TRANSCRIPT 🔗
00:00:02
Speaker 1: Hey there, folks. It is Thursday, November 19th. The state of Florida is about to set a record tonight. Not sure it's one they can be proud of, or maybe not. And with that, welcome to this episode of Amy and TJ Rhodes. They set a record last year for the number of executions that are going to beat that record tonight if everything goes as scheduled. Is this something you think DeSantis may be proud of?
00:00:25
Speaker 2: I think he absolutely is.
00:00:27
Speaker 3: I think this is part of what he campaigned on and what he promised us. families, victims, families who've been waiting for decades and decades to see justice carried out.
00:00:38
Speaker 2: What they were told was justice.
00:00:40
Speaker 3: A jury found the person who murdered their loved one guilty, sentenced them to death, and then they wait and they wait and they wait. And so, yes, Ron DeSantis wanted to put an end to that. He wanted to get some of these prisoners who had been on death row for 40 plus years and finally bring some peace to these victims' families.
00:01:01
Speaker 1: And this goes in line with all of that, including Robes, in line with, this is another 71-year-old. And I mean, I think there was a 60-something in there, but for the past several weeks, month plus, Robes, 70, 71, 75, 77. That was a 77-year-old. Was there an 80-year-old in there?
00:01:19
Speaker 2: There was an 80-year-old this summer, yes.
00:01:21
Speaker 1: But this is what he has promised and he has delivered. And once again- There is a 71-year-old man this evening at 6 o'clock there in Florida, Eastern Time, scheduled to die by lethal injection. And this crime, they're all heinous. They're all awful. And every one of them seems like the worst thing I've ever heard. Right?
00:01:46
Speaker 2: It's true.
00:01:47
Speaker 3: You get into the details of what this man was convicted of and.
00:01:54
Speaker 2: look, even folks like us who on principle.
00:01:57
Speaker 3: Are against the death penalty understand why a jury, and it wasn't a unanimous decision by the way, but why a jury sentenced him to death. When you start to hear the details, this is by the way, a crime that happened 35 years ago in August of 1991.
00:02:15
Speaker 1: Yes, this is a, um, this was a double murder. That's actually a triple murder. Um, Because their woman was eight months pregnant. One of the victims, folks, is eight months pregnant. One of the victims that was eight months pregnant was also raped by this man. I do, this is unfathomable. The behavior they describe of this man in that home. It's, it's a, you just don't understand human nature, human being, what's possible here. These things do maybe make you think, wow, evil is walking up and down the street.
00:02:58
Speaker 3: Because if you hear the details in this case, and by the way, I don't know if we've even given, excuse me, we've given the name of the murder in this.
00:03:07
Speaker 2: We have not yet.
00:03:08
Speaker 1: All right.
00:03:09
Speaker 3: This is Thomas Mitchell Overton. Again, 71 years old. And when we take you back to the evening of August 22nd, 1991, imagine, according to prosecutors, this man, Overton, he worked at a gas station, correct? And he was, he kind of became obsessed with, This pregnant woman, he and she had even told folks her name, that there was a creepy gas station attendant who looked at her like prey. That's how much of an impression he made on her.
00:03:46
Speaker 2: She went by Missy, right? Michael and Missy McIver were their names.
00:03:51
Speaker 1: The picture is so cute. Yes. It's an old school. They look straight out of the 80s. It is an amazing picture. The one I'm talking about just to give you, you've seen this one. That's just, that's awesome. That's just awesome. All in white. They look just perfect.
00:04:08
Speaker 3: They look.
00:04:08
Speaker 1: Perfectly 80s, right? Adorable, yes.
00:04:11
Speaker 3: Like a wedding cake topper for two people married in the 80s.
00:04:15
Speaker 2: Yes.
00:04:16
Speaker 1: Although, their ages, they were very young. They were expecting their first child. A boy had a name picked out that just finished the nursery.
00:04:27
Speaker 2: Kyle Patrick.
00:04:28
Speaker 1: That's what we're talking about here. This unsuspecting couple that had everything that they were looking forward to in a very short time. It was all taken away by a stranger in a From a gas station.
00:04:40
Speaker 3: Who had some weird fixation on Missy. And yes, her sister told investigators, my sister's telling me about this creepy gas station attendant. But what does he do? They believe, actually, she wrote a check to pay for gas. And they believe that he, I had not even thought about this. Back in the day, when we would write checks for things, your address would be on those checks. And so police believe that he saw... the address where she lived because he, she wrote a check for the gas and they believe he then staked out this couple, their home. And the idea that he cut the phone lines, climbed into a second floor window. And this is one of the more disturbing parts hid in the damn nursery that the couple had just painted in expectation for their new baby boy that they believe they were bringing home in about a month's time.
00:05:35
Speaker 2: How sad is that?
00:05:37
Speaker 3: This man dressed in a ninja outfit hiding out in a baby's nursery for an unborn child and knew what he was about to do.
00:05:48
Speaker 1: And he was about to die in a matter of hours in Florida. He will be the 20th person executed, which would set a new record for the state of Florida. That is the most executions they've had in one year. A hell of a difference from a couple years ago. Their record was 8. 8 in one year. Last year it went to 19. That's obviously a huge jump, 100% jump. And now it's going up. And the record's going to be set tonight. But this isn't done. Is it one more or two more?
00:06:29
Speaker 2: I believe there are two
Load full transcript
more.
00:06:30
Speaker 3: I believe if all goes according to plan and there are no more scheduled executions, Florida may land on 22 executions for 2026.
00:06:40
Speaker 1: And he has the right, the ability still, to sign another one before he leaves office because they have to give it 30 days. So before this year is out, he still has time to sign others. This couple, to add two, I guess how heinous. Some of these details. You mentioned the nursery. He enters through the nursery, hides in the nursery. And what they describe at this point is a scene of horror in that home for these two. They weren't together at the time. He was in a different part of the house from where she was.
00:07:10
Speaker 2: He was getting a glass of milk, correct?
00:07:11
Speaker 1: He attacks them separately. Attacks him in the... kitchen or coming from that milk but leaves him ties him up wrote what they describe it had masking tape blindfolded them tied them up leaves the man in one spot goes chases the woman apparently uh susan upstairs she's eight months pregnant what they describe he did to her baby.
00:07:34
Speaker 3: Ties her up with a clothesline a belt and a necktie. So he's found a way using household items to restrain her before he rapes her. And then he goes on eventually to strangle her to death and her husband, but he binded their heads with masking tape. And look, there are reports, according to the medical examiner who testified at his trial, The unborn baby, whose name was going to be Kyle Patrick, lived, they believe, for about an hour and a half after his mom died. He died in the womb, but was still alive after his mother's death.
00:08:19
Speaker 1: I mean, they could have saved that child, right?
00:08:21
Speaker 2: Absolutely.
00:08:22
Speaker 1: Oh, good chance. Oh, absolutely.
00:08:24
Speaker 3: Uh, there's no, I don't believe if they were able to, if they were able to get to her body in a quick period of time, yes, there absolutely would have been the opportunity to save that child's life.
00:08:37
Speaker 1: And we keep, uh, they've talking about how awful, I mean, it's heinous enough. Kill two people. One of them's pregnant. It's terrible stuff. You hear how they were tied up. You are using the nursery and whatnot. Uh, Prosecutors say he confessed to a witness that he actually saw her stomach moving and put his hand on it and actually felt the baby after he had done this to the woman. It's hard to find sympathy no matter what you feel about the death penalty. We still need to talk about this is a human life that we're supposed to respect. This is as disrespectful to human life That was a story you're going to hear.
00:09:18
Speaker 3: And on top of that, he's maintained his innocence from the beginning, has never admitted to this heinous murder other than this alleged, yes, confession he made. But publicly, to the courts, to the family members left behind, he's never admitted it.
00:09:36
Speaker 1: Kim Kardashian has not taken his case on.
00:09:38
Speaker 2: No, she has not.
00:09:39
Speaker 1: The point here being there is not a groundswell of support. Oh, you got to test this.
00:09:45
Speaker 2: There's DNA evidence linking him to the murders.
00:09:47
Speaker 1: There's none of that.
00:09:49
Speaker 3: Yeah, and it took officials a very long time, years, to actually make this arrest because, look, this murder happened in 1991.
00:09:57
Speaker 2: No arrests, by the way.
00:10:00
Speaker 3: Then he is arrested on a completely unrelated burglary charge in October of 1996, so a full five years later.
00:10:11
Speaker 2: He actually tried to.
00:10:14
Speaker 3: Kill himself after this arrest, and the blood that he lost... with his suicide attempt, was used to match DNA to the semen recovered from the McIver house. So the fact that he raped Missy, the fact that he tried to kill himself, those two things ended up being his undoing and that DNA matched.
00:10:42
Speaker 1: How.
00:10:43
Speaker 2: Wild is that twist.
00:10:45
Speaker 1: We're just in different times and what DNA can do and how you can find somebody. Is that person in the system kind of a thing? He wasn't in the system until he put himself in the system, if you will, and gave them another opportunity to catch him. And that is why we are. Who knows how long this could have gone and would have gone if they would have caught him. He fell under that law. I think it's another state that has this, right? Another southern state to where a jury could... give you the death penalty without a unanimous vote of that jury. Is there another state?
00:11:17
Speaker 3: It varies from state to state and laws have changed throughout the years. Um, but at one point, yes, it, you did not have to have a unanimous jury verdict to sentence someone to death.
00:11:29
Speaker 1: He missed that cutoff baby when they changed the law because he was sentenced to death separately on these two cases. Nine to three was the jury vote with Susan. I'm, I guess, I don't know. This is just how it goes. But they had two separate death penalty phases for him, one having to do with the man, one having to do with the woman.
00:11:50
Speaker 3: Yeah, I mean, different prosecutors, different times, different votes.
00:11:53
Speaker 2: It's all very interesting. And by the way, we should mention he protested his innocence.
00:11:57
Speaker 3: His whole, his defense the entire time, if you're curious, because if there's DNA literally linking him to the crime scene, he's claiming he was set up, right? He claims that police planted evidence. and that it wasn't him. And so he's said that all along. He claims that he was being persecuted by police because he says he had an affair with a deputy's wife who was a detective. And so the detective wanted to get him back and pinned these murders and this rape on him.
00:12:27
Speaker 2: That's what he claimed. Obviously, the jury didn't buy it. Okay.
00:12:32
Speaker 1: Everybody says that, right? Everybody on death row
is... Is innocent or has been set up. This is though, however, folks, in Florida, his execution method is going to be different from another execution. We haven't even mentioned, have we, Robes? This is a double execution day in the United States, Florida and Texas. Those are always the two leading states, for the most part, in this country for years and years and years. Florida has taken over.
00:13:00
Speaker 2: A massive lead.
00:13:01
Speaker 1: They have. However, these two states do have two different execution methods. methods. One of them uses the same method that they used in Tennessee on Krista Pike. Stay here.
00:13:22
Speaker 3: Welcome back to Amy and TJ. Thomas Mitchell Overton will become the record-setting execution in the state of Florida. He will become the 20th inmate executed in that state, set to happen at 6 p.m. Eastern time in Florida for the it's a double murder, but really a triple murder because he killed a couple. Susan Missy is what she went by, Missy McIver and her husband, Michael McIver. She was eight months pregnant with a little boy who was set to be named Patrick, correct? Sorry, Kyle Patrick, excuse me, Kyle Patrick. And just, we went into the details of this heinous, heinous murder. But Her sister, Missy's sister, Sharon, has been speaking out. And she was the one who told police, hey, there's this creepy gas station attendant you should look at. Well, she has been outspoken throughout all of this. And it's sad to think this happened 35 years ago. And she said her parents passed away actually pretty quickly after the deaths occurred. of her sister after he was sentenced. She said, I feel like their lives were shortened by the grief. They were never the same. That is so understandable. But she says that both her mother and her father would have wanted to be in that execution chamber witnessing his death tonight.
00:14:41
Speaker 2: And so because of that, she says she will be.
00:14:44
Speaker 3: There tonight to stand in for her parents and She said it's important for their sake that she's present to see this through to the end. And that's part of what DeSantis is trying to do here. He's saying these families were promised. They were told that this was closure, that this was justice. And so to not actually bring it home for them is an injustice to these families.
00:15:09
Speaker 1: They never saw justice carry out. Their family members were brutally tortured. Tortured. And treated this way by this man who has now outlived them. That's not, I don't know, no matter what you feel about the death penalty, you feel as a human being, your heart goes out to these families who are sick. The parents are dead. Yeah.
00:15:35
Speaker 3: And you know what, to your point, what you just said, Sharon said, talking about her sister and her husband, they were a delightful, wholesome couple who had their whole lives ahead of him. When she talked about Overton, she said, this guy was just an animal.
00:15:49
Speaker 2: That is how she described him.
00:15:50
Speaker 1: There's no other way to describe at least the... I mean, it's hard. Who was the judge recently just said, look, I don't think people are monstrous, but you did something monstrous. This is a difficult one who, once again, we should... I don't know if we mentioned, he was from the Dozier Boy School as well. This guy is... I say graduate. No, he was a survivor is what they called him of the Dozier Boy School that was down there 100 years. The state has now apologized for the behavior. I mean, even the same... Kids were killed there. There's supposed to be a reform.
00:16:21
Speaker 2: School for boys. Tortured, raped, killed.
00:16:23
Speaker 1: Horrific conditions to where they have a count of at least 34 boys from that school ended up on death row.
00:16:31
Speaker 3: Yes, and they say nearly 100 others were killed in that facility over a period of years. And so, yes, it's not that he shouldn't be held accountable. I mean, we can't still describe him as an animal, but it did appear that this Dozier School for Boys created monstrous.
00:16:49
Speaker 2: people who had monstrous things done to them.
00:16:53
Speaker 3: And then in turn did that when they were set free to members of their own community, because that's what they knew.
00:16:59
Speaker 1: It was the opposite, right? It was supposed to reform them. And what it did was it was almost.
00:17:03
Speaker 2: A, they took them into killing machines.
00:17:05
Speaker 1: It was a graduate school for criminals, right?
00:17:08
Speaker 2: For murderers.
00:17:08
Speaker 1: This is where you learn to be worse than you were when you came in. This is, this school is, it's remarkable. How can one place produce that? It's like talking about a, A good high school that produces a bunch of Ivy League kids.
00:17:23
Speaker 2: This is the opposite.
00:17:24
Speaker 1: It's the complete opposite. I do not understand how you could have that many folks from one school end up on death row.
00:17:32
Speaker 3: I totally forgot that he was one of the young boys who was... sentenced to or assigned to that school.
00:17:41
Speaker 1: Wasn't the last guy? No, the last guy was a veteran. Was he a Dozier person as well?
00:17:45
Speaker 3: Yes.
00:17:45
Speaker 1: Guardado.
00:17:46
Speaker 2: Yeah, Guardado.
00:17:47
Speaker 3: Guardado was absolutely at the Dozier School for Boys as well.
00:17:52
Speaker 1: This Thomas Overton was a vet as well. Did I see the number right? 67% of veterans that end up on death row are in Florida. This is the 15th vet that is going to be executed under desantis's watch what is happening bro that is a failure he did something monstrous he was developed into a monster he was coached almost into the i know baby but but you have to give some consideration to what people have gone on not suggesting leniency of any way but well how do you baby balance and have sympathy We need to understand.
00:18:38
Speaker 3: We need to understand how these people are created. Yes, I know that there's always this argument, you know, are you born that way?
00:18:46
Speaker 2: Are you made that way?
00:18:47
Speaker 3: But you have to look at so many of these death penalty cases in Florida and then look and see that they all came from this same reform school.
00:18:57
Speaker 2: You have to acknowledge that.
00:18:59
Speaker 3: And it has to have some level of acceptance that these monstrous murderers were created in a lot of ways by the state of Florida.
00:19:08
Speaker 1: Some people just are dismissive. You hear what he did and don't want to hear anything else. Don't care about his background. We have to incorporate that into these conversations. He'll get a three-dose cocktail tonight. Florida is a state that does a three-dose lethal injection. not the case in Texas. That'll be different tonight.
00:19:29
Speaker 3: Texas will be doing the same type of method that Tennessee used and has used, the single dose of pentobarbital. But Texas has just, I think, recently done two executions, same method, no problems, within 15 minutes pronounced dead. The most recent executions have, I hate to say, gone off without a hitch, but actually there's no other way to put it.
00:19:52
Speaker 2: That is what's happened. They've been uneventful.
00:19:54
Speaker 3: And honestly, after Krista Pike, we're grateful for uneventful executions.
00:19:59
Speaker 1: We'll keep an eye on this one. It's always fascinating to hear what the final words might be. Don't know if we'll get some tonight or not. Also, in a moment... You can check our feed here in just a little bit. We'll give you a preview of the execution taking place in Texas tonight. Another hell of a story, hell of a background, but we appreciate you as always spending time with us. For my dear Amy Robach, I'm TJ Holmes. We'll talk soon.