TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.519 --> 00:00:04.547
Good afternoon. This is John Richardson speaking with you from Toronto,
00:00:04.547 --> 00:00:10.562
Canada. Today is the afternoon of Tuesday, November the 17th, 2026.
00:00:11.261 --> 00:00:15.057
And with me today is an interesting and special guest.
00:00:15.057 --> 00:00:20.207
I'd like to introduce you to Mr. Robert Levitt, who is a U.S.
00:00:20.207 --> 00:00:24.817
Citizen, runs Levitt Capital, basically helping Americans abroad invest,
00:00:24.817 --> 00:00:27.097
do financial planning, among other things.
00:00:27.585 --> 00:00:33.227
And he also comes to us as an active member, I think second in command of the
00:00:33.227 --> 00:00:36.595
Democrats Abroad Taxation Tax Force.
00:00:37.100 --> 00:00:41.787
So we'll be pleased to hear his insights into where tax reform may be going.
00:00:41.787 --> 00:00:44.280
So first of all, welcome, Robert.
00:00:44.553 --> 00:00:47.276
Have I got that right in my initial description?
00:00:47.734 --> 00:00:50.532
You did very well, John. Thank you. Thank you. I'm glad to be here.
00:00:50.730 --> 00:00:55.029
All right. Likewise, a real pleasure to catch up with you here.
00:00:55.925 --> 00:01:02.177
Let's begin, you know, talking about the general problem in the world that everybody
00:01:02.177 --> 00:01:05.509
has, wherever they live, regardless of their citizenship. Okay.
00:01:06.214 --> 00:01:13.019
And that is financial planning, investing, and the problem of being subject
00:01:13.019 --> 00:01:18.337
to more than one tax system, which you would agree is not that uncommon anymore.
00:01:18.726 --> 00:01:23.309
No, it's actually, we consider it a mega trend where people have multiple,
00:01:23.309 --> 00:01:24.859
focus on multiple jurisdictions.
00:01:24.859 --> 00:01:29.729
So if you go back in time, you were born in one country, you were raised in
00:01:29.729 --> 00:01:32.419
that country, you were educated in that country, you worked in that country,
00:01:32.419 --> 00:01:33.299
you died in that country.
00:01:34.239 --> 00:01:38.759
And that country's jurisdiction, therefore, created a set of rules and regulations,
00:01:39.496 --> 00:01:42.899
and taxes in order to go through the full cycle.
00:01:42.899 --> 00:01:47.079
But today, the mega trend is that people can live in one country,
00:01:47.079 --> 00:01:50.259
have parents in another country that they're going to get an inheritance from.
00:01:50.259 --> 00:01:53.340
They have children that are living in other countries.
00:01:53.676 --> 00:01:58.149
They own property in another country. And so today, really, we see a lot of
00:01:58.149 --> 00:02:04.735
people who are living lives that are far more complicated across multiple jurisdictions.
00:02:05.130 --> 00:02:09.689
And this is a real challenge when you're trying to work through a variety of
00:02:09.689 --> 00:02:12.113
tax systems that don't work together.
00:02:12.817 --> 00:02:16.179
Well, I think, wow, I mean, that is absolutely
Load full transcript
correct.
00:02:16.179 --> 00:02:21.369
And of course, this is compounded, I suppose, by, you know, certain realities.
00:02:21.369 --> 00:02:25.919
I mean, every country I know of tax is income sourced in that country.
00:02:25.919 --> 00:02:29.679
So you could have investment income, rental income, you know,
00:02:29.679 --> 00:02:31.439
so you don't even live in the country.
00:02:31.439 --> 00:02:34.502
You're going to be subject to tax. The United States, of course,
00:02:35.088 --> 00:02:36.959
tax is based on citizenship.
00:02:36.959 --> 00:02:41.709
So, you know, you go and live in another country, you're automatically a dual tax resident.
00:02:41.709 --> 00:02:45.789
And, you know, and then you talk about inheritances. So not only do we have
00:02:45.789 --> 00:02:49.919
to worry about the law of inheritances in generally, but all of a sudden now
00:02:49.919 --> 00:02:53.447
we have to live with inheritance laws and countries that we don't even live in. Right.
00:02:54.097 --> 00:02:57.769
You know, because of our, our parents may live there. That's right.
00:02:57.769 --> 00:03:01.163
That's right. But I don't think it's like, you know, there used to be this commentary that America.
00:03:02.027 --> 00:03:07.222
America's the only country that had citizenship-based taxation and how very unfair it was.
00:03:07.530 --> 00:03:11.951
But it's not as bad as we think. For example, there are countries such as France,
00:03:11.951 --> 00:03:17.050
where I live, where being a U.S. citizen is far better than being a French-only
00:03:17.231 --> 00:03:19.179
resident paying taxes in France.
00:03:19.365 --> 00:03:23.601
So you get benefits. But there's also lots of countries that are now working
00:03:23.601 --> 00:03:26.099
or they work through a variety of exit taxes.
00:03:26.447 --> 00:03:31.433
So the U.S. allows you to leave the United States without paying taxes on all your capital gains.
00:03:32.147 --> 00:03:35.971
But now in Italy, for example, they're proposing a new law that will tax all
00:03:35.971 --> 00:03:38.272
of your capital gains the minute you leave the country.
00:03:38.492 --> 00:03:43.054
France already has an exit tax. So many countries have different forms of taxation.
00:03:43.321 --> 00:03:47.721
It may not seem like relevant and it's clear that for a country.
00:03:48.480 --> 00:03:52.222
Example, in France, they have been proposing other forms of citizenship-based
00:03:52.222 --> 00:03:58.292
taxation, not necessarily the same as the U.S., but the variety of ways that
00:03:58.292 --> 00:03:59.903
countries are looking to raise money,
00:04:00.403 --> 00:04:04.432
to raise revenues, to pay their fast-growing bills.
00:04:04.432 --> 00:04:11.182
And, you know, so much of Europe is aging and they have promised enormous retirement benefits.
00:04:11.182 --> 00:04:16.422
At one time, you know, for example, in France, when they created the welfare
00:04:16.422 --> 00:04:21.273
state, they had four people working for
everyone retired. Now there's 1.7.
00:04:21.580 --> 00:04:25.342
So they have to come up with new ways and new creative ways to come up with revenue.
00:04:25.853 --> 00:04:29.022
And it's a big political fight in many, many countries.
00:04:29.655 --> 00:04:34.192
But it's not just the issue of taxes, John. It's really involved in investing.
00:04:34.192 --> 00:04:39.092
It's also an issue of regulation because the way that the regulations work in
00:04:39.092 --> 00:04:41.984
Europe are different than the way the regulations work in the United States.
00:04:42.349 --> 00:04:47.162
And every country in Europe has different ways of looking at different things.
00:04:47.539 --> 00:04:51.730
So what makes you a resident in Italy is different than what makes you a resident in France.
00:04:52.067 --> 00:04:56.786
What makes you in Spain depends on where you live. It's like a local tax.
00:04:57.071 --> 00:05:01.472
So if you live in Barcelona, it's very, very challenging. You're going to be
00:05:01.472 --> 00:05:04.492
paying a wealth tax. But if you live in Mallorca, you're not.
00:05:05.980 --> 00:05:11.122
So I guess it's a tremendous component. So the solution is obviously to have
00:05:11.122 --> 00:05:13.004
no income and no assets, right?
00:05:14.400 --> 00:05:18.770
No, I don't think that's necessarily the solution, because if you have no income
00:05:18.770 --> 00:05:21.190
and no assets, you probably won't be living around the world.
00:05:21.190 --> 00:05:24.100
You'll be living in the country that you were born in. Oh, my God.
00:05:24.100 --> 00:05:27.103
In other words, Robert, life is tough.
00:05:27.724 --> 00:05:32.510
This is a wealthier person's problem not you know this is not you know this is not the,
00:05:33.270 --> 00:05:38.380
the the the you know the the person who has the modest income as we as we say
00:05:38.380 --> 00:05:41.770
diplomatically the poor people they're not going to be traipsing around the
00:05:41.770 --> 00:05:45.475
world but you know when you have a little bit more education a little more opportunity
00:05:45.817 --> 00:05:49.566
you have you have more and more challenges and you know what john
00:05:49.972 --> 00:05:52.161
the thing is is that all these problems are solvable,
00:05:52.671 --> 00:05:55.150
there are ways to do all this stuff that's you know,
00:05:55.770 --> 00:05:59.185
it's complicated which is nice for me because this is our business but we
00:05:59.585 --> 00:06:03.000
we focus on the solutions right so you can focus on the problems you can focus
00:06:03.000 --> 00:06:08.410
on the rules or you can focus on the solutions how does a u.s citizen in our
00:06:08.410 --> 00:06:12.376
case because we focus on u.s citizens get around these regulations what do you need to do
00:06:12.765 --> 00:06:18.247
how do you how do you navigate these these treacherous water and and and.
00:06:19.188 --> 00:06:23.228
There are ways. So it's, you know, there's a new regulation coming on in Europe
00:06:23.228 --> 00:06:24.854
now that deals with banking.
00:06:25.260 --> 00:06:31.638
So anyone who offers checking accounts to a European resident must have a physical
00:06:31.638 --> 00:06:34.534
location and a regulated location in Europe.
00:06:35.092 --> 00:06:39.938
This is what caused Chase Bank recently to send out thousands of notices to
00:06:39.938 --> 00:06:43.188
people that they were canceling their bank account and canceling their credit
00:06:43.188 --> 00:06:45.332
cards because they did not have a U.S. address.
00:06:45.645 --> 00:06:48.391
Now, are there banks that do allow this?
00:06:48.815 --> 00:06:55.138
Absolutely. But it's getting more and more complicated because you have to find
00:06:55.138 --> 00:06:58.508
workarounds. You have to find ways to skirt sort of.
00:07:00.528 --> 00:07:03.168
The intention of the law by focusing on the letter of the law.
00:07:03.168 --> 00:07:06.468
So one way people are trying to get around this problem of banks is they're
00:07:06.468 --> 00:07:09.268
opening accounts with the State Department Federal Credit Union.
00:07:09.552 --> 00:07:10.618
But the State Department Federal
00:07:10.618 --> 00:07:13.668
Credit Union, they don't have a physical location either in Europe.
00:07:13.993 --> 00:07:18.428
So they're counting on one of the exemptions that's called non-solicitation.
00:07:18.689 --> 00:07:21.569
So if you contact them, therefore it's okay.
00:07:21.865 --> 00:07:28.808
So there's, you know, there's always somebody out there that can find a way,
00:07:29.528 --> 00:07:30.890
to figure out how to make it happen.
00:07:31.152 --> 00:07:36.888
If you take a look at brokerage firms like Schwab or Vanguard or Fidelity,
00:07:37.201 --> 00:07:38.838
often they're not licensed anymore.
00:07:39.729 --> 00:07:44.041
Variety of countries around the world but there are firms like interactive brokers
00:07:44.041 --> 00:07:47.525
that make it their business to become licensed in these countries and so,
00:07:48.131 --> 00:07:51.831
they have created the methods and the procedures to do it the problem for most
00:07:51.831 --> 00:07:54.761
americans is they don't know how they don't know where they don't know these
00:07:54.761 --> 00:07:58.764
firms so if you're an american and you move to to europe are you going to trust
00:07:59.199 --> 00:08:02.651
you know your broker that helped you make enough money to get to europe and
00:08:02.651 --> 00:08:07.511
the brokerage firm that that you've known for years and years and years well probably,
00:08:08.091 --> 00:08:12.649
you you you will but they don't understand the rules on the other side,
00:08:13.339 --> 00:08:15.000
and that's they don't know how to do,
00:08:16.132 --> 00:08:21.941
is understanding the rules in a broader sense understanding the rules but knowing
00:08:21.941 --> 00:08:26.281
how to get around them so there's like this idea you can't buy for example if
00:08:26.281 --> 00:08:28.128
you're in Europe you can't
buy US ETF.
00:08:29.409 --> 00:08:33.487
That's sort of the standard line, but it's not true. You can buy a U.S.
00:08:33.487 --> 00:08:36.891
ETF. You can't buy a U.S. ETF if you're going to work with a U.S. brokerage firm.
00:08:37.489 --> 00:08:40.757
But if you work with a firm like Interactive Brokers, for example,
00:08:40.757 --> 00:08:42.218
you can apply for an exemption.
00:08:42.520 --> 00:08:45.527
It's kind of like an accredited investor rule in the United States,
00:08:45.527 --> 00:08:47.747
where if you have enough money and you have enough experience,
00:08:47.747 --> 00:08:52.318
you can get around the regulation. So all these things sort of have solutions.
00:08:52.771 --> 00:08:56.677
It's it's just a question of staying on top of them because not only if you're
00:08:56.677 --> 00:09:00.121
an american do you have to stay on top of all the regulations and rules and tax laws,
00:09:00.754 --> 00:09:04.347
affecting americans but if you live in italy you got to understand all of them
00:09:04.347 --> 00:09:08.907
in italy too and where do you go it's not so easy you know because in in for
00:09:08.907 --> 00:09:13.117
example in italy they don't use the first in first out method of accounting
00:09:13.117 --> 00:09:14.937
they use the last in last out so,
00:09:15.517 --> 00:09:20.517
the default the united states is first in first out default Italy last and first out, right?
00:09:20.517 --> 00:09:24.947
So there, if you have a capital gain because you owned an ETF on the United
00:09:24.947 --> 00:09:30.307
States, an ETF is a capital gain tax rate. But in Italy, an ETF on the United
00:09:30.307 --> 00:09:32.224
States is going to be taxed as ordinary income.
00:09:32.508 --> 00:09:36.137
Same thing in Austria. If you own a US product, it's taxed in a terrible way.
00:09:36.137 --> 00:09:39.607
In Austria, if you own an IRA, it's taxed, double taxed. You taxed when you
00:09:39.607 --> 00:09:42.717
take out money from the United States, you're taxed in Austria. So what do you do?
00:09:43.097 --> 00:09:45.293
Are there ways around it? Of course there are.
00:09:45.793 --> 00:09:49.339
It's just a little bit complicated. And there are not a lot of people who have
00:09:49.705 --> 00:09:53.397
developed an expertise in this as the market has just taken off.
00:09:54.577 --> 00:09:57.337
I think a lot of the problem started, maybe we shouldn't put a problem,
00:09:57.337 --> 00:10:01.337
but a lot of the reason why we have these issues comes from the development
00:10:01.337 --> 00:10:04.924
of FATCA, right? Because before, people could do almost anything and nobody would know.
00:10:05.417 --> 00:10:08.777
But now with FATCA and all the reporting, everybody started cracking down,
00:10:08.777 --> 00:10:12.314
trying to do, you know, what the law actually said you're supposed to do.
00:10:12.970 --> 00:10:18.857
And this created a whole potpourri of challenges for Americans who had been
00:10:18.857 --> 00:10:22.896
living, you know, for a long, long time without considering any of these issues.
00:10:23.971 --> 00:10:28.656
Yeah, for sure. Okay, let's break this down just a little bit.
00:10:29.236 --> 00:10:33.344
So, you know, it's interesting. So we start off with the principle,
00:10:34.091 --> 00:10:39.722
the reality of U.S. citizenship taxation. It's interesting how you describe,
00:10:40.324 --> 00:10:43.267
both the opportunities and the problems with that, right? Right.
00:10:43.749 --> 00:10:49.860
Now, citizenship taxation, of course, is worldwide taxation based on who you
00:10:49.860 --> 00:10:53.233
are as a U.S. citizen, regardless of where you live.
00:10:53.387 --> 00:10:56.250
So presumably you would agree with that.
00:10:56.250 --> 00:11:00.280
But now at the beginning, we're talking about France, where you live.
00:11:00.280 --> 00:11:05.180
And did I hear you correctly that you were saying that U.S. citizen France in
00:11:05.180 --> 00:11:09.830
some ways actually have tax advantages over those who are not U.S.
00:11:09.830 --> 00:11:13.500
Citizens? Is that what you said? I wouldn't say all U.S.
00:11:13.840 --> 00:11:18.520
It depends on the source of your income. But if your income benefits you.
00:11:18.880 --> 00:11:23.362
Many cases. Because you can pay taxes depending on the investments you own.
00:11:23.786 --> 00:11:28.819
You can pay taxes in the United States. You can choose where you want to pay taxes, for example.
00:11:30.354 --> 00:11:33.840
And you can also choose a lot of things. If you have IRAs, if you have Roth
00:11:33.840 --> 00:11:36.135
IRAs, those are all recognized in France.
00:11:37.156 --> 00:11:41.510
Those same types of securities, Roth and an IRA, they're not recognized in Austria.
00:11:42.108 --> 00:11:45.318
So different countries have, you know, different ways of looking at it.
00:11:45.318 --> 00:11:50.553
But for an American, well, and this is why the, I'm kind of skipping a lot,
00:11:50.826 --> 00:11:55.824
but you know, there's the residential-based taxation bill that's been introduced.
00:11:56.271 --> 00:11:59.898
And I know a lot about this because I remember years ago, I was one of the first
00:11:59.898 --> 00:12:04.238
to talk about it, in fact, with the House Ways and Means Committee.
00:12:04.238 --> 00:12:07.288
And I think I even spoke to you about it, John, around 14 years.
00:12:07.288 --> 00:12:11.468
Years ago when we were first trying a pre-meeting in dc a few years ago i think
00:12:11.468 --> 00:12:18.722
we chatted about this didn't we yeah right and so well the the idea of it being elective,
00:12:19.451 --> 00:12:23.598
i mean i can't understand anybody who would be opposed to it from from you know
00:12:23.598 --> 00:12:29.448
from um from the point of view of the taxpayer it's it's an ideal program and i i am a strong.
00:12:30.364 --> 00:12:34.433
Strong strong supporter and for those who benefit, they can take advantage of it.
00:12:34.961 --> 00:12:39.368
And for those who
don't, they simply don't, right? They just don't need to opt
00:12:39.368 --> 00:12:41.544
in, for example, under this program.
00:12:41.776 --> 00:12:48.028
The problem I see personally with the way it was structured was it went a long
00:12:48.028 --> 00:12:51.691
ways from the original intention, maybe.
00:12:52.040 --> 00:12:58.399
There was an idea that President Trump said, we want to eliminate double taxation for Americans abroad.
00:12:58.631 --> 00:13:03.618
The Republicans sort of wanted to offer a bill that you can't create a bill
00:13:03.618 --> 00:13:06.988
like this overnight. So they came to the taxation task force,
00:13:06.988 --> 00:13:10.588
the Democratic Party, and they wanted our bill, which we were very happy to
00:13:10.588 --> 00:13:13.298
share with them because it's a bipartisan issue.
00:13:14.111 --> 00:13:17.610
But it began the whole idea, at least when I,
00:13:18.467 --> 00:13:23.929
created the idea was to create a funnel and you could increase or decrease the
00:13:24.295 --> 00:13:27.360
ability to take assets out of the u.s,
00:13:27.940 --> 00:13:33.480
capital gains tax free and and you could make it so you could take no assets
00:13:33.480 --> 00:13:38.476
out of capital gains tax free and then it would have just been something that would have impacted,
00:13:39.062 --> 00:13:40.280
everybody going forward they
00:13:40.280 --> 00:13:44.797
would have never had these issues but instead they created all kinds of,
00:13:45.820 --> 00:13:47.961
benefits to allow people who had.
00:13:49.347 --> 00:13:52.630
Up to $4 and $5 million of capital gains tax-free.
00:13:52.630 --> 00:13:55.929
And the reality is that created a huge cost.
00:13:56.260 --> 00:14:01.914
And when the Joint Committee on Taxation, who scored the bill,
00:14:02.134 --> 00:14:05.400
they came up with this was going to cost us a huge amount of money.
00:14:05.841 --> 00:14:11.940
And so I think there was a big big opportunity that that in some cases it it got,
00:14:12.440 --> 00:14:16.820
maybe people were too optimistic of what they could get past and they allowed
00:14:16.820 --> 00:14:19.751
too much to be put into the bill to help people,
00:14:20.198 --> 00:14:24.270
not necessarily going forward but going backward and people who had nothing
00:14:24.270 --> 00:14:27.849
to do with living overseas at the time and just wanted to be able to exit,
00:14:28.378 --> 00:14:32.430
so this and you know this is my view where we're talking Well,
00:14:32.430 --> 00:14:35.340
you're talking specifically about the LaHood bill, the one that was.
00:14:38.397 --> 00:14:41.270
Introduced in 2024. Is that correct? Correct. And so the basics of the bill,
00:14:41.270 --> 00:14:45.750
I mean, certainly I'm a big supporter of the LaHood bill, and I lobbied on behalf
00:14:45.750 --> 00:14:50.020
of the LaHood bill in D.C., and I will continue to do so, and I hope it gets
00:14:50.020 --> 00:14:52.827
reintroduced, and I hope that we continue to work down
this.
00:14:53.217 --> 00:14:58.232
But there are certainly ways to make it less expensive and to make it much.
00:14:59.305 --> 00:15:04.850
New neutral. And so I think what we really, if we're really focused on RBT and
00:15:05.270 --> 00:15:08.820
ending sort of this system that can be very complicated for a lot of people,
00:15:08.820 --> 00:15:10.195
depending on where they live,
00:15:10.666 --> 00:15:16.565
then I think what the focus should be is going forward and not necessarily,
00:15:17.401 --> 00:15:20.095
those who have been involved in the system for a long time,
00:15:21.070 --> 00:15:22.230
that are already caught up.
00:15:22.230 --> 00:15:26.200
And I think if we can sort of move more towards the focus on the future and
00:15:26.200 --> 00:15:30.241
less on the focus on the past, I think we have probably a better opportunity
00:15:30.636 --> 00:15:33.550
to get some legislation passed, but it's complicated.
00:15:34.070 --> 00:15:39.510
What you're really saying is that, so the best chance of getting legislation
00:15:39.510 --> 00:15:42.094
passed is if it's prospective only,
00:15:42.758 --> 00:15:50.070
and therefore the focus of any legislative change, improving citizenship taxation
00:15:50.070 --> 00:15:52.839
should be based on people who are still in the United States,
00:15:53.513 --> 00:15:57.250
creating better opportunities for them to move outside the United States?
00:15:57.610 --> 00:15:59.092
Is that your basic position?
00:15:59.486 --> 00:16:04.210
I would say, to the most part, effectively, yes.
00:16:04.210 --> 00:16:09.239
But it's a question of the revenue, whether you can make it revenue neutral,
00:16:09.721 --> 00:16:14.070
or even generate revenue. And if you can generate revenue, you can get legislation
00:16:14.070 --> 00:16:16.391
passed. But if it's an expensive bill.
00:16:17.867 --> 00:16:21.311
Then I think it's going to be very, very difficult to get anything passed.
00:16:21.311 --> 00:16:22.284
It's going to cost money.
00:16:22.673 --> 00:16:31.758
And there's a history of Americans trying to use a variety of offshore tax methods,
00:16:32.333 --> 00:16:34.791
that have caused a lot of these issues.
00:16:34.791 --> 00:16:40.401
The whole issue of the PFIC, which is investing in foreign funds,
00:16:40.401 --> 00:16:44.871
which is going to be taxed very unfavorably, came from the fact that if they
00:16:44.871 --> 00:16:46.241
existed, it would be very easy.
00:16:46.241 --> 00:16:50.645
And if they created a law that went back to the old way where we could have,
00:16:51.789 --> 00:16:56.221
foreign investment funds, I will be one of the first to put my clients in it
00:16:56.221 --> 00:16:57.873
where they'll never pay taxes, right?
00:16:58.116 --> 00:17:01.241
They'll be able to defer taxes for the entire focus of their lives.
00:17:01.241 --> 00:17:08.192
So I have the perspective of when the legislative comes, what are we going to do about it?
00:17:09.551 --> 00:17:14.281
How can we best take advantage of it? But I think that from the point of view
00:17:14.281 --> 00:17:17.236
of my own personal point of view is I would like to see that,
00:17:17.671 --> 00:17:21.648
for example, young people who are in their 20s that move to Europe today,
00:17:23.211 --> 00:17:25.519
or move elsewhere to high-tax countries,
00:17:26.331 --> 00:17:29.797
they would not be subject to these issues.
00:17:30.291 --> 00:17:35.071
That have affected their parents and affected a lot of people that now have
00:17:35.071 --> 00:17:37.929
large capital gains. And so I personally think that if...
00:17:39.211 --> 00:17:45.154
The focus is on those in the past who are obligated, maybe unfairly,
00:17:45.154 --> 00:17:49.677
clearly in many cases very much unfairly, to pay taxes to the United States.
00:17:50.217 --> 00:17:53.758
But if we can sort of move on from there and accept that there are some casualties,
00:17:54.530 --> 00:17:58.791
in this and try to minimize the cost,
00:17:59.296 --> 00:18:05.544
it doesn't mean 100%, but it certainly can't be $4 or $5 million that one would
00:18:05.544 --> 00:18:08.264
be able to take out of the U.S. for that.
00:18:08.864 --> 00:18:13.084
Because, you know, for you, there's this old hat and that, but for people listening
00:18:13.084 --> 00:18:16.274
to this, I think this is a good moment for a bit of clarification.
00:18:16.274 --> 00:18:19.234
So I'm going to try to explain what I think you're saying. And,
00:18:19.234 --> 00:18:23.148
you know, you can agree, disagree or add or correct or whatever you want to do. But.
00:18:24.269 --> 00:18:28.733
So what I think you're saying, what I'm hearing from you is that,
00:18:29.140 --> 00:18:33.247
so somebody lives in the United States and they're going to move out of the United States.
00:18:33.998 --> 00:18:40.641
And what you're saying is that if there's an exit tax, meaning that if there
00:18:40.641 --> 00:18:46.993
are people who have to pay capital gains tax based on a deemed disposition of assets,
00:18:47.672 --> 00:18:52.051
that you think that basically the threshold should be, that there should not
00:18:52.051 --> 00:18:58.189
be a large enough threshold so that lots of people escape paying that tax, right?
00:18:58.427 --> 00:19:02.799
That you think that basically you pay the tax, right? Pay as you don't.
00:19:03.431 --> 00:19:06.148
It's not that I think that you should pay the tax, okay?
00:19:06.901 --> 00:19:09.898
I would hope that we can avoid paying taxes, but...
00:19:12.041 --> 00:19:16.021
The theory of the design, that's all. The whole concept initially,
00:19:16.021 --> 00:19:21.371
when I started to discuss about it, In the very beginning was to create a funnel
00:19:21.371 --> 00:19:24.312
that would, could be open, larger or smaller.
00:19:24.643 --> 00:19:31.051
And so if the need would be to have a revenue neutral bill, that would be something
00:19:31.051 --> 00:19:35.791
that would be much easier to pass than one that
costs money to the government, right?
00:19:35.791 --> 00:19:41.231
So if you can create something that's revenue neutral, you can't allow a large
00:19:41.231 --> 00:19:43.872
amount of capital gains to escape taxation.
00:19:44.698 --> 00:19:51.835
So the key is not necessarily to make every situation the most favorable situation you can.
00:19:52.254 --> 00:19:54.564
The key is let's stop.
00:19:57.107 --> 00:20:02.677
The impact on people going forward and then focus a little bit on how we can
00:20:02.677 --> 00:20:04.978
minimize the impact on people in the past.
00:20:05.443 --> 00:20:10.507
And I don't think that was the approach that was taken in the,
00:20:10.507 --> 00:20:15.611
you know, in the Lloyd Bill. How would you characterize the approach that was taken?
00:20:17.287 --> 00:20:20.138
It was a very expensive bill. I mean, it was very expensive.
00:20:20.493 --> 00:20:24.247
Was it primarily focused on the past, more so than the future?
00:20:24.247 --> 00:20:31.667
It was very much focused not only on the past, but even people that didn't live
00:20:31.667 --> 00:20:36.267
overseas could move overseas and avoid paying capital gains on millions.
00:20:37.518 --> 00:20:39.352
Of dollars worth of assets.
00:20:39.991 --> 00:20:44.187
And I mean that's a that's a great thing from a lobbyist point of view and of
00:20:44.187 --> 00:20:46.941
course there was lobbyists involved there were a lot of people involved in this
00:20:47.342 --> 00:20:50.067
and I'm sure you know from from many of the,
00:20:50.567 --> 00:20:54.337
of the Republican legislators who you know are very anti-tax they were very
00:20:54.337 --> 00:20:59.804
favorable but I think there's a difference between what we'd like to see and what,
00:21:00.527 --> 00:21:04.617
what might be realistic right what we can get past and so you know I've been
00:21:04.617 --> 00:21:09.459
going up on the hill every year for three or four years now. I usually...
00:21:10.377 --> 00:21:13.674
You know, sort of lead to technical teams. And I deal a lot with Republicans
00:21:13.999 --> 00:21:17.792
and, you know, they're, they're, they don't understand any of these issues.
00:21:17.903 --> 00:21:22.960
I mean, every time, you know, you're, you, you have to start from zero and there
00:21:22.960 --> 00:21:25.880
are other people that are out there also lobbying for these issues.
00:21:25.880 --> 00:21:29.210
And some of them are focused on how unfair it is and how, you know,
00:21:29.210 --> 00:21:30.730
Americans shouldn't have to pay taxes.
00:21:30.730 --> 00:21:34.570
They live overseas. And okay. I mean, the fairness issue is okay.
00:21:34.570 --> 00:21:37.900
If you look at United States in isolation, but if you
00:21:38.280 --> 00:21:42.310
are focused on many countries like i am and you see all the different techniques
00:21:42.310 --> 00:21:46.363
they use for example you know in the u.s you can have basically a couple can
00:21:46.683 --> 00:21:52.464
can die with 30 million dollars and not pay any estate tax well i'm you know in in france for example,
00:21:52.964 --> 00:21:55.431
after a hundred thousand dollars you're going to be paying.
00:21:56.981 --> 00:22:01.210
Tax that go up to 60 right so you know there are different levels of fairness
00:22:01.210 --> 00:22:02.984
in various different issues and i think sometimes
00:22:03.356 --> 00:22:06.845
there's too much of a focus on us right like we're americans and we we want
00:22:07.070 --> 00:22:10.020
what we want and we you know we don't think about the good things we have we
00:22:10.020 --> 00:22:12.080
just think about the bad things that are out there and,
00:22:12.751 --> 00:22:17.840
and i think that you know the i think a maybe a better approach would be to
00:22:17.840 --> 00:22:21.347
focus on trying to to get something passed that's realistic
00:22:21.765 --> 00:22:25.350
instead of you know betting the farm on something that i think there was a real
00:22:25.350 --> 00:22:27.762
opportunity and i think there was some,
00:22:28.442 --> 00:22:32.040
probably maybe maybe it was unavoidable but there were certain things that touched
00:22:32.040 --> 00:22:36.040
social security, which didn't allow it to go through, through the reconciliation
00:22:36.040 --> 00:22:37.463
process, this LaHood bill.
00:22:37.933 --> 00:22:42.320
And then I think the reality at some point was that if a Republican was for
00:22:42.320 --> 00:22:45.410
it, the Democrats weren't, and if a Democrat was for it, Republicans weren't.
00:22:45.410 --> 00:22:49.540
So you want a period of several years, uh, we've gone through where anything
00:22:49.540 --> 00:22:51.754
bipartisan was looked at with suspicion.
00:22:52.207 --> 00:22:57.770
And, uh, and, and so, you know, you, it's not necessarily only one reason that
00:22:57.770 --> 00:22:59.644
this was a very expensive bill.
00:23:01.135 --> 00:23:06.872
They had hoped to cut it down. I just think that would be a far better solution going forward.
00:23:07.352 --> 00:23:11.119
Of course, complexity is always a problem.
00:23:11.594 --> 00:23:16.712
Let me ask you this, right? So you focus on, I mean, there are obviously different
00:23:16.712 --> 00:23:18.572
components of the cost thing, right?
00:23:18.572 --> 00:23:22.892
But, you know, listening to you talk about this, you're focusing on,
00:23:22.892 --> 00:23:29.232
or your focus includes certainly the issue of capital gains taxation, right?
00:23:29.232 --> 00:23:33.822
That should people be able to you know accrue gains in the united states and
00:23:33.822 --> 00:23:38.552
then leave and by the way for the record i mean this is what all kinds of visa
00:23:38.552 --> 00:23:42.622
people in the united states right who are not green card holders do you know i mean they'll,
00:23:43.243 --> 00:23:47.472
be there for a number of years and you know i mean i've met many of them right
00:23:47.472 --> 00:23:51.192
accumulate massive capital gains or whatever and then
just leaving that stuff
00:23:51.192 --> 00:23:53.969
does does escape u.s taxation period.
00:23:55.894 --> 00:24:02.742
But let me ask you this, right? So assume, right, let's assume that capturing,
00:24:03.322 --> 00:24:07.443
as a capital gains tax, the increase in value of these assets while somebody
00:24:07.443 --> 00:24:10.748
lives in the United States is a priority.
00:24:11.110 --> 00:24:17.043
What would you think about just a change in the law that simply allowed the
00:24:17.043 --> 00:24:22.982
U.S. to retain taxing rights over all of an American citizen's assets until they were sold?
00:24:23.871 --> 00:24:26.853
In other words, don't worry about it. you know, and sort of moving up.
00:24:27.790 --> 00:24:32.473
That's a process actually that does exist in other countries where there's a
00:24:32.473 --> 00:24:37.509
period of time that if the asset is sold within five years, for example,
00:24:37.805 --> 00:24:41.038
then it would be taxed back to the country of origin.
00:24:41.434 --> 00:24:45.212
And if you held it more than five years, then you would escape taxation completely.
00:24:45.986 --> 00:24:48.790
There's all kinds of ideas and there's all kinds of ways to do it.
00:24:49.271 --> 00:24:54.123
Ultimately, though, the capital gains tax in the U.S., at least in terms of
00:24:54.123 --> 00:24:58.453
the European countries we work with is very, very low. It's the lowest, right?
00:24:59.249 --> 00:25:03.473
You can gain $50,000 as a single person without paying any taxes,
00:25:03.763 --> 00:25:07.182
and then you have a rate of 15%, and then eventually 20%.
00:25:07.525 --> 00:25:12.843
Well, yes, you can add the NIT, et cetera, to add a few percent,
00:25:12.843 --> 00:25:17.443
but it's nowhere close to the kinds of taxes you're going to be paying in Europe
00:25:17.443 --> 00:25:18.823
that can be far, far higher.
00:25:18.823 --> 00:25:23.252
I should say nowhere close, but they can be much higher.
00:25:24.033 --> 00:25:28.993
Well, clearly, as a general principle, unless you're looking at the edge case
00:25:28.993 --> 00:25:34.243
of aspects of being an American broad, I think we can agree that the income
00:25:34.243 --> 00:25:38.306
taxation in the United States is generally lower than other countries. Correct?
00:25:39.568 --> 00:25:44.854
That's, that's right. So also you have, you know, you have a market that's far,
00:25:45.914 --> 00:25:49.364
more conducive to making money in the United States and people are more focused
00:25:49.364 --> 00:25:53.614
on those kinds of things in the U S whether it's portfolio assets or,
00:25:54.054 --> 00:25:58.004
you know, the huge moves we had in, in, in real estate, which a lot of people
00:25:58.004 --> 00:26:00.074
made a lot of money on or stock options.
00:26:00.074 --> 00:26:01.674
You know those kinds of those kinds
00:26:01.674 --> 00:26:05.314
of gains don't necessarily exist everywhere in the world but you know.
00:26:07.180 --> 00:26:10.576
Whether they do
or not people own assets in europe they may be a u.s citizen
00:26:10.825 --> 00:26:14.499
they bought a house and you know in the netherlands up to 15 or 20 years ago
00:26:14.923 --> 00:26:18.744
and or in france if you hold a property for 30 years there's no capital gains
00:26:18.744 --> 00:26:23.565
tax in france if you hold the property that long and then to turn around and get a bill from uncle sam,
00:26:24.442 --> 00:26:29.387
for a property in in in europe that Uncle Sam had nothing to do with, right?
00:26:29.695 --> 00:26:33.003
You know, we remember the Boris Johnson case a few years ago when he was,
00:26:33.293 --> 00:26:36.624
you know, he got a bill for something like a half a million dollars on his townhouse,
00:26:36.624 --> 00:26:38.245
right? He was the prime minister of England, right?
00:26:38.506 --> 00:26:44.174
So, you know, there are plenty of aspects that don't make sense or taxing on
00:26:44.174 --> 00:26:47.934
the gains from currencies, et cetera. But, you know,
00:26:49.974 --> 00:26:55.189
it's not a good system, okay? None of them are very good, especially when they cross borders.
00:26:55.601 --> 00:26:59.224
Because in every country, when you start looking at these cross-border issues
00:26:59.224 --> 00:27:05.497
from the point of view of a national from that country, it can be very ugly for everybody.
00:27:06.374 --> 00:27:10.002
It's not just the Americans, right? It's just not fair to Americans.
00:27:10.908 --> 00:27:15.302
You have these exit taxes in many, many countries, and you have all kinds of
00:27:15.302 --> 00:27:17.943
other kinds of taxes and issues that make it complicated.
00:27:19.882 --> 00:27:24.792
You make a very interesting point about exit taxes, and this sort of echoes
00:27:24.792 --> 00:27:28.831
something that I believe for a very, very long time.
00:27:29.227 --> 00:27:32.342
And that is that, you know, so we compare U.S.
00:27:32.342 --> 00:27:38.662
Citizenship taxation to other countries' residence-based taxation system.
00:27:38.662 --> 00:27:41.823
And you see, what does that mean in terms of exit taxes? Well,
00:27:42.529 --> 00:27:45.492
you know, if it's a residence-based taxation system, like, say,
00:27:45.492 --> 00:27:49.862
Canada, for example, you know, you leave Canada and you're subject to,
00:27:50.182 --> 00:27:52.942
you know, their version of the exit tax.
00:27:52.942 --> 00:27:57.042
They call them departure tax. But what's interesting is that a U.S.
00:27:57.042 --> 00:28:02.462
Citizen can leave the United States, keep citizenship, and avoid exit taxes, right?
00:28:02.462 --> 00:28:08.582
So, I mean, would it be a legitimate argument that, in a way,
00:28:08.582 --> 00:28:13.362
Could one argue, should one argue that citizenship taxation actually enhances
00:28:13.362 --> 00:28:15.413
the mobility of American citizens?
00:28:16.602 --> 00:28:23.491
No, I don't think you can argue that because we see movements for citizenship-based taxation in Europe.
00:28:23.740 --> 00:28:27.711
France, for example, has one political party that would love to initiate it.
00:28:28.071 --> 00:28:31.461
And the reason is, is because they're trying to close their economy.
00:28:31.914 --> 00:28:35.937
In other words, if I have a tax rate and I raise taxes on the wealthy,
00:28:36.378 --> 00:28:39.142
well, the wealthy can just leave, right? They can move to a neighboring country.
00:28:40.060 --> 00:28:46.033
By offering or by creating a citizenship-based taxation, they're able to raise
00:28:46.033 --> 00:28:49.452
the tax rates on everybody without the ability to escape it.
00:28:49.905 --> 00:28:52.683
So clearly that's not, you know, more fair.
00:28:53.563 --> 00:28:56.573
That's just a way to capture the taxes of wealthy people.
00:28:56.573 --> 00:29:02.623
And many of the very populist governments are the ones that are promoting this tax, the rich, and tax.
00:29:02.623 --> 00:29:08.553
You know, there's a big issue in Europe where they're going to blame a lot of
00:29:08.553 --> 00:29:10.163
things on the billionaires, right?
00:29:10.163 --> 00:29:16.103
As if the billionaires are really that big of a percentage of the taxation or something else.
00:29:16.103 --> 00:29:21.504
So, no, I don't sort of support that if you raise taxes, people,
00:29:21.864 --> 00:29:24.473
well, I mean, seriously, if you raise taxes, people are going to hire people
00:29:24.473 --> 00:29:26.003
like me who are going to find ways to get them out of it.
00:29:27.043 --> 00:29:30.313
This is just how it works. I mean, it's part of our job is to figure out how
00:29:30.313 --> 00:29:31.393
to get around the rules, right?
00:29:31.393 --> 00:29:35.243
So, you know, we're here talking about how to play with the rules and maybe
00:29:35.243 --> 00:29:37.193
by changing the law so the rules are more fair.
00:29:37.193 --> 00:29:43.053
But, you know, those who have the assets, they can hire people like us and our
00:29:43.053 --> 00:29:46.803
role is to figure out how to avoid the taxes. So none of it's fair.
00:29:47.123 --> 00:29:51.883
Okay, none of it's fair. So what we're looking for, really, the gold standard
00:29:51.883 --> 00:29:57.003
would be an island of reasonableness and an ocean of basic unfairness.
00:29:57.003 --> 00:30:01.393
Fairness would that be a good way to well no i mean ultimately it comes down
00:30:01.393 --> 00:30:06.803
to the fact that the system was built on a single jurisdiction and now the,
00:30:08.063 --> 00:30:11.693
the the the trend is multiple jurisdictions right people living in one country
00:30:11.693 --> 00:30:15.753
having children in other countries having you know receiving inheritance from
00:30:15.753 --> 00:30:19.976
parents in a third country owning property in a fourth and the complexities are just,
00:30:20.783 --> 00:30:24.703
you know the systems would never created for that right not in the u.s not in
00:30:24.703 --> 00:30:30.443
europe not anywhere So this is why it's, it's,
let's say, let's say somebody
00:30:30.443 --> 00:30:31.912
comes to you and says, Robert.
00:30:33.474 --> 00:30:38.953
So thinking of moving to Europe, our families originally from Europe,
00:30:38.953 --> 00:30:44.245
grandparents, et cetera, what are the types of things we ought to be concerned with here?
00:30:45.113 --> 00:30:47.973
Well, if they're coming from the U.S., the first thing you might think about
00:30:47.973 --> 00:30:51.626
is do they have a trust or are they the beneficiary of a trust?
00:30:52.822 --> 00:30:56.843
Because now in many countries, because, you know, you have two different kinds
00:30:56.843 --> 00:30:57.936
of legal systems, right?
00:30:58.302 --> 00:31:02.103
You have the common law system, right, like in Canada or England or the United
00:31:02.103 --> 00:31:05.012
States or New Zealand, Australia. And you have the civil law system.
00:31:05.488 --> 00:31:13.523
So when you start crossing common law instruments like trusts with civil law
00:31:13.523 --> 00:31:20.100
regulations that don't recognize trust, you start getting into a whole set of complications.
00:31:20.605 --> 00:31:21.870
So it's not like a symbolic.
00:31:23.582 --> 00:31:29.927
Thing or if you have an llc right an llc in america may not be considered transparent
00:31:30.136 --> 00:31:35.430
in europe or depending on the country right so each each system is different
00:31:35.430 --> 00:31:37.140
if you are you know if you are,
00:31:37.860 --> 00:31:43.240
in in in denmark for example they tax you on your unrealized gains right 42
00:31:43.240 --> 00:31:48.890
unrealized gains netherlands was was looking for a similar proposal 36 on unrealized
00:31:48.890 --> 00:31:52.020
gains so it's you know and now they have a crazy system.
00:31:52.960 --> 00:31:57.970
That they call unconstitutional, but it's based on an estimated return on your
00:31:57.970 --> 00:32:00.280
assets, whether you earned it or you didn't earn it, right?
00:32:00.280 --> 00:32:06.422
So, I mean, you have all kinds of different systems out there that are not designed to work together.
00:32:07.041 --> 00:32:12.167
And that's what part of the lack of design, I can break this down a little bit.
00:32:12.817 --> 00:32:17.950
You know, it's interesting to me that you start off with trusts, LLCs, et cetera.
00:32:17.950 --> 00:32:23.950
And I think what you're really implying there is that it's quite possible in
00:32:23.950 --> 00:32:25.448
the United States to have
00:32:25.762 --> 00:32:31.377
assets and things that either are or are not taxed directly to the individual,
00:32:31.493 --> 00:32:33.668
and that treatment may be different,
00:32:34.173 --> 00:32:35.680
in the country that you move to.
00:32:35.680 --> 00:32:37.910
So for example, well, one that
00:32:37.910 --> 00:32:43.700
I know very well, in Canada, US LLCs are considered to be corporations.
00:32:43.700 --> 00:32:49.460
You know, separate legal entities, et cetera, which obviously sets up the potential
00:32:49.460 --> 00:32:51.356
for, you know, for double taxation.
00:32:51.699 --> 00:32:55.500
And yes, it does, because they may not be subject to the tax trees were not
00:32:55.500 --> 00:32:56.950
designed for corporations, right?
00:32:56.950 --> 00:33:00.540
They were designed for individuals. So, and you have a, you know,
00:33:00.540 --> 00:33:05.245
you have a whole series of things in different countries. For example,
00:33:05.716 --> 00:33:10.882
if you own a U.S. ETF and you move to France, it's taxed the United States.
00:33:11.630 --> 00:33:14.939
If you move to Italy, it's not only taxed in Italy, but it.
00:33:15.870 --> 00:33:20.514
It's taxes, ordinary income, which very quickly gets to be 43%, right?
00:33:20.700 --> 00:33:26.935
So a U.S. ETF is going to be very negatively taxed. Same thing in Austria. A U.S. ETF is a disaster.
00:33:27.521 --> 00:33:30.840
But in other countries, for example, France, a U.S. ETF is fine.
00:33:31.223 --> 00:33:34.235
And so then the question is, can you buy them? And the answer is yes,
00:33:34.235 --> 00:33:36.605
but you have to opt out from a regulatory standpoint.
00:33:36.866 --> 00:33:40.545
All of these things are just, you know, it's like people today used to be you
00:33:40.545 --> 00:33:44.135
would hire a firm that would do a big analysis of your taxes and what country
00:33:44.135 --> 00:33:47.431
you should move to and what passport you should get. And it still exists,
00:33:47.768 --> 00:33:50.425
but more and more people just say, yeah, I'm getting out.
00:33:50.725 --> 00:33:53.752
I want to move and I want to live someplace else.
00:33:54.350 --> 00:33:58.814
And they move without ever thinking about the financial implications.
00:33:59.244 --> 00:34:04.465
So if you move to Italy, you know, and you move there with capital gains, you know.
00:34:05.483 --> 00:34:08.426
And ETF capital gains, boom, you're going to get hit with, you know,
00:34:08.426 --> 00:34:13.086
43% tax. It's not a pleasant thing because you made all that money while you
00:34:13.086 --> 00:34:16.966
were living in the United States, but you're going to pay taxes the day you moved to Italy.
00:34:17.082 --> 00:34:20.556
But sometimes if you moved to Italy in August, you don't pay taxes because you
00:34:20.556 --> 00:34:21.876
haven't lived there for the year.
00:34:22.074 --> 00:34:26.586
So each country, I mean, it's just like there's so many complexities here, John.
00:34:26.906 --> 00:34:31.526
So don't you think that in general, in general, a starting question,
00:34:31.526 --> 00:34:34.866
say somebody wants to move wherever, leave the United States,
00:34:34.866 --> 00:34:36.698
leave anywhere, Canada, whatever,
00:34:37.366 --> 00:34:42.166
would be, let's take a look at your assets and let's see if there's any assets
00:34:42.166 --> 00:34:44.523
that you should not bring with you to the new country.
00:34:45.092 --> 00:34:49.696
For sure. That's definitely a question. That seems really, really
basic, right?
00:34:49.696 --> 00:34:54.106
You know, we can apply that to trusts. We can apply it to, you know,
00:34:54.106 --> 00:34:57.346
these various business entities, you know, et cetera. So, I mean,
00:34:57.346 --> 00:35:00.416
I agree with you. That's absolutely key.
00:35:01.105 --> 00:35:05.056
Second, another point that you make that, you know, I think is quite,
00:35:05.056 --> 00:35:09.326
quite interesting, but I'd like to try to generalize as a principle because
00:35:09.326 --> 00:35:11.476
I think it's so, so important would be this.
00:35:12.132 --> 00:35:17.466
Never assume that income from a certain kind of asset, that the way it's taxed
00:35:17.466 --> 00:35:23.252
in the country where you live in terms of how the income is characterized, the form of the income,
00:35:23.915 --> 00:35:28.588
that that will definitely translate over to how it's taxed in the new country. Agreed.
00:35:29.241 --> 00:35:34.786
Yes, that's true as well. And you have another issue is that there are,
00:35:34.786 --> 00:35:40.560
for example, in Germany, there is a new pension plan that's been established. It's like an IRA.
00:35:41.303 --> 00:35:43.806
It walks like an IRA. It talks like an IRA.
00:35:46.772 --> 00:35:51.196
It would be really everything an IRA would be, and it should be considered a
00:35:51.196 --> 00:35:53.651
qualified plan as a pension plan.
00:35:54.981 --> 00:36:00.301
But then you never have the IRS say, hey, you know, we've analyzed it.
00:36:00.301 --> 00:36:04.066
And yes, that is a pension plan. And therefore, you can treat it like a pension plan.
00:36:04.960 --> 00:36:08.331
And there's a huge risk in all of these things that the IRS one day will come back.
00:36:08.331 --> 00:36:17.007
And this is like a big push at the Taxation Task Force is to push for more disclosure, more,
00:36:17.577 --> 00:36:21.314
contact from the IRS or from the Treasury Department to be able to tell us what,
00:36:21.773 --> 00:36:23.391
could be considered a retirement plan.
00:36:23.391 --> 00:36:28.437
Because if, for example, this German plan is considered a retirement plan.
00:36:29.464 --> 00:36:33.998
It means I can invest in funds and ETFs, even if they are European funds and ETFs.
00:36:34.625 --> 00:36:38.631
I would never be concerned with getting hit with a big whopping tax from the
00:36:38.631 --> 00:36:42.911
IRS of what we call a PIFIC, a passive foreign investment corp.
00:36:42.911 --> 00:36:44.836
It's taxed at the highest tax brackets.
00:36:45.335 --> 00:36:49.441
But if the IRS 10 years from now, after I've been saving my money for 10 years
00:36:49.441 --> 00:36:53.514
in this retirement plan, one day decides, no, we're not going to consider that,
00:36:54.524 --> 00:37:00.211
a qualified pension plan, then boom, you know, you who have been innocently
00:37:00.211 --> 00:37:03.321
following what you thought was the rules, you know, one day you're going to
00:37:03.321 --> 00:37:09.432
wake up to find, oh no, you
know, now I'm going to have to pay huge taxes my retirement.
00:37:09.948 --> 00:37:13.170
And so, you know, these are the kinds of things that are incredibly irritating
00:37:13.449 --> 00:37:18.671
because we We don't get from the U.S. government, we don't get enough information.
00:37:18.671 --> 00:37:22.066
And, of course, I understand they're afraid to stop.
00:37:22.987 --> 00:37:27.289
This is approved. And then that country makes a change. They do something.
00:37:27.289 --> 00:37:29.628
These countries are changing their laws every year.
00:37:29.941 --> 00:37:33.343
And then the IRS misses it. And then, you know, it ends up becoming a big loophole.
00:37:33.633 --> 00:37:39.639
So you can understand both points of view, but it makes it really hard to know
00:37:39.639 --> 00:37:43.109
what to do. A lack of certainty, a lack of safe harbors, et cetera.
00:37:43.109 --> 00:37:46.119
Now, while we're on this particular point in the discussion,
00:37:46.419 --> 00:37:47.899
let me ask you a question.
00:37:48.607 --> 00:37:52.504
You know, this is an issue that It becomes more or less prevalent,
00:37:52.794 --> 00:37:54.769
you know, how people are talking about it.
00:37:54.769 --> 00:37:58.109
But let's talk about the Australian superannuation for a minute,
00:37:58.109 --> 00:38:06.063
which is, you know, a real sore point, right, for Americans abroad and how that is to be treated.
00:38:06.820 --> 00:38:12.129
And, you know, what this is in general is a, you know, these are required contributions,
00:38:12.129 --> 00:38:15.979
you know, based on employment and, you know, retirement plans.
00:38:15.979 --> 00:38:22.779
Yeah, they came into being after the 1982 U.S.-Australian tax treaty. Right.
00:38:23.459 --> 00:38:27.199
And this is, I think, a classic case, right? It's a poster child,
00:38:27.199 --> 00:38:32.549
if you will, for uncertainty, no guidance from the IRS, this sort of thing.
00:38:32.549 --> 00:38:39.499
What would be your view if you were advising somebody on not necessarily how
00:38:39.499 --> 00:38:43.741
that should be treated, but how to deal with the problem of uncertainty?
00:38:44.737 --> 00:38:50.989
It's you know there was a there's a big issue uh i'm not a specialist in australia
00:38:50.989 --> 00:38:52.549
i work in europe but there was
00:38:52.549 --> 00:38:59.006
a a product in europe called a chance v and for many years we thought it.
00:39:00.098 --> 00:39:04.201
This would be a perfect, this would just not be allowed by the U.S. government.
00:39:04.741 --> 00:39:08.657
But it turns out that there was a group of U.S.
00:39:08.657 --> 00:39:12.747
Accountants in France that met and they went through all of the,
00:39:12.747 --> 00:39:14.822
you know, the rules and regulations from an accounting point of view,
00:39:15.095 --> 00:39:19.567
and they all concluded that no assurance fee was not going to be a problem and
00:39:19.567 --> 00:39:21.092
people could buy it. Americans could buy it.
00:39:21.579 --> 00:39:25.115
And, you know, this is the kind of surety that we need,
00:39:25.654 --> 00:39:29.887
when, you know, you have basically the the american accountants in a country
00:39:29.887 --> 00:39:34.817
come out and and because ultimately they're going to have to prepare these tax
00:39:34.817 --> 00:39:38.692
returns and they're going to have to sign them that what you've done is,
00:39:39.296 --> 00:39:43.104
is correct right and so i think you you you know,
00:39:43.727 --> 00:39:48.996
you you try to to limit your risk by by you know getting,
00:39:49.919 --> 00:39:55.447
the sign off of of of a cpa in the country that you live that has some knowledge
00:39:55.447 --> 00:40:01.047
of But this is the best way that I would look to protect myself by working with
00:40:01.047 --> 00:40:02.487
those who are going to agree.
00:40:02.487 --> 00:40:05.967
And I can tell you there are many that won't agree with what you're doing.
00:40:06.507 --> 00:40:12.504
And if you continue to do it anyway, I think your risk is higher of being at fault.
00:40:12.986 --> 00:40:15.993
But there are so many things you can't think of, John, that you'll never think of. For example...
00:40:16.930 --> 00:40:21.822
Your your parents have revocable trust at their death it becomes an irrevocable
00:40:21.822 --> 00:40:27.832
trust and the idea is the money would go to you know to to the to the spouse to the to
00:40:28.272 --> 00:40:32.702
the husband or to the wife and when they die the second to die it would be distributed to the kids,
00:40:33.225 --> 00:40:35.627
but now see some countries who,
00:40:36.555 --> 00:40:41.922
don't do well with trust like france they may tax you 30 when you take the money
00:40:41.922 --> 00:40:45.232
from the trust And so, you know, you can look at all the things that you have,
00:40:45.232 --> 00:40:50.192
your assets, your life, but you may not even know that your parents created a trust,
00:40:50.832 --> 00:40:54.182
and the implications of all these kinds of things that fall years later.
00:40:54.182 --> 00:40:56.263
And then you realize, oh, I'm the beneficiary.
00:40:56.599 --> 00:41:00.152
And I never knew I was supposed to be filing returns on these or the trustee
00:41:00.152 --> 00:41:02.302
was supposed to be filing because I live in this country.
00:41:02.639 --> 00:41:07.312
And, oh, the fine, 20,000 euros a year. Like there, there, there's just like,
00:41:07.312 --> 00:41:09.774
there's just, it's not like, it's not easy.
00:41:10.121 --> 00:41:12.752
And you know i think too many people end up,
00:41:13.815 --> 00:41:17.312
you know not understanding this and there's no you know there's no books there's
00:41:17.312 --> 00:41:18.872
no courses you know they have they have a
00:41:19.272 --> 00:41:22.801
certified financial planner right and they have a certified financial planner
00:41:22.946 --> 00:41:26.661
in the united states but what a cfp in the united states learns is u.s law
00:41:27.044 -->
00:41:31.622
and they have a cfp in france for example and what a cfp in france is french
00:41:31.622 --> 00:41:35.732
law but they don't learn how to deal with a u.s citizen living in france or
00:41:35.732 --> 00:41:37.610
how to deal with a French citizen living in the United States.
00:41:38.979 --> 00:41:42.942
They don't deal with those kinds of things. So there's no real education programs
00:41:42.942 --> 00:41:47.751
out there, which makes it very, very, very difficult.
00:41:48.134 --> 00:41:53.152
And there are very few firms like ours out there that actually focus on these areas.
00:41:53.695 --> 00:41:59.192
And our learning curve continues to be enormous every year. I think you've got
00:41:59.192 --> 00:42:03.353
to be a permanent student of this stuff, right? And you're not doing your job. Agreed?
00:42:03.847 --> 00:42:06.532
Yeah. And the rules are changing, you know, in each country.
00:42:06.532 --> 00:42:08.652
We're coming up with a new law and, you know.
00:42:09.665 --> 00:42:12.998
And just like in the U S you know, they have, they have the new limits for the
00:42:12.998 --> 00:42:15.487
401k and et cetera, et cetera. You got to know all those for,
00:42:15.993 --> 00:42:19.328
for, you know, for dual countries. So I think it's, it's, you know,
00:42:20.088 --> 00:42:21.363
a lot of people just don't know.
00:42:21.827 --> 00:42:25.678
And ignorance is maybe, you know, good thing. Sometimes they,
00:42:25.678 --> 00:42:30.348
they, they, they escape, but here's what happened and making it really worse, John.
00:42:30.348 --> 00:42:34.128
And we went through a period of COVID and during the period of COVID,
00:42:34.128 --> 00:42:37.568
the tax authorities, right. And this is a particularly important time,
00:42:37.568 --> 00:42:41.138
right. because it's not that long after the FATCA regulations, et cetera.
00:42:41.492 --> 00:42:46.648
And for many years after COVID, the tax authorities were focused on catching
00:42:46.648 --> 00:42:49.608
up for what was done during COVID.
00:42:50.049 --> 00:42:54.999
And now they've caught up. And now they are turning their eyes on the things,
00:42:55.923 --> 00:42:57.590
that they weren't looking at before.
00:42:58.071 --> 00:43:01.608
So the rules were always there, but they were not paying attention.
00:43:01.608 --> 00:43:07.998
And then you add artificial intelligence, which allows them to target you even
00:43:07.998 --> 00:43:12.064
more specifically and so this you know this is relatively new,
00:43:12.523 --> 00:43:16.998
and particularly in the last six months in in in france for example where they're
00:43:16.998 --> 00:43:19.515
going after these trusts in ways they never did before,
00:43:20.084 --> 00:43:23.478
and it's because now they have the focus and guess what they don't know what
00:43:23.478 --> 00:43:28.216
a trust is right and neither do many of the lawyers that are are working tax.
00:43:29.283 --> 00:43:32.528
Lawyers in europe they don't know what a trust is because they don't really
00:43:32.528 --> 00:43:36.718
understand they can't really understand why a trust was set up because they
00:43:36.718 --> 00:43:39.878
don't have that you know that american knowledge they weren't they weren't living
00:43:39.878 --> 00:43:42.430
in america where people had these kinds of things right and so,
00:43:42.947 --> 00:43:47.538
they're working with a set of rules or trying to understand and interpret with
00:43:47.538 --> 00:43:52.038
products that they don't fully understand and in an environment that's changing
00:43:52.038 --> 00:43:57.172
and becoming much more hazardous and so it's it you know it it's it's.
00:43:58.519 --> 00:44:03.605
It's complicated, right? But it's all doable. It's, there are ways to get around
00:44:03.605 --> 00:44:07.295
all these things, but it's not like you can sit back in your house and,
00:44:07.295 --> 00:44:11.544
and, and, you know, and read, you know, a basic book on, you know, how to become an expat.
00:44:11.973 --> 00:44:15.125
And, and, you know, it strikes me that what you're describing,
00:44:15.125 --> 00:44:20.619
listening to you talk about this would be a problem equally for say Canadians
00:44:20.793 --> 00:44:22.805
or Australians moving to Europe.
00:44:22.805 --> 00:44:26.445
I mean, you know, the problem is the incompatibility of the tax system,
00:44:26.445 --> 00:44:28.765
not citizenship taxation.
00:44:29.145 --> 00:44:35.556
That's exactly right, John. Because you could be a citizen of Luxembourg,
00:44:35.904 --> 00:44:37.478
but you're working in the Netherlands.
00:44:37.756 --> 00:44:42.180
You're, you know, maybe you have property in Mexico, you have property in Spain,
00:44:42.412 --> 00:44:46.725
you have, you know, and you have the same set of complexities, right?
00:44:47.285 --> 00:44:52.786
It's not the U.S., it's not citizenship-based taxation, it's multiple jurisdiction
00:44:53.146 --> 00:44:55.293
and taxation within multiple jurisdictions.
00:44:55.642 --> 00:45:00.425
And finding the expertise to be able to navigate. Oh, the expertise.
00:45:00.425 --> 00:45:04.111
There's very little expertise on this. I mean, it's hard to even,
00:45:04.314 --> 00:45:08.935
part of the problem of this is, it's hard to even articulate what the precise issue is.
00:45:09.690 --> 00:45:13.195
I think on many cases you're trying to solve. But, you know,
00:45:13.195 --> 00:45:16.945
it's very interesting to me, and I appreciate this conversation because,
00:45:16.945 --> 00:45:18.815
you know, it strikes me in my mind, right?
00:45:18.815 --> 00:45:24.355
You know, I've got a thing about these people moving to another place with existing
00:45:24.355 --> 00:45:26.284
assets, whatever they may have.
00:45:26.665 --> 00:45:31.340
And then we have the overlay of the whole U.S. citizenship taxation problem
00:45:31.496 --> 00:45:35.822
that aggravates that for certain people in certain ways.
00:45:37.045 --> 00:45:41.765
Depending on the kind of
investment income they have and all that sort of stuff.
00:45:42.846 --> 00:45:48.105
But, you know, I mean, my God, I mean, this whole multi-jurisdiction taxation
00:45:48.105 --> 00:45:53.114
or citizenship taxation, I mean, it's really created a 21st century industry,
00:45:53.843 --> 00:45:56.890
of a different kind of financial planning, hasn't it?
00:45:58.066 --> 00:46:02.037
Well, I'm not sure that would consider us in an industry, right?
00:46:02.315 --> 00:46:07.880
Because as far as I know, in France, we're the only firm that works in this
00:46:07.880 --> 00:46:09.116
area that's licensed in France.
00:46:09.518 --> 00:46:14.476
So there used to be a series of firms actually in Europe that were from the UK.
00:46:15.089 --> 00:46:20.383
But with Brexit, they no longer had the licensing to be able to do it.
00:46:20.958 --> 00:46:24.140
So they kind of stepped out. But they didn't do it to the extent that it's done
00:46:24.140 --> 00:46:28.272
today because it's far more complicated than, you know, even three or four years ago.
00:46:28.644 --> 00:46:32.120
It's getting more and more and more complicated. And so to try to get into this
00:46:32.120 --> 00:46:34.070
business, I know there are a lot of U.S.
00:46:34.070 --> 00:46:36.537
Firms that are trying, would love to get into Europe because it's a,
00:46:36.926 --> 00:46:40.920
you know, it's a huge growth market, right, with lots of assets and lots of
00:46:40.920 --> 00:46:44.820
complexities, but they haven't figured out how to even get through their own regulatory system.
00:46:46.600 --> 00:46:50.740
They're shackled down by their own regulation. Yes, but they're also,
00:46:50.740 --> 00:46:52.046
you know, they're trying to create,
00:46:53.200 --> 00:46:56.180
u.s type of wealth management in europe
00:46:56.600 --> 00:47:01.340
and it just doesn't you know it doesn't work there's not one size fits all you
00:47:01.340 --> 00:47:05.470
can't create an expat factory and and there are firms that you know have have
00:47:05.470 --> 00:47:08.540
really tried to do that even entering into the mass market of people with a
00:47:08.540 --> 00:47:10.447
hundred thousand dollars in assets
00:47:10.818 --> 00:47:14.748
and uh it's it's you know it's very challenging but i think it's even more challenging
00:47:15.189 --> 00:47:19.148
for those who are trying to save in the beginning
00:47:19.537 --> 00:47:24.094
right who don't have much experience and need some level of expertise because
00:47:24.413 --> 00:47:28.581
it's it's very hard to find anybody who's going to take on someone who
00:47:28.964 --> 00:47:32.610
you know is just trying to put away you know three or four hundred dollars a
00:47:32.610 --> 00:47:36.780
month right how do you do that right and then you know to explain dollar cost averaging and,
00:47:37.552 --> 00:47:42.120
and how that's like a client that you seek i mean how does your you know,
00:47:42.707 --> 00:47:47.171
no i most of my clients personally that i work with have at least five million
00:47:47.496 --> 00:47:54.212
in assets our firm takes clients that with 1 million in assets that we we take under management,
00:47:56.080 --> 00:47:58.189
There's a, you know, a huge group of people that.
00:48:00.229 --> 00:48:03.709
Are much younger trying to, you know, they come over, they get a job,
00:48:03.709 --> 00:48:07.958
they try to save for their life, their retirement, and they're completely befuddled
00:48:08.260 --> 00:48:11.659
by all the different rules and regulations.
00:48:11.659 --> 00:48:14.819
I mean, it would impact anybody, right? If you took, you know,
00:48:14.819 --> 00:48:19.619
someone from Europe and you moved them to the U.S. and you started talking about
00:48:19.619 --> 00:48:23.849
401ks and 403s. Oh, absolutely. It's a mobility problem, right?
00:48:24.009 --> 00:48:27.979
Right. So, I mean, as we have enhanced mobility, we have enhanced complexity.
00:48:27.979 --> 00:48:31.369
And, you know, I think largely, you know, the create the well,
00:48:31.769 --> 00:48:37.639
I think we're at the beginning stages of the of a larger raising of the consciousness
00:48:37.639 --> 00:48:40.089
of this is a problem. Right. Or as an issue.
00:48:40.374 --> 00:48:44.454
Yes, because more and more people are living more and more complicated lives.
00:48:44.589 --> 00:48:47.269
Right. That's, you know, that's a big part of it. Yeah.
00:48:47.689 --> 00:48:52.639
Lots of people. there were 15 000 people that moved to france americans for
00:48:52.639 --> 00:48:55.631
the first year in 2025 15 000 people,
00:48:56.101 --> 00:49:01.609
moved to this country in 2025 for the first year so like there's a lot of people
00:49:01.609 --> 00:49:04.769
and part of it is you know there there seems to be,
00:49:05.929 --> 00:49:10.189
a larger exodus over the last year or two some of it had to do with the you
00:49:10.189 --> 00:49:13.479
know the political divisions in america but even before that there were a lot
00:49:13.479 --> 00:49:17.229
of people who were because americans they had they had a lot of money right
00:49:17.229 --> 00:49:20.869
they had made money on their real estate, they had made money on their pensions, they're,
00:49:22.049 --> 00:49:26.009
fairly wealthy compared to the rest of the world, and they want to take advantage
00:49:26.009 --> 00:49:28.145
and enjoy a lifestyle that's.
00:49:29.569 --> 00:49:33.571
A little bit more different, different strokes for different folks, I guess we say.
00:49:34.024 --> 00:49:39.991
But this problem is not just solve the citizenship-based taxation problem and everything goes away.
00:49:40.632 --> 00:49:45.972
But citizenship taxation problem is a problem for a significant number of people,
00:49:45.972 --> 00:49:47.932
not the only problem, but it is a problem.
00:49:47.932 --> 00:49:53.162
I'm curious now, as you're in your role with the Democrats Abroad Taxation Task
00:49:53.162 --> 00:49:58.316
Force, which, you know, has
been working very hard on this, you know, for a number of years.
00:49:58.877 --> 00:50:03.372
I'm curious what your thoughts are in terms of the prognosis for tax reform
00:50:03.372 --> 00:50:05.796
for Americans abroad as it stands today.
00:50:06.453 --> 00:50:11.672
Well, I mean, I have to be optimistic because we're out there working hard to
00:50:11.672 --> 00:50:13.692
try to get something done. And.
00:50:16.372 --> 00:50:20.992
If we weren't optimistic, it would be quite difficult to continue to pound the
00:50:20.992 --> 00:50:22.152
head up against the wall.
00:50:22.152 --> 00:50:25.340
But, you know, as people could become more aware,
00:50:26.052 --> 00:50:29.792
and I can tell you, there are, you know, there are a lot of politicians that
00:50:29.792 --> 00:50:33.612
come to Europe and I make it my business to try to meet as many as I can over
00:50:33.612 --> 00:50:36.712
here and to try to explain a little bit about what's going on.
00:50:36.712 --> 00:50:38.123
And honestly, they have no idea.
00:50:38.819 --> 00:50:42.471
They're just not tuned into this. And the other big problem in,
00:50:42.645 --> 00:50:45.414
you know, in D.C. is the unintended consequences.
00:50:46.157 --> 00:50:50.342
There are bills that are passed, like the GILTI, which was designed for big,
00:50:50.342 --> 00:50:54.862
big, big corporations, but ended up impacting anybody who was an American that
00:50:54.862 --> 00:50:56.162
owned even a small business, right?
00:50:56.162 --> 00:51:00.092
And all of a sudden, they're filing all kinds of tax returns that they shouldn't
00:51:00.092 --> 00:51:02.771
have to do. So there was never intention to do that.
00:51:03.136 --> 00:51:06.662
So, you know, when these bills come up for renewal or something,
00:51:07.282 --> 00:51:11.992
we go out there and we're talking to, you know, to the aides that are actually
00:51:11.992 --> 00:51:13.831
working on putting the bills together.
00:51:14.262 --> 00:51:18.661
Together and they had no idea of that what they did impacted,
00:51:19.288 --> 00:51:22.712
americans that just live abroad and happen to be caught up in these things and
00:51:22.712 --> 00:51:26.822
this is a big part of what at the taxation task force that we really try to
00:51:26.822 --> 00:51:30.492
accomplish is to try to educate these people and try to solve these smaller
00:51:30.492 --> 00:51:34.108
problems the you know the issues of currencies impacting you,
00:51:34.782 --> 00:51:38.792
maybe yes we do want to try to accomplish a big tax bill as well but it's not
00:51:38.792 --> 00:51:42.332
going to solve all the problems right Because, you know, if I tell you there's
00:51:42.332 --> 00:51:46.962
the problem of the mismatch between trusts, right, in a common law country and
00:51:47.402 --> 00:51:49.695
taxation in a civil law country, obviously the problems
00:51:50.136 --> 00:51:52.533
will still be there, right? There'll still be major issues.
00:51:53.642 --> 00:51:57.972
You know, we
won't, we'll still be in business, right? But there are so many
00:51:57.972 --> 00:52:03.742
things that we have to fight for because we find that the unintended consequences
00:52:03.742 --> 00:52:07.272
on Americans abroad are very negative.
00:52:07.272 --> 00:52:12.112
And yet there was never an intention to do that. And so a big part of our role
00:52:12.112 --> 00:52:15.162
is making legislators aware of,
00:52:17.682 --> 00:52:20.462
the damage that they're doing in some
00:52:20.462 --> 00:52:23.250
of this legislation that they never considered and to try to reverse it.
00:52:23.703 --> 00:52:27.789
So what have you thought? I mean, so you're trying to make them aware.
00:52:28.049 --> 00:52:29.652
Are they understanding the problem?
00:52:30.262 --> 00:52:35.002
Yes, yes. When we explain it, they understand it. So I think,
00:52:35.002 --> 00:52:36.491
you know, from that point of view—,
00:52:38.110 --> 00:52:41.530
If we weren't there, it would never cross their mind.
00:52:41.530 --> 00:52:45.220
It's an important aspect. And not just Democrats abroad. I mean,
00:52:45.220 --> 00:52:48.990
there are other organizations out there also that are lobbying on the Hill,
00:52:49.890 --> 00:52:53.770
you know, ACA and Arrow, and there are others, right?
00:52:54.550 --> 00:52:57.160
Absolutely, yeah. I mean, there's been a number of them over the years.
00:52:57.160 --> 00:52:59.753
And, you know, all of them should be supported, clearly.
00:53:00.125 --> 00:53:05.950
So, you know, you enhance the awareness. You get them to understand what's going
00:53:05.950 --> 00:53:08.984
on. And do they, in fact, though, see this as a problem?
00:53:09.569 --> 00:53:12.830
You know, you don't understand what's going on. Yeah, they see what's going
00:53:12.830 --> 00:53:16.633
on. Does they automatically see that as a problem then or no?
00:53:17.930 --> 00:53:22.500
They actually do. They do understand it as a problem. But that doesn't mean
00:53:22.500 --> 00:53:26.380
that, you know, legislation is like, you know, it's like making hot dogs, right?
00:53:26.380 --> 00:53:31.330
It's not an easy need process, right? So, you know, sometimes it's a question
00:53:31.330 --> 00:53:34.110
of timing, right? You have to be in the right place at the right time.
00:53:34.436 --> 00:53:39.080
And I think we got farther with LaHood's bill than we've ever gotten before.
00:53:39.492 --> 00:53:44.800
We got an enormous amount of, you know, we got a very interesting bill that
00:53:44.800 --> 00:53:48.630
was created. We got it introduced. We got, you know, lots of people that supported it.
00:53:49.019 --> 00:53:53.290
I think it could be improved if we could, you know, minimize the tax loss to
00:53:53.290 --> 00:53:55.979
have a better chance of getting it, you know, over the finish line.
00:53:56.647 --> 00:54:00.524
Although I would be thrilled if it went over the finish line as it is, but I would,
00:54:01.216 --> 00:54:04.562
but also be willing to accept
a lot less myself personally to,
00:54:04.562 --> 00:54:05.772
to get it over the finish line.
00:54:06.155 --> 00:54:09.752
And, you know, each, each time we get closer and closer and closer.
00:54:10.123 --> 00:54:13.512
And, you know, it's when, I mean, I, I can tell you that there are,
00:54:13.512 --> 00:54:17.572
you know, many people in, on the Hill and the Senate and the Congress that know
00:54:17.572 --> 00:54:19.762
that this is an issue and it's been an issue for a long time.
00:54:20.058 --> 00:54:25.592
And, and it's, it's, it's, it's a continual effort and the taxation task force
00:54:25.592 --> 00:54:27.906
and our chair, Rebecca Lambers in particular, I mean,
00:54:28.712 --> 00:54:35.082
she works tirelessly to educate not only Americans who live abroad on what they
00:54:35.082 --> 00:54:37.732
can do to protect themselves, which is a very important aspect,
00:54:37.732 --> 00:54:41.368
but in educating the legislatures and their staff
00:54:41.809 --> 00:54:44.822
on the impact of what they're doing on Americans abroad.
00:54:46.072 --> 00:54:52.292
And so, you know, it's a fight that will need to be continually fought because,
00:54:53.132 --> 00:54:54.752
there's continual legislation.
00:54:55.674 --> 00:55:00.723
Oh, yeah. As long as we have laws being made, we're going to have issues. That's for sure.
00:55:01.205 --> 00:55:05.962
Right. Let me ask you this as we find this down. What are the chances are of
00:55:05.962 --> 00:55:11.322
the LaHood Bill or some version of it being introduced before the end of 2026,
00:55:11.943 --> 00:55:14.712
before this Congress ends? this.
00:55:16.758 --> 00:55:21.738
Well, I'm not as close to it as others, so I really can't say.
00:55:21.738 --> 00:55:26.858
I mean, we have only a few months, and I would be hard-pressed to see that this
00:55:26.858 --> 00:55:30.988
would be a priority in the current changeover legislation.
00:55:30.988 --> 00:55:35.678
I think it's going to be very hard to get almost anything passed in the next
00:55:35.678 --> 00:55:41.148
couple of years, but a bipartisan bill has a much better chance going forward
00:55:41.148 --> 00:55:45.412
into the next Congress than it had in the previous two years.
00:55:45.912 --> 00:55:49.747
When it was, you know, simply voting on a party line.
00:55:50.287 --> 00:55:53.861
And so we're going to be out there. We'll be in D.C.
00:55:54.222 --> 00:55:57.317
Next summer. And particularly, we're going to be out there fighting for it.
00:55:57.665 --> 00:56:04.258
And anything we can do to improve the lives of Americans abroad is really what
00:56:04.258 --> 00:56:07.078
we're focused on at the Taxation Task Force of Democrats Abroad.
00:56:07.078 --> 00:56:09.158
Well, that's fantastic.
00:56:09.458 --> 00:56:12.548
You know, certainly I, along with many others, would thank you for that.
00:56:12.548 --> 00:56:15.318
And, you know, as you bring this to an end, And, you know, one of the reasons,
00:56:15.878 --> 00:56:20.928
I invited you to this podcast was because I found your newsletter very interesting,
00:56:20.928 --> 00:56:25.038
which, you know, revealed a lot of these sort of, you know, incompatibilities,
00:56:25.685 --> 00:56:27.128
here, there, and everywhere.
00:56:27.128 --> 00:56:30.538
And I think that a lot of people might benefit from reading your newsletter.
00:56:30.538 --> 00:56:34.921
So what are your coordinates, and how would they subscribe to the newsletter?
00:56:35.897 --> 00:56:40.747
Well, you can sign up for our newsletter on our website, which is at levitt.capital.
00:56:41.739 --> 00:56:48.176
So www.levitt.capital. But L-E-I-T-T.capital.
00:56:48.315 --> 00:56:51.820
L-E-V-I-T-T.capital, correct? Correct.
00:56:52.160 --> 00:56:58.230
And there you can sign up for our newsletter. And I try to cover issues mostly
00:56:58.230 --> 00:57:02.820
affecting people in Europe, but in different countries, but the things that are occurring,
00:57:03.740 --> 00:57:08.400
you know, in different themes and different issues, whether it's updates on
00:57:08.400 --> 00:57:11.276
legislation or whether it's legislation in the U.S.,
00:57:11.863 --> 00:57:16.600
for legislation in other countries or, you know, other issues that might be
00:57:16.600 --> 00:57:18.937
interesting to our readers.
00:57:19.913 --> 00:57:24.700
Yeah, I know. It's a very, very interesting newsletter. I mean,
00:57:24.700 --> 00:57:30.560
at a bare minimum, I think reading the newsletter would persuade people that
00:57:30.560 --> 00:57:33.836
the problems are a lot bigger than citizenship taxation.
00:57:34.578 --> 00:57:37.100
Yeah, yeah, you're absolutely right. You're absolutely right.
00:57:37.100 --> 00:57:40.060
Okay, well, let's wind down for now.
00:57:40.060 --> 00:57:43.700
We can pick this up another time. But I'm speaking with Robert Leavitt,
00:57:43.700 --> 00:57:51.940
who is the founder of Leavitt Capital, L-E-V-I-T-T, Doug Capital, based in France.
00:57:51.940 --> 00:57:59.880
And he is in the business of basically helping individuals navigate simultaneously
00:58:00.220 --> 00:58:04.960
the tax and regulatory laws of many countries at the same time. Fair statement?
00:58:06.039 --> 00:58:11.042
Yes. Plus, we also do investment management. Plus, we also work on succession taxes.
00:58:11.385 --> 00:58:15.640
Plus, we deal with all the various issues that can affect Americans from divorce
00:58:15.640 --> 00:58:19.660
to, you know, having their swimming pool pipes break and finding someone in
00:58:19.660 --> 00:58:22.510
another language in another country who they can work with.
00:58:22.510 --> 00:58:26.586
So it's a one-stop shop to an improved life.
00:58:27.046 --> 00:58:31.522
For a U.S. citizen. For a U.S. citizen. All right. Great.
00:58:32.213 --> 00:58:36.300
Robert, thanks. It's truly been a pleasure. I really enjoyed speaking with you
00:58:36.300 --> 00:58:40.489
today, and hopefully we can connect again. Sounds good. I appreciate it.