TRANSCRIPT 🔗
1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:25,280
Hello, hello, hello, and welcome back to Bitcoin News Weekly Live. We are here with a great panel of guests to discuss some of the biggest news we've heard in a while.
2
00:00:25,280 --> 00:00:31,160
Jamie Dimon bending the knee, an arch nemesis of Bitcoin. His bank just came around and said,
3
00:00:31,280 --> 00:00:36,620
hey, this might be the best performing asset of the next decade. So let's dive right into it.
4
00:00:37,200 --> 00:00:44,620
Jamie Dimon has called Bitcoin a fraud for 10 years, since 2017 plus. I mean, he said he'd fire
5
00:00:44,620 --> 00:00:50,820
any trader caught touching it. Well, this week, his own bank told clients Bitcoin will beat the stock
6
00:00:50,820 --> 00:00:57,060
market for the next decade. For the first time in 31 years of publishing its long-term forecast,
7
00:00:57,280 --> 00:01:06,460
JP Morgan included Bitcoin with a base case of 10% a year versus 7.5% for U.S. stocks and 5.5%
8
00:01:06,460 --> 00:01:14,400
for gold. On the same day yesterday, BlackRock's Bitcoin ETF took in $665 million, its biggest day
9
00:01:14,400 --> 00:01:19,440
in over a year. And the price didn't even move that much, but now we're starting to see the pump.
10
00:01:19,440 --> 00:01:48,100
And then BlackRock filed for a brand new Bitcoin fund. So, I mean, what is going on here? Is Wall Street preparing for a bull run it can see coming? Or is it just selling us the asset it has already packaged up and wants to make fees off of? Today, I am joined by Phil Rosen, Brian Kubelis, and Andrei Dragos. We're here to get the answers from the experts themselves. Gentlemen, welcome up on stage. We got Brian and we got Phil. Guys, how you doing?
11
00:01:48,100 --> 00:02:11,720
Hey, good morning. Morning. Doing well, Rob. Good to see you, brother. Yes. Happy to have you both on here. We get a little Tradify look into Bitcoin because we're talking about, of course, JPMorgan, Jamie Dimon with this latest report. Let's just bring up the report, show people what it looks like, the 2027 long-term capital market assumptions.
12
00:02:11,720 --> 00:02:29,540
All right. So let's first hand it over to Phil. Phil, you write a newsletter every single day for both retail and institutional investors. How important is this? What is the long-term capital market assumptions report and the fact that Bitcoin is in there? What does it mean?
13
00:02:29,540 --> 00:02:57,520
Look, JPMorgan does great research. They're consistently setting market trends, patterns, and everyone watches what they publish and how they talk about it. As far as Bitcoin is concerned, Bitcoin has been an asset that retail has been in for a lot longer than institutions. The second institutions came in, suddenly it became kosher to talk about in the media, on the news, right here on this channel, right?
14
00:02:57,520 --> 00:03:07,960
All these things came in because institutions are talking about them more and suddenly it became a quote real asset, even though a lot of early Bitcoiners and retail have known this for over 10 years now.
15
00:03:08,580 --> 00:03:12,560
JP Morgan is suddenly giving out a pretty bullish call on Bitcoin.
16
00:03:12,560 --> 00:03:17,640
And I would tend to agree that Bitcoin will outperform over the next decade against the stock market.
17
00:03:17,940 --> 00:03:20,460
I think that's a pretty vanilla call, frankly.
18
00:03:20,860 --> 00:03:26,780
But the fact that you have this behemoth of Wall Street coming out and saying that is pretty interesting.
19
00:03:26,780 --> 00:03:48,760
Another thing that is interesting to me is that they are not recommending Bitcoin for their own client portfolios, as far as I can tell. They say, look, there's this asset that's going to outperform, and that's super awesome, but we will not be putting that in our own portfolios here. And part of that's the volatility. They don't know if their investors can stomach it.
20
00:03:48,760 --> 00:04:04,300
All these things, to me, as someone who understands the concept of higher risk, higher reward, I don't know if JP Morgan can get around that concept, frankly, but I think Bitcoin is a no-brainer in a modern portfolio
21
00:04:04,300 --> 00:04:17,540
There you have it, yes, I mean, Bitcoin has been doing the same thing for, what, 18 years now, almost, just new blocks every 10 minutes, and now finally it has legitimacy to be included in these papers like this
22
00:04:17,540 --> 00:04:20,340
Brian, what's your take on J.P. Morgan, including Bitcoin?
23
00:04:21,000 --> 00:04:23,940
Yeah, no, I mean, there's so much here to unpack.
24
00:04:24,160 --> 00:04:27,460
I think, you know, my mind goes in a bunch of different directions.
25
00:04:27,880 --> 00:04:36,800
Coming from a TradFi background, these sorts of long-term capital assumptions, lots of different institutions put out reports like this.
26
00:04:37,420 --> 00:04:42,120
So the first thing that comes to mind is just the reality that this is the first time Bitcoin is even included.
27
00:04:42,120 --> 00:04:46,340
Like put aside the numbers and the estimates and it being above all these other assets.
28
00:04:46,340 --> 00:05:18,277
Just the fact that it being included I think is significant in itself It really is a strong signal that this thing is here to stay People can ignore it anymore even though Jamie Dimon is famously quoted as calling it a fraud a Ponzi scheme His firm is now rightly including it in something like this that assesses what different asset classes are expected to do over the coming 10 years Beyond that though the numbers are super interesting to dig into because you know you said it bullish Phil
29
00:05:18,437 --> 00:05:23,977
Like, you know, I would argue it's kind of bearish, like 10 percent over the next decade. Like, I expect it to be a lot higher than that.
30
00:05:24,537 --> 00:05:30,797
If you go back 10 years, obviously, you know, that feels like cherry picking past performance, not indicative of
Load full transcript
future results.
31
00:05:30,797 --> 00:05:36,357
But, you know, it's more like 40 to 60 percent over the past decade in terms of Bitcoin's annual CAGR.
32
00:05:37,077 --> 00:05:45,037
And it's exceeded 10 percent over if you take like any 10 year window going back, it's exceeded 10 percent all the time.
33
00:05:45,257 --> 00:05:50,277
And then if you shorten that to a five year window, there are some five year windows where it hasn't exceeded 10.
34
00:05:50,577 --> 00:05:54,117
Most recently sort of from the 2017 top and then the 2021 top.
35
00:05:54,117 --> 00:06:02,257
But still, every five-year window over its entire history, it's like 94%, I believe, it's exceeded 10% CAGR.
36
00:06:03,757 --> 00:06:16,177
And so I would say it's an extremely conservative estimate, but the reality that even a very conservative estimate puts it ahead of every other asset class in their minds over the next decade is super, super interesting.
37
00:06:16,177 --> 00:06:29,157
The other big element here, I think, is what you alluded to, Phil, around why they're not actually explicitly recommending it or saying that it fits into client portfolios as a true diversifying asset.
38
00:06:29,157 --> 00:06:42,577
And they point to the volatility. Their assessment of volatility is like 55%. And, you know, historically speaking, maybe that's fair. But as we know, the volatility has been coming down.
39
00:06:42,577 --> 00:07:06,497
Now, I'm not of the view that it will always come down forever. I think there's a point sometime in the future that we can't really foresee when that will happen. But at some point, volatility comes back primarily to the upside because of a number of factors. But even if you just look at the parallel of gold, which people perceive to be very not volatile, had extreme volatility over the past two years.
40
00:07:06,497 --> 00:07:20,017
So to say that and ask that it's only a trillion, two trillion in market cap can't have massive moves into the future as more and more of the globe recognizes it for what it is, its monetary properties, I think volatility can come back in a real way.
41
00:07:20,017 --> 00:07:30,857
Now, the other big thing about volatility is in this report, they are taking a blanket view of volatility, which I think misses the mark.
42
00:07:31,517 --> 00:07:33,837
Bitcoin is very unique in terms of its volatility.
43
00:07:33,837 --> 00:07:40,937
It has a positive skew to it, meaning it basically punches up more than it punches down in terms of the big moves that it makes.
44
00:07:41,417 --> 00:07:47,097
And that is different from pretty much every other asset on Earth, which tends to have a negative skew to its volatility.
45
00:07:47,097 --> 00:07:56,917
And so that's fundamentally why traditional finance people, allocators, investors have a negative perception around volatility, sort of, you know, all else equal.
46
00:07:57,277 --> 00:08:01,437
It's because most of the time that is the right stance because that volatility tends to be downward.
47
00:08:02,417 --> 00:08:05,137
Bitcoin historically acts in the opposite way.
48
00:08:05,377 --> 00:08:07,537
It's most volatile moves are to the upside.
49
00:08:07,537 --> 00:08:17,837
So I think they're missing a big piece of this in terms of them using volatility as sort of a merit against Bitcoin in terms of their allocation framework.
50
00:08:18,677 --> 00:08:23,457
Because the reality is, is that for its entire history, it's been more volatile to the upside.
51
00:08:24,137 --> 00:08:31,017
And so that's actually a feature of the asset, not a bug, sort of early in this, its monetization, it's going to be volatile.
52
00:08:31,457 --> 00:08:33,597
But most of that tends to happen to the upside.
53
00:08:35,137 --> 00:08:36,937
Yeah, Phil, I'd love your take on that.
54
00:08:36,937 --> 00:08:42,397
They left it out of their model portfolio because it was too volatile with a vol of 55.
55
00:08:43,017 --> 00:08:47,417
Do you think that that is still a common objection when it comes to institutional investors?
56
00:08:48,077 --> 00:08:53,997
It's very common. And most of my friends who are, let's say, millennials or younger,
57
00:08:54,717 --> 00:09:00,057
I don't think I know anyone who doesn't own Bitcoin. And these are all independent investors,
58
00:09:00,057 --> 00:09:08,397
retail guys, and everyone is as bullish as I am, if not more. So that's sort of the pulse in the room,
59
00:09:08,417 --> 00:09:15,257
I would say, for a younger profile of investors. But again, none of these colleagues or friends of
60
00:09:15,257 --> 00:09:20,797
mine are investing with JP Morgan. So maybe that also says something as well. But the institutions
61
00:09:20,797 --> 00:09:25,257
are going to take a lot longer to stomach the volatility that is associated with Bitcoin,
62
00:09:25,257 --> 00:09:32,577
which I think is totally fair. A lot of their jobs for their clientele is don't lose money.
63
00:09:33,157 --> 00:09:40,837
And if you're having a asset that according to their estimates has 55% volatility, yeah, you might lose some years there.
64
00:09:40,837 --> 00:09:54,377
But also if you zoom out and you say, I'm going to hold this thing for 20 years, it's very, very difficult for me to imagine a scenario where it's lower in 20 years from now than today.
65
00:09:54,377 --> 00:10:06,317
And one of the ideas that makes me forever bullish on Bitcoin is that the dollar is going to continue to lose its value every single year indefinitely.
66
00:10:06,317 --> 00:10:10,337
I think it's lost something like 30% of its purchasing power in the last couple of decades.
67
00:10:10,977 --> 00:10:19,397
And I don't see that slowing down. If anything, it's going to accelerate as the U.S. government, but also governments all around the world, continue to debase their currencies.
68
00:10:19,997 --> 00:10:41,233
Inflation is not going away Currency debasement is not going away So whatever JP Morgan says they are not they
almost ignoring the mega secular trend of currency debasement because they trying to look at oh on a year to year basis we might see extra wide volatility and we might expect this return whatever
69
00:10:41,233 --> 00:10:51,373
I think that's honestly too in the weeds if you just consider the fact that there is no bottom for how much these currencies can get debased.
70
00:10:51,373 --> 00:11:06,093
So gold and Bitcoin and even land, hard assets, these things should continue to go up as currencies around the world get debased and governments prove every single year how fiscally irresponsible they are.
71
00:11:06,093 --> 00:11:13,993
We're not getting out of that world, so I don't see Bitcoin losing its status as this new age hard asset.
72
00:11:15,693 --> 00:11:21,293
And when it comes to this report itself, we can actually just want to bring this up here.
73
00:11:21,613 --> 00:11:22,513
I mean, you can see it right here.
74
00:11:22,593 --> 00:11:31,313
Bitcoin is on top of the list, giving you the best compound returns over any asset that they have recommended here.
75
00:11:31,313 --> 00:11:34,153
So, I mean, Brian, talk to us about this.
76
00:11:34,153 --> 00:11:42,533
Who receives these documents? Is it just wealth advisors? How seriously do they take these reports from J.P. Morgan? And how much of an impact could this have?
77
00:11:43,533 --> 00:11:53,233
Yeah, stuff like this is distributed around sort of the financial management industry, whether that be an RIA, financial advisor, brokerage firms.
78
00:11:53,233 --> 00:12:01,013
And people do put a lot of stock in these things because, as Phil mentioned at the top, J.P. Morgan does have – they're very well-resourced.
79
00:12:01,013 --> 00:12:05,773
they put together good research and people respect them. They have that credibility, that social proof
80
00:12:05,773 --> 00:12:16,133
that people look to. Now, all that being said, I think there are some common misnomers. This idea
81
00:12:16,133 --> 00:12:22,573
that volatility alone is equivalent to risk, I just think is fundamentally not the case.
82
00:12:23,933 --> 00:12:29,073
These are 10-year capital market assumptions, right? So Phil, you said if you have a 20-year
83
00:12:29,073 --> 00:12:33,513
view. If you're looking at these for guidance, you should have at least a 10-year view, but you
84
00:12:33,513 --> 00:12:37,653
probably have a multi-decade, somewhat of a generational view on what these assets are
85
00:12:37,653 --> 00:12:45,253
going to do. And so the interim volatility is not necessarily risk in terms of permanent capital
86
00:12:45,253 --> 00:12:48,933
impairment, which is what someone would really be worried about if they're thinking about volatility.
87
00:12:48,933 --> 00:12:54,193
Is the asset going to be permanently impaired? Now, obviously, there could be some unforeseen risk
88
00:12:54,193 --> 00:13:00,553
in the future that makes Bitcoin fail and not work. And that would permanently impair any capital put
89
00:13:00,553 --> 00:13:05,773
towards that. But how I've always thought about the pushback against Bitcoin's volatility, it's like,
90
00:13:06,253 --> 00:13:09,913
well, that's ultimately like a position sizing discussion. It's not necessarily
91
00:13:09,913 --> 00:13:18,533
all or nothing, right? You're not aping into Bitcoin to be 100% of your client's portfolios,
92
00:13:18,533 --> 00:13:23,973
but it certainly deserves some amount of percentage whether that's 1, 2, 5, 10 percent.
93
00:13:24,473 --> 00:13:31,193
I think the data is pretty clear that it is a diversifier. It does have counter cyclical qualities
94
00:13:31,193 --> 00:13:38,033
relative to any other assets in your portfolio. It acts differently. It's at a very different sort of
95
00:13:38,033 --> 00:13:43,133
point in its maturity or life cycle relative to something like gold but they are sort of
96
00:13:43,133 --> 00:13:47,213
analog and digital counterparts in some way of this broader debasement trade
97
00:13:47,213 --> 00:13:51,753
which I think that as well, like just an aside, like that's obviously becoming more mainstream.
98
00:13:51,953 --> 00:13:59,453
I think about 12 months ago, it was really in the headlines around this debasement trade as gold was making its massive run up to all time highs.
99
00:13:59,593 --> 00:14:06,753
And it's kind of come back over the past like month or two, particularly with some of the actions from the Treasury doing a form of yield curve control.
100
00:14:07,213 --> 00:14:10,553
And people kind of seeing the writing on the wall that, yeah, we're just going to run this thing hot.
101
00:14:10,553 --> 00:14:16,813
We're going to continue to debase the currency. So you better own some hard assets, whether that be gold, Bitcoin, real assets,
102
00:14:16,813 --> 00:14:42,413
It's like real estate or other commodities. And so I do think there's a lot of just like misnomers in the traditional finance industry around volatility, risk, what does it mean? And generally, like people having too short term of a view on things, right? Like if you're going to use this document to construct a portfolio for the next several decades, the interim volatility of something like Bitcoin shouldn't scare you.
103
00:14:42,413 --> 00:14:58,993
The only thing it might do is just limit your position size to something that if there were some sort of capital impairment in the future, you're not losing 50% of your portfolio, you're losing 1% to 2%. And the upside potential of that certainly warrants having some amount of it in that portfolio.
104
00:14:58,993 --> 00:15:06,773
And when it comes to investing one's own money, I mean, in the past, you had to trust another
105
00:15:06,773 --> 00:15:10,653
individual to go out and do that. But now people are getting empowered, they can teach themselves,
106
00:15:10,753 --> 00:15:16,453
they can use AI. And Phil, I want to talk to you about what you guys are doing over at Sylvia,
107
00:15:16,953 -->
00:15:23,633
right? So you have built a platform to help people with wealth management using AI, and they can plug
108
00:15:23,633 --> 00:15:28,613
everything in, take a look at their finances and have AI analyze it. So explain it to people,
109
00:15:28,993 --> 00:15:31,153
What makes it different than just like a ChatGPT?
110
00:15:32,053 --> 00:15:42,150
So if I go on ChatGPT or Gemini or Claude and I say hey NVIDIA is down 2 today Should I buy more stock
111
00:15:42,850 --> 00:16:02,470
It's going to answer with general intelligence, which they're very good at. They know a lot of things about a lot of things, but it won't be specialized or personalized to my specific financial scenario, which is my net worth, my portfolio, my assets, whether I own private investments, public investments,
112
00:16:02,470 --> 00:16:08,850
if I'm saving for my kids' college payments, right? Or if I'm maybe saving for a house.
113
00:16:09,230 --> 00:16:14,730
All these things are personalized and contextualized when you use Sylvia. So if I ask Sylvia, hey,
114
00:16:15,010 --> 00:16:21,950
should I buy more NVIDIA stock today because it's down 2%, it is already hooked up to my portfolios,
115
00:16:21,950 --> 00:16:27,570
my checkings, my retirements. Maybe I have a crypto account. Maybe I have a family account or a joint
116
00:16:27,570 --> 00:16:33,670
account with my wife. All these things, Sylvia can internalize and it answers your questions with all
117
00:16:33,670 --> 00:16:42,830
that content. So if you download Sylvia or go to the website, cfosylvia.com and hook in all your
118
00:16:42,830 --> 00:16:48,590
accounts, it's all anonymized, private, secure. I trust it. I use it every single day, right? My team
119
00:16:48,590 --> 00:16:56,570
trusts it. Then I believe and I feel it in my own life, you will have a way better understanding of
120
00:16:56,570 --> 00:17:02,350
your wealth, your net worth, your personal assets. It's not buying and selling things for you in your
121
00:17:02,350 --> 00:17:07,070
portfolio, right? So you still have to do that. But when I think about, okay, I can have a single
122
00:17:07,070 --> 00:17:14,330
dashboard that has 10 accounts in one place in a single number. That to me is super useful, way less
123
00:17:14,330 --> 00:17:20,470
complex. I don't have to open 12 tabs on my computer or open six different apps on my phone. I can just
124
00:17:20,470 --> 00:17:26,270
see it all in one place. That is what we're building with Sylvia and it's free to sign up, right? I think
125
00:17:26,270 --> 00:17:35,270
I think it's a no-brainer to be using superintelligence to make more money and get smarter about your personal wealth and personal net worth decisions.
126
00:17:35,270 --> 00:17:40,270
To me, I think it's one of the more exciting things that exist in the market today.
127
00:17:40,270 --> 00:17:50,270
And the magic of Sylvia is that it is a superintelligence tool that is purpose-built for personal finance.
128
00:17:50,270 --> 00:18:16,170
So again, if you use Claude or Gemini or ChachiBT, Superintelligence, for sure, they are very effective. I use them all the time. But when I need something for finance, that leaves no room for hallucinations. You can't have fuzzy data. It has to be specific to your personal situation. Sylvia, to me, is really, it's in a class of its own. And of course, I'm biased. I work at the company. I work with the team very closely.
129
00:18:16,170 --> 00:18:23,050
But I have been using this product even before I joined the company. So to me, I think it's certainly worth a shot.
130
00:18:24,450 --> 00:18:27,670
Yeah. And Brian, I would love your take on this. Do you think this is the future of wealth management?
131
00:18:28,890 --> 00:18:35,790
Yeah. I mean, this isn't a novel take or comment, but stuff is changing super rapidly, right? Across
132
00:18:35,790 --> 00:18:44,670
various industries, wealth management and advisory included. One thing I think about, particularly as
133
00:18:44,670 --> 00:18:52,030
as it relates to like hard assets like gold or Bitcoin. Speaking firsthand from when I was in the
134
00:18:52,030 --> 00:18:55,530
TradFi world for about a decade, I worked at Brown Brothers Harriman for a long time.
135
00:18:56,850 --> 00:19:02,830
And they were very sort of call it like Warren Buffett disciples, cashflow oriented, looking for
136
00:19:02,830 --> 00:19:08,570
quality businesses. That was sort of like the crux of a lot of the investment strategies there, but
137
00:19:08,570 --> 00:19:14,170
they never had any exposure to gold. And as I started going down sort of the Bitcoin path,
138
00:19:14,170 --> 00:19:22,050
I found that kind of curious. Why isn't there even a 1% to 2% allocation to gold in some of our clients' portfolios?
139
00:19:22,790 --> 00:19:30,230
And what I came to realize over time is it's not necessarily... I mean, there is just a huge blind spot to real assets, like full stop in the TradFi world.
140
00:19:31,830 --> 00:19:43,590
But I think part of the reason is that there's this tendency to have an air of sophistication in the TradFi world, whether you're a wealth manager, an advisor, an RIA.
141
00:19:44,170 --> 00:20:04,250
Because that's how you literally make a business, right? Like you charge a fee to give your expertise on how to manage your portfolio, right? And so as that all gets disrupted, as people have access to tools like Sylvia or any number of AI assistants, you're able to do a lot of that work yourself.
142
00:20:04,250 --> 00:20:09,650
And the reality is that something like gold or Bitcoin, it's hard to charge a fee on, right?
143
00:20:09,710 --> 00:20:12,790
These are commodities, they're spot assets for the most part.
144
00:20:13,350 --> 00:20:19,850
Yes, you're going to see, as you mentioned at the top, BlackRock and other firms are going to try to make advanced strategies around these things, right?
145
00:20:19,890 --> 00:20:22,690
Because that's how
they're going to be able to charge higher fees on these things.
146
00:20:22,690 --> 00:20:33,730
But the reality is that for, call it the past 20 to 50 years, the traditional finance industry has ballooned into this massive thing in large part
147
00:20:33,730 --> 00:20:49,990
because there's this air of sophistication around, we're the smartest guys in the room, we know how to manage your money for you, let us charge you a fee to do so, and we're going to put you in all these super sophisticated strategies, whether that be across equities, credit, real estate, and all.
148
00:20:50,011 --> 00:21:19,991
All the while, if you look at the past 25 years, gold has outperformed the S&P 500. And so it's like, did you really need all of that sophistication? Now, yes, like, if you were in specific equity managers, they probably outperformed the S&P over that period. So yeah, there's an argument to be made there. But I think the reality on the ground is that there's been this massive blind spot for a reason. And it's largely because these things are harder to put management fees, carry fees, performance fees,
149
00:21:19,991 --> 00:21:25,591
and it doesn't behoove the industry as a whole to really recommend these things. But I do think we are
150
00:21:25,591 --> 00:21:30,771
in the early innings of that shifting. And I think part of that shift is a result of what Phil talked
151
00:21:30,771 --> 00:21:35,351
about and the access to these tools and the reality that you're just going to have to meet these
152
00:21:35,351 --> 00:21:41,751
clients where they are and give them actual advice around hard assets, or they're just going to leave
153
00:21:41,751 --> 00:21:45,111
and take their capital elsewhere and recognize that they should probably own gold and Bitcoin.
154
00:21:45,111 --> 00:21:53,051
Yeah. And I'll admit, I use Sylvia after talking to you a couple of months ago, Phil. And I mean,
155
00:21:53,091 --> 00:21:58,671
the number one thing that I was worried about before getting on it was privacy, right? And if you could
156
00:21:58,671 --> 00:22:03,551
just talk to a little bit about that as to how you keep everybody anonymized and the information secure.
157
00:22:04,491 --> 00:22:09,951
You know, that was one of the biggest issues that I personally had before I got on the platform.
158
00:22:09,951 --> 00:22:17,071
and, you know, I am an employee of the company, right? I'm very visible online. I don't want my
159
00:22:17,071 --> 00:22:22,011
coworkers on the engineering side to be able to see, hey, what's Phil's net worth, right? Obviously,
160
00:22:22,011 --> 00:22:27,151
I don't want that as much as the next guy doesn't want their information being seen by a company,
161
00:22:27,551 --> 00:22:35,211
but it's all anonymized, right? We cannot internally see what other people's finances are because
162
00:22:35,211 --> 00:22:42,351
Everything's encrypted, very private. And that is the biggest thing that I think people hesitate on.
163
00:22:42,711 --> 00:22:48,391
With Sylvia or other personal finance AI tools, they're like, well, I don't want people knowing my finances.
164
00:22:48,831 --> 00:22:53,851
I don't want people to know what my mortgage is, what my rent is, what my paychecks look like.
165
00:22:54,251 --> 00:23:00,251
All these things, I think we have spent a ton of time optimizing against that problem and trying to
166
00:23:00,251 --> 00:23:06,011
and figure it out to make sure that one, that the technology is super safe, super private,
167
00:23:06,011 --> 00:23:12,191
but two, that the user experience is such that they feel confident that this is not something
168
00:23:12,191 --> 00:23:16,431
that we can sort of peek behind the curtain and see how much money you're making just because
169
00:23:16,431 --> 00:23:21,351
you're on the platform. So I think the engineering team really is world class at doing what they
170
00:23:21,351 --> 00:23:26,771
do and building the tech stack. That has been resolved many times over with many fail safes
171
00:23:26,771 --> 00:23:32,691
backed into that. So I feel personally confident to be on the platform. Whether or not I work there,
172
00:23:32,691 --> 00:23:37,591
right? Even if I stopped working here tomorrow, I would continue to use the platform. I am a power
173
00:23:37,591 --> 00:23:45,071
user. I would continue to be a power user, right? Privacy concerns, I think we've figured out in a
174
00:23:45,071 --> 00:23:51,771
pretty solid way. Wonderful. Well, I know you have to run, but it was great to have you on here,
175
00:23:51,771 --> 00:23:57,511
get your comments on this JPMorgan report and what's going on over at Sylvia. It's very cool.
176
00:23:58,511 --> 00:23:59,691
Thank you very much for your time.
177
00:23:59,691 --> 00:24:01,271
Props to the team. Cheers. All right, Phil.
178
00:24:01,291 --> 00:24:02,331
All right. See you guys later, Phil.
179
00:24:03,911 --> 00:24:10,011
Nice. And so we will be joined by Andre Dragos of Bitwise shortly. But before we bring Andre up,
180
00:24:10,031 --> 00:24:17,411
I just want to talk about this chart that you guys at OnRamp made yesterday. And I mean, I think this is the biggest takeaway, right?
181
00:24:17,411 --> 00:24:34,551
J.P. Morgan's new 10-year forecast ranked Bitcoin first at 10% a year. But since 2013, Bitcoin has beaten that rate in 94% of five-year holding periods in an every seven and 10-year period. Do you think that Wall Street and these institutional guys grasp that yet?
182
00:24:34,551 --> 00:24:57,571
No, they don't. And even if they do, I still think they're hung up on the volatility stuff that I referenced. And they also, you know, they've had this notion of past returns do not predict future results drilled into their head for their entire careers, which, you know, is a valid stance to have.
183
00:24:57,571 --> 00:25:19,891
But I thought what was being reported around just the 10% assumption over the next 10 years needed a little bit more
context. So I put this chart together for us that just dug into, well, what does that look like? Obviously, you would expect all 10-year periods of Bitcoin to outperform 10%, just given what it's done since inception.
184
00:25:19,891 --> 00:25:46,851
But, you know, let's, I tried to say, like, let's see if we shorten that a little bit. What does it look like? Seven years, it still beats it every time. Five years, 94%. Three years, 93%. And then one year, it's a bit closer to a coin flip, obviously. But I thought that that was an important context for folks to have around this data, because it is a super conservative estimate. And even though it's conservative, they're putting it ahead of all these other assets.
185
00:25:46,851 --> 00:25:54,671
And maybe that says more about the other assets than it does Bitcoin, arguably, what they expect all these other asset classes to do.
186
00:25:55,511 --> 00:26:26,245
But I think the other thing to keep in mind here is like you know there a few assets on this list that I perceive not necessarily as investments but as savings technologies right I view Bitcoin and gold as forms of savings and everything else on this list I view as at least to some degree speculative You are making an investment There are assumptions to be made Those assumptions can change over time There competitive forces at play particularly in the equity space
187
00:26:26,245 --> 00:26:34,825
And so there's just a lot of other variables, things that can go awry when investing in all these other asset classes.
188
00:26:35,445 --> 00:26:43,145
And so even if they're saying, yeah, US large cap, that's going to do 7.8% over the next decade.
189
00:26:43,265 --> 00:26:46,345
It's like, okay, well, a lot of things have to go right for that to be the case.
190
00:26:46,865 --> 00:26:50,485
And there's a lot of different variables that could shift that number up or down.
191
00:26:50,485 --> 00:27:08,485
Whereas with something like gold or Bitcoin, we know what the properties are, we know what the supply is, at least in Bitcoin's case, we know that the supply is finite. And all you need to assess or determine is, is demand going to continue to increase?
192
00:27:08,485 --> 00:27:32,605
And I would say that's a pretty likely bet, just given that the vast, vast majority of the world has no fundamental understanding of what Bitcoin actually is. They perceive it as crypto, maybe a Ponzi scheme at sort of worst, but a speculative investment nevertheless, which if you're putting it in a speculative investment class, then maybe the volatility would scare you off.
193
00:27:32,605 --> 00:27:43,705
And I think most people just don't understand the actual fundamental properties that make it savings technology, not as speculative as some of the other assets on this list.
194
00:27:45,225 --> 00:27:48,225
And so I think that's a big, I talked about blind spots earlier.
195
00:27:48,505 --> 00:27:57,865
That's a big blind spot for TradFi, but even average retail participants that they perceive something like the S&P 500 as a savings technology.
196
00:27:57,865 --> 00:28:03,205
I mean, you could make that argument that, you know, that's how people have saved over the past 20 years.
197
00:28:03,205 --> 00:28:12,285
It's moved a little bit less or a little bit more away from bonds as a primary savings vehicle to just, you know, plowing into the S&P 500.
198
00:28:12,505 --> 00:28:16,485
And that's worked on a nominal basis, right?
199
00:28:16,485 --> 00:28:26,885
Like if you think about just the sort of past returns of the S&P over the past 10 to 20 years, like it looks like, you know, around 7, 8, 9 percent around there.
200
00:28:26,885 --> 00:28:34,005
But then if you compare that to the rate of monetary inflation, just the amount of money that's created, it's about the same rate.
201
00:28:34,005 --> 00:28:44,965
So you are effectively keeping pace if you're just plowing into the S&P 500. In order to actually outpace that debasement, you need to own something that is outside that system entirely.
202
00:28:45,605 --> 00:28:54,065
And really, the only two assets in my mind that work in that role are neutral reserve assets like Boulder Bitcoin.
203
00:28:54,065 --> 00:29:19,125
And it is this, you know, I think we're just super early into people recognizing that these are, you know, I would even say like this gold estimates probably low on here, like five and a half percent. Like I think gold is going to do way better over the next 10 years than that. Likewise for Bitcoin, obviously, but this debasement trade that people proverbially talk about, it is just in the early innings.
204
00:29:19,125 --> 00:29:25,365
and I would, you know, I always say this, but it's like, it is not a trade. It is a structural long-term
205
00:29:25,365 --> 00:29:30,605
shift that is occurring. And you could go back to the 70s as its actual starting point. And if you
206
00:29:30,605 --> 00:29:36,285
wanted to even go back to the creation of the Fed in 1913, you could go back that far as well.
207
00:29:36,725 --> 00:29:43,105
But this is a long-term story that people are waking up to. And you kind of have these two assets,
208
00:29:43,105 --> 00:29:50,685
the analog and the digital versions of expressing this view. And most people are not there yet. So
209
00:29:50,685 --> 00:29:54,545
like I said before, the only thing you need to assume is that more people get there,
210
00:29:54,785 --> 00:30:00,605
right? Understanding what money is, understanding savings versus speculating. And you're going to see
211
00:30:00,605 --> 00:30:06,125
these things go up a lot faster than these estimates, I would say. Such an important distinction
212
00:30:06,125 --> 00:30:12,005
between speculating and saving. And you're right. So few people get the fact that Bitcoin actually is
213
00:30:12,005 --> 00:30:21,485
that savings technology. Well, now we are joined by good friend of the show, Andre Dragos. Sir, calling in from
Europe. How are you doing?
214
00:30:22,525 --> 00:30:25,865
Good, good. Yeah, it's good to see you again, Rob. Thanks for having me.
215
00:30:26,285 --> 00:30:34,365
Yes, absolutely. So this is an institutional show. We're talking about JP Morgan putting out their new report, listing Bitcoin as the top asset there.
216
00:30:34,365 --> 00:30:39,505
Actually, your guy over Bitwise, Matt Hogan, sort of broke the story on X and made a blow up.
217
00:30:39,505 --> 00:30:47,465
So what has been the ramifications of this in terms of the institutional circles and Bitcoin being listed by J.P. Morgan?
218
00:30:49,025 --> 00:31:01,985
I mean, if you follow what J.P. Morgan's been doing, rather what they've been saying or Jamie Dimon's been saying, I mean, they've been into blockchain tech since 2019, right?
219
00:31:01,985 --> 00:31:24,238
So they launched their own JP Morgan coin in as a kind of enterprise blockchain solution I think back in 2019 Then they launched it on base as a kind of public blockchain coin right And now they launched it on Ethereum mainnet But I mean they been working on this whole story for the past
220
00:31:24,238 --> 00:31:31,898
seven years or so. So my general saying is don't listen to what they say, watch what they do, right?
221
00:31:31,898 --> 00:32:00,838
And so, I mean, you've just shown these performance expectations. And I think your headline was like, even in a conservative kind of, even with a conservative estimate, Bitcoin comes out on top, right? And that's the most important headline, because we all, I think we all agree on the fact that it's very conservative, because even the Paolo model implies like, I think, close to 40% caker over the next 10 years, right?
222
00:32:00,838 --> 00:32:17,398
But my gut feel is they probably couldn't show this to institutional investors because they wouldn't believe them, right? Because that bar chart would be even more outrageous. Not like, oh, Bitcoin comes out on top, becomes way above all other assets.
223
00:32:17,398 --> 00:32:47,098
So, and it's, Bitcoin is this kind of elephant in this kind of performance room because, and that's what's been, what has actually enabled this kind of arbitrage of Bitcoin treasury companies, right? Because they're arbitraging the traditional financial world, which was like single digit returns, right? Over the next 10 years, against Bitcoin was like high double digit returns, right? And so,
224
00:32:47,398 --> 00:32:57,918
Yeah, but my hunch is they've adjusted this kind of estimate to the lower end, you know, to the very lower end.
225
00:32:58,578 --> 00:33:06,598
I mean, to be more serious, but yeah, I think even their bull case suggests 60.6%, which is in my view very conservative.
226
00:33:09,718 --> 00:33:15,638
We can also talk about how they actually arrive at these estimates, I think.
227
00:33:15,638 --> 00:33:45,598
And then you can probably understand why they're coming up with like 10%. I think I had a look at their assumptions and I actually found their approach a bit random to be honest. So they run three separate valuation frameworks. So Bitcoin's fixed supply growth versus dollar global money supply growth. And they assume 10.7% CAGA on this. Then Bitcoin partly substituting for gold in investor portfolios. And I mean, that's also part of the whole story, right?
228
00:33:45,598 --> 00:33:47,118
Stole Value kind of destruction.
229
00:33:47,978 --> 00:33:51,378
And they also assume 10.7% growth in this case.
230
00:33:51,978 --> 00:33:57,958
And then network adoption of the Bitcoin blockchain, and they actually assume a negative growth rate for whatever reason.
231
00:33:57,958 --> 00:34:08,978
But they actually formulate base, bear, and bull outcome for each of those parts of the puzzle.
232
00:34:08,978 --> 00:34:23,598
and then they blend them together based on some kind of arbitrary weighting, 65% weight, 30% and 5% weight, which yields this 10.0% KGAR.
233
00:34:23,598 --> 00:34:41,598
right but anyways yeah and I found it a bit random and I also think these growth rates for both global money supply growth over the next 10 years and also the substitution of gold with Bitcoin is probably way too conservative.
234
00:34:41,598 --> 00:34:49,598
Yeah Brian would love your take on do you think they purposely made it just 10% so it didn't blow people's minds?
235
00:34:49,598 --> 00:35:19,578
They just happened to arrive at this nice round number of 10%. No, it's a good point, Andre. I think you're right. I mean, it's interesting. At firms like this, there tends to be sort of the in-house Bitcoiners, right, who push a lot of this stuff forward. They have to get support from whether it's investment committees or just their peers and colleagues to even put out something like this. And so I think you're right. I think there was probably people internally who wanted to put out an even larger number. And that
236
00:35:19,598 --> 00:35:48,058
got scaled back and they adjusted their frameworks and their methodologies to arrive at this number that feels reasonable, feels okay to the person who's newer to this asset class and newer to Bitcoin. They can even attempt to wrap their arms around it. So yeah, I think that that's spot on. The other thing I wanted to mention is like, this is just one piece of a broader mosaic that we've seen play out really over the past 12 to 24 months.
237
00:35:48,058 --> 00:36:06,338
If you think back to the wake of FTX, there were a lot of similar plans from the Wall Street class, from the institutional crowd to put a lot of these things in place, whether that be products and services or even just a research report like this.
238
00:36:06,758 --> 00:36:13,318
But all of that got shelved when FTX blew up and they really retreated from any plans they had around digital assets, Bitcoin.
239
00:36:13,318 --> 00:36:52,471
This time around it the complete opposite We entered this proverbial bear market threw down 50 odd percent and all of
these firms and institutions have continued to push forward with all of these plans So this is just one piece of a broader picture here that been playing out whether it you know JP Morgan themselves launching an ETF on sort of the heels of IBIT success You know right now they using subcustodians but they hinted at that they want to build custody internally And then you have the cities of the world Charles Schwab Deutsche Bank earlier this week everyone turning on different services whether that just be spot trading
240
00:36:52,491 --> 00:36:58,011
creating different products. You've had Goldman in the mix. It's really every name you could think of
241
00:36:58,011 --> 00:37:05,071
pretty much in this world that is getting up to speed, putting out reports like this, and most
242
00:37:05,071 --> 00:37:09,791
importantly, setting up infrastructure either by building themselves internally or just making
243
00:37:09,791 --> 00:37:15,711
partners, like partnerships. We've seen a ton of partnerships from firms like this with more
244
00:37:15,711 --> 00:37:23,091
digitally native firms over the past 12 to 24 months. And to me, it's one, this stark difference
245
00:37:23,091 --> 00:37:28,631
from the past bear market of all these firms just retreating on their plans and saying, okay, maybe
246
00:37:28,631 --> 00:37:34,531
the skeptics were right. This stuff is nonsense. Let's just pull back from all this. It's really
247
00:37:34,531 --> 00:37:40,691
been the opposite. And that's even in the face of Clarity Act stalling out and failing. It's like,
248
00:37:40,691 --> 00:37:46,911
whether it's the firms or the agencies themselves moving forward with rulemaking, everyone's just full
249
00:37:46,911 --> 00:37:51,291
steam ahead on this stuff, regardless of what's happening with the price or with actual legislation
250
00:37:51,291 --> 00:37:59,791
that's on the docket. So I just think that's super, super constructive and a reality that most people
251
00:37:59,791 --> 00:38:05,531
are probably still discounting, that all of these firms, the entire industry is moving in this
252
00:38:05,531 --> 00:38:13,271
direction. And it's become less about being offensive. I think if you rewind two years ago,
253
00:38:13,931 --> 00:38:19,331
a move like this, either putting out a report or launching a product or a service, it could be
254
00:38:19,331 --> 00:38:24,951
deemed offensive. You're taking a bet here. You're taking a stance that's definitely contrarian. I think
255
00:38:24,951 --> 00:38:30,711
now these moves are completely defensive because if you don't have plans in this space, you are just
256
00:38:30,711 --> 00:38:35,911
going to be left behind. You're going to see capital flight. That was one thing, particularly as it
257
00:38:35,911 --> 00:38:39,851
relates to, I think, Charles Schwab. I think they put out something maybe six or 12 months ago that was
258
00:38:39,851 --> 00:38:45,631
like, we are literally seeing capital flight, that people
are just pulling money out of our firm to go
259
00:38:45,631 --> 00:38:51,871
put it on Coinbase. It's like, we need to do something here. And so I think this is going to
260
00:38:51,871 --> 00:38:57,011
continue. It's going to accelerate as these moves really move from offensive to defensive. Everybody's
261
00:38:57,011 --> 00:38:59,551
Everybody's got to have a plan here.
262
00:39:00,791 --> 00:39:06,411
Bring up a great point. Last bear market, it was really BlackRock laying the groundwork for the ETF.
263
00:39:07,131 --> 00:39:12,011
And now that that was done for this bear market, you see this proliferation of all these institutional
264
00:39:12,011 --> 00:39:17,151
players, making sure they have the infrastructure in place, ready to go for what comes next. So,
265
00:39:17,431 --> 00:39:22,291
Andre, do you think that they are preparing? They know that the bull market is on its way and they
266
00:39:22,291 --> 00:39:25,351
want to make sure they have all their ducks in a row for what's about to happen.
267
00:39:25,351 --> 00:39:32,611
Yeah, I think they've been preparing essentially since the ETF launch in 2024.
268
00:39:32,611 --> 00:39:41,091
We put out an interesting report on a quarterly basis, a crypto market review, and it includes some really interesting charts.
269
00:39:41,871 --> 00:39:52,511
So we have one kind of table that shows this Bobbicon ETF ownership by professional investors, and it's mostly investment advisors, hedge funds, brokerages.
270
00:39:52,511 --> 00:40:20,591
it's not so much retail, right? And also to your point that you mentioned that many major banks, wire houses, financial advisors, they're starting to offer at least some kind of crypto related service. We also have this kind of interesting chart. I'll try to find it right now. But it's like a dotted chart where we show, okay, I found it. Maybe I can share my screen. It's really interesting.
271
00:40:22,511 --> 00:40:24,751
Making sure entire screen.
272
00:40:26,831 --> 00:40:33,471
So every time we update this report, it's like a new green dot.
273
00:40:34,471 --> 00:40:41,171
And as you can see, especially with respect to crypto ETPs, almost every major bank is already offering it.
274
00:40:41,171 --> 00:40:49,431
Almost every major warehouse in the US, whether it's Bank of America or Goldman Sachs.
275
00:40:49,431 --> 00:40:58,491
I think only CME, they're obviously not a bank, but MasterCard and Visa, they're not offering it.
276
00:41:00,491 --> 00:41:10,731
But you can see that, in my experience, this will only increase and you can see access at top US World platforms.
277
00:41:10,731 --> 00:41:15,731
So this is also increasing, that list is also increasing.
278
00:41:15,731 --> 00:41:21,351
And I think we are past this kind of early stage.
279
00:41:21,351 --> 00:41:26,351
I think it's the beginning of the end of this kind of early stage,
280
00:41:26,351 --> 00:41:31,891
and we're moving to this maturation phase in Bitcoin and crypto
assets in general.
281
00:41:32,891 --> 00:41:37,631
Yeah. If you had shown this to somebody back in 2019, 2020,
282
00:41:37,631 --> 00:41:39,991
their minds would have been absolutely blown, right?
283
00:41:39,997 --> 00:41:49,717
And shoot it over to Brian, like why do you think price has languished if we have all this institutional infrastructure and adoption?
284
00:41:50,997 --> 00:41:53,597
Yeah, I mean that's the million dollar question, right?
285
00:41:53,597 --> 00:41:58,197
I mean just hitting on what Andre pulled up there for a second before I get to price.
286
00:41:59,117 --> 00:42:09,957
I love that chart and I love that data because there's an interesting dynamic there where yes, all of these firms are turning on products and services.
287
00:42:09,997 --> 00:42:15,957
But I think we're just scratching the surface of active solicitation of underlying clients.
288
00:42:16,517 --> 00:42:24,437
And that's really when I think you will see a price reaction that relates directly to a lot of these things being built out.
289
00:42:24,437 --> 00:42:38,417
Because even on the ETF side for the past two years, if you're a brokerage or a wire house and you turn on access, that doesn't mean you're actively selling it to a client and saying, hey, you need 1-5% in this thing.
290
00:42:38,417 --> 00:43:00,277
That just means if they ask about it specifically, you have the ability to put them in it. That's a very different world from where I think we're headed, which is, hey, Mr. Client, I think you should have 5% in Bitcoin. Here's the number of ways we can execute that for you across different vehicles, but I think you need some exposure.
291
00:43:00,277 --> 00:43:26,197
Those conversations have barely, if at all, even started. And so while I agree with you, we're towards the end of that early phase. The next phase is, I think, when you actually get a more meaningful price response. Obviously, we saw a price response when the ETS went live. I think there was a lot of latent demand that wanted exposure through a vehicle like that. And so naturally, you saw a price reaction to that.
292
00:43:26,197 --> 00:43:31,637
But I think for the next leg of that price reaction, I think you're going to need active solicitation.
293
00:43:31,877 --> 00:43:36,277
And I really think we're just scratching the surface of that. Despite what you had pulled up there,
294
00:43:36,617 --> 00:43:40,857
it's sort of like that's the first stage of turning all this stuff on, getting the plumbing all set up.
295
00:43:41,337 --> 00:43:44,957
And then it's like, OK, it's go time. Now we're going to go actually sell this thing.
296
00:43:45,577 --> 00:43:52,097
And you're starting to see like little signals of that, like BlackRock putting out their commercials on sort of Bitcoin and its fundamentals.
297
00:43:52,097 --> 00:43:58,037
like that's the very beginning stages of what that will look like in terms of actually selling this stuff to clients.
298
00:43:59,257 --> 00:44:20,737
It's happening. It's happening. Yeah. And it seems as if like the floodgates are ready, they're primed, but they haven't been completely opened yet. And we will see that. And I want to bring up a video of Jamie Dimon pre-2020 because it's just so funny to see his former takes on all this. But before we get into the video of Jamie, got to give a shout out to our sponsors of today's show.
299
00:44:20,737 --> 00:44:27,497
because before getting access to Bitcoin financial services was slow, clunky, and scattered across all these different platforms.
300
00:44:28,157 --> 00:44:33,797
But Rhino is changing that. Rhino is a next-generation Bitcoin banking app designed to handle all of your needs in one place.
301
00:44:34,037 --> 00:44:41,497
Of course, you can buy Bitcoin with zero fees, get more sats for every dollar you spend, make payments over the Lightning Network instantaneously around the world,
302
00:44:41,497 --> 00:44:45,897
also send cash over Bitcoin Rails fast and easy to friends and family.
303
00:44:45,897 --> 00:44:52,497
And of course, you can DCA, set up an automatic savings plan so you stack sats on your schedule and build wealth over time.
304
00:44:53,117 --> 00:44:58,677
Soon you'll be able to pay your bills, direct deposit, and borrow against your Bitcoin.
305
00:44:59,297 --> 00:45:09,237
And Rhino protects your Bitcoin with the top level of verification of biometrics, 24-7 fraud protection, and the confidence of knowing your Bitcoin is never rehypothecated.
306
00:45:09,237 --> 00:45:38,877
Go today to rhinobitcoin.com, download for iOS or Android, use the code BITCOINNEWS, one word, BITCOINNEWS, and you'll get $21 of free Bitcoin when you deposit your first $100 into your app. Rhino is built to keep you in control of your Bitcoin every minute of every day. They're a great team, friends of the program. Highly recommend checking them out. Just got a huge new UX upgrade and got free sats dropping, free reports. Go check out Rhino Bitcoin.
307
00:45:39,237 --> 00:45:49,717
Thank you and back to the show. So let's get our boy Jamie Dimon up on stage. What is he saying back in like 2017? Let's see this.
308
00:45:49,717 --> 00:46:08,437
I could care less what Bitcoin trades for, how it trades, why it trades, who trades it. If you're stupid enough to buy it, you'll pay the price for it one day. I've also told people that it can trade at $100,000 before it trades to zero. Who cares about Bitcoin? The world economy is so big. We move, J-Dwell alone, at least $6 trillion. We move all the way.
309
00:46:08,437 --> 00:46:14,257
And Bitcoin in total is all these cards that are $50 billion, maybe a billion dollar trades a day.
310
00:46:14,677 --> 00:46:34,539
And the other thing I always heard of Bitcoin governments and this is not a technological statement governments are going to crush it one day Governments like to know where the money is who has it and what you doing with it Crazy Crazy how wrong he was with that
one Right Oh my God Let get Andre take on that video
311
00:46:36,119 --> 00:46:47,519
I mean, 2017 was quite early, to be honest. I mean, I started investing in 2014, but I mean, I remember in the institutional
312
00:46:47,519 --> 00:47:03,519
The virtual space, it was pretty much still novel. I think most of the institutional investments, they happened around COVID, and especially after 2024, the ETF launch.
313
00:47:03,519 --> 00:47:21,779
I mean, it was way too early, but still, I mean, going back to my earlier comment on J.D. Morgan, I mean, they've been working on blockchain tech and in-house for since at least 2019, right?
314
00:47:21,779 --> 00:47:37,099
They have their own NFT platform, Onyx, right? And so on. And so I think, yeah, they've probably been preparing in-house while not disclosing these kinds of projects, you know.
315
00:47:38,059 --> 00:47:43,419
But it's very clear that he has like a personal animus against Bitcoin, right? He hates this thing.
316
00:47:43,699 --> 00:47:44,099
Yeah, yeah.
317
00:47:44,099 --> 00:47:50,619
I don't know if he's like scared of it. Like, what do you think is, or the reasons for him being so mean against Bitcoin, right?
318
00:47:50,619 --> 00:47:53,079
I mean, yeah, sorry.
319
00:47:53,839 --> 00:47:57,419
Yeah, I mean, my head just goes to like many, many such cases.
320
00:47:57,419 --> 00:48:15,219
Like we've seen other soundbites like this from from other folks, either in his position or similar positions where, you know, the reality is, is that there's such great inertia at a firm like JP Morgan or really anywhere on Wall Street in the Tradify space.
321
00:48:15,219 --> 00:48:43,519
And Andre, I think your point is valid around like, you know, back then it was like, if you said anything other than what he just said, like you were crazy. And so, you know, that clip, I think it's very funny to look at it now. But I think the reality on the ground at the time that he was making those comments was like, that was the right thing to say for him. And, you know, he was obviously wrong in many different ways. But that was sort of the down the fairway take.
322
00:48:43,519 --> 00:48:47,159
And if you were saying anything other than that, you were looked at like you were crazy.
323
00:48:47,359 --> 00:48:57,019
I mean, I was, like I said, when I was at Brown Brothers back in the day, 2017 era, I was just starting to learn about Bitcoin and I would bring it up to our CIO and other colleagues.
324
00:48:57,499 --> 00:49:04,119
And they looked at me like I had five heads. Like, what are you talking about? We don't even own gold. Why are we going to own digital gold? What are you talking about?
325
00:49:04,119 --> 00:49:34,019
And so, you know, it's not surprising in hindsight, I think. But like I said, like, all of this stuff, it starts with a few people internally, right? And then it kind of spreads. And so you need those internal champions that start to change the minds of their peers, start to
change the attitudes and the perceptions. And then the other thing is just like the price doing its thing gets everybody on board eventually. It's like, oh, this thing didn't die again. It's coming back. Oh, now it has these vehicles.
326
00:49:34,019 --> 00:49:38,939
these products that are easier for us to access. Let's take another look at this. Let's reassess our
327
00:49:38,939 --> 00:49:45,719
priors. But like I said, there's immense inertia not to do that in the TradFi world, not to reassess
328
00:49:45,719 --> 00:49:50,759
your priors, not to admit that you were wrong about something. So yeah, it's not surprising,
329
00:49:50,859 --> 00:49:58,299
but it is funny to look back at that quote. Yes. And so, I mean, let's take a look at Bitcoin's
330
00:49:58,299 --> 00:50:05,559
price because, I mean, of course, a lot depends on that, right? And here we are coming off of the
331
00:50:05,559 --> 00:50:10,699
summer lows of around $62,000, right? In the middle of August when Bessent said that they were going to do
332
00:50:10,699 --> 00:50:17,079
double the size of the treasury buybacks, Bitcoin rocketed up, consolidated until the end of September,
333
00:50:17,239 --> 00:50:21,979
around September 21st or so, and then rocketed up once again. And now we've been digesting that move
334
00:50:21,979 --> 00:50:30,599
into the 80s. As guys who have been in finance for a while, what does this move off the summer lows look
335
00:50:30,599 --> 00:50:37,479
like to you? Does this look sustainable or is this just a BART waiting to happen? Let's go to Andre.
336
00:50:38,339 --> 00:50:45,599
Yeah, like our general take on the market has been we've moved away from this kind of crypto winter
337
00:50:45,599 --> 00:50:52,399
into a new crypto spring. And the simple reason is that we've taken out many key cost bases.
338
00:50:53,519 --> 00:50:59,759
I think it started with the short-term holder cost basis around $67k. Then we moved above the true
339
00:50:59,759 --> 00:51:20,442
market mean which is essentially the average acquisition cost of all on investors excluding the Satoshi wallets which was around 76 it now I think around 77k and then we moved above the ETF cost basis which at that time was I think around 81k and it now around 82 83k
340
00:51:20,442 --> 00:51:50,422
But our view was the moment we take out the ETF cost basis, the market sentiment flips from selling the rip to buying the dip. You get this kind of switch in investor mentality. And this is some kind of itself reinforcing to the upside. And you can actually see it on chain. The moment we retrace back to previous lows, there's more like a lot of money.
341
00:51:50,442 --> 00:51:52,882
like accumulation than distribution, you know.
342
00:51:53,462 --> 00:51:55,602
And so I think we're in a new bull market.
343
00:51:56,942 --> 00:52:08,142
But I wouldn't be surprised if we saw like a correction down into the mid-70s, which would be healthy in my view, around 75 probably where the
true market mean is right now or 76.
344
00:52:09,142 --> 00:52:11,282
I think that would actually be quite healthy.
345
00:52:11,282 --> 00:52:41,262
and yeah because I mean if you look around the macro environments not pretty right I mean Bitcoin has been more or less flat in October which is actually a victory if you consider the fact that semiconductor stocks have been down almost 10 percent the DRAM ETF has been down like 15 percent the COSP has been down like 10 percent you got you have to be
346
00:52:41,282 --> 00:52:47,122
I've seen this kind of sell-off in the AI trade, essentially.
347
00:52:47,122 --> 00:52:55,122
And despite all of these macro headwinds, Bitcoin has remained remarkably resilient.
348
00:52:55,122 --> 00:52:57,362
And so I think that's actually a win.
349
00:52:57,362 --> 00:53:00,642
I mean, we could talk about the reasons why that is.
350
00:53:00,642 --> 00:53:04,562
We think it's both the US stock market and Bitcoin.
351
00:53:04,562 --> 00:53:09,842
They're actually influenced by two very different macro factors right now.
352
00:53:09,842 --> 00:53:23,682
Bitcoin's more sensitive towards the dollar right now, while the S&P 500 is more sensitive towards global growth expectations, which are being revised downwards, right? And that's why you're seeing this kind of divergence in performances.
353
00:53:24,902 --> 00:53:26,602
Yeah, let's get your take, Brian.
354
00:53:27,022 --> 00:53:39,822
Yeah, I think that that's all well said. I would agree that I think this move off the bottom is sustainable. I mean, I almost look at it as more of a, from like a psychological framework of,
355
00:53:39,842 --> 00:54:05,522
You know, there's always going to be some amount of seller exhaustion that occurs towards and around these bottoms. That's what causes the bottom to form. And I think the reality is, is like, if you wanted to sell at around 100, you did so about a year ago. If you wanted to sell a little bit above that, maybe you got out around, you know, 115. And if you got worried and scared on, you know, this downtrend from the spring into the summer, you probably already sold already.
356
00:54:05,522 --> 00:54:30,562
And so that's what tends to form these bottoms is just all the sellers who wanted to sell end up selling at some point or another. There's sort of an end capitulation wick. And then it just starts to creep back up. And then that's when, in my mind, net new folks come in when they realize like, oh shit, this thing didn't die. It's starting to creep back up. And they've seen it do this before, right?
357
00:54:30,562 --> 00:54:39,462
So it's kind of a pattern recognition thing where it's like, okay, the last time it didn't die, it then went on to do a 5 to 10x.
358
00:54:39,462 --> 00:54:43,242
So maybe I shouldn't do the same thing I did last time and not buy any.
359
00:54:44,402 --> 00:54:48,802
And so I think that's how you get net due entrance when sellers are exhausted.
360
00:54:49,102 --> 00:54:52,782
It starts to creep back up off of this equilibrium base.
361
00:54:53,402 --> 00:54:56,042
I look at things like cost bases as well that you referenced.
362
00:54:56,042 --> 00:55:02,522
I think the ETF cost basis is particularly interesting in the context of kind of the past two years and how market structure has shifted.
363
00:55:03,202 --> 00:55:07,322
So we're back above that. And I think, you know, it's just a time thing.
364
00:55:07,402 --> 00:55:12,822
It's just like people have to see this thing not be dead and start to creep back up.
365
00:55:12,822 --> 00:55:16,702
And then it's a self-fulfilling thing. Like you said, people start to pile back in.
366
00:55:18,222 --> 00:55:21,382
Yeah. And what do you think how the rest of the year is going to play out, Andre?
367
00:55:21,382 --> 00:55:28,262
I think markets will stay volatile, both crypto markets and traditional financial markets.
368
00:55:28,262 --> 00:55:34,342
I think we've seen the very first innings of this kind of growth repricing to the downside,
369
00:55:35,062 --> 00:55:41,462
because I think most growth expectations, earnings expectations, they're still relatively high,
370
00:55:41,462 --> 00:55:56,704
right I mean semiconductor billings are still growing by more than 100 year over year right Korean semiconductor exports you name it right All of these variables are growing at record pace But the financial tightening
371
00:55:56,704 --> 00:56:01,624
that we're seeing actually implies that they will decelerate sharply from here. And so you have this
372
00:56:01,624 --> 00:56:09,164
kind of growth repricing to the downside. And I mean, measuring by the degree of financial tightening,
373
00:56:09,164 --> 00:56:18,564
I think it's comparable to the period in 2022, 2023 when we had like a 25% correction in the S&P 500.
374
00:56:19,004 --> 00:56:20,664
I think that's actually quite likely.
375
00:56:22,364 --> 00:56:27,884
So I think Bitcoin will stay volatile in this kind of environment until year end.
376
00:56:28,364 --> 00:56:38,224
But at the same time, I think one of the reasons why Bitcoin is so resilient is it's starting to sniff out this monstrosimulus, right?
377
00:56:38,224 --> 00:56:44,264
because what happens after such a market route is you usually get some kind of policy response.
378
00:56:45,344 --> 00:56:50,464
I mean, it depends on the level of financial pain, but you do get some kind of policy response.
379
00:56:51,484 --> 00:56:58,584
And I think that's what Bitcoin is starting to sniff out, which is why it's so resilient.
380
00:56:58,584 --> 00:57:03,984
And I think one of the key catalysts to watch is essentially yields and real yields.
381
00:57:03,984 --> 00:57:31,384
Bittis, funny thing is everyone expected like US treasury yields to blow out to 6% and so but they've come off like 5.4 the most cyclical the latest cycle high right and you're starting to see that this kind of equity weakness is starting to affect the bond market
financial conditions, monetary policy expectations and I think at the moment that turns more decisively it's big tailwind for Bitcoin.
382
00:57:31,384 --> 00:57:36,604
Do you agree with that, Ryan, that Bitcoin's already sniffing out the stimulus?
383
00:57:36,944 --> 00:57:43,764
I do. I thought it was interesting that when the Fed hiked rates, Bitcoin dipped in the minutes
384
00:57:43,764 --> 00:57:49,764
afterwards, but then it actually retries higher, which if you look historically, typically Bitcoin
385
00:57:49,764 --> 00:57:56,624
reacts negatively to interest rate hikes. So I do believe that it's sniffing out the trapped situation
386
00:57:56,624 --> 00:58:02,024
that the Fed and the US government is in with the deficit spending and the debt, that at some point
387
00:58:02,024 --> 00:58:07,624
there needs to be some accommodative measures taken, whether that's just increasing the scale,
388
00:58:07,744 --> 00:58:13,464
but we already saw in August, or doing something even more dramatic if equity markets were to sell
389
00:58:13,464 --> 00:58:19,384
off. So I would agree that Bitcoin is kind of looking through to the inevitability of the monetary
390
00:58:19,384 --> 00:58:24,964
situation. The other thing I would reference is like, you know, if there is any shakiness in equity
391
00:58:24,964 --> 00:58:51,084
markets and you do have a material sell-off there. I do think part of the story for Bitcoin is going to be a capital rotation because it's like if you're selling equities, what are you doing with that capital? Are you putting into bonds? Probably not. Are you putting into real estate? Probably not. Maybe you're just holding cash, but that seems silly if you're an active investor. And so this hard asset trade starts to look pretty attractive in that context, in that environment.
392
00:58:51,084 --> 00:59:03,424
And it's auspicious or convenient timing that all these firms have set up all their plumbing to allow people to make that rotation trade pretty neatly into gold or Bitcoin.
393
00:59:04,084 --> 00:59:06,304
And they're starting to market it as such as well.
394
00:59:07,904 --> 00:59:10,204
And we're also starting to see some global chaos.
395
00:59:10,204 --> 00:59:15,184
You look at the streets of Paris, Albania, things are going a little wild over there.
396
00:59:15,324 --> 00:59:17,384
And we might have a democratic sweep over here.
397
00:59:17,384 --> 00:59:24,144
like people are going to want to find ways to protect their money and Bitcoin offers them something that they really can't find anywhere else.
398
00:59:24,784 --> 00:59:28,104
Well, gentlemen, we are here at the end of our time.
399
00:59:28,664 --> 00:59:29,644
That was an awesome show.
400
00:59:30,304 --> 00:59:34,804
JP Morgan really gave us a great diving board to go off in all these different directions.
401
00:59:35,244 --> 00:59:36,304
So thank you so much.
402
00:59:36,484 --> 00:59:39,464
Andre, if people want to find out more about you and Bitwise, where should they go?
403
00:59:40,504 --> 00:59:43,664
Just find me on Twitter, Andre, and let's go, Andrey Gosch.
404
00:59:44,384 --> 00:59:44,804
There you go.
405
00:59:44,804 --> 00:59:48,504
And Brian, you and OnRamp, how should people check it out?
406
00:59:48,504 --> 00:59:55,144
If you want to find me on Twitter, I'm at backslash BTC, the word backslash spelt out, BTC.
407
00:59:55,804 --> 01:00:00,004
And then if you want to learn more about OnRamp, at OnRampBitcoin or OnRampBitcoin.com.
408
01:00:00,684 --> 01:00:01,424
There you have it.
409
01:00:01,784 --> 01:00:02,104
All right.
410
01:00:02,224 --> 01:00:04,664
JP Morgan is now pumping our bags.
411
01:00:04,904 --> 01:00:07,104
Sorry, Jamie, but we won this round.
412
01:00:07,464 --> 01:00:08,064
All right, everybody.
413
01:00:08,184 --> 01:00:10,624
We'll be back next Wednesday, 11 a.m.
414
01:00:10,644 --> 01:00:11,064
Thank you, Rob.
415
01:00:11,504 --> 01:00:11,884
Bye-bye.
416
01:00:14,804 --> 01:00:16,804
Outro