TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:06
Speaker 1: You're listening to the Kerrywood and Mornings podcast from Newstalk ZB. As you've just heard, unemployment has risen further. Stats NZ data shows the rate was 5.7% in the September quarter, up from the 11-year high of 5.6% in the June quarter. Job numbers have been rising across most of the country, particularly in Otago and Canterbury. and in public administration and health care. However, the numbers of people wanting those jobs have also risen. Economists were predicting an unemployment rate of between 5.4% and 5.6%. Infometrics Principal Economist Brad Olsen joins me now. And a very good morning to you. Good morning. Good morning, good morning. Is 0.1%, how many families, how many people does that mean will be affected by that?
00:01:02
Speaker 2: The Stats NZ figures suggest around 3,000 people additional are counted as unemployed in the September 2026 quarter. And that comes as you've got around 4,000 fewer that were employed with the sort of difference going back into what we call the not in labour force group. So some people may well have lost roles and they've become officially unemployed. Some might not even be looking for work anymore. You know, things have changed. Their circumstances are different. And so we have seen quite a big lift in that other group, that not in labour force group, which suggests, again, there might well be some more disenfranchised people out there who are going, look, it's just not that easy. The number of jobs available out there compared to the number of people looking makes the choice pretty difficult. There's a lot of competition. So some real pressure is showing through in the labour market, particularly when we also saw quite a large increase in the number of part-time workers who and a decline in the number of full-time workers. So clearly some changes in how the labour market is stacking up at the moment.
00:02:06
Speaker 1: It's not a figure the government would have been happy with, as we've got a few days to go before we can cast our vote, our final day for casting our vote. But at the same time, a lot of people would be putting off hiring until they know which way the political wind is blowing, wouldn't they?
00:02:26
Speaker 2: To a degree. I mean, we hear a lot about that sort of freezing of activity, be it hiring or investment or anything else that can happen before an election. It's sometimes hard to look at the numbers and pin it down quite so definitively. I suspect that it's more that there's a lot of caution still amongst businesses, yes, because of the election, but also because of what's happening overseas. I mean, clearly the US midterms could have an influence on the likes of Conflict in the Middle East and then what happens to oil prices and everything else. So for businesses, they probably are just being quite cautious around their hiring intentions at the moment. And we're seeing that despite the fact that economic activity itself is actually showing a bit more improvement. And I suspect when you look through it all, it is, you know, in some of those areas, it is businesses who are maybe not putting it off so much as just going, I'm not sure if the conditions are right for me to put someone in now. particularly when there's also AI and technology coming forward. So a lot of reasons that employers might be changing their thoughts around. I think that level of caution, though, speaks to the fact that you have seen that increase in part-time work. I mean, it was a fairly substantial lift we saw there. On a seasonally adjusted basis, there was a 2.5% lift in part-timers. That's one of the largest quarterly lifts we've seen in the last couple of years. And you generally see that when businesses are going, look, I do need a bit more talent, I need some more people, but I don't know if I can fully commit to a full 40-hour-a-week person at the moment. So I'll take someone on part-time, gives me a little bit of relief, but doesn't fully, fully commit me to more hours.
00:04:04
Speaker 1: Do we know, do the numbers tell us if these are young people that are doing the part-time work?
00:04:11
Speaker 2: There's an element of that. I mean, to be fair, it's young people who just don't have the jobs to start with either at the moment. If we look at the number of young people aged 15 to 24, there was a decline in employment there of around 3,000 or so people, unemployment up around 8,000, with the difference there coming from more young people who would be looking to hopefully enter the workforce. Again, they're struggling to find roles, and so they're not even sometimes looking and going into that other group. It means that the NEET rate now, those who are not in education, employment or training, is up to nearly 14%. So clearly some challenges there. And I know young people will be often going through exams at the moment or they'll be thinking about roles for the year ahead. And clearly that does become pretty tough. When we've looked before at some of the job ads out there, the numbers of roles being advertised, there's still something like three times as many people applying for every job available out there compared to, say, pre-pandemic levels. So competition is extremely strong across all age groups, but in particular for young people, when you're up against someone that might be 20 years your senior that might have had, you know, experience in a job, you sort of just can't compete. You can't get experience without having experience is the real conundrum for so many. Mm-hmm.
00:05:38
Speaker 1: And it looks like Australia is not going to be able to absorb quite as many if you look at the figures over there.
00:05:44
Speaker 2: No, their unemployment rate has increased as well, not quite to the same degree as where New Zealand's is, but again, it's going up. Of course, their inflation rate is also higher, and recently their interest rates have continued to climb too. And with all of that, you've also got their
Load full transcript
housing market that's sort of in a level of decline. So that idea previously where some Kiwis would look to head for Australia for better jobs, maybe better housing outcomes or similar if they were looking to invest, that sort of started to turn around. And to be fair, Australia is not the only area that we see that. We looked recently at some of the number of Kiwis who had visas to head off to the UK, often a pretty well-trodden route for overseas experiences. Outside of COVID, the number of New Zealanders getting a UK visa is at its lowest in about 20 years. So Clearly, people are going, there's not really as many great opportunities. I mean, the UK unemployment rate is lifting as well. It is interesting, though, to see the sort of regional differences coming through. Again, if you're a younger person or anyone else in parts of the South Island, not all areas are seeing it easy. But by goodness, there seems to be a bit more economic momentum showing through and greater opportunities in parts of the South Island. The North Island, of course, seeing some much more challenging numbers coming.
00:07:10
Speaker 1: Absolutely. So we have seen a government that hasn't wanted to do the sugar hit of immigration to get those house prices up, which is a good thing. We don't necessarily want to see the public service being expanded back up to where it was again to give a make-job scheme, do we? Surely it's better to have... employment come from increased productivity?
00:07:37
Speaker 2: Oh, absolutely. And I think that the challenge really is for policymakers, how do you create that productivity quickly? Because some of the changes that government has made will likely support greater productivity over time. You look at what's happening in education and so on, but it's never quick. It might well take, you know, years, if not a decade, and clearly people can't wait that long. The challenge, I guess, when we look at government spending and similar, is that unless that persists into the future, and we've seen this, I think, particularly in the public sector and businesses that support the government, is that if you provide a whole bunch of funding for a couple of years, that's good, it produces some employment. when you realise that you can't sustain that level of spending and have to pull the rug out from under people, people go from in a very good position to a very bad position quite quickly. And you can't, that whipsawing, I think, can be quite challenging and destabilising. I mean, Wellington City is, I think, you know, ground zero for that. But even, you know, Auckland, which has had a higher unemployment rate in recent times, has been feeling that pressure where you had construction that sort of went through its best period in about half a century. in the sort of first half of the 2020s. Now, of course, it's pulled back to probably a more reasonable and reliable, consistent level. But again, that sort of up and down sort of shift has really started to undermine some people's expectations of where their roles might be, how they'll make their money, what their earnings might be. I think particularly with inflation, of course, where it is with high fuel prices, people are also having that question with the boss over, look, Obviously, things are tight and the unemployment rate's high, and it's probably easier than before to find talent sometimes. But equally, I think there's starting to be a bit more pressure on businesses around pay. We did see, for example, the likes of wage inflation edge up just a touch, not a lot, to be clear, but just a little bit after sort of a year of it being roughly flat. And that does just indicate a bit more pressure starting to come on around those sort of pay conversations.
00:09:42
Speaker 1: Lovely to talk as always, and thank you for your insights. Brad Olsen, Principal Economist at Infometrics. Love to get your hot takes too.