TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Back to Murph and Marcus on The Sports Leader. Streaming live on thesportsleader.com and KNBR. The Sports Leader app. Murph and Marcus is sponsored by Bigelow Tea. Grab a mug and tea proudly. spanning the globe.
00:00:31
Speaker 2: We're going to get drunk before the game. We're going to get drunk during the game. And then we get drunk after the game.
00:00:37
Speaker 3: The thrill of victory. The agony of defeat.
00:00:44
Speaker 2: I'll be in Ireland like looking around going, damn, I lost.
00:00:46
Speaker 3: This is the wide world of Walt.
00:00:50
Speaker 2: Oh yeah, the Wednesday tradition.
00:00:52
Speaker 3: Great open.
00:00:53
Speaker 2: Always fires me up. Mike Brown always gets me going. It is at this time because it is the midpoint of the week. The 7.15 segment in the Wednesday show. J.D. John Dickinson in for... an ailing Marcus Boucher, who will be back eventually, one of these days. JD, this is that point where you almost like, my theory is it starts to maybe point the ship slightly towards the weekend, the midpoint show, you know? But you haven't, I mean, literally, I guess you've turned the corner. No, not there, not yet, just the beginning, just the beginning.
00:01:24
Speaker 4: I wouldn't feel like I've turned the corner till maybe the end of this show.
00:01:27
Speaker 2: Okay, or till the end of Wide World or Walt. Walt, take it away. What do you got for the first-timers around here, buddy?
00:01:32
Speaker 5: All right, so you know the deal, Murph. JD, I'll break it down for you. Welcome in to the Wide World of Walt 715 segment.
00:01:38
Speaker 2: I've played before.
00:01:39
Speaker 5: I know you've played before, but I've got to reintroduce it to everybody. We've got first-timers like the 12-year-old kid.
00:01:45
Speaker 3: Yeah, exactly.
00:01:46
Speaker 5: So what we do is I will read the question, you will answer it, and I will award a point. So all day, all week, I've been trying to figure out ways to penalize JD for not being in the KMBR Fantasy League. But actually, I'm going to start today... By penalizing Murph. Because, Murph, you did lose to me in fantasy. We buried the lead at the beginning of the week. I got to remind all the listeners, football mensch did lose to the initials of Derek Papa.
00:02:16
Speaker 2: Because we can't say it. I just got to take my ass whipping, bro, like a man. I mean, the squad ain't happening. This could be my... This could be my 2026 Tony V. Buster year. This could be the year it just ain't happening for me, dude. Devon Anchan, down.
00:02:31
Speaker 4: A.J.
00:02:31
Speaker 2: Brown, down. Mike Evans, knocked out. But, hey, we will rise and fight again. We'll lay me down, bleed a while, and I'll rise and fight again. Don't count out football mensch. I was thinking, though, I'm so injured, I was thinking changing my team name to the 49ers. But, anyway, well, take your flowers. By the way, congrats on your first win of the year. You were 0 for prior to that.
Load full transcript
00:02:54
Speaker 3: All right, what else we got, buddy?
00:02:55
Speaker 4: This is like the Rockies getting their elixir against the Giants.
00:02:58
Speaker 2: This is like when the Rockies played the Giants is what it was. Thank you.
00:03:02
Speaker 3: Thank you.
00:03:03
Speaker 2: All right, buddy.
00:03:03
Speaker 5: All right, so let's go ahead and get on into it. Talking about the Rockies and Giants, they're not in the playoffs. MLB playoffs started yesterday. A lot of fun if you're watching it, if you're dialed in. But I'm going to ask you guys this one straight off the rip. Because the Giants aren't in it, what are the playoffs here in the Bay Area?
00:03:18
Speaker 3: It's been a while.
00:03:20
Speaker 5: Giants aren't in it. We got to root against the Dodgers. Who is your pick? to take down the Dodgers and prevent the three-peat.
00:03:26
Speaker 2: So you mean who I think, like, analytically, or in my heart, like, I would like to see? I need a little clarification, to be honest.
00:03:34
Speaker 5: I mean, any way that you want to take it. Who you think is going to actually analytically win it, or who you want it to be?
00:03:40
Speaker 2: Okay, well, so J.D. already fired his shot earlier today. I don't feel like I want to steal his thunder, so I got to kind of root around elsewhere to... Listen, man, I think I got to go with the squad that just I just kind of don't think they really have it in them. But I would like to see them do it. They've never won a World Series. Their manager's last name is Murphy. They tailgate in the parking lots. They're brought eating beer, swilling ball fans. They got a guy who throws 119 miles an hour. They don't have a star-laden squad, but they'll be fun to see. Why not? The Miele Wacke Brewers finally deliver after being the one seed how many years in a row? Listen, Kyle Harrison, our kid, our buddy, he'll be in the bullpen there, but there's not like a guy you can hit your wagon to, maybe a Christian Yellich, maybe a Miz, obviously, the starter, but Murphy in the dugout, good, hearty Midwestern fans. Why not reward a medium, small market team? I'm going with the Brewers, J.D. and Walt.
00:04:40
Speaker 4: I'll stay consistent. I'm going to stick with the San Diego Padres. They got a little magic going. 17 in the last 20 going into last night, and they were dominant last night. Fernando Tatis Jr., Manny Machado getting it done. They've got the star power. They've got the youth, and they've got the bullpen, which is exactly what you need to to be able to win in the post season. So it's going to be a league championship series. The giants fans are going to have to Padres Dodgers, but Padres take them out.
00:05:12
Speaker 2: I think it's a bit, I couldn't take the take cause he had already shot his shot and you always want to kind of create controversy by taking some of those. It's hard to argue though. It might be their time. They're getting hot. They're doing what the 2010 giants to get hot at the
right time. And they have a great bullpen. And Oh, by the way, Petco is popping too. Down in, as you guys know, Diego. All right, what else you got, Walt? Who got the point, by the way?
00:05:35
Speaker 3: You lost that point. Point goes to JD.
00:05:37
Speaker 5: I mean, I do think that the Padres are going to dray at some point.
00:05:42
Speaker 2: No love for the Brew Crew? I don't believe in the Brewers, man. What about the jersey that says Brew Crew?
00:05:47
Speaker 3: I like that jersey. That's actually a solid jersey. Also, quick question.
00:05:50
Speaker 4: Did I actually win that point, or did I lose the point, but I'm getting the point because of the whole fantasy football thing?
00:05:57
Speaker 2: No, no, no.
00:05:58
Speaker 3: Oh, wait. Going back to the beginning?
00:06:00
Speaker 4: Because you made it out like I didn't actually win the point. So you didn't win a point. You didn't win a point, but he lost a point. So he's negative one, and you're one. But I was negative one on fantasy football. Am I now negative two?
00:06:11
Speaker 3: No, no, no. So you don't lose points.
00:06:13
Speaker 5: We're not making up rules here. So that question didn't count. No, it wasn't really a question. It's just a jab at Murph.
00:06:19
Speaker 2: Who won the MLB question?
00:06:21
Speaker 3: MLB question is JD. I already said that.
00:06:23
Speaker 1: Okay, okay.
00:06:26
Speaker 2: You didn't really say that. You said he lost a point.
00:06:28
Speaker 3: I'm out of order.
00:06:29
Speaker 2: You're out of.
00:06:29
Speaker 3: Order, says Al Pacino. I'm keeping count in my head.
00:06:32
Speaker 2: Yeah, he had a better answer. Listen, I'm just going with the Brewers. The Brewers, you can't even name like three Brewers. I picked a team I can't even name their lineup. They are very invisible. They are an obscure great team, but they do have the Miz. And shout out the Miz, who, friend of the program, came in studio back at Battery and Broadway. The wrestler, The Miz. Question number two.
00:06:52
Speaker 5: All right, question number two for those of you that are keeping count. All right, so let's go ahead and get into it. What happens first? The 49ers lose a game or the Warriors win a game?
00:07:03
Speaker 2: It's on you, JD. Oh, man. I think the 49ers are going to lose a game first. I do.
00:07:09
Speaker 4: I don't think the 49ers are going to beat both the Broncos and the Seahawks. And, man, the Warriors are going to get, they might be 1-4 when this thing starts, but I do think they'll win their home opener against Memphis on October the 23rd. And the Niners, if I had to bet, Seattle gets them. Not in blowout fashion coming up a week from this coming Sunday on October the 11th.
00:07:33
Speaker 2: So I'm going to say Niners. But, yeah, that's... close one. It's a good question. Just to make sure everybody knows the Warriors schedule because I didn't have to look it up until October 21st. They're at at Luca, not LeBron. They're at Luca on Wednesday, October. I would like to get that one. I would like to win that game. And then they host as JD knows because he's a savant and stuff like this. The Friday, October 23rd home openers against Memphis. They got to win that game, right? They're going to beat the Memphis Grizzlies. I'm giving them that one. It might be the only one the first week, though. There's three games before then. The 49ers, they host Denver on Sunday at Seattle October 11th and host Brandon Ayuk's Washington Commanders on October 19th. So will the Niners go 3-0 before the Lakers beat the Warriors? I hope not. I hate to mimic J.D., but he's right. October 11th at Seattle is a big ask with all the injuries. Niners will lose at Seattle before the Warriors win versus Memphis at home. I have the identical answer.
00:08:32
Speaker 3: Identical.
00:08:33
Speaker 2: So who are you going to give it to?
00:08:35
Speaker 3: The person that said it first. J.D. gets the.
00:08:38
Speaker 2: My brain's beating.
00:08:39
Speaker 3: I'm sorry.
00:08:39
Speaker 4: All right.
00:08:40
Speaker 2: Quickly. What else you got? All right.
00:08:42
Speaker 4: Let's keep it going. Payback from the, uh, for the round table, the, the left fielder off.
00:08:47
Speaker 2: I guess I should have, uh, come up with a different answer just to spice things up. Should have. I had to stay true to myself though.
00:08:53
Speaker 3: Could have gotten you a point.
00:08:54
Speaker 2: Yeah, you're right. Anyway, maybe I'll steal this one. What do you got?
00:08:57
Speaker 1: All right.
00:08:57
Speaker 5: So let's go ahead and get on into, uh, some more football stuff. 49ers quarterback talk. Your odds for Brock Purdy winning MVP this season.
00:09:09
Speaker 3: Odds?
00:09:10
Speaker 2: You mean like, you want like.
00:09:11
Speaker 3: Just set them.
00:09:12
Speaker 5: How realistic is it for Brock Purdy to win MVP this year?
00:09:16
Speaker 2: Well, I'll tell you what. He's won the September MVP. Nationally, they freaking love him. He is getting all the... Every national show I listen to, he's the guy. I mean, of course, Josh Allen's supposed to be the guy, but right now Brock is hotter. Here's the problem. MVPs are never won in September. And in fact, the guys who usually are the hottest in September get fade. They fade like flowers, like bad. They spoil like milk as the season goes on. So it's going to be somebody in November and December who gets hot. So while I do, I'll rate Brock Purdy right now as the as a top two MVP candidate with Josh Allen. I will say, though, by the end of December. he might have fallen down to fourth or fifth because the Niners will lose a couple games. So right now, top two, but by the end of the year, fourth or fifth. That's my answer.
00:10:00
Speaker 4: Yeah it's longer odds than you would think despite the fact that brock purdy's very much in that conversation the mvp right now though would be josh allen and if josh allen continues to be josh allen you're going to
give the mvp to josh allen over brock purdy you think right now.
00:10:15
Speaker 2: Josh allen i do is better than brock.
00:10:17
Speaker 4: I think right now josh allen would be the mvp interesting I think Brock Purdy would probably finish second right now. I also think as time goes on and the 49ers remain successful, it often becomes about the others. Kyle Shanahan, Christian McCaffrey, George Kittle, all the weapons, even though the weapons dwindle seemingly by the week. And so I think the name value of a Josh Allen coupled with the fact that Kyle Shanahan tends to steal a little bit of.
00:10:44
Speaker 2: Brock Purdy shine. So I would say long odds. that Brock Purdy wins. The one thing in Kyle's, in Purdy's favor is the schedule isn't that tough. The Niners might win a lot of games this year. I mean, really, honestly, JD, I'm looking at difficult games right now. It just might just be the two Seahawks and the Rams. That's it. Like three games. And then, I mean, you know, at KC after Christmas, December 27th. I mean, Philly doesn't look as good.
00:11:09
Speaker 6: Philly.
00:11:11
Speaker 2: They stink right now. They do. And that's here. That game's next. That game's in 2027. I got a problem with Philly.
00:11:17
Speaker 4: By the way, just real quick, looking at a list right now of MVB Canada, just some, you know, Joe Schmoe's random list. Kirk Cousins is ahead of Brock Purdy on this person's list. No, Kirk Cousins, Jackson Smith and Jigba. And then Brock Purdy, four. And then Kenneth Walker, five.
00:11:33
Speaker 2: To be honest, JSN might be the guy, really.
00:11:35
Speaker 4: It might be.
00:11:36
Speaker 3: We got another one, buddy? Who gets a point? Is that Marcus' list? What's going on there? Point goes to Murph.
00:11:42
Speaker 2: That was a pity point. You earned that one, Murph.
00:11:45
Speaker 3: You earned that one. I'm with you.
00:11:47
Speaker 4: All right.
00:11:47
Speaker 3: Do we have one more or are we out? We got a couple more here. Let's see what we can squeeze in.
00:11:52
Speaker 2: I'll be shorter.
00:11:52
Speaker 3: I hate to say this.
00:11:53
Speaker 2: I know.
00:11:53
Speaker 3: I hate to say this.
00:11:55
Speaker 2: We don't have to duck out because we don't have Mike Kruka.
00:11:59
Speaker 4: It's true.
00:11:59
Speaker 3: Damn.
00:12:01
Speaker 5: I need your thoughts on Crook, by the way. I think we all lose because of that. All right, what else we got, buddy? All right, so let's go ahead and get on into it. 49ers still 49er-centric with baseball season over in the Bay Area.
00:12:11
Speaker 3: Concern level. For Nick Bosa's injury, go. Massive.
00:12:16
Speaker 2: Massive.
00:12:17
Speaker 4: Because when Nick Bosa doesn't play, the 49ers pass rush goes from pretty good, if not great, to completely nonexistent. And if you have a nonexistent pass rush and you can't stop the run, I don't care how good your back seven is or your corners, you're going to find yourself in a whole lot of trouble. And the template, teams haven't been able to execute it yet.
00:12:39
Speaker 2: The Cardinals tried.
00:12:40
Speaker 4: The template of trying to keep the 49er offense off the field and ball control and make them run 81 plays until they break defensively, a lot of that can be mitigated if Nick Bosa's out there.
00:12:52
Speaker 2: So it's a huge deal. Yeah, I hate to say it. I mean, this guy's takes are too spot on. I mean, I want to come up with something different. No, I'm not concerned about Bosa at all. You know, that's my hot take. Of course I am. I mean, the knee is now, what is it, the third time, right, this has happened in ACL? And he's now getting a little bit older, and he's showing more and more injury tendencies with the calf and the knee. So, yes, I'm... Very concerned, as Polymax Sandbar used to say. I'm not concerned because why are you concerned? The Nick Cage bit from Bad Lieutenant. But man, oh man, the whole point of this season was the return of Nick Bosa and Fred Warner. That was like our entire mantra all summer. And here we are on September 30th, and there's no Nick Bosa. So it's a big problem. I mean, the defense, like I said, the only thing that might save them this year is the lack of a brutal schedule. But when you get to January, it's going to be a brutal schedule. And if you don't have Nick Bosa... So yeah, man, I am concerned. I'm very concerned. I'm mimicking JD's concern. So you're going to have to pick between two concerned guys.
00:13:51
Speaker 3: I'm going to have to go with JD on this one. Yeah, yeah, yeah. The avalanche just keep going.
00:13:55
Speaker 2: He went first. He's hot on this one. What can I say? Sometimes it does come down to who wins the toss. It's true. It's true. I feel like I've been fighting uphill this entire time. Ever since you brought up the freaking fantasy football.
00:14:08
Speaker 3: Yeah, it was just bad mojo for you. I told you.
00:14:09
Speaker 2: This wide roller wall might be my 2026 Buster Tony V wide roller wall. Do I have one last chance here or what?
00:14:17
Speaker 3: No, that's it. That's it.
00:14:19
Speaker 2: Take my L.
00:14:20
Speaker 3: You want one more game? You want more games?
00:14:22
Speaker 2: What's that meme with the guy dishing out L's? Isn't there a guy dishing out L's? Money Mayweather.
00:14:28
Speaker 3: Floyd Mayweather.
00:14:29
Speaker 2: Yeah, that's you. Congrats, JD. I appreciate it. You earned it. Damn it.
00:14:34
Speaker 3: All right.
00:14:35
Speaker 2: Sometimes winning the coin toss is all you need. Get this guy out here. Bring back Boucher. He's easy to beat. All right. 7.30 is our Mike Kruko time. I want to get your thoughts on Kruko, and let's revisit the press conference yesterday. Did any of you feel better after Buster and Tony spoke yesterday? Did any of you feel worse after Buster and Tony spoke yesterday? That's going to be our 7.30 thing and our big hit. 808-KMBR is the phone number.
00:15:00
Speaker 5: 415-808-4255.
00:15:02
Speaker 2: 5-6-2-7 is the Golden State Lumber and Sherwood text line on The Sports Leader.
00:15:06
Speaker 1: KMBR, The Sports Leader. Now back to Murph and Marcus on The Sports Leader. Streaming live on thesportsleader.com and KMBR. The Sports Leader app. Murph and Marcus is sponsored by Bigelow Tea. Grab a mug and tea proudly.
00:15:25
Speaker 7: I just want to say it out loud. We don't have blinders on today. the wins and losses were still not there with that group.
00:15:32
Speaker 3: So, I don't know.
00:15:34
Speaker 7: It's just something I was sitting here thinking because it's not that we shouldn't be positive and whatnot. I do want to be positive. There's some really good stuff that we saw from these guys. But I just wanted, I guess, to say it, that there's not blinders that the success as far as wins and losses were still not there.
00:15:50
Speaker 2: There was one of the few signature moments from a postseason presser that Buster Posey and Zach Manazzi and Antonio Vitello held yesterday. Now, in fairness to those guys, rarely do those postseason pressers, you know, reveal these amazing moments in time, whether it's Farhan Zaidi or Brian Sabian or whoever. They tend to be sort of rote, you know, wrap-ups. But when it is after the third worst season in Giants history, you are scraping for something. As a Giants fan or as a Giants analyst or as a radio host or as a commuter in the morning, you're looking for something. And I don't know what they could have said. You know, Larry Kruger yesterday said he wanted to see some anger and he wanted to see somebody flip a spread, you know? And of course, sometimes that's performative, but it sometimes feels good. Buster ain't going to go be that guy. That was as far as he got right there because it was at a point in the press conference where people started talking about things other than the 97 losses. And Buster, to his credit, kind of grabbed the wheel and said, I want to bring this back and say, you know, we're talking about some stuff here. Just the overarching thing is we're not happy with 97 losses. And we were kind of like, Well, yeah, kind of. Nobody is, right? So that's what we're here for, guys. It's kind of our Kruko segment here, turning into sort of our big hit here, which is reaction to yesterday's press conference. There I was in the front row. I had a bad seat, J.D. John Dickinson, by the way, in. Marcus Boucher out, sick today. Thanks, J.D. Yeah, great to be here. Doing great. Thanks for the whipping I got in Wide World of Walt. I'll not forget that soon. But I sat in the middle of the front row. You know, just so Buster could see me, right? But that put me out of reach of the microphone right early. You got to sit on a corner, which I don't know. Listen, I thought we were going to have Buster tomorrow. That's why I didn't ask any Buster questions. But now it turns out he's punting again. So we're not going to have Buster tomorrow. I guess I should have asked more questions, but I don't know. We talked about it before the show. We talked about it in the opening of the show, but now we've got a whole new audience here at 739, and neither one of us was overwhelmed. Curly asked me, he goes, what's your big takeaway from the press conference? I said, my big takeaway is I don't have a big takeaway. You had a couple that I thought were pretty good observations you want to share.
00:17:59
Speaker 4: Yeah, one was the clip that we played just coming back from the break, so I won't reiterate it, but I do think it's important that there was an acknowledgment of the fact that this season was a failure in some, in some form or fashion to the level at which Posey said it, I think can, can be debated.
00:18:18
Speaker 2: Was it strong enough? I think it was pretty strong for him.
00:18:20
Speaker 4: I took it to mean unacceptable, even though he didn't say unacceptable. I think a lot of people probably would have been happier had he said unacceptable. The other thing was the bullpen Posey acknowledging that he was deserves the blame and took the blame for the bullpen.
00:18:38
Speaker 2: Didn't do it with you.
00:18:39
Speaker 4: Probably should have. It was a little too early in the season for him to do it. But acknowledging, hey, I overestimated what we had and we didn't build that thing right. And look, in the long haul, it probably wouldn't have mattered, honestly, because, all right, add 10. Even if you want to take 12 wins and add them, you still weren't going to be sniffing the playoffs. And it still would have been, I think, if this team had won 75 or 76 games, maybe it would feel a little bit different.
00:19:03
Speaker 2: But I actually think it would still feel like a colossal, you know, bad season.
00:19:08
Speaker 3: Yeah.
00:19:08
Speaker 2: Well, I mean, it could have changed the Tanner early in the season.
00:19:11
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:19:12
Speaker 2: You know, I, I go back to the day. I mean, you know, as a, as an old beat writer or columnist or jock blog or whatever, you're looking for narratives and maybe sometimes we create them, but I would say that that double walk-off loss in Philly was my narrative turning point like that in early in the season when they had yet to find their footing and Two games in the bag that you close out and you lose them both began the spin out. Three days later, they blew one on the Sunday in Tampa. They had three in that one series. So maybe if they fix the bullpen early, there's a different sort of vibe. And then maybe they treat the trade deadline differently and all that good stuff. But anyway, we want to get some of the sound out. there because not everybody got to hear it yesterday. It was at 11 in the morning. Some people work for a living. God bless. You're our commuters. You're our listeners. So here was kind of Buster's almost opening. They didn't have an opening statement. I don't know if they're going to make an opening statement, but Susan Slessor grabbed the mic and
said, you guys aren't doing a statement, are you? Anyway, here's my question. And she kind of barged in. So Buster's sort of a de facto opening statement in which he does what J.D. mentioned, takes the blade for the bullpen, actually touched his chest physically when he says it. Go ahead. And looked at Murph. He did not.
00:20:17
Speaker 1: Go ahead, yes.
00:20:19
Speaker 7: Yeah, I mean, I think we started off the year pitching pretty well. We didn't hit, and then it switched to– We were hitting a little bit and we weren't pitching. And then I think things just started to compound. We were not able to get any momentum throughout the year. I think the easy thing to point to is we walked too many guys when we were pitching and then we weren't drawing enough walks when we were hitting. You mentioned injuries. I want to be clear, we were already in a bad spot before the injuries happened. I don't think we could sit up here, any of us could say that Injuries were the key reason why we were not successful this year. We did have injuries open up, gave us some opportunities to see some guys that otherwise we would not have had. The bullpen, the bullpen struggled this year. I'll take the blame for that. That was something that probably overestimated some of the guys that we had in the pen. And, uh, as I've already mentioned, that's something that we're going to do our best to try to address this off season.
00:21:29
Speaker 3: Okay.
00:21:30
Speaker 2: So that last part was the one overestimated some of the guys we had in the pen. I mean, immediately you think about the guy they named the closer Ryan Walker, right? I mean, I don't know how you felt when that was, we have to go back and find our round table receipts. It was doomed.
00:21:42
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:21:43
Speaker 2: I mean, that was what you were hoping that, you know, a mental He had done some mental work in the offseason. He had done some physical work in the offseason, and it just, you know.
00:21:51
Speaker 4: He'd always been a guy that was pretty good, if not fine at a minimum in other innings, but not the ninth inning.
00:21:58
Speaker 2: We kind of knew that going in. Yeah, and that's one he talks about underestimating or over-evaluating, I should say. Guys, I think you start there. And we joked about earlier today, do you know who led the Giants in saves this year? It was Caleb Killian with eight.
00:22:12
Speaker 3: Save.
00:22:13
Speaker 2: So, and again, Buster said in their fairness, he goes, I don't want to use injuries as an excuse. And he wouldn't. Injuries was not the excuse. It was terrible play. And it was also Tony V's lack of authoritative imprint, especially in the first half of the season when they spun out. And, you know, it turns out that hiring a guy who's, you know, had no experience at all wound up hurting you because he wound up not controlling the veterans or telling Matt Chapman or Willie Adamas they had to take a day off. or pinch running for Rafi Devers or things like that. So Tony was asked, I think it was a guy from NBC, um, NBC Bay area about, did you lose the clubhouse? Good question. And I think we're gonna go to cut L Walt from the Tony V sound. I think this is about his job performance cut L. This is what Tony had to say.
00:23:00
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:23:01
Speaker 6: We've talked about in the dugout before. I mean, the amount of things that are small stack up to be, um, not as tall as a building, but pretty dang high. So, um, it's like a hitter getting in the cage. You get information every single swing. You're just trying to make adjustments. So I think we'd be up here all day if I was just trying to list off all the things different that I learned. But I think a big thing that sticks out is at the core of it, it is still just baseball. And I think that was the theme to begin with. And, uh, we talk about, can you contend for the playoffs? And, um, Much of what we do in the offseason will be less of me, more of the group, although I'm grateful that I'm involved in those conversations. But I think for me, what I saw the last few weeks is if we have a game tomorrow, whether it's against the Dodgers, Padres, Diamondbacks, Rockies, anybody else you can list off, do we have enough in that locker room to win that game? The answer is yes, if we play good baseball. And obviously part of that is our job as coaches and the manager in particular, put those guys in the best possible position to succeed. And yes, we can win that game. So then you do it again the next day. And if you do that successfully enough, then you find yourself in a position that we're talking about at the end of the year.
00:24:20
Speaker 2: Okay, so not much there. That wasn't the one I was thinking about. But he talks about if you do win that game, then you win the next one, then you're in a position. That gets to something they didn't do all year. They never won four in a row. They never won four in a row. I mean, there was just abject failure across the board, how the bullpen was managed, how the bullpen was constructed, how the stars performed at the start of the year.
00:24:42
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:24:43
Speaker 2: I mean, all of this stuff adds up. And again, if I'm going to be my most optimistic self, because, you know, you don't want to be a baseball fan just wallowing in misery all the time. But, you know, bad years happen. Bad years happen. Doesn't mean they have to happen next year, but obviously they won't be the same team next April. First of all, we haven't talked about the lockout. That's a whole nother deal. And that can't, let's just assume for fun of sports talk radio and getting through our morning that let's just assume there is a 2027. Okay. And they're not going to brun back. Obviously they're going to, it's going to be hopefully a new pitching staff, a new bullpen. So everything we're saying about this year's team might not apply. the 2027 team is going to be up to the winter meetings and sure. And what they
do, because like, you know, we're not, it's not going to be Ryan Walker as the closer on opening day, 2027.
00:25:32
Speaker 4: No. Yeah.
00:25:33
Speaker 2: It definitely won't.
00:25:34
Speaker 4: The one thing I'll say as much as you might want to think Tony Vitello became more comfortable as the season went on. And I think he did look more comfortable, let's say August, September and the style of play with, more young players and more speed. And, and, you know, they were bunting and they were doing all this different stuff at the end of the year. And that can be, Hey, the little things that you need to do to give yourself a chance to win games as much as you like that and may want to give, you know, Tony some credit for that. It's going to be back to Willie Adamas and Matt Chapman endeavors. Like the team that they're going to have in all likelihood at the beginning of the year is going to be more similar to the team that they had at at the beginning of this season. And so I'm not sure that the ways that he was able to get comfortable are going to apply, right? It's going to be back to, and Buster Posey said, and I thought this was another one of the big takeaways.
00:26:27
Speaker 2: Buster Posey said, Hey, Willie Thomas is a shortstop. Like, Oh really?
00:26:31
Speaker 4: I think there are a lot of giants fans that were thinking let's move them to second. And maybe part of that is Casey. Schmidt's got to play second because they don't really have a position for him. Why don't they have a position for him? Because he's, Matt Chapman's still on the team and he's going to be playing third. And so like, you may like some of these other guys and want to see more of them, but in a weird way, they don't have spots for Jonah Cox to play a ton and, and, you know, Turner Hill to get it run and, and, and.
00:26:56
Speaker 2: This and that. Buster did. He was pressed a couple of different times on, are you still open to trading Adamas Chapman or Devers, which I'm sure he is. And he, his answer, I must say left doors open. I will say he was kind of like, well, you're always going to take a call. He didn't say like, hey, my guys are my guys. I'm ride or die with those guys. Put it in blood ink that there you're starting. He said kind of, oh, here, here's a cut. Cut O, Walt from Posey. See if you hear the same thing I heard. It was kind of like, eh, it could happen. Cut O here.
00:27:28
Speaker 7: Look, I mean, I mentioned it. I mentioned it earlier. A lot of belief in all of those guys. Unfortunately, we were in a spot at the deadline where we had to consider all options. And one thing I really have learned in two years of doing this now is you have lots and lots of conversations with teams, and 99% of them are hypotheticals. And that's just we're not doing our due diligence if we don't have conversations.
00:27:57
Speaker 2: There it is. We're not doing our due diligence if we don't have conversations.
00:28:01
Speaker 4: So, you know.
00:28:02
Speaker
2: That was a Sabian-esque answer. There's something, yeah, due diligence, the famous phrase, kicking tires. So there's something, too, that could happen in the winter.
00:28:10
Speaker 4: I think they'd love to do it if they can, just to get off the financial component. And it frees up a spot for maybe somebody else to play. And, you know, I think maybe this story still comes out because I think there's beat writers that are kind of waiting. You know, you get through the press conference and you let things settle a little bit, and then you go with maybe your big, you know, powerful– reporting on, on things that happened during the season hasn't really happened yet, but I think in part, the reason we haven't seen a lot of, or read a lot of to this point, the, Hey, things got weird in the clubhouse and the veterans didn't really appreciate.
00:28:48
Speaker 2: Tony or what he's cause a lot of those guys were gone by the end of the year. It is interesting. You got to bring a point. There was never, nobody ever reported that smoking gun thing. The way we had Bagley had the jock Peterson playing the domino game or whatever, you know, that stuff. Remember that story? Yeah. We didn't, we didn't get that.
00:29:03
Speaker 4: It either hasn't happened yet or because the, a lot of those guys that would have been the guys that would have been doing the talking on it weren't around at the end of the year. And it was this younger team that, that Tony could have a little bit more control over, which.
00:29:17
Speaker 2: By the way, Andy, Alex Pavlich had a sentence in his wrap up that shark, you know, we all sort of liked this team. And there was a stretch where they went eight and seven. And I was like, that counts as like the best stretch of the season. They finished by going 0-9 against the Padres and Dodgers. 0-9 against the Padres and Dodgers. So it ended ugly.
00:29:35
Speaker 3: All right.
00:29:36
Speaker 2: Listen, looking at the clock, we got to get some fun stuff going on. We got Ron Rivera at 830. We got cooler content at 815. So let's continue. This is sort of our big hit, our post-Mike Kruko big hit. 49 Giants reactions. There's a ton of texts coming in. If you guys want to call 808-KMBR, you can. And we got more sound from that Posey Vitello and more reaction to how you felt yesterday. Come on. How you feeling? On Esports Later.
00:30:01
Speaker 1: This is the big hit. Sponsored by Benjamin Moore Paints. Experience the Benjamin Moore retail difference at our independently owned authorized retailers today or at BenjaminMoore.com. Murph and Marcus continue live from the Casino Matrix Progressive Jackpot Studios. Casino Matrix. Progressive jackpots are here.
00:30:22
Speaker 2: Where are you?
00:30:23
Speaker 1: Just drop in.
00:30:23
Speaker 5: 1-800-GAMBLER.
00:30:26
Speaker 6: I think if anything, it was just more reps, there's more game days. So I would say that, um, I think the second question was, do I have the clubhouse? I, you know, they made fun of me because I, I made a comment about being the boss or manager or something, all that in a team meeting at some point, I still, I've learned more and I understand that manager is a specific name for a reason. And I think there's some adaptations there too. Um, I still see myself as a teammate and, um, The only thing I've experienced, again, if you were to take training room, weight room, and all the other different areas, is, again, the outcomes didn't show it, but I felt like everyone was hooked up, you know, more than anything at the end of the year in a better fashion, and I'm one of those guys. So, again, I realize I've got to make decisions and stuff like that. I think I'm in a better position to do those things, but my hope is next year when it starts, there's a bunch of people on a mission, and I'll be one of those people.
00:31:24
Speaker 2: There he is, Tony Vitello, in yesterday's press conference. 808-KMBR is the phone number. You guys react. The one that jumped out was, I still see myself as a teammate. Everybody's like, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, because he was talking about, they made fun of me for being a boss or a manager. I don't know what he meant. Was it lighthearted?
00:31:38
Speaker 3: Was it.
00:31:39
Speaker 2: jocular. Sometimes with Tony, it's hard to tell what's going on, but there he is saying he thought everybody was hooked up and he wants to be on a mission. He is fiery. We can discuss that and say good morning, everybody. You're listening to KMBR AM and KMBR FM San Francisco, the sports leader at Cumulus Media Station. Thanks to JD. John Dixon hopping in after working the afternoon shift, turns right around and works the morning shift. Hardest working man in show business. By the way, we're only three weeks away from Dubs OT. Warriors-Lakers. Literally. Three weeks from today. Three weeks from tonight. There you go. You hear Tony there. We talked about it a little bit. We were saying this off the air, too. We're going to kind of do our big hit is our sort of parsing and evaluation of Buster and Tony. I mean, in fairness to Zach, there's really no need to have Zach up there in times like that. It's the Buster show, really, at that point in time. But what Buster and Tony had to say, and you and I agree. We think somewhere Tony does care. He's not like one foot out the door looking for a college job.
00:32:34
Speaker 4: You wouldn't think, although I, I have had the thought, I will admit, I wonder if that does come to fruition at some point. Like I had wondered as things had gotten progressively worse throughout the season, would he think, Hey, this is not for me maybe, and have another opportunity because he, at any point I would imagine can get the most premium college job he wants. Just, anytime he wants, essentially. So it doesn't sound like that's the case.
00:33:02
Speaker 2: I will say that. Listen, 808-CAMBR is a phone number. 415-808-5627 is a Golden State Lumber and Showroom text line. What are you
guys saying? Here we go. 415 says, if Tony continues with the same mistakes and he's 10 under by the All-Star break, will he make it to the end of 2027? Well, that's just, I mean, that's a hypothetical that I can't get into right now. We'd have to see how the season went. 831 says, the only way they could possibly turn this around is finally opening the checkbook. This offseason, they need to sign big name pitchers for big time money. If you go through this offseason with another Harrison Bader type move, you can just go ahead and tune out until 2030. This is something we brought up yesterday with Krug. Dude, the payroll was 13th. I mean, this is a team that drew $ 2. 8 million that has no mortgage on their park. And they supposedly have Lot A or Mission Bay, that whole Mission Rock, was supposed to create cascading revenues and all. Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Why are the Giants 13th in revenue, in spending? And I don't know if that would have been the difference between a couple of Bolton or a couple of eighth-inning guys or a starting pitcher here or there. And you can't always wave a wand. Shout out Mark Melanson and Armando Benitez, right? I get it. They sign a closer, Edwin Diaz. They sign a closer, and it doesn't always work, but they should be spending more.
00:34:16
Speaker 4: Yeah, I think they would also tell you that they've opened the checkbook and taken on Rafi Devers and taken on Adamas and Chapman. Well, signing Adamas. Signing Chapman, I should say, and those guys. So I think they'd probably tell you they have.
00:34:31
Speaker 2: But the facts are that I would say to Larry and Greg, and I would say this to their face.
00:34:36
Speaker 3: Hi, Greg.
00:34:36
Speaker 4: Hi, Larry.
00:34:37
Speaker 2: You're 13th. Other guys have opened up more. There's holes there. So anyway, that's a good text from the 831. 707, not happy. Says, I'm tired of the Tony V cliches. He's faking it, but not making it. When you lose 97, pretty much anything you say is going to get ripped.
00:34:57
Speaker 4: The problem is, I don't think he's faking it. I think this is just who he is. And I was thinking about something else I wanted to hit you with. Did we get schnookered?
00:35:05
Speaker 2: Did we get schnookered on just Tony?
00:35:10
Speaker 4: Who Tony actually is? Because I do think he genuinely cares. I just think he's much more thoughtful and caring and to the point of almost... overthinking himself into oblivion. Whereas he was filled as a guy that was just going to come in and, and just be a leader of men.
00:35:32
Speaker 2: He was just going to walk.
00:35:33
Speaker 4: He was going to hogs out to, to, you know, honor shout out Kruko hogs out and come at us. And we're, and we're going to send it back at you. He was nothing like he, he was supposed to be somebody that exuded confidence.
00:35:45
Speaker 2: Correct.
00:35:46
Speaker 4: And he came off as completely unconfident, I would say, for five months out of the six.
00:35:52
Speaker 2: I would agree with you. And I don't know if Schnuckert's the right move, or did they just pick the wrong guy at the wrong time? Like, we talked about this earlier in the show. Like, if he was hired to manage the 104-loss Rockies or the Pirates who never spend, that might be the place for him. No pressure, no expectation, a bunch of young kids looking up to a young guy. But to come to a big market that has high expectations, that has a big veteran presence in the locker room, clubhouse, it might have been the wrong fit. So there you go. Lots of texts coming in. 408 saying, can't help but think a lot is on ownership for how Tony plays out. You knew he'd be a rookie with growing pains. You did not give him a decent roster to judge him. And now we are constantly judging. What did we give him? to gauge his ability to manage. I think it was a no-win situation for Tony, says Cousin Vinny. 4-5 with a cheap shot. Oh, you already sent in, so I'm not going to read that. 6-5-0 says we should be celebrating the season. The Giants more or less broke even.
00:36:44
Speaker 4: Ha-ha.
00:36:45
Speaker 2: Did they win $ 2. 8 million? 8-3-1 says does anybody really good want to play in San Francisco these days? Well, pitchers generally will if you pay them. 702 says, give Tony V a blank canvas and see what he could do. 831 says, I think Posey is holding Tony back. Posey's team was terrible. Tony V's AAA team looked more exciting to watch. The AAA team looked better. Suspending doesn't always mean better. Well, it does, hopefully, in the bullpen. 408 says, legitimately wondering what part of Vitello felt was the team coming together and getting better at the end when they lost eight. of their last nine to close it out. 415 says the downfall was signing Matt Chapman and Willie Adamas. And I think if you go back and listen to what we all said at the time, we liked him. Remember Brody Brazil told us you take that x-ray of Matt Chapman's hip and you see that dog in him, that dog in him. Nobody didn't want Matt Chapman on their team. Everybody likes Matt Chapman on their team. The glove is incredible. I think it's a fact we all take Matt Chapman's glove for granted. He saves a lot of runs out there and nobody cares. They're like, yeah, whatever.
00:37:43
Speaker 4: I don't care.
00:37:44
Speaker 2: He's hitting. 220. The defense is phenomenal. Willie Adamas, I think everybody said, well, they need a shortstop. They need a shortstop. They need a shortstop. They need a shortstop. They don't have a shortstop. They don't have a shortstop. That's your guy. They go get him. He has leverage, so he gets seven years. Yep. And then he underperforms. Pet peeve of mine.
00:38:02
Speaker 4: Just because you and I liked it doesn't, doesn't absolve Buster Posey in the front office from, from making a mistake. It's their job to get it right. Like I, this drives me nuts and drove me nuts all off season. Is it related to the warriors? Give me a specific example of who they should have got,
who they.
00:38:20
Speaker 3: Couldn't get anybody.
00:38:20
Speaker 2: Who could they get a guy? That's not my, that's not my job.
00:38:23
Speaker 1: Yeah, sure.
00:38:24
Speaker 2: Yeah.
00:38:24
Speaker 4: Maybe my job is to present options for the sake of conversation. But the fact that the warriors did nothing in the off season, other than draft the axle Lindenberg, the, it, they don't get absolved from that because I can't come up with 20 options that, that realistic, like that's their freaking job. So that like, I, that is one of my pet peeves. Like we can, we can keep our own score of, Hey Murph, you were right about this. We were wrong about this. And I'll own the fact that I like those signings as well. But the fact that we liked him doesn't, doesn't mean that Buster Posey gets absolved from what have been two at this point.
00:38:58
Speaker 2: What it means is like, I think the warriors are open to more criticism because they did nothing. Whereas Buster did something. The Rafi trade comes to mind.
00:39:08
Speaker 4: I think that I think the giants are open to more criticism because they've been far worse. And I know, I know there's this perception that the warriors are like catastrophically bad.
00:39:16
Speaker 2: Like the, wait, Say that again. I'm going to skip it. What?
00:39:21
Speaker 3: Is that me?
00:39:22
Speaker 2: I'm going to leap.
00:39:24
Speaker 4: Oh, look out.
00:39:25
Speaker 2: I was doing my Steph impression. That was my Steph comedy impression. But unfortunately, my head... fell off. It's just funny.
00:39:32
Speaker 4: The perception, I think, because of the more recent standard with the Warriors is that 500 or a little bit better than 500 is... 37 and 45.
00:39:41
Speaker 1: Yes.
00:39:42
Speaker 2: This year. Yeah, for sure. No question.
00:39:45
Speaker 4: But what I'm saying is the Warriors... Again, not to get into the whole comparison thing, but they've actually made it to the second round of the playoffs and won a title since the last year the Giants were even good.
00:39:57
Speaker 2: It's like having Aaron Judge or, you know, it's like having Shohei Otani. My point is both franchises deserve a lot of criticism. No, but I do want to stand by and say I credit Buster the Devers trade. I thought it was great. Even if Kyle Harrison went on to win Cy Young's, which he might, He's looked fantastic at times, and then he's had a little bit of arm trouble, and now he's back throwing hard again. I was like, yo, we're never going to get a 30. Wait for it. What did he hit this year?
00:40:27
Speaker 4: 37, 39?
00:40:27
Speaker 2: I don't even know what he finished with. I think it was 37. It was going to be 40, and then all of a sudden he just wasn't playing. By the way, Bryce Eldridge might be a 37-homer guy coming up there. So I loved the Devers trade. When it didn't work in the second half of last year, I was dumbfounded. I was dumbfounded. And when it didn't work in the first two months of this year, I was like,
wow, that's unbelievable that it didn't work. But I would have done that trade.
00:40:54
Speaker 1: I would have.
00:40:54
Speaker 2: I would have too.
00:40:55
Speaker 4: Yeah.
00:40:55
Speaker 2: So anyway, there's a lot of text to get in. Here's one.
00:40:58
Speaker 3: 408.
00:40:59
Speaker 2: If Tony V says he's a teammate, then who's the leader? Who sets the culture? Or is he just part of the team like a follower? I mean, is that comment, are we reading too much into that comment? I see myself as a teammate. Do you think maybe, I mean, he might say, guys, I'm talking about like, I'm on the same mission as you guys.
00:41:17
Speaker 4: I don't know.
00:41:17
Speaker 2: Four and five says Chapman will need to be benched. And I'm not sure Tony V will do it. No team will trade for his contract and huge decrease in production. Good defense is not enough. I don't know. There might be a team out there. If the giants eat some of the, eat some of the contract for sure. Six, five Oh says a lot of blame to go around, but the veterans deserve a healthy dose of it. They did not take care of their job. If Tony didn't have good command of the locker room, they should have set the example instead. Some of them were the biggest disappointments with their performance.
00:41:45
Speaker 3: It's true.
00:41:45
Speaker 2: Adamas Chapman endeavors. His first six weeks, eight weeks were a disaster.
00:41:49
Speaker 4: And they were counting on, and I'm even going to throw Logan Webb in there. I know he was an all-star, but it was basically only because of the June that he had the June and his, his career, you know, the, his reputation got him that all-star nod. And like your leaders were Logan Webb of the pitching staff, Matt Chapman, Willie Adamas, All underperformed. And all underperformed early, which prevented that tone from being set.
00:42:15
Speaker 2: 530 says, Posey needs Vitello to do well. That was a major and unnecessary risk of a hire. I don't care the circumstances. If they start the season slow, you got to do what the Phillies did in getting Don Mattingly or the Red Sox with Chad Tracy. How about that? Here we go. 408 says, would the Giants have been a better team if someone like Joe Girardi was mentioning them? I ask this rhetorically. I mean, we don't know, but we certainly think, well, Joe Girardi, maybe Joe Girardi wins 75 with them instead of 65. Cause it really was, it does come down to the players a lot too. 415 says at the end of the season, the third base play by Shea Whitcomb acknowledges how important Chapman is to the team. 775 says, I think Tony needs a master class in speaking with the media. He rambles for sure. 209 says, I thought the idea of mixing a young coach with veteran players to somewhat lean on, but he got waved off. 415 says, is this the Jim Tomsula, Chip Kelly era for the Giants? 408 says, I'm all for Tony V, but did Buster save money by hiring a college student?
00:43:15
Speaker 4: No, they actually.
00:43:16
Speaker 2: ate money by firing Bob Melvin and took on money for Tony V. It was a bold move that did not work in year one. Here we go. Sorry. 805 says, y'all keep talking about Chappie's defense, but what did his numbers show? Was he actually a gold glover as advertised? 209 says, it was a blank season. Everyone acknowledged that the roster did not perform up to standards, period. So there you go. Just a lot of reaction there. Everybody's upset. It's going to come down to the move. Somebody's saying, guys, everything we're saying about this press conference means nothing until they start making moves this winter. And it's true. I mean, Adrian Morahan's the guy you want, right? He's the big stud lefty. One of them. I don't know. If you don't get him, then what are you going to do? He's, by the way... JD's pick to click. He'll be hoisting the commissioner's trophy in late October, early November. All right, fun. Big hit. Appreciate everybody. I still haven't gotten your Kruko thoughts. We'll have to do that at some point in time because I haven't heard your elegy, your poetic farewell for Mike Kruko's era. The cooler of content than Ron Rivera and then Larry Krueger on a Wednesday on The Sports Leader.