. But I was feeding you that one, cause I figured, in your DPO, what happened at Linklaters is a Petri dish for what happens in any big organization. It's always the tone at the top and convincing at the top level that hey, compliance does matter. It can impact our reputation. It's something that we have to do. And privacy is obviously increasingly becoming more and more important, particularly as we have cybersecurity breakdowns, the US is no exception there.
So you went on to GE capital, then you went to Baker McKenzie and by then you were beyond just binding corporate rules. You were getting into AML compliance, data protection audits, records management, cloud computing, regulatory approvals, data breach management, wow. You had your shovels going and you still had all those children, which we noted earlier.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:08:53] I guess that's the joy and the challenge of data, right? It is all pervasive, so it touches upon everything. And so as a practitioner, you've
got to be able to deal with these issues as they arise and help organizations navigate them. And there are lots of tensions. So you mentioned a few there. The tension between ensuring AML compliance, which requires you to actually go deep into an individual. Research what they do, their backgrounds, beneficiary owners, lots of information that's required in that exercise in that due diligence exercise, but can cause tension and conflict with data protection and privacy. And how do you strike that right balance between the two?
And there was a belief within financial services that, AML will always trump because the risk of getting that wrong was far greater than any fine that you could receive from a data protection authority. And then the data protection fines started to come in and were rising. And so there was this recognition that actually we need to take both seriously. And there is a path and a way forward where actually both rights are recognized and you don't need to infringe the fundamental rights of individuals to have a strong and a robust AML program in place. But you have to understand what the obligations are and to have those conversations and to have that accountability in terms of the decision-making around those processes.
Eric Hess: [00:10:22] That's for sure. One thing I always... I'm stunned at is the inherent conflict between AML, which basically, you know, you see it in the US now even relating to things like digital assets and the amount of information that's being, that's being sought after. All at the same time as you're hearing about SolarWinds, compromising those very institutions, which would centralize this information, it's just it's a stunning irony. And , there's an inherent tension that I don't think is going to be alleviated anytime soon. You can't have one without the other, and it's a delicate balancing act because you do start to infringe on developing countries but there are a lot of countries in the world where financial privacy is very important because of totalitarian regimes and the likes. And yet, having that privacy can actually facilitate things where you don't have those protections.
But that said... schrems II. The US has just not had a good time getting it right in the EU with privacy. We've been on, we've been off. We're constantly trying to find our way, but Schrems II, EU said no. Not good enough. It's not working. Do you want to talk a little bit about that and what it means for us in the US?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:11:26] Yeah, so this is this sort of a long history of frameworks that were found to not be fit for purpose effectively. There was a safe Harbor. You remember that?
Eric Hess: [00:11:37] Yeah I remember
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:11:40] It existed before the privacy shields.
Eric Hess: [00:11:43] I got schooled up on the safe harbor just to then worry about the privacy shield. Now I got to go back to the books again.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:11:50] Exactly. So that was declared
invalid, there was a scramble to find a replacement for it. And that replacement was the shield and we felt well, okay this will facilitate transfers of data between the EU and the US. Incredibly important, if you think of the value really associated with that transfer, so many tech companies that deliver services to the rest of the world based in the US that rely on data flowing freely between the various regions and the frameworks that facilitate that one of which was the privacy shield.
But there was a challenge to that. And effectively, what Schrems put forward was that the shield did not offer the level of protection that was required under European law. So it was effectively an ineffective mechanism to protect the rights and freedoms of individuals. And initially that challenge was raised with the Irish supervisory authority. And they referred eventually to the European court of justice. And I think it's a very interesting decision in that what it does, it shifts the responsibility, back to organizations and also to supervisory authorities to think about the data that they handle to think about the risk that data processing presents to fundamental freedoms and rights of individuals, and to do their own assessment and risk mitigation around that processing. Now that, some would argue is a very onerous responsibility for organizations to carry. But, the truth is it exists anyway under law. Under the GDPR, you're required to do this. And I guess what Schrems does is just, it throws that spotlight on the obligations that sit within organizations in any event. And yes, I think there has been a scramble to actually even understand the data that's being processed because many organizations really didn't have a good handle on the information that they're processing. And whether indeed that information is flowing to the US or other third countries that may not offer the same level of protection as individuals would have if the data remained within Europe. Interesting time, certainly.
Eric Hess: [00:14:11] Yeah. you're right in that the obligations really don't fundamentally change. Although from a reporting perspective, from a diligence, from a contractual perspective, you have to deal with it differently yet again. So keep your privacy agreements flexible. And then of course, here we are thinking about... oh geez, the Schrems decision impact, and then Brexit comes along and now we're going through the same thing again. I don't think that the UK is going to be kicked out of the privacy shield, but that's also being assessed, right?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:14:41] Yeah, so Brexit. It's been very fraught right to the dying moments. But a deal has been struck and I think it will take some months to unravel the devil that will be in the detail for sure. But certainly, in terms of data flows from the UK to Europe, we have a six month reprieve and they will still be considered adequate for the next six months, certainly while the European commission decides on whether the UK is going to be afforded the status of an adequate country for the purposes of data flows. Certainly whilst the UK was part of the membership of the European economic area and the EU. It was part of the 28 member States. Information could flow freely from the UK to Europe and vice versa. Now we enter this phase of the UK falling out of the European Union. It's effectively a third country. Organizations that have flows of data from Europe to the UK, need to ensure that data is properly protected. And what we understand for at least the next six months, and thank goodness, cause there's so much that we're having to deal with the pandemic and COVID and an economic pain really that organizations are going through. Thank goodness that there is at least the six month period where we have a degree of assurance that transfers are safe. But essentially the issue doesn't go away. We still are looking to see whether the UK is going to be afforded adequacy by the European commission. We still need to think about the mechanisms and programs around data transfers. And then some practical considerations because the UK will have its own version of the GDPR. So organizations that are operating within the UK or targeting individuals in the UK will have to think about the UK GDPR and compliance with it, in much the same way as you would if you were running a global program would have to consider what the obligations are. For example, in Brazil, under the LGPD or in Singapore or in China or India and South Africa, you also have to add to that list, the UK. If you are targeting or operating within the UK .
Eric Hess: [00:17:12] And I guess that leads me to my next question, which is... so Google and Facebook, which are American companies and they have their own GDPR compliance structures in the US, they had them in the UK and they say, you know what, we're just going to migrate. This is too much for us. It's too confusing. We don't know what to do. Let's just move all that data back to the US. What do you think was behind those decisions and is it... does it represent something more?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:17:36] Yeah, so it's a very interesting move and I guess... and I don't have any more insight into the decision-making than you Eric, but, just as an outsider objective sort of reviewer of the situation, I guess they have a strategy around managing European data. Which is that European data is going to be managed through Ireland. And actually that's quite a common strategy in particular for the US tech companies. They effectively have their lead supervisory authority as the Irish supervisory authority and their main sort of European center, if you like is Ireland. And there were all sorts of practical reasons why that would happen. Same language, common law background and history. You can understand why that would make sense. And it's growing in terms of the attraction to locate your European operations in Ireland. And they may then
have an approach to deal with rest of the world data and obligations from the US. Just very practically speaking that's perhaps what sits behind that decision-making. What I would say though, as a data protection officer and looking at the landscape globally is that there really ought not to be certainly a race to the bottom because that's the fastest way to lose trust of your customers or your employees.
And I just think the world has moved in a different direction when it comes to privacy and data protection and any organization that's not moving in that direction of enhanced rights, recognizing how important this topic is to individuals will lose the trust of individuals. So I don't for one second believe that it is a race to the bottom. I certainly hope not. And I know the two organizations that you've mentioned certainly invest a lot in privacy and data protection to holding themselves out as understanding and respecting those rights. Is it a race to dilution? I hope not too, because I think the world is moving in the direction of enhanced rights and certainly individuals are very aware of their rights and wanting to exercise them.
So it may just be a practical step in terms of managing global data from the US and managing European specific data from Ireland. But we'll see how that plays out. Essentially, the GDPR has raised the bar and many organizations operate to that standard globally don't they? Because they feel well, if we're meeting the GDPR standard, then we will generally speaking, meet our obligations across multiple regions. We may have to make some tweaks locally to deal with localized requirements, but we're not going to find ourselves falling far short the bar and requirements in different regions.
Eric Hess: [00:20:47] And, even in the US where we're on the other end of the Schrems decision , California is basically positioning itself where it probably could benefit from the privacy shield as its own jurisdiction for companies operating underneath the, now CPRA as well as the more recent one that, California is going to have its own data protection authority. That's wow.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:21:08] And it's always been at the forefront California, in setting the standards on privacy. And yes, absolutely, it seems to be doing things and there's still very much a consumer focused element, which is slightly different from the fundamental human rights approach that the Europeans take to protection. And I think those local differences and nuances need to be understood and respected and observed. But yes, I think in terms of championing transparency and privacy rights , California is leading the way. But there are other States as well following. Washington's looking to introduce legislation so I think this is, as I say, the direction of travel and the US is no exception. There's still lots of talk about whether there might be a federal act in place like what would be your bet Eric, on that?
Eric Hess: [00:21:59] Not 2021, But actually think it will start to gather steam. I think, this gets into the politics of it, but I think definitely with the Biden administration, definitely with... you see things like the SolarWinds just heightens the sense of that privacy is needed even while we're pursuing, more stringent AML controls, which we talked about. So I think it's something that gets underway something of that magnitude wouldn't move swiftly through in 2021, but I could definitely see it within the Biden administration. In fact I will just go out on a limb and say, I'm 95%, it occurs within the next four years. And I think that's a safe prediction because I think, I don't know how you can, look at what's going on in the way that California is positioning itself, the way that Washington, so many things in the United States is done on a state by state approach.
It's if you want to be, for example, I've talked to another guest Felix Shipkevitch about money services businesses laws. If you want to do the money services business in the US, you have to apply. You have to register in 50 States. That is really expensive. And if you have data across multiple States or you want to contemplate more of a national level approach to privacy, how do you do that? What are you gonna do to Washington and California? You get your big grid out. The lawyers are making tons of money, but they're just exacting this rent from everybody, for doing something that could be simplified. So I don't think there's a choice.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:23:23] Yeah. Having that certainty and having that sort of umbrella approach would just make a lot of sense. Fragmentation that currently exists and increased fragmentation
Eric Hess: [00:23:32] And confusion. You know, people get the wrong advice or they can't get, the experts don't emerge. There's so many problems with doing it state by state and piecemeal approach. And, particularly now that we've gone to the Schrems kick in the butt as a reminder that we need to get our act together on that.
So now I want to talk about that. The other thing I have on my list, which is privacy by design. So we talk on this podcast, we do a lot talking about like machine learning and AI and, when we were talking prior to this podcast, we talked about how the dangers of bias and there's practical. Aspects to bias in machine learning, meaning you get bad data, you get the wrong decisions, you violate people's privacy rights and then there's policy aspects to it too in that, are you favoring certain portions of the population? Is there a bias that you don't even detect? So I'm going to ask you about both of those starting with the practical and shifting over to the policy. And again, you've been advising EU legislators so it'd be very interesting to hear your thoughts on that.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:24:34] Yeah. I think it goes back to who is doing the coding, ultimately what are the structures that we have in place? And it is a fact isn't it, that
certainly, women are very underrepresented when it comes to design and coding and machine learning. So that's the first, and then, when you start to think of minorities the structures that we have in place are already not designed for diversity. And you're not bringing to the discussion and the product design... diversity or privacy. Because those are afterthoughts and they're not built in. So what you can have as you say is, bad decisions, but multiplied and actually made at sort of the speed of light. And it's very difficult then to reverse that process, because you already have the biases built into the code. It's like, how do you then... how do you reverse that?
And we've seen some practical examples where, for example, there's facial recognition technology that had a bias against dark skin. And this was in the gaming context, but you can see in other contexts too where perhaps the bias is to train the recognition technology on darkend skin, because there hasn't been the built-in concerns around the impact to certain groups of society. And inevitably, the vulnerable groups are not at the table when the design is happening because they are disenfranchised, they don't even know about it. And so it becomes very challenging and it's built in. That's the sort of practical implications of... and we've seen this, in different contexts certain organizations even pulling back from sharing their technology with certain regimes and also with law enforcement, because of the fear of the biases that have been built into the technology. There's a sort of recognition that look, we need to take a step back and address this before we start to use these technologies, because they are very powerful incredibly powerful.
And I think it's always raising the awareness. It's like the black lives matter movement. You've got to be aware of the prejudice that exists and have done for centuries. And once you have that degree of awareness, you can start to think about, how do we reverse these, how do we break them down? But if you're operating in ignorance, you're just perpetuating. And I think what 2020 hopefully has taught us is that there's a lot we need to learn, and we need to have the humility to accept that really, because we can't start to make progress until we accept that there's a lot that we've achieved as a human race for sure, but there's a lot that we absolutely need to learn too. And leading to your second part, we need to influence the policy makers around this too, and raise their awareness.
Eric Hess: [00:27:50] For sure. When you think about machine learning, it is often very outcome specific, right? Why are we taking in all this data, running all these algorithms, collecting all this data? We have different outcomes we want to achieve, and those outcomes can become the Oracle, so to speak for other technologies that feed into it. So if you're focused on specific outcomes, but you don't understand sort of the micro forces or the policy implications or the places where your algorithm, it seems like it's minor, it doesn't necessarily change your outcome that you're looking for at the moment, but then you're building other things into those outcomes. And now you're institutionalizing these mistakes, these failures that may not become apparent initially, but down the road, all of a sudden somebody is like, whoa, hold it, that wasn't intended. But now you have an Oracle that people have accepted as being the Oracle, so to speak, and you're drawing data from that and you're making other determinations from it. And you could find yourself in a situation where you've institutionalized certain biases that nobody might have actually even affirmatively, sat down and said, we're going to do this, but now they're built into the system.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:29:00] Absolutely, absolutely. And it's that systemic and institutionalized bias. It's just the most difficult to eradicate because as you say, you almost sleep, walk into it. And so it's for us to say, Hey look, we have evidence of how this can just have a devastating impact over time. Let's address it now because actually it's accelerated when it comes to big data.
Eric Hess: [00:29:25] Yeah, it would be ironic if in the wake of black lives matter and everything we've gone through as a society, if looking at the more physical the real world examples and missing, what's occurring at the machine learning and AI, and, the large systems level.
And listen, privacy by design, there's biases throughout. Meaning, it's something that, there's the policy considerations, there's race, there's gender, and then there's just getting it wrong too. This makes sense in the long run. We need to create models that are actually reflective and that reflect policy decisions as well. And that's how we're going to get better systems. And that's how we're not going to have major breaks later on that people are scratching their head and trying to figure out how to undo it.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:30:05] Absolutely. And this is what we absolutely advocate for as a data protection office, because we are able to bring that sort of objective view to the boardroom. And, we don't have any ties either with the organization except for wanting them to do the right thing, which we think will add value to the brand. Really that's our interest. So we can have that objective voice and we can hold them to account in a really good way and help them build that sort of privacy by design into their processes and their products, and ultimately doing it in a way that is fitting with their organizational culture, because that's the thing about privacy by design. Effectively, it has to come from within and it has to fit within the organizational culture. And so that's something that really excites me because it's not this sort of nebulous concept. It's very practical. And a good friend of mine and fellow practitioner, she said, it's almost like you're building a pizza. So
you give the organization all the ingredients and then, they go ahead and they build that pizza that's right for them. Now they may place the mushrooms and the sweet corn and the pepperoni in different places, but, that's okay. It's just as long as it's done and it's understood by the organization. And that's what privacy by design is about. It's about bringing that concept to life . And much like we discussed earlier, you have to have the buy-in at the top level in order to achieve that change. And to also champion all the good things that are being done on the privacy front within an organization, because that's also part of how you build privacy by design, you recognize when you're doing it well, and you reward that you amplify that you champion the good things that are happening on privacy.
Eric Hess: [00:31:50] So I'm going to throw you a bit of a curve ball. So we talked about the prevention, but what about detection?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:31:55] Yeah. And actually the internal detection that is, that's actually very challenging because often what you find is where an organization is investing in a robust program, they will find more issues.
It's almost in a way... it's easier to look away and not do the work. Because you're going to come across issues. But actually that's a good thing because it's any sort of unresolved problem. It's just going to grow and it's going to become a bigger problem.
So the sooner you tackle it, as challenging as it might be at the time of doing it, the sooner you tackle it, the better. And that's where having an infrastructure within your organization that allows you to have the sort of foot soldiers on the grounds that firstly have an understanding of data protection, privacy, what the requirements are, operating within the different functions of your organization and being able to detect the issues as they arise and escalate them and feed them to those that have responsibility for decision-making and it may require some times a degree of risk taking. That's fine, it's just a question of doing so with awareness. Mindful risk-taking as opposed to blind risk taking. So if you have that awareness, you have to issues race to you, you say this is a level of risk that we are prepared to accept and senior individuals in the organization sign that off, fine. But you might find actually there's some risks that you're simply not prepared to accept as an organization, as a business. And better those risks are raised and you're aware of them and you are able to do something about them then for them to just continue to exist un detected.
Eric Hess: [00:33:47] Yeah, I wonder, like in, cybersecurity we have bug bounties, right? To identify security bugs in systems and programs. I wonder if at some point in the future, we start to do privacy bug bounties, right? We're testing out various outcomes and somebody gets a bounty for figuring out, particularly as you start to get to some of the more impactful consumer base.
Obviously you couldn't do it in real customer consumer data, but that would be intriguing.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:34:12] Absolutely. And actually, look, you've got an opportunity to really listen to your internal stakeholders who can actually draw your attention to a lot of significant issues as a senior leadership team, as a board, really paying attention to what's coming up and bubbling up from within the organization.
And actually if you're a consumer facing business, often your call centers and individuals that interface with consumers can be a really useful source of information to actually understand how your services are landing. So are you really listening? Are you gathering that information? Because it could be incredibly helpful to you as an organization.
Eric Hess: [00:34:56] That's a great point. That's a great point. Let me ask you a question now, shifting gears a little bit. So how might GDPR and all the privacy regulations that we're putting into place create additional exposures of consumer information?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:35:11] I think ...look the GDPR has definitely raised awareness across the globe of the importance of privacy and actually being transparent as an organization about what you are doing with individuals' data . In terms of increased risk to information, I think some of the frustrations that have been felt and certainly articulated to me is, where there is a fear of acting and actually sharing information. And and sometimes what's raised is oh data protection or GDPR concerns. This can't be done. And sometimes it's been argued that might create risks to individuals because it may prevent them from accessing certain services or in particular, when it comes to public sector data sharing or lack of could result in harm to vulnerable individuals.
So that's where sometimes there are concerns that, actually it's not the GDPR itself. It's typically a lack of understanding of the law and a fear of acting in a way that may be perceived as a breach of the GDPR, regardless of whether it is an actual breach or not. And that's where you really do have to have qualified advisors, but understand the nature of law ,understand the guidance that's issued by the supervisory authorities and are able to advise. And I do sympathize in particular with small businesses where they don't have that expertise available to them in particular, in-house. And that can cause frustration, but for those that have got good advice, good advisors, and you're able to put the guard rails in place, it gives you the sort of ability to operate freely and to innovate as organizations need to do or indeed to share data for, public interest benefits and others, and to prevent harm.
So it's understanding and being able to interpret it and being able to advise. And the flip side is where you don't have that understanding, or you have bad advice, which occasionally does happen sometimes. It can result in harms and an inability to access services or also
stifle innovation.
Eric Hess: [00:37:37] Great. So I'm going to ask you... so GDPR creates all kinds of rights for the residents, right? They can, they can bring suits against the processors, the controllers, the data protection authorities, but has that been executed on, are there obstacles to that? Do you have a point of view on that?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:37:58] Yeah, it's interesting. Cause there was a perception that there would be an explosion of class actions with with the GDPR. And that Europe was going to follow in this sort of American style approach. But I think that there are local and cultural differences that need to be understood.
Just generally speaking there hasn't been that explosion. And that's because actually, to bring a class action, the kind of the number of barriers in certain European jurisdictions.... you have to opt in to be a participant within the class action, as opposed to the US style where you effectively can begin a class action where a number of individuals are impacted and they have the right to opt out.
So that in itself is, a very different way of doing things and can act as a barrier. Also under the GDPR, not for profit organizations are able to bring class actions on behalf of individuals, but how do the rules around what qualifies you as a not-for-profit organization? And if you are raising funds to bring an action, you may be disqualified and litigation is very expensive. In terms of individuals, organizations being galvanized to bring an action often it's said the beneficiaries are not necessarily the individuals because by the time an action has been funded , the lawyers have been paid, the representative organization has taken out its costs, individuals that actually are ultimately left with very little. So there's all sorts of practical financial challenges, legal procedural challenges around bringing class actions. That said, there have been a number of cases, certainly in the UK, which suggest that actually the courts are more open and certainly facilitate the idea of class actions being taken. And Morrison is a good case, which was related to an employee that effectively disclosed large volumes of personal data of colleagues in almost a sort of... as a way of attacking Morrison's the organization. And the courts did find actually that in that situation that the employees could bring a class action against Morrisons. Ultimately the individual who disclosed that data was found criminally liable. So it's not the good idea for employees to act in that way. And ultimately also Morrisons were found not to be liable... vicariously liable of the actions of their employee. But that said, it was a landmark case in that it did facilitate the bringing of a class action by an employee base. So I think, ultimately it is possible. And as individuals become increasingly aware of their rights and exercise to bring claims, it's very much something that we could see a rise of. And we talked about how successful Max Schrems has been in raising issues of privacy failures. And you can see how effective those sorts of organizations and bodies can be in, in their action.
Eric Hess: [00:41:20] Max Schrems, was you would classify him as more of an activist as opposed to, somebody seeking a maybe a monetary reward or damages for their... for the privacy failure.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:41:31] Indeed, but there are definitely a rise in claims being brought against organizations and obviously Max Schrems has the sort of headline platform in terms of the impact that he's had, but many organizations face claims from employees, claims from customers for mishandling their information and actually it can be incredibly expensive and disruptive to an organization in particular, if they don't have the procedures in place to deal with those claims.
One of the rights under the GDPR is this right of access, subject access rights that individuals can bring against organizations. And actually if organizations aren't able to meet those requests. It can prove to be incredibly disruptive and individuals can claim for compensation.
And there's a question of, what do you do? Do you face the risk of an individual going to a supervisory authority and exposing your lack of compliance or do you do settle? Do you offer compensation? So those sorts of issues can be incredibly challenging. And that's where I will always advocate for a proactive program build as opposed to reactive dealing with the risk of individual s bringing claims or issuing subject access rights, or indeed risk of class actions.
Eric Hess: [00:43:00] And it's interesting if you think about the US getting back to the federal law. If you have a number of jurisdictions that start to recognize these rights and you have actions being brought in jurisdictions that don't have these legal frameworks, but how can it not bleed? Basically is the judge gonna rule, say you don't have that right? And whereas the right is increasingly being recognized. And I think it's hard to have once you start to get a critical mass of enough States, it makes it very difficult not to, because it's almost like you're exposing, the companies within those jurisdictions that don't have that legal framework. It's actually more risk long-term because they're not going to catch up.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:43:38] Absolutely. And you're at such a disadvantage if you don't have that framework in place ultimately. Especially where you're operating globally and this, as you say, the standards are rising, so you don't want to have that weak link really, which will leave you very exposed.
Whether it's at a sort of state level in the US or a jurisdictional level globally.
Eric Hess: [00:44:00] So in 2021, you take out your Heward Mills crystal ball, what do you see in privacy or what are the big changes?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:44:08] So I think definitely a trend of increased awareness, engagement by activists, individuals who are very
excited about their rights. I definitely see organizations that are progressive developing privacy by design frameworks, implementing them, championing them, recognizing that as the only way to build trust.
I definitely see legislators and the supervisory authorities and supernational organizations such as the commission looking to develop ethical as well as legal requirements around data. Because there's a sort of understanding that actually you can get some very clever lawyers to help you navigate around the laws, but actually just because you could do something with data doesn't mean that you should be doing something with that data that would potentially not be within the legitimate expectation of individuals and how can you be ensured as an organization that you're acting within legal, as well as ethical compliance and increased engagement with stakeholders, and also vulnerable groups or individuals who represent vulnerable groups to ensure that not only are you baking in privacy by design, but also diversity by design, which is a big passion of mine.
Eric Hess: [00:45:39] And it's funny, I had David Harris from Manetu has a platform that's basically for consumers to access the various information about how a company is using your information, consent, all that stuff. Largely playing into the California set of regulations. But what he's told me is that the people who are experiencing the most amount of interest in his platform, aren't necessarily from California, they're companies who want to get ahead of it. They want to implement this now. They don't want to wait until some point in the future. They want to answer their shareholders. They want to answer their employees. They want to answer their customers. They want to say, this is how we're treating this information. We have a process in place. And so what was really intriguing to me in talking to him, was it isn't people running to him and saying, Oh my God, California have to comply with California.
It's companies saying, we want to implement this because it's a sound company practice. We're a multinational company. We don't want to be caught trying to backend this, we want to get ahead of it and we want to implement it. And we don't want a massive disruption to our systems as we're trying to get into place in response to whatever kind of regulatory or illegal threat that we may face. I thought that was, and that ties right into what you're saying, which is this, it's not just about being forced to do this. It's about saying, listen, this is where we're going. If we have a multinational company, who are we kidding? This is where the world's going.
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:46:58] It's not about, we're just gonna, we're gonna meet the expectations. No, you want to exceed expectations. That's what you champion, right? And so those progressive organizations want to exceed expectations on privacy because it's the right thing to do, respecting individuals' personal information, upholding data dignity, that's the right thing to do. So you want to exceed expectations on that.
Eric Hess: [00:47:21] Yeah. And it's not that much harder to do once you start. In the financial services space being over compliant, there's tons of laws. If you're over compliant, you're shelling out big bucks. In the privacy space do more than what the statute actually requires you to do, once you're down that path, it's not that much harder.
Dyann, where can people find out more about you and Heward Mills? Find out what you're saying, what you're writing when you're speaking all that good stuff?
Dyann Heward Mills: [00:47:46] Oh, yeah. So on I'm on LinkedIn. There's not many if any other Dyann Heward Mills' you'll definitely find me there under Heward Mills and on the website, www.hewardmills.com. So when we post a lot of stuff as well, we post some blogs and I'm always really keen to hear from other practitioners, other individuals, organizations share your thoughts on data dignity on data ethics, on data protection, compliance and privacy, and the way in which world is going on this topic.
Thank you so much for the invitation, this has gone so quickly. I really enjoyed chatting with you. And so thanks so much for the opportunity.
Eric Hess: [00:48:24] No it was great to have you on the show. Thanks so much Dyann.