TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:04
Speaker 1: Welcome to Newt's World Podcast on the iHeart Podcast Network. My guests today are two of the country's sharpest political analysts. John McLaughlin is the CEO and partner at McLaughlin & Associates. Doug Sosnick is a research fellow at the Harvard Kennedy School. In October, John and Doug joined me to size up the midterms. Now the votes are in, and Democrats have won control of both the House and the Senate, including... Senate seats in Texas, Kansas, and South Carolina. John and Doug are back to tell us whether the polls got it right, what drove the results, and what comes next. That's next. I'm really pleased to welcome my guests, John McLaughlin and Doug Sosnick. John is the CEO and a partner at McLaughlin & Associates, a national survey, research, and strategic consulting firm. He has worked as a pollster and strategist for more than 40 years and served as an advisor and pollster for Donald Trump in 2016 from the primaries through Election Day. He is a founding partner of Opiniones Latinas, which researches the views of Latino voters nationwide and and he writes a regular polling column for Newsmax. Doug is a research fellow at Harvard Kennedy School's Center for Business and Government. He served six years as a senior advisor to President Bill Clinton in the White House, including roles as senior advisor for policy and strategy and White House political director. Before that, he was chief of staff to Senator Chris Dodd of Connecticut. They're joining me to compare their pre-election polling with Election Day results, break down the results, and discuss what a Democratic Congress means for President Trump, both parties, and 2028. John and Doug, welcome back, and thank you for joining me again on Newt's World. I'm grinning because both John and I realized that Doug was the wise person who actually understood what was going on, and the two of us feel a little bit chagrined here. But let's begin with the results. How close were they to what you expected? Doug gets to go first here because he earned it. How close was this to what you expected?
00:02:41
Speaker 2: Well, I always thought there were two very competing factors going on at once. One was the historical precedent, which said to me in every single metric possible that this was going to be a blue wave election.
00:02:55
Speaker 3: On the other hand, the structural changes in American.
00:02:57
Speaker 2: Politics where we had so fewer competitive seats, I thought it was going to put a ceiling on the Democratic wins, even though everything said to me it was going to be a banner day. So I thought the Democrats could win up to six Senate seats. And from what they say, it looks like the Republicans will probably lose Mississippi and Alaska. If that's the case, I'll make it nine seats. So I was pretty short there, you know, on my high end at six compared to nine.
00:03:27
Speaker 3: And in the House, I thought until the last couple of days, it was probably going to be in the mid-20s.
00:03:31
Speaker 2: And then I thought it might be closer to, let's say, 30. And I think it's actually going to be closer to 50. So I guess that's a long-winded way of my saying I expected a really good Democratic day. I thought the structure of the politics was going to put a ceiling on how big it could have been. And that wasn't the ceiling that I thought.
00:03:50
Speaker 1: What was your sense, John?
00:03:52
Speaker 4: My sense was, I always thought it'd be a record turnout. And it seems from Michael McDonald, he runs that US Elections Project, it was 124 million voters, which is higher than 118 million you had in 2018 when we lost both houses during Trump's first midterm. I was always hoping that we could keep the Senate. We knew that the House was going to be gone. The people that controlled the super PACs were taking money out of Republican districts that were competitive. But It counted on the 10% who were undecided, who really like three quarters of what the country was in the wrong track. So for those of us who remember, it was like 1994 in reverse. And a lot of Democrats that I don't think they expected to win basically came across. And the other part is Democrats, to Doug's credit, he was sending us the blue wave PowerPoints. It looked very, very real. And you're sitting there and you're saying, we've got to stop this. And you just couldn't stop it because the Democrats had a very simple message. They were anti-Trump. All they wanted to do was maximize their votes under the voters who disapproved of the president's policies. The Republicans never were able to contrast. They didn't have a message. They didn't have a strategy as a party, whether it was the House or Senate. We have a post-election survey that we're going to post that was started over the weekend that we completed the night before last. And most Republicans were voting for the Republican. Most Democrats were voting for the Democrat. But a third of their vote was anti-Trump and anti-Republicans, which was higher than one-fifth of the Republicans that was anti-Democrats. And when you have an election where public opinion has soured on your incumbent, and the incumbent in this case was not on the ballot, but he was on the ballot, was President Trump. So they have this high disapproval rating. The only way to win is to raise your opponent's disapproval rating. It never happened. There was never a strategy. There was never a message to make that happen. It was never a contrast election. It really was where they flipped the independents. And the independents, according to these exit polls, they voted 56 to 39 for the Democrats, for the House.
00:06:11
Speaker 2: I would just say, John, though, that it is much harder in a midterm election. It's much harder to make it a choice election. if you're the party in power compared to presidential. I think just two other things. The turnout at the raw numbers was higher than the previous midterms, but as a percentage of
Load full transcript
eligible voters, it was actually lower than 22 and lower than 18. And I think you'll see, if you spend some time on the data, that Democratic turnout was closer to presidential election year turnout and Republicans wasn't. And the last thing I'll say, And this is no exaggeration. As a Democrat, if I had to script what I would want Donald Trump to have done for the last year, I couldn't have scripted better. I mean, how he handled the cycle, how he handled going after Republicans and pushing them out of races that they would have won, wasting money, waiting till the end to spend the money, having a midterm convention in Dallas, spending all the time talking about his pet projects, calling affordability a hoax, closing his campaign at the pool. I actually could not have scripted a more effective way for the Democrats to have a good election than how Donald Trump conducted himself.
00:07:34
Speaker 4: Just a comment on that. For President Trump, I mean, it was such a contrast from 2024 when we had the campaign. He was focused on winning. He was listening. We would meet. We'd go over polls. I never met with him, went over a poll the last two years because we had to raise his job approval. And if you can't raise his job approval, then it puts a lid on everything we can do. I think that was a big mistake. You know, you learn more from losing. The From 2024. And we had a great campaign. My mentor in polling, Arthur Finkelstein, he would always say, the best candidates will have lost, whether it was Reagan or Nixon, and then come back. And that was true about Donald Trump. He lost, but he'll never say he lost. But in 2020, we lost. In the campaign between, from the time of 2021, we had polling that most Republicans wanted to run again until we won in 2024. He was focused. He had a message. He had a contrast with Joe Biden and Kamala Harris. And this time around, we never had a contrast. We never had that kind of focus. There was no strategy for the Republicans and no message for the Republicans as a group to stop what was coming with midterm election. And for those of us who went through the 2002 cycle, where I worked for the Speaker of the House, I worked for Jim Gilmore, was the chairman of the RNC, and I was on my way to working for Bush Cheney. There was a different focus and a different message. We won eight House seats and two Senate seats. But there was a real focus message in terms of recovering from 9-11. There was a tax cut that was growing the economy. The economy, what's amazing is the economy was growing, but it wasn't in perspective. Because like in our poll, this post-election survey that we're going to post, what was amazing is that most Americans don't think we're in recession. They think the economy is good. But it's still the top issue. 50% of the voters told us it was the top issue. 27% specifically mentioned higher prices and inflation. There was no focus on that, that we were going to bring that down. And it wasn't in perspective. It wasn't like it wasn't beaten. They still thought the economy was getting worse. They said the economy was getting worse 62 to 32 in this poll. But when you told them the facts about the economy, they said, oh, it's really getting better, 62, 33. They never heard the message because there was no focus message.
00:10:05
Speaker 1: This might be simple-minded. You guys have a much deeper knowledge about this than I do, but I'm curious. I said about three months ago, tell me the price of gasoline on Labor Day. And I'll tell you the outcome. It seemed to me that no matter what he said about the macro economy, I had this experience. Yeah, I went out to fill up my truck two weeks ago. And I'm standing there at the pump getting totally pissed off because it's like $ 4 and something a gallon. And I have a really big tank. I just had a sense that there was a common sense, real life level where people were feeling pain even if in the long run things might get better. Citizen Collins' real opponent in Maine was the price of heating oil. This was the time of year when Maine fills up their tanks for the winter, and the price of heating oil was within nine cents of the all-time record high.
00:11:07
Speaker 2: The price of gasoline at Labor Day was the highest in history for Labor Day. Go back to the 2002 midterm. There's a big difference there, you know, having come off of the attack from 9-11. I think it mitigated some things. But we're a different country now than we were then economically. And our distribution of income and wealth now is so much skewed towards the top 10%. And this is a problem that Biden had and Trump had where you can cart out our economic numbers in America and it's the envy of the world. But the problem underneath that is it's not distributed evenly. And you have 60% of the people in the country who are living paycheck to paycheck. And inflation is an incredibly high regressive tax. And I think to Newt's broader point, beyond winning in 2024, a big part of it was, you know, you weren't Biden and you weren't Harris. The three planks were immigration, sealing the border, the economy, and not having endless wars. So I think, you know, you drove the Hispanics back into Democrats' arms. They don't like the Democrats. Based on how the immigration enforcement was handled, the economy, I think, speaks for itself. And staying out of endless wars, I think, speaks for itself.
00:12:25
Speaker 4: To your point about Hispanic voters, I mean, that was a big drop because Trump got 46% from the exit polls and Republicans had 45. We were doing polling for Univision at the time. But I made the remark that we didn't own the Hispanic vote. We were just renting it for one election. But the top issue was cost of living and prices. To Newt's point, the price of gas, a lot of times you're looking at the polls and you're looking at these undecided voters and you're saying, I think we can get them until they go buy gas. And if they own a truck, holy cow, are
we in trouble if they got diesel? And by the way, we had a poll, 80% of the voters said, Wanted us to suspend the gas tax, call Congress back and suspend the gas tax. And if we floated it up, nobody did it. The Speaker didn't do it. The Senate didn't do it. All you had to do was suspend it to the end of the war. Maybe we'll save 50 cents a gallon. The economists on the Committee for Prosperity who figured out Steve Moore and these other guys, just do it. And then you look back and a lot of the gains we made with all different voter groups, the Democrats went to work four years ago. They went after younger men. They went after younger voters. They got back their African-American support. They got back their Hispanic support. And your point about inflation, it's a different economy. And you're exactly right, Doug, because you inspire me sometimes when you send these papers out. The younger voters don't pay bills the way the older voters and the older voters were voting Republican. The younger voters, when they were talking about tax cuts and you were wanting to see the benefit, it's all on their credit card. They don't get the bill until the end of the month. It's in their phone. They pay it with their cell phone. They pay it on their credit card. And we'd ask, or this year, what their balance was on their credit card. The average person has $ 6, 000 balance, the average voter. And they were paying what they said to us was an interest rate of 16%. They never saw the benefit of the tax cut with that. You know, you're telling them inflation went down. Their monthly bill on their credit card said inflation didn't go down. And then they can't get a mortgage.
00:14:31
Speaker 1: Let me switch gears for a second. There are two Senate races that are still outstanding. In Mississippi, the margin's very close. The Democrat Scott column is ahead by about 1,800 votes, which is a pretty decent margin, I think. And they still have a bunch of affidavit ballots to count. But it sounds to me like it's very likely. And I would think that that one It would not have occurred to me in January that the Cindy Hyde Smith was going to get beaten in Mississippi. I don't know to what extent that was price of gasoline, to what extent it was black anger of various things at the administration.
00:15:14
Speaker 2: There are two things I think that had a big impact on this election, one of which you just touched on.
00:15:18
Speaker 3: But one is the corruption.
00:15:21
Speaker 2: If we had peace and prosperity, I don't think people would be as concerned about corruption. When they're out there like you are, Newt, spending a fortune filling up your truck. And what I would say is brazen, open, pay-to-play corruption, that issue matters more to people. And so we didn't just talk about corruption. We tied it back to people's lives. And I think that had a huge impact. And we spent hundreds of millions of dollars in the last 30 days on ads on that. The other thing, though, getting
back to Smith is, you know, there's a great quote from John Sears after the 1988 Reagan landslide when you guys picked up like 11 Senate seats and he said, hell, if we didn't know we were going to win all these races, we're going to run real people. And I think all of them except for Grassley lost six years later. And I think the poor candidate recruitment and the poor incumbents on the Republican side and strong candidate recruitment on the Democratic side really makes a difference. And there's nothing more ripe than than a vulnerable senator in a wave election that hasn't had a tough race before. If you look at Smith in Mississippi or in the Kansas seat, you know, not to mention, you know, you guys spent a billion dollars in Texas and Georgia that you didn't have to have spent. So I think the candidate quality had a huge impact in the election. We as Democrats did a better job not only of getting our tier one candidates in, But we started running candidates that are more native to the areas that they were running in.
00:16:55
Speaker 3: And that's been a big.
00:16:56
Speaker 2: Problem for us as a party because we have all these college elites in Washington trying to find people just like them in these states. And they get killed because they don't reflect the states. And you guys, over time, have done a much better job of recruiting people who are kind of native to the districts and states that they run in.
00:17:14
Speaker 1: Let me go to the second case, which I find, frankly, complicated. Mary Patola leads Senator Dan Sullivan by 637 first-choice votes, with a quarter of the ballots still out. But in addition, they have this second choice where if nobody gets to a majority, you then take the votes that are left, starting with the candidate who got the fewest votes, and you redistribute them. But I can't understand, if the game is played out, Whichever of these two candidates ends up with the most votes, and it's clearly going to go to this forced choice, because neither one's going to get 50%. Whoever wins, it seems to me, wins. What am I missing?
00:18:01
Speaker 3: You're not missing anything.
00:18:02
Speaker 2: The courts up there already ruled that this is a states' rights issue, and the feds have no standing. And I've spent a lot of time working in Alaska. My understanding, though, is that most people think she's going to win based on the system. at least in Alaska, has an excuse that California doesn't have, which is it's so big. And a lot of these ballots that they haven't counted yet are in these rural areas that you can't reach except by air or by boat. That's where the Alaska Natives are, and she is an Alaska Native. So I think that you're right that when it's done, it's done. And by the way, the right choice voting process, once they do it, will not take very long to execute.
00:18:45
Speaker 3: I think once they're done, they're done.
00:18:48
Speaker 2: Not to give you flashbacks, this is not quite like Indiana in the 80s when we were fighting over that seat.
00:18:54
Speaker 3: I'm not sure that was.
00:18:55
Speaker 2: Our most honorable moment in politics, but I don't think we're going to go through that in Alaska.
00:19:01
Speaker 1: You hear people saying that they wouldn't seat her, but it seems to me the Alaskan system is the one that is legitimately what the Alaskans have passed, and whatever happens in the end is what happens.
00:19:15
Speaker 4: You know, if you go back to when they made the change, it was to save Senator Murkowski because she voted for impeachment against President Trump. So instead of having a real Republican primary or a real Democrat primary where the winners of the primaries, you know, would then be the nominees. Having worked in Alaska for a long time, that doesn't necessarily mean that I'm the strongest candidate because I used to work for Wally Hickel. That was the Alaska Independence Party at a time where libertarian candidates do well up there. But they went to this top four system in ranked choice voting. And that's the system, like Doug has said and you've said, that's what the court will uphold. However, the part of where there may have been some sort of legal violation was if the Democrat Senate Committee used resources to recruit the second Dan Sullivan and then establish that candidacy is kind of like an independent expenditure when it wasn't independent. But that's a different kind of investigation. That's something that the New York Times talked about. And, you know, you have to have Justice Department be able to look at it. Whether that changes the outcome of the election, I don't know. But I agree with both of you in terms of, OK, they've got a system with ranked choice voting and that's what's going to happen. But were there legal violations in the recruiting of this other Dan Sullivan and did one party manipulate the system against the laws? I don't know. That's up for the legal people to find out.
00:20:42
Speaker 2: Just for the record, they had to be morons to have a second Dan Sullivan strategy. They have to be complete morons to have done that. Things cost so much more in Alaska than anywhere else in America because you have to fly it all in. So you can imagine what the impact of inflation knew. I think you're absolutely right. It's been understated how much Heating homes and air conditioning homes have gone up in the last year, and that really has driven a lot of the dissatisfaction.
00:21:14
Speaker 1: When we come back, John and Doug go head-to-head on what drove the wave, the cost of living, the Iran war, and President Trump himself. That's next. I'm a little surprised that there'll be 259 Democrats, which would be the largest House majority since 2008. From the House standpoint, Hakeem Jeffries will actually be able to be an effective speaker. He'll have enough votes that no faction will be able to blackmail him.
00:21:54
Speaker 3: Well, you're right. And I thought that was going to be a bigger problem.
00:21:58
Speaker 2: And what's interesting in the House caucus now, as the herd has been thinned, The House caucus now has never been more Trumpy because there are no moderates left in the caucus.
00:22:10
Speaker 3: They're all defeated.
00:22:11
Speaker 2: And if you look at Jim Jordan and Scalise right now, who are both running for minority leader, they're both hugging Trump as tight as they can because all that's left of the House Republican caucus now are MAGA Republicans.
00:22:27
Speaker 1: Which will make it a little more difficult for them to sort out what they have to do in the next few years.
00:22:33
Speaker 2: You've seen it, and I'm sure you not only have more fun when you're in the opposition than running the place, but you also, I think, probably would acknowledge it's a lot easier when you're in the opposition than when you're responsible for governing.
00:22:46
Speaker 1: Phil Graham, when he switched parties, after about three months, said to me one day, it is so easy to be in the minority, and all you have to do is vote no. You don't have to write legislation. You don't have to have hearings on legislation. You don't have to go through amendments. You just cheerfully vote no and go back to whatever you were doing. And that's a danger because, in fact, you want a party seeking to become a majority, not a party happily in the minority. And that's a real challenge. And I think in some ways, the Republicans may face bigger challenges than the Democrats in sorting out where they go from here.
00:23:28
Speaker 3: To your point about the Republicans, and John, I'm sure you're way more dialed in than I am. I thought this before the election.
00:23:34
Speaker 2: I think given the results of the election, I can see a splintering into three groups of Republicans going forward. One is the MAGA. The second is America First, which is not MAGA. And then the third are the kind of remnants of what's left of the old establishment Republicans. But particularly the differences between the Make America First, where I think you could get someone running you know, who's outside the political system. I think that's a very real division for MAGA. It is, but Trump's base still inside the party is still solid. We've been here before after January 6th. I think the biggest change in the Republican party is under Donald Trump is it's become the party of the working class. You've had these working class voters come into the Republican primaries over the past couple of decades.
00:24:22
Speaker 4: And it started before he was there. He became their leader. And they'll still be there after. The question is, do they stay in the Republican party? Do the Democrats try to bring them back? I don't know.
00:24:33
Speaker 2: Also, they demonstrated it again Tuesday. They've never voted when Trump's not on the ballot.
00:24:38
Speaker 4: Right. That's why I said it's a big question. The post-election polls, there were three or four points more Harris voters than Trump voters in this election. And there were some Trump voters that defected.
00:24:49
Speaker 1: So.
00:24:50
Speaker 4: Last year's governor's race in Virginia and governor's race in New Jersey, where the Harris voters outnumbered the Trump voters five to four in the lower turnout, was really a warning signal to what was going to happen this past Tuesday. And what happened this past Tuesday was people that voted anti-Trump who were Harris voters came out in bigger numbers than the Republicans. And probably when you go through the states where the Senate races that mattered the most, that's what happened. So in a lower turnout election, but more of them come out, you have a big problem because those of us who wanted to hold the Senate, we had to have more Trump voters come out than Harris voters and it didn't happen.
00:25:30
Speaker 2: In 22, there was very different turnout patterns in competitive and non-competitive areas. The Republican turnout was pretty high in non-competitive seats in 22, but it was much lower in the competitive seats where the Democrats did turn out. And I think that probably happened again. The broader point to what you said there, Newt, is I don't think the country wants to vote for a Republican for president in 28. I think it would've been very difficult for a Republican to have won in 2008 after eight years of Bush. So I think the most important thing is not going to be who the Republicans nominate, it's who the Democrats nominate. And if we nominate someone who the bulk of people in America are not comfortable voting for, they will gladly vote for a Republican.
00:26:15
Speaker 3: But I don't think they want to vote for a Republican.
00:26:18
Speaker 2: And we've still got two more years of Trump, who every single day is going to remind everyone he's not a lame duck. And every single day that he's out there reminding people he's not a lame duck is a good day for Democrats.
00:26:30
Speaker 4: Today, we got a great jobs report, right? Unemployment's down to 4.1%. They got 160,000 votes. If the economy keeps growing, I think you started to write about this in some of your post-election columns where Reagan, certainly 86, was a bad election. We lost the Senate. Things didn't go right. But Reagan rebounded. That helped George H.W. Bush get elected. Bill Clinton certainly rebounded for the 94 election and certainly 98 wasn't as good as Republicans expected at all. So you've seen presidents rebound from bad midterms and kind of hand off to a future successor. So that could happen again.
00:27:08
Speaker 2: The broader issue is this country dislikes both parties, and they don't want one party to be in the White House too long. By the way, that was one of the biggest problems Hillary had in 16. The country didn't want to have three terms in a row of a Democrat. It's only happened once since World War II, and that was, as you mentioned earlier, in 88. So I think in part it's Trump because the country's exhausted from him,
but it's also part of the fact that you just don't want one party to be in charge too long.
00:27:34
Speaker 1: I think Doug's probably right that having... a Republican president for psychologically 12 years, because Trump was around even during the Biden presidency, makes it more likely they'll vote Democrat unless they fail so decisively in Congress that the country sort of drifts back to us as sort of the last best hope. I have to ask you guys, probably the biggest surprise to me was that Tallarico was ahead by 2.6 points and won by 12. And the underlying momentum of Republicans not voting wiped out every statewide Republican in Texas. Isn't Texas, in a way, the most surprising result?
00:28:25
Speaker 3: Well, it was for.
00:28:25
Speaker 2: Me because I've always thought as a Democrat, Texas and Florida was fool's gold for Democrats.
00:28:31
Speaker 3: And I don't think that all of a sudden Texas is a blue state. I think it is gettable.
00:28:37
Speaker 2: But I think that the totality of the win and the margin of the victory now is a mitigating factor there with Paxson, who may actually be the single worst candidate running for the Senate in my lifetime. And we've seen some doozies. And I think that was a real drag. And also, you know, Trump sees as the president, it's harder to be the change candidate when you're in office. I mean, he's the ideal change candidate. Abbott is exactly the kind of person that people are tired of. They've been around forever. You got on the wrong side of AI and the data center issues. So I think it was a confluence of events. And again, I wouldn't underestimate the impact, particularly in South Texas, of the roundups of these people's friends and neighbors getting shipped off to prisons in El Salvador and other areas. I wouldn't underestimate the impact that had with Hispanic voters in Texas.
00:29:33
Speaker 1: John, how much were you surprised by the depth of the collapse?
00:29:37
Speaker 4: That's probably the biggest shock because Texas, in a way, had become the new Ohio. When you go back to history, it was the center of the Republican Party geographically, and Texas had become the heir to it. Certainly it moved from Democrat to a reliably Republican state, except this year, just in the midterm election. After they voted for Tallarico, they kept voting Democrat. for the reasons that Doug talks about, but Paxson, the fact that they were unable to have a successful message to beat Tallarico and have a focus on that, that's the real toughest lesson for the Republicans to learn from because it costs us the governorship, all the statewide offices.
00:30:18
Speaker 1: If you think about that and you say both about what happened in Michigan and what happened in Texas... How badly had the Republicans done that these candidates were preferable? It just seems to me it drives home how big the rethinking by Republicans has to be.
00:30:41
Speaker 2: Tallarico and the Democratic candidate in Kansas and some other candidates, I think they've kind of touched on the nerve of people feeling like they're tired of all the nasty.
00:30:53
Speaker 3: They're tired of people saying outrageous stuff. And there's a softer way that they campaign.
00:31:00
Speaker 2: And I think the single most important event that happened in the midterm elections, as it relates to at least the Republican primary for president, and you touched on this, was Vance doubling down in Ohio on that.
00:31:15
Speaker 5: Ad that Vivek put on. And he talked like Trump. And I think that is completely... out of touch with where the country is now. I think the country has changed on that. And I think we are moving into a different tone of what people are willing to accept now. And that position he took on that ad is going to be hung around Vance's neck like a noose.
00:31:41
Speaker 1: I agree that Paxton, probably the worst candidate in the country for a major office. But I've known Ramaswamy for a good while. That ad where he had The Democratic candidate's mother attacking her daughter, given the background of the family, had to be the most suicidal single event that I've seen in years. What kind of a consultant sat in a room with a candidate and said, I have this great idea. We're going to take this terrible family tragedy and we're going to take this legitimate hostility that the daughter had for the mother who had basically betrayed her. And we're going to put the mother on TV and put down five million bucks and make sure everybody sees it. You can't imagine being this stupid.
00:32:35
Speaker 3: I agree with that, but my point is, it's Vance.
00:32:39
Speaker 2: He went out there after that and doubled down and said, that's okay, I don't have a problem with that.
00:32:46
Speaker 1: Well, no, he said more than that. He attacked the people who had a problem with it. He said, it's a sign you're a coward. and you lack courage, and you ought to stand firm. I found it very offensive what Vance said, and insane what Ramaswami did. Probably, John, it should have been a good sign to us that this just was not going to be a good year.
00:33:06
Speaker 4: You figured there was an act of desperation on that. I'm on the outside looking in, and I wasn't involved in the statewide in Ohio. And you had Sherrod Brown was ahead in the media polls. It goes back to what Doug was saying is, I think a lot of the Republicans were depending on President Trump, and they thought that, oh, we've got more money than the Democrats. We've got Donald Trump. That'll elect us. And you didn't have candidates who could stand on their own brand. And with Ramaswamy, that here comes on, and I'm just looking at him saying, they got a bad poll, and that's an act of desperation. And it's obviously backfired.
00:33:46
Speaker 1: Coming up. John and Doug on what a blue Texas means for both parties, what a Democratic Congress means for President Trump, and what this election tells us about 2028. That's next. Doug, you had a
substantially better year than John and I. So let me put you on the spot. We'll now look to the future because the past is boring. What does your gut tell you about how the Democratic nominating process works its way out.
00:34:25
Speaker 2: We're a party that's sort of, it's always been in the witness protection program for the last 11 years. I mean, we've stood for nothing for the last 11 years except opposing Trump.
00:34:34
Speaker 3: And we papered over all of our differences.
00:34:37
Speaker 2: And depending on how you want to keep score, Bill Clinton, Hillary Clinton, Obama, Biden administration has dominated the top rungs of Democratic candidates presidential politics now for a quarter century. So we haven't given anybody an opportunity to run next generation and see who's got what. And so we're going to learn that and see who actually has it. I will say some oddities right now. We have around 15 people.
00:35:05
Speaker 3: That are running.
00:35:06
Speaker 2: And right now, the sort of animating energy in the party is on the progressive left. And of the 15 people who are talking about running, 14 of them are center left candidates. Roe Cannell is the only full-throated populist who's running.
00:35:23
Speaker 3: Now, AOC may run. I doubt it, but she could. And Bernie could run.
00:35:28
Speaker 2: So part of the process is just to let these people get out and see who's got it. And the other is, though, to see what part of the wing of the party that is energized is going to run a candidate. Right now, Roe is the only one in that lane. I don't see anybody right now That stands out to me as a logical person to emerge. I do think the candidate's going to have to be for change and not for the status quo. And he can't talk, look, and act like a politician. But he's got to be for change. Trump is the ultimate change candidate. And he tore down a lot of systems in our country that people would probably tell you needed changes. Now, a lot of people will tell you he didn't change them the right way. And he certainly didn't put anything in its place. But he did run as a candidate for change because people think the system doesn't currently work. The last thing I'll say about history, and I don't know whether or not history will repeat itself, the last time the Democrats nominated the most liberal candidate for president was George McGovern in 1972. And the last time the Republicans nominated the most conservative candidate for president was 1980 with Ronald Reagan.
00:36:42
Speaker 3: So the point is, at least in the past, At the end of the day, both parties ultimately have settled for the last 75 years. They've settled on the candidate who they think has the best chance of winning.
00:36:56
Speaker 1: In the Democratic side, my assumption is if J.D. Vance has been heard, and I think he has been, then you have an open nominating process much more than we would have guessed two weeks ago on our side. And you're going to have an open nominating process on your side. And there are many occasions in American history where both sides at the same time are open. That will make this, I think, an unusually dynamic nominating process, it seems to me.
00:37:31
Speaker 2: And it's going to intersect with the debate in Washington on policy. So it was the policy discussion in the presidential campaign where you're going to have open seats in the progressive left for the Dems and the right-wing populists on the right for the Republicans, are going to drive a lot of the positions that people in Washington have. And the people in Washington are going to push proposals that are going to rebound back in the presidential race. I think that's going to be like a catalytic event. The way I look at where we are is, I view from the day that Trump rode down that escalator and announced for president, for 11 years, we have been living in the age of Trump. And I think the age of Trump ended on Tuesday. The 2028 presidential election is going to be the election about the future in America after Trump. It's going to be like the 1960 election where we had a generational change.
00:38:26
Speaker 3: We moved past World War II.
00:38:28
Speaker 2: Whereas television redefined politics in 60, I think AI is going to redefine politics in the 2028 campaign. And so the 27-28 period that we're now entering in is a transition period. between the age of Trump and the age after Trump. And whereas I don't think much policy is going to get done in 27 and 28, I think the policy debates in 27 and 28, both in Washington on the campaign trail, is going to determine the policy direction of this country when the next president takes office in January.
00:39:01
Speaker 4: 20th of 2029.
00:39:02
Speaker 1: John, what's your thought?
00:39:05
Speaker 4: I agree with you. It's going to be wide open. I always thought it was going to be wide open because you There's partisan parity right now in the electorate where the Republicans and Democrats for the last few cycles have been about equal. When Doug was told about when Ronald Reagan became the nominee, you had two majorities in the country. You had an ideological majority of conservatives and you had a partisan majority of Democrats. And as those Democrats switched into the Republican Party, it became partisan parity, which the last two decades has been a competition between the Obama coalition and the Trump coalition. And they've been pretty close balanced. I mean, when George W. Bush got reelected, he only got 51% of the vote. When Trump won in 2024, he only got 50% of the vote. So there's this partisan parity. And you think about it, when Obama got reelected, he was losing the week before. And then Mitt Romney decided to skip over the Hurricane Sandy victims. And Obama got reelected with 3%. So when you have the bigger presidential turnouts nationally, those coalitions have been in this kind of pretty close balance. for control. And the primaries, as you look at it, a national primary
question that we've asked for, you know, among likely Republican primary rows, likely Democrat primary voters, primary is the one based on ideology, demographics, and geography. And the sequence of the primaries, I mean, right now we have Kamala Harris ahead. And she's ahead because she's ahead with African-American voters. She has the highest name ID, et cetera. But we did a poll for the California Post and over a week ago where AOC was ahead in California, not Newsom, which was a shock to the political system. And why? Because she had 41% among the most liberal voters, and she was ahead with Hispanic voters, and Hispanic voters are a third of their primary. So as the Democrat primary goes on, usually the African-American voters in South Carolina become really important in picking the nominee, whether it was Clyburn endorsing Joe Biden or whether it was Barack Obama winning. and defeating Hillary Clinton. Or then when you look in the Republican primaries, usually there's a conservative majority that when it swings through South Carolina and Super Tuesday, evangelical Christians dominate it. At one point, Donald Trump said to me in the beginning of 2016, he was worried about losing to Marco Rubio and Jeb Bush. And I said, they're not going to beat you. He said, why? I said, because they're Catholics. And he looks at me, he's kind of like puzzled by it. And I said, The majority of primary voters in the Republican primary are evangelical Christians, to which Mr. Trump then said to me, you know, I'm Presbyterian.
00:41:52
Speaker 3: And I was like, OK.
00:41:55
Speaker 2: By the way, John, the percent of people who voted on Tuesday that were evangelical is way down compared.
00:42:03
Speaker 3: To what it was before.
00:42:04
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:42:04
Speaker 4: And I pointed that out in a blog that I wrote for Newsmax, that not only were they down— When you look at it, we've won the Catholic vote by 20 points two years ago, and that's a big swing group, which includes Hispanics too. The Republicans going into the election were splitting with the Democrats. So the Democrats, just like when Joe Biden got elected, he had done better with Catholic voters because he was a Catholic. One thing's for sure, Trump is going to be the last baby boom president. When you think about it, you're going to have that generational change that you're talking about again, but it's who the parties pick. and the coalitions they were able to form that will shape 2028. What we saw in this election was the Republicans didn't have a strategy to win the middle for the midterms. They didn't win the moderates, they didn't win the independents, they didn't make progress among the moderates. So, the presidential election is more dependent upon the middle than the primary basis.
00:43:03
Speaker 2: Also, I think probably figuring out they can't keep rolling out the transgender stuff and think they're going to win elections.
00:43:10
Speaker 4: Well, that issue's changed. That was two years ago.
00:43:13
Speaker 1: We might actually have to go back to solving problems.
00:43:15
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:43:17
Speaker 1: That's my optimistic thing. Let me thank both of you, John and Doug. I always find these conversations so fascinating. And I hope sometime early next year we can get together again. And in between, by the way, everybody can... Keep track of these guys, and they're both worth following. John's polling is at McLaughlinOnline.com, and Doug's political memos are at DougSosnick.substack.com. And they're both remarkably well-informed, and I'm very grateful that you two would have this kind of a chat with me.
00:43:55
Speaker 3: Thanks for having us.
00:43:58
Speaker 1: Thank you to my guests, John McLaughlin and Doug Sosnick. Newt's World is produced by Gingrich360 and iHeartMedia. Our executive producer is Garnsey Sloan. Our researcher is Rachel Peterson. Special thanks to the team at Gingrich360. If you've been enjoying Newt's World, I hope you'll go to Apple Podcasts and both rate us with five stars and give us a review so others can learn what it's all about. Join me on Substack at gingrich360. net. I'm Newt Gingrich. This is Newt's World.