TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
1
00:00:01.740 --> 00:00:11.920
Hi there. This is Attorney Matthew Hill, along with Attorney Carol Ponton, coming to you live from Hill & Ponton on another veterans Q&A session. We are excited to be here and excited to be back.
2
00:00:11.980 --> 00:00:20.950
I have been gone for the last several weeks on some trips, one of which was our Nova trip that, uh, Carol and I are gonna talk about as far as learning more from the VA about what's going on.
3
00:00:21.440 --> 00:00:29.960
Uh, but first let's just jump into some questions, and then Carol has, uh, Carol has some more stuff to talk about when it comes to VA exams, but we'll wait till there's more folks on that.
4
00:00:30.040 --> 00:00:40.720
So let's jump in, get our first question. Michael: "Do any of your clients have success when filing claims for chronic fatigue syndrome? It's a Gulf War presumption, so I'm thinking about filing. I have a diagnosis."
5
00:00:41.240 --> 00:00:48.970
That should be an automatic grant. If you were in the Gulf, you have chronic fatigue, that's all you need. Okay? Um, it becomes a little- But you need treatment.
6
00:00:49.080 --> 00:00:57.680
Yeah, you really need to make sure you have treatment that gives you a current diagnosis of chronic fatigue. That's where I'm seeing a lot of the problems. Yeah.
7
00:00:57.750 --> 00:01:05.140
One thing- They're going and complaining about being fatigued, but they're not diagnosed with chronic fatigue. Yeah. And, and that's the thing.
8
00:01:05.200 --> 00:01:18.880
If you, if you don't have the diagnosis, then what the VA can do is try to say, "Oh, you're not diagnosed with, uh, with this disability," and therefore they won't give it to you. Right, Carol? Right.
9
00:01:20.560 --> 00:01:29.300
Um, in that event though, see that's the problem. You guys ask us tight, short questions, but we always have these expansive answers. If they come back and say, "Hey, you don't have chronic fatigue.
10
00:01:29.400 --> 00:01:38.380
You've got these touch points. It looks like you have this problem," guess what? That's Gulf War syndrome, and you still get service connected. It's heads you win, tails they lose in this, okay?
11
00:01:38.440 --> 00:01:43.540
You wanna have the, the diagnosis 'cause that just makes it easier, but if you don't, don't stop fighting, okay?
12
00:01:43.620 --> 00:01:58.680
Because if you don't have a diagnosis, yet they concede in their C&P exam that you do have problems, you know, there, there is some kind of disability, uh, affecting you systematically, then you need to fight and say, "Well, that's Gulf War syndrome," if it's not, uh, if, if it's not just IB...
13
00:01:58.930 --> 00:02:09.039
or not obvious chronic fatigue syndrome. But a- as Matt says, it just makes it harder because they don't recognize it. You're gonna have to go up to someone who finally does recognize what the law encompasses.
14
00:02:09.100 --> 00:02:22.660
So if you have a diagnosis of chronic fatigue, it sure makes it
Load full transcript
easier. Yeah. Okay. Let's, uh, Joseph: "Hello. Received a letter from VA for favorable findings. VA failed duty to assist. Now I have a second C&P exam.
15
00:02:22.740 --> 00:02:33.040
Is that normal?" Yes. Probably means the first one was, yeah, w- w- just didn't do what it was supposed to, and they're sending you back hopefully to clarify some, you know, some small part or big part.
16
00:02:36.180 --> 00:02:47.960
James: "How do I get more from the VA on a rating for leaky urine and wearing briefs after prostate treatment?" Carol, you see this all the time. I do. Okay, so the VA looks at a number of things.
17
00:02:47.980 --> 00:02:59.740
They look at how many times you get up at night, how many times, how often do you have to go to the bathroom during the day. So if it's less than an hour a day, every less than an hour, then that's a 60% rating.
18
00:03:00.020 --> 00:03:11.900
If you wear pads and they have to be changed at least four times a day, that's a higher rating. Uh, if you're totally incontinent, that's something even more so. So what you need to do is clarify the record.
19
00:03:12.280 --> 00:03:19.020
You know, you need to put in a statement about exactly how, where you fit in in that rating, and if you...
20
00:03:19.030 --> 00:03:28.680
Uh, you know, these pads are free from the VA, so you ask the VA to send you pads and tell them how many you need to use a day. Is it more than four? Um, so that's how you prove your case.
21
00:03:29.060 --> 00:03:46.700
And Carol, you know what we see that's so frustrating is in cancer cases, and we see this a lot in prostate cancer, is when you have the cancer, when you're treating for it, and you have, uh, what, radiculopathy, not radiculopathy, uh, you're, you're getting, uh [tsks]- You can get neuropathy.
22
00:03:46.760 --> 00:03:56.720
You can get pain- No, no, no, I'm, I'm sorry. What I'm saying is if you're treating for it and you're going through ch- chemo, let's say- Right, or radiation... radiation, that's what I was trying to say.
23
00:03:56.840 --> 00:04:07.410
Uh, if, if you're try- if you're going through either of those, you're 100%, boom. But once you stop, your, your, your prostate goes down to zero, okay? And, and that makes no sense because as you're seeing here, James,
24
00:04:08.560 --> 00:04:10.040
y- you can have all these secondary problems.
25
00:04:10.080 --> 00:04:19.140
So what Carol and I see a lot are veterans who get dropped to zero, yet there is no way in the world they could work due to their incontinence and due to their problems and due to secondary depression.
26
00:04:19.160 --> 00:04:25.219
And so you just need to, to take stock of all those issues, depression as well, and file and see what you get.
27
00:04:25.260 --> 00:04:33.200
If you get over 60% and you're not working, I mean, let's, let's face it, if you're having to use multiple pads a day, there's probably a good chance you're having accidents.
28
00:04:33.840 --> 00:04:38.700
Um, you need to
file for unemployability if you can't stay in the workforce. Right.
29
00:04:38.720 --> 00:04:54.220
But, and these, if you have cancer, you need to start setting your case up because, as Matt says, as soon as the treatment, chemo, radiation, as soon as it's in remission, you're gonna be zero unless you have proven to them that you have ongoing problems, so everybody has depression from this.
30
00:04:54.800 --> 00:05:05.250
As soon as you get cancer, file for service connection for the depression so that's ongoing. But then you need to document, "I'm having leakage. I have to go to the bathroom all the time. I'm every 30 minutes.
31
00:05:05.380 --> 00:05:17.140
I'm up all night long. I have neuropathy in my hands because of the radiation or the chemo." It... You need to be proactive on this, 'cause they will drop you to zero immediate- They're supposed to reevaluate you.
32
00:05:17.270 --> 00:05:28.640
They do not. What they do is they see the day treatment stop, and then they drop you. So, uh, this happens to everybody, and you need to know, and you need to be proactive. And, and one more note on the depression.
33
00:05:28.880 --> 00:05:38.320
You know, most people think of depression as just, like, this overwhelming sadness or sitting there all day. What Carol and I are talking about is you had, you have, you had an identity, right?
34
00:05:38.360 --> 00:05:49.220
Who you were, you worked, what you could do at home. Once you have cancer, that just can destroy or at least completely alter your identity, and going through that change is not a positive change. Right.
35
00:05:49.320 --> 00:05:57.240
That leads to things like doubting yourself, wondering why you can't hang out with family more, wondering why you can't do the job you used to. That's what we see.
36
00:05:57.270 --> 00:06:07.780
And so when we say just, we're, we're not just saying off our cuff, "Just go file depression," we're saying, "This, this is what you're going through, whether you realize it-" This is real. Yeah.Uh, erectile dysfunction.
37
00:06:07.790 --> 00:06:20.800
Okay, I'll give you a minute on, oh. That's another thing. If you've got bladder, prostate, you probably have erectile dysfunction. Uh, loss of, uh, female arousal if there's, uh, some kind of, um, gynecological,
38
00:06:22.020 --> 00:06:38.180
um, cancer. So if you have any of those things, you need to tell the VA, 'cause they're not gonna do that for you. All right. Let's go again here. Uh, we got, "Good morning, Brian.
39
00:06:38.220 --> 00:06:51.280
At the end of December '22, I was awarded service connection for five claims that I was denied back in 2013 by a BVA judge." It's your follow-on. "What is the process after a judge makes a decision?
40
00:06:51.700 --> 00:07:03.200
Will I have another C&P, or will they use my past exams? It's May, and no new notice from, or info from the VA." You will have- When was, when was that decision, January? It was in December last year.
41
00:07:03.280 --> 00:07:13.020
And I wonder, was it a BV- it didn't say whether it was a BVA or not. It did. It said it was a BVA grant service connection. All right. This is something I'm having a problem with, um,
42
00:07:14.620 --> 00:07:27.620
my clients are having a problem with. The BVA will grant, um, benefits, and it goes right through, and then all of a sudden I'll have a veteran where the BVA grants, and it's like the case gets thrown into the trash can.
43
00:07:27.740 --> 00:07:39.920
I send emails. I do everything I can, and it's like it's in this black hole. And we have heard that this is a backdoor way for the VA to ask the BVA, "Did you really mean it? Are you really giving these people?"
44
00:07:40.080 --> 00:07:51.020
I don't know what's going on, but I have had a number of veterans who have this problem. I cannot get any action. So what I tell my clients to do is you call your congressman, you call your senator, and you keep on them.
45
00:07:51.110 --> 00:08:02.160
"I filed this claim all this time ago. I've been given these benefits. Where, what's going on?" Uh, because it sounds like you are caught in that trap. Otherwise, here's the latest then.
46
00:08:02.180 --> 00:08:09.540
What they, they should do is they should send you out for a C&P exam. But what they do is they look all the way back and see what's the lowest rating they can give you.
47
00:08:09.660 --> 00:08:13.440
They give you that, and then they say they're gonna send you out to see what you currently are.
48
00:08:13.880 --> 00:08:26.959
So if you haven't gotten that, especially in this time, you're in that black hole, and you need to call your congressman, your senator, and s- have them complain for you. I can't say it any better than that, Carol.
49
00:08:28.960 --> 00:08:38.920
Am I using my team-building voice? Am I a little harsh here? [laughs] I'm a little irritated about how they treat veterans. Randy, "Who invented VA math?"
50
00:08:39.280 --> 00:08:52.300
[laughs] I don't know, but I bet you they put that guy in hiding, 'cause- [laughs]... the most frustrating thing I've ever [laughs] anyway. What, what you don't, what I didn't realize right away is it, they don't say,
51
00:08:53.380 --> 00:09:07.540
they say combine, but it's in the VA, it's not like add. They don't use the word add, they combine. And so what combining is, they take whatever percentage of the body you have, 40%, and they say, "Okay, that's gone.
52
00:09:07.680 --> 00:09:18.720
You don't have any more. You only have 60% of your body left." So the next time you get a rating, it's, if it's 10%, it's 10% of 60%, so it's 6, um, and so on.
53
00:09:18.760 --> 00:09:27.100
And that's why it's so hard to get, uh, higher and higher ratings. But you're right, it's crazy. [laughs] All right.
54
00:09:27.200 --> 00:09:34.760
John Johnson, "Can enrolling in the VA's Psychosocial Rehabilitation Recovery Center Program help or hurt my mental health for TDIU claim?"
55
00:09:35.380 --> 00:09:43.380
Well, first
of all, let's talk about two different things, one, your health, and two, your benefits, okay? If you need this for your health, you need this for your health, and you need to go, okay?
56
00:09:44.160 --> 00:09:53.700
Um, if you, you know, w- when I look at benefits-wise, I don't see how this hurts you. You know, if, if you go and you get completely better, you don't wanna be on TDIU.
57
00:09:53.820 --> 00:10:04.470
You wanna go back in the world, you wanna reassimilate. You know, TDIU is basically kind of the, you know, it's, it's, it's what you need if it's the last bastion of, uh, you know, benefits if you cannot work.
58
00:10:05.280 --> 00:10:14.360
But I think if you go in that program, it's kind of a honest assessment, showing how you are, and hopefully it's a program where they document everything that's going on. You need to be honest.
59
00:10:14.520 --> 00:10:21.840
You need to say what's going on, if you're having suicidal ideation, homicidal ideation, if you can't be around people, if you hate listening to authority.
60
00:10:22.260 --> 00:10:33.180
You know, you need to lay all that out there and let them know this is what's going on, and hopefully that gets documented. If that's documented in their own PRRC program, that's pretty hard for them to ignore.
61
00:10:33.220 --> 00:10:36.900
You know- Yeah... it's not like they can say, "Oh, this is your treating doctor. He's just trying to be nice to you."
62
00:10:36.920 --> 00:10:45.060
No, you, you went into serious recovery, and, it, so I, I think you should, you know, your health's the most important. And if they're saying you need to do it, I think you need to do it for your health.
63
00:10:45.400 --> 00:11:01.320
But for your benefits, I don't really see a downside. I agree. Go for it. Modern Intelligence, "EOD tech with VA and DOD-approved evidence of chemical warfare agent in Afghanistan. Believe it will help other vets.
64
00:11:01.760 --> 00:11:10.220
May I speak to Mr. Kerry, Ms. Ponton, or Mr. Hill?" Um, let's see. If you, y- uh, yeah, how do I get you to reach out to us?
65
00:11:10.680 --> 00:11:17.960
I know that Kerry Baker would love to know this, 'cause he is just so great with chemical agents and, and understanding how they affect people.
66
00:11:18.080 --> 00:11:28.979
And if you look on our, you know, look on our website, you can see how many different places we have that we've kind of marked for chemical exposure. Um, I don't know his... Do this for me.
67
00:11:29.310 --> 00:11:42.140
Go to our info, um, if you just go to our general email and put, "For Matt Hill and Kerry Baker, chem exposure," then I will know, if you put that in that subject line, th- they'll route it to me, and I'll get it to him, okay?
68
00:11:42.780 --> 00:11:55.140
Um, I just can't remember his email off the top of my head. [laughs] I can't either. Sorry. So anyway, but that's, that's great. Thank you so much for that. It's that time. It's good to see you. It's been a while.
69
00:11:56.040 --> 00:12:07.920
"For a rating of disabilities 40% requiring insulin and restricted diet and regulation of activities, please define regulation of activities sec-" [laughs] uh, "except before increase to Carol, uh, to 40%."
70
00:12:07.980 --> 00:12:20.676
Carol, you go first on this one.I don't know what it is anymore, and the Diabetes Association doesn't know what it is according to the VA. Because, [laughs] no matter what we put down, they keep denying it.
71
00:12:20.756 --> 00:12:31.916
I don't know what they're doing. Everybody who has diabetes that requires a lot of insulin and diabetic diet, diet has to regulate their activities. Yeah. But the VA, for some reason, is...
72
00:12:32.456 --> 00:12:38.336
I don't know what they're doing. They, you know, you'll see, they'll grant, they'll grant, and then all of a sudden no one gets 40%.
73
00:12:38.556 --> 00:12:46.336
That's what we're seeing lately, and we have no idea how they've changed the, the rules, because it's their rules. Yeah. And they don't tell us what the rules are.
74
00:12:47.176 --> 00:12:57.756
I, I mean, the first thing to do is go to your doctor and say, "You got me on insulin. Uh, my diet's being restricted. What, what can I can't do?" Or, "What can I and cannot do?"
75
00:12:57.776 --> 00:13:05.896
And then get him to write that down, what kind of, what kind of issues he believes you... You know, can you not run? Can you not go eight hours without, uh, eating? I, I, I don't know.
76
00:13:05.996 --> 00:13:13.936
Just get him to write all that down. That's where we used to win, is have the vets treating doctors say, "This is the regulation of activities that the person can do."
77
00:13:14.016 --> 00:13:22.996
But, as Carol said, the VA decided, no, we know better than, than the treating V- the treating diabetic doctor. So, uh, that's a frustrating one, because it's- Very...
78
00:13:23.036 --> 00:13:30.556
it's nebulous and, and they- they've decided just to, frankly, not define it. Right. So I, I would also do exactly what Matt said.
79
00:13:30.736 --> 00:13:43.776
I would go in and say, "When I tried to jog, when I tried to work out, even when I hadn't eaten for just two hours, my, my insulin dropped. I got really light-headed. Um, I do these activities and they really bother me."
80
00:13:43.856 --> 00:13:53.136
If you're, if you're doctoring the record, then maybe there's a chance at the Court of Appeals. Just telling you, lately, I don't know what's going on, but they're denying them all. Yeah.
81
00:13:53.936 --> 00:14:06.956
It's the definition, and they get to be in charge of it. Modern Intelligence, "Army NG is forcing open my VA 100% P&T nine-year-old rating via IDS process. Who do you recommend to help me in my case?"
82
00:14:09.736 --> 00:14:22.896
So I guess I'm- What is the IDS process? I don't know what that is, and I also don't know what the Army NG is. Army National Guard, okay. It's forcing to open my 100% case. Um- Well, they, Matt, they
do do this.
83
00:14:23.056 --> 00:14:37.516
I find, but once you have had 100%, especially this long, it is very hard. The burden is on the VA to show that you have gotten better in the n- in, in normal life, not just a one-time situation.
84
00:14:37.616 --> 00:14:45.896
So first I'd find out, I want every C- I want all the evidence they have. Give me a copy of my file. And you wanna find out, what have they done lately that makes them think that?
85
00:14:46.056 --> 00:14:54.536
I'd get my VA medical records or whatever medical records have been sent in, and see, is somebody saying you're doing great? I mean, you really need to see where this is coming from.
86
00:14:54.596 --> 00:15:05.716
A lot of times it's just coming from, um, the VA not wanting you to go past that 10 years, because then that's usually permanent and total. You know, there's nothing they can do about that.
87
00:15:06.276 --> 00:15:17.965
But, um, the burden is very much on the VA to show you've had a significant improvement. So I wouldn't be worried about it, um, but I would take those steps. Find out what evidence they're using.
88
00:15:18.356 --> 00:15:31.226
If you have a doctor, please have the doctor fill out a DBQ for you showing you need unemployability and why, related solely to service-connected problems. Remember, anybody can have a good day. Yeah.
89
00:15:31.256 --> 00:15:37.466
And if they feel they caught you on a good day, you need to let them know what the other six days of the week look like, okay? Right.
90
00:15:38.056 --> 00:15:46.516
Y- you know, you put that forward, and you just show them how you're living, through your statements. If you can get statements from loved ones, just showing what it looks like day to day to you, you know? Yeah.
91
00:15:46.556 --> 00:15:58.416
They, they should not be grading you on your good day. They should be grading on you on your, you know, what you are on a, on average every day. Okay. Carlos Ruben Flores Sr., "Good afternoon Carol and Matt.
92
00:15:58.856 --> 00:16:10.456
I have a question. Could you please explain to me what is SMCS, and am I stuck here pay-wise? What do I do to qualify for home improvement due to housebound PTSD? Thank you."
93
00:16:12.656 --> 00:16:27.796
So it looks like he's SMCS, Carol, for, uh, for housebound. SMCS, VA has some very strange definitions. SMCS is called housebound, but it also mostly means something else.
94
00:16:28.196 --> 00:16:43.396
It mostly means that you have 100% rating or a TDIU rating for one condition, or several conditions, but you have additional conditions that add up to 60% for, for other service-connected things, and that gives you SMCS.
95
00:16:43.736 --> 00:16:58.156
Has nothing to do with you being homebound. There is a homebound, which means you can't leave the home. But that is rarely what that means. So if you have SMCS, the only way you get higher is from other SMCs.
96
00:16:58.376 --> 00:17:07.156
So you need to look at the rating schedule and see if you qualify. Most of these are pretty dire. Loss of sight, loss of vision, loss of hearing.
97
00:17:07.716 --> 00:17:21.836
Um, now they do have, um, inability to use your, loss of use of feet and hands, which doesn't mean you've lost them, but it, you've lost the ability to use them, like balancing on your feet or picking up things, small things with your hands.
98
00:17:22.336 --> 00:17:27.416
But there are a number of SMCs, and you really need to look at them, 'cause that's the only way you're going to get more money.
99
00:17:28.356 --> 00:17:41.416
A home improvement has to do with keeping you safe because of a service-connected problem, and I don't know, um... So if you have neuropathy and you can't walk, you need a, a ramp or things like that.
100
00:17:41.556 --> 00:17:51.676
But for PTSD, I'm not sure how you would qualify for any home improvement. Uh, I think you'd probably have to have a physical problem in order to qualify for that. Matt, what do you think?
101
00:17:53.436 --> 00:17:57.336
Carol, I've only seen physical problems. I mean- Me too... it, it's interesting.
102
00:17:58.456 --> 00:18:10.216
I don't know what you, you know, if there's something you'd wanna rewire the house as far as if the person has dementia due to PTSD and, you know, you put in a system where the door opens and there's a beep that, that somebody else gets.
103
00:18:11.076 --> 00:18:22.166
I, I don't know, I just don't know what that would look like, but I, I've only seen physical problems as well. Right. I've never seen it just for PTSD or a mental problem. [clears throat] Okay.
104
00:18:23.306 --> 00:18:32.046
Randomly Rusty, "I got my BVA advance on the docket denied. I have a Purple Heart, and it was submitted on the advance because of that.
105
00:18:32.166 --> 00:18:42.266
I was under the impression that was a valid reason, or is that only at the regional level?" Carol? Sometimes you have to point things out to them. Uh, um- Multiple times.
106
00:18:42.326 --> 00:18:52.386
I don't know, but I would do it again and I would, I would ask for, um, reconsideration on my mo- motion, that I have been awarded a Purple Heart and n- you might tell them what it's for.
107
00:18:52.486 --> 00:19:00.326
Attach just a copy, and could you please reconsider this for advance on the docket because I don't know why they turned you down. Um,
108
00:19:01.686 --> 00:19:10.275
but I'm just telling you- I, I don't have the regulation in front of me, but I was gonna say, I don't have the regulation in front of me, but I've, I've got- I've won that before. I have, too.
109
00:19:10.526 --> 00:19:11.366
Advance on the docket with Purple, Purple Hearts.
110
00:19:11.376 --> 00:19:22.706
I've done- But I'm just telling you, sometimes I get these, these opinions and I don't know what, and then I just ask for reconsideration, and that's what I'd do if I were you. Yeah. Okay. All right.
111
00:19:23.426 --> 00:19:36.406
Matthew Thomas, "I'm 90% with TDIU. I'm confused
about whether I should go to 100% P&P or leave well enough alone." I would leave well enough alone. Carol would want more information. Yeah, I would, but I just...
112
00:19:36.466 --> 00:19:48.296
You know, is it possible that you could get 100% for mental and then use the other ratings you have to get SMCS? I don't really know. I don't know how long have you had the 90%.
113
00:19:48.946 --> 00:19:59.946
Uh, is there a chance of losing what you have? I mean, there's so much information that I don't know the answer to here. If you're really, really young, uh, and you just got this rating, I might be more hesitant.
114
00:20:00.006 --> 00:20:12.686
I mean, I, I really would need to know more, but I wouldn't blanketly say, "No, I wouldn't go farther." Jackie Johnson, "Hey there. I'm back with an update on my husband's TDIU claim.
115
00:20:12.766 --> 00:20:25.086
He won his claim, but instead of getting TDIU, he was awarded 100% P&P for his PTSD- Great... and migraines. We are still in shock. Thank you for all- Great... your videos. You and Combat Crazy made this possible."
116
00:20:25.286 --> 00:20:35.696
That is great to hear. That is great news. We love that. Congratulations. And he also got SMCS. Look at that. Perfect. So he makes, he makes Carol happy a- across the board. [laughs] That's wonderful to hear.
117
00:20:35.766 --> 00:20:44.506
It's great to hear success stories, folks, because I know- Congratulations... there's so many people here- And this proves you can do it. Yes, and it proves that you can get the benefits you deserve. Thank you, Jackie.
118
00:20:45.386 --> 00:20:58.366
Carlos, "Three unnecessary exams. All disabilities are static. Over 55. Do I need to show up? Actually 75 years old." Uh, Carlos, I'd wanna know why they have, they're having the exams.
119
00:20:59.306 --> 00:21:10.756
Um, did you reopen something or did they come and say that, "We think you should be reduced"? Usually, you can't just turn down an exam, uh- Yeah... or else they can come after you.
120
00:21:10.766 --> 00:21:15.166
They have a, they have a valid legal argument to reduce you if you're there.
121
00:21:18.726 --> 00:21:29.726
Jackie, "We are now applying for SSDI, but we're wondering if we should get another vocational assessment for that or wait to hear back from the office, SSA office." I'd wait to hear back.
122
00:21:29.746 --> 00:21:37.386
I'd make sure you've submitted any evidence that you gathered, including, uh, favorable C&P exams just to show that, that he can't work.
123
00:21:42.066 --> 00:21:53.666
Reek, [laughs] um, Mai, "I'm a Gulf War veteran covered under 1119 and 1117. I stated that as an argument, the VA did consider the benefit of the doubt rule and did not use my evidence.
124
00:21:54.126 --> 00:22:05.595
What are my chances of winning on HLR?" We hate the benefit of the doubt rule. We're just never given it, and so what we always do is just try to overwhelm them with evidence. Right. Um- There is no- Oh, go ahead...
125
00:22:05.595 --> 00:22:08.346
benefit of the doubt rule. I mean, not applied to veterans.
126
00:22:08.426 --> 00:22:17.766
I mean, you just, like I keep saying, if you have five things in your favor and they have one and decide to approve you, they call that the benefit of the doubt. So- So he says here, Carol,
127
00:22:19.186 --> 00:22:30.726
um, the veteran, uh, he says here that he submitted to HLR due to the VA not using his two Nexus letters or spouse lay statement for psoriasis or psoriatic arthritis that was part of the claim.
128
00:22:31.446 --> 00:22:42.766
I, I think you- Now, that I would use as failure to consider all favorable evidence in my case. Yeah. And relying on an inaccurate C&P exam because they didn't consider all of that. Yeah, I, I...
129
00:22:43.026 --> 00:22:57.246
That's what I would go with, too. Yeah. Nighthawk, "Filed in 2004, denied, and then awarded 20% in 2020. Acquired C-file and shows line of duty investigation confirming original filing. Is that a cue issue?"
130
00:22:58.366 --> 00:23:02.806
Well, let's put it this way. If there was... That's... If the line of duty investigation
131
00:23:03.786 --> 00:23:19.026
was not discussed or listed as evidence in 2004, you're not looking at cue, you're looking at what's, uh, you're looking at basically an open claim all the way back to then under 38 C.F.R. 3.156c. 38 C.F.R.
132
00:23:19.346 --> 00:23:31.726
3.156c, which basically says if they are bringing in service records now into this claim that they should have done in your original claim, but they were too lazy, then you should, you, you are entitled to go all the way back.
133
00:23:32.146 --> 00:23:35.186
You do not wanna file a cue claim if you don't have to.
134
00:23:35.626 --> 00:23:49.426
If you can say that that claim should be con- reconsidered under that regulation I just gave you, that's the better way to do it because you get to put in new evidence, you get to argue new law, and you get to show basically what you have now proves back then.
135
00:23:49.906 --> 00:24:01.746
If you go cue, you're stuck with the evidence in the file at the time and the law at the time. You do not wanna do that, and the standard of proof is clear and unmistakable error, okay? Versus as likely as not right now.
136
00:24:02.086 --> 00:24:17.466
So, no cue. I think you got a way to go back, though. Right. Kevin, "Denied TDIU, filed for a higher level review. Any advice on how to highl- handle the higher level review person when I get a phone call?
137
00:24:17.506 --> 00:24:27.406
I'm 90% currently with bilateral eye disease."Um, I would have in front of you whatever evidence you think you've submitted that proved your claim.
138
00:24:28.106 --> 00:24:39.706
I would, I would hopefully have a copy of their C&P exam so that you can, you can kinda tear it apart, saying, "Well, they didn't consider this," "They didn't ask me this," or, you know, "I told them this and I don't see that reflected anywhere."
139
00:24:40.266 --> 00:24:45.966
So those are the kind of things, the more evidence you have that was used, the better informed and the better your presentation can be.
140
00:24:46.566 --> 00:24:57.436
Um, you gotta realize they had nothing to do with your first claim, so you wanna be kind and respectful. Um, I tried not being kind and respectful a couple times in my career and guess what? That got denied.
141
00:24:58.086 --> 00:25:04.866
Uh, felt good for a second, but didn't get me where I needed to be. So, so you just kinda wanna have the evidence you need in front of you.
142
00:25:05.066 --> 00:25:14.506
The conversation's gonna go quickly and y- you wanna say, "Hey, did you consider this? Did you consider that?" A- and, and go from there. Carol, any other thoughts? No, that's...
143
00:25:14.546 --> 00:25:19.956
You need to point, because they have a lot of work, they have a lot of paperwork in, they probably didn't note all this stuff. Yeah.
144
00:25:19.986 --> 00:25:33.566
So if you point out, out everything favorable, that's gonna give them a chance to reverse what was done before. Benny, "I had a C&P for TDIU on Friday. What should I bring..." Oh, I have one on Friday.
145
00:25:34.656 --> 00:25:46.326
"TDIU for PTSD C&P exam on Friday. What should I bring besides the PTSD questionnaire to the exam?" I always want a witness. I want my spouse, sibling, son, friend, somebody to go there with me.
146
00:25:46.416 --> 00:25:54.926
And even if they don't let them in, uh, then I want them to s- to take notes as far as how long that, you know, they're sitting there, how long were you back there, um, you know, what, what kind of...
147
00:25:54.986 --> 00:26:03.106
How did the doctor present when you saw him? Those kind of things. Carol has found a great way to get especially your spouse in, and I'll let her have the glory on this.
148
00:26:05.346 --> 00:26:13.736
You just tell them you're not going in without them, that they are your memory, they are, they, you know, you're gonna mix up the dates and that's why they're here and you're not going in without them.
149
00:26:13.846 --> 00:26:26.166
Remember, the rule that you, that they can exclude anyone is privacy for you. Right. You can waive that privacy. And so you say, "I waive the right to privacy in regard to my wife. She can come in with me."
150
00:26:26.646 --> 00:26:37.156
And just sit there and say, "I'm not going in without them." And I have yet to have somebody call me and tell me they didn't do the exam. Right. And I mean, if- And now that we're here, can I bring up my exam thing?
151
00:26:37.186 --> 00:26:49.366
Oh, great, Benny. You brought it up. Here she goes. All right. This is the, uh, miracle- It's bright... brought to you by Carol Potten, and it's her, her, or her doozy of the week, let's call it that way. Oh. All right.
152
00:26:49.666 --> 00:26:58.946
Remember, it used to be that the VA did the C&P exams themselves. That stopped years ago. They hired three companies, LHI, VES, and
QTC.
153
00:26:59.806 --> 00:27:10.386
Those companies are paid to do these exams, and so when they get an order to do them, they wanna do them. If they don't have a doctor near you, they can find one 200 miles away and send you there, and they do.
154
00:27:11.666 --> 00:27:22.626
LHI, as you've heard me speak before, has been horrible to my clients. I think they're so horrible that for some reason they're now called Optum. They changed their name, but they haven't changed their tactics.
155
00:27:22.706 --> 00:27:29.546
So this week, honest to God, 'cause I saw it in writing, they sent my client a notice for two exams.
156
00:27:29.926 --> 00:27:40.226
One was in Colorado Springs at 11:00, same day, and the second was in Burns, N- Newth- North Carolina at 11:30, same day. My client called them.
157
00:27:40.326 --> 00:27:47.906
They said they weren't gonna change it and he would be denied if he didn't go. He calls me. He and his wife are in tears. They don't have the money to fly... They live in Colorado.
158
00:27:48.226 --> 00:28:01.946
They don't have the money to fly to North Carolina. I mean, this is ridiculous. They had been so upset about that. Please don't let these people do this to you. You call the VA 1-800-827-1000.
159
00:28:02.446 --> 00:28:15.106
Ask to speak to the C&P scheduling department. They're the ones that send these cases to the VA. Tell them exactly what's happened. I had another client, same day, he was sent 100 miles away for a blood test.
160
00:28:15.846 --> 00:28:23.826
Call them and say, "I don't have any transportation. I have no way to get there. I can't go 100 miles. It's supposed to be near me. Would you please help me?"
161
00:28:24.246 --> 00:28:35.376
They'll take down your information, and then they'll take care of it. Now, they may not say, "Okay, you're, um, uh, you don't have to go," or whatever. They will say, "I will note this."
162
00:28:35.606 --> 00:28:45.926
And then, then you say, "That's why you didn't go." That way these people can't just send in failed to, uh, show up at the C&P exam. That protection, please don't let them do this to you.
163
00:28:46.466 --> 00:28:57.446
Carol, I wanna take that a step farther. VA actually has an internal police officer, if you will. The, uh, and it's the Office of General Inspector. Of, excuse me, of Inspector General.
164
00:28:58.006 --> 00:29:07.646
And what they do is they go all across the VA and they monitor and make sure the VA is doing what it's supposed to be doing as far as regulations. Now, um, this doesn't always pertain to us.
165
00:29:07.986 --> 00:29:14.276
You know, they go across hospital, cemetery, uh, other things. But sometimes they come out with reports that are o- of interest.
166
00:29:15.186 --> 00:29:22.586
Well, lo and behold, what they found is that the VA has a medical disability examination office. So basically that's what Carol's talking about.
167
00:29:22.596 --> 00:29:28.066
That's the hub office that sends the contracts out
for you to get an exam wherever.
168
00:29:28.126 --> 00:29:41.726
Those examiners that they send you out to, if they are over 50 miles away for just a regular doctor visit or, you know, just a G&P, a general practitioner, they ha- they can only send you 50 miles, up to 50 miles away.
169
00:29:41.866 --> 00:29:48.496
If they send you over 50 miles, they have to have your express consent. So you have to consent saying, "I will do this."
170
00:29:48.566 --> 00:29:55.886
Now, if it's a specialist, let's say it's an oncologist for cancer, they can send you over 100 miles, to 100 miles, excuse me.
171
00:29:56.366 --> 00:30:04.286
If they try to go over 100 miles, again, they have to, they have to get from you your express consent. So you have power in this game.
172
00:30:04.346 --> 00:30:14.206
If they're sending you to Burns, North Carolina, and you live in Colorado, you just call them up and say, "You do not have my consent to schedule me there." And then I would always follow up with a letter.
173
00:30:14.226 --> 00:30:24.046
Write them a letter saying, "As I stated in our phone call, I live in Colorado. You're trying to send me across the country for some crazy exam. I'm not going. You do not have my consent."
174
00:30:24.076 --> 00:30:26.906
And so what the vendors are do- the, the vendors, it's a money game.
175
00:30:26.946 --> 00:30:34.026
They wanna send you to their people, and they don't care how far away they are, they just wanna get you there, get the exam so they can get their money from the VA.
176
00:30:34.056 --> 00:30:41.838
And we're talking tens of millions of dollars for them, okay? So they, they're in it to get the exam.And they're not gonna follow these rules.
177
00:30:41.898 --> 00:30:48.278
Now, the VA has been admonished, uh, the, the, the disability office has now been admonished and told they need to start following these rules.
178
00:30:48.318 --> 00:30:58.598
So as Carol said, you give them a call, and they, they know they're on the hot seat, okay? So they're gonna talk to the vendors and say, "What are you doing? This is not, th-this is not the law, it's not the regulation."
179
00:30:58.658 --> 00:31:06.798
So, um, I'm ex-I was excited to see this, because it actually shows that the VA is looking at this thing, and now it's on their radar.
180
00:31:06.918 --> 00:31:18.538
Hopefully they will be more respectful to you when you call and get you an exam that, that's closer. But, but don't get upset. Don't keep fighting with these people.
181
00:31:18.558 --> 00:31:28.978
When you see it's not going anywhere, and you call the VA, because they're not gonna change their minds. I have had a number of people denied. My client didn't let me know they were trying to deal with the...
182
00:31:29.138 --> 00:31:39.998
We can't, they won't talk to us, because it's supposed to be a privacy thing from the VA medical. But, you know, when they told me about it, you know, then if they tell me, that's when I say, "Please call the
VA."
183
00:31:40.418 --> 00:31:47.938
If you call the VA, they can't deny you, because you've already made your complaint, "I can't get there." Okay? You don't know what these people are gonna tell the VA.
184
00:31:48.018 --> 00:31:55.358
Normally, they say the person failed to cooperate, they failed to show up. You know, that's what they're telling them. They're not telling them that you called and said you couldn't get there.
185
00:31:55.438 --> 00:32:06.898
Not in one case have they done that. They've just said, "Failure to, uh, come to the exam." Yeah. So protect yourself. This is, I hear this all the time, and I'm telling you, don't...
186
00:32:07.148 --> 00:32:14.958
Y-you're sick, you have problems, you don't need to go through this mental agony- Right... that these people cause. You just say, "Okay, great. I'm gonna call the VA."
187
00:32:15.958 --> 00:32:26.798
And if they don't do something there, hang up, call the VA. But remember, you, you have rights in this. They can't just jerk you around- Mm-hmm... and try to take you wherever just so they can make a buck. Okay? Right.
188
00:32:27.258 --> 00:32:36.418
All right. Carol's pedestal for the, for the week. [laughs] If you come down now, we'll go back to answering questions. She can go back up there if we get a question that gets her all hot again.
189
00:32:37.618 --> 00:32:51.898
Richard Dix filed for increase in rating for heart valve 2017. While the claim was open, had a pacemaker placed in 2018. Do I need to file another claim for the pacemaker, or would it be included in his open claim? Hmm.
190
00:32:54.038 --> 00:33:02.178
Did they- So if that's ongoing- Did they- Yeah, he just needs to make sure they know that, that he had a pacemaker. He- Yeah.
191
00:33:02.238 --> 00:33:14.778
I mean, if they can, if they knew you had a pacemaker in 2018, meaning like if you got this done in the VA medical, um, facility, then, then they knew and they should have, uh, considered it back then.
192
00:33:14.938 --> 00:33:26.238
If you had a private surgery done and they didn't know, then I think you need to go ahead and refile. Um, but I don't... So- I, I can't tell, Matt, 'cause it, I think it, I thought it was still open.
193
00:33:26.588 --> 00:33:29.898
And while the claim is open, had a pacemaker. Right.
194
00:33:30.258 --> 00:33:41.058
Do I, I guess, but it sounds like it's over, so yeah, you would need to go back and say, ask for higher level review or there was an error, uh, because you didn't consider that I had a heart valve put in or a pacemaker put in.
195
00:33:45.138 --> 00:33:53.498
Austin C, "My appeal is on the advanced direct docket. It was sent to a judge last week. You are my co-counsel. Thank you.
196
00:33:53.998 --> 00:34:03.258
How long will the decisions take once the judge, attorney, it reaches the judge or attorney advisor?" It could be tomorrow, it could be next month. You know, we, we, we don't know.
197
00:34:03.318 --> 00:34:13.708
But the fact that it's been advanced on the docket, I don't know, Carol, I usually see, what, a 30-day turnaround on those? I mean, it's not, not typically too long. I would, I would say three months at the most. Yeah.
198
00:34:13.738 --> 00:34:27.438
There are some that are three months, there are some that are within the month, well within the month. But it varies. It's all over the place. Okay. Nigel, "Can comorbidities be considered secondary medical conditions?"
199
00:34:30.278 --> 00:34:42.138
You know, it, it just depends. There, there needs to be, you gotta show a causal relationship there, so like diabetes and neuropathy, uh, back disorder and radiculopathy. You know, it just, it just depends on what it is.
200
00:34:44.398 --> 00:34:53.908
Right. Does it, does it cause, does your service-connect condition cause something else? That's what you need to look at. Yeah.
201
00:34:53.958 --> 00:35:07.958
Kenny S, "How can I get detailed information about protected work environment while using TDIU? I can earn income by trading financial instruments an hour or two a day, but that exceeds the poverty level income."
202
00:35:08.728 --> 00:35:17.878
So, uh, Kenny S, this is actually pretty interesting. We had an oral argument on what protected work environment means with the Court of Appeals for Veterans' Claims two weeks ago now.
203
00:35:18.458 --> 00:35:20.858
So we're gonna hopefully hear what a definition is from them.
204
00:35:21.358 --> 00:35:32.318
But what I would say is, if you are doing this yourself and not for someone else, um, you know, I, I think that's, that's a protected work environment, because you're, you set your own hours.
205
00:35:32.358 --> 00:35:40.378
You know, you show up when you want, you work when you want. Nobody's telling you what to do or where to be. So I don't, I don't know that that would... I, I think you would have a good argument there.
206
00:35:40.758 --> 00:35:46.318
Um, because I imagine if you look in the regular workforce o-of traders, they don't get that luxury.
207
00:35:51.338 --> 00:36:03.538
JB, "I was in, I increased my rating from 40 to 80, lum-lumbar/sacral 20 to 40, radiculopathy 40, hypertension zero, UC 30. My PTSD exam went badly.
208
00:36:03.698 --> 00:36:17.218
She misunderstood and claimed my stressor, my stressor was recovered memory, and said she had disqualified my doctor's letter that said she's treating me for service-connected PTSD. Responding with new form
209
00:36:18.158 --> 00:36:31.858
enemy combatants that only requires evidence on location during, uh, [audio cuts out] uh, US, uh, with Marines should have that information. My obstructive sleep apnea is now severe, and not sure how to connect."
210
00:36:33.318 --> 00:36:50.214
All right. So we got a lot going on here. Yeah, can we go back a little, Nate, to see the whole question?Okay. Back, hypertension. What's UC? Ulcer colitis, I imagine. Okay. PTS.
211
00:36:51.154 --> 00:37:01.774
Okay, so I would try to say that my sleep apnea is
service connected to my hypertension and/or my, uh, PTSD as well. It could be from my back pain, 'cause I wake up all night long.
212
00:37:02.194 --> 00:37:12.954
I would have the VA examine you for all of those things. I would also definitely appeal that, you know, that I had an inaccurate exam who didn't consider all the evidence. Here's the evidence they didn't consider.
213
00:37:13.533 --> 00:37:22.794
If it wasn't in the file before, you can't count on the Marine Corps having it. If it wasn't in there, maybe you file a supplemental claim. If it was, then you file an HLR, higher level review.
214
00:37:22.874 --> 00:37:27.354
I, I would hope that his, the VA went out and actually got his service records for his C file.
215
00:37:27.714 --> 00:37:37.253
And so if the service records show that you were in a theater, combat theater, then yeah, you get that presumption that, uh, you were there and that, uh, there were enemy combatants around you.
216
00:37:37.754 --> 00:37:49.154
So if that's the case, then you can argue the higher level review and say, "Hey, look, I, I, uh, I was there and the, and the, the C&P examiner didn't consider it, therefore that's a duty to assist violation."
217
00:37:50.634 --> 00:37:58.874
But you need to look in your file and make sure it's in there, 'cause a lot of times for whatever reason, they don't pick up the military personnel. I don't know why sometimes they do and sometimes they don't.
218
00:37:59.154 --> 00:38:05.014
But you wanna make sure it's in there, 'cause, 'cause the, the decisions we get don't address what we say.
219
00:38:05.414 --> 00:38:12.454
The decisions just say whatever they wanna say, and if you've argued this, they may not say, "Hey, it's not in there." They may not let you know that.
220
00:38:12.954 --> 00:38:20.054
So you need to make sure that, um, you've looked in the file, it's there, point it out. You may wanna copy and attach it to your higher level review.
221
00:38:20.674 --> 00:38:33.894
If it's not there, it's a duty to assist, they need to go get that for you, and I would write to the National Archives as well to see if I could get it. Yeah. John Johnson, "My VSO didn't file my claim in time.
222
00:38:33.954 --> 00:38:44.054
Can I still file it after one year?" If you are after one year, unfortunately you gotta file a new claim. Um, I would use a different VSO. I don't understand why that happened. But, uh,
223
00:38:44.974 --> 00:38:50.874
a year is a year, and they basically say the VSO is, you know, your advocate, so if he doesn't get it in, then you don't get it in unfortunately.
224
00:38:52.374 --> 00:39:06.274
I actually took that up to the court years ago and lost, 'cause they said, "It's your VSO," you know? Okay. Ship Howard, "Out in '95, medical says excessive worry, anxiety.
225
00:39:06.674 --> 00:39:19.874
I was not treated in service or out, but can I claim that and will PT..." Uh, excuse me, "And will a C&P provide a diagnosis?" So we're looking for a diagnosis of a mental health condition. Um, yes, you can claim that.
226
00:39:19.914 --> 00:39:25.694
I mean, that's something that happened in service. Um, looks like you haven't treated at all since then.
227
00:39:25.734 --> 00:39:35.474
You might consider starting to treat, but a C&P exam would, would have to give you some kind of diagnosis, you know, or exclude all diagnoses and say why they did that.
228
00:39:37.134 --> 00:39:47.654
Matt, I'm worried that they may not give him a C&P exam. Um, I have a number of clients, the exact same scenario, and they say, "No current diagnosis, so I'm not sending him out."
229
00:39:48.314 --> 00:39:59.054
Um, I find a lot of the raters now are trying to take shortcuts. Mm. Remember, I think it says if there's a reason from the record that a C&P exam is needed, then you can order one.
230
00:39:59.534 --> 00:40:10.394
So if he doesn't see a current diagnosis, then they're saying there's no reason to order one. So I think you really need to go, and you can go ahead and file, but I would definitely get in and get some treatment. Yeah.
231
00:40:10.434 --> 00:40:22.354
And when you file, put a letter in describing your current symptoms. Okay? Right. How this affects you, what's going on. If you have a spouse, loved one who sees you regularly who could do the same, that would be great.
232
00:40:22.704 --> 00:40:33.414
But since you don't have a diagnosis, as Carol said, it's a bit of an uphill battle to start. And remember the way that it gets service connected is it's the same problem that you had in service that you have now.
233
00:40:33.854 --> 00:40:46.314
So you wanna show the chronicity. I had this in service, it's continued, it's affected me all the way through in this manner, and I still have it. Don Reddy, "Hi.
234
00:40:46.514 --> 00:40:59.614
Can I claim a back condition as secondary back to separation if I initially applied as, for it as a standalone condition, and then it should've been secondary?" All right, so- Yeah, you can file anything you want.
235
00:40:59.974 --> 00:41:04.274
You know, you, you can file under multiple theories of law there, so that's, yes.
236
00:41:05.314 --> 00:41:15.414
And that's exactly what I do if, if I've asked for service connection, then later on I see, well, this guy had two service connected knees, they affected his back. I'm gonna file for service connected secondary to back.
237
00:41:18.914 --> 00:41:31.114
Andy Charles, "Facing appeals judge in two weeks with my VSO. Oh, who makes the presentation, him or me, since I have all the researched responses?" Y- you wanna be proactive, okay?
238
00:41:31.354 --> 00:41:41.874
Maybe your VSO understands some of the stuff and maybe he's gonna s- he's gonna be able to present some things, but it's your claim. Uh, I've seen good VSOs and I've seen VSOs who just phone it in.
239
00:41:42.274 --> 00:41:51.004
You know, "Please, Your Honor, give us the benefit of the doubt. This is a good man. He served our
country," yada, yada. That's all great. That's a, that's a stamp denial right there. Okay? Right.
240
00:41:51.094 --> 00:41:59.714
So I would be prepared if I were you to present your evidence. Just think, what's the disability? What do you need to service connect it? What's the rating? Why do you think it's higher? Okay?
241
00:42:00.114 --> 00:42:05.434
So you can let your VSO talk, but you have a right to speak as well, and you can say, "Okay," you know, "thanks for so..."
242
00:42:05.594 --> 00:42:14.954
May- maybe he, he states some law, that's great, but you need to be ready to present that evidence, because nobody knows your claim as well as you. And here's the problem.
243
00:42:15.654 --> 00:42:22.754
You have waited so long to talk to somebody, so long to go over this, that you just start talking to talking and talking, and they cut you off mentally.
244
00:42:23.114 --> 00:42:28.674
So what you wanna do is you wanna put issue number one, what do you want out of that? How do you get that?
245
00:42:29.074 --> 00:42:41.914
If it's I, I h- or you're entitled to a higher rating, you wanna tell him succinctly why you are entitled to, here's the evidence for that. Number two, this is what I think I deserve. This is why.
246
00:42:42.154 --> 00:42:52.798
Number three-Don't kill your count- claim by just going on and on and on. Uh-uh they just look, they just start writing maybe notes down to themselves about a party they're going to.
247
00:42:52.958 --> 00:43:08.138
You, you've got to make it brief, you've got to make it clear, and you've got to stop when you've finished. Amen. Remember the one way you can really hurt yourself is by them finding you not to be credible.
248
00:43:08.258 --> 00:43:18.658
That's the one finding you do not want. So if they find you're not credible, um, that, that really hurts your case from then on. So you don't wanna go talking, talking, talking.
249
00:43:18.978 --> 00:43:32.678
Stick to the exact things that you can prove and that are clear, okay? Sorry, Matt, were you gonna say something? No. [laughs] Okay. Carlos again, "How or can the VA take away your unemployability?" Yes, they can.
250
00:43:35.798 --> 00:43:51.898
John Price, "Are there any statistics on the percentage of PACT Act claims granted to not granted by condition or any other info on stats?" Not at this point, Matt. I, I think it's too new. They're just starting. Yeah.
251
00:43:51.978 --> 00:43:57.078
They're, they're still- Have you heard anything?... getting things going. Um, I've got some- Right... stats that I would like to share.
252
00:43:57.738 --> 00:44:08.678
So Carol and I got to go see the, uh, VA present at Nova, and this was the VBA, meaning the people who do the regional office stuff, not the Board of Veterans' Appeals.
253
00:44:09.578 --> 00:44:26.958
What, the only thing they really said about the PACT Act is that they're hiring over 300 more employees this year, um, and hoping that will be able to decrease the, uh, the, uh, caseload if you will, um, to get that down and get that into a manageable position when it comes to the PACT Act.
254
00:44:27.858 --> 00:44:32.998
Um, so let's see. And they had a couple other things that I thought were interesting in their presentation.
255
00:44:33.618 --> 00:44:44.758
They said that this year, um, claimants are, when they talk about appealing rating decisions, so rating decisions from a supplemental claim, that's are, are appealing about 12% of those.
256
00:44:45.298 --> 00:44:52.518
When they go to higher level and they're denied, they're, they're appealing 9%, and then y- you got 5% are appealing to the board.
257
00:44:52.578 --> 00:45:00.098
So basically, when people get a decision, they're saying, "This was wrong," they either file a supplemental claim, and 12% of people are doing that, uh,
258
00:45:01.098 --> 00:45:06.218
9% are doing a higher level, and 5% are doing an appeal to the board. The rest of the folks just aren't appealing.
259
00:45:07.058 --> 00:45:19.458
Um, and then obviously the overwhelming lane that they're, they're, uh, picking is the, uh, is the AMA, uh... Excuse me. What is this lane? This is the supplemental receipt lane. Okay?
260
00:45:20.158 --> 00:45:30.438
Um, but what they did show us is that the supplemental lane has gone down year over year, and the higher level review has gone up, and also the Board of Veterans' Appeals has gone up.
261
00:45:30.478 --> 00:45:43.598
So appeals are going more to the H- H- higher level review, and then also to the Board of Veterans' Appeals. Um, the grant rate, interestingly enough, for higher level review, the grant rate for an appeal is 18%.
262
00:45:44.358 --> 00:45:55.058
For supplemental claims, meaning you filed a claim, and then you file another claim within a year on that through supplemental claim, there's a 45, 46%, um, rate of grants.
263
00:45:55.598 --> 00:45:58.978
So, um, it's kind of a interesting thing to see.
264
00:45:59.698 --> 00:46:22.858
Carol and I don't necessarily see that playing out, but, um, just something to think about if you're, if you're apply- if you get a decision you disagree with, you look and see what are the favorable findings, and that lets you kind of deduce what was de- why it was denied, go out and prove why it was denied, and it looks like there's a chance to get a pretty, pretty good chance of actually getting the decision that the, uh, you know, what you deserve there as far as the decision.
265
00:46:24.458 --> 00:46:36.638
All right. Next one. Miguel: "I have a law firm working on my case, but they do not answer my questions. I'm thinking of firing my lawyers. Communication is terrible. They file claims without notifying me."
266
00:46:37.978 --> 00:46:49.797
Y- you know, you need to be comfortable with, with, with who, w- whom is representing you. Um, I would ask why they're filing c- claims and, and why they're not answering your questions.
267
00:46:50.658 --> 00:47:01.998
There are so many, um,
lapses of time, Mary, that, you know, [laughs] time is, is in a different kind of universe with the VA, okay? So it, it takes years.
268
00:47:02.558 --> 00:47:13.058
And so, you know, if, if a law firm is taking a long time, you gotta realize there's, there can be long periods without anything happening, and there's nothing to update you on, unfortunately. We see that all the time.
269
00:47:13.118 --> 00:47:24.318
Our veterans get, um, upset about that, and frankly, we're upset too, but there's nothing we can do to force the VA to move faster. So just, just realize they can only do so much.
270
00:47:24.558 --> 00:47:28.918
Um, you know, filing claims without notifying you, I would, you know...
271
00:47:28.958 --> 00:47:36.338
If we had a veteran with a back problem, and we saw that they had radiculopathy, we would know that's due to the back problem, so we would wanna file that right away.
272
00:47:37.338 --> 00:47:49.118
I agree that it would, should be communicated to you what's been filed and why. Um, so that, that is something that I definitely would check up on if I were you. Yeah, but I think sometimes that does happen.
273
00:47:49.838 --> 00:47:59.628
Um, but when clients... I had someone ask me the other day how long do you usually have these clients. I said, "Usually until they die." And, and that's how long we...
274
00:47:59.698 --> 00:48:09.278
Because unfortunately, most of the disabilities are progressive. So if I have a client who has Parkinson's, I know I'm gonna have that client till he dies, because
275
00:48:10.478 --> 00:48:25.258
unfortunately, he's gonna get worse, but hopefully I will be able to get him SMCs. I just got a client SMC 42 today. That's $10,350 a month. I'm sad that he needs that, but I'm glad he's gonna get that.
276
00:48:25.618 --> 00:48:37.098
So it, it's, and I've had, we have these clients for years and years and years, and when someone comes to me, the first thing I wanna tell them is, "I can't get, I can't promise you that I will have your case done fast.
277
00:48:37.398 --> 00:48:39.558
There is no such thing with the VA.
278
00:48:39.998 --> 00:48:49.390
But I will get you everything I think you're entitled to, no matter how long it takes me."And, you know, a lot of people are discouraged because they say, "Well, my friend just filed and he got whatever."
279
00:48:49.970 --> 00:48:53.229
Well, they do do the brand-new claims really well.
280
00:48:53.570 --> 00:49:07.350
But if they don't happen to give you what you want on that, you're in for a longer time, and you can either give up or you can let me handle it, or you can have the patience to handle it yourself because you can get those benefits, but that's their game.
281
00:49:07.970 --> 00:49:15.210
I get the benefits, you don't have anything, you're gonna go away. I'm not going away, and I don't think you should either. She's a bulldog.
282
00:49:15.450 --> 00:49:23.480
She has a beautiful smile, but those teach- teeth clench on and my God, you better watch out. [laughs] Like, and Carol, actually, let me just give some more stats on this.
283
00:49:23.490 --> 00:49:30.180
They're saying the average days to completion for a supplemental claim was a hundred and twenty-two days last year. Mm-hmm.
284
00:49:30.550 --> 00:49:41.730
Um, and they're saying that last year to get a, get a decision from the higher level review, it was thirty-six days. They're saying this year that's nearly doubled to, uh, sixty-eight days.
285
00:49:42.390 --> 00:49:49.490
So just kinda letting you know where we're seeing, uh, the higher level reviews getting more backlogged. Um, but that's so, that's so true.
286
00:49:49.530 --> 00:49:58.790
You know, there, there are these pre-claim, uh, filing companies like Vet Guardian out there that say they get their claims decided faster than attorneys.
287
00:49:58.810 --> 00:50:04.590
What they're not telling you is they're talking about an initial claim, and those go faster.
288
00:50:04.610 --> 00:50:15.170
And what else they're not telling you is, is they don't get it done any faster than the, than, than the VA would process your claim. So those- Right... claims, you know, faster, we're talking a hundred and twenty days.
289
00:50:15.740 --> 00:50:21.390
My math says that's four months. I don't really think that's fast, but that's their faster, okay?
290
00:50:21.400 --> 00:50:30.710
And so if somebody's telling you they can do it fast, faster than an attorney or faster than whoever else, we gotta do apples to apples. 'Cause once you get into appeal, we're looking at about twenty-four months, okay?
291
00:50:30.750 --> 00:50:41.350
And that, that, that's their timeline, that's their backlog. You know, I remember, Matt, we were talking with Tom Murphy, who was the head of VA benefits for a number of years, who I thought was really good.
292
00:50:41.930 --> 00:50:46.190
You know, he was talking about the veterans needing a fast decision and how we can give them one.
293
00:50:46.830 --> 00:50:55.649
And after we looked at it, I think one of the things that we said is, they want a fast decision, but they don't want a fast denial. They want a fast, accurate decision.
294
00:50:56.190 --> 00:51:03.490
And if you can't do that fast, then, then wait because- Yeah... why do you want a fast denial? You want somebody to really look at your case.
295
00:51:03.590 --> 00:51:13.770
You wanna put the evidence in, and you want, hopefully, to get the best result that you can. Fast is not a word you should look for with the VA. You should look for winning. Yeah.
296
00:51:15.650 --> 00:51:21.670
All right, we only have time for a couple more questions, so we're gonna go through and get two or three more here. That,
297
00:51:22.770 --> 00:51:30.950
uh, that girl Tam, "Hi, does a note from a mental health therapist suffice as proof of continuity of care, or do we have to have submit actual therapy note sessions?"
298
00:51:31.850 --> 00:51:43.350
You want a note of a
current diagnosis, is what I would put in there. And usually it says, "I have been treating this patient from this date to now. This is the current diagnosis."
299
00:51:43.390 --> 00:51:49.870
So that gives you the continuity of care. No, you don't, 'cause a lot of therapists do not wanna put in their session notes, and the VA knows that.
300
00:51:50.250 --> 00:51:55.520
But y- like Matt said, you need a diagnosis, and you need to show how long these people have cared for you. Yeah.
301
00:51:55.560 --> 00:52:03.790
And then they need to get into the nexus, if you're missing that, in other words, the service connection for the VA. And then they need to look at the rating decision.
302
00:52:03.850 --> 00:52:16.710
Have they commented on everything that would get you the highest rating possible? All right. Louis C, good to see you. "Helped my friend go from ten to twenty for his back. How do I connect other issues to this?
303
00:52:17.210 --> 00:52:19.270
He also had an aneurysm twenty years ago."
304
00:52:20.650 --> 00:52:29.970
Oh, that's a, that's a- Well, the back, remember you're looking at, the back alone is usually, we said forty percent is the most you can get, depending on how far you can bend forward.
305
00:52:30.330 --> 00:52:37.430
But they also have radiculopathy down each leg, pain, numbness. There could be, he's had to go to the bathroom much more than before.
306
00:52:37.490 --> 00:52:42.150
He could have depression because of the pain and the limitations that the back caused him.
307
00:52:42.630 --> 00:52:53.090
Aneurysm, you're looking for some neurological problems, some heart problems, some hypertension, something else that would be service connected that would cause that. Yeah, I, I, I agree with Carol.
308
00:52:53.130 --> 00:53:02.550
There's plenty you can look for. I just don't know that that's the one that's gonna be a winner. The aneurysm? Yeah. Yeah. All right, let's take two more here.
309
00:53:03.129 --> 00:53:14.750
Ryan- Oh, by the way, I was supposed to tell you to check like, please. Okay? [laughs] Or something like that. I think we got it wrong. Yeah. [laughs] Like it. I don't know, subscribe, I think would summarize it.
310
00:53:15.270 --> 00:53:25.370
Oh, subscribe. Please check that. Uh, like and subscribe, I think, uh, Nate, Nate- Okay... Nate keeps us in order here. All right. "I just had an informal conference, higher level review," says Ry.
311
00:53:25.740 --> 00:53:36.950
"There was a duty to assist here, identified per VSO. Is there a chance that they will make a decision or send to reg office for new exam?" The chance is more the secondary part, that they'd send it for a new exam.
312
00:53:37.010 --> 00:53:42.190
That's kind of, they're more likely to remand your case for a new exam than they are to, to flat out grant it.
313
00:53:42.230 --> 00:53:51.710
And if that was the only evidence about your medical condition, that one C&P exam, they are not gonna grant it. They're definitely gonna send it back. All right, last question. What do we got?
314
00:53:52.370 --> 00:54:06.930
B Retire, "Rated S service-connected twenty-three years ago, ninety percent combined, of which PTSD seventy, migraines thirty. Kept, kept me from working. I've not seen a doctor in twenty years. Can I claim TDIU?
315
00:54:06.940 --> 00:54:15.250
What about chronicity and continuity?" Yes, you can claim TDIU, and you should. And you basically need to put in there why you think those things keep you from working.
316
00:54:15.270 --> 00:54:21.810
The fact that you're over twenty years, you got the, you know, they can't take away these benefits from you. I would do that. I'd ask for a...
317
00:54:22.470 --> 00:54:36.310
It's, if, if your migraines are so unpredictable that you don't know when you're gonna get them, if you get them more than a couple times a month, uh, that to me would say that in and of itself, your migraines might keep you from working, um, which you should apply for fifty percent for.
318
00:54:36.930 --> 00:54:51.110
But yes, it doesn't matter when you stopped working. You know, they can't use that against you. All right, folks. Thanks so much for joining us. Um, please submit your questions. We, we have the, uh, channel.
319
00:54:51.210 --> 00:54:55.769
If you go on our channel, there's a community button, and you can, uh, submit questions there.
320
00:54:55.830 --> 00:55:05.630
Questions that get voted up, we will go into and, and try to make sure we answer the next week, but I know we only get to so many. Um, and, and I just wanna make sure that we're, we're doing this.
321
00:55:05.750 --> 00:55:15.170
So if you go to the community tab on our homepage on YouTube, then we will look to make sure we get some of those questions answered. All right. Thanks so much. Have a great day.