TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:08.287 --> 00:11.149
[SPEAKER_02]: From the nation magazine, this is Start Making Sense.
00:11.629 --> 00:12.489
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm John Weiner.
00:13.270 --> 00:16.951
[SPEAKER_02]: Later in the show, how socialism can work in the real world.
00:17.272 --> 00:22.334
[SPEAKER_02]: Last Garsun Cara will explain, his new co-authored book is The Blueprint.
00:23.014 --> 00:27.957
[SPEAKER_02]: But first, the Texas earthquake, Steve Phillips, will comment in a minute.
00:30.058 --> 00:34.521
[SPEAKER_02]: The most significant single race of the year turned out to be the one nobody predicted.
00:34.981 --> 00:38.423
[SPEAKER_02]: The election of Gina Inahosa is the governor of Texas.
00:38.943 --> 00:41.445
[SPEAKER_02]: For comment and analysis, we turn to Steve Phillips.
00:41.985 --> 00:45.167
[SPEAKER_02]: He wrote the best seller, Brown is the new white.
00:45.227 --> 00:48.869
[SPEAKER_02]: How the demographic revolution has created a new American majority.
00:49.489 --> 00:59.946
[SPEAKER_02]: He hosts the podcast, Democracy, and Color, he writes for the Guardian, the Washington Post, and the nation, and his new book has the wonderful title, our white men smarter than everybody else.
01:00.306 --> 01:01.949
[SPEAKER_02]: It's a USA today, bestseller.
01:02.310 --> 01:03.552
[SPEAKER_02]: Steve Phillips, welcome back.
01:04.156 --> 01:04.896
[SPEAKER_02]: They're threatening.
01:05.236 --> 01:23.761
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, our best political forecasters did not think Gina Inahosa would win, Nate Silver didn't, neither did the cook report, neither did any of the best pollsters at the New York Times and the Washington Post, but Gina Inahosa beat Greg Abbott, 53 to 46.
01:24.161 --> 01:25.061
[SPEAKER_02]: It wasn't close.
01:25.761 --> 01:38.337
[SPEAKER_02]: You say that victory is not just the biggest surprise, it's more consequential for the future of American politics than any of the other amazing victories that we had last week.
01:38.638 --> 01:40.820
[SPEAKER_02]: Why is it more consequential?
01:41.577 --> 01:49.319
[SPEAKER_03]: For two reasons, we'll probably even three, but one is we should not skip over that, you know, there's now millions of people in Texas whose lives will be better.
01:49.780 --> 01:55.601
[SPEAKER_03]: And we'll not have to deal with constant oppression and suppression, hostility and attacks.
01:55.761 --> 02:06.044
[SPEAKER_03]: They've eliminated many of not most of the higher ed programs that for anybody who's not a straight white man, eliminated all the diversity programs and women and people of color.
02:06.064 --> 02:07.305
[SPEAKER_03]: It's just the quality of life.
02:07.925 --> 02:09.287
[SPEAKER_03]: has been very, very difficult.
02:09.347 --> 02:11.048
[SPEAKER_03]: And so just we shouldn't skip over that.
02:11.088 --> 02:15.953
[SPEAKER_03]: And there's what that will mean in terms of having both Gina and the Texas State House being democratic.
02:16.574 --> 02:17.956
[SPEAKER_03]: So you take that as one piece.
02:18.656 --> 02:24.663
[SPEAKER_03]: Then another reason, in terms of the national significance, and this is what I wrote about, for the nation back in 2021,
02:26.264 --> 02:40.869
[SPEAKER_03]: after Georgia left after the work of the AC Abrams over a decade, the registered voters there and sent Ossiff and Warlock to the U.S. Senate in 2021 and flipped the entire United States Senate balance of power.
02:41.749 --> 02:55.034
[SPEAKER_03]: And so that everything was able to happen from that standpoint, where the AC called me in 2021, I was like, so you took that first money we helped you raise in 2010 years ago and you've turned it into $2 trillion for the American people.
02:55.674 --> 03:09.928
[SPEAKER_03]: as I like to provide return on investment, you know, obviously the Biden record is mixed, but everything positive that happened in those years would not have happened had Georgia not flipped and had that work not taken place.
03:10.949 --> 03:16.474
[SPEAKER_03]: Texas is both larger and more racially diverse than Georgia.
03:16.954 --> 03:21.758
[SPEAKER_03]: Texasism is 51% of its eligible voters, our people of color.
03:22.759 --> 03:24.980
[SPEAKER_03]: There are more Latinos in Texas than whites.
03:25.321 --> 03:36.109
[SPEAKER_03]: So the popular conception is that Texas is, you know, white men in cowboy boots and they are there, but that's not the majority of the people.
03:36.930 --> 03:55.602
[SPEAKER_03]: And so the significance is both in the federal balance of power in terms of the U.S. Senate seats in the composition of the House of Representatives and also then looking at the presidential that Texas has been reliably Republican in terms of its voting if it's a partisan skew.
03:56.527 --> 04:05.274
[SPEAKER_03]: But if you take that out of the Electoral College equation for the Republicans, then you're almost having to know where to go in terms of 2028 and beyond.
04:05.835 --> 04:07.676
[SPEAKER_03]: And so that's what was so significant.
04:07.696 --> 04:13.581
[SPEAKER_03]: And then it shows the path that the Democrats are losing Latino voters.
04:13.621 --> 04:17.244
[SPEAKER_03]: They moved over to Trump and whatnot.
04:18.225 --> 04:33.853
[SPEAKER_03]: I was watching racial matter election night and they were smart enough to send a Latino reporter to Gianna Jose's victory party, the joy of the young Latina women there when the race was called for her.
04:34.053 --> 04:35.854
[SPEAKER_03]: It was like transcendent.
04:36.969 --> 04:43.655
[SPEAKER_03]: And that's the kind of depth of allegiance and partnership and connection that's generational.
04:44.235 --> 04:57.547
[SPEAKER_03]: And so if she's locking in, young Latinos and Latinos as seeing the Democratic Party is looking like them and being for them, the long term implications of that for politics in this country are enormous.
04:58.570 --> 05:15.822
[SPEAKER_02]: I want to take the step back to two years ago when Trump won a majority of the
Load full transcript
popular vote nationally, Terrible Day, a huge number of pundits declared Trump's victory in 2024, even though it was only one and a half percentage points that that represented
05:16.342 --> 05:37.887
[SPEAKER_02]: A fundamental realignment in American politics, and they said it was led by Latinos, switching from the Democrats to the Republicans, especially in Texas, especially in the Rio Grand Valley, which four years before Joe Biden had won those counties by 15 points, Trump for the first time carried all of them in 2024.
05:39.407 --> 05:55.940
[SPEAKER_02]: Now, this year, the shift from Republican to Democratic votes in the midterm nationwide is what, 14 or 15 points, how much did the governor's race shift in Texas towards the Democrats compared to 2024?
05:56.621 --> 06:05.608
[SPEAKER_03]: It was a 2021 point shift in terms of the partisan lean in terms of where things actually went from the prior election to what we actually saw in 2016, which is enormous.
06:08.443 --> 06:14.185
[SPEAKER_02]: One conclusion some people might draw is that Texas Latinos are very volatile a group.
06:14.265 --> 06:22.628
[SPEAKER_02]: They flipped it gigantically from 2024 to 2026, maybe they'll flip back again in 2028.
06:23.488 --> 06:25.549
[SPEAKER_02]: What do you think of that possibility?
06:26.089 --> 06:30.471
[SPEAKER_03]: That's why genus race in particular is so strategically significant.
06:30.731 --> 06:34.092
[SPEAKER_03]: If we're just a situation of Latinos repudiating
06:34.892 --> 06:49.186
[SPEAKER_03]: Trump administration and all of its hostility and all of its attacks, frankly, on Latinos noise, other communities, and they voted in favor of white guys, let's just tell Rico, you could say, well, maybe it would switch back, etc.
06:49.286 --> 06:50.927
[SPEAKER_03]: I mean, that's underlying issue here around.
06:51.608 --> 06:56.511
[SPEAKER_03]: Democrats not being willing to be seen as fighting for Latino issues.
06:56.911 --> 07:01.694
[SPEAKER_03]: And so they are not embedded in the psyche and the culture as the champions of Latinos.
07:01.714 --> 07:08.578
[SPEAKER_03]: They've been more concerned about alienating whites who might be mad that they're too close to Latinos.
07:08.638 --> 07:10.439
[SPEAKER_03]: So that's been a fundamental dynamic.
07:10.960 --> 07:12.801
[SPEAKER_03]: So yes, it could go back and forth.
07:13.541 --> 07:25.472
[SPEAKER_03]: It has somewhat gone back and forth, certainly from 2022 when it was democratic in the 2024, when there was more of a move to Trump and then back here to ring her six.
07:26.053 --> 07:28.255
[SPEAKER_03]: But this is why Gina is so significant.
07:28.535 --> 07:35.482
[SPEAKER_03]: This is not just a issue around this set of issues or inflation or even the ice crackdown to what not.
07:36.529 --> 07:44.536
[SPEAKER_03]: this is somebody people can identify with and who can personalify the community comes from the Rio Grande Valley.
07:45.096 --> 07:50.921
[SPEAKER_03]: She is
a progressive Latina who has worked in the civil rights law area.
07:51.742 --> 08:07.415
[SPEAKER_03]: And so she connects culturally as well as politically, and that's the kind of deeper psychological, cultural, social connection that's far more enduring and less likely to switch on election to election.
08:08.377 --> 08:13.339
[SPEAKER_02]: We're told the number one issue for white voters everywhere was the cost of living.
08:13.920 --> 08:19.002
[SPEAKER_02]: Do you think Latinos care more about high prices than white people?
08:19.222 --> 08:25.125
[SPEAKER_02]: Is that why the turnout was so gigantic or was there another issue?
08:25.245 --> 08:28.527
[SPEAKER_02]: While Latinos switched from Trump.
08:29.067 --> 08:29.988
[SPEAKER_03]: Affordability.
08:30.628 --> 08:40.977
[SPEAKER_03]: Let reality is real, but I think it's limited in terms of its, and so if you look at Latinos, African-Americans, actual women, we don't leave all, keep it saying, oh, it's like about kitchen table issues.
08:41.477 --> 08:51.185
[SPEAKER_03]: There is a, a, a, a gargantuan racial wealth gap in this country between whites and Latinos, between whites and African-Americans, there's a very sizable gender pay gap.
08:51.545 --> 08:55.148
[SPEAKER_03]: Those are kitchen table issues, but a lot of Democrats don't want to lean into them.
08:55.208 --> 08:58.071
[SPEAKER_03]: So I say that to say that affordability has always been an issue.
08:58.471 --> 08:59.672
[SPEAKER_03]: for Latino community.
09:00.273 --> 09:16.527
[SPEAKER_03]: It really has to do with the hostility and the hatred that has been core to Trump's rise is hatred and hostility and demonization of Mexican Americans in particular.
09:16.687 --> 09:20.531
[SPEAKER_03]: They're rapists, they're murderers, and it's very first presidential speech in 2015.
09:21.832 --> 09:39.239
[SPEAKER_03]: And then you take, you know, Steven Miller and people coming in power and the what they've done with ice and unleashing that on communities and breaking up families, that's just been a, you know, a really a bridge too far in terms of assaulting this community and what it is all about.
09:39.279 --> 09:47.882
[SPEAKER_03]: So I think those issues are actually much more core and fundamental on top of the underlying affordability piece.
09:48.653 --> 10:02.459
[SPEAKER_02]: And as far as the 2028 goes, if Trump had learned to moderate his policies regarding Mexican Americans, it's conceivable he might have made some progress.
10:02.519 --> 10:05.801
[SPEAKER_02]: But appointing Stephen Miller, as you say, this is doubling down.
10:05.881 --> 10:14.325
[SPEAKER_02]: So it's likely to get worse and more frightening to be perfectly frank about it for Latinos everywhere in the United States and especially in Texas.
10:15.214 --> 10:18.696
[SPEAKER_03]: Yes, and but now there's been so much progress at the state and local level.
10:18.776 --> 10:32.662
[SPEAKER_03]: So if you're just looking at the, you know, the different newspapers and the different counties that the leadership in Harris County in Houston and Austin, they are now directing their local police to not cooperate with ICE.
10:33.442 --> 10:39.307
[SPEAKER_03]: And so they had to before because of Abbott and the really repressive state leadership.
10:39.907 --> 10:43.310
[SPEAKER_03]: Harris County, where Houston is larger than 25 states.
10:44.291 --> 10:45.912
[SPEAKER_03]: And so it's enormous.
10:45.952 --> 10:55.320
[SPEAKER_03]: And so if you can really make some progress there, improve people's lives, back off the repression, it's quite consequential both there and statewide.
10:55.938 --> 11:02.861
[SPEAKER_02]: And you say in your article in the nation, Latinos were the cornerstone of Inohosis when, but they were not alone.
11:03.402 --> 11:04.362
[SPEAKER_02]: Please tell us about that.
11:04.922 --> 11:10.405
[SPEAKER_03]: Texas has actually one of the largest concentrations of African Americans in this country.
11:10.945 --> 11:12.546
[SPEAKER_03]: It's in terms of the raw numbers of people.
11:12.566 --> 11:13.587
[SPEAKER_03]: There's a very big state.
11:14.127 --> 11:17.328
[SPEAKER_03]: And so the black community, the black voters, went very large.
11:17.348 --> 11:23.391
[SPEAKER_03]: And again, it always happens, black women are the single most progressive, certainly most democratic voting block, as well as different
11:24.832 --> 11:25.913
[SPEAKER_03]: Finally following behind them.
11:26.473 --> 11:27.954
[SPEAKER_03]: So she did quite well there.
11:28.034 --> 11:35.778
[SPEAKER_03]: So that and there was a larger turnout of black voters as well through group plate technical organizing project and other and efforts like that.
11:36.558 --> 11:39.439
[SPEAKER_03]: That was another a part of the cornerstone.
11:39.459 --> 11:45.042
[SPEAKER_03]: So the other Latino piece and then you have the African American part, which has always been solid democratic but got bigger in this election.
11:45.102 --> 11:46.803
[SPEAKER_03]: So that made it even more possible.
11:46.823 --> 11:54.129
[SPEAKER_02]: I just want to spend one more minute on the fact that Gina Inahosa is not just Hispanic, she's also a woman.
11:54.730 --> 11:55.310
[SPEAKER_03]: Oh, exactly.
11:55.330 --> 11:56.471
[SPEAKER_03]: Which is something people have in it.
11:56.511 --> 12:00.135
[SPEAKER_03]: And I've actually kind of wondered about, I'm not wondering about, worried about.
12:01.115 --> 12:09.323
[SPEAKER_03]: And there's very too, there's much too little discussion of the, you know, when people say that, that oftentimes the clearest, most simple answer is the right answer.
12:09.783 --> 12:11.525
[SPEAKER_03]: Now Trump is one for president three times.
12:12.105 --> 12:14.287
[SPEAKER_03]: twice against a woman once against a man.
12:14.987 --> 12:17.129
[SPEAKER_03]: And the only time he lost was against the man.
12:17.609 --> 12:29.538
[SPEAKER_03]: And so if we believe that I certainly do that
sexism transcends the different demographic groups that had to come into play as a factor in 2024 with Kamala.
12:31.780 --> 12:34.781
[SPEAKER_03]: And so it raises the question around, what is the potential?
12:34.821 --> 12:36.781
[SPEAKER_03]: What are the challenges that we fade?
12:36.802 --> 12:42.363
[SPEAKER_03]: The additional challenges in terms of trying to get the electorate to embrace a woman leader.
12:42.923 --> 12:50.165
[SPEAKER_03]: And so the fact that Gina actually prevailed and did that is very, very encouraging on multiple different levels.
12:50.205 --> 12:54.927
[SPEAKER_03]: And it is interesting that the prior democratic governor was also a woman.
12:55.007 --> 12:57.187
[SPEAKER_03]: And Richards back in 1994, and whatnot.
12:57.247 --> 12:58.708
[SPEAKER_03]: So there isn't anything to be said there.
12:59.612 --> 13:13.725
[SPEAKER_02]: When more Factor, I asked Claude AI, how many voters of color in Texas did not vote in 2026, and they came up with an estimate of something like 5 million or 6 million.
13:14.326 --> 13:18.329
[SPEAKER_02]: I wonder if you agree with that number, and I wonder what you conclude from that number.
13:19.176 --> 13:20.897
[SPEAKER_03]: So yes, I do agree with that number.
13:20.937 --> 13:26.661
[SPEAKER_03]: We've cited the similar numbers off looking at 2024, 2022 from the census.
13:26.901 --> 13:31.444
[SPEAKER_03]: They put out voting statistics and it's been around that number there.
13:31.544 --> 13:36.047
[SPEAKER_03]: So it was probably a little bit small because turn out was higher, but they over aggregate at speeds.
13:36.107 --> 13:40.430
[SPEAKER_03]: We're in the realm of 5 million people of color who did not vote.
13:41.230 --> 13:51.477
[SPEAKER_03]: And so that is an enormous upside, and it's an important lesson too, because right now, you know, the next week, it'll be this moderate Democrats gathered, how about where do we go from here?
13:51.497 --> 13:59.103
[SPEAKER_03]: And because there's all these efforts that continuing to try to woo more of the moderate, and if there are such a thing, but the whites who are not with us,
14:00.132 --> 14:01.955
[SPEAKER_03]: where as the upside is enormous.
14:02.515 --> 14:09.164
[SPEAKER_03]: And so one of the, like there's a group being Texas for all that's done working at a precinct captain program.
14:09.485 --> 14:11.808
[SPEAKER_03]: To be able to get as many people out to vote.
14:12.288 --> 14:13.430
[SPEAKER_03]: That's the future.
14:13.450 --> 14:16.634
[SPEAKER_03]: In terms of locking this down solidly is having every single,
14:17.355 --> 14:31.228
[SPEAKER_03]: precinct in the state have a precinct captain so we can get those five million more voters out and that's also will help flip the state Senate, which will then make checks Texas the blue trifecta state, which will be enormous as well.
14:32.102 --> 14:38.685
[SPEAKER_02]: five million more voters of color to be turned out at the polls next time around.
14:39.166 --> 14:41.227
[SPEAKER_02]: Steve Phillips, you can read his latest piece.
14:41.607 --> 14:48.270
[SPEAKER_02]: Gina Inahos' win was the most important of the entire midterms at thenation.com.
14:48.871 --> 14:50.411
[SPEAKER_02]: Steve, thanks for all your work.
14:50.712 --> 14:52.232
[SPEAKER_02]: It thanks for talking with us today.
14:52.833 --> 14:53.433
[SPEAKER_02]: Thanks for having me.
15:06.087 --> 15:19.876
[SPEAKER_02]: Now it's time to talk about socialism with Boskarsun Kara, of course he's president of the nation magazine, founding editor of Jacob and the columnist for the Guardian and co-author of the new book, The Blueprint, how socialism can work in the real world.
15:20.056 --> 15:20.977
[SPEAKER_02]: Boskars welcome back.
15:21.377 --> 15:22.158
[SPEAKER_02]: Thanks for having me, John.
15:22.498 --> 15:24.979
[SPEAKER_02]: Well, first, can we talk briefly about the election?
15:25.359 --> 15:26.039
[SPEAKER_02]: A few facts.
15:26.559 --> 15:31.701
[SPEAKER_02]: In addition to gaming control of both houses of Congress, Democrats gained six governorships.
15:31.801 --> 15:40.284
[SPEAKER_02]: Now Democrats will lead nine of the ten most popular states will govern states representing 75% of Americans.
15:40.804 --> 15:44.645
[SPEAKER_02]: Democrats also won six new state government trifectas.
15:45.246 --> 15:49.947
[SPEAKER_02]: Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, Michigan, Minnesota, and out west
15:52.428 --> 16:01.334
[SPEAKER_02]: Nearly every group of voters move towards Democrats, the biggest shifts came among Latinos, Asians, young people, and rural voters.
16:01.954 --> 16:05.396
[SPEAKER_02]: So what do Democrats need to do now?
16:06.097 --> 16:10.240
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I think for one, we should just obviously be excited about what's happened.
16:10.260 --> 16:15.543
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, the victory and this is simply especially, and it looks like it's headed toward a victory that
16:15.963 --> 16:22.171
[SPEAKER_01]: is one of the biggest triumphs of the broad left in the US since reconstruction.
16:22.471 --> 16:32.603
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a symbolism of obviously we know that the economic part of the revolution needs to be finished, but the long battle against Jim Crow, the long battle,
16:33.003 --> 16:39.265
[SPEAKER_01]: to have people see each other as equals in society, the long sugar struggle of racial justice.
16:39.345 --> 16:40.806
[SPEAKER_01]: It is a real victory in that regard.
16:40.826 --> 16:54.150
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think from a lot of the left that has grown up in this more pessimistic environment where we've been unable to say, yes, you know, the election of Barack Obama and him winning a state like Indiana in 2008 actually means something as far as Burrometer of our success.
16:54.370 --> 16:57.352
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, this victory especially Mississippi does matter.
16:57.852 --> 17:01.033
[SPEAKER_01]: And broadly, you know, the victory is in Texas does matter.
17:01.713 --> 17:23.985
[SPEAKER_01]: where I put sort of some caution, you know, in the mix is just simply the environment was so favorable for Democrats, not because of the seats that were contested and they had a pretty rough map in the Senate, but simply because of how on popular Trump is, you know, appropriating these by some measures in the low thirties, really on popular Iran war, spiking diesel prices,
17:28.948 --> 17:48.199
[SPEAKER_01]: the general sense that he's not delivering on his promises, this yielded a really favorable terrain for any opposition party, and I think more work needs to be done to make sure that democratic party gains stick, particularly in rural and summer rural areas, where Democrats were used to losing 37.
17:49.500 --> 17:55.185
[SPEAKER_01]: And this election is sort of proof that if you lose 40, 60, you can be competitive, stay alive in a lot of these places.
17:55.866 --> 18:02.351
[SPEAKER_01]: And this isn't even me making a round of socials point, this is saying, let's look back to the Howard Dean 50 state strategy.
18:02.672 --> 18:08.637
[SPEAKER_01]: Let's look to the people wherever they were in the spectrum, that decided to invest in Mississippi.
18:08.677 --> 18:09.558
[SPEAKER_01]: Thought it was winnable.
18:09.898 --> 18:16.924
[SPEAKER_01]: People cared about the races in Kentucky, which would have been winnable on Tennessee, which would have been winnable if there was more investment.
18:17.164 --> 18:27.111
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't care where they are in the spectrum, I think those are the voices to sort of elevate and we're sort of the focus of the party should be going forward, but obviously it's very exciting.
18:27.451 --> 18:35.597
[SPEAKER_01]: It's now easier to see the map to get to 58-59 solid Democrats in the Senate in the next cycle, and maybe he could approach like...
18:35.817 --> 18:53.743
[SPEAKER_01]: like some sort of grand compromise the labor can make with the Josh Holleyes of the world and and others not that I generally support working with those people but you know if you get if you get something like the proact past I think it could really change the the game as far as the organized workers move into this country.
18:53.803 --> 18:55.384
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's very exciting.
18:55.424 --> 18:59.445
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm much more optimistic about the direction this country can go in and that I was a month ago.
19:00.682 --> 19:08.509
[SPEAKER_02]: your book, the blueprint how socialism can work in the real world starts with the fact that capitalism is not working for most people.
19:08.709 --> 19:09.710
[SPEAKER_02]: That's pretty obvious.
19:10.131 --> 19:18.178
[SPEAKER_02]: But the big question of course is what is to be done and there's one preliminary objection to the whole project of a blueprint for socialism.
19:18.438 --> 19:19.860
[SPEAKER_02]: It goes all the way back to Marx.
19:20.260 --> 19:22.422
[SPEAKER_02]: He never wrote anything like the blueprint.
19:22.482 --> 19:29.489
[SPEAKER_02]: His view was that the workers themselves should decide what they needed and wanted, and it would be a mistake.
19:29.729 --> 19:30.630
[SPEAKER_02]: It would be wrong.
19:30.831 --> 19:36.456
[SPEAKER_02]: It would be on democratic for leaders and intellectuals to tell workers what they needed.
19:37.037 --> 19:38.858
[SPEAKER_02]: Why do you disagree with that?
19:38.898 --> 19:42.022
[SPEAKER_02]: Why do you think socialists owe people a concrete model?
19:43.262 --> 19:56.553
[SPEAKER_01]: The whole idea of a blueprint today is to tell people that, in fact, despite the past failures of different models of socialism, the barriers to constructing a better world are political, not technical.
19:57.053 --> 20:00.536
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's a great start of a conversation if you're a socialist.
20:01.247 --> 20:09.196
[SPEAKER_02]: It's easy enough to see what the minimum program of socialism is, robust public system of social support.
20:09.497 --> 20:16.565
[SPEAKER_02]: We all know it, Medicare for all, free childcare, free public college, strong unions, higher minimum wages.
20:17.406 --> 20:30.753
[SPEAKER_02]: You know, decent housing, clean water and air, basically with the social democracies of Denmark, Norway, and Sweden achieved at their peak, you call them the most livable societies that human beings ever built.
20:31.253 --> 20:37.856
[SPEAKER_02]: But there's one huge thing missing even from Scandinavian socialism, from the viewpoint of socialists.
20:38.436 --> 20:39.217
[SPEAKER_02]: Tell us about that.
20:40.146 --> 20:45.148
[SPEAKER_01]: ultimately it left huge chunks of the economy and private hands.
20:45.528 --> 20:49.430
[SPEAKER_01]: So there should be a couple objections come to this in the social perspective.
20:49.850 --> 20:57.273
[SPEAKER_01]: We as socialists don't believe in this sort of division of society between those who own and those who have to work for them.
20:57.813 --> 21:08.342
[SPEAKER_01]: We think that in those conditions, even entering into our free contract as a laborer is sort of a contract made underdress, a sort of worker star of bargain.
21:08.923 --> 21:18.451
[SPEAKER_01]: Furthermore, we believe that there's tons of capacity that ordinary workers have to make decisions about production to participate in the democratic governance of a firm.
21:18.471 --> 21:24.016
[SPEAKER_01]: So we favor, instead of private capital ownership, labor-managed firm, purely on that normal basis.
21:24.656 --> 21:46.105
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, there's a lot of people who say, well, my objection to capitalism is mostly distributional and it's mostly about the outcomes of poverty, of neglect, of, you know, women not being able to be truly free because they don't have access to child care for instance and that shaping with their outlook in life and their opportunity to support to them.
21:46.465 --> 21:57.062
[SPEAKER_01]: for someone being perpetually unemployed and not being able to fully participate in civil
society because they're always worried about under employment and not being having the money to participate in civil society.
21:57.522 --> 21:58.624
[SPEAKER_01]: For those people I would say,
21:59.426 --> 22:18.180
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I, one, perfectly agree with all those social democratic objections to capitalism, but even if you just want a robust welfare state that expands and continues to expand to meet, meets people needs, and as we have more productivity gains is, you know, we plow more of that those gains into the welfare state.
22:18.760 --> 22:31.004
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you're still allowing a class of people who have a vested interest in keeping people insecure enough to accept unacceptable bargains at work.
22:31.584 --> 22:42.267
[SPEAKER_01]: So my, in my view, the social project is about both voice, voice in the workplace, voice in civil society, the democratic voice aspect, but it's also about giving people exit options.
22:42.687 --> 22:45.368
[SPEAKER_01]: And under capitalism, those exit
22:46.948 --> 23:01.036
[SPEAKER_01]: are limited and by simply the fact that ordinary people have to work for a living in our dependant jobs created disproportionately by private capitalists, we can't have a true democracy.
23:01.971 --> 23:06.136
[SPEAKER_02]: So, voice, democracy in the workplace, worker control.
23:06.216 --> 23:09.359
[SPEAKER_02]: That's really the heart of the socialist idea.
23:10.200 --> 23:13.904
[SPEAKER_02]: The first problem there is the conflict between what consumers want.
23:14.445 --> 23:19.250
[SPEAKER_02]: Now we're calling it affordability and what workers want, basically, higher wages.
23:19.751 --> 23:22.554
[SPEAKER_02]: What's your proposal about how that should be decided?
23:23.241 --> 23:26.645
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, simply, the market mechanism does, in fact, resolve this.
23:27.105 --> 23:38.517
[SPEAKER_01]: People are given choice as consumers to look for items on the basis of quality and also cost and take sort of like, you know, pick between an array of choices.
23:39.558 --> 23:42.762
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's something that actually works quite well in capitalism.
23:43.242 --> 23:55.243
[SPEAKER_01]: The problem with this consumer choice and capitalism is obviously are grossly unequal distribution of income, which a social society could resolve through taxes and transfers and to get down into your right to work.
23:55.701 --> 24:09.766
[SPEAKER_01]: and all sorts of things, but the actual choice and also the fact these choices are private, you know, does matter, but workers simply would compete with other firms, other labor manner firms for market share.
24:10.346 --> 24:24.071
[SPEAKER_01]: They would find their market niche, they would grow and expand at a more efficient or they will contract and fail and I think this is the market mechanism actually working well and serving egalitarian outcomes.
24:25.346 --> 24:46.031
[SPEAKER_02]: You also propose investment banks that are public institutions that would decide which worker controlled firms would be allowed to borrow money to expand or upgrade, but those decisions require economic expertise that ordinary workers, ordinary people don't have.
24:46.131 --> 24:48.752
[SPEAKER_02]: So how would that be democratic?
24:49.877 --> 25:06.912
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I think for one, the Democratic aspect comes merely in today, the expansion of existence for arms or the creation of your arms is entirely dependent on the, or not entirely, mostly dependent on the entrepreneurial risk of capuous.
25:07.780 --> 25:10.041
[SPEAKER_01]: and also their ability to secure capital.
25:10.201 --> 25:16.304
[SPEAKER_01]: So sometimes they secure capital by starting a new venture and seeking equity partners.
25:16.604 --> 25:22.347
[SPEAKER_01]: So sort of dead for their kind of raising their capital in that rubber bar.
25:23.207 --> 25:28.289
[SPEAKER_01]: Other times are getting dead from a private bank.
25:28.349 --> 25:29.550
[SPEAKER_01]: They're taking out loans.
25:30.339 --> 25:39.570
[SPEAKER_01]: So if we accept the capitalist aren't entirely parasites in the performing this useful function, we have to find a way to socialize this function in a socialist system.
25:40.310 --> 25:44.215
[SPEAKER_01]: We do this by turning private banks into public banks.
25:44.796 --> 25:50.322
[SPEAKER_01]: These public banks and these bankers would simply like existing capitalist bankers.
25:51.089 --> 25:58.533
[SPEAKER_01]: be trying to give out loans and sort of maximize returns within a given risk profile.
25:58.873 --> 26:05.336
[SPEAKER_01]: There would also be state-run development banks, which exist in the world today, that would serve longer-term social objectives.
26:05.376 --> 26:07.697
[SPEAKER_01]: Let's say we want to invest in this region.
26:07.817 --> 26:09.398
[SPEAKER_01]: Is this region is lagged behind?
26:09.498 --> 26:12.500
[SPEAKER_01]: We want to lower unemployment here.
26:12.820 --> 26:15.741
[SPEAKER_01]: We have this big infrastructure project.
26:15.781 --> 26:16.582
[SPEAKER_01]: That those are sort of,
26:17.822 --> 26:24.144
[SPEAKER_01]: long-term profitable things, but short-term might not be profitable, so there would still be that function.
26:24.684 --> 26:36.887
[SPEAKER_01]: The actual decision of a banker or of a bank to give additional funds to a firm to allow to expand or reject a business plan is not a democratic decision.
26:36.927 --> 26:39.208
[SPEAKER_01]: That decision is sort of a technocratic decision.
26:39.648 --> 26:49.518
[SPEAKER_01]: the recourse that these worker managed firms would have is that they could seek sort of different banks to be the partners with any given project.
26:49.799 --> 26:56.085
[SPEAKER_01]: But the democratic part comes in simply from socializing the function as a whole.
26:56.145 --> 26:58.348
[SPEAKER_01]: And again, you know, this might sound sort of
27:02.652 --> 27:09.854
[SPEAKER_01]: over the past 200 plus years has
been this reconciliation of democratic equality and technical expertise.
27:10.114 --> 27:21.238
[SPEAKER_01]: So this is a battle we'll continue to have to figure out what should be within this fear of one person, one vote, you know, democratic decision making and what should be a, you know, a technocratic function.
27:22.180 --> 27:30.243
[SPEAKER_02]: One of the deepest criticisms of your project here is your reliance on markets.
27:31.083 --> 27:43.728
[SPEAKER_02]: Some of our friends say markets by definition push people to be selfish and competitive to make fear and greed central to life, basically to make people like capitalists.
27:43.928 --> 27:48.750
[SPEAKER_02]: Isn't the market the enemy of community and equality?
27:49.427 --> 27:53.852
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I would say the market certainly, competitive markets are by definition of competitors.
27:53.872 --> 27:57.475
[SPEAKER_01]: So it does push the firms towards competition.
27:58.376 --> 28:00.839
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's a virtue in certain respects.
28:00.919 --> 28:06.084
[SPEAKER_01]: So one, I believe in reclaiming efficiency as a socialist value.
28:06.425 --> 28:11.050
[SPEAKER_01]: So if you're at a firm that can produce,
28:11.610 --> 28:17.852
[SPEAKER_01]: 10 widgets it with four hours of time and use less natural resources doing it.
28:18.332 --> 28:26.995
[SPEAKER_01]: Wouldn't you want that firm to succeed and expand compared to the firm that waste 10 hours of people's time and more resources produce the same 10 widgets?
28:27.496 --> 28:29.836
[SPEAKER_01]: So I think this efficiency is a value.
28:30.177 --> 28:33.898
[SPEAKER_01]: And then after that it's up to society what to do with this surplus.
28:34.378 --> 28:38.702
[SPEAKER_01]: that comes from our competition and our efficiency.
28:39.083 --> 28:45.028
[SPEAKER_01]: So one, I do think the social values, the firms are democratic, the firms are known by private capitalists.
28:45.128 --> 28:46.450
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's one social value.
28:46.670 --> 28:53.316
[SPEAKER_01]: But two within these firms, making them efficient and producing more social surplus, made allow us to make decisions like saying,
28:54.077 --> 28:54.457
[SPEAKER_01]: You know what?
28:54.778 --> 28:56.059
[SPEAKER_01]: This fear of work.
28:56.079 --> 28:58.140
[SPEAKER_01]: We're still going to be not great.
28:58.160 --> 29:12.650
[SPEAKER_01]: You're still going to have to deal with, you know, working hard and trying to get results from your in the office, but maybe everyone should only be in the office for a nine to two every day to allow more time to pick a kids up from school and spend time with their families and in our in our communities.
29:12.931 --> 29:14.152
[SPEAKER_01]: So in this case, you really see how
29:14.992 --> 29:31.565
[SPEAKER_01]: efficiency and competition can actually be married to this wider social goal making a collective decision saying, you know, now in this more productive society, we don't necessarily need more output, we actually would rather value our leisure time and but because there's still competition,
29:32.165 --> 29:34.007
[SPEAKER_01]: we're going to make sure that these are actually rules.
29:34.167 --> 29:51.968
[SPEAKER_01]: So even if I would rather work 60 hour weeks, I actually have to work less hours, then if I stop lots of energy, I can volunteer, I could do other stuff outside production, but I won't be undercutting other people who live in the society with certain labor norms.
29:53.345 --> 30:00.990
[SPEAKER_02]: Can we talk about DSA, DSA, Democratic Socialists of America, is actually existing socialist organization.
30:01.030 --> 30:05.673
[SPEAKER_02]: We have 130,000 members, largest socialist organization, American history.
30:05.953 --> 30:08.074
[SPEAKER_02]: You've been a member since you were a teenager.
30:08.455 --> 30:10.676
[SPEAKER_02]: Mom, Donnie is a member, A.O.C.
30:10.716 --> 30:11.357
[SPEAKER_02]: is a member.
30:12.017 --> 30:16.940
[SPEAKER_02]: Bernie is not a member, of course, DSA has factions and fights.
30:17.661 --> 30:19.482
[SPEAKER_02]: Tell us about your view of DSA.
30:20.566 --> 30:28.130
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's a messy democratic organization and its primary problem is just the fact that it has a weak social base.
30:28.430 --> 30:33.472
[SPEAKER_01]: Even where DSA has a lot of members, like in New York City, where thousands and thousands of members.
30:34.433 --> 30:41.596
[SPEAKER_01]: These members cut across all sorts of, you know, their black, white, Hispanic, Asian, and come from all backgrounds.
30:42.076 --> 30:48.978
[SPEAKER_01]: Men and women, people from different, you know, income groups and whatever else, but it's primarily like a youth movement.
30:49.158 --> 30:50.919
[SPEAKER_01]: It feels mass in the youth sense.
30:51.659 --> 30:55.660
[SPEAKER_01]: It doesn't have older people, particularly older workers.
30:55.740 --> 30:56.580
[SPEAKER_01]: Obviously, they're simple.
30:56.920 --> 30:58.761
[SPEAKER_01]: Lefty's in the organization.
30:58.781 --> 31:03.122
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a lot of no one going to get a message from at least one of them, for the way I painted the organization.
31:03.762 --> 31:06.064
[SPEAKER_01]: But I think about someone like my godmother.
31:06.524 --> 31:14.311
[SPEAKER_01]: She's a nurse, you know, in her 60s at this point, she's Jamaican.
31:14.411 --> 31:15.732
[SPEAKER_01]: She was kind of a manly eye.
31:15.812 --> 31:16.913
[SPEAKER_01]: She comes from that tradition.
31:17.414 --> 31:19.195
[SPEAKER_03]: So she considers herself a socialist.
31:19.215 --> 31:20.837
[SPEAKER_03]: It's like a very particular sort of like,
31:21.557 --> 31:26.604
[SPEAKER_01]: So I, you know, populous, you know, traditions, I would love her to contact the essay Beaton.
31:26.824 --> 31:32.731
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like she not because anyone's racist or has any sort of biases towards people.
31:32.751 --> 31:36.917
[SPEAKER_01]: I just feel
like it would be hard for her to get inculcated and sort of the culture.
31:37.573 --> 31:41.294
[SPEAKER_01]: and run for a democratic position in the ASAC.
31:41.535 --> 31:52.699
[SPEAKER_01]: And it sometimes has the feeling of a youth organization and that way, which both gives its cultural relevance, as part of its power, but I feel like it's very different.
31:52.719 --> 31:55.060
[SPEAKER_01]: And when people diagnose the problem, they sometimes say,
31:55.700 --> 31:59.003
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like a lack of diversity or a lack of wealth.
31:59.023 --> 32:00.264
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, I don't think that's actually it.
32:00.344 --> 32:02.466
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's a lack of class rootedness.
32:02.927 --> 32:04.508
[SPEAKER_01]: So what does it mean to be an organization?
32:04.528 --> 32:08.592
[SPEAKER_01]: That doesn't recruit people in ones and twos, but who it's people in masks?
32:08.612 --> 32:12.956
[SPEAKER_01]: Because it's really powerful and industrial or even service sector.
32:13.497 --> 32:14.758
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's involved with the strike.
32:14.778 --> 32:20.503
[SPEAKER_01]: So you're getting dozens of people like my godmother, you've on, you know, to join the
32:21.804 --> 32:22.425
[SPEAKER_01]: organization.
32:22.445 --> 32:25.248
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like that's the big challenge.
32:25.689 --> 32:32.316
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's more broadly a challenge for left and center left, you know, candidates around the country.
32:32.376 --> 32:40.925
[SPEAKER_01]: Like can you root yourself in the language and practice of ordinary working-class people, which is necessarily more conservative,
32:41.746 --> 32:47.975
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, but it is, I think, a little bit different than some, like, the rhetoric and the paints we have in the organization.
32:48.015 --> 32:49.197
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's, that's our challenge.
32:49.237 --> 32:52.181
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's, that's, honestly, it should be a challenge for the Democratic Party as a whole.
32:52.201 --> 32:58.070
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, how do you restore sort of the association of the left and all forms with working class people?
32:58.933 --> 33:01.535
[SPEAKER_02]: One last word about the election and its significance.
33:01.895 --> 33:05.798
[SPEAKER_02]: All our lives we've been told politics is the art of the possible.
33:06.178 --> 33:12.343
[SPEAKER_02]: And that was always a reason why we couldn't get what we wanted, why we had to give up our most important goals.
33:13.143 --> 33:17.246
[SPEAKER_02]: But this year's election really transformed the idea of the possible.
33:17.707 --> 33:19.068
[SPEAKER_02]: We never thought it would be possible.
33:19.108 --> 33:26.213
[SPEAKER_02]: As you said, they have a black senator from Mississippi, or a Democratic senator from South Carolina, or a Latina governor of Texas.
33:26.833 --> 33:29.295
[SPEAKER_02]: What do you think is possible right now?
33:30.516 --> 33:37.700
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I think there's clearly, in my mind at least, a social democratic majority in the US that exists today.
33:37.840 --> 33:39.321
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm now a majority, but a majority.
33:40.174 --> 33:43.155
[SPEAKER_01]: The question is really how we activate that majority.
33:43.175 --> 33:54.658
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think it actually gets a bit complex in that I don't think we have a majority for the type of tax and transfer policies that we need to create a really egalitarian society.
33:55.078 --> 34:03.340
[SPEAKER_01]: I do think we have a majority for a certain guarantees, even if they're policy-wise more complicated and actually more invasive than taxes and transfers.
34:03.400 --> 34:08.661
[SPEAKER_01]: I think we have a majority for a job strategy and we could have a majority for national insurance,
34:09.281 --> 34:12.583
[SPEAKER_01]: we don't have a majority for the taxes to fund those program.
34:12.603 --> 34:15.985
[SPEAKER_01]: So I think it's complicated.
34:17.546 --> 34:29.552
[SPEAKER_01]: I think it's also complicated because people see in their bosses and in the rich, the sources of prosperity, not just oppression and theft.
34:29.912 --> 34:36.576
[SPEAKER_01]: And this is obviously some of the story I would love to talk at some point with you about about the California campaign and the billionaire
34:39.527 --> 34:42.752
[SPEAKER_01]: People, it seems like it's going forward to rejection.
34:42.792 --> 34:45.216
[SPEAKER_01]: I know there's still votes to be counted.
34:45.496 --> 34:55.471
[SPEAKER_01]: But I think people saw in billionaires not just people who side for their labor, but saw in them like job creation and wealth opportunities.
34:56.192 --> 35:20.369
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think we need to make sure that our version of transformation that we're offering to people is not just about redistribution, but also dignity and wealth creation, which is another can of worms, but I really do think that the American people have shown themselves to one be not nearly as racist and xenophobic as Trump, you know, a low bar, but I think it's an important one.
35:20.969 --> 35:24.270
[SPEAKER_01]: And also willing to listen to people, have something to offer for them.
35:24.290 --> 35:25.731
[SPEAKER_01]: That's why again, I go back to call them.
35:25.751 --> 35:27.091
[SPEAKER_01]: I go back to Mississippi.
35:27.751 --> 35:34.994
[SPEAKER_01]: And I say that this is, I think, a sign of the America that we want to live in.
35:35.653 --> 35:43.256
[SPEAKER_01]: And again, after November 2024, I personally had a more pessimistic view of the direction they were going to go in.
35:43.456 --> 35:49.479
[SPEAKER_01]: And we did see a bit of it, we saw more racism, more xenophobia, more just general meanness and bullying.
35:49.999 --> 36:02.664
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think now we have the chance to really offer a positive alternative in which we like look at one another as a to a solidarity as people who are in a community together, not like burdens to one another.
36:03.561 --> 36:05.361
[SPEAKER_02]: The America we want to live in.
36:05.901 --> 36:12.063
[SPEAKER_02]: Oscar Shunkara, his new co-authored book is The Blueprint, how socialism can work in the real world.
36:12.543 --> 36:19.244
[SPEAKER_02]: And he and his co-authors have a new piece at thenation.com, do socialist even believe in socialism anymore?
36:19.884 --> 36:21.504
[SPEAKER_02]: Oscar, thanks for talking with us today.
36:21.524 --> 36:22.044
[SPEAKER_02]: Thanks for having me.
36:22.084 --> 36:30.406
[SPEAKER_00]: You're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you're bad, you
36:31.903 --> 36:32.944
[SPEAKER_02]: Start making sense.
36:33.125 --> 36:38.772
[SPEAKER_02]: A podcast from the nation magazine is recorded at our upstairs studio in Los Angeles.
36:39.232 --> 36:43.718
[SPEAKER_02]: Renee Reynolds is our associate producer, Alan Minsky is our producer.
36:44.152 --> 36:53.515
[SPEAKER_02]: Ricky D'Ambrose is executive producer, Boskarsun Kara is president of the nation, Katrina Van Nouvelle is editor and publisher of the nation.
36:53.935 --> 36:58.276
[SPEAKER_02]: Our theme music is Barcelona Afrobeat, licensed by Creative Commons.
36:58.736 --> 37:09.199
[SPEAKER_02]: You can find out more about start making sense at thenation.com and subscribe to start making sense on Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts.
37:09.679 --> 37:11.780
[SPEAKER_02]: I'm John Weiner, thanks for listening.