TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Jesse Henry: Everything in your life started as a thought. The chair you're sitting in, the phone in your hand, the food in your fridge. Somebody thought it, said it out loud, and then convinced enough people to go build it. When the world shows up toxic, and it does, that didn't start at the factory, it started upstream. This is no tox and we're cleaning it up from the first thought all the way down to the last atom. Ken Cook, welcome to No Talks. Jess, it's great to be here. And I'm going to call you Jess, like your friends call you. Even though I'm just meeting you now, it feels like we're ⁓ brothers in arms already, brother. Awesome. I so appreciate you, Ken. You've got such an interesting background. When I was doing some research on you, it said you've been called one of the seven most powerful foodies on the planet, which I would love that title as well. But, you know, you co-founded EWG back in 1993. This has obviously become one of the go-to resources for Tens of millions of families trying to navigate a toxic world. You guys got the dirty dozen, the skin deep, and the tap water databases. These are tools that, you know, people I know personally, we use these tools every day. And I am one of those people. But I want to go back before all of that. You really came up as an agricultural policy guy, as a lobbyist, as a soil scientist. What were some of the first events that that really sparked? That early critical massive demand for sustainable food, sustainable water, and sustainable products. You know, I I think it was a combination of in college becoming aware of and engaged more in ⁓ agricultural science, soil science, agronomy generally, worked in a chemical analysis lab, ⁓ it was my master's thesis, was comparing two chemical analysis methods and really understanding at that time That this scientific background was going to be important to me, even though I might not become a bench scientist. And I it turned out I didn't become a bench scientist. The other thing I think that f fed into it was obviously background going to my uncle's farms in Missouri. I had two uncles who had cow calf operations and I would go down there. My dad died when I was five, but I was, you know, sort of scooped up by my aunts and uncles on the cook side of the family who were farm people. And an unusual kind of exposure for a St. Louis suburbs kid at that time to be spending summers and vacations. Generally, oftentimes at those farms. And then the environmental movement came along and they did all kind of blended together. The first Earth Day, I was at the University of Missouri, helped organize it a little bit, and was profoundly moved by this notion that everything's connected to everything else. And that's what really defines me as an environmentalist. I I love the intellectual pursuit of those connections. And then to me, once you've intellectually made those connections, it's hard for your heart not to follow and think, well, you know, we we're here on this big beautiful blue marble that's right behind me on the screen for a very limited amount of time. ⁓ how am I gonna make use of it? And I just decided early on as environmentalism was developing and it still is, this was something that really called out to me. This was a a profession, an avocation that I thought was going to be nourishing for the long term. a precocious insight for a a smart Alecky college kid at the time, but but it's borne out. And ⁓ so then I went to Washington. I got to do some agricultural policy work right away and you know, I was kind of hooked on that connection. And only later kind of the the policy work became much more difficult, much stronger headwinds to get things done in Washington. That's when ⁓ a lot of these tools that you mentioned That were developed by my smarter colleagues at EWG that I was fortunate to hire, that's when that really sort of took hold. And that's why I say, you know, environmentalism is still evolving. I s I believe it is. It's not the environmentalism I came up with in the 70s and the eighties when we were passing environmental laws all the time. It's an environmentalism that's much more intimate. It's not to give up on law and regulation. We need those structures, we need those frameworks, but we know now the limits. of all kinds that we can't wait for a policy to come along. We have to make changes ourselves and change marketplaces, change st state law and regulation. It can't just be one Clean Air Act after another, right? It's just changed in that way. And partly because we're you know, we've been successful as a movement. We've regulated a lot of industries. They noticed and they started spending a lot of money pushing back, whether it's agrochemicals, pesticides, energy, you name it, the immune system of the regulated industries has really kicked in in the past fifteen to twenty years that I've been active, maybe even a little longer. And so now I think what we're trying to do is refashion environmental responses, bring in the personal piece of it, bring in the, you know, the accountability of of companies, a lot of good companies out there that are on our side, they're trying to do the right thing. They don't have guideposts always. ⁓ they don't always compete very effectively against their cheaper, dirtier competitors. So there's lots of issues there. But by and large, I think the cultural war has been won. We're gonna try and make the environment more sustainable. We're gonna make our lives healthier, more holistic, we're gonna be eliminating toxins wherever we can from our environment. That's the cultural, that's the tip of the cultural spear. That hasn't changed, but a lot of the mechanics have. A lot slower now, brother. A lot slower. Yeah, I get it, man. And I actually want to dive into the immune system in a little bit. But as a millennial, I find it so interesting. Where did all of these things start? That's a a lot of what what I'm asking myself. It looks like you were
Load full transcript
one of the principal architects of some of the conservation provisions in the nineteen eighty five farm bill. This was before I was even a thought, before I was even a zygote or an embryo. Which, you know, a lot of people don't think back that far. So that was a huge win at the time in nineteen eighty-five. For the first time ever, you know, US farm policy it moved beyond just grow more crops and really started weaving in soil and water and wildlife protection. So walk us through what that battle felt like on the inside, what you were up against, and how some of those experiences really planted the seed for what eventually became EWG. Yeah. I mean, that's exactly how it did unfold. I was working as a freelance writer. had just left working at the Library of Congress as a policy analyst in agriculture policy was a very difficult time for the agriculture economy. We had tractor cades on the mall, plowing up the mall in Washington, DC because farmers were protesting the low prices they'd overexpanded too quickly, the prices dropped, the incomes dropped. ⁓ farm suicide rates were up. It was a really intense time. This is you know sort of mid-1970s and 73, 74, 75, right around in there, this was a farm crisis. And I came in with an environmental background, a soil science background, a natural resource background, and most of the attention was being focused on the economic needs of agriculture, not the longer-term resource needs. This is a common situation, right? We always put off the resource and environmental questions and focus and I I get it. I knew dozens and dozens of farmers who were in this stress. But that gave us an opportunity to say, okay, if there's going to be a big intervention on the part of taxpayers to bail out these farmers, help them out, get them through this tough time. Are there some ways we can add some rules and regulations That are linking the subsidies to environmental performance. You'll have to develop a plan if you're gonna continue to farm h highly erodible, fragile cropland. You won't be able to get a subsidy if you're gonna plow up wetlands ⁓ or fragile prairie lands. And at that time, the farm industry agreed with those deals and we had strong s bipartisan support. Republican Bill Armstrong from Colorado, Senator out there, he was one of the strongest advocates of saying we don't wanna create more crop surpluses by plowing up this fragile eastern Colorado rangeland. We're paying twice. Once we're paying the farmers with the subsidies and once we're paying for the environmental damage and the degradation of the resource for future generations. So there's a lot of really ⁓ bipartisan and conservative thinking in the best sense of the broadest sense anyway. What do we do with this investment? What do we want for the long term for the land, for the families on the land, for quality of the environment, since agriculture was such a big contributor to water pollution and loss of endangered species. It was a very exciting time. But again, the context, ⁓ Jess, was ⁓ you know, this is when we were still passing major environmental laws. Laws we couldn't pass today. You couldn't pass the Clean Air Act today. You couldn't pass the indeed because ⁓ what has happened is because we had those laws and we had industry pushing back, you know, the experiment was getting scary for some big companies, big industries. The scary part was that regulation was working and they were still making money, and that opened the door, they thought, to more regulation. So the problem was it worked. Economy continued to grow, we continued to have technical advances, continued to have rising incomes and so forth, but but we were also at the same time dealing with air pollution and water pollution. These Gross manifestations of industrial activity that had just been ignored without the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Safe Drinking Water Act, reforms in the pesticide area. All of these were coming along in the seventies and eighties, and the reaction to that hit in the nineties. There's been pushback ever since. We're in a different Again, people want these things. If you ask Republican rank and file, they want to get rid of they don't want pollution. They want they want healthy kids. They want you know the they don't want hormone disruption. They don't want stuff in their food that might pose a risk. But at the political level, and this is not just Republicans, it's Democrats as well, but mostly it it hardened the lines hardened most on Republican side. You have a gap between what rank and file voters think and what their leadership thinks, because at the leadership level that's where industry has spent so much time and so much money and made it im you know, in some in some ways you know, impossible to even run for office if you have too much of an agenda that looks like it's pro-environmental, might be inclined toward regulation. And you then you see even extreme examples of it. I mean look at the if you look at climate investments over the past ⁓ five years, particularly at the end of the Biden administration when some of those big infrastructure laws and investment laws came to play, everyone thought that because so many of the investments were in red states and red districts, that they would be sustained. But You had an election and lo and behold, even those investments that were, you know, leading to ribbon cuttings and tens of thousands of jobs and investments and local local taxes, the con the the bread and butter for politicians, right? This is all good stuff. But at the leadership level, that was considered to be too partisanly democratic. Most of those investments are big a great number of them have been wiped out, even in red states and red districts. So we're in a perilous moment. Kind of lost sight of the ability, obviously, to work together, work toward a common cause, and even work a cause that does butter your bread politically locally, right? If you can't build an EV plant or
can't build a battery plant or a solar panel plant in your district, because those types of energy resources are somehow identified as partisan and democratic and you're a Republican, we're in trouble, right? We're in big trouble. Because in China and other places where they don't don't worry about these political these narrow political distinctions They're just going gangbusters ahead and and making the investments and overtaking us. So the politics, the environmental politics have gotten much more complicated, you know, much more bothersome to me anyway. I came up in a time when I mean, you know, we had enormously valuable allies on both sides of the aisle. I mean Republicans who literally would take you under their wing and say, Okay, I don't think some in my caucus are gonna go for this, but here's how to reach the folks in the middle. I wanna get this done, we wanna protect natural resources, we want a you know, a a Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act amendment that really really cleans up these industries. But that's Very rare now at at the federal level. The closest we've had recently, and then I'll I'll let you get to your next question, but the closest we've had recently was on these PFAS chemicals, these forever chemicals. It's faded a little bit now, that bipartisan support at the federal level. But for a while there, it really was a breakthrough because these chemicals are so bad, so many health effects, so ubiquitous in our world, in our bodies from the birth, that Republicans you know, you could tell Republicans saying, you know, this this may be Democrats talking to me about this mostly, but this ain't right. We've got to do something about this. And and it was everywhere. It was, you know, it wasn't respecting congressional district lines that have been drawn to gerrymander. It was everywhere that ⁓ bo were getting contaminated. And so you do see these important moments where people can come together and overcome these tribal distinctions and divisions. But they're just too rare. Now that's why it's so important to have some of the other tools at our disposal to engage you know, help people help themselves, make these small wins, these small victories in their personal behavior and how they deal with ⁓ toxins in their homes and their families' exposures. That gets so exciting. And also where so many companies are saying, Hey, I'm gonna make money making cleaner products. I'm gonna make money with cleaner processes. And I know your your background is heavily in that area. Seeing the power of that. I was late to see it. I confess. You know, I wanted to be Ralph Nader. Let's regulate the right and right. And it does work. ⁓ you know, it gotten to the point where it's harder and harder to do. And it turns out, you know, it wouldn't be the preference for me. I don't wake up every morning wondering who I can regulate. I wake up every morning wondering, ⁓ how do we make progress getting chemicals, these toxic chemicals out of food? And it turns out The engine of the marketplace right now is more reliable for trying to do that than in many cases than than any government agency. It's our own agency that's more. Absolutely. And it's what I learned in the industrial sector is until you change consumer behavior, it's very difficult to get these changes. You're so right, Ken. Like the window of Republicans that are supporting these causes is less and less. But you do have, you know, senators like Joni Ernst, you have some people in Congress. There's I forget who the Republican is that's supporting the No Immunity for Glyphosate Act, but there are some bipartisan movements, but it seems like you're referring to this this eternal immune system. Yeah. That is that is conflicting with the things that consumers want. But you mentioned the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act. These are things that are so bipartisan in nature. And so when they all passed by back in the day, again, this is before you're, you know, th this is when you were an maybe an idea. They all passed by massive bipartisan margins. And we're experiencing some great successes here in California, where I'm I'm calling in from now. We have a very active policy team here in California in Sacramento and have had for years and we've passed thirty plus bills that have advanced environmental protection here in the state. It's a different politics, obviously, than other states or n or even nationally. But still, you you can still see there are strong interest with Republicans. When we went after ultra-processed foods, the guy who led the charge here in California, Democrat Jesse Gabriel, ⁓ Assembly member, he he was the kind of politician who wanted it to be bipartisan. And so he went out and recruited and and connected with all kinds of Republicans, and most of his bills passed with strong bipartisan support. So it's still possible. Comes down to people and personalities oftentimes. If you can push through the tribal stuff, it's very it's very exciting. It make you know, ⁓ gives me that warm and fuzzy feeling because I remember it from back in the day when you would have Republican leaders on the floor of the House and Senate taking your amendment as their own. And if we can get back to that point, ⁓ that would be very exciting. But until we do, we have to do some other workarounds. We have to change the market. That's an exciting prospect. Absolutely. Let's dive into really like the first steps at EWG. So fast forward from nineteen eighty five. Now we're at nineteen ninety-three. You co found this with Richard Wiles. Yep. And the first thing you guys publish is a report on pesticides in children's food. Yeah. I didn't focus on subsidy or policy stuff. But baby food. Walk us walk us through why you started there, what you found, and what happened when that report hit the public. When I had started the organization, but I consider Richard the co founder, even though I Hired him early on, and I hired him to do work on pesticides. And
he was one of the leading thinkers in the field in the public interest world, but also at the National Academy of Sciences. He had come from the academy where he did a lot of the staff work, lead staff person on a landmark report that came out the same time our first report came out. There was a bit of a lag because of political opposition. And so Richard stepped away from the academy, did a few other things, and then joined EWG. It was really his expertise and his creativity. I always called him the Michael Jordan of EWG. You know, you just put the guy in the game and he's gonna before you know it, everyone's gonna be looking at him like, Holy cow, how did we do that? Well that was all Richard in my view. And Richard, you know, his take was that we could go at this pesticide issue that at that point it had been after the Alar scare. ⁓ pesticide reform advocates were kind of in retreat because Alar got too hot, and I just encourage anyone to look at the sixty minutes episode, ⁓ also probably before your time, ⁓ that had ⁓ had run I guess it was ⁓ nineteen nineteen eighty nine. It scared people. ⁓ Alar was a an ingredient that was used in apple orchards. It was used as a growth regulator and It was carcinogenic and there was a sixty minute story that scared people because the acting head of EPA said we would never let this chemical on the market now if it was new, but because it's been on the market for a while, it's grandfathered in, we can't get rid of it. And moms all all over the country were saying, What? And they weren't Maha moms quite yet, but they're the predecessors, right? Moms have always been central to the environmental movement. Let's just stuff stipulate that. We welcome the maha moms and dads now. To join it and ⁓ it's exciting ⁓ that they have, but you know, early on that was the environment and the the pushback from the pesticide industry was this is too scary. People were throwing out their apple juice, schools were stopping serving apples, all these responses that were, you know, unnecessary, but you could understand the emotion of it. And we didn't support throwing out the food, we just supported getting the chemicals out of it. And again, it's chronic exposures. You You know, over time y you accumulate these risks, but in the short term, we should have just acted. And ultimately EPA did on that chemical, but it it introduced a period where the pesticide industry was really in control of the debate. Environmentalists had gone too far, they'd scaremongered, ⁓ the chemical wasn't that bad. Well, it was that bad. And it turned out that that was when Richard came along and he had this way of using data and analysis and showing that children weren't just the same as they weren't just little adults, they were growing rapidly. Their brains were developing, their nervous systems were developing. Everything about them made them more vulnerable during that explosive period of growth to any toxic chemical they might be exposed to. So we
needed to start regulating pesticides to keep kids safe. That was really the breakthrough. ⁓ Phil Landrighan, the great ⁓ public health ⁓ leader, Dick Jackson, his colleague on the National Academy, when they released their report that made that case, we released our report, Pesticides and Children's Food. That was our first report, and it was on the front page of papers all over the country. ⁓ that was a great way to start. And back in the day, y you know, we got the hang of it. We thought, let's let's produce research that that breaks through in the media. Let's not take the media for granted. Let's do original research. Let's start hiring number crunchers who could go and get raw data, which has been a hallmark of our work for thirty plus years, really from since our founding. I think I was one of the first ⁓ nonprofit leaders to hire a database manager, and then I hired three more. And they would go into these big government data files that no one ever saw and pull out this incredible information, build databases that ultimately would We began making them available on what became the World Wide Web, ⁓ you know, in the late nineties. When all that unfolded, we were at the you know, we were right there ready to apply it to public interest civil justice issues, environmental justice issues too. And as we did that, you know, we produced things that we thought might be good for policy, but it turned out they were most powerful with everyday people. ⁓ The Dirty Dozen Guide to Pesticides and Produce, we wanted to tell people, look, these are the fruits and vegetables that tend to have the most pesticides on them. There are lots of ways you could calculate that and so forth. We came up with one. We just revised it last last couple of years. And we basically said if you can find an afford organic for these particular fruits and vegetables, oftentimes it's apples and strawberries and a few other occur every year in our in our list, do it. But if you can't, maybe you should look at some of the fruits and vegetables that because of the timing of the application of the pesticide or the nature of it, ⁓ they just are lower from a dietary exposure standpoint, ⁓ f less exposure. And that's not to say the farm workers growing them weren't exposed to pesticides when they grew them and so forth. We acknowledge all of that. That's an i a big issue, but at least From your dietary exposure was going to be down. And that those kinds of reports, then we did the same thing for personal care products. We looked at the ingredients in personal care, built big databases there. We built big databases on drinking water quality from data that EPA required utilities to to collect, but wasn't readily available nationwide. We built that and and many more. Food scores were that's driving the debate now on ultra-processed food. And so it's just been It's been an interesting evolution for us. Again, I don't think of myself as a a n a neo liberal who thinks markets can solve all the problems. I was late to realize the power of consumers in the marketplace. It really was only when the internet came along, since we had all these techies, we had all the data servers, all the analysis was in-house. It was all handmade and homemade, right? At EWG. So we were very close to it. And when we started seeing the traffic coming in, building up. We realized, okay, you know, we hope that if we show Congress that there are lots of chemicals and personal care products, maybe it's time to revisit a law that hasn't been reauthorized and given a fresh makeover since the since Roosevelt was in the White House. Maybe it's time. Same with same with pesticides and same with with drinking water. Once we started doing that and saw people responding, we thought, well, you know We're not making the headway we thought we'd make in the eighties and seventies. I think everybody in the movement thought we'll just keep reauthorizing these laws as the science unveils new dimensions of the problem, right? But that didn't happen. Those laws didn't get reauthorized and so what do you do? Well, I think you you go directly to consumers and you say, you know, you don't have to you don't have to have ⁓ all this stuff in your personal care products. There are there are choices out there. We find more and more of them now, and I think we helped in support companies that wanted to do that. Same with food. You know, you have choices out there. You can avoid some of these toxic exposures and have a perfectly healthy diet, maybe even more. So just finding those everyday workarounds. You know, if if you were an environmentalist in the 70s or maybe even eighties, Jess, let's come up with a policy fixer of that problem. And I'm not saying we shouldn't still be thinking that way. I don't want to turn the policy debate, the regulatory debate over to, you know, the vested interests that are pushing back in the other direction. I we're contesting it still, the field. But we realize then that the internet that gave you that very granular relationship with millions, potentially millions of people at a very low entry cost. When that finally dawned on us, and I'll say I was one of the last on our team to really ⁓ fully embrace it, but once we did get it, we realized this is you know, there's there's a culture out there that's hungry for this. And you're exactly right. It's not a democratic culture, it's not a progressive culture, it's not it's a it cuts across all lines. You know, all lines of race and gender and economic status and political persuasion. It's just people out there you know, really want this. Kennedy has tapped into that, I think, extremely effectively, right? That's why so many people crossed over and gave him gave him a listen because he was speaking their language and we had seen it in polling going back decades. People have been concerned about clean food, you know, ever since we first started looking at polls in the eighties and nineties. I mean it was
obvious that people didn't want pesticides in their food. Thank you very much. I I'd I'll I'll have I'll have the Cheerios without the Roundup on it. That's just me, but you know, that's I'll have the, you know, personal care products that don't have the endocrine disruptors or the mild carcinogens if I've got a choice. And and once people start looking for those choices, companies come in and say, I can make I can make something better. Yeah. I can make something better. And once that dynamic starts, we're jumping ahead probably a little bit, but you know, now there's a lot of pressure on ⁓ tr trying to tamp down these sort of non-economic signals that companies are trying to send in the ESG world and and also just in marketing, like let's no, no, let's just take care of of making things of high quality and affordable. Let's not worry about the other attributes like whether they're toxic or whether they have a carbon footprint or whatever. And I think that's threatening to companies because that they can't control. There's a communication directly to consumers who are saying, you know, I i if there's a way I can cut my carbon footprint and, you know, heat my home, drive my car, I wanna take a look at that. And that, you know, that's ultimately, you know, one of the most powerful forces we're relying on now during a period where to say the very least, we're not moving forward with ⁓ you know, better regulation, better policy, better federal investments, at least not here in the US. Yeah. But consumers are asking for it. And from what you're saying, it seems like it almost starts with the kids. Once you have a birthday, then the mothers are focused on what's in this lotion? What's in this baby formula? What am I putting on my baby's skin? How's that impacting their hormone production? And I feel like Ken, like the tools as EWG evolved, the tools like the Dirty Dozen and the Clean Fifteen, the Skin Deep Database, the Water Databases, these were the things that got me hyped because they're all free. They inform people And they actually change consumer behavior at scale. And when you have millions of people that are standing at the grocery store, they're now pulling out their phones, they're checking their strawberries, they're checking their sunscreen, they're checking everything in between. Walk us through how those tools really came to be and how you imagine consumers might react to those tools. Well, again, you know, you're exactly right. Back in the day, if you had a market-oriented ⁓ strategy to make social change happen, it was a boycott. That was the idea. Right? Not to invoke Cesar Chavez. He's ⁓ Has a a very different profile ⁓ as of a few months ago than he has now. But really that was the idea. If you had a problem with some social justice issue, you you didn't buy grapes. But when the internet came along and you could reach people with this much more granular information and they could start making decisions, suddenly it was boycotts, not boycotts, right? It was people just changing their purchasing patterns and they were doing it on a long, long tail of a curve where they could, you know. They they might d not do it in every aspect of their life, but by God they'd start with what's under their sink. So w we started looking at that. We would love to have policy changes that made all of it, the whole sector, cleaner by regulation. But if we can't get there, let's at least start telling people this stuff's looks to us with imperfect information, and it's imperfect largely because it's not been regulated, so there's no demand from federal agencies to submit safety and health data. ⁓ so we have to go to the open literature or to jurisdictions, sometimes Europe, sometimes South Korea, Japan, whatever, where they do have restrictions, we apply that science. And then s what pops up is a a set of products that kind of stand out for their health and safety above the rest. And once we saw that people were responding to that, even if we weren't as successful as we tried to be presenting this information to Congress and making the case that see this you know, people want this, you should modify the law, that's where industry was able to to choke things off and slow things down. So we spend time on that. We still push back. Every day I have people on the hill and in state legislatures across the country now who are, you know, making the case that we ought not to abandon law and regulation as a strategy. But the public is is way ahead. And it's it was amazing when we first put out the Skin Deep database. We first we had, I think something like ten thousand products in it, then we had fifty thousand. Before you know it, we ⁓ you know, up eighty, a hundred thousand products. The first I saw was on Amazon where people would say, Hey, you know, how I saw that this is given a good rating on EWG. Does it work for you? Just these conversations in the comments, right? And we didn't have we weren't selling anything online, but we saw that where others were. And then we started getting calls from from companies. And I remember very early on My colleagues who are on the science and technical side said, ⁓ these companies call and they're they're really angry with us. I said, What why what are they angry about? is it the companies we're rating red, the ones we're giving the worst rating to? It was like, ⁓ no, no, they don't call at all. They're not interested in t conversation with us. The people who are calling and are are on edge are the ones that have the the best rated products. Because they if we make any slight change They're relying on us for their marketing and part of their marketplace reputation, referring to us all the time. I didn't realize that. Then I started meeting with some of the heads of these companies. And you know, just to get to know them. And and it was astonishing that I came back to my colleagues and said, They're very friendly to me. I don't know why they're so grumpy with
you. Sort of CEO to CEO, they were saying, Look, we're trying to pursue the same mission, but as A for-profit we think you're pursuing as a nonprofit. And because you are a nonprofit and you own these standards, you've invented them, you've brought them into being, people trust you in a way they wouldn't trust a company. And we just want to know where are you going next? Because oftentimes our rating system, our the data we have, Jess, is limited. And I know you know this from your experience in the industrial world. On the surface, it might look like all the suppliers, all the vendors are equal, they're all doing the right thing, they're all working to certain standards, but the reality is much messier. And that's true of food, personal care products, all the rest, you know. A lot of these companies don't really have a deep scientific staff, and so they mostly marketing, they want to do the right thing, they want to have clean ingredients, but they don't know what the clean ingredients are, or they don't know as science changes, something that was considered clean a a short while ago, when a new study comes out, or maybe the European Union or regulators in Japan or in other countries say, well, this stuff might affect your endocrine system, so we're gonna place a restriction on it. We would bring that into our database, into our rating system, and it would could upset some of these companies. We did it and we tried to give them as much notice as we could, but the real lesson there was that these companies would adapt as best they could and as quickly as they could to what was considered to be and they considered our standard to be one that was robust enough that they wanted to chase after it. They wanted to be right there with us. And that was really eye opening for all of us, right? Then suddenly we thought, okay, well, so what if we're not making headway on Capitol Hill? We're seeing the web traffic. We're seeing that people are calling us from companies and saying, You're not going to change this ingredient rating, are you? Or have you seen this new rating coming out of the EU? What is that going to affect my product? Those kinds of conversations. And then we started our own certification, our EWG verified brand. This was a big leap for us. Mm-hmm. We decided, well, okay, we're limited now in personal care by what's on the label, the ingredients. We don't know anything about really how they formulate. They are not disclosing fragrance. It's a black box in the world of cosmetics regulation. It can be hundreds of chemicals can be hidden under the term fragrance, as you probably know from your background. Some of these industrial terms are shielded by intellectual property rights and NDAs and all the rest. So we started a system where all that would be disclosed and we'd added a layer of health and safety assessment. And companies, I think we have something like three thousand products in the program now. It's mattresses, it's diapers, it's personal care products of every kind. And that to us was also a revelation that companies would I mean, it's a pain in the ass to go through our system. I mean, it's really it's not the way if you were a CEO, you wouldn't pick that set of steps to take. You have to really want to do it, and a lot of them do, hundreds and hundreds of companies. I just feel like we're starting to unleash that across energy, food, personal care, cleaning products, right? You can't stop this because that's what people want. You know, people want clean energy if they can get it. They want healthy food if they can get it. So let's try and remove the barriers in their day-to-day lives so they can easily identify and make those changes. And you don't have to change everything at once. Don't sweat that you're Not perfect. Everything doesn't have to be organic. Everything doesn't have to be EWG verified. Let's teach people habits of mind, reading ingredient labels, finding trusted sources of information on toxics so they can make their own decisions. It does place the burden on individuals, oftentimes women, often moms. There are moments, great learning moments when you're starting a family or adding to it. As you said before, yes, that's a great learning moment. The other great learning moment is Bad news at the doctor's office. Yeah. And with those opportunities, a way to begin moving the economy in a cleaner direction that, you know, isn't necessarily waiting on law and regulation. It's moving faster than that. It's messy. There are different standards, you know, not as clean as one would like in every case. But that's been the revelation for us the past ten to fifteen years, where we have seen the private sector kick in and now we have all these incredible partners. Who, you know, are teaching us stuff. I mean, if you want to learn how to make a healthy fragrance, you go to Michelle Pfeiffer now, right? She's on our board. You go to her, she's like, Yeah, I decided I'm gonna make a pure, fine fragrance, fully disclose all the ingredients, and pass all of EWG's standards and other standards beyond. What she learned about how to source that raw ingredients, what she learned about formulation and so forth, we were able to learn from that too and understand. that it's a big deal to make stuff. It's risky. I mean, you know, y you develop an appreciation for the companies who are in any way, from farmers to perfume makers, making stuff and putting your name on it, putting it on the market, there's all kinds of risks to doing that. And the risks get even greater if you're trying to do it really right, because then everyone's looking at you extra careful and they're wondering is this all it's cracked up to be? Premium I need to be paying, whether it's organic food or an EWG verified mattress or personal care product or shampoo. It's extra money. Is it worth it? And then is that driving the whole sector toward cleaner? Is that moving the center point of competition in the
healthy direction? That's what, from your background I know, that's the holy grail, right? Where it just begins to happen because if you're not part of that process, you're left behind. Right. Yeah. And it seems like there's this big ripple effect, Ken, where it starts with negative health outcomes for human health or planetary health. Then it leads to more research. Research leads to more consumer behavior demand changes, which leads to more legislation. And it seems like this happens in big tranches where it's it's a specific chemical or material or toxin or pollutant. And one of them that we've mentioned is PFAS, forever chemical. So this is one of the biggest ongoing battles, presumably one that's fairly bipartisan at this point. EWG's data it shows 158 million Americans have tap water that's contaminated with PFAS. That's about half the country. Yeah. The EPAs finally like set these water limits in twenty twenty four, which was a win, but then within a year it seems like there's this pressure to roll back the limits. Just walk us through what the PFAS story was from when EWG first started tracking this and then what did it take to get those limits set and what's at stake right now if they get pulled? Yeah. Th these PFAS chemicals Came on our radar in 1999-2000. There was a story that broke in the New York Times that said 3M Company was going to change the formulation of his Scotchguard family of products, everything from post-it notes to tape to everything else, because there were some customers wanted other options. That was the first story in the New York Times. Second story in the New York Times, just a few days later, came after that reporter was called by EPA scientists who said, you know, this wasn't just a voluntary deal by 3M. And what unfolded then was this incredible story of a family of chemicals we had never heard of. Carbon chains are occupied to one degree or another by f fluorine atoms. And this makes a bond that is almost indestructible, doesn't break down, lasts for a long time, and bioaccumulates. Well We didn't know anything about that, and neither did EPA until they started finding out from litigation and documents that were dumped on the agency by a guy named Rob Ballot in West Virginia. The whole story is told in Dark Waters, starring Mark Ruffalo, another documentary, The Devil We Know, that I participated in. It turned into this nightmare that was well understood by the chemical. Manufacturers, DuPont and three ⁓ for decades. They had done testing, they had seen the problems, and they didn't tell anybody. Didn't tell the government. In the late nineties, early two thousands, I read this article, I went down the hall to colleagues and I said, I think we should be working on this chemical. What is this stuff? What Ballant did, the attorney did was he disclosed information that the companies had accumulated for decades really scary information. That was all reported in that second New York Times article in, I think it was May of 2000. And we went to work. Bird dog DPA found out what they had in their files. We had several PhD toxicologists looking at at it right away. And the long and the short of it was this was a family of chemicals that was widely used in the economy and was widely dispersed in the environment. And it was also Turning up in people. They had done studies, 3M and and Dupont had done studies to try and find out how widely this set of chemicals had contaminated the living world. And they found it everywhere. They found it in birds in the middle of the Pacific, on you know, endemic to tiny islands. They found it in beluga whales. They found it in people all over the planet. It was already in everybody by the time we even knew about it. It was there. And no one really knew all the exposure routes. Water seemed important. Food seemed important. Everyday products, it was shedding off of everyday products, fabrics, and so forth. Any number of ways that this family of chemicals was in our lives that we didn't know it, beginning in the womb. We did a study in two thousand three and we found these chemicals in umbilical cord blood, just as three ⁓ and DuPont had found. So as we started working on this, one of our first concerns was drinking water. How widely is it contaminating water supplies? And we talked, you know, as early as the early 2000s, we've tested drinking water around the country. I wonder if we should test for this stuff. And to tell you the truth, we were worried that we didn't have a good analytical method. Because here's the thing. These companies, not only do they not have to disclose, they should by law, they should disclose if they've found harmful effects, but they're not obligated to tell you how to find these chemicals in your bodies or in the air or water. That's the government's job. It's with microplastics now, right? Here we have a plastics industry that's been around for a century, and they're coming forward and saying, What we really need are methods to find this stuff in people and water. It's like, really? A century on with Whatever you have, a million scientists and engineers, you don't have a method for doing this? Come on. But anyway, so as the testing began, we asked ourselves, we might send this on the wrong track if we do a bunch of testing with a method that's not exquisite enough, not accurate enough, and get a bunch of false negatives back, people might think, well, this is not a big deal. So we backed off. I regret that now, but at the time, we weren't comfortable with the chemistry, with the analytical chemistry. That was My background, we had PhDs on the staff, had an even deeper, fresher background in it. But finally EPA started testing, and that's when the dam broke, because they found it everywhere. That's what we're reporting on our our map of PFAS contamination. And this just turned into, you know, something that bipartisan concern immediately crystallized around this. Well, why is this stuff in our
water? What can we do about it? It has all these health effects. You know, as you look at it, it's not just cancer, it's not just, you know, ⁓ neurodevelopmental, it's not just hormonal, it's all those effects. ⁓ it was so dangerous when they did some of the tests back in the 70s, eighties, and nineties in these company labs, they would expose animals to some of these chemicals. I remember one particular study, I think it was at 3M, might have been DuPont. They exposed the monkeys to these chemicals, our closest relatives, and the monkeys died during the experiment. Right? Like they didn't they didn't make it through to the sacrifice phase where you would look at their organs and see if there were tumors or anything. They frickin' died in the cage. And so this is stuff that shouldn't have been introduced into the living world, but it was. And so we pushed very hard, so did Rob Ballot, finally. EPA moved under the Biden administration finally and posed some really tough, tight limits at the part per trillion level, four parts per trillion. So we're we way beyond parts per billion now, a thousand times tighter than a part per billion, of course. And they set these limits. Two groups sued them the water utilities who didn't want to have to comply. They thought, you know, they push back, and the chemical companies that thought they might be liable. Those cases are still pending, but meanwhile those rules were finalized when the Trump administration came in. One of the first things they did was they pushed back the enforcement for two years on two of the main substances that were regulated under that rule. dozen others, four or five others, they just said we're not going to regulate those. We're going to take another look and before we decide. But this is a perfect example of where something was so overwhelmingly bad. And I know people are hoping climate will reach that point. It hasn't yet. But with chemicals it did. To your point earlier, this is something that's intimate. It's personal. It affects your health. It's much easier to understand than a melting ice cap. or a stranded polar bear or whatever it might be, or even a heat wave or a forest fire in some ways. It's it it affects everybody. And I think also people think we can do better than that. Do we really have to have an economy that has these chemicals, so many industries? Can't we invent our way out of it? And that's what's happening now. Other inventive powers are being trained on how to clean it up, get it out of water, get it out of soil, get it out of organic matter. That's coming along too. But The first thing that we saw, to go back to my theme about the market power, we started raising concerns. We were meeting with DuPont experts every few weeks. A good friend of mine who worked there brought them in and they wanted to know why we were so upset. And we said, Well, we're just reading your internal documents. Why why wouldn't we be upset? And they didn't really fully know where in the economy all of this stuff was being used. We didn't have a clear idea, this early 2000s, what the exposure routes were. But we started raising concerns. about Teflon coated pans. And before you know it, there were tags on nonstick pans, no PFOA, no PFOS. The cookware industry began responding right away. Buy stainless steel, buy cast iron, buy ceramic, don't buy nonstick because it might migrate into your food or come off the pan if it's overheated, expose you or kill your pet birds, which it does a good job of ⁓ when you overheat a Teflon pan. The first response a full decade before Anything happened with regulation on drinking water was in cookware. Right. And it seems like, Ken, like when you mention the water utilities and the chemical companies kind of fighting back against this, you're almost going back to what you described earlier in our conversation, which is this idea of an industry immune system that really kicks in the moment real change starts happening. You've seen it with PFAS and pesticides with GMO labeling. What does that immune system actually look like up close? And what are the sophisticated pushback mechanisms that you've personally face when EW research starts gaining real traction? Well, it's surprisingly similar across industries. It looks like, first of all, erecting a counter narrative that this isn't really a problem, or if it isn't a real problem, we need to spend more time researching it to see if it's a problem. So rather than avoiding the exposure, just when you don't know, rather than avoiding the exposure, I say just let's just go ahead with the exposure and we'll study it. And see what the impact is, right? So that's a divide right there. Then, you know, campaign contributions, lobbying. Anytime we go into a regulatory proceeding, for every environmentalist who dressed up for the day with a necktie, there's fifty suits from industry in that same proceeding, and they have more money, they have ⁓ access to members of Congress. They have I think done a very effective job and has been very deliberate. They've tried in a bipartisan way, but they've been especially effective, unfortunately, with Republicans, in making it very risky to be pro-regulation and survive a Republican primary. It's just very clear. And that's been the case since Gingrich, since Gingrich took over and flipped the Congress in ninety-two, and it's remained ever since. And so it's really hard to pry people away from that leadership. position that we don't regulate. EFAS was an exception and you saw people at least temporarily stepping away. And it's not as strong at the state level. You have more and more Republicans, to process food, food dyes, additives is a good example. Many Republicans now are waking up to the fact that food companies here are putting stuff in food that they don't put in the exact same foods just in Canada, much less in Europe or elsewhere. You know, no one seems to be going hungry in Canada or France or Germany or
Italy. I think th those the toolkit is consists of those course mechanisms and then a lot of investment in alternative science to not just in the regulatory system but independent studies. Some of those have been found to be problematic over time. When industry invests, sometimes they overstep. And help write the articles, help write design the studies and so forth. That happened recently with a a major paper that came out in defense of ⁓ glyphosate and roundup that was retracted, but was retracted decades late. And so all of these tools are at play. The basic dynamic though, Jess, is that people have decided, companies have decided that it's really pennies on the dollar to push back against law and regulation early on. And they learned their lesson that if they didn't do that early on and stop this momentum for government regulation early, then they had to comply. And it's interesting. In compliance, some companies win and some lose, right? If you have an innovative company that isn't so weighed down by capital investments that are hard to change, if you have a new company or a company that's more dynamic, has a deeper commitment to RD, you can invent your way out of it, and it's actually good to have, to your advantage economically, to have strong regulations and laws because you can compete against that and your fellow industry members can't. And so you get ahead. Cummins engine comes to mind, organic food comes to mind. There's lots of companies that have thrived managed to thrive. But overall I think the feeling in industry is we don't want regulation to proceed. We can metabolize it. We can still make money, but it just leads to more regulation when we do that. So those are the tools. It's propaganda. You know, a lot of money spent on lobbyists on the hill. You see that the explosion of corporate lobbying. And this was before Citizen United. Now it's even more out of control because of campaign contributions. And it just makes a difference when you can hire a former chief of staff in your lobbying firm who's worked with a congressman for decades. They're gonna get an audience and they're gonna walk into that congressional office with the promise of a a pack check or a contribution that will be made later, or let's do it why don't you come on a a junket with us, or why don't we have a big reception for you and celebrate whatever you want to celebrate and we'll bundle money for you there across industries. We don't have anything like that in the public interest world that we compete with, that raw power of money. Yeah. I want to dive into something, Ken, that you just mentioned about Canada and Italy and all these other countries. And it's really the gap between what is legal and what is safe. And it's something that I highlight oftentimes because legal does not mean safe. And there's 10,000 plus food additives that are allowed in the US, but many have been fully reviewed. Europe's banned something like 10,000 plus chemicals from where you sit after 30 years of doing this type of work. What's the single biggest gap right now between what's technically legal in our food, our water, our personal care products, and what science is actually telling us about safety? Yeah, you know, it's a good question. It varies across category of consumer goods or exposure scenarios, whether it's in your home or in something you put in your shopping cart. It varies by statute. Some statutes make it harder to avoid. They narrow that gap between what's legal and safe, but there are still gaps. Even the Clean Air Act, the queen of environmental The one that really works consistently. The regulations come out, although the Trump administration's trying to change that too. Every five years they review toxic chemicals in our air and oftentimes come up with new standards on a sort of maybe seven to eight year ⁓ interval, but they review it consistently. Even in the Clean Air Act, there's a contest every time, it's or it's contested every time. How low are you going to require companies to go to reduce soot and smog? And The thing that people often don't realize is that when we set a legal limit, underneath that legal limit, the limit that companies are obliged to do something around or violate the law, every time you set a legal limit, unless it's a ban of a chemical where it just makes it go away, generally speaking you have some harm at that legal limit, right? We feel like at EWG, we work in that oftentimes in that zone between what's legal and what's safe. And it's ⁓ it's true across drinking water contaminants. That's one where it's notorious where the government will come forward and say, Yeah, this is a level that's that won't hurt you if you drink it, which is the least we can hope for our water, I think, right? We're supposed to get so much of it. Yeah. Let's not have something that harms us in water if we can avoid it. But then they'll set the legal limit that regulates what utilities are required to do much higher than that health limit. That gap is enormous. It's true in pesticides, where from our standpoint we work to regulate pesticides. We try and A ban is appropriate, we go for that. We're reducing exposure in some fashion is appropriate. We will go for that at EWG. But the truth of the matter is the best approach is in most cases to not have the chemicals at all. That's why we recommend to people, if you can find it and afford it, organic is, you know, work that into your diet if you can, especially if you have little kids. Just eliminate that exposure scenario. And if you're smart with your, you know, food spending with your food budget, you can dramatically reduce these exposures, not just pesticides, but organic also has profound restrictions on additives you can use compared to other foods. All of those tips we try and walk people through just so that people feel that they have some agency, some ability to make a difference in their own life, because we know that this gap between what's
legal and safe is not going to be closed anytime soon by regulation, right? I mean I get up and I give talks, I'm sure you do too, and People ask, what should I do? And I don't know why, but it seems like half the people who come to my talks are pregnant women. I don't know why you come to one of my talks, but but maybe that's the moment where people thought maybe I should listen to this guy. But when that happens, I got to the point early on where I thought, I'm not gonna tell someone that the way to deal with PFAS, the only way to deal with it is is pass a a law and a regulation, 'cause now we're talking about not the baby that you're carrying, but maybe that baby's baby before anything happens. So let's figure out how do they get it out of their water? What foods can they avoid? What cookware can they avoid? It gets you into this space which I'm not always comfortable with. I have to say, we're putting a lot of responsibility that should really belong in the government's realm to regulate and keep us safe, but you're putting it on people. I don't relish doing that, but we just concluded that it would also be irresponsible to not apply our science and say, hey, you know, look, if you overheat a Teflon pan and those fumes come off, And even if it kills your pet canary in the next room, we know the fumes are there, we know they're bad. You might come up with flu like symptoms that will pass. You know, there may not be long term effects. These are chronic exposures, long term exposures, little bit at a time. Deal with them that way. So, you know, start changing bit by bit. You know, go under your sink and clean it out. Get the safer stuff we recommend. Pay attention to what you're Bringing back from the grocery store, be a little bit smarter about personal care products. We go, here's a filter that works when you look it up on our website. ⁓ here's a filter that works for the contaminants that have been found in your tap water. We've just tried to refine that to make it easier for people to have that kind of control and power and sense of accomplishment. And to me. The most exciting thing is, and it's true in my own life, when I have these small winds that begin to add up that really help form habits, habits for sustainable living, healthy living, it's not because I put solar panels on my roof as the first step. That was like I only did that three years ago. I didn't start there, right? I didn't start there. I started with organic food, I started with shopping from the cleaner stuff on the EWG personal care lists. I did all those steps and And not everyone can take even those steps because some of them are expensive. People don't have access. If these things aren't democratized at EWG, we feel like our job is not anywhere near done. We need to have everybody to have access to clean and healthy products. Everybody. That's the bottom line. And so those partial steps and a sense of satisfaction of them, just like any habit, that's the rhythm you want
to create. That's the pattern you want to create. It's like exercise, right? If I've laid off the exercise for a couple of weeks, it's really hard to take that, you know, get back on the bike. In my case, I'm a cyclist. If I stick with it, every time I do it is easier. It's pretty easy. So it's all about giving yourself that reward system, getting yourself to understand the benefits of it, not having to take it on everything at this at once. Just being thoughtful about and sometimes the investments are big, a new mattress. You know, get one that's well rated by EWG, you're talking about a big investment. Getting rid of a couch. ⁓ I would love to address the elephant in the room right now for you, for me, for EWG, which is Maha is a thing, RFK Juniors in government, food dyes are getting pulled, red die number three was banned. A lot of people in the wellness space, like me, for most of these things, are cheering. These are good things. But EWG, you guys operate in a very specific lane. It's nonpartisan and it's it's science first. How do you guys navigate this political moment that we're in where some of what you've been fighting for your whole career It's suddenly getting the attention from an administration that's also doing a lot of things that potentially concern you. And then what's EWG's take on whether Maha is really a net positive or a net negative for the mission? Yeah. Well, I think Maha is a net positive if you're talking about the rank and file enthusiasm and engagement of so many people. A lot of these folks have been EWG followers for a long time. We hear that from them. We learn from you about food additives. You Kennedy didn't do any work on food additives until 2025 or the campaign. We'd been working on it for decades. And so these people were attuned to that. And I found it exciting that rank and file folks were saying, yeah, this is great. And also, if I may say, it gave permission to Republicans to talk about these issues in a way that they for whatever reason didn't feel before. Now we have a lot of Republican supporters on our the tens of millions who come, and we know that because Anytime we raise concerns about say a a Trump appointment, people will say, Hey, why don't you just keep giving us good advice on what to buy and what's safe and don't get political. Well, it's not political for us, it's just policy. If you have an EPA administrator like Lee Zeldon, whose we know his job is gonna be to tear down the agency, we are gonna speak out because we're not just a consumer advice organization. That's one where place where the tension comes in. I also feel like Kennedy ⁓ dramatically overpromised what he could possibly do in a Trump administration. If Maha was in a Harris administration or administration where there was more room to engage positively against ⁓ these vested interests who are pushing back, I would feel more hope for it as a formal administrative effort. But a lot of the things Kennedy wanted to do or claimed he was gonna do on pesticides, PFAS, toxic chemicals, and so forth, not only haven't happened, but because they aren't in his jurisdiction, which he wa didn't make clear during the campaign, they're in the jurisdiction of Lee Zeldon, who's taking the agency in the exact opposite direction. We've never had as much deregulation or dysregulation in an administration in history. It's really scary. Thousands of scientists being fired, laid off, sidelined, studies being stopped, regulations like the endangerment finding and The regulation on PFAS and drinking water being at least delayed, if not overturned. So it the public interest community is spending billions of dollars pushing back against this that we wouldn't have had to spend otherwise. Feels like waste to me. I don't like to spend my time that way, but we don't have much choice. The other thing that's a l that is more than a little worrisome is early on, I think people celebrated the possibility, at least, that maybe Maha was going to be bipartisan. But that has hardened now around the political leadership of the Maha movement, where they have announced, like Tony Lyons has announced, that he he's going to raise a hundred million dollars. He wrote a long memo about this to only to Republican leaders. He said, I'm gonna raise a hundred million dollars to reelect a Republican Congress. And Maha is there for you if you, you know, if if you'll keep talking about healthy eating and some of these other anodyne things, they're gonna avoid Vaccines for a while because that got too hot. Too many mistakes were made, you know, mostly by Kennedy in that realm. So overturned by the courts and pushback from politicians. But that's the thing that bothers me that I hope Maha folks are paying attention to is that they're being used now, unfortunately, by some of the political leaders in the Maha movement. This is not the rank and file folks concerned about food additives and so forth. I'm I'm talking about the people who are Building political action committees and raising campaign funds. That is most unfortunate because if you look what Congress has done, it's almost nothing on the Maha agenda. In fact, fighting against the Maha agenda has been led in Congress by Democrats. So to go to these Democrats and say, keep fighting against Monsanto so that they don't preempt state pesticide laws. The people taking the lead there, mostly, except for Thomas Massey and a few others, a Republican that you made reference to earlier, mostly it's Republicans who are pushing that preemption and mostly it's Democrats who are fighting it. So Maha's funding only Republicans? It's just what happens, I think, particularly in the Trump era, where allegiance and loyalty and towing the line are so tightly regimented. Now I'm not saying that's not true when Democrats are in power. They're They're pressures all the time, of course. But this is a little different, you know, and that's been a disappointment. Who knows what Kennedy
really thinks about all the glyphosate decision making? I think he probably feels like it's out of his control. I think probably internally he argued against some of those things, but he toes the line. And so now you have the leader of Maha coming out and saying, It's okay that we're expanding glyphosate. It's okay that we had the Justice Department weigh in. on behalf of Bayer and Monsanto. That's not what was sold, to put it mildly at the beginning, right? Yeah. And that's where, you know, you have this the very sort of corruption that Kennedy talks about where political interests extinguish integrity, extinguish science, extinguish independence in a way that's not helpful. But going back to the spirit of Maha, people wanting healthy food, get these additives out, deal with pesticides, this is fantastic. They're not the first to do it. I of course I gotta I gotta speak for all the moms that were there before Maha was Maha. They were there. ⁓ my gosh. There were millions of them that are supporters of EWG. Thank God. I mean, I think eighty plus percent still of our web traffic is women. And a lot of them are moms, but you don't have to be a mom. A right minded person wants to avoid these exposures. The fact that Kennedy had a pulpit to talk about that. Trump said a few things about it, not always clear what he meant, Bobby, go wild on the health. I want you to deal with the pesticides, Bobby. You know, who knows what he really knew about that or was thinking about that. But it was out there. And let's be clear, it caught the Democrats off guard. They felt like these were their issues, so much so that they took us for granted. And that would be, you know, that's my partisan concern going the other direction. I think Democrats, I think they've spent too much time and effort on some climate policies t at the expense of kitchen table policies. And those kitchen table policies are things like, well, there's food on the kitchen table. Let's start there. Let's start with the home environment. Let's start with the things that, you know, make a difference in people's everyday lives in terms of toxic chemical exposure. That's been underinvested in by the party at the leadership level, underinvested by philanthropy and others, because there's been so much focus, as you mentioned earlier, on, you know, Carbon uberalis, as a friend of mine said at one point. It's just carbon and everything else will take care of itself. Turns out that's not the case. Yeah. I love how multi-dimensional your answer is there, Ken. It's not a pro or con. You've really thought through the dimensionality of these issues. And that gives me hope that people aren't so reductionistic in how they solve these things, that they're more holistic and kind of zoom out. One of the things that I'd like to cover is, and this is probably a question that you might not get asked very often, but EWG does have critics, and some of those are probably from people private interests that want the exact
opposite. But you know, scientists and industry groups and some academics who say, you know, your risk ratings aren't always calibrated perfectly, and that might, you know, cause some recoil or some harm, and that you might overweight certain chemicals in a way that scares people more than science warrants, which might be okay, might not be. But how do you respond to that? And on the flip side, What are some of the things that EWG's genuinely gotten better at or corrected course on over the past few decades? Yeah, we do have our critics. Some of them think that we're scaremongers and we've never met a chemical that we didn't want to scare people about. I get that from our standpoint when we look at who those folks are, if they're not directly in industry, if they just have s a science background in some area of science, it's pretty rare that they understand regulatory science. And the role money plays and the decision-making process there. They might think that regulation is about science and it's not. It's a combination of judgment that's largely conditioned by financial, by economic interests around the regulatory decision making. When we look to see if we're on the right course, increasingly I point people to medical societies that in the past ten or fifteen years have come around to the many of the viewpoints. In fact, in some cases, as it were, a little to our left, they take a even stronger position. I think of this the endocrine society, you know, these are the nineteen, twenty thousand people in the world. They're researchers, they're clinicians, they're practitioners. They're people who you would go to if you had a problem with your immune system. They have made it very clear that low doses of some of these synthetic chemicals, pesticides, PFAS, other things, are of great concern. To the functioning of our bodies. The same is true of the Academy of Pediatrics, long since. They've been allies of ours since the nineties on pesticides, but other issues too. The American Heart Association, the American Lung Association, these entities are all deeply concerned about environmental exposures. Now, we even within our ranks might have different views about what level would be acceptable, what we would propose for a regulatory solution, and so forth. Mostly we align with Groups like the Natural Resources Defense Council, an amazing organization, Environmental Defense Fund, Earth Justice, oftentimes with smaller groups like Beyond Pesticides or Food and Water Watch, there's not a big range of difference ⁓ amongst those groups in the direction we think things should be headed, even though we may disagree on sometimes on tactics and strategy. But for me, the fact that we're publishing in the scientific literature, our research is being published there in in peer-reviewed publications, the fact that So many of these medical and scientific societies are inviting us to participate in events. It's not a sort of a zoological concern to see what we eat and
how we groom ourselves. It's because our science is good, right? And is driving some of these debates. And also, you know, we've been accused I'll give you one example. They'll say, Well, the dirty dozen isn't risk-based. You haven't added up the risk of these exposures. You're just talking about the chemicals that are occurring or appearing in the produce. That is certainly true. But the point we're we would make in response is first, we have engaged many times on chemical by chemical. We haven't always won, but many times it's been an analysis we contributed that got the government to strengthen regulation. And you know, from time to time, the government that has been telling us in some cases for decades that a chemical is perfectly safe, they say that right up until the time it isn't, and they ban it. And people remember this. know, people remember that chloropyrophos was ⁓ the insecticide that's commonly used on farm crops. They remember that EPA and the industry and farmers said it's perfectly safe. EPA says so, there's no risk, it's fine. And then suddenly EPA says it's gotta come off the market because science has revealed that it's a problem. Well, that's underneath a lot of what we do on pesticides, but the other thing that's underneath it is we never in the regulatory process look at combinations of contaminants. We know our bodies have hundreds and hundreds of chemicals in them, toxic chemicals, carcinogens, neurotoxins, chemicals that affect our hormone system. There is never any effort at the regulatory level to really understand the combined or synergistic effect of those mixtures. And so when we tell people, look, on the dirty dozen, yeah, there's lots of different ways you could come up with that. And industry would prefer we not come up with any approach. We get that. We get that. We've put a an approach out there, we've just recently published a peer-reviewed article about it. And we acknowledge there are other ways to doing it, but what we're really trying to tell people is you're not crazy to be worried about pesticides in your food. Come on. You're not ⁓ I mean, there have been so many pesticides that have been banned from food because it was shown to be dangerous. There's a regulatory cloud over a lot of them that are still on the market. People don't penetrate that cloud in their daily lives because life's too short. People are worried about college tuition, they're worried about getting to work on time, worried about hanging on to a job. But we delve into all of that and we see this gray area where regulators are saying, you know, maybe we need another study because this looks bad, or maybe we need another study because It used to look bad but now looks good. All these nuances, we try and, you know, as best we can present our best judgment and lay out our assumptions so that people know, hey, if EWG says this is the dirty dozen, there might be a a slightly different array of fruits and vegetables that could meet that different criteria that would fall under that name. But basically what we're trying to say is, you know, these are Fruits and vegetables that the way they're produced conventionally now, there's enough pesticides on them that you might want to think about opting for organic. Or pick something from a elsewhere in the produce aisle that, even if it's conventional, has lower pesticides. If you're worried about pesticides. And you're not crazy to worry about pesticides. And so I'm especially fond of industry arguments where they're saying, look, these pesticides are all safe and they're approved, and yet they give awards to farmers who use less pesticides. And so anyway. We have our critics. We try and respond to the ones that we feel, you know, are critics in good faith. Obviously we're up against industry critics formerly day in and day out. But ⁓ we'd happy to debate them as well. I love this, Ken. And I could keep chat with you for hours. I would love to power through a final few questions, man. I would like to get tactical for the listeners who are still tuning in right now. Say you're a parent, you're busy, you got somewhat of a limited budget. You want to start reducing your family's toxic load without losing your mind and pulling your hair out. What are a few moves that would help move the needle most for parents who might be in that position? Yeah, that's a great question. There's a couple levels to start at. Before I start at any one of the levels, I'll just say, look, just start on the journey. You don't have to do it all by Tuesday. Let's take this one at a time. It's like going to the gym. You know, we hope you're benching or more or running more. in two weeks from now than you are now, but don't worry about the future, just get to that future. So one is home hygiene, which is oftentimes as simple as getting the dust out of your home where a lot of these toxics accumulate, ventilating your home on a regular basis, having, you know, when you're replacing a major piece of furniture or a rug or something like that, taking care to do that in a way that at least consults some of the guidelines that we have out there or other reputable organizations have that rate those things. Home health is really a vital thing to think about. And then that can take you under your sink to get cleaning products that you scrub your bathtub with, that you scrub your sink with, that you wash your dishes with, you know. And don't throw out what you have now. Go ahead and use that. We're talking about chronic exposures. Don't throw it away. Just try something different the next time you have to restock. Try something safer. Then go to your refrigerator or your pantry and again take a little bit of stock. People go to EWG and they say, Should I throw out these conventional strawberries or blueberries? No, I eat conventional strawberries all the time because I go to hotels, right? Or my son goes to a birthday party or whatever it might be. We're not talking about
that level of perfection. We're talking about having a learning, a student's mindset and learning that, okay, I'm gonna finish these and then maybe the organic strawberries will be in season and I'll I'll be able to afford them. Maybe they won't be so pricey. Maybe the blueberries that will come on will be a market window for organic. During that period I'll buy the organic versions and then when I'm not buying those, I'll try and shift to something that has lower pesticides. If you buy organic packaged foods, it's always going to have lower additives, food additives than conventional. Okay. That's it's by law. But you can also use our food scores guide to s to sort of look through and say, okay, well these foods rate pretty well. EWG looks at nutrition, we look at additives, look at degree of processing and contaminants. We look at all those factors to come up with a score. Shop toward the green end of things, if you're inclined. Many of them are affordable, regular conventional foods, not necessarily organic. Step by step, that's the way we think of it. Personal care products, I there are many occasions that people have gone on TV and said, ⁓ I came across this EWG app and so I just threw everything out of my makeup and person and my shower. Don't do that. Don't throw it out. You can use it, right? It's okay. We're not talking about something. If it was going to kill you, it wouldn't be on the market. So it's going to expose you. Think of that way, and you want to stop that exposure. You want to shift to something that's more benign. That's how we live our lives here. And you know, my son likes some really bad food. He likes some bad food. We let him have some bad food. We don't police it in such a way that we want to punish him, but he's the first one when we bring the groceries home to say, Hey, you know, did you know Dad this isn't organic? Okay, that's the seed I want to plant, you know, because you can't always find or afford organic with some of the foods that he likes to eat, and we want him to be well nourished. It's not that hard and fast. I would just say relaxed resolve. I like that. ⁓ You know, just like, hey, I got this, you know, I don't have to do it all every shopping trip, every week. I've got some time here and ⁓ I'm on the right track and I wanna support these companies that are making the good stuff that I'm putting in my shopping cart increasingly. They're gonna start expanding. Their price is gonna go down over time, real prices should drop if more people are buying it. All for all those reasons. You're remaking the economy with what's at the end of your fork or what you're putting in your hair or whatever. That churn is what we need. And And give yourself a little grace to do that at your own convenience and what works for you and your family. Yeah. And it's the power of the consumer. We just gotta put one foot in front of the other, man. I feel like Kent, you've been fighting this fight for thirty plus years. You've seen
the industry immune system up close. You've had the wins, they've gotten taken back. You've watched chemicals get flagged. Twenty years ago, they finally get banned or almost get banned, and the goalposts move. What still drives you in this? And what do you see the landscape right now, whether it's new science, new consumer behavior, new political openings, that actually gives you real hope that we're turning the corner here? Talking to people like you, talking to people who get it and are excited to do more. That's one of the big things that nourishes me. I I also, you know, I don't like the idea of giving up when you know you're right. Of course, my loyal opponents on the opposite side feel the same way. I get that. But to me it feels like moving the culture and the economy in this direction. It's not moving fast enough by our lights. Environmentalists are paid to be impatient. And sometimes we tend to finger wag a little bit. We try not to do that at EWG. Who likes that? But one of the things that really keeps me going is when people say, Hey, you're you know, EWG's really made a difference in my life. You've given me some tangible things to do. People don't come up to me so much and say, Hey, Congratulations on getting this new law passed that will restrict ultra-processed food in California schools. Some people do, but mostly people, it's the consumer everyday thing that keeps me going because you get that feedback, or a company that says, we're killing it on Amazon because we have the EWG certification. So it's the it's the human interface that keeps me excited. It's not necessarily the big wins or it's nice to be in the New York Times. It's nice, it's important, I'll say it's more than nice. 'Cause there might be a New York Times reporter listening. It's more than nice. But the real thing that keeps me going is the fact we've been able to apply science to this gap between what's legal and what's safe. We've been able to give people actionable things they can do to make a difference in their lives. And they come up to me from time to time, more often than I feel like I deserve, and say, EWD's changed my life. And you don't need many of those during the course of a year. to kind of think, okay, well, you know, I'm on we're on the right track. I've got these great people working with me, you know, leading the organization now, scientists that I mean, I'm glad I was hired early on. Because I couldn't compete now. I probably wouldn't get a job now if I was coming to EWG. They're all so much smarter and and more creative. But I have to say it it's that human feedback that really and what a privilege to be able to do this work, right? You must feel the same way. On on its w on its worst day. It's an incredible privilege. I never lose sight of that. I love that, Ken. You know what's funny though? I was on the phone yesterday and I said, you know, fighting this fight, it's kind of a thankless task. I told her I was like, I don't wake up in the morning and receive any texts like, Thank you, Jesse, for saving the planet. I'm sure you might get those texts. I don't get those texts. So I got off the phone with her and I look at my phone and I have a text message from her that said, Jesse, thank you for saving the planet. And I couldn't help but laugh because I was like Finally someone's, you know, thanking me, but I'd like to end with one final question, Ken. It's it's a question that I'm now asking to every guest that I bring on the show is what's one tangible or intangible toxin that people should be way more aware of in their daily lives? Well, that's a good one. I do get that question from time to time. It's the matrix that brings toxins to you that you should look at first. And for me it's always food. All the additives, all the pesticides, increasingly now, even some PFAS chemicals. PFAS are really a great candidate to avoid if you can because of all the health effects. And practically every major regulatory entity on the planet is trying to deal with those now. And that tells you something right there. But for me, I start with food. I really encourage people obviously to find a diet that nourishes them. Quite apart from the toxins, although of course they interact. But for me it's you know, healthy eating that makes a huge difference. And the second one is sleep. Mm-hmm. The second one is sleep, which I'm not good at. Yeah. I look at that as a toxicant that if you're not dealing with it right. And I've struggled with it partly because we have a new dog that his muzzles right by the bed at about five in the morning every morning. It's not too much later than I get up anyway, but or earlier than I get up anyway. But yeah, I think food and sleep are the places where I encourage people. And if you're eating a clean diet and whole foods, Kennedy's calling it real food, so did Michael Pollins. So is everyone else before him. Marian Nessel called it the same thing. You're le if you're eating a a clean and healthy and nourishing diet and you're getting good sleep, I feel like you've won the day already. It's a great point, Ken. And outside of your dog keeping you up, it's pretty apparent what's keeping you up at night outside of your dog. But thank you so much. I actually developed a bit of a health problem this year. I had high blood pressure for the first time ever. And when I was talking to my doctor about it, ⁓ she said, Well, is there anything you're particularly stressed about? I said, Well, just the world. The world. State of affairs. I'm working on it. I'm working on that b blood pressure now. Taking that in stride as best I can. But yeah, that keeps me up too. You know, for all the folks who are listening in, Jesse, thank you so much for you know, mounting this podcast. I'm very excited about where you're taking it. Very excited that someone with your background is bringing that experience and that openness to this set of topics. We really need voices like yours, so psych, brother. Thank you. No, ⁓ you're the second person in twenty four hours to tell me I'm Proverbially saving the planet. So thank you. And it it takes in order for me to do what I'm doing, Ken, we need leaders like you who have preceded me, who have done that heavy lifting in the 70s, 80s, 90s, and early 2000s for me to be able to step in and do what I'm doing. So I appreciate you for hopping on with me. I know this went a little bit over what we expected, but thank you so much, Ken, for doing this. And maybe one day we'll do a follow up. Happy to be in the foxhole with you, brother. Awesome. Thank you so much, Ken.