TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Welcome to Dynastic and part two of our deep dive on the history of Ohio State football. Chuck Todd, we finished part one discussing Woody Hayes' incredible coaching streak, which included Eric Parsegian, Lou Holtz, and of course, Bo Schembechler.
00:00:15
Speaker 2: Yeah, no, as we ended things, we reminded you, Bo was a grad assistant, sort of a Padawan of sorts, right, with Woody in 1952. Then he becomes a full assistant from 58 to 62. He leaves to go to Miami of Ohio, which is, of course, very famous of being a cradle of coaches. Arapart Seeging being one of them as well, who went on to Notre Dame. And he's at Miami of Ohio from 63 to 68. And then, J.A., he goes to Michigan. And the rivalry is on.
00:00:48
Speaker 1: Ohio State and Michigan, the Scarlet and Gray, Maize and Blue, Woody and Bo. There's so much to the rivalry, but it always comes back to those simple words. They're so similar in their approach. I had to go back and see who was responsible for the phrases, three arts and cloud of dust. And there are three things that can go happen when you pass. And two of them ain't good. I wasn't sure if they both said it, if Woody said it. Turns out they were both attributed to Woody Hayes, but they very easily could have been said by Bo Schembechler.
00:01:13
Speaker 2: Absolutely. You know, to Woody Hayes, ever the military historian, the rivalry wasn't just between two schools. It was between two states dating back to 1836. When Andrew Jackson made Michigan give Toledo back to Ohio, it's a famous story of the time, Hayes was in the car with an assistant coach on a recruiting trip in Michigan. With the car running low on fuel, Hayes refuses to stop at a gas station until they made it back across the state line to Ohio because we're not stopping in this goddamn state and paying taxes to the state of Michigan. Of course, when I was growing up, I had family that lived on the border of Michigan and Ohio State. Excuse me, Michigan and Ohio. It was a Monroe, right? Not far from Toledo. And guess what Michiganders always like to do? They went to Toledo to go buy their soda pop. You know why? Because it was only five cents for the deposit and they had the infamous 10 cents. So Woody may not have liked paying taxes to Michigan, but Michiganders didn't mind the cheaper soda in Toledo.
00:02:17
Speaker 1: They were saving money.
00:02:18
Speaker 2: That's right.
00:02:20
Speaker 1: It's funny because I'm not trying to give money to the state of Indiana, but when I'm coming back to Chicago, driving through on the Skyway, the gas is a lot cheaper over there. So I always stop and refuel.
00:02:29
Speaker 2: Well, I mean, you know, the Bears are headed to Indiana, too. So, you know, it's all the rage in Chicago.
00:02:35
Speaker 1: These days, Mr. Adane. So prior to Bowe arriving in Michigan, the rivalry started to get kind of lopsided. Woody had beaten Michigan seven out of nine times from 1960 to 1968. But Bowe beats Woody in their very first head-to-head matchup in 1969. And he winds up winning five out of the ten against him with one tie. And Woody had the score of that 1969, that first loss to Bowe. He had it woven into the carpet in the team locker room so that the players would be reminded of it all year leading up to the next meeting. Like, that's how seriously he took it.
00:03:07
Speaker 2: Well, we can't forget, you know, the 68 team is probably Woody's greatest team. Is that fair?
00:03:13
Speaker 1: Right?
00:03:13
Speaker 2: The 68 national title team. It's stunning that they lose to Michigan that next year. And I think they turned the ball over 7,000 times that game. So it's no wonder he was so angry and upset about that game. So the 70 matchup was the first time both teams entered the annual November clash undefeated, which of course we now have gotten used to that in the modern day as well. But that was when the rivalry went to the next level. That was the first time it felt like These are two national powers playing a local rivalry.
00:03:48
Speaker 1: It's almost as if the game had become this end-all to the detriment of everything else, including the pursuit of the national championship. These two teams, it's like they were optimized to beat each other on artificial turf, which was new at the time. I think Ohio State put theirs in in 1971. And that was the true astroturf, which was like a small grade above concrete. They went into their first game against Michigan, the year they had the turf in, They had like eight starters were injured from playing on that turf. But these two teams were built to play each other on artificial turf at the onset of winter in the Midwest. And then they were just incapable of going out to the Rose Bowl and playing on a natural grass at the Rose Bowl under the California sun sign on January 1st. And they would just get both rates. Hayes went one and four in the Rose Bowl after Schembechler gets to Michigan. And Schembechler goes 0-5 in the Rose Bowl in that stretch. And Hayes was 2-7 in bowl games overall during that time, culminating in that Gator Bowl.
00:04:45
Speaker 2: Well, just remember, everything was played in the warmth by the time December and January came along. That isn't what they trained for. J.A., you know, you're the Big Ten historian among the two of us. I would argue the Big... I don't think any school cared about winning the national title in the Big Ten until the 21st century, really until that Ohio State team in 01. You know, Michigan wins a split title in 97. But, you know, the Big Ten schools... were sort of, they fell behind the Sunbelt, right? When I, you know, and to me, I'm counting Pac-10, you know, Florida schools or Texas, you know, Southwest conference, Southeast conference, you know, the, the big 10 was its own thing.
00:05:25
Speaker 1: And I would argue that even like Colorado surpassed them, right? Right.
00:05:28
Speaker 2: Because the big 10 schools cared more about the Rose bowl than the
Load full transcript
national title. They always did. Whether you were in Madison, Bloomington, um, champagne, like you name it, Iowa city, right? You know, this better than most.
00:05:43
Speaker 1: Well, it was about carried into the nineties, you know, like early in my career, I'm covering a game in Michigan and they go for the tie and knowing full well that it's going to cost them a chance at the nationalists. You know, they could go for the win, like, like go for two points or something, go for the win. This is before they had overtime in college football. So go for the win. Or play for the tie. And the win, then you keep your shot at a national championship alive, right? But Gary Moeller, who was the Michigan coach at the time, said, hey, you know, we want to win the Big Ten championship. That is our goal. We want to go play in the Rose Bowl. And it was to the detriment of the national championship.
00:06:20
Speaker 2: Look, my favorite line about a coach ever. There was a coach at Michigan State named Muddy Waters. And a sports writer said, roses don't grow in muddy waters. And it was just such a, it's always like, I'll never forget the coach's name because that phrase is just etched in my head. But to me, that's a reminder. That's what mattered. That conference win, getting to the Rose, winning the Rose Bowl didn't matter. But if you were in the Rose Bowl, it meant you won the Big Ten. And nothing else mattered. Those national titles, it didn't, Michigan fans, Ohio State fans, I never got the sense in the 80s I don't want to say they didn't care about not being national champs, but they just were, they were grading themselves differently. That's what it felt.
00:07:06
Speaker 1: They're also a little bit squeezed out in the 1990s because as the bowl coalition, which later became the bowl Alliance, right. Or maybe I have that order mixed up, but you know, these kind of these precursors to the BCS, you know, that we're trying to find ways to pit the number one and number two teams together in the bowls. Well, The Orange Bowl was a part of it. The Fiesta Bowl was a part of it. The Sugar Bowl was a part of it. The Rose Bowl was not a part of it. Right. So the Big Ten was almost excluded from the opportunity to play the highest ranked opponent on New Year's Day. So, you know, in some ways, you know, they were they were, you know, beholden to the tradition. But they also were kind of contractually obligated to compete for those. Well, they didn't have an option to try to play, you know, Notre Dame or Florida State or somewhere, someone in another bowl game.
00:07:56
Speaker 2: Well, look, and I've always said that as a University of Miami guy, there was never a conference. You know, people say, oh, don't you care that you've never won the ACC? It's like, no, Miami's never really had a conference alliance.
00:08:07
Speaker 1: Right.
00:08:07
Speaker 2: They were an independent for so long. Notre Dame, they measured themselves on winning the whole thing. There was no
conference to win where both, frankly, the culture of the SEC is a bit was a bit more conference focused, too, for a long time. And the Big Ten. And it may explain why you had schools like Nebraska who wasn't in the Big Ten then. Miami, USC, and the Pac-10, who seemed to be more prepared to compete for national titles because they didn't have the same, frankly, care about their conference titles. What mattered to those Big Ten schools was that.
00:08:43
Speaker 1: Also recruiting nationally, Chuck. Woody will go to that. Michigan State, again, early there, recruiting black players and out-of-state players, maybe just as importantly. Right. And Woody Hayes was just really concerned with Ohio and recruiting in Ohio. It's interesting. I really feel like until USC, UCLA joined the Big Ten, the Big Ten was the only conference, the only major conference that didn't have a toehold in California, Texas or Florida, which is nowadays the majority of where the great, particularly the speedy players come from. The football talent is in those states. And the Big Ten didn't have real access to those states.
00:09:21
Speaker 2: Look, one of my favorite. maps that I use both for politics and sports is the high school football recruiting map of 1980 versus the high school football recruiting map in 2000. In 1980, two of the most important states producing the big talent was Ohio and Pennsylvania. By 2000, it's Florida and Georgia. And just like the population went north to south, right? Like, you know, it was sort of, and this is why I expect at some point Nevada and Arizona, those two states, and you're seeing it, Las Vegas produced more high school athletes all the time as they mature and become a bigger, bigger. high school football power, it eventually will turn into college, and you've seen it in Phoenix, too. You saw it in the Southeast, and that's one of my favorite maps because the football talent went north to south, and guess where political power went? North to south. I don't think it's a coincidence. So by 1978, Things are actually really getting in the way, getting away from Woody Hayes. Not only did they lose to Michigan for the third time, it was their third straight loss without a touchdown. Relegated to the Gator Bowl. And that's right, relegated, because you weren't in the Rose Bowl. And by the way, it was fairly new in the 70s that Big Ten teams went to bowl games outside if you didn't make it to the Rose Bowl. But it's Keith Jackson calling the game for ABC.
00:10:44
Speaker 1: Whoa, Nelly.
00:10:46
Speaker 2: Although he never said, whoa, Nelly, which is one of my favorite little myths out there. But he gave Woody Hayes a pair of boxing gloves before the game. He thought he was being lighthearted about it. But rather ominously, now we look back and go, oh, Keith knew something. So late in the game, the player on Clemson is Charlie Bauman. He intercepts Arch Schlichter. He gets pushed out of bounds next to Woody Hayes. He raised his arms to celebrate, and Hayes grabbed his jersey and punched him in the chest. Now, he told his personal scribe, remember Paul Hornick, the Columbus reporter. Not the Green Bay Packer. Not the Green Bay Packer, that he would resign. But he didn't tell his bosses. They were going to have to fire him. What he always believed about Nixon never quit. So it was that Ohio State held a 10 a.m. press conference the next day and announced Coach Hayes has been relieved of his duties as football coach at Ohio State. Boy, it was, you know, it was really a rough moment for television at the time. It was one of those things that's happening on live TV, and you're like, oh, whoa, that just happened. But it was missed by Keith Jackson, J.A.
00:11:55
Speaker 1: Yeah, and they couldn't watch it. It's weird. ABC Sports had made the decision not to spend the money because, again, it's a Gator Bowl. It's a second-tier bowl. They're spending the money on the Rose Bowl or something like that, right? So they didn't want to spend the money on what's known in the TV biz as a return feed. So Keith Jackson couldn't see it, right? He didn't have a ways to see a replay. They had one slow motion replay camera that was like separate. It was a, it was a separate dedicated camera. So they couldn't just run replays back from, from all the normal angles of the game. So, yeah, so he didn't see it. So they probably underplayed a little bit, but it, it, it did get out. And, and of course the, the newscast replayed a lot too.
00:12:35
Speaker 2: Yeah. Our, that was the 1978 version of going viral. It's probably the way to put it.
00:12:42
Speaker 1: Yeah. I think about like, I just remember I saw it like it's not like I was watching the Gator Bowl live. I can guarantee you. But, you know, everyone says, oh, my God, this coach from Ohio State punched a player.
00:12:53
Speaker 2: Well, you know, it's funny. You know, this is one of those stories where you're like, it's probably not the first time a coach had punched a player in a game. It's just the first time we all saw it on national television.
00:13:05
Speaker 1: Right.
00:13:05
Speaker 2: Sometimes seeing it the first time can be shocking. And it's a reminder of why I've always thought the visual medium is different than the written word. You can write about something, but to see it sometimes puts it in another category to how you receive it.
00:13:23
Speaker 1: Especially because back then, it was rare to see things, right? Now we see everything that happens. And don't get me started on these flock cameras recording everything, ring cameras recording every move that we make. But yeah, back then, for something to happen on TV, and also TV, you know, the shares that they were getting or the ratings that they were getting, right? You know, Vermont culture. So if it happens on television, everyone is seeing it. Stuff that goes viral in the real world, like it's not that many people are seeing. I don't care how many likes it's getting on social
media. It's still not really breaking through to the extent that these things broke through back then.
00:14:02
Speaker 2: But let's be honest about Woody's end there in 78. I mean, would you say that it arguably took the full 23, 24 year, it takes 20 really is 25 years later. If you go by a calendar date, it's January of 2003. So he's fired essentially the end of 78 and 24 years. And a few days later, Ohio state wins its first national title since Woody Hayes. That's how long it took him to get it, to, to get back from, uh, from the depths of that, isn't it?
00:14:39
Speaker 1: Yeah, they, they were no longer on the top, but also, uh, it was not the last time they had to make an announcement. They were letting their goats go. Right. Maybe not as under such dramatic circumstances, but you know, Earl Bruce comes in, he's plucked from the Woody Hayes tree and he does fine. He's got an 81, 26 and one record, but they make the decision of firing before the Michigan game in 87. Cause they think, ah, this isn't good enough. And then he winds up beating Michigan. It's an upset victory, but it wasn't enough to save his job.
00:15:09
Speaker 2: I'll be honest. I don't remember a lot of Ohio state, making it to the Rose Bowl in the 80s. And I think that was part of the problem for Mr. Bruce. After Bruce came the John Cooper era. And boy, Cooper, he is the living, breathing example of sort of the Ohio State that I know. He's the epitome of the risk of coaching at Ohio State. Cooper had a tremendous record. 111, 43, and 4. There's many schools that that would be an all-time great career record, most wins at a certain school. He had three seasons when he only lost one game, but the problem was two of those three seasons, the one loss was Michigan. His record against Michigan was 210-1, right? So think about it. He's won 11, 43, and 4, but 25% of his losses are Michigan, right?
00:15:59
Speaker 1: 25%. You know, he was....
00:16:10
Speaker 2: You just sit there and you're just like, wow, you know, and that's why they fired him. He is, he is, he is the coach that was fired simply for not beating Michigan. It didn't matter how many other wins he had. And it's why some of us were wondering if Ryan day can survive, not beating Michigan. He won a national.
00:16:30
Speaker 1: Title despite winning the national championship. Yeah.
00:16:33
Speaker 2: And there were questions with some going, yeah, but he's not beating Michigan.
00:16:38
Speaker 1: And, you know, the question you have to ask Ohio State fans, would you rather have the national championship or would you rather be Michigan?
00:16:45
Speaker 2: Well, in the 20th century.
00:16:46
Speaker 1: And that's a legitimate question for the Ohio State fans.
00:16:49
Speaker 2: Well, there's no question in the 20th century. It was all about Michigan. And the Rose Bowl, they didn't care about national titles.
00:16:58
Speaker 1: Right. And I think even now. With so much emphasis, we're starting to see college football turn into the NCAA tournament. Well, all that happens is in March. All that matters is what happens in March.
00:17:11
Speaker 2: I think that is the case now. I do think that we are seeing the beginning of the end of the significance of conferences on the field. Conferences matter financially. Conferences matter for other reasons. But winning the conference, does it really matter anymore?
00:17:31
Speaker 1: I mean... they're probably going to do away with these conference championship games as they expand the playoffs. Right. So yeah, that, that would be the ends. And I think we, we'd be completely on the other end of the spectrum for where the importance that Michigan and Ohio state put on beating each other and winning the big 10 in the process. When we get to the point where, you know, we don't even care who the big 10 champion is anymore. All we care about is seating in this 2014 playoff, which would just be, ridiculous. Yeah.
00:18:01
Speaker 2: I am a little concerned, you know, that, that the, that 25 years from now, it's only going to be old guys like you and I, that are going to care about the Ohio state Michigan game. And instead, cause some days the Ohio state Michigan game might matter. And some years, one of the teams may decide to rest their players to prepare for the playoff. And, you know, that's just going to be where, where the sport is headed. And, you know, look, If you measure it in national titles, that makes sense. But if you miss, if you're nostalgic for the old days, you're, you're, you're going to feel like you're missing something.
00:18:38
Speaker 1: So the departure of John Cooper leads to Jim Trestle in his glasses and his sweater vest. You know, he looked like the last guy you'd have to worry about punching an opposing player, right?
00:18:50
Speaker 2: No, I mean, by the way, I know I shocked you when I reminded you, you know, he's currently the Lieutenant Governor of Ohio and, But he kind of was dressed like a lieutenant governor.
00:18:58
Speaker 1: Like, you know, he always looked really good. That's for the job you want, not the job you have.
00:19:02
Speaker 2: It's possible he did, right.
00:19:07
Speaker 1: What he did do, he took it to Michigan, though. Yes, he did. He was not a librarian or a lieutenant governor when he went against Michigan. He was 9-1 against the Wolverines. And he led that Buckeyes team to that national championship against your Hurricane. So why is he still coaching at Ohio State? Yeah, he is.
00:19:24
Speaker 2: He is going to be the timing trivia question. It's like me trying to explain to my son what happened to SMU football in the 80s. And he's going, wait a minute. They got they they lost their program because they paid players. Isn't that what it how it works now? And it's like, yeah, that's kind of what happened to Jim Trestle. He was coach when Terrell Pryor and four others sold their Ohio State gear in exchange for tattoos and other services around Columbus. If it
had been today, they'd have just used cash. They wouldn't have had to trade stuff because they would have had the money. It wouldn't have been a thing. And the great irony is.
00:19:59
Speaker 1: They had to give up their gold pants.
00:20:00
Speaker 2: No, the Ohio State boosters bragged about the 2024 championship roster costing $ 20 million, but Trestle was done in by players essentially selling trinkets for a couple of grand. You know, it was honestly, these were, you know, they were selling their autograph.
00:20:17
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:20:17
Speaker 2: They were selling their jerseys. They were getting it in exchange for services to fan bases, but it was essentially making money on what I think one would call the name, image and likeness.
00:20:27
Speaker 1: Right.
00:20:27
Speaker 2: And it is, you could argue that scandal is among the straws, right? Obviously the O'Bannon case is, had been filed by then at that, you know, this was, you know, we were in the, but there was something about this scandal where a lot of people said, really? We're about to destroy a football program over tattoos, right?
00:20:52
Speaker 1: Part of it was in the timing of the suspensions, right? So no one was denying that this was a violation of the NCAA rules as they existed. Once it came out, it was pretty clear, right? Right. But, what happened was ESPN steps in and says, hey, we've got the rights to the Sugar Bowl. We kind of like it if the starting quarterback and these other key players are playing so that our ratings don't tank in the game. So can you just hold off on the suspensions until, you know, delay them until next year or the spring quarter, you know, spring semester. They don't play in the spring game or whatever. Suspend them later, right? We kind of need them then. So then somebody says, all right, we'll bend to you. So now you're admitting that It's not about the principles. It's not about maintaining this so-called amateurism, right? That's not first and foremost, or at the very least, it can wait until after ESPN sells its commercial windows for the Sugar Bowl. And so, Chuck, as you said, one of the last draws was this blatant pandering to the almighty dollar on behalf of the conferences and the NCAA. and the networks. Whereas again, the players can't get a couple thousand bucks, you know, for, for, for what they built up, right. For, for what they've established. And so, yeah, the whole thing was just absurd.
00:22:17
Speaker 2: Yeah, it was. And, and look, it is, I'm sure Trestle found the, you know, found it frustrating and I'm sure he looks back on it and finds it frustrating. But look, the important thing Trestle did is he, he turned the page on the perception that you couldn't do it all at Ohio State, that somehow they weren't going to be prepared for the modern era of football. And he did turn it into an attractive job again, right? Especially when you realize the guy like Urban Meyer, for instance, who knew, you know, he'd come from the
University of Florida, knew what it took, you know, financially and with your boosters and what.
00:22:58
Speaker 1: It would take.
00:22:59
Speaker 2: And all the ingredients were there at Ohio State and Trestle. had he some way had sort of greased the, you know, it sort of greased the one runway there a little bit and had it ready. And, and so, you know, the hiring of Meyer is, is proof that Ohio state never would have fired Trestle if they didn't think they kind of had to, if the whole thing hadn't been such a weird thing, because look, urban Meyer was no, was no NCAA saint. And that's all I'll, you know, I'll put it there. In fact, Ohio state, overlooked all of the reasons why urban Meyer sort of supposedly stepped down for Florida. He said he stepped down for health reasons. There was all sorts of stuff, you know, nobody will take urban Meyer at his word on what happened.
00:23:42
Speaker 1: Overlooking the 25 of his players that got arrested while he was.
00:23:44
Speaker 2: At Florida, including a double murderer, you know, later, I mean, you know, Aaron Hernandez is, is part of that team. And so, you know, the point was Ohio state just wanted to win.
00:23:58
Speaker 1: Right.
00:23:59
Speaker 2: And they were willing to overlook the messiness of that program. And that's because they saw football as king, and they saw that they had the support base and the booster base to do this. And you know who was not going to punish Ohio State for hiring a supposed controversial coach as long as the coach won? The fans. And ultimately, who was going to make that decision? I would argue it's the fan base. Wouldn't you, Jay?
00:24:26
Speaker 1: Yeah. And backing up a little bit, you mentioned that Trestle had made this job attractive again and shown that it could be a premier job again. But kind of the changing nature of this slow, gradual process for the NCAA meant that it could be an attractive job, even in the wake of the allegations and the punishments. Right. Right. So you brought up the SMU death penalty issue. which eventually not only took down SMU's program and delayed them, they're just now, within these last few years, getting back to relevance again. But it kind of took out the whole Southwest Conference because there was scandal after scandal over illegal recruiting and all this stuff for the recruits. But one thing they learned, remember back in the 70s and 80s, you get in trouble, no bowl games for you, but also you can't appear on television. And then once again, the TV network said, wait a minute, you're going to hurt us. We can't have USC. We can't have Ohio State. We can't have these nice big ratings draws on television anymore. Who are you hurting? Are you hurting Ohio State? Are you hurting Alabama or USC? Or are you hurting the entire product of college football? So notice the TV bans went away. And some of the harsher punishments went away. So not only had Trestle proven that you could win again, But it was an attractive job also
because you didn't have to linger with years of NCAA sanctions. I think there was a one-year bowl ban. I think they kind of rescinded or negated, whatever the term is they use, for taking away their Sugar Bowl victory that year, even though we all saw them win the game.
00:26:05
Speaker 2: Yeah, I know. I never know what to do with those.
00:26:09
Speaker 1: We saw it, Chuck. Right.
00:26:11
Speaker 2: It's like John Calipari saying, And how many Final.
00:26:13
Speaker 1: Fours has he been to? Vacated, vacated is the term, right.
00:26:16
Speaker 2: How many Final Fours has Calipari been to? I know the ones I've seen.
00:26:20
Speaker 1: Right.
00:26:21
Speaker 2: And I know he took those schools to the Final Four, but they've been vacated, right?
00:26:26
Speaker 1: Exactly. So not only was Urban Meyer's baggage not a detriment to Ohio State, but Ohio State's even more so, I think. There was less disincentive. There was less baggage that Ohio State was bringing to this transaction than Because the NCAA had started to appeal and cater to the greed and the money-making aspect of college football.
00:26:51
Speaker 2: Look, I think the lesson, and we're going to get to it in a minute on Urban Meyer, but with Jim Trussell, is you only get fired in college football if your scandal gets in the way of winning. Pure and simple. If it gets in the way of your ability to win, then it's a problem. If it doesn't get in the way of winning, I don't know if it's a problem.
00:27:13
Speaker 1: No, I look at Kirby Smart, who, you know, in the wake of winning championships at Georgia, has all these vehicular violations, most egregiously, when a team or, you know, a department staffer is out drinking with the players, leading to a drunk driving accident, which leads to a death, right? And.
00:27:39
Speaker 2: So if Kirby Smart were 8-4, what kind of coverage do you think that would get?
00:27:43
Speaker 1: So there's a big difference between defending national championship coach Kirby Smart dealing with all this and, yeah, a middling record Kirby Smart having to deal with all this. It's just amazing. I don't see how there can be a bigger– Jim Trestle lost his job over a player selling gold pants and this much more serious allegations and tragic events that happened at Georgia– And there's nothing. So you're right. The seriousness of the punishment and the tenure, the grasp that someone has on their job is strictly a function of winning. Although I would argue that it really got pushed to the limits with Urban Meyer because what was on his resume at Ohio State, well, that national championship in 2014, perhaps more importantly, a clean 7-0 record against Michigan. And that allowed him to survive, at least initially, the mess involving his assistant coach, Zach Smith, who faced spousal abuse allegations, which at first Meyer denied any knowledge of the situation at all. Then investigations show that he was aware and failed to follow the proper response protocols. So
it ends in a suspension for three games, and then he winds up leaving at the end of the year, once again citing health reasons and health concerns. But I'll let the NPR headline on the story speak for itself, where it just said, Urban Meyer will retire as Ohio State's football coach after a scandal-marred season.
00:29:26
Speaker 2: You know, I do want to bring up one thing about Meyer and the transition from Trestle to Meyer that sort of also is a transition for Ohio State in how they, you know, one of the You know, we talk about Woody Hayes as sort of the ultimate Ohio first coach, right? He didn't even like trying to recruit players outside the state of Ohio. A majority of Jim Trestle's players for that championship team were recruited out of Ohio. Urban Meyer's early classes were the first ones to where a majority of the roster wasn't from Ohio anymore. And now it is normal for a majority of the recruits to Ohio State, not to necessarily be from Ohio State. I mean, I could tell you this, you know, Jeremiah Smith went to high school down in South Florida. Trust me, University of Miami had the last fight. They threw a bunch of money at him and he delayed on signing day. He delayed six or seven hours before he finally sent his letter of intent to Ryan Day. But the point was Urban Meyer, you know, they didn't just hire a coach that coached in Florida. They hired a coach who knew how to recruit in Florida. And while, you know, Jim Trestle opened the door to it, Urban Meyer totally transformed to it. And in that respect, he also, you know, he opened the door to making Ohio State a national destination for, outside the Midwest. And look, if you're going to keep up with the modern way of college football, I think you kind of have to figure out how to recruit Texas, California, and Florida.
00:31:05
Speaker 1: I think that's a great and important legacy at one of the premier football programs in the country. So it still feels the stamp of Urban Meyer. And it's interesting because he's still welcome there. When he goes there with Fox Sports, You know, they love him. Like, he's still, again, it didn't end well. It didn't end on his terms. But, like, there's no lingering anger there for him.
00:31:31
Speaker 2: J.A., that 2014 season is still remarkable. He had three different quarterbacks, right? And he finds, I mean, Cardale Jones became a draft pick simply for his performance over three games. Look, that 2014 team, I mean, they were a freight train. by the time of the call of that. And that's the first year of the 14 playoff. They were a freight train by the time they got, they got done with everybody. And you got to give them credit. It was three different quarterbacks and you're right. He is definitely viewed that way. So Ryan day, how does it end for him? You know, he's got a losing record against Michigan though. He's got two of them. Now he can finally say that he's got a championship, including a year where he lost to Michigan, but won the title. and that lost to Michigan that year before he wins the title in 24. My old friend, the former governor of Ohio, John Kasich was calling for day's head for losing that Michigan game. And it just shows you that the, certainly there's still a segment of the Ohio state community that has that, that still cares about that beating Michigan still matters as much, at least if not all. So, you know, I, they've still had a ton of drama themselves in the past two years. They've lost a coach, uh, Michigan, you know, Michigan now is the one going through all the drama, right? They've lost a coach, uh, who won a championship suspended for half the games that season because of a spying scandal. They've lost his replacement. He was having an affair with an athletic department employee, broke into our apartment, threatened her. Then they replaced the athletic director who oversaw the drama. Um, It should make the perfect time for Ryan Day to flex some Ohio State supremacy over the Wolverines while they're regrouping. But I'll tell you, Ryan Day can't lose. Can't lose to a Michigan team that's reeling like this team is reeling and like this iteration of the program or gosh, God only knows. But again, he's got four losses against Michigan. He's got 13 total. 25% of his losses are to Michigan.
00:33:44
Speaker 1: Unsustainable ratio, Chuck. Unsustainable ratio. So beware. This could be the most perilous time. He's two years out of winning the national championship, and it feels like his grip on his job is as tenuous as anyone at any of these major programs.
00:34:02
Speaker 2: Well, look, I do think what you're really impressed with with Day and what he seems to be doing as successfully as Nick Saban showed the world how to do is he's doing this with new assistants every year. He's got a new offensive coordinator this year from the offensive coordinator. He had the year before from the offensive, you know, he's had multiple different defensive coordinators and, and that seems to be part of the job description these days as a head coach of a college football program, you got to, You've got to have some, you've got to know when to get rid of loyal assistants if they're not up to the job. You've got to be cutthroat because if you're not, you're going to be cut. Your throat's going to be cut.
00:34:46
Speaker 1: Well, you know, the offense coordinator that he won the championship with, Chip Kelly, is now here at Northwestern after an unsuccessful stint with the Raiders in the NFL. Ryan Day's son is actually on the roster at Northwestern here too. So I'm kind of forced to, we're tied in now. So just to bring it full circle, like my early years First introduction to Ohio State when they came in here and had three running backs go for 100 yards each on us in my sophomore year. And now the son of Ohio State's football coach goes here to Northwestern. And their former offensive coordinator is here doing an incredible job. So that brings us all the way back, Chuck. It
does.
00:35:28
Speaker 2: And I think we can end this way. This is not a dynasty that feels like it's at a crossroads at the moment. I don't know if you feel that way right now. They feel like they're the king of the Big Ten, and it's hard to see. We know the rain can end at any time, but they're the king, and it's hard to see who's going to knock them off the pedestal. Oregon and Indiana, you know, it's always somebody in Ohio State. It was Michigan and Ohio State. It was Oregon and Ohio State. Currently, it's Indiana and Ohio State, but the common denominators have been Ohio State.
00:36:01
Speaker 1: And I think they've made it institutional, right? That's the goal for anything is it institutional. So on one hand, it's fortunate for them that they haven't been dependent, that not all of their fortunes have been tied to that one coach. You know, we see it in various college sports, right? When you have that dynastic coach and once they're gone, it's never the same again. We've seen multiple iterations of Ohio State. So the university itself, you know, what those students envisioned way back in the late 1800s that the football program could put back then, they thought it put them on par with the Ivies, but what it's done is put them on par with, with the Alabamas and the Miamis and the USC is wherever you want to name. They're a prominent program.
00:36:47
Speaker 2: Let me, before we get to our favorite part of all these episodes, when we get to design our Mount Rushmore's here, let me ask you this. We know Alabama is the SEC. There are other SEC schools, right? But I don't think there's– it's a consensus. Alabama is the number one ranked all-time school. They're the face of the SEC. LSU, Georgia, all these schools matter. Alabama is the face of the SEC. The Big Ten. Is it Michigan or is it Ohio State? Who's the face of the Big Ten?
00:37:23
Speaker 1: I'm going to cop out and say both. Yeah. Remember, for so long, it was the big two. I actually think that's fair.
00:37:28
Speaker 2: You're doing what I want to do with my Mount Rushmores, right? I want multiple Rushmores. But I'm glad you answered that way because I feel like you cannot talk about one without the other. And frankly, I can look one way and say, oh, Michigan. I can look the other way and say, oh, Ohio State. They both... can lay claim to this.
00:37:56
Speaker 1: And the fact that, you know, Michigan just imperils all these Ohio State coaches, right? That for all the success, John Cooper, Ryan Day, you know, losing a fourth of their games to Michigan is those 25% completely outweigh the other 75% of the losses. You probably can't even name who they lost to those other games. But everyone can remember in exact detail every loss that they've had. to Michigan, in addition to the success on their own right, right? You know, not as many national championships in the last 30 years or so, but, you know, Michigan going to the Rose Bowl all the time, the fact that every year there's significant stakes, that's the thing too. Every year the Michigan-Ohio State game, I forget the stats on it, but there have been, and I'm sad that this is going away as the Rose Bowl, you know, first of all, there's no Pac-10 to play, or PAC 12 even to play in the Rose bowl on new year's day. And, you know, I know they, they kind of try to accommodate the big 10 and try to put the big 10 champion to play in the Rose bowl. If it can work in the college football playoffs, but it's not the same, right. It used to be, you knew you win the big 10. You're going to be playing in Pasadena new year's date on that. We know that with the sun setting on the Arroyo Seco mountains in the fourth quarter, all the beautiful things that go with it. And, and that's gone away. Um, I'm just glad at least Michigan versus Ohio State hasn't gone away. We still have that. But it's diminished a little bit because. a trip to the Rose Bowl in Pasadena is not, you know, waiting the victor. No. And in these days, they're both the victor. Right.
00:39:39
Speaker 2: I see what you did there. In these days, like I said, they may be just simply playing for who gets the bye in the college football playoff.
00:39:47
Speaker 1: Just not as sexy. You don't run around like... Woody Hayes one time ran around passing out roses, right? After they qualified to go to the Rose Bowl. What do you pass out when you get a buy? An empty sheet? What do you pass out?
00:40:02
Speaker 2: Hey, should you get credit? So there's been this running debate that if you earn a buy and you don't have to play in a round of the playoffs because you're so good, you earned a buy. Should you get an extra win on your record for that?
00:40:21
Speaker 1: No, because there's no guarantee if you had played that you would have won the game. No, you should not get.
00:40:25
Speaker 2: A win for that. But you did basically get Olaid into the next round.
00:40:31
Speaker 1: No, that doesn't count as a victory because you're picking up a ghost victory somewhere. Put it in those same places with those vacated championships. All right, Chuck. Mountain Rushmore time. Four players and staff from the long history of Ohio State football who are cut above the rest. Chuck, I'll have you go first. Who are your picks? We know who he is.
00:40:52
Speaker 2: Look, I think you have to put Woody Hayes. I think you have to. It's weird. It would be weird to have a Mount Rushmore without Woody Hayes on there. But he's the only coach I'm going to put on there on that front because in some ways he sort of created the program or what it is. And then my players, you win two Heisman Trophies, You're going to be in Granite as far as I'm concerned. So you got to have Archie there. And I'm going with Orlando Pace with two Lombardis. And then I'm going to put Chris Carter on there because I want a wide receiver on there. But I'll tell you honestly where I think I'd like, I think it's weird to say I want to put a player who's currently playing on
Mount Rushmore.
00:41:37
Speaker 1: You want this to age well. You want someone to come across this in years from now and say, Of course, Jeremiah Smith was on the.
00:41:43
Speaker 2: Ohio State number. It feels like he's that good. And again, I go back to Ohio State has become wide receiver U, right? If the 20th century Ohio State were about linebackers and running backs, right? 21st century Ohio State really, for me, is about wide receivers, right? Almost more than anything else. They've certainly had their share of running backs. You brought them up before with Zeke Elliott and a couple of those guys. And they got this guy, No relation, Bo Jackson. You know, you have a guy named Bo Jackson. You better be pretty good at running back, right? But the receivers, I mean, every time you turn around, you're like, oh, my God, that guy went to Ohio State. I mean, it's either Ohio State or LSU these days.
00:42:23
Speaker 1: Somebody, yeah. Oh, Olave.
00:42:25
Speaker 2: Olave is always open.
00:42:26
Speaker 1: Incredible running.
00:42:28
Speaker 2: I mean, always open down there for the Saints, you know. So I say Chris Carter because, you know, all he does is catch touchdowns. But I say him because I could argue he was sort of the first. Would you say he was the first great Ohio State wide receiver?
00:42:45
Speaker 1: Certainly that I was aware of, right, and coming off all those running backs, and then he was just so good. I got a chance to know him a little bit at working at ASPN together with him. Yeah, he's right up there. I just feel like he set a standard. I think he set the standard. Yeah, and that's why I'm going to put him there now.
00:43:06
Speaker 2: But, Chris, man, if Jeremiah has a Heisman, I think he bumps you in my– I'm outrushed more the next time.
00:43:13
Speaker 1: All right.
00:43:13
Speaker 2: What about you, brother?
00:43:13
Speaker 1: All right. First two are the same. Woody Hayes, Archie Griffin, you know, no more needs to be said. Navigard. I'm going to go Eddie George.
00:43:21
Speaker 2: That's a good one.
00:43:23
Speaker 1: Uh, I was in Trump for winter and kind of, kind of brought things back. It's funny. So I, I, I covered college football that, that year. And, and, uh, I was there when he won the Heisman is funny because there's a lot of speculation. Oh my God, this is going to be the closest Heisman competition. Nobody knows who's going to win. And, uh, No, it actually wound up being pretty clear-cut. It was Eddie George. So as I wrote that day for the Washington Post. Who was the runner-up that day? I know Darnell Autry was a finalist from Northwestern. Running back from Northwestern.
00:43:56
Speaker 2: Drinking game. Boy, you didn't see that one coming.
00:43:59
Speaker 1: Not in the Heisman. We're talking Heisman Trophy room. But, you know, it was a running back from the Big Ten, which there have been probably certainly at that time, more of those than any other Heisman Trophy winners. But also literally the
impression he made of me. So I was covering Ohio State practice and we're standing on the sideline and he comes running out and he just kind of ran the ball all the way down the field. And this guy ran by me and I'm thinking, God, I would hate to tackle this guy. He's such a big guy. He moves so well. Just, you know, an incredible running back who's doing really well as a coach now. But I... The visual impression he made of me, you know, it's kind of what the epitome of what an Ohio State running back should look like. And again, this is the 90s, so we're still in the era when Ohio State meant running backs.
00:44:49
Speaker 2: Wasn't he one of those guys that did the ballet for flexibility? And he's like, he really is sort of a, he's wired a bit differently. He's a big, I think, like I said, a classical music guy. It's my understanding he really is sort of Renaissance man-esque.
00:45:07
Speaker 1: I know he moves extremely well, so I wouldn't be surprised if he was balletic.
00:45:13
Speaker 2: Had learned some ballet moves. But it was like, done. I know he's not the first football player, but to learn the flexibility, you know, and strengthening that.
00:45:23
Speaker 1: Lin Swan was big on that. I saw a video recently of Peyton's play, so they revisited that, his days with the Pittsburgh Steelers. All right, Chuck, my final one is a wild card. Eugene Weigel, the creator of Script Ohio.
00:45:38
Speaker 2: Oh, wow.
00:45:40
Speaker 1: This is your love. I told you, Chuck. I love me some Script Ohio.
00:45:45
Speaker 2: I was just going to say, you know, the running gag for both Jay and I in this to let you in a little bit. It's like, you know, we're both sort of root for schools that have been like where Ohio State has caused us pain. They've been more like a kidney stone to us than anything else. But your enthusiasm for Script Ohio has been contagious. I mean, you really... And I mean it. Like, because it does... It is, you know, there's the pageantry of college football. This is their piece of the pageantry. So I love it. Good for you. Good on you.
00:46:13
Speaker 1: So he's not responsible for what they're doing lately. So like the last 10 years or so, what they've done is they use these computer-assisted designs for the marching formations, right? So now they have these dynamic formations. So they've had a moonwalking Michael Jackson. They had a T-Rex for Jurassic Park feature. The T-Rex, like, bends down and bites something they've had a top gun fighter jet soaring and taking off so kind of the modern iteration you know it was something that mr weigel probably couldn't have dreamed of uh is these really incredible uh band marching formations that have gone viral on social media from time to time so that's kind of he's not responsible for that but i think he created this this uh stand you talk about chris carter setting the receiver standard i think I think Eugene Weigel said the marching band standard that Ohio State has certainly lived up to and built upon over the decades.
00:47:14
Speaker 2: Well, I think I love it. I think those are fair picks on that. And like I said, the only hesitance I have on mine is we're in the middle of, I think Jeremiah Smith is going to be one of the most famous players in the history of that program.
00:47:32
Speaker 1: You can put him on. Chuck, there was some negative feedback when the NBA came out with its 50 all-time team on its 50th anniversary and Shaquille O'Neal was on there. A lot of people thought, well, you know, he really hasn't done anything. Certainly hadn't won any championships by then. Hadn't won an MVP. But looking back on the all-time 50 team, yeah, Shaquille O'Neal is there. It looks right. It'll look weird. Right.
00:47:56
Speaker 2: This is one that I am hoping will age well, which is why I have the... I have my Chris Carter backup plan there.
00:48:06
Speaker 1: Chuck and I and our team read some great books as part of our research for this episode. We want to share those with you. They were Ohio State Football, The Forgotten Dawn by Robert J. Roman. Greatest Moments in Ohio State Football History by Jack Park. A Fire to Win, The Life and Times of Woody Hayes by John Lombardo. And I read War as They Knew It, Woody Hayes, Beauchamp Beckler, and America in a Time of Unrest by Michael Rosenberg. Also, Buckeye Rebirth, Urban Meyer, an inspired team, and a new era at Ohio State by Bill Rabinowitz.
00:48:37
Speaker 2: A quick reminder, please follow us on social media, Dynastic, at DynasticPod. And follow, like, and review us wherever you listen to your podcast. Or, of course, on our YouTube channel, we will take all those five-star reviews that you want to get us. And, of course, constructive critiques. We love those as well.
00:48:56
Speaker 1: Along with our executive producer and partner, Steve Hull, we want to thank Andrew Sampson, the head of programming at our production partner, Showboat Media, Kevin Kennedy, our producer, and Meredith Bioli, our researcher. Thank you for all your hard work.
00:49:08
Speaker 2: And in our next episode, our third and final episode on the history of the Ohio State football program, we'll be interviewing a major figure from the Buckeye football community. We're looking forward to it, and we'll see you then.
00:49:22
Speaker 1: O-H. I-O.