TRANSCRIPT 🔗
WEBVTT
00:00:00.017 --> 00:00:02.837
Welcome to In the Clinic with Camille. My name is Camille Freeman.
00:00:03.037 --> 00:00:06.717
I'm an herbalist and nutritionist, and in this podcast, I share little tips
00:00:06.717 --> 00:00:08.877
and tidbits that might be helpful for other practitioners.
00:00:09.537 --> 00:00:14.217
Today, I wanted to share a follow-up thought after teaching the first class
00:00:14.217 --> 00:00:16.797
in my supplement deep dive earlier this week.
00:00:17.357 --> 00:00:21.237
For those of you who are not in the supplement deep dive, this class was about
00:00:21.237 --> 00:00:22.557
smarter supplementing.
00:00:22.677 --> 00:00:26.277
And so what we did in the class was really an overview of some of my thoughts
00:00:26.277 --> 00:00:27.897
on the philosophy of supplements.
00:00:27.897 --> 00:00:32.977
We talked about the definitions and ethical concerns and considerations around
00:00:32.977 --> 00:00:38.437
recommending supplements, and then also dove more into why we would recommend
00:00:38.437 --> 00:00:39.837
them, why we would not recommend them,
00:00:40.037 --> 00:00:42.977
thoughts on how long people take them, the reasons we're taking them,
00:00:43.417 --> 00:00:45.877
whether those are justified, all of that sort of thing.
00:00:46.377 --> 00:00:49.977
To be super clear, again, for those of you who weren't in the class,
00:00:50.097 --> 00:00:53.177
I think most of you know this, but just to make sure we're all on the same page,
00:00:53.337 --> 00:00:54.937
here in the United States,
00:00:55.137 --> 00:00:59.037
the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act, also known as DISHAY,
00:00:59.217 --> 00:01:03.357
from 1994, is how we define a supplement officially.
00:01:03.757 --> 00:01:07.197
And they define it as a product intended for ingestion that,
00:01:07.357 --> 00:01:11.897
among other requirements, contains a dietary ingredient intended to supplement the diet.
00:01:12.277 --> 00:01:15.017
So it's a little bit circuitous, but that is the definition,
00:01:15.297 --> 00:01:21.377
and it includes vitamins, minerals, herbs, botanicals, amino acids,
00:01:21.917 --> 00:01:27.497
dietary substances such as berberine that are a part of one of the categories
00:01:27.497 --> 00:01:33.297
above, things like protein powders, protein bars, etc. Those are all considered dietary supplements.
00:01:35.517 --> 00:01:40.617
One of the points that I was making in this class is that when a client is taking
00:01:40.617 --> 00:01:49.097
a supplement over a long period of time with the intended outcome of preventing a condition or disease,
00:01:49.277 --> 00:01:52.097
which technically we are not supposed to do as practitioners,
00:01:52.117 --> 00:01:55.457
we are not supposed to recommend that because that is practicing medicine outside of our scope.
00:01:55.457 --> 00:01:59.037
But a lot of people are taking supplements with the idea that,
00:01:59.477 --> 00:02:00.797
oh, this is good for my heart.
00:02:00.957 --> 00:02:06.137
This is good for my, you know, it's shown to prevent dementia or whatever else.
00:02:06.437 --> 00:02:09.497
One of the points that I made in this class is that realistically,
00:02:09.497 --> 00:02:15.237
if you are taking a supplement with the idea that it's going to prevent something
00:02:15.237 --> 00:02:18.137
or lower your risk of some kind of disease or condition,
00:02:18.377 --> 00:02:21.717
10, 20, 40 years down the road, it is a gamble.
00:02:21.717 --> 00:02:25.857
In almost all cases, not all, in very few cases,
00:02:25.857 --> 00:02:33.337
do we have solid human evidence showing cause and effect in a clinically meaningful
00:02:33.337 --> 00:02:39.837
effect size that a specific supplement is going to meaningfully reduce your
00:02:39.837 --> 00:02:42.177
risk or prevent certain conditions.
00:02:42.297 --> 00:02:45.177
Again, it's not nothing, it's not never, but most of the time,
00:02:45.357 --> 00:02:49.237
that is a maybe we're taking this on a sort of just-in-case basis.
00:02:49.517 --> 00:02:52.657
So we talked about the implications of this, and if it makes sense,
00:02:52.717 --> 00:02:54.657
and under which circumstances, and so forth.
00:02:55.257 --> 00:02:58.097
And I think that's an important point, and I think it's one that a lot of people
00:02:58.097 --> 00:03:01.017
don't think through fully. We fleshed that out in the class.
00:03:01.577 --> 00:03:04.977
However, the reason that I was lying in bed thinking, gosh, I think I might
00:03:04.977 --> 00:03:08.577
have missed explaining a certain aspect of this, is at the end of the class,
00:03:08.717 --> 00:03:13.617
somebody asked, well, Camille, what about things like herbs or mushrooms,
00:03:14.077 --> 00:03:16.477
you know, reishi and lion's mane, and some of these things.
00:03:17.341 --> 00:03:23.181
How do we think about recommending those or people who are working with those for long-term use?
00:03:23.641 --> 00:03:27.181
And I have a couple things to say about this that I, again, did not say in the
00:03:27.181 --> 00:03:30.161
class and meant to, should have, etc.
00:03:30.781 --> 00:03:37.361
One of them is that because our definition of supplement is so big in this country,
00:03:37.361 --> 00:03:43.221
I think there's a very large spectrum of what falls into that category.
00:03:43.221 --> 00:03:46.601
So in my mind, taking a
00:03:46.601 --> 00:03:50.001
single nutrient such as vitamin A or
00:03:50.001 --> 00:03:57.381
magnesium or something like that is in many ways akin to taking a specific phytochemical
00:03:57.381 --> 00:04:02.021
from an herb in an isolated form in a higher dose than we might be getting it
00:04:02.021 --> 00:04:07.041
from just consuming that herb in a more standard way and taking it by itself
00:04:07.041 --> 00:04:09.161
and then looking to see what happens.
00:04:09.161 --> 00:04:12.001
So this is, in my opinion,
00:04:12.501 --> 00:04:15.921
a lot closer to kind of our pharmaceutical model
Load full transcript
of medicine,
00:04:15.921 --> 00:04:21.141
where we're taking these specific components outside of their standard food
00:04:21.141 --> 00:04:27.141
or plant matrix, and then using them in doses that are generally higher than
00:04:27.141 --> 00:04:29.321
what we might ingest them in in one sitting.
00:04:30.041 --> 00:04:32.701
Not that that's always bad, not that that's never a good thing,
00:04:32.701 --> 00:04:36.221
or it's never helpful for people, but that's how I think about that.
00:04:36.221 --> 00:04:42.321
Then in terms of herbs, if we're looking at a whole plant model where you're
00:04:42.321 --> 00:04:46.781
taking the herb and you're grinding it up and putting that powder on something,
00:04:46.961 --> 00:04:50.961
or we are making an herbal infusion or an herbal decoction for people who don't
00:04:50.961 --> 00:04:52.621
know what that is, basically just tea.
00:04:52.921 --> 00:04:57.101
If we're making an herbal tea, in my opinion, it's a lot closer to food's.
00:04:57.708 --> 00:05:02.828
So I think we also don't have, you know, we don't have great evidence about
00:05:02.828 --> 00:05:06.688
carrots to be like, oh, well, you know, if you eat X number of carrots every
00:05:06.688 --> 00:05:11.708
day for 30 years, you're going to reduce your risk of heart disease or what have you.
00:05:11.708 --> 00:05:15.768
But we do have good evidence about eating a very diet rich in vegetables and
00:05:15.768 --> 00:05:18.588
fiber being associated with lower risk of things.
00:05:18.748 --> 00:05:23.288
So I think about herbs as being in the long-term preventative sense as being
00:05:23.288 --> 00:05:28.148
closer to foods where we're like, yeah, any single herb does not have studies
00:05:28.148 --> 00:05:32.188
for the most part looking at long-term effects over decades.
00:05:32.188 --> 00:05:38.448
However, there's reason to believe that incorporating herbs into your diet,
00:05:38.448 --> 00:05:40.648
the same as you do fruits and vegetables,
00:05:40.988 --> 00:05:46.248
is expanding your sort of phytochemical regime, unlikely to cause harm in most
00:05:46.248 --> 00:05:50.228
cases if you're taking some of the more, you know, gentle, accessible herbs that are food-like.
00:05:50.728 --> 00:05:54.128
And there's, you know, I don't think it's the worst idea in the world,
00:05:54.388 --> 00:05:57.268
just like I wouldn't say, no, we don't have evidence for carrots,
00:05:57.388 --> 00:05:58.208
so you shouldn't eat them.
00:05:58.648 --> 00:06:02.768
On the other hand, if we are taking a single isolated constituent of an herb
00:06:02.768 --> 00:06:07.988
and we are putting it in a gel cap in a plastic bottle and extracting it in
00:06:07.988 --> 00:06:10.548
some factory somewhere and shipping it across the country and saying you're
00:06:10.548 --> 00:06:12.828
going to take that with the idea that it might be.
00:06:13.615 --> 00:06:16.575
Support your health over 20 years or something like that.
00:06:16.735 --> 00:06:20.535
I think it's a cause for a little bit more investigation, a little bit more
00:06:20.535 --> 00:06:24.715
thought, and a little bit more explanation to our clients about what evidence
00:06:24.715 --> 00:06:26.215
we have that this is true.
00:06:26.895 --> 00:06:31.015
So anyway, I'm not sure if that clarifies things for people or if that's a helpful
00:06:31.015 --> 00:06:35.895
point or if you're like, yeah, Camille, that's just something we already know and think about.
00:06:36.215 --> 00:06:39.475
But I wanted to say it out loud just to be really clear.
00:06:40.295 --> 00:06:44.015
My points from the class. Other points from the class still stand,
00:06:44.175 --> 00:06:47.155
which is anytime we're recommending anything to somebody, we need to be really
00:06:47.155 --> 00:06:50.015
thoughtful about whether this is the best use of their time,
00:06:50.235 --> 00:06:54.755
of their money, what evidence, either traditional or clinical.
00:06:55.615 --> 00:06:57.615
Supports its use, and so forth.
00:06:57.915 --> 00:07:02.315
So there you go. If you have not joined the Supplement Deep Dive and you would
00:07:02.315 --> 00:07:03.915
like to, it's not too late.
00:07:04.095 --> 00:07:08.555
You can still join the January class as it was recorded. You can watch it any time.
00:07:08.815 --> 00:07:13.935
You can join any time throughout 2026. Our next class is going to be with Jacqueline,
00:07:14.535 --> 00:07:20.395
Sclaver, who is a nutritionist who supports professional and Olympic level athletes,
00:07:20.455 --> 00:07:23.275
as well as just regular people interested in fitness.
00:07:23.475 --> 00:07:26.755
And she's going to come and talk to us all about the supplements that people
00:07:26.755 --> 00:07:30.155
often take with the idea that they might be supporting athletic performance
00:07:30.155 --> 00:07:33.415
and fitness, kind of break down for us what's true, what's not true,
00:07:33.655 --> 00:07:36.675
what do we need to do about dosing, safety, and that sort of thing.
00:07:36.755 --> 00:07:40.315
So I'm really excited for somebody with such expertise and such experience to
00:07:40.315 --> 00:07:41.435
come and share her knowledge.
00:07:41.795 --> 00:07:43.995
Certainly not something that I know a lot about. So I really,
00:07:44.155 --> 00:07:45.315
really can't wait for that lecture.
00:07:45.615 --> 00:07:49.375
Love to have you join us. You can just go to camillefreeman.com slash supplements
00:07:49.375 --> 00:07:50.395
if you want to learn more.
00:07:50.655 --> 00:07:53.815
And otherwise, let me know if you have any other questions. Thank you so much
00:07:53.815 --> 00:07:55.315
for listening, and I'll talk to you later.