TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Nick: we remember Leonardo because of his painting, but he made all of his money inventing. All of his money. This is why half of his paintings were unfinished. to me that's a really interesting thing because when you look at the world now, the people that are making money are engineers, not artists. Sam Altman's gonna make a lot more money than Rick Rubin this year. this has really changed the way we think as a species, And I think the obvious result of that is is this we've reached the physics of our attention.
Gully Flowers: Nick Law, welcome back to Second Wind.
Nick: It's great to be here. Thank you.
Gully Flowers: Last time you were here, you told us production companies were going to disappear. Agencies still hadn't figured out the fu*king internet. And the industry was overdue for a fairly serious shake up. A year later, Omnicom's swallowed IPG. Every holding company seems to have discovered AI. And you've been at Cannes telling business leaders they need to get a lot more creative. Let's start with Cannes. You presented some research showing that 81% of business leaders think their companies are good at coming up with ideas, but only 16% say they regularly turn those ideas into growth.
Nick: first of all, you know, saying you can come up with ideas, you know, th that's a that's a big number like of of companies say they come up with ideas. The quality of those ideas might be uneven, but what what is definitely true is that getting an idea out of someone's head into the real world seems to be really difficult. and it might be that the bigger the company The more bureaucratic it is, the more layers, and and the sort of lack of a sensibility amongst leaders for what constitutes a great idea is is the thing that makes it so difficult. you know, anyone that's that's that's worked in a big company knows that this is true. So now the only reason this matters, obviously now, in a way that it hasn't mattered previously, is that the The the people that are building the models that are changing everything, the leaders in AI are all saying something like taste is important, discernment is really the thing that's gonna separate you from everyone else, you know, and creative thinking is gonna be the thing that you sit on top of these models. Because the models will be able to do, you know, they'll be able to solve for the how. They won't solve for the why. And they also won't solve for the end experience, which only a human can can judge whether it's interesting or not. So so this is why it's a bit of a crisis, because at the very time when creative thinking is the thing that's gonna make companies powerful, companies find it difficult to actually apply those ideas.
Gully Flowers: Is that because creatives have never been as good at selling their ideas as they have at coming up with them?
Nick: No, I think it's because we've seen this secular change from and particularly in the in the in the creative industry, but this is true generally, of of leadership teams like you know, the executive suite and the boards of big companies have have been captured by operations and finance. So, you know, like if you look at the names on the on the doors of of the most storied agencies, a lot of them are creative people. Ogilvy's and Bernbach's you know, Droga. I mean d these and Wieden these are creative people. but they're not being run by creative people anymore. And I think that this is as much to do with with creative culture losing interest in business as business losing interest in creative culture. Which is absurd.
jake: a lot of the conversations that we're having, I think, sit in this world of applied creativity. I think that it's this growing vertical. I don't think it has a commercial lane yet, but what's been the response to the report thus far?
Nick: I think it's been universally understood and and agreed upon, really. I often quote Peter Drucker, who's a a business theorist and analyst a blue flame thinker, and he argued that quite obviously, but in retrospect, we've sort of lost this idea that you don't have a business without a customer, right? So your job the job of a business is to create a customer. and and therefore the two most important corporate functions are innovation and marketing. Innovation, what products are you selling and how do you make them different and and useful and interesting? And marketing, how do you make people care about them? Now that seems obvious, right? That if you don't have those two things, you don't have a company. And he also claims that everything else is a cost. I've been lucky, I've worked at companies where we've balanced creative thinking with operational thinking. I'm not arguing that we don't need really good oper Bob Greenberg is a was a he's a creative operations person, but a brilliant operation person. And Tim Cook, amazing, incredible, right? it's the balance thing. So you've got to be able to you need people that make things work and you need people that know how to make people care. And typically they're not the same thing. If you have that balance, then I think you're set up pretty well. I'm not seeing the balance. In the same study, I think we looked at a bunch of large companies, a cross section of large companies, and found that there was there was less than 9% of people that you could call creative, and I'm using that term broadly, less than 9% on boards. Like on on a group of people that are are hopefully, you know, s helping steer these companies. and I understand why by the way, it's like there's a logic to when you have a big company That's complex, that you need people that can understand that complexity and make it run. I get it. So look, David Droga was the CEO of Accenture Song. And he is a creative thinker and a visionary. And he surrounded himself with great operations people. And so I would expect operational leaders to surround themselves with great creatives and and vision visionary people. But that is that seems to
Load full transcript
have been less and less the case. I use as an archetype of these two ways of thinking you know Walt Walt Disney and Roy Disney. Roy was a really important part of that. but Walt had visions that scared Roy. You know and
Gully Flowers: Wait, which was which? Which was Walt
Nick: It's
Gully Flowers: the Creative?
Nick: no, what yeah, Walt are creative and Roy was his brother who was who was more the business guy, and
Gully Flowers: Also creators probably Right, yeah, yeah.
Nick: and they were both important. But the the point is that you take one away and and you lose that balance and you use you you either lose the rigor or you lose the ambition. You need both. And so this report is basically saying on the eve of this technology that is gonna flatten a lot of the sort of operational stuff. and make getting things done in a big corporation a lot easier and more connected. we need to have creative thinkers, in leadership positions, not just creative people that are, nested layers below I start the study with with an introduction that says, you know, every company starts with an idea and it dies when it runs out of ideas. and to me that seems obvious, but somehow a big companies, more and more, not all of them, but more a a lot of them, have abstracted themselves away from the customer. They've become an internal facing operations, sort of financialized institutions, and they've forgot they really the only way to grow is to create customers. So if you don't have a theory of mind about your customer, if you don't have an empathy for your customer, if you don't know what your customer is gonna care about and find useful, then then at some point, yeah, things are gonna start shrinking.
jake: it's super interesting because, there are all these independent agencies popping up and, I think there's a cohort that really believes that they're doing something on the scale of what, you know, Bernbach and Ogilvy did back in the day in terms of creating the modern creative advertising company. On the flip side of that, like I don't feel feel like any of these companies are rooted in the tech that's going to change things. And I
Nick: Yeah.
jake: think, I think your conversation is, very much about category creation. do you see this cohort of people who are going to create the new category, is it gaining traction or are we still too early for that?
Nick: No, I think it's happening, but it's happening where it always happens, which is in this this unappreciated sort of production world. You know, I mean this is the irony. I'm saying production companies are going to be challenged. There's a type of emerging production company which is starting with AI as as as the sort of medium. There's a whole bunch of them. Some of them will die, some of them will will mature. You know, it's it's RGA was a production company at the beginning and then it added layers on top. it added a strategic layer to become an agency, added an innovation layer with the accelerator, It does seem that with new technologies, it's easier to build a company from the bottom up.
Gully Flowers: Mm.
Nick: Because because strategy is always informed by practice. Right? You can't have a strategy unless you have a you have facility with the technology in the context of new technology. And so this is why a lot of great companies do come up from the bottom. I think it's the same with the MediaMonks There's it was the same with Whalar, who, the great creator agency. They start in the weeds, understanding technology, figuring out the details of it, and they build a strategic layer on top. I think it's a lot harder to to build it down. because it's not about being smart. It's about It's about understanding the sort of texture of the medium and how to use it. So going back to your original question, I think that there are some pretty talented people that have started small agencies, but a lot of them seem to me to be just a better version of the old model and they're probably stealing share from a shrinking pie. So they can grow as the rest of the industry shrinks, but they're gonna it's gonna reach a a limit. and then back to the point of are they building as though they didn't know anything but the new technology. No, they're not. so look, I mean the other thing about the industry is I'm not even sure what the industry is sometimes. I I don't really care about the industry to be honest, because I can't put my arms around it. What I care about is creative people. getting good jobs and and earning good money and adding value. That's what I care about. and and when I look at the at the more traditional structures right now, it just it reminds me of the magazine industry in the twenty tens. a lot of talented people that they won't be able to afford their place in the Hamptons anymore. And so they'll probably leave and go somewhere else. And you know, some of them will do really great. A lot of them are going Brand-side. A lot of them are going to Silicon Valley. and there there you know, there's thousands of people that are being let go with these big these big old structures and they're trying to pivot and figure it out. Maybe they will, but I just I I just think it's more likely that something will grow out of the new technology as opposed to an old structure trying to figure out the new technology.
Gully Flowers: And you you you mentioned R/GA and Whalar and MediaMonks when I think about those examples, I don't want to say it was luck and I don't want to say it wasn't competitive, but those capabilities were in massive growth stages. And when I think about right
Nick: Yeah, that's right.
Gully Flowers: now, everybody's chasing the same pie.
Nick: Mm-hmm.
Gully Flowers: Right. So it's intensely competitive. Do you think that
Nick: Yeah.
Gully Flowers: works when everybody's going for the same brand dollars?
Nick: Yeah, I think I I'll give R/GA as an example. I remember, I started at R/GA in in 2001 and and so pretty soon after I joined and we were
sort of building this company, the bubble
Gully Flowers: Wait, was that that was after the bust?
Nick: No that yeah, that was just before and then the bust happened, right. Right. Yeah. I mean it started
Gully Flowers: J just before. Right.
Nick: it actually it's it was already starting to happen, but but it really happened after that. And and the but the point there is that There was a period where every company needed a website. There's this new thing, everyone can and so you it was like shooting fish in a barrel for a lot of these web these web agencies, right? Yeah, yeah. No, but the the point
Gully Flowers: Yeah, I remember. We all remember. Yeah. We all were there.
Nick: the point is that that what R/GA did at that time was dignify a medium that was like this weird hyperlink brochure, where people colored in wireframes and then shipped them to, to get HTML. RGA gave this medium a thought and a craft and a innovative energy that meant that once everyone had the website and the industry started to mature, we were the last ones standing along a lot of those. A lot of those early agencies didn't survive
Gully Flowers: Yeah.
Nick: because they they were growing by doing mediocre work just because of the demand. And I think that the smartest thing to do in the early period of these things is. is to start with excellence. And don't expect that, when the market becomes more mature that all of a sudden you'll become excellent if you weren't up until then. this is why great agencies and great creative companies are have such a singular vision, feel very cultish, because they believe in what they're doing and they put their heart into it. And it matters to great companies if they do good work or not. And I think yeah it's t it
Gully Flowers: Is excellence a by product of focus? making sure you're not going too wide?
Nick: It's it's it's focus and talent, that in some ways R/GA really had a broad focus because the internet was our medium and the internet kept eating things. So,
Gully Flowers: Yeah, right.
Nick: when e-commerce became a thing, then we had to figure out that. Social became a thing, we had figure out that. So we s we sort of we did accrete a breadth of a sort of a Bauhausan creative structure. But it was all connected. And this is a thing. When you take something on, the first thing is to is to recognize that strategically it's important to you and that it's going to integrate and you'll be able to do it. but you always do it badly at the beginning, and then you get to a place of competence. And the last step, this is what I found that R/GA and I think it's true for any company now, as you build out capabilities, the last step is to integrate it. Because wh when you take on something new and then you integrate it into the structures. it it inverts everything and changes the way you do things. our narrative practice completely changed once we integrated into this into the core teams because all of a sudden you had people that, you know, tell great stories thinking about how that lived in a medium where people had to interact with it, could share it, could, you know, could augment it. And it changes the way you think about storytelling. You know, it's not this this This one directional thing like TV became something else. And so we created a whole grammar around our narrative work at RGA that recognized that social was the acid test of whether a story was good or not. Not, you know, not not you know the amount of money you spent on TV placement. So so I think this is true now too. If you if you're a big company and you try to bring in a AA capability. You don't want to have it off to the side and incubated for forever. You it and this is one of the problems with the agencies, you know, we we were joking about they never figured out the internet. They never figured out the internet because they thought it was for the kids. You
Gully Flowers: Yeah.
Nick: know, and and even now the idea of having a t a s a social team separate from your brand creative team is absurd. Since the single most important suite of surfaces in media is social. it's a good example would be the creator economy where, 70% of the attention on the internet is creators and 5% of the media spend is. So there's this sort of delta between
Gully Flowers: Well.
Nick: where people are and and there's lots of reasons for that. we haven't been able to figure out how to make the some of the creator work programmatic and scale in the same way. So that it'll they'll figure it out, it'll mature and it'll become I don't think anyone's gonna stop that. But the act of taking on new capabilities, the act of designing yourself. It's not just putting a few slides at the back of your deck saying, look at this great AI stuff that we just did. It's understanding deeply how you need to redesign yourself to take advantage of the opportunities and the constraints of the new medium.
jake: Nick, I have a bit of a thesis maybe that I think where we're at with AI transformation that if you're starting a creative company, may not actually need a traditional creative director type leader for anything other than perceived impact. you could have a really smart media strategist that are really great creative technologists who can figure out a system to help scale assets. Cause that's mostly what people are buying at the moment. But the, the reason people would buy that is because Nick Law is the creative director of this new company or Iain Tate is the creative director
Nick: No, I don't I don't agree with that thesis. I was at a conference last week where a a psychologist got up and was talking about that we've had fifteen years of frontal cortex overload. Right. So it's sort of aligns with our online life and and us living you know, in the feed. And what she was claiming is that this has really changed the way we think as a species, right? And I think the obvious result of that is is this we've reached the physics of our attention. So this is
why when I hear
Gully Flowers: Hm.
Nick: people talk about, we've got to do personalization at scale and we're gonna create a content supply chain and be always on, it's like that's such bullsh*t. So we we've reached the the the limits of how much people can absorb. And so then you've got to ask the question. and by the way, that was when we had unlimited distribution. What happens when you add to that unlimited distribution infinite creation, which is what these tools create? Well, it's gonna be even more. We're gonna we're gonna it's gonna be more overloaded. And so then that asks the question so if our job is to get the attention of the people and make them care about stuff, how is that gonna work when we've switched off to this sort of this stream of stuff? And the obvious answer to that is is it's not quantity, it's quality. Right. And so where does the quality come from? Well, the quality comes from from your ability as a creative person to make good decisions. You see, i if you look at what it meant to be a great creative for most of my career, you had to have a facility with the tools. You had to be able to build the three hundred layer Photoshop file and know which filters to do and and and then, it create a a a after effects file and then and then add it to final cut or what there was always this this this this craft this this manual craft but but what would drive that manual craft was decisions that looks good that doesn't look good this is funny this isn't funny that composition is is is clear I know where to click now I'm you know whatever that whether it's design or storytelling or whatever it is it's a series of decisions good creatives make good decisions because they've got taste because they've got experience Because I understand something about the customer, they've got a theory of mind, and that hasn't changed. In fact, that becomes even more important. If I can create anything instantly, then then then then having a creative discernment and making good decisions and having that focus and understanding that you've got to enter that process with the constraint that can focus you, that discipline, it's discipline, apply creativity is discipline. So I think it's become more important. Now how you build a team, I think becomes very different. So if you if the sort of cognitive craft becomes the most important thing, then you've got to look at the types of ways people think. And this goes back to the sort of framework that I talk about in the paper, which is that this is a continuum of creative thinking between inventive and expressive. Right? And inventive thinking is spatial thinking. It's knowing how to make things work, and and expressive thinking is more narrative and it's knowing how to make people care. One is temporal, one is spatial, one is additive, one is subtractive. And then you've got in between those two ways, those two endpoints, a gradation. So, you know, it's a bell curve of people with that have a mix of those things. What's interesting about this, and this is something Simon Barron Kalman talks about, he's a an English scientist. Is that once you get to the edges of this bell curve, it becomes a bit of a zero-sum game. So if you're incredibly systematic, you may not have a good intuition about people. And if you're really good at understanding people, you're probably not going to be very technical. And we see this every day, right? Why that's important is because there's deep craft once you get to the edges of this bell curve. And so then the challenge becomes, if if if once you get to the edges, you're you're you've only got one part of this way of thinking, then then you have to build teams. Right. And so not only is the craft important, the cognitive craft, and it's also how do you start connecting these things in ways so that not just you're not making stuff that people don't care about and you're not you're not coming up with ideas that can't be delivered because you don't understand the technology. So you have to blend teams. It's a little bit analogous to the early RGA model of stories and systems. Now the difference is we've now got these other partners called agents who are informed. Yeah, no, so there's a collaboration. There's a collaboration that you
Gully Flowers: Partners. Partners. Yeah. Jesus. Yeah.
Nick: that you have, and you we've all experienced this already. you know, it's a it's a collaboration which is not as dimensional and not as challenging as true creative partners partnerships, but it's productive. Right. And so then you've got to start thinking about when do humans need to meet? When do you go deep with using an agent? And there's all sorts of Things to think about. But the reason I'm saying this is because these because the how is solved, it's gonna be more and more solved, the how. Then the why, which is your ambition, your human ambition, and and the way you can imagine what the future could look like, and the what, which is what's the artifact, what's the experience at the end. This is something people are gonna care about. Those bookends of of of of the why and the what become even more important because you've solved the middle. So I do think that there's this idea right now, and this this was true at the beginning of the internet too, which is generalists are really good. We want Swiss army knives, right? That was true. I remember this, at the beginning of the internet. You wanted a a designer that could write HTML, that could do a little bit of writing, could do all these things, and that was silly. And the only reason that you had these journalists is because the tribe of people that had that that that had enough knowledge about the medium was so small that you asked for generalists. I think this I think we're going we're I hear a lot of people talking about the same thing now. I think it's bullshit. I think what you have is this generalized technology that connects everything, but you want to have deep
disciplines sitting on top of that and collaborating horizontally, going deep, vertically and then collaborating. And you probably need a few connectors that can see the whole thing in their head that can sort of help coordinate. But a lot of the coordination is going to be done by the these models. So I think that deep creative expertise is more important than ever. And it's not it's it's it's conceptual but it's also stylistic. Again, making decisions about what what looks good, what what doesn't look good, what means something, what's funny. I think it becomes hugely important that you have creative people involved. More important than ever.
Gully Flowers: And one thing I know AI is not good at is challenging the status quo. And, you know, in your research you found nearly sixty percent of people think that challenging the status quo makes you difficult. As an Australian, I find that like we're a
Nick: Yeah.
Gully Flowers: bit more open to doing that. but I feel like that's almost like the most important job, particularly in a large enterprise. It's like tr you know, you
Nick: Yeah.
Gully Flowers: mentioned innovation, but I is that really the the key skill for a creative person?
Nick: Well, you don't want to be unbearable. But but I have to say that some Yeah, no,
Gully Flowers: What's the bell curve? Yeah.
jake: Hahaha
Nick: I do think that I think corporate culture has become less has b ha has become very invested in making good corporate citizens. It's just like bureaucracies mint bureaucrats. and th there is it's definitely true that big companies don't really want to deal with difficult people. it seems unlikely that that that a young Steve Jobs would be able to get a job at lot of companies, right?
Gully Flowers: That's right.
Nick: Now I'm not sa I I think that difficult people are okay. Disrespectful people I don't have time for. Right. But I've worked with b I've worked with people that I've sort of had to protect from from from the sort of from the corporate world. They they because they didn't Well, no, and also just like
Gully Flowers: From Ajah. No.
Nick: the the the administration tax that comes with a big company. You know, like filling out times all this stuff that you it's all important. But
Gully Flowers: Right.
Nick: But there's trade-offs. I there was a a brilliant designer that I work with at at R/GA who would who would quit every Friday and come back every Monday. It was a pain in the ass. You know, and I would never be able to put him in front of a client. Yeah, so
Gully Flowers: dramatically? on the email or something like
Nick: dramatic. Yeah. But but this but this person was so good that you could, you know, send him to an office to work with a local team. He would crack something in a week and make it perfect. in a way that a big team couldn't do in months. So so it's a trade-off. You figured it out how to work with it. And and I do think that but the the the thing about these models is that they are what they're really good at, and this is why a lot of people in the valley think that all jobs are gonna die, is because their jobs are are particularly vulnerable to these models. Because these models are really good at at solving complex but logical problems. Logical problems that can be jer that can be you know that can be can be shown to be true. Like so they're verifiable. And and that and that's that's a skill of of of great engineers and coders it is yeah like you've got a
Gully Flowers: Systemic thinkers? Is this the yeah, yeah.
Nick: you've got to hold a lot of things in your h in your head at the same time. You've got to be able to hold complexity in your head. And that's a that's a that's a more systematic inventive way of thinking. but but the more narrative or the more empathetic stuff, it's it's it's it's simple and intuitive. It's not complex and logical, it's a simple and intuitive. And it's intuitive because you have to have a theory of mind about the person who's gonna receive it. Like that sort of creativity is is a is a communal act. It doesn't exist without someone receiving it and understanding it. And it's why, by the way, that the the mo the most difficult mathematical problems that have ever been thought of are now being solved. But but but these models still can't tell a good joke. Right? They and it's because humor is a really great example of something. It's really sensitive to context, time, place, whatever's going on the world, and the person you're telling the joke to. You've got to know how to trip them up in their head at the right time. And so it's about timing, it's about culture, it's about If you listen if you look at humour from even twenty years ago, it's not funny. It's like Shakespeare's comedies are not funny. They were funny back then, just as things that we think are funny right now aren't gonna be funny in 20 years. So it's so culturally specific and so human specific. It's why, you know, it's why you're gonna always need this stuff that you know that Jake and I were talking about, which is someone sitting on top of these models that has a sort of perverse humanity. that it's really difficult for these models to simulate.
Gully Flowers: Perverse humanity, I love that.
jake: Nick, if you're, if you're one of these, new creative companies, you know, 28 year old you, and you're trying to get the attention of the board CEO or even the CMO, what excites you or what do you think is gonna just create that hockey stick growth?
Nick: I think a lot of this is gonna happen in the brands. Right. And it's and and only because the agency commercial model is challenged, you know, we talked about it last time, the fact that you know, they went all in on media and media seems to be the thing that would get flattened most 'cause it's a system, right? And these models would be able to solve a lot of this. And I also hear from a lot of clients that They're exhausted with dealing with the black box that is principal media. so they're
already starting to try to bring some control. And it's hard because the scale is hard for them to replicate internally. but they're already thinking ahead about having more control over this stuff. Control of the data, control of the of the distribution, all that sort of stuff. And and the and the reason I think they're bringing creative people in-house is because of what I was saying before. The commercial model, especially for creative agencies, is such That they just can't earn the money in the agencies that they can elsewhere. This started happening with the with the tech companies earlier, but it's gonna happen more and more with brands. Now, what's interesting is that not every brand will find it easy to create a corporate function that is creative because it's different. Right? You need a different incentive structure, you need a different culture, you need different processes, you need to work with the tools differently, you need different talent, you need different leadership. So it's gonna be I think there's gonna be a lot of brands that just have to commit to doing it and it's gonna take some time for some of them to get it right. And it'll be a hybrid model. Some of them will bring creative teams in-house, others will bring creative leaders that can interact with a network of, really interesting new companies. So I think there's gonna be a different ways of doing it. but I'm that that's one thing I think is gonna ha is gonna be accelerated.
Gully Flowers: The in housing, right?
jake: Yeah.
Nick: in in housing, yeah, and different types of in housing and this is very different to the internet because the internet was a networking technology. This is a this is a deep computing technology that's gonna affect everything. And so, you know, there were some companies that you know They thought about the internet was either as a as something that could help them distribute information but it didn't didn't change their internal operations. This is gonna change everything. So if companies are having to change everything, then part of that is figuring out how marketing and how creative services fit into all of that. If you're gonna do if you're gonna make a huge change and you're gonna have to go through this transformation. You're gonna have to connect everything and think about everything. So I think that's why I think it's more likely big brands will will make the effort to bring their stuff in house because they're changing so much already, they may as well change it all.
Gully Flowers: But the pendulum already swung, right, towards in housing and I feel like it's swinging back or maybe it's just evolving because when you guys were in sauntering around Cannes, I was in Huntington Beach at the ANA in house event. And
Nick: Yeah.
Gully Flowers: it couldn't have been more different, and I think generally
Nick: Yeah.
Gully Flowers: what we we've seen is a big in-house build out, right? And then they figured out maybe our corporate culture doesn't know, mix play nicely with like a more vibrant creative culture. And so is the answer a a a smaller layer of people who have you know, an understanding of how that world operates,
Nick: Yeah, I yes, but but I think that the difference between in housing ten years ago and now is that is is that the quality and the vibrancy and the talent in agencies was a lot higher.
Gully Flowers: Mm.
Nick: Right? look I you know, I mentioned magazines. I was
Gully Flowers: Business was healthier.
Nick: I'll mention magazines as an example. when I was at Apple there were a handful of people that came from Condé Nast, New York Times, all these different and they're really talented, incredibly talented people. And they're making more per vesting than they would in their whole career back in the so people will move, creative people will move to where they're where where they can get compensated and where they have can have impact. So I think until that transition has settled itself out, some of these AI native startups have scaled. it's you I don't think it's a given that you'd be able to get what you want out of agencies on the client side. Now there are obviously exceptions, right? There there are there are some great there are just less of them, I think. And it's just and and and you know, we need to I think there some exceptions could be in the sort of creator world. and th and there are some interesting, you know There interesting companies that are are doing things with these video models and these image models, which are I think gonna change everything. Yeah. Th I think one of you mentioned that there's a the sort of cultural uncom discomfort with with AI generated images. I think that's gonna go away very quickly. I I
jake: same.
Nick: I you know, and I and I in the beginning of photography. I think photographs were considered somehow more artificial than paintings, that paintings had more depth and and and photographs were these sterile weird things. and I think that
Gully Flowers: That's why all the old f old photos, no one's smiling. I was like, What are you doing?
Nick: Well, it just felt it just felt like a technical achievement, not a creative achievement.
Gully Flowers: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Nick: and I think that we will look we we we won't even ask whether an image is real or not. Maybe there'll be a curiosity if it is real or if it's captured. Might be it might be so but but generally w it's it's just like painting with your mind now. Right? It's because you can do anything. So it's painting and and painting is dignified expression. It you know, from a creative perspective. You I'm not talking about journalistic integrity. I'm talking about creative integrity. And I j I'm already seeing amazing stuff done with these models. That that stuff that couldn't have been done six months ago. So there will be it's it's the version of the production company. It it's just that the that the production won't be separate from the creative thinking and
the ideas. They'll be all collapse into one thing. And there's gonna be a lot of groups that can do that. individuals that can do that, creators that can do that. and that network of of you know of companies could be the new outsourcing. But you can still gonna this is the thing, you're still gonna need people internally that have a creative sensibility. Because they're in the end they're gonna be buying things and saying yes or no to things. And if they don't understand or have a a sort of a more expressive sensibility or more inventive sensibility, then you're not going to get good work. the in the in the study I talk about these these these three layers, right? Commitment, which is a sort of culture and incentives, the structure, which is like the model and the processes, and then talent, right, which is leadership and teams. Right. So and the thing about these three things of commitment, structure, and expertise, is only one if one of those things is off, everything collapses. So If you don't have the culture, if you don't have this commitment, it doesn't matter how good your processes are, it doesn't matter how good your talent is, if you figured out the the the the commitment piece, and you've got really great people, if you don't have the right processes and structures, it doesn't matter. Jony Ive was at Apple before Steve came back and they were making beige boxes that crashed. I remember I was using them. They were shitty computers. And then Steve came back, put a culture on top that really cared about creative, reorganized the the the the design disciplines, bought in great people and the the iMac came out. So, and and now Jony's like the a Knighted designer. So you've got to get all of these things right. Because one link breaks and the whole thing collapses. Your ideas, Jony would say this, ideas are fragile. And so you've got to get these things right. So it's not like it's not just, let's get some talented people in. And it's not just, let's just let's let's get the right technology. It's you gotta get it all and and it's gotta work together and it's not easy. And if you can get it right, then you'll separate yourself because it's not easy. the best companies separate themselves from any ev everyone else because they do the hard things. Barry Waxman and I used to go to Canada every year and talk about R/GA's model. We would talk about how we're organized, what how we think an idea is, would show the work. Why weren't there more R/GAs? Because it was hard. It was really hard. It was hard to get people that are introverts who think about technology, working with people that are extroverts that love telling stories. It's hard. And we had to put it in the structure, in the process. It couldn't be left up to good intentions. It had to be part of the structure and the way we worked and the incentives. and this is what companies are gonna have to do, and that's why very few are gonna survive.
Gully Flowers: Can you talk about finance and creative people getting along? Because I think I I see kind of finance fu*king up creative companies as sort of like the life cycle of our industry, maybe. I w I was
Nick: Yeah.
Gully Flowers: at Firstborn when they were bought by Dentsu, so I saw that one firsthand. I mean, you were at R/GA for 17 years, including the IPG you know, acquisition,
Nick: Yeah.
Gully Flowers: I guess, and then they've just gone independent, but with PE. Like what what is
Nick: Yeah.
Gully Flowers: your take on creative people being able to do great work whilst, clearly under some sort of financial structure, maybe pressure to perform.
Nick: Well I think I think it's not a money versus creative argument. It's a timescale argument. Right? It's like because I believe that great creative companies make good money. You know, I I d I always joke about Bob Greenberg, you know, who's obviously my dear friend that he was that he was just as greedy as he was vain. Right? And and so we made money and we did good work. Right. Th Apple does that. There are companies that do that, right?
Gully Flowers: Yeah.
Nick: And and so I think there's a logic to if you do great powerful stuff as a credit person, especially now, as we've said, it'll make you money. The question is how much time does it take to get that? And it's like the brand versus performance argument. Yeah. It's a timescale issue.
Gully Flowers: Yeah. It's the time scale. Yeah.
Nick: So I and I think it's completely irresponsible for creative people not to care about the business. I think in the same way I think it's irresponsible for finance or operators not to care about the product. They need to care about the product. but this is one of the things that happened in the in the holding companies. Product people disappeared from leadership. And so they started to make these sort of abstract financial decisions because they didn't understand the product. but you also, you know, the only reason we're doing this, if we wanted to be fine artists and you know live in Cessnock in a in in a you know and
Gully Flowers: That's a good re you might need to fill that one in for the global audience here.
Nick: Yeah, like yeah, but if you want to live in a low cost regional center,
Gully Flowers: Yeah.
Nick: and and you know, and do s and do some sculpture, that's fine, that's cool. Ex express
Gully Flowers: Enjoy the fresh air. Yeah.
Nick: yourself. Yeah, but we're we are in applied creativity. We're applying it because it it it grows the economy, it it and it makes life interesting and and great for people and they want to pay for it. And so I think I don't I just don't believe Look, I don't think David Droga would say he's not interested in growing business, but he's a creative person. He's a deeply creative person. He cares about the quality of the stuff that he does. And he assumes that the quality of stuff that he does, if there's a market for it, will make money. So I just you know, I don't think so that's why, you know, like I
you know, R/GA un you know, being owned by a P E company is fine if they if they if if they're patient and trust R/GA to be able to grow. you know, look here's the thing. if if finance is running a company and is completely insensitive to the quality of the product and therefore to what they're giving customers, at some point it's gonna die.
Gully Flowers: Yeah.
Nick: So it'll it'll sort itself out.
Gully Flowers: Now, how do you avoid replicating those agency client dynamics, the sort of toxic negative ones, when you have an in house shop? 'Cause I've seen a lot of times they'll just build a separate
Nick: Yeah, yeah.
Gully Flowers: in house team and then it becomes a the same dynamic
Nick: That's it. Yeah.
Gully Flowers: of like, the client, you know?
Nick: Well, this is why yeah, you're absolutely right. This is why I think those layers that I referred to, the pillars, are so important.
Gully Flowers: Mm-hmm.
Nick: And the commitment one is the one at the top, because if you're gonna build these things you've got to believe that it's worthwhile and that it's gonna be valuable. And you've gotta understand that that person that you think is really irresponsible because they because they don't fill out their timesheets or because they can't, you know, f figure out an earnings report. in the same way that you can. It doesn't mean that the ten thousand hours that they spend getting good at what they do is invaluable. Right? It doesn't mean that that that that Walt Disney or Jony Ive or these people that are that have a creative sensibility aren't contributing. it's a balance thing. now, there are other ways you could do so structurally where you have the creative organization connected but protected, that somehow they have a parallel process that that encourages the right things, the right out the right outcomes. and people are sensitive to that and they don't need to understand it as long as they're delivering. So there are ways to do it, right? I Xbox was always a different culture to Microsoft, even though they're part of the same company. I mean Song is a really important part of Accenture. But there's some things we do differently, even though we're pretty integrated, we we do some things differently because we've got different people doing different things. But it it has to come from the top. If if you don't have that commitment at the top, then it's really difficult to build that and you start getting the dynamics you're talking about, Gully right? Which is that's exactly right. There and
Gully Flowers: And you that's why you need C suite creatives. Yeah.
Nick: there's two reasons for that. One is that the pe the leaders then understand how these people work and what they create and why it's valuable. But also, and this is really important at R/GA, that you need to model the behavior that you expect in the teams at the leadership. so the reason that that every team of 150 at RGA had a stories and systems creative pair running, working together, running the whole team, was because that's what our teams were composed of. And if we just had a bunch of copywriters at the top, then the experience designers were like, hang on a sec, they're telling me what to do, they don't understand what I what I do. And the same might be true at a company that's run by engineers. It's like if I'm a great storyteller and at some point I think in the layers above me, it it's what I do is just gonna yeah,
Gully Flowers: It's no appreciation, right?
Nick: this yeah, this so so that's why leadership needs to to model the ambition of the company and the ambition of the company isn't just to make money without understanding what we're selling to customers. Right? And so it's I'm not I'm not arguing that companies should just be run by creative people. What I'm saying is that you need a balance between
Gully Flowers: Yeah.
Nick: the systematic sensibility and this more expressive sensibility.
jake: I think in your report you talk about the talent problem is really coalesced around ambition, authority and opportunity within organizations. and if you think that innovation is going to come from brand in-house teams, are there prototypes right now of that, that you're. particularly interested in?
Nick: look, every company is doing a version of this. I I don't I can't go inside every big company and see what's going on. I do know that some of the models, right? So some Accenture is exposed to all of this because we work with these frontier companies and we see what they're doing and we we we we in some cases inform what they're doing, in some cases borrow from what they're doing. But I would say that from structurally I think it's really important, first of all, to If everyone you you need deep expertise but you also need a a diversity of expertise. What you don't need is to take take one type of thinking and then step and repeat that to build out to build out a a a capability. What you need is less people, right? They have that a particular cognitive craft and then you need to empower those people with these new tools because when you have I don't know if you've used any of these these these these agents that have been, the the dots, the muses, the the instincts, all of these they're they're incredible.
jake: I have two of them running while we talk.
Nick: Yeah, no, but but but the thing is in a in an enterprise environment, it means that it really does expand your role. It expands your influence and your scale. So then the important thing is less how do you create homogeneous teams to s to solve for a particular task. And more about how do you create a variety of experts that are connected and then and then you know empowered and and and scaled with with these with these with this sort of agentic world. And so then you have to start thinking about okay, if if what we're looking for are these sort of this cognitive craft, these specific cognitive crafts, and creatively I'll I've already talked about the sort
of continuum that I'm thinking about, but then how do you map that against an organization? And you know, I've seen, for example, in some of these frontier companies, that they think about they organize by craft and then they organize by context, and then they've got a smaller team That's experimenting because the future comes so quickly that if you don't have these cross-disciplined teams that are separate, and maybe just five percent of the if they're not always iterating and f and then you're gonna get left behind. So you've got you know cognitive crafts, how you bring those cognitive crafts together is right the context, right? So these these are these are related but connected teams. And then And then a a an experimental future forward team that that is continuing to iterate and learn things. Because the the thing is that there is a a lot of companies are are are encouraging their people to innovate, but you've got to organize it and give it a pointiness and get the right people involved. So there is a natural exploration that everyone is going through right now, but you've got to organize at some point around around delivery. around, getting things done for your for your clients or for your or for or for your audience in parallel to to experimenting. So there's different structures, but I think that those three ways of thinking about how you might put an agency together now make sense to me.
Gully Flowers: Have you changed your
Nick: Yeah, no worries.
Gully Flowers: mind about anything since we last talked the last twelve months? Try to think back.
Nick: Yeah. Yeah, I think I'm I've become more sure, right, that
Gully Flowers: I don't think that qualifies.
Nick: in be no, no,
jake: Hahaha
Nick: no, because because I do think that there was things have have become clearer. They've become clearer, I think. You know,
Gully Flowers: Okay. Yeah. Yeah.
Nick: and I think, you know, like i what I I'm sure about I'm sure the talent's really important. I'm sure that talent, which is a combination of aptitude, training, experience, all of those things become important. And I think that we need to we're at a point where this new world has been built by technologists and they are amazing tools and have all this potential. And we need to stop obsessing about about the about the different types of technology and start obsessing about the different types of people. That we're going to need to use the technology. Because I've noticed there is this in big companies there's this sort of idea that, well, we just put some people on this without really thinking about who are we putting on what and what are they doing. So this sort of nuance and specificity around the wetware of humans needs to be at the level that we're giving to the hardware and the software. We've really got to think about. How they how are we organizing people? Who do we need? How are they working together? And and also be honest about the ability of these, like don't be threatened by this technology. By every measure, it is creative. By every measure, this technology can be creative, autonomous of humans. But it's downstream from human activity because all the data is collected from humans. And and it at some point it's going to be experienced by a human. And so it's fine. Let's use the technology to be creative, but also steer it and understand that it's got a map against what you know what what we imagine the future to be and what what's gonna please us and get us excited in the moment. So, you know, I'm I'm more sure that if we're if we're not idiots That it's gonna be a great time for creatives.
jake: the incentive thing is interesting to me just because I think in part of that you explain the creative SWAT teams that have always existed inside of larger organizations that sort of go Cannes Lion hunting where it's like, here's our 10 people that are going to come up with ideas that are going to make the thing that helps make the agency famous. And
Nick: Yeah.
jake: I'm just interested how that gets. integrated into a like brand side team where like that's the issue with brands is everyone goes there says I never cared about the stock price before now I do and it's like that idea of just being famous and vain to a degree where it's just like we want the company to be known as ambitious and we're going to put out this crazy awesome story to do it and not care like I don't see that very often. I guess maybe
Nick: Yeah.
jake: Coinbase is the only one or David Lee with some audacious Super Bowl spots,
Nick: So I look I think there's a difference between having a SWAT team that's trying to get awards and an incubation of something you think is important that you always intend to integrate. Right. This is a really important this is what I was talking about. When you bring something in new, you bring it in because it's important and because it's a part of what you want to do. Right. And so th this is always the case. When we did something new at RGA, when we started to do social, when we started to do commerce, when we started we would incubate it so we got it right and so you can see it in clear sight, you can get the right people and you can go through that generation of not doing it well and then a generation of doing it competent. And then when you get a competent, you pull it in and you connect it to everything. So the reason to have a separate team isn't to do something separate from the business. You know, RGA never had a lab. A lot of companies had labs. We didn't have labs because we're like if we're not innovating for our clients. It's not gonna happen. None of these labs lead lead to anything in in the in the agencies. They they all close down without really creating anything that had commercial value for the clients. We innovated for our clients, not for ourselves, for our clients. Right? And so when you have a a team that's separate and working on something, it's because that's the best way to grow it before you integrate
it into the main thing. So to me, I I I don't and I you know, I think that The people that can don't want work that was created just for Cannes. The people that can want work that they can celebrate because it's growing businesses. That's their whole thing. That's why Cannes is a valuable place for clients to come. And so I think the days of having a a team working on awards is just gone. If if it isn't, then then then your company's fucked. th actually I thought of the I thought of an answer for the the what have I thought, what what have I changed my mind?
Gully Flowers: well, you changed your mind on.
Nick: Change your mind. Yeah, so I I went down this rabbit hole because this hardly anyone in history can do that inventive and expressive thing. It's like it's almost impossible to do both because they're such different ways of thinking. You could argue that the one historic figure that has been inventively creative and expressively creative is Leonardo da Vinci, right? Evidence would suggest that he could do both. He had gr he had a great engineering mind, all of these crazy inventions, these war machines and his supplying machines. And then he painted like and sculpted. He was amazing, right? Now what's interesting about Leonardo da Vinci is that we remember him because of his expression, not not not not for his inventions, right? Because his inventions were a step, and this is the thing about inventions, a step that's since been surpassed. His paintings haven't been surpassed because they're so singular and so human. This is the thing about expression. It's not like you innovate an expression so that it gets better and better. It just becomes different sort of techniques and everything, but it doesn't get better. Invention gets better. And so we remember Leonardo because of his painting, but he made all of his money inventing. All of his money. He didn't make any money. This is why half of his paintings were unfinished. Because he was being, Da Vinci's and and heads of state were paying him money to to create these engineering miracles for their military or for their for their towns and everything. So to me that's a really interesting thing because when you look at the world now, the people that are making money are engineers, not artists. Sam Altman's gonna make a lot more money than Rick Rubin this year. Right? They're both brilliant. Now, what I've changed my mind about is that this historic relationship between making things work, making lots of money, and making people care, a bit interesting culturally, but add adding texture, but you know, not scaling to the same thing. I think that's gonna change. I've just I I think that actually expression is gonna become so important because of because of the the paucity of attention and because we're so overwhelmed that we just I think that we're gonna see some very wealthy artists in the future and not just wealthy engineers. That's the thing I change my mind about.
Gully Flowers: What a place to end. I love that.
Nick: Ha ha ha.
Gully Flowers: Well, Nick, you returned. You conquered.
Nick: It's yeah, it was fun. Always, always fun with you guys.
jake: Appreciate it, Nick. Thank you so much.
Nick: No. Yeah, you too. Cheers.