TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Howard, my dad was T-boned by a utility vehicle and is in surgery now. What should I do?
00:00:07
Speaker 2: I'm sorry to hear about that.
00:00:08
Speaker 3: It's really great that you're getting him the medical care and treatment that he needs right now. These are three important things that I think you need to know. Injuries are unexpected and turn lives upside down. I'm Howard Ankin, and I'm here to help.
00:00:20
Speaker 4: If you or a loved one have been hurt at work or in a car, truck, or ride share accident, call 312-6-MILLION. Injury law made personal. That's Ankin Law.
00:00:43
Speaker 2: From your favorite source for Chicago White Sox talk, delivering news, interviews, analysis, and more.
00:00:49
Speaker 5: This is the Sox Machine Podcast with your hosts, Jim Margulis and Josh Nelson.
00:00:55
Speaker 1: Hello, folks. Welcome to a new episode of the Sox Machine Podcast, part of the Foul Territory Network. I'm your host, Josh Nelson. And we are bringing a new episode to you during this offseason, continuing our offseason plan projects. We know that many of you have already submitted plans on SoxMachine.com. Continue to do so. In this episode, I'm going to be sharing a little sneak peek of my upcoming offseason plan project. for the Chicago White Sox this offseason, starting with the five players that I am not going to be having the White Sox return. Now, that is with an asterisk because it is more than just five players, but I'm grouping some players that are in the same boat, same position, same inefficiency when it comes to their performance, and we're going to be taking a look at how easy or difficult it's going to be for the White Sox replacing that production with what they have internally. And if it is going to be difficult... how they're going to have to find it in free agency or via trade this offseason to replace that production. But we all know the Chicago White Sox love themselves a reunion. You can never say never with some of these players. So we'll also debate whether or not, how likely... a reunion is between the white socks and these players. And joining me is socks machines, mansion editor, Jim Margulis.
00:02:18
Speaker 2: And hello, Jim.
00:02:20
Speaker 1: Uh, so far, let's get a quick, uh, heat check on the off season plan project. Uh, how are the plans coming in?
00:02:28
Speaker 2: A lot of variety, a lot of, uh, people stuck between adhering to the $ 130 million soft cap that I issued and people getting angered by it and blasting by it. Uh, Copying and pasting the previous plan into the next plan to create a template. A lot of disagreement over the middle of the arbitration eligible players. I'm really interested to see what the percentages are like because aside from Miguel Vargas and to a lesser extent, Brenton Doyle, not a whole lot of agreement on the top four players on that ARB eligible list. So that's something that's kind of unusual. Usually it's a little bit more You know, 90 percent, 40 percent, 10 percent in terms of the calls. So that'll be interesting. A lot of disagreement over the impending free agents about whether to retain all the players that had better than expected seasons with the White Sox and some. Internal arguments or arguments inside the heads of the GMs wondering like are we doubling down on a bet that worked out the first time but might not work out well the second time? Or is it a case of just like a guy like Eric Fetty? He seems to like pitching in Chicago. The White Sox have ideas for him. He fares fairly well. Why not keep that arrangement going? So I thought it was going to be a varied– off-season plan project just because of all the ways you can go with it and the ways you can read 84 and 78 and look at it both ways in terms of a team on the rise or a team that's hit its head on its own ceiling based on what they currently have and and a lot of revision is needed and it should be pretty fun when it comes to tabulating the end results by the end of you know like i don't know a few scores of uh plans here uh just seeing exactly what the consensus.
00:04:26
Speaker 1: Is Yeah, so again, with this podcast, I'm going to be sharing in bits and pieces my off-season plan project, focusing on the players that I'm not having return. So for those that have already submitted plans, you and I get to compare and contrast of what you have submitted when it comes to the tender or non-tender the arbitration eligible players and the impending free agents. So these are the five. Now, it's a little bit more than just five players. It's a total of seven players that I know are not returning, but I grouped some of them in the same position group or the same inefficiency gym. But we're going to start with number one, and I hope he does not find me because I do not want to ever fight this van, but Tommy Pham. And The reason why Tommy Pham's not returning, Jim, is that he was a short gap fix. When the White Sox brought him on, I wasn't necessarily sure if that move was necessary. He had a big home run against Parker Messick, which ultimately didn't mean anything because the White Sox still lost that game. And he had that almost an extra base hit. Fantastic defensive play by Angel Martinez at the wall to rob Tommy Pham. But when you look at his numbers, just the one home run, with a 176 batting average. For me, this is one of the easiest decisions of the off-season plan project. But, you know, looking at its production, I also think it's pretty easy to replace internally. on what Tommy Pham provided to the White Sox. However, Jim, as I mentioned in the intro, this team, this franchise loves reunions. They've already brought Tommy Pham back. This was his second stint with the White Sox. Could we see a third stint with the White Sox?
00:06:17
Speaker 2: And this one was off the boards, too, in terms of a reunion. Hadn't been in the majors basically all season, aside from early April, I think, with the Mets. And just
Load full transcript
been hanging out in the Phillies AAA roster all year. And then come at the end of August, White Sox feel they need to have a right-handed bat on the roster. And they come knocking for Tommy Pham and add him to the roster. So he's eligible for the postseason roster. And he's getting postseason at bat. So a lot of things already clicked into place to make a reunion possible. To say, well, the odds aren't as low as they probably seem. But it does seem like, yeah, I would say internally they don't have replacements for him yet. But that's the kind of roster spot, the kind of area on the depth chart that you rotate quadruple A players, post-type prospects, free agents. Is anybody with a hint of potential? I'm looking at Dustin Harris. He had some moments with the White Sox early on before he was on the wrong end of the roster crunch. And then he went to Houston and it was unremarkable there. But then San Diego, I didn't realize how good he was in San Diego. I know he's getting at bats, but I looked at his numbers. 322 batting average, 364 OBP, 422 slugging. Like just the bat to ball is working. Probably some Babbitt luck because the strikeouts were always pretty reasonable at every level. Just a matter of like whether he hits the ball hard enough to succeed. But, you know, he's somebody you can look at and say, well, you know, he's one of those, you know, he's lefty, but just in terms of the kind of Previously interesting prospects who's bounced around and has kind of stalled out at AAA or Cups of Coffee, Tristan Peters is another one. Those are the kind of players you give those plate appearances to early on. You give those roster spots to and you hope one clicked. And if not, like Tommy Pham probably will be around, you know, if he's still producing. If they do need to reunite with him at some point or definitely need that bat. So that's why I would say probably pretty low to hit those odds twice.
00:08:22
Speaker 1: All right, so not expecting a third reunion with Tommy Pham for the White Sox. Let's move over to number two in the five, not returning, and this is the first grouping, the backup catchers, Jake Rogers and Joey Bart. Now, we barely got to see Joey Bart. He only appeared in three games and then broke a knuckle after getting hit by a pitch as he was one of the midseason trade acquisitions. With MLB trade rumors and the arbitration value of $ 2. 9 million, I would not spend that on a backup catcher if I were the Chicago White Sox. And Jake Rogers, Jim, he had good defensive numbers for the White Sox in his short stint. He was worth plus three fielding runs above average. But the bat is just not there. Yeah, he had that walk-off home run. But Jake Rogers just batted 103. And defensively, like when you look at Drew Romo, most of Drew Romo's positive fielding runs above average was because of how well he did with the ABS, with the automatic ball strikes. He was worth plus two and better than Kyle Thiel. I thought Thiel was getting better. Offensively, Drew Romo doesn't provide a whole lot either, but I just don't feel like in a tight offseason budget with a soft cap of $ 130 million, Jim, I would be spending millions of dollars on either Joey Bart or Jake Rogers to back up Kyle Teal. Now, the first question is, comparing Jake Rogers and Joey Bart to, let's say, even Drew Romer or Edgar Caro, is the production from Jake Rogers easily replaceable by what the White Sox already have to back up Kyle Teel at catcher?
00:10:11
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think so. I think Drew Romo is there. Even Edgar Caro, to an extent. Like, Caro is, you know, it's amazing how much his stock has collapsed. I'm thinking back to last winter when he was the subject of a big ESPN piece about his work at Driveline, you know, talking about how they spent two days following him. Like, perfect candidate for Driveline or that kind of intensive hitting program because he'd been doing everything well enough aside from hitting the ball hard. And so that just seemed like the last thing to unlock. before he embarks on a 10-year career and then it just kind of all collapses and just you know now there's a point where it's like you know two's a coincidence three's a trend and i just think of like driveline and white socks and i think of carson fulmer and tim anderson and now uh edgar carroll in terms of guys some of these guys are.
00:10:55
Speaker 1: Getting hired by front offices now jim.
00:10:58
Speaker 2: Yeah i mean like it's not you know it's not slagging driveline just a case of like uh it it's not a silver bullet. It doesn't work for everybody. And perhaps it's more a sign of like, I'm going to driveline because something's fundamentally wrong with my game versus I'm going to driveline and they're going to add 15 points to my WRC plus, you know, it might be kind of like a pounds of muscle thing of like when a player comes into spring training, talking about pounds of muscle, it's usually a poor season follows afterwards. And that's just because they have to talk about what they're doing better in the first place. And I wonder if driveline is kind of the same thing of just, you know, those stories about, hitting labs and pitching labs, et cetera. You know, it's kind of like the new pitch, best shape of my life type thing. But yeah, Caro is still there. Like I think Romo is probably your backup catcher who prevents you from over-investing in the position. Like I think, you know, the White Sox could trade, they could sign. Like Joey Bart, I think they could maybe non-tender and bring back. I think there are a lot of catchers on that tier of just maybe call them second division starters or second division backups. I think Romo is kind of a quintessential third catcher at this point. They seem to like having him around. Seems to work well with the pitchers. Occasionally comes up with a hit, but doesn't strike out all that often to where he doesn't look completely overmatched in a game. So if you want to start him once or
twice a week while somebody's down, like Romo's, that's a fine use of a third catcher spot. And he's got one option left, so he may as well take advantage of that. But I think Caro is the more interesting one in terms of Does he hang around? Does he produce kind of back to where he was two years ago? Does another team look at him and say, like, we can fix that? But I think as long as those two guys are on the roster, I don't see the White Sox adding more catchers to the roster until they have to. So when it comes to those decisions with firm dates like they have with Jake Rogers and Joey Bart, it seems like they wouldn't necessarily let that force their hand. It really seemed like with Bart– They talked about him like a rental, as opposed to like Brenton Doyle and Huascar Brazoban at the deadline, who they talked about, we're signing, we're trading these guys with years of control. They're not only here for this year, they're here for 2026 too, or 2027 too. Versus, you know, Bart was like, oh, you know, Teal's coming back. We'll see what we have. Yeah, right.
00:13:17
Speaker 1: So likelihood of reunion between the White Sox with Jake Rogers or Joey Bart?
00:13:23
Speaker 2: I'd say... more than fam. So medium, I guess, in terms of wouldn't shock me if, you know, they, they looked at the entire market and we're looking for a right-handed compliment to, uh, Kyle Teal and thought like, yeah, these guys can do the job for the right price. Uh, just doesn't strike me as like, maybe, uh, you know, kind of like when the Tigers non-tender James McCann and then the White Sox brought him in, like, I think the tender price isn't quite right for his market value, uh, But perhaps they could come back at a slightly reduced rate or guarantee in terms of a minor league contract versus a major league contract. And then at the end of the winter, end of the spring, I should say, when they look at who is the best player, possible bat and glove to back up, hopefully help the Kyle Teal. That'll be when they ultimately make the call.
00:14:12
Speaker 1: See, I have it as low, low chance that either of these guys return to the White Sox. I still feel like they're going to get gigs in the major leagues. Well, Jake Rogers and Joey Bart, we'll see them on other MLB teams, just not the White Sox. And then our other group that I've created here, the injured pitch pitchers slash inefficient pitchers and the, Jordan Leisure, he's hurt with Tommy John. I don't know if we're going to see him at all in the 2027 season. So I don't think it really makes a whole lot of sense tendering him a contract. Chris Murphy, is Murphy better than what the White Sox currently have from the left-handed side of the bullpen? I don't necessarily think so. And when it comes to production, I mean, Jordan Leisure had an ERA over six in 18 innings. And Chris Murphy in 33 innings with the White Sox had a 4.81 earned run average before he spent most of the time in Charlotte. So I guess when it comes to Leisure and Murphy, seeing as how I'm not having either of these guys returning, Jim, with the production, little production that they provided to the White Sox in 2026, is this going to be easy or difficult for the White Sox to replace these innings with what they have internally?
00:15:28
Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, leisure is easy because it's just greater than zero.
00:15:31
Speaker 1: Can you throw a baseball? Yes. Without pain?
00:15:35
Speaker 2: Unfortunately, Tommy John surgery. Yeah, that seems like it'll be like a Tim Elko or Juan Carella case of just getting injured at the wrong time, getting Tommy John surgery at the wrong time. And you just can't take up a spot in a full 40-man roster when you have so many months of off-season remaining. So I could see him being brought back in a Meyer League contract. Uh, it kind of like they've done with other guys, you know, to see the rehab stints through and bring them all the way back and then see how they look after they return. But yeah, I would say he's on the outside looking in Chris Murphy and he doesn't have options remaining. So I think that's makes a little bit harder to retain him knowing that like, if he looks like he did last year where he's just kind of, yeah, he's an up and down guy. I think it's fair to say like probably too good for AAA, not necessarily good enough to hold down like medium leverage, uh, in the majors as he's shown so far. And, you know, like they have Jaden Woods, who's currently not on the 40 man might have to be protected from the rule five draft. If there is a rule five draft with the lockout, there may not be a rule five draft. But like Jaden Woods might be able to come in and kind of do a similar job. So I think they can replace him on the depth charts. I just wonder if it's a case where the price is low enough, you know, you're talking about like, you know, a million or less based on the projection that, Do they bring him back and say, well, even if he's on the wrong side of the squeeze, can we try sneaking him through waivers and keep him around because he's nice to have? And if another team claims him, so what? Or is it a case where you can swing a trade between two roster crunches where I can use that player and they can use my player and we can swing a trade to ease a little bit of roster pressure that makes it mutually agreeable since he does have some arm talent. I think the one thing that kind of... Maybe gives me some pause is just watching Cam Boozer just really deliver for the Rays. And it's kind of a similar case of like the White Sox acquired Boozer from Boston. Had a bad year. They released him. The Rays picked him up. And you just kind of made a couple more tweaks. And Boozer is throwing strikes, not giving up homers and being the best lefty and lefty reliever in the American League. And I think with Murphy, it's kind of similar of just there's some arm talent there. They traded him, traded for him for a reason. And if they give up on him after
one up and down year, do they risk the same thing of just like another team figuring it out? Should they have two bites of the apple, so to speak? So I could see it going either way. Leisure would be low probability, Murphy medium, just because they can replace him, but also they can probably just hang on to him because of the cost and see like if he looks great in the spring, they can carry him and then like let the lack of options Complicate matters like once you're into April or May or whenever the season starts.
00:18:30
Speaker 1: Well, we have two more players on my list that will not be returning to the White Sox in 2027. We're going to be reviewing those two players and those decisions that I am making my offseason plan project after a quick word from our sponsors.
00:18:44
Speaker 6: It's that time of year where all the sports are pretty much going right now from the baseball playoffs, which obviously on foul territory, we love NCAA football. There's huge games this weekend, conference games. There's NBA starting, NHL is going, and the NFL is in full swing right now. So if I need to get tickets because I go everywhere and I go to a lot of games, I use SeatGeek.
00:19:06
Speaker 5: I don't need to go everywhere. I just need to go to the World Series. Maybe I got to go see LeBron play too. So I just scroll across. I figure out where the best place to watch the game is. SeatGeek's got me.
00:19:18
Speaker 6: That's right. Red dot, bad deal, they think. Green dot, great deal.
00:19:22
Speaker 4: But you get to choose.
00:19:23
Speaker 6: That's the one great thing about SeatGeek. And of course, we have a code. Kratz and I have a code for you. You can use code TERRITORY10 for 10% off your next set of tickets at SeatGeek. That's 10% off all tickets with promo code TERRITORY10. Make sure you click the link in the description to download the app and have the code automatically added to your account so you can use it later.
00:19:44
Speaker 1: Howard, my dad was T-boned by a utility vehicle and is in surgery now.
00:19:50
Speaker 3: Now.
00:19:50
Speaker 1: What should I do?
00:19:52
Speaker 4: I'm sorry to hear about that.
00:19:53
Speaker 3: It's really great that you're getting him the medical care and treatment that he needs right now. These are three important things that I think you need to know. Injuries are unexpected and turn lives upside down. I'm Howard Ankin, and I'm here to help. If you or a loved one have been hurt at work, or in a.
00:20:07
Speaker 4: Car, truck, or ride share accident, call 312-6-MILLION. Injury law made personal. That's Ankin Law.
00:20:14
Speaker 1: Visit the new Sox Machine store at SoxMachineShop.com to pick up your new white socks and Sox Machine gear. Sam Antonacci, Munitaka Murakami, Tristan Peters, Chase Myadroth, and the celibate for Sean Burke shirts are available in the store, plus new Sox Machine three-quarter zip-ups, sweaters, coffee mugs, and Sox Machine shirts, officially licensed gear from the MLB
Players Association. Visit SoxMachineShop.com. Welcome back to the Sox machine podcast.
00:20:45
Speaker 6: All right.
00:20:45
Speaker 1: So we already reviewed the three areas of players that are not returning for my off season plan project. Tommy Pham, Jake Rogers, and Joey Bart, the backup catchers, and the hurt, inefficient pitchers, Jordan Leisure and Chris Murphy. So technically, I've already given you five. But as I mentioned, there's seven on my list that I was pretty certain that will not be returning. But that doesn't mean that replacing their production is going to be easy for the White Sox, which brings me to number four. And that is reliever Trevor Richards.
00:21:14
Speaker 2: And.
00:21:16
Speaker 1: One, I think the reasoning is the White Sox kind of made it for me. They didn't seem to trust him enough to add him to the postseason roster, Jim. I don't know what spots in any of these playoff games that Richards would have pitched for the White Sox. Maybe game three of the American League Division Series when Cleveland had it in hand. Instead of using Davis Martin or David Sandlin, maybe do go to Trevor Richards in those situations. But again, In this era of max velocity, when it comes to relievers and bullpen arms, Trevor Richards just doesn't have the juice. That doesn't mean that he's not effective or he can get outs. He can, but his foreseeing fastball is just getting hurt by right-handed batters. And the fact that he's a right-handed reliever and he's got to go to off-speed stuff, a change-up slider combination to get righties out, that makes it difficult to see his staying power in the major leagues coming out of the bullpen. However, his misproduction because he was a rubber arm during the regular season for the White Sox, he appeared in 52 games, Jim, and he covered more than 78 innings for the White Sox out of the bullpen. So I don't think this is easy production to replace internally. Do you disagree with that notion, Jim? Is this going to be easy or difficult for the White Sox to replace his production?
00:22:40
Speaker 2: Should be able to replace his effectiveness maybe the way he was used and the way Will Venable would run him out for two-plus innings or sometimes one-plus innings on back-to-back days. That was kind of unique. So... It struck me when they acquired him and they purchased him from the Phillies. So it's a case where he might be available again based on how they acquired him the first time to where they don't have to commit to him now to have him on the roster later, whether it's a minor league contract or mid-season trade. But it did seem like they were just kind of using him to use him. Not necessarily exploiting him, but it did seem like, well, he can respond. He's helping us protect our other arms. We're really just Indulging that luxury we have of having this guy who will just take the ball whenever in order to prevent Grant Taylor from being used too often or Sean Newcomb in some situations with Richard Changeup being effective against lefties. He did try to fill both sides or the responsibilities of both arms sometimes in a higher leverage situation. He was also a well-traveled veteran to where if he blows a game, we're not worried about his psyche or anything like that. He can take it. He's been around the block. So he did serve a purpose and kind of fit a really unique niche with the White Sox to where I could see him coming back. Maybe, you know, if they just loved what he brought and, you know, he was game for anything and just Will Venable like managing him. Zach Bove liked having him around. But I think the way he was used struck me as like. we're just going to use the hell of this guy. Cause he, you know, just, you know, he, he allows us to protect our more valued arms. And so like the mileage, it kind of like a rental car, like just the, the mileage they put on him was rough. And he was like, I wouldn't buy that car. I know how I drove it. So I don't know if they would do it the same way, but that's kind of how it struck me in terms of how they were using him. And one thing that surprised me while looking up Richard's stats, he led the league in wild pitches, right? which I did not know. Like he, you know, he threw 78 innings and his 12 wild pitches led the American League, which is one kind of a lower total than I thought would lead the AL. But also like Sean Burke was second and he threw nearly a hundred more innings. Gavin Williams is third. So it's like seeing Richards, like he didn't start spiking change-ups at the end to where when, you know, he's on fumes, you can definitely see it and the misses get pretty, And so that's why I think that, yeah, just it's a case where I first looked up a service time. Like if he's getting close to 10 years of service time, yeah, bring him back, get him over the hump, get him that ceremony. Cause that's always cool to see, but he's at 6.1 years or either six or seven, depending on whether roster resource updates their service time after the season or at the beginning of like a new year. But either way, not close enough to the service time threshold to make that part of the calculation.
00:25:44
Speaker 1: It is something that I have to consider, though, because it is a big chunk of innings. And I'm not sure, Jim, if Mike Vassell is going to be healthy enough to count on him for another 100 innings like he pitched for the White Sox in 2025. So this is something I'm trying to be mindful of with my offseason plan project. If I'm not bringing back Richards, somebody needs to help out and take on these innings or this mop-up role for the White Sox in 2027. And my last one, And it's a bit difficult, but I think most of us, I'm going to assume, Jim, with the offseason brand projects, are not bringing back Randall Gritchick. Now, I don't, I have to admit, I don't have a good feeling about what direction the White Sox are actually going to take. But my reasoning is that if this was a decision based
on Randall Gritchick and Andrew Benetendi, and you only had to bring one back, I'm taking Randall Gritchick. However, it's Gritchick that's a free agent and Ben Attendee still has a year left on his deal and he's not cheap. So that's why Ben Attendee is going to continue staying on this roster is just because the soft cap that you provided to us at $ 130 million, and let's say you're spot on with that, the White Sox are just not in a position right now to really eat that money unless they're going to increase their payroll to $ 150 or $ 170 million, then maybe things change. Misproduction, this is significant production that the White Sox would be losing having Randall Gritchick leave, Jim. I mean, he was worth $ 1. 7 war, according to baseball reference. He batted $ 2.
00:27:24
Speaker 3: 99.
00:27:25
Speaker 1: He slugged $ 5.
00:27:25
Speaker 2: 98.
00:27:25
Speaker 1: He had 15 home runs and 44 RBIs, playing sparingly in left field, but part of this DH platoon with Andrew Benatendi. So, looking at the internal options right now for the White Sox, these 15 home runs and some of the slugging power that they were able to get from Randall Gritchick against left-handed pitching and even some right-handed pitching later in the season, is this going to be easy or difficult for the White Sox to replace with the options they have internally?
00:27:55
Speaker 2: It's difficult. It's also difficult to count on Gritchick doing it again, which is why this conversation is complicated here. I'm looking at Gritchick's Baseball reference page looking at the OPS plus and like he's had good seasons like this or, you know, this was like his best season in terms of like a platoon bat. But just there's a lot of variation looking at since 2023 of those partial teams. OPS plus numbers 122, 81, 139, 101, 58, 47, 154. So it's a case of just the variance going between hot and cold is notable. And when you look at his numbers, the White Sox, obviously the power was there, just a lot of impact, but didn't draw walks. And while you wouldn't want Gritchick drawing walks with what he was doing with his contact, it does hint at maybe like a one-trick pony or somebody who's played approach, like if it's not going well, is a lot of quick outs and unremarkable defense in left field. And now you've like fixed a roster spot for that guy or fixed like an aging platoon, uh, with that guy. And so that's why I think it's a, it's a tricky, uh, it's a tricky player, uh, just characteristics to bring back and fit on a roster that already has, like you mentioned with Andrew Van Tendi, a similar player in terms of just age and, um, Yeah, I think the signs of decline in Benintendi are obvious, but just, yeah, you're locking in on an otherwise youthful roster, two 35-year-old players, basically, who are, yeah, platoon bats at best, and with Benintendi, barely hanging on to the platoon bat, Gritchick has lost it and regained it, lost it and regained it. So that's why it feels like, you know,
it was awesome watching him produce the level that he did after, like the Yankees usually get that kind of production from platoon bats and the White Sox did instead. And that's a hell of a thing. But I just think that making that bet two times in a row and if that bet doesn't come through, then you may have lost some flexibility in terms of the players you could bring up and down in audition and missed out on younger players who might have their best years in front of them. So, yeah, you know, we talked about with like players that can be reacquired, like I think you know, Gritchick based on his history as somebody who signs with a team that needs an outfielder and then gets traded at the deadline or gets DFA. So like you can always let another team sign them and then see what he has left. And if that team is, you know, isn't contending and just needs the needs the player, or if he's disappointed again, you can always, you know, history says you can always take a look at mid season at what you need and what he looks like and see if there's a fit again.
00:30:49
Speaker 1: Yeah, that's why I like the likelihood of reunion. I'm going to put it at medium for Randall Gritchick. I could totally see him returning to the White Sox in that type of situation. Because again, they brought Tommy Pham back. So they brought Tommy Pham back. Maybe they could bring back Randall Gritchick if they are contending again in 2027, come to the trade deadline. They would just like a veteran right-handed bat to help out coming off the bench in pitching situations. They counted on Randall Gritchick, and he delivered in 2026, so it wouldn't be a bad bet. But when you're looking at creating a roster from the get-go to try to get as many wins as possible early on, I just don't see the logic in bringing back Randall Gritchick and running it back again with the platoon at DH Gym between Gritchick and Andrew Benatendi. But the more I think.
00:31:40
Speaker 2: About it, I also don't know.
00:31:42
Speaker 1: I don't think there's a lot of logic right now in bringing back Andrew Benatendi only because of his contract. His contract is saving his spot. There is a part of me, Jim, that wanted to add Andrew Benatendi to my list of players not returning to the White Sox. You can't play him in the field. He just looked really overwhelmed against Gavin Williams in the postseason. So I am concerned about a velocity difference. is going to be an issue for Andrew Benatendi. He's in between two approaches at the plate. And I don't know if his bat still has enough juice to even be a 25 homer or a better type of hitter. So he's not that effective as a designated hitter for the White Sox. He's on this team because of that contract. That's not really a great reason to have someone on your team.
00:32:34
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:32:34
Speaker 2: No, it's, you get to the point where if Benintendi is costing you better opportunities to use that roster spots or the, you know, create your platoons or more versatility in the outfield, you have to look at that and say like, how much is that worth? How much is that, you know, that remaining financial obligation for Benintendi? As much as it, Probably sucks to, you know, eat that amount and just say, you know, probably not going to be able to trade them. If you do trade them, it's probably kicking in like most of the freight to where you're paying like, you know, 13 million or whatever, you know, at the very least for some, you know, arm of, you know, I would say like minor league arm of note basically. you can look at that and just say like, well, you can create maybe $ 13 million of opportunity or 15, 17, what have you, just by having some younger players that we like be able to get those opportunities. And if they're being paid the league minimum, kind of like we did with Austin Hayes and Randall Gritchick last year, like with Hayes being on the shelf, but Gritchick being so productive, you looked at those contracts and say, oh, $ 7 million for that production, that's fine. And so I think you can maybe look at the same thing with Benintendi and say, well, $ 17 million, whatever he's owed, and then the $ 1 million for the league minimum guy, it's like $ 18 million. Try to take a shot at using that roster spot for cheaper players that might be as productive and then just lump it on the cost of Benintendi. That might be worth it if you phrase it that way. So if they cut Benintendi over the course of the winter, I wouldn't be surprised. I should say I'd only be surprised based on the cost. But we've seen the White Sox shed money before or just kind of acknowledge a sunk cost and eat the money before. And so if they did with Benintendi, knowing that they have a young roster, they have so many pre-R players everywhere else. That creates a luxury to move on from a one-year obligation for Benintendi. Maybe makes more sense than ever to do it. We talk about more bats than spots. I think they just have to probably add enough to where Benintendi becomes a casualty based on like, look at the numbers here. We just have too many guys we want to look at instead, and they're not quite there yet. But Gritchick, I think you raise an interesting point in terms of Or it struck me as, you know, he's out of options. And one of the problems is that, you know, when you have guys out of options, and we saw this last year with Austin Hayes and Everson Pereira and Derek Hill, just like they're, you know, when you have so many of those guys, you really either have to shed somebody too early because they don't have options, or you have to reserve a spot for somebody who might not ever be able to just answer the call. And I think if you had Gritchick and not Ben Attendee, you could live longer with Gritchick being you know, one of us colder spells to start a season, but with two of them going, if you create a crunch that way of just out of options guys, that just might be a lot of wasted money at the end and also wasted
months because you just reserve the roster spots for these guys through the off season and into the first month of the year when so many other opportunities that players you might've scouted or, you know, your evaluators might've liked your acquisitions department might've liked you know, they, they, They tried to get your attention, didn't do it, and now you're missing out on players who might have more to offer.
00:35:54
Speaker 1: The elephant in the room when it comes to this left field spot for me is Caleb Bonhamer, Jim, and how well Bonhamer hit at the Arizona Fall League. I get it. The average isn't all that great, but he does a good job of drawing walks, and guys, this power seems legit. Like, He's only going to be 21 years old next year. And he's really exciting. He continues to excel. The White Sox in recent years have used these great production at the Arizona Fall League Gym as a trampoline into the next year on guys that we are serious about having them join our roster sooner than later. I don't know what Charlotte is going to provide on the severity on a test or difficulty of a test to Caleb Bonham or Jim. I could see him absolutely crushing the first month and then month two comes along and that's enough for Chris Gatz. If they're not able to replace that production so easily internally with Randall Gritchick leaving gym, maybe that is replacing Gritchick's production internally is Caleb Bonhamer. It does raise the question, what do you do with Sam Antonacci? But I think that's a conversation for a different show. But I think it's Bonhamer and how he progresses and how he fares this off season, continuing to work on his craft. Whenever spring training starts, what shape.
00:37:27
Speaker 2: Is he in?
00:37:29
Speaker 1: How much better is he in the outfield? It doesn't seem like he's going back in the dirt anytime soon for the White Sox. Maybe it's Caleb Bonhamer, who is the future left fielder, Jim, that could help out being a middle-of-the-order bat, hopefully, that this power continues to evolve and develop and translates into the major leagues. I think Bonhamer here is playing a factor in my off-season plan project.
00:37:55
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think as long as you don't make him– we've seen this before. Starter on day one. Hey, it worked with Oscar Colas. What are you talking about? Yeah, I was going to say Andrew Vaughn and Oscar Colas. Yeah, those are the cautionary tales of penciling in somebody who may not ever be ready or somebody who feels like a major leaguer but not yet. That would be the two counterpoints. But I think he's worth– having the conversation of just like you don't have to go nuts addressing this position. You don't have to overinvest in a left fielder you don't love because Bonhamer might be there within the year to really just, if not set the league on fire, at least provide league average production, above average power, and seems like the athleticism in the outfield should be enough to play left. I think
center, it's funny watching him play center just because he– Well.
00:38:48
Speaker 1: They restricted him, right? They're playing with those restricted rules.
00:38:50
Speaker 2: Oh, yeah. I mean like watching him in Birmingham. It's just funny because like Birmingham's outfield is so big alley to alley and not used to watching him run defensively just because he plays third base. It's like a step and a dive basically. So you're not really used to seeing him cover just like so much running for him, just gap to gap in some games, especially with some of the pitchers that Birmingham had. It's a case where– Maybe they're running him through the ringer right now in Birmingham center field and the switch to left field will look pretty easy by comparison because either have Tristan Peters next to you in center or Brenton Doyle to cover that ground in the alley. And now you're just working on one side and perhaps all this.
00:39:31
Speaker 2: Time in center field is just over-preparing him for a corner, which would be a nice change of pace from giving Sam Antonacci a week basically in Charlotte and saying, yeah, you're good. We'll figure it out. Don't kill yourself or anybody else. Sorry, William Bergoglia. That's, I think, where, you know, that's where I'd have him is just in that corner Two months in, but have a good plan for April, not just Caleb Bonhamer. And, you know, whether it's injury or whether Bonhamer being too good, there's a way for him to hit his way in, regardless of how well left field is working out for you.
00:40:03
Speaker 1: And again, how you guys are attacking the outfield situation, that's the beauty of the Sox machine offseason plan project.
00:40:09
Speaker 3: You can.
00:40:10
Speaker 1: write up your reasoning and your perspective and how you're thinking about the situation. But the outfield is ever evolving for the White Sox, but I do not have Randall Gritchick coming back. So out of these five, technically seven players, let me know who you disagree or you agree with the reasoning not returning to the White Sox in 2027. And before we conclude this episode of the Sox Machine Podcast, Let's go ahead and check in on the World Series real quick, Jim. It's Game 3 of the World Series as it goes to St. Petersburg, Florida. Will be on Monday night, but the Milwaukee Brewers, Jim, are up 2-0. A fantastic Game 2 comeback for the Brewers. I thought that... They were in real trouble with the Rays going up four to nothing in the first inning, Jim. But the Brewers continue to do this. They did this in game four of the National League Championship Series against the Dodgers. Shohei hit that home run, and I just thought, well, Dodger Stadium is alive. Dodgers are going to at least win one game. Brewers came back and won that. Rays up four to nothing early. It's the Rays. It's really tough to score runs against the Rays. Brewers still found a way to win five to four. I'm incredibly impressed with how well Milwaukee played at home against the Rays. And I am curious on how things translate now in St.
00:41:35
Speaker 2: Petersburg.
00:41:35
Speaker 1: Does a pendulum swing into the Rays favor because they've been so good at home?
00:41:41
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:41:42
Speaker 2: I mean, it's, uh, two games to nothing. You know, the Brewers winning, but there were two one run games, two games that came down to the ninth inning runners in scoring position. Um, The Brewers' bullpen is showing that, yeah, you can understand why they blasted past the Dodgers, why they're able to come back in games, because even if they dig an early hole, even the Brewers' middle of the bullpen is throwing scoreless innings to keep them in the game and allow them to come back, buy them a lot of time. So you can see that that has translated from one series to the other, but it's still 200 in losses. The Rays had to come back against the Guardians, and they did. And pretty convincingly as well, you know, after an early wobble. So, you know, the saying is that, you know, it's not really a series until a home team loses a game. And I could see the same thing being the case here to where like, yeah, the Brewers won a couple of games, but by one run, the Rays are still, they're close, like close. you can understand, you kind of see why the Brewers, because of the two strike hits that it got, the fewer strikeouts, better bullpen, et cetera, why they're winning games. But the Rays have won games in similar fashion too, with a lot of depth. So game three, I think is pivotal game three. It's not quite pivotal in the classic sense because of just, you know, it's not going to give a team a lead. It's going to just have the deficit that the Rays are currently facing. But in terms of, I could see this being a case where both teams hold serve at home and either whether it's home field advantage becomes a factor or just because both teams are good and they play slightly better in friendly environments, but otherwise they're evenly matched. I'm not throwing in the towel or raising the white flag for the Rays just yet.
00:43:26
Speaker 1: No, nobody should because they got Freddy Peralta starting game three. And Freddy Peralta has been awesome for the Rays ever since he's joined the team via trade. From the New York Mets. It is something that's on my mind, though, is that if the Brewers do find a way to win games three and four, Jim, and sweep the Rays, that's an 11-1 postseason. That matches what obviously the 2005 Chicago White Sox did. when they won the World Series. So it is possible the Brewers could finish 11-1. That's still alive for the Milwaukee Brewers. But a great scene in Milwaukee. The crowd was awesome, an American fam. Just the reaction to Sal Freelick hitting that home run, just really cool moments in Milwaukee. We knew this World Series was going to be entertaining. Can't wait to see how it unfolds in Game 3 in St. Pete between the Rays and the Brewers. But that will do it for this episode of the Sox Machine Podcast. Thank you guys so much for watching and listening. This is a video podcast, so you can watch the show at our YouTube channel at youtube.com slash Sox Machine. We continue to gain subscribers. Thank you guys so much for subscribing to the Sox Machine YouTube channel. If you haven't subscribed yet, please hit the subscription button. We greatly appreciate it. If you need something to listen to, you can listen to the audio version of this show wherever you listen to podcasts such as Spotify and Apple Music. Follow us on social media. We're on all the social media platforms at Sox Machine. And the Sox Machine podcast is a production of SoxMachine.com. We offer all things Chicago White Sox baseball and part of the Foul Territory Network. Alongside Jim Margulis, I'm Josh Nelson. Thanks for watching and listening.