TRANSCRIPT 🔗
[0:01] Welcome to the Empathic Edge.
[0:07] Hi everyone, welcome back to the Empathic Edge with Megan Smith, founder of Empathic Edge.
[0:12] Megan is an attorney, negotiation professor, and dispute resolution professional focused
[0:17] on the future of human communication in an AI driven world.
[0:21] Through negotiation strategy, emotional intelligence, and high stakes conversation training, she
[0:27] helps professionals build confidence and perform more effectively under pressure.
[0:31] I'm Sean O'Connor, and today Megan and I are getting into a conversation about why empathy
[0:38] may be one of the most misunderstood advantages in negotiation.
[0:44] Hi Megan, how are you?
[0:45] I'm doing great, how are you, Sean?
[0:47] I am doing pretty well myself.
[0:50] I'm relatively excited to get into what this is about, you know, empathy as a super power,
[0:57] so to speak.
[0:58] Empathy sounds, you know, overly emotional to some professionals, a little touchy feeling,
[1:05] maybe.
[1:06] How do you define empathy in the context of negotiation and difficult conversations?
[1:12] So I think about it less in terms of feelings and more about information.
[1:18] So when I define it for professionals or law students, lawyers, I describe it really
[1:24] as like the ability to accurately understand what the other person is experiencing, what
[1:30] they need, or like their interests, or their underlying why, and what's really driving
[1:35] their position, and then they can actually use that to understand the situation more strategically.
[1:43] That makes a lot of sense.
[1:44] It's sort of like understanding what drives a person, so to speak, coming, understanding
[1:54] their motivation, and it's insight, you know, it's like being intuitive and like, oh, I
[2:00] get the sense that this person is x, y, z, but you know, more concrete than that.
[2:05] I like it.
[2:06] I like that.
[2:08] Exactly.
[2:09] Yeah, and sorry just to add on to that.
[2:10] So one thing I always start with law students is we do this conflict mode assessment.
[2:16] So they get to learn which one of five different conflict modes they are, and I tell them
[2:20] that this is information in.
[2:22] So every piece of information you can learn about yourself and the other side, whoever
[2:27] it is you're negotiating with, you get to use that strategically.
[2:31] So it's not about softening your position when I say like use empathy, it's really about
[2:36] knowing enough about where they're coming from and what they're underlying motivations or
[2:40] their why is so that y'all can actually work together to find solutions and maximize value.
[2:46] Yeah, it's interesting, because it shifts the idea of, we said softening their
[2:54] position or you know, maybe like reducing leverage, which is a, you know, sort of a dynamic
[3:00] and negotiation.
[3:02] And now we're in like, oh, no, this is a strategic advantage if you master it.
[3:08] Is that what you're saying?
[3:09]
Load full transcript
Absolutely.
[3:10] Yes, especially if you're thinking about the relationship.
[3:13] So not all relationships are relationships that are being broken.
[3:18] A lot of them you need to repair or strengthen or you're continuing in a long term relationship
[3:24] so being empathetic with the other side really can just benefit you in the long term.
[3:31] Yeah, so you're in a, you're in a negotiation and want the other person feels genuinely
[3:41] heard, genuinely understood.
[3:45] What shifts?
[3:46] Everything.
[3:47] I think at that point, if they feel heard, then you're really at a place where you both
[3:53] can collaborate and focus on, I mean, really, I would say two big things.
[3:58] One is, you know, creating more value and maximizing the value for both sides.
[4:06] So the goal isn't really to say, okay, we've got just this much pie and I'm going to take
[4:11] 80% of it, you only get 20%.
[4:13] I want to work to grow the pie.
[4:15] How do we expand and come up with creative solutions together so that we can benefit
[4:21] either ourselves more and better or our clients?
[4:25] What kind of pie?
[4:26] Well, that's a great question.
[4:28] You know, I don't know why I have to talk about cherry pie, but I don't even like cherry
[4:32] pie that much.
[4:33] Maybe a rhubarb.
[4:34] That's good.
[4:35] Yeah.
[4:36] I like a good apple rhubarb.
[4:39] I want 80% of the rhubarb pie.
[4:43] You can have, I'll take 20% of the cherry pie.
[4:48] There we go.
[4:49] See, we're going to split it.
[4:50] Right.
[4:51] There's a, there was this example I saw on social media recently and I think it was a couple
[4:55] where the husband would always take the like crispy fries from the wife and the wife would
[5:01] always take the other kind of fries and they've never really communicated about it.
[5:06] They just thought, oh, that's because that's my spouse's preference.
[5:09] I want to give them what they, what they enjoy and they learn and we're really just doing
[5:13] it to benefit each other all those years and they really liked the kind that they were giving
[5:17] away or that they were I think taking.
[5:20] So communicating through those things too.
[5:23] So we now know you prefer the cherry back to the, you know, the empathy, you're, you're
[5:27] talking about, you know, empathy as a strategic tool or, you know, strategic empathy.
[5:33] What does that actually look like in the midst of a difficult conversation or negotiation
[5:38] like in real time?
[5:40] How's that show up?
[5:41] So I think two specific ways that you could see it or that you could incorporate it like
[5:47] into your daily life and communications, one would be taking a break or a pause if you need
[5:53] to.
[5:54] So when tensions do get high, if you feel as though you're not really making any progress,
[6:00] if you take a step back, you can then help yourself to reset and again, remind yourself
[6:05] of what are my interests or my clients interests, like what's
their really underlying motivation
[6:11] and what's the other sides.
[6:13] And am I allowing ego to get into the way?
[6:16] Because that is what happens a lot of the time.
[6:20] I think the other thing that you can do to is ask yourself in the moment, whether you take
[6:24] a break or not is, am I coming from a place of genuine curiosity?
[6:30] I like to say that the ABCs are so important in negotiation.
[6:34] It's always be curious.
[6:36] And so if I kind of ask myself that question, okay, sort of like, was that an open-ended
[6:41] question?
[6:42] Was I really actively listening?
[6:44] Did I actually care about what the other side was saying?
[6:47] And if the answer is no, then I do need to pause and reset.
[6:52] Well, in personal relationships and certainly in legal context, conversations can escalate
[7:01] quickly.
[7:02] The temperature gets turned up.
[7:04] What do you think tends to push people into defensiveness versus problem solving in those
[7:10] relations?
[7:12] One thing that I'm not certain most people would think of immediately is a lack of preparation.
[7:19] You do tend to become more defensive if you do not feel that you are adequately prepared.
[7:25] So by just over-preparing or prepare, prepare, prepare before the negotiation and the difficult
[7:32] conversation, that should actually alleviate a lot of those rising tensions that tend to
[7:38] occur in difficult conversations.
[7:41] So I think that that is primarily what happens.
[7:45] But then I also think that any time your core values or your sense of who you are or your
[7:54] integrity or your competence or your kindness, right, well, I feel like I'm a kind person
[8:00] and you're saying that I'm mean or I'm a bad person, that's addressing one of my core
[8:06] values.
[8:07] And that's when we tend to become defensive.
[8:09] Yeah, that makes sense.
[8:11] Yeah, and that lack of preparation can relate to that in a number of contexts.
[8:16] I hope they don't bring up X, Y or Z, because I know I'm under-prepared and that's just
[8:23] going to off my game generally, interesting.
[8:27] But I actually see what happens with most people is they don't realize that they're under-prepared.
[8:32] So they go into it and I see it a lot with like salary negotiations or like for an employment
[8:37] agreement.
[8:38] So a student is trying to get a first job and they just wing it and they say, well, I thought
[8:43] about these things beforehand.
[8:45] So then the question comes down, well, what research did you do beforehand?
[8:50] What did the preparation look like?
[8:52] Did you look at, you know, even the American Bar Association provides some like salary information?
[9:00] Did you go there?
[9:01] Did you talk to colleagues?
[9:03] Then did you, you know, practice with interview questions with a partner?
[9:08] And most of the time the answer to that is no, but they say they thought they were prepared
[9:14] before going into it.
[9:15] But it's almost
as if they need a checklist before going into it.
[9:18] Yeah, I know, you know, in all your experience, I mean, I know you have a lot of scenarios.
[9:25] I'm curious if maybe you could share an example of a negotiation or a difficult conversation
[9:30] where empathy change the direction or the outcome of that interaction.
[9:37] Yeah, I think also being a business owner, I, you know, have to have difficult conversations
[9:42] with our team at times.
[9:46] And sometimes that's because, you know, certain expectations aren't being met or there seems
[9:52] to be a lack of communication or some kind of misunderstanding.
[9:56] And so I, I believe, you know, going into a conversation, first of all, actually having
[10:01] the conversation, that's a huge piece of it, right?
[10:05] I think a lot of people tend to be more reactionary and say, we're just done.
[10:09] This isn't working.
[10:10] I want to have a conversation.
[10:12] I want to know what's going on.
[10:14] And I also hope that I get to know my people well enough beforehand that I can kind of tell
[10:21] if there are certain triggers, maybe outside of work that could be impacting them.
[10:25] So I have to pay attention, I have to listen to them.
[10:29] But I think going into that conversation, I would prepare, especially for a conversation
[10:34] with a team member, because I know I, you know, I can get emotional about it too, right?
[10:39] Especially if you've worked with somebody for a long time and you feel like they're letting
[10:42] me down.
[10:44] So I would go and prepare and then I would really definitely want to listen.
[10:50] And this, not like I invented this, someone told me once where just to acknowledge that,
[10:57] because like you said, sometimes the first of all, have the conversation, right?
[11:00] Because a lot of people just sweep it under the carpet or whatever, but just acknowledge
[11:04] that, hey, this is a difficult conversation for me to have.
[11:08] And then, you know, the other person may be like, oh, me too, you know, and then right there,
[11:13] you're kind of, it's okay not to necessarily be super articulate in the moment or whatever
[11:18] because, you know, it's just like, no, I'm not a cold, hard monster, you know, I'm, I'm,
[11:25] I'm, I'm feeling hesitant about having this conversation.
[11:29] So, absolutely.
[11:30] I like that.
[11:31] I'll, I'll do that.
[11:33] All right.
[11:34] I got you.
[11:35] You're going to have that.
[11:36] Hey, let's, some, you know, just got a couple minutes left.
[11:38] I'm wondering, I was thinking about boundaries, you know, leverage boundaries.
[11:42] That sort of thing.
[11:43] And I'm wondering, you know, when you have an effective negotiator, like, how do effective
[11:48] negotiators stay empathetic without, you know, crossing or losing boundaries, clarity, leverage,
[11:57] which is often, often comes up in the legal realm.
[12:01] Part of the preparation beforehand that I think any strong
negotiator should be doing is considering
[12:07] a few key things, including their interests, so both their own underlying interests and
[12:13] the other parties.
[12:15] And also your batna, your best alternative to a negotiated agreement.
[12:19] So it's called batna, it's the best alternative to a negotiated agreement.
[12:26] All right.
[12:27] So before going into a negotiation, I need to do the prep work to say, what, what do I have
[12:34] kind of as a backup?
[12:36] So for instance, if I am interviewing for a job that I really want, because let's say the
[12:40] culture is great, the pay is wonderful, and this is really where I want to go, but I
[12:46] do have another offer already.
[12:50] I know that it may not be my batna in this scenario, we'll just say that it is because it's
[12:55] the only offer outside of this one that I'm hoping to get that I have.
[12:59] So I know that if I do not reach an agreement, if I do not get what I need today in this negotiation,
[13:06] I do have a pretty solid kind of backup.
[13:09] So it's my best alternative.
[13:11] So I know that if let's say I have a certain salary range, and I say, I need to get this
[13:17] amount, and they're just far below it, and this other company has offered that.
[13:24] I've got to then weigh some other things that maybe not salary, but maybe it is the corporate
[13:30] culture, the environment, the PTO, those sorts of things, but are the most part, if I've done
[13:36] the work and I can sort of compare beforehand, I know that I should not take a deal if it
[13:41] doesn't reach, you know, these certain aspects that I need.
[13:47] So I know that I'm not going to end up in a worse position because I'm always going to keep
[13:51] my batna at sort of the forefront of my mind.
[13:56] The other thing that I think is really important, that I see my law students struggle with a lot
[14:02] is, I love that you use the word boundaries, because I think it's very important to all
[14:07] so remember that just because somebody asks you a question, doesn't mean you have to be
[14:13] responsive to it.
[14:15] Oh.
[14:17] Right?
[14:18] I mean, so sometimes we see students will say, we'll just tell me what your bottom line is.
[14:23] I mean, that will be the first question out of the gate.
[14:26] And then the other student, I mean, probably at least eight times out of 10 will say, oh,
[14:31] and they get flustered, they're like, well, I mean, okay, I guess I'll tell you the best
[14:35] deal.
[14:36] So well, why they didn't build rapport yet, you haven't learned anything.
[14:40] You didn't owe them that.
[14:41] You did not need to do that.
[14:43] So you can still stay firm while also being empathetic, right?
[14:48] You could still actively listen to them.
[14:50] You could still acknowledge them and their feelings.
[14:54] You can summarize what it is that they're saying, but you don't have to just give in.
[15:00] Yeah.
[15:02] Yeah.
[15:04] Exactly.
[15:05] Just respond like, oh, well, thanks for giving me the opportunity to tell you that, but
[15:10] I want to learn more about XYZ first.
[15:13] But whatever.
[15:14] Exactly.
[15:15] Yeah.
[15:16] Super cool.
[15:18] Um, what anything else you want to share with the world here on that, Megan?
[15:25] You know, I would just say when it comes to negotiating, I sort of ascribed to the, the
[15:32] the Ted Lasso model, which is be curious, not judgmental.
[15:37] That's Ted Lasso quoting Walt Whitman,
[15:39] although I think the Walt Whitman Foundation said
[15:41] that Walt Whitman never actually said that,
[15:43] but it always comes back to genuine curiosity.
[15:47] So go go into negotiation being genuinely curious
[15:50] about the other side.
[15:52] Do your prep work first, right?
[15:53] You shouldn't be like completely surprised by things
[15:55] most of the time if you've done the work beforehand.
[15:59] But if you remain curious,
[16:02] you'll learn so much more and I think be able
[16:04] to create more value for yourself and the other side.
[16:07] Oh, great, great wrap up.
[16:10] A pleasure talking to you, Megan.
[16:12] Thanks for sharing your expertise
[16:13] and your point of view, really enjoyable.
[16:16] Thank you so much.
[16:17] You bet.
[16:18] That's it for today's episode of The Empathic Edge.
[16:21] If you'd like to learn more about Megan Smith, Empathic Edge,
[16:25] and their work around negotiation,
[16:27] communication and AI-powered practice training,
[16:31] visit the website empathicedge.com.
[16:34] Thanks for listening.
[16:35] Do us a favor and leave some thumbs up.
[16:38] Maybe a review, share a link, subscribe to the podcast,
[16:42] so many things you could do.
[16:44] And we would be grateful.
[16:45] I'm Sean O'Connor.
[16:46] Have a great day.
[16:51] Thanks for watching.
[16:53] Be sure to hit that like and subscribe button
[16:56] and leave us a review in the comments.