TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:25.000 --> 00:00:48.000
Food, drugs, or ideas, what you consume influences who you become. On the Mind & Matter podcast, we learn together from the best scientists and thinkers alive today about how your mind-body reacts to what you feed it. Before starting Mind & Matter, I spent 10 years in academia doing scientific research. I got a PhD in neuroscience, where I focused on neuroendocrinology and the neurobiology of behavior.
00:00:48.000 --> 00:01:12.000
And before that, I specialized in molecular, developmental, and evolutionary genetics. I use my scientific background to help parse and translate the information that guests share on the podcast. In addition to the podcast, I write long-form written content inspired by the show where I integrate what I've learned across episodes. I also have a free weekly newsletter where I provide you with upcoming guests, share links, and provide commentary on scientific studies and research that I'm reading, and more.
00:01:13.000 --> 00:01:29.000
Visit mindandmatter.substack.com to find all of my content. Thank you for joining me.
00:01:30.000 --> 00:01:30.000
Thanks for having me. I'm
00:01:31.000 --> 00:01:35.000
glad to be here. Can you start off by just telling everyone a little bit about who you are and what you study?
00:01:36.000 --> 00:01:50.000
Yeah, so I'm a professor and chair of the Department of Human Evolutionary Biology at Harvard. I study developmental genetics and how that relates to the evolution of the human body, particularly the human skeleton.
00:01:52.000 --> 00:01:58.000
And so at a basic level, how do you generally go about studying that?
00:01:59.000 --> 00:02:28.000
That's a good question. So we take a very multifaceted approach in my lab. So the idea is we're trying to understand where in the human genome are the genetic changes that generated the unique human body form, particularly our ability to walk on two legs, our ability to throw our big brains. And to do that, we can scan the genomes.
00:02:28.000 --> 00:02:54.000
and try to understand the human genome as it compares directly to, say, the chimpanzee genome, our closest relatives, or the gorilla genome, a more distant relative. But that gives us lots of DNA changes that really don't make any sense. So what we need to do is provide context for them. So what we do is we look at the phenotype, the observable physical traits that we're trying to understand.
00:02:54.000 --> 00:03:26.000
So, for instance, looking at the pelvis between humans and chimpanzees and understanding where in the pelvis are the changes, the anatomical changes that have occurred in human evolution to make us walk on two legs. And so we can use phenotyping data on the pelvis and how it forms and on humans and other primates to get comparative contextual information. And that gives us the phenotyping side. And we have the genetic side, but really what we want to do is link the two.
00:03:26.000 --> 00:03:52.000
So we have to bring in a bunch of
Load full transcript
other types of data. So those data include functional genomics, so tools that we have now to assess what genes What regulatory regions for genes are used in cells during development to sculpt the morphology that we see in the adult. So we bring in functional genomic techniques. We bring in comparative sequence analyzes.
00:03:52.000 --> 00:04:30.000
We do functional experiments in the wet lab where we can modify cells or the mouse model to look at changes and how they affect the phenotype. So to bridge the genotype or the genetic sequences to the phenotype, the observable differences, we bring all these different tools. And one thing I'll say is we believe that when we're developing a hypothesis or a model of how evolution occurred, how the genotype connects to the phenotype, we have to bring in as much different types of data as possible. And if we do this correctly, it only supports the model.
00:04:30.000 --> 00:04:54.000
If we generate data and it does not support the model, well, we don't throw out the data. We actually change our model. We have to think differently about how we approach the question at first and generate new hypotheses. So we're really about trying to understand how you build a model with existing data and new data that you can generate to connect the genetics to the traits that we're interested in in human evolution.
00:04:54.000 --> 00:05:20.000
Yeah. And I think one of the things that you said that's important there is you can't merely look at the DNA and compare the DNA of different creatures and learn much of anything. Like, you know, if we want to understand how humans walked on two legs and how we got there compared to our ape ancestors, we can't just bring up the chimp genome, bring up the human genome, know that they have a different pelvis and a different sort of musculoskeletal anatomy.
00:05:20.000 --> 00:05:42.000
and just look up the answer, we have to know something about how the development of the organism actually happens. How is the pelvis and the legs and the muscles, how are they constructed in a human differently than a chimp? And how do the genes actually change in a way that changes that sculpting and construction process? So you can't just look it up in the raw genomic sequence.
00:05:42.000 --> 00:05:51.000
You need to know more about the animal, its ecology, what was driving the pressure to move a certain way, and then literally how the animal is built in an embryonic sense.
00:05:52.000 --> 00:06:12.000
Yeah, exactly. And so when you look at the human genome and compare it to the chimpanzee genome, there's three billion base pairs, right, that you can find, that you can look and see. And when you actually, and that's in the haploid genome, it's six billion in the diploid genome. And so what you have to do is kind of filter those base pairs.
00:06:12.000 --> 00:06:50.000
You have to figure out a way to narrow down to the more important ones. And that's where these tools like functional genomics come in. So you can take, developing cells of an embryo, a human embryo or a mouse embryo, and you can identify in those cells, if they're from parts of the pelvis, what genes are turned on and what regulatory sequences, switches, are used. And then when you have the switches and the genes that are turned on to sculpt the pelvis, you can then narrow in on those genes and those regulatory elements and look, where are the changes between humans and chimpanzees in those elements?
00:06:50.000 --> 00:06:59.000
and you can further refine and refine as you get closer to where you think the targets are for evolution. And that's a more involved part, but I'm sure we'll get into that today.
00:06:59.000 --> 00:07:11.000
Yeah. And so, you know, a lot of people are interested in human evolution, obviously, because we're humans. And there's a lot that makes humans unique, or at least different in important ways. There's a number of them we could talk about.
00:07:11.000 --> 00:07:27.000
We'll probably have time to talk about some of them. One of them, obviously, is our big heads, which in case our big brains, maybe we'll get to that. But another one is our musculoskeletal system. And there's two really interesting things about our musculoskeletal system.
00:07:27.000 --> 00:07:53.000
that I think we'll talk about today. One is the fact that we walk upright, we are bipedal, and that's a key differentiator for our lineage compared to most other animals that are still alive today and not extinct. And then the other one is sort of our limbs and muscles more generally, especially as it relates to things like throwing and using our arms for that type of motion. Obviously, the dexterity of our hands and our grasping and writing abilities and all that.
00:07:53.000 --> 00:08:10.000
But you've done work recently on the evolution of bipedality. And so I want to talk about that first. Let's set the stage here by thinking in terms of sort of the why and the what before we get to the how. So obviously at some point, some creature started walking on two legs at least some of the time.
00:08:10.000 --> 00:08:29.000
And then eventually you get humans and we pretty much walk on two legs all of the time once we learn how to do it as little babies. When, roughly, did bipedality evolve and become commonplace? What part of our history and our lineage was that, the common mode of locomotion? Is this a million years old or deeper?
00:08:29.000 --> 00:08:30.000
When did this happen?
00:08:31.000 --> 00:09:03.000
Yeah, so that's a kind of a controversial question in some regards because we know that humans and chimpanzees shared a common ancestor between six and eight million years ago. And the argument is that the common ancestor probably looked more like a chimpanzee or a gorilla. And that's because Chimpanzees and gorillas, as African apes, and they're our closest living relatives, are those that have particular types of locomotion that are common between the two. That is knuckle
walking.
00:09:04.000 --> 00:09:22.000
They are generally semi-upright. They rely on longer forelimbs than their hind limbs, longer arms and legs. They rest a lot of their mass on their front digits on their hands, and they propel themselves that way with their hind limbs. pushing them forward as well.
00:09:22.000 --> 00:09:48.000
They also spend some time in the trees. Chimpanzees spend a lot more time in the trees than gorillas, especially big gorillas that are mostly terrestrial. And so they share, the two types of African apes share this common locomotor pattern. And by the rule of parsimony, you expect that the last common ancestor was probably like a knuckle-walking animal that then eventually stood upright.
00:09:48.000 --> 00:10:15.000
Some people argue that's maybe not the case. Some people would argue that the earliest forms of humans might have been already more upright because they might have been more suspensory. That is, they use their arms to hang down from trees and therefore they're moving more below the branch rather than coming down to the ground that often. And if they came down to the ground, maybe then they would use their legs to walk more bipedally.
00:10:15.000 --> 00:10:22.000
There's been some debate about how far you can push back the origins of bipedality based on which model you follow.
00:10:22.000 --> 00:10:35.000
More like a gibbon. If we imagine a gibbon, it hangs from branches and was some of the earlier predecessors to humans, was it more like a gibbon or more like a chimp? That's basically what we're talking about here.
00:10:35.000 --> 00:10:53.000
Yeah, exactly. Gibbons are Asian apes. They're the oldest living relative to humans. They diverged quite some time ago in the Miocene, early in the Miocene, close to, I believe, 22 million years ago, if not later.
00:10:55.000 --> 00:11:18.000
These forms are long arms. They're the brachiators. They're the Animals that you when you look at in the in your zoo there the primates that really move quickly under the branch. Are they very long for limbs very short high limbs and they can walk upright they'll do it all the time but when they do their long arms have to hang above their bodies as a walk on two legs now other primates like like.
00:11:18.000 --> 00:11:39.000
Gorillas and chimpanzees can also walk by P. Elegias, they just don't do it that often. They do it in particular contexts, like if they're waiting in water, or if they're, you know, trying to carry some things, or if they're becoming threat, making threat postures, right, they'll stand up and move around like that. So there's some evidence in the living primates that bipedality could have occurred.
00:11:40.000 --> 00:12:05.000
And that makes people believe that maybe bipedality was a little more common in the fossil record. And of course, you know, I'll just like pause here and just kind of preface that all of our models are based on living humans, which are bipeds. and living apes that have their own
specialized locomotor patterns. And there's a diversity of locomotor patterns that exists in the fossil record that may not be evident or modeled by living forms.
00:12:06.000 --> 00:12:21.000
And we have to be careful about how much we rely on modern forms, the crown, the distal tips of branches on the phylogenetic tree, if you're interested in phylogeny, as being informative of what happens at a node, where the combination would be, where
00:12:21.000 --> 00:12:42.000
they split. Yeah, we only see obviously what's present today. We only see a small portion of what was present in the past because we only dig up so many fossils and they're really hard to find. And also we often, we can show many examples in the tree of life that we do know about where creatures had features back in the day that we don't really see today.
00:12:42.000 --> 00:13:02.000
And so if you're basically saying we need to be careful and not be too present day centric in our thinking and our hypothesizing, you know, there could have been creatures, I guess, you know, ape like creatures that maybe walked on branches in the trees and maybe they had given like arms, but also were kind of bipedal and just stuff we haven't thought about yet.
00:13:03.000 --> 00:13:37.000
Yeah, exactly. And so the other part to consider in all this, and I know I haven't gotten to answer your question yet about when bipedality arose, but the other part to consider is that species and their morphologies can sometimes change pretty rapidly. And so the idea that if African apes shared knuckle-walking, and that was what the last common ancestor could look like, it's very possible that the last common ancestors didn't look like that, looked more like a biped, and both African apes converged on the same morphology, the same shape, the same locomotor practice.
00:13:37.000 --> 00:14:05.000
They both gained knuckle-walking independently. And that really depends on what happens in the fossil species that are existing around that time. And so you can get convergence of biology. You can also have shared homology, or the fact that, OK, if you think that humans diverged from a knuckle-walking ancestor, that kind of makes sense, because chimpanzees and gorillas had that shared biology.
00:14:05.000 --> 00:14:29.000
And therefore, humans diverged and created a new form of locomotion. So there's both convergence and there's also homology, shared ancestry that drives the kind of biology of what we think about. And we have to use those kind of concepts to think about how we reconstruct the last common ancestor of humans and chimps and the changes that led to humans to become bipedal.
00:14:29.000 --> 00:15:04.000
So, you know, there's some controversy with this stuff and there often is in the paleo world just because the fossil record is always so imperfect. But if we define bipedality to be having an anatomy that would enable bipedal locomotion to be the primary mode of locomotion for a creature in the past. What is our best current guess today as to when we had something like a human or an archaic ape of some kind that had the ability, anatomically speaking, to primarily get around through bipedal locomotion?
00:15:05.000 --> 00:15:23.000
Yeah, that's great. So that's called obligate bipedalism, as opposed to facultative, where you might do it temporarily. And I would say Australopithecus afarensis, Lucy, has pretty clear signs of being a biped, and likely an obligate biped. So that would be around 3 and 1⁄2 million years ago.
00:15:23.000 --> 00:15:48.000
The fossil forms that occur before Lucy, Australopithecus afarensis, for instance, Ardipithecus ramidus, which dates to around 4.5 million years ago from Africa, East Africa, Their pelvises and their knees and their feet suggest kind of a mosaic-like pattern of locomotion where they probably could walk on two legs fairly well, but they didn't do it all the time. They
00:15:48.000 --> 00:15:48.000
probably
00:15:48.000 --> 00:16:14.000
spent some time in the trees. And one of the pieces of evidence is that they have a big toe that's separate from the rest of the digits. opposable, whereas humans have the big toe that's aligned with the rest of the digits, making us a good walker. So Ardipithecus has some traits that may really clearly show that it could probably walk on the ground or in the trees, but locomote not necessarily as an obligate biped.
00:16:15.000 --> 00:16:21.000
Around 3.5, 3.3, we see evidence of more obligatory bipedalism
00:16:21.000 --> 00:16:21.000
in the
00:16:21.000 --> 00:16:22.000
fossil record.
00:16:22.000 --> 00:16:34.000
So roughly speaking, if you go halfway in between humans today and our last common ancestor with chimps, around that time, there were things that probably could walk on two legs quite a bit.
00:16:35.000 --> 00:17:01.000
Yeah. Yeah. And so, interestingly enough, the development of bipedalism in early hominins, the forms that would give rise to eventually humans, and that's a large group of organisms now that we know that existed between six and two million years ago, there's lots of those forms of hominins that look like they could walk bipedally.
00:17:01.000 --> 00:17:25.000
And so if you think about this, I'm gonna digress for a second. Evolutionarily speaking, bats acquired at one point wings that allowed them to fly. And the bat wing is considered an evolutionary novelty. It really facilitated a new form of locomotion that let the ancestors of bats and bats themselves to go across the world and occupy new niches.
00:17:26.000 --> 00:17:28.000
And we call that an adaptive radiation.
00:17:28.000 --> 00:17:40.000
So there's no other mammals literally flying around and able to occupy that part of the natural world. And so they had a really strong competitive advantage and they could really exploit that and diversify a lot very quickly.
00:17:41.000 --> 00:18:13.000
Exactly. And so some people argue that the earliest changes in bipedalism did the same, that
there are now forms of hominins like Australopithecus afarensis, Paranthropus, another lineage of hominins, Ardipithecines, all of these forms that could walk somewhat on two legs, some more obligatory and others more facultative. But that set up a new adaptive radiation, a new way to get around the landscape that in some ways, out-competed other forms or allowed them to exploit new niches that other forms could not exploit.
00:18:14.000 --> 00:18:25.000
Okay, so we've touched on the when. A few million years ago, there was creatures starting to walk around bipedally more. Now, we're getting into the why. What was the selective pressure?
00:18:25.000 --> 00:18:42.000
What was the advantage that was opened up by being able to move around in this way? I want to dig into that more. Before we do, so you've already mentioned that we had Australopithecus a different genus than Homo that was probably using bipedal locomotion. What's the difference between Australopithecus and Homo?
00:18:42.000 --> 00:18:48.000
Would we consider these to be proto-humans but not quite human in the full sense? Can you just explain that difference there?
00:18:48.000 --> 00:19:10.000
Yeah, so Australopithecus is a group of hominins that date basically from 3.8 to roughly like 2.5 million years ago, depending on who you ask. And the definitions are dependent on morphology and how you define morphology. But this group of organisms had the ability to walk on two legs. But they had very small brain sizes.
00:19:10.000 --> 00:19:55.000
They had brain sizes about the size of a chimp, maybe a little larger. So 300, 400 cubic centimeters. In comparison, human brains are 1500 cubic centimeters, if not larger. And so these forms of hominins are distinguished from from humans really based on other traits like for instance enlarged brain size or the kind of changes in body proportions that come with becoming not just an obligate biped but a good biped, an animal now that can run and walk long distances and really get good stride lengths. So, having long, long legs compared to arms. These Australopithecines didn't have that. They had about equal sized limb proportions.
00:19:55.000 --> 00:20:26.000
You know, forelimbs and hindlimbs were about the same size. In comparison, gorillas and chimpanzees have very long arms compared to their legs, right? So you're moving in space and time to a group of organisms that are upright, they're facultative to obligate bipeds, they're doing it fairly well, but they're not efficient like modern humans are. And Homo starts to acquire really the body proportions of modern humans, the brain size of modern humans, a lot more dexterity in the hands and feet, and the feet losing the dexterity and gaining a big toe.
00:20:27.000 --> 00:20:36.000
And also, Homo's got associations with stone tools and cultural aspects that we don't necessarily see in early Australopithecines, even though there's some rudimentary tools with
00:20:36.000 --> 00:20:57.000
Australopithecines. So by the time we get Homo on the scene, certainly, but by the time we have obligate bipeds that are good at getting around on two legs, what Thinking about the why question here, what is bipedality buying you as opposed to being able to walk around on four legs? Can you physically go into different types of environments that you couldn't before?
00:20:57.000 --> 00:21:06.000
Is there some kind of energetic or physiological advantage or disadvantage that being bipedal gives you compared to being a four-legged animal?
00:21:07.000 --> 00:21:38.000
Yeah, so I think this gets to more of the why question, and this is related to more of the, you know, you can ask why on the ultimate sense and the proximate sense. And, you know, at the time of the, of basically the Plioplisocene, which is the window of time we're talking about, you know, between six and two million years ago, we're really looking at this window of time, climate change is occurring, and the Earth is actually getting a bit cooler. And as the earth is cooling, these tropical lush forests in parts of Africa are becoming smaller.
00:21:39.000 --> 00:22:07.000
They're reducing their size, and they're transitioning from these tropical woodland plants to more wooded vegetation that's more patchy forests. So you're getting forests, but they're shrinking in size and becoming more patchy from one forest to the next. And so that opens up tracks of land in between the forests, and animals actually need to move from one forest environment to the other, or they don't. They just stay in the forest environment that they're in.
00:22:07.000 --> 00:22:44.000
So one could argue that chimpanzees and gorillas are probably so efficient at what they've done that they stayed in the tropical forest environments that were changing the least. But these other hominins that arose began to exploit this new environmental opening, this new area between the forests and having to traverse between one forest to the next, potentially to collect resources, potentially because they were pushed out by competition from other forms. We don't know the exact answer. but being able to walk on two legs gave them more efficiency to move between forest environments.
00:22:44.000 --> 00:23:10.000
It also allowed them to carry objects in a very efficient way, carry offspring. Primates carry offspring, the offspring will cling on to them. So I'm not sure if that would be a very big advantage, but maybe carrying other objects might have been. Being tall and being able to see over the savanna grasslands that are occurring at the time may allow them to look and see over the grass so they don't stumble upon a predator or can avoid predation.
00:23:11.000 --> 00:23:41.000
See distance as well. And then there's the argument that some people make that being more linear, being tall and linear, changes the way sunlight hits the body and that might have reduced the heat load that's generated on a body over time. What's clear
is that, and this is, again, based on models of living forms, right, that modern humans, when we walk, we do it very efficiently. And if you take a chimpanzee and you, say, walk, and you put them on a treadmill and try to make them walk, they don't do it efficiently.
00:23:41.000 --> 00:24:06.000
Well, that's kind of not fair, because they don't typically walk that way. But it does suggest that human walking is more efficient than chimpanzee walking, and it's more efficient than chimpanzee walking on all fours. So there seems to be a decreased, you know, oxygen use and consumption and less energetics, less energy consumption involved in human walking than other forms. And that might have, that's a modern thing, right?
00:24:06.000 --> 00:24:31.000
Modern humans are walking and we're very efficient. How you model that to look at the earliest time is difficult. But must have been some energetics advantage. And I say energetics because When we think about evolution, we often forget that it's really about energy and how we use energy and how we distribute energy to development, reproduction, growth, and homeostasis, fighting disease.
00:24:31.000 --> 00:24:46.000
And you only have so much energy in your body and almost energy availability. It would have been important for early humans to exploit and to acquire energy through diet and exploiting new resources and not use a lot of energy to do so.
00:24:46.000 --> 00:25:19.000
Yeah, yeah. And I think implicit in some of the things you were saying is that a lot of these advantages to bipedal locomotion and related adaptations, like being taller, they make a lot of sense if the forest our ancestors were dwelling in became sparser or patchier. Because maybe you want to get from one patch of woods to another, but there's a grassland in between. those things are only going to be advantageous if the forest is going away or you're moving into a more grassland-like environment or something like this.
00:25:19.000 --> 00:25:34.000
When these adaptations were rising and we start seeing bipedality become more common in Australopithecus and in early Homo, is there also evidence in the fossil record that the climate was changing, the grasslands were expanding, the forests were getting sparser and that type of thing?
00:25:34.000 --> 00:25:46.000
Yeah, there is. There's changes in the plant life. So people do paleoecological reconstructions. They reconstruct the past ecology based on what they find in the fossil record.
00:25:46.000 --> 00:26:24.000
They can find fossilized plants that have particular morphologies that are coincident with either being in a tropical forest or a wooded environment. They can also look at isotopes and isotopes accumulate and change according to the different plant species that are out there. There's shifts in carbon isotopes that tell researchers that the climate is getting more cool, that the plants are getting more grass-like as opposed to tropical vegetation. And they can look at those ratios of particular isotopes to really understand how the climate is changing.
00:26:24.000 --> 00:26:46.000
And then, of course, they can also look at sediments themselves to identify the types of windblown sediments that are present in a core from the ground. And that might tell them something about wind patterns and temperature and what was in the actual environment at the time.
00:26:47.000 --> 00:27:07.000
I see. So the environment would have been changing in some way like this. It opened up the opportunity for bipedal locomotion to then offer an advantage if you start evolving it. And despite any patchiness and gaps in the fossil record, at some point, there was something like a knuckle walking ape.
00:27:08.000 --> 00:27:25.000
And at some point, there was an Australopithecine that was more of a mosaic that probably walked upright sometime, more than a chimp, but not all the time like us. And eventually, you do get really good bipedal locomotion by the time of early Homo. And it offers certain advantages. We've gone over some of those.
00:27:25.000 --> 00:27:38.000
So we sort of understand the why part of it to a reasonable extent. We know roughly when this was happening, and we've got a decent picture of the timeline, it sounds like. And obviously, it did happen. We walk on two legs, and somehow we got here.
00:27:40.000 --> 00:28:04.000
What are these sort of anatomic changes that needed to happen to make this possible? So for example, the bones and the anatomy of a chimp are such that the chimp can't walk upright all day long, even if it wanted to. What are the physical changes to the hips, the pelvis, the legs that needed to start to happen in order to enable something like us to walk around on two feet all the time?
00:28:04.000 --> 00:28:16.000
That's great. Great question. Bipedality is really a full body trait. It really affects the entire body.
00:28:17.000 --> 00:28:39.000
So when you look at something like an African ape, they're knuckle walkers. So their center of mass is far forward. when they use their forelimbs to knuckle walk, their center of mass is forward. And so as a result, their rib cage, for instance, is deep from front to back.
00:28:39.000 --> 00:28:59.000
And their arms are long, because they support their weight on their knuckles and their long forelimbs. Their high limbs are shorter. And their pelvis, the classic pelvis that you'd see in a human, is not present in a chimpanzee or gorilla. Now the pelvis has a number of different changes.
00:29:01.000 --> 00:29:26.000
The pelvis in primates that are not human, non-human primates, generally have the upper part called the ilia. And the ilia are these blades that you see that stand upright. So the way to think about this is that if I was standing behind you and I had my hands on your back, about the place where your kidneys are, that's where their pelvic ilia would be. And they would sit exactly in that plane with my hands on your back.
00:29:27.000 -->
00:29:35.000
That's called a coronal plane. Coronal because it's like a crown across your head. So they sit in that same plane. And they're flat and they're tall.
00:29:35.000 --> 00:30:11.000
and they're narrow from side to side, they're narrow. So these ilia support big muscles in the back called the gluteal muscles that push the anchor to the back of the femur and they actually push the leg forward when they contract. And in humans, the pelvis ilia have actually been shortened drastically. They're short, and instead of being short and narrow and sitting on the back, they're actually short and wide, and they sit on the sides of the body.
00:30:11.000 --> 00:30:37.000
So they've been curved around the body. The classic, in fact, the word pelvis is Latin for basin. And so the earliest anatomists who are looking, who are describing these phenotypes, you know, we're calling a pelvis based on the human form, but the human form is very unique. The human form has these unique ilia that curve around the sides of the body, whereas all the other forms actually have more of these flat bladed like structures.
00:30:37.000 --> 00:30:58.000
And so when the ilia got short and curved around the body, the muscles that I talked about, the gluteus muscles that are typically on the back, well, one of them called the gluteus maximus stays on the back. We still have that. That's our butt muscles, you know, and we use that when we walk and run. But two of them, gluteus minimus medius, have curved around the sides of the body.
00:30:58.000 --> 00:31:13.000
So having muscles that are now positioned not on the back but on the sides of the body allows for us, when we walk, to stabilize ourself. So what do I mean by that? Well, when we take a step and we're off the ground, we could fall over because we're
00:31:13.000 --> 00:31:13.000
on
00:31:13.000 --> 00:31:20.000
one leg, and these muscles pull us back down. They contract and pull our bodies back down to be stable. So
00:31:20.000 --> 00:31:24.000
if a chimp is walking upright, they're literally easier to push over because they don't have this kind of
00:31:24.000 --> 00:31:35.000
musculature. They don't have the lateral stabilizer. In fact, when a chimp walks upright, they do so with a bent knee and a bent hip. So they actually are very flexed and low to the ground.
00:31:35.000 --> 00:31:57.000
Whereas like in humans, we have a straight knee and straight hip. And when we walk, we just walk, you know, we just walk like a biped does with a straight hip and a straight knee all the way to transfer down to our knee. So our pelvis has gone from an ape-like pattern where the blades were sitting on the back of the animal to being short and curved low and curved around the sides of the body. Now that's the pelvis.
00:31:57.000 --> 00:32:17.000
There are other changes below the pelvis. For instance, in the femur, our femora are longer. our thigh bones are longer, and they're angled inward. And the knees, at the knee, we rest
all our weight down from our pelvis to our knee, down to our foot, because we stand upright.
00:32:18.000 --> 00:32:42.000
In chimpanzees, their pelvis are not angled inward, they're kind of straight. And what happens is that when they put weight down on their knee, their knees are bent, they're angled. So their shin bones are at an angle to the actual femur. And that means that they're not putting all the weight down directly on the top of their tibia, like humans would.
00:32:43.000 --> 00:32:54.000
And that's because their mass is farther forward. It's about the level of where the thoracic vertebrae would be, as opposed to like us, where it's right over our pelvis, if that makes sense.
00:32:54.000 --> 00:33:27.000
One of the things that people often talk about in the context of bipedality and what it unlocked for us or how it makes us different than other mammals that are out there is, you know, most large bodied mammals that run on four legs can outrun us. for a while, but we're really good at endurance and distance. What is sort of the story here in the thinking around things like persistence hunting, long distance travel, and the benefits and disadvantages that bipedality had versus quadrupedal locomotion?
00:33:28.000 --> 00:33:50.000
Yeah, so a colleague in my department, Dan Lieberman, has studied this at length. Spent many years studying persistent hunting and the evolution of endurance running. And the arguments there is that humans are really terrific long distance runners. We can outrun, for longer distances, most animals.
00:33:51.000 --> 00:34:21.000
It doesn't mean we'd still be, you know, track down, and if they're trying to catch us, they'd probably track us down and eat us. But if we had a good advantage to them, we could outrun them for a long time, because animals often can run quite well, but they overheat. And one of the reasons why they overheat is because they pant, whereas humans sweat. And sweating allowed us to actually run and lose heat through our bodies naturally, as opposed to panting, which, like your dog would pant.
00:34:22.000 --> 00:34:37.000
Other animals would pant. And so we became a very efficient runners, not just from our skeletal proportions, but also from other physiological adaptations that allowed us to run and not overheat in the process. I hope that answers the question.
00:34:38.000 --> 00:35:02.000
Yeah, yeah. And so when we start to now think about the mechanics of the evolutionary changes that took place, and how development had to be tweaked over time to construct muscles and bones in a more human-like way that was conducive to bipedality, rather than a more ape-like form that isn't conducive to bipedality. How do you go about starting to study this?
00:35:02.000 --> 00:35:24.000
Obviously, you can look at the chimp, look at the human, look at the bones of the things in between, and just notice the anatomic differences. Obviously, you can also take out the DNA sequences and put them side by side and look at the genomic differences here. How do you fill in the in-between part where you're thinking about how the genes encode proteins that then sculpt the anatomy into what it ends up looking like?
00:35:24.000 --> 00:35:45.000
That's, yeah, that's great. So the first thing we do is contextualize any anatomical difference that we see between humans and chimps using the fossil record. And one of the things that we noted, and it's been noted for a while, is that the changes to the pelvis seem to be the earliest types of changes that we see in the fossil record. So I mentioned Ardipithecus and Australopithecus.
00:35:45.000 --> 00:36:10.000
When you look at them, as I mentioned, they have relatively equal size limbs. But their pelvis blades seem to be short and narrow and somewhat curved around the sides of the body. So Australopithecus, like Lucy, for instance, has a more human-like pelvis. It doesn't look exactly like humans, but it has the short, broad, curved ilia.
00:36:11.000 --> 00:36:34.000
And so we can contextualize where to first look for the differences in the body by actually saying, where in the fossil record do we expect to see the first changes? And that's why we looked at the pelvis. And so my lab's been focusing on the pelvis for quite a while. And the way we put together and piece together what happened is by looking at development.
00:36:34.000 --> 00:37:03.000
So we work with human embryonic samples, which are donated to us through very ethical channels. I can talk more about that process later. And we receive human embryonic samples at stages where we've figured out where the human pelvis is actually forming. And so what happens in human pelvic development is the ilia, the upper part of the pelvis I talked about already, starts off looking more ancestral.
00:37:03.000 --> 00:37:22.000
It starts off as a thin blade that looks like it's positioned on the back of the animal. It's a thin blade, but it's made of cartilage. And let me pause for a second and just describe a little bit of bone development. So almost all the bones in our body below our head form through a process called endochondral auspication.
00:37:22.000 --> 00:37:50.000
Endo means within, chondral means cartilage, so it forms within a cartilage model. So what that means is that all the bones below our head basically first start off as a cartilage model, a bunch of cartilage cells called chondrocytes that form a model. And the model looks a little bit, sometimes very much like the adult bone. And then that model gets replaced by bone cells that come in and start to replace the model from within.
00:37:50.000 --> 00:37:51.000
It's almost like a mold.
00:37:51.000 --> 00:38:28.000
It's like a mold. It's like if you look at the development of the femur, for instance, in humans, at some point you'll see a femur that will have the traits of a femur, but they'll all be cartilage, all be made of chondrocytes or cartilage cells. And in the mid shaft of the femur,
like in the midpoint of your thigh bone, in a developing embryo, you'll get the invasion of blood vessels that will come into the mid-shaft and bring in bone-producing cells that will then replace the bone from the mid-shaft moving towards both ends, to the head of the femur and towards the knee.
00:38:28.000 --> 00:38:52.000
The head of the femur would be where your hip is, and the knee is obviously towards your knee. And so the bone cells are replacing the cartilage. So let's go back to the pelvis. So in humans, the earliest rudiment that forms This early model is made of cartilage, and it's positioned in the coronal plane, but it's small, and it's not really well-developed.
00:38:53.000 --> 00:38:59.000
You're saying very early in development in humans, this anatomy looks kind of ape-like at first.
00:39:00.000 --> 00:39:11.000
It looks ape-like. It actually looks like all the primates that we looked at. So in this study, we didn't just look at apes and chimpanzees, like gorillas, chimpanzees. We looked at gibbons.
00:39:11.000 --> 00:39:42.000
We looked at all the different primates across the order. We looked at 30 different representatives across the order of primates, which is a very, very expansive order dating back 60 to 80 million years of evolutionary history, right? So, we looked at embryonic samples across those different primates that we got from museum collections. I could talk about that in a moment, but what we did was we looked at the cartilage model that was forming across the ileum, and all the non-human primates started the same way.
00:39:42.000 --> 00:39:52.000
They had an ileum that was cartilage, and it was tall. and narrow. But the cells at that stage were generally undifferentiated. They didn't have specialized functions.
00:39:52.000 --> 00:40:15.000
They were just cartilage cells. At some point, what happens is that those cells start to form what they call growth plates on either side of the ends of the model. So in this case, the upper part and the lower part of the ileum, just like your femur would. And those growth plates are dividing cells that make the cartilage model get bigger and bigger in the long way, in the longitudinal axis and the long axis.
00:40:14.000 --> 00:40:43.000
So the ilia of non-human primates all form as these kind of rods, right, that are vertically oriented and positioned in the back. And humans start that way. But what happens very shortly after the model forms is it flips and you get growth occurring now, not longitudinally, but in the transverse direction, in the perpendicular direction. So side to side, as opposed to up and down.
00:40:43.000 --> 00:41:16.000
So whereas chimpanzees and all the other primates are growing and getting bigger and bigger and bigger at Ilia, taller and taller at Ilia, humans are now growing sideways. the growing perpendicular. And that was a major finding that we saw and had never been reported before, that the cartilage ilia changes its direction of growth in
humans as opposed to all the other primates. And that kind of helps us understand why the ilium is short and broad as opposed to tall and narrow.
00:41:17.000 --> 00:41:33.000
Right. And I guess in theory, so A, it didn't need to be the case that the anatomy of the earliest thing that looked like a pelvis in the embryo of apes looked at the same and then they became different later. It could have been that they were just sort of built different from the ground up at the very beginning. That's not the case.
00:41:33.000 --> 00:41:59.000
So they have kind of a similar starting point and then they sort of become different later when you compare humans to other apes. And essentially what you're saying is, In our lineage, things grow out rather than up, you might say. And that could simply be a matter of a change in a gene that pushes some type of cell one direction versus the other. Is that how you start to then think about what to do next?
00:41:59.000 --> 00:42:21.000
So once we contextualized what was happening developmentally to the structure of the ileum, and we can also see through histology, the tissue level biology, that that's what was happening. Then we needed to understand, well, how does that process happen? Why? What's causing the pelvis to start changing its direction of growth?
00:42:21.000 --> 00:42:34.000
And that's where the genes come in and the regulatory sequences. So genes are, you know, segments of DNA that code for protein. And genes are used throughout the body. There's about 20,000 genes in the human genome.
00:42:35.000 --> 00:42:54.000
And you can think about there's thousands of different cell types and each cell type expresses hundreds of thousands of different genes. So a lot of the genes are used over and over again in different cell types in the body. But what turns a gene on is called a regulatory switch, kind of like a light switch. And this is the analogy I give.
00:42:55.000 --> 00:43:05.000
Imagine the gene being the light bulb. And it's like a 60-watt GE light bulb that you go to the store, Home Depot, and you buy a whole bunch of them. In every room in the house, you put that 60-watt
00:43:05.000 --> 00:43:09.000
bulb. Right. You need to use the light bulb in every cell. But how much of them do you need?
00:43:09.000 --> 00:43:11.000
When do you need to turn them on? All these things.
00:43:11.000 --> 00:43:28.000
Exactly. And so that light bulb, that switch, that light bulb is just that one gene, right? And then you have like, for instance, the bathroom switch, or the kitchen switch, or the living room switch. These are independent switches that turn the light bulb on only in that room.
00:43:28.000 --> 00:43:49.000
So what we know is that genes are shared across different tissues, but regulatory switches are present and they're not shared often, that they become very specific. So in other words, when we're studying cartilage cells, we can find switches that are unique to cartilage cells and unique to the ileum and maybe not other bones in the body.
00:43:49.000 --> 00:44:10.000
Right. So the idea here is you've got a kind of modularity and flexibility in these switches that you don't have in the bulb or the power grid. If I go start messing with the power grid outside, I could accidentally turn off everyone's electricity, which is catastrophic. But if I just want to tweak the light in the bathroom, I can just mess with that one switch.
00:44:10.000 --> 00:44:26.000
Exactly. So if you went and bought a defective batch of light bulbs, every light bulb would be defective and you wouldn't have any light in your house. But if the light bulbs were fine and you just had a short circuit in your switch, then only that room would lose light. right?
00:44:26.000 --> 00:44:49.000
And that's really like what's happening evolutionarily is that mutations, DNA changes in the switch, because switches are DNA sequences, mutations in the switch can be tolerated if they are affecting very specific parts of the body and not the whole body at once. And so those changes could then be beneficial if they generate a morphology, a shape that was actually beneficial.
00:44:49.000 --> 00:45:11.000
Yeah and let's bring two things into the equation here because hopefully this will make a lot of sense to a lot of people. So what we're really talking about here is there's a distinction to be made between protein coding sequences in the genome and non-protein coding sequences. So let's talk about that and talk about how much of the genome is protein coding versus non-protein coding.
00:45:12.000 --> 00:45:29.000
That's great. So in the human genome, and this is true pretty much across mammals and other vertebrates, about 2% of the genome is protein-coding regions, right? Genes are not that common. There are small segments of DNA in a vast sea of DNA.
00:45:30.000 --> 00:45:39.000
Most of the genome is non-coding. about 98% of it is non-coding. It could be a little more or less, but generally it's around that number.
00:45:39.000 --> 00:45:41.000
Vast majority is non-coding.
00:45:41.000 --> 00:45:51.000
Vast majority, yeah. And for a long time, people just thought it was junk. And maybe you've covered this before. Junk DNA is a misnomer.
00:45:51.000 --> 00:46:05.000
It's not really junk DNA. It's actually made up of a lot of the rest of the DNA, 98% of it is made up of a bunch of switches. And it's made of other things too. that might not regulate gene regulation or how genes are turned on and off, how protein-coding genes function.
00:46:06.000 --> 00:46:40.000
But these switches are litters scattered throughout the genome, and they're nearby genes, roughly. Sometimes they can be pretty distant, but they're generally near genes, and they help turn on those genes in very site-specific and temporal-specific ways. So, development of an embryo, which starts as a single cell and becomes a multicellular organism, is really how the non-coding sequences, the rest of the genome is used
to turn on a small portion of genes in individual cells to orchestrate their functions and develop over time.
00:46:40.000 --> 00:47:14.000
So, so in the abstract, at least, you can start once you sort of understand the mechanics and the dynamics of how all that gene regulation stuff works at a detailed level, and you understand the differences in the patterning of the tissue and development, like what you guys looked at, you can start to think like, okay, you know, the human, the human tissues moving out in this direction, the ape tissues moving up in this direction, Maybe that was just due to a change in some of these switches that change sort of when or how much growth of a particular tissue happened at some time in development.
00:47:15.000 --> 00:47:34.000
Exactly. So when we discovered that the growth was changing direction, then we can start studying those cells. And we can ask, in those cells, where are the switches? And we identified the switches in those cells and the genes that they target, the genes that they turn on and off.
00:47:34.000 --> 00:48:09.000
And then we can start looking at those switches and say, hey, is the sequence of these switches different between humans and other primates? And based on the difference in sequences, we can determine whether or not these regions are likely showing evidence of past evolutionary selection, and therefore under some kind of adaptive evolution, or they're just changing at the natural mutation rate. And so they're not really that important for generating the, or driving the phenotypes that we're interested in. And so, yeah, after you.
00:48:09.000 --> 00:48:42.000
So yeah, so basically like for a study like this, we're referring to a study that just came out. Basically, you have to understand the anatomical differences in the adult. How did the pelvis and the bones and the anatomy of a human, how do they end up differently than a chimp and compared to archaic species of hominids that aren't around anymore? And then you have to like line up the embryos literally, and you look at like the early stages of pelvis development and you can say, okay, all of the apes kind of look similar, but then they become different.
00:48:42.000 --> 00:49:08.000
And then you can dig into the tissue differences and how they're moving differently once they start to develop differently at these stages of development. And then you can look at the DNA of these creatures and start to really say, okay, what was driving that? And what are the genomic differences that evolved to create that tissue difference in development that gives you the final end product, having a different anatomy. So you're really cutting across like multiple, what you would call multiple fields of study here.
00:49:08.000 --> 00:49:14.000
Exactly. In the very beginning of this conversation, we talked about how we bring in data from a lot of different fields. Exactly. That's what we had to do.
00:49:15.000 --> 00:49:51.000
We're trying to connect the genotype, the genetic sequence to the phenotype, the physical appearance of traits, and we're bringing in all these levels of inquiry to do it. And so when we discovered these switches, we then had to say, well, do they have harbor sequences that look like they're evolved relative to other primates? And that's not always easy to do either. And you know, there's a notion out there in the field that existed for a while, that one's going to find the gene that makes big brains, or the gene that gave human culture, or the gene that gave language to humans, or the gene that made us upright.
00:49:51.000 --> 00:50:22.000
And the reality is that, well first, as I mentioned, it's not the genes, it's the non-coding sequences, the other stuff. But it's not one region of the genome, and that was something that we discovered. We discovered that when we found these sequences, these switches that control the cartilage, and we found evolutionary signals in those sequences, it wasn't one switch, it was hundreds of switches. Hundreds of switches targeting lots of genes across the body, across the developing ileum.
00:50:22.000 --> 00:50:49.000
developing pelvis. And that tells us that it's a bunch of changes of small changes of small effect rather than one gene of large effect that can generate the biological phenotype that we look at. And I think that makes a lot of sense from the standpoint that you're evolving a structure that's so critical to walking. But remember also the pelvis is also important for giving birth to a fetus, right?
00:50:49.000 --> 00:51:19.000
There's a birth canal that's formed by the pelvis. And so it's not like you can just change one thing very drastically without ramifications of other traits, like giving birth, which is huge from a Darwinian perspective, right? And so the fact that we found a whole bunch of changes, hundreds of changes, a small effect, really suggests that this is a gradual process. slowly changing the growth and trajectory of the developing ileum to make it short and broad.
00:51:19.000 --> 00:51:43.000
Why is that important? It helps us inform on the fossil record to say, you know, what do we expect now when we look at the fossil record? Do we expect to find a form all of a sudden appearing at thin air that has flipped growth and a normal pelvis that looks like humans automatically? Or do we expect to find transitional fossils where the pelvic blades might have been rotated slowly
00:51:43.000 --> 00:51:44.000
and slowly
00:51:44.000 --> 00:52:05.000
over time? The model that we have now is that the polygenicity, the many different inputs that we're seeing genetically likely reflect a more gradual rotational process. Now, it doesn't mean this gradual process didn't happen quickly. It could happen very quick because it's evolutionarily speaking, if it's something selectively advantageous.
00:52:05.000 --> 00:52:12.000
It could have been a 100,000-year process, which is relatively quickly, but it's not like
one day, an eighth day of birth to something that had this new kind of pelvis.
00:52:13.000 --> 00:52:20.000
Yeah, just think about that. And I've gotten people who have said, well, maybe it is one change. I'm like, well, think about it. You're that ape born with a different pelvis.
00:52:20.000 --> 00:52:23.000
How are you gonna mate? How are you gonna interact with other animals
00:52:23.000 --> 00:52:24.000
that have different
00:52:24.000 --> 00:52:35.000
morphology than you? You likely would not survive. And so it's gradual shifts in the morphology. That could happen over a 100,000 year period or a 500,000 year period, whatever the timeframe is.
00:52:36.000 --> 00:52:39.000
But it's a lot of changes that are happening across the genome. And
00:52:39.000 --> 00:52:39.000
that's
00:52:39.000 --> 00:53:07.000
because, the other thing is that all these all these genes and all these switches in the cells that we're talking about, the chondrocytes, they're acting in networks that interact with each other. When one gene gets turned on more because the switch is activated higher, it could also mean that another gene has to be turned down or interacts in a different way. So these are interactive networks. And you can't just take a sledgehammer to the network without disrupting it.
00:53:07.000 --> 00:53:10.000
You'd make subtle changes over time. And that's what we're seeing.
00:53:10.000 --> 00:53:21.000
Right. Yeah. I mean, yeah, you brought a lot of important points there for those unacquainted with this realm of biology, evolution, development, and all this stuff. Sometimes it's easy to overlook that.
00:53:21.000 --> 00:53:51.000
Like when we say the word pelvis, that's a word that corresponds to a concept that we made up. And like, obviously there's a pelvis, there's like an anatomy there that we can point to, but there's no pelvis gene that does all the pelvis stuff. There's hundreds of cell types and multiple tissues that are all working together and integrated in some fashion that correspond to the pelvis. And what you're saying empirically is you didn't find differences in one or two or even three genes between all of these different apes.
00:53:51.000 --> 00:53:58.000
You found many different changes in many different genes, all of which are relevant to all of the tissues in that region of the body.
00:53:59.000 --> 00:54:36.000
Yeah, and I've been talking about the cartilage cells, but really what we found in the paper is that when you look at other cell types, like muscles and tendons, and even bone proper, you can start seeing lots of evolutionary changes. And it kind of makes sense, because what we also discovered in this paper is that the cartilage model that forms and starts to grow in a different direction is already being anchored or attached by muscles. And that's something that's not always common, actually. The key muscles that make us walk show connections to the cartilage model.
00:54:37.000 --> 00:55:11.000
And this is something surprising because the other muscles that are involved in human-specific walking do not show connections to the cartilage. And when we look at the muscle cells themselves and how they're anchoring to the cartilage, the regulatory regions in those muscle cells also show evidence of evolutionary change, as do the tendons, as do the bone cells. It's an entirely adaptive complex that's changing in a very complicated way over evolutionary time. And we see this across the genome in different cell types, in different regulatory regions controlling those cell types.
00:55:12.000 --> 00:55:13.000
It's pretty fascinating.
00:55:13.000 --> 00:55:50.000
Yeah yeah but basically if you look at the pelvis of an ape and an archaic human and a human today they have a different anatomy that anatomy either facilitates or does not facilitate efficient bipedal locomotion and some kind of model seems to be supported whereby a bunch of changes to a bunch of genes over time gradually sort of tilted and shifted how those bones and how those tissues get shaped into the geometry of the human pelvis. And that happened over time. And you can imagine just a pelvis going from more upright to more sideways, changing the angle of the bones and all that stuff.
00:55:50.000 --> 00:55:58.000
That just sort of general shift happened in development over time after many, many different changes to many genes took root.
00:55:58.000 --> 00:56:21.000
Yep. And this is happening at a time where, evolutionarily time, where the animal where this was happening really had some other changes in their bodies compared to chimpanzees and gorillas, but nothing major. They had about the same brain size. So any pressure on childbirth probably wouldn't have been there
00:56:21.000 --> 00:56:43.000
by changing- This is great because I was actually going to ask you about this. I wanted to talk about co-evolution in another way. Another way that I think our pelvis is different is women have to give birth to little babies with giant heads compared to other creatures. It sounds like bipedality came before most of the increase in skull size in our lineage.
00:56:43.000 --> 00:57:10.000
Yeah, so as I mentioned, you asked the question before about what distinguishes Australopithecus from Homo. And really, when you get into the genus Homo around 2.5 million years ago, you get slightly bigger brains. You go from 300, 400 cubic centimeters to 600, 700, 800 cubic centimeters. You get to a fossil species called Homo erectus around 1.8 million years ago, 1.6 million years ago, which is found in Africa, but now also parts of East Asia.
00:57:10.000 --> 00:57:36.000
And these hominins have brain sizes of around 800 to 1,000 cubic centimeters. But then around 1 million years ago, 1.5 million years ago, pushing back a little bit, brain sizes start to accelerate. You start to go up to 1,500 to even 2,000 cubic centimeters, right? So it's really within the last million, a million and a half years that brain
size is increasing.
00:57:36.000 --> 00:57:53.000
And it's increasing at a time where, prior to, body proportions are established. Our length of our legs are about what they, you know, at 1.5 million years ago, are about what they are now. They're long legs. We have a big toe that's brought into line, right?
00:57:53.000 --> 00:58:02.000
Our pelvis looks parasitically aligned. It looks curved around the body in a right way. And then you can start seeing the increase in brain size.
00:58:02.000 --> 00:58:20.000
So, at some point in the past, a couple, three, four million years ago, there were human-like or proto-human creatures walking around on two legs that looked like humans in the sense that they were bipedal, but they basically had chimp skulls or very small heads compared to us.
00:58:20.000 --> 00:58:44.000
Yeah, and they probably had the ability, they probably had hair, for all we know, thick hair. We don't really know what they look like, but they probably had the ability to still climb in some respects, and they didn't have very powerful forearms yet for throwing, right? We talked about throwing as a potential phenotype. That occurs more gradually, we think around 2.5 to 2 million years ago, to 1.5 million years ago with Homo erectus,
00:58:44.000 --> 00:58:45.000
you start to
00:58:45.000 --> 00:58:46.000
see lateralization of the shoulders,
00:58:47.000 --> 00:58:47.000
allowing
00:58:47.000 --> 00:58:49.000
them to throw and projectile.
00:58:49.000 --> 00:59:11.000
I see. So if we rewind the clock and then play it forward, there were creatures walking around on two legs. And then sometime later, did their heads grow. And that was probably also connected with other musculoskeletal changes like dexterity of the hands and the ability to use your upper limbs, your arms to do things like throw spears.
00:59:11.000 --> 00:59:19.000
So when Australopithecus started walking on two legs, they weren't strong enough and they weren't smart enough to start hunting mammoths with spears, let's say.
00:59:20.000 --> 00:59:48.000
That's the argument people make, and it's really hard. They could have been using wood tools for all we know. One of the fascinating things that we discovered is that when the pelvis shifts in its growth, it starts to grow to the side, it inherently makes the birth canal, the upper part of the birth canal, wider. And this is at a time when the brains are still small.
00:59:48.000 --> 01:00:04.000
Interesting. So there's no way to do that without widening the birth canal. So if I'm going to anticipate where you're going, maybe, because this is just clicking in my head, the evolution of bipedality could have opened up essentially the niche for big skulls to actually evolve. It wasn't possible before.
01:00:05.000 --> 01:00:17.000
Yeah. That's the thing I would go out on a limb and say. When humans started walking, we shifted our pelvis. One of the things that happened to our birth canal is that, oh, we'll back up.
01:00:17.000
--> 01:00:34.000
In chimpanzees, the birth canal is deep from front to back, from the front of the animal to the back. And so it's a deep, more ovular structure from front to back. In humans, it's wide. It's wider than deep from side to side.
01:00:34.000 --> 01:01:03.000
And when the early, When you look at the birth canal of early Australopithecus and early Homo, it also is wide and not deep like a Chimpanzee, it's wide. And so when the pelvis started to shift in its growth, it creates that widening. Now, the upper part of the pelvis, which is the part that the fetus coming down would first experience, is the widest. And still in modern humans, it's narrow towards the bottom part, where the fetus eventually comes out of.
01:01:04.000 --> 01:01:17.000
That's the pelvic outlet, and the pelvic inlet is the top part. The pelvic inlet is the widest part, and the pelvic outlet is still narrow. So there's still a constraint. There's still a pressure to get a big fetal head through a narrow pelvis at the bottom.
01:01:17.000 --> 01:01:53.000
But in theory, opening up of a larger Up pelvic inlet the upper part could have allowed for brain sizes to be accommodated during fetal growth. And then of course humans do things like rotate the fetus during birth to maybe shift them and position them correctly. And our hypothesis moving forward and we're trying to study this in lab now is potentially. is really that the earliest changes to the pelvis facilitated, as you said, the ability to allow variation to develop in brain size later on,
01:01:53.000 --> 01:01:53.000
and that
01:01:53.000 --> 01:02:00.000
was tolerated, and that could actually be passed through the fetus, through the birth canal. It's a pretty fascinating contingency. right?
01:02:00.000 --> 01:02:10.000
Yeah. Yeah. Interesting. It also sort of explains why, you know, people might ask the seemingly simple question, like, well, why aren't there, why aren't there more types of really smart creatures?
01:02:10.000 --> 01:02:23.000
And one answer is, you know, for a mammal, you have to give birth to the babies through the birth canal. And if it's not already wide enough to accommodate a bigger brain, then you, you can't get that. Cause then the baby can't, you can't give birth to it.
01:02:23.000 --> 01:03:01.000
Yeah, it's pretty amazing. I think evolution has a bunch of contingencies, things that happened before that affect later, they're constraints, and this is potentially one of them. It might have actually not been a constraint as much as something that facilitated future brain growth. Now, in that line, if I may, one of the other things that we discovered in the paper on the pelvis that we recently published is that when the pelvic ilia rotate and start to grow to the sides, they also change their type of bone formation.
01:03:01.000 --> 01:03:40.000
So all the long bones of the body, like your femur, even the ilia of other primates and ilia of mouse, the mouse model, they all, when you get
blood vessels coming in into the middle part of the element, the skeletal element, you actually get bone cells coming in. And those bone cells start to mineralize internally and get hard bone internal and externally. So, when you look at Chimpanzees, that seems to be the process. Those Ilia that are forming, along the mid part of the Ilia, you get internal auspication and external auspication, bone mineralization internally and externally.
01:03:40.000 --> 01:04:02.000
In humans, what we found, remarkably, is that the Ilia that are growing They get blood vessels to come in, but they don't bring bone cells internally. There's actually a block to bone cells entering into the actual developing iliac model. They stay on the peripheral side, the external. They coat the model.
01:04:02.000 --> 01:04:15.000
They don't internalize. And what that means is that humans have delayed the internal ossification of the developing ileum. Now, why would that be important? Well, inside the ilea are still cartilage cells that can divide and grow.
01:04:15.000 --> 01:04:55.000
So if you create a shape, and then you need to grow that shape as the fetus grows, you can grow the pelvis wider, bigger and bigger and bigger, and still maintain the proportions. And if those proportions are important for walking, but also now a large fetal head in the future, when that individual has to give birth, then you want those proportions to maintain. So what you do is you delay the bone development internally, and you just coat it on the external surface, allowing the internal cells to divide and divide and divide because they're cartilage. Now, I went into that pretty quick, but the idea is that there's another adaptation that we identified that might link to brain evolution.
01:04:56.000 --> 01:05:14.000
Yeah. And I wanted to ask you about brain evolution to some extent and muscle evolution. So earlier you mentioned, you know, you know, everything's about trade-offs, energetic trade-offs. There's only so much energy than an organism ever has, and you've got to allocate it and pattern it in some way.
01:05:14.000 --> 01:05:45.000
And it's finite, right? So the more you put into reproductive output, the less you can put into growing a bigger brain, the more that you put into muscles, less leftover for other tissues. And so everything is about these constraints and these trade-offs in terms of how energy is used to build tissue, build phenotypes, and then deploy it one way or the other. One of the areas that I know that there's been a lot of thinking around in terms of the human story is, okay, we started walking upright and that had certain energetic advantages that we touched on earlier.
01:05:45.000 --> 01:06:02.000
We can go over distances. It opened up our ability to eventually use our hands and do tool making stuff like that. But we've also got these big brains that we just touched on some of the anatomical constraints there. that may have paved the way or enabled us to evolve these big brains.
01:06:03.000 --> 01:06:25.000
But when we did start building really big brains doing fancier, fancier human type stuff, that has to come with a trade-off. And one of the potential trade-offs here is brain versus muscle versus maybe other tissues we can talk about. Maybe one way to hook into this is people are always struck when they see the hairless chimpanzee, right? Chimpanzees are just, they're jacked.
01:06:26.000 --> 01:06:44.000
You could take the toughest human MMA fighter and the most average chimp, and the chimp would just rip their arm off. What can you start to tell us about some of the trade-offs between, say, muscle, just total musculature, and how our muscles are different and have changed, and how that might relate to things like building the bigger brain over time?
01:06:45.000 --> 01:07:06.000
That's a great question. I work with a collaborator at the University of Oregon, Kirsten Sterner, on this, looking at the evolution of muscle fiber types. So there are fibers in muscle, and they can be muscles involved in power generation. They can also be muscles involved in endurance biology.
01:07:07.000 --> 01:07:10.000
And so there are different energetic costs to each.
01:07:10.000 --> 01:07:12.000
These are the type one, type two fibers? Type one, type
01:07:12.000 --> 01:07:13.000
two fibers,
01:07:13.000 --> 01:07:14.000
yeah. Which one's which? I always
01:07:14.000 --> 01:07:39.000
forget. the type 1 fibers are the fast-twitch and the type 2 fibers are fast-twitch type 1 and slow-twitch. Generally, what you see is the evolution in humans of having more slow-twitch fibers. There's been an evolutionary process by which human muscles have actually acquired slow-twitch muscles, the fiber types.
01:07:41.000 --> 01:08:38.000
Previous work show that actually when you look at most muscles in the body, there's actually lots of more slow twitch muscles and fibers in humans compared to chimpanzees. So some people have argued that in the hind limb used in walking, that the muscles like the gastroc, the calf muscle, which is a slow twitch dominated muscle, would have evolved because you need that muscle to walk in terms of endurance walking and running. And that by having so much which fibers what you're doing is you're allowing them to recover the muscle to recover more quickly and for longer periods of time so And unlike power muscles, which you know you use you use a lot of energy energy for but the recovery time is slower that's really the kind of the difference between the two and so I When you look at the hind limb, yes, you see differences in slow twitch contributions in humans compared to chimpanzees, but you also see that across the body.
01:08:38.000 --> 01:09:15.000
And it does make one to suggest that potentially there had to be some type of energetic cost to having large brains. And potentially as we acquired larger brains, we had to shift our energetic costs in other ways, potentially by generating slow-switch
fibers across our muscles. But that's really hard to say because we started to evolve endurance locomotion at the time when our brains are evolving and getting bigger, right? And so, you know, Maybe not a trade off, it actually might have been two adaptations.
01:09:16.000 --> 01:09:42.000
Another way one can think about it is looking at the relative energetic use of different organs in the body. And so the brain uses lots of energy, but other organs in the body use less. And it's been argued in human evolution that the human brain uses more energy than the chimp brain relative to body size. And that even in that our guts have actually become more efficient and smaller, as opposed to other primates, right?
01:09:42.000 --> 01:10:04.000
We have larger sacculous guts for processing leaves and stuff. And so people can now look at different organs in their energetic uses. to really look at these trade-offs in more detail. Rather than just looking at the muscles and thinking about the relationship of muscle changes to brain changes, we can look at the whole organism and all the different organs to know where are the trade-offs happening, right, if that makes sense.
01:10:04.000 --> 01:10:18.000
Yeah, yeah, yeah. And so, is it just that we have proportionally more of these slow twitch endurance type fibers, or really, how's our total muscle mass change? It certainly looks like a chimpanzee is just more muscular overall.
01:10:18.000 --> 01:10:31.000
Yeah, human muscles are generally smaller than chimpanzees and gorillas, right, of course. And they are made up of predominantly more muscles, more slow-twitch muscle fibers.
01:10:32.000 --> 01:10:33.000
Which ones?
01:10:33.000 --> 01:10:35.000
slow twitch. Humans are made up of more slow
01:10:35.000 --> 01:10:36.000
twitch. Humans are slow twitch,
01:10:36.000 --> 01:10:50.000
yeah. They're smaller muscles per body size, and they're also generally reduced fast twitch or increased slow twitch contribution. And then... After you.
01:10:50.000 --> 01:11:13.000
No, I was going to say, I don't know if this is your area that you've studied in particular, but when we think about these changes to musculoskeletal system generally, when we think about bipedality and then the origins of bigger brains. The other thing I wanted to ask you about is our other two limbs. When do we start to see some of those shoulder arm changes that facilitate things like hunting with tools and doing that sort of thing?
01:11:14.000 --> 01:11:47.000
Yeah, this is a very, very interesting question. So I worked on the project a while back in 2015 with Nathan Young and Neil Roche, who basically were looking at the pectoral girdle and the shoulder girdle. And what I argued there in that paper was basically that over the course of human evolution, And unlike what you see in the pelvis, the changes to the shoulder were more gradual. Let me put this in perspective.
01:11:47.000 --> 01:12:22.000
In chimpanzees, in gorillas, in gibbons, for instance, the show the scapula or shoulder blade, the thing that sits on your back, right, that you can feel if you touch on your back. The shoulder is oriented in such a way that the joint, the shoulder joint is in those primates faces more towards the head. not directly in line with the vertebral column, but like on an angle to them. So basically, they're basically pointed more cranially.
01:12:22.000 --> 01:12:48.000
That's the way you describe it. In humans, our shoulder joints face laterally. If you've ever seen an x-ray of a human, you'll know that the scapula and the humeral head or the humerus comes right off the scapula on the sides of the body laterally. And so when we modeled evolutionarily what was happening in fossil hominins, we can see that there was a gradual rotation from that cranial orientation to the lateral rotation.
01:12:49.000 --> 01:13:05.000
And the lateral rotation, the true human pattern, is found at about Homo erectus. So that would be the period where one would argue that potentially high-powered spear throwing and potentially tool use was most adaptive at that point.
01:13:05.000 --> 01:13:15.000
I see. The pelvic changes you mapped out that facilitated the evolution of bipedality, those didn't come overnight, but you're saying all of these upper body changes were even more gradual, it seems.
01:13:15.000 --> 01:13:40.000
More gradual, yeah. They definitely took place over several millions of years. fossil hominins that you, if you can place them along a trajectory as being either more cranially if they're earlier in time or more laterally if they're later in time. Whereas in the pelvis, we don't have a lot of fossils from the early, early window of 4.5 to 6 or 8 million years ago.
01:13:41.000 --> 01:14:06.000
But it looks like that would be the more drastically faster process, right? And you know, This is an interesting question to me. If scapula or shoulder blades are becoming more lateralized over time, that's kind of what's also happening in the pelvis. But in the pelvic, it seems to be through the mechanism of shifting the growth.
01:14:06.000 --> 01:14:12.000
Now, in my lab, we're trying to understand what's happening in the shoulder to see if it's actually shifting its growth as well.
01:14:12.000 --> 01:14:18.000
It could be a similar morphogenetic move that evolution made just with different switches or something.
01:14:18.000 --> 01:14:41.000
Exactly. It could be that ingrained in the genetic architecture of building the pelvis is a bunch of switches and genes that are in a network. that could have been co-opted again or used again to shape the scapula. Or maybe the scapular morphology is more ancestral to the pelvic morphology, and that's a much more involved question.
01:14:42.000 --> 01:14:58.000
But in any case, the idea is generally that instead of evolution recreating the wheel, It just uses the wheel already. It uses the wheel to actually generate a new morphology. It's fascinating.
01:14:58.000
--> 01:15:04.000
What other questions and problems are you working on in the lab today related to human evolution?
01:15:04.000 --> 01:15:16.000
Oh, great. So as I mentioned, we're looking at the pelvis, but now we're studying the birth canal. So we're trying to understand how is the human birth canal forming. It's remarkable that we know very little about this really critical structure.
01:15:17.000 --> 01:15:31.000
And so we're looking at the shape of the other parts of the pelvis, which is the ischium and pubis. The pubis is the interior part of the pelvis that you see on an x-ray. And we're looking at how that birth canal forms. We're studying the shoulder, as I mentioned.
01:15:32.000 --> 01:15:53.000
We're also studying the lower back. so the lumbar vertebrae and how they connect to the sacral vertebrae. The pelvis itself is the ilia connected to the sacrum or the sacral vertebrae. And over the course of human evolution, humans have developed a lordotic curve or S-shaped curve in their vertebrae to push the center of mass over their pelvis.
01:15:53.000 --> 01:16:08.000
We're trying to understand that as well, developmentally. Chimpanzees have more of a C-shaped vertebrae, whereas humans have an S-shaped lower lumbar region. We're trying to understand that mechanism as well. And that might be tied to how the pelvis is forming also.
01:16:08.000 --> 01:16:26.000
It's a whole adaptive complex. We have projects on the knee and how the knees have evolved. We have projects on the hands and feet. We have a paper that we've just submitted looking at the molecular architecture of how hands and feet develop and how their proportions develop in humans.
01:16:27.000 --> 01:16:40.000
Shoulders, we're looking at the shoulders. And recently I have a student who said, she came into my lab and said, I want to study the brain. And I'm not a brain lab, but I said, let's do it. Let's try to use the tools that we have to study the brain.
01:16:40.000 --> 01:17:02.000
And what we're trying to do is study these cells called the microglia, which are supporting cells to neurons in the brain. And there's some evidence in human evolution that microglia have changed functions. As support cells, it's potentially equally important that they've changed in addition to neurons in the brain to support human brain development and diversification. So we're in that project as well.
01:17:02.000 --> 01:17:23.000
Is there anything that you want to reiterate for people or any final thoughts you want to leave them with, particularly as it relates to, you know, the how to think about things in evolutionary context and sort of all the things you need to keep in mind to think well and not just sort of make up just so stories when it comes to this stuff?
01:17:23.000 --> 01:17:46.000
Yeah, it's something I mentioned in the very beginning that I truly hold dear. When you develop a hypothesis or a model, the model has to be supported. The assertions you're making have to be supported by the data and all types of data. And if there's a type of data that doesn't support your model, first question whether the data are good.
01:17:46.000 --> 01:18:00.000
They're generated in a robust way. And if they were, you can't ignore them. You can't ignore that one class of data because it doesn't make sense. In our studies on the developing pelvis, we incorporated all these different data sets and they made sense.
01:18:00.000 --> 01:18:11.000
They connected very well. And we did not have to ignore pieces of data. In fact, we modified our model along the way. as we learn more about the different contributions from different data types.
01:18:12.000 --> 01:18:43.000
And so we want our hypotheses to be robust and strong, and they have to be strong against all different types of inquiry, right? And that's what I think is probably most important. The other thing I would say is, from an evolutionary lens, that the tissues in biology is complex It's hierarchically complex in very different ways, in very complicated ways, with lots of genes and regulatory sequences and networks interacting with themselves. And there's likely no gene for a trait.
01:18:43.000 --> 01:19:01.000
It's more a complicated series of changes that have to be tolerated and allow for the generation of variation in a trait for the selection to occur to that trait to eventually manifest into what we see in nature. And that's going to be underpinned by many different genetic changes. not just one.
01:19:02.000 --> 01:19:05.000
All right. Well, Professor Terrence Capellini, thank you very much for your time. This was fascinating.
01:19:06.000 --> 01:19:08.000
Oh, thank you. It was a wonderful conversation. I appreciate it.
01:19:17.000 --> 01:19:36.000
Visit mindandmatter.substack.com to find all of my content. If you like to read like I do, then you should check out the ReadWise app. It's totally free to download, and if you go through the link in the episode description or on my support page, you can get a free 60-day trial for zero cost. ReadWise is a really cool app.
01:19:36.000 --> 01:20:11.000
that allows you to import digital highlights from over 30 different platforms such as Kindle, iBooks, PDFs, and more. It makes it really easy for you to review and find and share excerpts and quotes from whatever it is that you're reading, whether it's PDFs of scientific papers or books that you're reading on your Kindle, and you can even save and use highlights from physical books. I read a lot of physical books before bed, for example, or when I'm traveling, and the Readwise app actually integrates with the camera on your phone so that you can take a photo of a page that you're reading, highlight a specific chunk of text from that page, and export it to the app so that you can reference it or find it or share it later.
01:20:11.000 --> 01:20:32.000
They even allow you to export really cool looking graphics of some of the highlights that you have in the books or the papers you're reading so that you can share them in an engaging way. So check out the Readwise app today if you are a reader and you like to reference and organize what you read. Go through the link in the episode description or on my support page or in my free weekly newsletter at mindandmatter.substack.com and try the ReadWise app 60 days free today.