TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Sanjay Bhojraj (00:00)
Hey everybody and welcome to this episode of the curious cardiologist podcast where we are always introducing people to you who are looking at old problems and new ways. And today we are so excited or I am so excited to have Dr. Sam Shay with us here today. Dr. Shay is a DC also like me certified through the Institute of functional medicine. You can find him at drsamshay.com and he is also the CEO founder of fit genes USA which is a
genetic testing company that actually makes genetic testing understandable in ways that you as a consumer or as health practitioners can really put things together and not just see a thousand little pieces, but how they come together to form a big picture. Does that sound about right, Dr. Shea?
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (00:46)
It sounds about right. Technically, I'm the distributor for FitGenes. FitGenes is originally in Australia, but I'm the Western Hemisphere distributor. And I'm also the worldwide lead educator for the whole company. I've been working with FitGenes for over 10 years now. They've been around for much longer than 10 years. And when I first started studying genetics, I was like, wow, this really fits my brain. I can really understand genetics. It's like the matrix. Like you see the code and stuff. Like you just see the genetics.
Sanjay Bhojraj (00:49)
Okay.
You just, and there are some people I remember when I took bio in college, like genetics and Punnett squares, and it was just so difficult. For some reason, my brain did not work that way. So I kind of had to struggle through, but you know, for some people it's like Mozart looking at a piano, right? And so it's great that your brain works that way because there is a lot of information and synthesize. ⁓ and I think more importantly, as we were talking, ⁓ before we got on, you're also a standup comedian. in a, in a former life or in a
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (01:19)
Mm-hmm.
Yeah, most importantly. Yeah, so mean, the thing for your heart is to laugh. I mean, that is science enough.
Sanjay Bhojraj (01:38)
I think you're a boy-
You know, we talk about joy, adding joy into your life is so important when it comes to the emotional side, the mental, emotional, spiritual side of cardiology. So definitely. ⁓ so let's just kind of launch in, I guess, and let's start.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (01:53)
So to that, well, let's linger on the cardiology health with humor. I was a keynote for the 2025 annual conference for the American Academy of Therapeutic Humor. That's a real organization. been around for 30 years. Patch Adams spoke there in the 90s. And they're actually the leading proponents and researchers in laughter therapy.
Sanjay Bhojraj (02:09)
Really?
makes sense.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (02:20)
and actually incorporating laughter as a therapeutic agent, and it's particularly helpful for heart health. So AATH, American Academy of Therapeutic Humor, aath.org for people that are interested in it. They actually interviewed me for their
Load full transcript
podcast as well. And it was wonderful to perform my entire one hour educational show called Neuro Spicy Love Life and Comedy on the Spectrum, because I have Asperger's Syndrome, in front of about 250 doctors.
Sanjay Bhojraj (02:31)
Mm-hmm.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (02:50)
and basically do what I wish, like the 60 minute show I made was something about living on the spectrum was what I wish, the 60 minutes I wish I had 30 years ago and my teachers, my family, the community, doctors and other gatekeepers. I got, so I'm wanting to take this show at scale and educate, know, state and national associations or teachers, counselors, principals, doctors, clinicians, coaches, therapists, you name it, because
you know, being on the spectrum is I describe it's like having several superpowers and a buffet of kryptonites and being and having, you know, just educating entire entire groups of professions at once at scale using humor is going to be the most effective way to advocate and educate on this very emergent subject. and then afterwards I did a plenary session, you know, like
I'm sorry, I'm being bit nerdy. When you have like five different speakers you can go to and you pick one. Yeah, breakout sessions. Then I did a follow-up session right after that on how to make your office more spectrum friendly from sound, scheduling, etc. All the things that go into that people may take, people with more normative brain types may just take for granted. So ⁓ I use my comedy for advocacy and
Sanjay Bhojraj (03:54)
big sessions.
Mmm.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (04:17)
an education and anyone listening, can literally just put in Dr. Sam Shay Neuro Spicy into YouTube and you'll find it. My whole show is for free on YouTube. And I've got a 12 minute highlights. I got the full 60 minute show. I've got some other clips. My same YouTube channel is also on my other interviews and information on there as well. feel free to, it's all for people who are curious, it's clean observational comedy. There's no politics. There's no cursing. There's no gratuitous body.
Sanjay Bhojraj (04:45)
It's safe for work. I watched, I watched part of it last night and it was really great. And I feel like, you know, it's funny because before we met, I already felt connected with you because you were able to share your humor. And I think as clinicians, a lot of times, you know, I think back to when I was like a first year attending, ⁓ and we want to be kind of a source of authority and, and stodgy and, know, ⁓ you know, kind of, start
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (05:10)
This is the 80s.
Sanjay Bhojraj (05:11)
starch collar and all that stuff. And what happens is it creates a barrier between you and the patient. And I feel like really impedes the therapeutic ⁓ relationship rather than make it happen. And like, if you think about when you connect with somebody, you connect through humor, right? You connect through joy, you connect through shared experience. So I love that you're sharing your journey and it just made me feel like I knew you. And I think that to your point is that we need to employ humor a little bit more, but also realizing that
where humans talking to humans, right? Like we, you know, like I tell people, I'm like, there are patients, I'm like, I'm like that guy, like your friend, that buddy that you like to hang out with that just gives financial information, like because he just knows it really well, right? He's really, really well informed in one particular area. My area just happens to be cardiology. And if you're not feeling that love with your doc, you know, that there's always gonna be a little bit of a little bit of barrier, I guess, in that relationship. So I mean, an hour, people don't realize an hour of comedy
is a lot to write and it probably takes about a thousand hours to get it down to one hour, right? Of a trial and error.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (06:11)
that they have no idea.
Yeah, it's, it's, it's, you want to, you want to assume it's about 10 hours for every minute polished minute. When you include cra ideating, crafting, practicing, editing, positioning, testing, open mics, rewriting all like it's you're, you're looking at, you're looking at a minimum of 600 hours. You you said like a thousand hours for a 60 minute show. That's about right. Like there's anywhere from 600 to a thousand hours.
It's kind of like, it's basically like a bachelor's degree. you're putting in a lot to get an hour. And I got inspired to do an hour because I listened to Tim Ferriss interview Seinfeld. And my humor is modeled after Jim Gaffigan and Seinfeld mostly. And I listened to the interview with Seinfeld and he said, can you do the hour? You're not a real, you're like.
Sanjay Bhojraj (07:01)
sure.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (07:10)
you know, can you do then you're a comic. Can you do the hour? And I was like, in my head, guess, sir, I will do the hour. And my I'm working on my second show right now, which was I grew up with a lot of chronic illness and how it became a function. It's how it became a functional medicine doctor. And I'm writing the second show to to help people who are struggling with chronic illness get better visibility, because a lot of times people look at some chronic illness and they're invisible illness.
Like, you know, heart disease, you don't know unless they're pallid and like sweating and like they're having like an acute episode or whatever.
Sanjay Bhojraj (07:45)
I mean, the most common manifestation of sudden cardiac death is sudden cardiac death. Like you don't know until it hits you, right? I mean, it's the craziest thing, but it's the truest thing. So yeah, I mean, I think definitely that communication and the intention behind the communication on stage, right? I mean, if you think about 10 hours per minute, is that what you said of polish? That informs how you approach clinical.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (07:49)
It is going to take a couple of minutes.
10 hours per minute to get an average.
Sanjay
Bhojraj (08:13)
discussions as well. has to and you're very intentional because what I've learned being on stages is that each word has a certain gravitas and you do not want to waste words. And particularly that is we shift gears into genetics. You know, this is something that can be quite scary for people. So I think interweaving some levity in the gravity certainly makes sense. And it makes this whole world a bit demystified for people probably.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (08:40)
Well, totally. mean, the one good thing about genetics is this is the one field where you can totally blame your parents.
Sanjay Bhojraj (08:49)
Yeah, totally. You can't you can choose your genes. Yeah, just it's already already the parent guilt, right?
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (08:50)
So right out of the gate, 100%, you can put this squarely at the feet of your parents. So good news, bad news, who knows? So just to give some context, I'm very interested in cardiology because one, my grandfather, who was arguably one of the most famous gastroenterologists in the West, he was the founding director of the Fells Cancer Research Center in 1937 and published over 300 scientific articles in his career.
He actually died on the operating table from medical misadventure because he had crippling claudication. And at the time, the theory was, in the medical theory, is that there was a reflex arc from an inflamed gallbladder causing pain in the heart or angina, and then this kind of downstream effect causing claudication. For people who don't know what that is, it's just pain in your legs when you're walking. from a...
Sanjay Bhojraj (09:46)
when you're walking, from narrowing in the arteries.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (09:49)
So the reflex arc theory was so they went in to take out his gallbladder and he died of a coronary on the table. And he told my father, yeah, I know, it's crazy, right? He told my father who's in the beginnings of his medical school career journey was that the carotid arteries were so thick that they couldn't fit a pin through one of the carotids. So. ⁓
Sanjay Bhojraj (09:57)
geez.
So he was what we call a vascular path. I mean, it sounds like he just head to toe had vascular issues.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (10:19)
Totally. And then my mother had an aortic dissection also in, ⁓ I think it was 2006 or something like that. And so I've got, and my father has coronary artery disease as well. my grandma died on my mother's side, of Alzheimer's and dementia. My father currently is dying of dementia. So to me, cardiovascular health is deeply personal and genetic.
Sanjay Bhojraj (10:23)
my goodness.
Well, and what people don't realize about cardiovascular health is the vasculature perfuses everything in your body, right? So when we think of the cardio side, certainly we focus on the heart, but we forget that vascular gives blood to the brain, to the eyes, nose, ears, head, shoulders, knees, and toes, all of those things. it is really, I think, of course, to a cardiologist, all the world looks like cardiovascular complaints and concerns, but it is central to everything. Not to make light of the situation, but it reminds me of this line from the Big Bang Theory.
where Harold Walowicz, if you know the character, his mom was in the hospital with chest pain because he found out that she was dating a non-Jewish girl. And so they asked him, you do you have any family history of heart disease? And it's just a line that stuck with me as a cardiologist. goes, my family is the history of heart disease. It's just so funny.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (11:35)
⁓ So, that's funny, but also on a meta level, I actually talk about Big Bang Theory in my comedy show because of this whole thing about Sheldon being on the spectrum and it's towards the end. ⁓ I won't spoil it for you since you haven't finished the show, but I specifically wrote in about several pop culture figures on the spectrum like Data, Sheldon, and a couple others.
Sanjay Bhojraj (11:43)
okay.
Mm-hmm. yeah.
Mm-hmm.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (12:04)
my, did you ever go to the body worlds exhibit with the plastic bodies? Okay, so just for people who aren't aware, but there's an exhibit called body body worlds where they take, they basically plasticate the whole body. And then they, then they fly off the skin so you can see all the organs, all the nerves, all the blood vessels. I saw just the intestinal system where they took away absolutely everything except the blood vessels.
Sanjay Bhojraj (12:11)
yeah, totally. Yeah, absolutely.
They plastinate bodies and this was.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (12:32)
and like everything except the blood vessels. And I can tell you that you could identify every single organ, every single fold of the intestines, every single nook and cranny and crevice of everything because the blood vessels are so infused and interwoven that it's the exact shape. Like literally you could point to everything.
Sanjay Bhojraj (12:34)
Yeah.
It's like the chalk outline of where things go. and I would say, the thing about the circulatory system is it has a finite volume with an infinite surface area, right? Because it has to give, so it's amazing. I mean, we're gonna geek out about cardiology stuff, but we'll need to get back to genomics and genetics. ⁓ to your point, so several members of your family have developed cardiovascular disease or manifest cardiovascular disease. And I think one of the things that,
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (12:56)
Three dimensional, like yeah.
Sanjay Bhojraj (13:21)
that we don't do a great job in the conventional world of cardiology is really looking at upstream genetic factors that may predispose, right? So we'll talk about blood pressure or cholesterol or blood sugar as these lifestyle things and whatnot that may be affected. And for blood pressure, we're giving meds, right? For cholesterol, we're giving meds, but we're not getting into the why blood pressure is high. Why is your cholesterol high, right? Why is your sugar
off? ⁓ And that's really where I think
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (13:37)
I still wait but yeah.
Sanjay Bhojraj (13:50)
Genetic testing is a powerful tool for us to add, not to subtract from anything else, but to add, to really inform us of cardiovascular risk, and I think ways that we can avoid that risk with just diet and lifestyle changes.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (14:05)
Yeah, say instead of, frame it on genetics not as adding, it's something I say it's foundational. I'd say it's like the place that people should start. And the way to understand genetics is functional genetics. So the difference between Western genetics and functional genetics. Western genetics is very, Western genetics versus functional genetics is very much the same dialogue and debate between Pasteur and Boucans. And in...
germ theory according to Pasteur, it's like one germ causes one disease, where Boucamp, who was his competitor, said it's actually the terrain, not the germ. So you can throw seeds onto concrete, nothing's gonna happen. You throw them into fertile soil, then they're sprout. So in Western genetics, it's a similar thing, like what's the one gene that causes the one disease? It's equivalent of germ theory. And then in functional genetics, it's not necessarily one gene causes one disease. So that does happen. It's what is the...
clustering of genes and what is the behavior that triggers these genes to behave in a specific way as opposed to some deterministic thing like oh you have this gene you're and kind of the classic case is you know, Baraka 2 where oh you're gonna get breast cancer well 50 % of women of Baraka 2 don't get breast cancer 50 % do so but why is it 50 % don't and that would be lifestyle and other epigenetic factors and things like that and then
Sanjay Bhojraj (15:02)
What's the neighborhood? It goes up right here.
Right.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (15:29)
again, use this term, epigenetics, basically understand epigenetics. It's how your external environment and internal environment affects how your genes express. It's better to think genes of as like a dial, like a readout on a dial than a switch. your genes are, like you can think of your dials as having a green zone, a yellow zone, and a red zone, like a traffic light. And that's where we have like the green dot, yellow dot, and red dot.
in genetics where you have a green dot is two good copies, one from mom, one from dad. A yellow dot is one bad copy from mom or dad and one good copy from mom or dad. And a quote red dot is two, two quote bad copies of one bad from mom and one from bad copy from dad. So if you instead just don't think of them as like switches, but they're actually dials and needles that move. And if someone is born with a green dot in
in ⁓ overall in their cluster of inflammation control, that means their default setting in life is low inflammation. If they've got a cluster of inflammatory genes that are on average about a yellow, that means their default setting is that they're
just kind of ambiently inflamed. Red is like they're very ambient, they're red, they're very inflamed. Yellow in almost all cases, and we're looking at health genetics, does not mean middle of the road, benign, meh, whatever. It's actually a slightly less worse version of a red dot.
Sanjay Bhojraj (16:43)
Right.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (16:53)
We take yellows as seriously as red dots in this space with a couple exceptions, but just in general, don't think of a yellow dot as, it's fine. No, it's not. It's not fine.
Sanjay Bhojraj (17:05)
Right. And I think this gets into kind of a lot of the heavier side of testing, but let's maybe step back a little bit because as we were talking before, you're talking about five categories of labs, five general categories of labs. genetic testing is certainly one part. And I like how you said it's foundational because I think we have to think of it differently. In the battle days before we had genetic testing readily available, was something of like science fiction. You mentioned data from Star Trek, right? Like it was something like very, you know,
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (17:15)
Yeah.
Sanjay Bhojraj (17:32)
science fiction and all that stuff now, luckily through the human genome project and better technologies, we can get a lot faster. But there's still almost like this sci-fi approach or at least thought, residual thought kind of momentum that happens in the conventional world. But getting back to like the foundational, what are these five categories of labs that you like to talk about?
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (17:53)
So, genetics is the foundational of the five. if you know, the way to understand genetics as a foundation is that genetics will tell you how you're optimized to live and where your fault lines are. Where's the weak points in your chain? Because if you don't shore up those weak points, they will show up. So, when people say, I don't want to know my genetics. Well, you're going to find out anyway. You're going to find out.
Sanjay Bhojraj (18:14)
Right.
one way the other. it's yeah, it's like, it's like being a priest. Eventually the sins will come out, right? Like, well.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (18:22)
like it's, it's your symptomatology and your diseases and your symptomatology will show up anyway. You might as well know what's coming. And more importantly, through epigenetics and you can actually figure out what things you can do to shift that needle from being your red and yellow dots will never become green, but they can behave green like. So that's what epigenetics does is that it makes the behavior of your genes change to behave like a green dot, even though it will never be a green.
Sanjay Bhojraj (18:52)
And that's why I'll have to say genes are not your destiny, right? Your genes are not your destiny. And. Right.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (18:56)
They're fixed, but flexible. That's the flexibility. So it's like you have a range and a set point, or your reset point, your default zone, but the flexibility is your lifestyle and environment that can make it swing in one direction or the other, which is actually an empowering message. You can just do something about it. So genetics is the foundation. And what you can learn from genetics is your optimal diet. You can learn, you ideally suited for more of a keto style, paleo style, Mediterranean style, or high carb style diet that exists now.
Sanjay Bhojraj (19:11)
It is.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (19:26)
You can identify if you're genetically vulnerable to certain trigger foods like caffeine-induced anxiety and depression. Sorry bulletproof coffee drinkers. Are you sensitive to histamine? Are you sensitive to gluten, to lactose, to food allergens? Do you have genetic vulnerabilities to your eating behaviors? Like are you genetically less likely to feel full after normal amounts of food? If so, don't fight your willpower, change your environment.
That's if you've got other genes where you crave sugar more than others, don't fight your willpower, change your environment so sugar's not in your environment so you can't lose even if you crave sugar. So some of these genes may seem like, my God, I'm doomed. No, you just change your environment so you can't lose despite your genetic vulnerability.
Sanjay Bhojraj (20:11)
Well, and I love what you talked about there because I'll talk about nutrigenomics all the time. Some people, you you read a book, you mentioned bulletproof, right? So somebody reads a book and they say, man, I'm going to put a stick of butter in my coffee and I'm going to be healthy. And they show up on my cath lab table in their mid thirties with cardiovascular events, right? Because they're just not designed for that. ⁓ so I want to kind of. Yeah. So, so maybe before we kind of move on, I would love to explore this because it's something I think is so important. ⁓ particularly as I.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (20:30)
Yeah, they're API.
Sanjay Bhojraj (20:39)
do a lot of counseling on diet and lifestyle is this APOE gene, which is, think, probably the one that you're referring to as probably the most common. But what are some of the other clusters of genes that are really important that help determine what the best diet will be for you as an individual?
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (20:53)
The histo- so number one, would be histamine sensitivity. So the big ones in terms of daily consumption that people need, that call it as a trigger food category, I already mentioned some of them. What's your relationship to lactose, sugar or dairy? What's your relationship to gluten? Are you vulnerable to celiac disease if you have gluten? If you are genetically vulnerable, don't have gluten, period, not negotiable. ⁓ Are you genetically vulnerable to caffeine? Meaning, can you get caffeine-induced anxiety and depression? Are you genetically vulnerable to alcohol?
Sanjay Bhojraj (21:12)
Yeah.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (21:21)
Are you genetically vulnerable to histamines? Histamine is part of the
inflammatory pathway. I call it the body's emergency flood switch. A bee stings your arm. The bee didn't inject a half quart of water into your arm. Instead, your body pulled the flood switch called histamine to drown and dilute venom from the bee sting so it wouldn't destroy tissues, muscles, nerves, arteries, and flesh, and so on. But if you eat high histamine foods and you're genetically vulnerable to histamine, that's the equivalent of consuming a slow-moving full-body bee sting.
and people who have histamine sensitivity, they start to swell with water weight. They get brain fog, digestion issues, their fatigue, you know, they're just globally inflamed.
Sanjay Bhojraj (21:55)
That's
And they keep going back because they don't know.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (22:03)
Yeah, like avocados, like it's actually in my comedy set. I have a whole section on histamine intolerance. I say, say this, set the program is in Boulder in front of 180 people. And I said, and some health foods are high in histamine, including, and I say this at great personal risk.
avocados. And 180 people started booing me. Yeah, actually, I said, Are you a part of the Are you part of big avocado? I said, you're part of big avocado. And, and then so that let them boo as I let them let them boo me. And I was just pause and let them boo me. And then I turned to my notes. And I said literally says in my notes to wait for booing to subside. And just this person laughter about from a comic standpoint, just a little meta thing.
Sanjay Bhojraj (22:21)
Yeah.
The Avocado Mafia is real.
Pick up.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (22:48)
My favorite type of joke is when you intentionally bomb a joke as a setup to the next joke and the audience doesn't know they've been played. And when they realize they've been played, it's just wonderful for everybody.
Sanjay Bhojraj (22:53)
yeah.
I it's almost like an Andy Kaufman kind of, you know, but he would do, he would do like an entire set of bomb. That's like, that's like next, next level. But, but to your point, it's funny because in my, the, the program that I run, the cardiometabolic program that I run, ⁓ avocados are out for the first six weeks because they can be an inflammatory trigger foods that were low histamine kind of all these things. And I live here in California and the amount of groans and pushback, it's almost easier for me to tell people not to drink alcohol for six weeks.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (23:02)
Totally.
No, that's I'm not that masochistic. Andy was a different person. No, no, no, no, no.
Nice to meet you.
Okay, so in my set, I have to say this, in my set, I literally have things, ⁓ it's like, you tell California that avocados are bad, then California will secede. Like, California will secede if you poop on their avocados, yeah.
Sanjay Bhojraj (23:30)
than to avoid avocado.
California exit, like forget about it. Well, and if you ever need to kind of temper your avocado enthusiasm, Netflix does always a great job of taking things you
love and making a haze them after a documentary. But there's an avocado documentary that I watched about how the cartels are taking over and diverting rivers from villages and all that stuff. it'll temper your enthusiasm for avocados, but you know,
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (24:05)
By the way.
then for, know, almonds, almonds take something like thousands of gallons of water to make one pound of almonds, you know, in California. Yeah. So, so going, going back to like how much genetics and diet. So you have the, the, the, the trigger foods, gents that are genetically based. have the eating behaviors that are genetically based. Then you have, are you keto, paleo, Mediterranean, or high carb, which is genetically based. Then you've got, are you.
Sanjay Bhojraj (24:15)
Yeah, it's a very thirsty plant.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (24:37)
pro-inflammatory as such genetically. And if you are very pro-inflammatory, that means that you have to eat an anti-inflammatory diet more so than other people because when you look at the genes that I run, I run about 140 genes and I don't look for quote disease genes. Those are downstream. I look for these cluster of dietary genes. Then I look at the genes that account for the seven drivers of
Sanjay Bhojraj (24:39)
Hmm.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (25:06)
chronic disease. And there's a priority to them, which is really important to understand. Not all genes have equal priority when it comes to health. In fact, cardiology genes are downstream from inflammatory genes. So the drivers of disease in order of priority are number one, inflammation. There's about, and not just the genes of inflammation, because there's hundreds of those that directly or indirectly affect inflammation. You want the top
most important genes for inflammation, which there are about 15 or 16.
Sanjay Bhojraj (25:39)
like NF Kappa B and a bunch of interleukins probably.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (25:41)
⁓ So it's not it's actually not an on a camp to be it's actually interleukin. It's three interleukin 10 interleukin ones interleukin 6 TNF alpha interleukin 8 interleukin 18 CRP genes cox genes There's three CRP genes two to three cox genes and three interleukin 10 genes later I Am that's where my glasses
Sanjay Bhojraj (25:49)
Mm-hmm.
We have just dropped nerdiness to a new level, but I love it. It makes sense. It makes sense to me. Here, I'll put my glasses on.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (26:07)
But even more, and I have some debate with the chief science officer of genes. I actually think the VDR genes, VDR1 and 2, are actually more important than the inflammatory genes. Vitamin D receptor genes. So vitamin D for context. So the original order is the inflammatory genes are priority one, 15, 16 of those. The next one are the three most important genes for...
Sanjay Bhojraj (26:19)
Which are the vitamin D receptor genes?
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (26:33)
is quenching free radicals in the mitochondria. So that's MnSod, GPX1, and catalase. And 95 % of all your free
radicals are made in your mitochondria. For people to understand the analogy, when you burn a log on a campfire in the presence of oxygen, you get sparks. So when you burn protein, amino acids, carbohydrates, and fat in your mitochondria, you generate sparks. Those sparks are called free radicals. Now you need to catch the sparks
Sanjay Bhojraj (26:47)
You smoke.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (27:02)
because if you don't, like at a campfire, things will catch on fire that should not catch on fire. And in this case, in the mitochondria, the mitochondria will catch on fire, which is bad. So you've got these three janitors, MN sod, GPX1, cat, MN sod, or I call Mr. sod, he's the head janitor. Yeah, and Mr. sod, he's the head janitor. They quench, Mr. sod, MN sod quenches, I think it's like four million free radicals a second.
Sanjay Bhojraj (27:18)
Superoxide does me taste.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (27:31)
or something insane. It's like,
Sanjay Bhojraj (27:32)
I mean, when you think about the biology of humans in existence, it's mind boggling.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (27:35)
It's like it's something crazy. So if he's slower because you have a red or yellow dot and MN-SAWD, then you can't catch all the free radicals and things will start to catch on fire, which shouldn't catch on fire. So you've got inflammation, free radical scavenging, mitochondria, then liver detox. So you've got phase one, phase two, you got genes in there. Then you have the VDR receptors. Now, I, through clinical observation, saw that 100 % of my chronically ill clients
100 % with only one exception, one exception only, had a double green in their VDRs who are chronically ill. Every other one had double yellows, double reds, or red and yellow in their VDR1, VDR2. The exception was that this individual had horrific stress of an inch I won't describe on air that would drive anyone to chronic disease. Everyone else chronic disease had yellows and reds their VDR1s and 2s.
Sanjay Bhojraj (28:12)
So they had a quote unquote.
So.
Okay, so the two green alleles or the good alleles, they were healthy and anybody with an abnormality of D receptor had some level of chronic disease.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (28:38)
chronic now just to be fair I just want to acknowledge I had a selection bias in my practice because people were coming to see me usually when they were unwell so but but that still is valid because if I every single one except one of them that was chronically unwell had reds and yellows and then so
Sanjay Bhojraj (28:48)
Mm.
So in other words, we know the numerator, not necessarily the denominator. Right.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (29:01)
Correct. So what happened is that I contacted two science officer and I said, look, you have access to the master database and the other practitioners who run a lot of volume on this. I see the VDR connection to chronic disease. Can you please check this with the other people and your database? came back to you about a month or so later and said, you're absolutely right. There's a correlation. I think the VDRs are actually the top priority. And here's the connection to inflammation. It's not actually separate because vitamin D, though people think it's for bone density,
Sanjay Bhojraj (29:20)
And it
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (29:30)
It is, it does that, hooray, good for it. Put it on its resume. The vast majority of what vitamin D does is control inflammation in your immune system. It controls between three to five percent of your entire human genome. That's 1 20th to 1 33rd of your entire human genome. So to me, VDRs are related to the inflammation, the top priority. So you've got...
Sanjay Bhojraj (29:50)
Yeah. And, and I think you're right. We anchor on one function. It's like in the Seinfeld when he said, you know, the wizard is just a tip calculator, right? And Jerry goes crazy. ⁓ but, but vitamin D you've got literally receptors on every cell except maybe red blood cells, right? In your body. Yeah. But, but it, so that speaks to how important it is. And it's funny because I'm one of those people that I just always run low with my vitamin D. I was running, you know, training for a marathon. I was outside all the time. My vitamin D was low. I supplement.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (30:05)
I it's their blood cells and dead skin cells.
Sanjay Bhojraj (30:20)
And I have vitamin D receptor polymorphisms and that is scary, right? Like, like what do I do? Like, do I get gene therapy? What happens? I don't, I don't know what that's going to look like. I control, I control the best I can. Yeah. It's not going to help.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (30:29)
So taking more vitamin D will only help up to a point if there is not even enough vitamin D to fill what few receptors you have, but to actually increase the transcription or VDR receptors. Number one, you have to avoid smoking, have to avoid pollution, and then sulforaphane is the thing that has been shown to upregulate vitamin D receptors. But the one thing about sulforaphane people may not know,
is you really can't take it with any high amounts of antioxidants because the mechanism of action of sulforaphane is that it's a hormetic effect, which means it's a mild pro-oxidant. So if you give it with vitamin A, C, E, selenium, or enough of those things, it'll muzzle the pro-oxidant mechanism and not make it work. so... ⁓
Sanjay Bhojraj (31:17)
My body is so complicated. Yeah, here I am thinking I'm doing a great job eating broccoli sprouts, but... ⁓
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (31:22)
Well, I'll add some other complications to your, it's hard to ruin your breakfast, but what happens is that there's over 300 varieties of broccoli and not all of them have the sprouts of the correct ratio of morassinase to glucoraphanin. I learned this directly from Dr. Houghton, who's been studying sulforaphane for several decades in Australia. Sulforaphane is one of those things where you're honestly better off just doing the supplementation because you cannot guarantee your
broccoli sprouts have the correct ratio of
Sanjay Bhojraj (31:26)
⁓ no.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (31:52)
enzyme and substrate to join together to make the sulforaphane in your gut. You can't guarantee it.
Sanjay Bhojraj (31:55)
my god.
I'm just gonna jump off a bridge. you know, but life is a lethal condition, I guess, right? So we all go out at some point, but.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (32:03)
that in a while. So seven drivers, we've inflammation, free radicals, liver detox, vitamin D receptors, then methylation, then methylation. So I heard Gary Brekha on Rogan in December of 23 and I started yelling, or 24, I started yelling into my mic on my phone. I was so angry. He was like, five genes for methylation, all you need. He's like, dude, Gary's a great teacher in a lot of things, but methylation is not. And when I get angry, I make a PowerPoint. And I did, I,
Sanjay Bhojraj (32:11)
And everyone loves talking about methylation, right? Everyone loves.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (32:33)
I found all my citations to show that methylation is downstream from inflammation and I went on three podcasts, hour each minimum and just ripped it apart with their articles. And like for people who think, you use your methylation genes, you're out of your mind. It's a fifth priority from the top, not the top priority. Then after methylation with cardiovascular health and blood pressure, then we have fat and energy metabolism. the whole point of this is that
Sanjay Bhojraj (32:58)
Hmm.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (33:02)
When you run a genetics test, you really want to work with a company or a practitioner that understands that genes have a priority. If you're concerned about chronic illness, you got to think about your dietary genes and then these drivers of chronic disease genes. It's because when your inflammation genes are provoked long enough and strong enough, that's when they poke on the quote disease genes downstream. I don't run genes to find the quote cancer gene, the quote heart disease gene.
the quote dementia gene, the quote diabetes gene. don't run those types of genes. I'm looking at the upper level drivers of what I just mentioned in order of priority. And now how is that practical? What do you do about that? So say someone has across your inflammation free radical liver vitamin D methylation genes, that's about 40 of the 70 odd genes of the O7 drivers. You've got about 25 or so of those top 40.
are red and yellow dots, meaning that they've got bad variations on them. So then what I wanna do is then what I do do, I'm not saying what I wanna do, I'm what I do, is that I find the interventions that show in peer-reviewed research done on humans, not wombats or nematodes, that the nutrigenomic or lifestyle or dietary change alone will shift the genetic expression from behaving like a red or yellow dot into a green dot. So meaning, I wanna find the one recommendation
Sanjay Bhojraj (34:02)
Mm-hmm.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (34:30)
shown in human trials that's just
lifestyle diet or supplement wise that will change not one gene but 10 of those.
Sanjay Bhojraj (34:40)
Well, and I think of it like that, like a pyramid, right? Like a wedge, right? Is changing that top thing will change all the underlying. I love that triaged approach because if you're taking care of inflammation, right? I've said this for years, atherosclerosis is a bad term. really should be atheroscleritis because it's inflammatory in nature. ⁓ Blood pressure is an inflammatory condition, right? Like, like damage of cholesterol that causes immune activation. These are all inflammatory.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (34:57)
I haven't heard that. That makes total sense to me. Thanks for sharing that. ⁓
Sanjay Bhojraj (35:10)
situations. So by taking care of one, you're not just taking care of cardiovascular health, also, by the way, cancer, right? Also, by the way, autoimmune, your body attacking itself. So it really just elegantly, I think, lays out that the framework where both functional medicine trained of that root cause medicine, really looking at the genetics and how that informs that entire cascade of things that can go sideways.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (35:33)
In fact, the entire, the chief science officer mentioned Dr. Beaver, I've got two, he doesn't really give interviews anymore, but let me interview him. I interviewed him once in 2017 and once in 2019. They're on my YouTube channel. If you want to listen, look directly from the horse's mouth. The reason why he was a PhD engineer, not a doctor, because his parents, then his parents both developed cancer and he switched his genius in engineering to genetics because he was concerned about his health, his...
Sanjay Bhojraj (35:46)
And we'll link your YouTube channel so that everyone can find this.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (36:02)
his grandkids health. Now, him being an engineer is to his credit because what do engineers do? They are concerned solely with what works. What can we look at that's reliable every single time to get a very specific, predictable outcome? So he's the one who read over 5,000 genetics articles personally. He's the one who figured out the seven drivers and figured out what genes are the highest priority within those drivers and then figured out which
Sanjay Bhojraj (36:07)
analyze.
technical. ⁓
Yikes.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (36:31)
recommendations and what human review studies would then properly cross-link to then you pick the fewest number of interventions that help the most number of the highest priority genes. And he did it because he was scared about cancer and he did not go researching cancer genes. He went researching the drivers, the upstream drivers, those seven things we mentioned. whether it's, and then, cardiovascular disease is there and it's also, it's one of those downstream effects. And so when I look at my family history and the
rife amount of neurodegeneration and cardiovascular disease. And also my grandfather, my mother said had cancer. ⁓ Like I'm
deeply, deeply committed to genetics, if anything, because I just want to avoid as you know, the fate of what happened to my prior generations there. my, so when you're looking at genetics, ⁓ really, really important to have a model
Sanjay Bhojraj (37:20)
Absolutely.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (37:31)
where you're looking at the drivers of chronic disease that the recommendations are prioritized so you don't get overwhelmed with 300 health tips. Like here's the top five, start there. And you want to have genes that organize your diet, which are one the biggest epigenetic influences of your whole life. And then there's also genes on exercise, like what's the best type of exercise to do to have the highest performance? And then also what's your recovery reality like? Do you have weak collagen genes and are you at risk for X…
Sanjay Bhojraj (37:40)
Right.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (38:00)
exercise-induced inflammation which can cause injury. So then you got to focus on a recovery. And this is, you see like this all the time in the CrossFit community, people who over exercise and they develop, they get fatter. They put on water weight because they're retaining water from all the inflammation from over exercising because their genes can't handle that amount of heavy exercise.
Sanjay Bhojraj (38:21)
Well, and I had genomic testing done, genetic testing done. And it's funny that you mentioned CrossFit because I stopped because everybody I knew was like covered in KT tape. Like there was always some injury happening or something. And so now as you say, you know, we didn't realize there's probably a genetic influence of how your body is able to repair, right? How you're able to detox. You mentioned, you know, all the reactive oxygen species and, know, CrossFit is intense when you do it. ⁓ and so you're just not giving yourself that recovery time and what most athletes, well,
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (38:31)
injuries.
Sanjay Bhojraj (38:50)
what most professional athletes get that most recreational athletes don't is your recovery time is just as important, if not more important, than your performance time. And so you need to get those adaptive responses. And I don't think anyone's really talking about the genetic propensity towards that. So maybe you
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (39:01)
Totally.
I literally gave a conference talk at the Fit Genes conferences on exercise-induced obesity, which sounds like a paradox, but it had nothing to do with calories. It had everything to do with water retention from excess inflammation. And by the way, the clusters, they had their VDRs had variations. Their interleukin-10s had variations. TNF-alpha, interleukin-6. Interestingly enough, ⁓ their CRP genes had inflammation.
Sanjay Bhojraj (39:16)
Yeah.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (39:38)
variations, which CRP codes for the acute phase inflammation protein in the liver. So the liver is responsible for a lot, but a lot of it's dealing with inflammation. Now, if your liver genes already are vulnerable to inflammation, when you get inflamed like from over-exercising, now like your liver is just like on fire all the time, and so you can't clear it, and then you suddenly start retaining tons of water because your body like diluting that B-venom, inflammation is a toxic chemical.
So your body's retaining water between the cells called the interstitia and you swell up with water. That's why you see a lot of people in CrossFit. They may look strong, but you can't see their definition because they've got this like watery, ruddy water weight that's covering over their muscle. Yeah. So that's the overview of genetics. That's the foundational lab people should be getting for chronic, not only for chronic, ⁓ for concerns around chronic issues.
Sanjay Bhojraj (40:21)
It's there's just something in between. Yeah, for sure. Yeah.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (40:36)
But if you're wanting to optimize, mean, you can't optimize unless you know your genetics. You simply can't do it. so that would be genetics. And the other four categories of testing for people who want to look at old problems in new ways, the next category of testing is gut testing. Now there's three different subcategories of gut testing. There's the big gut tests, GI map, GI effects, GI 360, CDSA, you know.
The ones that look at your microbiome, hidden infections, digestion markers, inflammatory markers, gluten antibodies, intestinal permeability markers. That's the real core one. Then you've got SIBO testing, small intestinal bacteria. And then I haven't found a CIFO test. If you find one, let me know. Fungal overgrowth. I haven't found an official one yet. I just kind of infer, but otherwise.
Sanjay Bhojraj (41:13)
those things, zonulin, kind of all the things. Yeah.
Small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, yeah.
Sure. Small intestinal fungal overgrowth, which is going to be fun.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (41:32)
then the third gut test would be your food intolerance testing, like your ⁓ IgG, Ig antibodies and whatnot. So that's one category, is the gut testing. The second category is hormone testing.
Sanjay Bhojraj (41:43)
So genomics, GI, gut testing, gotcha.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (41:45)
Hormones, so you got adrenals, sex hormones, thyroid, melatonin you can either get with your sex hormones or your adrenal testing. but basically it's adrenals, sex hormones, thyroid, and melatonin you can kind of tack on to at least two of them. And hormones, that'd be whole other 10 hour conversation, but those are the tests you should think of. And just a little caveat, functional testing, does it include medical thyroid testing and functional thyroid testing? Medical thyroid testing is you get your TSH,
And if you beg and kick and scream and get exert, know, pull enough pity from your primary, they may, may give you a free T4 if you're lucky or maybe a T3. But, but functional testing for thyroid is a minimum of these six. TSH, free T3, free T4, reverse T3, anti-TPO, anti-TG. There are others,
total T3, total T4, anti-TSH receptor antibodies, a couple other odd denotes, whatever. But just those original six are the ones you really should
Sanjay Bhojraj (42:21)
may get a free T-Code. Right. Yeah.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (42:45)
focus on. ⁓ So that's hormones. we got genetics, gut hormones. A fourth category is mitochondria and metabolism. Mitochondria metabolism is this is your organic acids testing, amino acids testing, fatty acid testing, ⁓ minerals, your irons, your blood sugars, these, whether it's C-peptide or insulin or hemoglobin A1C.
Sanjay Bhojraj (42:55)
Yes, let's talk about this.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (43:10)
inflammatory markers are usually chucked in, they're like high-sensitivity, active protein, CBC, CMP. It's a huge, I I helped design one of the largest mitochondria tests in the world. It's called the NutriStat. And it's like 240 to one, I can't remember, 240s metabolites on it. It's enormous. It's a huge test. But the mitochondria,
Sanjay Bhojraj (43:33)
It's a beast. It's a beast.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (43:39)
Testing is really important for people who are wanting to optimize their brain, their heart, because there's so much mitochondria in the heart.
Sanjay Bhojraj (43:46)
30 % by weight of your heart is mitochondria.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (43:50)
That's, I didn't know that. Thank you. That's interesting. And your mitochondria test and metabolism test also functions as your micronutrient testing. Are you missing in these different nutrients in one, whether it's an amino acid, a fatty acid, a mineral or B vitamin or otherwise. So then you've got the last category from genetics, gut hormones, mitochondria, metabolism. The fifth one is called very scientifically, the weird stuff. So the weird stuff.
Sanjay Bhojraj (43:52)
Yeah. Yeah. File that away.
metabolism in my cognitive.
leftover.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (44:21)
No, mold, metals, environmental toxins, lime, and other weird infections.
Sanjay Bhojraj (44:26)
Yeah. Which I mean, expose home is fascinating. You know, the idea of the expose home and something that I was supposed to as a kid a hundred years later could hit me, but yeah, it is. It's the things that you don't link together temporally, right? Is that you could have exposed, had a tick bite years ago and now, you know, 10 years later manifesting.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (44:34)
Totally.
Like me. Yeah. Yeah. had I got to bit by tick when I was a kid in summer camp and I didn't figure out I had Lyme's disease till my 30s. I had been suffering my whole life with Lyme disease. So so the thing about the weird stuff and why it's all in one category is because unfortunately if you have one of the weird things you usually accumulate the others because your immune system gets weakened and then the other things begin to play. For example you get mold poisoning.
Sanjay Bhojraj (44:50)
Wow. Cheers.
Hmm.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (45:10)
Then suddenly people have symptoms of dormant Lyme that became reactive or dormant Epstein-Barr or now they started accumulating heavy metals because like your body is now just so overburdened with dealing with all this other stuff. It can't put detox or fend off or keep dormant the other things. Yeah.
Sanjay Bhojraj (45:24)
It's in survival mode, right? So it's just trying to do what it can so all this other stuff builds up. Absolutely.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (45:31)
So those are the five categories if people are wanting to have a framework around understanding optimal, around testing to go from chronic to normal or from normal to optimal. Same five test categories. ⁓ Genetics, hormone, mitochondria, slash metabolism, weird stuff. Those are the five.
Sanjay Bhojraj (45:53)
Simple. I mean, it's a great framework. Let's talk about fit genes a little bit here. ⁓
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (45:58)
By the way, I cardiac, I forgot. I put cardiac markers in the mitochondrial metabolism, to, yeah. Yeah, APL, lipids, all that stuff, yeah. Just, I've been making sense on the cardiology show. I should mention that, I forgot to.
Sanjay Bhojraj (46:03)
Yeah. I mean, as would I like, so like advanced lipids and all that stuff. definitely, yeah. Sorry. Don't worry. I don't take offense. yeah. It's funny because I equate a lot of cardiovascular disease with mitochondrial disease. You know, we talk about heart failure clearly, but there's evidence in atherosclerosis and hypertension. In fact, I'm doing a lecture at the end of this month for, for Jeff Bland's PLMI, ⁓ group, a webinar on the association of mitochondrial disease and cardiovascular disease. So I think, you know, we,
That's when people ask me about why I'm a functional cardiologist and if everyone else is a dysfunctional cardiologist, my snarky answer is yeah, because we're thinking of things the wrong way, right? We're just treating the top layer, the surface layer, but not really getting to your point, kind of that foundational stuff. I think mitochondrial health is so important as you mentioned for cognition, for brain, and the way that genetically we use fuel becomes very important. In fact, one of the most interesting things that came up was as we get older, our mitochondria,
shift from free fatty acid metabolism to glucose metabolism. ⁓ And that's right around the time most people started to become insulin resistant. So now the favorite fuel of your mitochondria, and you probably know this as well, with all your work with mitochondrial health, the favorite fuel now becomes less available. So you're going to send out distress signals and you're going to have a lot more reactive oxygen species because you're going through all these alt pathways to generate energy. it's just beautiful how the biochemistry makes sense ⁓ when you understand the clinical side and the
the molecular bio side of this. mean, we can drop nerdy forever, but getting back to the testing that you do, I think that one of the things I credit the Human Genome Project for was really kind of making a great
awareness of this. For better or for worse, there are companies like 23andMe and Ancestry that you gave it out for Christmas. You swab your cheeks and you get this great report back, but there is a big concern with the quality.
right of the testing and not getting the right genetic information that is spit out on these reports. And so that's why I think it's so important to go with a company that's doing the right like NGS sequencing and using the right things. So as it comes to...
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (48:15)
Yeah, I'm not a fan of spit testing. Cheek swabs, I think, are much more accurate because you're getting cells. It's much closer. You're getting actual cells. We do cheek swab testing. There's some results you can't get from a 23andMe or Ancestry, or frankly, most other tests, because there's a three-dimensionality to the genetics testing that very few companies know about, and that's called copy variant analysis.
Sanjay Bhojraj (48:24)
you're getting the actual cell genetic material. ⁓
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (48:45)
And so that's looking at not what color dot your gene is, if it's a good green dot, double dot. It's actually looking at how many duplicates the gene has. And so when we talked about that test that checks for are you more keto style, paleo style, Mediterranean style, or high carb style diet, that's looking at the copy variant analysis of the Amy1 gene that makes salivary amylase. So what it means, in simpler terms, is imagine your digestion is a fork.
Sanjay Bhojraj (48:51)
Good, or ugly. Yeah.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (49:13)
And now you've got carbs charging your fort like Vizigoths in the medieval days. And you've to mow down these Vizigoths with cannons. So the number of cannons is the number of copies of these genes that make the enzyme amylase. And it's additive. If I've got two copies of this gene, I can make 2X C-mino-cellulose amylase. If I have 10 copies, I make 10X. And in this gene in particular, some of these companies say, we checked the variation of amy1. The variation.
in this case between yellow, green, and red is quite trivial. That's one of the rare cases where it is actually trivial, the variation. So it doesn't matter really what green, yellow, red does. It just matters the number of cannons. I'd rather have 10 cannons than one. So people who have few numbers of cannons can't really break down carbs that well. And for me, example, like I did this test in 2016, 10 years ago, just over 10 years, or maybe, actually over 10 years ago, because if you count 16, anyway, it doesn't matter.
The math, not just, so 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, okay, anyway. I was eating a perfect Mediterranean diet, all organic, local, I knew my names and my farmers and my farmers' chickens. Like it was that the quinoa was grown by left-handed monks and harvested in the last wolf moon, know, all this, whatever. And I was still having digestive.
Sanjay Bhojraj (50:10)
There's a big hole in the COVID era, like whatever.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (50:38)
mood and energy variations and fluctuations through the day. And then when I got my genetics test back, had of the 20 copies you can have of this AME1 gene, I had a grand total of two. I had the second lowest carb tolerance you can have. So I was eating from, I was eating appropriately for Mediterranean, which is, you know, on the lower carb Mediterranean is a five, high end carb one is an eight. So between five and eight is more Mediterranean.
Average is about six in Mediterranean. So I was eating like, it was just way beyond my carb capacity. And within one week of shifting my diet to more low carb paleo, my energy, my mood and my digestive issues leveled out. and you can't get that from a 23-millimeter ancestry because it's not even looking at the number of duplicates of the genes. In fact, when we do it,
People are sent two swabs if they're gonna do both of those tests. They've got one swab for the 140 odd variations like the other dietary influences like trigger foods, eating behaviors, and then those genes for the seven drivers of chronic illness and the exercise genes. That's one swab. The other swab is completely devoted to the copy number for this AME1 gene to help determine if you're keto, paleo, Mediterranean, or hikers.
Sanjay Bhojraj (51:55)
And I think that is so important because, and you, you know, I'm, part of several Facebook groups and online and people are always asking me, what's the best diet. And really my answer is it depends because it does depend. Right. And we've all seen that. Like, it's funny that you talk about CrossFit because there are people that would go on pure keto and they would do great and other people's would puff up. Right. Like, like, and, and like me, for instance, I've gotten April for a single April for a gene. And so that's not great for me to go on a keto diet. Like it would set my.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (52:14)
too terrible. They would do absolutely terrible.
Sanjay Bhojraj (52:24)
blood vessels on fire, whereas if you're a 2-2 or a 2-3, I don't think there's a ton of 2-3s, but a 2-2, you can actually do better with a pure fat diet. it really just depends. And maybe in our last few moments here, we can talk about, which we may should have talked about before, is what do you think are the maybe misconceptions and the things that you wish people really understood about themselves to reach optimal health as informed by their genes? Does that make sense?
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (52:53)
The misconceptions about how to reach optimal health as informed by their genes.
Sanjay Bhojraj (52:56)
Like the misconceptions people have about what healthy is when they don't know about their genes. I don't know if that question makes sense, like how do people make sense of using their genomics, their genetic data to really reach optimal health, right? It's a very basic question.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (53:05)
Okay, so...
So I think it's really the question about the definitions around health because
in the Western canon, health is defined as an absence of bothersome symptoms. So when they say like, you know, hundred healthy subjects, which us is no, that means asymptomatic. It doesn't mean healthy. And like you're a cardiologist. It's like the 50 % of the time, the first symptom of cardiac problems is death.
Sanjay Bhojraj (53:36)
Right, as we talked about in.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (53:37)
Like, so the thing about the human body is that it does an amazing job suppressing any subjective experience of ill health. Up until it gets so bad, your body can't ignore it you feel it. So there's so much that you don't know that's happening under the hood that doesn't mean you're, you may be within the accepted normative bell curve, it doesn't mean you're healthy. So.
you have what I call bell curve biochemistry and bell curve medicine, where it's like, well, are you within this parameter of what we consider normal? And it's like, okay, is that healthy or is that non-emergency? And to understand why that's the term non-emergency is so significant is because Western medicine was built philosophically on the foundations of triage from World War I.
Sanjay Bhojraj (54:11)
Within one standard deviation of the mean and.
Right.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (54:31)
triage is are you dying, gonna lose an eye or a limb? No, here's a painkiller if we have any, go over there and stop whining, there's more serious people we're dealing with. So Western medicine was built on the foundation of emergency medicine, philosophically. So Western medicine is focused on what is the, every symptom we see is an emergency and we got to cut it, drug it, burn it, deal with it because the symptom is the problem.
That's Western. Now, if your eye is falling out or your arm is five feet over there, yeah, the symptom is the problem. You don't have missing arm disease. You've got, you you've got to it back. ⁓ it's, ⁓ Western medicine philosophically is a hundred percent appropriate for the emergency room, is a hundred percent inappropriate for an emergency room mentality for a chronic issue. Unless of course a chronic issue creates emergency situations that are intolerable or lethal or dangerous to yourself or others.
Sanjay Bhojraj (55:25)
like a heart attack or stroke or something like that.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (55:26)
Yeah, yeah. the medicine is a giant sandbox and the problem is not Western medicine. The problem is mission creep of an emergency style philosophy into non-emergency situations using the tools of emergency medicine in non-emergency situations. That's the problem. No different than applying the tools of functional medicine in the emergency room. It goes both ways.
It goes both ways.
Sanjay Bhojraj (55:56)
You can't do a deep breathing exercise and unclog your artery, right? Like if you have an acute attack, and I think that's the benefit for so many ⁓ of the practitioners that are equally conversant with both sides, right? And I think that's where a lot of the friction
gets engendered between the quote unquote, you know, integrative, alternative, let's just call it, even though I hate that word, kind of universe and the conventional world is that they will often...
not take the time, and this is really true of any conflict, they don't take the time to truly understand the principles of each other and realize to work together. And it becomes an adversarial relationship as opposed to a synergistic relationship. And the patient then, what happens, just gets ping pong back and forth. Like I remember I practiced here in Southern California and I'd have patients that had heart attack that they would go to a naturopath doctor and the naturopath would say, my God, they're trying to kill you with all these medications, stop everything.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (56:27)
Yeah.
Yeah, we.
Sanjay Bhojraj (56:46)
And I would be like, whoa, let's just, you know, let's get on the phone. Let's talk here because I just put a stent in that guy yesterday. And if you stop that medication, it's going to clot. Right. So, so I think just more conversations need to happen. Well, I mean, such an industry in chat, I feel like we could go on forever, but when people are looking for you, when they were, they're trying to find you and they say, you know what, I'm interested in getting my testing done. ⁓ and I want to figure out what's the right diet or what my cascade is. How can they find you?
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (56:49)
Yeah.
Yeah, yeah, yeah, totally.
Is
Sure, so if you're a lay person that just wants to get your genetics looked at, you can go to DrSamShea.com and click on the DNA Decoded link right above on top or you can just go to TheDNADecoded.com. You've to put the the in there, TheDNADecoded.com. We've been having some IP issues with that one. We're fixing those so if not, just go to my website and click on it. So that's if you're a lay person that just wants to your genes tested.
Sanjay Bhojraj (57:39)
meaning a non-practitioner.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (57:40)
Non-practitioner, non-health coach, non-licensed practitioner. If you are a health coach or a licensed practitioner and you want to start incorporating genetics into your practice, go to fitgenesusa.com, F-I-T-G-E-N-E-S-U-S-A.com, and then you can apply to become a practitioner. what I do is that I'm the trainer. I've got a whole learning library.
Sanjay Bhojraj (57:51)
like this.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (58:10)
And I can show you how to incorporate this into your practice and making genetics really, really much more easy and efficient and effective to implement and to understand genetics much more simply and straightforward. it's like, I found a way to have, you don't have to spend like three hours necessarily analyzing your genes. can be like, it's just so much more efficient if you understand that genes are prioritized.
and that you're looking at clusters and that you have to find the top recommendations that affect the most number of highest priority genes. That alone
will simplify so much and solve so many people's problems around trying to understand and implement genetics.
Sanjay Bhojraj (58:55)
It's true. mean, I was sharing with you, I had a gene test done. It was like 1700 genes and I got that thing done like three years ago and I'm still trying to make sense of that report. So I love, I love that it's tactical and I love that, that you take this kind of root cure approach, right? With, with what are the, what are the 20 things that we can, 20 % of things that we can do.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (59:00)
Oh my god.
Well, is a four-letter word in medicine, so we can't really say that just by the way.
Sanjay Bhojraj (59:19)
Okay, fair enough, fair enough. you know, one of the 20 % changes that we can make that's going to have the greatest 80 % impact, right? So I love it. So, so Dr. Sam Shay, at the end of the podcast, I always ask three questions of my guests to kind of do a getting to know you. So number one is what's your favorite food on earth? Health aside, it can be burgers, it can be pizza, whatever, but what's the one thing that you
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (59:24)
Yeah, totally.
So I thought you were going to do Monty Python. Like what's your name? What's your quest? What's your favorite color? I said, hear three questions. I. Yeah.
Sanjay Bhojraj (59:45)
That would be really funny though. didn't like I was just the other day I was just talking about always look on the bright side of life. I was stuck in an airport. ⁓ And, and it was like snowmageddon across the southwest or southeast rather. And so I just started humming that song and then somebody else was like, was that Monty Python? I should incorporate more incorporate more Monty Python. So what's your favorite food? What's the thing that you love to eat?
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (1:00:06)
So it's a really, really good New York Strip steak.
Sanjay Bhojraj (1:00:11)
Okay. And I'd say 80 % of my guests will go steak of some sort. so it's interesting. Number two, what's your favorite place on earth? A place that you would live forever and ever with an unlimited amount of New York strip stakes and you'd be happy till the end of days. Colorado. And where do you live? well, there you go. I was like, wait, that's great. And number three, outside, and I think I might have some answer to this, but outside of the world of...
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (1:00:15)
Yeah, totally.
Colorado.
In Colorado. Yeah.
Sanjay Bhojraj (1:00:37)
genetics and medicine, what's something that keeps you curious, something that you love to learn about or something that you love to do.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (1:00:44)
Well, outside of comedy, which would be my first answer, but we already answered that. ⁓ The primary things I really love studying is ⁓ evolutionary psychology and mythology. And mythology is actually, I think, a kind of a more ethereal construct of evolutionary psychology.
Sanjay Bhojraj (1:00:57)
And mythology. Okay.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (1:01:12)
that I feel that mythology and evolutionary psychology create the two most important ⁓ frameworks for predicting human behavior. if you can understand, when in doubt, I always go back to evolutionary biology and psychology. And if I wanna be able to predict someone's behavior, I also wanna look at their mythology.
Sanjay Bhojraj (1:01:34)
Hmm. That is a very deep answer. I think you exist. You exist on multiple planes. I love it. Well, Dr. Shay, thank you so much for being here. It's been a great conversation. ⁓ and I hope our listeners kind of now have a much better appreciation of not just the role of genetic testing, but how to triage it, how to look at it appropriately, ⁓ and how to make sense of these clusters of data so that you can really get the biggest bang for your buck in terms of.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (1:01:40)
Talk about another podcast.
Sanjay Bhojraj (1:02:04)
optimizing diet, optimizing lifestyle, optimizing mindset. We didn't talk too much about mindset, but your emotional state really informs a lot of this as well. So thank you for being here and we'll have all the links in the podcast ⁓ notes.
Dr. Sam Shay, DC, IFMCP (1:02:16)
We do test for the comped and MAOA genes in the genetics, that's related to mindset. So that's something anyway. There, we covered it. See, box ticked, done.
Sanjay Bhojraj (1:02:22)
So those are involved in neurotransmitters. For those of you who are not genetics nerds like we are, guess. Yeah, but but it's awesome. So for the listeners, thank you guys for being here so much. If you like what you heard today, like I don't know where the button is on your screen here, here, here, here, but like and subscribe to the podcast, leave comments. I love to take a look at the at what you guys are saying what you have to say. If this connects, if this doesn't connect, if you say Sanjay, you're full of it.
Let me know. I would love to engage with you. ⁓ And I hope to see you on the next Curious Cardiologist podcast. Bye everybody.
and see