TRANSCRIPT 🔗
1
00:00:01,953 --> 00:00:08,803
Charlie: I was 22, and I had been working on a project in India.
2
00:00:09,503 --> 00:00:16,443
And after that finished, I went for the first time to a meditation retreat.
3
00:00:16,443 --> 00:00:19,053
And I had never meditated before.
4
00:00:19,513 --> 00:00:33,126
And I went from never having meditated at all, into 16 hours a day very intensely, at my own volition.
5
00:00:33,126 --> 00:00:35,806
Like, I was really curious, like "What is this?
6
00:00:35,806 --> 00:00:37,036
I wanna get to the bottom of this.
7
00:00:37,036 --> 00:00:39,476
I want to really understand, what is meditation?
8
00:00:39,476 --> 00:00:40,205
How does it work?"
9
00:00:40,485 --> 00:00:43,693
Oshan: This is Charlie Awbery, who's currently a meditation teacher.
10
00:00:44,136 --> 00:00:47,092
What we're hearing is the story of their first pivot point.
11
00:00:47,731 --> 00:00:58,496
Charlie: And towards the end of those three weeks, I had, what I now would understand as a central channel opening energetic experience.
12
00:00:58,496 --> 00:01:09,186
Some people would call it kundalini, energetic, rising up from the, the base of my spine all the way up, explosive.
13
00:01:09,926 --> 00:01:13,836
My heart opened, completely out of control.
14
00:01:13,836 --> 00:01:24,595
I, I was, probably for about eight hours in energetic experience that I have no idea what was occurring
15
00:01:24,595 --> 00:01:32,069
and then the energy kind of continued up to my throat, and over a long period the, my throat opened up,
16
00:01:32,069 --> 00:01:36,722
and then this whole area up here, also opened up.
17
00:01:37,112 --> 00:01:51,697
Eventually that ended in a sense of clear, vast, extremely peaceful, calm, vibrant, very difficult to put into words.
18
00:01:51,697 --> 00:02:03,685
Just a sense of my whole body having been almost like a fire hose had just been put up through my entire system and totally cleaned out.
19
00:02:03,685 --> 00:02:06,225
And I was left in shock amazement.
20
00:02:07,435 --> 00:02:10,695
For me, it was extremely positive.
21
00:02:10,765 --> 00:02:18,955
I knew that something important and good was happening to me.
22
00:02:19,725 --> 00:02:22,815
For people around me, I can't remember exactly.
23
00:02:22,815 --> 00:02:27,842
I must have been very vocal, screaming, or my body was moving a lot.
24
00:02:28,025 --> 00:02:30,635
For people around me, they were very concerned.
25
00:02:30,635 --> 00:02:33,345
They thought I was having a psychiatric breakdown.
26
00:02:33,765 --> 00:02:39,635
There was some talk afterwards of putting me back on a plane to the UK, getting me treatment.
27
00:02:40,275 --> 00:02:41,055
For weeks.
28
00:02:41,055 --> 00:02:43,335
I was utterly, utterly exhausted.
29
00:02:43,335 --> 00:02:47,675
I remember sleeping for a lot of the rest of the time that I was in India.
30
00:02:47,675 --> 00:02:50,825
And then when I came back to the UK I got very depressed.
31
00:02:51,425 --> 00:02:54,815
I didn't understand what had happened.
32
00:02:54,815 --> 00:02:57,785
I didn't know what to do with myself.
33
00:02:57,785 --> 00:03:00,935
After that, I was a little bit frightened of meditation.
34
00:03:01,835 --> 00:03:13,745
And so I stopped practicing for a while and started reading a lot, asking questions, meeting teachers going, and, just talking about that experience.
35
00:03:13,745 --> 00:03:20,925
I also went through the medical system and asked doctors whether there was something wrong with me.
36
00:03:21,060 --> 00:03:29,100
I, I wanted to really understand what had happened in my nervous system, in my body.
37
00:03:29,500 --> 00:03:37,780
Thankfully, very supportive, helpful doctor said, nah, don't worry about it.
38
00:03:37,990 --> 00:03:39,400
See if something happens again.
39
00:03:39,400 --> 00:03:43,600
And if anything happens again, then, you know, maybe we'll take a look.
40
00:03:43,600 --> 00:03:45,280
But yeah, you seem okay.
41
00:03:45,670 --> 00:03:46,060
Off you go.
42
00:03:46,990 --> 00:03:52,210
And I'm very grateful for that because, I thought, oh, you know, okay, must be all right then.
43
00:03:53,875 --> 00:04:04,165
And then eventually I came back to meditation probably some months to a year, I think before I really wanted to start sitting again.
44
00:04:07,538 --> 00:04:15,909
Oshan: Last episode, we heard scientists drawing from the theory of predictive processing to try and explain what's happening during these pivot point experiences like Charlie's.
45
00:04:16,516 --> 00:04:19,257
And the science has come up with some interesting stories.
46
00:04:20,286 --> 00:04:25,188
But at the same time, the science of deep meditation is incredibly early in its development.
47
00:04:25,832 --> 00:04:34,242
And there's another perspective that's been doing the same thing, working on stories that explain these experiences for roughly a few thousand years:
48
00:04:34,242 --> 00:04:37,924
contemplative traditions and the meditation teachers who carry them forward.
49
00:04:38,859 --> 00:04:46,260
Teachers are drawing from decades of experience where they've seen hundreds, if not thousands, of these experiences play out across their students.
50
00:04:47,064 --> 00:04:50,226
So in this episode, we're gonna hear from the teachers.
51
00:04:52,173 --> 00:04:56,016
For starters, I wanted to ask them the same questions I asked the scientists.
52
00:04:56,698 --> 00:04:58,033
What is a pivot point?
53
00:04:58,902 --> 00:05:04,893
When someone has an experience that feels like hooking their entire system up to a fire hose, what's going on there?
54
00:05:05,541 --> 00:05:07,991
And what can they teach us about how minds work?
55
00:05:08,845 --> 00:05:15,958
Unlike the scientists who are trying to raise public awareness about these experiences, teachers have taken the opposite approach.
56
00:05:16,806 --> 00:05:22,744
When it comes to pivot points, teachers have traditionally advised students to just
Load full transcript
ignore them and keep meditating.
57
00:05:23,783 --> 00:05:29,849
Teachers caution students that focusing on these experiences can actually undermine your meditation practice.
58
00:05:30,829 --> 00:05:34,196
But the teachers in this episode are doing something a little different.
59
00:05:35,114 --> 00:05:39,932
Rather than advising students to ignore them, they embrace these experiences.
60
00:05:40,706 --> 00:05:47,768
Tina: Teachers have traditionally told people not to, to let it go to their heads, to move on.
61
00:05:47,768 --> 00:05:51,588
But to me that is not working with what's there.
62
00:05:51,588 --> 00:05:55,238
What's there is that this person had a, something profound happen.
63
00:05:55,238 --> 00:05:56,438
Let's celebrate that.
64
00:05:57,366 --> 00:06:03,246
Oshan: While at the same time balancing that embrace with the risks of obsessing over these experiences.
65
00:06:05,058 --> 00:06:09,546
Tina: If you let this go to where now it's a notch in the belt,
66
00:06:09,546 --> 00:06:15,108
that is going to derail your practice because now it's all just about ego gratification.
67
00:06:15,800 --> 00:06:18,240
Oshan: So this is the second question I asked the teachers.
68
00:06:18,819 --> 00:06:24,601
How can we make the most of what these experiences can teach us about the mind and deepening a meditation practice,
69
00:06:24,601 --> 00:06:30,400
without getting stuck in the traps that led teachers to discourage focusing on them in the first place?
70
00:06:31,598 --> 00:06:36,128
Tina: We're having an orgy of spiritual materialism right now around the Jhanas.
71
00:06:36,668 --> 00:06:42,398
And this is why the practices were hidden for a long, long time, because teachers were afraid this would happen.
72
00:06:42,698 --> 00:06:43,958
And now it is.
73
00:06:44,858 --> 00:06:51,308
Michael: It's not that it's wrong to find it interesting, it's just that it's just a distraction at that point.
74
00:06:51,758 --> 00:07:02,378
Richard: We should not pretend that we don't want these wholesome, powerful, important experiences that come.
75
00:07:03,188 --> 00:07:05,558
Let's just not make it an object of clinging.
76
00:07:06,752 --> 00:07:10,187
Oshan: I'm Oshan Jarow, and this is episode four of Pivot Points.
77
00:07:13,631 --> 00:07:19,121
Michael: I have my own maps and taxonomies to try to make sense of this stuff, and they're idiosyncratic.
78
00:07:19,441 --> 00:07:22,418
They do roughly line up with, traditions.
79
00:07:22,819 --> 00:07:27,385
Oshan: This is non-dual meditation teacher Michael Taft, who we heard from a bit earlier in the series.
80
00:07:27,921 --> 00:07:35,309
Michael: What I call the stack model, is something very simple that I came up with, that I used because I,
81
00:07:35,309 --> 00:07:39,364
I'm sort of characterologically opposed to these maps because of the,
82
00:07:39,364 --> 00:07:44,000
how reductive they are and how people will then try to match their experience to the map.
83
00:07:44,000
--> 00:07:48,598
But, I realized that I was using one internally when I was working with students anyway.
84
00:07:49,618 --> 00:07:55,768
So I thought, well, I might as well figure out what, you know, what this really is that I'm using, and then make it explicit.
85
00:07:56,146 --> 00:08:00,351
Oshan: You can think of Michael's stack model as four stacked layers of the mind.
86
00:08:00,978 --> 00:08:05,868
The first is the layer of concepts, where by default us adults probably spend most of our time.
87
00:08:06,670 --> 00:08:15,702
And one of the first shifts that Michael often sees meditation lead to in students is going from experiencing concepts to experiencing their phenomenology
88
00:08:15,702 --> 00:08:20,232
or the underlying sensations more directly, which is the stack's second layer.
89
00:08:20,700 --> 00:08:23,430
Michael: There are little breakthroughs and bigger breakthroughs.
90
00:08:23,430 --> 00:08:26,460
The one that I think is very low bar,
91
00:08:26,700 --> 00:08:40,696
but actually matters a lot is the first time people notice that meditating on phenomenology gets them into suddenly a much deeper place than
92
00:08:40,696 --> 00:08:47,360
when they've been meditating basically using thinking, which is how we all start out.
93
00:08:47,810 --> 00:08:57,566
So the first time they're really, let's say, tracking sensations in their bodies in a phenomenological way, instead of thinking about sensations,
94
00:08:57,566 --> 00:09:02,808
suddenly it's like the gear of meditation engages and they find themselves absorbed.
95
00:09:03,322 --> 00:09:10,324
Oshan: Michael is basically describing that same process of unhooking from thought that we talked about with insight experiences in the last two
96
00:09:11,332 --> 00:09:18,568
Michael: Because when you think about an arm, it's just a meta tag in your head arm and you might feel this or that,
97
00:09:18,568 --> 00:09:19,963
but you're used to ignoring it.
98
00:09:20,533 --> 00:09:28,813
And the way that you are engaging it, which is through an idea, through a sort of a mental meta tag, is inherently not interesting.
99
00:09:29,633 --> 00:09:31,943
It's just a mental tag.
100
00:09:32,823 --> 00:09:38,343
But when I say: Feel the skin on the back of your fingers.
101
00:09:39,018 --> 00:09:39,888
Is it warm?
102
00:09:39,888 --> 00:09:40,818
Is it cold?
103
00:09:40,818 --> 00:09:41,678
Is it tight.
104
00:09:41,678 --> 00:09:42,578
Is it loose?
105
00:09:42,578 --> 00:09:46,238
Can you feel you know the blood in your palms?
106
00:09:46,238 --> 00:09:49,388
Can you feel the heartbeat in your wrist?
107
00:09:49,718 --> 00:09:57,027
It turns out that there's a world of sensation there when we let go of these very productive,
108
00:09:57,027 --> 00:10:00,948
very uninteresting sort of meta tags of concept.
109
00:10:01,398 --> 00:10:03,858
And start engaging with the phenomenology.
110
00:10:04,098 --> 00:10:05,028
It is rich.
111
00:10:05,078 --> 00:10:11,888
It's a IMAX
experience of your body and you've never noticed that before, except sometimes maybe if you were high or whatever.
112
00:10:12,315 --> 00:10:14,600
Oshan: And that moment of noticing can be a pivot point.
113
00:10:15,365 --> 00:10:25,172
Michael: Most of us are, trained to live in a extremely impoverished mental environment of just ideas of things.
114
00:10:26,432 --> 00:10:33,752
And ideas of things can be really fun to play with, but in another way, they're very, very, very stripped down.
115
00:10:34,442 --> 00:10:40,032
And we have this incredibly rich world of sensation of every kind.
116
00:10:40,732 --> 00:10:46,453
I think of, Walt Whitman talking about what it's like to have a body that feels things and how intense it is
117
00:10:46,453 --> 00:10:51,572
and how amazing it is, and how it unfolds and unfolds and unfolds, and that's what's there.
118
00:10:51,572 --> 00:10:57,942
It doesn't have to be, it doesn't have to be intense, and it doesn't have to be, like a major visionary experience,
119
00:10:58,422 --> 00:11:01,782
but it can just be really interesting.
120
00:11:02,922 --> 00:11:05,772
I didn't realize it felt so interesting.
121
00:11:05,772 --> 00:11:07,392
I'm just, my arm is the thing.
122
00:11:07,392 --> 00:11:10,389
I used to lift the coffee to my face and it's like, no,
123
00:11:10,389 --> 00:11:15,782
actually there's a lot of stuff going on in your arm that is really kind of amazing to feel.
124
00:11:16,550 --> 00:11:21,607
Oshan: The body is an easy example for this IMAX experience lurking beneath the surface of thought.
125
00:11:22,208 --> 00:11:28,896
But I also heard a lot of people report that after a deep meditation session, or even during or after a retreat,
126
00:11:28,896 --> 00:11:37,693
even the most ordinary, mundane, but external experiences also opened up into these kinds of rich and incredibly interesting scenes.
127
00:11:38,274 --> 00:11:42,969
Claudia: And I was just sitting there and I just realized I had spent hours.
128
00:11:43,189 --> 00:11:50,889
And it would zip by like that, just like watching the birds and listening to the trees and looking at the little ants marching by.
129
00:11:51,099 --> 00:11:56,169
And yeah, I just realized I hadn't been like, attuned to my present moment in that way since I was like, what,
130
00:11:56,169 --> 00:11:57,459
like five years old or something.
131
00:11:57,891 --> 00:12:00,021
Evan: I'm walking and it's a beautiful path, right?
132
00:12:00,021 --> 00:12:09,042
It's lots of opportunities for little sightings like deer and little critters, and you notice all of these things down to the smallest animal.
133
00:12:09,762 --> 00:12:12,612
But also you're just, you're like heightened, I guess.
134
00:12:13,182 --> 00:12:21,747
It felt as though the refresh rate on my noticing had increased by an order of a magnitude.
135
00:12:21,807 --> 00:12:31,131
It's just that my appreciation for things that were happening moment to moment was clearer,
136
00:12:31,131 --> 00:12:37,501
not obscured by the weather of my mind as much my thinking.
137
00:12:39,080 --> 00:12:45,439
Oshan: These experiences of heightened noticing or deeper attunement to what's happening in the present are still all in
138
00:12:45,439 --> 00:12:48,345
that shift from the first to second layer of Michael's stack.
139
00:12:48,839 --> 00:12:52,348
You're relaxing the attachment of awareness to conceptual thinking.
140
00:12:53,063 --> 00:12:58,252
And as you go deeper into the stack, you're just relaxing deeper habits of perception.
141
00:12:59,020 --> 00:13:02,657
And each step along the way is another opportunity for a pivot point.
142
00:13:03,088 --> 00:13:07,168
Michael: And then the next step after that is seeing the continuous change in everything.
143
00:13:07,168 --> 00:13:12,448
So we might call that impermanence, but I would just call it continuous change, or flux or flow.
144
00:13:13,009 --> 00:13:15,350
Oshan: Flux is the third layer of Michael's stack.
145
00:13:16,113 --> 00:13:22,225
To get an intuition for it, think about all the different kinds of experience that stitch together in every moment.
146
00:13:22,794 --> 00:13:27,044
You're seeing the world, you're hearing it, you're smelling it, you're tasting it, you're touching it.
147
00:13:27,953 --> 00:13:32,860
And at first glance, it might seem like these are all very different kinds of experiences.
148
00:13:33,695 --> 00:13:41,647
To hear the slamming of a door is a different kind of experience than the lingering feeling of the meditation cushion's coarse fabric against the back of your calf.
149
00:13:42,901 --> 00:13:50,883
But at the same time, even just from a basic scientific perspective, these different experiences all run on the same kind of underlying signal.
150
00:13:51,674 --> 00:14:00,788
When photoreceptors in your eyes take in light, when hair cells in your ears take in vibrations, when skin cells take in pressure and temperature,
151
00:14:00,788 --> 00:14:06,805
they all convert these different inputs into the same thing: electrochemical signals that get sent to the brain.
152
00:14:07,702 --> 00:14:15,118
And depending on their patterning and the pathways they travel, the brain interprets them into these differentiated kinds of experience.
153
00:14:16,215 --> 00:14:25,463
So if the science paints a picture where all of these differentiated sensory experiences are interpretations of the same kind of signal,
154
00:14:25,463 --> 00:14:34,614
the third level of Michael's stack, flux, makes a similar claim from the experiential side, that all experience is made out of,
155
00:14:34,614 --> 00:14:38,847
or interpretations of, this same underlying process.
156
00:14:39,674 --> 00:14:43,789
In this case, a vibratory feeling of continuous change.
157
00:14:44,653 --> 00:14:48,985
And we've actually already heard a few accounts of what it can feel like to notice that.
158
00:14:49,764 --> 00:14:50,664
Evan: One moment.
159
00:14:51,234
--> 00:14:53,634
Searing pain, genuine pain.
160
00:14:54,264 --> 00:14:58,434
And then the next moment, it was just like static.
161
00:14:59,534 --> 00:15:06,764
I will never forget the feeling of a very gross sensation, giving way to this fizz.
162
00:15:07,355 --> 00:15:12,785
Henry: And the pain in my knee, which had been acute, just became an interesting tingle.
163
00:15:13,780 --> 00:15:23,897
Oshan: This direct experience of a particular feeling decomposing into fizzy, static, tingling sensations, is that shift into the third layer of the stack.
164
00:15:24,644 --> 00:15:31,155
The experience itself starts to blur and the boundaries begin to break down, at which point it's not just your knee,
165
00:15:31,442 --> 00:15:38,315
you might notice your whole field of experience is just made up of these vibratory feelings of continuous change.
166
00:15:38,992 --> 00:15:40,202
Remember how Tobin put it.
167
00:15:40,889 --> 00:15:47,339
Tobin: My hands and my feet are not separate in those moments, they are part of the same sort of experience.
168
00:15:48,759 --> 00:15:54,389
That was a big sort of turning point as to my sense of what it means to be a cloud of sensation.
169
00:15:55,402 --> 00:16:02,541
Oshan: Once everything begins to blur or really refine into this quality of continual change, there's one more layer.
170
00:16:03,011 --> 00:16:05,561
Michael: And then beneath that is spaciousness.
171
00:16:06,431 --> 00:16:09,101
Or what might be called emptiness or awareness.
172
00:16:09,821 --> 00:16:14,804
Oshan: Famously, there are no good words to describe what Michael's pointing at with the label of spaciousness.
173
00:16:15,159 --> 00:16:19,174
But to be clear, it's not just a roomier experience of the world than usual.
174
00:16:19,739 --> 00:16:23,305
Spaciousness is like the context in which everything is happening.
175
00:16:23,819 --> 00:16:26,847
It's the screen on which the movie of consciousness is projected.
176
00:16:27,227 --> 00:16:33,878
All the continuously changing sensations, all the different flavors of phenomenology, all the thoughts and concepts,
177
00:16:33,878 --> 00:16:37,945
all of that is usually getting in our way of noticing spaciousness.
178
00:16:39,107 --> 00:16:44,938
Michael actually has a series of guided meditations on the Waking Up app titled Nondual Awakening.
179
00:16:45,464 --> 00:16:51,948
So rather than continuing to try and describe that which a few thousand years of instructions tells us can't be described,
180
00:16:51,948 --> 00:16:57,738
here's a clip from one of those meditations where Michael is narrating the listener into spaciousness.
181
00:17:00,142 --> 00:17:04,882
Michael: Notice how experience doesn't have a boundary.
182
00:17:05,972 --> 00:17:21,181
All this experience of sensation and emotion and thought activity and selfing activity is arising in this boundless space.
183
00:17:22,245 --> 00:17:31,965
Vibrating, moving, changing for a while in boundless openness and returning once again to boundless spacious ease.
184
00:17:32,895 --> 00:17:39,465
And when we see the boundlessness, the openness, the ease of spacious awareness,
185
00:17:39,465 --> 00:17:45,365
we recognize that not only does it have no boundary, it has no center.
186
00:17:46,985 --> 00:17:51,025
And we rest in a boundless, centerless awakeness.
187
00:17:53,688 --> 00:17:59,494
Oshan: So if we take up the stack model and then ask, "According to this framework, where are the pivot points?"
188
00:17:59,494 --> 00:18:02,596
We've already heard examples at each layer of the stack.
189
00:18:03,346 --> 00:18:06,624
Michael explained that people usually progress sequentially.
190
00:18:07,193 --> 00:18:15,330
More often than not, someone's first weird meditation experience will be in the unhooking from thought territory, and they'll feel and experience things differently.
191
00:18:16,105 --> 00:18:23,509
And once they've done that and kept practicing with it, they might eventually find this unifying sense of flux in all experience.
192
00:18:24,128 --> 00:18:29,029
And from there, they might eventually find that there's this sense of spaciousness that opens up,
193
00:18:29,029 --> 00:18:32,226
where any sense of self and space and time start to fade away.
194
00:18:33,305 --> 00:18:35,273
And we've seen parts of this progression already.
195
00:18:35,949 --> 00:18:41,411
For example, with the engineering professor, Sean, his first pivot point was sitting on the airplane.
196
00:18:42,152 --> 00:18:50,167
Sean: I basically noticed that I could pay attention to just seeing itself as something entirely separate from thinking,
197
00:18:50,167 --> 00:18:54,662
and that the scene itself maybe was what awareness is.
198
00:18:55,085 --> 00:19:03,392
Oshan: He has this unhooking awareness from thought experience, the conceptual middleman between his awareness and experience is briefly suspended.
199
00:19:04,054 --> 00:19:08,864
And 10 months after that, he had the headless experience where he had no sense of self.
200
00:19:09,608 --> 00:19:11,498
Sean: It's like I subjectively disappeared.
201
00:19:12,338 --> 00:19:15,668
There's no actual me here.
202
00:19:16,230 --> 00:19:20,801
Oshan: But we've also heard people go straight into the deep end, right into spaciousness.
203
00:19:21,582 --> 00:19:23,318
For example, the lawyer, Matt.
204
00:19:24,073 --> 00:19:31,681
He'd been meditating for years without any crazy experiences, and then his first pivot point, which we heard him describe back in the first episode,
205
00:19:32,149 --> 00:19:37,442
was about this spacious awareness coming into the foreground and finding no sense of self that remained.
206
00:19:38,275 --> 00:19:41,243
Matt: Then just in a flash, everything reversed.
207
00:19:41,623 --> 00:19:49,048
So instead of becoming a person in space listening to external sounds coming in.
208
00:19:50,133 --> 00:19:51,313
It was like it flipped.
209
00:19:52,153 --> 00:19:57,763
So the
spacious awareness that was in the background was suddenly in the foreground.
210
00:19:58,123 --> 00:20:05,563
And the objects all seemed, rather than me looking at an object, it was like all these objects were just arising in this spaciousness.
211
00:20:06,253 --> 00:20:10,233
And at the middle of it there wasn't a person there.
212
00:20:11,213 --> 00:20:19,102
Oshan: These sudden experiences of going straight from the normal conceptual mind into a selfless spaciousness are surprisingly common.
213
00:20:19,798 --> 00:20:27,974
There are whole non-dual traditions like Dzogchen or Advaita Vedanta organized around what are called direct pointing out instructions,
214
00:20:27,974 --> 00:20:32,796
where instead of guiding students through a series of small steps and techniques,
215
00:20:32,796 --> 00:20:38,498
the instruction is just trying to get meditators to recognize that spacious awareness right out of the gate.
216
00:20:39,613 --> 00:20:43,383
Another example that we've already heard about is Douglas Harding's Headless Way practice,
217
00:20:43,383 --> 00:20:49,178
where the instruction is to notice that in your direct experience, you don't have a head.
218
00:20:50,013 --> 00:20:54,397
And usually the instruction doesn't make any sense until it does.
219
00:20:55,205 --> 00:20:57,648
And Michael's seen this happen with plenty of students.
220
00:20:58,216 --> 00:21:00,656
Michael: It's like they've drilled down with a needle.
221
00:21:00,656 --> 00:21:05,871
They're all down doing something in the fourth level, but just extremely narrow.
222
00:21:07,290 --> 00:21:13,140
This is the thing about non-dual traditions is they can drop you right into the awakeness or the emptiness,
223
00:21:13,830 --> 00:21:15,450
at least a little bit right away.
224
00:21:15,640 --> 00:21:19,480
The headless way is surprisingly effective, and a cool technique.
225
00:21:19,480 --> 00:21:25,060
It doesn't do enough as far as I'm concerned, but it's great as far as it goes.
226
00:21:26,230 --> 00:21:37,120
The breakthroughs, pay off, but unless you keep nurturing that opening, the kind of regular way of seeing things will slowly re encroach.
227
00:21:44,412 --> 00:21:47,064
Oshan: Michael's stack model is a vertical metaphor.
228
00:21:47,469 --> 00:21:49,598
We start on the surface and drill deeper.
229
00:21:50,480 --> 00:21:55,981
But speaking with Henry Shukman, I heard a more horizontal take on the different kinds of pivot points.
230
00:21:57,183 --> 00:21:58,981
Henry is a poet and an author.
231
00:21:59,411 --> 00:22:06,358
He studied meditation for about 35 years, mostly in the Sanbo Zen lineage, where he was appointed a teacher back in 2010.
232
00:22:07,271 --> 00:22:10,742
Since then, he's taught in a number of meditation schools and styles.
233
00:22:11,581 --> 00:22:15,847
So when I asked him about how he's seen pivot points play out across his students,
234
00:22:16,211 --> 00:22:19,997
he told me about the different registers or contexts that he's seen them in.
235
00:22:20,875 --> 00:22:27,177
Henry: For example, there's an emotional register and for many people that I've interacted with and heard from,
236
00:22:27,177 --> 00:22:38,165
it's about some shift whereby a familiar negative emotion that's been a long running theme in their life, their relationship with it has suddenly shifted.
237
00:22:38,585 --> 00:22:42,455
Another register would be what we might call philosophical.
238
00:22:42,965 --> 00:22:47,345
That my understanding of the way things are has shifted.
239
00:22:47,405 --> 00:22:51,125
It could be, for example, I'd never questioned the sense of time.
240
00:22:52,025 --> 00:23:03,005
Suddenly I've realized that it's actually a kind of construction I myself make or I unwittingly determine my relationship with time, for example.
241
00:23:03,335 --> 00:23:08,975
And therefore I've come to see that time is not an absolute in quite the way I had thought.
242
00:23:09,535 --> 00:23:13,675
I suppose another register would be just in the realm of thinking and thought.
243
00:23:13,735 --> 00:23:19,735
That it's possible to have thoughts without immediately identifying with them.
244
00:23:20,755 --> 00:23:29,839
So in other words, sort of cognitively, I would ordinarily own the thoughts, unthinkingly, they're just part of me.
245
00:23:30,169 --> 00:23:32,239
They're almost a manifestation of who I am.
246
00:23:32,659 --> 00:23:39,109
But suddenly I recognized: they're not, they're arising without any effort on my part.
247
00:23:39,139 --> 00:23:48,439
They just keep arising and I'm, I can in fact watch them and not identify with them, not be the possessor of them.
248
00:23:49,469 --> 00:23:56,759
Another register was just: I've been meditating six months, it's always been a bit of an effort, and yesterday, boom, I dunno what happened.
249
00:23:56,969 --> 00:24:02,349
Suddenly, I was just in this very calm, clear, somewhat blissful state.
250
00:24:02,809 --> 00:24:07,129
And the sense of effort somehow disappears.
251
00:24:07,129 --> 00:24:12,949
And there's sometimes there's a sense of, you know, reduction awareness of time and self-consciousness, and.
252
00:24:13,954 --> 00:24:14,824
It's pleasant.
253
00:24:14,824 --> 00:24:20,922
It's deeply pleasant, it just came on and the moment I really appreciated it and realized how marvelous it was,
254
00:24:20,922 --> 00:24:29,304
I didn't want it to go away and it went away, you know, and, and, and that, that's a moment of samatha or, or Samadhi,
255
00:24:29,374 --> 00:24:34,344
I would say, or you know, flow, state of a kind coming on in meditation.
256
00:24:35,245 --> 00:24:37,974
Oshan: We can recognize a bunch of themes that we've already outlined.
257
00:24:38,424 --> 00:24:41,625
There's unhooking, whether from thoughts or emotional patterns.
258
00:24:42,102 --> 00:24:47,091
There are insights where the ordinary constructions of experience are temporarily suspended.
259
00:24:47,700 -->
00:24:52,338
We've heard a lot about the various layers of selfhood, but here that sense of time is another piece.
260
00:24:53,032 --> 00:24:57,332
And there's concentration experiences, those shifts into blissful flow states.
261
00:24:58,568 --> 00:25:03,197
Henry adds that we can even go one step up in the ladder of abstraction to see
262
00:25:03,197 --> 00:25:07,504
that all of these different registers share one fundamental quality.
263
00:25:08,277 --> 00:25:15,347
Henry: I'd say there's a common theme, which is some variation of: oh my gosh, I've been wrong.
264
00:25:16,727 --> 00:25:17,867
About whatever it is.
265
00:25:17,867 --> 00:25:24,497
About an emotion I thought I had to feel, or a thought pattern that I just couldn't shake off.
266
00:25:24,587 --> 00:25:33,482
Or, some discovery that the perspective I've had was not the only way of looking at life.
267
00:25:34,612 --> 00:25:37,176
Oshan: And this is the quality that defines a pivot point.
268
00:25:37,490 --> 00:25:41,358
It's the same way that scientist Ruben Laukkonen defined pivot points, just in different
269
00:25:42,324 --> 00:25:56,063
Ruben: I would describe a pivot point as a major restructuring in the models that underlie our understanding of the world, ourselves and experience.
270
00:25:57,203 --> 00:26:06,508
When the meditation practice hits us somewhere deep enough that our understanding of reality has to change.
271
00:26:09,707 --> 00:26:13,342
Oshan: In addition to Michael's stack and Henry's registers,
272
00:26:13,342 --> 00:26:18,585
I heard one other way of categorizing the different kinds of pivot points that teachers have seen across their students,
273
00:26:19,129 --> 00:26:20,978
and this was from Tina Rasmussen.
274
00:26:22,365 --> 00:26:29,775
Tina was initiated into a Tibetan Buddhist lineage and was later ordained as a Buddhist nun by the Burmese Theravada monk Pa Auk Sayadaw.
275
00:26:30,461 --> 00:26:32,245
She also has a PhD in psychology.
276
00:26:33,311 --> 00:26:38,611
And when I asked her about pivot points, she described two different kinds of meditation experience.
277
00:26:39,618 --> 00:26:50,338
Tina: Anytime we're meditating, we're either experiencing transformation, the transformational side of the equation or the transcendent side of the equation.
278
00:26:50,818 --> 00:27:04,428
So when we're encountering our patterning, our, you know, repetitive thought patterns, whatever's taking us off of our meditation object, that is transformation.
279
00:27:04,528 --> 00:27:12,928
So when we meditate, if we're actually working with the personality material, we start seeing that we get some freedom from that.
280
00:27:14,653 --> 00:27:23,868
Transformation of the personality material that causes us to suffer, We're liberated from the compulsive acting out or identification with that,
281
00:27:23,868 --> 00:27:25,243
and we got some space from it.
282
00:27:25,813 --> 00:27:33,283
And I've had a lot of students who actually, their first pivot point was on the transformation side.
283
00:27:34,247 --> 00:27:42,021
Oshan: The other side of the equation, transcendence is more like what happens when you don't get caught up by what Tina's calling the personality material.
284
00:27:42,606 --> 00:27:56,396
Tina: So from the Buddhist perspective, the one that we all want is transcendence, going beyond the personality, experiencing something mystical, something, profound.
285
00:27:56,786 --> 00:27:57,986
A sense of freedom.
286
00:27:57,986 --> 00:28:01,917
A sense of depth of expansiveness…
287
00:28:01,917 --> 00:28:05,336
Like when I teach Dzogchen, it's seen as rigpa.
288
00:28:05,426 --> 00:28:09,296
So it's seen as, as really knowing that we are our deeper nature.
289
00:28:10,116 --> 00:28:13,686
That's a more ultimate aspect of what we are than the body.
290
00:28:13,986 --> 00:28:18,330
And then the personality, we're seeing what's under that…
291
00:28:18,330 --> 00:28:31,328
That is how in the non-dual taste of our deeper nature, we're really, Our consciousness is going down to that fundamental mystery that's animating everything.
292
00:28:32,077 --> 00:28:36,397
So that's what everyone wants, you know, that's the good stuff.
293
00:28:36,646 --> 00:28:39,455
Oshan: But of course, the good stuff is usually more difficult to reach.
294
00:28:39,969 --> 00:28:43,641
Transcendence is like the fourth layer of Michael's stack, spaciousness.
295
00:28:44,250 --> 00:28:49,711
And just like Michael explained that he usually sees students starting out in the first layers of the stack
296
00:28:49,711 --> 00:28:57,642
and moving from concepts to direct sensations, Tina's seen most of her students' pivot points happen in the arena of transformation.
297
00:28:58,458 --> 00:29:05,109
And if you listen to her describe transformation in more detail, you'll hear a lot of the patterns that we've already heard meditators describe.
298
00:29:05,953 --> 00:29:15,363
Tina: Sometimes people will have a gap in thoughts and it's like this is the first taste of really being disidentified from the thoughts.
299
00:29:15,363 --> 00:29:17,433
It's a little bit of a taste of no self.
300
00:29:17,433 --> 00:29:21,413
It's not quite that, but it's, a freedom from the me.
301
00:29:23,149 --> 00:29:29,779
From the sense that I am the me I am, the personality patterns that are really just our software program.
302
00:29:31,009 --> 00:29:34,669
You know, they're what's gotten programmed into us and what we came in with.
303
00:29:34,669 --> 00:29:39,589
And we can upgrade that software program through practice.
304
00:29:40,249 --> 00:29:46,189
And when people see they can actually upgrade their own software program and get some freedom from it,
305
00:29:46,189 --> 00:29:50,749
that they don't have to live like that or be that for the rest of their lives.
306
00:29:50,749 --> 00:29:51,979
That is freeing.
307
00:29:54,509 --> 00:30:03,388
Oshan: One reason I was excited to speak with Tina was that
in 2009, she co-authored a book focusing on concentration meditation, and specifically the jhanas.
308
00:30:03,980 --> 00:30:09,213
Remember that concentration states are one half of our taxonomy of pivot points we heard in the second episode.
309
00:30:10,009 --> 00:30:17,538
And the first of the eight jhanas is that blissful concentration state that we've heard a number of people describe as their first pivot point.
310
00:30:18,533 --> 00:30:20,283
Sasha: First jhana is always very intense.
311
00:30:20,303 --> 00:30:26,308
You first go to a, what's called access concentration, which is very nice, relaxed, but concentrated state.
312
00:30:26,668 --> 00:30:30,538
And then the instruction is to focus on some pleasurable sensation in your body.
313
00:30:30,838 --> 00:30:38,328
And if all works well and you let it kind of take over and grow, then it's like fireworks, especially for the first few times.
314
00:30:38,658 --> 00:30:40,458
And it's very emotional.
315
00:30:40,458 --> 00:30:41,628
It's very pleasant.
316
00:30:41,778 --> 00:30:42,408
You cry.
317
00:30:42,408 --> 00:30:48,213
There's also an intense feeling of like something very big and important happening to you.
318
00:30:49,027 --> 00:30:55,233
Oshan: Tina talks about three different levels of concentration: momentary, access, and absorption.
319
00:30:56,083 --> 00:31:00,078
Momentary being our default and fragmented state of attention.
320
00:31:01,024 --> 00:31:03,904
Tina: We don't like momentary 'cause it's a slog.
321
00:31:03,904 --> 00:31:06,604
We're stuck in the patterns, we can't get out of 'em.
322
00:31:06,604 --> 00:31:10,234
And meditating is a slog and at the end you're like, I had a bad sitting.
323
00:31:10,624 --> 00:31:11,464
That's how it feels.
324
00:31:12,104 --> 00:31:18,097
Oshan: Momentary concentration is the mind hooked into thinking so that it's always jumping around from one thought to the next.
325
00:31:18,929 --> 00:31:24,237
Access concentration builds up as the mind begins to settle, and it can feel really good.
326
00:31:25,008 --> 00:31:29,656
Last episode, we talked about how concentration can build up this feeling of pleasure,
327
00:31:29,656 --> 00:31:37,560
and Tina thinks this first taste of the pleasure of concentration is both really important and widely neglected in the West.
328
00:31:38,159 --> 00:31:41,284
Tina: To me, access concentration is the unsung hero of Buddhism.
329
00:31:42,284 --> 00:31:46,004
It's the unsung hero because it's not talked about much.
330
00:31:46,064 --> 00:31:55,075
But at that point, we know something different is happening that we can't just produce on demand without the meditation,
331
00:31:55,075 --> 00:32:01,045
and we're breaking free of the gravitational pull of the ego self at that point.
332
00:32:01,825 --> 00:32:08,095
But in access concentration, we are experiencing aspects of our deeper nature.
333
00:32:08,515 --> 00:32:18,629
The joy, the rapture, the bliss, that is part of our deeper
nature when the me isn't obscuring the flow of the dynamism,
334
00:32:18,629 --> 00:32:25,401
of the mystery that's coming into form, when we're in touch with the flow of that dynamism, it's blissful.
335
00:32:26,241 --> 00:32:28,671
'Cause there's no, the me isn't obstructing it.
336
00:32:29,021 --> 00:32:35,818
It's the unhooking from the incessant running of the personality patterns, when we're free of that.
337
00:32:36,188 --> 00:32:39,038
Some people tend more towards the bliss side, some don't.
338
00:32:40,238 --> 00:32:43,128
But it is very pleasurable.
339
00:32:44,418 --> 00:32:47,978
And we know that there's something good that's happening.
340
00:32:48,028 --> 00:32:49,672
It's good for our wellbeing.
341
00:32:50,805 --> 00:32:55,663
Oshan: In access concentration, you don't necessarily feel an erupting volcano of bliss.
342
00:32:56,109 --> 00:32:58,589
You might feel more like what the filmmaker Stuart described:
343
00:32:59,406 --> 00:33:06,873
Stuart: And there were just moments where I'd be following the breath, and I'd suddenly think, God, I feel relaxed, I feel a sense of.
344
00:33:07,443 --> 00:33:10,053
I don't wanna say equanimity, maybe a sense of serenity.
345
00:33:10,603 --> 00:33:13,231
And then this sort of, sometimes it would be bliss.
346
00:33:13,231 --> 00:33:17,757
Sometimes it would just be a, a sense of comfort, a sense of warmth, and then yeah,
347
00:33:17,757 --> 00:33:21,751
to be distracted 10 minutes later by something else and back to back to living.
348
00:33:22,051 --> 00:33:23,221
But that stuck with me.
349
00:33:24,301 --> 00:33:29,528
Tina: And people get that, this is profound.
350
00:33:29,828 --> 00:33:34,083
It's different and I want more of it.
351
00:33:34,593 --> 00:33:36,303
That's how it feels.
352
00:33:36,303 --> 00:33:44,043
Because people are getting a taste that the things described in the freedom and the practice can happen to them.
353
00:33:44,978 --> 00:33:48,397
Oshan: But we did hear about more intense concentration experiences,
354
00:33:48,766 --> 00:33:54,266
the ones that felt like fireworks or the coursing bliss that forced Max to pull over while he was driving.
355
00:33:55,130 --> 00:34:00,165
Max: I was like almost shaking, while I was driving because there was just this,
356
00:34:00,165 --> 00:34:05,575
this physical excitement and energy and bliss just happening and coursing from my whole body.
357
00:34:05,995 --> 00:34:11,245
I pulled over and just like calmed down for a second and thought, what the hell was this?
358
00:34:11,835 --> 00:34:15,902
Oshan: As he learned later on, this was what some teachers would call the first of the jhanas.
359
00:34:16,455 --> 00:34:24,220
And the jhanas in Tina's spectrum of concentration, are where the terrain of absorption begins Now,
360
00:34:24,220 --> 00:34:31,685
I will very briefly acknowledge that there is a centuries-long and still raging disagreement within Buddhism, sometimes called the jhana Wars.
361
00:34:32,172 --> 00:34:39,219
Different traditions and lineages have different ways of slicing up where access concentration ends and the first jhana begins.
362
00:34:39,917 --> 00:34:44,582
Tina would probably call what Max experienced in the car access concentration, not jhana.
363
00:34:45,145 --> 00:34:48,178
But for this series, we don't need to get stuck in terminology.
364
00:34:48,721 --> 00:34:54,750
The point is that whatever you call the coursing bliss that forced Max to pull over, or whatever you call this
365
00:34:55,159 --> 00:35:03,329
Samuel: This tingling sensation starts to grow and expand from my hands, like into my arms and then into my chest.
366
00:35:03,929 --> 00:35:10,439
And it starts to like build up, build up, sort of like, sort of feels like a volcano starting to erupt.
367
00:35:11,239 --> 00:35:20,301
Oshan: People are having some kind of significant meditation experience along the spectrum of concentration that completely changes how they think about meditation practice.
368
00:35:20,845 --> 00:35:25,705
Tina: It's not just the Buddha or their teacher or their friend who's been meditating for 10 years.
369
00:35:25,705 --> 00:35:26,515
It's them.
370
00:35:27,145 --> 00:35:31,705
And you don't need to be an advanced practitioner to have this happen.
371
00:35:32,155 --> 00:35:35,245
It is part of our capacity as humans.
372
00:35:35,302 --> 00:35:42,232
And I believe with the right instruction in the right setting, everybody can experience access concentration.
373
00:35:42,772 --> 00:35:46,062
And it is profoundly motivating for you to keep practicing.
374
00:35:52,420 --> 00:35:59,780
Oshan: In the ways that people describe pivot points, especially these blissful concentration experiences, you can hear how excited they get.
375
00:36:00,673 --> 00:36:03,229
And it's a great thing to be excited by your practice.
376
00:36:03,942 --> 00:36:10,516
But it's also the reason that teachers have traditionally been extremely cautious about feeding into that excitement,
377
00:36:10,516 --> 00:36:16,881
because it's very easy for that excitement about a pivot point to become a problem, like it was for Stuart.
378
00:36:17,668 --> 00:36:20,465
Stuart: Honestly, from that first sort of raw experience of bliss,
379
00:36:20,465 --> 00:36:26,628
I think from then on it had impacted me quite negatively in the sense that I was chasing something.
380
00:36:27,258 --> 00:36:34,338
Because all of my meditation was suddenly then directed towards, I want to feel fantastic again.
381
00:36:34,758 --> 00:36:36,948
And why is this not working?
382
00:36:37,658 --> 00:36:42,113
Oshan: In Tibetan, there's actually a word for flashy meditation experiences like pivot points.
383
00:36:42,184 --> 00:36:43,235
They're called nyams.
384
00:36:44,127 --> 00:36:52,424
The scholar and practitioner of Tibetan Buddhism, Andrew Holecek, wrote, "If you relate to a nyam properly, it blossoms into realization.
385
00:36:52,424 --> 00:36:58,304
If you
don't, it rots and becomes the most subtle and serious of all spiritual traps."
386
00:36:58,304 --> 00:37:02,660
He calls them the sweetest honey covering the sharpest hooks.
387
00:37:03,886 --> 00:37:06,828
This same sentiment appears across Buddhist teachings.
388
00:37:07,325 --> 00:37:11,424
Here's Matthieu Ricard, for example, the French geneticist turned Buddhist monk.
389
00:37:11,955 --> 00:37:18,282
He writes, "Meditators who run after experiences, like a child running after a rainbow, will be misled.
390
00:37:18,926 --> 00:37:27,075
When you practice intensely, you may have flashes, various signs of accomplishment, but all they do is foster expectations and pride.
391
00:37:27,770 --> 00:37:31,805
They're just devilish tricks and the source of obstacles."
392
00:37:31,805 --> 00:37:38,557
So traditionally, the response from teachers has been to say something like, "If a cool experience arises, great.
393
00:37:38,879 --> 00:37:40,295
Just don't focus on it.
394
00:37:40,479 --> 00:37:41,759
Don't make a big deal about it.
395
00:37:41,943 --> 00:37:44,822
Just let it go and keep meditating."
396
00:37:44,822 --> 00:37:51,901
And in the West, many teachers still teach this posture of not paying attention to exciting meditation experiences.
397
00:37:52,501 --> 00:37:54,220
It's something I heard throughout my interviews.
398
00:37:55,074 --> 00:37:57,324
Jonathan: They're all just sort of like, let it go.
399
00:37:57,714 --> 00:38:01,454
But you're not gonna elaborate on this, crazy thing that happened.
400
00:38:01,744 --> 00:38:06,694
Even just my intellectual curiosity was just like, come on, there has to be something for this.
401
00:38:10,278 --> 00:38:13,758
Pranab: And I talked to my meditation teacher after And I'm like, ah, okay man, I can't even enjoy this.
402
00:38:14,359 --> 00:38:15,319
Aaron: He kind of like plays down.
403
00:38:16,684 --> 00:38:20,164
Extraordinary experiences in my experience of him as a teacher.
404
00:38:20,644 --> 00:38:21,754
He doesn't wanna hype them up.
405
00:38:22,486 --> 00:38:26,772
Oshan: There are very good reasons for this taboo around focusing on pivot points.
406
00:38:27,460 --> 00:38:33,574
It's often considered a mark of spiritual immaturity to go around talking about your big flashy meditation experiences.
407
00:38:34,163 --> 00:38:35,750
It can also make you rather insufferable.
408
00:38:36,569 --> 00:38:40,717
But carrying this taboo into the West has unique consequences.
409
00:38:41,471 --> 00:38:48,321
Unlike in Thailand or India, mainstream Western culture doesn't really recognize the deep end of meditation as a real thing.
410
00:38:49,103 --> 00:38:54,433
So the taboo against talking about these experiences, whether with your teacher or in public,
411
00:38:54,433 --> 00:38:59,186
has had the effect of helping to keep everything beyond basic mindfulness in the dark.
412
00:38:59,960 --> 00:39:06,460
Tina: I hear this all the time from people, 'cause I do one-on-one interviews in all my retreats that are week or longer.
413
00:39:06,930 --> 00:39:09,198
Oshan: This is meditation teacher Tina Rasmussen again.
414
00:39:09,680 --> 00:39:11,990
Tina: And sometimes people will come in just in tears
415
00:39:11,990 --> 00:39:16,846
and wanna tell me about this thing that happened 10 years ago that was like the most profound moment of their life,
416
00:39:16,846 --> 00:39:18,410
and their teacher just poo-pooed it.
417
00:39:19,160 --> 00:39:20,750
To me that is tragic.
418
00:39:21,470 --> 00:39:22,880
That is tragic.
419
00:39:23,210 --> 00:39:31,130
Because this person had a taste of their deeper nature of the mystery, of the human experience, and it wasn't validated.
420
00:39:32,330 --> 00:39:34,160
This is the whole point of practice.
421
00:39:35,017 --> 00:39:42,080
Teachers have traditionally told people not to, to let it go to their heads, to move on.
422
00:39:42,080 --> 00:39:45,900
But to me that is not working with what's there.
423
00:39:45,900 --> 00:39:49,550
What's there is that this person had a, something profound happen.
424
00:39:49,550 --> 00:39:50,724
Let's celebrate that.
425
00:39:51,100 --> 00:39:53,066
Oshan: And I heard the same thing from Henry Shukman.
426
00:39:53,804 --> 00:39:54,464
Henry: The fact that.
427
00:39:55,133 --> 00:40:00,383
Some teachers I know will sort of dismiss them and brush them aside and say, don't, don't worry about that.
428
00:40:00,833 --> 00:40:03,323
I, I personally don't do that.
429
00:40:03,353 --> 00:40:11,098
I think it's really important that people have an opportunity to share something really decisive, and it's often the most important thing somebody's ever experienced.
430
00:40:11,948 --> 00:40:17,948
It's a fantastically good thing that that is now more widely spoken about.
431
00:40:18,488 --> 00:40:23,798
Because it's a real part of our human nature that Western tradition largely overlooked.
432
00:40:24,456 --> 00:40:30,296
Oshan: All of which is to say, in addition to the role that pivot points can play in deepening your meditation practice,
433
00:40:30,296 --> 00:40:37,011
they also represent this big and neglected category of profound experiences that can stretch our understanding of psychology,
434
00:40:37,400 --> 00:40:42,305
and they're basically uncharted territory as far as our understanding of consciousness and wellbeing goes.
435
00:40:43,866 --> 00:40:47,132
So this is the second big question I asked the teachers I spoke with.
436
00:40:47,932 --> 00:40:53,147
How do we allow ourselves to give more attention to these experiences without getting
437
00:40:53,147 --> 00:40:56,298
so caught up in them that they undermine our whole meditation practice?
438
00:40:56,809 --> 00:41:00,649
Tina: In Buddhism, there's unwholesome desire and wholesome desire.
439
00:41:01,579 --> 00:41:08,849
So I work with helping people distinguish between wholesome desire and unwholesome desire.
440
00:41:08,879 --> 00:41:12,059
'cause the minute
we're trying to get somewhere, we're not in the present moment.
441
00:41:13,379 --> 00:41:15,569
All the good stuff is in the present moment.
442
00:41:16,889 --> 00:41:26,699
So if I am aiming for something that isn't here, now I'm suffering and I'm not getting where I wanna be.
443
00:41:26,699 --> 00:41:28,154
I'm not like…
444
00:41:28,154 --> 00:41:36,808
One of my, tips for both practice and realization is to show up a hundred percent and to surrender a hundred percent,
445
00:41:36,808 --> 00:41:41,119
surrender the outcome because we can't control the outcome.
446
00:41:41,329 --> 00:41:44,839
But what we can do is we can show up a hundred percent.
447
00:41:45,109 --> 00:41:50,287
If you show up up a hundred percent in your daily sit, you may have a good sit, you may have a bad sit,
448
00:41:50,287 --> 00:41:53,959
but your practice will deepen because you're showing up.
449
00:41:54,491 --> 00:41:57,287
Oshan: Which sounded similar to the advice that Henry Shukman gave.
450
00:41:57,822 --> 00:41:59,366
Henry: Just like with an old ship,
451
00:41:59,366 --> 00:42:06,472
you can set your course and then you forget about the island 3000 miles away that you know you're heading for.
452
00:42:06,832 --> 00:42:10,012
You just do your day-to-day practice as on a ship.
453
00:42:10,017 --> 00:42:16,924
You can't force the wind to blow, you just settle in to taking care of the polishing of the deck,
454
00:42:16,924 --> 00:42:20,827
the soaking of the salt beef or whatever, all the things that they had to do on an old ship.
455
00:42:21,217 --> 00:42:28,777
So really we want to acknowledge it's true and it happens and it's real, but then we kind of wanna forget about it.
456
00:42:29,507 --> 00:42:31,340
Oshan: In both Tina and Henry's advice,
457
00:42:31,340 --> 00:42:33,723
the idea is basically not to cling
458
00:42:33,723 --> 00:42:39,929
so tightly to whatever goal you have for your practice that it creates friction with whatever's actually happening while you meditate.
459
00:42:41,132 --> 00:42:46,174
But of course, the reason this is such universal advice is that we all tend to do it anyway.
460
00:42:47,049 --> 00:42:54,856
And one teacher I spoke with told me that in his experience, sometimes it's better to just let ourselves cling and learn from the experience.
461
00:42:55,470 --> 00:43:00,088
Richard: And a lot of meditation teachers warn people about don't cling and everything.
462
00:43:00,268 --> 00:43:04,778
I'm different in that I'm just like, "Go ahead, just cling all you want."
463
00:43:05,551 --> 00:43:06,802
Oshan: This is Richard Shankman.
464
00:43:07,383 --> 00:43:12,168
He started meditating back in the '70s and has been more formally teaching for the last 30 years.
465
00:43:12,428 --> 00:43:15,158
Richard: I'm not trying to get them to cling, but it's just like, "You wanna do that?
466
00:43:15,358 --> 00:43:15,970
Fine."
467
00:43:15,970 --> 00:43:18,158
It's a fantastic teacher.
468
00:43:18,788 --> 00:43:22,448
And if you're gonna cling anyway, you do that and we learn.
469
00:43:22,758 --> 00:43:27,608
And by clinging and chasing and suffering, it doesn't make it come faster.
470
00:43:27,608 --> 00:43:29,248
It actually is counterproductive.
471
00:43:29,248 --> 00:43:30,178
It's a hindrance.
472
00:43:30,548 --> 00:43:33,418
So you learn that it's actually stopping what you want.
473
00:43:33,768 --> 00:43:38,918
Because non-clinging is not only a fruit of the practice, it's actually the path of practice.
474
00:43:39,418 --> 00:43:41,298
So sometimes we have to learn that.
475
00:43:41,328 --> 00:43:43,378
I know that very well in my own practice.
476
00:43:43,938 --> 00:43:47,328
We have to go through what we have to go through, and then we learn.
477
00:43:47,758 --> 00:43:49,998
Not just learn as a good idea, we really get it.
478
00:43:50,048 --> 00:43:51,978
And then we're just good with what's happening.
479
00:43:53,130 --> 00:43:57,603
Oshan: One reason I really liked this answer, to just go ahead and cling as its own kind of teaching,
480
00:43:58,162 --> 00:44:01,766
was that I had a growing concern as I was making this series.
481
00:44:03,499 --> 00:44:11,404
Am I just glorifying meditation experiences in exactly the kind of way that teachers all tell us is going to undermine meditation practice?
482
00:44:12,348 --> 00:44:20,154
And not only did I sometimes wonder whether this whole project was a naive mistake, I also worried that it might be setting listeners up,
483
00:44:20,517 --> 00:44:25,420
setting you up, to relate to meditation in that same counterproductive way.
484
00:44:26,044 --> 00:44:30,194
As if the only way to get into deep meditation is to have a pivot point,
485
00:44:30,194 --> 00:44:34,210
and so to take on a goal for your practice of having a particular experience.
486
00:44:35,436 --> 00:44:38,105
So I posed a hypothetical to Richard.
487
00:44:39,310 --> 00:44:45,984
Say someone listens to this series and gets really excited about pivot points, and they look Richard up since they heard him on the series,
488
00:44:45,994 --> 00:44:50,369
and they come to him saying, "Hey, I heard you on this series about cool meditation experiences.
489
00:44:50,369 --> 00:44:51,822
I'd like to have one myself.
490
00:44:51,822 --> 00:44:52,809
Can you teach me?"
491
00:44:54,251 --> 00:44:56,792
I wanted to know, would that be bad?
492
00:44:57,433 --> 00:44:59,508
Is that unwholesome desire?
493
00:45:00,150 --> 00:45:05,994
Is that starting a meditation practice from the very position of clinging that teachers all advise we're better off avoiding?
494
00:45:06,866 --> 00:45:09,818
So my question to him was, how would you handle that?
495
00:45:11,611 --> 00:45:12,751
Richard: I would just say, "Great.
496
00:45:12,751 --> 00:45:13,031
Good.
497
00:45:13,031 --> 00:45:13,811
Let's start.
498
00:45:14,161 --> 00:45:20,571
I don't assume that because they want to have a certain experience means that it's unwholesome
or that they're clinging.
499
00:45:20,911 --> 00:45:22,531
Look, this is important.
500
00:45:23,401 --> 00:45:33,891
We should not pretend that we don't want these wholesome, powerful, important experiences that come.
501
00:45:34,791 --> 00:45:44,325
The Buddha himself is quoted in the source texts, that says, "Samadhi and jhana should be cultivated, should not be feared."
502
00:45:44,325 --> 00:45:48,761
He basically said, "Go for it," and it's actually important to go for.
503
00:45:49,751 --> 00:45:55,531
So, let's not pretend that we don't want to be more liberated, more enlightened.
504
00:45:55,651 --> 00:45:57,881
Who wouldn't want to have blissful experiences?
505
00:45:57,941 --> 00:45:58,951
They feel great.
506
00:45:59,341 --> 00:46:03,121
They're actually healing somatically in the body and in the mind.
507
00:46:03,121 --> 00:46:03,941
They're powerful.
508
00:46:04,221 --> 00:46:05,471
They're faith-inducing.
509
00:46:05,471 --> 00:46:07,771
There's many, many good benefits there.
510
00:46:08,201 --> 00:46:10,281
We don't have to pretend that we don't want those.
511
00:46:10,401 --> 00:46:14,361
Every human being who's ever existed wants that, if they knew.
512
00:46:15,171 --> 00:46:17,461
Let's just not make it an object of clinging.
513
00:46:18,291 --> 00:46:20,221
So you can want it and go for it.
514
00:46:20,221 --> 00:46:22,971
How can you move in that direction skillfully?
515
00:46:24,031 --> 00:46:29,151
The way I do that is I try to present things that seem seemingly contradictory.
516
00:46:29,531 --> 00:46:34,631
That we are on a path and yet we don't want to get anywhere at all.
517
00:46:34,681 --> 00:46:35,741
So how can that be?
518
00:46:36,371 --> 00:46:39,591
Because the way you progress on the path is just be here.
519
00:46:39,891 --> 00:46:41,691
Tend to what's happening now.
520
00:46:41,951 --> 00:46:43,481
Which is all you really have anyway.
521
00:46:43,811 --> 00:46:52,059
By being here wisely and skillfully, you may need help, that's why people work with teachers, that progresses you on the path,
522
00:46:52,059 --> 00:46:57,594
so you get the best of moving along in a good direction and just allowing yourself to really be…
523
00:46:57,594 --> 00:46:59,221
It's that be here now thing.
524
00:47:07,190 --> 00:47:14,454
Oshan: So far, teachers have described the risks of clinging to pivot points as creating obstacles to deepening your meditation practice.
525
00:47:15,100 --> 00:47:17,317
Either the very desire to have that exciting
526
00:47:17,317 --> 00:47:23,057
or blissful state again each time you meditate can turn into the thing that is preventing you from having that state,
527
00:47:23,057 --> 00:47:30,248
or feeding the egoic drive to have these experiences can wind up reinforcing the attachments to the sense of self
528
00:47:30,252 --> 00:47:32,079
that meditation often aims to loosen.
529
00:47:32,824 --> 00:47:38,936
But Richard mentioned another reason why obsessing over these initial experiences can look a little silly in the long run.
530
00:47:39,801 --> 00:47:45,079
For example, let's take the first jhana, which we've heard described as this intense pleasure shooting through the body.
531
00:47:46,136 --> 00:47:49,721
When meditators first have these experiences, they're often really exciting.
532
00:47:50,602 --> 00:47:56,200
But talking to meditators who spent years with these practices, they've all pretty much told me the same thing.
533
00:47:57,092 --> 00:48:00,718
The bliss was fun at first, but it gets old pretty quickly.
534
00:48:01,470 --> 00:48:07,747
Richard: Bliss is boring and everybody I know before you have bliss, it's just like, "Man, I want some of that bliss."
535
00:48:07,747 --> 00:48:08,577
And I understand that.
536
00:48:08,577 --> 00:48:10,017
I've been there myself, for sure.
537
00:48:11,187 --> 00:48:14,757
And then it's like, yeah, what's the point?
538
00:48:15,167 --> 00:48:21,961
Because what we find is that Because it can be strong, it can fill so much of our consciousness,
539
00:48:21,961 --> 00:48:31,073
even though there are other qualities and aspects going on, like clarity, like stableness, like feeling emptied out, all these…
540
00:48:31,073 --> 00:48:37,253
There's a lot of things we could talk about that actually are s- they're subtler but can feel more satisfying.
541
00:48:37,543 --> 00:48:42,232
And it's only, when the bliss part settles out It's sort of like if you look up,
542
00:48:42,232 --> 00:48:47,773
go out in the day and you look up and I can't see the stars because the sun has filled the sky.
543
00:48:47,853 --> 00:48:52,368
And then when the sun sets, if you've ever been up where it's very dark skies,
544
00:48:52,368 --> 00:48:56,103
maybe up at high altitude and seen that, it's amazing.
545
00:48:56,843 --> 00:49:02,923
And there's probably more awe looking at that than a blue sky that we see every day.
546
00:49:05,311 --> 00:49:10,030
Oshan: Whether someone's pivot point involves the bliss of concentration, or the excitement of insight,
547
00:49:10,030 --> 00:49:14,175
it tends to get dwarfed pretty quickly by the further experiences it can lead to.
548
00:49:15,116 --> 00:49:23,485
And this is one reason that every teacher I spoke with described pivot points as waypoints along the path of a deep meditation practice.
549
00:49:24,519 --> 00:49:26,799
Michael: If it's helping you to practice more, great.
550
00:49:26,799 --> 00:49:29,339
And if it's helping you to stay on the path, great.
551
00:49:29,819 --> 00:49:31,019
Tina: Let's celebrate that.
552
00:49:31,019 --> 00:49:32,369
This is the whole point of the path.
553
00:49:32,374 --> 00:49:34,354
Henry: And this is one of the nice things about having a path.
554
00:49:34,974 --> 00:49:36,909
A spiritual path, meditative path.
555
00:49:37,604 --> 00:49:43,694
Just having the trust of being on a path already makes a great difference in our life.
556
00:49:44,954 --> 00:49:50,262
Oshan: Remember in the first episode, I described pivot points as experiences that open doorways into the deep end.
557
00:49:51,059 --> 00:49:59,096
Something seems to happen through the experience of a pivot point that gives meditators this direct, visceral feeling of meditation,
558
00:49:59,096 --> 00:50:05,273
not as something that just produces the same experience over and over, but actually goes somewhere.
559
00:50:06,927 --> 00:50:12,471
You begin to glimpse the possibility of a long-term trajectory to your practice, a path.
560
00:50:13,488 --> 00:50:25,259
Michael: If you just have that deep sense that there's something about the fundamental nature of the world that you are sniffing in meditation
561
00:50:25,259 --> 00:50:30,209
and not anywhere else, that's what's going to bring you back.
562
00:50:31,389 --> 00:50:36,009
There's a, a whiff of truth in there that isn't anywhere else.
563
00:50:36,573 --> 00:50:40,083
For a certain kind of person, there it is the whiff of truth.
564
00:50:40,083 --> 00:50:41,680
Or it could be, the heart.
565
00:50:42,926 --> 00:50:51,446
It just opens your heart in a way that nothing else does, and that kind of love vibration is irresistible.
566
00:50:52,516 --> 00:50:55,666
Oshan: So you can think of pivot points as the beginnings of a path.
567
00:50:56,559 --> 00:51:04,528
Something happens, however faint or strange or intense, that creates this motivation to keep practicing, to see where it leads.
568
00:51:05,401 --> 00:51:07,777
And this is the question we'll take up next episode.
569
00:51:08,767 --> 00:51:11,171
What happens after a pivot point?
570
00:51:15,781 --> 00:51:19,951
If you wanna learn more about the series, head over to pivotpoints.xyz.
571
00:51:20,662 --> 00:51:24,580
There you can find transcripts, guest information, and links to more material.
572
00:51:25,504 --> 00:51:31,635
I'll be publishing bonus episodes and collections of short clips that didn't make it into the series through my newsletter,
573
00:51:31,635 --> 00:51:35,285
which you can subscribe to at heretodisappear.org.
574
00:51:36,189 --> 00:51:42,445
And if you'd like to support the series and more projects like this, you can become a paid subscriber of my newsletter.
575
00:51:42,817 --> 00:51:44,869
Or just share the series with a friend.
576
00:51:46,616 --> 00:51:49,461
Pivot Points is supported by the Waking Up meditation app.
577
00:51:50,119 --> 00:51:58,496
Edited by Amy Standen, original theme music by Marcus Bagala, cover art by Valero Doval, mixed by Lucas Del Calvo,
578
00:51:58,925 --> 00:52:06,898
created and hosted by Oshan Jarow, and made possible by the generous meditators willing to share their weird experiences for public listening.
579
00:52:07,791 --> 00:52:08,312
Thank you all