TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:01
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
00:00:12
Speaker 2: Good morning. Welcome to this Tuesday, 13th day of October. I hope you can stay with us throughout the morning. On the show today, cash-strapped small business owners are turning to short-term loans, personal guarantees as a temporary lifeline to cover wages, supplies and tax bills. But if they default... Apparently, there are big problems. We'll find out more about that. In the studio this morning, 5AA resident GP, Dr. Emily Kirkpatrick, 8223 0000. You can ring and have a chat with her. Do you have a weird symptom, something you're not sure about? Maybe a family member has an odd habit, something you're too embarrassed to ask your own doctor?
00:00:47
Speaker 3: Dr.
00:00:48
Speaker 2: Emily is here to answer your questions, 8223 0000. Scammers are now having a new way of doing business, if we can call it that. They're getting you to call them. How does that work and how do we prepare against it? Lee Stark from picker.com will join us. Um, a bizarre story that really is concerning, uh, begs the question, should Australia block a U S military execution live stream? Now, apparently U S defense secretary, Peter Hegske plans to live stream the, the fire squad execution of Nadal Malik Hassan. He's the former army major who killed 13 people at Fort hood in Texas in 2009. Uh, Peter Hexeth wants to show it live as a way of dissuading or discouraging people from carrying out similar events. I find it horrific. Should it be banned and blocked in Australia? Can we ban it or block it? Live streaming. We'll find out more about that. On a much happier note, $ 100 million Powerball this Thursday. There are a lot of people I know that don't bother with buying Lotto, you know, $ 1 million, $ 2 million, $ 5 million, but when it gets... up to big numbers like that, $ 100 million, many of us are tempted. And what would you do with $ 100 million? Let your mind race. Just think about it for a second or two. You've won $ 100 million. There it is sitting, waiting to be collected from the lotto office, $ 100 million. What would you do with that? Do you know how to spend it? Well, I tell you what, where would you start? I think most of us would sort of think, look, if I won $ 1 million, that'd be terrific. I'd do this, that, the other. $ 5 million, help out the family, buy a new house, world trip. But when you get to a number like $ 100 million, what would you do? I mean, you could do a lot of wonderful charitable things. You could help out a lot of people. But where would you start? It's a bit scary. We'll speak with Senior Financial Advisor Simon Robertson about that a little bit later on. Welcome to all the cruise people that have come to town. The Official South Australian cruise season is underway. The arrival of the Princess Cruises Crown Princess at Outer Harbour this morning. 3,080 guests on board, 1,200 crew. So if you're from the Princess Cruises Crown Princess and you're in Adelaide, give us a call. Welcome, firstly. We've turned on an okay day, nothing special. It usually is better than this, but they're all good in Adelaide. So enjoy your time here. And if you're a cruise person, Does this stir the memory of the last time you took a cruise? What was your favourite cruise? When did you go on a cruise? Do you have any cruise horror stories? Let us know about them. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. The question I want to ask, and I think most of us should be asking, is should we all be paying for public EV charges? How would you feel about helping to pay for new public electric vehicle charges, even if you don't drive an EV? Well, the Australian Energy Market Commission says has backed a draft proposal to install up to 14,000 public charges right across Australia. It'll be particularly in regional areas and densely populated urban areas where residents lack off-street parking. Now, under the proposed $ 14 million federal government initiative, taxpayers would cover 30% of the cost, while electricity distribution networks would cover the remaining 70% from consumers. Now, for a typical household, the estimated impact is about $ 1 a year, on your electricity bill over five years. At first glance, that seems a small price to pay for cleaner transport and better access. Regional motorists and apartment residents could benefit significantly, especially where private charging businesses see little financial incentive to invest. However, private charging companies argue the proposal could give electricity distributors an unfair advantage. While commercial operators must fund their own investments and carry the financial risk, network companies could pass much of their costs on to us, the electricity consumers. That raises a fair question. Should households subsidise infrastructure that private businesses may profit from? Expanding EV charging is important, but so is protecting consumers and maintaining competition. Before approving the plan, the regulator must demonstrate the public benefits, justify the costs, and that private investment cannot adequately meet the need. And while it is only a dollar a year for five years, remember the old saying, once a tax is introduced, They are never repealed. And who's to say that $ 1 won't become $ 5, become $ 10, or even more? Now, consultation on the proposal is being carried out at the moment with a final determination due by the end of the year. So how do you feel about that? Do you drive an EV and think, well, that's fair game? You don't drive an EV. You think, well, $ 1, that's okay, $ 1 a year. But as I say, thin edge of the wedge, should we be concerned. 8223 0000. is the number to ring, 14 past 9, 5AA. Well, despite Australia's deepening cost of living crisis, there are certain businesses that are thriving as households are slashing spending. Joining us now is Gary Mortar from the QUT Business School. Gary, good morning to you, and thanks for joining us today.
00:06:07
Speaker 4: Yeah,
Load full transcript
good morning. Great to chat again, Graeme.
00:06:09
Speaker 2: Yeah, so what's happening out there in the retail world at the moment?
00:06:12
Speaker 4: Yeah, it's really interesting. So, obviously, cost of living crisis is really starting to eat into family household budgets. And what we're seeing is Aussie shoppers really looking at ways to save. And certainly one of the areas they're looking at is food and groceries. And this is a cost that we can't avoid. We spend a couple hundred dollars every week at our supermarkets. What we're seeing is a shift towards the discounters like Aldi, but also other alternatives like Costco so that they can buy in bulk. They're looking at places like marketplaces like Amazon where you can buy about 30% now. of the range of a big supermarket's dry grocery offer, and also third-tier discounts, like the reject shop soon to be called Dollarama. So really shopping around in order to save on that household grocery spend.
00:07:01
Speaker 2: So when it comes to groceries, you can't put it off. We need the groceries every week, and it could be $ 100, $ 200, $ 300, however much. But what about discretionary spending? What about things like buying a new outfit or a new pair of shoes?
00:07:13
Speaker 4: Yeah, and once again, shifting towards the discounted. So, you know, what we've seen in the middle of the market, so we think about sort of Katie's, Mosaic Brands, Rockman's, Miller's, you know, it's that middle market's really starting to shrink. Some of those businesses are simply closing because those shoppers are now shopping down. They're shopping at the likes of Kmart, Big W, Target. But also, again, those online marketplaces like Shein and Temu. So looking for discretionary spending, footwear, clothing, accessories and fashion. But moving away from that middle market, obviously the top end of the market, if you're spending $ 8, 000 on a Louis Vuitton handbag, you're not too concerned about your mortgage or paying your rent. So the top end of the market is pretty insulated from cost of living. The middle market really shifting down to looking for greater value options.
00:07:59
Speaker 2: Now, many years ago when I was growing up, getting a pair of shoes repaired was a common occurrence. And in this day, this more disposable age, it doesn't happen very often. But I hear shoe repairers are coming back into their own.
00:08:11
Speaker 4: Yeah, really interesting that this notion of repair, reuse, upcycle, recycle. I think about my daughter who's 25. She doesn't shop sort of new now. She shops at op shops and some binnies and Lifeline. And a lot of her friends do as well. So they're looking for sort of pre-owned, pre-loved clothing now. If you've got a reasonably good pair of shoes, rather than just throw them out, which we probably used to do, it's like, actually, I could probably go down to the local shoe repair and get $ 20 and get a minor repair done on them. So we're looking to hold onto things much longer, get them repaired, get them upcycled.
00:08:44
Speaker 2: Is that also happening with cars? Are we hanging onto our cars longer?
00:08:48
Speaker 5: Yeah, we are.
00:08:49
Speaker 4: And I think that at the cost of cars, we certainly have the pandemic. We saw even the price of secondhand cars go through the roof. What we can also see, though, in the market is the shift towards Chinese-made vehicles, and they're really starting to flood the market now. Really good quality, certainly well underneath the Japanese, Korean-made prices and US vehicles as well. So it's really interesting. Despite the cost of living prices, we're still spending, but we're just being more cautious in how we spend, more disciplined and more purposeful.
00:09:17
Speaker 2: Do you think the definition of a bargain has changed for Aussies over recent years?
00:09:22
Speaker 4: I think we're looking for greater value, not necessarily the cheapest prices. And buying cheap is great, but if it doesn't last very long, it doesn't create any real value. So I think when it comes to bargain shopping, I think we're looking for a product that's reasonably priced, but that's going to last longer. It's going to give me some durability. The other thing I think we're seeing is this shift towards private label products. Now, once again, private label, supermarket branded products, generic products, We're always considered the cheaper alternative. But shoppers know that supermarkets have invested millions and millions of dollars in improving the quality. Now more than one in three products bought in a supermarket is a private label, own branded product. That's certainly come a long way over the last 25 years.
00:10:06
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think there's definitely the case that going back a few years, the people who are buying those own brands and things like that and the lower end were those really struggling, the lower socioeconomic groups, but it's cutting into, you know, typical families, even two-income families, are now having to really make some cost savings.
00:10:27
Speaker 6: Yeah, it is.
00:10:27
Speaker 4: Like, I mean, obviously that Aussie dollar lesson strikes as far as it used to. You know, we've just had another interest rate hike again. So if you're a mortgaged listener, then obviously you're going, I need to find some more cash to service that mortgage. There's potentially another one coming in the first week of November, around about, you know, the Tuesday first week of November. We'll see another interest rate hike again. There's obviously pressure on rents as well. And of course, you've got the fuel crisis as well at the same time. I know I put about $ 2. 80 a litre in my car only two days ago. And putting $ 2. 80 a litre, I'm sure only a couple of years ago, I was putting $ 1. 85 a litre in my car. So it's a significant extra cost to families.
00:11:07
Speaker 2: There's no doubt. Bower's a shock at the moment. Twice I've filled up in the last couple of weeks and it's ticked
over $ 100. And I thought, I can't remember if ever I've paid over $ 100 to fill the tank. But it's a common occurrence now.
00:11:21
Speaker 4: Yeah, unfortunately so. And some of these are the costs that we just cannot avoid. So we can't avoid not paying our electricity bill or our gas or water bill. Our insurance bills, those tend to go up. It's interesting. I always get my insurance premium and I go, it's gone up again. And yet I've not put any claims in. Fuel, I can't avoid not putting fuel in my car. Groceries, I cannot avoid putting groceries on the tables. So, you know, when it comes to these costs that we cannot avoid, shoppers really looking at third parties, marketplaces, online discounters and discount retailers just to make ends meet.
00:11:53
Speaker 2: So it looks like discount stores and Leica are thriving. What's happening with middle tier retailers? Are they, you know, on the way out?
00:12:01
Speaker 4: Yeah, listen, it's obviously a very, very tough market. And we've seen even this year that the likes of Linkraft, so, you know, Manchester Haberdashery, Fabrics, Craft, They're closing their physical stores. At the beginning of this year, we had Mosaic Brands, the likes of Katie's, Miller's, 90B, Rockman's, all closing as well. Jean's West obviously closed late last year. Unfortunately, if you're stuck in the middle, it's a challenge because it's those middle market consumers that are mortgaged, that are paying rent, that are struggling with the cost of living crisis. And they're now shifting down to the likes of discounters and online fashion chains.
00:12:39
Speaker 2: Now, Gary, when the economy finally improves, and surely it will at some stage, do you think these frugal habits that we have at the moment are going to stick around?
00:12:47
Speaker 7: I think so.
00:12:47
Speaker 4: And, you know, habits form. And once we've experienced shopping at a particular retailer, whether that's a discounter, and we've had a good experience in the product or the service delivers us real value, we tend to stick to that. And that means we end up with a little bit more extra cash in our bank, and then we can start to splurge on things like holidays and taking the kids.
00:13:08
Speaker 2: Away and things Ah, memories. That'd be nice. Good on you, Gary. Always great to chat. Thanks for your time today. Professor Gary Mortimer, QUT Business School. Have your shopping habits changed? Are you buying home brands and the like now where before you didn't? Are you shopping at places that you'd never shopped before because you know you can get a bargain? Has your loyalty to, say, a particular department store or a supermarket where you always went to the same supermarket year in, year out, Now you're thinking, no, I'm going to chase a bargain. And if one of the other outlets is going to sell it cheaper to me, I'll go around. So do you shop around? Has brand loyalty changed for you? Let's know your thoughts. 8223 0000 is the number. Back shortly. At 26 minutes past nine, your calls in a moment on 8223 0000. Well, should we all pay for public EV charges? John says charging stations. If the taxpayer puts money into establishing the stations, the taxpayer should get a return on its investment. We should not be making private companies rich. Loan the money to them, make them pay it back. John, I think that's a sensational idea. I agree entirely. Now, if the costs are involved because everybody will benefit, like if everybody drove an EV and they charged everyone a dollar a year for five years to set up these charging stations, maybe.
00:14:33
Speaker 8: Maybe.
00:14:34
Speaker 2: But the fact is that still only about 30% of vehicles, and it's growing rapidly, I know, but still only about 30% of vehicles are EVs. Why should everybody be paying for the setting up of charging stations? I think you make a good point. Good morning, Graeme. In regards to staying loyal to your shopping habits, for example, I was with Foxtel for nearly 25 years, and in recent months, sadly, I've cancelled my Foxtel subscription and gone to Netflix. It's not the same, but affordable point of view. You can't compare the two. Have a wonderful day. Good on you, Will. Thank you very much for that. Yeah, sometimes you can try these companies on. And I did with Foxtel once. I rang up and said, that's it. I'm going. And they said, look, we'll put you on to another department. And I got a really good deal. And I thought, this is good. And after 12 months, same thing happened. I thought I was paying a bit much. I'll try the same trick. And I said, look, I'm going to have to change. So I'm going to cancel my Foxtel subscription. And they said, OK, sign on the dotted line. So I got away with it once, but not a second time. Jim, good morning.
00:15:37
Speaker 9: Good morning, Graeme.
00:15:38
Speaker 10: How are you going?
00:15:38
Speaker 2: Good, thanks.
00:15:40
Speaker 10: I agree with John too, mate. If we're going to pay for it, let it all go back into the government coffers and for them to waste on something else.
00:15:47
Speaker 2: Yeah, I agree entirely.
00:15:50
Speaker 10: Now, I'm ringing about that $ 100 million, Graeme. I wouldn't really care about it because I live in South Australia and I've got a little lad that calls me dad, so I'm a millionaire at any rate, Graeme.
00:15:59
Speaker 11: Oh, yeah.
00:16:00
Speaker 2: Jim, that is a wonderful story. That is beautiful. You've won the lottery of life.
00:16:06
Speaker 12: That's it.
00:16:07
Speaker 10: I live in a lovely little place. I've got a girl that walks beside me who thinks I'm a lot better than I am, and I've got a lad who's 36 who calls me Dad.
00:16:16
Speaker 4: I'm a millionaire.
00:16:18
Speaker 2: Jim, you brought a tear to my eye.
00:16:20
Speaker 10: Well, you know what, Graeme? I sent you a text yesterday afternoon. My father and my uncle, we had a shack in Port Hughes, and my dad liked the pub, so... Because he grabbed me and my cousin.
00:16:30
Speaker 13: And the uncle.
00:16:31
Speaker 10: There used to be my mother and my uncle's wife were the sisters. And we'd go to Kadena, and they'd give us a couple of dollars to go to the fun parlor and play pinball. Any father that takes their lad to look at airplanes and play pinball is a Bonza father, Graeme.
00:16:44
Speaker 2: Beautiful, Jim. I love your outlook on life, and I think you brought a smile to a lot of people's faces.
00:16:48
Speaker 10: Now, what I want to say about that money, Graeme.
00:16:50
Speaker 14: Oh, yeah.
00:16:52
Speaker 10: I'd upgrade Red Hill Oval, and I'd have the West Coast team, one of the teams play, one of the Sydney teams. First game of opening round, I'd have the Indian Pacific Park there, all on the footage, so people can get the train from the west. And the last game of opening round, I'd have the other West Coast team play the other New South Wales team and have the return trip of the Indian Pacific. So I'd throw $ 50 million or $ 80 million, whatever it costs, give everyone a bag of chips, and then I'd just live off the merch for a while, Graeme.
00:17:22
Speaker 2: Jim, I love your thinking. Outside the square. So that's how you'd spend at least part of your $ 50 million or $ 100 million.
00:17:28
Speaker 10: Oh, was that? I was at the Oval yesterday and a train went by and I snapped a picture and I sent it to Timmy and Rowey. So I'll text it to you and you can see it's the freight train. It's not the Indian Pacific, but imagine it with the Indian Pacific in a silver glory sitting there. Slim Dusty singing the Indian Pacific. Well, he's gone, but we can have Slim Dusty singing the Indian Pacific and change a few of the lyrics to mention the West Coast teams.
00:17:47
Speaker 2: Yeah, maybe get John Williamson to sing True Blue or something like that.
00:17:51
Speaker 10: Good thinking, Graeme.
00:17:53
Speaker 2: I love your thinking, Jim, and thanks so much for your call.
00:17:56
Speaker 13: Thank you, Graeme.
00:17:57
Speaker 2: May you win part of the lottery. as long as I win some too. What would you do with $ 100 million? Does it worry you? Does it scare you if you won that much? Or would you say, I know what I'm going to do? Let's know your thoughts. 8223 0000. Back shortly.
00:18:14
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
00:18:24
Speaker 2: 27 minutes to 10 this Tuesday morning. Hope we find you well. Sonia sent in a picture of Red Hill Oval, as we heard from Jim. If he won $ 100 million regarding Gather Round, he would stage a Gather Round game there, a team from the West and a team from the East at Red Hill Oval, and the Indian Pacific would be parked nearby, and he reckons that would be a good thing. So we have a picture of Red Hill Oval. What a thought. I love people thinking, outside the square. From the text line, 30% electric vehicles equals 30% of vehicles not paying for the upkeep of the road network. Who's going to pay for the roads when it's 70% EVs? EVs need to start contributing. And that is dead right. I'm wondering how long the government is going to leave it because there should be a user pays tax. And for a lot of reasons, EVs cause a lot of damage to the road. They are heavier than your traditional vehicles, which causes more damage, of course. And yet they're not contributing. They don't pay the fuel excise, which is what, 53.7 cents per litre? When you think you fill up every litre you're paying, 53.7 cents to the government. It was once supposed to go to maintaining our roads. Now it goes to general revenue, and part of that is siphoned off. off or apportioned to the roads. But if you look at the condition of our roads, you wonder just how much is being spent on them. So the more EV vehicles on the road, the longer it takes to start charging them as the user pays, the worse our roads will probably get. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Well, cash-strapped small business owners are turning to short-term loans with personal guarantees as a temporary lifeline to cover wages, supplies, tax bills, and other costs. But if they default, well, there could be big problems. Joining us now is Dr. Susan Stone, Credit Union SA Economics Chair, Adelaide University. Doctor, good morning to you. Thanks for your time today.
00:20:29
Speaker 15: Good morning, Graeme.
00:20:30
Speaker 16: Nice to be here.
00:20:31
Speaker 2: So, obviously, economic factors are driving small business to take this action.
00:20:37
Speaker 7: That's correct.
00:20:39
Speaker 15: There have been a number of either expected or unexpected cost increases that we've seen. We've experienced them as households, and the same thing is happening to businesses in terms of energy costs, changing regulation, uncertainty in terms of getting the goods that you need. Things take longer. That's more expensive. So all of these things are really... hitting businesses and creating cash flow issues that they need to cover.
00:21:11
Speaker 2: So if small businesses take out short-term loans with personal guarantees, what sort of pressure does that place on the small business owner?
00:21:19
Speaker 15: Well, because it depends upon what kind of loan they've taken out. They have to be very careful because some loans You can also make personal guarantees. The reason that these loans are generally easier to get is because they aren't required to kind of do the same due diligence as a bank. So they'll just say, I'm sure we'll lend you the money for your business, but if you don't pay it back, you're also putting your house on the line or other personal assets that you may have. And so that's where things can get tricky because If the business owner then fails to make the required repayments, they have these personal assets in addition to whatever business assets may be acquired by the lender.
00:22:12
Speaker 2: Is there another way that small business can get money without a personal guarantee?
00:22:18
Speaker 15: It really depends.
00:22:21
Speaker 17: Some
businesses.
00:22:23
Speaker 15: anybody who's going to lend you money, whether it's in a private source, a non-bank source, or a bank, they're going to look at what they think is your ability to repay. And obviously, the more they're confident in your ability to repay, the easier it is for you to negotiate a loan and the more favorable terms you can negotiate. For those businesses who really are on the edge. Um, they're going to have a hard time convincing anybody to lend them money unless they put up some, some guarantees. And that often goes into the realm of personal assets. And then this is basically an individual decision on whether they believe that they can repay that and it's worth putting their personal assets on the line or not.
00:23:12
Speaker 2: And I guess this is highlighted the issue that, uh, well, the ATO suspending, um, being able to pay by credit card, that's held in suspense for, well, the government said for 12 months. But you can see that that's sent shockwaves through small business.
00:23:27
Speaker 7: Right.
00:23:28
Speaker 15: And as you guys and others have reported, I think the government was a bit surprised by that because there is this real cash flow crunch for many businesses now with the changes in the way super gets paid, with the increasing energy costs. many businesses are really struggling with making their cash, you know, make ends meet, if you will. And so they really rely on whatever small means they can to kind of plan and make their cash flow go as far as it can. And so this was obviously a big issue. And I can imagine that in another country, economic period when things weren't so volatile or unpredictable for small business, that change with the ATO may not have been.
00:24:24
Speaker 6: Such a big deal.
00:24:25
Speaker 15: But because they're already getting a lot of pressure from other sources, that was kind of like the straw that broke the camel's back.
00:24:34
Speaker 2: Do you think that the decision by the RBA has taken people, including the government, by surprise?
00:24:40
Speaker 15: To raise, oh, to change the, no, this was, I don't, I think that it's, they were discussing this for a long time. The RBA did kind of put out there that they were going to make these changes. They did, you know, institute what they were going to be. There was a lot of coverage about it from the consumer perspective. Maybe there wasn't as much cover from the business perspective, but they had come out and said this for a while now.
00:25:11
Speaker 2: What advice would you have for small business who are really feeling the pressure at the moment, thinking, unless I take out some sort of short-term loan, I'm going to go over the brink? What advice would you have for them?
00:25:22
Speaker 15: I think that there's nothing wrong with the business getting these short-term loans. They're flexible. They can give a much-needed cash injection. If you're If you're a business, you know that it's just this month you need to get through and then you're going to get a contract in or you're going to get some more cash flow in. So it really is just to get you over that hump. These short-term lending, non-backlending things can prove a real lifeline for some businesses. But businesses need to be sure that they're able to repay it because the interest rates tend to be much higher because these loans, as I said, are riskier. especially if there's any, and they need to be really clear about what the conditions are under which they're borrowing. And so that if there are personal guarantees, exactly what those personal guarantees imply and what exactly are they putting up for collateral so that if the worst happens and they find themselves in a position where they can't repay, they really have a full understanding of what the.
00:26:29
Speaker 4: True costs are.
00:26:30
Speaker 15: They really do need to look at the fine print Sometimes businesses, it's a real rush, and they kind of just think, oh, God, I'll just get this money now, and maybe they don't look into it as much as they should.
00:26:42
Speaker 2: Great advice. Thanks for your time today.
00:26:43
Speaker 3: Dr.
00:26:44
Speaker 2: Susan Stone, Credit Union SA Economics Chair at Adelaide University. Advice for small business. On the text line, Rick says, Hi, Gigi. I wonder if Albo used the same modeling company that produced $ 275 cheaper energy costs. Tell us after October 1st. coffee prices would decrease. We know how both of those promises have ended. This lot couldn't run a chook raffle. Look, Rick, I agree entirely. I don't quite know how the government, the advice to the Prime Minister, and what's he got, 59 advisors and a treasurer and a whole department, how they thought that removing the surcharge on credit cards would reduce the price of a cup of coffee. Now, I went and bought a loaf of bread at West Lakes the other day at a the shop that sells bread, and often pay by card. And there's been a surcharge of about 10 cents. Now that surcharge is removed. They've just added to the price, and that price has gone up by 15 cents. And I know people who buy coffee say at certain places they're paying extra from what they paid before. So not only are they not getting a decrease in the price of coffee and items, the price has gone up. What sort of advice has the government been getting? I don't quite know. 8223 0000. Graham, we, the common people, are already paying road tax for EVs, subsidised sales. Now they want us to pay for this. When are EV drivers putting their hands in their pockets? Good question. 8223 0000. Back with your call shortly. 13 to 10, 5AA.
00:28:27
Speaker 1: What's happening on the stock market? The All Ords is up one. ASX down.
00:28:37
Speaker 10: Three.
00:28:37
Speaker 2: Dow Jones up by 195. The NASDAQ down 120. Brent crude, pretty stable on 106.65 US dollars a barrel. West Texas crude oil, 93.35. Gold is currently US $ 4, 170 an ounce, the Aussie dollar steady on 69 US cents. 8223
0000 is my number. Love to hear from you on the subject we've been talking about or something that takes your fancy. While Australia's health system is struggling to cope with the growing number of elderly patients arriving in emergency departments, with ailing seniors left waiting in hospital corridors, left in chairs instead of beds, That's a report by the Australian College of Emergency Medicine. Joining us now is SA Deputy Chair, Dr Richard Goldsmith. Doctor, good morning. Thanks for your time today.
00:29:30
Speaker 18: Yeah, good morning, Graeme.
00:29:31
Speaker 11: Thanks for having me.
00:29:32
Speaker 2: Yeah, it's a grave situation. Just how dire is it?
00:29:36
Speaker 18: Look, it is dire. You know, what this report highlights is that we can see that older Australians are coming to our emergency department more unwell and in greater numbers and having to wait longer with a 20% increase since 2018-19. And, you know, the system is just not built to... manage that at the moment and we need change.
00:30:01
Speaker 2: And it's only going to get worse, isn't it? Because we're getting more and more people pushing into this older age, you know, 70 and above.
00:30:07
Speaker 18: That's correct. And sort of the latest estimates show that by 2050, there will be an over 400% increase in patients over the age of 85 arriving to our emergency department.
00:30:22
Speaker 2: What impact is the hospital bed shortage delaying admissions having on older patients?
00:30:28
Speaker 18: So we know that longer waits in emergency departments are linked to sort of avoidable harm for older patients. You know, the environment in an emergency department is not designed for long-term care. And so there is a genuine health impact on these patients arriving.
00:30:48
Speaker 19: And at the moment, you know, we.
00:30:49
Speaker 18: Have over 500 older Australians currently occupying inpatient beds across South Australia awaiting treatment. movement to an aged care facility, which is compounding the problem.
00:31:02
Speaker 2: What does the Australian College of Emergency Medicine see needing to happen and happen soon?
00:31:09
Speaker 18: So, look, we know where the bottleneck is. You know, older patients arriving to the ED, they get stuck twice. They get stuck in the emergency department waiting for an inpatient bed, i.e. they get stuck waiting to move to the ward. And we know that they're getting stuck once they're in hospital waiting to leave to an appropriate care facility. You know, the ask is that we need to fund alternatives.
00:31:31
Speaker 19: To hospital care.
00:31:32
Speaker 18: We've got, you know, services like hospital in the home, which just need to be brought up to scale to really help manage this and provide alternative pathways for these patients that can avoid hospital altogether. We need substantially more aged care beds. You know, nationally, we're looking to be, should be building by 2028 around 10,000 aged care beds a year. In the last
financial year, we've built 800. So we're way behind where we need to be in that space.
00:31:58
Speaker 2: I mean, that's a terrifying fact. I mean, we had Health Minister Mark Butler in this year and he said exactly that. And I thought, you know, surely those figures can't be right. And I think the figure was we needed 10,500 new aged care beds every year and we're building less than 1,000. That's correct.
00:32:15
Speaker 18: I mean, we basically need a new aged care home.
00:32:17
Speaker 19: Built every three days.
00:32:19
Speaker 2: And that is not going to happen?
00:32:21
Speaker 6: No.
00:32:22
Speaker 2: I mean.
00:32:23
Speaker 18: You know, the federal government controls the purse strings in that space, and so they're the ones that really need to be stepping up to help meet that need.
00:32:33
Speaker 2: So if the government is reticent to do that, is there any interim measure? Is it, you know, money is important, obviously, but better administration, better use of the resources we have?
00:32:43
Speaker 7: Yes.
00:32:44
Speaker 18: I mean, money is important. Safety is more important. And, I mean, you know, avoidable hospitalisations cost our nation about $ 7. 7 billion a year. So there are substantial savings can be made if we create alternative pathways for those patients who don't need to be, you know, if we can, I guess, come up with a pathway. And those pathways exist. There are multiple services in other states and within South Australia trying to prevent older Australians from having to come through the.
00:33:12
Speaker 19: Hospital system at all.
00:33:14
Speaker 18: And we just need those services, you know, brought up to scale to meet the need. you would fix about a billion dollars a year if you could just fix exit block getting those patients out of hospital beds. The downstream impact on the overall health system would be enormous.
00:33:30
Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean, when you say it like that, it seems like the obvious line of action to take. So why isn't it happening?
00:33:38
Speaker 18: Yeah, look, that's a good question. You know, The Australasian College of Emergency Medicine is highlighting what we think needs to happen, and it's really up to the government to figure out the how.
00:33:51
Speaker 2: Yeah. Wish we could flick a switch and get the right answers or get the right money. Absolutely.
00:33:58
Speaker 1: Yeah.
00:33:58
Speaker 2: Thanks so much for your time today, and thanks for highlighting the problem. That's Dr. Richard Goldsmith, SA Deputy Chair of the Australian College of Emergency Medicine, highlighting a problem we're all too aware of, and governments have been aware of this coming. because the baby boomers made up the biggest section of the population all the way through, right back from the late 40s. We knew it was coming. This tsunami of older people was always going to happen. And successive governments have turned their back on it and said, you know, this is not our problem. This is a problem for future governments. Well, it is a problem facing this current government and more needs to be done about it. I mean, and as I said, when we had Health Minister Mark Butler in the studio yesterday, saying we had to build and have a new aged care bed every three days, 10,500 new aged care beds every year. And in the last year, the last year, the past 12 months, just 800 beds were created. 800. We need 10,500 a year. So just 8% of the estimated need. And the government is, you know, I know the state government is doing what it can regarding aged care. And I'll, you know, I'll give them credit for that. but it's a federal government issue. And of course, when there are no aged care beds, where do these aged care people who need somewhere to live, somewhere to sleep, where do they end up? In public hospitals. And that should not be the case. And that exacerbates the problem we already have there. I'd like to know your thoughts. 8223 0000. It is a problem that is not going away, but the government doesn't give it the more than lip service, I'm afraid to say. Um, Andrew says, did you hear Albo's reply in Question Time yesterday about the harm to businesses from cancelling the credit card fee? He pushed back saying the rate of businesses closing their doors wasn't as much as the previous government in COVID times. He's a disgrace, says Andrew. I am sick and tired of governments saying what happened with the last government, you know. That's like my red light analogy yesterday. You drive through a red light, get pulled over by the cops and you say, oh yeah, but three other cars went through the red light too. You've, you've, committed an offence, you've done the wrong thing and successive governments keep doing the wrong thing. Julie, good morning.
00:36:15
Speaker 8: Yeah, good morning, Graeme. I've rung you in the past about the aged care issue and I had been nursing my mother for six years. She passed a couple of months ago and so I'm now out of it. But the reality is Going forward, I will be in that bracket and we need to be thinking outside of the square about how we do this. You know, I spoke to Butler and he quoted those statistics about aged care facilities being needed to build. Well, that's not sustainable. The reality is our generation want to stay at home and so we need to be looking at that space where possible, either empowering family to financially help them look after people at home Or things like going forward, I would be more than happy to have a CTV camera in my living spaces at home and an agency monitor my care. You know, these are the sort of things going forward we need to think about staying in our own home and having support services. You know, there's Apple Watches that can protect you from falls. There's so much technology now that can help us. shoving us in a nursing home is not going to be the best practice going forward, particularly for my generation going forward.
00:37:29
Speaker 2: Yeah, no, you make some
good points, Julie, and thanks for making them and commiserations on the passing of your mother. Let's move on out to Grenwith. Dave, good morning, Dave.
00:37:40
Speaker 13: Yeah, g'day, Graeme.
00:37:41
Speaker 11: How are you?
00:37:41
Speaker 2: Good, thanks.
00:37:43
Speaker 13: Really some good points there, I reckon, Julie.
00:37:45
Speaker 7: Yeah.
00:37:47
Speaker 13: I reckon... And she's right, you know, we've got to think about it differently because the federal government couldn't run a trip raffle. And multiple governments can't. They just can't. I reckon, I'm a simple person, I reckon I could go in to the federal government's accounts, budgets, and I reckon I could find $ 100 million worth of savings, I'd find $ 1 billion worth of savings in 24 hours. And you know why? Because you run and manage a household budget, and where you've got fat, you're trimmed. And it's as simple as that. And everyone has to just accept it. Chris Bowen, he would be the first person on the hook. And I reckon I could save multiple, multiple, multiple people's lives through his greed and his stupidity with what he's doing. Pause it. Just pause. That's all they need to do. Pause for, I don't know, two years, three years. They put a ban on snapper fishing. Pause renewables for a bit.
00:38:47
Speaker 2: Yeah, no, you make a good point. I mean, that Fiji conference, 20 million, the whole COP involvement is about $ 160 million that his office is spending.
00:38:58
Speaker 20: Exactly.
00:38:59
Speaker 2: We've got to prioritise. And governments don't seem to think it is necessary. They have their own ideologies and they think their ideologies are more important.
00:39:08
Speaker 13: They do, Graeme, but the frustrating bit is I know that all of these people, they've all got a heart and they all go in with the right attitude, right? They all want to save the world. in politics. But what happens to them? How do they get this brainwashed that they can't see the basic needs for a country?
00:39:24
Speaker 4: They just can't.
00:39:25
Speaker 13: It's mind-boggling. Anyway, sorry, but it just does my head in.
00:39:30
Speaker 2: You've said it well, Dave. The thing is, they live in the Canberra bubble. And once they're there, they get all these wonderful perks of office. And I'm not against politicians being well-paid, because it's not a great job. And in private enterprise, you can probably earn more. But they do OK, thank you very much. They get all these perks. They get to fly their family around the nation because they can't be away from their families. Yet if you're a fly-in, fly-out worker or you're having to work in a regional area and your family's left in the city and vice versa, you don't get paid extra for that. But our politicians do. They can regularly fly their families to Canberra to join them, fly them around the country. We're paying for that. Now, that might be fine in economic good times when the money is flowing and we're doing well, but in tough times, it's like when they accept another pay rise and say, oh, well, there's an independent remuneration tribunal. Hands off. We don't touch it. But who appointed the remuneration tribunal in the first place? Wasn't it a government? Wasn't it a parliament that sat down and said, you'll do the job for us? And don't you think they give them the flick the moment they didn't give them the pay rise they wanted? And when was the last time a politician said, look, the nation is doing it tough at the I'm going to set the example. I'm not going to accept a pay rise because it comes out of the public purse and the taxpayers are paying enough. Wouldn't it be nice if, wouldn't it, would that be a sway your vote if a party coming up to the next election said all our members, if we're voted into power, will defer our next pay rise. Whatever it is, we will defer it for 12 months, two years, whatever it happens to be as an act of faith, as a show of faith to the people of Australia who are doing it tough. But our politicians, they seem to think differently. What are your thoughts? Love to hear them. 8223 0000, back after the news. 9 past 10, 5AA, it's Tuesday morning. Let's take a call. Jan, good morning.
00:41:33
Speaker 21: Good morning, Graeme. Thank you for taking my call. I have a way to solve the problem of the people getting into aged care.
00:41:42
Speaker 5: Oh, really?
00:41:43
Speaker 2: Go ahead.
00:41:43
Speaker 21: Yes, I have, Graeme. We're living it. The first thing you have to do is investigate the nursing homes. They are accepting.
00:41:53
Speaker 10: Wealth over health.
00:41:57
Speaker 21: You could empty out half of those nursing homes. People could be home, having care at home, which we have. And then you can put probably another half a dozen into your nursing home who really need nursing. Graham, I keep saying, what is nursing? Nursing is looking after the sick and the elderly.
00:42:23
Speaker 7: Not Mrs.
00:42:23
Speaker 21: Jones, who doesn't want to stay home anymore, but she has a lazy $ 600, 000, so she's in the nursing home. And in the hospital, you've got my husband, waiting for a bed. He's been there in and out since April.
00:42:41
Speaker 14: Well, that must be so frustrating for you, Jan.
00:42:45
Speaker 21: Yeah, it has to be looked into. I couldn't believe it when I heard what was going on. But we were three and a half weeks into a respite into a beautiful home. And then they found out that my husband didn't have a lazy $ 558, 000. So they immediately sent us an email saying that they could no longer offer him a permanent place because they called it respite. They're getting $ 68 a day for respite, but after their respite finishes, which is usually around about four weeks, we put another lot of respite in there. They are making money hand over fist. I'm sorry to be so angry, but it has angered me for so many weeks, and I haven't heard one person mention this wealth over health.
00:43:43
Speaker 2: Jan, thank you so
much. I feel your pain. It would be nice to have an answer, but I think it's the whole system's stuff. There's no question about that. We can't rub it out and start again, but we need some clear-thinking people, put political ideology aside, and work out what is best for the ageing in this country. Your thoughts, 8223 0000. Well, on another issue, should Australia block a US military execution live stream? It really is going to happen. US Defence Secretary Pete Hexeth plans to live stream the fire squad execution of Nadal Malik Hassan, who's the former army major who killed 13 people at Fort Hood in Texas in 2009. Joining us now from Amnesty International, Kinzom Dongdu. Good morning. Thanks for your time today.
00:44:33
Speaker 3: Hi there.
00:44:35
Speaker 7: Hello.
00:44:36
Speaker 2: Yeah, go ahead. What are your thoughts on this military execution being live-streamed?
00:44:42
Speaker 17: The U.S.
00:44:42
Speaker 22: Administration's plan to live-stream a military execution by the Francois, it raises profound human rights concerns. The death penalty is a cruel, inhumane, and degrading punishment, and turning that execution into a public broadcast really adds another level of cruelty and risks normalising state-sanctioned killing. It shows the inherent cruelty of the death penalty and the authorities' utter disregard.
00:45:11
Speaker 23: For the right to life.
00:45:12
Speaker 2: Evidently, the Defence Secretary says it will be seen as a public deterrent, and that's why he wants it done.
00:45:20
Speaker 22: There is no evidence that the death penalty has a unique deterrent effect. In fact.
00:45:29
Speaker 22: And making an execution more visible really does not make it more effective at preventing crime. I know this is one of the central arguments sometimes being used to justify capital punishment, but really the evidence does not establish that it deters crime more effectively than any other punishment.
00:45:49
Speaker 2: So you're totally against capital punishment per se, and obviously the live telecasting of that. Is there any way it can be prevented coming into Australia?
00:45:59
Speaker 22: So I understand there have been concerns being raised by members of parliament about preventing this live streaming from coming to Australia. And yes, of course, the live broadcast does raise serious human rights concerns and social media platforms must take their responsibilities very seriously. However, we must ensure that the focus is remains on the source of this harm, that the U.S. government must commute the death sentence, and the Australian government, being a close partner, should use its diplomatic influence to press Washington to halt the execution altogether. So yeah, we oppose the death penalty in all cases, without exception, regardless of the crime, regardless of the person convicted, or the method of execution. The answer really is now not simply to prevent people from watching an execution, but to end this cruel, inhumane and degrading punishment.
00:46:58
Speaker 2: Kinzom Dongdu, thank you so much for your time today. That's the Campaigns and Advocacy Manager of Amnesty International Australia. What are your thoughts, folks? I mean, it seems a bizarre thing. I think we've all seen and read about, you know, public stonings in the past and people who turn out to see public hangings in Britain and they've made movies about them and the like. But in this day and age, whatever your views on capital punishment, and I think it is a pretty basic and an inhumane thing to do, particularly that execution that didn't happen in the States, where they tried to kill Christa, I can't think of her surname, on two occasions, gave her two lethal injections. Neither of them worked. They realized that she was still alive when they heard her snoring. And then they raced her to the hospital and battled to keep her alive, which sort of defeats the purpose somewhat, doesn't it? Your thoughts, love to hear them, 8223 0000. Sherry says on the text line, surely millions, even billions could be saved if all government travel is economy. And if they want to travel business, they pay the upgrade themselves. Fair point. Fair point. Can't argue with that. Morning in regard to the Emirates flight that had to turn back. How can these sorts of things happen if the planes are checked before takeoff? We've had a few incidents with Malaysia Airlines. We were taxiing out And then all of a sudden there was an issue and huge delays. One incident resulting in having to get on a different plane. I don't understand it. We never fly with Malaysia Airlines anymore. Look, I guess no matter how many checks you do, when you think of the number of flights in the air at any one time and the few airline incidents that happen, it's somewhat of a miracle and a credit to the quality of the workmanship and the checks and so forth and checks and balances. But I guess Every now and again, it goes bad. Jay says we should implement this for Albo and his team. I won't use the word you used. And it comes from Warren Buffett. He says, I can end the US deficit problem in five minutes. Just pass a law that any time there's a deficit of more than 3% of GDP, all members of Congress are ineligible for re-election.
00:49:12
Speaker 11: How about that?
00:49:13
Speaker 2: That's pretty severe, isn't it? Look, should they be paid, as I think public servants should be paid, the upper tier public servant, on performance-based? So at the end of the year, if you have saved money, you've done a great job, you get a bonus and you're paid accordingly. But these automatic bonuses that people get are just quite remarkable. What are your thoughts?
00:49:38
Speaker 11: 8223 0000.
00:49:38
Speaker 2: Elizabeth, you want to speak about that public execution?
00:49:41
Speaker 7: Yeah, I was watching Planet America last night, Graeme, and they said the dude that done the shooting was in a wheelchair. So that's going to look really good on a live
stream or whatever. Someone shooting this guy in a wheelchair.
00:50:01
Speaker 2: Yeah, I take your point, but I.
00:50:04
Speaker 7: I mean, I know what he'd done was disgusting, absolutely horrendous. But, you know, two wrongs don't make a right. So, you know, it just seems so bizarre.
00:50:15
Speaker 2: Yeah, I take your point. It does seem bizarre. But I think a public execution of any kind is bizarre in this day and age.
00:50:21
Speaker 1: Absolutely.
00:50:22
Speaker 7: It should not happen. But I just find it strange that, you know, there's this guy going to be sitting in a wheelchair.
00:50:29
Speaker 2: Wheeled out in a wheelchair and shot.
00:50:31
Speaker 7: And executed.
00:50:32
Speaker 10: So.
00:50:34
Speaker 7: Could you find that out for us?
00:50:35
Speaker 2: Yeah, look, yeah. All right, Elizabeth, we'll see what we can find out. We'll move on. Tony, good morning.
00:50:41
Speaker 20: Good morning, Graeme. Listen, Graeme, two things. What about, let's ask the families. How do they feel? The ones that lost their families and members. They've got a life sentence already.
00:50:55
Speaker 13: Is that correct?
00:50:58
Speaker 2: Yeah, I take your point, but you sort of think that justifies showing an execution live on.
00:51:05
Speaker 20: Just switch your TV off, mate. If you don't like it, he's coming on 12 o'clock Wednesday and they're going to show it. Switch off the TV. Don't watch it.
00:51:12
Speaker 2: Would you watch it?
00:51:14
Speaker 20: No, I wouldn't watch it. But I know, look, the crimes that he committed, well, he deserves that. Look, Zimbali. Look, Chambo Zimbalo, one of those two guys there, they got hanged for, what, one gram of heroin, what it was at the time. I can't remember what it was.
00:51:37
Speaker 2: I do, I do. Yeah, that was drawn out for a long time and they were both executed. Yeah, that was pretty horrific.
00:51:42
Speaker 13: I agree.
00:51:42
Speaker 2: Good on you, Tony. Thanks for your call. Back shortly.
00:51:46
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
00:51:51
Speaker 2: We'll take your calls in just a moment on 8223 0000. A little bit later on, we're going to talk more about the Powerball. What would you do with the dollars if you're the lucky winner? $ 100 million. That is a scary amount. You know, one, two, three million. Yeah, that's a lot of money. But you sort of think, well, buy a new house, pay off that, help the kids out, do a few things. Yeah, I can manage that. Then you get up to sums like $ 100 million. Earth-shattering stuff. From the text line, Andrew says, any screening of an execution is barbaric and takes us back to medieval times. It's also a badge of honour for some perpetrators and their followers. Also, it will be accessible to kids as half the kids in Australia can still access social media due to Albo's failed under-16s media ban. You make some good points there, Andrew. Yes, that media ban isn't working the way the government hoped it would. Screening of an
execution is barbaric. And I take the point about it could be seen as a badge of honour. This person will be a martyr to all terrorists and the like who will be seen as achieving something and pushed on a pedestal because it was all made public. So for whatever reason, I don't think it will be necessarily seen as a deterrent. What are your thoughts? 8223 0000. Matt, good morning.
00:53:12
Speaker 14: Good morning.
00:53:13
Speaker 16: How are you doing?
00:53:13
Speaker 2: Good, thanks.
00:53:15
Speaker 16: Okay. I'd just like to say, yes, I don't. I don't believe that this live execution should be shown anywhere in the world. But if there's any person I believe that should be executed is Martin Bryant.
00:53:34
Speaker 2: After the massacres in Tasmania?
00:53:39
Speaker 16: Exactly. Yes, it poured out of there. I mean, there was more than, what, 30 people shot dead?
00:53:46
Speaker 2: Yeah, there was more than 30.
00:53:50
Speaker 16: Little children would run away and hide behind a tree and he'd go behind the tree and just shoot them. How many hundreds of millions of dollars has it cost the government to keep him in jail all this time?
00:54:08
Speaker 2: Yeah, look, I take your point. I take your point. Mind you, I think capital punishment is brutal. we know that, and maybe that's what somebody who commits a crime as heinous as that deserves, but it is a cold-blooded killing. If, you know, I ask a person, you know, could you do it? If somebody killed somebody, maybe if it was a family member, you wouldn't find it all that difficult, but to carry out... I actually spoke, and this goes back to the last public execution in Australia. It was in Victoria, I believe, in the Maybe 60s? I just can't think who it was at the moment. But I spoke to a journalist who I actually worked with at 3AW, who was one of the witnesses. Now, when they have an execution of a murderer, there have to be witnesses, independent witnesses. And he was selected as one of those. And he said before he saw it, he fully believed that in capital punishment, But he said sitting through it and just seeing the brutal death of somebody, and I think it was by, I'm not sure it was lethal injection or electric chair, but he said it was something that horrified him for the rest of his life. He struggled with it. You can draw your own conclusions from that, but it is pretty horrific. John says, Amnesty International claims there is no evidence that the death penalty is not a deterrent to crime. Please show the research. Perhaps if there were regular public executions, we could do some research. As a retired funeral director, I have no problem in killing murderers. Thank you for that, John.
00:55:52
Speaker 1: Hi, Graham.
00:55:53
Speaker 2: You can't make public servants responsible because they use consultants and contractors to distance themselves from stuff-ups. I hear what you're saying, Gavin, but I think if we made them responsible, if the money that you paid a public servant, and I'm talking about the senior tier public servants here, and said, at the moment, we're not going to pay you $ 700, 000 a year. We'll pay you $ 450, 000 a year. But if you make budget, if you save money for your department, if you make money or create something that is a benefit to the community, there will be for you a bonus. And you might earn up to $ 700, 000, but you come in on a set fee and you work your way up. At the moment, they come in on a huge sum still get bonuses. I mean, people working on the Snowy 2 project earning millions of dollars are getting bonuses for a scheme that is running years and years overdue and billions and billions of dollars over budget. I mean, this is taxpayers' money. If this had to come out of every politician had to apportion some of his pay to some of these schemes and some of these bonuses, I wonder if they'd think differently. What do you think? 8223 0000 is the number. Rob says they can kick and scream until the cars come home, Graham. But if the execution is streamed live, there will be no way of stopping its viewing on the Internet. And that is correct. It is horrific to think it could happen. Hi, Graham. While I agree with the death penalty for heinous crimes, I disagree with the public display of the death penalty. Just don't watch. We all have a free will to switch off. Yeah, Bill, I take your point. But you know what? People are ghouls, you know. When you drive past an accident, we all want to see what's happening. We all crane our necks to see the blood and gore. Horrible fact of life. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. On a brighter note, coming up shortly after news headlines, our resident GP, Dr Emily Kirkpatrick, in the studio. If you have a question for her, you can ring now.
00:57:56
Speaker 10: 8223 0000.
00:57:56
Speaker 2: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings. 28 to 11, 5AA, this Tuesday morning, 13th day of October. That's my great pleasure to welcome to the studio our 5AA resident GP, Dr Emily Kirkpatrick. Doctor, good morning to you.
00:58:21
Speaker 24: Good morning, Graeme, to you and your listeners.
00:58:22
Speaker 2: Are you well?
00:58:23
Speaker 24: I am really well, thankfully. I'm not struck down with a cold or sore throat today and no hay fever, so.
00:58:30
Speaker 2: Yeah, I'm... I mean, you're in the... As a GP, you're in the firing line. Do you think doctors tend to get sicker more often than the average public because you're Hmm.
00:58:39
Speaker 24: Certainly if we have some sick people into our rooms, I think though, since the COVID days, people are much better now about not coming in when they're really unwell or they see the mask in the waiting room and they put a mask on. So in many ways, I feel pretty safe when I go to work. I wash my hands, I wear a mask if I need to. And I feel like it hasn't increased my own personal risk.
00:58:58
Speaker 2: That's funny. Going back to the days that, you know, you're sick, you go to see the doctor. I found it fun. It was, I've
probably set off during the COVID days that You rang up for an appointment and they said, well, if you're sick, you can't come in. And I thought, well, hang on. That's why I'm not coming because I'm sick.
00:59:13
Speaker 16: Exactly.
00:59:13
Speaker 24: Many patients got very frustrated with that. And thankfully now we've still got telehealth available and of course, masks available to wear when you come into the waiting rooms.
00:59:22
Speaker 2: If you've got a symptom that you're not sure of, a family member's got some sniffles and different intriguing things or something you're too embarrassed to ask your own doctor, Dr. Emily is here to answer your question. 8223 0000. You don't mind answering any sort of questions? Absolutely not.
00:59:36
Speaker 24: But just to disclosure, you know, statement here, of course, I'm not your GP, so please always seek independent medical advice.
00:59:42
Speaker 2: Exactly. Before we get to calls, I see Armiforce, which is available from chemists and health food shops, has been recalled. What's that all about?
00:59:52
Speaker 24: Yeah, it's a really interesting recall that's come out at the end of last week, which is essentially the Therapeutic Goods Administration, which is the TGA here in Australia, has put out a medicines recall for what we know to be a particular substance that's found in a number of these immune supplements, such as Armiforce. And some of your listeners may be familiar with Armiforce. You may have a bottle of Armiforce in your cupboard at the moment. And essentially, it has an ingredient in it called andrographis paniculata. And what they've shown over the last couple of years, in fact, is there's increased cases of anaphylaxis and allergic reactions to this particular component in the medication. And there has been some very serious outcomes as a result. And so the TGA has come out now and said, look, we're going to recall and we're not going to allow any new medications with this ingredient to be listed here or be available to purchase here in Australia.
01:00:45
Speaker 2: So this is not a specific batch of Armiforce. It's Armiforce per se, the whole lot.
01:00:49
Speaker 24: It is all tablets, so all Armiforce that contains that particular ingredient, which is the adult version, essentially, of those tablets. And some of your listeners may be aware, a couple of years ago, there was some advice that came out around this risk of allergy. And so when you went to the chemist, they would ask you and say, you know, do you have a history of anaphylaxis or allergy? And if you did, they wouldn't give you the medication or those tablets because it is over-the-counter medication. It's behind the counter at the chemist. But now, of course, this is a recall. So it does mean that you can bring back your tablets. If you have a bottle at home, you can bring it back into the chemist where you bought them from and you can organise then a refund of that medication.
01:01:26
Speaker 2: If you'd like
to have a chat with Dr Emily Kirkpatrick, now is your chance. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Something that's concerning our listeners and it's not going away anytime soon, the private health subsidy for those over 65 is being removed. That's causing a whole lot of consternation.
01:01:44
Speaker 24: There's a lot of talk happening around this, and particularly the risk is that if we make it difficult for our older population, particularly aged over 65, who this impacts, of course we know the risk is that could this group of individuals then be coming over into our public health system? And is this about shifting pressure across the system unnecessarily? And as a doctor, Graeme, our concern is that we know that people have been paying their private health for many, many years. And in fact, they find that, you know, this is the way that they get their orthopedic treatment. It's the way that they get their specialty cardiac care, for instance, in hospitals. So it's very concerning potentially to see very large numbers of people then shifting across into the public health system as a result.
01:02:25
Speaker 2: And we know the strain the public health system is under at the moment. I mean, it is crippling.
01:02:31
Speaker 24: Absolutely. And this creates, I think, this broader, I guess, this murkiness around private health insurance that I see in my patients. And You know, patients and our consumers, our community are thinking, well, why is this happening? You know, I've got my private health. I've been on it for many, many years now. I've been using it. I'm staying out of the public system. I'm getting good care. Why make it harder? And so there's a lot of this sort of talk at the moment about private health insurance. You know, what's the value for me? And of course, I see this in some of my patients thinking, okay, well, is it worth it now? Will I just go back into the public system? And I'm pretty worried about that as a GP and also thinking about how much pressure our system is under currently.
01:03:08
Speaker 2: Yeah, I think we all need to put more pressure on the government to rethink that.
01:03:11
Speaker 24: Absolutely.
01:03:12
Speaker 10: Yeah.
01:03:12
Speaker 2: When it comes to pressure, people feeling the pinch, are you finding people coming for a consultation are probably coming in later than they should have because they're worried about added costs?
01:03:24
Speaker 7: Oh, yes.
01:03:24
Speaker 24: There's certainly a lot of talk around delaying appointments coming in. And we see that people will often walk in and wander into a chemist and have a look around and think, OK, I'm not feeling great, but I don't want to spend money on a GP consult and coming and seeing my GP. And this really comes down to, you know, what are your options available to you around seeing your GP? You know, is there advice lines that you can call and seek free healthcare advice before you then go and see your GP? And then, of course, Graeme, we do have bulk billing options available for people in urgent care, the Medicare urgent care clinics, which are of no cost to patients who can go and see a GP or a nurse within those clinics who is trained in urgent care and at no cost.
01:04:06
Speaker 2: So how do people find out about these urgent care clinics?
01:04:09
Speaker 24: Yeah, so the Medicare urgent care clinics, so there's a listing available online and we have a number around Adelaide and in the regions as well. And what these clinics are designed to do is really for on-day urgent appointments where you can either walk in or you can organise a time to come in on the day. And it's that sort of step down from the emergency department. So you're thinking, okay, I've had a sprain. I've been playing football. I've got a sprain.
01:04:33
Speaker 20: Great.
01:04:33
Speaker 24: Come into one of these clinics. Or I've had a rash for a couple of days. It's not going away. I can't get into my usual GP today. Come into one of those urgent care clinics. And We do try and encourage people to think about that as an alternative to our emergency departments. It's nice and easy. There's access to x-ray and imaging if you need it, and we can provide the treatment for you at the time when you come in. If your listeners are thinking, okay, well, where is this clinic close to me? How can I get there? Is it the right place for me? In fact, people can call up Health Direct, which is our national health directory information service. It's answered by a nurse. It's talking through your symptoms, and in fact, that call service can then direct you into a Medicare urgent care clinic as well.
01:05:15
Speaker 2: Now, you mentioned Health Direct. I think we need to flesh this out a little bit more. I had a look at the website and I was amazed at how comprehensive it was. I mean, it took you in so many directions. So explain Health Direct and the benefits to most of us.
01:05:30
Speaker 24: Yes, so just to declare, I am on the board of Health Direct. It's an appointment I have based on health minister's appointment to that board. It's funded by the jurisdictions and the Commonwealth. So that's, you know, all of the states, territories and the Commonwealth funded as our national source of trusted medical and health care information. And Health Direct has been used for many, many years across the country as the nurse on call line in Victoria, for instance. where you can then call into a 1-800 number. So for your listeners, that's 1-800-022-222. And that number is available then to be able to say, I've got this particular issue. And they work through with you regarding whether you should go and see your usual GP, go to an urgent care clinic, or is it something you can manage yourself at home with nurse advice? And what we're seeing now more and more with these call services, Health Direct, is that people are using the online version more and more. So there is a triage online that you can do, plugging in your symptoms
and working out, okay, who should I call in that situation?
01:06:32
Speaker 2: Okay, let's make a call. John, good morning.
01:06:35
Speaker 25: Morning, how are you going?
01:06:37
Speaker 2: Good, thanks.
01:06:38
Speaker 25: Yeah, when I wake up in the morning, my fingers are numb or like, pins and needles and actually sometimes they really hurt just the ends of my fingers wondered what that was.
01:06:49
Speaker 24: Yeah it's a great question John thanks for calling in today I mean there can be so many reasons why your fingers are feeling not great in the morning And what I would suggest is, you know, having a chat with your GP or if you don't have a GP, using the Health Direct GP Clinic Finder online. And in fact, what we do find often with the fingers being numb is there can be all sorts of reasons. It can be that your body and the way you sleep at night. It can be that you're getting a little bit of a compression or a bit of a pinching happening of your nerve that runs down through your wrist can sometimes cause it. And then finally, we know that there can be different biochemical things. So different levels in your blood that may be showing as to why you're getting numbness in your fingers or your toes or things like that, such as B12, for instance, that we check. We check your cholesterol. We check through all your blood counts as well. So a few different reasons why, John, you can have fingers that numb in the morning. And what I would suggest is just have a bit of a think about how you're sleeping at night. Think of that information. And then when you go and see your GP or have a chat about this a bit more Make sure you can tell them, you know, how you sleep at night, when you first noticed it, and then we can work through that from there. Does that sound okay?
01:07:56
Speaker 26: Yeah, okay.
01:07:57
Speaker 25: Thank you for your time.
01:07:59
Speaker 2: Good night, John. Thanks for your call. 8223 0000 is the number if you have a question for Dr. Emily Kirkpatrick. On the text line, Martin wants to know, I am 57 years of age. What are the signs of shingles?
01:08:12
Speaker 14: Yes.
01:08:13
Speaker 24: So if you're getting shingles, it's quite common to see it. We certainly see that shingles can all of a sudden present often in a time of stress in your life. It can be where it's sort of living dormant in your body. We know it's related to the chickenpox virus. And so what we see with shingles that often you'll start with getting this funny sensation on an area of your body. It may feel a bit tingly. We see it sometimes on the face, on the back, a patch emerging. And then you start to see these little red spots emerge, which are like what we call little vesicles or little Little rays, little spots there. And it's really quite painful shingles. And so it's the sort of thing where you think, okay, this is a bit strange. I've had it for a day now. What is this? It's the sort of thing to go and see your GP because in fact, you can get treatment to reduce the pain, both from the shingles, but also to help you with long-term complications. So some of the long-term issues with shingles are it can be really quite painful over many months. You get this, what we call nerve-type pain or neuropathic pain that happens with shingles. So it always starts a bit funny, and then you can notice these little red spots that come up in the shingles areas.
01:09:14
Speaker 2: How can it be treated? Will it go away eventually of its own accord.
01:09:17
Speaker 8: Or- It does.
01:09:19
Speaker 24: It does go away. But what we try to do really early on with shingles is think about the location of where it is on your body. So I've seen some really nasty shingles over the years, Graham, particularly around the face and the eyes. And you actually have to often get an ophthalmologist or an eye doctor to have a special look into the eye as well sometimes with shingles because it can cause permanent damage. And so you need special eye drops, antiviral eye drops for the eyes, and often some oral antiviral medication as well.
01:09:45
Speaker 2: You say it's connected with chickenpox, and I guess most kids of a certain age, or adults over a certain age, had chickenpox. Can you get shingles if you never had chickenpox?
01:09:57
Speaker 24: The good thing is with shingles, it is related to chickenpox, so you need to have had chickenpox. So it means if you haven't had chickenpox and you've had the chickenpox vaccine, then the chance of you having shingles are very, very low.
01:10:08
Speaker 2: And you can get a vaccine against shingles?
01:10:11
Speaker 24: Yes, absolutely. We do vaccinate for this and it is part of the National Immunisation Program as a free vaccine available that you can have a shingles, the Shingrex vaccine.
01:10:22
Speaker 2: Is there a recommended age that you should have it?
01:10:24
Speaker 24: Yeah, generally I start talking about from the age of 65 with my patients and then we have a further conversation at 75 as well. There has been a change recently in the vaccine type that is used for shingles. And so if you've had one dose and you're thinking, okay, do I need another dose? Good idea to have a chat with your GP so we can check what previous shingles vaccine you've had.
01:10:44
Speaker 2: I've heard some people have had shingles and it's been very mild and doesn't bother them. And others have been in absolute agony.
01:10:50
Speaker 24: It can be so painful, unfortunately. And it's one of those things you think, oh, if I go on to the GP early, it's something, Graeme, that if you leave it for a few days, it's often too late then to treat. So it is something in that first 48 hours, you need to have it treated If you are going to help reduce the pain and it is somewhere on your face, for instance, definitely a GP appointment or an urgent care clinic would be great for that sort of presentation.
01:11:13
Speaker 2: Can you pass it on to someone else?
01:11:15
Speaker 24: No,
it's very safe in terms of transmission if you cover it up. I generally just advise my patients to put a bandage over it. It's generally not a problem. The vesicles, the little red spots are generally contained under a bandage and low risk of transmission.
01:11:29
Speaker 2: Doctor, thanks for coming in today. Always great to chat. Thanks for your time.
01:11:32
Speaker 25: Thank you, Graeme.
01:11:33
Speaker 2: 5AA' s resident GP, Dr Emily Kirkpatrick, who will return same time next week.
01:11:39
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:11:47
Speaker 2: At 11 to 11, your calls in a moment on 8223 0000. But first through from the text line. Graeme, I'm 81 years old and have paid for private health insurance since I started work at 17 years of age. I will not vote Labor at the next election. It's a disgrace for the elderly. who need their cover late in age. Have a lovely day. Jan, hear you loud and clear. Good morning, Graham. When Barlow and Chambers paid the ultimate price, we had a choice to watch it or not. Maybe people need to be reminded when committing heinous crimes as the Thailand family who seek the maximum penalty for Simon Carman. Have a good day, Marie. Thank you for that, Marie. I disagree with you regarding Barlow and Chambers. They did pay the ultimate price, but it wasn't telecast or broadcast. Although I do remember coverage on the news that they were hung in, what was it, Pudu Prison in Kuala Lumpur after being convicted of drug trafficking. After the execution, they were removed from the place of execution. And you could see the feet of one of those executed under a sheet as they were wheeled away. But no, we did not effectively see the execution. Julie, good morning.
01:13:00
Speaker 27: Good morning, Graeme. Nice to see you had the right month today. It's after yesterday.
01:13:06
Speaker 2: And thanks, Julie, for pointing out that I got it wrong. I appreciate that.
01:13:10
Speaker 27: That's my job.
01:13:12
Speaker 5: I'm here to pick.
01:13:13
Speaker 27: Up on your little mistakes.
01:13:15
Speaker 2: You're the enforcer.
01:13:17
Speaker 9: I am.
01:13:17
Speaker 28: No, not at all, Graeme.
01:13:18
Speaker 14: I love listening.
01:13:19
Speaker 4: To your show.
01:13:20
Speaker 2: Well, just make sure you don't make a mistake, Julie, because I'm listening.
01:13:24
Speaker 27: Oh, I'm sure you'll pick me.
01:13:25
Speaker 4: Up if I'm incorrect, Graeme.
01:13:28
Speaker 27: You were talking about the last execution in Australia. I was trying to put it through to the radio to you. It was Ronald Ryan.
01:13:37
Speaker 2: Oh, that's right. Peter Walker and Ronald Ryan. That was back in the late 60s. 1967 he was executed.
01:13:42
Speaker 27: But in 1965 there was an attempted escape at Pentridge and a warden was shot and.
01:13:46
Speaker 14: Killed and.
01:13:57
Speaker 27: Now, there was always some.
01:13:59
Speaker 5: They.
01:14:00
Speaker 27: Weren't too sure whether Lionel Ryan actually did it in the end,
but obviously he was executed. And after that, they stopped.
01:14:10
Speaker 4: Executions.
01:14:11
Speaker 27: That was the final one in Australia because there was a little bit of controversy.
01:14:16
Speaker 28: They really weren't sure if he did it.
01:14:19
Speaker 27: But, yeah, he was the last one. It was in February 1967.
01:14:22
Speaker 1: It was.
01:14:26
Speaker 27: Sorry, I was just going to say, I have a mad fascination for history and it sounds awful, serial killers, and I like any true murder things. I like all the podcasts.
01:14:40
Speaker 2: True crime stuff you love.
01:14:41
Speaker 27: True crime, yeah. I just find it to be, oh, I just love to get into the psyche of some of the perpetrators. I just find it absolutely amazing how people and how people can do such a thing, you know?
01:14:57
Speaker 10: Yeah.
01:14:57
Speaker 2: Well, look, I can remember I was working at 3AW at the time and our deputy news editor at the time, Brian Morley, I don't know if he was seconded, but evidently when there is a public execution, you have to have independent witnesses to make sure it was all carried out fairly and squarely. And he was one of those. And I remember talking to him and he was firmly in favour of, you know, executing murderers and the like. but he said after sitting through and watching a cold-blooded execution, he said he changed his opinion.
01:15:28
Speaker 28: It's a really touchy subject. I have the opinion, if it's 100% absolutely no doubt, like the gentleman said before about Martin Bryant, there's absolutely no doubt that he was responsible for that. And then you have the likes of the Snowtown Killers, Now, here we are having one of them to be released, which we're the first country in the world, I.
01:15:57
Speaker 27: Think, to have a serial killer to be released.
01:16:01
Speaker 7: Yeah.
01:16:02
Speaker 5: Now, I don't agree with that at all.
01:16:05
Speaker 27: I mean, we have a backstory to that. We didn't know... Well, my husband knew some of them through 10-Pin Bowling, and there's a little bit of a backstory to that. But, oh, you know... It was horrendous what the Snowtown killers did. And you put yourself in the shoes of some of the, all of the families involved, they probably have a completely different outlook to it than what you and I would.
01:16:35
Speaker 28: But I don't believe in sitting there.
01:16:38
Speaker 27: And watching it as a public execution.
01:16:40
Speaker 29: I don't agree with that.
01:16:42
Speaker 27: But if it's 100% absolutely no doubt, I really don't have a problem with it.
01:16:48
Speaker 13: Yeah.
01:16:49
Speaker 2: I think a lot of people would agree with you, Julie.
01:16:51
Speaker 5: Yeah, yeah. But, yeah, it's quite an interesting topic.
01:16:56
Speaker 27: When you get into it. People are just... How the mind works, Graham, and, you know, obviously there's a lot in America, and you just wonder how people could commit such horrendous crimes and what a person can do to another person, you know? And, yeah, it just fascinates me. You know, I mean, I know it's probably not a good thing to be fascinated by, and I don't mean it as in I love it, as in I love it.
01:17:26
Speaker 2: It's just … It fascinates you.
01:17:28
Speaker 24: Yeah.
01:17:29
Speaker 2: I can understand that.
01:17:30
Speaker 9: Yeah.
01:17:31
Speaker 27: Yeah, I like true crime. None of the fiction or anything like that. Like I said, I think to me it's more the psyche.
01:17:37
Speaker 5: Of people, because I always liked science and things like that, and.
01:17:43
Speaker 27: You know, delve into that.
01:17:45
Speaker 2: Do you watch … true crime stories on television as well? Do you like sort of murder mysteries and the like?
01:17:51
Speaker 27: Oh, yeah, I do. Yeah, like last night, every Monday night at 8.30, there's always buried in the backyard and snaps and things like that.
01:18:02
Speaker 5: And there's a lot on Monday and Friday night.
01:18:04
Speaker 27: Are the really good nights on TV for that. And it is fascinating, Graham, you know.
01:18:13
Speaker 5: And it's funny, the one that I watch on a Monday night, snaps, Most of them, well, actually all of them that I've come across have been women. The amount of women in America that.
01:18:24
Speaker 27: Are actually responsible for killing partners or lovers or whatever, it's.
01:18:34
Speaker 7: Just amazing.
01:18:35
Speaker 5: And they're all women.
01:18:36
Speaker 27: And I said to my husband, sometimes when I'm watching the football, I'm going to be happy on snap one night.
01:18:41
Speaker 9: You know.
01:18:43
Speaker 27: That's my heading. But no, seriously, if you watch it, Graham, that one in particular, they.
01:18:48
Speaker 5: All seem to be women.
01:18:51
Speaker 2: Interesting observation. Julie, lovely to chat. No doubt we'll do it again in the future. Julie loves her murder mysteries.
01:18:59
Speaker 1: Hi, Graeme.
01:18:59
Speaker 2: I'm absolutely disgusted with this government. I voted Labour all my whole working life. What they've done to this country and the pensioners is outrageous. Maybe they're politicians of Labor to cut back on their wastage spending, such as travel expenses, using the excuse it was a work trip. I'm getting sick and tired of this government. Thank you. Thank you very much for that. Yeah, a lot of people are a bit distressed. Government. Last Australian public execution was at Pentridge Jail, February 3rd, 1967. Ronald Ryan was his name, hanged for the killing of a warden. Thank you for that, Robert. Yes, there are plenty of people out there. Wonderful thing. Working on a show like this, there will always be someone who's got the information for you. All you have to do is give you the time. Barry says, I can still stream videos of Hamas executing, beheading, and raping innocents in Israel. Make it make sense. Pretty horrific, isn't it, Barry? Unfortunately, if enough of that is shown, it sort of dehumanizes it. It makes it to a
point where you become immune to some degree. If you see enough of it, it normalizes it. I think that's the word I'm looking for, and that is scary. David, good morning.
01:20:06
Speaker 12: Good morning. Now, the important thing we have to learn as voters is politicians lie. I believe it was Mr Howard back in the day who suggested that if you took up health insurance prior to the age of 21, and I believe the advertising is you'll be 21 forever. There'll never be yearly markups. Now, I chose to take that advice on board before the age of 21, and I have followed through now for a very long time. And now that I'm nearly at the point where the loadings would appear, I'm going to pay them anyhow. Bottom line is if a politician says something, know that they are lying, obfuscating, or being disgenerous in some way, because if you think you're going to get an advantage of any kind, they will change the rules.
01:20:54
Speaker 2: David, you've summed it up in a nutshell. What can we do? I mean, we've got to have politicians, don't we? Is there a better way?
01:21:03
Speaker 12: Unfortunately, there needs to be a position where they can be held accountable. Your earlier comment to the amount they get paid. Now, we don't want the worst of the worst. They need to be paid reasonably. But people get in there. It's about the money and the glory. We don't need those people. I would take to it with the big prune is we need to get rid of a level of government altogether. From my point of view, hey, let's have local government And the very best of each local government forms the state government, which sends the very best of that group to Fed. So literally, the system builds itself. We need to get rid of layers. We need it to be simpler. And we need to be able to find that politician like, you know, the Greens. And I'll only pick on them because they're a great example in my area here in the hills. During the electoral campaign, you'd go have a coffee anywhere in the hills and there'd be a Greens candidate saying, They're in the coffee shop wanting to tell you about their position and other politicians. Where are they today? You could shake that shingle until you were blue in the face and not find one. They only want us when they want the next four years paycheck. They do not wish to see us or know we exist at any other time.
01:22:21
Speaker 2: David, we might get this call and put it in a time capsule because what you've said is absolutely correct. and I don't think anyone would disagree with you. All the lights have gone out in the studio. That's good. I hope you can still hear us back after the.
01:22:36
Speaker 1: News.
01:22:43
Speaker 2: As we enter the final hour of the show, could Qantas' reputation drop any further? I just heard about this story. Economy passengers on a Qantas flight from Perth to Rome... were allegedly bitten by bedbugs in their seats. The affected aircraft had to be sent back to Australia empty and left the travellers stranded. Those
affected were reportedly provided with antihistamines, but supplies apparently ran out. Following the incident, Qantas cancelled the Boeing 797 Dreamliner's return trip from Rome to Perth, with the aircraft subjected to a deep clean. I should think so. Well, we've heard the movie Snakes on a Plane, but bedbugs on a plane? Oh, Qantas. Do better. Maybe it's too late. What do you think? 8223 0000 is the number to ring. On a much cheerier note, Thursday night, have you bought your ticket yet? Powerball, $ 100 million. The mind boggles just thinking about what you would do with it. $ 100 million. Have you thought about it? Give it a moment's thought. Let it digest. But it comes with a warning if you do win it. Joining us now is Simon Robinson, Senior Financial Advisor for RSM Australia. Simon, good morning to you.
01:24:00
Speaker 19: Good morning, Graeme.
01:24:00
Speaker 18: How are you?
01:24:01
Speaker 2: Good, thanks. Now, you're not trying to be a downer, are you? I mean, we'd all love to win $ 100 million. What's the downside?
01:24:07
Speaker 19: Oh, look, it's just the windfall could make an enormous difference for you. Obviously, right, it's $ 100 million. But it does come with a few pretty critical catches along the way. It's very easy. to spend that money, surprisingly enough. The numbers, it was a US study that I was looking at in putting this article together, but it's 70% of people who win a windfall like this end up bankrupt within five years.
01:24:36
Speaker 2: Hang on, hang on. Run that by me again. So people who win this sort of money, $ 100 million, 70% end up bankrupt within five years?
01:24:46
Speaker 7: Surely not.
01:24:47
Speaker 11: Wow.
01:24:48
Speaker 19: No, that's the study that came through. So it is a phenomenal number. It shocked me, to be honest, as well, because you think $ 100 million, surely you can set yourself up with a wonderful lifestyle, but it is very easy to see that money disappear quickly. If you, bad decisions, helping out people because there will be lots of people who will come to you for help, it can evaporate pretty quickly. So you know, while it was a bit lighthearted, the key thing is a plan that you put in place with this can really create that financial freedom for you long-term. So that is absolutely critical if you're lucky enough to win on Thursday.
01:25:28
Speaker 11: Wow.
01:25:29
Speaker 2: I mean, look, I said earlier that, you know, if you're winning sort of one, two or $ 3 million, wonderful life-changing pay off the house or buy a house or help the kids out, you know, go on a world trip and something like that. So you're but you can streamline it. But when it's $ 100 million, I mean, you know, all bets are off. You feel like you could do absolutely anything.
01:25:50
Speaker 19: You would think so, but if you buy a flash car or a fancy boat, a couple of overseas holidays and take the family, the extended family, friends with you, those costs can add up pretty quickly. And then, you know, do you want to pay off kids' mortgages beyond your own? Do you want to pay off your parents' mortgages? Do you want to buy family a house? you can see how quickly you could essentially drop $ 5, $ 10 million very quickly. And again, that's 10% of $ 100 million if you were to spend $ 10 million on family and friends. But that all starts to eat away at this really big number. So it seems absurd, but people find a way to spend $ 100 million.
01:26:41
Speaker 2: So what advice would you have for people? You know, all right, we'll all assume we've won $ 100 million. What should be the first step we take?
01:26:50
Speaker 19: Keep it quiet initially. Don't go yelling from the rooftops that you've won that kind of money just to protect yourself as best you can because once that news gets out, you will have people looking to get their slice and that might be for very good reasons but there will be people out there who will be looking at this going, well, there's my lotto ticket as well. You know, my friend, my parent, my aunt, your uncle has just won all this money. I'm going to get my share. So keeping it quiet, I think is really important initially until you've set up your plans and structures to make sure this does become your ticket to financial freedom. So once you've collected that, you've got that money in your hot little pocket, then advice, professional advice is really critical because there will be tax implications. Setting up a passive income from that wealth could set you up for the financial freedom that should come with this windfall.
01:27:54
Speaker 10: Yeah.
01:27:54
Speaker 2: I mean, getting that financial advice would just be top of the list because most of us would never even contemplate this sort of money. So all of a sudden having it there, you need someone who knows about large sums of money and where to where to start putting that money, where to invest it, how to set up the rest of your life.
01:28:13
Speaker 19: That's right. And it can be very overwhelming. I'm sure it would be. If whoever happens to win that $ 100 million, seeing that much money in a bank account would be overwhelming. So having someone who understands how to help you achieve those things that are most important, and that might be helping family and friends, It might be setting up a passive income so that you can quit the job so that you can buy the flash car or the boat. But making those decisions fully informed about the initial and ongoing cost, the impact to your wealth, that is going to set you up for success long-term.
01:28:54
Speaker 2: I think for most people, all of a sudden, you've got $ 100 million in your pocket. I'll go out and spend... You react or overreact, do things quickly. It's sounding like what you're saying is, you know, you've got it, settle down, take stock and let things evolve. Don't have a knee-jerk reaction to it.
01:29:12
Speaker 19: Yeah, take a few deep breaths if that happens to you and take your time. So, you know,
like I get questions quite a bit, you know, how do I find the right people to help me with getting this good advice, right? And that can be a process like going for a job. go and have a chat to a few different advisors. You might have a really good accountant or financial advisor in your team already. Great, they can probably help you out. But if this is a whole new experience, go and have conversations with a few different advisors to find one that you are confident saying, well, they've got my best interests at heart. They understand what I'm trying to achieve and they're going to help me put a strategy in place that will work for me, whatever that might be.
01:29:58
Speaker 2: Now, Simon, Lily has called in. She has a question for you. Lily, go ahead.
01:30:03
Speaker 16: Oh, hello, Simon.
01:30:04
Speaker 17: I just wondered if I would be able to contact you on your website and I could actually see you about some... I've got a probate in process and it's going to be released this week and I'm so excited because it's here for the banks to actually finalise everything. I think it's due to their backlogs and I got so frustrated with the delay. I'm disabled, so a little bit of my money from my parents' estate will be going to modifications for my home, housing trust home. But I found out that I don't know who to contact for some accountant. Would you be able to assist me in that area?
01:30:46
Speaker 2: Back to you, Simon. We've gone off subject a bit there, but Simon, you have an answer for Lily?
01:30:52
Speaker 17: No.
01:30:53
Speaker 19: That's okay. Yeah, look, we'll be absolutely happy to have a conversation later today or this week so we can have a chat about your situation and help you get the right people around you to make the most of your situation. So, yeah, more than happy for you to reach out to me. On our website, you'll be able to find me, RSM Australia. So, yeah, please feel free to reach out.
01:31:17
Speaker 2: Now, Simon, before we let you go, are you going to buy a ticket in Thursday night's lotto?
01:31:22
Speaker 19: Look, I think I need to. It's not what I would call a prudent financial plan, relying on Lotto to win. But look, a couple of dollars here or there for the chance to win $ 100 billion. Yeah, I think I'll have a ticket.
01:31:37
Speaker 2: Beautiful. Good on you, Simon. Thanks so much for your time. Senior financial advisor from RSM Australia on the $ 100 million Powerball jackpot. That figure that he quoted, the US statistics show that 70% of those who've won in the realm of $ 100 million have gone bankrupt within five years. I mean, can you believe that? So you've got someone who's just living a normal life, battling along, never ever going to go bankrupt. Then all of a sudden they got $ 100 million and they've got a 70% chance of going bankrupt within five years. Ah, we can dream, can't we? But let's get some advice, financial advice afterwards. 822-300-00 is the number. If you want to comment, give me a call.
01:32:23
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graham Goodings.
01:32:32
Speaker 2: 22 past 11. 5AA to the tunes of the Pushbike song.
01:32:36
Speaker 1: Hi, Graham.
01:32:37
Speaker 2: Do you know what was achieved from the insignificant Bowen Summit? I think he should be made to pay it back, says Philip. Maxine says, Hi, Graham. I think I would still take the chance on going bankrupt if I was to win... $ 100 million. Or we could take the advice of the soccer legend George Best. He said, people say I wasted my money. I say 90% went on women, fast cars and booze. The rest I wasted. Tony, good morning.
01:33:07
Speaker 14: Hi, Graeme. I had a fabulous experience. I was in Melbourne and I attended the Neil Diamond musical.
01:33:16
Speaker 11: Oh, right.
01:33:16
Speaker 2: It's on at the moment.
01:33:18
Speaker 14: Yeah, yeah, it's magnificent. It's a wonderful musical at the Princess Theatre in Spring Street. Yeah, and it was wonderful. They've got a nine-piece backing band with a fabulous brass section, and the actors were sensational. You can be proud of the Australian theatre. It's wonderful. They're wonderful actors, and the guy playing lead was sensational, Graeme.
01:33:45
Speaker 2: Oh, he sounded just like Neil Diamond.
01:33:46
Speaker 7: Did he?
01:33:48
Speaker 14: He had a terrific voice. It was good. And, Graeme, I also want to let you know what I've got you there. I stayed at the Windsor Hotel in Spring Street, and the rooms are beautiful.
01:34:01
Speaker 2: It's a classic old hotel, isn't it? I've never stayed there, but I've walked past it often enough.
01:34:06
Speaker 14: Yeah, and it's close to the trams and the theatres and the restaurants. It's in a prime position.
01:34:14
Speaker 2: Yeah, no doubt about that, Tony. Thanks for sharing your story with us. I mean, the people that knock Melbourne's trams, it's a fabulous way to get around. I remember growing up in Melbourne, you'd go to Sydney or someone from Sydney, oh, Melbourne, you know, trams, how archaic. But they're a wonderful way of getting around. And the extensive tram system in Melbourne is great. Mind you, we had a great tram system here in Adelaide. If you look at the old maps of where the trams went, they went all over the four corners of the city and suburbs. It was a great tram service. We ripped it up, left the Glenelg line. Increase that slightly. Ah, the trams. Do you remember? John says, if you win $ 100 million, what financial advice would you need? Absolutely nothing. Put it in the bank and draw as needed. What a load of rubbish. Obviously, the knuckleheads who lose everything aren't very bright. Yeah, John, I'm afraid that is the case. A lot of people win that money and they think it's a total bottomless pit. You need advice. No question about that. Caesar says, if I win $ 100 million, I don't need a passive income while I'm in the Maldives. On my yacht. Ah, dare to dream. Doesn't sound good. Helen, good morning.
01:35:23
Speaker 24: Oh, hello, Graeme.
01:35:23
Speaker 6: It's Helen from Mill in Victoria up in the Wimmera.
01:35:27
Speaker 2: Beautiful part of the world.
01:35:29
Speaker 14: Absolutely.
01:35:30
Speaker 6: Actually, I'm in Adelaide right now, but I'm heading home tomorrow. And I just wanted to speak. Was it Peter just prior who spoke about the Windsor Hotel?
01:35:39
Speaker 2: Yes.
01:35:40
Speaker 3: No, Tony.
01:35:42
Speaker 10: Tony.
01:35:42
Speaker 6: Well, Tony, I used to work at the Windsor Hotel in the front office area many years ago when you got service, good service. But every time I do treat myself, if I'm on my own, I go down to see a show in Melbourne, which is quite rare now because we always go Adelaide way now. And I always have a night or two at the Windsor.
01:36:05
Speaker 16: I do it.
01:36:06
Speaker 6: And the doorman always says to me, welcome home.
01:36:09
Speaker 14: Isn't that lovely?
01:36:11
Speaker 6: I think they're very nice.
01:36:13
Speaker 2: I've looked through the doors, Helen. I've never stayed there, but it just looks like from another era.
01:36:19
Speaker 6: Graham, there's two people. There's Josephine in Reservations, who's been there well over 40 years now. And Joseph, who is the butler, he used to be the maitre d' in the lounge. And he has been there 45 years and he's still there.
01:36:37
Speaker 2: Brilliant. Isn't that wonderful?
01:36:38
Speaker 6: There you are. But I was there when the Oberoys of New Delhi hotels were in charge then and the Hard Rock Cafe. That was being built at the time when I was there. Remember the Hard Rock Cafe?
01:36:51
Speaker 13: I do, I do. What a terrible place.
01:36:53
Speaker 6: What a place to put it, though. It's a Windsor, but never mind.
01:36:55
Speaker 12: We just went along with it all.
01:36:57
Speaker 2: Wonderful memories. Good on you, Helen. Thanks for.
01:36:59
Speaker 16: Glory days.
01:37:00
Speaker 6: Thanks, Graeme.
01:37:01
Speaker 3: Bye-bye, everyone.
01:37:02
Speaker 2: Safe travels back to nil. Lovely to speak with you. The Windsor Hotel, if you've ever stayed there, tell us what it's like. As I've said, I've walked past, I've looked inside, and it looks like you're stepping into the last century, or maybe the century before the last century, because it is so old and charming and beautiful. And yeah, a classic hotel. Greg says, morning, Graham. I think the public is slowly waking up to the mess our government is making of the country, but I'm afraid it's too late. Greg, I hope you're wrong. And Ben says, can we sue the government for making promises and not keeping them and causing us more financial harm or costing us financially? Like Gary suggested, taking up health insurance before 21, now having to pay the increases. Yeah, that's the thing, isn't it? When we were all inveigled or encouraged to take up private public health Way back when, because it would be there with us right through our years, and now we find the government is reneging on a promise to subsidise private health for those over 65. The thing is, it's going to rebound on the government, rebound on the public health system. We can't have that happening or can't afford to have it happening. Hi, Gigi. Just imagine how many would tune in to watch politicians having to answer questions or they lost their jobs. Ratings winner. Good on you, Brent. Thanks for that. 8223 0000, the number to ring. Scammers, they're out and about. They're coming up with new ways to trick us. Apparently, they're making you call them. How can you spot it? And what do we do about it? We'll find out from Lee Stark shortly.
01:38:33
Speaker 1: Ah, so.
01:38:40
Speaker 2: Much to talk about this morning. Should we be paying for public EV charges? That's the plan or a proposal. that we would all chip in to pay for the public EV charges, even if you don't have an EV vehicle yourself. If you think it's a good idea or not, give us a call. 8223 0000 is the number to ring. Well, my next guest is Lee Stark from Picker.com. Lee, good morning to you.
01:39:01
Speaker 20: Good morning, man.
01:39:02
Speaker 15: How are you going?
01:39:02
Speaker 2: Good, thanks. I believe there's a new twist in scamming with scammers having you call them. How does that work?
01:39:08
Speaker 23: Oh, they're always going to try something, but the approach here is that instead of having them message you and call you immediately after, they're messaging you with something that is clearly a fake, clearly a fraud, and instead what they want you to do is then call them. So the idea is that they'll pretend to be Amazon, they'll pretend to be the NBA and Microsoft, all that sort of fun stuff, and they will send out a message to you. Now, obviously, they've been able to do this for ages, but previously they've been able to hide themselves as Amazon by faking the sender ID. They haven't been able to do that for a few months now. The Australian government made that difficult. But they can still send it out and some phones will report it as unverified or not verified and some will just put the phone number on. And we're not always checking that. And so what's happening is they're sending out these messages with basically a pretend alert, a pretend notice saying that you owe money or that something has been charged to your account, call this number. And the moment you call that number, you have effectively called a scammer. I spoke to Telstra about this, and what Telstra systems and other telco systems normally do is they can prevent some scams from coming in, so them calling you. But the moment you call out, their systems don't really have a way of discerning that. So if you actively call a scammer, it's really difficult for them to kind of put a prevention system in place.
01:40:27
Speaker 13: Right.
01:40:28
Speaker 2: So, I mean, we have to be wary. I mean, they're getting cleverer and cleverer all the time.
01:40:32
Speaker 23: It's a multi-billion dollar industry.
01:40:35
Speaker 2: Yeah, and a growth
industry, unfortunately. So what advice of people out there who don't trust anything, the phone rings, it's a scammer. Text, a scammer. Email, it's a scammer. You've got to be on the alert. What simple steps should we take to make sure we don't get caught up.
01:40:50
Speaker 3: In it all?
01:40:51
Speaker 23: Yeah, so with this type of scam, the fact that the government did roll out that sender ID registration is actually crucial. So Every phone that is out right now, if the information from the sender isn't actually legitimate, they're not registered as part of businesses, it will pop up as either unverified, not verified, or with just the phone number. So now when Amazon messages you or JB Hi-Fi messages you, it will actually be from the company. So ATO is a perfect example of that. The ATO messages you, which it's unlikely to do, but if it did, it would more than likely say ATO on it. For anyone else, it's going to be false. So check the sender ID first. The other thing that scammers do, which is kind of a hoax, is that they'll send messages usually randomly, possibly in the middle of the night, and we treat that as urgency. We see that urgent request and go, oh, maybe it's important to respond to it immediately.
01:41:40
Speaker 20: Don't.
01:41:40
Speaker 23: When you receive a message, first of all, check the sender ID. That's your first inclination to find out whether something is real or not. But second, give yourself a moment to think about it. And if you're concerned, if you get... a message like this and you're not sure what to do, then totally what you should do is actually Google the real company's number online. And the reason why I say that is the phone number a scammer gives you will just be you dialing into them. But they can't affect Google. They can't affect Bing. They can't affect any search engine because a larger company is taking up that presence. So if you're worried about someone pretending to be Amazon or MasterCard or any company like that, find the actual number or look at the back of your credit card or something like that and call that and ask. And that's your... first way of knowing whether that message is real or not. It more than likely isn't. We're not special. We're all getting hundreds of thousands of these things. And any one of us that gets one of these, effectively, if we fall for it, that's banked for the scammers.
01:42:35
Speaker 2: Yeah. Look, I tell this story often, and I think I'm pretty tech savvy, but how I almost got caught getting a call from Amazon saying, look, did you recently buy an iPhone of $ 1, 500 or something like that? And I said, no, I didn't. And they said, well, it It's just shown up here and it's been flagged and we want to ring you to check. And I said, well, no, I certainly haven't. And they said, well, it hasn't shown up in your bank statement yet, but it will. And they said, look, we'll escalate this and we'll put you through. And they put me through to someone else. And I was being led further and further down the path. And I'm thinking, this is legit. I'm really being taken. And then the alarm bell went when they said, look, if we can get access to your computer... you know, we can check to see, you know, where it's gone awry. And that's when the alarm bells went off. But it was incredibly sophisticated that I can see a lot of people would fall for it.
01:43:29
Speaker 23: They very much are. In that sort of instance, one of the first ways of trying to work it out, because everyone is on top of it, everyone has mobile phone access and mobile banking, is that while something like that is happening, pull out your phone or computer if you can, if you're on speakerphone, and log in and simply see whether anything has happened because, as I said, these sorts of scripts are normal. They just target anyone and everyone. This is different from the whole you're in the Windows computer and needs to be accessed because everyone has a card, everyone is just spending money. But while something is happening, if you're on the phone with someone, you're not actively sharing data from your phone. You're just on a voice line. So if you really need to, pull out your phone and check your bank account and say, Well, it's not in my bank account. See what they do there. Because chances are you can simply say, this doesn't seem right. I'm going to call up the bank immediately. If you're ever worried about that, an incoming phone call, all you have to say is, this doesn't seem right. I'm going to hang up and call up the bank. And you can watch them scramble the moment that happens.
01:44:27
Speaker 7: Yeah.
01:44:28
Speaker 2: I mean, this instance that I had, they asked me to download an app so they could get access to my, and the alarm bells really went off then. But I could see, With a good case and a good story, people could be sucked into believing that this was a legitimate case.
01:44:45
Speaker 23: It happens a lot. We do find it does affect older generations more than it does younger generations, but that's the target. The target is people who typically have more money. That being said, younger generations, this affects, but we find from the statistics that younger generations are least likely to actually talk about it, to tell people it happened to them. They'll count it as, oh, a lesson learned and then fall into it again. So Being aware of this, telling your friends that it's happened to you, is actually a really good step because it warns other people that this can happen to them as well. It can happen to anyone, to be honest.
01:45:17
Speaker 2: Are there any sites that you can go to where they can tell you what scams are happening at the moment and what to look out for?
01:45:22
Speaker 23: The best site's actually run by the Australian government. The ScamWatch site is actually one of the best sites for scam tracking, not just because it tells you what's actually happening out there, but it also tells you quickly how much
money is being lost from it. If you've ever been scammed from it, you can also make a report there and that goes into the statistics as well. It's one of the better ones. There is another one by the company that owns Norton. It's a little bit different. Its whole concept is to show you the major scams happening around the world and the major internet activity, but it's more of an interactive demo rather than a really good primer for what's happening. Weirdly enough, the government, or the ACCCs rather, the ACCC Scam Watch Project is one of the best resources we have in this country for the protection of scams.
01:46:07
Speaker 2: Yeah, we need to be vigilant, ever vigilant. I notice on your website, real fake phones can be found with real malware. I mean, this is scary. I mean, you buy a phone, you think it's brand new and clean, but maybe it's not.
01:46:22
Speaker 23: Well, the good news for this sort of thing is that it shouldn't affect most people. So this is a fairly new story. It's so new, I think I only published it this morning. This is a fairly new story that basically suggests from research that there are companies making inexpensive, so budget phones, which is important because phones obviously are more expensive than they've ever been this year, at least in smartphones. And so there are people buying budget phones that come in the guise of Real phones, they're named like an iPhone, but they're clearly an Android, or they're named like a Samsung, but they're actually not made by Samsung. And so they may be inexpensive. You might spend $ 200 or $ 300 on them, which does sound pretty good as far as a phone is concerned. But what's included on them is a bit of software that you can't really tell is there. It'll run ads in the background, which seems kind of harmless. but they can also be used for what's called a botnet. So they can effectively be taken over by external hackers, by scammers, and have your screen read be used as a part of a denial of service attack. So it's effectively, it's an inexpensive phone that looks too good to be true, and in turn is, but in ways you least expect it. And they do exist. Australia doesn't seem to be hit as hard, but they are on Amazon. We were able to find that out there. You can find them locally. It's one of those instances where it's not from any of the major players. So It doesn't matter whether you buy Android or iPhone. You're not going to find this from a telco or a local store. But if you do happen to be looking on places like Amazon or AliExpress or even Timu for a phone because you can get that sort of stuff there, you may want to think twice before buying a phone from them because it may include this technology that can read your screen and take over your device.
01:47:57
Speaker 2: Sounds like, you know, if it looks too good to be true, it probably is too good to be true.
01:48:01
Speaker 23: It's very much in that category, absolutely.
01:48:04
Speaker 2: Lee, great to talk. Thanks for your time today.
01:48:06
Speaker 23: Always happy to help.
01:48:07
Speaker 2: Lee Stark from picker.com.au, tech expert. Any scams? And I think, as Lee mentioned, that if you fall subject or fall to a scam, a lot of people are so embarrassed about it. you know I got caught out by a scammer and you don't let anyone know because you're embarrassed but the point is if you let people know they won't fall for the same trap help people out the more we can talk about the scams and how they operate and how you're almost trapped pass that on and we can combat it Danny good morning Good morning, Graham.
01:48:41
Speaker 9: I was hoping to get on with your guest because I was wondering what his opinion of scam baiting is.
01:48:48
Speaker 2: Oh, tell me. What's scam baiting?
01:48:51
Speaker 9: Scam baiting, basically, there's people mainly in America, England, and I think there's some in Australia as well. Basically, what they do is they're very sophisticated cybersecurity experts with systems of their own, and they basically backhack the scammers. And they've done things like break into their cameras, steal files, return money to people who've been scammed and stuff like that. I was just wondering what your guest's opinion would have been of that sort of thing. And what you did, Graeme, even though you nearly got scammed, you didn't get scammed. But what you did is you wasted that scammer's time. So that was time he couldn't use scamming somebody else.
01:49:33
Speaker 14: So good work.
01:49:35
Speaker 2: Danny, Lee is back on the line. Lee, did you hear what Danny had to say?
01:49:41
Speaker 11: I did.
01:49:42
Speaker 23: So two things there. One is that wasting their time doesn't actually do a whole lot. We'll eventually head to the field that it'll be... It's effectively a business for them as well. So wasting your time... I've heard this one used quite a bit, especially by Australians. Australians love messing with scammers. It doesn't waste their time as much as you believe. It doesn't prevent them from doing it to another simply because it's an industry and they'll just put you down. And any time you engage with a scammer, You kind of get put on a list and they'll just come back to you eventually with the hope that they can get you again later on. So wasting their time, probably less important than hanging up on them or telling them that you're not going to fall for their stuff. That's more important, trying to get you off their list as quickly as possible. Scan dating itself, really interesting process. There's a lot of stuff happening on TikTok and YouTube for this. I'm not against it. There's some really neat technologies that actually allow people to see how scamming works. I think the better part of scam baiting, what it is effectively, is someone who's quite good at security and who understands technology, well, they record the process of trying to be baited by a scam and to double back on them, so to find out where they are to
effectively return money. So in a way, it's kind of like, I guess, a current affairs show or like a Today Tonight example of catching someone out but in the process of international scams. Almost always affects scams in Africa and Middle East. So that's effectively where it goes to. I'm not necessarily against it. I think it's good to actually pull the covers off of scams in general, and scam baiters do a good job of that. But I caution anyone who thinks that they're going to do that themselves. The technology when you do these sorts of scams, when you bait people for them, can get risky. I would suggest to people, I bait myself for scams at times so I can write articles. This is the more extreme version of that. It's really interesting to see it actually play out, but no one who is, if you're not a security expert or not a programmer or someone who's confident in this, you should definitely not try it because some of the scam houses are run by syndicated crime and it's really not the sort of area you want to get yourself into.
01:51:55
Speaker 2: Good advice. Thanks for that, Lee. Thanks for staying on the line. Lee Stark, picker.com.au. John, good morning.
01:52:02
Speaker 11: Oh, great. Three times in about three months. One was I went to a funeral in Grote Street, and I went into the U Park, or the Easy Park. It wasn't very easy. And I had to use the QR code, and I couldn't bloody see properly. The sun was shining on my phone. Anyway, I'll get home and double-check. I've signed up for... Three subscriptions, you know, Deets Jam in Czechoslovakia. Oh, really? Yeah, for $ 59. 95 a month. They're all legitimate.
01:52:30
Speaker 25: Yeah.
01:52:31
Speaker 11: But I just pressed the green button, you know, it was an ad. Anyway, I sorted that out. Then I was looking at something on PayPal, I wanted to check something, and there were two cancelled items for about $ 1, 200 on my PayPal account.
01:52:47
Speaker 6: Yeah.
01:52:48
Speaker 11: Now, after hours of mucking around with PayPal, they said, it's under control, forget it. Anyway, so then the next one, I went and bought a printer and had to download the drivers. And I went, that's not working. It turned out Branch was touching, and my tree was touching the internet line and was stuffing it up. So inadvertently, I rang the number of Epson, and the Epson site on the computer was fake. So I'm talking to Sanjit in Calcutta. And he's got me to download any desk. What's this all about? And he said, look, mate, your computer's riddled with viruses. I hung up and rang Richard Pascoe. And he came around and said, why did you do that? And I said, I didn't know.
01:53:36
Speaker 2: It's so easy to fall for it. Unbelievable. Be warned. Good on you, John. Thanks for sharing that with us. Debbie, what's your story?
01:53:46
Speaker 17: Oh, my goodness, I just have to laugh. Good old Sanjay, he's pulling more than his weight in the scamming world, isn't he?
01:53:53
Speaker 29: Now, you know how when you get
scammed and it's a fake mobile number that calls you because if you call that mobile number back, you get the actual mobile user?
01:54:02
Speaker 7: Yeah.
01:54:03
Speaker 29: So one day my phone rings and it was my number scamming me.
01:54:09
Speaker 2: Wow, how does that work?
01:54:12
Speaker 29: Well, because that number is just a fake number that they use, But oddly enough, they chose to ring me.
01:54:19
Speaker 17: So when I looked at.
01:54:20
Speaker 29: My phone, it said Debbie calling. Debbie calling Debbie.
01:54:24
Speaker 2: So you're calling yourself, theoretically.
01:54:26
Speaker 29: But when I answered, it was a scammer.
01:54:28
Speaker 2: And it wasn't you. No, it wasn't me. Look, they're clever. And obviously, if you see your own number, the warning sign doesn't go up. You think, oh, that's my number. And if you don't think it through, yeah, you answer and you're hooked on the line.
01:54:44
Speaker 1: Yeah.
01:54:45
Speaker 12: What are the odds?
01:54:46
Speaker 2: What are the odds? Good on you, Debbie. Thanks for sharing that with us. And one more on scamming. Peter, good morning.
01:54:52
Speaker 14: Good morning, Graeme.
01:54:53
Speaker 26: Just a quick word of advice that I think might be useful that I do is everyone has to remember when we speak to people we don't know on the phone, especially scammers or people who try to sell you something, they can copy with AI your voice. And it only takes a short 10 seconds, I hear. One word of advice I do might sound silly. What I do is if I answer someone and it's this voice, if it's a pause, I hang up straight away and say anything. Two, if people start talking to me, I immediately find a speaker. I change the voice, my voice.
01:55:26
Speaker 28: Oh, really?
01:55:26
Speaker 1: Yeah.
01:55:26
Speaker 26: Hello, this is a Peter here. How can I help you today? I just change my voice. Just because I just heard that they can, yeah, just can use your voice and ring up loved ones. and sound like you, like they sound like me or you, Graeme, and scam other people. So we've just got to be vigilant in everything we do, unfortunately, these days.
01:55:49
Speaker 2: Yeah, no, good advice. Good on you, Peter. Thanks for that. You do have to be careful. I mean, AI can clone your voice. But I know in the past they've done things like, I've been advised, don't say yes or no when you ask questions deliberately because they'll often lift that. And I don't know if you've ever done it, but you had to fill out a contract online where they ask a question and you have to answer yes or no, something like that. Well, if they've got your voice, a voice imprint, they can put that into a contract as if you've actually said those things. So instead of saying, if, if you're questioning whether it could be a scam or not, don't say yes. Yeah. Okay. Maybe be very vague and evasive, but don't use yes and no. Uh, Andrew says, Graham, you create a family password. Yeah, that's true. If you're not sure you
get one of those calls that dad said, money, I've lost my phone. So I'm ringing on a mate's phone. You call back and say, what's our family password? Yeah, that's good advice. Graham, can you ask your guest, unfortunately he's gone, about scam calls will ring once on a mobile number and mimic Adelaide local numbers starting with 08. What I do is Google the number, A lot of people already have reviews warning they are scams. Good advice, Pat. Yeah, we're all in this together. So if you've got any advice on scams, let's know about it.
01:57:10
Speaker 1: 5AA Mornings with Graeme Goodings.
01:57:16
Speaker 2: News coming up at midday, then after one, it's Leith Forrest, who, hang on, he's not in the studio. Leith, where are you?
01:57:22
Speaker 3: Graeme, I'm never coming back. I'm going to be honest right now.
01:57:27
Speaker 2: We are forever.
01:57:28
Speaker 3: We're letting management know this live on air. We are broadcasting from the back of the Crown Princess, which is just docked here, tended here at Outer Harbour. Graham, Adelaide's turning it on weather-wise, but this ship, we've only been here half an hour or so. It is extraordinary what these people are enjoying. So many people have got off already. They're heading to Harndorf. The Harndorf buses were sold out. People are going around to the Barossa, checking out all that Adelaide has to offer, Cleland, etc., But Graham, Madeline and I, producer Madeline and I may never leave. We are sitting just looking over the pool and the spa area.
01:58:02
Speaker 2: Why do you guys get all the good jobs? I don't know.
01:58:06
Speaker 3: Is it more wasted on anyone who doesn't drink alcohol and food than me though, Graham? we've got the chef joining us. We've got the head of beverage joining us. We've got the sea captain joining us. I want to know how you become a captain. Like, is there a university course for that? How do you go from an.
01:58:21
Speaker 2: Able seaman to a captain? It's a damn big boat to push around.
01:58:25
Speaker 3: Oh, my Lord. Have you ever tried to drive a houseboat? Have you ever tried to reverse one of those in a manor?
01:58:30
Speaker 2: It's hard. I love houseboats, but they don't go all that fast.
01:58:34
Speaker 3: No, but imagine this. It's just superb. And there's a lot of tourists here. You know what it's like, too, where some people get off to enjoy everything that Adelaide and South Australia has to offer, and the others say, no, no, I'm just going to stay on the ship and enjoy everything here. No, we get to broadcast the show from one... Have you cruised before?
01:58:51
Speaker 2: I have cruised, yes. You and lovely Mrs Goodings? I've done a couple of cruises, but never in Adelaide, and I've never been offered... to do my show on a cruise ship. And what time does it head out? I mean, hopefully it's... Yeah.
01:59:03
Speaker 3: No, we've got plenty of time. It's here all night. I think they head out. So it got in first thing this morning, and I believe it heads out first thing tomorrow morning.
01:59:12
Speaker 2: And you and Matty are going to be on board, you reckon?
01:59:16
Speaker 3: Well, yeah, we're just... And Peter's here, our super tech. So as long as he can get us to air, we're more than happy to continue because it sails now from here. and goes towards Western Australia. So Albany, Albany, thank you, is the next stop. And then it makes its way up the coast of Western Australia, up to the top end, around to Queensland, then comes back to Sydney. So, so far they started in Sydney, went to Newcastle, Melbourne. Now, of course, they've come to God's country in Adelaide to see all that SA has to offer.
01:59:44
Speaker 2: So it could be Lee Forest coast to coast.
01:59:47
Speaker 3: Could you imagine? I think there are people, in fact, Megan was telling me here from Princess before, we've got some guests coming on the show today. How many cruises have they done? 3,000 days.
01:59:57
Speaker 2: 3,000 days, Graham, to see this couple. Might as well be living on board.
02:00:02
Speaker 3: If you could afford it, and many times you do the math, it's almost more cost-effective to just live on a cruise ship forever because you've got a doctor on board, you've got food, you've got drinks, so you never have to go shopping again because everything's sorted for you here.
02:00:16
Speaker 2: I've heard people do it. They do their sums and work it out. Are we going to go into a retirement village or cruise for the rest of our life?
02:00:24
Speaker 3: And why would you not? So I should say, just so people don't think this is just a complete junket for Madeline and I, we are here for a very important reason, Graeme.
02:00:32
Speaker 7: Of course you are.
02:00:33
Speaker 3: Because it is the start of the 26-27 summer cruise season. Estimated $ 22 million of economic benefit to the state with people coming in. I've even... Oh, Graeme, you'd love this. I've got the largest head ever, Megan. This may not fit. So the team from Princess have just brought over a bedazzled... jeweled uh uh captain's crown for me to wear graham you you've seen me i've got the world's largest head this may not fit you know at christmas time when you get the bonbon and you get the the little hat in that yeah it all it always splits you have to get the triple x size i've got such a large scone madeline has a uh normal size head so we might have to get her photographed in this but no so 22 plus million dollars worth of economic benefits so we thought today You know, they twisted our arm and said, would you like to come out and hang and be wined and dined and hang out in this beautiful ship for the day? So we said, oh, Graeme, all right.
02:01:26
Speaker 2: If we have to.
02:01:26
Speaker 3: If Graeme doesn't want to, we will do it. So we're here from one o'clock and we cannot wait. It's going to be a lot of fun.
02:01:32
Speaker 2: Good on you, Leith. Enjoy.
02:01:33
Speaker 3: I will fill my pockets with things for you from the ship, Graeme. Anything you want from the buffet, I'll bring it back.
02:01:39
Speaker 7: Beautiful.
02:01:40
Speaker 2: We'll see you tomorrow. Leith Forrest, on board. How good. How lucky. Princess Cruises Crown Princess at Outer Harbour, 3,000 guests. Well, that's it for today, folks, from the studio in Hindmarsh Square. Not quite cruising, but still, we enjoyed it. Thank you so much for your company. We'll do it again tomorrow.