TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:03.007 --> 00:00:11.374
Today I'm taking apart a word that most of us have used to describe ourselves, our bosses, or the person who got the job we wanted.
00:00:11.374 --> 00:00:13.695
The word is meritocracy.
00:00:13.695 --> 00:00:24.524
And I'm going to show you that the man who invented it invented it as a warning, and that that warning was ignored, and that the ignoring was not an accident.
00:00:24.524 --> 00:00:27.807
I'm Chisom Udeze, and this is Overnight Wisdom.
00:00:27.807 --> 00:00:30.981
So first let's discuss the warning that nobody kept.
00:00:30.981 --> 00:00:39.006
In nineteen fifty eight, a British sociologist named Michael Young wrote a book called The Rise of Meritocracy.
00:00:39.006 --> 00:00:45.911
He invented the word and before Young it did not really exist and he did not invent it as a compliment.
00:00:45.911 --> 00:00:51.283
The book is a satire written as a history from the year twenty thirty four.
00:00:51.284 --> 00:01:10.055
Looking back at a Britain that had recognized itself or reorganized itself entirely around intelligence and effort, Jung called this quality merit and he built in fiction the society that would result from selecting people by it and nothing else.
00:01:10.055 --> 00:01:13.397
He did not write a utopia, he wrote a warning.
00:01:13.397 --> 00:01:18.400
In his telling, the people selected as as ~ meritorious.
00:01:18.400 --> 00:01:27.167
hardened into a class that no longer had to justify its position because the position had already been declared earned.
00:01:27.167 --> 00:01:38.353
Young's own sentence for this is the one that survives him and I think it goes something like every selection of one is a rejection of many.
00:01:38.353 --> 00:01:40.825
He meant that as an indictment.
00:01:40.825 --> 00:01:47.218
2001, more than forty years later, Young was still alive to watch his warning fail.
00:01:47.218 --> 00:01:54.123
He wrote an essay for The Guardian asking Britain's political class to stop using his own word as praise.
00:01:54.123 --> 00:02:10.350
He's watched Tony Blair's government adopt meritocracy as a governing ideal, and he said so plainly that a society ruled by people who believed Your position is earned becomes a society with no language left for the people underneath it.
00:02:10.350 --> 00:02:17.743
Because if the system is fair and you are at the bottom, then the only explanation left is that it is your fault.
00:02:17.743 --> 00:02:21.421
And that is the first thing I want us to sit with today.
00:02:21.421 --> 00:02:29.349
The word we have been using as a description of fairness was coined as a description of a trap.
00:02:29.349 --> 00:02:33.301
So let's actually unpack what the word would actually require.
00:02:33.301 --> 00:02:41.370
And I want to be precise about what meritocracy claims because precision is how we are able to dismantle fallacies.
00:02:41.370 --> 00:02:45.032
Meritocracy claims that position tracks output.
00:02:45.032 --> 00:02:49.917
If you work harder, if you produce more, if you contribute more, you rise higher.
00:02:49.917 --> 00:02:55.562
For that claim to be true and not decorative, three things would have to hold.
00:02:55.562 --> 00:03:00.064
one, everyone would have to start from a comparable position.
00:03:00.064 --> 00:03:12.254
Two, the mechanisms that sorts people in tax systems, in hiring, in admission, in pay would have to actually reward output rather than origin.
00:03:12.254 --> 00:03:24.139
And three, the outcome over time would have to be a society where each generation's position would depends on what they do rather than what they were born into.
00:03:24.139 --> 00:03:29.204
And in how the world is currently organized, none of those three things hold.
00:03:29.204 --> 00:03:38.002
So I'm gonna walk through some of them with the record because it's easier for us to see clearly when things are open on the table.
00:03:38.002 --> 00:03:40.133
So let's talk about the tax record.
00:03:40.153 --> 00:04:00.971
If merit is actually rewarded and the system is fair, the tax code is one of the clearest places that fairness would have to show up Because taxation is the state so system's own official statement of what it thinks you owe it for what you have taken from the common pool.
00:04:00.971 --> 00:04:11.465
In 2021, Pro Publica ~ obtained the tax record of the 20 richest Americans and calculated what they call a true tax rate.
00:04:11.465 --> 00:04:25.031
so essentially, these are taxes paid measured against the growth of their wealth over the same period, not against reported income, since reported income is not where most of the gains sit.
00:04:25.240 --> 00:04:34.978
So between 2014 and 2018, those 25 people saw their collective wealth grow by $401 billion.
00:04:35.238 --> 00:04:39.802
They paid $13 billion in federal income taxes.
00:04:39.802 --> 00:04:41.165
over the same period.
00:04:41.165 --> 00:04:46.807
In simple arithmetic, that is a true tax rate of 3.4%.
00:04:47.028 --> 00:04:59.375
Jeff Bezos, across a longer window from 2006 to 2018, saw his wealth grow, I believe by around $127 billion.
00:04:59.375 --> 00:05:03.458
His true tax rate over the years was 1.1%.
00:05:04.439 --> 00:05:08.992
I also want to be precise about what that number is and what it is not.
00:05:08.992 --> 00:05:19.327
A true tax rate measured against wealth growth is not the same measurement as the tax burden an ordinary household pays against its incomes.
00:05:19.327 --> 00:05:22.701
So here is the actual mechanism stated plainly.
00:05:22.701 --> 00:05:28.704
The tax code taxes realized income, so money you have actually taken.
00:05:28.704 --> 00:05:33.148
It does not tax the rise in value of an asset you still hold.
00:05:33.148 --> 00:05:36.209
That rule exists for ordinary people too.
00:05:36.209 --> 00:05:46.047
The value of your house is not taxed in most countries as it appreciates, and it is a defensible rule in the abstract.
00:05:46.047 -->
Load full transcript
00:05:58.745
But at the scale of a founder's shareholding, the same rule means the growth I just described, hundreds of billions of dollars can sit untaxed indefinitely.
00:05:58.745 --> 00:06:10.153
While the person building it borrows against the value to fund whatever they need to fund, using it as collateral rather than income without ever triggering the tax.
00:06:10.153 --> 00:06:13.165
The rest of us pay on money we actually spend.
00:06:13.165 --> 00:06:21.278
That borrowing route is smaller in total scale, but it is quite real and it is also documented.
00:06:21.278 --> 00:06:23.978
The rule was written for a family home.
00:06:23.978 --> 00:06:25.959
It was not written for this.
00:06:25.959 --> 00:06:36.983
A meritocracy that lets the largest fortunes in a country grow for decades without ever being taxed as income is not rewarding output.
00:06:36.983 --> 00:06:44.221
It is exempting position using a rule built for someone else's circumstances entirely.
00:06:44.221 --> 00:06:45.812
Let's look at the pay record.
00:06:45.812 --> 00:06:57.608
If merit sets your price, the ratio between what a company's leadership is paid and what is workforce is paid should track the value each side is actually contributing.
00:06:57.608 --> 00:07:08.512
In 1965, the chief executive of a major, say, US company earned~ about 21 times what a typical worker at that company earned.
00:07:08.512 --> 00:07:12.764
In 2025 The ratio was three hundred twenty five to one.
00:07:12.764 --> 00:07:13.663
So hear this.
00:07:13.663 --> 00:07:23.026
Between nineteen seventy-eight and twenty twenty-five, top executive compensation rose by one thousand three hundred and sixteen percent.
00:07:23.026 --> 00:07:29.269
Typical worker compensation over the same period, basically forty seven years.
00:07:29.269 --> 00:07:30.918
Rose by twenty eight percent.
00:07:30.918 --> 00:07:45.072
Listen, I'm not here to argue that a chief executive in 2025 is doing fifteen times more of the job their predecessors were doing in 1965 relative to the workforce that they carry.
00:07:45.072 --> 00:07:47.853
and the gap did not open because the work changed.
00:07:47.853 --> 00:07:58.639
The economist, and I don't want to butcher their names, ~ but Lucian Bebchuk and Jesse Freid named the mechanism quite plainly.
00:07:58.639 --> 00:08:06.940
Executive pay is said by boards that chief executive has substantial influence over appointing.
00:08:06.940 --> 00:08:13.644
Advised by compensation consultants, those same executives hire and can replace.
00:08:13.684 --> 00:08:19.110
That is not a market discovering merit through arm's length bargaining.
00:08:19.110 --> 00:08:31.182
it is a negotiation between a person and the people who owe their seats to him, pricing itself by proximity to power rather than output.
00:08:31.182 --> 00:08:35.966
listen, I've had a lot of conversations with people who are meritocracy defenders.
00:08:35.966 --> 00:08:46.374
And oftentimes quite a number of them will grant the tax points and the pay points and still insist that opportunity itself, the starting line is open.
00:08:46.374 --> 00:08:48.003
So let's look at the starting line.
00:08:48.003 --> 00:08:55.139
I'm using this case because it's well documented and not to claim that every institution runs identically.
00:08:55.139 --> 00:09:01.485
But let's look at litigation over admission ~ at Harvard University and what it forced into public.
00:09:01.485 --> 00:09:20.184
So litigation over admissions at Harvard forced into public record on that discovery the actual data on legacy applicants, so basically children of alumni, and they examined them between 2014 and 2019.
00:09:20.184 --> 00:09:28.149
They saw that legacy applicants were admitted at I think they're almost 34%, I think 33.6%.
00:09:28.149 --> 00:09:35.441
Non legacy applicants at the same institutions in the same years were admitted at roughly one sixth of that rate.
00:09:35.441 --> 00:09:46.486
The grounded and nuanced version of this finding, I do want to be honest about that version, is that legacy applicants tend to already be strong candidates.
00:09:46.486 --> 00:09:48.567
That may very well be true.
00:09:48.567 --> 00:09:55.751
So of course the multiplier is not evidence that ~ unqualified people are walking through the door.
00:09:55.831 --> 00:09:57.572
I think it's actually worse than that.
00:09:57.572 --> 00:10:10.336
It means that among a pool of people who are already competitive on the merit the institution claims to be selecting for, birth still functions as the deciding factor.
00:10:10.817 --> 00:10:13.998
Merit gets you into contention.
00:10:13.998 --> 00:10:17.698
Ancestry decides who wins the tiebreaker.
00:10:17.698 --> 00:10:21.019
That is not a system rewarding output over origin.
00:10:21.019 --> 00:10:38.572
That is a system where origin decides the outcome precisely at the moment when merit has already been equalized, which is one moment that meritocracy's own logic says should stop mattering entirely, but it doesn't stop mattering.
00:10:38.572 --> 00:10:39.984
It actually does matter.
00:10:39.984 --> 00:10:49.178
And I think there's something about the finding that should also worry us because it is not about billioniers or Ivy League admission offices.
00:10:49.178 --> 00:10:54.722
I think it really is about whether the whole promise still functions for anyone at all.
00:10:54.722 --> 00:11:02.269
the economist Raj Chetty and his colleagues measured what they call absolute income mobility.
00:11:02.269 --> 00:11:06.712
The share of children who essentially grow to earn more than their parents did.
00:11:06.712 --> 00:11:11.297
Incomes compared at the same age across different generations.
00:11:11.297 --> 00:11:16.761
For children born in nineteen forty, that share was approximately ninety percent.
00:11:16.761 --> 00:11:22.668
For children born in nineteen eighties, It had fallen to approximately fifty percent.
00:11:22.668 --> 00:11:32.761
For
sons specifically, the comparable figures are 95% for those born in 1940 and 41% for those born in 1984.
00:11:32.761 --> 00:11:43.265
Economists are still arguing over how much of that fall is mobility failing and how much is timing of when income gets measured across a career.
00:11:43.265 --> 00:11:50.558
The argument, of course, is legitimate, and I am not going to pretend that it is settled because it is not settled.
00:11:50.596 --> 00:11:54.239
What is not argued enough though is the top line number itself.
00:11:54.239 --> 00:11:58.402
Peer reviewed and unrevised since publication.
00:11:58.402 --> 00:12:01.984
So this is not a story about people who are falling behind.
00:12:01.984 --> 00:12:04.239
It is closer to a coin flip.
00:12:04.239 --> 00:12:15.676
A child born in this era has roughly even odds of doing better than their parents did, an outcome that used to be close to guaranteed.
00:12:15.677 --> 00:12:21.221
Meritocracy's core promise is that the ladder rewards climbing.
00:12:21.221 --> 00:12:27.067
the ladder itself is failing to deliver on the terms is set for its own success.
00:12:27.109 --> 00:12:33.351
And it is failing the moment you start looking at tax records and the pay records.
00:12:33.351 --> 00:12:38.227
also want to be clear that every data I have used for this argument today comes from the US.
00:12:38.227 --> 00:12:57.291
Mainly because the US data on this is the most publicly documented ~ record because they've often been forced into daylight by litigation and by investigative reporting That essentially pried open tax records nobody wanted anyone else to see.
00:12:57.298 --> 00:13:00.091
But this is not limited to the US.
00:13:00.091 --> 00:13:06.034
Oxfam has a global data that tells you that this is not just an American story.
00:13:06.034 --> 00:13:21.822
Billionaire wealth has grown by$2.5 trillion globally in 2025 alone, Which is basically a sum that is close to the entire wealth held by the poorest half of humanity.
00:13:21.822 --> 00:13:25.614
Over four billion people combined.
00:13:25.636 --> 00:13:31.659
In today's world there are more than three thousand billionaires, I believe, in for the first time.
00:13:31.659 --> 00:13:39.918
Wherever a society tells itself that position is earned, the same three mechanisms are essentially worth checking.
00:13:39.960 --> 00:13:50.296
What the tax code actually exacts, what the pay setting mechanism actually rewards, And what the entry actually filters for.
00:13:50.356 --> 00:13:55.673
No matter how we turn it around, And who wields meritocracy as a weapon?
00:13:55.875 --> 00:13:58.697
The architecture continues to repeat itself.
00:13:58.748 --> 00:14:02.399
So let's look at this from my three clarities framework lens.
00:14:02.399 --> 00:14:04.500
So let's look at identity clarity.
00:14:04.500 --> 00:14:08.883
Who does the word meritocracy actually serve?
00:14:08.883 --> 00:14:11.563
It doesn't serve the people who are working hardest.
00:14:11.563 --> 00:14:24.629
Since the data I just also discussed showed that effort and output have been decoupled from each other, and they have been decoupled from reward at literally every level.
00:14:24.847 --> 00:14:40.001
Meritocracy serves the people actually already holding positions because the word gives them a story in which their position required no explanation beyond their own virtue or their own sense of having worked hard.
00:14:40.001 --> 00:14:53.472
Michael Young, the person who coined the term meritocracy, named exactly this group in nineteen fifty eight before it fully existed and before it exists as it currently does now.
00:14:53.472 --> 00:14:55.278
So let's look at context clarity.
00:14:55.278 --> 00:14:57.143
How does the word maintain itself?
00:14:57.143 --> 00:15:05.860
It maintains itself through the same move every word that is used to launder or justify harm makes.
00:15:05.860 --> 00:15:07.861
It offers just enough true cases.
00:15:07.861 --> 00:15:14.913
You know, the founder who did build something from nothing, the scholarship students who did decline and succeeded.
00:15:14.913 --> 00:15:18.390
And it makes that exception feel like the rule.
00:15:18.390 --> 00:15:22.433
Every meritocracy needs its visible exceptions.
00:15:22.433 --> 00:15:28.852
They are not evidence against the arguments that They're essentially the cover story for the argument.
00:15:28.852 --> 00:15:30.594
So let's talk power clarity.
00:15:30.594 --> 00:15:31.514
Who benefits?
00:15:31.514 --> 00:15:32.693
Who pays?
00:15:32.693 --> 00:15:41.096
The people who benefit are the ones the tax record, the pay record, and the admission records all point towards together.
00:15:41.096 --> 00:15:49.500
The people who pay are everyone told that your position, whatever your position is, is a fair reflection of what they are worth.
00:15:49.500 --> 00:16:01.311
and who therefore experience every failure to rise as a personal verdict rather than as a mechanism working exactly as it was designed to work.
00:16:01.360 --> 00:16:09.702
And listen, I as usual, I believe that we should be able to name systems in which we exist in even when we benefit from those systems.
00:16:09.702 --> 00:16:11.740
So I will name my own position.
00:16:11.740 --> 00:16:13.524
I am an economist.
00:16:13.524 --> 00:16:16.683
I have been educated in a lot of these institutions.
00:16:16.683 --> 00:16:26.547
I run businesses and consultancies that advise organizations on exactly the kind of selection mechanisms that this episode is naming.
00:16:26.547 --> 00:16:35.591
I believe that we do it as fairly and equitably as possible, but that doesn't remove us from our participation in the system.
00:16:35.610 --> 00:16:39.005
So I also want to say I am not describing this from the outside.
00:16:39.005 --> 00:16:46.687
I am describing this as a system that I have had to learn to see clearly while standing in the rooms where it operates.
00:16:46.687 --> 00:16:48.965
And listen, what
does this actually require of us?
00:16:48.965 --> 00:16:54.934
I'm not gonna tell you that the answer is working harder because you can work your ass off and still not climb.
00:16:54.934 --> 00:17:04.905
And from what the data tells us over forty seven years, it shows that working harder stopped being the variable that actually matters.
00:17:04.957 --> 00:17:14.949
And at the same time I'm not gonna tell you that the answer is despair, because despair is what a system wants from people he it has already decided will not rise.
00:17:14.949 --> 00:17:15.990
So what can you do?
00:17:15.990 --> 00:17:29.471
If you sit in a room where pay is set, where hiring happens, where admission decisions get made, The concrete act that is available to you is naming that mechanism out loud before the decision is finalized.
00:17:29.652 --> 00:17:32.834
Ask what the tiebreaker actually was.
00:17:32.834 --> 00:17:37.256
Ask whether the criteria apply to everyone equally.
00:17:37.471 --> 00:17:41.605
And ask if that criteria would have produced the same outcome.
00:17:41.645 --> 00:18:00.825
Sometimes a simple question like that asked consistently by enough people with a seat at the table is the closest thing to friction this kind of system has because it currently runs on nobody asking sufficiently persistently all the time.
00:18:00.827 --> 00:18:07.573
If you do not sit in that room where decisions are made, the lever is not individual and it was never going to be.
00:18:07.573 --> 00:18:16.759
Every gain the record shows on wages relative to executive pay came from collective bargaining, not from individual workers negotiating harder.
00:18:16.759 --> 00:18:25.384
Every gain on tax fairness came from public pressure sustained long enough to force legislative change.
00:18:25.384 --> 00:18:28.934
Not from a single taxpayer filing more honestly.
00:18:28.934 --> 00:18:34.480
The mechanism responds to organized weight, organized pressure.
00:18:34.480 --> 00:18:41.926
It has never once responded to a single person trying to outmerit it, and that I'm pretty sure of.
00:18:41.979 --> 00:18:44.013
So this is where I'll leave this one, you know?
00:18:44.013 --> 00:18:58.507
Michael Young spent his whole life watching people turn his warning into their excuse and we need to sit with what the record of meritocracy and the history of it, you know, says versus what it promises.
00:18:58.507 --> 00:19:00.049
I am a big fan of history.
00:19:00.049 --> 00:19:06.844
I'm a big fan of mapping how things come to be, even down to language.
00:19:06.844 --> 00:19:10.851
And then it helps us better understand how we move.
00:19:11.045 --> 00:19:27.416
clarity is a core focus of my work, and ~ it is present in you know how I think, how I demand accountability, how I rationalize and how I make decisions.
00:19:27.416 --> 00:19:34.251
So if this episode of course gave you something, send it to one person who needs to hear it, and of course follow along.
00:19:34.457 --> 00:19:36.971
so the next episode can find you too.
00:19:37.034 --> 00:19:40.781
Alright, I'm Chisom Udeze and this is Overnight Wisdom.
00:19:40.804 --> 00:19:42.185
See you next time.