TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.017 --> 00:00:04.017
Welcome back to RealClear Podcast for this special edition interview with economist
00:00:04.017 --> 00:00:06.817
and prolific writer Jeffrey Tucker from the Epoch Times.
00:00:06.937 --> 00:00:10.617
The reason I wanted to talk with Mr. Tucker is to try to gain the bearing as
00:00:10.617 --> 00:00:13.137
to where the U.S. economy is now and where it's going.
00:00:13.357 --> 00:00:17.597
Most people are concerned and want to have some idea as to technically what is happening.
00:00:17.817 --> 00:00:21.077
I hope that this interview is valuable to you and provides you with insight
00:00:21.077 --> 00:00:24.057
as to where the economy is going and how to best prepare yourself.
00:00:24.957 --> 00:00:29.217
Subscribers to RealClearPodcast.com can access the video of the interview.
00:00:29.557 --> 00:00:33.537
Just go to realclearpodcast.com, sign in, and you'll have it there.
00:00:33.757 --> 00:00:36.597
So without further delay, here is my interview with Jeffrey Tucker.
00:00:37.397 --> 00:00:41.477
Welcome back to Real Clear Podcast. I am so pleased to be joined by economist
00:00:41.477 --> 00:00:43.397
and prolific writer Jeffrey Tucker.
00:00:43.697 --> 00:00:47.817
You can find his work at the Epoch Times. He writes every day.
00:00:47.977 --> 00:00:52.837
In fact, I just caught up today that he has already posted one of his many excellent
00:00:52.837 --> 00:00:54.417
writings, and they have varied topics.
00:00:54.837 --> 00:00:58.497
Yesterday's was, it's not just government that is bloated. The day before that
00:00:58.497 --> 00:01:00.637
was, is wallpaper coming back? It should.
00:01:01.937 --> 00:01:04.857
And today is, the internet faces upheaval again.
00:01:05.037 --> 00:01:09.577
But in all seriousness, Mr. Tucker is a prolific writer, an economist,
00:01:09.737 --> 00:01:11.477
and advocate for libertarian ideas.
00:01:11.597 --> 00:01:14.197
We'll see what his evolving ideas are as of today.
00:01:14.397 --> 00:01:19.197
He's known for his work in technology, social philosophy, and culture in addition to economics.
00:01:19.777 --> 00:01:23.417
He's the founder of the Brownstone Institute, which is a non-profit think tank
00:01:23.417 --> 00:01:26.557
that helps Americans think about social and economic research.
00:01:26.817 --> 00:01:31.717
He started to write about his opposition to COVID lockdowns and the many foibles
00:01:31.717 --> 00:01:36.017
he sees as unfolding since those times, and we'll get his thoughts on those things today.
00:01:36.437 --> 00:01:41.097
I could go on about his Vitae, it's so expansive, but we'll get to know each
00:01:41.097 --> 00:01:44.637
other live in our dialogue here, where I want to ask Mr.
00:01:44.777 --> 00:01:48.197
Tucker a series of really important questions that on everyone's minds.
00:01:48.737 --> 00:01:51.597
Namely, are we in a recession? I think his answer is yes.
00:01:51.777 --> 00:01:55.337
In fact, I know it's yes. And I'd like to hear more details about that.
00:01:55.497 --> 00:01:59.817
And then how can Americans understand where the United States has been,
00:02:00.037 --> 00:02:06.417
where we are now, and where we're headed, and how long those various processes will take?
00:02:06.617 --> 00:02:11.277
Mr. Tucker, thank you so much for joining Real Clear Podcast. How are you, sir?
00:02:12.057 --> 00:02:15.397
Fine. Thank you for having me. I'm disappointed that my article on wallpaper
00:02:15.397 --> 00:02:17.417
didn't really take hold. I don't know.
00:02:17.517 --> 00:02:21.577
It didn't really connect with people. And I don't know if I didn't approach it the right way.
00:02:22.237 --> 00:02:27.457
Or maybe I think what happens is that people move into a new apartment or something,
00:02:27.557 --> 00:02:30.037
they hate the wallpaper and then they get mad at it, you know,
00:02:30.237 --> 00:02:32.417
and they turn against wallpaper in general.
00:02:32.597 --> 00:02:35.517
Maybe that's the problem. I didn't really address that in the article.
00:02:36.077 --> 00:02:40.077
Is wallpaper looked at as a sign of antiquity, much like fiscal restraint?
00:02:41.107 --> 00:02:45.267
All right, maybe that's right. Yeah, it was sometime after World War II when
00:02:45.267 --> 00:02:47.027
wallpaper became not a thing.
00:02:47.227 --> 00:02:50.647
When we started getting rid of pretty things, beautiful things,
00:02:51.067 --> 00:02:53.727
stopped decorating our ceilings, certainly, and then the walls,
00:02:53.747 --> 00:02:58.047
and then we just want to paint on them, and it was part of a brutalist fashion.
00:02:58.507 --> 00:03:03.727
And nowadays, people are moving around all the time, and people are renting.
00:03:03.987 --> 00:03:07.547
You don't feel right putting up wallpaper to rent a spot and so on,
00:03:07.687 --> 00:03:11.227
right? So, there's a lot of factors
00:03:11.227 --> 00:03:16.307
here, but designers have told me that wallpaper is making a big return.
00:03:16.467 --> 00:03:22.547
I'm glad for it. I think wallpaper is a thrilling thing, and it's actually tremendously affordable now, too.
00:03:23.287 --> 00:03:28.407
Paint isn't. I wonder if wallpaper is coming back partly as a reflection that
00:03:28.407 --> 00:03:30.587
Americans are trying to anchor more.
00:03:30.747 --> 00:03:35.247
Do you see that? I know there's a rise in single-income formulations of households,
00:03:35.247 --> 00:03:38.687
And I wonder if that could be kind of reflected in a wallpaper scene.
00:03:38.807 --> 00:03:39.707
That would make sense to me.
00:03:39.887 --> 00:03:45.467
My general outlook on all this stuff is that we're going back to pre-Great War
00:03:45.467 --> 00:03:48.747
styles and thinking on everything.
00:03:48.967 --> 00:03:55.447
I think we've been through about a century or more of calamity in art and in
00:03:55.447 --> 00:04:03.807
economics and fiscal policy and architecture and family organization and values and everything.
00:04:03.807 -->
Load full transcript
00:04:08.647
And our times are in such upheaval.
00:04:08.807 --> 00:04:13.487
We're going through such a gigantic paradigm shift. And I think a lot of this
00:04:13.487 --> 00:04:17.707
is prompted by COVID lockdowns, which we talk about that.
00:04:17.867 --> 00:04:23.767
But this is the application of science that imagined that you could have the
00:04:23.767 --> 00:04:29.827
government controlling the microbial kingdom and mastering it with a shot they
00:04:29.827 --> 00:04:33.487
invented two weeks ago. And it didn't work.
00:04:33.807 --> 00:04:39.247
And it seemed to be, I guess, sort of the apotheosis of government planning.
00:04:39.847 --> 00:04:47.787
And it revealed a terrible system of fraudulent experts, of willingness of a
00:04:47.787 --> 00:04:52.487
ruling class to play with our lives in dangerous ways in the name of helping us.
00:04:52.587 --> 00:04:54.927
And so, as a result, that sort of spawned.
00:04:55.709 --> 00:05:04.649
A global sort of incredulity that is leading to political upheaval and cultural change, too,
00:05:05.289 --> 00:05:09.089
and a whole variety of areas, people returning to religion, people returning
00:05:09.089 --> 00:05:13.889
to tradition, figuring out ways to cobble together one-income households and
00:05:13.889 --> 00:05:16.549
so on. I think that all this is connected.
00:05:17.869 --> 00:05:24.369
So, Mr. Tucker, where are we now as an economy in the United States, and where are we headed?
00:05:24.769 --> 00:05:30.329
We've been in recession for almost, well, growing on five years now,
00:05:30.609 --> 00:05:37.169
and all the data is largely fake and barely faked.
00:05:37.369 --> 00:05:45.109
I mean, like once you apply even a moderately realistic version of the CPI to
00:05:45.109 --> 00:05:48.729
output data, we've been in the red now for five years.
00:05:49.389 --> 00:05:57.929
Job markets in terrible shape. The unraveling has been taking place slowly and not all at once.
00:05:58.129 --> 00:06:03.029
You know, the crisis was five years ago, really, and we never really recovered
00:06:03.029 --> 00:06:05.689
from it. So that's sort of where we are.
00:06:05.969 --> 00:06:11.209
Right now, we're seeing job markets sort of, the reality is donning on people.
00:06:11.409 --> 00:06:15.669
The jobs are, you know, high-paying, stay-at-home, remote jobs or whatever are
00:06:15.669 --> 00:06:21.789
no longer really available, as many, many government bureaucrats are discovering now.
00:06:22.089 --> 00:06:29.489
And the calling of the professional management world is picking up pace.
00:06:29.749 --> 00:06:34.609
You notice that all the corporate layoffs that are taking place right now are
00:06:34.609 --> 00:06:37.689
never with customer-facing employees.
00:06:37.689 --> 00:06:41.629
They're all from the C-suites, you know, and the management players.
00:06:41.629 --> 00:06:45.969
But there's so much more to go in all these areas.
00:06:46.129 --> 00:06:51.109
They got bloated up over essentially 20 years of zero interest rate policies
00:06:51.109 --> 00:06:57.609
that massively distorted their production structures and led many, many companies,
00:06:57.989 --> 00:07:02.489
especially those that are floating stocks, to believe that there was just no
00:07:02.489 --> 00:07:04.569
limits. And they threw through.
00:07:05.837 --> 00:07:14.197
All vast numbers of resources to their labor forces and through labor and credentials at every problem.
00:07:14.377 --> 00:07:19.257
And now that's all coming unraveled. The inflation problem, I think,
00:07:19.437 --> 00:07:21.937
has never went away, really.
00:07:22.217 --> 00:07:27.297
And the great challenge of the inflation problem right now is to avoid a second wave.
00:07:27.537 --> 00:07:33.597
And that's always been a danger, you know, to repeat basically what we did in the 1970s.
00:07:33.857 --> 00:07:36.317
I mean, policymakers never learn, right?
00:07:37.177 --> 00:07:39.497
So in the 1970s— What happens if there is a second wave? Sorry,
00:07:39.577 --> 00:07:40.177
you're about to get there.
00:07:40.397 --> 00:07:43.537
Yeah, well, in the 1970s, what happens, we had a first wave,
00:07:43.557 --> 00:07:50.417
and then some interest rate hikes, and then it died down, and the Fed threw a party,
00:07:50.997 --> 00:07:52.497
popped champagne corks, lowered
00:07:52.497 --> 00:07:55.477
interest rates, and then the second wave came, and then that happened.
00:07:55.657 --> 00:08:00.777
Same exact thing happened again, and then it culminated in the third wave that
00:08:00.777 --> 00:08:07.437
ate everybody's savings, disrupted American capital valuations,
00:08:08.017 --> 00:08:12.677
and destroyed the American family, created the two-income household, and so on.
00:08:14.037 --> 00:08:21.657
So we're seeing the same patterns. We unleashed this inflation with crazy stimulus
00:08:21.657 --> 00:08:25.717
payments and zero interest rates after COVID began.
00:08:26.017 --> 00:08:28.657
Then, sure enough, right on track. You know, 12 months later,
00:08:28.717 --> 00:08:30.877
the inflation was here. It got worse and worse. They said, oh,
00:08:30.917 --> 00:08:32.597
it's a chance to, it'll go away. No, it didn't.
00:08:33.057 --> 00:08:37.017
So it got worse and worse and worse until the Fed just finally just panicked
00:08:37.017 --> 00:08:46.057
and did the largest, in the scope of time, the largest increases in history and interest rates.
00:08:46.057 --> 00:08:53.757
And that squeezed the inflation out a little bit, and we began to see it fall
00:08:53.757 --> 00:08:58.677
from essentially double digits down to 3% and 4%.
00:08:58.677 --> 00:09:02.817
We're still 50% to 100% based on targets.
00:09:03.057 --> 00:09:07.397
And then sure enough, the Fed started going, well, maybe we should start lowering
00:09:07.397 --> 00:09:11.737
rates again. And I think they already lowered rates one time,
00:09:11.897 --> 00:09:16.577
but money supply statistics are showing growing
money growth.
00:09:16.697 --> 00:09:22.857
I think we're up $1 trillion in money over the last 12 months or something like that.
00:09:23.077 --> 00:09:31.097
And the Fed has paused more quantitative easing now in light of existing inflation fears.
00:09:31.537 --> 00:09:36.637
But it's only going to get, my read of the situation is that it's going to get.
00:09:37.867 --> 00:09:47.167
And it's not going to get better for at least 12 months, even if we clamp down on Fed easing.
00:09:47.347 --> 00:09:55.927
But you've got the countervailing problem right now of volatility and the velocity of money.
00:09:55.927 --> 00:10:02.687
So, a higher velocity is going to lead to higher inflation given even the same existing money stock.
00:10:03.487 --> 00:10:08.367
And a lower velocity is going to lead to a tamping down of inflation.
00:10:08.727 --> 00:10:12.787
Velocity declined in the last quarter of last year, which is interesting.
00:10:13.047 --> 00:10:16.067
Would you mind telling us what velocity of money is? Yeah, sorry.
00:10:16.187 --> 00:10:19.847
That's just the rate at which people spend it. So, you know,
00:10:19.927 --> 00:10:23.587
if you stuff all your money that you have into your mattress,
00:10:23.847 --> 00:10:26.307
that's kind of like, and everybody has said, that's a zero velocity. That's slow money.
00:10:26.687 --> 00:10:31.447
Yeah, that's zero velocity. But if you're moving it out very fast and buying
00:10:31.447 --> 00:10:35.347
all sorts of new things and maintaining a zero balance for living on credit,
00:10:35.467 --> 00:10:36.587
that's going to be high velocity.
00:10:36.827 --> 00:10:41.167
So, you know, Jeffrey, I'm sorry to interrupt you, but an anecdote there.
00:10:41.267 --> 00:10:45.807
I was just talking with a friend yesterday. In fact, the first person who sent me some of your work,
00:10:45.907 --> 00:10:50.267
and he was describing to me a weird phenomena where he lives in Los Angeles
00:10:50.267 --> 00:10:57.107
where there are people still spending money almost on like the tulip fantasies of yesteryear,
00:10:57.487 --> 00:10:59.807
like at a particularly high-end store,
00:11:00.387 --> 00:11:04.807
a vosed or encased strawberry for $19. dollars.
00:11:05.887 --> 00:11:10.707
Meanwhile, electricians can't buy Romax cable to wire up houses for anything
00:11:10.707 --> 00:11:17.967
less than 300% of what it costs in 2019 and are skimping on prices everywhere they can.
00:11:18.147 --> 00:11:24.927
So we have this strange cultural relationship with money right now while we're in flux.
00:11:25.387 --> 00:11:33.087
Can you say something about what is the American relationship with money right
00:11:33.087 --> 00:11:35.667
now across the level of individuals?
00:11:36.067 --> 00:11:41.987
And then what are Americans going to need to be doing during these next painful 12 months?
00:11:42.807 --> 00:11:48.307
People are in denial right now. I get really worried about when Trump was elected.
00:11:48.767 --> 00:11:54.487
There was many, many people just proclaimed the new golden age.
00:11:54.487 --> 00:11:59.327
You know, and people thought it was going to end inflation like instantly, which you cannot do.
00:12:00.967 --> 00:12:05.147
You can't bring about a golden age instantly by snapping your fingers.
00:12:05.287 --> 00:12:06.767
So there's certain things that have to be done.
00:12:07.962 --> 00:12:11.182
And I can see the Trump administration working towards those,
00:12:11.302 --> 00:12:15.482
but at nowhere near the pace, it's going to be necessary to mitigate against
00:12:15.482 --> 00:12:17.542
the necessary corrections we have to.
00:12:17.922 --> 00:12:21.162
We're dealing with five years of denial, essentially.
00:12:21.902 --> 00:12:24.842
And I'm afraid individuals are in that same position.
00:12:24.982 --> 00:12:28.602
They just think that the money's always been there, so it's always going to
00:12:28.602 --> 00:12:32.202
be there. And that is just simply not true.
00:12:32.862 --> 00:12:39.082
You know, there is a class out there of people that are starting to develop
00:12:39.082 --> 00:12:40.362
a kind of a new frugality.
00:12:40.582 --> 00:12:46.642
There's, you're trending online about a fortnight ago was the thing don't spend in 25.
00:12:47.042 --> 00:12:52.102
It's like, no spend 25. Okay. Well, that's good. And it was saving money and that sort of thing.
00:12:52.242 --> 00:12:57.562
But I don't think that that pertains, you know, culturally, cultural-wide.
00:12:57.902 --> 00:13:02.742
People are still under the impression that this can go on forever. And it clearly can't.
00:13:02.902 --> 00:13:07.322
And the correction, yes, Washington
00:13:07.322 --> 00:13:12.742
is in a panic right now about all the changes that are taking place.
00:13:12.882 --> 00:13:17.182
But when you kind of look at it, it's not been that much.
00:13:17.322 --> 00:13:22.122
This is a beast that needs to be slayed, complaining that his fingernails are
00:13:22.122 --> 00:13:23.982
being cut. It's not real.
00:13:24.602 --> 00:13:31.122
So, and if you have any doubt about it, just look at the budget the House passed last night.
00:13:31.462 --> 00:13:35.602
It's like a joke. It's like nothing happened in November. They're not serious.
00:13:36.002 --> 00:13:37.442
It's a big spending bill, right?
00:13:37.862 --> 00:13:47.182
Big spending and more debt. They're giving cosmetic changes in the tax code.
00:13:47.922 --> 00:13:52.202
It's just not serious. I mean, they need to, you know, look.
00:13:53.802 --> 00:13:57.442
I know what I feel like I need I know what Trump needs to do but he's not going
00:13:57.442 --> 00:13:59.142
to do it but he should he should
00:13:59.462 --> 00:14:02.642
simply say I want a balanced budget I'm not going to say anything but a thoroughly
00:14:02.642 --> 00:14:07.682
balanced budget for next year zero based budgeting next year I want a budget
00:14:07.682 --> 00:14:09.682
balanced that would do it,
00:14:10.182
--> 00:14:14.882
he would in that case probably the Senate would override his veto so he wouldn't
00:14:14.882 --> 00:14:19.242
get it through but at least make it clear that we need some serious action here
00:14:19.242 --> 00:14:23.802
but you know from a from a responsible from a fiscal point of view,
00:14:23.882 --> 00:14:26.422
the idea that you can be cutting taxes right now.
00:14:26.522 --> 00:14:31.702
I'm all for tax cuts, but they have to be sort of earned, I think.
00:14:32.162 --> 00:14:39.022
And Congress is not earning these tax cuts. And we talk about the savings that Doge is doing.
00:14:39.982 --> 00:14:45.822
I wrote in the Wall Street Journal today that Doge has to succeed or else America
00:14:45.822 --> 00:14:47.742
is doomed. And I believe that.
00:14:47.942 --> 00:14:53.562
But they've been stopped by multiple federal judges that have restricted their
00:14:53.562 --> 00:15:00.422
access to the books, and they can't really cut spending outside the executive
00:15:00.422 --> 00:15:02.762
orders that Trump has passed.
00:15:02.942 --> 00:15:07.302
So they're doing their best, but when I saw yesterday Doge bragging about the fact that they've ended.
00:15:08.601 --> 00:15:13.261
Photoshop licenses for Department of Labor employees who are not using them.
00:15:13.541 --> 00:15:15.341
I thought, well, this is getting pathetic.
00:15:15.781 --> 00:15:18.001
I mean, this is not real, you know.
00:15:18.581 --> 00:15:23.301
No, they are an advisory committee, right? Essentially, anything that they present
00:15:23.301 --> 00:15:26.381
has to be ratified by Congress in order to make it into a bill?
00:15:26.741 --> 00:15:32.101
Yeah, well, so this is where the complications come from, because there's a
00:15:32.101 --> 00:15:35.221
question about whether and to what extent the president can actually control
00:15:35.221 --> 00:15:36.421
the executive agencies.
00:15:36.421 --> 00:15:41.341
And that has been at issue now, again, for a better part of 100 years.
00:15:41.561 --> 00:15:43.301
Nobody really knows the answer to that.
00:15:44.001 --> 00:15:47.561
Trump's view is that he takes responsibility for whatever these agencies do.
00:15:47.701 --> 00:15:54.081
Therefore, he should be able to hire and fire from them and change regulations as he sees fit.
00:15:54.381 --> 00:15:59.961
But the real issue concerns the spending itself. Now, there's a long-running
00:15:59.961 --> 00:16:04.941
controversy in American history over this question of executive impoundment.
00:16:05.541 --> 00:16:11.121
And Trump wants to reassert his right to impound the money, which I think is
00:16:11.121 --> 00:16:13.101
correct. That's what Jefferson did in 1800.
00:16:13.401 --> 00:16:16.541
Congress allocated a bunch of money for gunboats in light of,
00:16:16.621 --> 00:16:20.041
it was 1803, I guess, in light of the Louisiana Purchase.
00:16:20.141 --> 00:16:22.701
And Jefferson said, we don't need that, so we refuse to spend the money.
00:16:22.841 --> 00:16:25.181
I mean, that's kind of a good precedent. Like it's.
00:16:25.796 --> 00:16:30.396
I think the correct way to think about this is that Congress gives is the credit
00:16:30.396 --> 00:16:35.536
card issuer and they give the limits, but the president owns the card itself
00:16:35.536 --> 00:16:40.716
and determines what to spend. I have a related question on that.
00:16:41.156 --> 00:16:46.116
Let's pause here. One second, my black lab just pushed open my office door, so I have to close it.
00:16:46.116 --> 00:16:50.196
So, Jeffrey, as you're describing the credit card and the interest rates with
00:16:50.196 --> 00:16:51.976
respect to the executive branch versus Congress,
00:16:52.276 --> 00:16:57.776
a real clear member had suggested that I ask you what your thoughts are on the
00:16:57.776 --> 00:17:01.916
reclamation of gold coming into the United States right now at record numbers.
00:17:01.916 --> 00:17:06.356
I believe the figures that I looked up this morning were 13 million troy ounces.
00:17:06.636 --> 00:17:10.556
For people's reference, that's around 31 ounces of gold coming back into the
00:17:10.556 --> 00:17:12.196
United States just in the month of January.
00:17:12.576 --> 00:17:16.536
Is that related to what you're describing? impounding?
00:17:17.056 --> 00:17:23.016
No, I don't think so. And I would comment on that in more detail,
00:17:23.016 --> 00:17:24.616
but I don't know anything about it.
00:17:24.836 --> 00:17:29.876
I do find it interesting that Trump and Elon are talking about going to Fort
00:17:29.876 --> 00:17:32.076
Knox and to see if the gold's there.
00:17:32.256 --> 00:17:36.556
I mean, this is a long-running kind of dark conspiracy theory that there's no
00:17:36.556 --> 00:17:37.936
gold in Fort Knox, you know.
00:17:38.156 --> 00:17:41.336
Well, there's something more broad going on there.
00:17:41.336 --> 00:17:46.776
Elon's request for emails to federal employees to substantiate what they're
00:17:46.776 --> 00:17:53.336
doing, and then Trump's rationalization of that request, is basically one of finding gold or no gold.
00:17:53.496 --> 00:17:56.556
In other words, is the person there? Does this person exist?
00:17:56.996 --> 00:17:59.016
Is that level of skepticism as to
00:17:59.016 --> 00:18:03.276
the breadth and size of the Federation starship, if I can put it that way?
00:18:03.456 --> 00:18:09.096
And that represents something quite striking about where we're at right now.
00:18:09.096 --> 00:18:14.856
It's almost like this illusory experience of government, of money,
00:18:15.176 --> 00:18:18.256
of roles, of competency, of value.
00:18:19.197 --> 00:18:26.557
Are we in a complete reformation and reworking of the word and concept economics?
00:18:27.637 --> 00:18:32.257
And by that, I mean, I'm framing that in the backdrop of AI is going to put
00:18:32.257 --> 00:18:35.617
a lot of people out of business. It might put me out of business as a psychologist.
00:18:35.797 --> 00:18:40.737
I suspect in two years, you'll be able to talk to an AI bot that probably will be better than me.
00:18:41.417 --> 00:18:44.657
You know, in some ways. I say this all the time as a writer.
00:18:44.657 --> 00:18:51.797
Sometimes I try not to do it, but I'll sometimes pick a topic and then ask Grok about it.
00:18:51.977 --> 00:18:55.657
And Grok will write an essay that I think, wow, I wish I could have written that.
00:18:56.297 --> 00:18:59.097
Sometimes I just drop the topic because it's so intimidating.
00:18:59.937 --> 00:19:06.497
But listen, to go back to your point about the fiscal situation and these jobs.
00:19:07.377 --> 00:19:11.077
Yeah, you're right. Elon was asking for a proof of life.
00:19:11.697 --> 00:19:16.757
Right. And people were taking it as some sort of humiliating request to substantiate
00:19:16.757 --> 00:19:18.777
what you do. Well, you have to do that in the private sector.
00:19:18.957 --> 00:19:22.957
I have to do that to 30 patients every week, by the way. I have to substantiate
00:19:22.957 --> 00:19:25.117
everything I do for 30 hours per week.
00:19:25.237 --> 00:19:30.897
They're watching me making sure that I'm doing my job second by second, not just email weekly.
00:19:31.237 --> 00:19:35.697
So I really didn't have a whole lot of, let's say, heartstrings pulled for the
00:19:35.697 --> 00:19:41.237
employees who took it, who took personal umbrage at wanting to write five things they did last week.
00:19:41.437 --> 00:19:45.097
You know, you have thousands of readers, tens of thousands, I assume,
00:19:45.437 --> 00:19:48.897
making sure you're doing your job as an essayist at the Ebbuk Times.
00:19:49.117 --> 00:19:53.117
Every time you write, I have patience staring at me, adoringly,
00:19:53.177 --> 00:19:55.557
I must say, making sure that I am competent.
00:19:55.857 --> 00:19:58.097
And so, but he wasn't even doing that.
00:19:58.737 --> 00:20:01.797
He was literally saying, and I'm not defending the initiative,
00:20:01.957 --> 00:20:06.777
I'm just pointing out that he wanted to know, Do these people exist?
00:20:07.437 --> 00:20:11.437
Yeah, that's the problem that they're dealing with.
00:20:11.597 --> 00:20:15.577
So Doge has gone about this in a very systematic way. After the...
00:20:17.019 --> 00:20:21.159
After Trump took the oath of office, there was a whole series of parties who
00:20:21.159 --> 00:20:27.079
went and cut cakes and went to dance and did some performative signings of executive orders and so on,
00:20:27.139 --> 00:20:32.879
and basically engaged in a series of distractions until 2 a.m., during which time,
00:20:33.039 --> 00:20:35.519
Doge had entered into the U.S.
00:20:35.639 --> 00:20:38.919
Treasury Building and gone up to the space
00:20:38.919 --> 00:20:43.719
occupied by the fiscal assistant secretary and his handful of civil servants
00:20:43.719 --> 00:20:51.819
that have controlled the outgoing payment systems since 1939 without any oversight
00:20:51.819 --> 00:20:56.519
from any Secretary of Treasury or any election president or any of their appointees.
00:20:56.759 --> 00:21:03.739
This has gone on for, you know, 85 years, and nobody has really been able to
00:21:03.739 --> 00:21:06.799
audit the books or see who's being paid what.
00:21:07.019 --> 00:21:10.099
And since those times, more
00:21:10.099 --> 00:21:15.459
than $200 trillion have flown out of that spigot that nobody has been able to
00:21:15.459 --> 00:21:24.339
monitor outside a tiny group of a small little tiny cartel or just a handful
00:21:24.339 --> 00:21:27.539
of people raised in the Treasury system.
00:21:27.999 --> 00:21:31.679
So this is the first time that that had ever been breached, and the headlines
00:21:31.679 --> 00:21:34.399
in the next day were screaming about it, you know.
00:21:34.899 --> 00:21:41.219
And they fired the fiscal assistant secretary, who has always been chosen by
00:21:41.219 --> 00:21:43.679
the Secretary of Treasury, but not really.
00:21:43.839 --> 00:21:48.139
It's chosen from within the bureaucracy, and it's not subject to any kind of cynic confirmation.
00:21:48.399 --> 00:21:52.799
There have been 15 of them since 1939, and you've never heard of a single one of them.
00:21:52.999 --> 00:21:56.699
So they, for the very first time, fired the guy and replaced him with.
00:21:58.322 --> 00:22:02.702
I forget his name now, but he's a good entrepreneur and experienced businessman
00:22:02.702 --> 00:22:05.082
who's in that position now.
00:22:06.682 --> 00:22:11.582
But federal judges immediately began to restrict Doge's access.
00:22:11.862 --> 00:22:15.902
So as of today, they still don't really have access to these payment portals.
00:22:16.162 --> 00:22:21.482
And now they've been restricted on auditing Department of Education, Department of Labor.
00:22:21.702 --> 00:22:24.862
There's all these agencies that they want to get an audit, but they're being
00:22:24.862 --> 00:22:29.602
restricted by federal judges. So we still don't know actually what's going on.
00:22:29.742 --> 00:22:35.242
So faced with this frustration, they're trying to cut whatever they can.
00:22:35.462 --> 00:22:39.362
You know, they're following Trump's executive orders like no DEI.
00:22:39.542 --> 00:22:43.962
So they scramble through, use AI to find any DEI or, you know,
00:22:44.122 --> 00:22:47.122
related contracts and cancels those.
00:22:48.502 --> 00:22:52.922
And otherwise, there's very specific things that they're canceling within the
00:22:52.922 --> 00:22:57.862
agencies and saving some amount of money. But you're right, they don't really
00:22:57.862 --> 00:23:01.062
have power over spending, really, not yet.
00:23:01.762 --> 00:23:05.502
And the biggest problem is they don't have audit access.
00:23:05.782 --> 00:23:08.962
You know, they can't really figure out what's going on with these agencies.
00:23:09.042 --> 00:23:15.142
And the federal judges are stopping them from having
access.
00:23:15.302 --> 00:23:16.982
So I don't know what we're going to discover.
00:23:17.182 --> 00:23:20.902
This is part of what's driving Elon crazy right now.
00:23:21.282 --> 00:23:24.982
He doesn't really know what's going on. And he's suspicious.
00:23:25.842 --> 00:23:31.382
He's a bit of a conspiratorial mindset anyway. But after he went to Twitter, you remember...
00:23:32.656 --> 00:23:37.636
He discovered that almost the entire payroll was fake. You're right. I remember that, yeah.
00:23:37.836 --> 00:23:41.556
And he asked people to. And it was federal governments running the thing that,
00:23:41.576 --> 00:23:43.356
you know, the thing was bloated beyond belief.
00:23:43.496 --> 00:23:46.796
Nobody actually did anything that had made changes in the code except to restrict
00:23:46.796 --> 00:23:49.616
and censor their own users. It was insane.
00:23:49.836 --> 00:23:54.676
So that kind of traumatized him. So now he's feeling like this was going on
00:23:54.676 --> 00:24:00.476
at Twitter, a private company with a public-facing stock and every incentive
00:24:00.476 --> 00:24:04.576
to serve their users and advertisers.
00:24:04.976 --> 00:24:08.276
What could be going on a government where there's no oversight,
00:24:08.436 --> 00:24:12.756
no audits, no elected officials seeing the books since 1939?
00:24:13.376 --> 00:24:17.016
What is really going on? So, that's what he's really up to.
00:24:17.176 --> 00:24:24.816
He's trying to figure out strategies to test the extent of the corruption and
00:24:24.816 --> 00:24:28.096
the depth of the scandal, possibly,
00:24:28.636 --> 00:24:32.276
in federal spending. And he's having a hard time doing it.
00:24:32.876 --> 00:24:37.976
For one thing, he's the first person who's tried since World War II.
00:24:38.416 --> 00:24:42.596
Was Simpson Bowles, but that was a bit different. That was a sort of watered-down version of this, yes?
00:24:43.236 --> 00:24:47.136
What year was that? But Simpson-Bulls was 2010 under Barack Obama.
00:24:47.296 --> 00:24:49.656
That was the Government Efficiency Commission.
00:24:49.896 --> 00:24:53.936
They ended up, yeah, they ironically proved themselves ineffective and couldn't
00:24:53.936 --> 00:24:56.796
agree on their stated aims and had to disband.
00:24:57.196 --> 00:25:00.696
Oh, listen, you know, and going back to the Grace Commission in the 1980s,
00:25:00.776 --> 00:25:03.296
which is just a big report, oh, here's what you should do.
00:25:03.676 --> 00:25:07.636
We don't have a lack of plans. What we have is a lack of knowledge, you know.
00:25:08.936 --> 00:25:13.676
I've made this analogy. And the reason they can't grant access is always the
00:25:13.676 --> 00:25:17.116
same. And they say, well, we've got security of the data to consider.
00:25:17.216 --> 00:25:19.316
We've got proprietary stuff here.
00:25:20.096 --> 00:25:22.956
These people haven't been properly trained and so on and so on.
00:25:23.036 --> 00:25:28.356
This is all these reasons are exactly the same reasons that Bernie Madoff used
00:25:28.356 --> 00:25:33.656
for decades to keep people out of the trading desk and keep them out of the books.
00:25:33.776 --> 00:25:36.496
They said, oh, but we have proprietary strategies here.
00:25:36.636 --> 00:25:40.096
We have to secure our customer data and so on. This is highly suspicious.
00:25:40.376 --> 00:25:43.296
So it turned out in the Bernie Madoff case, there was no money. There was no money.
00:25:43.296 --> 00:25:50.036
He was using new money to pay returns on the old money, and it was a big Ponzi
00:25:50.036 --> 00:25:55.436
scheme and used extremely intimidating tactics to keep people from finding this
00:25:55.436 --> 00:25:57.296
out. And it worked for decades.
00:25:58.574 --> 00:26:04.414
Well, I'm just suspicious, as is Elon, that something very similar is going on with the Treasury.
00:26:04.594 --> 00:26:06.554
You know, where are they getting the money and who are they paying it to?
00:26:06.634 --> 00:26:09.514
These are the only two questions you have to ask about any institution.
00:26:10.134 --> 00:26:14.434
Where does money come from and where is it going, right? And if you don't have
00:26:14.434 --> 00:26:20.034
answers to that, it opens up possibilities of fraud and abuse and lies and corruption.
00:26:20.734 --> 00:26:25.354
That's why we have audits. That's why we have transparency. That's all that
00:26:25.354 --> 00:26:29.834
Elon's trying to bring to the government, and this is the source of outrage
00:26:29.834 --> 00:26:32.534
and scandal and screaming. It's weird.
00:26:33.254 --> 00:26:37.474
In terms of the outrage, I'm curious to get your perspective on this.
00:26:37.634 --> 00:26:39.014
We're both behaviorists in a way.
00:26:39.834 --> 00:26:44.334
Economics, I think, could be categorized as a form of behaviorism.
00:26:44.654 --> 00:26:49.774
And as a psychologist, I'm looking at people scared and, as you say, screaming and so forth.
00:26:49.974 --> 00:26:55.094
And I'm wondering, is there a way that Doge could have been presented and be
00:26:55.094 --> 00:27:01.754
presented in a more subtle fashion? Why the need for the chrome chainsaws, right?
00:27:01.894 --> 00:27:08.734
Why the need for the, you know, WWE style glasses and the trench coats and the
00:27:08.734 --> 00:27:11.374
hats and rather than sit down at a desk,
00:27:12.014 --> 00:27:15.414
appear like someone's wise father or something,
00:27:15.754 --> 00:27:18.554
speak in a reasonable, you know, do the things you're doing,
00:27:18.814 --> 00:27:23.594
but do them in a way that doesn't alarm the pigeons who, when one pigeon lands
00:27:23.594 --> 00:27:29.794
on a rooftop, they all go, you know, and why not avoid that kind of chain reaction?
00:27:30.074 --> 00:27:33.194
I wonder why they didn't do that. I don't know if you have any thoughts on that.
00:27:33.694 --> 00:27:34.954
Yeah, there's two reasons.
00:27:35.514 --> 00:27:41.874
Yeah, there's two
reasons. I mean, one is that people have been trying to control
00:27:41.874 --> 00:27:46.394
this beast for a long time and nobody's ever been able to succeed at it.
00:27:46.414 --> 00:27:49.214
So they had to try something completely different. That's the reason for it.
00:27:49.434 --> 00:27:54.754
It's a shock and awe. And the reason for all the performative antics and the
00:27:54.754 --> 00:27:59.374
posting of examples of terrible things, oh, we're supporting.
00:28:00.726 --> 00:28:06.586
Drag queen shows in Haiti or whatever, gender transitions in Afghanistan,
00:28:06.606 --> 00:28:07.346
whatever they're doing.
00:28:07.646 --> 00:28:14.746
This is to generate public support for Doge because they believe that the only
00:28:14.746 --> 00:28:21.326
real, that they have to move fast and they have to outwit and outsmart the establishment on one hand.
00:28:21.406 --> 00:28:26.846
On the other hand, their only real base of support, the thing that gives them
00:28:26.846 --> 00:28:33.766
energy and power over the system is going to be generating a kind of a public
00:28:33.766 --> 00:28:35.046
support for what they're doing.
00:28:35.446 --> 00:28:42.686
And so that's the reason for all this stuff. And they would love to just go
00:28:42.686 --> 00:28:46.786
about this system with the Sirioso, put on the suits,
00:28:47.286 --> 00:28:50.986
go through all the channels and stuff. But that's not how Washington works, and they know that.
00:28:51.146 --> 00:28:56.246
That's not how Trump won either, by the way. You know, he won with the McDonald's
00:28:56.246 --> 00:29:00.026
thing, taking out the trash and, you know, his antics and stuff.
00:29:00.206 --> 00:29:08.266
So this stuff, this kind of cultural capital that drove Trump into office is extremely valuable.
00:29:08.986 --> 00:29:14.226
And this is what Musk and Doge are trying to do right now. I mean, is it going to backfire?
00:29:14.526 --> 00:29:19.146
I mean, maybe. I mean, I think among the haute bourgeoisie, like you and I,
00:29:19.266 --> 00:29:23.046
we kind of think it's kind of tacky, you know, and we wish it were otherwise.
00:29:23.346 --> 00:29:30.326
But we also, it's not, you and I are not in there fighting the fight in Washington right now.
00:29:30.466 --> 00:29:36.846
And I can just tell you from talking to many, many people at what we think of
00:29:36.846 --> 00:29:41.926
as being the highest levels in Washington, they will all tell you that their
00:29:41.926 --> 00:29:43.666
only real power is public opinion.
00:29:45.046 --> 00:29:51.166
It's people like you and me and our friends and neighbors and communities cheering them on.
00:29:51.446 --> 00:29:55.186
That is the only source of their power going up against this leviathan state.
00:29:55.426 --> 00:29:57.806
Without that, they're just nothing.
00:29:58.827 --> 00:30:05.587
Jeffrey, are we going to be able to return to an economics and a world where
00:30:05.587 --> 00:30:12.027
material reality backs the
concept of value? Or are we lost into the obscurity
00:30:12.027 --> 00:30:13.467
of representational value?
00:30:13.807 --> 00:30:21.047
It depends on your assessment of how bad the situation is.
00:30:21.227 --> 00:30:26.267
And this is, again, what Musk is trying to find out. We don't actually know
00:30:26.267 --> 00:30:30.067
the answer to that. The debt is incomprehensibly gigantic.
00:30:30.407 --> 00:30:33.207
The amount of fakery that's out there is incredible.
00:30:34.067 --> 00:30:37.827
You know, this was all exposed during the lockdowns. It's like,
00:30:37.987 --> 00:30:41.827
okay, so let's shut down the economy and pay everybody to stay home.
00:30:42.067 --> 00:30:45.647
And then a third of the workforce just languished at home in their pajamas,
00:30:45.847 --> 00:30:52.587
streaming movies for two and three years, and with no real disruption in their income.
00:30:53.247 --> 00:30:56.507
That would seem to me to almost disable a person.
00:30:56.967 --> 00:31:02.347
So another question that we'll get into is, is our workforce kind of disabled from that?
00:31:02.587 --> 00:31:10.147
Yeah, I think so. Well, generally, the belief that you have to work to obtain
00:31:10.147 --> 00:31:13.427
income and provide value in to get value out,
00:31:13.627 --> 00:31:17.527
that sort of, or understanding what is valuable and what is not,
00:31:17.707 --> 00:31:20.967
that has been declining for decades and decades and decades.
00:31:20.967 --> 00:31:25.247
But during COVID, it just became, you know, the ultimate absurd thing where
00:31:25.247 --> 00:31:28.567
you imagine that a third of the workforce could, you know, could live like,
00:31:28.647 --> 00:31:33.627
you know, lords and ladies and the English aristocracy in the 1890s or something.
00:31:33.767 --> 00:31:35.687
It was just, it was just absurd.
00:31:36.427 --> 00:31:41.367
And the more you dig into this, the more you discover that vast amounts of the
00:31:41.367 --> 00:31:43.547
white collar workforce doesn't believe it has to work at all.
00:31:43.967 --> 00:31:45.227
They don't even know what that means.
00:31:47.707 --> 00:31:49.847
What metrics do you have in mind there as you say that?
00:31:50.788 --> 00:31:53.408
Is there some sort of survey data that you're relying on? Yeah,
00:31:53.528 --> 00:31:56.368
yeah, but there's this back center, disgruntlement.
00:31:56.568 --> 00:32:01.748
I mean, look at the number of books that have come out in the last 10 years about bullshit jobs.
00:32:01.928 --> 00:32:05.328
I hate my boss. I don't do anything at the workplace.
00:32:06.228 --> 00:32:11.488
The amount of litigation that takes place in workplaces right now,
00:32:11.568 --> 00:32:15.468
this is just a result of idle hands doing the devil's work.
00:32:15.628 --> 00:32:18.828
That's all it is. Well, you can't fire anybody anymore. It's not possible.
00:32:18.828 --> 00:32:22.068
You can't fire anybody. And so you have to, you know, put them on a performance
00:32:22.068 --> 00:32:23.908
improvement plan or whatever the kind of thing is.
00:32:24.328 --> 00:32:28.648
And the workplace has become this legal minefield where everybody's ready to
00:32:28.648 --> 00:32:29.888
sue everybody else. Why?
00:32:30.108 --> 00:32:32.528
Because they don't have anything to do. This is the problem.
00:32:32.808 --> 00:32:36.808
So everybody's just living in a cushy world and they don't want anybody to look
00:32:36.808 --> 00:32:41.788
cross-eyed at them because they think that the company is their family.
00:32:42.248 --> 00:32:47.548
It's like the private sector has become this giant welfare state of its own.
00:32:47.548 --> 00:32:50.968
Are you lighting so many fires in my mind where we could go so many different
00:32:50.968 --> 00:32:54.448
directions, you know, like as I think about what you're saying,
00:32:54.668 --> 00:32:57.328
it's one of the reasons why I have a solo psychology practice.
00:32:57.488 --> 00:32:59.028
I wouldn't hire anybody.
00:32:59.408 --> 00:33:02.628
Who would hire anybody during a culture?
00:33:03.008 --> 00:33:09.568
So as, as what you're describing, my hats off to employers. No, and I feel bad.
00:33:10.008 --> 00:33:16.108
For a lot of people, the stay-in orders were relief because they hate the offices
00:33:16.108 --> 00:33:23.288
because the office is just a minefield of human relations, relation disasters, you know?
00:33:23.448 --> 00:33:28.308
They can't stand HR lording over them all the time, reporting to bosses who
00:33:28.308 --> 00:33:30.068
report to other bosses who report to other bosses.
00:33:30.168 --> 00:33:33.628
Nobody's actually doing anything. The amount of fakery that's existed in the
00:33:33.628 --> 00:33:35.308
corporate world is huge.
00:33:35.448 --> 00:33:40.688
And it's created a kind of a class of chasms in this country.
00:33:40.828 --> 00:33:45.948
Like, especially when, you know, the government, through the agency called CISA,
00:33:46.088 --> 00:33:48.968
decided to break the workforce into essential and non-essential.
00:33:49.228 --> 00:33:52.728
And these were interesting, non-essential and essential. These are interesting
00:33:52.728 --> 00:33:58.228
categories because within the category of essential, you had essentially the
00:33:58.228 --> 00:34:01.028
entire white-collar professional managerial class.
00:34:01.208 --> 00:34:06.388
Okay, if you work in media or you work in medicine or if you work in education
00:34:06.388 --> 00:34:09.648
systems, those were all essential.
00:34:10.348 --> 00:34:14.008
Those people could stay home with their laptops, but they would continue to
00:34:14.008 --> 00:34:20.828
get paid, okay? then the other essential class of workers were the people that
00:34:20.828 --> 00:34:22.488
the intellectuals imagined.
00:34:23.367 --> 00:34:28.007
Were necessary to serve this ruling class segment.
00:34:28.287 --> 00:34:31.847
So it was the people delivering groceries, the people running the grocery stores,
00:34:32.047 --> 00:34:36.907
the nurses at the hospitals, the people with fixture plumbing, or grass, or whatever.
00:34:37.127 --> 00:34:44.947
They were declared essential, along with the higher realms of the professional
00:34:44.947 --> 00:34:47.247
ruling class, professional managerial class.
00:34:47.427 --> 00:34:53.687
So what was excluded? There's this entire middle third that consisted of people
00:34:53.687 --> 00:34:55.747
that nobody thinks are valuable at all.
00:34:55.827 --> 00:35:00.707
Even the people who are doing nails, cut your hair, preach the sermons, you know, like that.
00:35:00.867 --> 00:35:06.587
I mean, just sort of what you would call the, what we used to call the bourgeoisie, right?
00:35:07.007 --> 00:35:10.067
I mean, this was central planning. Small business owners, servers,
00:35:10.467 --> 00:35:13.567
bartenders, accountants, and so on.
00:35:13.667 --> 00:35:18.207
I mean, they were all just like, we can do without you for as long as necessary,
00:35:18.387 --> 00:35:22.147
really into the election. Then, until everybody got the shot and so on.
00:35:23.267 --> 00:35:26.647
Central planning doesn't quite describe it. It was grim. And what it did was
00:35:26.647 --> 00:35:29.487
it set off a kind of a class war.
00:35:30.407 --> 00:35:35.547
And so you had the working classes hating the laptop classes and the service
00:35:35.547 --> 00:35:37.227
sector hating everyone.
00:35:38.447 --> 00:35:46.947
And this continues to this day. And what happened was that that has sent our
00:35:46.947 --> 00:35:50.707
normal assumptions about politics into upheaval.
00:35:50.927 --> 00:35:55.907
So even though the lockdowns began under Trump, Trump began to oppose them quite
00:35:55.907 --> 00:36:01.267
early on, and he became sort of the champion of opening up.
00:36:01.267 --> 00:36:06.727
And then Biden took power, usually at one time representing the sort of working-class
00:36:06.727 --> 00:36:11.407
interests, are now suddenly forcing shots on everybody.
00:36:11.407 --> 00:36:14.967
And there's a great deal of hatred that rose up around that to the point that
00:36:14.967 --> 00:36:18.567
Trump's base of support is mostly working class.
00:36:18.767 --> 00:36:21.507
And people assume this.
00:36:21.747 --> 00:36:25.007
It was a funny thing that happened a couple of days ago. I was like.
00:36:25.825 --> 00:36:30.505
Rounding the corner. And yeah, I was wearing a suit. I had on a wool overcoat
00:36:30.505 --> 00:36:34.705
and a top hat or not a top hat, but like a driver's hat or something.
00:36:34.925 --> 00:36:38.165
And I heard two people talking and they were talking politics.
00:36:38.365 --> 00:36:41.685
And I kind of stood there for a second listening. They were denouncing Biden,
00:36:41.845 --> 00:36:46.945
denouncing policy, denouncing the mainstream media, raging against Chuck Schumer
00:36:46.945 --> 00:36:51.945
or whatever, praising Musk and praising Trump. And it was kind of making me laugh.
00:36:52.425 --> 00:36:56.405
And so I rounded the corner. And as soon as they saw me, they climbed up.
00:36:56.665 --> 00:37:01.325
There's two working-class guys standing around a truck talking like this.
00:37:01.465 --> 00:37:04.685
As soon as they saw me, they didn't have to look at each other.
00:37:04.785 --> 00:37:05.645
They both immediately went.
00:37:06.105 --> 00:37:11.365
They assume that you're of a different echelon class, like an Arian person. Yeah, of course.
00:37:12.265 --> 00:37:15.245
A blue-pilled, you know, ruling class guy.
00:37:15.685 --> 00:37:20.385
And they just stopped talking. And they're just like pretending as if to admire
00:37:20.385 --> 00:37:22.105
the weather and look around, you know.
00:37:22.665 --> 00:37:25.085
And waited for me to pass by.
00:37:25.965 --> 00:37:32.365
You know, I thought, there it is. You know, there's the class divisions that
00:37:32.365 --> 00:37:35.905
have been unleashed, and those things don't get healed right away.
00:37:36.105 --> 00:37:41.145
I'm so concerned about this, especially as we have people scurrying around the
00:37:41.145 --> 00:37:47.685
earth to carry bags of food to us, you know, at the behest of their technological overlords.
00:37:48.025 --> 00:37:53.125
We have people, you know, Instacart shoppers. I mean, we really have pressed
00:37:53.125 --> 00:37:56.825
down the American person into a subservient role.
00:37:57.025 --> 00:37:59.125
It breaks my heart, Jeffrey.
00:37:59.985 --> 00:38:05.985
And the entire opinion-making classes in the upper echelons have dehumanized
00:38:05.985 --> 00:38:11.825
and disregarded and robbed of dignity everybody lower than them.
00:38:11.905 --> 00:38:15.965
And routinely, so much so they don't even know they're doing it.
00:38:15.965 --> 00:38:22.245
And so for years, the New York Times ran a thing that said what you should do
00:38:22.245 --> 00:38:24.165
about COVID, put in your zip code.
00:38:24.565 --> 00:38:28.145
So you type in your zip code and they would generate instructions like some
00:38:28.145 --> 00:38:31.485
goofy gamification of lockdowns, right?
00:38:31.625 --> 00:38:34.385
And so put in your zip code and it tells you what to do.
00:38:34.565 --> 00:38:41.525
And the first instruction was always stay home and order your groceries to be delivered.
00:38:42.805 --> 00:38:50.565
Well, that is a very revealing statement, because delivered by whom was never
00:38:50.565 --> 00:38:56.845
addressed, just as if they just get delivered by subhumans directly.
00:38:58.224 --> 00:39:02.204
Warm bodies somewhere. The servant class. The servant class.
00:39:02.324 --> 00:39:05.284
They know for sure that these people are not reading the New York Times.
00:39:05.464 --> 00:39:08.544
There's a presumption of that statement that everybody who's reading the New
00:39:08.544 --> 00:39:14.004
York Times is among the ruling class, stay at home, type on your computer,
00:39:14.224 --> 00:39:19.064
stare at a screen, juggle
your mouse class, right? That's embedded in that statement, too.
00:39:19.864 --> 00:39:23.444
And I'm sure that, you know, it takes a long time to construct those sort of
00:39:23.444 --> 00:39:27.004
machines online for the New York Times. It was whoever did it and whoever wrote
00:39:27.004 --> 00:39:28.644
it and they lived there for two years.
00:39:28.924 --> 00:39:32.284
It never occurred to them that there was something strange about this.
00:39:32.524 --> 00:39:36.664
They just presumed it. This sounds like, well, a number of things,
00:39:36.824 --> 00:39:41.424
but that the country and large swaths of the population were engaged in a kind
00:39:41.424 --> 00:39:44.444
of economic masturbation.
00:39:45.004 --> 00:39:48.364
Nothing was produced. Nothing was relational. Nothing was transactional.
00:39:48.524 --> 00:39:53.124
There was a sort of microcosm within which the computing class existed.
00:39:53.744 --> 00:39:58.444
Now we're faced with the question of, are they kind of disabled after having
00:39:58.444 --> 00:40:01.624
not really worked for three years? Well, they certainly are.
00:40:01.884 --> 00:40:05.384
They certainly are. This is one of the reasons why most public sector workers
00:40:05.384 --> 00:40:07.344
did not take the deal to resign immediately.
00:40:07.664 --> 00:40:10.684
They expected 10% to take eight months severance.
00:40:11.704 --> 00:40:15.604
Instead, it was more like 3%. Okay, now it's possible they didn't get the email.
00:40:15.744 --> 00:40:18.904
It's possible they don't exist, right? That's part of last suspicion.
00:40:19.184 --> 00:40:22.364
But it's also... Sorry, but it's hard to interrupt you. But another option could
00:40:22.364 --> 00:40:25.484
be that they also are worried about the, what your words are,
00:40:25.624 --> 00:40:28.484
a coming storm, and they don't want to depart with stable income.
00:40:29.344 --> 00:40:31.544
That's right. And they don't even know if they could get a job.
00:40:31.724 --> 00:40:35.124
They might not even know what it means to face a job marketplace.
00:40:35.864 --> 00:40:39.564
I've talked to several of these people that said, well, I'm not going to leave
00:40:39.564 --> 00:40:40.424
here because I don't even know.
00:40:40.564 --> 00:40:45.204
What do I do? Go to Indeed.com, you know, and scroll through job ads?
00:40:46.044 --> 00:40:49.444
Well, most of those are fake. You know, they're not real.
00:40:49.644 --> 00:40:53.304
So how do you get it? How do you apply for a job anyway?
00:40:53.484 --> 00:40:58.664
These people, they don't have any clue about having basic skills and how to
00:40:58.664 --> 00:41:00.744
navigate the real world.
00:41:00.844 --> 00:41:03.744
And in a sense, institutionalized for a long time.
00:41:04.064 --> 00:41:06.884
Yeah, and I would say this is true not just in the public sector,
00:41:06.964 --> 00:41:07.884
the private sector, too.
00:41:08.404 --> 00:41:13.844
And this went on for like 20, 25 years, really, since the turn of the millennium.
00:41:14.644 --> 00:41:19.344
The path to success in the United States has been to stay in school long enough
00:41:19.344 --> 00:41:27.424
for a very long time, never work, get your credential from a fancy university in a particular field,
00:41:27.784 --> 00:41:31.944
be hired into first an internship and then to a large company,
00:41:32.124 --> 00:41:39.024
and then collect your six figures and do nothing except brandish your credentials
00:41:39.024 --> 00:41:45.304
and hang around with other people in your class.
00:41:45.644 --> 00:41:53.124
And this has gone on for two generations now, and this is not sustainable. It is not sustainable.
00:41:54.309 --> 00:41:59.049
Jeffrey, you have written about what you call the coming storm economically,
00:41:59.389 --> 00:42:02.409
and I'd like to, or at least you've referenced such a thing,
00:42:02.589 --> 00:42:05.649
and I'd like to get your thoughts on the coming storm.
00:42:06.189 --> 00:42:10.929
Yeah, I think in a funny way, the storm has been with us already for five years.
00:42:11.089 --> 00:42:15.869
We're just unwilling to recognize it. We're living in a sort of a strange state of unreality right now.
00:42:16.929 --> 00:42:21.269
But at some point, it's going to become ever more real.
00:42:21.409 --> 00:42:24.229
I mean, for a lot of people, it is becoming real right now. Like,
00:42:24.589 --> 00:42:27.729
you know, for the 1,200 people fired from Starbucks management,
00:42:28.249 --> 00:42:31.069
two days ago, it's become more real.
00:42:31.249 --> 00:42:36.929
For really, a few hundred thousand public sector workers, it's becoming real.
00:42:36.989 --> 00:42:40.349
And this is going on more and more.
00:42:40.469 --> 00:42:44.269
But I think this is going to be the next, this is going to continue to unfold
00:42:44.269 --> 00:42:45.549
for the next five or 10 years.
00:42:45.929 --> 00:42:51.969
I don't think inflation is going to be tamed anytime soon. So our standard of
00:42:51.969 --> 00:42:53.829
living is going to continue to decline.
00:42:54.729 --> 00:43:00.569
I'm worried that the Trump administration is not acting fast enough to mitigate
00:43:00.569 --> 00:43:03.669
against these winds that are blowing
00:43:03.669 --> 00:43:10.089
against the possibilities of economic growth and the growth of debt.
00:43:10.969 --> 00:43:17.529
So I think I'm fully expecting this to get worse. There is a way out,
00:43:17.709 --> 00:43:20.829
but I just don't, Congress is not interested in it.
00:43:21.129 --> 00:43:24.289
Well, I'm not sure the American people are either. Tell me if this metaphor
00:43:24.289 --> 00:43:27.629
is apt, that the difference between the, broadly,
00:43:27.809 --> 00:43:31.769
the difference between the Democrat perspective on our economic situation versus
00:43:31.769 --> 00:43:36.249
the, what you might call the Trumpian perspective is, the Democrats were basically
00:43:36.249 --> 00:43:37.949
opining to the American
people and saying,
00:43:38.329 --> 00:43:41.949
let's keep pushing the illusion a little further down the road.
00:43:42.449 --> 00:43:46.709
We're we're not going to knock the stilts out from the cabin on the beach let's
00:43:46.709 --> 00:43:50.849
just kind of take some sand and keep patching it up and propping it up and we'll
00:43:50.849 --> 00:43:52.489
keep on going the way we're going,
00:43:53.029 --> 00:43:57.509
and trump is coming in and taking a sledgehammer and he's going nope and he's
00:43:57.509 --> 00:44:02.029
knocking the pillar out from the cabin and it's slowly teetering and that's
00:44:02.029 --> 00:44:06.189
where we are and it's going to crash down onto the seabed yeah and americans
00:44:06.189 --> 00:44:11.009
are i think some americans are going hey i don't know if i I want to see what's behind Oz's curtain.
00:44:11.689 --> 00:44:15.789
And some Americans are saying, no, no, no, no, this has been very scary.
00:44:15.789 --> 00:44:19.789
I've known it's all nonsense behind there. Rip it out. Is that an apt metaphor?
00:44:20.209 --> 00:44:27.949
I think it's fine. My biggest worry right now is that I think that the Trump
00:44:27.949 --> 00:44:30.289
partisans have oversold Trump.
00:44:30.804 --> 00:44:37.604
His Midas touch, you know, this celebration that you saw on Inauguration Day
00:44:37.604 --> 00:44:40.964
that the new golden age is here, this worries me. He even said that.
00:44:41.564 --> 00:44:45.784
He did. He did. And it worries me because there's just a lot of work to do.
00:44:46.004 --> 00:44:48.504
I don't think we're going to get out of this for a very long time.
00:44:48.744 --> 00:44:53.304
We're not out of recession. It's possible that it's going to get worse.
00:44:53.304 --> 00:44:58.024
Here's the other thing that's interesting is, you know, the dynamics of media
00:44:58.024 --> 00:45:02.044
coverage of economic affairs have dramatically changed in the last month,
00:45:02.144 --> 00:45:05.764
of course, because for the previous four years, you know,
00:45:06.004 --> 00:45:10.004
all the media was downplaying the problems.
00:45:10.004 --> 00:45:13.664
Like, oh, inflation's cooling, the job market's really strong,
00:45:13.984 --> 00:45:18.624
output is up, and this has just been this constant prattle, even though it's
00:45:18.624 --> 00:45:23.344
really been true. Jeffrey, personal story though.
00:45:23.524 --> 00:45:26.264
That's how I came upon you, by the way. I forgot to lead off with that.
00:45:27.504 --> 00:45:35.184
Interestingly enough, last summer, last July, July, I had this feeling that
00:45:35.184 --> 00:45:39.384
things were really, really screwed up, like instantaneously.
00:45:39.504 --> 00:45:44.284
I was noticing behaviors in people, financial unreliability.
00:45:44.504 --> 00:45:49.504
I was noticing a shakiness in the marketplaces around me, just locally.
00:45:49.944 --> 00:45:55.184
Something was off, and I'm used to tapping into that psychologically, given my profession.
00:45:55.544 --> 00:46:01.344
And yet I would look on the economic news sites and listen to the administration's
00:46:01.344 --> 00:46:05.744
ponderings on it, and everyone was saying, it's all fine. It's all fine.
00:46:06.244 --> 00:46:11.464
And then a colleague sent me your article where you said, no, no, no.
00:46:11.864 --> 00:46:16.084
We've been in a recession since July. This was about two months after I had that experience.
00:46:16.224 --> 00:46:21.444
And it was very grounding for me, much like patients of mine who are contained
00:46:21.444 --> 00:46:26.564
and actually grounded by hearing reality, even if it's not a desirable one,
00:46:26.724 --> 00:46:27.724
they want to hear the truth.
00:46:27.944 --> 00:46:32.244
I read your article and went, that's it. And it was July.
00:46:33.577 --> 00:46:37.477
Yeah, you know, and you have to know how to read the data to understand.
00:46:37.577 --> 00:46:42.497
One thing, labor market data has been very confusing and contradictory.
00:46:42.997 --> 00:46:48.077
There's a growing gap between the two survey sources that are irreconcilable.
00:46:48.337 --> 00:46:52.957
The other strange thing I began to notice is the figures that were released
00:46:52.957 --> 00:46:58.057
three months ago kept being revised backwards to the point that everything they, it's a strange.
00:46:58.237 --> 00:47:02.377
They had this like movie target. There was always another 600,000 jobs being created.
00:47:03.017 --> 00:47:06.757
Then when the new 600,000 jobs were being created last month,
00:47:06.957 --> 00:47:12.097
600,000 jobs were suddenly reduced to 200,000. They're just shifting them?
00:47:12.357 --> 00:47:16.037
Yeah. And it just kept going on like this. This went on for basically two years
00:47:16.037 --> 00:47:20.577
so that, you know, it always looked like there were new jobs being created,
00:47:20.737 --> 00:47:25.477
but the new jobs being created were being vanished backwards in time.
00:47:25.777 --> 00:47:29.937
And this went on for… That's really weird. And I have no idea what that's about.
00:47:30.077 --> 00:47:33.657
I'm sure you do. But when I looked even a little bit into the data,
00:47:34.177 --> 00:47:37.837
even standard metrics of a recession seemed to resemble a recession,
00:47:38.037 --> 00:47:40.697
like the inversion yield curve and the ROMS predictor.
00:47:40.857 --> 00:47:43.897
They were ignoring basic measurements like that.
00:47:44.097 --> 00:47:48.617
Yeah. There was one moment, and I'm forgetting exactly what month it was.
00:47:48.617 --> 00:47:55.977
I think it might have been second and third quarter of 21, where we had two
00:47:55.977 --> 00:48:01.097
successive quarters of declining real output.
00:48:01.737 --> 00:48:04.757
And that is technically what a recession is.
00:48:04.957 --> 00:48:09.777
And the entire media at the time was screaming, well, that's not a recession,
00:48:09.817 --> 00:48:13.617
because look how strong the jobs market
is. And so it's like,
00:48:13.697 --> 00:48:14.937
wait a minute, I look up recession.
00:48:15.097 --> 00:48:18.937
The technical definition of recession is two successive declines.
00:48:19.897 --> 00:48:22.857
Two quarters of successive declines in real output.
00:48:23.237 --> 00:48:25.857
That's what I'm seeing right here.
00:48:26.597 --> 00:48:29.877
Oh, well, that's the old definition. We have a new definition now.
00:48:30.137 --> 00:48:32.077
It's just like, oh, here we go again, right?
00:48:32.957 --> 00:48:34.797
But what's strange about that
00:48:34.797 --> 00:48:38.537
is that even that was underestimated because the CPI has been messed up.
00:48:38.877 --> 00:48:45.617
We've been living with a CPI that's been obviously fake for the better part of three years.
00:48:48.197 --> 00:48:53.617
The housing prices, I mean, the CPI is using a version of housing prices that
00:48:53.617 --> 00:48:55.357
are not actually housing prices.
00:48:55.677 --> 00:49:01.897
And the grocery indexes do not fit with the private sector grocery index.
00:49:02.077 --> 00:49:09.657
The used and new car indexes from private sources, from the industry itself,
00:49:09.877 --> 00:49:13.777
completely contradict what the CPI was saying.
00:49:14.457 --> 00:49:18.157
And the excuses for this are just crazy.
00:49:19.480 --> 00:49:23.680
They keep talking about hedonic adjustments in light of increased quality or whatever.
00:49:23.940 --> 00:49:27.960
And my favorite adjustment that the Department of Labor started doing is that
00:49:27.960 --> 00:49:34.420
when technologies would become green compliant, they would, and then go up in
00:49:34.420 --> 00:49:37.600
price, they would reduce the price and say, well, in effect,
00:49:37.720 --> 00:49:38.840
the quality has increased.
00:49:39.020 --> 00:49:42.000
So that's like you're getting more for your buck.
00:49:42.180 --> 00:49:45.880
So that's not inflation. So it's just crazy. It's so crazy. And this has been
00:49:45.880 --> 00:49:49.860
going on now for four years. So you can't trust the data anymore.
00:49:50.240 --> 00:49:54.580
But I tell you, with Trump in charge now, they're going to start getting really
00:49:54.580 --> 00:49:57.440
more blunt about the truth.
00:49:57.580 --> 00:50:04.600
It's like for the first time in four years, we had the media last month at the
00:50:04.600 --> 00:50:10.100
CPI and PPI reports screaming that inflation was up. Oh, that's really interesting.
00:50:10.380 --> 00:50:15.900
We just lived through the worst inflation in 40 years, maybe in 100 years,
00:50:16.060 --> 00:50:18.760
and hardly heard a word about it.
00:50:18.840 --> 00:50:26.360
And now we've had one month of sticky prices that actually were declining month over month.
00:50:26.880 --> 00:50:29.220
And now we hear this worst inflation ever.
00:50:29.880 --> 00:50:34.700
And people underestimate the power of the media here, you know?
00:50:34.700 --> 00:50:37.260
It's like, yeah, nobody believes mainstream media anymore.
00:50:37.380 --> 00:50:41.220
Oh, sure. What's the problem is there's nobody else or anything else to believe in.
00:50:41.400 --> 00:50:48.080
You know, the independent press doesn't really cover breaking economic news
00:50:48.080 --> 00:50:52.200
the way the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times does or the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
00:50:52.500 --> 00:50:58.000
So the power of the mainstream press to frame this up.
00:50:59.261 --> 00:51:04.641
Is really something. I assume that by the summer, there's going to be widespread
00:51:04.641 --> 00:51:06.981
knowledge that we are in a recession right now.
00:51:07.121 --> 00:51:11.561
And of course, the entire thing will be blamed on Trump, for sure.
00:51:11.661 --> 00:51:13.881
There was a headline in the New York Times a couple of days ago,
00:51:13.921 --> 00:51:14.961
I just couldn't believe it.
00:51:15.381 --> 00:51:19.221
It showed people stockpiling groceries. And they said, well,
00:51:20.001 --> 00:51:23.001
Americans are stockpiling groceries to get ready for Trump's tariffs.
00:51:23.221 --> 00:51:25.321
Oh, really? Yeah.
00:51:26.821 --> 00:51:31.361
Eggs, look at that. I mean, we killed off an enormous part of our national flock
00:51:31.361 --> 00:51:33.601
and now eggs are 20 bucks a dozen.
00:51:33.821 --> 00:51:37.521
It's crazy. As you were describing everything that you were just listing,
00:51:37.761 --> 00:51:41.681
the audience can only see my reaction if they're on realclearpodcast.com watching
00:51:41.681 --> 00:51:46.701
the video, but I was just kind of contorting myself to in some way believe that
00:51:46.701 --> 00:51:49.841
I could encapsulate the emotional angst,
00:51:50.021 --> 00:51:53.761
you know, that was arising within me as you're describing these things, Jeffrey.
00:51:54.121 --> 00:52:00.821
To say the least, our basic epistemological stance is way off.
00:52:01.021 --> 00:52:05.101
I mean, how do Americans grasp what truth is anymore?
00:52:05.641 --> 00:52:09.521
That's an enormous question. This has been a question, I think,
00:52:09.541 --> 00:52:13.021
in my mind for quite some time, but especially over the last five years,
00:52:13.041 --> 00:52:16.641
because we've never really had truth about what happened to the country,
00:52:17.121 --> 00:52:20.301
about why the businesses were shut down, why you couldn't go see grandma,
00:52:20.481 --> 00:52:21.621
why you couldn't go to church.
00:52:21.821 --> 00:52:24.561
I mean, nobody's really talked about this. The vaccine didn't work.
00:52:24.741 --> 00:52:27.321
There's been so many lives. We live in a war of lies.
00:52:28.201 --> 00:52:35.501
And combined with that, we had forced isolation and forced shattering of our
00:52:35.501 --> 00:52:42.241
communities and forced segregation of society on essential,
00:52:42.321 --> 00:52:44.061
non-essential facts, un-vaxed, and so on.
00:52:44.161 --> 00:52:47.561
So our social networks have been shattered.
00:52:47.981
--> 00:52:52.541
Our trust institutions has been shattered.
00:52:52.781 --> 00:52:56.101
It's not just government, but our trust in the big tech platforms,
00:52:56.321 --> 00:53:04.841
which we used to depend on for giving us our friendships and our social relationships.
00:53:04.941 --> 00:53:08.581
It turns out they're just surveilling us and commoditizing our data.
00:53:08.741 --> 00:53:12.861
We didn't know that, and they all played along with lockdowns and censored the
00:53:12.861 --> 00:53:13.881
critics. So there's been.
00:53:14.718 --> 00:53:22.978
People are lonely, addicted, sad, having lost touch with their communities.
00:53:23.338 --> 00:53:28.838
We're all in the process right now. I'm speaking for a lot of people here that
00:53:28.838 --> 00:53:32.798
we're reassembling and re-putting our lives back together.
00:53:33.098 --> 00:53:37.458
One of the things Brownstone did three and a half years ago is we started a separate club.
00:53:38.278 --> 00:53:41.238
And it was like the greatest thing that ever happened to people's lives.
00:53:41.298 --> 00:53:44.518
And now there's no chance I could ever not have the separate club.
00:53:44.718 --> 00:53:48.598
It's a monthly thing. People, I sell out, a hundred people come to it.
00:53:48.698 --> 00:53:53.178
I sell it out instantly every time because people just think of it as their community.
00:53:53.978 --> 00:53:57.158
Everybody lost their old communities. We're trying to find new communities now.
00:53:57.338 --> 00:54:00.458
That's where we are right now. A broken, shattered, indebted,
00:54:00.838 --> 00:54:06.738
addicted people desperately trying to find our way back to a normal civilized
00:54:06.738 --> 00:54:09.038
life. And we're not there.
00:54:09.318 --> 00:54:13.198
We're not there. So well put. I'll tell you, Jeffrey, I had my private practice
00:54:13.198 --> 00:54:17.698
and I was living up in Portland, Oregon between 2018 to 2022.
00:54:18.158 --> 00:54:23.498
I'll never forget amidst the lockdowns, I had this amazing office that I built
00:54:23.498 --> 00:54:25.678
downtown, had it all built out for me.
00:54:25.758 --> 00:54:30.258
I had floor to ceiling windows, it overlooked the cityscape and I had a great practice going.
00:54:30.798 --> 00:54:36.358
Lockdowns came and I would occasionally go down there to gather the mail and
00:54:36.358 --> 00:54:43.038
I'd walk into my amazing office and it was like this museum to the prior times.
00:54:43.518 --> 00:54:48.418
And I'd sit down on the couch and open my mail and look out on the empty cityscape.
00:54:48.538 --> 00:54:52.938
I will never forget one moment where I was doing such a thing.
00:54:53.278 --> 00:54:58.598
And I just walked over to the window and looked out and my heart sank.
00:54:59.038 --> 00:55:02.058
I looked at all of the buildings in front of me.
00:55:02.318 --> 00:55:09.078
In the middle of the day, it was around four o'clock, there were three lights on. And I said, wow.
00:55:10.538 --> 00:55:15.978
Wow i don't know what this means but it's time to go i don't know where i'm going,
00:55:17.538 --> 00:55:20.458
and i hope it's i hope it's
00:55:20.458 --> 00:55:25.518
going to be okay i'm you know i i really appreciate you telling me and us the
00:55:25.518 --> 00:55:30.698
truth today about about your analysis and and where we're headed as i'd mentioned
00:55:30.698 --> 00:55:36.638
patients often appreciate simply hearing bad news even if it's true i i appreciate
00:55:36.638 --> 00:55:38.218
your personal story, by the way,
00:55:38.478 --> 00:55:44.178
and I will say this, that I've noticed this over the years, and you probably have too,
00:55:44.658 --> 00:55:47.538
that it takes a while to.
00:55:49.134 --> 00:55:57.554
To develop a sort of a conversation that becomes truthful about what's happened in our lives.
00:55:57.694 --> 00:56:00.454
And I've noticed this for several years now.
00:56:00.654 --> 00:56:05.034
I'll have people over and we'll small talk for 45 minutes to an hour.
00:56:05.174 --> 00:56:11.674
And then at some point, the person will start telling about what happened to
00:56:11.674 --> 00:56:13.414
them during the lockdowns.
00:56:14.374 --> 00:56:19.914
And the stories are so incredible, so tragic.
00:56:19.914 --> 00:56:27.254
Just the spiritual and psychological trauma of those days, it's so hard that
00:56:27.254 --> 00:56:31.514
people don't even, they're not even ready to speak about it yet.
00:56:31.674 --> 00:56:35.694
And there has to be an element of trust between people before people will even
00:56:35.694 --> 00:56:40.774
broach the topic. Because you remember in those days, people complained and
00:56:40.774 --> 00:56:46.334
thought there was something odd, were treated like pariahs, like you're not with the program.
00:56:46.554 --> 00:56:50.514
It was like a Maoist-style cultural revolution or something like that.
00:56:50.674 --> 00:56:57.514
So, the only thing I would say about this is that we all right now need friends
00:56:57.514 --> 00:57:01.574
that we can open up to, if only just to hear our stories,
00:57:02.134 --> 00:57:06.534
somebody to tell our stories to, somebody that we can trust with the stories
00:57:06.534 --> 00:57:11.074
of the tragedies that have hit our lines over the last several years.
00:57:11.114 --> 00:57:16.014
I think this is essential to getting past this stage.
00:57:16.794 --> 00:57:22.094
Thank you so much, Jeffrey Tucker from the Brownstone Institute for coming on RealClear podcast.
00:57:22.494 --> 00:57:26.554
We hope you'll be a returning friend and have these kinds of conversations in
00:57:26.554 --> 00:57:29.034
the future. Nice to be here. Thank you so much.