TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Joe Pine: one of the things that companies need to realize is that fostering flourishing is in fact the raison d'etre of business. That
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: as a company, as a brand, you exist to help people flourish. Not just customers, but employees. not just them, but the communities in which you reside and society overall, You don't exist to make a profit, right? What a horrible goal that is, right? Is that profit is the measure of how well you foster human flourishing.
Matt: Helping you create loyal customers and loyal employees all through the power of simplicity. This is the Simple Brand Podcast, now heard around the world, including Cyberja Malaysia. I'm Matt Lyles, and today I'm talking with Joe Pine. Joe's the co-author of the groundbreaking customer experience book, The Experience Economy. It's been helping to change the way that brands think about creating value through customer experience. For over 25 years. And now, in his latest book, The Transformation Economy, Joe argues that creating a great customer experience may no longer be enough. Well, Think about how much time you and your team spend trying to understand what your customers want. Like, what products do they want? What service do they need? What problem are they trying to solve? What kind of experience do they expect from you? And those are all important questions, but But there's an even more important question that you need to be asking. Who does your customer want to become? So your customers aren't simply buying products, services, or even experiences. They're trying to make progress in their own lives. They may want to become healthier, more knowledgeable, more capable, more successful. Essentially, they want to become a better version of themselves. And the brands that understand that. Have an opportunity to create an entirely different level of value, not simply by giving customers what they want, but by helping them become who they want to become. So Joe and I talk about what it means to move beyond creating experiences and to start guiding customers on transformations. We explore how to understand the progress your customers are really trying to make, how transformations can create greater customer loyalty, and What it looks like to intentionally help your customers achieve their aspirations. So if you're continually asking, what do our customers want, then this conversation may convince you to start asking, who do our customers want to become? So here's my conversation with Joe Pine.
Matt Lyles: Hey Joe, welcome to the show.
Joe Pine: Thanks, Matt. Pleasure to be with you today.
Matt Lyles: Yeah, well I am excited that you're here. Gosh, I I've followed your lessons with the experience economy for a number of years now, but I am looking forward talking about The transformation economy guiding customers to achieve their aspiration. Well, but before we get into that, the experienced economy It came out 27 years ago,
Joe Pine: 1999 was the first edition, yep.
Load full transcript
Matt Lyles: 1999.
Joe Pine: Long time ago.
Matt Lyles: You know, I yeah, so on one hand, yes, that is kind of a long time ago. And not many business books seem to have that much life in them as this one has. So why has that book stood the test of time, so to speak?
Joe Pine: you we continue to sell thousands of copies every year. I just got the royalty statement. I know that's still holding. And it's basically because my co-author and partner, Jim Gilmore and I didn't discover a fad. We discovered a fundamental change in the very fabric of the economy that we had moved from an agrarian economy based off commodities to industrial economy based off goods or a service economy. And that we were going, as we said, in 1999. to shift into an experienced economy or experiences became the predominant economic offering. And I used to have to argue with people that this was so had data and all this, know, marshallied arguments and, it wasn't too long in the future where I stopped having to argue with people. And now you just say it, everybody gets it right. Because, because experience was in the air, right? We know that there when, when we came out with the update edition in 2011, we stopped talking about the forthcoming, the nascent, the emerging experience coming. We said it's here.
Matt Lyles: Yeah, it was already there.
Joe Pine: Now this is now 15 years later than that. So we're surrounded by experiences. We all understand that we prefer experiences over things.
Matt Lyles: since that time, what do you think has changed in the world and what do you think stayed the same?
Joe Pine: Well, experiences have always been around. So I'd say it hasn't changed from time immemorial that we've always craved experiences. but I will say that you can put a demarcation point on July 17th, 1955, which is when Disneyland opened in California and got so much press, right? And so many guests. because of the great experiences they created. That's sort of where people began to notice experiences as this thing, right? It's almost this distinct thing, as they call it, a distinct economic offering. But one of the things that's changed since 1999 is originally we just talked about definition of experience as a memorable event that engages each individual in inherently personal way. Being memorable was the key. experiences is expansive word. You know, there's a sense in which if we're conscious, we're experiencing. People say, if you're dreaming, you're experiencing. don't even have to be conscious. But as distinct economic offering, a lot of that experiencing doesn't rise to the level of memorability. So it's got to be memorable. And then one of the things that's clearly changed is that increasingly people don't want just memorable. They want the merely memorable. They want the highly meaningful as well. that that memorable experience engage who we are and meaningful experiences connect with who we are in some way. there also have always been, but just recently sort of noticed
by me this another distinction, which is transporting experiences, experiences take you out of who you are by giving you awe or getting you into flow or having a euphoric peak experience, right? That are even deeper. than meaningful experiences in that sense, that they get us out of who we are. and then the fourth type of experience is transformative experiences, experiences that change who we are. Now that was actually in the experience economy. The
Matt Lyles: Right.
Joe Pine: last two chapters were on transformations. We talked about it, right? But people often forget that because, and I've been asked for 27 years, you when are you going to write a full book on transformations? And I, I said, well, one, the world wasn't ready for it and I don't know enough about it. And that's what's changed, right? Is that I know enough about it. I did a lot of research on it. And the world has become ready for it where it were today. I even though on the first publication of the book, again, it's been around, but nobody objects. Nobody says, says, well, really is that distinct economic offering and I have to prove it and so forth. Right. Again, people get it. They get the fact that they want transformative experiences. They get the fact that change is hard and they need help transforming
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: themselves. So we are in the midst of this experience and transformation economy together.
Matt Lyles: do you think are some of the signals that showed you, yeah, the world is ready for it now?
Joe Pine: one of them was research that I did with Stone Mantle and Insights Consultancy. They've run these collaboratives for 20 years. In the last five or six years, they've included transformations in them, right? And it's just seeing the research that says, yeah, people are open-ended. They want change. They need help with change. Thinking about how they define change and so forth was a big deal. There was never any, well, I don't know. I don't know what you're talking about, right? They got that too. And then also the founding of the World Experience Organization, again, I'm going to say six or seven years ago, by James Wallman in London. He lists me as a co-founder, but all I did was say yes when he called me and said, is it okay to do this? And yes, yes, I want somebody to do this. So thank you.
Matt Lyles: There you go.
Joe Pine: We started having the summits. I just returned from the fourth summit in London in April. And I start talking to all these people at the summits and also in these weekly campfires that they did during the school year, where the experience designers themselves would constantly talk about how they wanted to create transformative experiences, impactful experiences. And so that was another big signal that the designers of these experiences recognize that it's not just about having a good time, that they can have an impact, that they can change individuals and that they want to design them. to do so. I think those are the two biggest things. Particularly on the demand side, right, of what do customers want. COVID helped too, where we recognize we want more meaningful experiences and up to transformative. On the supply side, it's also recognized, and there are more and companies that were doing this for various reasons, and that some experiences were starting to be commoditized. You know, I a lot of point out the theme restaurants, right? Probably the first experience industry to commoditize themselves because you
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: in there done that you go once, you don't have to go again. But a colleague and I wrote an article in the Harvard business review, uh, two years ago in which we talked about how Starbucks is commoditizing itself, you know, that they're getting rid of the comfy chairs in favor of hard chairs. So people don't stay as long. You're hiding electrical
Matt Lyles: Right.
Joe Pine: outlets, you know, you lose the smell of the coffee as they now come in vacuum packed rather than being. roasted right there or ground right there. I'm sure this is pure coincidence, right? Purely. But three weeks after we wrote that article, Starbucks fired its CEO. And they hired
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: somebody who is basically going down the list of things that we talked about. know, that Brian Nichols is doing a great job in sort of restoring Starbucks to that third place where people do want to come in, buy and hang out. to, visited my first mobile only store in New York city a couple of weeks ago, where you, you have to order mobile and come pick it up. There's no way to order it inside. which is interesting, a very small place. with actually the sort of like kitchen, if you call it that, the back. that commodization of experiences means that that companies will increase. look, you know, search for differentiation. And that last final frontier, if you will, is transformations that you help customers achieve their aspirations. So you think of transformations as Effectual outcomes that change customers in a significant way and that lasts over time.
Matt Lyles: Gotcha, well, and you talked about designers having that desire to want to create transformative experiences and that there's a demand for them as well. So what is it that customers are actually looking for in a transformative experience?
Joe Pine: They want to be changed, They want to change the mouth in some way, either in degree, become a more of something they are, become better at it, becoming more capable because they have some ambition or some desire to enhance who they are, or a change in kind where they have some new element of identity. All transformation is identity change. It's important to understand. It's
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: not You know, somebody could change me from being hungry to full in a restaurant, could change me from being sad to happy in some experience. But are transitions in state, right? Not transformations in identity. They don't last. You make it last.
Matt
Lyles: Yeah. I am this today. I aspire to be this
Joe Pine: Right.
Matt Lyles: tomorrow.
Joe Pine: Exactly. I'm actually an applied math major, so I use parameters. say I was X, now I am Y. But that's what transformations are. They're from twos, right? From one, who you were before, to who you want to become. They have aspirations. That's why I call the customers of transformations aspirants. Commodities sell into markets, goods have users, services, clients, and experiences have guests. Transformations have aspirants. it may not be a term you want to use with your customers, but internally, if you call them aspirants, that immediately changes how you think about it. Right? You understand there are bundled aspirations and they need help. experiences and services, goods, and commodities, transformations have always been around. They're not a new economic offering, just newly identified.
Matt Lyles: Right.
Joe Pine: before, the past, we were all sort of our own general contractors trying to make this happen, but change is hard, right? Significant change anyway, is hard. And it just helps to have somebody to guide us. And that's what you're doing with, transformations. You're guiding, You extract commodities, you make goods, you deliver services, you stage experiences, you guide transformations. You, you can't change them. They have to change themselves, but you can create the conditions under which they undergo that change.
Matt Lyles: guiding guidance, that's a key word there that helps with everyone's mindset, everyone who's a part of the brand that helps them better understand this is the journey that our customer's going on. We're there to help guide them along the way. And so because of that, we need to ensure that every interaction that's designed, that's built and delivered to them helps in guiding them along their
Joe Pine: Right.
Matt Lyles: aspirational path.
Joe Pine: Right, right. as a branding guy and marketing that, you know, the companies always look at the customer journey, right? The customer journey. But
Matt Lyles: Right.
Joe Pine: that's your view of what you want them to do. For an
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: internal, it's not what their journey they're on, right? They are on a transformation journey. Often before they interact with you, or it's something that you can instigate with them. to help them realize they have an aspiration, uncover what their aspirations are and help them along that journey. But that journey is their journey. It's not your journey with the customer, right? So you
Matt Lyles: Right.
Joe Pine: gotta be careful in using the term customer journey, unless people think you mean that. So just using aspirant would help. It's an aspirant journey. But talk about it as a transformation journey, not how they interact with us as a company.
Matt Lyles: And I think that that does something else as well for brands and that are working there is when you look at it that way, when you look at it as an aspirant, depending on what it is you offer, depending on that customer, it's recognizing that each individual customer may not have the same starting point. If you're looking at transformation, Sometimes like some may be starting from way over here and some may be starting from here.
Joe Pine: Right, exactly. Some may be starting from scratch, where again, it's where they may come to you for help in uncovering it or help in thinking about it. and others may be on that journey and then want help in, and pushing it forward, so to speak. I gave a talk in January in Rotterdam at a third place summit. was about, about, third places like Starbucks itself is a third place, neither work nor home. A lot
Matt Lyles: well.
Joe Pine: of libraries were there, interestingly, in addition to cafes, but also barbershops and other places. And one of the things I told them is that if you think of your places they're liminal places. They're neither work or home. They're in between those two and think of them
Matt Lyles: Okay.
Joe Pine: as a chrysalis. Right. So chrysalis is a metaphor. mean, for, for a caterpillar, it's an actual transformation, right? But it's a metaphor
Matt Lyles: Right, yeah.
Joe Pine: for human transformation, right? A place where you can transform a place that is neither who you were before, nor who you're about to become. And so third places can think of themselves that way is this chrysalis of how do we help people? reflect on where they are in the journey and help them prepare for the next stage in their journey. And there's a lot of brands that can do that as well, even if they're not the overarching experience guider that's helping them.
Matt Lyles: Yeah, and to me, I start to think about, if you look at it that way, then that requires that much more personalization that's needed for your customers and understanding them as individuals to be able to give them that personalized experience.
Joe Pine: Yes, you can't really mass produce the transformation. You've got to understand those individuals
Matt Lyles: Yeah. Yeah.
Joe Pine: because I say, you I was X, now I'm Y, but for every person, they're going to say that slightly differently or even the same words are going to mean things slightly differently because they're starting from a different point and they have, you know, a potentially different endpoint in mind. And you've got to be able to customize for them. you know, I like to think of it as, as Lego building bricks. Yeah. What can you do with Lego? Right.
Matt Lyles: Love the visualization. Yeah.
Joe Pine: Anything you want. Right. So, so you get all these different possibilities that you have and need to put them together in different ways for different customers. You in fact need to sense and respond what is going on because transformation journeys are never monotonically increasing. There's always ups and downs. There's always regress as well as progress. You need to figure out when they regress, I need to call another Lego brick off the
shelf and put that into play. and do something differently for this individual customer based on where they're at.
Matt Lyles: the whole time that I was kind of thinking through all of this, my mind kept going back to, when I decided that I was not identified as a long distance runner, but I wanted to identify as a long distance runner.
Joe Pine: Yeah.
Matt Lyles: And so I started working with a long distance coach that coached people on running half marathons and marathons. based on where I was, my age, my weight, my strength, my abilities, my speed, she helped work with me to create a personalized plan to transform me from not a long distance runner to a long distance runner. And then after that, it was identifying as a long distance runner, but now being transformed to a long distance runner that runs at this faster speed now and improving.
Joe Pine: Right. And that's beautiful, Matt, is identify, right? Because you recognize it as an aspect of identity. and maybe at one point you weren't a long distance runner, then you took that on aspiration is I want to become a long distance runner. And then you
Matt Lyles: Right.
Joe Pine: became a long distance runner, but then you recognize, well, the transformation isn't done because I can get better. Right. I want to improve
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: my time and want to, use it in other ways. And so that, that identity or identifying with it as as a very key aspect. And by the way, the rise of coaching over the last 20, 30, 40 years is another reason why I thought we're ready for the transformation economy because like everybody has a coach, right? Everybody. I actually asked in a talk I gave in San Francisco a week or two ago, I asked for a raise of hands. How many people here have ever used a coach? And there are two or three people that raise their hands. I said, come on, really? And I put it, they said, okay, yeah, we did. You everybody has used a coach in
Matt Lyles: yeah.
Joe Pine: some way.
Matt Lyles: to me, different types of coaches based on different aspects in my life. Sometimes coaches that help focus on physical development. Sometimes coaches that help focus on emotional development. And some coaches helped on professional development.
Joe Pine: Right. some are, focused on that, the, uh, psychological aspects of winning, of you know, actually feeling comfortable winning that it's okay to actually, uh, win in things and not be scared of it. And you want to embrace that, the tension that
Matt Lyles: right?
Joe Pine: comes in with it.
Matt Lyles: so thinking of it that way, when we think of this need for helping others to transform, say that it's simply not just a one and done type experience, like that there's always an ongoing relationship?
Joe Pine: Yeah, usually, about always, but sometimes it's one and done. But often it is because a key aspect of transformation is actually sustaining it through time. You need to think about there's three phases of transformation. First is diagnosis. Who is this customer? Who do they want to become? Then there's a series of experiences that we talked about including the remedial ones that take people back up and so forth. And then you get to that top, the top of the mountain where they say, hey, I'm transformed. I was X, now I am Y. But is it sustained? If you start to then really fall back and say, okay, I've got it, but then let that change dissipate. So the
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: transformation guider has to stick around and say, let me integrate this. So I call it follow through. Right? You follow through with the transformation, not follow up, which is high, how you doing, but follow through, which is ensuring that the transformation takes hold. and so that's a key aspect. And then, so you may have a very long time relationship with them. And that may also then lead into a another transformation, including like you said, Hey, you transform me a long distance runner. can do a marathon anytime I want, but I want to get faster. want to beat the, four hour mark or three hour mark or whatever. think two hours the record, right? Now, but whatever that record is, I
Matt Lyles: Somebody just hit that yeah, it's crazy
Joe Pine: know it's crazy. You want a personal best, right? And so now I'm gonna take and say, okay, this is now a new transformation that I'm.
Matt Lyles: Yeah, so to me, I think that's like two different ways of looking at it if you're using the mountain analogy. One is, you're helping somebody to climb the mountain and then you help them to make sure that they stay at the top of that mountain.
Joe Pine: Right. Right.
Matt Lyles: And then there's the other opportunity of they climb the mountain, they're at their top, and then you show them, and now there's another mountain right over there that's even higher. Let's go do that.
Joe Pine: Hey, right. Right. Yep. Exactly. It's a good way to put it.
Matt Lyles: Well, one of the things that you focus on, I guess all throughout the defining of experiences is the influence of time and how time plays a role in experience and in transformation. So what's the influence of time in transformative experiences?
Joe Pine: this progression of economic value, as we call it, the five stages, five different genres of economic value, it's all about time, if you think about it. What commodities, goods, and services do is that they save our time, time well saved. They save our time do things for us that we can't do ourselves. I could go out and You know, so some so some oats had to use a phrase. I could go so some oats. Sorry.
Matt Lyles: Right.
Joe Pine: I didn't mean it. I go so some oats and and pull that up and then bake, you know, or make oatmeal. But I save a lot more time for commodity company does that in bulk, much lower cost and provides me the oats, my oatmeal or as goods. They I would just give you the oats. I'll give you the actual oatmeal. Right.
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: You you can make it from there. or service of
going to breakfast restaurants I often have oatmeal at Starbucks, go to Starbucks and let me have the oatmeal and you prepare it for me. all of that is time well saved. And in fact, one of the key things is that pushes forward this regression of economic value is that people want goods and services to be commoditized. They want goods and services to be bought at the lowest possible price and the greatest possible convenience. So they spend their hard earned money and their hard to earn time on the experiences that they value. And experiences offer time well spent, Time well saved, yes. But now with that time and money I've saved, I'm gonna go spend them on experiences that I value much more highly. And then what transformations do is they add another layer to that, another level to that with time well invested. That every experience I have with you, I'm actually investing it. in becoming more of who I want to become or getting closer and closer to that identity change that I want to have. And that's the greatest economic value you can provide is to help somebody achieve his aspirations.
Matt Lyles: and when I think of investments, when I think of investing, my mind always goes to, well, if there's an investment, then there should be an expectation of a return, a return
Joe Pine: turn.
Matt Lyles: of more than what was invested. And when I think of time well saved, to me, I can see that as maybe a one-to-one ratio. But
Joe Pine: Mm-hmm.
Matt Lyles: if I think of time well invested, that means that I should get a pretty significant return from this. And that does speak to high aspirations as well as an expectation of a significant transformation.
Joe Pine: Right, exactly. that compound interest that you're doing in each experience you have that's going to you
Matt Lyles: Yeah, that's it.
Joe Pine: great benefits in the future.
Matt Lyles: Yeah. Well, so how can we better focus on time well invested in designing what we deliver to our customers?
Joe Pine: so focus number one on their aspirations. Try and do that diagnosis. And it may be something you can specifically charge for itself is that diagnosis. to figure out who they are and what they want to become. And then it's a matter of designing those sets of experiences to take them from here to there. recognizing that investment on each one. needs to build on top of the previous ones and you can't like skip step. you don't want to get like sort of stuck in doing the same thing for them and they're not, there's no longer an investment, but get them through that investment all the way to the end identity change.
Matt Lyles: that makes a lot of sense in thinking about that aspirate type journey, is making sure that you are not skipping things and that you are building on the previous steps.
Joe Pine: Correct.
Matt Lyles: So then what's the process to be able to deliver on that transformative experience?
Joe Pine: three phases are key is thinking about them as process, but also
Matt Lyles: Okay.
Joe Pine: what you need is, sort of that sort of phases, also for every experience that they have, right. That they're investing with you. And this I call encapsulation and encapsulation
Matt Lyles: Okay.
Joe Pine: is something that if you stage experiences today. or you're at the good service level and you really start creating experiences, by encapsulation, can actually make them transformative pretty much automatically. And so what it requires is one is preparation, right? The first step in encapsulation is preparation. Prepare them for the experience. Prime them for the experience that they're going to have. Get them thinking about it, what the possibilities are. Maybe you get thinking about Are there any aspirations that you have or where are you on a transformation journey? how might you use this to further along that journey? then you have the experience and then ideally immediately, but at least afterward you have reflection. Reflection is where you look back at that experience, ask them what the highlights were, what things were most meaningful to you. How can you see yourself taking what you learned there, what happened there, and bringing it into your life on an ongoing basis? And reflection retroactively increases the value of the experience. Just doing that will increase the value because you cement the memories. You get people thinking about the impact it has on them. They go like, wow, that really was impactful. And then the final step is integration. And that's like the fall through.
Matt Lyles: Okay.
Joe Pine: integration is where you help them integrate
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: that experience into their lives. You don't just leave them hanging and say, what can we do after this experience that furthers you along your journey? And that integration then becomes preparation for the next experience that you invest in to further the journey as well.
Matt Lyles: So that helps make it an ongoing experience, an ongoing journey.
Joe Pine: Correct.
Matt Lyles: Well, so one of the things, and we were talking about this earlier, it sounds like the goal is to help people flourish. So how do you define flourishing and what should flourishing look like?
Joe Pine: so flourishing is when we have many aspects of our lives that are going well, so to speak, that we are who we want to be to a degree, not that there can't always be improvement. And there's been this renaissance in flourishing, particularly with the rise of positive psychology in the last 20, 30 years. I mean, the concept goes back to Aristotle and his Greek word eudaimonia. And even before that, Psalms and Proverbs in the Bible talked about flourishing and what it takes to flourish. So it's a very old concept, but positive psychology has really bought it to the fore. And there's a lot of different definitions of it. And I like just a simple definition that flourishing is the extent to which you are who you are meant to be.
Matt Lyles: Okay.
Joe Pine: The extent to which means that
there's levels of flourishing. I can be flourishing a little, I can be flourishing a lot. And it's who you are meant to be, right? All the possibilities of who you are and how can you become more of that no matter who or capital W, who does the meaning of who you are. And so the entire progression of economic value is a model of flourishing. For any economic offering, nobody ever buys your offering unless they think they're going to be better off in some way. They're exchanging money out of their wallet, out of their purse, out of their account, and they're giving it to you because what you have is more valuable to me than the money. But transformations do that most explicitly by focusing on what is that aspect of identity that will help you flourish more and become more of who you are meant to be.
Matt Lyles: And then I like tying it to Psalms and Proverbs, and so that gets me thinking as far as how we are preparing our customers and explaining it to it. I think this ties more to my recollection of Proverbs than Psalms, but a lot of what's in Proverbs are what I call like if-then statements.
Joe Pine: Right, right.
Matt Lyles: If you do this, this great thing will happen. But if you do this, then this bad thing will happen. So it's like
Joe Pine: If you do this, this will happen. Right.
Matt Lyles: here is the way, like explaining to him, here is the way to flourish. When you do this, you can flourish.
Joe Pine: Right, right. That's a very good description of Proverbs, think, making
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: that happen. so one of the things that companies need to realize is that fostering human flourishing is in fact the raison d'etre of business. That
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: as a company, as a brand, you exist to help people flourish. Not just customers, but employees. not just them, but the communities in which you reside and society overall, You don't exist to make a profit, right? What a horrible goal that is, right? Is that profit is the measure of how well you foster human flourishing. So if you focus on the flourishing,
Matt Lyles: It's a byproduct.
Joe Pine: exactly, that's a byproduct. The profits will come if you focus on human flourishing. If you focus on profits, then you will do things that actually diminish human flourishing overall. and set yourself up for failure in the future.
Matt Lyles: Yeah, so, okay, I understand that, I get that, but if I'm trying to get my C-suite to buy into that and to buy into the idea of fostering human flourishing, not just for our customers, but for our employees and for our community, our world, what does it take to help them understand the value in doing this?
Joe Pine: what it takes is to understand it viscerally in their own lives. Get them.
Matt Lyles: Explain that.
Joe Pine: So get them to understand what are your aspirations? What do you want to become? Right. And think about those and then get to understand that. Let's think about this concept of human flourishing. What helps you flourish? When are you at your best? When do you are most happy? Although it's not nearly about happy. Well, I'll define, four spheres of transformation here to make it easy. What gives you health and wellbeing? What gives you wealth and prosperity? Prosperity, meaning having a good life, right? The money being the means to the end. What gives
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: you knowledge and wisdom and what gives you purpose and meaning in life? Right? If you get them to define those four things themselves on what they're looking for, what they mean for them and say, our customers are just like you. They want to flourish. They want to have these aspects often not, not just to themselves, but often of their kids, sometimes of their parents, particularly as they, as they age in life, depending on what business you're in to think about how do you help them and their families flourish and that that's our goal. I think that like the number one thing companies need to do is uncover what their meaningful purpose is, Sort of a related concept. Meanful purpose is a reason you exist in the world other than making a buck. it's rare that you have to go into company and like make one out of whole cloth. There already is one, right? What got you into this business in the first place? And why did you create this business and, and, uncover it and say, okay, this is it. This is what we're about. Right. And where money is never mentioned, right. It's not about making money. It's about why we exist in the world. And again, then how does that lead us to help our customers flourish, to help our employees flourish, to give them the wherewithal to help our customers flourish, and as well support communities and the society and the planet. And a stakeholder rights person, right? I don't believe that these are stakeholders that have rights on you. I say you have a responsibility to them. You have a higher calling. extractive in this world, but to benefit the world, not to make your products addictive, but to do what is right for your customers and your employees. You have a fiduciary responsibility to do what is right for others that's been entrusted to you as a C-suite of this company.
Matt Lyles: so then what does it look like to be able to do that for our employees?
Joe Pine: So it includes understanding, obviously you've got salary and benefits and that sort of thing, right? But it's also recognizing that each of them is on a journey. So you've got a win-win situation if you help your employees become who they want to become at work, which then helps you and the company because they're more productive, more creative, whatever the measures that you want to put on that. So you do need to have development plans as we call them. And you'd give people assignments to stretch them and see if they could do that. But we don't do enough guidance. It's one of the problems. We may have these
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: plans. You do this. We may send you to an educational class.
But the educational class, the teacher there may not understand what their role is in helping these individuals. They may be like, mass producing this thing instead of understanding them as individuals and customize to them, making sure they get it and so forth. And so you need to treat them with the human dignity that they have and as much as possible do what's right for them. It doesn't mean you can never lay off anybody. You can never fire anybody. You can't close or sell a business for that. Those are business decisions. But the way in which
Matt Lyles: Yeah, it happened.
Joe Pine: you do them, right, should be with that eye towards human flourishing. that in the end makes them better off than they were if they had stayed in a losing business, let's say.
Matt Lyles: Yeah, well and to your point, if you are investing that much, whether it's financially or actually investing of yourself, in guiding your employees and helping them to flourish, then your employees will be that much more engaged in their job and will be
Joe Pine: Right, exactly.
Matt Lyles: much more able to deliver more to your customers who will likely be more loyal to you. So then, you would be less likely to have to close down locations, have layoffs.
Joe Pine: Right. Exactly. Exactly. Cause you're given the wherewithal to succeed, you know,
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: under many different conditions.
Matt Lyles: Love it. All right, well Joe, last question for you. If you were to create a five song playlist
Joe Pine: you
Matt Lyles: for the transformation economy, what songs would you include?
Joe Pine: I'll start with, I got a kick out of how you, how you started it, Matt, when you first thing you said was Hey Joe, right? Cause that's
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: the first song, right? Hey Joe by Jimi Hendrix. Not obviously because the lyrics, right? Right. So it's not about the lyrics. But I get that all the time. got
Matt Lyles: Just the time.
Joe Pine: it. I got it yesterday in church where somebody said, hey, Joe, you know, what you doing with that gun? so just because my name's Joe, I get that. Hey, Joe, it's a good thing. And then and then I'll point to another Jimi Hendrix song, which is Are You Experienced?
Matt Lyles: yeah!
Joe Pine: Right. Are you experienced now? He meant it in a psychedelic way, right? But the question is, are you?
Matt Lyles: But yeah. Another transformation.
Joe Pine: Right. Are you experienced in an experience economy way? Right. Are you taking advantage of the experiences out there as a business person? Are you giving experiences, staging experiences
Matt Lyles: Yeah.
Joe Pine: for your customers? And then I'll give you another one that I actually have used in workshops with customers is The Roaches "-Ing" song, where they go, you know,
Matt Lyles: I don't think I'm familiar.
Joe Pine: -ing, -ing-, -ing, -ing like, forty some times, They're going, the chorus is ing, right? And one of the things that Jim Gilmore and I came up with in the experience kind of book is that the first principle experience staging is understanding "ing" ing. Right? In other words, -ing means the word is a gerund, So it means that you are experiencing something. That's what gerunds mean, right? So I'm playing, I'm reading, I'm listening to music and and so forth. I'm talking, all of those are experiential words. Once you put that -ing on there? And of course, transformations are all built on top of experiences, right? So all this relates. And then I was asked in February, I gave a speech in Monaco to the Forbes Travel Guide Summit, and they asked for walk up music, right? You know,
Matt Lyles: Right.
Joe Pine: I've often had walk up music, but nobody's asked me what walk up music do I want? So talking about the change, the experience, the transformation economy and changes. uh, David Bowie's right. Ch-ch-ch-ch-changes. Right. And everybody. Right. Right.
Matt Lyles: Yep. I was hoping that would be one of those songs. Nice.
Joe Pine: Exactly. Right. That that's what the transformation of the economy is about. It's about those, those changes. And then the other one I suggested, is the TV theme song to the show, The Transformers, which
Matt Lyles: more than meets the eye.
Joe Pine: And it's basically, you know, it doesn't mean a lot. It's about, it tells a little bit about the story of these things that transform into, which are really just transitions actually. But nonetheless, it just goes, the Transformers!
Matt Lyles: You know what? Like now that I think about it, you're right. It was more really like when you think of the literal definition, it was more of just a transition than actual transforming. Huh. But yeah.
Joe Pine: Right, right. Because it was a state that could go back to and from, you know, back to and that it wasn't a real ascendance to a new level.
Matt Lyles: Yeah, and never really changed their identity either. Yeah, they're,
Joe Pine: Right, right, exactly.
Matt Lyles: hey, I'm always an Autobot. I'm always a Decepticon, no matter what.
Joe Pine: Whoa, you know your transformers!
Matt Lyles: Well, yeah, I watched it too.
Joe Pine: Alright.
Matt Lyles: I love that. that that is a really fun playlist. I really appreciate you playing along with me on that. Well, Joe, I've learned a lot. from your books and your writings. I've learned a lot from our discussion today. But where can we go to learn more?
Joe Pine: You can always LinkedIn with me and LinkedIn just look up Joe Pine and and if you do I'll send you little email about learning more as well which is we have a quarterly field notes newsletter that you can find on the contact page on our website which is strategichorizons.com strategic horizons with an "s" .com
Matt Lyles: Nice.
Joe Pine: but also I'll say that I wrote the transformation economy actually on Substack So transformationsbook.substack.com is where I'm ongoing talking about the transformation economy, continuing to come up with new ideas, new exemplars, new ways of thinking about it. And actually over 125 % of the book is on Substack because I edited some stuff out so you can find models that weren't on there and so forth if you really want to dig into it.
Matt Lyles: Yeah, you can find the extras. Excellent. And if anybody does connect with you on LinkedIn, they should then message you and say, hey Joe.
Joe Pine: Yeah. Yes, absolutely. I'll know if
Matt Lyles: Excellent. Well, Joe, thank you.
Joe Pine: they do that. I'll know where it came from.
Matt Lyles: Exactly. Well, Joe, I really appreciated this. I appreciated your time today. Thank you so much for being here.
Matt: Well, thanks again to Joe Pine for joining me on the show. And thank you for joining me. You know, one thing that really stuck with me from my conversation with Joe is this idea of time well invested. We talk about how services can give customers time well saved. Experiences can give customers time well spent. But transformations can give customers time well invested. And I love that distinction because Think about what it means to invest in something. When you invest your money, you expect to eventually get something greater in return. So if your customers are investing their time with you, then what's the return on that investment? Maybe they leave more knowledgeable than they were before. Maybe they're more confident. Maybe they're healthier. Maybe they're more capable of doing something that they couldn't do before. Maybe they're one step closer to accomplishing something that's important to them. Or maybe they're simply closer to becoming who they want to become. Like how I went from seeing myself as a non-runner to seeing myself as a long-distance runner. And that's a different way to evaluate the experiences we're designing and delivering to our customers. So we often ask: Was the experience simple? Well, it better be. Was it enjoyable? Was it memorable? Was the customer satisfied? And Those are all good questions, but maybe we should be asking something more. Was the customer's time with us well invested? Did we help them make meaningful progress towards something that matters to them? Sure, creating an experience that customers enjoy, like that is valuable. But creating an experience that makes their lives better, that helps them transform into someone who they want to become? That's an entirely different level of value. So think about one of the experiences your customers regularly have with your brand. What's the return they're getting on the time that they invest with you? And what could you change to make that return even greater? Thanks for listening. Thanks for watching. Until next time, keep it simple.