TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: It was an upset for the ages, another upset in the past weekend, as Wales have beaten the All Blacks for the first time since 1953. The 35-28 victory reflected utter determination from the Welsh, particularly in defence. To take a look at what went wrong, Geoff McTish, Sky Rugby commentator, joins me now. Thank you for joining me this morning. What did go wrong? What a loss.
00:00:25
Speaker 2: Good morning, Katie. Yeah, it's the question, what went wrong for the All Blacks? As you highlighted there in the intro, Wales were just superb defensively. It was a masterclass from them. And as you say, 1953, Queen Elizabeth, the coronation of Queen Elizabeth II, Sir Ed climbed Everest. So it's been a long time for the Welsh getting one over the All Blacks, 73 years. But I think changes for the All Blacks was probably a big factor. They had 10 changes from that team that played Scotland in the first match of the tour. So it they really lost you know those key guys those key game drivers that they had there the week prior Cam Royguard, Damien McKenzie, Geordie Barrett of course they're without Artie Savia you're throwing a goal like Cody Taylor that would make a big difference too and of course someone like Will Jordan so they're without a number of their senior leaders as I say key game drivers as well so I think that had an impact but you can't take anything away from the Welsh look they were I think they made 179 tackles in the final 20 minutes where the All Blacks occupied about 70% possession and 90% territory. So for them to perform in the way they did was just simply sensational in Cardiff.
00:01:29
Speaker 1: Was that a bit of arrogance on our part that I guess that you thought we could make those changes that we were going to win anyway no matter what?
00:01:37
Speaker 2: I think it's a bit of six of one, half a dozen of the other. I think they had to try something. They know that they've got a World Cup next year. They've got a number of guys that haven't played a great deal of test rugby coming back from Eritrea, South Africa. So there are guys probably a little bit short on game time. Richie Wong are probably one of them. Did he have a great game? No, he didn't by his standards. So they had to look at players and they obviously felt that the Welsh was the time to do that. They obviously had some other ideas. So, look, it's easy to say in hindsight that it was the wrong thing to do. But I think all things considered, they had to make some changes. But clearly there'll be some more for England next week.
00:02:12
Speaker 1: Who does it reflect on, on the Welsh for playing well or the All Blacks for playing badly?
00:02:18
Speaker 2: Well, as I said, I'm not sure it's a case of, you know, that. that all-black team isn't one and the same, as I say. There were 10 changes, so you put that team who played against Scotland back on the park, and I think it is potentially quite a different result. So, again, you can't take the flowers away from Wales. They were excellent, and they would have tested a lot of teams yesterday in Cardiff. So I think it's a little bit of both. Wales were, again, they played out of their skins defensively, so they certainly deserved their win.
00:02:48
Speaker 1: What does it say about Dave Rennie's coaching? Is this a blot on his copy book or just one of those things?
00:02:56
Speaker 2: Well, 64% for Dave Rennie in the coaching regime at the moment. That was their fourth loss of the year. Look, by no means England, they're going to be a tough prospect next week. We lost to the English last year at Twickenham. So certainly if we want to be in that kind of final picture come the final weekend of the Nations Championship, they need a resounding win, they need a performance against England. What does it say about it? I think they're building. No one likes to see the All Blacks lose a test, but as I say, they have to try a few things, they have to give guys game time, because ultimately it leads to the World Cup next year, which we all want to see the All Blacks win.
00:03:30
Speaker 1: And it was a bad weekend all round for the southern hemisphere, with only Argentina winning over Italy. What does that say about what we've got coming up? What's going on? Yeah, exactly.
00:03:41
Speaker 2: Like they played very, very well, the Northern Hemisphere teams. And I think, Katie, like what it says about this Nations Championship, I think when we all saw this come out, that this was going to be a thing that we thought, oh, this is a novel idea. What's it going to be like a year from a World Cup? Is it going to be, are we going to have too much of a good thing? But I think given the way that things have shaped up, and as you say, the Northern Hemisphere teams getting one over the Southern Hemisphere, Heading into the final round next week, it's all on. So, look, we need to beat England. We need to hope maybe that Ireland beat South Africa as well. And if that's the case, maybe we finish top of the Southern standings. We can go into that final on the final weekend. So it all shapes up nicely.
00:04:19
Speaker 1: Are you willing to take a punt on the game against England? Are we going to win and in what score?
00:04:24
Speaker 2: Oh, there you go. Look, I think the All Blacks do respond. They've got very high standards. They'll be hurting after the loss. So I think they do come back and win. But I think it's probably a little bit narrower than we might have thought, perhaps, if we had a good win over Wales. So I think maybe the All Blacks by 12 and under.
00:04:45
Speaker 1: All right, we'll see how we go. We'll hold you to that. Thank you for your time, Jeff McTish, Sky Rugby commentator.