TRANSCRIPT 🔗
Megan Willome: George Orwell wrote that bad writing habits can be avoided if one is willing to take the necessary trouble. Welcome to Necessary Trouble, a pilgrimage into writing faithfully. Each season, we read a book about writing craft and critique each other's work right here in real time. As we grow in love of words, we grow in love of God and of our neighbor. Words, they're worth the trouble. All right, welcome to Necessary Trouble Season One. we are in chapter 10 of Marilyn McIntyre's Caring for Words and a Culture of Lives. I am Megan Willamy.
Tresta: I'm Tresta Payne.
Callie: I'm Kelly. I'm so sorry.
Tresta: Ha ha ha.
Megan Willome: And who are you? Who are you, sorry person?
Callie: I always forget who is who.
Megan Willome: Cowy fa Cowley Faye.
Callie: That's Kelly.
Tresta: Exactly.
Callie: Hi!
Megan Willome: and we are all we were talking before we started, we are all tired. We are all super duper tired, displaced. One person is sick. I'm sure the time change is in there, although we didn't we didn't bring that up. We're just all feeling
Callie: Ha ha ha.
Tresta: Yeah, right.
Megan Willome: it, but we're here today and This chapter is on play and I have a feeling that none of us are getting a lot of play in our lives right now. Can I get an amen?
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: Amen. although I did have my grandson, he stayed the night with us Sunday night, he's and he's two and a half. and
Megan Willome: nice.
Tresta: what a good time that is. So that was play.
Megan Willome: Okay. So you got you got your playing in. Okay.
Tresta: Yes. Yeah.
Megan Willome: See, I think that's the good thing about being a grandparent. It's dedicated
Tresta: Yeah, it keeps you.
Megan Willome: playtime.
Tresta: Yes. Yeah.
Callie: Haha, yeah.
Megan Willome: The rest of us don't get. We just don't know how to put it in there. But that's
Callie: Hmm.
Megan Willome: what Marilyn McIntyre is talking about in this chapter: playing not only with words, but approaching life in a playful way. So this was a longer chapter than I expected. I thought it might be a quick
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: one, but it was not.
Callie: Hahaha
Tresta: Which is such a great testimony that she's devoted so many words to to play. I love it.
Megan Willome: Absolutely. Absolutely. So is there a place where y'all would like to start?
Callie: Well, I could say we're recording this in my second month, I guess, of being a fifth grade teacher. And the chapter came to me at a very good time because all my students want to do is play.
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: And they'll do anything as long as they think it's fun. So I... jump through lot of hoops because I want to make sure that they are having fun in class. so one of the things that I know that they love is going outside. So a lot of my lessons take place outside or we will just go outside. But one of the things that two things that that came that stuck with me, the first one was play comes from loving life. And then she took a quote from Auden that said, if it's worth doing, it's worth doing badly. And I liked both of those for a couple of reasons. The first one is a reminder that my students want to play because they love life. And they might not be able to articulate that, but it is absolutely palpable. to see them play, like palpable joy to see them play, even if it's with words or in math or in going outside and kicking a soccer ball around. And then the other thing to remember or to remind me is we're not going to do these things perfectly. We're not going to know multiplication and the difference between an adjective and a verb right away perfectly. We have to play and we have to play a lot. And That's how I'm driving my classroom. So I really liked this chapter. I thought it was an important one for me to read as a teacher.
Megan Willome: Yeah, maybe giving you some inspiration.
Callie: Absolutely. absolutely. the other day I was in, class and they were, they were doing great. was like eight o'clock in the morning and we had been going, going, going, and it was about nine 30 and that you could just tell they were starting to like lose it. And they, you know, they were in their chairs, they were blah, blah, blah. They were doing all the things that they were supposed to be doing, but things were just starting to spark, you know, like it was like a pot of water was starting to boil and I could tell. And I thought for a second, I could fight my way through recesses in for another hour and a half, or I could just take them outside. So I was like, all right, guys, put your pencils down and line up. And they were like, what is happening right now? And I was like,
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: I'm going to give you five minutes. We're going outside. You run around, shake it all out. and then we're coming back in and we'll still go out for recess. Like I told them that we'll go out for real recess, but this is just pretend recess. We're going out and I gave them five minutes to just run around and I got another 60 minutes out of them. So it's just an important
Megan Willome: Who
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Callie: reminder that we ask a lot of students to sit in a classroom from essentially eight in the morning until three o'clock in the afternoon. And I know that
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: at high schools move from class to class and elementary too, there's a lot of movement that goes on. But in reality, they are contained within these four walls and it's constant learning. And I think if we don't put the play back into that, put the mystery back into it and put that like idea that if you're doing this, if this is worth learning, it's worth learning badly at first.
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: I think they're going to feel a lot safer to play and to learn.
Megan Willome: And it's important for us too. in a couple of weeks, excuse me, John and I will be going out of town for a wedding of son of some friends of ours. And as we get closer to it, we're thinking, my gosh, this is great.
Load full transcript
We're leaving the state for a weekend, you know, we're taking a big road trip. We're like, what do you want to do? Maybe we could. Go to the movies, because we don't have a movie theater here. We're too small. Tresta can appreciate that. it's
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: like, what what might we do in a big city? You know, just
Tresta: Good catchment.
Megan Willome: just the idea of getting to play for a three-day weekend right now sounds amazing.
Callie: Yeah, absolutely, absolutely. And we don't get it enough, I think. she even says it's not something that adults do enough.
Megan Willome: No.
Tresta: Yeah, so as writers,
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Tresta: I'm I'm thinking I'm thinking about Substack right now, because I I go back and forth with the type of writing that I hit publish on. and sometimes it just feels like I'm stuck in those four walls of a classroom and this is
Callie: Hmm.
Tresta: you know, this is I have to be serious, there has to be a point, there has to be some
Callie: Mm.
Tresta: spiritual application. It needs to be polished, but not too polished, because then people will think it's AI, right? But leave some typos in.
Callie: No.
Tresta: versus just not overthinking it, just playing with words and letting it be what it is and that and that my substack newsletter can be that
Callie: Mm-hmm
Tresta: playground, so to speak, you know, from the away from the serious writing that I might be doing for a a bigger project. I mean Substack can
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: be the the playground for just letting it go and being free.
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: I mean month or so ago I wrote an essay called Waning Gibbus and my one of my daughters said that she read it aloud to her husband and they just laughed. I'm like, really? Well that's you know, mission accomplished. If I can make somebody laugh, that's
Callie: Right. That's right. That's right.
Tresta: gosh, don't we need that?
Callie: Yeah, I've always thought of blogging as playing in a giant sandbox and just, you know, giving it, just not taking anything too seriously. But I think play has that seriousness to it that I don't know. guess that's the I'm seriously playing when I'm blogging.
Tresta: Right. And for me if I can lower that bar and just play, it does have
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: a value beyond just being funny. I mean, you know,
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: because I've lowered my defenses. I've lowered my
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: Sure,
Megan Willome: Well, and then sometimes
Callie: yeah.
Megan Willome: we end up as writers writing something unexpected because we're
Tresta: Yeah, yeah.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: playing. I think I've mentioned before that I am in a Thursday morning poetry group. I've been in it for 10 years. The group has been going for 30. It's an artist ray group.
Tresta: Wow.
Megan Willome: And the format is super simple. We sit around and talk. And a couple people make lists of words and then they read the list and then we write a poem. And you can use the list of words if you want to, but you don't have to. It's just like a jumping off point. And
Callie: Wow, that is so fun.
Megan Willome: because of that, I probably play more in my writing in that group. Cause there's no judgment, you know, the only things you're that anyone says, I won't say you're allowed to say, it's just who we are, is like, thank you, or that was really good. Or can you read that again? I mean,
Callie: Mm-mm.
Megan Willome: you know, this is not a critique group, it's really a play group. And often
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Callie: Mm-hmm. I love that.
Megan Willome: things that I write in there, maybe they're not good, but they're interesting. And I
Callie: Mmm.
Megan Willome: want to go back and revisit them. And sometimes they turned into things that are good, There goes my microphone.
Callie: Yeah, yeah.
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: See, this is
Megan Willome: Excited.
Callie: a perfect chapter for the situation that we're in right now. So everything needs to be playful right now for all three of us.
Megan Willome: That's right. What kind of day has it been? So how
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: do y'all play in in your writing? Do you have so trust you're bringing up a good thing that Substack is a place that can be playful or it can be taken very, very seriously because it is, let's be honest, it's part of our platform, right? As writers,
Callie: Right.
Megan Willome: all three of us are on there.
Tresta: Right. Yeah, there's room for both. Yeah, I
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: she says on page one hundred eighty nine that play involves risk and trust. And sometimes I'll be just hovering
Callie: Mmm.
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: over an essay. just analyzing it to death, second guessing myself, and I'll just like, okay, that's it, no more thinking, publish. It's like I'm just
Callie: Yeah, yeah.
Tresta: it just has to go. I just have to risk and trust.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: and it's nobody's gonna die if I put out an essay that's that's dumb. Nobody's what's the big deal? This is not a high stakes game. So
Callie: Right. Nobody's gonna die. I love that. Yeah.
Megan Willome: Why? It is not.
Callie: Yeah. That's right.
Megan Willome: You're not being graded. There's not gonna be some stamp come out of the ether and say this is dumb.
Callie: Right, you're done.
Tresta: Right. You're done. Yeah. Go to the principal's office.
Callie: Yeah, yeah.
Megan Willome: That's right. That's right.
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: So Callie, is it easier for you to play in your writing? Does that come a little more naturally for you?
Callie: I've never thought of writing as work, I guess. I'm trying to think. I mean, I know that, I know it's not that it's not hard. I'm trying to think of, I think that it's hard fun.
Megan Willome: Come?
Callie: I've never, I mean, am I crying while I'm writing? Sure, there are times where what I'm writing about makes me cry or it's very hard and I'm very frustrated because I can't get words on the page. But I try very
hard not to think about what the outcome of my writing is.
Megan Willome: Hmm.
Callie: I just try to attend to it as best I can. and then let it go.
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Callie: yeah, I was reading something the other day about figuring out like somebody had figured out who had unsubscribed to their blog. And I was like, huh, I didn't even know
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Callie: that like, you could do that. And why would you want to know that? Like, I don't even want to know that.
Megan Willome: Right, right.
Tresta: All right.
Megan Willome: I'm sure.
Callie: And yeah, in fact, I would like to, I would like to like get rid of the numbers on my, sub stack to see who subscribes. And I just, I don't that that's, that's not play, you know, I mean, I'm
Megan Willome: Now.
Callie: thinking if like you're in a sandbox and you're building and a, and a kid comes sitting next to you, like, you just want to say, here's a shovel, like, come on, let's just, let's just keep going, you know,
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: nobody is in there for, I don't know. Like we all know that we're not going to be professional sand builders. So let's just have some fun. You know, like, I don't
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: know. And, like with Trista says, we're, nobody's going to die. Like I'm, I'm, I'm okay. If, if what I'm writing is not going to be fantastic for today. Although I don't send stuff out that I'm not happy about. So I'm not going to. I'm not going to share something just to share it because I know when it's ready and when it's not ready.
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: Well, recently over Halloween, I don't know if you saw Callie, but you introduced me to that wonderful picture book, The Little Old Woman Who Wasn't Afraid of Anything.
Callie: my gosh, I love that book.
Megan Willome: And so you had written about it. This is what I love about Substack on your Substack a year ago, because you said that you always teach with it. And so I wrote a poem from it a year ago, and I'd been saving it for a year to run at Halloween.
Callie: fun.
Megan Willome: And I thought, okay, I'm I'm gonna put this out there. I had fun writing it. I'd shared the poem with you. You thought it was good. I'll just put it out there. Well, I got so many comments because so many people love that book, which I didn't know,
Callie: yay!
Tresta: Mm.
Megan Willome: but that made me so happy. Who's it by? Is it Linda Williams?
Callie: There is a Williams. Yeah, I think her last name is Williams. But yeah, I think it is Linda Williams. Yeah.
Megan Willome: Baritha Williams. Okay. Anyway, so that was completely something I did to play because I'm like, well, if Callie likes this book, I want to check it out. And then
Callie: It is so good.
Megan Willome: it's have you seen this book, Tresta? It's yeah, I'll put a link.
Tresta: I have not, no. Mm-hmm.
Callie: This is a great book to discuss for this chapter
Megan Willome: Ooh, it would be.
Callie: because it is all about keeping this playful attitude. when
I read it out loud to students, you you can see the pictures, the title is The Little Old Lady Who Isn't Afraid of Anything. There's a jack-o'-lantern that's following her and there's some shoes that are following her and there's a shirt that's following her. as the book progresses, you can tell the old lady is actually afraid. And at one point she runs into the house, slams the door and kind of sits in her rocker and is kind of clenched. And at that point I always pause and I say to the students, Is she afraid? And they're all like, yes. And I said, how can you
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: tell? And they're like explaining how she can tell. so anyway, she opens the door. I'm going to spoil everybody. She opens the door and she says to all these articles of clothing, I'm not afraid of you. And they're like, well, what are we going to do now? And it's such a sad moment
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: because their purpose They think their purpose is done. they believe that they're supposed to scare people. And so she thinks for a second and says, just a minute. And then anyway, she makes them into a scarecrow. And so my question is to the students, what can you do with your fear? So like, what can you create from your fear? And I think that's a very playful question because Fear is not, you don't really associate that with play. To be afraid does not sound very playful. But yeah, I think it's a great question to sit with is how can we take what we're afraid of and turn that into something, create from.
Megan Willome: Hmm. I think that's a great question. And frankly, that's something that Halloween invites us to do. It's to be able
Callie: Yes.
Megan Willome: to be a little bit scared, look at fears, and but then with this invitation for us as writers to create from them. I mean,
Callie: Yes.
Megan Willome: Marilyn McIntyre makes the point, and I think we've brought this up before, that the word essay means to try.
Callie: to try.
Megan Willome: To So It can be a place to just try.
Callie: Yeah, that's all we're doing. It's just,
Megan Willome: We're just trying.
Callie: it's just to try. Yeah. Yeah. I can remember, when, I, I, so I had a miscarriage before I had Hadley. And when I found out I was pregnant again, I called my mom up and I was just sobbing and she's like, like, why are you crying? And I was like, cause I don't want this to happen again. You know, I don't want it to happen again. And she's like, So you don't even want to try? And I thought it was such a, like the, her tone was so innocent and like shocked. Like, don't you just want to keep trying? Like, why wouldn't you want to just try? And she wasn't chiding me or, or she wasn't angry. It was just this like delightful innocence. And I'm like, yeah, well, yeah, I do want to try. But yeah, I think that's really what, the essay is about is it's just about trying. And I
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Callie: ask myself that all the time when I'm frustrated with writing is like, okay, this is painful. Do you want to stop? Don't you want to keep trying? And the answer is yes, I want to keep trying. So
Megan Willome: Yeah. Yeah, because sometimes we really surprise ourselves
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: and write something that I didn't know that was in there.
Callie: I didn't know that could come from there. Yeah.
Megan Willome: Yeah. Yeah. All right.
Callie: For sure.
Megan Willome: Well, I am in the trouble seat this week.
Callie: Yes.
Megan Willome: And I decided to, in the spirit of the chapter, do something playful. So
Callie: Thank
Megan Willome: Callie will know because she introduced me and we've mentioned him before. Kwame Alexander has written a few books, but one that she and I both love is called The Crossover.
Callie: Hmm.
Megan Willome: And it is a novel told in verse and it's for middle grade students because it's about junior high. Right. So would you consider it would it be YA since it's middle since it's junior high?
Callie: I think YA, you know, I don't know. I think YA starts in high school, but it's in all the elementary libraries.
Megan Willome: Yeah, okay. Okay. it's a wonderful book and he has it's about these twin brothers, it's about basketball, and it's fantastic. It won the Newberry, but he has this form of poem in there called the As in poem. And neither Callie nor I know if Kwame Alexander invented this or not. I would like to think he did. So what he does is
Callie: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Me too.
Megan Willome: he takes a Big word, a five dollar word that you don't know what it
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: means,
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: and he defines it at the beginning, like an actual dictionary definition, and tells you what part of speech it is, and then he goes through and says, as in, stanza by stanza to through the poem show you what the word means. So I decided to play and have a little fun. Because Marilyn McIntyre used the word that I'd never heard of concatenation.
Callie: Hmm.
Megan Willome: Had either of y'all heard of this word before? I just have to ask.
Callie: No.
Tresta: No, I hadn't. And I was I had put a box around it to look it up, but I got lazy and never did. So I'm
Callie: Hahaha
Tresta: so glad that you did find it.
Callie: Hahaha.
Megan Willome: I let's see if I can find what page that's on. I know it's near the bottom and I know I marked it, but now I can't find it. So anyway, I thought, okay, I'm gonna work I'm gonna work with this. I'm gonna play with this. So The way you do this is the title of the poem is the word. So I will read and then get feedback. I will read from the trouble seat and then Callie and Tresta will enlighten me. So concatenation, noun, a group of things linked together in a way that produces an effect. As in, this chapter contains Puddle Wonderful and a Mad Farmer and Wits. My favorite extraterrestrials, a veritable card deck of concatenation. As in when I sit on my rocker to write, I have poems, book quotes, notes scribbled in the dark onto neon index cards, a concatenation
to hopscotch through. As in when you stick your probe into cavity megan to play act an operation. You must excavate my hymnal without breaking it. Warning the pink duct tape may not hold together the concatenation of notes inside, and if you buzz me, I may hit a high one.
Tresta: Bravo. I love this.
Callie: Yeah. So I admit I skipped the definition just to see what would happen. So I read the poem and I think one of my comments is, let me see, where did I said? I love how it's showing itself to me in the second stanza and. I can, I get, I get the, I don't know, I just get the feeling of it, especially that word hopscotch. There is, there is a playfulness to that. And I think it shows like how we go about writing with these poems and book quotes and notes. They're all scribbled and we don't really always know what is going to come of these scribbles. And yet we're trying to find ways to link them together. And I liked the idea of, of hopscotch because that, is a playful game. it's also one that takes some effort to figure out, you know, how you're going to get to where you're going. So I really liked that. the other thing, that I noticed about Kwame Alexander's as in poems, there are three stanzas and each one gets more and more intense. It's deeper as it goes. And I think that's what has happened here. I especially find that third stanza. I think that one is the most intense, also like because of the word excavate, and cavity, feeling like I already feel that pinch of what a cavity might feel like. And then to excavate something also like entails some scraping, some cleaning, some lifting, some like, I don't know. It just feels like a lot. of of pinching I guess is what I'm trying to say and so it doesn't so I'm thinking like maybe something is not right here something's not going to go right and then this person who's probing cavity Megan and yet we've got this hymnal and a hymnal feels like okay a point of faith so we are being probed we are being excavated but we've got this hymnal within us. And then you say, and if you buzz me, I may hit a high one. And I'm interpreting that two ways. First of all, to be buzzed in operation. You're not, you know, you're not supposed to buzz the person, but I also know that you're a soprano. And that also came as a surprise to you that you, that you're a soprano. And so I think,
Megan Willome: Mm.
Callie: maybe a buzz. is some kind of a nerve that has been hit to produce beauty. And so that's
Megan Willome: Okay.
Callie: the way that I'm interpreting this third stanza.
Megan Willome: Ooh, interesting.
Tresta: Well done, Kelly. That was that was awesome. Yeah.
Megan Willome: Yeah. I'm making notes while they talk. Okay, go, Tresta.
Callie: You
Tresta: I love the juxtaposition of some of your words. Like in the third stanza, I this isn't a juxtaposition. They're related, but the cavity and excavate to take out
Callie: Hmm
Tresta: of a c to take out of a cavity. I love that. And just yeah, everything Callie said
about Getting deep inside, what's there? A hymnal, a concatenation
Callie: Mmm.
Tresta: of notes that are gathered in a way to produce an effect, as according to the definition of concatenation. I loved I loved reading it the second and third time and just really sinking into the definition because when I first read the c a can concatenation as a group of things linked together in a way that produces an effect. I was just thinking of nouns. So like in your second
Callie: Mm.
Tresta: stanza where you have poems, book quotes, notes, index cards. I was thinking of how that is a gathering of things that produce an effect
Callie: Hmm.
Tresta: when you're sitting down to write. but I think it's more than that and you got to it in the in that third stanza. It's more than just things that are gathered to produce an effect, I guess, is what I'm saying.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: and in the second stanza, I think it's a juxtaposition to have you sitting in your rocker and then talking about hopscotch. Because you have, you know, a rocker we think of an older an older person and you have
Callie: Mmm.
Tresta: hop hopscotch, which is the young kid. So it's you you sitting in your favorite comfy chair to play with
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: with the words that you've gathered on the neon neon
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: index cards. one thing I'd like to know more about because I don't want to read too much into it, but in the first stanza when you talked about Puddle Wonderful and Mad Farmer and Wit,
Callie: Cough
Tresta: your favorite extraterrestrials, why did you choose extraterrestrials?
Callie: Yeah, the first stanza was also something that I wanted to know more about as well.
Megan Willome: Yeah, as I look back, I'm not sure I like my first stanza all that much. but it's very much drawn from the chapter, as y'all can tell. Almost
Callie: Mmm.
Megan Willome: feel like it was getting ready to write,
Callie: Hmm.
Tresta: Mm.
Megan Willome: you know, versus writing. But okay, let's let's just say that this was prequel that doesn't need to be there. But but there is this three stanza quality to the as
Callie: Mm-hmm
Megan Willome: in poem. That's what makes me wonder then, do I do I need another stanza? And would it go would it replace the first one? Would it go as the second? Like is should the third one stay the third or should there be a a new one
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: after that is what I'm wondering now.
Tresta: I feel like they go in good order. You've got
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: you've got these layers in the first stanza you have you end with the card deck. In the second stanza you talk about index cards. In the second stanza you talk about the game of hopscotch. In the third stanza you talk about the game of operation. So I feel
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: like I feel like they're all tied together that way.
Callie: Mm-hmm So maybe the first stanza is some kind of a game. Although you do have the card deck in the first one, in the first stanza.
Tresta: Mm. True. That's a game too. Game words.
Callie: I think with the first stanza, a reader would need to know that this is coming from, and that was the only reason that it took me out of it, because I was thinking, I feel like I need to know something about this. And so I paused, but then the second and the third stanzas, I was like, okay, I'm right here, I'm right here.
Megan Willome: Yeah, yeah. I see what you're saying.
Callie: but I do like the the imaginativeness of the first stanza. mean, that, that puddle wonderful is such a great word. and wits and mad farmer and even extraterrestrials, you know, there's this, whimsical vibe to the first stanza that I really like. And I think that's how we need to start the as in poems too is, gentle entering.
Megan Willome: Hm, okay.
Tresta: I wonder if you just if you left those three things but instead of saying this chapter was it Elliot that used the word puddle wonderful? Cummings.
Megan Willome: No, it's Cummings, E. E. Cummings.
Callie: Hmm.
Tresta: Yeah, if you said as in Cummings' Puddle Wonderful and Barry's Mad Farmer and who was the she talked about done. It's wit.
Megan Willome: Yeah, with wet. Yeah. Okay.
Tresta: Maybe.
Megan Willome: Yeah, well I'm at least make the notes to go back to.
Callie: I love it.
Tresta: I do too.
Megan Willome: Well, one reason I love poetry is I am very willing to play when I sit down to
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: write a poem. And then it's once I start editing and once I start thinking, Okay, there is such and such a journal, you know, with a deadline
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: of the fifteenth, and that's when I start freaking out a little bit when I'm trying to make
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: Ha ha ha.
Megan Willome: them a little bit better and they're no longer playful. I'm I'm not approaching them in that way, but I do try to at least
Callie: Right.
Megan Willome: start from a place of play.
Callie: Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Megan Willome: I just want to fill pages in my notebook. I really don't care if it's any good. And I do
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: that a lot. I I read a lot of poetry, whether I'm reading it on Substack or whether it's the collection that I'm reading or or whatever,
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: and I'm I'll read something and think, ooh, that looks like fun. I want to try that.
Callie: Yeah, yeah.
Megan Willome: So I'll try it. And maybe it's good, maybe it isn't. But usually something good comes from the trying, especially if it's a form poem.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: I didn't know you could write a sonnet that way. That's a different rhyme scheme than I've ever seen. But it's obviously a sonnet. Let me try that.
Callie: Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. I love what you said. Usually something good comes from the trying. I think that's a great thing to remember.
Tresta: On page one ninety-one, one thing I underlined McIntyre says she's talking about play and and being childlike. That play gives us lets us be free to look stupid in the interests of
honesty, because there are no
Callie: Mmm.
Tresta: grades and there is no competition in the kingdom of heaven. But
Callie: So...
Tresta: just free to look stupid in the interest of honesty. It's like better better to be pursuing something good and maybe look stupid and in the process than to be pursuing
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: something selfish or evil and and also look stupid, you know. You're trying you're reaching
Callie: Yeah. Yeah. I love that.
Tresta: for a good thing.
Callie: For reaching for a good thing. That's, that's yeah. I love that.
Megan Willome: When I'm I'm thinking of a friend of mine, she's not a writer, but she's just very honest. She's just not capable of telling anything that's even a half truth, you know, and it's so
Callie: You
Megan Willome: refreshing
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: to be around her.
Callie: Yeah, I love that.
Megan Willome: yeah, because of that honesty that trust is talking about.
Callie: I have a friend like that too and I can even tell when it's on her face, you know, like when she is going to say something or really wants to say something, but you know, we're in a group setting or whatever and you could just see it on her face. And I was like, it's coming. It's coming. I love it. I love it. Even when it's directed at me, I'm like, okay, let's go.
Megan Willome: Let's go. Well, then Tresta, you have these little ones in your life, and they're they are just who they are.
Tresta: They're honest.
Callie: my gosh, they are. they're so cute. Yeah.
Megan Willome: No, I don't like that food that you just made me.
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: my goodness, I have to share this. So he Augustine yesterday he asked it to watch Bob the Builder. And so I was turning it on and I said, Can we fix it? And he says he says,
Callie: yeah.
Tresta: Can we not fix it like
Callie: you
Tresta: my gosh, you're hilarious, kid.
Megan Willome: my gosh, he's
Callie: That's so funny.
Megan Willome: already got that sense of humor.
Tresta: Can we not? Yeah. Yeah. I know. Exactly. I loved the last
Callie: Can we not? Can we not do this right now? I just want to watch the show. So funny. My, remember Hanley when she was really young, two or three, I came, you know, out of the bedroom or something and I was, you know, we were ready to go somewhere and she's like, do you like the way that you look right now?
Tresta: honesty. my gosh.
Callie: I was like, I guess not. Do you like the way you look right now? All right,
Megan Willome: Ouch Ouch.
Callie: this from somebody who forgets to put on underpants every day, know, like, but you're
Tresta: Right, right.
Callie: yeah, the honesty that they have is hilarious.
Tresta: That's funny.
Callie: Hmm.
Megan Willome: That's great. That's great.
Callie: Huh.
Megan Willome: Well, is there anything else? I think I'm gonna revisit that first stanza of mine for sure.
Callie: I think it's solid. I'd love to see what you do with the stanza if you wanted to do something with it, but I think it's a great poem.
Megan Willome: Do you think the third stanza should stay the third stanza? Or do you think that there's some place I need to go and explore that I haven't yet?
Callie: I don't think so. Yeah, I
Tresta: I think it's a great place to end. I think it's
Callie: mean.
Tresta: like Callie said, it gets more and more intense. I think it's a it's a great place to end.
Callie: Yeah. Yeah, I would, I think I would be, I don't know what I would be. I really like it being left on the high note.
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm. Okay.
Callie: Because I don't know exactly this good? Is this bad? It makes me feel like this is what it feels like to have a gift. It is, we are being excavated or we are excavating ourselves when we're using ourselves. So.
Megan Willome: I like that. Here I'm writing this down.
Tresta: Or maybe yeah, maybe the high note is just a a scream of protest if someone were to try to remove the hymnal from you.
Callie: maybe that's what
Megan Willome: Hmm,
Callie: it is.
Megan Willome: maybe. I will say I
Callie: I like it.
Megan Willome: have been offered many times, would you like to grab a new hymnal from the stack?
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: And I'm like, no. One, the paint
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: I like the pink duct tape one.
Megan Willome: duck tape, everyone knows it's mine. And then secondly, I have years worth of notes in there. I I
Callie: Yeah, my goodness.
Tresta: Mm, mm.
Megan Willome: don't want to have to redo all of those.
Callie: Yeah, no.
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: Yeah, if it's still working, yeah, I would have such a hard time getting rid of something like that.
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Tresta: That reminds me of when my dog was a puppy and she got a hold. She never chewed shoes, but she chewed books and she chewed my husband's Bible that had years and years of notes.
Callie: shoot.
Tresta: Yeah. That was a sad, sad day.
Callie: that's so hard.
Megan Willome: Well, near the end of the chapter, and I mentioned it in my poem, but McIntyre referenced Wendellberry's Mad Farmer. So you know, he passed away, of course, not that long ago, but for anyone who does not know Manifesto, the Mad Farmer Liberation Front, I'm going to read it because you need to know it. So, Mad Farmer. Love the quick profit, the annual raise, vacation with pay. Want more of everything ready-made. Be afraid to know your neighbors and to die. And you will have a window in your head. Not even your future will be a mystery anymore. Your mind will be punched in a card and shut away in a little drawer. When they want you to buy something, they will call you. When they want you to die for profit, they will let you know. So, friends, every day do something that won't compute. Love
Callie: Okay.
Megan Willome: the Lord. Love the world. Work for nothing. Take all that you have and be poor. Love someone who does not deserve it. Denounce the government and embrace the flag. Hope to live in that free republic for which it stands. Give your approval to all you cannot understand.
Praise ignorance, for what man has not encountered he has not destroyed. Ask the questions that have no answers. Invest in the millennium. Plant sequoias. Say that your main crop is the forest that you did not plant, that you will not live to harvest. Say that the leaves are harvested when they have rotted into the mold. Call that prophet. Prophesy such returns and Put your faith in the two inches of humus that will build under the trees every thousand years. Listen to Carrion. Put your ear close and hear the faint chattering of the songs that are to come. Expect the end of the world. Laugh. Laughter is immeasurable. Be joyful, though you have considered all the facts. So long as women do not go cheap for power, please women. More than men. Ask yourself, will this satisfy a woman satisfied to bear a child? Will this disturb the sleep of a woman near to giving birth? Go with your love to the fields, lie easy in the shade, rest your head in her lap, swear allegiance to what is nighest your thoughts. As soon as the generals and the politicos can predict the motions of your mind, lose it. Leave it as a sign to mark the false trail, the way you didn't go. Be like the fox who makes more tracks than necessary, some in the wrong direction. Practice resurrection.
Callie: I love that poem.
Tresta: Me too. That's another another one I have half memorized. I need to finish.
Megan Willome: Ooh, I am impressed, Justin. Do you know how far ish you got?
Tresta: to the sequoias, plant sequoias, I yeah. Yeah. But don't test me. Yeah.
Megan Willome: to the Sequoia's okay. It's a long. No, I'm not going to, I'm not going to. But I'm
Callie: So long,
Megan Willome: but I'm seriously impressed.
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: Well, I'm not finished, so don't be impressed. Push me to finish.
Callie: You
Megan Willome: Does it, you know, because I I do memorize poetry, but in this doesn't have form, but does it does it kind of propel itself forward? Like do you see a logic as you start to memorize
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: it?
Tresta: Yeah. yeah. Yeah. And it reminds me, the beginning of it, about your mind being punched in a card and shut away in a little drawer. It reminds me of I think it's a T. S. Elliot poem to the unknown citizen. Yeah, it it begins it's very nineteen eighty four ish. Like, you know, the government is keeping an eye on this person and if anything had been wrong surely we would have known and
Megan Willome: Yeah. So Callie, you have read this poem before? The Okay.
Callie: I yes. I love the line, do something every day that doesn't compute.
Megan Willome: Mm.
Tresta: At the end of this chapter she talks about she talks a lot about wit. Do you guys feel like poetry is just a natural avenue for wit?
Megan Willome: Mm.
Callie: Yeah, I think of wit, then I think of clever and I think poetry, you have to have those. You have to be clever, you have to have wit to be a poet. And I'm not saying like everything has to be funny, but there has to be some kind of,
I don't know. don't know what I want to say about it. It feels like a dart or a change of seeing things differently.
Tresta: Well, it's like when you were talking about play in the classroom and getting your kids out to run around
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: or using games to teach them things. It's kind of
Callie: Yeah.
Tresta: like coming at you sideways, sneaking in so y you don't you don't know and then all of a sudden you know. Like,
Callie: Mm-hmm. Yeah, yeah.
Tresta: The poem is by Aden, the unknown citizen.
Callie: Mmm.
Megan Willome: by odd, okay, okay.
Tresta: Yeah.
Megan Willome: Well, Callie, I like that word dart that you used, because one
Callie: Hmm.
Megan Willome: of the things McIntyre says is real wit waits, you know, she's not necessarily talking about ha ha funny, but that that cleverness,
Callie: Right.
Megan Willome: that dart that affects something.
Callie: Yeah. And it's precise.
Megan Willome: It's precise, yes.
Callie: And you have to know how to use it. And you have to know what you're aiming for, but
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Callie: maybe you don't. Yeah, I don't know. I just I like what that poem does. And I think that, yeah, it's full of wit.
Megan Willome: Well, it is. It is. It's very sharp.
Callie: Yeah. Maybe that's what I mean. Sharp.
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: Yeah, I just I wanted to to clarify 'cause she's using it in the the John Dunn sense of wit and not the stand up comic sense of wit. Although occasionally
Callie: Yeah.
Megan Willome: there can be real moments of wit and incision in a really good stand up comic. You know.
Callie: Sure, sure. I think a poet can be humorous and also can be witty. I think
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Callie: there's lots of, lots of, I mean, and writers too. I think we need both.
Megan Willome: Yeah. And I think that most of us contain more than one. We contain multitudes,
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: right? But it's easy to let ourselves get pigeonholed, kinda like you were talking at the beginning, Tresta, of this is the kind of essay that I write when I'm on Substack. Even though you've written so many different types of things, right?
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: But it's easy to box ourselves in.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: Yeah, I agree.
Megan Willome: And this is
Tresta: There's so much more to write if we don't box ourselves in. There's no reason to ever have writer's block, but
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: Yeah. Yeah.
Megan Willome: Yeah. And that's why I know all of us try to to read a lot and to enrich ourselves with a variety of things that st stir us in ways we wouldn't
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: have expected.
Callie: Mm-hmm. Yeah, I can remember when I set out to write what is now my second book, but it was supposed to be my first book. L. Barquette said, want you to write as if you cannot write about faith and you can't write about motherhood. And at first I was like, what? Because that's basically
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: all that
I was doing. But man, did that free me up. I could, and
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: they're, they're in both of the books, there is motherhood and I don't think there's overt faithfulness, faith based in those first two books, but I think one could read it and see it as such. But at any rate, it really freed me up to explore other things. And I've always taken that with me when I sit down to write is okay.
Megan Willome: Interesting.
Callie: When I'm headed towards motherhood, what else can I write about it? And when I'm headed towards faith, what else? I mean, sometimes those things are great to write about. They
Megan Willome: Right.
Callie: should be written about. But there's so much more as well.
Megan Willome: Well it's like she forced you to play a little bit, you wanted to just
Callie: She did.
Megan Willome: use here are my two tools. And she's like, Okay,
Callie: Yeah, yeah.
Megan Willome: there's all kinds of other stuff in this sandbox that you're not paying
Callie: Right.
Megan Willome: attention to.
Callie: And what's so funny was she, she reached out to me based on what I was writing about. So I was like, great. You know, these, these are what she's happy with this, this type of writing. But then she's like, I want your writing and I want you to think about it in this different kind of way. She did the same thing to me with a poetry column years ago when I was doing, was like, I'm not poet, what are you talking about? And she's like, Yeah, I want you to go ahead and do this. And that was also so
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: Yeah.
Callie: fun. Yeah, I mean, she just she always had a great way of like, picking things for me that I guess took me out of my comfort zone. But I don't really it was really like, hey, come into the sandbox. We're trying this. Do you want to give it a shot? And I was like, Yeah, sure. Okay.
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: So
Megan Willome: Well, she did the same thing with me with, would you write a monthly column about children's books? Which
Callie: Mmm.
Megan Willome: I loved, but I hadn't ever written about them in a any kind of a professional way, you know, or any
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: kind of a for publication way is what I mean. And then
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: also with adult books, because there would be a theme every year at Tweet Speak Poetry. So
Callie: yeah.
Megan Willome: every book review had to tie into the theme in some way.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: And so that was a challenge, but it was a playful challenge. It didn't feel
Callie: Sure.
Megan Willome: like an edict. It felt like like, okay, here's the hand you've been dealt, here's your deck
Callie: Yes.
Megan Willome: of cards. This is what you got. What can you do with it?
Callie: Yes. Yes. I agree. Good assignments.
Megan Willome: We learned a lot. We learned a lot.
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Callie: We did. We did learn a lot.
Megan Willome: Was there anything else in this chapter that y'all wanted to talk about? That we miss?
Tresta: There's a whole paragraph I outlined, boxed on page two hundred and two where she's talking about wit, and I just I wrote in the margin that it's the first Corinthians 13 of wit.
Callie: Hmm.
Megan Willome: Mm-hmm.
Tresta: She's just stating all these things that wit is and does. wit doesn't I won't read the whole paragraph, but wit doesn't argue with sophists, simpletons, or demagogues. It waves them on their downward path with a quip. Wit withers with a smile, it never wrangles, it prefers fine pointed instruments to bludgeons and uses them to more effect. And she just she just goes on and on detailing all these things and it just reminded me of First Corinthians thirteen. Yeah.
Callie: I love that.
Megan Willome: Yes. my goodness. I'm rereading it as we speak. The first
Tresta: Yeah, the last sentence of that paragraph, it doesn't proselytize or preach, but it does speak truth to power, expose
Callie: Mm.
Tresta: the hypocrite, and incite its victims to the distressing self awareness that they may have sought to avoid. medicine.
Callie: Yeah, I love it.
Megan Willome: Very good. Very good. I'm gonna reread that one. All right. Well thank you, Tresta. who has the tip this week? Okay, go for it, Callie.
Callie: believe I do. Okay, so this one I was trying to think of play and how we can use play in our writing. So I have a story first and that happens to do the tip. So I was a freshman in college and it was the spring and I had, I have a terrible time with transitions. Like I did not college at all for like the first three months. And it wasn't until January where I started to like it a little bit more. But I started to get, I began letting go of stuff, not physical stuff, but just like stuff that I was holding onto in Chicago and trying to make fit into my life at Calvin. And anyway, it was, was happened right, right around March that I finally broke up with a guy that I was dating who was, you know, he's perfectly fine. But the distance was just not good. It was just not working out, blah, blah, blah. And I got off the phone and I was crying. I was in my dorm room and there were all my friends, know, I had seven or eight really tight friends by that point. They were all sitting in my room and I came in and I was, you know, they could see that I was crying and they were all like, And then I just started laughing so hard. And That feeling was so strange to me. I'm like, how can I be so happy and also sad at the same time? But I knew it was because I was shedding myself. I was, I was molting. And so I tried to take that feeling, which is really a shock. was a, it was a shock to experience those two feelings at the same time. into my writing. So if I'm writing about something hard that I know is making me sad, will absolutely or angry or whatever it is, I will absolutely write it all out, get all of it out. And then I will say, what else? So then I will go back and usually with another color or a highlighter, I will highlight stuff that is
the what else. And sometimes the what else is simply I wrote that pain in a very beautiful way. And it made it so that I believe that the reader will be able to bear it because I'm done bearing it. I'm done bearing
Megan Willome: I could do.
Callie: it alone. And I think that that scene in my life is sort of an arrow to all of that because I was done bearing whatever I was going through. I wasn't going through alone. all these other girls were in the exact same situation with me with this whole idea of molting and growing. And it's like a kindergarten on steroids.
Megan Willome: Mm, mm.
Callie: So at any rate, I always think of that scene in my life when I'm having trouble writing another scene where I'm like, okay, I know this is probably very, very sad. And so get it down and then ask yourself, what else is there?
Megan Willome: Okay.
Callie: Was the day gorgeous?
Megan Willome: Hmm.
Callie: What was the meal? What was going on at the meal? Who was there? What were you wearing? Is there anything that can balance out the scene? And even if there is not, is there something that's beautiful that we can hold onto as we go into the next one? even if that's the ending as we carry this on with our, as we carry this story together. So that's my tip. And it's definitely a lot
Megan Willome: Well up there.
Callie: of trouble.
Megan Willome: Well, yes, but one thing I what I like about this that you're sharing, I have noticed that often when I do that first step of writing something out, okay, I need to write this.
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: I can be at the beginning a little too satisfied with what I've written.
Callie: Right?
Megan Willome: You know, like, okay, I got it down. There it is.
Callie: Yes.
Megan Willome: And then I look at it a few days later and I'm like, Did I really need to write that? But I think
Callie: Yes.
Megan Willome: if I followed what you're saying, what else,
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: then I might begin to see what is actually worth exploring or what what's more worthwhile than just a little therapy through the pencil?
Callie: Exactly, exactly. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, think, I think it's so good to honor your experience and, how you experienced it. And, and if it means that it was sad or angry or whatever, put it out there. but yeah, the go, go back and ask what, what else is there? You know, you can think about it as a picture, you know, what's, what's right in the picture, but what's not. quite in focus or what's not in the picture and what can you add to that? And again, it may still be a very sad scene.
Megan Willome: Sure.
Callie: But I think, yeah, yeah, how can you help
Tresta: But it gives perspective. I think it adds perspective because there's never just one thing.
Callie: the reader hold it so that you don't have to anymore?
Megan Willome: It's so good. Do you have any thoughts on this, Tresta?
Tresta: No, I I think I can just write what else on a note card and put it on my computer and it will remind me 'cause
sometimes,
Megan Willome: Yeah.
Callie: Yeah, yeah, what else?
Tresta: you know, the first brush is the easiest thing. And then asking what else, even if even if you've written something that's hard or difficult, sometimes
Callie: Yeah!
Tresta: it's it's easy to just tell about it, but to say what else, I mean that's there's more going on. There's not just one thing that you're feeling about it or one thing that's happening.
Callie: Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah.
Megan Willome: this is good. And I like the idea of coming back in another color too. I'm very color conscious. Yeah.
Callie: Me too. I'm very color oriented. I can. Yeah. And it'll help you look for those things too. Now I find myself looking for those kinds of scenes, you know, in TV or books or whatever. It's kind of nice to collect them. One scene that comes to mind, I don't know if you guys have ever seen the movie Return to Me. It's one of my favorite movies. I won't go into what it's about, but there's one scene that is So, so sad. It's just, it's heartbreaking. And Minnie Driver is one of the actresses. And then I can't remember. she's so good. And I feel terrible that I can't remember what her name is, but Bonnie, Bonnie Hunt, I think. She, she's the one who wrote the, the screenplay. So she, they're both on the couch and, they're both crying and they're, they don't know what they're going to do and blah, blah, blah, blah. And at one point, Minnie Driver screams, what was God thinking? And it was, it's so funny, but also you're, you're really sad. And I'm like, this is so true to the situation. It was absolutely what I, we're all thinking at this point. We're all wondering what in the world was God thinking. And at any rate, kinds of things, I like to collect those kinds of things because I like to. mimic in my own right.
Megan Willome: Yeah. Well, I I recently read Pachinko, which is the novel. It's a historical drama that takes place in Korea. things I liked about it, things I didn't, but I really loved her author's note at the end. And she talked about how this book was thirty years in the making and how she's not an efficient writer, but those inefficiencies were such gifts to the plot as she talks
Callie: Nice.
Megan Willome: about different places where she lived and you know how that informed the story and
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: et cetera et cetera et cetera but I thought yeah there's you know let's let's raise a toast to inefficiency.
Callie: Yes, please, always.
Tresta: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: Yeah, because it's a I'm sure it's a better story for that time and those experiences that wove their way into the plot.
Callie: Yes,
Megan Willome: So
Callie: I'm always on the side of inefficiency.
Megan Willome: Yeah. All right. Well, that is it for this episode. next week we will read chapter 11, which you know this chapter just had one word, it was play. For next week, it's pray.
Callie: Hmm.
Megan Willome: So if you are reading along and if you are writing along, and if you are on Substack, which we hope that you are, feel free to join us and drop a link. In the comments and let us know if you've written something from the chapter because we'd love to go over there and support each other. Our
Callie: Mm-hmm.
Megan Willome: blessing for this week is from page 183. And it's blessed are those who love words, delight in them, honor their possibilities, and take them seriously.
Callie: Amen.
Megan Willome: All right, thank you all so much and we'll see you soon.
Callie: Thank you.
Tresta: Thanks, guys.
Callie: Bye.
Megan Willome: Alright. Thank you for listening to Necessary Trouble as we read Marilyn McIntyre's Caring for Words in a Culture of Lies. Follow us at NecessaryTroublePodcast.substack.com. For more writing and trouble from us, visit our websites listed in the show notes.