TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:03.550 --> 00:09.394
[SPEAKER_01]: Hey listeners, about of illness kept us from finishing our review of savage blooms, but don't worry, it's still coming.
00:10.095 --> 00:17.400
[SPEAKER_01]: Instead this week we dove into the paperback pleasure's archives and found a never-released episode, our originally meant for Patreon only.
00:18.461 --> 00:25.366
[SPEAKER_01]: Now we hope you enjoy falling down the rabbit hole with us while we learn about an early internet fandom that may have gone too far.
00:26.287 --> 00:28.409
[SPEAKER_01]: These are the secrets of the sneakists.
00:29.109 --> 00:31.171
[SPEAKER_01]: And we'll be back next week with the book review.
00:32.172 --> 00:32.572
[SPEAKER_01]: See you then.
00:51.221 --> 01:11.357
[SPEAKER_00]: Dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun, dun
01:17.922 --> 01:22.807
[SPEAKER_00]: Like, highly recommend it is now called fan gazzum, which is also great.
01:22.967 --> 01:25.970
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I heard a pot of rauticas probably because you were talking about it.
01:25.990 --> 01:29.093
[SPEAKER_01]: I did not realize that that changed a fan gazzum because I've heard of both of them.
01:29.113 --> 01:30.475
[SPEAKER_01]: I didn't realize they were one of the same.
01:31.354 --> 01:33.215
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that is a before and after.
01:33.235 --> 01:45.244
[SPEAKER_00]: I have a question for you for today's very, very important discussion and you may like see it coming, but I want to know you ever had a crush on a fictional character.
01:45.264 --> 01:49.147
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, In a bell.
01:52.646 --> 01:55.748
[SPEAKER_00]: Most of my questions have been on fictional characters.
01:55.908 --> 01:59.529
[SPEAKER_00]: What would you say is like you're a biggest obsession in terms of a fictional character?
02:00.069 --> 02:02.671
[SPEAKER_00]: Unforge.
02:03.751 --> 02:08.473
[SPEAKER_01]: Edward probably wins just because I was 12, 13.
02:08.633 --> 02:09.114
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
02:10.474 --> 02:14.556
[SPEAKER_01]: And I mean all the way like into high school like 14, 15.
02:14.916 --> 02:17.758
[SPEAKER_01]: I was like completely in love with him.
02:18.854 --> 02:22.456
[SPEAKER_01]: What did it feel like to be crashing on Edward Collin every day?
02:22.476 --> 02:25.898
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it was heartbreaking because it wasn't real, you know?
02:26.138 --> 02:31.962
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I was so obsessed with this idea of this person that didn't exist.
02:32.102 --> 02:37.225
[SPEAKER_01]: And when it's a fictional character, you can put so much on to them, you know?
02:37.365 --> 02:37.826
[SPEAKER_01]: And so like,
02:38.466 --> 02:42.949
[SPEAKER_01]: between Romi, Brain, just made a million things up.
02:43.150 --> 02:56.740
[SPEAKER_01]: You start to imagine them everywhere you are, and what would it be like if they were in your life, or how your life would be more exciting if they were there, that's kind of stuff I would imagine, right, like if I had Edward Collin, what would my life would be different?
02:56.780 --> 03:02.024
[SPEAKER_01]: And of course, middle school, early high school, Romi was like, oh, it'd be so much better, right?
03:04.125 --> 03:08.568
[SPEAKER_01]: I think there's also like that pull to like be as obsessively love.
03:08.608 --> 03:10.269
[SPEAKER_01]: Do we talk about this on our Twilight episode?
03:10.369 --> 03:17.333
[SPEAKER_01]: Like that idea that like this fictional person exists almost to adore you.
03:18.174 --> 03:21.676
[SPEAKER_01]: Almost like the wicker husband, like the wicker husband.
03:22.556 --> 03:28.080
[SPEAKER_01]: That kind of idea to underdevelop Tormodal teenage brains is so addicting.
03:29.020 --> 03:31.222
[SPEAKER_01]: So, I mean, I literally would consider it.
03:31.882 --> 03:42.389
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't say, I don't want to say addiction because addiction is actually a very serious thing, but like, as Sudo addicted to the idea of Edward Colton, for sure when I was younger.
03:42.569 --> 03:49.874
[SPEAKER_01]: And then I've had like crushes here and there from then on, but nothing, nothing to that caliber were like every song I listened to reminded me of it.
03:49.914 --> 03:54.397
[SPEAKER_01]: Like it was a ridiculous, it was so stupid, but it was so, so, so real.
03:55.332 --> 04:00.193
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, be nice to my friend, first of all, Tween Rummy was a bummer of a person.
04:01.094 --> 04:03.774
[SPEAKER_01]: In fairness, being a Tween is a bummer of an experience.
04:03.874 --> 04:06.635
[SPEAKER_01]: So you're just dealing with the cards you've dealt at that point.
04:07.135 --> 04:08.816
[SPEAKER_01]: It was just such an easiest scape.
04:08.856 --> 04:16.398
[SPEAKER_01]: It's the easiest way when you're going through it to imagine a different, better life is to have that fictional crush.
04:16.658 --> 04:21.199
[SPEAKER_01]: And my teenage brain latched onto that because I was going through watching back then.
04:21.299 --> 04:21.519
[SPEAKER_01]: So,
04:22.308 --> 04:35.735
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, in having a crush makes life really exciting, like all the mundane things of going to class and going to homework, you can imagine a layer of like fantastical that makes it more fun to like be alive.
04:37.156 --> 04:42.179
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think it's a really, really like natural normal thing for people to do.
04:42.199 --> 04:43.419
[SPEAKER_01]: Mm-hmm.
04:44.020 --> 04:47.862
[SPEAKER_01]: I also really liked Phantom of the
Load full transcript
Opera, which is not surprising to any of our loyal listeners.
04:49.551 --> 04:53.474
[SPEAKER_01]: No, seriously, Phantom of the Opera was a huge, huge, huge, fictional crush for me, too.
04:53.534 --> 04:57.236
[SPEAKER_01]: So that was kind of my in-between from book to movie and back.
04:58.157 --> 05:04.100
[SPEAKER_00]: I kind of disagree with you on one of your words in that sentence, and it's when the word was.
05:04.120 --> 05:08.984
[SPEAKER_00]: I believe this is a, this is a crush that is alive and well.
05:09.324 --> 05:11.705
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you want to pretend that it's on the past, we can.
05:11.725 --> 05:13.867
[SPEAKER_00]: All right.
05:15.708 --> 05:16.368
[SPEAKER_01]: All right.
05:16.589 --> 05:18.490
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not, it's not obsession, love, a lot of war.
05:19.862 --> 05:28.888
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, and I think when I think about obsession level, fan-girling over a fictional character, I think back to like my middle school high school days.
05:29.028 --> 05:41.135
[SPEAKER_00]: So I'd have like huge, huge crushes on real boys, but it was mostly like an idea of who they could be, somewhat based on fictional characters, because like, wasn't having very deep conversations every day.
05:41.955 --> 05:49.200
[SPEAKER_00]: And then I would go home every night and read my Draco self-insert fan-fick on Quazilla.
05:53.072 --> 05:58.537
[SPEAKER_00]: And it was very much like of the time to have the part of that huge, huge fandom.
05:59.117 --> 05:59.537
[SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely.
05:59.557 --> 06:04.662
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, and I think you got into fan fiction way before I did too, because you you've read a lot of it.
06:04.762 --> 06:08.885
[SPEAKER_01]: And I, for some reason, you'd think the way I was obsessing over these people.
06:08.965 --> 06:13.789
[SPEAKER_01]: I would also be like deep in the trenches of fandoms like a lot of my friends were in those days.
06:13.989 --> 06:17.833
[SPEAKER_01]: I just never was, but you, you did and was Draco kind of your go to,
06:19.110 --> 06:28.376
[SPEAKER_00]: I just like to the the writing of the couple of Draco stories that I found, I was a Draco jury like you like the fan fiction for the writing.
06:29.016 --> 06:30.737
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that was it.
06:30.757 --> 06:30.997
[SPEAKER_01]: That's it.
06:31.017 --> 06:32.518
[SPEAKER_01]: That's what we're going with really.
06:32.578 --> 06:33.879
[SPEAKER_00]: I watched it for the plot.
06:37.240 --> 06:38.963
[SPEAKER_00]: Uh, yeah, okay.
06:39.083 --> 06:56.404
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, also like, I think that there would be these sort of like sweeping characters that would be front and center for different age groups that would have Fanfic that was like quote unquote appropriate for that fan group right like I was really into Draco because the fanfic was all about like seven minutes and haven't been making out.
06:57.146 --> 06:57.786
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, sure, sure, sure.
06:57.986 --> 06:59.367
[SPEAKER_00]: Absolutely because he was younger.
06:59.387 --> 07:09.512
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I have one bummer of a thing that like there's very little there wasn't fanfic about when I was younger, but there is now what Colonel Brandon from sense and sensibility.
07:10.293 --> 07:17.076
[SPEAKER_01]: What there was like when I was like a young girl crushing an Alan Rickman, which is the reason for here today.
07:17.096 --> 07:18.317
[SPEAKER_01]: Correct.
07:18.337 --> 07:21.579
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I was Colonel Brandon in sense and sensibility there wasn't like.
07:22.820 --> 07:26.924
[SPEAKER_01]: The Jane Austen fanfic was not a thing that we were finding when we were tweeds.
07:28.025 --> 07:29.526
[SPEAKER_00]: No, it was harder to find.
07:29.706 --> 07:32.509
[SPEAKER_00]: I will say like ultimately did get published.
07:33.250 --> 07:46.202
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, I was like lost in Austin dead comes to Pemberley, but like yeah, I wish that I could go back to high school and like give you just a stack of phantom and Colonel Brandon fanfic.
07:47.970 --> 07:52.232
[SPEAKER_00]: And I don't know if it would mess you up or make you better, but probably would give you some comfort.
07:53.233 --> 08:04.519
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I think when I was younger, and this is not the way I feel nowadays, but I think when I was younger, one of the reasons I didn't fall into the fanfic hole was because I didn't want to share my questions for other people.
08:04.799 --> 08:11.963
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was just like a sick, tween brain, Roamy was like their mind.
08:12.483 --> 08:15.105
[SPEAKER_01]: And the way I've imagined them is the right way.
08:16.248 --> 08:22.133
[SPEAKER_01]: And I didn't want that illusion to be shattered by other people coming in and being like, well, I know them better.
08:22.173 --> 08:22.973
[SPEAKER_01]: So I could write this.
08:23.073 --> 08:24.975
[SPEAKER_01]: That is not fiction as an adult.
08:25.015 --> 08:25.816
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm very aware of that.
08:25.836 --> 08:28.518
[SPEAKER_01]: But I genuinely think that's why I didn't gravitate towards it as a kid.
08:29.635 --> 08:36.876
[SPEAKER_00]: It's funny that you say that because that actual mindset is going to bring us like straight right into what we're talking about today.
08:36.896 --> 08:36.956
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh.
08:37.436 --> 08:37.976
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh.
08:38.817 --> 08:42.137
[SPEAKER_00]: So, let's, let's tell the scene is the early 2000s.
08:42.377 --> 08:45.318
[SPEAKER_00]: So we're talking like 2005 to 2009-ish.
08:46.078 --> 08:50.079
[SPEAKER_00]: And Harry Potter books were coming out, they weren't all out yet.
08:50.219 --> 08:51.959
[SPEAKER_00]: Last one comes out in 2007.
08:52.599 --> 08:53.999
[SPEAKER_00]: Did you read them as they came out?
08:55.020 --> 08:55.440
[SPEAKER_00]: I did.
08:55.460 --> 08:57.160
[SPEAKER_00]: I didn't start at the beginning.
08:57.940 --> 08:58.380
[SPEAKER_00]: You didn't.
08:59.261 --> 09:00.262
[SPEAKER_00]: My older brother did.
09:00.482 --> 09:01.863
[SPEAKER_00]: It was like, I was too young.
09:01.883 --> 09:06.847
[SPEAKER_00]: I think the first one that came out like when I had already read them was the fourth.
09:07.448 --> 09:12.392
[SPEAKER_00]: And then my brother's and I all had to share a coffee as my friends were like, we're not buying three copies of this book.
09:12.872 --> 09:14.113
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I remember that.
09:14.133 --> 09:14.654
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, actually.
09:15.194 --> 09:16.916
[SPEAKER_01]: So we would read them out loud to each other.
09:17.503 --> 09:18.164
[SPEAKER_01]: That's right.
09:18.244 --> 09:21.526
[SPEAKER_01]: I do remember there being a reading out loud element to your Harry Potter experience.
09:21.647 --> 09:21.887
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
09:22.427 --> 09:22.667
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
09:22.727 --> 09:22.948
[SPEAKER_01]: Cool.
09:23.608 --> 09:26.070
[SPEAKER_01]: I had never heard of them until a relative.
09:26.110 --> 09:29.333
[SPEAKER_01]: I think my grandmother gave me a copy of the first one.
09:30.274 --> 09:33.537
[SPEAKER_01]: And I remember thinking that the first two sentences were really fucking boring.
09:34.617 --> 09:38.060
[SPEAKER_01]: And so it took me a really long time to get to get back into the room.
09:39.982 --> 09:40.622
[SPEAKER_00]: Incredible.
09:40.903 --> 09:41.864
[SPEAKER_00]: Did you ever get into them?
09:43.073 --> 09:43.694
[SPEAKER_00]: I read all books.
09:44.995 --> 09:45.676
[SPEAKER_00]: I saw the movies.
09:45.756 --> 09:47.317
[SPEAKER_00]: It's kind of like fourth wing for me.
09:47.678 --> 09:50.620
[SPEAKER_01]: Very entertaining, cool world that she created.
09:53.123 --> 09:57.006
[SPEAKER_01]: I was never as obsessed as everybody else in my grade seemed to be.
09:57.207 --> 09:59.929
[SPEAKER_01]: I have friends that have the Deathly Hallows tattooed on them.
10:00.429 --> 10:08.037
[SPEAKER_01]: I have other friends that have its real for us tattooed on them because they were so swept away by Harry Potter.
10:08.697 --> 10:12.260
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, I don't know if that's because I was already reading a lot of other fantasy.
10:12.420 --> 10:21.888
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I was able to come at fantasy with the critical lens, because like we've seen Akatar in fourth, weighing that can be a lot of people's first entrance into adult fantasy.
10:21.908 --> 10:24.150
[SPEAKER_01]: So it becomes this obsession for them.
10:24.551 --> 10:26.592
[SPEAKER_01]: Akatar is like that for me, a hundred percent.
10:26.773 --> 10:30.175
[SPEAKER_01]: It was just that was where people escaped to for Harry Potter.
10:30.195 --> 10:33.398
[SPEAKER_01]: But even as a kid when I was reading them, I remember
10:34.519 --> 10:40.826
[SPEAKER_01]: being distracted by plot holes and wanting more about, I wanted more world-building about how things work.
10:40.906 --> 10:42.788
[SPEAKER_01]: So because of that, I really enjoyed the books.
10:42.868 --> 10:43.609
[SPEAKER_01]: Don't get me wrong.
10:44.610
--> 10:50.337
[SPEAKER_01]: I just, I always kind of felt like there was like something, I was kind of felt like a dick because I just wasn't as into it as everybody else.
10:50.837 --> 10:53.100
[SPEAKER_01]: But the soundtrack for the movies is fucking good.
10:54.220 --> 10:54.620
[SPEAKER_00]: It is good.
10:55.241 --> 10:55.901
[SPEAKER_00]: It definitely is.
10:56.542 --> 10:59.483
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I was unabashedly into it.
10:59.503 --> 11:01.365
[SPEAKER_00]: I loved to love those them.
11:01.525 --> 11:14.993
[SPEAKER_00]: And I remember in second grade, there was a big fight in our grade because we were putting on a playground wide rendition of the first Harry Potter movie and I was cast as an extra and I was.
11:15.253 --> 11:15.674
[SPEAKER_00]: Who's?
11:16.214 --> 11:17.054
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you remember who I was?
11:21.752 --> 11:25.255
[SPEAKER_00]: Nope, I was Snape, stop it.
11:26.375 --> 11:28.997
[SPEAKER_01]: Cause Max was the Max.
11:29.037 --> 11:30.318
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, we all remember this.
11:31.519 --> 11:32.960
[SPEAKER_01]: And nobody wanted to play Snape.
11:34.581 --> 11:35.062
[SPEAKER_01]: That's why I did.
11:36.843 --> 11:46.710
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, look, I was like, I will be an extra instead of several Snape, you were an extra playground in the description of a fairy plotter.
11:47.410 --> 11:49.412
[SPEAKER_00]: Guys, this is why I really enjoy
11:51.757 --> 11:53.277
[SPEAKER_00]: This is why I have a podcast now.
11:54.518 --> 11:55.998
[SPEAKER_01]: This is where you're all started.
11:57.079 --> 11:59.279
[SPEAKER_01]: That's enough to give any kid a complex.
12:01.560 --> 12:03.461
[SPEAKER_01]: That's really fucking funny.
12:03.481 --> 12:04.561
[SPEAKER_01]: I know.
12:07.322 --> 12:10.303
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so anyway, you were an extra, and I was the villain.
12:12.464 --> 12:18.886
[SPEAKER_00]: But there was, there was like a lot of room for imagination in these things, because the books were still coming out.
12:20.347 --> 12:21.988
[SPEAKER_00]: There, we didn't know what was going to happen.
12:22.389 --> 12:33.657
[SPEAKER_00]: And like you're seeing now for Akataar, for fourth wing, tons of opportunity for people to write fan fiction and one with ideas about what they thought the plot was going to be.
12:34.197 --> 12:39.001
[SPEAKER_00]: And then have opinions about how it did happen, compared to what they hoped.
12:39.601 --> 13:03.411
[SPEAKER_00]: And what they thought would happen that like really led to this sense of ownership of the characters and this is really a like don of internet forums like people becoming really active online in these communities and the conversions of this huge giant franchise coming out and these online communities becoming.
13:04.028 --> 13:10.770
[SPEAKER_00]: more and more prevalent meant that we had fandom online in a way that had not been seen before.
13:11.491 --> 13:11.911
[SPEAKER_01]: Wow.
13:12.791 --> 13:13.591
[SPEAKER_01]: That's really cool.
13:14.252 --> 13:17.113
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, and it's something that we kind of take for granted.
13:18.053 --> 13:22.815
[SPEAKER_01]: Now 100% absolutely, but I'm glad you're bringing this back up because I remember that and it was so
13:24.220 --> 13:24.740
[SPEAKER_01]: new.
13:25.361 --> 13:32.566
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, even just thinking of like Tumblr, which is kind of like the very surface of the whole fandom and fan fiction and fan casting.
13:32.726 --> 13:41.252
[SPEAKER_01]: And for all that you have to say about Harry Potter and especially the woman who wrote it, it is very, very cool that so many people found solace in that world.
13:42.553 --> 13:43.014
[SPEAKER_00]: It's true.
13:43.274 --> 13:47.218
[SPEAKER_00]: I think there's also something to be said for the way that the internet worked to then versus now.
13:47.419 --> 13:51.443
[SPEAKER_00]: A lot of the areas where people were gathering were not like social media sites.
13:51.663 --> 13:53.105
[SPEAKER_00]: So like I mentioned Quizella.
13:53.485 --> 13:58.871
[SPEAKER_00]: That was originally a quiz site that turned into a fan fiction site because people would rate quizzes that were like,
13:59.692 --> 14:04.394
[SPEAKER_00]: one to five and then you'd pick a random number to it would send you to the same result which was a new addiction.
14:04.534 --> 14:07.196
[SPEAKER_00]: But like a lot of things were happening on live journal.
14:07.556 --> 14:10.437
[SPEAKER_00]: Fun fact last time I checked George R.R.
14:10.457 --> 14:19.101
[SPEAKER_00]: Martin has been posting on his live journal more than writing as far as I can tell last time I checked which was admittedly in like 2020.
14:19.481 --> 14:20.342
[SPEAKER_00]: He was still posting.
14:21.032 --> 14:22.494
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, my God, that is wild.
14:22.554 --> 14:25.016
[SPEAKER_01]: I didn't even realize life journal was still functioning.
14:25.056 --> 14:25.697
[SPEAKER_01]: Blast website.
14:26.097 --> 14:32.384
[SPEAKER_00]: And it meant that like, these fandom conversations, they weren't like organically surfaced to people.
14:32.404 --> 14:34.926
[SPEAKER_00]: You had to go out and try and find them, and it was harder to find.
14:35.186 --> 14:38.009
[SPEAKER_00]: There was a bunch less group think, and like it was much,
14:39.070 --> 14:43.751
[SPEAKER_00]: more inside thoughts were being shared on outside forums in a lot of ways.
14:43.911 --> 14:59.635
[SPEAKER_00]: And there are certainly parts of the internet that are like that still, but it's definitely a different animal when you're posting something and you know it's only going to be sent to those like 200 people that follow you versus it's going to be like served to random people to get them to follow you.
14:59.895 --> 15:03.736
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean it was almost a, I've never thought I would say this about the early 2000s internet,
15:09.357 --> 15:27.952
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, yeah, yeah, although like, you know, with the way back
machine, a lot of these things are preserved in ways that like people didn't expect them to be I'm going to be talking about a community that is like documented somewhat a lot of things have been lost to time just because people have deleted their accounts and that we're never chronicle, etc.
15:27.972 --> 15:28.392
[SPEAKER_00]: etc.
15:28.453 --> 15:31.975
[SPEAKER_00]: So I've done a six stack of research.
15:32.175 --> 15:34.878
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to show you my thick stack.
15:35.999 --> 15:37.280
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, she thick.
15:38.801 --> 15:42.525
[SPEAKER_01]: Holy shit, that's like you're writing a thesis on snake wives.
15:43.206 --> 15:43.986
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, and fairness.
15:44.006 --> 15:45.268
[SPEAKER_01]: I still don't even know what it is.
15:45.288 --> 15:47.470
[SPEAKER_00]: I only got through, like, here.
15:47.930 --> 15:49.852
[SPEAKER_00]: Also, like, this is another episode.
15:49.952 --> 15:51.394
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, we will be talking about these.
15:52.335 --> 15:53.896
[SPEAKER_00]: So I'm going to give you a couple of these.
15:53.916 --> 15:54.917
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm talking about these.
15:54.997 --> 15:56.359
[SPEAKER_00]: The wife's part one.
15:57.401 --> 16:00.002
[SPEAKER_00]: Uh, the rest of this is going to be beyond the Snape wife.
16:00.482 --> 16:06.643
[SPEAKER_00]: It goes a little bit into like, generally, the relationship between readers and their fandoms.
16:07.523 --> 16:12.104
[SPEAKER_00]: Um, I'm going to give you a couple of headlines.
16:12.185 --> 16:13.445
[SPEAKER_00]: And I want your reaction.
16:13.465 --> 16:14.305
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
16:14.485 --> 16:23.367
[SPEAKER_00]: So the most important text, which I've seen cited in all of the other texts, like this is the original like most thorough research is called Snapewives
16:28.008 --> 16:34.110
[SPEAKER_00]: From 2014 by scholar Zoe Aldertin from the University of Sydney in Australia.
16:36.191 --> 16:38.972
[SPEAKER_00]: Religion, can you read that just to headline back to me?
16:39.232 --> 16:39.772
[SPEAKER_00]: Just to headline.
16:40.632 --> 16:44.753
[SPEAKER_00]: Snape wives and Snapeism, a fiction-based religion within the Harry Potter fandom.
16:46.354 --> 16:46.714
[SPEAKER_00]: Snapeism.
16:46.754 --> 16:46.854
[SPEAKER_00]: So,
16:52.141 --> 17:01.970
[SPEAKER_01]: I might not understand that enough people drew enough from the character of Snape to construct a reality around him.
17:01.990 --> 17:09.616
[SPEAKER_01]: That was so strong, religions and ideologies and ways of thinking were constructed around this character.
17:10.517 --> 17:11.858
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh God, it's Snape from a style.
17:11.898 --> 17:12.619
[SPEAKER_01]: We're gonna keep going.
17:13.079 --> 17:14.721
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, that will be all we'll be answered.
17:17.161 --> 17:18.343
[SPEAKER_01]: And it's not Alan Rickman.
17:18.623 --> 17:20.005
[SPEAKER_01]: It's just Snape the character.
17:20.065 --> 17:21.487
[SPEAKER_01]: That will also be discussed.
17:22.128 --> 17:32.123
[SPEAKER_00]: OK. OK. Next one is a website called Snape Wives, the Ancient Church.
17:42.702 --> 17:43.162
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
17:43.382 --> 17:50.766
[SPEAKER_00]: Then we have a Jezebel article entitled, Consider the Snape Wife by Ashley Reese.
17:51.567 --> 17:51.927
[SPEAKER_00]: From 20 to 10.
17:51.947 --> 17:53.048
[SPEAKER_01]: Consider the Snape Wife.
17:54.629 --> 17:54.829
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
17:55.129 --> 18:03.614
[SPEAKER_00]: The main other one that I used was called Self-Insert Fanfiction as digital technology of the self by F.E.
18:03.894 --> 18:04.234
[SPEAKER_00]: S.A.P.
18:04.294 --> 18:04.734
[SPEAKER_00]: Rightes.
18:05.074 --> 18:06.855
[SPEAKER_01]: Digital technology of the self.
18:07.576 --> 18:07.776
[SPEAKER_01]: Mm-hmm.
18:08.376 --> 18:09.637
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think I know what that means.
18:10.762 --> 18:14.864
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's why I'm here, okay, okay.
18:14.884 --> 18:22.508
[SPEAKER_01]: So I'll be honest, when you said snake lives, I was thinking it was like, you know, how like some people really like to like marry serial killers while they're still in jail.
18:23.028 --> 18:25.689
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's kind of what like the vibe I was getting from this.
18:25.829 --> 18:26.850
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm thinking I was wrong.
18:28.395 --> 18:30.437
[SPEAKER_00]: You're not necessarily 100% wrong.
18:30.977 --> 18:38.181
[SPEAKER_00]: It's actually in the Jezebel article, our author basically says that she felt that was true of the Snape Wives.
18:38.241 --> 18:46.506
[SPEAKER_00]: She was like, I compared them to people who really love to the Columbine shooters and empathize with them.
18:47.166 --> 18:49.188
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, her like at Haude over Ted Bundy and shit.
18:49.268 --> 18:49.528
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
18:50.105 --> 18:52.946
[SPEAKER_00]: Which I feel is perhaps a bit extreme.
18:53.426 --> 18:54.746
[SPEAKER_01]: That's a very extreme.
18:55.526 --> 18:57.706
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, there's a lot to be talked about with snakewives.
18:57.886 --> 19:01.267
[SPEAKER_00]: I do wanna just like talk about snakewife versus snakeism.
19:01.427 --> 19:04.408
[SPEAKER_00]: I actually learned in evocabulary word through this.
19:04.948 --> 19:08.288
[SPEAKER_00]: And the word is edic, ETIC.
19:08.808 --> 19:09.509
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you know what it means?
19:09.869 --> 19:13.469
[SPEAKER_00]: No, like Eric with a T. That's what it means?
19:14.049 --> 19:14.270
[SPEAKER_00]: Mm-hmm.
19:15.190 --> 19:16.370
[SPEAKER_00]: No, no, just to start with you.
19:19.014 --> 19:45.011
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't
know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't know, I don't
19:48.111 --> 20:17.488
[SPEAKER_00]: Remember how I talked about how fans started seeing these characters as somewhat separate from JK Rowling, yes, like JK Rowling writes these books, but in some ways like this is not a very new idea like there are ideas of characters that kind of go beyond what an author writes in a book and this is something that is like basic to the creativity of fan fiction and basic to a lot of imagining and human creativity at all, which is like,
20:18.767 --> 20:22.812
[SPEAKER_00]: The idea of Snape is not the collection of words that JK Rowling wrote down.
20:23.273 --> 20:24.334
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, not a crazy idea.
20:25.135 --> 20:26.057
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, sure, sure.
20:26.595 --> 20:35.580
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, like so as an example, like Lizzy Bennett, like you and I could probably identify what her latte order would be, right, even though that's not part of the text.
20:36.140 --> 20:41.122
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's kind of like anthropomorphizing and character, except that they're human, yes.
20:41.383 --> 20:52.048
[SPEAKER_01]: But you know what I mean, where it's taking something that's not necessarily a real human and signing it, real human characteristics, predictions, giving it its own autonomy, et cetera.
20:52.756 --> 20:53.136
[SPEAKER_00]: It's true.
20:53.357 --> 20:58.220
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, although I will say like the creative process as authors tell it.
20:58.301 --> 21:12.592
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, you and I have talked to Kale Parsons and she said, you know, the the characters decide the smart level of the not me a lot of authors will talk about like, you know, the idea came to me and I had to like run to a computer to write it down.
21:21.359 --> 21:22.819
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's make this chair roll up.
21:23.680 --> 21:37.824
[SPEAKER_00]: And so their whole idea is that JK rolling is sort of like an imperfect scribe for the spirit of this being that is Severus Snape who exists on the astral plane.
21:39.985 --> 21:40.705
[SPEAKER_00]: Why Snape?
21:41.185 --> 21:42.886
[SPEAKER_00]: Ooh, great question.
21:43.646 --> 21:48.667
[SPEAKER_00]: There are a lot of theories about that in some ways the sort of misunderstood bad boy trope.
21:51.771 --> 21:58.336
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, Lusha, Lusha and they're whatever, Lusha's, whatever his dance lesson, cool Lusha's.
22:02.278 --> 22:02.858
[SPEAKER_00]: Who's to say?
22:03.159 --> 22:08.663
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, there are ideas out there about like why I think Stamp was one of the more popular characters.
22:09.063 --> 22:19.512
[SPEAKER_00]: There's also this really interesting part of the Zoe Alderton paper that talks about sort of the the type of person that was Snapeist at this time.
22:20.012 --> 22:23.455
[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm going to like bring this up because I think it helps us understand why Snape.
22:24.015 --> 22:32.660
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, I think it's also going to answer another question I have, which is when did the Snapeists, Snapeists, when did they come into fruition?
22:33.020 --> 22:36.783
[SPEAKER_01]: Was it when the series was almost complete or was it starting in book one?
22:37.083 --> 22:47.589
[SPEAKER_01]: I have more on that, too, because if it's like, but the series was almost done and we got to learn more about Snape's background and how he, you know, had a big crush and was bullied and stuff.
22:47.649 --> 22:51.471
[SPEAKER_01]: Then I can, that's what made him so empathetic and that's what made him.
22:52.752 --> 23:07.602
[SPEAKER_01]: the villainized human, instead of the villain, you know, and so I could understand wanting and and and reaching for the depth that was discovered about the character once that was revealed in the series.
23:08.062 --> 23:11.905
[SPEAKER_01]: But I'm wondering if this all started even with episode one step.
23:13.186 --> 23:17.028
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, I'm just going to talk about it just in terms of the release of the series.
23:18.823 --> 23:27.809
[SPEAKER_00]: There is a scene in which Harry observes inadvertently observes Snape's memories, you remember this in the book?
23:28.089 --> 23:31.431
[SPEAKER_00]: Then he sees him being bullied and loving his mom.
23:31.651 --> 23:40.237
[SPEAKER_00]: And it really seems like the Snape Snape's community was biggest in in between the time when that happened in the book releases.
23:40.937 --> 23:44.720
[SPEAKER_00]: And when the like the end of the seventh book,
23:45.560 --> 23:58.285
[SPEAKER_00]: And they still existed for a while after it fell apart a little bit due to infighting within the community, which we can talk about a little bit too, but that's like kind of the window of when we're talking.
23:58.886 --> 24:01.006
[SPEAKER_00]: So like 2005 to 2009?
24:01.407 --> 24:01.627
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
24:01.867 --> 24:02.927
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, that makes a lot more sense.
24:03.127 --> 24:09.050
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so sorry, I do where I'll do you're about to talk about who the Snapeist, like describe your typical seat.
24:09.930 --> 24:11.971
[SPEAKER_00]: It's almost the same in us, so they best.
24:12.832 --> 24:18.895
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, because you and I were talking about how, like, this really appealed to us at a time in our lives when we felt very invisible.
24:19.855 --> 24:22.737
[SPEAKER_00]: And when it's just being like a pre-teen girl is part.
24:23.157 --> 24:32.202
[SPEAKER_00]: So we all just make a great point that a lot of women who fell into this category were women who felt invisible, like women in their 40s who were not super,
24:35.143 --> 24:41.450
[SPEAKER_00]: scene as desirable, not super happy in their marriages, trying to find something to give them that spark back.
24:41.871 --> 24:48.338
[SPEAKER_00]: So I have a quote
here from one of the rapists who's live-journal still exists, Rose.
24:48.598 --> 24:52.402
[SPEAKER_00]: This is her talking about her relationship with her actual husband, her physical husband.
24:52.622 --> 24:54.444
[SPEAKER_00]: She says, ah yes, married life.
24:55.225 --> 24:59.670
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, we're still in love, but I think more and more, we are very much used to each other.
25:00.191 --> 25:00.992
[SPEAKER_00]: Why do I say that?
25:01.012 --> 25:05.997
[SPEAKER_00]: Because wherever I go, I barely hold his attention anymore, and he looks around or stops here and there.
25:06.618 --> 25:08.180
[SPEAKER_00]: No, not to look at other chicks and stuff.
25:08.400 --> 25:14.107
[SPEAKER_00]: I just think, I now know why so many my age have affairs, because things at home have become mundane.
25:15.590 --> 25:27.770
[SPEAKER_00]: So there's something to be sad for like feeling unfulfilled, feeling invisible, and like trying to find desire in your own life in a interesting, fun, exciting way.
25:28.153 --> 25:34.596
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the other part of that is then one sooner and that, you know, that's a really famous moment with Snape where he just goes always.
25:35.317 --> 25:38.098
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, that, I mean, that is what solidified him is.
25:38.198 --> 25:39.439
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a romantic hero, right?
25:39.499 --> 25:49.244
[SPEAKER_01]: Because how often does this come up in our podcast, it's very addicting this idea that somebody has just still there loving you from afar and binding after you and you've always held their attention.
25:49.424 --> 25:53.085
[SPEAKER_01]: You've always been in their thoughts and part of themselves is always belong to you.
25:53.986 --> 25:55.487
[SPEAKER_01]: That's what Lily was to Snape.
25:56.387 --> 26:06.836
[SPEAKER_01]: and so it does not surprise me at all that women whose marriages were not as spicy and fun as they once were saw that and were like wow that's the epitome of romance and being wanted.
26:07.863 --> 26:14.146
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, which is sad, but also beautiful that they made their own thing, but also complicated.
26:14.667 --> 26:15.167
[SPEAKER_00]: More to come.
26:16.087 --> 26:20.610
[SPEAKER_00]: I wanted to, okay, so I already gave you part of a vocabulary lesson with Edic.
26:20.810 --> 26:24.092
[SPEAKER_01]: Does Edic apply like all fandoms or was this, okay, okay?
26:24.452 --> 26:26.673
[SPEAKER_00]: It actually is like a, it's an Anthropology term.
26:27.333 --> 26:27.934
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, okay.
26:28.054 --> 26:32.716
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm gonna give you some words, and I'm gonna ask you to, like, guess at a definition.
26:33.277 --> 26:34.077
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, God, okay.
26:35.198 --> 26:36.238
[SPEAKER_00]: All right, here we go.
26:39.180 --> 26:40.346
[SPEAKER_00]: Daydream Believer.
26:43.385 --> 26:47.307
[SPEAKER_01]: are these people that, okay, I have a few different guesses.
26:47.347 --> 27:01.413
[SPEAKER_01]: It could be people who have a really hard time differentiating between reality and the things that they're wishing for themselves in their daydreams, or it could be people that believe the things that their daydream about will eventually become a reality.
27:01.593 --> 27:06.716
[SPEAKER_01]: And whether that's because they're willing it into existence with their own dreams, or they're thinking that, you know, it's possible future for them.
27:07.796 --> 27:11.118
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that would be my best guess with the term needs.
27:12.149 --> 27:14.130
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, um, it's a song by the monkeys.
27:14.150 --> 27:14.851
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm just kidding.
27:15.111 --> 27:16.912
[SPEAKER_00]: Um, okay.
27:19.034 --> 27:28.160
[SPEAKER_00]: No, it's a, uh, this is a TV tropes definition and it is used to sort of talk about this group of people, but there it appears in a lot of fandoms.
27:28.460 --> 27:38.667
[SPEAKER_00]: So TV tropes definition is a subgroup found in several fandoms who believe that the events characters in places depicted in the object of the fandom are in some form or another real.
27:39.507 --> 27:56.602
[SPEAKER_01]: And it goes on to say this is often explained away by talking about like parallel universes like oh, in some universe Harry Potter's real in some universe for NCIS is happening, but I mean when you look at that and like mainstream religious context those are called extremists.
27:57.230 --> 28:05.961
[SPEAKER_00]: I think you might be underestimating the number of very, very religious people who are not extremists and believe things that are very difficult to prove.
28:06.642 --> 28:07.202
[SPEAKER_01]: That's true.
28:08.324 --> 28:09.345
[SPEAKER_00]: But I hear you.
28:09.665 --> 28:10.927
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't disagree 100%.
28:10.947 --> 28:12.108
[SPEAKER_00]: Zoe Alderson goes.
28:13.470 --> 28:26.995
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a great length to talk about how similar Snapeism is to Christianity and not only it's belief structure, but also the realisticness of the actual beliefs and the actual texts.
28:27.155 --> 28:29.676
[SPEAKER_00]: I think that it's an interesting conversation.
28:29.696 --> 28:35.398
[SPEAKER_00]: I do think that there is an element of reality that is unexplainable and up for grabs.
28:35.718 --> 28:36.458
[SPEAKER_00]: I will leave that there.
28:37.754 --> 28:39.575
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, I mean, that's what imagination is, right?
28:40.015 --> 28:40.955
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, yes.
28:40.975 --> 28:42.316
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, why we enjoy fiction, right?
28:42.416 --> 28:52.100
[SPEAKER_01]: Absolutely, but, you know, I mean, this is just commentary on some people who do struggle with figuring out what is reality, what is based in reality, and what isn't.
28:52.180 --> 28:59.182
[SPEAKER_01]: That's something that every single group fandom religion community experiences on some level.
28:59.282 --> 29:00.423
[SPEAKER_01]: So, okay, it's not surprising at all.
29:00.483 --> 29:05.045
[SPEAKER_01]: There are ties
between religious groups and really, really serious fandoms, especially.
29:06.785 --> 29:11.206
[SPEAKER_01]: with people who believe that, you know, no, Harry Potter, okay, think, okay, Lord of the Rights.
29:12.026 --> 29:18.468
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, Tolkien wrote that as a creation myth for our current Earth.
29:18.968 --> 29:25.910
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, yes, it is, you were supposed to read it and believe that this is what was happening here before us.
29:27.562 --> 29:32.904
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, yeah, this is not, and this is not unique to this fandom, like there are matrixisms as well.
29:32.964 --> 29:34.224
[SPEAKER_00]: There's so much here.
29:34.244 --> 29:38.405
[SPEAKER_00]: We're going to focus on snake wipes to see if it's excuse me.
29:38.485 --> 29:39.046
[SPEAKER_00]: I apologize.
29:39.306 --> 29:40.526
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a more vocabulary for you.
29:41.466 --> 29:42.127
[SPEAKER_00]: SSRS.
29:42.827 --> 29:45.107
[SPEAKER_00]: Sorry, I just started to give SSRI's the medication.
29:47.088 --> 29:48.890
[SPEAKER_01]: as this fandom wider is a Snapeism.
29:49.270 --> 29:50.051
[SPEAKER_00]: This is Snapeism.
29:50.411 --> 29:50.711
[SPEAKER_00]: Snapeism.
29:50.731 --> 29:54.815
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, actually it's a little bit wider with base, but they've been diagram.
29:55.476 --> 29:59.059
[SPEAKER_00]: The Snapeists are within this circle, but they're not the whole circle.
30:01.281 --> 30:01.841
[SPEAKER_00]: I have no idea.
30:03.282 --> 30:04.704
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, we're self is in there.
30:04.724 --> 30:05.544
[SPEAKER_00]: Nope.
30:06.365 --> 30:07.086
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, then go.
30:07.166 --> 30:08.267
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to get away wrong.
30:08.787 --> 30:10.649
[SPEAKER_00]: It's the Severus Snape Rescue Squad.
30:11.903 --> 30:13.824
[SPEAKER_00]: There's no fucking way I was going to.
30:16.325 --> 30:19.147
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, that's actually kind of sweet to quote them.
30:19.407 --> 30:24.669
[SPEAKER_00]: Hey, if Sherlock Holmes fans could rescue him from Conan Doyle, we can rescue Severus, Snape from JKR.
30:25.150 --> 30:40.197
[SPEAKER_01]: So when they say rescue him from the author, does that mean like take him out of the misery of the life he's living and kind of cuddle him a little bit and be like, it's not all bad or is it like, we believe that the author is doing this character a massive disservice and we know better for him.
30:41.098 --> 30:44.121
[SPEAKER_00]: Um, I would say the latter with some of the former sprinkled in.
30:44.702 --> 30:45.743
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, it makes sense.
30:46.603 --> 30:52.609
[SPEAKER_00]: Um, okay, two more fandom wink wink or wink wink wink.
30:52.649 --> 30:55.212
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, that means masturbate true correct.
30:55.252 --> 30:55.512
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
30:57.454 --> 31:00.477
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, um, is it like, is it like a circle jerk before a fandom?
31:01.103 --> 31:01.303
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
31:01.323 --> 31:01.423
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
31:01.783 --> 31:01.963
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
31:01.983 --> 31:05.645
[SPEAKER_00]: So it's an online community dedicated to mocking like overzealous fandom.
31:08.066 --> 31:09.467
[SPEAKER_01]: So trolls basically.
31:09.907 --> 31:10.147
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
31:10.687 --> 31:10.887
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
31:11.167 --> 31:16.990
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's where a lot of the sneakest posts became public and widely ridiculed.
31:17.610 --> 31:18.610
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, that's sad.
31:19.191 --> 31:20.611
[SPEAKER_01]: I know that's sad.
31:20.771 --> 31:21.031
[SPEAKER_01]: They don't.
31:21.051 --> 31:22.232
[SPEAKER_01]: It could be so mean sometimes.
31:22.612 --> 31:23.172
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
31:23.192 --> 31:24.873
[SPEAKER_00]: And last one dead from snake.
31:26.173 --> 31:27.674
[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm going to I'm going to write it for you.
31:27.754 --> 31:28.975
[SPEAKER_00]: It's D.E.D.
31:29.355 --> 31:33.778
[SPEAKER_00]: from snake, is such a like old internet speak.
31:34.379 --> 31:34.979
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, it is.
31:35.519 --> 31:40.523
[SPEAKER_00]: All right, we're going into the ancient religion of snakes.
31:41.510 --> 31:47.293
[SPEAKER_01]: from snake is that like when something's been released into like the outer world and it's being ridiculed.
31:47.313 --> 31:48.413
[SPEAKER_01]: Is that it?
31:49.034 --> 31:54.736
[SPEAKER_00]: Kind, I mean like there's a snake in our midst and no, but that's like not totally wrong.
31:54.756 --> 31:58.638
[SPEAKER_00]: This was a community that was dedicated specifically to mocking snakes.
31:59.319 --> 32:01.119
[SPEAKER_00]: It's specifically like people who love snake.
32:01.680 --> 32:02.700
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god, it'll lie.
32:03.541 --> 32:06.782
[SPEAKER_00]: Which was okay people who love snake have a word for them.
32:09.622 --> 32:12.645
[SPEAKER_00]: No, you think they were just called themselves snake.
32:13.126 --> 32:13.746
[SPEAKER_00]: We are snake.
32:15.428 --> 32:16.629
[SPEAKER_01]: Early 2000s in, right?
32:16.649 --> 32:17.050
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
32:17.430 --> 32:18.471
[SPEAKER_00]: We are snake and we are leaves.
32:18.491 --> 32:20.753
[SPEAKER_01]: Just the era of eye has cheeseburger.
32:20.833 --> 32:22.435
[SPEAKER_01]: So, yes, true.
32:22.956 --> 32:27.200
[SPEAKER_00]: They were called snake fenn, which was plural for fans, snake fenn.
32:27.260 --> 32:30.803
[SPEAKER_00]: Wait, so these are the people that ridiculed snake pests?
32:31.590 --> 32:34.311
[SPEAKER_00]: No, they, those were the snapists, they were okay.
32:34.451 --> 32:48.778
[SPEAKER_00]: Snape fun, were snake fans, and Snapeists were an extreme group of snake fun, got it, but then dead from snake, mocked Snape fun more widely, got it.
32:48.819 --> 32:56.662
[SPEAKER_01]: So you have this super serious Snapeists, and then you have people who are just like, I thought was Snape, and then you have people who are like y'all are stupid.
32:57.263 --> 32:57.483
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
32:58.083 --> 32:58.343
[SPEAKER_00]:
got it.
32:58.503 --> 33:10.249
[SPEAKER_00]: Interestingly, the Jezebel article is written by someone who was in the group of like a dollar stupid during this time and then wrote for Jezebel and was like, I hated people during this time.
33:10.650 --> 33:12.190
[SPEAKER_00]: Like, I hated these people so much.
33:12.691 --> 33:23.156
[SPEAKER_00]: Meanwhile, Zoe Aldertin's paper is much more like sympathetic and trying to understand them and ultimately, like, it's kind of down to what you want to take from it.
33:23.636 --> 33:26.338
[SPEAKER_00]: So shall we talk about their beliefs?
33:27.234 --> 33:28.415
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, convert me.
33:31.358 --> 33:31.878
[SPEAKER_00]: Great news.
33:32.579 --> 33:38.385
[SPEAKER_00]: Severus Snape again is a mortal being who lives on the astral plane, right?
33:38.645 --> 33:41.047
[SPEAKER_00]: He has a lot of important characteristics.
33:42.308 --> 33:48.855
[SPEAKER_00]: Now, how would you describe Snape from the books or the movies, whichever it pick your poison?
33:49.340 --> 33:50.621
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I do think they were different.
33:50.641 --> 33:52.623
[SPEAKER_01]: I think that the movies did a good job.
33:52.643 --> 33:57.787
[SPEAKER_01]: But remember, we were seeing snakes through Harry's eyes in the books.
33:57.887 --> 34:01.830
[SPEAKER_01]: Harry described snake as like disgusting, like as like greasy.
34:01.910 --> 34:04.011
[SPEAKER_01]: And like this like huge nose.
34:04.051 --> 34:11.917
[SPEAKER_01]: And he like the way that Harry saw him is like he was like dripping with grease and ghostly white skin was like bones sticking out almost.
34:11.957 --> 34:14.660
[SPEAKER_01]: Like he was like he was a horror character.
34:15.380 --> 34:18.565
[SPEAKER_01]: But this is an 11-year-old boy who's being bullied by his teacher.
34:18.605 --> 34:23.572
[SPEAKER_01]: Of course he's going to have to give me a whole one question.
34:23.612 --> 34:31.243
[SPEAKER_01]: We can table for later and you can come back to this, but I want to know how these snippets view Snape's actions towards Harry.
34:32.004 --> 34:34.024
[SPEAKER_01]: Hmm, again, we can come back to that in a bit.
34:34.765 --> 34:40.906
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's very interesting because I want to know if they are just like, he had his reasons to like, he bullied a child, he abused this kid.
34:41.446 --> 34:43.967
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, because his mom said no, like, come on.
34:44.407 --> 34:47.047
[SPEAKER_01]: Anyway, in the movie, they did a really good job of making it.
34:47.087 --> 34:50.888
[SPEAKER_01]: So like Alan Rekman was not made to look handsome in this movie at all.
34:51.008 --> 34:59.390
[SPEAKER_01]: He did wear entirely black clothing up to his, the very top of his neck underneath his chin, then down almost to like his knuckles.
34:59.610 --> 35:07.253
[SPEAKER_01]: It didn't make him look more slender, it didn't make him look chiseled in any capacity, and his hair was always really, really, really slicked back.
35:08.333 --> 35:09.714
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, I know not everybody agrees with me.
35:09.754 --> 35:11.634
[SPEAKER_01]: I think Ellen, or I mean, is a really handsome man.
35:11.714 --> 35:13.895
[SPEAKER_01]: He does not look handsome in that role.
35:14.335 --> 35:16.096
[SPEAKER_01]: And so they stayed true to the book that way.
35:16.256 --> 35:21.318
[SPEAKER_01]: At least in my opinion, I think that he was just a little bit more realistic and tangible in the movies, probably.
35:22.682 --> 35:25.824
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I'm gonna like, I'm gonna say something that might upset you.
35:26.385 --> 35:28.026
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you think he was hot as Snape?
35:28.686 --> 35:28.846
[SPEAKER_00]: No.
35:30.027 --> 35:32.189
[SPEAKER_00]: So Alan Rikman and these movies is in his sixties, right?
35:32.649 --> 35:32.789
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
35:34.450 --> 35:35.971
[SPEAKER_00]: Guess how old Snape is in the book?
35:37.272 --> 35:37.773
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't know.
35:38.213 --> 35:39.214
[SPEAKER_01]: Actually, how old is he?
35:39.754 --> 35:40.595
[SPEAKER_00]: He's in his thirties.
35:41.996 --> 35:43.256
[SPEAKER_01]: Wow, really?
35:43.957 --> 35:46.018
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that makes his character even worse.
35:46.439 --> 35:46.819
[SPEAKER_00]: I know.
35:47.780 --> 35:49.421
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm like, oh, are we Snape's age?
35:49.661 --> 35:50.562
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, no.
35:52.789 --> 35:56.472
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, it's real, it's real, that's, I don't like that.
35:56.532 --> 36:03.557
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it makes sense, I guess, for the age difference, because like, Harry's won 11 years old and his parents died and you assume they kind of had him young.
36:03.577 --> 36:06.299
[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, I mean, yeah, it makes sense that he's in his thirties.
36:06.499 --> 36:07.180
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, interesting.
36:07.520 --> 36:08.381
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, so,
36:09.727 --> 36:19.896
[SPEAKER_00]: There's already like sympathy towards Snape in the books, but as the movies start to come out, people are like dang, like, not only is it Alan Reckman, who just is beautiful.
36:20.076 --> 36:22.318
[SPEAKER_00]: Alan Reckman has this incredible voice.
36:24.139 --> 36:26.802
[SPEAKER_00]: And like, the books are coming out faster.
36:26.942 --> 36:29.844
[SPEAKER_00]: So you've seen the movies, but you like know that he's,
36:30.765 --> 36:33.486
[SPEAKER_00]: there's something more to him than what we're seeing.
36:34.046 --> 36:48.330
[SPEAKER_00]: And actually I would argue that you are like on your way to Snapeism right now by talking about how we have Harry vision through the books and all of the descriptions of him doing terrible things and looking ugly and all of that are Harry's bias.
36:48.730 --> 36:54.091
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, absolutely because Harry is number one, even when he gets older, we presumably straight.
36:54.732 --> 36:58.573
[SPEAKER_01]: And so like he's never looking at Snape in a way that could paint him as attractive or
36:59.838 --> 37:04.701
[SPEAKER_01]: I was not expecting you to stay straight as kind of like you're going to be like, is, you know, a dick.
37:05.502 --> 37:06.322
[SPEAKER_01]: He has also a dick.
37:06.682 --> 37:09.244
[SPEAKER_01]: Also very potter, famously unreliable narrator.
37:09.664 --> 37:10.725
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, I get it.
37:10.805 --> 37:17.129
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, this is a very easy lens to read through to be like obviously there's more than meets the eye.
37:17.149 --> 37:27.336
[SPEAKER_01]: And that's actually like very like active and critical reading because you do need to remember your reading through the lens of an 11 year old boy and then a puberty written boy and then a really angry young adult.
37:28.156 --> 37:31.462
[SPEAKER_01]: And there's a reason Harry is maybe the worst character in the series.
37:32.968 --> 37:55.004
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, to your active and critical thinking point, I mean, we can go into this later down the line, but like fanfiction and engaging with characters in ways beyond the prescribed narrative are the definition of critical thinking of critical reading and of really like being a strong reader in so many ways.
37:55.585 --> 38:00.549
[SPEAKER_00]: And so these conversations, while they are about a character on the astral plane,
38:01.490 --> 38:07.566
[SPEAKER_00]: It can also be very political and can be very gender-based, often have that more.
38:09.050 --> 38:09.991
[SPEAKER_00]: Just talk about it.
38:11.412 --> 38:19.778
[SPEAKER_00]: So the sleepists, as I mentioned, largely women, largest straight women, many of them have married sleep on the astral plane.
38:20.139 --> 38:21.740
[SPEAKER_00]: So we have some of their vows.
38:22.220 --> 38:28.825
[SPEAKER_01]: So is this like, there's one sleep in his marrying all of them, or are there many sleeps?
38:29.046 --> 38:36.952
[SPEAKER_01]: Everybody has their own astral plane, or is it just, are we just not taking back direction of logic with it?
38:37.492 --> 38:38.433
[SPEAKER_00]: Great question.
38:38.613 --> 38:40.774
[SPEAKER_00]: It kind of varies through time.
38:41.575 --> 38:50.420
[SPEAKER_00]: So Snape, he is like a being who is sort of beyond the corporeal realm at this point and he can be channeled.
38:54.082 --> 38:59.785
[SPEAKER_00]: by certain members of the Snapeist community, specifically one member is really good at channeling.
39:00.845 --> 39:11.211
[SPEAKER_00]: Tanya, she channels Snape pretty well and there are other members of the community who are very jealous of these channeling of abilities and she offers them to people.
39:11.231 --> 39:11.971
[SPEAKER_00]: So she will channel
39:20.684 --> 39:22.185
[SPEAKER_00]: Look, did they hurt anyone?
39:23.706 --> 39:24.267
[SPEAKER_01]: Mostly no.
39:24.327 --> 39:24.747
[SPEAKER_01]: No, no.
39:24.807 --> 39:26.588
[SPEAKER_01]: Call to do me dirt people.
39:28.770 --> 39:30.051
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, you're not.
39:31.172 --> 39:32.533
[SPEAKER_00]: Look,
I'm not an expert in cults.
39:33.373 --> 39:38.557
[SPEAKER_00]: But I've listened to, is this a cult podcast enough to say yes.
39:38.877 --> 39:39.978
[SPEAKER_01]: This is a cult.
39:40.418 --> 39:43.220
[SPEAKER_01]: So let's talk about, I'm going to just give you some of the core beliefs.
39:43.741 --> 39:45.122
[SPEAKER_00]: Just so that you fully understand.
39:45.142 --> 39:45.962
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, all right.
39:46.002 --> 39:47.483
[SPEAKER_00]: If you're making these accusations,
39:49.855 --> 39:51.358
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, all right, this isn't all cops.
39:52.060 --> 39:55.006
[SPEAKER_00]: I believe that Severus Snape exists independently of J.K.R.
39:55.487 --> 39:57.090
[SPEAKER_00]: He is a living, feeling spirit.
39:57.331 --> 40:00.658
[SPEAKER_00]: I believe anything is possible and that Severus does visit those he chooses to.
40:02.742 --> 40:04.843
[SPEAKER_01]: You're all cups for us giving me life.
40:08.164 --> 40:10.505
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, that's, that's, that's going to be our introduction.
40:10.565 --> 40:12.486
[SPEAKER_00]: So, snake exists.
40:13.066 --> 40:17.508
[SPEAKER_00]: Again, as we discussed, this is not, the existence beyond JK rolling is not a crazy idea.
40:17.528 --> 40:20.709
[SPEAKER_00]: Like we do often talk about characters as entities separate from the authors.
40:21.629 --> 40:22.009
[SPEAKER_01]: Great.
40:22.289 --> 40:23.790
[SPEAKER_00]: He is a living feeling spirit.
40:25.670 --> 40:26.911
[SPEAKER_00]: That's where I get lost a little bit.
40:27.701 --> 40:28.682
[SPEAKER_01]: our small thing.
40:30.182 --> 40:31.203
[SPEAKER_00]: This is a good question.
40:31.703 --> 40:33.664
[SPEAKER_00]: Don't think about it too hard.
40:34.345 --> 40:48.053
[SPEAKER_00]: But there is, first of all, there's a lot of like interesting spellings here that are very of the internet time, like naked is spelled UK and ACK ID.
40:48.073 --> 40:49.633
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, I have to do one.
40:49.654 --> 40:50.454
[SPEAKER_01]: That's like a racketed.
40:53.703 --> 41:03.826
[SPEAKER_00]: But they sort of argue that people not feeling or seeing him doesn't really negate the fact that he exists because he only shows himself to people who he feels like it.
41:23.135 --> 41:25.996
[SPEAKER_00]: in her life, this is how Zoe Alderton describes it.
41:27.177 --> 41:33.080
[SPEAKER_00]: Konjita loves Snape, quote, more than I ever loved anyone and would die for him, quote, without hesitating.
41:33.640 --> 41:37.262
[SPEAKER_00]: He is an antidote to her life, which is otherwise quote, cruel and pointless.
41:37.382 --> 41:41.224
[SPEAKER_00]: He is her quote, eternal life, the one that made me feel alive.
41:41.664 --> 41:42.704
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, so sad.
41:42.944 --> 41:43.505
[SPEAKER_01]: I know.
41:43.645 --> 41:50.288
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's what I think about this in terms of like filling a gaping hole
41:51.769 --> 41:53.856
[SPEAKER_00]: with the closest material possible.
41:54.538 --> 41:57.688
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, a fictional character can't let you down.
41:59.171 --> 42:14.063
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, although Kanchita is frustrated by like she keeps on setting up opportunities for Snape to channel and he does not channel into her and like that's been that's a repetitive disappointing experience for her.
42:14.243 --> 42:15.504
[SPEAKER_00]: It's really hard for her to handle.
42:16.185 --> 42:19.508
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, so not necessarily what I said wasn't necessarily accurate for her.
42:19.728 --> 42:19.908
[SPEAKER_01]: And for
42:26.843 --> 42:32.806
[SPEAKER_00]: Tonya's having visions and I'm going to give you a couple examples of like how these visions manifest in every day life.
42:33.307 --> 42:45.854
[SPEAKER_00]: Because the Jezebel article really describes like how they basically brought in, stamped to like spice up their sex life and make their mundane life better, and like make it feel like sighting.
42:46.014 --> 42:47.675
[SPEAKER_00]: And that has some basis in reality.
42:48.455 --> 42:59.638
[SPEAKER_00]: Um, or based on what we have found of the text, but I think there's there's also something to be set here in terms of creating a Ball for the hills in your life.
43:00.518 --> 43:01.758
[SPEAKER_00]: And imagining things better.
43:02.178 --> 43:09.480
[SPEAKER_00]: It almost feels like very Anne of Green Gables to just be well, if I imagine that it's nice, I can be happy even though things are terrible.
43:09.600 --> 43:16.422
[SPEAKER_00]: So, Tanya, for example, talks a little bit about what it's like to have sort of an erotic relationship with the
43:18.863 --> 43:26.467
[SPEAKER_00]: She says, it might be lucky that I can't see your grab him because I would be on him in the floor behind me, going wild on him.
43:27.727 --> 43:28.688
[SPEAKER_00]: She romances.
43:28.768 --> 43:32.610
[SPEAKER_00]: He has sat here for over an hour just stroking and sucking on my neck and shoulders.
43:32.810 --> 43:34.091
[SPEAKER_00]: He is so erotic.
43:34.111 --> 43:39.614
[SPEAKER_00]: And he is apparently very jealous, God, even though he has all of these wives.
43:40.054 --> 43:41.995
[SPEAKER_01]: He has a fucking hair on, what is he jealous of?
43:42.747 --> 43:45.231
[SPEAKER_00]: He doesn't want them to be with anyone else.
43:45.912 --> 43:46.653
[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
43:46.853 --> 43:51.860
[SPEAKER_00]: Even though a couple of them have husbands, Tanya and Rose both have husbands, he channels through the husbands.
43:52.100 --> 43:57.148
[SPEAKER_00]: This is through Tanya's channeling he says, and this feels very dark romance.
43:57.288 --> 43:57.729
[SPEAKER_00]: So I like,
43:58.189 --> 44:01.090
[SPEAKER_00]: want to plant that seed for you and see what you think of this too.
44:01.591 --> 44:05.473
[SPEAKER_00]: He says, I am unlike anything you have ever known previously or will now.
44:06.073 --> 44:09.835
[SPEAKER_00]: I will not be just another passing fancy that you put aside when you see something new.
44:10.315
--> 44:11.235
[SPEAKER_00]: Do not make me jealous.
44:11.355 --> 44:12.116
[SPEAKER_00]: You will regret it.
44:12.356 --> 44:15.497
[SPEAKER_00]: I shall not be put on the same level as your previous conquests.
44:20.179 --> 44:22.701
[SPEAKER_01]: So is that part of the channeling through the husband?
44:23.081 --> 44:27.303
[SPEAKER_01]: Or is that part of her just hanging out with saying about their last role visits?
44:28.156 --> 44:39.522
[SPEAKER_00]: It's hard to tell because like the sexual side of this is fascinating and I think I like dive into this a little bit before the mundane life, but I just find it so interesting that I want to share it.
44:40.403 --> 44:49.388
[SPEAKER_00]: So Tanya offers her channeling to the Snape's Castle group, which is all where all the Snapeists are and is basically like sexting everyone.
44:49.885 --> 44:57.948
[SPEAKER_00]: while channeling Snape, but everyone considers it like deeply heterosexual because she's channeling Snape.
44:57.988 --> 44:58.609
[SPEAKER_00]: It's not Tanya.
44:59.249 --> 45:00.349
[SPEAKER_01]: She's a fucking cult leader.
45:00.970 --> 45:01.150
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
45:01.270 --> 45:02.150
[SPEAKER_01]: Are you serious?
45:02.870 --> 45:03.091
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
45:04.671 --> 45:06.032
[SPEAKER_01]: That's horrible.
45:06.472 --> 45:08.713
[SPEAKER_01]: That gives her so much control over people.
45:09.983 --> 45:14.427
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, whole life with Snape seems very exciting.
45:14.667 --> 45:19.251
[SPEAKER_00]: A couple examples of what they chronicle as like the influence of Snape in their lives.
45:19.592 --> 45:25.837
[SPEAKER_00]: Snape heals Tanya from digestive pain by giving her a potion containing ginger according to the alderton.
45:26.418 --> 45:30.782
[SPEAKER_00]: This is a rose's recollection of Snape helping her with flight anxiety.
45:30.802 --> 45:32.923
[SPEAKER_00]: Hopefully had a visual of him standing still.
45:32.943 --> 45:34.104
[SPEAKER_01]: I think they want help with her.
45:34.144 --> 45:34.785
[SPEAKER_01]: So pure.
45:34.805 --> 45:35.766
[SPEAKER_00]: I know.
45:35.786 --> 45:35.906
[SPEAKER_00]: Sorry.
45:37.107 --> 45:42.368
[SPEAKER_00]: I had a visual of him standing between the rows of seats on the plane, resting his hands on either side while we took off.
45:43.048 --> 45:46.109
[SPEAKER_00]: And then another great boon for rows.
45:46.569 --> 45:48.670
[SPEAKER_00]: This is a direct quote from Zoe Aldrich's article.
45:49.130 --> 45:53.311
[SPEAKER_00]: He caused roses parents to accidentally send five times as much money to her account as they attended to.
45:53.591 --> 45:57.452
[SPEAKER_00]: She kept the funds thinking, quote, master, who quote, had his hand in this one.
45:59.646 --> 46:00.066
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, okay.
46:00.106 --> 46:05.971
[SPEAKER_01]: So with the with the earlier quote about how he's like the very possessive.
46:08.632 --> 46:09.713
[SPEAKER_01]: The use of the word master.
46:11.855 --> 46:18.540
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that's like straight out of a like BDSM dynamic, like a very, very, very strong BDSM dynamic.
46:19.440 --> 46:25.985
[SPEAKER_01]: Is that is that because like earlier was kind of like that can just be kind of like dark fantasy, but that's that's a very specific title.
46:26.732 --> 46:32.777
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, I mean, I think if I remember correctly, they use Master in the Harry Potter books.
46:32.837 --> 46:33.317
[SPEAKER_00]: Is that right?
46:34.198 --> 46:35.639
[SPEAKER_00]: Professor St. Master Potter.
46:36.540 --> 46:37.440
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, Master.
46:37.500 --> 46:37.861
[SPEAKER_01]: Potions.
46:37.901 --> 46:39.022
[SPEAKER_01]: He's the Potions Master.
46:39.322 --> 46:40.403
[SPEAKER_00]: He's the Potions Master.
46:40.603 --> 46:41.623
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, that's where it comes from.
46:41.844 --> 46:44.286
[SPEAKER_00]: But it does have very dumb sub.
46:45.188 --> 46:45.908
[SPEAKER_00]: text.
46:45.968 --> 46:46.168
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
46:46.308 --> 46:57.732
[SPEAKER_00]: And there's actually infighting in the community about that, too, because Konchita thinks that it's like not in Steve's nature to be talking about his sex life and meanwhile Rosentonia are like, he's changed our sex life, but it's been great.
46:58.412 --> 46:59.392
[SPEAKER_00]: Sure.
46:59.412 --> 47:07.875
[SPEAKER_00]: And so there are different interpretations of Steve's desires in that area, but like everyone calls him master, my Lord.
47:10.119 --> 47:27.428
[SPEAKER_00]: While I wanted to give you the sort of happy side of the channeling and how sleep could enter their lives in a good way, Tanya also attests to sleep intervening in much more harmful ways.
47:27.568 --> 47:37.033
[SPEAKER_00]: So according to Zoe Alderton, Snape caused Tanya's father-in-law to have a heart attack and assisted her brother in getting arrested after she shared her concerns about his drug problems.
47:37.693 --> 47:41.459
[SPEAKER_00]: He got Rosentonia's irritating neighbors evicted much to their delight.
47:41.940 --> 47:44.144
[SPEAKER_00]: Quote, Master provides again, they testified.
47:44.665 --> 47:48.131
[SPEAKER_00]: Saip has perceived as an omnipresent life guide who can aid in all areas.
47:48.471 --> 47:50.575
[SPEAKER_01]: Wait, wait, Rose and Tony will live together?
47:52.080 --> 48:12.192
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, so Rose and Tanya are neighbors, what what I couldn't figure out through all of this is whether at one point one of the moves I don't know if they moved to be closer to each other, but like their husbands and each other, they know each other and they actually have like a shrine room with posters of snake everywhere.
48:12.800 --> 48:26.611
[SPEAKER_00]: in which apartment tenants of course of course of course but but Rose has some too well yeah it might be in roses apartment hold on because there is that is part of the falling out is the the snake posters so are they all married to snake
48:27.058 --> 48:28.519
[SPEAKER_00]: Not
everyone is married to Snape.
48:28.539 --> 48:33.001
[SPEAKER_00]: There are different degrees of like, it's kind of a privilege to be married to Snape.
48:33.461 --> 48:33.701
[SPEAKER_01]: Sure.
48:33.921 --> 48:38.543
[SPEAKER_00]: But they all accept the the polygamy, so it's like his hair.
48:38.823 --> 48:47.987
[SPEAKER_00]: Tanya and Rose, they post pictures of them with Snape that are like, there's one specifically that's both of them with Snape and they're both dressed as brides.
48:48.845 --> 48:54.287
[SPEAKER_00]: Are these like Photoshop things or is it like a caught out or yes, Severus and his brides watch out.
48:54.447 --> 49:07.430
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm gonna show you some of the Photoshop art because this is a lot of the live journals are like vows to Severus name, talking about their everyday life, et cetera, but then there's also like a whole slew of Photoshop images.
49:07.730 --> 49:10.391
[SPEAKER_00]: And I'm gonna start with like a relatively innocuous one.
49:10.511 --> 49:16.353
[SPEAKER_00]: You might recognize an acronym on this that we've discussed in today's show, the last,
49:17.113 --> 49:20.195
[SPEAKER_00]: The last letter is different, but let's see if you can remember what it stands for.
49:27.861 --> 49:39.929
[SPEAKER_01]: So it's a butterfly.
49:40.289 --> 49:42.491
[SPEAKER_01]: Sephora's Snape Rescue.
49:44.913 --> 49:45.754
[SPEAKER_01]: alliance.
49:46.675 --> 49:50.158
[SPEAKER_00]: I assume so it was the one I know is Severus sleep rescue squad.
49:51.239 --> 49:53.781
[SPEAKER_00]: I assume this is some sort of like association or alliance.
49:54.502 --> 49:55.082
[SPEAKER_01]: Rescued.
49:55.883 --> 49:56.343
[SPEAKER_01]: Always.
49:57.785 --> 50:01.788
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think I can't stop
50:07.047 --> 50:13.589
[SPEAKER_00]: but so many of these things were photo shop edits of the women with sleep.
50:13.729 --> 50:16.590
[SPEAKER_00]: So this is an image of Rose and Snape in marital bliss.
50:19.710 --> 50:23.791
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, it's like that woman that married the Iphal Tower and divorced it so she could marry her fans.
50:23.872 --> 50:27.973
[SPEAKER_00]: But it's not because two things.
50:28.333 --> 50:32.934
[SPEAKER_00]: One, Rose has a husband, like a real life husband and two.
50:34.320 --> 50:41.243
[SPEAKER_00]: It's two people, nope, three, and maybe some more that we don't have documented all marrying the Eiffel Tower.
50:42.764 --> 50:45.405
[SPEAKER_00]: And talking about the Eiffel Tower's influence in their daily life.
50:47.052 --> 50:48.333
[SPEAKER_00]: This is much more serious.
50:48.894 --> 50:49.975
[SPEAKER_01]: What does their husbands think?
50:50.215 --> 50:52.217
[SPEAKER_00]: We don't like have a ton of info on that.
50:52.517 --> 50:57.721
[SPEAKER_00]: There is one section in this paper that talked about their husbands take on this.
50:57.942 --> 50:58.963
[SPEAKER_00]: And I will read you.
50:59.063 --> 51:03.046
[SPEAKER_00]: So this is actually a Tonya
talking about George, who's her husband.
51:03.867 --> 51:06.750
[SPEAKER_00]: She says my husband offended him by saying he was not real.
51:07.130 --> 51:10.573
[SPEAKER_00]: He got revenge by making my husband appear to not exist if it's tough.
51:12.838 --> 51:13.258
[SPEAKER_01]: What?
51:14.239 --> 51:18.882
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, which to me, is that like he tried to speak up in a meeting and no one listened to him or something?
51:18.922 --> 51:21.484
[SPEAKER_00]: Like, I felt like I don't exist at a job before.
51:21.584 --> 51:23.785
[SPEAKER_00]: We all have, but I find it very funny.
51:24.586 --> 51:25.987
[SPEAKER_00]: And that is their event.
51:26.007 --> 51:30.610
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, I do find that funny that Snape wasn't only a positive force in their life, too.
51:30.630 --> 51:37.134
[SPEAKER_01]: You've mentioned that it was responsible for a very scary medical incident with a dad, a rest of her brother.
51:37.434 --> 51:41.177
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, is this so going so far as like,
51:42.901 --> 51:53.047
[SPEAKER_01]: Snape caused the father's heart attack because she disappointed him in some way or, you know what I mean?
51:53.548 --> 52:01.693
[SPEAKER_00]: It's so interesting because from what I could tell, based on what I read, Rosentonia have a largely positive relationship with Snape.
52:01.873 --> 52:03.674
[SPEAKER_00]: Like, it's, I will love him forever.
52:03.694 --> 52:06.556
[SPEAKER_00]: I like, I'm so grateful for his intervention.
52:07.077 --> 52:09.858
[SPEAKER_00]: When I mess up, he always helps correct me.
52:10.159 --> 52:13.080
[SPEAKER_00]: But Konchita, like, really talks about,
52:14.121 --> 52:18.482
[SPEAKER_00]: having to become better than she is in order to deserve sleep.
52:19.023 --> 52:22.664
[SPEAKER_00]: Wow, and that's what I think is really really alarming too.
52:22.884 --> 52:33.687
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, there are several alarming things and we can go further into that too, but conchita attests to calorie counting and trying to lose weight to all the good sleep, which to
52:39.269 --> 52:40.510
[SPEAKER_00]: That's so sad.
52:40.670 --> 52:41.071
[SPEAKER_00]: I know.
52:41.291 --> 52:42.012
[SPEAKER_00]: It's for women.
52:42.592 --> 52:43.553
[SPEAKER_01]: Jesus Christ.
52:43.813 --> 52:48.958
[SPEAKER_00]: She literally says, I can't risk losing the only man I love so dearly over body fat can I?
52:49.218 --> 52:54.763
[SPEAKER_00]: They do talk about like bad habits, Tonya's asked to swear less and stop biting her nails.
52:54.883 --> 52:56.925
[SPEAKER_00]: Also brush her hair twice a day.
52:56.945 --> 53:03.071
[SPEAKER_00]: Apparently helped her overcome her addiction to chocolate and Rose gives up green eye shadow
53:05.129 --> 53:17.677
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, to to slither and to slither and all this to say like it's interesting that and and so the older ten goes into this as like a portrayal of the Christian God.
53:18.037 --> 53:28.743
[SPEAKER_00]: But it also is something to be said
about like misogyny is so deeply embedded in their view of what God is in this case
53:33.445 --> 53:33.845
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
53:34.405 --> 53:35.025
[SPEAKER_01]: Which we all do.
53:35.285 --> 53:37.926
[SPEAKER_01]: That's something we're just designed by our society to do.
53:38.246 --> 53:38.566
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
53:38.946 --> 53:39.166
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
53:39.446 --> 53:49.028
[SPEAKER_01]: So even when they are making their own cult religion following ideology, whatever you want to call it that internalized misogyny is still ruling the roost.
53:50.368 --> 53:50.608
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah.
53:51.068 --> 53:53.729
[SPEAKER_00]: And they're very quick to see themselves as the problem.
53:54.889 --> 53:55.589
[SPEAKER_00]: Jesus Christ.
53:55.909 --> 53:59.770
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, because their perfect fictional person can't be anything but imperfect.
54:01.093 --> 54:06.198
[SPEAKER_00]: And in fairness to them, a lot of other people thought that they had problems, that's fair.
54:06.538 --> 54:13.305
[SPEAKER_00]: So Phantom Wank obviously jumped on this and thought it was hilarious and immediately started posting their photos everywhere.
54:13.325 --> 54:17.609
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, which like I also think is quite sad in a lot of ways.
54:18.089 --> 54:22.994
[SPEAKER_00]: That's me and the people were saying they're not fit to have kids, they have kids, they are parents.
54:23.074 --> 54:25.917
[SPEAKER_00]: They're like child protective service who should be involved.
54:27.198 --> 54:31.322
[SPEAKER_00]: None of this ever came through on their blogs that they had any trouble with being a parent.
54:31.402 --> 54:33.583
[SPEAKER_00]: It's just kind of a very fringe belief.
54:33.784 --> 54:41.250
[SPEAKER_00]: There are different points throughout all of these articles that are basically like, I mean, lots of people believe crazy things.
54:41.330 --> 54:43.932
[SPEAKER_00]: So a lot of religions have crazy beliefs as well.
54:43.952 --> 54:46.554
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, there's a lot of obviously not all of it.
54:46.574 --> 54:53.280
[SPEAKER_01]: But like, a lot of the things you've brought up, it's like, how is that different than some very, very, very fanatical?
54:53.400 --> 54:55.802
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm gonna say believers of certain religions.
54:57.400 --> 55:16.824
[SPEAKER_01]: And even on the non-finatic side, the way you were talking about how he helps with anxiety or stuff like that like people imagine Jesus and that way sometimes just because it brings them comfort or it's helpful to think that their prayers have been heard because of a sign, you know, whether it's like the sun comes out or something, you know, it's a spectrum is what I'm saying.
55:17.044 --> 55:18.465
[SPEAKER_01]: And these,
55:19.545 --> 55:27.047
[SPEAKER_01]: people are kind of falling on a more fanatical side of this religion that you created.
55:28.247 --> 55:29.007
[SPEAKER_00]: No, completely.
55:29.027 --> 55:44.051
[SPEAKER_00]: The Jezebel article came out in 2020 and so it has kind of an interesting take from our author who was like very much online at the time and critiquing these people Ashley Reese and you know she reaches out to one of her friends who is also you know critiquing
55:49.912 --> 55:55.075
[SPEAKER_00]: being so obsessed with a character that they're unwilling to see the flaws.
55:55.736 --> 56:12.786
[SPEAKER_00]: And those flaws are like very politically relevant, especially when you look at Snape using the term mudblood, and like that being excused or Snapeists, and this is what Ashley Reese talks about very very in depth in this article, or as in depth as you can on a very quite
56:18.638 --> 56:24.666
[SPEAKER_00]: who became Lily Potter, it was originally Lily Evans, should have forgiven Snape.
56:26.431 --> 56:28.272
[SPEAKER_00]: Why is that Lily's problem?
56:28.972 --> 56:30.253
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's that there it is.
56:31.133 --> 56:32.874
[SPEAKER_01]: And this is, sorry.
56:33.714 --> 56:41.417
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that there's this sense that like, Snoop Wads are like, well, or it's Snoop Wads are like, I would have loved to have him be obsessed with me.
56:41.437 --> 56:43.178
[SPEAKER_00]: I would never have been upset about that.
56:43.218 --> 56:51.621
[SPEAKER_00]: But the large majority of these folks from what we can see in what's left are white women who don't really have the experience of being discriminated against in that way.
56:52.321 --> 57:07.957
[SPEAKER_00]: And so it's really, really telling that they're unable to even see the flaws in this character, especially given how right-wing and extremist corners of the internet that were more isolated became over the next 10 years.
57:08.348 --> 57:14.276
[SPEAKER_01]: So a lot of what you're describing and the fact that it's women acting this way is very ironic.
57:14.337 --> 57:22.869
[SPEAKER_01]: Considering what I'm about to say, but the parallels between that in the current in cell group is striking because we'd like to joke on the podcast.
57:22.889 --> 57:23.650
[SPEAKER_01]: We love a urine.
57:23.910 --> 57:44.896
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, and guess because in romantic literature, Gurning is sexy and fun and on a God's Sony, but there is this very real belief that in our actual real life, because a man wants something and has wanted it for so long and has left her for so long, he has a right to ownership.
57:45.696 --> 57:50.197
[SPEAKER_01]: And Lily Potter, Lily Evans is just a girl who just wasn't interested in him.
57:51.605 --> 57:53.847
[SPEAKER_01]: And she's a lot and that's the fucking end of it.
57:54.708 --> 58:03.854
[SPEAKER_01]: She's a girl who said no and he as far as I'm a boyer I guess backed off and and whatever and she got married and he pined over her for the rest of his life.
58:04.834 --> 58:06.355
[SPEAKER_01]: That was his decision.
58:07.476 --> 58:10.638
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah to do and as absolutely nothing to do with her.
58:10.658 --> 58:11.879
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, great.
58:12.239 --> 58:15.802
[SPEAKER_01]: And he decided to actively bully her child because of it.
58:16.672 --> 58:17.973
[SPEAKER_00]: which is uncooled behavior.
58:18.333 --> 58:18.553
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes.
58:18.873 --> 58:22.676
[SPEAKER_01]: So what do the SNAPists think of his behavior towards Henry?
58:23.436 --> 58:25.097
[SPEAKER_00]: They think Harry deserves it.
58:25.377 --> 58:25.877
[SPEAKER_00]: That's the thing.
58:25.957 --> 58:27.678
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the 11 year old boy deserved it.
58:28.119 --> 58:31.581
[SPEAKER_00]: They're really unwilling to engage with any critique of Severus.
58:32.221 --> 58:32.581
[UNKNOWN]: Wow.
58:33.522 --> 58:33.722
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
58:33.962 --> 58:34.663
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, that's the thing.
58:34.723 --> 58:39.645
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like one of the things I really liked about the character of SNAP is that he was incredibly imperfect.
58:40.826 --> 58:42.087
[SPEAKER_00]: And that he was Alan Rickman, right?
58:44.841 --> 59:08.616
[SPEAKER_01]: But you know, I mean, like he doesn't just because he's in love with the girl and has been pining over her for so long and that makes him a little bit more human and then he did a little bit to protect Harry in the long run, doesn't make him the series hero and he doesn't need to be so complicated character and he's allowed to be complicated character that acted poorly that made mistakes that did shitty things and did some good things.
59:09.256 --> 59:10.237
[SPEAKER_01]: That's just what humans
59:11.657 --> 59:16.079
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, a couple of these sources talked about Snape as a bironic hero.
59:16.099 --> 59:18.099
[SPEAKER_00]: So someone who's like, really?
59:18.119 --> 59:20.580
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, that's not okay.
59:21.260 --> 59:23.041
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, Byron, let's think about this.
59:24.421 --> 59:31.744
[SPEAKER_00]: He's done that like a traditional bironic hero in a lot of ways, but he's like a brooding and very passionate and very thoughtful.
59:31.884 --> 59:33.465
[SPEAKER_00]: And in that way, yes.
59:34.865 --> 59:35.265
[SPEAKER_01]: That's true.
59:36.165 --> 59:39.587
[SPEAKER_01]: So the last time we talked about bironic heroes on the podcast was Heathcliff.
59:40.267 --> 59:40.607
[SPEAKER_00]: That's true.
59:41.540 --> 59:44.922
[SPEAKER_01]: And he was very much straight out of a Byron poem.
59:44.982 --> 59:50.506
[SPEAKER_01]: So you could technically convince yourself to like any closed off male character who's like hyper masculine as a Byron and Kero.
59:51.687 --> 59:52.567
[SPEAKER_00]: You're not wrong.
59:54.537 --> 59:55.498
[SPEAKER_00]: and I do love them.
59:55.738 --> 59:57.038
[SPEAKER_00]: You asked about Alan Reckman.
59:58.239 --> 01:00:02.101
[SPEAKER_00]: And I was super curious about this, too, because of Severus, Snape is an astral being.
01:00:02.161 --> 01:00:03.462
[SPEAKER_00]: What is Alan Reckman doing here?
01:00:04.002 --> 01:00:13.347
[SPEAKER_00]: And
there's an interesting point at which, like, Tanya admits that she's been looking at Alan Reckman playing other characters and gets in trouble with.
01:00:14.367 --> 01:00:15.889
[SPEAKER_00]: Severus.
01:00:15.909 --> 01:00:21.355
[SPEAKER_00]: So based on all of this, Alan Rickman is a portrayal of Severus' name, but is not Severus' name.
01:00:21.495 --> 01:00:26.441
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you enjoy him in his poster form, that's fine.
01:00:27.202 --> 01:00:31.927
[SPEAKER_00]: And if you enjoy him as Severus' name, that's fine, but he can't be playing any other character.
01:00:32.748 --> 01:00:49.472
[SPEAKER_00]: And there was a severest snake doll that the snakeists very much policed the photos of like people would post this doll like do my gone thing or with like his butt showing or whatever and it was so realistic that they would get upset.
01:00:49.632 --> 01:00:52.292
[SPEAKER_00]: There are norms and behaviors around portraying
01:00:56.744 --> 01:01:06.514
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh my god, sorry, I clicked a button and then I got to jump scare with the full-demort doll from this line.
01:01:06.614 --> 01:01:09.677
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm sending it to you.
01:01:09.717 --> 01:01:10.919
[SPEAKER_00]: Jesus Christ!
01:01:13.001 --> 01:01:14.282
[SPEAKER_01]: Jesus Christ!
01:01:15.603 --> 01:01:16.184
[SPEAKER_01]: Jesus Christ!
01:01:21.734 --> 01:01:22.054
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, interesting.
01:01:22.074 --> 01:01:22.755
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't like the snake dolls hair.
01:01:22.775 --> 01:01:26.517
[SPEAKER_01]: It's a little, it's a little, it's a little freaky, but um, I, I, the rest of the rest of it is others, a whole thing called, oh my god, this website has a thing just called doll faces.
01:01:26.538 --> 01:01:44.971
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, no, I should out of clicked on that board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board board
01:01:45.459 --> 01:01:55.107
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, so there are rules and regulations, okay, so they basically like copy write it's Snape a little bit, which is interesting and I'm sure some other would have something to say about that.
01:01:55.727 --> 01:02:00.671
[SPEAKER_00]: There seems to have been like a falling out
between Tanya and Rose.
01:02:02.053 --> 01:02:03.854
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, no, okay, what happened?
01:02:04.234 --> 01:02:14.663
[SPEAKER_00]: It's really unclear in a lot of ways, but there are theories that this photo had something to do with it, and I'm going to send it to you, loving for these live journal links.
01:02:17.234 --> 01:02:22.758
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, why, why this photo, I don't, I don't understand what I'm not looking at.
01:02:23.538 --> 01:02:24.859
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you recognize this character?
01:02:26.260 --> 01:02:26.500
[UNKNOWN]: No.
01:02:27.661 --> 01:02:30.663
[SPEAKER_00]: That's totally fine because I didn't either.
01:02:30.783 --> 01:02:31.743
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, who is that?
01:02:34.265 --> 01:02:35.525
[SPEAKER_00]: That's not Severus, Nate.
01:02:35.986 --> 01:02:36.706
[SPEAKER_00]: Sure isn't.
01:02:37.227 --> 01:02:39.248
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, it's half Severus, Nate.
01:02:39.428 --> 01:02:41.009
[SPEAKER_01]: Who's the guy I'm lurking behind him?
01:02:43.928 --> 01:02:45.069
[SPEAKER_01]: Why do I recognize him?
01:02:45.129 --> 01:02:48.292
[SPEAKER_00]: Has expanded her horizons.
01:02:49.533 --> 01:02:49.714
[UNKNOWN]: Yeah.
01:02:50.474 --> 01:02:51.515
[SPEAKER_01]: Damn girl.
01:02:52.056 --> 01:02:57.441
[SPEAKER_00]: So this is Jethro Gibbs portrayed by Mark Harmon on NCIS.
01:02:57.881 --> 01:02:59.082
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, I never want to NCIS.
01:03:00.175 --> 01:03:01.015
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, yeah me neither.
01:03:01.395 --> 01:03:02.216
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean he's attractive.
01:03:03.036 --> 01:03:03.536
[SPEAKER_00]: He's fine.
01:03:03.936 --> 01:03:04.857
[SPEAKER_00]: His name is Jethro.
01:03:05.537 --> 01:03:06.057
[SPEAKER_00]: Evidently.
01:03:06.637 --> 01:03:06.898
[SPEAKER_00]: Wow.
01:03:07.158 --> 01:03:07.398
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
01:03:07.418 --> 01:03:08.318
[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think I renew that.
01:03:08.458 --> 01:03:10.159
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm working nice as face, but I never knew his name.
01:03:10.279 --> 01:03:10.559
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
01:03:10.639 --> 01:03:12.380
[SPEAKER_00]: Bring back crazy names.
01:03:12.600 --> 01:03:13.220
[SPEAKER_01]: Apparently.
01:03:13.240 --> 01:03:13.520
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
01:03:13.540 --> 01:03:13.860
[SPEAKER_01]: Wow.
01:03:14.020 --> 01:03:14.320
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
01:03:14.540 --> 01:03:14.821
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay.
01:03:14.881 --> 01:03:18.602
[SPEAKER_01]: So Rose is now getting with Snape and Jethro.
01:03:19.787 --> 01:03:23.450
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes, and Rose talks about, like, kind of blames JK rolling for all of this.
01:03:23.811 --> 01:03:24.291
[SPEAKER_00]: Sure, sure, sure, sure.
01:03:24.551 --> 01:03:26.813
[SPEAKER_00]: You're not giving it enough merchandise for sleep.
01:03:27.113 --> 01:03:27.934
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't have enough.
01:03:28.134 --> 01:03:32.198
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm really interested in this guy, but like, I still have sleep.
01:03:33.193 --> 01:03:34.573
[SPEAKER_01]: This is delusional validation.
01:03:34.753 --> 01:03:38.214
[SPEAKER_01]: This is validation rooted entirely in delusional and fantastical thinking.
01:03:38.554 --> 01:03:45.857
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, the way that Rose writes after her break with Tanya is like a little bit different.
01:03:46.277 --> 01:03:49.618
[SPEAKER_00]: And I do want to read a little bit of her some of her post.
01:03:49.798 --> 01:03:56.920
[SPEAKER_00]: So like reality and illusion, she says that the differences between those are merely quote, Eons of societal brainwashing.
01:03:58.920 --> 01:04:14.107
[SPEAKER_01]: Wait, the differences between reality and delusion, you said, and elusion, elusion of our self insert there, um, okay, so the reality, so the difference between reality and elusion is societal conditioning is essentially what she's saying.
01:04:14.607 --> 01:04:25.956
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, she says, yet more and more people who want more, who ache for more than the prescribed normalcy have found loose bricks, looks spots on the wall and are working to lose them more open.
01:04:26.557 --> 01:04:31.981
[SPEAKER_00]: And while doing so, sharing the news as others become aware as well, we do make our own reality here in elsewhere.
01:04:32.441 --> 01:04:36.004
[SPEAKER_00]: The box has been opened and people are pouring out in curiosity and excitement.
01:04:36.184 --> 01:04:38.486
[SPEAKER_00]: Some will stay within the safety of their box, which is fine.
01:04:38.786 --> 01:04:40.768
[SPEAKER_00]: That's the beauty of it all each their own.
01:04:41.965 --> 01:04:46.426
[SPEAKER_01]: And you know what, I don't have any problem with that because I, I do believe that it to some degree.
01:04:46.547 --> 01:04:51.948
[SPEAKER_01]: I think the creating your own reality, I literally have a tattoo of the symbolizes the term career on reality.
01:04:52.168 --> 01:04:56.830
[SPEAKER_01]: I've always believed that we should talk about this in the form of king, but you know, like as long as nobody's getting hurt.
01:04:56.890 --> 01:04:58.330
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, sorry, I hurt anybody.
01:04:58.370 --> 01:05:00.031
[SPEAKER_01]: I, you know, believe what you want to believe.
01:05:00.691 --> 01:05:02.912
[SPEAKER_01]: And besides hurting their friendships and possibly their marriages.
01:05:03.732 --> 01:05:04.392
[SPEAKER_00]: Don't worry about that.
01:05:04.833 --> 01:05:05.853
[SPEAKER_00]: And maybe causing a heart attack.
01:05:06.360 --> 01:05:07.660
[SPEAKER_01]: It may be causing a heart attack.
01:05:07.680 --> 01:05:36.327
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, that is a very joyful way to look at life and there is nothing wrong with falling in love with the inanimate being or a fictional being or whatever, but it is concerning when it gets to this degree and it's being police or it's policing your life or there's a power dynamic which it sounds like there was when Tanya was involved what she wrote was really lovely and very idealistic and I think there's a lot of truth to it, but I don't think that that's exactly what she
was experiencing.
01:05:36.948 --> 01:05:37.928
[SPEAKER_01]: to be completely honest.
01:05:37.988 --> 01:05:43.914
[SPEAKER_00]: That's my own editorializing, but yeah, I think there's there are layers here, right?
01:05:43.954 --> 01:05:58.406
[SPEAKER_00]: Like I think that it's important to recognize your own role in creating your reality, but you also have to be willing to receive information that might tell you otherwise and not immediately attack it.
01:05:59.095 --> 01:05:59.435
[SPEAKER_00]: correct.
01:05:59.735 --> 01:06:20.484
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think that's the line that I draw on this end is like them being unwilling to critique some of the very real concerns that others had while they were very accepting of other people having their own reality and like very much trying to have their own experience of life.
01:06:26.367 --> 01:06:36.193
[SPEAKER_00]: basically creating more massage and extractors within an already very difficult world that like replicated some of the racism and gender bias that already exists.
01:06:36.553 --> 01:06:51.602
[SPEAKER_01]: That level of society, I guess, that they've kind of created for themselves, this level of community in the way that that's being run in that level of insular thought is when I feel comfortable starting to throw out
01:06:53.526 --> 01:06:56.867
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, because it can be really harmful for other people.
01:06:57.988 --> 01:07:11.473
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, but I think that we should take a critical look at like if we're going to critique something that's like this where it's like people who feel invisible finding ways to connect with a more emotional, more alive reality.
01:07:11.913 --> 01:07:21.477
[SPEAKER_00]: I think we need to take a closer look at the way that men, middle-aged men look at sports and like they're just because this is not normalized
01:07:23.678 --> 01:07:29.502
[SPEAKER_00]: and cringy does not mean that it doesn't have merit, even if it's a bit messed.
01:07:30.182 --> 01:07:41.269
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh absolutely, everything that they did is a very easy thing to do and tap into with in our culture and with the minds we are given.
01:07:41.289 --> 01:07:45.932
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, like every step of the way during this, you and I have had moments where like yeah, that makes sense.
01:07:45.972 --> 01:07:46.832
[SPEAKER_01]: I see why they did that.
01:07:46.872 --> 01:07:47.993
[SPEAKER_01]: I can see where they're coming from.
01:07:48.753 --> 01:07:50.795
[SPEAKER_01]: I can see how somebody would fall into X, Y, and Z.
01:07:51.590 --> 01:07:52.952
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, they created a power structure.
01:07:52.992 --> 01:07:57.358
[SPEAKER_01]: They created Dynamics, they created the sociological imagination to the certain degree.
01:07:57.698 --> 01:08:04.266
[SPEAKER_01]: And we see that in every, I mean, there are a lot of arguments to say that certain sports followings are also cults.
01:08:07.190 --> 01:08:18.615
[SPEAKER_01]: religions aren't called cults, for good reason, but there are all sects of certain religions and groups within certain religions that also mirror what we're seeing within these the small community.
01:08:18.815 --> 01:08:19.815
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, great news, Romney.
01:08:19.855 --> 01:08:29.659
[SPEAKER_00]: So I wanted to send us off with a little bit of advice that I think will help with the Edward Cohen problem and for anyone else who may have fallen in love with a fictional character.
01:08:29.820 --> 01:08:33.921
[SPEAKER_00]: So Wikki Howe has a great article on what to do if you fall
01:08:35.988 --> 01:08:42.572
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, okay, there's a wiki how I guess and the steps are very confusing.
01:08:42.592 --> 01:08:43.773
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm going to give you that now.
01:08:43.993 --> 01:08:47.255
[SPEAKER_00]: So, okay, method one.
01:08:47.656 --> 01:08:51.198
[SPEAKER_00]: And I think this is what Snape has said, sharing your love with others.
01:08:51.678 --> 01:08:52.939
[SPEAKER_00]: So, know you're not alone.
01:08:52.959 --> 01:08:54.260
[SPEAKER_00]: You're not the only person out there.
01:08:54.280 --> 01:08:55.841
[SPEAKER_00]: He's attracted to a fictional character.
01:08:56.301 --> 01:09:00.284
[SPEAKER_00]: chances are you aren't even the only person attracted to that particular character.
01:09:00.665 --> 01:09:02.766
[SPEAKER_00]: It's a perfectly normal thing to experience.
01:09:03.307 --> 01:09:08.031
[SPEAKER_00]: If you're wondering why you might have fallen in love or how it's possible, there are several explanations.
01:09:08.191 --> 01:09:12.494
[SPEAKER_00]: Some people fall in love with fictional characters because they know this person will always be there for them.
01:09:12.514 --> 01:09:15.036
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, is that Edward?
01:09:16.017 --> 01:09:16.417
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, for sure.
01:09:17.318 --> 01:09:17.518
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
01:09:18.239 --> 01:09:18.399
[SPEAKER_00]: Two.
01:09:20.140 --> 01:09:23.803
[SPEAKER_00]: Fictional characters are also written specifically to appeal to consumers.
01:09:26.087 --> 01:09:27.888
[SPEAKER_01]: What did we talk about during our Twilight episode?
01:09:27.908 --> 01:09:29.769
[SPEAKER_01]: You know, it's like Bella was the every woman.
01:09:30.370 --> 01:09:34.312
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, you know, every single person thought that they were Bella swan.
01:09:34.512 --> 01:09:39.755
[SPEAKER_01]: When you read it, the character is designed so anybody reading it can be like, because I thought I was Bella swan.
01:09:40.376 --> 01:09:42.377
[SPEAKER_01]: And then I read it as adults, and I was like, what the fuck was I thinking?
01:09:43.037 --> 01:09:51.883
[SPEAKER_01]: Because I did approach it as an adult again for the podcast episode with the knowledge that I used to believe I was exactly like her in every single way.
01:09:53.025 --> 01:10:00.550
[SPEAKER_01]: And I was like, I wonder how many like see things like preteen things about myself in this character and I didn't it
was completely fabricated in my brain.
01:10:01.450 --> 01:10:11.837
[SPEAKER_01]: Because well it's like that that one chick that loved Snape who Snape was telling her she had to lose weight x y z It's like, yes, and it's like well Edward loved her.
01:10:12.618 --> 01:10:14.419
[SPEAKER_01]: So therefore I need to be her.
01:10:15.279 --> 01:10:15.780
[SPEAKER_00]: It makes sense.
01:10:16.780 --> 01:10:17.561
[SPEAKER_00]: The logic is sound.
01:10:17.581 --> 01:10:19.562
[SPEAKER_01]: It's it's tween logic.
01:10:19.722 --> 01:10:20.943
[SPEAKER_01]: It's hormones logic, but
01:10:21.328 --> 01:10:22.328
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I don't disagree.
01:10:22.769 --> 01:10:25.269
[SPEAKER_00]: Option two for sharing your love of the character.
01:10:25.349 --> 01:10:26.530
[SPEAKER_00]: You could talk about it with your friends.
01:10:26.590 --> 01:10:27.470
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh my gosh, that's what I do.
01:10:27.490 --> 01:10:29.931
[SPEAKER_00]: So that's literally what this podcast is.
01:10:32.072 --> 01:10:36.953
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay, option three, you could allow yourself to fantasize about your fictional love.
01:10:37.934 --> 01:10:38.274
[SPEAKER_00]: Totally.
01:10:38.654 --> 01:10:42.255
[SPEAKER_00]: And fantasy is apparently a normal reaction according to WikiHow.
01:10:42.415 --> 01:10:44.716
[SPEAKER_00]: So I feel like they're basically saying
01:10:51.387 --> 01:10:51.567
[SPEAKER_00]: Yes.
01:10:52.468 --> 01:10:54.429
[SPEAKER_00]: All right, they're just following the Wiki how.
01:10:54.690 --> 01:10:57.192
[SPEAKER_00]: Four, this also is following the Wiki how.
01:10:57.572 --> 01:10:58.493
[SPEAKER_00]: Right, fan fiction.
01:10:59.613 --> 01:11:00.674
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, my God.
01:11:01.975 --> 01:11:05.238
[SPEAKER_00]: And then the alternate is if you're more of a visual person, you can do fan art.
01:11:06.038 --> 01:11:07.500
[SPEAKER_00]: That's a true, I love fan art.
01:11:08.200 --> 01:11:09.121
[SPEAKER_01]: We've talked about this before.
01:11:09.161 --> 01:11:12.183
[SPEAKER_01]: When there's a book that I love the first thing I do is go try to find all the fan art.
01:11:12.203 --> 01:11:13.044
[SPEAKER_01]: The people have made about it.
01:11:14.202 --> 01:11:14.922
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, I love that.
01:11:15.202 --> 01:11:19.384
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, step five, and thank God for this, is sure you're worked with others.
01:11:19.844 --> 01:11:22.305
[SPEAKER_00]: It's post your fanfiction or your fan art.
01:11:23.385 --> 01:11:29.187
[SPEAKER_00]: I mean, all of this I feel isn't really helping me cope with my crush, but like, that's validating it.
01:11:29.207 --> 01:11:31.148
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like, it's like, it's like you can make it.
01:11:31.188 --> 01:11:33.789
[SPEAKER_01]: It's like you can make a buck, sell your fan art.
01:11:33.809 --> 01:11:35.150
[SPEAKER_00]: It's like your fan art.
01:11:36.230 --> 01:11:38.631
[SPEAKER_01]: If you're gonna have a session at least make it lucrative.
01:11:39.827 -->
01:11:41.509
[SPEAKER_00]: Snape us did not scroll past this.
01:11:41.769 --> 01:11:46.693
[SPEAKER_00]: So I'm wondering like this might resonate a little bit more with your Edward Colin experience.
01:11:46.813 --> 01:11:48.755
[SPEAKER_00]: This section is called breaking the spell.
01:11:49.335 --> 01:11:49.696
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, no.
01:11:49.956 --> 01:11:50.136
[SPEAKER_01]: Nope.
01:11:50.156 --> 01:11:51.077
[SPEAKER_01]: They don't do that part.
01:11:51.497 --> 01:11:52.939
[SPEAKER_01]: They leaned in hard.
01:11:54.538 --> 01:11:57.120
[SPEAKER_00]: Uh, one, figure out if this love is hurting your life.
01:11:57.300 --> 01:11:58.921
[SPEAKER_00]: Do you think your Edward Cohen crash hurt your life?
01:11:59.402 --> 01:12:00.383
[SPEAKER_01]: No, but did I tell you?
01:12:00.403 --> 01:12:01.403
[SPEAKER_01]: I think I've told you this.
01:12:01.663 --> 01:12:05.206
[SPEAKER_01]: Um, I did end a relationship after re-reading Twilight and High School.
01:12:05.506 --> 01:12:06.267
[SPEAKER_01]: Did I ever tell you with that?
01:12:07.048 --> 01:12:07.508
[SPEAKER_01]: No!
01:12:07.528 --> 01:12:08.869
[SPEAKER_01]: I remember sitting in my bed.
01:12:09.009 --> 01:12:12.752
[SPEAKER_01]: I stayed up all night reading new moon on my laptop.
01:12:12.772 --> 01:12:13.232
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, uh, um...
01:12:14.518 --> 01:12:15.239
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh, a pre-read?
01:12:15.439 --> 01:12:18.681
[SPEAKER_01]: No, like somebody typed out the entire novel and put it on the internet.
01:12:19.042 --> 01:12:20.443
[SPEAKER_01]: Her people who couldn't afford the books.
01:12:21.003 --> 01:12:22.604
[SPEAKER_01]: And I found that.
01:12:22.724 --> 01:12:23.365
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, super legal.
01:12:23.665 --> 01:12:25.566
[SPEAKER_01]: I stayed up all night reading it.
01:12:25.587 --> 01:12:30.630
[SPEAKER_01]: I feel like the 15th time, but for some reason I just couldn't sleep, and I was really into the story again, and I was getting all sucked in.
01:12:31.111 --> 01:12:38.316
[SPEAKER_01]: And there's one part where Jacob, the idea that he's supposed to be, if Edward didn't exist, he was supposed to be Bella's soulmate.
01:12:39.237 --> 01:12:43.260
[SPEAKER_01]: And he describes his relationship with Bella as easy as breathing.
01:12:44.452 --> 01:12:45.893
[SPEAKER_00]: And you're like, this is not what this is.
01:12:46.334 --> 01:12:55.283
[SPEAKER_01]: And I realized, and I was like, I can't say that about my own relationship, not that it was a bad relationship, but that's not what I wanted out of a relationship.
01:12:55.924 --> 01:12:57.745
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I ended my relationship.
01:13:02.052 --> 01:13:05.513
[SPEAKER_01]: There were other things going on, but that was where really what made me realize.
01:13:05.573 --> 01:13:09.134
[SPEAKER_01]: I felt like things were fistling and I felt like things weren't perfect for a while.
01:13:09.674 --> 01:13:13.795
[SPEAKER_01]: And I think that that's where they would help to clue me into
what I wanted versus what I had.
01:13:14.335 --> 01:13:17.636
[SPEAKER_01]: Again, I had a bad relationship, it was what I wanted.
01:13:18.176 --> 01:13:20.257
[SPEAKER_00]: And I felt like I might be able to imagine more.
01:13:22.298 --> 01:13:25.562
[SPEAKER_01]: and like the easy things should be as easy as breathing.
01:13:25.782 --> 01:13:27.885
[SPEAKER_01]: Like the everyday things should be as easy as breathing.
01:13:28.666 --> 01:13:30.808
[SPEAKER_01]: To me, that's what I want in my relationship.
01:13:30.829 --> 01:13:33.051
[SPEAKER_01]: It's not everybody is me, but that's what I really need in mind.
01:13:34.173 --> 01:13:34.733
[SPEAKER_01]: No, me too.
01:13:35.074 --> 01:13:36.115
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
01:13:36.896 --> 01:13:41.662
[SPEAKER_01]: So anyway, not Edward, but it was a toilet thing that did directly impact my life.
01:13:42.303 --> 01:13:44.624
[SPEAKER_00]: Oh my god, I don't know if it harmed your life.
01:13:45.144 --> 01:13:46.405
[SPEAKER_01]: No, it definitely didn't harm it.
01:13:47.245 --> 01:13:48.085
[SPEAKER_00]: But change it.
01:13:48.425 --> 01:13:49.546
[SPEAKER_00]: Hmm?
01:13:49.566 --> 01:13:49.886
[SPEAKER_00]: Okay.
01:13:50.506 --> 01:13:56.269
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, once you've gotten past number one, the next step is to remember that the character isn't real.
01:13:56.449 --> 01:14:03.431
[SPEAKER_00]: So you look for the flaws and the negative aspect, and sometimes it helps to have other people tell you about it instead of the other.
01:14:04.252 --> 01:14:06.873
[SPEAKER_01]: Make sure your friends stage an intervention and shame you.
01:14:07.582 --> 01:14:08.763
[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, great.
01:14:08.963 --> 01:14:09.364
[SPEAKER_00]: Thank you.
01:14:09.584 --> 01:14:11.425
[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe that's what fandom wankled trying to do.
01:14:11.826 --> 01:14:14.027
[SPEAKER_00]: Step three, recognize stereotyping in characters.
01:14:15.989 --> 01:14:19.772
[SPEAKER_00]: Apparently, especially in a visual fiction, it's a helpful way to do it.
01:14:20.453 --> 01:14:29.540
[SPEAKER_00]: Supposedly, I haven't stepped forward, which I do feel is like opposite of the first method, completely cut yourself off from the fictional character.
01:14:29.560 --> 01:14:32.683
[SPEAKER_00]: They are so confusing.
01:14:33.667 --> 01:14:35.969
[SPEAKER_01]: Wow, okay, so do you lean in or do you lean out?
01:14:36.369 --> 01:14:36.969
[SPEAKER_01]: Don't know.
01:14:37.610 --> 01:14:39.191
[SPEAKER_01]: Well, we don't know letting us down.
01:14:39.791 --> 01:14:43.293
[SPEAKER_00]: I know, but you can deal with the loss of a character as well.
01:14:44.194 --> 01:14:49.918
[SPEAKER_00]: So if you've tried to break the spell and you're sad about it, they have method 3, which is dealing with the loss of the character.
01:14:50.418 --> 01:14:51.358
[SPEAKER_00]: And confusingly,
01:14:52.395 --> 01:14:54.476
[SPEAKER_00]: We're gonna undo everything we just did with method two.
01:14:55.096 --> 01:14:56.916
[SPEAKER_00]: So you can remember that it's okay to grieve.
01:14:57.296 --> 01:14:58.497
[SPEAKER_00]: You can vent your feelings.
01:14:58.757 --> 01:15:07.059
[SPEAKER_00]: You can find ways to remember your character, like rereading or rewatching parts of the book or show, and remember that all good things must come to an end.
01:15:07.219 --> 01:15:08.619
[SPEAKER_00]: So which is it, Wiki Howe?
01:15:08.659 --> 01:15:09.839
[SPEAKER_00]: Are we supposed to reread?
01:15:09.919 --> 01:15:11.420
[SPEAKER_00]: Or are we supposed to cut ourselves off?
01:15:11.460 --> 01:15:12.180
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't understand.
01:15:12.743 --> 01:15:13.523
[SPEAKER_01]: That is wild.
01:15:14.024 --> 01:15:15.244
[SPEAKER_01]: That is absolutely wild.
01:15:15.745 --> 01:15:16.925
[SPEAKER_01]: I love that there's a wiki how.
01:15:17.065 --> 01:15:18.426
[SPEAKER_01]: Can anybody just write a wiki how?
01:15:18.466 --> 01:15:23.109
[SPEAKER_01]: Do you need like a certain like, like, is there something you need to do to be somebody that writes a wiki how?
01:15:23.189 --> 01:15:24.449
[SPEAKER_01]: Like, do you need credentials?
01:15:25.390 --> 01:15:26.010
[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know.
01:15:26.030 --> 01:15:33.114
[SPEAKER_00]: I would love to learn more about that because I have read the wiki how and how to befriend a squirrel like a few times now and it's never worked for me.
01:15:33.134 --> 01:15:37.977
[SPEAKER_01]: I read the wiki how on how to fold a fidgeti and then still can't fold a fidgeti.
01:15:38.037 --> 01:15:38.257
[SPEAKER_01]: So.
01:15:54.451 --> 01:16:13.059
[SPEAKER_01]: This is one of those things where it's like I knew it was out there and I know that people not with snake, but like I know that people, you know, think that they get married to their fictional crushes of photoshopped pictures of like her with him like I've seen iterations of that for other things before I hadn't thought about it in a long time.
01:16:16.261 --> 01:16:27.650
[SPEAKER_01]: And so learning more about this specific one, it's very easy to fall into the, what was a dead from snake or something group, you know?
01:16:27.810 --> 01:16:28.110
[SPEAKER_01]: It is.
01:16:28.190 --> 01:16:28.410
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
01:16:28.931 --> 01:16:36.877
[SPEAKER_01]: Okay, if we go back to the fucking Wicker husband, it's really easy to become one of the villagers that's just like, you're not supposed to get good things.
01:16:36.917 --> 01:16:38.979
[SPEAKER_01]: That's how I retain my power over you.
01:16:39.639 --> 01:16:46.807
[SPEAKER_01]: It's very easy to look at people who are acting silly on the internet, and might not be harming that out outer wider world.
01:16:47.028 --> 01:16:50.292
[SPEAKER_01]: It's very easy to fall into the camp of let's drag this bitch.
01:16:50.492 --> 01:16:51.773
[SPEAKER_01]: Still happens on the internet today.
01:16:51.973 --> 01:16:58.962
[SPEAKER_01]: And while the photograph, the Photoshop image of safe with all the butterflies
and roses, I retain is very, very, very funny.
01:17:01.009 --> 01:17:10.717
[SPEAKER_01]: My first reaction when I saw the picture of her with him, of Rose with him was just fucking sadness.
01:17:11.558 --> 01:17:19.525
[SPEAKER_01]: And so I'm really lucky in that like I never was in a place I wanted to be an internet savvy enough, maybe or maybe it was just the way I was raised.
01:17:20.955 --> 01:17:22.857
[SPEAKER_01]: I wasn't bullying people on the internet.
01:17:22.937 --> 01:17:27.100
[SPEAKER_01]: I hope that if you were somebody who was bullying people on the internet, you've grown a lot since then.
01:17:27.120 --> 01:17:31.943
[SPEAKER_01]: Because like I said, that group think is just easy to fall into and it makes you feel powerful.
01:17:32.004 --> 01:17:37.808
[SPEAKER_01]: It makes you feel above other people and that's something that as humans we like to feel.
01:17:38.028 --> 01:17:42.732
[SPEAKER_01]: So something I'm taking is just that reminder that cruelty is out there.
01:17:44.490 --> 01:17:53.817
[SPEAKER_01]: And there's always a human behind the silliness or the delusion or the thing that you don't understand.
01:17:53.858 --> 01:17:58.501
[SPEAKER_01]: There's always a human, it's usually a human in pain, which is what it sounds like for these women.
01:17:58.721 --> 01:18:00.082
[SPEAKER_01]: So that's something I'm taking.
01:18:00.242 --> 01:18:01.964
[SPEAKER_01]: I'm leaving behind the cinephests.
01:18:03.965 --> 01:18:07.947
[SPEAKER_01]: I am, I am all for having your fantasies.
01:18:08.087 --> 01:18:23.795
[SPEAKER_01]: I am all for doing things that you want to be doing because they make you happy, they make you feel whole, they're a ballman on your soul, whether that is through religion and prayer, whether that is through reading, look me, you know, whatever it is, but however you're finding solace, please please please do it.
01:18:24.736 --> 01:18:26.257
[SPEAKER_01]: But this became incredibly unhealthy.
01:18:26.957 --> 01:18:44.741
[SPEAKER_01]: for the human, incredibly unhealthy, and I understand that I'm sitting here from a point of judgment saying that, but also I've studied enough psychology to be sitting here saying this is incredibly troubling for how they're moving through the world, how they're seeing that other really important people in their lives, like their best friends and neighbors.
01:18:45.621 --> 01:18:47.122
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, if the picture
01:18:48.802 --> 01:18:55.104
[SPEAKER_01]: imagining yourself with two fictional lovers is the downfall of this really really incredible friendship that's hard.
01:18:55.144 --> 01:18:58.145
[SPEAKER_01]: You're actively cutting people out of your life now because of it.
01:18:58.225 --> 01:18:59.285
[SPEAKER_01]: That's dangerous.
01:18:59.645 --> 01:19:00.566
[SPEAKER_01]: It's dangerous thinking.
01:19:00.686 --> 01:19:05.347
[SPEAKER_01]: There is a lot of merit to sharing what you love with other people and finding your clan out there.
01:19:06.047 --> 01:19:10.129
[SPEAKER_01]: This is one of those situations where it gets dangerous fast.
01:19:10.249 --> 01:19:14.030
[SPEAKER_01]: This stuff can really ramp up in really, really scary ways.
01:19:14.590 --> 01:19:15.951
[SPEAKER_01]: It got to a point where you were saying
01:19:17.611 --> 01:19:24.198
[SPEAKER_01]: literally sexting other people and taking advantage of them that way.
01:19:24.759 --> 01:19:25.940
[SPEAKER_01]: That's scary behavior.
01:19:26.141 --> 01:19:28.123
[SPEAKER_01]: Some exams, I feel like it's just what I want to like a tangent.
01:19:28.756 --> 01:19:30.777
[SPEAKER_00]: No, I think that's totally fair.
01:19:30.937 --> 01:19:34.679
[SPEAKER_00]: And I mean, I think that there's a line to be drawn between fantasy and delusion.
01:19:34.699 --> 01:19:37.500
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's a line that's crossed here.
01:19:37.980 --> 01:19:41.422
[SPEAKER_00]: Luckily, it's not too very, very harmful to Greta.
01:19:41.442 --> 01:19:41.842
[SPEAKER_00]: Exactly.
01:19:42.403 --> 01:19:51.147
[SPEAKER_00]: But I also think that there, like, the second that you refuse to question your beliefs, you become dogmatic and entrenched in delusion.
01:19:51.927 --> 01:19:53.088
[SPEAKER_00]: And that's a slippery slope.
01:19:53.748 --> 01:19:58.371
[SPEAKER_00]: It's important to stay flexible, stay nimble, work that narrow plasticity.
01:19:58.951 --> 01:20:05.856
[SPEAKER_00]: Great way to do that is by reading different perspectives and building that empathy even with people like the snapists.
01:20:06.056 --> 01:20:06.356
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
01:20:07.116 --> 01:20:09.338
[SPEAKER_01]: I didn't got to have empathy for people like that.
01:20:09.358 --> 01:20:09.578
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh my god.
01:20:09.978 --> 01:20:10.438
[SPEAKER_01]: You got to.
01:20:11.079 --> 01:20:16.922
[SPEAKER_01]: You start to lose your humanity if you can't see the pain behind some of this behavior that we would call quote unquote crazy.
01:20:17.082 --> 01:20:17.643
[SPEAKER_01]: This bit kind of a
01:20:21.345 --> 01:20:28.255
[SPEAKER_01]: regularly ridden path of our societal expectations and standards in the ways that we've constructed what is quote normal and not normal.
01:20:29.077 --> 01:20:30.999
[SPEAKER_01]: This is very very until a field.
01:20:31.901 --> 01:20:32.682
[SPEAKER_01]: There's always a reason.
01:20:34.826 --> 01:20:38.308
[SPEAKER_00]: You know, it is so funny, like objectively.
01:20:38.489 --> 01:20:39.749
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, it's fucking hilarious.
01:20:39.930 --> 01:20:44.593
[SPEAKER_00]: I also wanted to bring, like, come at this from a place of kindness and you did.
01:20:44.973 --> 01:21:00.944
[SPEAKER_00]: And especially like, the idea that things women like aren't silly and the importance of being able to talk about your sexual desires, your self-fulfillment desires, your value as a human being and not have to cloak it in.
01:21:02.285 --> 01:21:04.566
[SPEAKER_00]: and
invisibility-cloth-provided by Alan Wickman.
01:21:07.406 --> 01:21:13.788
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, these are not the only women who have done something like this, and they will not be the last people to have done something like this.
01:21:14.568 --> 01:21:21.830
[SPEAKER_01]: And hopefully it never gets to a point where it escalates further than this, but there was definitely a power dynamic happening there that I don't think was very healthy and some kind of glad it fizzled.
01:21:22.870 --> 01:21:29.972
[SPEAKER_01]: And I hope that they're happy now, I really hope they found other friends if they still have astral plane husbands out there treating them right,
01:21:32.512 --> 01:21:36.235
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, but no, I mean objectively, it's ridiculous.
01:21:36.855 --> 01:21:37.475
[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, it's so funny.
01:21:37.916 --> 01:21:38.836
[SPEAKER_01]: It's fucking ridiculous.
01:21:40.597 --> 01:21:42.959
[SPEAKER_00]: Anyway, thanks for having done the rabbit.
01:21:44.140 --> 01:21:45.260
[SPEAKER_01]: Thank you for diving into all that.
01:21:45.280 --> 01:21:49.703
[SPEAKER_01]: And by the way, you did a really lovely job, but I'm sorry that my squirrel brain derailed you so many times.
01:21:49.743 --> 01:21:51.004
[SPEAKER_01]: I just had so many questions.
01:21:51.084 --> 01:21:52.185
[SPEAKER_01]: And thank you for staying on track.
01:21:52.795 --> 01:21:53.656
[SPEAKER_00]: No, I loved it.
01:21:53.796 --> 01:21:54.276
[SPEAKER_00]: I loved it.
01:21:54.616 --> 01:21:55.897
[SPEAKER_00]: Preview of more to come.
01:21:55.937 --> 01:22:01.121
[SPEAKER_00]: I'm just going to give you a couple of headlines and then we're going to call it quits.
01:22:01.221 --> 01:22:09.327
[SPEAKER_00]: So we already talked about the self insert fan fiction reading spelled with a W to be reading and writing on online literature platforms in their own words.
01:22:09.467 --> 01:22:13.910
[SPEAKER_00]: Why do we care about literary characters, the religious affordance of fiction.
01:22:14.370 --> 01:22:24.433
[SPEAKER_00]: Paras social relationships with fictional characters in therapy, Ficto sexuality, Ficto romance, and Ficto Felia, a qualitative study of love and desire for fictional characters.
01:22:24.673 --> 01:22:25.613
[SPEAKER_01]: Ooh, I love that.
01:22:26.353 --> 01:22:28.013
[SPEAKER_01]: And Ficto Felia, that's a great word.
01:22:28.534 --> 01:22:30.954
[SPEAKER_00]: Adult attachment and engagement with fictional characters.
01:22:31.594 --> 01:22:41.577
[SPEAKER_01]: So when you in a spare-party company a research, I think a really really really good modern lens to do that research through is heated rivalry.
01:22:42.910 --> 01:22:46.173
[SPEAKER_01]: Yes, yes, that's a great one.
01:22:46.554 --> 01:22:57.004
[SPEAKER_01]: Our expecting these two actors who are just humans do in a job to be Shayna Nieluga, and it's getting to be really, really inappropriate.
01:22:57.164 --> 01:23:06.132
[SPEAKER_01]: Everything from allegations of queer bathing, which people do not ever fucking use that term right, playing a queer character is not queer bathing.
01:23:07.073 --> 01:23:26.329
[SPEAKER_01]: Now, if that is fucking educate yourself before accusing anybody of this, there's a lot there's a there's a there's harassment there's a lot of blog posts online a lot of people are writing about this how it's just like this is going to far the you do not have any ownership over these men because they play a character that you love so much.
01:23:26.529 --> 01:23:39.018
[SPEAKER_01]: how we've seen book conventions fall apart because authors will hire actors to play some of their characters and they'll someone dropped an air tag on a guy and fall it on back to his hotel room once and author was assaulted because of it.
01:23:39.038 --> 01:23:40.860
[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, it's a big problem.
01:23:41.020 --> 01:23:41.360
[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah.
01:23:44.242 --> 01:23:44.823
[SPEAKER_00]: Edge cases.
01:23:45.323 --> 01:23:46.164
[SPEAKER_00]: Let's be very clear.
01:23:46.504 --> 01:23:48.866
[SPEAKER_01]: But yes, but I mean, that's what this was.
01:23:48.906 --> 01:23:52.608
[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, you started off this down the rabbit hole by asking me, tell me about your craziest crush.
01:23:52.648 --> 01:23:59.433
[SPEAKER_01]: And mine was like, oh, I thought that like death cab for QD songs reminded me of Edward Collin, and I imagined him walking me the class sometimes.
01:24:00.154 --> 01:24:03.897
[SPEAKER_01]: And then we got to the darker end of the spectrum, which is it can go this far.
01:24:05.178 --> 01:24:07.639
[SPEAKER_00]: You didn't mention death cab, but that makes me very happy.
01:24:13.782 --> 01:24:16.204
[SPEAKER_00]: Well, not not, we leave you all dear readers, love you.
01:24:16.324 --> 01:24:19.887
[SPEAKER_00]: May you have the best astral marriages possible.
01:24:20.848 --> 01:24:21.829
[SPEAKER_01]: Insane, we trust.
01:24:27.512 --> 01:24:30.713
[SPEAKER_01]: Thanks so much for listening to another episode of Paperback Pleasures.
01:24:31.093 --> 01:24:36.394
[SPEAKER_01]: If you have a moment, please consider liking, subscribing, rating, or leaving the review wherever you're listening.
01:24:36.594 --> 01:24:39.315
[SPEAKER_01]: A few clicks on your end to make a world of difference for us.
01:24:39.395 --> 01:24:41.115
[SPEAKER_01]: It is truly the best way to support us.
01:24:41.595 --> 01:24:43.996
[SPEAKER_01]: We also have a Patreon page for just $5 a month.
01:24:44.116 --> 01:24:47.677
[SPEAKER_01]: You could access to Blubber Reels exclusive mini-sodes we even do movie nights.
01:24:47.877 --> 01:24:52.578
[SPEAKER_01]: If you're wondering who else is listening to Paperback Pleasures, we have a discord channel, full of our listeners.
01:24:52.678 --> 01:24:55.198
[SPEAKER_01]: The links to these can be found in the episode description.
01:24:57.682 --> 01:24:59.099
[SPEAKER_01]: until then, happy reading.