TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:00
Speaker 1: Good morning.
00:00:00
Speaker 2: Welcome to Tuesday, this 20th of October on 5AA. Well, I think we're all trying to come to terms with the horrifying attack on MP Helen Haynes overnight. She remains in a critical condition in a Melbourne hospital after she was attacked near her electorate office in Wangaratta, North East Victoria. Evidence suggests it was a premeditated and deliberate attack. The Prime Minister says the car that struck Haynes did a U-turn in order to hit the Indi MP. Now, the Prime Minister is leading cross-party condemnation of the incident, while counter-terrorism police continue their investigation. Victoria police say a 43-year-old Tarawingi man was arrested at the scene of the incident. While attacks on Australian politicians are a rare occurrence, this attack is likely to see changes that will make our pollies even more remote from the electorate than ever before. I think it's fair to say we've been one of the few countries where politicians can walk the streets without security, have face-to-face contact with constituents, They don't always agree, but they walk away. They often live in the electorate. Serious physical violence remains uncommon, but non-physical threats have increased substantially. Up until now, only the Prime Minister and threatened politicians have regularly had security. But what now? We'll follow the story of Helen Haynes throughout the morning as it progresses. Now, apparently some listeners have challenged us for not naming the suspect, claiming, well, it's all over social media. Why aren't you broadcasting it? Well, there's a very good reason for it. We here at 5AA and other forms of the recognised media have to be accountable. Social media doesn't and is often wildly inaccurate. 5AA and other news outlets haven't named the man because he hasn't been charged. The investigation is still in its early stages and Australian media and the police follow standard legal and ethical practices that generally withhold names of suspects until charges are laid or other clear public interest thresholds are met. So we will name the man when it is apparent and obviously the right thing to do, but not at the moment. 8223 0000 is the number to ring if you'd like to comment on the case or other stories of the day. Something we're going to comment on is that the barley fuel shortages at the moment have sent a huge warning to Australia. We'll discuss more of that as the day progresses. We were speaking with supply chain expert David Leaney. Apparently, Labor knew in July of the ATO's plan to ban credit card tax payments. Assistant Treasurer Daniel Molino has admitted he and Treasurer Jim Chalmers knew in July that the Australian Tax Office was considering banning credit card payments for tax bills. That was more than two months earlier than previously claimed. Mind you, Jim Chalmers told Parliament last week he only learned of the decision in late September, shortly before it became public. We'll speak with Sky Cappuccino, or Capuccio, not cappuccino. I'm thinking of other things. It's Guy Capuccio who's representing small business about that a little bit later on. Are you allergic to penicillin? Well, maybe you're not allergic after all. We'll take up the matter with 5AA resident GP, Dr. Emily Kirkpatrick. And if you have any questions for her, give us a call on 8223 0000, the number to ring. And there's outrage in the eastern suburbs. Norwood parents are fuming over a proposal to slash red bin collections to once a fortnight. Councillor Sandy Wilkinson wants weekly green bin pick-ups instead, claiming big environmental savings. But locals aren't buying it. What are your thoughts on changing the way bins are collected and when they're collected? Give us a call. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Well, I want to get back to this Bali fuel shortage. The recent shortages there have left tourists and locals stranded. after a tanker's mechanical failure disrupted supply lines. Now, normal supply operations are expected to resume within days, but energy experts are warning that the chaos serves as a stark warning and wake-up call for Australia. Joining us now is ANU International Supply Chain's expert, David Leaney. David, good morning to you.
00:04:07
Speaker 3: Good morning.
00:04:07
Speaker 4: Great to be back.
00:04:09
Speaker 2: Is this something we should be concerned about?
00:04:12
Speaker 5: No, and there's a couple of reasons for that. Australia is in a very, very different situation to Indonesia and Bali in particular, also Malaysia and other places in Southeast Asia. They're at the end of a long supply chain as we are, but we have great supply. supply contracts in place with quite a few different countries. South Korea is our most important one for our diesel. And we have the leverage point of our natural gas. And so basically we say to our Southeast Asian partner countries, hey, we'd like to buy diesel and petrol from you and jet fuel. And would you like to buy natural gas from us? And they go, oh, yes, please. And that's our leverage point. And if you're a country like Indonesia or Malaysia, you really don't have that leverage point. So they're really in a tough place.
00:04:58
Speaker 2: Did we set up these links earlier this year when the Prime Minister visited some Southeast Asian nations?
00:05:05
Speaker 5: Yes, they were really strengthened then. They were in place for years before that. We've actually had a very long-standing relationship with South Korea in particular for supply of fuel, but it was strengthened when the Prime Minister did those visits and it locked them in for longer terms and for really long good, steady supply. Unfortunately, it doesn't stop prices going up, but it does mean we've got continuity of supply, and that means we won't see those same problems that we've seen in Bali.
00:05:33
Speaker 2: I mean, one of the issues with Bali was a ship was stranded, and that caused the problem. We rely on
Load full transcript
shipping, international shipping, so do we have enough domestic supplies here to tide us over if ships were delayed for any period of time?
00:05:47
Speaker 5: We've got about 30 to 40 days of different fuel types. We usually run, or we have for years, run about 30 days worth of supply onshore in our system. And then we've actually increased that recently to about 40 or 42 days worth of supply because we've realised it's a really tough and volatile situation at the moment. So we can handle things up to about 40 or 42 days So essentially six weeks worth of disruption, and then we'd be in real trouble if some disruption lasted longer than six weeks.
00:06:20
Speaker 2: So do we need to be doing more at the moment?
00:06:23
Speaker 5: I think Australia's actually done very well out of this in so many different ways, and that some of it is because of the fuel companies from a private sector perspective. Governments at state and federal level have actually been really proactive.
00:06:36
Speaker 1: On this as well.
00:06:37
Speaker 5: So I don't think there's a lot more needs to be done. Of course, it would be better to have more sovereign capability and sovereign capacity. What I mean by that is we've only got two oil refineries that can turn oil into fuel. and it would be good to have a third one. We used to have eight, and we decreased that because it was cheaper to buy it from overseas. So we've lost that Australian national capability to manufacture our own fuel, other than what currently happens in Geelong and Brisbane with those two operating refineries. So a third one, Western Australia would be the perfect place for it, would really boost it. And then boosting our Our storage from above that 30 or 40 days up towards, say, 50 days would give us even more coverage in event of emergencies.
00:07:24
Speaker 2: Isn't there a feasibility study underway at the moment regarding a possible new oil refinery in the West?
00:07:31
Speaker 5: There is, and they're looking at a couple of different places. So there is, in the southern part of WA, there's an area called Kwinana, and that's actually the site of one of the previous oil refineries, and they're looking at rebuilding that one. But there's also a feasibility study is for Karratha in the far north. And that's actually an excellent location because of the logistics of getting that sort of fuel. But, of course, we're still suffering the effects of, you know, especially this next couple of weeks as Donald Trump gets more and more desperate as he comes into his midterm elections on the 3rd of November. He's going to do more and more crazy stuff around fuel because he's really hurting the polls because the US is seeing diesel prices above $ 6 per gallon.
00:08:17
Speaker 2: Yeah, and he's just done a deal with Russia. Does that suggest that he's getting really anxious?
00:08:22
Speaker 1: It does.
00:08:23
Speaker 5: And it's actually, in terms of volume, that deal with Russia is actually tiny. It sounds a lot, 300,000 tonnes of diesel. It's 2.25 million barrels of diesel. But that's less than one day's consumption in the US. So it's a drop in the bucket. But it's politically very telling. He's prepared to go against Congress and provide a waiver on the ban of Russian fuel. He's done a deal with his great friend Vladimir Putin, which, of course, gives Putin more money to attack Ukraine. And we've seen Trump now actively going against Ukraine, which is very unfortunate. When he said he'd stop the war, people thought he was talking about in favour of Ukraine. No, he wasn't, unfortunately. So, yeah, that one's a tough one. But all of the stuff from the US really doesn't impact us that much at all. We just don't import much from the US. Our imports from the USA are less than 1% of the stuff that we import from South Korea alone. So US doesn't impact us. We're much more interested.
00:09:31
Speaker 2: In Southeast Asia. Yeah, I was going to say that was my next question. Would it reflect on the Australian situation? And you were saying it just effectively won't impact us at all.
00:09:41
Speaker 5: No, less than 1% impact. And what Trump's trying to do is he's trying to flood the market in the US domestic market with as much fuel as he can to try and bring prices down before the 3rd of November midterm elections, because he knows he's going to get smashed. The US is a bit spoiled. They're talking about $ 6 per gallon. Just to put that in context, that's $ 1. 65 per litre. So they're freaking out because they're having to pay $ 1. 65 a litre for diesel. We're paying $ 3 a litre for diesel. Americans would lose their minds if they had to pay those sort of prices.
00:10:17
Speaker 2: You're suggesting that what is happening between Trump and Putin won't impact Australia, but what about other Western nations?
00:10:24
Speaker 5: It's certainly got an impact politically, and that's, I think, this is getting a little bit out of the supply chain side of things. From a supply chain point of view, it puts a tiny bit of... additional fuel into the system. It decreases the pressure on prices a little tiny bit, but it goes up so much more than that based on what happens with the Houthi rebels in Yemen attacking the Red Sea or other things that are happening in the Middle East. So the stuff that Trump's doing is politically telling. It's certainly showing signs of desperation and volatility in It's going to create more and more unstable prices, but it's not really going to decrease prices. That's going to take months. Even if we solved all of the problems straight away, it's still two or three months to get there. the fuel flowing properly around the world and get those prices back down so unfortunately for uh for motorists in south australia what does it mean it means you've got volatile and high fuel prices but good supply of fuel so that's that's my a bit good news for.
00:11:33
Speaker 2: Everybody no indication i i think brent crude yesterday was about
108 109 dollars no suggestion that'll that'll go up or down in the near future.
00:11:42
Speaker 5: I think it's highly likely to be volatile. So I think there's things that could happen. Iran, from a politics point of view, know they've got Trump over a barrel. I know it's an oil barrel. And on the side of that oil barrel is written midterm elections. So anything they do in the next two weeks has a much more political impact than usual. So we can expect that they're going to do something in the next two weeks. What is it? No idea. But they'll do something to disrupt Trump and make him look bad. And that means that, unfortunately, that's going to probably, at some stage in the next two weeks, we'll see some volatility in that Brent crude global oil price, which then flows through into fuel prices. But hopefully after the midterms, the same political clout isn't there, and so the same driver won't be there to do more and more volatile things, and hopefully things can start to settle. But it's a long time, unfortunately, before fuel is returning to a more stable and affordable level.
00:12:48
Speaker 2: Well, the world seems to be far less reliant on the Strait of Hormuz, much less is coming through there. Is that such a critical point now?
00:12:56
Speaker 5: Actually, that's a great point, Graeme, because the world used to have about 20% of its fuel or oil going in and out of the Strait of Hormuz. It's down to about 9% now. Where is that other fuel coming from? It's going across Saudi Arabia on the east-west pipeline out into the Red Sea. and then out through another choke point, the one near the Houthi rebels in Yemen and the pirates in Somalia, called the Bab el-Mandeb Strait. So that's now the more critical choke point than the Strait of Hormuz. So that's still an issue, but it's also the world has adjusted by ramping up production in other countries. Of course, Trump gave Putin the free kick of removing the embargo on Russian oil into Europe. which has increased supply in Europe. So we're not as reliant on the Strait of Hormuz, but we're still reliant on the Middle East and that other choke point, that Bab el-Mandeb Strait, known as the Gate of Tears, very happy-sounding name, that's now more critical than the Strait of Hormuz.
00:14:02
Speaker 2: David, always great to chat. Thanks so much for your insight today.
00:14:05
Speaker 4: Thanks.
00:14:06
Speaker 5: Always good to talk.
00:14:07
Speaker 2: Our new international supply chains expert, David Leaney, back with your call shortly on 8223 0000.
00:14:14
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
00:14:16
Speaker 2: 25 past nine, 5AA, your calls in a moment on 8223 0000. Regarding councils considering changing rubbish pickups, it seems the councils keep changing more for rates and doing less and less. Bell says, if councils have a money flow budget issue and cannot provide the services that we expect, we should be seriously considering reducing the number of councils from 69 to three metropolitan greater north, greater south. We do not need so many administrative councillors, managers, CEOs, and complicated individual red tape. Each council's imposed to justify their existence. Yeah, you make a good point, Bell. I think it is probably time that if we're to have a third tier of government, that we looked at the number of councils we have. I think in more regional areas it is difficult because they cover such vast areas and they have specific needs. But when it comes to metropolitan councils, I think less is more. Heather, good morning.
00:15:13
Speaker 3: Good morning, Graeme.
00:15:15
Speaker 6: Just a bit of a query.
00:15:16
Speaker 7: I haven't heard it mentioned, but it doesn't mean it hasn't been mentioned, about the credit card charges.
00:15:22
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:15:24
Speaker 7: Registrations for cards.
00:15:26
Speaker 5: Yes.
00:15:28
Speaker 7: Well, if you pay for your retro over the internet, there's only one way you can pay it, and that's through a credit card.
00:15:34
Speaker 8: Right. Now, SA services are run.
00:15:38
Speaker 9: By the government, so all our retro is going to go up.
00:15:42
Speaker 2: Now, look, I don't know. That hasn't been decided yet. I mean, the ATO are formally the only ones that have suggested that they're going to ban credit card bill payments.
00:15:53
Speaker 9: Yeah, I know the ATO, but I mean.
00:15:55
Speaker 8: But no other.
00:15:56
Speaker 2: Government instrumentality has suggested they're going to do that as yet.
00:15:59
Speaker 7: Yeah, as yet, because let's face it, the ATO is owned by the government because they get the money. So all your regos, all your licences, if you pay for it on the internet, which you've only got the choice of using a credit card.
00:16:15
Speaker 2: Or a debit card.
00:16:16
Speaker 7: or all our cheap coffee is going to become very expensive, 1.7% extra in.
00:16:23
Speaker 7: Your fees for your licence enricher.
00:16:24
Speaker 2: Well, the Prime Minister said you're going to save $ 1. 6 billion. I hope your forecast of that ban being imposed by state government instrumentalities is wrong. I mean, there was a suggestion, particularly in New South Wales, that local government councils would ban credit card payments. That hasn't come to being as yet, and let's hope it doesn't, because that will cascade right through every area, because if one council thinks it's OK to do it, or one government department thinks it's okay to do it, they'll all do it. There's no question about that. So I don't know that the Treasurer, Jim Chalmers, realised what he was setting up in this situation with the credit card ban. But the Prime Minister said we'd save $ 1. 6 billion. We might be saving $ 1. 6 billion, but how many extra billions is it going to cost the taxpayer? 8223 0000 is the number to ring. We'll take a break for news headlines. 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings. My next guest is Kieran Gilbert, News 24 Chief Anchor. Kieran, good morning to you.
Thanks for your time.
00:17:29
Speaker 4: Graeme, thanks, mate.
00:17:31
Speaker 2: This story of independent MP Helen Haynes, it's really sent shockwaves around the nation.
00:17:38
Speaker 5: It has.
00:17:38
Speaker 4: It absolutely has.
00:17:40
Speaker 10: I think it's a good way to put it, Graeme, and it's talking to a lot of MPs members of parliament, senior people in opposition and government, and One Nation, they're off.
00:17:53
Speaker 4: Kilter today for obvious reasons.
00:17:57
Speaker 10: Helen Haynes is one of the nicest people you'll meet. She's the least divisive politician, I think, in the place. So the idea that it Tragically, her fighting for her life in hospital is just almost impossible to get your head around.
00:18:22
Speaker 4: It is so awful.
00:18:25
Speaker 2: When the Prime Minister spoke about it last night, you could see how emotionally involved he was.
00:18:31
Speaker 10: Yeah, because she's a very, very popular local member in her seat of Indi.
00:18:38
Speaker 4: She's won her seat three times.
00:18:41
Speaker 10: She's popular in the Parliament too because I was talking.
00:18:45
Speaker 4: To one of her colleagues just before you.
00:18:47
Speaker 10: Called and before we had a chat on radio and he was saying to me, the thing about Helen Haynes was she would listen to every single person and their opinions, not interrupt, and take everyone seriously and then would give her opinion when the time comes and would always be thoughtful and But it's the way democracy should be carried out. And it's a tragedy. I really hope she pulls through for her husband and three kids. I hope she pulls through for her seat and for the country because she's got a lot more to give. And yeah, I think she's a great person, a midwife. She spent most of her life bringing people into the world and knew how Our life should be cherished, and the idea that this would happen to her is just unfair.
00:19:44
Speaker 2: I mean, it shouldn't happen to anybody in any walk of life, but there are a lot of possibilities. who draw anger, who draw, you know, who create an environment where you understand people are upset with them. So what makes it more incomprehensible is, as what you were saying, Helen Haynes was the antithesis of the politician who was antagonistic.
00:20:09
Speaker 4: Yeah, exactly. Yeah, I think that's what shocked everyone.
00:20:11
Speaker 10: There have been more than 1,000 threats in the last 12 months against elected representatives that the federal police have investigated, more than 1,000. And there are a lot of politicians who have 24-hour personal protection with the federal police. But Helen's not one of them, because she wouldn't be seen as a target, sadly, before yesterday. And I think that's what shocked everyone. because of that very reason, because of who she is. But also the warnings have been coming for a while from the Prime Minister down. People need to, all of us need to dial the temperature of the debate down, disagree, have a debate, but it should be done in a civil, respectful way. We live in a great country and a great democracy, and you need to protect that.
00:21:04
Speaker 2: And I think that's something that we've always prided ourselves on on Australia. We can disagree whether it be about the footy or politics or whatever and have a beer and say, well, you know, you go your way, I'll go mine, but we'll agree to disagree. But it seems the temperature has gone up considerably in the past couple of years.
00:21:23
Speaker 4: I think you're right, yeah, for whatever reason.
00:21:25
Speaker 10: And it's not just here, it's around the world. We've seen elected representatives killed in the UK, obviously in the US. Political violence is a big part of their history, but it's not a big part of ours. There's one New South Wales MP shot and killed several decades ago, John Newman in Cabramatta.
00:21:47
Speaker 4: Arthur Caldwell was shot, survived that in 1966.
00:21:50
Speaker 10: But other than that, The acts of political violence of this sort are very rare, and I hope that that remains the case. And we hope and pray that Helen pulls through and she becomes, you know, she already is a beacon, I think, for democracy, the way she carries herself. And I just, yeah, do pray that she pulls through.
00:22:14
Speaker 2: Well, I mean, if anything positive is to come out of this, maybe it will make people sit up and take notice of, You know, you can have your disagreements, you can be upset with what politicians are doing, but we all have a right to a voice, a right to express our opinion. But let's not take it any further than that.
00:22:32
Speaker 4: Yeah, exactly, mate. I could not agree more.
00:22:35
Speaker 10: Let's hope that that's a turning point in that sense. And, yeah, have your disagreement, have a debate. But the things that unite this great nation of ours, They're larger than those that divide us.
00:22:51
Speaker 4: And, yeah, I agree with you.
00:22:54
Speaker 10: I hope it does take the temperature down eventually. Obviously, right now, it's a very difficult time. People are, as I said, they're off kilter, certainly MPs and elected representatives. I know they're all sort of conversing with one another about their own situations and the various threats that MPs and ministers have faced. It's only human to do that, but I think the forefront of everyone's mind, and obviously not just members of Parliament, but members of the community, is Helen, and that she's got the best of care. Let's hope she pulls through. That's obviously the forefront of everyone's mind at the moment, Graeme, I think it's fair to say.
00:23:42
Speaker 2: Yeah, no, most certainly. What do we know of the man who's been questioned at the moment?
00:23:49
Speaker 10: Yeah, they just released his name, Brendan Nugent's name.
00:23:53
Speaker 4: Other than that, I don't know.
00:23:55
Speaker 10: They've just released that name. They also said he had been on their
radar.
00:24:03
Speaker 4: I'm not exactly sure for what the authorities.
00:24:06
Speaker 10: They'll be holding a news conference in the next hour or two. But, yeah, the name.
00:24:12
Speaker 4: Released as to.
00:24:15
Speaker 2: what had him on their radar.
00:24:17
Speaker 10: I'm not exactly sure at this point, but the authorities will be holding a news conference in, you would.
00:24:24
Speaker 4: Say in the next hour or two, with.
00:24:26
Speaker 10: An update as to what.
00:24:31
Speaker 4: This guy was on about, why he was on their radar, and how.
00:24:34
Speaker 10: On earth he would have ended up allegedly committing such a horrific crime.
00:24:40
Speaker 2: Yeah, in the meantime, Helen Haynes remains in a critical condition in a Melbourne hospital.
00:24:47
Speaker 4: Indeed, yep, she is.
00:24:48
Speaker 10: And there's a lot of goodwill being sent to her and all of her colleagues, her family, obviously. We just hope that she's going to be okay. You know, she's in the best possible hands right now. Parliament's due to come back next week. That will be a sombre affair for sure. As the reality of what struck yesterday hits home, as you put it, it's reverberated around the country. And certainly when Parliament returns on Monday, I think that'll be a moment where they will seek to try and Learn from this period, because whatever the motivation was, there's no excuse for political violence in this country.
00:25:33
Speaker 2: Most certainly. Kieran, thanks so much for your time today.
00:25:37
Speaker 4: Graeme, thank you for having me. All the best, mate.
00:25:39
Speaker 2: Kieran Gilbert, News 24 chief news anchor on the latest regarding Helen Haynes. The Prime Minister spoke about the issue this morning, about increased threats to politicians, but he said it's still important to engage with the public.
00:25:53
Speaker 11: We know that there has been increased threats made to members of parliament and we need to make sure, though, I think it's very important in a democracy such as ours that we cherish the fact that people can get out and about at community events, go to their local shops, engage at the local footy or netball courts on the side, engage with people. That's an important part of who we are. as Australians.
00:26:25
Speaker 2: I have to agree with the Prime Minister. An important part of who we are as Australians, we surely can't lose that. Angus Taylor, Opposition Leader, had this to say regarding the Helen Haynes incident a short time ago.
00:26:37
Speaker 12: Acts of political violence are un-Australian and unacceptable. Our nation cannot become a place where these kinds of acts are normalised. We have long been able to resolve in our country differences of view through vigorous and rigorous debate. We resolve them through debate and through choice at the ballot box. That is one of the great things about our nation.
00:27:06
Speaker 2: Any further developments in the Helen Haynes attack as they come to hand, we'll
certainly bring them to you and you'll hear them in the news throughout the day. 12 to 10, 5AA on this weathercast Tuesday. Bit of rain on the way. Has it hit your place yet? Let's know about it.
00:27:29
Speaker 4: 8223 0000, the number.
00:27:30
Speaker 2: To the stock market, the All Ords is down by 0.8%. ASX 200 also down by 0.8%. Dow Jones ended the day down by 0.07%. NASDAQ was in the green, closing up by 1.1%. Brent crude, $ 109 a barrel. West Texas crude, $ 103. 00. Gold, $ 4, 136 an ounce. The Aussie dollar, steady, buying 69 US cents. Mark, good morning.
00:28:00
Speaker 4: Good morning. How are you, Graeme?
00:28:02
Speaker 2: Good, thanks.
00:28:04
Speaker 8: Look, this is dreadful news, but one of the things politicians do as part of their job, they come across, as you do on radio, Graeme, every type of humanity. And some people are.
00:28:21
Speaker 8: Not quite as together as others, if we can be polite.
00:28:26
Speaker 4: I'm rather hoping.
00:28:27
Speaker 8: And, look, it doesn't diminish the tragedy of the case, but I'm rather hoping that this will prove to be a case of somebody who has mental health problems, who has got to be sort of in his bonnet. It's nothing to do with right or left. It's nothing to do with extremism in any form. It's simply to do... with the problem we face and irresolvable problem we face of how do you predict the person who's going to have a mental health crisis and do something stupid. Look, in my time, somebody came into my office once and I just knew something was wrong. So I rang the police and said, look, I just don't feel right about this. I got a call back to say the person had absconded from Glenside. And that's the sort of thing that happens. And it can happen daily because politicians are in the public eye. And I don't know if there's any way around it. But let's wait and let's not overreact. Let's sympathise with the person who needs the sympathy and not turn round and make a cause célèbre until we know what's going on.
00:29:45
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think that's a very reasoned way of looking at it, Mark. We can all jump to conclusions and lay the blame and look at terrorism and the like, but we don't know. I mean, it's still very early days in the investigation. Yep, thanks, Graeme. Good on you, Mark. Thanks for your input. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. It's 8 minutes to 10, 5AA. Peter says, Morning, Graeme. I've just driven up Greenhill Road from Wavell to Fullerton Road and noticed the grass on the median strip is uncut. It looks terrible, absolutely very shabby. It's usually neat and well manicured. What's the deal there? On the council preserving lawnmower fuel? Get on to it. So thank you for that, Peter. Up Greenhill Road from Wavell to Fullerton Road, grass on the median strip, uncut and unkempt. If you're listening, Unley Council, let's know what's going on. Well, we hear today that Labor knew in July of the ATO's plan to ban credit card tax payments. Assistant Treasurer Daniel Molino has admitted he and the Treasurer Jim Chalmers knew in July that the Australian Tax Office was considering banning credit card payments for tax bills. That was more than two months earlier than previously claimed. Now, the Treasurer told Parliament last week he only learned of the decision in late September, shortly before it became public. Molino said on ABC's Insiders that after the Reserve Bank banned merchant fees from October 1, the ATO considered three options and preferred a ban. The Ministers insisted on a transition period and continued negotiations with credit card companies for lower fees. Facing strong backlash from small businesses, the Government has now funded a delay of the ban until mid-2027. The ATO decision sent shockwaves through the world of small business who, let's face it, rely heavily on credit cards to ease cash flow problems. Joining us now is Skye Capuccio from COSBOA, which is the Council of Small Business Organisations. Skye, thanks for your time today. What impact on small business?
00:31:41
Speaker 14: Graeme, there's around 250,000 small businesses who are regularly paying their tax bills with credit cards. And they're using that as part of their cash flow management plan. So this is going to put significant pressure on those small businesses who no longer have that payment access, or won't for the second half of this year, have that payment.
00:32:01
Speaker 15: Access available to them.
00:32:02
Speaker 14: And we need to understand that this is happening at a time when there is already significant pressures on small businesses across the country.
00:32:11
Speaker 2: Did it surprise you that the ATO... planned to ban the credit card tax payments, but they expected you to absorb them?
00:32:19
Speaker 14: This has certainly not been well received by small businesses.
00:32:22
Speaker 15: It's definitely a concern.
00:32:24
Speaker 14: Particularly concerning was that this announcement was shared with us as small business advocates. you know, mere hours before the announcement was made publicly.
00:32:34
Speaker 15: And we miss that.
00:32:35
Speaker 14: Opportunity to have those conversations about how it would impact and what actually needs to be done to support small businesses to meet their tax obligations.
00:32:46
Speaker 2: Did it surprise you to hear that Labor knew in July of ATO's plan to ban credit card tax payments, but not pass that information on to you?
00:32:54
Speaker 14: It's really disappointing to learn that the government has known this since July. As I said, as small business advocates, we were given literally hours of notice of this change. And then to find out that there were actually months where we could have been having constructive conversations and that didn't happen.
00:33:12
Speaker 15: Was really disappointing.
00:33:14
Speaker 14: We would say that consultation is an absolutely critical part of good policy and policy development and process development.
00:33:22
Speaker 15:
And we missed that opportunity here.
00:33:24
Speaker 14: It is really encouraging that the ATO has now delayed the ban and that we are now moving into that consultation phase. But it would have been good to embrace the opportunity to do that earlier.
00:33:35
Speaker 2: So now you have time on your side. How will you use that?
00:33:39
Speaker 14: We are actively in conversations with the ATO about what the best options are here. I don't want to pre-empt where they are going to land, but everybody is engaging in good faith and From our perspective, we really do need to make sure that we can continue to give small businesses as many payment options as possible. But we also do need to work constructively with the ATO so that we are minimising the impact of the surcharge ban on taxpayers.
00:34:09
Speaker 2: Has small business lost trust and faith in the Treasurer?
00:34:14
Speaker 14: I think small businesses across the country are really hurting. They're feeling the pressure of year-on-year increase of cost of doing business. But the last six months in particular have been really, really challenging. We've had a fuel crisis. On top of that, they've had things that really put pressure on managing cash flow, like the introduction of payday super. And we've seen in that environment a number of decisions that really are harmful to small business. At the moment, for example, we are working through the decision of around a 30% minimum on discretionary trusts, which impacts hundreds of thousands of small businesses negatively.
00:34:52
Speaker 2: What do you say to people outside of small businesses who say, you know, what sort of business has to use a credit card to run their business? Surely they don't need to do that, or they shouldn't need to.
00:35:02
Speaker 14: It's often a part of cash flow management for small businesses, particularly for small businesses who might have bumpy and unpredictable seasonal income who might just be getting started and just finding their feet or who might be in a growth phase. And in that space, it's a legitimate way to support your cash flow management.
00:35:22
Speaker 2: I think a lot of Australians don't realise just what major role that small business plays in Australia. Without small business, this country would effectively grind to a halt.
00:35:32
Speaker 1: Exactly.
00:35:32
Speaker 14: We've got 2.7 million small businesses across the country employing over 5 million people and constituting around a third of the GDP. So at an economic level, small business is significant. But at a community level, small business is where you get your hair cut. It's the cafe owner who knows the name of your dog. It is literally what makes up our community and the uniqueness of our local communities.
00:35:56
Speaker 2: Interest rates keep going up. The cost of fuel rises by the day. it all impacts small business. And of course, you can't absorb those costs.
00:36:05
Speaker 15: At the moment, those impacts are cumulative.
00:36:07
Speaker 16: So you're right.
00:36:08
Speaker 14: We've had interest rates, falling consumer confidence, fuel crisis continues and fuel costs continue to have a significant impact. Also have seen significant increases in energy and insurance and labour.
00:36:21
Speaker 15: All of that takes a toll. It adds up and it adds pressure.
00:36:25
Speaker 2: We get feedback from people who go and buy their daily cup of coffee and The surcharge was there before. Now it's not there. And they're saying, well, that surcharge was, you know, five or 10 cents. All of a sudden I'm paying 20 or 30 cents more. How do you account for that?
00:36:38
Speaker 14: I think there's a few things that we are seeing going on there. We don't have eight cent coins. We don't have seven cent coins. So we have seen a lot of small businesses actually round up to an appropriate number to recost their menu because the charges to use a credit card haven't disappeared.
00:36:58
Speaker 15: They're just not visible. We just don't have that transparency anymore.
00:37:01
Speaker 14: The small business owner is still paying them.
00:37:04
Speaker 15: On top of that, the.
00:37:05
Speaker 14: Cost of doing business for most small businesses is have been increasing quite steeply. So we have seen some small businesses taking this opportunity, as they should if they want a sustainable business, to say, actually, we need to revise some of those prices and make sure that we are accommodating things like increased costs of labour when we're reviewing the price of a cup of coffee.
00:37:27
Speaker 2: So the ATO has delayed its ban. What's happening right at this moment?
00:37:31
Speaker 14: Right at the moment, you can pay your tax bills using a credit card and the ATO is actively consulting with advocates like ourselves about what will happen in the second half of next year.
00:37:44
Speaker 2: Will the delay be enough or would you like to see it go on into the future?
00:37:50
Speaker 14: It really does depend on where this lands. We need to find a solution where small businesses can continue to use all of the payment methods that they need to to pay their tax debts or to meet their tax requirements and to manage their cash flow. So the focus now is on constructive consultation to try and find a position where small businesses continue to be able to pay those tax debts as they need to and in a manner that works for them.
00:38:20
Speaker 2: Sky Capuccio, thanks so much for your time. After the news, which is coming up at 10 o'clock, we're going to look at... Motivated crimes, politically motivated crimes, are they on the rise in Australia?
00:38:34
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
00:38:38
Speaker 2: At 10 past 10, 5AA, a reminder that at 10.30 we'll have our 5AA resident GP, Dr Emily Kirkpatrick, in the studio. Any medical queries you have, anything you want to clear up, give us a call, 8223 0000. Well, my next guest is Strategic Analysis Australia Director Michael
Shoebridge. Michael, good morning to you.
00:38:58
Speaker 1: Morning, Graeme.
00:38:59
Speaker 2: How are you? Look, well, thanks. Look, in light of the horrifying attack on Helen Hayes, people are asking, are politically motivated crimes on the rise in Australia? Should we be concerned or do you see this as an isolated incident?
00:39:14
Speaker 17: Well, I think we should be concerned. Certainly the federal police say that the number of threatening and violent calls and approaches to our elected representatives is at an all-time high and went up to over 1,000 last year, up by about 100. There's a difference between people abusing an MP's electorate office or office here in Canberra and moving to be violent. But that anger directed towards our politicians is something that's on the rise and it's a negative for our democracy.
00:39:53
Speaker 2: Do you know, other than the Prime Minister, are there many politicians who have around-the-clock security?
00:40:01
Speaker 16: Not a lot do.
00:40:01
Speaker 17: I think some of the Cabinet Ministers have security. I remember Defence Minister Richard Miles said he wouldn't publish his flight itineraries anymore for security reasons.
00:40:14
Speaker 16: But I think it's a strong.
00:40:16
Speaker 17: Point of Australian democracy that our politicians can walk around the streets. And as the Prime Minister said, he can go to the supermarket and buy food for his dog.
00:40:26
Speaker 16: And if people see him, they talk to him. They don't attack him.
00:40:30
Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, this is where Australia has been pretty well unique in the world, that we do have contact with our politicians. We might not agree with them. We can disagree, you know, vehemently, but we can be on almost first-name basis with them. We can visit their office in the suburbs somewhere. They usually live in the electorate. We have this really close contact that isn't replicated in many countries.
00:40:54
Speaker 17: Yeah, and it's really valuable because the whole point of a democracy is our political representatives are connected to the people they represent. I've thought since 9-11, the 9-11 attacks, The security levels around our federal parliament have just gone up. It's got harder and harder to get in and get out of that enormous building. And that has isolated our political class, even in Canberra, a government town. So I think we don't want a future where our politicians are walking around the streets surrounded by people with microphones in their ears and weapons.
00:41:34
Speaker 18: Yep.
00:41:34
Speaker 2: I mean, you've said that the threat level is higher possibly than it's ever been. What do you think's driving that?
00:41:41
Speaker 17: Well, I don't think Australia's alone in the rising grievance towards, you know, how the system works. That Trump campaign slogan, drain the swamp, you know, seeing politics and therefore politicians as the problem, that's a rising phenomenon. You look at the UK, they've had three
politicians killed since 2016.
00:42:02
Speaker 19: Mm.
00:42:05
Speaker 16: And each of those was horrific.
00:42:07
Speaker 17: They had Joe Cox murdered by a far-right extremist, a conservative politician stabbed by someone inspired by Islamic State, and then Ann Whitcomb killed by somebody who's still before the courts on terrorism charges. So the UK is is often a few years ahead of Australia in political trends. I hope we buck the trend this time.
00:42:35
Speaker 2: Do we have a national hate crimes database?
00:42:40
Speaker 17: I think, I don't think so, but I think the different state police share that kind of information about individuals and ASIO obviously has people on watch lists. And this gets back into, you know, what's hate? Is it in the eye of the beholder? Is this you know, what particular language makes the grade. And terrorism academics have always said, look, the problem is the path to violent action is not clear. Someone who's done the same thing, said the same things, hung out with the same people never moves to violence.
00:43:19
Speaker 16: So it's not as simple as a direct link.
00:43:22
Speaker 2: What role do you think social media is playing?
00:43:25
Speaker 16: Well, it lets people emote, doesn't it?
00:43:27
Speaker 17: And it lets people pile in and join other people's sources of anger and grievance. So, yeah, I think social media companies need to start taking more responsibility for their products. That's something that there's been a public debate on around young people using social media in Australia. Well, I think we're all part of that. And we can say, well, it's just all the individual users, but it's quite obvious, isn't it, that the algorithms, drive people who have shared anger and grievance together.
00:44:00
Speaker 2: Looking at Helen Hay's office, she's in Wangaratta, you know, regional Victoria, a peaceful town, a popular person. It begs the question, are politicians' offices adequately protected and resourced?
00:44:14
Speaker 17: Well, I think it's worth looking at that, but she was hit in the street getting stuff out of the boot of her car, apparently. So, you know, a more secure electorate office wouldn't have stopped that. And I I think it's back to that problem of if we barricade our politicians behind security barriers and guards, people will just feel more disconnected from them. And that can drive the kind of anger that we're talking about.
00:44:38
Speaker 2: If you were to advise the government on future security, what would you be suggesting?
00:44:44
Speaker 17: Well, I'd say take threats seriously, but let's not get paranoid because a paranoid response will make the problem worse. And so let's all wrap our arms around Helen Haynes and her family and the people that work for her in her offices. Let's condemn this and have it go through the courts. But let's keep our democracy open.
00:45:07
Speaker 2: Yeah, well said. Thanks for your time today. Strategic Analysis Australia Director Michael Shoebridge. Your thoughts, love to hear them. 8223 0000. Back in a moment.
00:45:17
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
00:45:19
Speaker 2: 20 past 10, your calls on 8223 0000. At 10.30, we'll have Dr. Emily Kirkpatrick in the studio to talk all things medical. Interesting subject about penicillin. I was told at a very early age, I don't know why, that I was allergic to penicillin. So any time I see a doctor now, are you allergic to anything? Yeah, penicillin. Well, it appears that a lot of people who thought they were allergic to penicillin aren't. We'll ask Dr. Emily about that when she comes in. And if you have a question, give us a call now, 8223 0000, the number. On the text line, Joe says, I remember our first political assassination attempt 50 years ago. Three killed outside the Hilton, a bomb hidden inside a rubbish bin in Sydney. Prime Minister Fraser was inside with other Commonwealth dignitaries. Well, Joe, I do recall that, but there was an attempt before that back in 1966, Arthur Caldwell, was the leader of the opposition, the Labor Party at the time. He survived an assassination attempt. He was in his car leaving a rowdy demonstration, and someone approached the car, and he thought it was someone, a well-wisher, and he wound down the window, and a young fellow had a. 22 caliber rifle, point-blank range, fired it at Arthur Caldwell. Luckily, it hit the window, and Caldwell was just left with some glass slivers in his chin, as I recall. But yeah, So they're few and far between, but they shouldn't happen at all, should they? Hi, Graham. I just received an email from Westpac advising that on the back of RBA changes, they're increasing the interest rates on my credit card by 3% on purchases and 2.5% on cash advances. How on earth are the two things linked? The bank is still charging the fee. Screwing people over even more. Yeah, look, I know, and that's going to happen. I don't know how banks justify it. And I would suggest that Westpac won't be the only ones. Small businesses are using credit cards to pay their tax bills so they can earn frequent flyer points on their payments. Yeah, I think that might be an oversimplification. If you speak to a lot of small business people, it's the only way they can get from point A to point B when the cash isn't flowing, that the credit cards tied them over. Hi, Graham. As a small business owner who doesn't need to use a credit card to assist our cash flow at the moment, I'm happy to have some of the significant tax I pay go toward assisting those businesses that do need the credit card. Brian the Builder. Good on you, Brian. Thank you for that. And re-knowledge of credit cards refused by the ATO. Surely Labour not telling lies to cover their lack of planning and foresight. This would be a first, I think. This is Labour's standard operating procedure. No surprise here, sadly. And yeah, here's someone at the Case in point here, where the Prime Minister said, well, we're going to save
a lot of money, $ 1. 6 billion overall. Well, regarding the surcharge, yesterday I bought two Dim Sims and was advised the price had gone from $ 2. 50 to $ 2. 80 each due to the surcharge. Imagine if I had bought six. That is well over covering the surcharge as well as increasing government GST. Totally understand it. You were listening to 5AA Breakfast this morning. The story about... The fortnightly waste pickup caused a lot of consternation. Joining us, or joining the breakfast program, was Norwood, Payneham and St Peter's Councillor Sandy Wilkinson, who had this to say.
00:48:46
Speaker 9: They can only do it as a trial. They can't do it as a permanent thing. So the Norwood, Payneham and St Peter's Council could do it as a trial, but that's really just a way of sidestepping the legislation.
00:48:58
Speaker 19: Exactly.
00:48:58
Speaker 20: That's what the other councils have done.
00:49:01
Speaker 4: Yes.
00:49:02
Speaker 9: So we could do that, but it seems to me that in this day and age, it would be better to, if the government's serious about reducing landfill, to facilitate councils and encourage councils to divert more stuff from the landfill, which all goes to the mountain at Wingfield. And rather than go there, it should be going onto our gardens, food scraps and the like. And dog poo. Do you have dogs where you put your dog poo? I put my dog poo when I pick it up off the lawn. It's in the green bin. So if anything's smelly.
00:49:37
Speaker 3: It's a smelly fish.
00:49:39
Speaker 9: That I put in the green bin, and the dog poo that's in the green bin.
00:49:43
Speaker 3: So that's the greatest sense of smell.
00:49:45
Speaker 9: And I've said that the nappies and things can get put for the proportion of the population that use disposable nappies, put them in sealed plastic bags to seal in the smell, and that deals with that issue, in my view.
00:50:00
Speaker 2: So that's Councillor Sandy Wilkinson from the Norwood and Painterman's Peters Council regarding the potential changes to rubbish collection.
00:50:08
Speaker 16: They.
00:50:09
Speaker 2: proposed to slash red bin collections to once every fortnight. How does bin collection work in your area? Are you comfortable with it? Would you like to see any changes? Let's take a call. Andrew, good morning.
00:50:19
Speaker 4: Hello, Graeme.
00:50:20
Speaker 3: About Ms Haynes' attack and everything, and listening to Phil Currie and yourselves, I'm laying the blame with politicians and parts of the media, and largely, why is it okay for them to lie and deceit? I mean, I'd love for you to ask every politician that comes on, whether it be the Premier or opposition, you know, have you lied or do you lie and deceive the public?
00:50:45
Speaker 2: I'm sorry, I'm laughing, Andrew, but I agree entirely. How do they get away with it?
00:50:50
Speaker 3: So if we've got those standards and honour restored, hopefully we'll get back to an even keel and everything. But I'm going to mention the public broadcaster. Everyone seems to have forgotten that. It was only a few months ago when they had run a satiral skit about the murdering and torture of a famous businesswoman.
00:51:09
Speaker 16: Yeah.
00:51:10
Speaker 3: We're going down into the gutter, and like someone mentioned before about lone wolves and everything, and look, I foresee much worse to come. We're being divided, but now the politicians are acting like victims. Well, they've created the mess themselves.
00:51:26
Speaker 2: Yeah, and that doesn't justify what is happening. But I take your point.
00:51:29
Speaker 4: I agree.
00:51:30
Speaker 2: I take your point, Andrew. I mean, the accountability for politicians. I mean, there is a rule in advertising, you know, there's got to be honesty in advertising. If you're found to be wrong, you can get sued and have to pay huge fines. It's happened to companies. But politicians, the state is different, to be fair, but federal politicians can lie on their advertising and they're not accountable.
00:51:54
Speaker 3: I believe they should be, if they're caught deceiving and lying, like Barry O'Farrell, who resigned over a bottle of wine, if they don't resign, they should be stood down and lose all their pension and perks.
00:52:06
Speaker 2: Well, ministerial accountability doesn't exist anymore. Once upon a time, if somebody in a department committed a reasonable offence, it was beholden on the minister to step aside and take the blame. But do they do it anymore?
00:52:20
Speaker 13: No.
00:52:21
Speaker 2: So it's all buck passing, unfortunately. Good on you, Andrew.
00:52:25
Speaker 13: Thank you, Graeme.
00:52:25
Speaker 2: Yeah, no, thanks for your comment. Yeah, look, it would be great to have a politician who was consistently honest, but they're not. They are absolutely not. Deceptive in the extreme. And we only have to go back to the current government who said there'll be no change of capital gains tax and negative gearing. 50 times I said it, said the Prime Minister. Went to the election with that promise and immediately after it, oh, we've had a change of heart. We've changed our mind. That to me is like going into a restaurant that's got a sign up saying, free meals, free meals. And you go in and eat the meal and they say, oh, that'll be $ 85. Hang on, you said free meals. Oh no, we've changed our mind. We've had a change of thought, a change of heart. No, if you make a pledge and promise to do something, do it. Graham says, how do fortnightly bin collections reduce landfill? Yeah, I thought that same question. If you just, yeah, people are still going to generate the same amount of waste. Babies are still going to go through the same number of nappies. Yeah, that confused me a bit, but because that was taken out of breakfast this morning, I couldn't question it. But good point. 8223 0000, we're going to take a break for news headlines. Then after news headlines, we have our 5AA resident doctor, Dr. Emily Kirkpatrick in the
studio. Lots of questions to ask her. If you have any medical queries that you want to put forward to her, now's the time to ring 8223 0000. 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings. 38 minutes to 11 on this gloomy, although there's a little bit of sun peeking through, but not a whole lot of sun. Joining me in the studio now is our resident GP, Dr. Emily Kirkpatrick. Doctor, good morning to you.
00:54:04
Speaker 20: Good morning, Graeme, to you and your listeners.
00:54:06
Speaker 2: As I always say, are you well?
00:54:08
Speaker 21: I'm very well today, but unfortunately this weather's a little bit confusing.
00:54:11
Speaker 1: It is, isn't it?
00:54:11
Speaker 20: You think it's warm, but it's gone a little bit chilly, actually.
00:54:14
Speaker 2: Yeah, the rain hasn't arrived yet, but there's going to be some of that apparently. something that i mean the whole range of things and if you want to have a chat with the doctor now's the time to ring 8223 0000 people get lots of um prescriptions over the years you know they're diagnosed with this and given drugs and that and some people that i've found i'll talk about my father here i remember visiting him because he was living at a state and um he was getting on in years and uh he bought out his pills and things and there's a whole range of things uh Dan, what do you take that for? And there were some things he didn't even know what he was taking them for, but I don't even remember how long it had been. What are the issues with having a cocktail of drugs?
00:54:57
Speaker 21: Oh, well, it's a common problem, actually, Graeme, that I do see is that people are on so many medications and often don't know why they're taking.
00:55:05
Speaker 20: A particular medication.
00:55:07
Speaker 21: And of course, now we know there's so many supplements as well that people are taking. And so you've got prescribed medications from their GP. You might have a specialist cardiologist who's prescribed medication as well.
00:55:18
Speaker 20: And then you have, of.
00:55:19
Speaker 21: Course, then supplements that someone has purchased from a chemist. So the risk of this is actually quite significant if you are on a number of medications. And in fact, there's been a really interesting research study that's just come out of Adelaide University here in Adelaide, which is great to show really around the risks that we see with people who are on so many medications. And in fact, they were looking at hundreds of thousands of scripts that have been generated to see what was the risk. And there was an increased risk we know of falls in particular if people are on more medications. And We look at, in this particular study around individuals who are aged over 60 years of age, if you're on more than five medications, your risk of falls can actually be significantly increased and you may be completely unaware of that. So it is important to sort of think to yourself, why am I on all these medications? Have I had a discussion with my
GP about it? And do they know what other supplements or tablets I take from home that I've purchased over the counter at the chemist? So I'll tell you, Graeme, I've seen patients bring in bags and bags of tablets, all sorts of things that come out that they'll pour out onto the desk in front of me and we'll start looking through the packets and the pills and some things expired. Some things were antibiotics from a couple of years ago that I say, oh no, that course is finished, get rid of those. But what I tend to do is I say to people, have you ever had a pharmacist look at your medications. And they go, no, well, I got to go get my script at the field at the chemist. But in fact, every 12 months, if you're on five or more medications, you can in fact get what we call either a home medication review, or you can actually get the pharmacist to go through your medications with you and you have an appointment with them and they go through all of your supplements. all of your prescribed medications, explain what you're on and why you're taking it. And I get back as the GP a fantastic summary as to why someone's taking those medications, but also, is there a risk that we haven't thought through about a fall, for instance, or low blood pressure being on that cocktail of medications? So, A great thing to think about and ask your GP or ask your pharmacist is, could I have a meds check, it's called, which is a Commonwealth-funded medication review every 12 months, or a home medication review?
00:57:33
Speaker 2: So I guess while each medication might be fine in isolation, sometimes the cocktail can have counter, what we call it, they interact with one another and have negative impacts on you.
00:57:48
Speaker 5: Absolutely.
00:57:49
Speaker 21: And what I tend to find is often it's the blood pressure medication. So someone might be on two or three different medications for their blood pressure, and then they might be on something to help with their anxiety. And then we start to think, okay, is there something going on that could be at risk for their kidneys? Or actually, in fact, is this a risk for those medications all to be taken at the same time?
00:58:08
Speaker 2: Great advice. 8223 0000. If you have a question, you like to have a chat with Dr. Emily Kirkpatrick, now's the time to do it. Something that came to light, and this actually affects me because when I go to see a doctor and go in for some sort of procedure and they sort of say you're allergic to anything, yes, penicillin.
00:58:25
Speaker 10: Why?
00:58:26
Speaker 2: Well, I don't know. I think, well, I was a kid and at the time, you know, my mother always said, if you go to the doctor, say you're allergic to penicillin. But apparently new research suggests that a lot of people, a lot of us who think we're allergic to penicillin aren't.
00:58:42
Speaker 21: Yes, it's very common to see this and I hear it and I'll say, okay, medication allergies, yes, penicillin, childhood. I had a rash when I
had a virus when I was a child. And in fact, we do know that about 90% of people who are saying that they have a penicillin allergy actually don't have an allergic reaction to penicillin. It may have been, for instance, when they were younger, they had a virus. So Epstein-Barr virus or glandular fever is one of those that if you take antibiotics for it, it can actually give you a rash. And so people tend to think, oh, was it the antibiotics or was it in fact the virus? So there are different things that we need to sort of.
00:59:17
Speaker 20: Go through on your history.
00:59:18
Speaker 21: But what we're trying to do more and more now, Graeme, is actually understand, are these true allergies? And your listeners may be thinking, well, does it really matter? It doesn't matter because so many medications now, we know that if you have a penicillin allergy, we have to look. at an antibiotic that's much broader spectrum so that means that you're at higher risk of resistance to antibiotics or you might be having an antibiotic that's much harsher on your gastrointestinal tract that you didn't need and so we talk through with patients around okay would you benefit from a review that may be a blood test or a skin prick test to see in fact are you still allergic to that particular medication or was it in fact originally just a virus that produced a rash.
01:00:01
Speaker 20: And you took an antibiotic at the same time?
01:00:03
Speaker 21: So this is great research that's come out of ASCIA, which is the Immunology Society here in Australia, that really does show us now that 90% of people who have those labels attached to them, actually in fact it's not a true allergic reaction.
01:00:18
Speaker 2: Kay says, I took Amoxil and came out in hives all over me. Too scary to risk?
01:00:23
Speaker 21: Yes, and that's why it's important to have that conversation to say, okay, is this a true reaction or not? And sometimes what we see, Graeme, as well, is that people have lots of different reactions to different medications or cross over into other types of antibiotics. And, of course, that requires careful consideration. But certainly important to have the conversation with your GP, and we can either undertake that testing in general practice or refer you to an allergist or immunologist to review further.
01:00:50
Speaker 2: I mean, if you have the fear that you've had an allergic reaction to penicillin, what test do you undergo that doesn't trigger such a reaction again if you are, in fact, allergic?
01:01:03
Speaker 21: Yeah, so there's different things that we do. Sometimes it's a trial under observation. So we might get you to take a particular medication and then we have some steroids or something else that we give you to help reduce an inflammatory response to that in your body. But it's really about working that through, you know, taking a good history, different blood tests that are taken.
01:01:20
Speaker 20: We do skin prick testing.
01:01:22
Speaker 21:
As well and understanding, in fact, is this a family history or is this a personal history of a reaction? And I'm so pleased to see now so many GPs undertaking additional training and now have special expertise in allergies, and particularly this issue around penicillin allergies is something that you can now quite easily get assessed for to see, is it a true allergy? Could you remove this off your allergy chart when you go to hospital, for instance?
01:01:49
Speaker 2: We have a caller for the doctor. Ray, go ahead.
01:01:53
Speaker 22: Oh, good morning.
01:01:55
Speaker 21: No, um.
01:01:56
Speaker 22: I won't mention the actual name of the medication. I can leave it with your producer, if you like. But there's, to me, extremely important medication that I haven't been able to get for three or four months now. And the supplement to replace it does not work anywhere near as well as it should. and I keep losing weight because I'm unable to eat without the medication. I broke the bones on my jaw many years ago, and my eating went downhill from that time on.
01:02:49
Speaker 18: And I.
01:02:54
Speaker 22: There are times when I simply cannot eat for a day or two. Only what I can consume through a straw.
01:03:05
Speaker 20: That sounds very tough, Ray. And thank you so much for calling in today.
01:03:10
Speaker 21: I mean, what you're describing really is a couple of issues, the first being around access to medications. And unfortunately, we do find that some medications either get removed off the listing, so that can be through the TGA, the Therapeutic Goods Administration, that oversees the listing of medications. And I mentioned last week around some of the issues we've had with some of the immune supplements, such as Armiforce, and that being removed off the shelves. But we also know as well there can be short supply of medications that we saw particularly during COVID. But of course, now, for various reasons, we see short supply come in. And that's where the role of the pharmacist can be really important to go through. What are the alternatives available? And with your GP and your specialty, if you're seeing a specialist for your issues as well, what can we do to support you with alternative medications? But a really tough one, Ray, and I hope... Your GP can help you with some other options or additional medications that you could then take to support you.
01:04:06
Speaker 2: Ray, thank you very much for your call. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. A question, are people dealing with an iron deficiency, there's concern over some forms of treatment?
01:04:17
Speaker 21: Yes, there has been some media over the last couple of weeks regarding reactions that people have had to iron infusions. So some of your listeners may have had an iron infusion. You might be aware of people who've had an iron infusion. But what we've seen over the last decade is a drastic increase. in iron effusions being administered, both within general practice and in outpatient clinics at hospitals.
01:04:37
Speaker 20: And that's for various reasons.
01:04:39
Speaker 21: We know that iron deficiency is something that certainly has increased in the community. We see it particularly in celiac disease and when you have absorption issues in your gut, you have a higher risk of iron deficiency as well. And in fact, we've had these available in general practice for quite some time now, certainly over a decade, I've been giving iron effusions. And what we have seen is, in fact, some cases increasing of what we know as low phosphate levels after someone's had an iron infusion.
01:05:06
Speaker 20: And there was some media.
01:05:07
Speaker 21: Around the impacts of low phosphate levels after an iron infusion, particularly with a type of iron that's been given, which is ferringectin. So what we sort of are aware and trying to create awareness now in the community is that if you are someone with iron deficiency, first line is always oral iron tablets. But if you are someone who's had an iron infusion or going to have an iron infusion, have a chat with your GP or your healthcare provider about what's what blood tests to have done first to make sure that you don't have low phosphate or low vitamin D levels before you have the iron infusion, and also what product is being used. Because we do know that there are different products that have less of a risk for you for developing what we know as low phosphate. Typically, the symptoms of that, you get this quite significant fatigue and muscle aches after you've had an iron infusion. Generally, it's about one to two weeks after the iron infusion that you can develop it.
01:05:58
Speaker 20: And so we do.
01:05:59
Speaker 21: Really make sure that people have good follow-up with their GP after having an iron infusion, but also talking through those risks and side effects as part of the consent process. But otherwise, iron infusions are generally a very safe procedure to have done.
01:06:13
Speaker 2: Adrian on the text line says, I had contrast dye injection when having a CT scan. and had a very bad seizure and had to be resuscitated. It happened three years ago. I'm 60 years old. It was a shocking experience.
01:06:25
Speaker 20: That sounds terrible for you. I'm very sorry to hear that.
01:06:28
Speaker 21: It is actually one of those risks and sometimes can be familial as well. I've seen it familial. People have had a contrast CT scan and had really bad reactions, which is why we have you know, everyone ready to go. If you have the, because you're in the middle of the CT at the time, you're in the machine having a scan and we give you the dye, the contrast to see things better. And then we do know if you are one of those people, you do need to avoid then having the contrast in future scans.
01:06:54
Speaker 2: So there's no way knowing ahead of time?
01:06:56
Speaker 20: Typically not, no.
01:06:58
Speaker 21: Sometimes we see cross-reactivity with shellfish allergies or
other allergies that you may have, and so that's why we're set up in our radiology departments and units so that if you do have a reaction, we can quickly administer some medication to reduce that reaction.
01:07:12
Speaker 2: Okay, final call. Lynne, good morning.
01:07:15
Speaker 6: Good morning, and good.
01:07:16
Speaker 2: Morning, Doctor.
01:07:17
Speaker 6: I'm just calling on behalf of my husband, who's a bit shy to go on the radio, but it's about the tetanus injection. Now, when he was a young child, he apparently had a tetanus injection back in England and had a reaction to it. Now, we'd both like to have the whooping cough vaccination, but we're told that that comes with the tetanus. And we don't know whether the tetanus he had back then is a different one to what they've got now. We've had, yeah, he's now in his late 70s, but this probably happened back in the 50s when he had this tetanus injection, which he reacted to.
01:07:51
Speaker 20: Thank you, Lynne. That's a great question.
01:07:53
Speaker 21: Look, it could in fact be a different formulation as to what was had at the time. And so there's a couple of things to think about with this. The first is that we know that certainly the tetanus vaccine can be combined with the whooping cough. And it's important then to think, okay, do I need to have the tetanus with the whooping cough or not? And have that conversation with your GP. The second is looking at as to what the reaction was at the time that the that your husband had with the tetanus injection and then having a further conversation with your GP and saying, okay, would I benefit from having a tetanus vaccine together or not? We say it's about, you know, over the age of 50 to have a repeat being given anyway or every 10 years is suitable. And certainly I find it in healthcare workers who are coming in regularly for with pertussis vaccines is that we then have to have a conversation and chat and go, you know, would you benefit from the pertussis vaccine being given on its own or with tetanus combined? So a great question to have a chat with your GP about and what you may be eligible for or what you may be able to have or have testing for as well. But great question, Lynne, and thanks for calling on behalf of your husband.
01:09:01
Speaker 2: And Jane has just called in. Jane, go ahead.
01:09:04
Speaker 24: Hi, yes, thank you for taking my call.
01:09:07
Speaker 25: Just a query.
01:09:08
Speaker 24: My mother sadly passed away a number of years ago, but she was a chronic hay fever sufferer. She did have hay fever, as I said, and she was chronic with it. After she had her stroke, they thought that she was a bit depressed, so they put her on an antidepressant. I don't know that she was, but... And she never got hay fever again. Has there ever been a study, or are you aware of anything like that? And a similar thing has happened to me. I used to get hay fever. I've been on a very low dose.
01:09:47
Speaker 20: Yes, it's a great question. Thank you so much, Jane, for calling in.
01:09:50
Speaker 21: In fact, there has been a lot of work in this space. Some of the really interesting medications from many decades ago that were looking at depression and anxiety, in fact, have been seen a crossover into hay fever treatment, and there's various reasons why that occurs. It's all about turning off different receptors in the body, and we also know as well that If someone is on a particular medication for perhaps depression, it may make their mouth more dry or dry up secretions, which can in itself then help someone's hay fever as well. Particularly if there's someone who's got chronic sinusitis or a runny nose all the time. In fact, those medications can help dry things up really well. And there has actually been a lot of work and studies looking at both medications. medications from depression, anxiety, but also some of the medications for neurological conditions such as Parkinson's as well. There's been different crossover and some evidence that in fact they can help with hay fever. And that's one of the great things about medical studies is we often look to see what are the outcomes or results. And so we can help them with the best medication for treating the problem or maybe you get dual benefits.
01:10:54
Speaker 20: So thank you, Jane. Great question and call.
01:10:56
Speaker 2: I'm getting a late run on call. Paul, go ahead.
01:11:01
Speaker 4: Oh, good morning.
01:11:02
Speaker 18: Thank you for taking my call.
01:11:04
Speaker 23: My question is in regard to my knee.
01:11:06
Speaker 10: Which is worn out.
01:11:08
Speaker 23: It's bone on bone, and it really hurts to walk.
01:11:12
Speaker 18: I do a lot of cycling and gym work and squats, and obviously it's always in pain. But I'm reluctant to have it replaced.
01:11:23
Speaker 23: I was misdiagnosed to have my hip replaced, and I was put under a lot of pressure to have it replaced. especially they were saying that it's cheaper to have it replaced than to have it cleaned out. Well, I ended up getting a second opinion and I absolutely did not need it replaced.
01:11:41
Speaker 22: I had it.
01:11:42
Speaker 10: Cleaned out and it was perfect.
01:11:44
Speaker 23: But my knee maybe is a.
01:11:46
Speaker 18: Different situation and it's probably more of a major surgery. I was told by someone just recently that it does take a while to get back on the bike because you lose your range. That's, You know, and it's going to be a big, long recovery again. I'm just not sure whether I just keep going as long as I can or do I get it replaced.
01:12:11
Speaker 20: Yeah, thank you, Paul.
01:12:12
Speaker 21: It's a tough one always when you're thinking about, you know, what surgery do I need when you're in that sort of elective space where it's not urgent to be done right now, but, you know, could it improve or not improve the situation? And I always say to my patients, and I would suggest you have this conversation with your GP,
Paul, is, you know, what are the risks and benefits of this? It sounds like you're a really active person, you're doing squats, you're.
01:12:32
Speaker 20: On the bike, all of that.
01:12:33
Speaker 21: You know, what's going to be your long-term benefit from having some form of procedure? And what are some of the newer options available around some of the knees? Like I've seen some amazing, amazing recovery now post knee replacements with really intensive, you know, rehab, getting those knees moving, good range of motion. And, you know, having that conversation with your GP and then with your orthopedic surgeon to go, okay, what are the benefits here? Or actually, should I do some more intensive work first? Or, you know, what can I do differently? And having that back and forth conversation, because you have to think about your long-term benefits. And certainly we know there's been so much advancement now in terms of replacements and particularly how quick we get people moving afterwards. I'm just Absolutely in awe. I see people, you know, up and about, you know, same day. It's just fantastic to see. And really great to have that conversation with your GP and your orthopaedic surgeon about what your options are and making sure that you can continue to lead that active, healthy lifestyle, Paul.
01:13:29
Speaker 2: Thanks for your call, Paul. That's it, Doctor. Thank you very much for dropping by today. We'll see you again next week.
01:13:34
Speaker 20: Thanks so much, Graeme.
01:13:36
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:13:38
Speaker 2: 8 past 11, 5AA.
01:13:41
Speaker 10: Well.
01:13:43
Speaker 2: You only have to ask the question, and a 5AA listener will give you the answer. Somebody wanted to know why the flags were flying at half-mast. Phil says, the flags are flying at half-mast for the passing of former Speaker of the House of Representatives, Neil Andrew AO. Thank you for that. And we hear that Neil Andrew's state funeral this afternoon will be in the Pilgrim Church in Flinders Street. He was also the member for Wakefield. And on the subject of... knees replacement knees etc wendy says i have had three sessions of knee injections it was excellent but lasts about six months i will now have a knee replacement thank you for that and that man who had injections in the knee may have euflexa or had euflexa i think it regrows the cushion i think it's been in australia for about two years but use overseas at least 14 from what i was told So thank you very much for that. As I say, we have the collective minds of the 5AA audience, the collective intelligence. No matter what question, no matter what query we have, we get the answers sooner or later. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Yeah, more people are saying what is happening on Victoria Square and why the flags are in half-mast. The bin solution. Mark says we need more bin chickens. More they eat, the less pickups. Solution done. All we need to do is get the bin chickens under the employ of the local council and we've got no problem. John says, Albo referred to too much shouting, not enough discourse amongst people. He should lead by example and leadership. His intimidation, disrespect and shouting in parliament is disgusting. No wonder it's on the street. John, it does happen in all politics, I'm afraid, in all parliaments, in Australia anyway. Federal parliament question time is an embarrassment, I think. because I think, uh, and whoever is in the treasury benches should provide answers, but they deflect and, um, you know, treat questions with disrespect. And yeah, question time is an embarrassment. I think for us all. Eight double two three double O double O, uh, morning, Gigi. What a joke.
01:15:52
Speaker 4: The St.
01:15:52
Speaker 2: Peter's council with the rubbish collection. I have a family of six and I need my rubbish taken every week. Thank you for that, Danny.
01:16:00
Speaker 1: Yeah.
01:16:00
Speaker 2: Uh, How do fortnightly bin collections reduce landfill? People are still going to generate the same amount of waste. Babies are still going to go through the same number of nappies. Questions, questions, questions. How often do you get your rubbish collected? Would you like to see it rearranged? Would you see a better situation with rubbish done in a different way? 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Just before 12, we'll have a chat with Leith Forrest to see what is on his program today. Well, the nation remains in shock after the a horrifying attack on MP Helen Haynes overnight. Seven News reporter Andrew McCormack is in Wangaratta, been there for some time. He was there with... Andrew is not ready for us, but we will be crossing to Andrew shortly. The attack has shocked the nation, as I said. The latest we've heard is that she remains in a critical condition in a Melbourne hospital. She was attacked near her electorate office in Wangaratta, north-east of Victoria. If you've ever been to Wangaratta, it's just a delightful mid-sized town, lovely people, salt-of-the-earth people, and every report we hear about Helen Haynes was that she was inoffensive, effective as a Member of Parliament, she listened to people, she cared for people, there was no way that she would incite I mean, there are some politicians you can understand people getting upset with, never to the level that it deserves a violent reaction. But, I mean, you can understand some politicians get your goat up and get you upset, but that is the level it should be. Helen Haynes was not one of those people. So why the attack happened, I don't know. But we'll find out from Andrew McCormack shortly when he becomes available, obviously very busy in Wangaratta. Len, good morning.
01:17:49
Speaker 4: Why the attack happened? I don't know, but we'll find out from Andrew.
01:17:53
Speaker 2: Lynne, are you there?
01:17:54
Speaker 3: Yes, I am.
01:17:55
Speaker 2: Can you turn your radio down, Lynne, because I'm hearing myself, and it's very annoying. I'd
rather hear you.
01:18:01
Speaker 5: Okay.
01:18:05
Speaker 1: Yeah, go ahead.
01:18:07
Speaker 25: Oh, well, I just think we'd have an enormous amount of less rubbish if we went back to cloth nappies for babies. You cannot buy them anywhere, and the disposables of the companies have completely taken over, of course, because you have to buy them every week. People have a lot more money, and it would save the environment a lot, and it would be a lot better. We all survived with cloth nappies and survived incredibly well, so I would really like to see a go back to cloth nappies.
01:18:44
Speaker 2: Well, I know my daughter has used cloth nappies with both her kids. Mind you, it's a lot of work, Lynne.
01:18:51
Speaker 25: Cloth nappies?
01:18:52
Speaker 4: Yeah.
01:18:54
Speaker 25: If you've got four or five maybe, but one or two, I can't see where the work is. Honestly, I can't. You dispose of it in the toilet or in the garden, which is what we used to do, using it for a bit of fertiliser. and then just pop them in the washing machine, hang them on the line.
01:19:13
Speaker 2: A lot better for the environment, no question. Good on you, Lynne. Thanks for that. Maybe people will think twice. Think of the environment first and use cloth nappies. Well, we've been talking all morning about the horrific attack on MP Helen Haynes overnight. Joining us now from Wangaratta is Seven News reporter Andrew McCormack. Andrew, good morning to you.
01:19:32
Speaker 4: Graeme, good morning.
01:19:35
Speaker 2: This has shaken the nation, there's no question about that, and it must must have shaken the town of Wangaratta.
01:19:42
Speaker 26: Absolutely, yeah. I mean, look, it is a large, you know, regional hub in many ways, but it's also, yeah, a small town as well. Everyone knows everyone. And you're right, it's shaken the nation and none more here than in Wangaratta, three hours north It's a pretty large electorate. Helen Haynes is independent seat here in Ndai. I think there's about 100,000 people in the electorate. It covers quite a span. But, yeah, in Wangaratta here, there's people laying flowers as probably at least several dozen outside her office. We're just metres away yesterday. She was the victim of a horrific attack, which appears to be definitely deliberate, the motivations of which we're unsure of as of yet. The alleged attacker can be named as 43-year-old Brendan Nugent. He is from a town called Tarawindji, which is about 10 to 15 minutes east of Wangaratta, so very much in the local area. Understand he is known to police and they are aware of him and dealt with him before. Understand in April of this year there was a road rage incident involving him. Unsure if it was the same Land Cruiser used in yesterday's incident. alleged attack, but it was involving another member of the local community out here where he allegedly rammed them and then chased them on foot with a hammer, allegedly. But he is known to them he's currently in custody, undergoing
a mental health assessment. And then from there, they'll increase their questioning and try and find a motive behind this attack. As for Helen Haynes herself, 65-year-old mum of three, she's currently in hospital in Melbourne at the Alfred. She was flown there last night. She's undergone surgery overnight. Her husband, Phil, is by her bedside. Anthony Albanese, the Prime Minister, spoke with the husband late last night and she remains in a critical condition, fighting for her life with those severe injuries to her legs, and lower legs after being struck multiple times by this vehicle.
01:21:48
Speaker 2: Do we know if the alleged attacker was known to Helen Haynes?
01:21:54
Speaker 26: I believe it appears that certainly on social media there were some interactions. His Twitter feed, for example, is followed by Helen Haynes' office, whether or not she had direct knowledge of him or maybe they just... Correspondent, you know, this is going back several years now, there's correspondence there on Twitter or X. So potentially, but in terms of just how much they knew each other or she knew him or vice versa is unclear at this stage. As I said, he is currently in custody here in Wangaratta. He will remain here. No charges as of yet. So police still undergoing that mental health assessment before they can question him. But another incredible, just remarkable silver lining to this story, Graeme, is the bystanders in Good Samaritans who came to Helen's aid in the middle of the afternoon, on a Monday afternoon, and a barber who has directly neighboured Helen Haynes' office, a man named Ricky Jeffries, who's a 32-year-old father of three. He's got three young kids, all under the age of three. And he leapt to her aid along with a number of other locals. He actually ripped this driver from the driver's seat with the engine was still running and pinned him to the ground. He discovered that he had a knife in his pocket, a sort of a flick knife. He has then pulled that knife out, thrown it away. So it was out of reach of this driver. and pinned him down and held him there until police could come and take him into custody.
01:23:34
Speaker 4: Quite extraordinary.
01:23:35
Speaker 26: He was back at work this morning, Ricky. He owns a barbershop called Ricky Chop on one of the main streets here in Wangaratta. Lovely guy, a religious guy, a Christian, and says, you know, one of his first thoughts was, oh, I hope I don't get injured in this incident because my wife would be very disappointed. He sort of said jokingly, but he's humble as they come. Didn't want to take any of the attention away. Just said, you know, he did what he had to do in that situation. And, you know, was very much speaking glowingly of all the others who stepped in to help Helen and the first responders who were first on scene here. But, yeah, an incredible story for him. The Prime Minister's called him a hero. He doesn't like to call himself a hero. He thinks he just did what he had to do in the situation and would like to think anyone else would do the same. But quite an extraordinary tale.
01:24:25
Speaker 3: Yeah.
01:24:25
Speaker 2: And, I mean, he obviously did it disregarding his own safety because, I mean, he didn't know that the man did have a knife. Anything could have happened. and yet he sprang to the rescue. An amazing story.
01:24:37
Speaker 26: Well, not only that, but there were people sort of giving aid to Helen as she was on the ground, and he potentially saved them from getting caught up in this because the engine was running, and it looked like this driver was looking to continue his attack on the independent MP, and they were potentially in the way.
01:24:58
Speaker 4: So, yeah, incredible.
01:24:59
Speaker 2: Has there been any further update on Helen Haynes' condition?
01:25:02
Speaker 26: Critical condition, yeah, so she's remaining. We probably won't get an update, I would say, until mid-afternoon at this stage. So the Alfred provided an update mid-morning after she underwent surgery last night on those severe injuries to her legs. So, yeah, we'll wait, I'm sure, seven years at our 4pm bulletins and 6pm we'll have the latest on her condition with her husband. And her adult children, she's a grandmother as well, so her family very much by her side. And the thoughts, not just in Wangarad, but right around Australia, obviously, with Helen and her family.
01:25:38
Speaker 2: They most certainly are. Andrew McCormack, thanks so much for your report. And you can see more on that story tonight on 7 News. 8223 0000 is the number. Back shortly. 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings. This used to be one of my favourite songs. I'd let it roll on every time you walk in the room.
01:26:00
Speaker 4: Ah, yes.
01:26:01
Speaker 2: Memories, memories.
01:26:02
Speaker 1: Hi, Graham.
01:26:03
Speaker 2: The Dolly Parton Tribute Show is on ABC America and streaming on Disney only at the moment. Thank you for that, Jane. Gary says, Hi, Graham. I hope someone at 5AA or a listener has the ability to record the Dolly Parton Show and give it to that sweet old lady in a format that she can watch it on. The world is mostly wonderful. Gary, can't do it. It's illegal. We're not allowed to record it and do it that way. You can record things for your own private consumption. I don't think you can pass them on, but maybe someone is listening. Here's what you're saying. Yeah, so hopefully that Dolly Parton tribute concert will get to free-to-air television at some time or in a format that people without streaming or Disney can get to watch it. But one way you can hear music and enjoy singing the Sing for Joy Choir, a community choir program run by ACH Group in South Australia. To tell us about it, Conductor Paul Sinkinson. Paul, good morning to you.
01:26:59
Speaker 13: Good morning, Graeme. Lovely to be speaking with you this morning.
01:27:02
Speaker 2: Now, amid all the doom and gloom, we're looking for a good news story, and this certainly
seems to be one. Tell us about the Sing for Joy Choir.
01:27:10
Speaker 13: Absolutely.
01:27:11
Speaker 27: Well, you've caught me at an excellent time. We have literally just stopped singing about three minutes ago now. I've just finished cutting the choir off from our Lovely song we just finished with, Hallelujah, Leonard Cohen.
01:27:22
Speaker 13: Oh, brilliant. It's a lovely one to finish with.
01:27:26
Speaker 27: I run six of these choirs each week with ACH Group, and so we spread all across Adelaide, six different locations, and it's really a social, fun... I like to call it a step up from a sing-along, but it sort of doesn't have the intensity of, I guess.
01:27:45
Speaker 13: A more formal choir, and so.
01:27:55
Speaker 13: To hopefully foster and continue their love of music.
01:27:59
Speaker 27: Or if they have never sung in their life before and they've just decided to give it a go, that's exactly.
01:28:05
Speaker 13: What we're all about.
01:28:06
Speaker 27: Come along, give it a go, and you might find many like-minded people. You'll make some friendships. We have a lovely sort of afternoon or morning tea, lovely chat afterwards, and do some singing and learning as well.
01:28:18
Speaker 2: Oh, it sounds wonderful. But what about people in that age group that you talk about who just are tone deaf, basically?
01:28:26
Speaker 27: Well, I have never come across somebody in my– I've been doing this, what, eight years now.
01:28:31
Speaker 13: Yeah.
01:28:32
Speaker 27: I've never crossed anybody that is truly tone deaf.
01:28:35
Speaker 2: You haven't heard me.
01:28:37
Speaker 27: Look, Graham, I'm sure we get you in. We could get you doing a solo in no time. I've never heard anybody that cannot sing. And so even if you have no singing experience, I encourage you to come and give it a go. We'll find something that is a light bulb moment for you and suddenly things will click into place. I find that particularly people of a slightly older age group, they may have been told as a child or maybe when they were at school by maybe one teacher that perhaps they shouldn't sing or that they can't sing or that they sing out of tune. And that has really prevented them from ever singing again in their life. And so this is kind of shaking that up and shaking that idea up and encouraging people to come and give it a go despite what they might think about their voice because everybody can sing. Everybody deserves to have music in their lives. And that's what I love about my job.
01:29:28
Speaker 2: Yeah, I can hear it in your voice. So, I mean, the social connection, I can understand some people reach an age where, you know, they've lost a partner, they've lost friends, people, you know, and then they get into the later age that they don't get out and socialize like they used to. It sounds like this Sing for Joy Choir is a wonderful outlet for them.
01:29:49
Speaker 13: Look, it is so wonderful.
01:29:50
Speaker 27: One of my favorite things to
hear is when someone says, this is my favorite hour and a half of the week, I get to come out and just have a ball and make music together. That is what warms my heart and makes me so passionate about what I do. It is definitely that social aspect as well. Sure, I have a teaching background as well. I've sort of got a background in music theatre, conducting, and I play piano too. And I always try to, I'm a big believer in lifelong learning. And so as I go, I sprinkle in little.
01:30:21
Speaker 13: Tidbits of knowledge and things like that.
01:30:24
Speaker 27: We sort of put the music up on the wall so everybody can see it nice and large.
01:30:29
Speaker 13: We don't have books.
01:30:29
Speaker 27: It's all sort of hands-free. And we learn, but in a really fun, digestible way.
01:30:36
Speaker 2: Yeah, I can understand that. I've had dealings with the Woodville Concert Choir over the years, and I remember going to watch them practice. And, you know, to see the joy and the fun they were having, the shy acting, you know, it's my turn, your turn, you know, and it's just... Just to be involved with a group of people with the same aim.
01:30:58
Speaker 13: Exactly right. We're all celebrating music.
01:31:00
Speaker 2: Yeah, and when you hear the end result, you can see it in their faces.
01:31:03
Speaker 1: Is that us?
01:31:04
Speaker 13: Exactly right.
01:31:05
Speaker 2: Sounds great.
01:31:06
Speaker 13: Did we actually make that sound? Are you sure that wasn't a recording? No, it was you.
01:31:10
Speaker 2: So it's great for the members of the choir in rehearsal and practice. Are they putting on performances as well?
01:31:19
Speaker 27: Yeah, so what we do is it's a weekly session. So we come together 48 weeks of the year. And then because, as I said, we've got sort of six choirs spread out, what we do is every couple of years we come together, we join, and we put on a big performance together with over 120 choir members coming together. They've all learnt the same things. I've taught them all at the same level, so we've all progressed together. We come together and our last concert was in May at the Entertainment Centre and And we just put on a spectacular performance there for friends and family and the public. And it was just so wonderful to see because I like to think that these are largely sort of older people.
01:31:58
Speaker 13: They're grandparents. They've gone along and supported their children.
01:32:01
Speaker 27: They've gone along and supported their grandchildren at their sort of performing arts and creative endeavors. Now it's time for the family to come and see what grandma or grandpa have been doing. Or even if they don't have kids, they've got someone in their life that can see what they've been working at and what they've been enjoying each week.
01:32:19
Speaker 13: It's really, really wonderful.
01:32:20
Speaker 2: And they might be surprised at just how talented grandma or grandpa really are.
01:32:24
Speaker 4: Absolutely.
01:32:25
Speaker 27: And look, we do every genre of music under the sun. We do sort of vintage pop. We do a bit of rock and roll, a bit of Elvis. We do more modern stuff.
01:32:32
Speaker 13: We do folk. We do music theatre. There is something for everybody in this.
01:32:36
Speaker 27: Even today, we sang a whole mix of John Farnham and The Beatles and a bit of Mary Poppins and ABBA and Shanae O'Connor, a bit of Bonnie Tyler.
01:32:44
Speaker 13: Everything under the sun we cover.
01:32:46
Speaker 2: Who gets to choose?
01:32:49
Speaker 27: So I've got a big request list that I take from the choir members and I'm slowly working my way through that. But I like to hear stories and we share our life experiences at the choir too. And so it's always nice to hear if a song has a special meaning or a special connection to somebody.
01:33:08
Speaker 2: Now, I don't doubt for a second there'll be people listening and say, hmm. That interests me a little. Paul, what do people need to do? How can they get in touch?
01:33:17
Speaker 4: Absolutely.
01:33:18
Speaker 27: So I would encourage anybody, even if it's just a little glimmer of, oh, I think I've got an interest here that I might give it a go. ACH Group offer a free come and try session to anybody that wants to come along over 65. All they've got to do is either visit the ACH website or call the ACH number, which is 1300 222. And then they can just say, hey, I would like to join the Sing for Joy Choir. And the locations, hopefully there's a close location to everybody around Adelaide. We are at Glandor, we're at Finden, we're at Glenelg, Portnolunga, Teatrigully-Durnancourt area, and also Campbelltown.
01:34:04
Speaker 2: And how often do you have rehearsals and at what time?
01:34:06
Speaker 27: So we get together once a week and it's an hour and a half of singing and then half an hour of morning or afternoon tea. Generally, Glendore is a Tuesday morning at 10 a.m. Finden is Tuesday afternoon at 1 p.m. Glenelg is 10 a.m.
01:34:21
Speaker 13: On Wednesdays. Port Nollunga is 1 p.m. on Wednesdays.
01:34:26
Speaker 27: Dernancourt is 10 a.m.
01:34:28
Speaker 13: On Fridays. And then Campbelltown is 1 p.m. on Fridays as well.
01:34:33
Speaker 2: Fantastic. I think you're going to get flooded by people saying, uh, we want a piece of this.
01:34:37
Speaker 27: I mean, look, I, you know, if I could put a big shout out for, if anyone lives around the Glandall area or the Campbelltown area, we, um, we, there are two smaller choirs. And so I even had, uh, some choir members this morning say, Hey, if we could, Get some more people along. That would really help boost my confidence as well, because I think we're about, we had about six people this morning, which is a scary thing to do when you're singing in a choir. But I would love to have some more people come along and join us.
01:35:03
Speaker 13: And I promise you will have the time of your life.
01:35:05
Speaker 2: Well, I think you'll get some
5AA listeners coming along, Paul. Quite sure.
01:35:09
Speaker 13: Thank you. And thank you for having me on as well. I really appreciate it.
01:35:12
Speaker 2: Now, Paul, can you give us that number once again?
01:35:14
Speaker 8: Yeah, sure.
01:35:14
Speaker 27: It is 1-300-2244- 1300 224477.
01:35:20
Speaker 4: Excellent.
01:35:21
Speaker 2: That is it.
01:35:24
Speaker 27: Or even if they want to do a Google search and put in ACH Group Sing for Joy Choir, the ACH website will pop up and all the information's.
01:35:32
Speaker 13: On there too.
01:35:34
Speaker 2: Great to chat and keep up the good work.
01:35:36
Speaker 13: Thank you very much, Graeme.
01:35:37
Speaker 19: Pleasure.
01:35:38
Speaker 2: Paul Sickinson, Sing for Joy Choir is founded by ACH Group as a social program for older people to sing, to connect, to learn and perform. It sounds like a lot of fun. What do you reckon? Back shortly.
01:35:50
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:35:54
Speaker 2: And the final minutes of the show, but still time for you to call, 8223 0000. Good morning, Graeme. Regarding Anzac Highway, the overground nature strip was very noticeable during the Bay to Birdwood rally and was definitely a bad look. And on the subject of the tribute concert by Dolly Parton, it's on Disney +, not ABC here. the US network. So hopefully it will be seen by many. I think there are so many people who'd like to see it. Hopefully it will turn up on free-to-air at some stage. John, good morning.
01:36:24
Speaker 4: Morning, Graeme.
01:36:24
Speaker 19: Thank you for taking my call. Graeme, I'll just answer some people's opinions. I listened to the Prime Minister's discussion this morning in regards to the incident with the MP yesterday. I was a bit disappointed. I thought it wasn't a leader's discussion about it, what happened. I'm just, you know, as a person of the public, you can't go out anywhere anymore without you not being disrupted by people who are either under the influence or yelling and screaming. It should not be happening in our society. You should be safe to go wherever you want. It's not happening anymore. We need to change this. We need to maybe get another jail, hold people accountable for what their actions.
01:37:09
Speaker 2: Are, So you think people are just not being accountable? I mean, the bail laws and the like, young people who commit crimes get out on bail. It's sort of like a revolving door. Correct.
01:37:20
Speaker 1: Correct.
01:37:21
Speaker 19: That gentleman yesterday apparently had a police history, as it was mentioned in your show earlier. It's just not happening. This government needs to harden up. We need to harden up as a society. It's changing every day, and we need to change with it.
01:37:35
Speaker 24: Yeah.
01:37:35
Speaker 19: And not be nice.
01:37:37
Speaker 2: I can't disagree with you, John. Um, It does seem there's a change. I mean, we look back on history unfondly and talk about the good old days, but when you
did feel a lot safer, when you could go to Hindley Street on a late Friday night, Saturday night and feel totally safe, doesn't happen anymore, unfortunately. Go to regional shopping centres, you don't feel so safe. You're out at night, you don't feel as safe as you once did. Maybe our attitudes have changed. Maybe it's the law.
01:38:04
Speaker 10: I don't know.
01:38:04
Speaker 2: There are so many factors involved. uh leah says graham you should see golden grove and green with footpaths the foot it's four feet high everywhere oh the over undergrowth of growth sick of it council or whoever should maintain it fortnightly uh nice home for brown snakes thank you for that leah and someone else saying that flags flying at half-mast for the passing of former speaker of the house of representatives neil Andrew. Thank you for that. Leith, good afternoon.
01:38:32
Speaker 28: Good morning. Do you know people have different kinks when it comes to things they enjoy on the internet to watch? One of mine is guys who go to lawns and verges and clean them up for free. As someone who just loves cleanliness... Are you one of those people?
01:38:50
Speaker 2: Oh, my Lord.
01:38:50
Speaker 28: If I was better with a whippersnapper, if I could actually do a straight line, I would do it in my spare time.
01:38:56
Speaker 2: Is that right?
01:38:56
Speaker 28: There's a heap of videos. So if you look it up online, you can watch. There's an Australian guy. There's a couple of guys in the US. And they go and knock on just random people's doors. And they say, hey, I do this for YouTube. And I get clicks and advertising spend, et cetera. Can I do your lawns for free? And the person goes, yeah, sure, no worries. But it's always verges. It's verges of councils where the councils don't do it. So these guys do it for free. People watching their millions, they get money for it and they go and do more. I mean, it's amazing what is on YouTube. You have any sort of interest, perversion or whatever, you will find it on YouTube. What's the thing about people unwrapping presents and things?
01:39:38
Speaker 21: Oh, yeah.
01:39:38
Speaker 2: What is it? Unboxing.
01:39:41
Speaker 4: Yes.
01:39:42
Speaker 2: Unboxing.
01:39:42
Speaker 28: There's another one. So I'll give the guy some love. Nathan's Lawns. If you look up Nathan's Lawns on social media, it's just a guy who goes around to neighbourhoods, sees overgrown lawns slash verges, and chops them for free. And it's so refreshing, Graeme, because it goes from a mess to just neat and tidy. Order is what we need more in this day and age, and he does it. And I love it. I could sit and watch that stuff for hours.
01:40:07
Speaker 2: Well, maybe you could start up your own YouTube page. I can't go straight.
01:40:11
Speaker 28: That's my drama. So we actually embarrassingly had to buy or rent a lawn guide just to do my edges. I'm happy to mow, but I just can't get it straight. And then everyone looks at it.
01:40:22
Speaker 2: And you're not happy with imperfection, obviously. No, I want it to be like- Perfect.
01:40:27
Speaker 28: Perfect. I want it to be sort of ruler.
01:40:30
Speaker 2: See, that's where you and I differ.
01:40:33
Speaker 8: No.
01:40:33
Speaker 2: If it's a little bit. sort of curvy and whatever or a little bit overgrown that's okay.
01:40:37
Speaker 28: Can i give you another confession on similar kind of issue but slightly different i love watching hairdressing videos too because it's male female it doesn't matter it's the exact same thing where it goes from a mess to neat and tidy i love hoarding videos i love when people's houses are six foot high of magazines and books and junk And then someone comes in and cleans it all.
01:41:00
Speaker 4: Oh, Graeme.
01:41:01
Speaker 2: You've got too much spare time.
01:41:03
Speaker 28: Way too much. That's what everyone says. What are you doing in your spare time? I'm watching those. So for your caller, let us know what neighbourhood that is and we'll send someone around.
01:41:11
Speaker 2: Well, there was somebody evidently that used to do that and got a parking fine from the council.
01:41:16
Speaker 1: Really?
01:41:17
Speaker 28: They were doing the council's work. There's another guy I watched the other day. He walks around with a bin and he's got this contraption, which is sort of half tongue, half extended arm. And he basically goes around and just picks up litter and rubbish. And again, makes his neighborhood look beautiful, which again is refreshing.
01:41:35
Speaker 2: That's great. There's a guy on Port Road. I don't know if you've ever seen him with the sign. No, I haven't seen it. Have a wonderful day. Have a happy day. See, that's what we need more of. And you toot your horn and it makes you feel really good. Yeah, that's what we need.
01:41:47
Speaker 28: See, in this day and age where there's so many depressing things, I'm going to give you my algorithm. Give me your phone for half an hour. I'll get some good videos on there for you. And then you can just sit at home and watch people mowing lawns.
01:41:59
Speaker 2: When you have grandkids, you see some bizarre things happening. Like, I have a grandson who loves garbage trucks.
01:42:04
Speaker 8: Right.
01:42:05
Speaker 2: I'll tell you what, you put in garbage trucks on YouTube, you have a panacea.
01:42:09
Speaker 1: Yes.
01:42:09
Speaker 2: And there's one guy who's made millions, I think his name's Hal.
01:42:12
Speaker 13: Okay.
01:42:13
Speaker 2: And he rides on garbage trucks, he cleans garbage trucks, he shows you how to... They load and unload, and he's having a ball.
01:42:20
Speaker 28: There is something for everyone on the internet. It's beautiful, isn't it? Your grandkids probably do the same, where you pick up your phone, go to your photos, and you'll find 65 of their face, where they've just taken endless amount of selfies that you have to go through and cull.
01:42:34
Speaker 2: It's a different world.
01:42:35
Speaker
28: I probably overshared. After 1 o'clock, did you ever see the film or read the book, Mal's Last Dancer?
01:42:42
Speaker 5: No.
01:42:42
Speaker 28: It's a very famous... I have heard of it. So it's a very famous story of a guy from China by the name of Li Xuansin who was plucked from a village in China from poverty at about 10 siblings. And then he becomes this famous world ballet dancer. And he dances for Mao. And he's like one of Mao's last dancers. Anyway, huge book, huge movie. He's written a new book. He's on the show today because he's in Adelaide tomorrow. He's doing a speaking engagement, which is kind of the new thing now where these authors are coming to Adelaide. They're booking at like the Regal Theatre. And then in front of hundreds of people, they talk about their books, which I kind of like. So he's going to join us and talk about his new book. And we're also going to get to the bottom of the amount of insects that are in Adelaide at the moment.
01:43:30
Speaker 2: Have you noticed this?
01:43:31
Speaker 28: Have you noticed around your household?
01:43:33
Speaker 13: Extra insects?
01:43:34
Speaker 2: Every now and then, we have an invasion of these tiniest little bugs, and they get in through an air conditioning vent or something like that. We can go weeks, months, and don't see them. And all of a sudden, houses are infested with these tiny little flies.
01:43:49
Speaker 28: Well, it's the perfect storm for them weather-wise. So my wife was driving yesterday, and she described it as a sheet of butterflies just flew across the road. Never seen anything like it. So I reached out to a friend who works in the industry, and she said, yes, there are thousands of these white butterflies descending on Adelaide because it's too hot in the north. Hang here for a little bit, and then it gets cooler here, and they'll go back. So just in case you're wandering around, because there's a lot of ants at the moment. There's a lot of mozzies around. Flies are in there, squillions, as they normally are. But more than normal for this time of year. So we'll have a look at that after.
01:44:22
Speaker 13: One o'clock as well.
01:44:23
Speaker 2: What about bogong moths?
01:44:24
Speaker 28: Well, thankfully, we're not getting those like Sydney and Melbourne.
01:44:27
Speaker 2: But they're a threatened species.
01:44:30
Speaker 16: Yeah.
01:44:30
Speaker 2: And people say, you've got to be kidding. They overtake cities.
01:44:34
Speaker 4: That's right.
01:44:35
Speaker 28: People pull off their thongs and use it like tennis rackets or paddle ball.
01:44:38
Speaker 2: Story for another day.
01:44:39
Speaker 28: There's a bogong moth map, actually, you can watch where they sort of let you know where they're There's a couple in South Australia, but not many. But no, have a look for the butterflies when you're driving around next. And if you can lend me your phone, I'll put some good videos on.
01:44:51
Speaker 2: You're not touching my phone. On your bookmarks. I'll tell you about the garbage trucks.
01:44:54
Speaker 13: All right.
01:44:55
Speaker 4: See you, Graeme.
01:44:55
Speaker 2: Good on you, Lee. Lee Forrest coming up this afternoon. Just about time to go. A good news story from the text line. Good morning, Graeme. I thought you and your listeners might appreciate a good news banking story. I happen to bank with the Commonwealth Bank. I had an issue with my account. I went into my local branch and my issue was resolved promptly and efficiently. They were wonderful to deal with. I can't fault them one iota. Catherine, a lovely story and kudos to the Commonwealth Bank because we do knock the banks. There's no question about that. But the publicity about banks is usually way more negative than positive. So if there's a positive angle we can take, we'll take it. That's it for today. Thank you for your company. We'll be back tomorrow. Then we'll do it again.